Comparative Study of Group 15 Elements
Comparative Study of Group 15 Elements
Comparative Study of Group 15 Elements
Element I.E. (kJ mol−1) E.A. (kJ mol−1) E.N. (Pauling Scale)
Nitrogen 1403 −6.72 3.0
Phosphorus 1012 +71.94 2.1
Arsenic 947 +77.28 2.0
Antimony 834 +101.64 1.9
Bismuth 703 +105 1.9
Ionization energy: There is a drop in ionization energy from N→P (Figure 1(a)) with
the increase in atomic volume. From P→As the drop in I.E. is lower due to greater
effective nuclear charge (3d10) for As. Again, from As→Sb→Bi there is a gradual drop in
I.E. as normally expected.
Electron affinity: The electron affinity of N (Figure 1(b)) is unusually low due to strong
interelectronic repulsion in ‘2p’ sublevel. The sudden increase in E.A. in P is a result of
relaxation of this repulsion, which gradually diminishes with the increase in atomic
volume explaining the gradual increase in E.A. on descending the group.
δ+ δ−
P O
Figure 3
Electronegativity and Metallic and Nonmetallic Character
Metallic character increases within the group with increase in atomic number.
Nitrogen and phosphorus are nonmetals, arsenic and antimony are metalloids and
bismuth is a true metal. This is evidenced by the increase in basic nature of the oxides
with the increase in atomic number and increased tendency to form positively charged
ions. Thus the normal oxides of N and P are strongly acidic, whilst that for As and Sb are
amphoteric and Bi is largely basic.
Compounds of Group 15 Elements and Bond type
The ionization energy required to produce M5+ ion is so immense that it never
occurs. The sum of the first three ionization energies for Sb and Bi are just low enough
for them to form M3+ ions.
Fluorine is the only element which gives a large enough electronegativity
difference to permit ionic bonds and thus SbF3 and BiF3 exist as ionic solids. The M3+
ions are rapidly hydrolyzed in water to produce SbO+ and BiO+, but this change is
reversed by the addition of 5(M) HCl:
H 2O
Bi
3+
BiO+
HCl
It is possible to attain inert gas configuration ns2np6 e.g., N3− by the acceptance of
three electrons only by the reaction of nitrogen with highly electropositive metals to give
ionic nitrides e.g., Li3N, Be3N2, Mg3N2, Ca3N2 etc. In majority of the cases the bonds are
predominantly covalent.
Hydrides: All the elements form volatile hydrides. The ease of formation, stability,
ability to use the lone pair of electrons for coordination (and hence the basic strength)
decrease on descending the group.
NH3 is prepared in the laboratory by heating ammonium salts with a strong base
e.g., NaOH: NH4Cl + NaOH = NaCl + NH3 + H2O
N N N N
H H H H H
Structure-I: staggered Structure-II: gauche
Figure 5
Dr. Jishnunil Chakraborty - Assistant Professor - St. Paul’s C. M. College, Kolkata 9
Figure 5 shows that the lp-lp repulsion is smaller in Structure-I and hence seems to be
more stable. The high dipole moment value of N2H4 can of course be explained only by
assuming the gauche form (Structure-II).
It forms two series of salts:
N2H4 + HX = N2H5+ + X−
N2H4 + 2HX = N2H62+ + 2X−
Hydrazine is a powerful reducing agent in alkaline solution but a mild one in acidic or
neutral solution:
N2H4 + 2I2 = 4HI + N2
N2H4 + O2 = 2H2O2 + N2
Phosphorus has greater catenated compounds (P−P, B.E.= 209 kJ mol−1) than nitrogen
e.g., P2H4, P3H6, P4H6 etc.) which are unstable.
Halides: Unlike heavier members nitrogen forms a series of halides derived from HN3,
for example FN3, ClN3, BrN3 and IN3 resembling covalent azides in extreme instability
and explosive nature.
Trihalides: All the possible trihalides of N, P, As, Sb and Bi are known; with the
nitrogen compounds are least stable. NF3 is stable but NCl3 is explosive and NBr3 and
NI3 are known only as their unstable ammoniates e.g., NBr3.6NH3 and NI3.6NH3. The
trend for stability: NF3 >> NCl3 > NBr3 > NI3. The greater stability of NF3 over the other
analogs is due to the higher N−F bond strength (arising out of the overlap of less diffused
orbitals having similar sizes with no steric congestion) and absence of vacant d-orbital of
suitable energy.
The instability and explosive nature of NCl3, NBr3 and NI3 may be attributed to
the lower bond-strength of N−X (X = Cl, Br, I) arising out of the overlap of orbitals
having wide differences in sizes and greater steric congestion.
All the trihalides are sp3 hybridized leading to a pyramidal geometry with one
position occupied by a lone-pair of electrons.
The trihalides all hydrolyze readily with water, but the products vary depending
upon the central element.
NCl3 + 3H2O = NH3 + 3HOCl
H NH3
Figure 6
PCl3 + 3H2O = Cl H3PO3 + 3HCl
Cl Cl
SN 2 P
P Cl
sp3d hybridized
Cl Cl TBP structute
O
H O
H H
H
OH Cl
Repeating in two steps
P OH P Cl
OH OH
O H O
P OH Tautomerization P
OH HO OH
H
Phosphorous acid
Figure 7
Figure 8
PCl5 + Cl PCl4 PCl4+ PCl6-
Acid Base
N + + N N
220 pm
N
+ O O + O
262 pm
O
Figure 11
The notable reluctance of NO to dimerize can be related both to the geometrical
distribution of the unpaired electrons over the entire molecule and to the fact that the
dimerization to O=N−N=O leaves the total bond-order unchanged (2 × 2.5 = 5). When
NO condenses to a liquid, partial dimerization occurs and the cis form is more stable than
the trans form.
The valence bond description of NO as a hybrid of (I) and (II) is less efficient and
gives a three electron bond between the nitrogen and oxygen atoms:
N O (I)
N O (II)
Dr. Jishnunil Chakraborty - Assistant Professor - St. Paul’s C. M. College, Kolkata 14
Nitrogen dioxide: It is a sigma radical and not a pi radical with a slight tendency to
dimerize to N2O4 and tends to lose its brown color. The N−N bond distance in this
compound is 175 pm and is weak (B.E. = 63 kJ mol−1). The most stable structure of the
dimer is planar.
O O
N N
O O
Figure 12
The planarity of N2O4, according to a full MO study arises from the fact that the
HOMO of NO2 has appreciable ‘O’ character affording some long range bonding
between the syn oxygen atoms in the N2O4 M.O. otherwise characterizing the N−N bond.
According to valence bond theory, in NO2 the central nitrogen atom is in the state
of sp2 hybridization (angular) with one position occupied by an odd electron.
N
O O
1340
Figure 13
Nitrogen sesquioxide: Spectroscopic studies show that N2O3 has a nitronitroso structure
with one nitrogen atom planar (sp2) and other angular:
O O
N N
N N O O O
Unstable
O Stable
Figure 14
In the vapor or liquid state it dissociates as:
N 2O 3 NO + NO2
O sp2 O
O
sp3 sp2
N N
O O
Figure 15
Oxyacids of Group 15 Elements
Oxyacids of nitrogen: The two most commonly known oxyacids of nitrogen are nitrous
(HNO2) and nitric (HNO3) acid. Nitric acid may be regarded as the contribution of H+
and NO3− and also an adduct of OH− and NO2+ according to the following dissociation:
_ + _
OH + NO2 HNO3 H+ + NO3
In presence of strong acid In neutral solution
e.g., H2SO4 or
in basic medium
H2SO4 apparently dehydrates HNO3 to form NO2+ according to the following equation:
H2SO4 _
HNO3 NO2+ + HSO4 + H2O (solvated)
N N N N N N
O O O O O O O O O O O O
HNO2: It is considerably less stable than nitric acid in the sense that the acid solution
tends to disproportionate to NO and HNO3. It may be noted that there is no change in the
number of OH bonds, and an increase in N−O π-bonding and an associated loss of
effective lpN−lpO repulsion is achieved in the disproportionation reaction:
π∗
O
H
3 O N 2 N O + HO N + H2O
O O
HO OH OH
Figure 17
A large number of phosphoric acids and their salts, phosphates arise by sharing oxygen
atoms at one or two corners of the P4 tetrahedron:
O O O O
O
P P P P P
O OH O O OH
HO HO O O
O O O H
H H H H
H4P2O7 H5P3O10
Pyrophosphoric acid Tripolyphosphoric acid
Figure 18
Metaphosphoric acid, (HPO3)n is prepared by heating Orthophosphoric acid. The
metaphosphate ions have the following structures: O
O
O O O P
O O
P P O O
O P P
O O
O O O
Di-metaphosphate ion
O O Tri-metaphosphate ion
O P O P O
O P O P O
O O
Figure 19
Cl OH
P Cl + 3H2O = P OH + 3HCl
Cl OH
OH
O P H
OH
sp3
Orthophosphorous acid
From the hydrolysis of PCl3, orthophosphorous acid seems to have the trihydroxy
structure. It is readily tautomerized to the P=O oxo form by the overlap of the filled p-
orbital of oxygen and the vacant d-orbital (which is contracted as it is linked with oxygen
atom of high electronegativity) of P. The dibasicity of H3PO3 and its reducing character
supports its structure.
Hypophosphorous acid, which is a dibasic one, is prepared by the following
reaction:
P4 + 3NaOH + 3H2O = PH3 + 3NaH2PO2
H+
H H OH
Hypophophorous acid
Dr. Jishnunil Chakraborty - Assistant Professor - St. Paul’s C. M. College, Kolkata 19
Pyrophosphorous acid is formed by the hydrolysis of P4O6 and has the following
structure:
H H
HO P O P OH
O O
Pyrophosphorous acid
Figure 20
Of the oxyacids of phosphorus, e.g., H3PVO4 (pKa1 = 2.16), H3PIIIO3 (pKa1 =
2.00), and H3PIO2 (pKa1 = 1.00), H3PO4 is the weakest and H3PO2 is the strongest one,
which is the reverse trend as expected from the oxidation state of the central element.
This may be explained from the stand-point of acid weakening due to salvation effect
where H3PO4 has the maximum number of OH groups for this purpose (Figure 21).
H
H
O
OH H
O P OH O
OH H
O
H
H
Figure 21