دور التكنولوجيا المالية في عصر ما بعد كوفيد
دور التكنولوجيا المالية في عصر ما بعد كوفيد
دور التكنولوجيا المالية في عصر ما بعد كوفيد
No.
176
2021
Arab Regional Fintech Working Group
This document was produced within the Arab Regional Fintech Working Group (WG)
mandate, which aims for the exchange of knowledge and expertise, continuously
strengthening the capacity of the Arab regulators, as well as building a network of peer to
peer between Arab and international experts from the public and private sectors to promote
Fintech industry and foster innovation.
This report on “The Role of Fintech in Post-COVID Era” is prepared by Mr. Najib Choucair
from Banque Du Liban in collaboration with Dr. Nouran Youssef from the AMF and based
on contributions of ten Arab Central Banks and Monetary authorities as following:
Special thanks go to the Arab Central Banks and Monetary Authorities, members of the Arab
Regional Fintech WG, for their insights and comments on the topic.
The opinions expressed in this vision paper are solely those of the writers and do not necessarily
reflect those of entities they represent.
2
2
Table of Contents
Introduction ............................................................................................................................ 4
Conclusion............................................................................................................................ 27
Sources ................................................................................................................................. 28
3
3
Introduction
In the early stages of the Coronavirus outbreak, what seemed to be an isolated epidemic
swiftly ushered in the start of a new historical era that has triggered a global economic
meltdown. At the time of writing, countries and entire populations have been in pandemic
mode for over a year, demonstrating how the world we live in is a tiny place. Despite the
economic hurdles brought on by COVID-19 new opportunities take shape on the horizon for
financial innovation. The pandemic crisis has given fintechs a unique opportunity to rapidly
grow their user profile, geographical foothold, and reputation. The widespread adoption of
digital financial solutions, which was previously expected to take years, was shortened to just
a few months due to the global pandemic. Digitization will have leap –frogged several years
with technologies having implemented and tested in a fraction of the time they would have
taken innormal times. Despite the global financial turmoil, COVID-19 acted as a driver for
economic growth across specific subsectors such as payments and Regtech, providing new
and unexpected opportunities for fintechs. By reducing the dependence on physical financial
interactions and the need for cash, FinTech can facilitate coordinated responses and enable
secure ways for governments and providers to reach vulnerable populations quickly and
efficiently. The pandemic will indeed have a lasting impact, and as life normalizes,
consumers and businesses may not fully revert to past habits and practices.
The Fintech ecosystem continued to advance access to financial services during the COVID-
19 pandemic—particularly in emerging markets—with strong growth in all types of digital
financial services except lending, according to a joint study by the World Bank1, the
Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance at the University of Cambridge’s Judge Business
School.
Furthermore, the demand in digital financial services witnessed a surge in demand as working
practices and customer banking habits changed in the COVID-19 era. The arrival of digital
financial services has created faster, more efficient, and typically cheaper banking compared
to traditional financial services.
Investments in the Fintech sector have been enormous in the last decade and increased over
13 times in the past ten years from $8 billion in 2010 to over $110 billion in 2019, driven by
venture capital funds and crowd funding, significantly contributing to the growth and success
of Fintech globally.2
1
CCAF, 2020. The Global Covid-19 FinTech Market Rapid Assessment Study – University of Cambridge and
the World bank.
2
WAIFC, 2020. Innovation and Fintechs in a Post-Pandemic world. World Alliance of International Financial
Centers (WAIFC)- December 2020.
4
4
Transformation into Cashless Channels
One of the most popularized technologies at the moment are mobile payments and digital
wallets which substantially increased as a means of transaction without the need to be
physically present thus disregarding another vector for transmitting the virus.
Physical cash payments have become less practical thus opening the door to an increase in
digital payments and e-wallets. According to a MasterCard survey looking at the implications
of the coronavirus pandemic, 82% of respondents worldwide viewed contactless as the
cleaner way to pay, and 74% said they will continue to use contactless payment post-
pandemic3. Though the use of cash was previously predicted to decline, COVID-19 has
accelerated their use due to concerns over cash handling and human to human transmission of
the virus. As a result of these technologies, users can conduct online purchases, check
deposits, and money transfers from the convenience of their homes.
The COVID-19 outbreak has boosted the cashless payment industry globally, fuelling the
shift from card payments at points of sale (POS) to contactless digital wallets. While this shift
was already underway before the pandemic, the absence of a requirement to key in Personal
Identification Numbers (PINs) or codes has made contactless payments more popular,
particularly via digital wallets. That shift, in turn, will have implications for how we structure
and implement digital ID systems in both the physical and online environments, which
ultimately means more investment in new payment technologies.
More recently, the Fintech industry is discussing measures for these innovations in providing
swifter services which focus on checks from the government stimulus package. Doing so will
assist in mitigating the deteriorating economic and social impact of the pandemic. According
to Deloitte, fintechs, in strategic partnerships with financial institutions, retailers and
government sectors across jurisdictions, can help democratize financial services by providing
basic financial services in a fair and transparent way to economically vulnerable populations.
As online channels have been on an increase, advances in improved ‘know your customer’
services are being developed.
Traditional onboarding practices of being present in-person and using hard documentation is
being replaced by secure and digital solutions which facilitate the remote onboarding process
thus enhancing customer experience, lowering costs and becoming time efficient.
Furthermore, the approach offers a solution to strict lockdown measures resulting from the
COVID-19 pandemic.
3
CCAF, 2020. The Global Covid-19 FinTech Market Rapid Assessment Study – University of Cambridge and
the World bank.
5
5
Hence, with the contribution of fintechs, banks and Financial Institutions (FIs) are now
capable of processing and onboarding customers through digital and remote means while
undergoing the standardized compliance practices such as data and document collecting,
screening against AML and other regulatory bodies, document proofing, and analyzing risk
credentials.
These methods are essential to counter the rise in digital fraud and cybercrime. As more of
the global economic and financial system continues to move online, cyber defenses will
become even more critical for consumer protection.
As the global economy recovers from COVID-19, one particular area of focus for Fintech
companies is financial inclusion. According to the World Bank, there are currently around 1.7
billion unbanked individuals worldwide, and fintechs are becoming a vital player in their
efforts to integrate these people into the global financial system. For vulnerable segments of
the population, access to and use of basic financial services is critical for poverty reduction,
increased resilience, and improved economic growth. Fintech innovations are contributing to
the reduction of costs associated with providing services, facilitating more reach, and
reducing the need for face-to-face interactions, all of which are essential for keeping up
economic activity during the pandemic.
As the financially underserved population is devoid of a veritable credit history due to lack of
documentation and income instability, traditional banks face challenges facing this untapped
demographic. Therefore, Fintech and payment enterprises seek to capitalize on this
underserved segment by optimizing the best of technology and innovation.
The results of smartphone and internet penetration allow emerging Fintech companies to
gather vast amounts of data through data analytics and Big Data. Data can be generated from
social media platforms, search engines, and telecommunication providers. This approach is
believed to be more inclusive as it provides the opportunity for tailor-made financial services
to individuals with much lower costs per customer. Fintech companies are developing
measures to attain behavioral patterns and optimize data collection.
Developments include combining big data with behavioral economics through the creation of
credit scores by analyzing behavioral patterns of calls and text messages. An algorithm
measures financial appetites and risks of defaults. The information generated also allows
companies to gauge whether a person is likely to repay the loan on the established terms. This
alternative data is highly effective in substituting the absence of valid documentation and
tangible credit histories. It is further used for extending small packet loans for short periods
that can empower this extant overlooked category.
6
6
Fintech companies such as Cignifi do that without relying on credit history while others use
gamification or questionnaires to formulate psychometric scores. The technology allows for
‘administratively re-ordering’ borrowers based on the ‘moving target’ of changing behaviors.
Data can then be used by either informing behavioral change strategies by lenders to “nudge”
borrowers into adjusting their spending habits and behaviors.
Prior to the outbreak, it was clear that Fintech would play a pivotal role in financial services
going forward. COVID-19 has undoubtedly accelerated that process. Fintech companies
demonstrated resilience and an ability to handle difficulties while remaining intact despite the
ongoing pandemic. Their high level of equity finance, agile operations, and a willingness to
embrace remote working, Fintech companies were able to withstand the disruption.
Established FIs, on the other hand, have been forced to expedite their digitalization plans to
meet new demands. fintechs were ready to deliver innovative solutions while traditional
banks were left behind still attempting to transform from legacy systems to agile and
seamless deliveries. Automation and other digital services have become more important.
Therefore, digital transformation will be on top of the agenda for governments and regulators
in months and years ahead, mainly because of the repercussions caused by the pandemic.
Whereas previous efforts to integrate technology may have been limited in scope, many FIs
are coming to the realization that in order to deliver an efficient, effective and sustainable
banking service, they must adopt a more holistic approach to digital transformation, which
includes utilizing Fintech.
With a global shift into digitalization, a main concern across all sectors is cybersecurity
especially in the financial and banking industry which is subject to malicious fraudulent
actions and cybercrimes.
7
7
The Region’s Response
Regionally, the Middle East and North Africa saw strongest growth, up 40 percent, sub-
Saharan Africa and North America, both up 21 percent. In general, emerging markets and
developing countries experienced faster growth than developed markets. The MENA region’s
response through the pandemic to ensure security and continuity illustrates the region’s
quick-to-action response.
In November 2020, CGAP identified 400 fintech solutions in the Arab region. With 44% of
these solutions being payment products, and half of those offering store of value. 75% of
these solutions were located in just 6 countries: the UAE, Egypt, Morocco, Tunisia, Jordan
and Lebanon. If the latter countries were to expand access to financial services to 50% of the
untapped market there, it would generate 7 billion $ in revenues.
Fintechs operate primarily in the GCC, followed by North Africa and Levant
“Valify” is an Egyptian digital identity solution which formed part of the Central Bank of
Egypt’s regulatory sandbox on e-KYC. Their solution allows digital onboarding in a three
step solution of information extraction, facial recognition and authentication.
8
8
Similarly, Tunisia set a national electronic database which resulted in the opening of vast
amounts of digital wallets remotely, thus responding to safety precautions and lockdown
parameters. Moreover, recent developments include the submission of a Fintech into the
country’s regulatory sandbox. The company is based on Artificial Intelligence (AI)
technologies which aim at facilitating the cell phone customer onboarding process.
Besides the increased acceptance of remote working, over 83% of FIs in Jordan plan to
prioritize digital capabilities expansion over branch expansion. The crisis and the shift to
digital finance, both by clients and Financial Service Providers (FSPs), have yielded the
unanticipated benefit of expediting the digital transformation process in the financial sector.
On another front, nearly 64% of FIs intend to put a crisis management framework in place to
be better prepared for similar unforeseen situations. Following the pandemic, over 50% of the
FIs are keen to introduce new products and services targeting new customer segments and
increase the distribution of financial services to all governorates.
In Morocco, the country put in place stricter oversight over payment services to secure bank
cards against fraud, Bank Al Maghrib implemented a set of requirements which payment
institutions must comply with. These requirements include the establishment of a fraud alert
and monitoring system for transactions, equipment of anti-skimmers for ATMs, and
enhancing card security standards.
In the case of Tunisia, the pandemic assisted in accelerating the digitalization of financial
services in the country. The Central Bank of Tunisia published Circular No. 2020-11 in May
2020 with aimed at promoting a favorable ecosystem for the development of digital payments
and promoted security of mobile payment transactions.
Palestine’s response to the increased collaborations with fintechs was the development of an
internal strategic framework to promote financial technologies which include a section for
financial inclusion. Furthermore, licenses were granted to companies that provide electronic
wallet services, prepaid cards, and additional services.
9
9
Amendments in Digital Fees & Charges
The UAE’s response to the pandemic included increasing cap limits for contactless payments,
promoting awareness campaigns and the suspension of CBUAE’s payment fees. Similarly,
Bahrain increased the limits for digital payments by amplifying the volume limit of
contactless Near Field Communication (NFC) transactions.
The UAE mandated higher level of security under “Circumstances of Remote Operations”
where security risk assessments are conducted for new technologies developed for the
purpose of remote operation. This allows an enhancement in control capabilities, better
authentication, data security, and other security precautions.
Jordan
o Recommending the use of e-wallets through mobile phones, and enabling payment
companies to provide the service of opening e-wallets for clients, stores and
companies remotely and without any costs aiming at enabling clients to make
transfers and receive salaries and aid related to the National Aid Fund and any other
governmental programs electronically, in addition to enabling them to implement
payment and transfer operations with no limitations in terms of place or time.
o Providing electronic channels for enabling clients to send financial transfers abroad in
a completely electronic manner from anywhere and at any time away from using
banknotes and without the need of the client’s actual presence at the financial
institutions.
o Providing the supportive modern technologies for accepting electronic payments
within points of sale located with merchants and retail business sectors such as the QR
code; based on the standard issued by the EMVCo (Europay, Mastercard, and Visa)
international committee, using these technologies aims at enabling merchants and
retail business sectors to receive the values of their sales from clients electronically
instantly and remotely ,away from using cash, to limit the spread of Coronavirus.
o Enabling clients to implement cash deposit and withdrawal operations from e-wallets
through ATMs of some banks that are the most widespread in the kingdom without
the need to use the card for that (Cardless).
UAE
The UAE response to the pandemic includes increasing cap limits of contactless payments,
promoting awareness campaigns and suspension of CBUAE’s payment fees.
10
10
Furthermore, the UAE mandated higher level of security under “Circumstances of Remote
Operations” where security risk assessments are conducted for new technologies developed
for the purpose of remote operation. This allows an enhancement in control capabilities,
better authentication, data security, and other security precautions.
Digital Payments
o Temporary suspension of CBUAE’s processing fees in payment systems operated by
the CBUAE till end of year 2020.
o Increase the cap limit of contactless payments from AED 300 to AED 500.
o Execution of awareness campaigns to encourage contactless channels on banking
channels .
Cyber Security
o Mandated higher level of Information Security under Circumstances of Remote
Operations to security risk assessments are conducted for any new technology being
introduced for the purpose of remote operations, Intensify monitoring capabilities,
Inventory of endpoints enabled for remote access scenarios, Data Loss Prevention
capabilities, Use Multi-factor authentication, Prevent unauthorized access to
resources, remote access should be managed and maintained at all times via e.g. AV
update, MDM, MAM, security hardening, disk encryption etc. and other related
security precautions.
o Provide ATMs with an intrusion detection system (IDS) and Consider cancelling
some ATMs, which are rarely used and located in high-risk areas.
ATMs
o All ATMs must be sanitized at frequent intervals; Hand sanitizers for customers
should be kept near all the ATMs; and Disposable latex gloves should be provided for
customers use for ATMs in the bank’s premises and other places, and these gloves to
be restocked frequently.
o Requirement of filling the ATMs with new banknotes during this critical period and
providing new banknotes to customers for all over the counter cash withdrawals.
Branch Operations
o Changing working hours or temporary closing of branches located in commercial
centers, shopping malls or crowded places.
o Multiple decision and mandates communicated to Banks included (e.g. should allow
only the critical staff necessary for the continuation of these services to work from the
bank’s premises, Limit the number of staff at clearing and counter services, Closing
selected smaller branches on a temporary basis, Limiting the types of transactions that
can be provided by the branches, Determine the eligible staff categories to work from
home, Institutions should use Virtual Meeting Rooms and video conferencing,
and other related).
11
11
Bahrain
Bahrain increased limits for digital payments by amplifying the volume limit of contactless
NFC transactions.
Additionally, the country accelerated digital transformation and digital partnerships by
establishing a Fintech Hub which supports integration between FIs and Fintech start-ups; an
open banking framework through an API sandbox which allows Fintechs to develop, test and
deploy solutions; and e-KYC’s allowing banks and Fintech companies to verify customers
through their digital channels; and amended regulatory frameworks to support digital finance.
In October 2020, CBB launched the Bahrain Open Banking Framework (Bahrain OBF) to
ensure holistic implementation of Open Banking services by the industry.
Framework includes:
1. Detailed operational guidelines
2. Security standards and guidelines
3. Customer experience guidelines
4. Technical open API specifications
5. Overall governance framework to protect customer data
6. Follows rules on Open Banking previously issued in December 2018.
12
12
7. Developed in consultation with retail banks /other financial institutions in Bahrain.
8. Open Banking services entail the provision of two broad categories of services.
9. “Account information service” which provides customers with access to all bank
account information in an aggregated manner through a single platform.
10. “Payment initiation service” which allows licensed third parties to initiate payments
on behalf of customers while allowing seamless transfers between different customer
accounts through a mobile based application.
11. In line with CBB’s vision with regards to digital transformation and attracting
Fintechs.
National eKYC4
Launched in January 2021, the national eKYC platform, targets retail banks, financial
services providers and money exchange networks.
o Operated by BENEFIT in collaboration with the Information and eGovernment
Authority (IGA) and under the supervision of the CBB.
o Provides a national digital identity database for financial institutions to securely verify
the identities of their customers, validate their information and share data digitally
before providing products and services.
o This includes retrieval of customer data from governmental entities including IGA.
o API for the platform allows seamless integration with financial institutions core
systems, digital channels and mobile apps.
o Provides an opportunity for banks/Fintech companies to verify customers’ identities
through their online and mobile applications.
o Implementing eKYC API integration with digital channels and mobile apps.
Tunisia
Enabling digitalization
The pandemic assisted in accelerating the digitalization of financial services in Tunisia. The
Central Bank of Tunisia published Circular No. 2020-11 in May 2020 with aimed at
promoting a favorable ecosystem for the development of digital payments and promoting
security of mobile payment transactions.
Regarding customer onboarding, the process was based on the submission of a national ID
number accompanied by a valid phone number. The country set a national electronic database
which resulted in the opening of vast amounts of digital wallets remotely, thus responding to
safety precautions and lockdown parameters. Moreover, recent developments include the
4
Source: Central Bank of Bahrain. Fintech Developments During COVID-19 and Financial
Stability Implications. February 4th, 2021.
13
13
submission of a Fintech into the country’s regulatory sandbox. The company is based on AI
technologies which aim at facilitating the cell phone customer onboarding process through:
1. Data collection
2. Document proofing and anti-impersonation checks
3. Risk credentials
4. Bank AML checks
5. Account activation
KSA
The Saudi Central Bank (SAMA) has taken different procedures to mitigate the impact of
Covid-19 pandemic on economy and to encourage people depend more in cashless payment
ways as preventive procedure during that period.
It is worth noting that The Central Banks awarded the Saudi Central Bank the Business
Continuity Award for the best initiative for the year 2020. This is based on the committee’s
evaluation by ensuring that the award criteria are applied which includes creativity and
innovation for business conduct, in addition to applying international standards for the
business continuity program through which the Central Bank was able to continue doing its
business without interruption or influence.
For the Saudi Central bank’s business continuity efforts, The Central Bank provided the
technical capabilities that contributed to remote work, which was implemented during the
Coronavirus pandemic and access to internal services and systems safely and easily, in
addition to effective communication with employees and stakeholders.
Moreover, Saudi Central Bank has taken Fintech solutions during the pandemic including the
following:
As part of SAMA’s role in activating the available monetary policy tools and enhancing
financial stability, including enabling the financial sector to support the growth of the
private sector, and supporting the efforts of the government in combating the Coronavirus
(COVID-19) and mitigating its expected financial and economic impacts on the private
sector, especially on SME sector, SAMA has announced the introduction of Private
Sector Financing Support Program with a total value of about SAR 50 billion. The
program aims at supporting and enabling the private sector to promote economic growth
through a package of measures that includes Supporting SME Finance, Deferred
Payments Program, and Funding for Lending Program, Loan Guarantee Program in
addition, Supporting Fees of POS and E-Commerce.
14
14
2. Using Blockchain technology in money transfers with the local banks
SAMA has Deposit a part of the liquidity to the banks by blockchain technology as part
of its measures aimed at enhancing the sector's potential. It should be noted that the Saudi
Central bank is one of the first central banks to experiment with using blockchain
technology in remittances, which is one of the innovative initiatives launched by the
corporation, as part of its efforts to empower and develop financial technologies in the
Kingdom.
This is accomplished via supporting payment fees of all stores and entities in the private
sector. The program aims to mitigate the expected financial and economic impacts on the
private sector in light of the Covid-19 circumstances and to Support participants in the
payments ecosystem in the Kingdom, and ensuring the continuity of growth and
continuous expansion in providing safe and effective payment services.
4. Increasing purchase limit for Mada Atheer to SAR 300 with no pin required
SAMA has decided to increase the purchase limit of atheer-enabled cards (supporting
NFC technology) from SAR 100 to SAR 300 for a single transaction with no need to
enter PIN. This step comes in line with SAMA’s supervisory and regulatory role and its
pursuit to implement the precautionary and preventive measures issued by the competent
authorities to stop the spread of the novel coronavirus (COVID-19).
SAMA has decided to raise the allowed top-up of the monthly ceiling limit for e-wallets
up to (20,000) SAR. This is based on SAMA’s supervisory and regulatory role and is in
line with the goal of boosting the digital payment transactions, in accordance with the
prudential procedures taken to prevent the spread of the corona virus (COVID-19). This
contributed to the hygiene of the users of the digital payments, and smoothen their
payment transactions via e-wallets applications provided by those PSPs.
Oman
1. CBO waived all transaction fees on the banks for the payment systems it operates
including RTGS, ACH, MPCSS, Cheque Clearing etc. to encourage the use of
electronic transactions.
2. On boarding policy for the MSMEs by the banks for using various payment systems
was published to encourage the use of electronic transactions by the customers of
these MSMEs.
15
15
3. Merchant Service Fee for e-commerce transactions were fully waived during the
period from April to September 2020. Generally, the customers of Money Exchange
Entities (MEEs) used to carry out remittance transactions by physically visiting the
branches. However, due to the movement restrictions due to Covid-19 pandemic and
our waiver of MSF for 6 months saw a huge jump in online remittances. The average
number of online transactions during the period of waiver increased by 1157 % and
their value increased by 1251%.
4. CBO permitted MEEs to digitally onboard new customers for undertaking online
transactions during the period from April to July 2020.
5. Advised banks to consider reducing existing fees related to various banking services
and to abstain from introducing new ones during year 2020 and 2021.
6. CBO has waived fees and charges that are charged to banks on POS transactions, and
accordingly banks were directed to waive the fees levied by them to the customers for
such transactions with an aim reduce cash transactions.
8. Banks and PSPs were advised to open wallets with light KYC norms including the e-
KYC to avoid the physical visit of persons to branches or outlets.
9. CBO and banks waived all transaction fee charged on the RTGS, ACH, MPCSS and
Cheque transactions during the pandemic period.
10. Banks were advised to augment the IT infrastructure in view of the likely increase in
demand for online/electronic/digital banking, etc.
11. To reduce reliance on physical cash and facilitate digital transactions, CBO has
revised/increased various limits prescribed, earlier, for transactions carried out on
mobile banking/mobile wallets/prepaid cards, and also increased the “No CVM limit”
for contactless card transactions from OMR 20 to OMR 40.
12. Banks were advised to instantly credit beneficiary for all ACH inward transactions
after completing the necessary validations, even before the settlement taking place in
RTGS at CBO.
13. CBO has put many efforts in digitizing the salary payments in the country by
collaborating with Ministry of Finance and Ministry of Labour, with almost all the
salary payments now being digitally processed.
14. With the aim of E-payments services expansion in Oman, CBO directed all licensed
banks and PSPs to provide the e-payment service to private sector entities, without
charging any setup cost, equipment cost or any other charges and fees. Banks and
PSPs are only allowed to charge the Merchant Service Fees (MSF) specified by CBO.
15. As regards the ‘loan deferment programmes’ for ‘Covid affected borrowers’, CBO
had advised banks to disseminate the information related to the said programmes
16
16
through electronic means and had also permitted to obtain the needed documents
digitally.
16. The licensed institutions (banks, FLCs and MEEs) were advised to implement ‘work-
from-home’ concepts, with controls, whenever there were disruptions due to mobility
restrictions so as to provide banking/financial services without any interruption to the
customers/public.
Palestine
Since the Palestinian market is an open market that accepts change, the current crises led to
the increase in its collaborations with Fintechs, PMA developed an internal strategic
framework to promote financial technologies which include a section for financial inclusion.
PMA launched a Financial Inclusion Account in addition to “Light Wallet”.
Additionally, it has been working on strengthening the infrastructure for the usage of modern
alternatives that support the shift towards payments and e-commerce through:
1. Granting licenses to companies to provide electronic wallet services, prepaid cards,
and additional services.
2. Issuing instructions to regulate the business of payment service companies
3. Accomplishing the requirements for developing a project for linking payment services
companies with PMA's databases in order to facilitate entry into this sector and
raising the levels of financial inclusion.
4. Launching the electronic clearing system ECC as an alternative to the ACH clearing
system.
5. Accomplishing Preparations for the implementation of the Bill Presentment project.
6. Preparations for the implementation of the Mobile Payment Switch project
7. Executing tests with banks to verify the passage of all transactions of payments using
debit cards through POS through the national switch and to carry out clearing and
final settlement operations locally.
Qatar
When the COVID-19 restrictions were put in place in Qatar, demand for cashless and
contactless payment drastically increased, largely fuelled by the need to stay physically
distant as a precaution for mitigating the spread of the virus. CWallet rolled out its first
service at this point to respond to the needs of the businesses and individual customers across
Qatar to go cashless by using a package of comprehensive online payment tools available free
of cost to all users through its application that is easily and freely downloadable on
smartphones. The service is designed in a way that provides quick, cost-effective solutions
for everyone in the community to use. Businesses have already started using the service as
petty cash to pay off their low-cost internal and external transactions. It has been used to pay
17
17
freelancers as businesses dropped the idea of using physical cheques. Schools started to use
CWallet credit to have kids purchase groceries from the school canteens instead of using
cash, and with hospitals making payments by cards mandatory, another set of opportunities
presents itself for the firm to explore in the coming future.
Kuwait
The Central Bank of Kuwait (CBK) encouraged its regulated entities to apply and utilize the
latest digital technologies to achieve financial inclusion. To that end, below are the most
important measures taken towards achieving growth in the E-Payment sector in a consistent
manner:
o Nine local banks have been permitted during 2020 to provide point-of-sale payment
service through digital wallets such as Apple Pay, Fitbit, Samsung Pay and Garmin.
o During the years 2020 and 2021, the Central Bank of Kuwait (CBK) received a number
of innovative products and services within the Regulatory Sandbox. These innovative
products are being evaluated and tested in a safe environment, in order to support
innovative business modules, whether those related to electronic payment or other
products and services that could improve the financial services in the state of Kuwait.
o The CBK issued a circular to all regulated entities to take the necessary measures
regarding the approval of the Kuwait Mobile ID (Hawyti) application issued by the
Public Authority for Civil Information, which represents a secure national digital
identity that can be used in many governmental and non-governmental electronic
transactions, including financial services.
o The Central Bank of Kuwait allowed the increase the limit for contactless payments
(TAP/NFC) from 10 KD to 25 KD during the lockdown periods to promote the use of
electronic payments and encourage social distancing measures, ensuring safety to
combat the coronavirus pandemic.
o The CBK endeavor to take advantage of latest technologies towards providing banking
services around the clock. In this regard, a number of regulated entities were permitted
to provide the Chat-Bot service, which is a solution based on conversational
middleware programs that relies on Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Machine Learning
(ML) technologies. When integrated on a knowledge base system, the solution allows
for response to inquiries that may seem seamless to the customer in order to enable a
communication channel with their client base during the time of curfew.
o A circular was sent out to all banks including K-Net (the Shared Electronic Banking
Company) to provide hand sanitizers at all Automated Teller Machines (ATMs) and
Point of Sale (POS) machines.
o Banknotes are being isolated and stored for four weeks to ensure their safety prior to
market recirculation. Moreover, the CBK is disinfecting its vaults, bank note counters
and sorting machines to protect the public.
o CBK ensured the continuity of banking services through electronic channels and points
of sale.
18
18
o CBK mandated that no charges or fees for POS transactions, ATM withdrawals and
online banking for 6 months starting on the 13th of March 2020.
o CBK introduced the Eidity (Eid gift money) service during the 2020 Eid Al-Fitr, which
was an initiative to minimize the use of cash during the COVID-19 pandemic, as CBK
did not issue new bank notes during that period. The Edity service, is a free service
which functions as an e-wallet that facilitates sending Eid gift money from and to any
mobile number registered in the state of Kuwait. The “Eidity” application allows the
public to send and receive Eidiyah electronically easily and quickly.
o CBK currently is moving forward with open banking initiative that concentrate on
issuing an Open Banking Framework that mandates incumbent financial institutions
regulated by CBK, which includes Banks/ Electronic Payment Infrastructure Providers-
(EPIPs), to allow data to be accessed by other banks, Fintechs / Third Party Service
Providers (TPSPs) and Electronic Payment Agents (EPAs).
o Diraya awareness campaign that was initiated by the Central Bank of Kuwait and the
Banking Association to highlight customer rights and banking awareness in the area of
banking fraud, information security and cyber awareness.
Lebanon
Measures taken by Banque du Liban (BDL) as response to COVID-19, the BDL has been
always striving to develop electronic banking and banking services technologies, and to
launch consumer protection programs in terms of dealing with electronic banking.
In fact, BDL was heading towards a cashless economy, but unfortunately the sequence of
events that Lebanon went through lately was pushing more towards the use of cash.
Lebanon has been living multiple shocks in the past few months, starting with the liquidity
crisis that erupted in the last quarter of 2019, followed by the government’s decision to
discontinue payments on all its outstanding US dollar-denominated Eurobonds in March
2020, the COVID-19 pandemic imposing lockdowns in the country starting the second
quarter of 2020, and the Beirut port explosion in August 2020 which caused major
destruction in the Lebanese capital and led to the resignation of the government.
In the midst of these challenging circumstances, BDL has been deploying all measures to
help the economy survive, and it has taken a series of initiatives including those related to
FinTech and Digital Payments activities.
The BDL Intermediate Circular number 539 on electronic banking and financial operations
issued on January 2020 is one of the steps towards digital transformation. This circular allows
customers of different banks in Lebanon holding bank accounts or payment cards such as
Visa Card and MasterCard to make instant financial transfers via the use of mobile devices
and appropriate applications, and this was not allowed previously. Accordingly, in
application of this circular, bank customers can make immediate transfers between each other
at a very low cost, as the commission ceiling for these immediate transfers does not exceed
19
19
0.5% of the transfer value. Through this circular, customers of different banks can use the
appropriate applications to make instant transfers between them or to pay merchants and self-
employed persons. This circular will contribute to reducing the use of banknotes as a means
of payment, as it adds a safe and fast electronic payment method that meets the necessary
standards. (Intermediate circular 539 dated January 17, 2020 that amends Basic Circular 69
on electronic banking and financial operations).
Moreover, the BDL is planning to launch its own digital currency in Lebanese pounds. In a
statement dated November 2020, the Central Bank Governor announced a plan to introduce a
digital currency in 2021 “to restore confidence in the banking sector and to make a transition
into a cashless system”. Its goal is to ease payment methods, to activate monetary
technologies and to lower the costs borne by consumers.
In an effort to control the parallel foreign exchange market, BDL has established an
electronic platform for exchange operations that includes BDL, banks and money exchange
houses. On April 15, BDL invited banks and exchange houses to attend a training session
before launching the platform operations.
Egypt
The Central Bank of Egypt (CBE) has acted proactively as first movers to withstand the
economic shocks of the Covid-19 pandemic from various perspectives, in terms of flexibility
in regulations, digital infrastructure enablement and electronic payment incentives.
Regulations:
The CBE issued multiple regulations on March 15, 2020 to maximize the banking sector’s
contribution in implementing the State’s plan to deal with the potential consequences of the
of the Covid-19 pandemic. The newly issued regulations’ objective was to stimulate the use
of electronic means and payments channels and facilitate conducting financial transactions
for citizens while limiting the spread of the virus. Said regulations focused on the
precautionary measures and procedures that banks must implement in order to ensure the
safety and security of the banking sector and ensure the banks’ ability to continue carrying
out their various businesses and activities to meet customer needs; and in coordination with
the AML Unit with regard to customer due diligence.
A. Mobile Wallets:
To facilitate registration & utilization of mobile wallets, the CBE mandated issuance of
Mobile wallets to be free of charge for a period of 6 months extended till end of June 2021 &
have increased the maximum wallet limits to become EGP 30,000 for individuals & EGP
40,000 for merchants daily, which led to increasing of the volume of mobile wallet
transactions by 300% in 2020 compared to 2019.
Additionally, and starting from 15th March to 30th September banks were allowed to
onboard and verify new bank customers by any electronic means that the bank deems
20
20
appropriate, including but not limited to obtaining his/her national number and mobile phone
number in an electronic way and verifying the customer's ownership of the mobile phone
number used during the registration process via the NTRA platform.
Customers had to complete the necessary KYC process to comply with the due diligence
procedures within 3 months from the date of wallets opening. In case the customer did not
complete the required procedures, the bank shall close the account, provided that the
customer shall be able to recover any outstanding balance after his/her account is closed.
B. Prepaid Cards:
The following measures have taken place to promote contactless cards & “Tap & Go”
transactions to limit the spread of the virus:
1- Issuance of prepaid contactless cards free of charge for a period of 6 months
extended till end of June 2021.
2- Raising the limit of “Tap & Go” transactions without requiring Pin for
authorization from EGP 300 to EGP 600.
3- Increasing the maximum daily cards transactions to become EGP 30,000 for
individuals & EGP 40,000 for merchants daily.
C. Digital Acceptance:
Banks that had a license for digital acquiring services were mandated to promote
digital acceptance through the following:
1- Activation of payments through QR codes and "Request to Pay" service for all
merchants who have points of sale "POS".
2- Complying with the simplified KYC procedures for merchants and micro-
enterprises according to the clause 5.3.2 of the due diligence procedures for
mobile payment customers issued in March 2019.
D. Internet Banking:
In order to limit the customer’s visits to the banks premises during the pandemic
to apply for internet banking services, CBE has applied the following measures:
1. The bank may register its existing customers over a period of 6 months
extended till end of June 2021 through the verification of the customer’s
identity using the usual electronic verification methods commonly used for
any of the banks products.
2. The customers are required to comply with the bank’s procedures to enroll to
the internet banking service within the period of 6 months.
21
21
Digital Infrastructure Enablement:
Besides the precautionary measures the CBE has taken to counter the repercussions of
Covid-19, it is crucial to work on a simultaneous expansion and spread of various
electronic acceptance channels that support contactless transactions, across all
governorates, by targeting merchants who currently do not have electronic acceptance
channels as Point of Sales (POS) or digital acceptance through QR code.
The challenges faced in electronic payment acceptance in Egypt, including but not limited
to:
o The need to expand number of Point of Sales (POS) machines.
o The need to rely more on digital acceptance through QR codes.
o Taking in account geographical distribution of electronic acceptance channels.
o The need to raise awareness and motivation of consumers and merchants towards
usage of various electronic payments channels.
Within this framework, the CBE funded the initiative to increase the number of electronic
acceptance channels with an estimate budget of EGP 1 billion with the intend to reach
300,000 electronic POS machines and to support the digital acceptance through QR code to
reach 200,000 new QR codes.
As part of CBE’s role to support the mostly affected citizens in the emerging pandemic,
CBE, in collaboration with governmental entities, has facilitated the national initiative
conducted for informal and irregular workforce sector of a monthly grant of 500 EGP
through disbursement of amounts on their cards or mobile money wallets, ensuring that
citizens comply with social distancing standards.
22
22
Covid-19 Innovation Sprint
The COVID-19 innovation sprint was hosted by the Central Bank of Egypt, in
collaboration with the British Embassy, the FRA and organized by DFS Lab and FSD
Africa. This initiative objective is to match the Egyptian Banks and Financial Institutions
with FinTech startups who have ready-made solutions that can solve the pandemic-related
challenges which arouse due to COVID-19. The sprint targets the development of
FinTech solutions through an innovation sprint for relief to immediate COVID-19
challenges faced by Banks and Financial Institutions. A three days’ sprint was done
followed by a demo day where the selected FinTech Startups showcased their prototyped
solutions.
Recov-Tech Sprint
The aim of the project is to develop public-private prototype FinTech solutions which
may help advance an inclusive, resilient economic recovery on the African continent post
the Covid-19 pandemic shock. It is implemented by: BFA Global / Catalyst Fund and in
collaboration with the British embassy. The project consists of 4 main participant
countries: Egypt, Kenya, South Africa, Nigeria and 3 main phases:
- Phase 1: consists of roundtable sessions with the aim to come up with
feasible problem statements.
- Phase 2: consists of 2 virtual Tech-sprint with the aim to develop
prototypes of solutions to the problem statements of phase 1.
- Phase 3: will be a physical event for participants to meet and to assess and
evaluate the different prototype solutions developed.
Phase 1 of the project is already completed where 3 roundtable sessions were held
between private and public entities in Egypt to formulate and consolidate feasible
problem statements to be addressed in the Tech-sprint stage.
Morocco
In response to the increase in digitalization, the country put in place stricter oversight over
payment services to secure bank cards against fraud, the Bank Al Maghrib implemented a set
of requirements which payment institutes must comply with. These requirements include the
23
23
establishment of a fraud alert and monitoring system for transactions, equipment of anti-
skimmers for ATMs, and enhancing card security standards.
o With the Lockdown measures taken by the government, Bank Al Maghrib quickly put in
place the necessary flexibility in order to lighten conditions of account opening including
the possibility remote account opening:
Banks are able, temporarily, to use new technologies to proceed e-KYC for bank
account opening:
Deliver a specific assistance to retail payment systems, namely the ACH and the
switch, which are functionally critical to maintain public confidence in the use of
scriptural payment instruments and to enable the distribution of social assistance
to the poorest in the best possible conditions.
All of these measures aim to promote the use of digital financial services in the best
conditions and support Financial Inclusion development.
24
24
o Development of adapted channels to guarantee the accessibility of financial
services (Mobile Payment, Low Cost Service….).
o Maintain the effectiveness of Central Bank actions and the alignment of these
orientations at the national level.
o provide adequate assistance to enable financial institutions as part of the
country's anti-covid strategy, to meet the needs of citizens, cope with the costs
generated by their new services and guarantee their sustainability:
As part of efforts to reduce the effects of the crisis caused by the Coved-19 epidemic and its
implications for businesses, Morocco’s Economic Vigilance Committee, which includes the
Bank Al Maghrib, has decided to take a series of measures:
Bank Al-Maghrib, for its part, has adopted a set of monetary and prudential policy measures
to support access to bank credit for the benefit of businesses and households. Indeed, these
measures aim to allow banks to raise their refinancing capacity with Bank Al-Maghrib
through the reduction of the central bank rate, access to a set of instruments in dirham and
foreign currency, the extension to a very wide range of securities and bills accepted by the
Central Bank in return for the refinancing granted and the extension of the duration of these
refinancing.
Financial education
o Strength and coordinate efforts of public and private actors in favor of proactive
financial education targeting the segments whose revenues have been impacted
by COVID-19.
o Support them by disseminating good practices to adopt, explain how they can benefit
from Government aids, protect themselves against fraud etc.
o Ensure financial inclusion promotion during this period by using the digitalization of
financial services as well as financial education programs. Given that a large
25
25
proportion of the vulnerable population is not familiar with this method, it
appears essential to provide specific measures to encourage the use of digital services.
o Establishing a trust relationship between institutions and target segments, Media
channels such as television and radio can play an important role in this context.
Financial education is very important at this stage if we want to move from cash aid delivery
to electronic one.
Therefore, it is necessary to strengthen the task of monitoring payment systems and means,
raising the level of vigilance and supervision of actors using financial technologies.
26
26
Conclusion
As witnessed with the current global pandemic, fintechs are essential in providing sustainable
financial services as they are agile, digital, and can withstand shocks that have disrupted
traditional banking service providers. The Fintech industry will further expand as
technologies continue to evolve, thus accelerating investments in digitalization and
innovation. The reach goes beyond digital KYC’s, online payments, or bank reconciliations
thus disrupting the way that financial services operate, changing customers' expectations.
From the statements presented in this paper, it is evident that Fintech companies provide an
array of services crucial for the financial service sector to remain resilient against external
shocks. It is also evident that a digital eco-system and establishment of digital-focused
delivery channels is key for traditional banks to remain relevant as consumer tastes have
shifted. Hence, collaborations between banks, fintechs is inevitable and more importantly, a
favorable regulatory environment is essential in nurturing these collaborations from the
promotion of digitalization.
27
27
Sources:
- Kebede et al., 2020. Lockdown but not shutdown: The impact of the covid-19
pandemic on financial services in Jordan - October 2020.
- CGAP, 2020. Fintechs Across the Arab World – A look into the region’s 400+
fintechs and their multi-billion-dollar opportunity to advance financial inclusion –
December 2020.
- CCAF, 2020. The Global Covid-19 FinTech Market Rapid Assessment Study –
University of Cambridge and the World bank.
- WAIFC, 2020. Innovation and Fintechs in a Post-Pandemic world. World Alliance of
International Financial Centers (WAIFC)- December 2020.
28
28
Copies of publications issued by the Arab Monetary Fund
may be requested from:
29
29
http://www.amf.org.ae