ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL GOVERNANCE

ASSIGNMENT

Submitted By: Syed Muhammad Umer Munir (BSMT20006)

TABLE OF CONTENTS

1|Page
Critical Evaluation of National Sanitation Policy.....................................................................................3
POSITIVES........................................................................................................................................................3
NEGATIVES.......................................................................................................................................................4
Areas of Improvement......................................................................................................................................4
Potential Threats..............................................................................................................................................4
Conclusion.....................................................................................................................................................5
Pakistan Sanitation and Policy Evaluation Framework..........................................................................5
Policy Context................................................................................................................................................5
Policy Goals....................................................................................................................................................6
Policy Implementation..................................................................................................................................6
Policy Effectiveness.......................................................................................................................................6
Policy Impact.................................................................................................................................................6
Policy Recommendations..............................................................................................................................6
Conclusion.....................................................................................................................................................6
Bennett and Satterfield's framework (2018).............................................................................................7

Critical Evaluation of National Sanitation Policy

INTRODUCTION
Pakistan faces significant challenges in ensuring access to adequate sanitation facilities for its
population. The Government of Pakistan introduced the Sanitation Policy aimed to improve the

2|Page
sanitation situation and implementation of waste reduction, recycle and reuse across the country
for achieving sustainable environment. This critical evaluation assesses the positives, negatives,
areas of improvement, and potential threats associated with this sanitation policy.

POSITIVES
 The policy adopts a comprehensive approach by addressing various aspects of sanitation,
including infrastructure development, hygiene promotion, institutional strengthening, and
behavior change.

 The policy emphasizes equity by targeting marginalized communities and rural areas
where sanitation facilities are inadequate. It acknowledges the importance of ensuring
access to sanitation for all, irrespective of socio-economic status.

 The establishment of the National Sanitation Secretariat and Provincial Sanitation Units
provides a structured institutional framework for policy implementation and coordination
at national and provincial levels.

NEGATIVES
 While the policy outlines broad objectives and strategies, it lacks a detailed
implementation plan specifying timelines, responsibilities, and resource allocation. This
ambiguity may hinder effective implementation on the ground.

 The policy does not provide a clear commitment to allocate sufficient financial resources
for sanitation initiatives. Without adequate funding, the ambitious goals outlined in the
policy may remain unattainable.

 The policy primarily focuses on rural sanitation, overlooking the significant challenges of
urban sanitation in rapidly growing cities. Urban areas face unique sanitation issues, such
as inadequate sewerage systems and solid waste management, which require specific
attention.

Areas of Improvement
 The policy presents an opportunity to engage the private sector in sanitation service
delivery, including the construction and maintenance of sanitation infrastructure. Public-
private partnerships can leverage resources and expertise to accelerate progress towards
sanitation goals.

3|Page
  Sanitation has significant implications for public health, including the prevention of
waterborne diseases. Integrating sanitation interventions with existing health programs
can enhance their effectiveness and maximize health outcomes.

 The policy recognizes the importance of community participation in promoting sanitation

Potential Threats
 Political instability and changes in government priorities may undermine the continuity
of sanitation programs and funding commitments. A lack of political will and sustained
leadership could impede progress towards achieving sanitation targets.

 Deep-rooted socio-cultural beliefs and practices related to sanitation may hinder the
adoption of improved sanitation practices, especially in conservative rural communities.
Overcoming these barriers requires culturally sensitive approaches and sustained
awareness campaigns.

 Climate change poses significant challenges to sanitation infrastructure, particularly in

Conclusion
The Sanitation Policy of Pakistan outlines a comprehensive framework for addressing the
country's sanitation challenges. While it has several strengths, including its equity focus and
institutional framework, there are also notable weaknesses and challenges, such as the lack of
implementation strategy and limited funding allocation. To effectively address these challenges
and capitalize on opportunities, concerted efforts are needed to prioritize sanitation, allocate
adequate resources, engage stakeholders, and promote innovative approaches to sanitation
service delivery. Only through sustained commitment and collaboration can Pakistan achieve its
sanitation goals and improve the well-being of its population.

Pakistan Sanitation and Policy Evaluation Framework

Pakistan's Sanitation Policy represents a crucial step towards addressing the nation's sanitation
challenges comprehensively. By prioritizing universal access to sanitation facilities and
promoting hygiene behavior change, the policy aims to improve the well-being and quality of

4|Page
life for all citizens, particularly those in rural and marginalized communities. The establishment
of the National Sanitation Secretariat and Provincial Sanitation Units demonstrates a
commitment to institutionalize sanitation management at both national and provincial levels.
However, the policy's effectiveness is hampered by a lack of detailed implementation strategies
and inadequate funding allocation, especially for urban sanitation initiatives. Moreover, political
instability and socio-cultural barriers pose significant threats to the policy's successful
implementation. To maximize its impact, the policy should prioritize funding allocation, develop
clear implementation plans, and engage communities through culturally sensitive approaches.
Additionally, integrating sanitation interventions with existing health programs and fostering
public-private partnerships can further enhance the policy's effectiveness in improving sanitation
outcomes across Pakistan.

Policy Context
Pakistan's Sanitation Policy aims to address the country's sanitation challenges comprehensively,
recognizing the need to improve access to adequate sanitation facilities, particularly in rural and
marginalized communities.

Policy Goals
The policy sets out ambitious goals to achieve universal access to sanitation, promote hygiene
behavior change, and strengthen institutional capacity for sanitation management.

Policy Implementation
While the policy establishes a structured institutional framework, including the National
Sanitation Secretariat and Provincial Sanitation Units, it lacks a detailed implementation strategy
with clear timelines, responsibilities, and resource allocation.

Policy Effectiveness
The policy's effectiveness is hindered by limited funding allocation, particularly for urban
sanitation, and a lack of political stability, which may affect continuity and sustained
commitment to sanitation initiatives.

Policy Impact
The policy presents opportunities for public-private partnerships, integration with health
programs, and community participation, which can enhance its impact on sanitation outcomes.
However, socio-cultural barriers and climate change impacts pose significant threats to its
successful implementation.

5|Page
Policy Recommendations
To enhance the policy's effectiveness and impact, recommendations include prioritizing
sanitation funding, developing a detailed implementation plan, addressing socio-cultural barriers
through culturally sensitive approaches, and adapting sanitation systems to climate change
impacts.

Conclusion
Pakistan's Sanitation Policy provides a comprehensive framework for addressing the country's
sanitation challenges. While it has strengths, such as its equity focus and institutional framework,
there are also notable weaknesses and challenges that need to be addressed to achieve
meaningful improvements in sanitation outcomes.

Bennett and Satterfield's framework (2018)

Bennett and Satterfield's framework (2018) provides a structured approach for evaluating policy
effectiveness, equity, responsiveness, and robustness. Applying this framework to Pakistan's Sanitation
Policy reveals both strengths and areas for improvement.

Effectiveness
The effectiveness of Pakistan's Sanitation Policy can be assessed based on its ability to achieve
its intended goals of improving access to sanitation facilities and promoting hygiene behavior
change. While the policy sets ambitious objectives, its effectiveness is hindered by several
factors.
Firstly, the lack of a detailed implementation strategy undermines the policy's effectiveness.
Without clear timelines, responsibilities, and resource allocation, it becomes challenging to
monitor progress and ensure accountability. As a result, there may be delays in implementation
and a failure to achieve desired outcomes within the stipulated time frame.
However, the policy demonstrates some effectiveness through its focus on equity and community
participation. By targeting marginalized communities and engaging local stakeholders in
decision-making processes, the policy aims to address disparities in sanitation access and
promote sustainable solutions tailored to the needs of different communities.

Equity
Equity refers to the fairness and impartiality in the distribution of benefits and burdens of a
policy across different population groups. Pakistan's Sanitation Policy exhibits a commitment to
equity by prioritizing access to sanitation facilities for marginalized communities and rural areas.
The policy acknowledges the disparities in sanitation access and aims to address them through
targeted interventions. By focusing on rural and marginalized communities where sanitation

6|Page
facilities are inadequate, the policy seeks to ensure that the benefits of improved sanitation are
equitably distributed across the population.
However, challenges remain in ensuring equitable access to sanitation, particularly in urban areas
where rapid population growth and inadequate infrastructure exacerbate disparities. Addressing
these disparities requires targeted interventions and sustained efforts to prioritize equity in
resource allocation and policy implementation.

Responsiveness
Responsiveness refers to the policy's ability to adapt to changing circumstances and respond
effectively to emerging challenges. Pakistan's Sanitation Policy exhibits some responsiveness by
recognizing the evolving nature of sanitation issues and incorporating strategies to address them.
The policy acknowledges the need to adapt to climate change impacts, such as flooding, which
can damage sanitation infrastructure and compromise access to sanitation facilities. By
integrating climate resilience measures into sanitation initiatives, the policy demonstrates
responsiveness to emerging challenges and seeks to ensure the sustainability of sanitation
interventions in the face of environmental threats.
However, the lack of a clear implementation strategy hampers the policy's responsiveness by
limiting its ability to adapt to changing circumstances in a timely manner. Without clear
guidelines and mechanisms for monitoring and evaluation, the policy may struggle to identify
emerging challenges and adjust its approach accordingly.

Robustness
Robustness refers to the policy's ability to withstand internal and external pressures and maintain
its effectiveness over time. Pakistan's Sanitation Policy exhibits some robustness through its
institutional framework and focus on community participation.
The establishment of the National Sanitation Secretariat and Provincial Sanitation Units provides
a structured institutional framework for policy implementation and coordination. By
institutionalizing sanitation management at both national and provincial levels, the policy
enhances its robustness by ensuring continuity and consistency in decision-making processes.

7|Page