Tremor
Tremor
Tremor
com
Essential Tremor
Updated: Feb 24, 2023
Author: Natalya V Shneyder, MD; Chief Editor: Selim R Benbadis, MD
Overview
Practice Essentials
The task force on Tremor of the International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society defines tremor as an involuntary,
rhythmic, oscillatory movement of a body part.
Essential tremor, the most common movement disorder, is a syndrome of unknown etiology characterized by a slowly
progressive action tremor (postural and/or kinetic tremor), usually affecting both upper extremities. An isolated tremor
syndrome of bilateral upper limb action tremor present for at least 3 years is a requirement for the diagnosis of essential
tremor.[1] It is recommended that tremor of less than 3 years' duration that otherwise fulfills criteria for essential tremor be
labeled an indeterminate tremor.[2] Fundamental debate exists as to whether essential tremor is a neurodegenerative
disease.
Essential tremor is considered to be monosymptomatic (tremor only). Patients with neurological signs of uncertain
significance, such as mild memory impairment, mild balance problems, or subtle body posturing that could be dystonic, fall
into the category of ET plus.
ET plus syndromes do not include other clearly defined tremor syndromes such as dystonic tremor or task-specific tremor.
The concept of ET plus is controversial, as many essential tremor patients with longer duration of disease may experience
mild cognitive problems, gait impairment or resting component of the tremor. There are currently no specific markers that
exist to differentiate ET vs ET plus.[3]
Patients with essential tremor may exhibit the following signs and symptoms:
Tremor begins in one upper extremity and then affects the other upper extremity; tremor rarely extends from an upper
extremity to the ipsilateral lower extremity
Tremor may initially be intermittent, occurring during periods of emotional activation, and then becomes persistent
over time
A mild degree of tremor asymmetry is not unusual
Tremor may also affect the head, voice, jaw, lips, and face (but not isolated to these body parts)
The tremor frequency is fixed at any point in time
The tremor amplitude is highly variable, worsened by emotion, hunger, fatigue, temperature extremes; the amplitude
gradually increases over years; ethanol intake temporarily reduces tremor amplitude in about 50-70% of cases
Typically, there is a degree of voluntary control; tremor may be suppressed by performing skilled manual tasks
Tremor resolves when the body part relaxes and during sleep
Muscle tone and reflexes are normal; there is no rigidity, bradykinesia can be present without other signs of
Parkinson’s disease and with no sequence effect [4]
Diagnosis
Essential tremor is usually diagnosed based on family history and examination; thus, laboratory and imaging studies are
usually not required. No biologic markers exist for essential tremor. Electromyography or accelerometry can be used to
assess tremor frequency, rhythmicity, and amplitude but is not part of the routine evaluation.
Laboratory testing
If the patient’s family history and examination findings are not indicative of essential tremor, consider the following laboratory
studies:
Imaging studies
Head computed tomography (CT) scanning and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) findings are normal in essential tremor.
Perform MRI if the tremor has an acute onset or stepwise progression. MRI also helps to exclude structural and
inflammatory lesions (including multiple sclerosis) and Wilson disease.
Single-photon emission CT (SPECT) scanning using 123I-ioflupain (DaTSCAN) may be used to support a diagnosis of
parkinsonism, thereby reducing misdiagnosis of essential tremor in Parkinson disease.[5, 6, 7]
Management
Primidone and propranolol are the cornerstones of maintenance medical therapy for essential tremor. These medications
provide benefit in reducing tremor amplitude in approximately 50–70% of patients.[8]
Some patients require only intermittent tremor reduction (eg, to attend a meeting or engage in a social activity). For these
patients, a cocktail or beer prior to the activity may be sufficient, or they may take propranolol (10–40 mg) approximately one
to one half hour prior to the event.
Alcohol consumption is not an appropriate maintenance therapy for patients who seek tremor reduction throughout the day.
[9]
Pharmacotherapy
Surgery
Consider surgical intervention in patients with disabling, medically refractory upper extremity tremor. The procedures of
choice are thalamic ventralis intermedius (VIM) nucleus deep brain stimulation and MRI-guided transcranial focused
ultrasound thalamotomy.[10]
Background
Essential tremor is the most common movement disorder. It is a syndrome characterized by a slowly progressive postural
and/or kinetic tremor, usually affecting both upper extremities. The etiology of essential tremor is not known, and
fundamental debate exists as to whether essential tremor is a neurodegenerative disease. (See Etiology and Presentation.)
Bilateral, largely symmetrical, postural (occurring with voluntary maintenance of a position against gravity) or kinetic
(occurring during voluntary movement) tremor involving hands and forearms that is visible and persistent
Possible additional tremor in head but absence of abnormal posturing
At least 3-year history of tremor
The presence of known causes of enhanced physiologic tremor, including current or recent exposure to drugs that
are known to cause tremor or a drug-withdrawal state
Historic or clinical evidence of psychogenic (functional) tremor
Convincing evidence of sudden onset or evidence of stepwise deterioration
Primary orthostatic tremor
Isolated voice tremor
Isolated position- or task-specific tremors, including occupational tremors and primary writing tremor
Isolated tongue or chin tremor
Isolated leg tremor
Essential tremor has been hypothesized to be a risk factor for the development of Parkinson disease. Some patients with
Parkinson disease report a long-standing history of bilateral upper extremity postural tremor. Moreover, in a large cohort
study by the Mayo Clinic, the risk of essential tremor was significantly increased in relatives of patients with Parkinson
disease with younger onset and in relatives of patients with tremor-predominant Parkinson disease. (See Etiology and
Presentation.)[11]
Without biologic markers for these diseases, however, determining whether long-standing postural tremor is part of a
Parkinson disease syndrome or reflects the presence of both essential tremor and Parkinson disease is not possible. (See
Workup.)
An association between essential tremor and dystonia has also been suggested. Some patients with focal dystonia, such as
torticollis, have mild, bilateral upper extremity postural tremors. Again, however, without biologic markers for these diseases,
determining whether postural tremor is part of a focal dystonia syndrome or reflects the presence of both dystonia and
essential tremor is not possible.
Etiology
The etiology and pathophysiology of essential tremor is not well understood. No pathologic findings are known to be
consistently associated with essential tremor. However, the following has been hypothesized:
Essential tremor is the result of an abnormally functioning central oscillator, which is located in the Guillain Mollaret
triangle near the brainstem and involves the inferior olivary nucleus
Cerebellar-brainstem-thalamic-cortical circuits are likely involved
The pathophysiology of essential tremor is heterogeneous [12, 13]
Harmane, a heterocyclic amine (HCA), is a potent tremor-producing neurotoxin. It is often found in the human diet. Blood
concentrations have been found to be elevated in patients with essential tremor as compared with controls.[14] The most
likely etiology appears to be alterations in metabolism rather than increased dietary intake.
In patients with essential tremor, [18 F]fluorodeoxyglucose positron emission tomography (18F-FDG-PET) scan studies
identified increased glucose consumption in the medulla. In addition, [15 O]H2 O PET scan studies demonstrated an
increase in medullary regional cerebral blood flow in subjects with essential tremor (only after the administration of ethanol),
and bilateral overactivity of cerebellar circuitry.
Fundamental debate exists as to whether essential tremor is a neurodegenerative disease. Data suggesting that it is
neurodegenerative includes postmortem findings of pathologic abnormalities in the brainstem and cerebellum,[13] including
Lewy bodies in the locus ceruleus, loss of Purkinje cells, and abnormalities of the dentate nucleus[15, 16] ; reduction in
cerebellar cortical N-acetylaspartate/total creatine (NAA/tCR)[14] ; white matter changes on diffusion tensor imaging;[17] and
clinical studies demonstrating an association with cognitive[18, 19] and gait changes.
Conflicting data argues against essential tremor being a neurodegenerative disease. This data includes improvement of gait
abnormalities with ethanol administration,[20] lack of gray matter volume loss on voxel-based morphometry,[21] failure to
confirm prominent presence of Lewy bodies in the locus ceruleus,[13] and other pathologic findings.[22]
Genetics
Essential tremor probably represents a syndrome, and multiple etiologies will likely be identified. Many of these causes are
probably genetic.
Essential tremor is familial in 50-70% of cases. Transmission is autosomal dominant, with incomplete penetrance. Some
cases are sporadic with unknown etiology. Twin studies suggest that genetic and environmental factors contribute to the
pathogenesis. Non-Mendelian transmission in kindreds with an apparent autosomal dominant inheritance of essential tremor
was demonstrated in one study.[23]
Variations in methodology (ie, assessment procedures and diagnostic criteria) account for wide variation in findings; reported
studies have found that 17% to almost 100% of cases are familial.
One study demonstrated that the frequency of having an affected relative increased from 67.7% to 96% after repeated and
varied questioning followed by direct interviews of family members.
An association with a polymorphism in the HS1-BP3 gene has been reported, but this has not been confirmed.[23, 27]
In one family with levodopa-responsive, autosomal dominant, Lewy-body parkinsonism, a chromosome arm 4p haplotype
that segregates with the disease was identified. This haplotype also occurred in individuals in the family who did not have
parkinsonism but rather a postural tremor consistent with essential tremor. This suggests that in some cases, postural tremor
can be an alternative phenotype of the same mutation.
LINGO1 (leucine-rich repeat and Ig-containing domain 1) variant rs9652490 has been identified as a risk factor for familial
essential tremor.[28, 29, 30]
Epidemiology
Occurrence in the United States
Assessments of the prevalence and incidence of essential tremor vary widely depending on ascertainment methodology and
diagnostic criteria employed in detecting the condition.
The prevalence of essential tremor has been reported to differ considerably in individuals living in various regions of the
United States (New York, Mississippi, and Arizona), with estimates for ages > 60 years ranging widely, from 1.3% to 20.5%.
[31]
International occurrence
In 2020, the global prevalence of essential tremor in the general population was estimated to be 0.32%, ranging from 0.04%
in people younger than 20 years to 2.87% in those aged 80 years and older. The total number of people suffering from
essential tremor worldwide was 24.91 million in 2020.[32]
Race-related demographics
Race has not been extensively studied in essential tremor. One evaluation of a multiethnic group (White, African American,
Hispanic) found differences in the presence or absence of head tremor and a variable tremor score among the subgroups.
White subjects had a tremor score that was 5.3 points lower than that for nonwhites. Head tremors were present in 25% of
Whites and 29% of Hispanics and were absent in African Americans.[33]
Sex-related demographics
Essential tremor affects both sexes with equal frequency. However, head tremor may be more frequent in women, and
postural hand tremor may be more severe in men. Childhood essential tremor may be more frequent in boys than in girls.
[34]
Age-related demographics
The prevalence of essential tremor increases with age. Data has suggested bimodal peaks in age of onset—one in late
adolescence to early adulthood and a second in older adulthood. The mean age at presentation is 35-45 years. One
comparison of a population-based cohort with patients at a tertiary care center found a significant bimodal presentation only
at the center, with the population-based study revealing a significant peak only in older adults. This suggests that the
bimodal peak may be attributable to preferential referral of young-onset essential tremor patients to tertiary centers.[35]
Essential tremor usually manifests by age 65 years and virtually always by age 70 years. Tremor amplitude slowly increases
over time, but tremor frequency decreases with increasing age. An 8–12 Hz tremor is seen in young adults, and a 6-8 Hz
tremor is seen in elderly individuals. Although essential tremor is progressive, no association has been found between age of
onset and severity or disability.
A strong correlation between age of onset before 20 years and family history of essential tremor was found in an
environmental epidemiologic study of 195 essential tremor cases.[36]
Prognosis
Mortality rates have been thought to be the same between patients with essential tremor and the general population.
However, in a longitudinal, prospective study of patients aged 65 and older from 3 communities in central Spain, the risk of
mortality in persons with essential tremor was found to be increased.[37] Further studies are needed.
Disability from essential tremor is common.[38] Of individuals with essential tremor, 85% report significant changes in their
livelihood and socializing, and 15% report being seriously disabled by the condition.
Decreased quality of life results from loss of function and from embarrassment. In a study of hereditary essential tremor,
60% of affected individuals did not seek employment; 25% changed jobs or took early retirement; 65% did not dine out; 30%
did not attend parties, shop alone, partake of a favorite hobby or sport, or use public transportation; and 20% stopped
driving.
Presentation
History
The following characteristics can be noted in patients with essential tremor:
Visible tremor is generally pathologic, but distinguishing between essential tremor and enhanced physiologic tremor can be
difficult. Causes of enhanced physiologic tremor, including medications, stimulants such as caffeine, hyperthytoidism, fever,
and anxiety, and should be excluded.
Physical Examination
Essential tremor is considered to be monosymptomatic (tremor only), although some patients have abnormalities in gait and
balance. If patients have such abnormalities, the diagnosis should be carefully considered because these could be clues to
an alternative diagnosis.
The tremor is characteristically postural (occurring with voluntary maintenance of a position against gravity) and/or kinetic
(occurring during voluntary movement). It usually resolves when the body part relaxes. Other characteristics of essential
tremor include the following:
There are data calling into question the tenet that essential tremor is truly monosymptomatic. Findings associated with
essential tremor include changes in cognition, personality,[39] mood,[40] hearing,[41, 42] and motor symptoms associated
with cerebellar outflow.[43]
DDx
Diagnostic Considerations
Conditions to consider in the differential diagnosis of essential tremor include the following:
Cerebellar tremor
Dystonia and dystonic tremors
Enhanced physiologic tremor
Isolated chin tremor
Isolated voice tremor
Movement disorders
Orthostatic tremor
Palatal tremor
Rubral tremor
Writer's tremor and other task-specific tremors
Psychogenic tremor
B-12 deficiency
Hyperthyroidism
Hyperparathyroidism
Hypocalcemia
Hyponatremia
Kidney disease
Liver disease
Alcohol
Arsenic
Caffeine
Dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane (DDT)
Lead
Nicotine
Toluene
Withdrawal of alcohol, cocaine
Differential Diagnoses
Drug induced tremor
Dystonic tremor
Parkinson Disease
Parkinson-Plus Syndromes
Wilson Disease
Workup
Workup
Approach Considerations
No biologic markers exist for essential tremor. If the family history and examination findings are indicative of essential tremor,
no laboratory or imaging studies are required. However, if the family history and examination findings are not indicative of
essential tremor, laboratory and imaging studies should be considered.[44, 45]
Procedures
Electromyography or accelerometry can be used to assess tremor frequency, rhythmicity, and amplitude but is not part of the
routine evaluation.
Imaging Studies
Findings on computed tomography (CT) scanning and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the head are normal in
essential tremor. MRI helps to exclude structural and inflammatory lesions (including multiple sclerosis) and Wilson disease.
MRI should be performed if the tremor has acute onset or stepwise progression.
Although the classic resting tremor of Parkinson disease is different in many aspects from essential tremor, Parkinson’s
disease often does cause postural and action tremors in addition to resting tremors and may be difficult to distinguish from
essential tremor if other signs are absent or minimal. Single-photon emission CT (SPECT) scanning using ioflupain 123 I
(DaTSCAN) is a US Food and Drug Administration (FDA)–approved procedure that can help determine whether there is loss
of dopamine neurons as occurs in Parkinsons disease and related disorders (and not in essential tremor), thus helping to
distinguish these conditions.[5, 6, 7, 46]
Midbrain ultrasonography has been suggested as a tool to differentiate essential tremor from Parkinson’s disease as a result
of a study finding that high substantia nigra hyperechogenicity has a high positive predictive value for Parkinson disease.
Another study found a significant increase in substantia nigra hyperechogenicity in patients with essential tremor compared
with controls.[47, 48, 49, 50]
Other Tests
In 2017, researchers described an electrophysiological measure that can discriminate Parkinson's disease tremor and
essential tremor with high diagnostic accuracy. The tremor stability index, derived from kinematic measurements of
tremulous activity, was tested in a cohort comprising 16 rest tremor recordings in tremor-dominant Parkinson's disease and
20 postural tremor recordings in essential tremor, and validated on a second, independent cohort comprising a further 55
tremulous Parkinson's disease and essential tremor recordings. The index's maximum sensitivity, specificity and accuracy
were 95%, 95% and 92%, respectively.[51]
Treatment
Approach Considerations
Primidone and propranolol are the cornerstones of maintenance medical therapy for essential tremor. These medications
provide good benefit, reducing tremor amplitude in approximately 50–70% of patients.[52, 53, 54]
Some patients require only intermittent tremor reduction, such as when attending a meeting or engaging in a social activity.
For these patients, a cocktail or beer prior to the activity may be sufficient. An alternative is propranolol (10–40 mg)
approximately one to one half hour prior to the event. Alcohol consumption is not an appropriate maintenance therapy for
patients who seek tremor reduction throughout the day.[9]
Surgery
For patients with disabling, medically refractory upper extremity tremor, surgery is considered. MRI-guided focused
ultrasound thalamotomy and thalamic ventralis intermedius nucleus deep brain stimulation are the procedures of choice.
Both procedures offer high rates of tremor reduction in the contralateral arm. Information suggests that they are also useful
in reducing head and voice tremor.[55]
Bilateral thalamotomy is associated with a relatively high risk of dysarthria, occurring in as many as 29% of patients, and a
risk of cerebral hemorrhage. The potential advantage of thalamic stimulation is that it is adjustable. If the stimulation causes
an adverse effect, the stimulation can be modified or discontinued
In 1996, Benabid et al initially proposed that thalamic stimulation might be a useful procedure on the opposite side in
patients who have already had a unilateral thalamotomy, in an effort to avoid the potentially serious complications of bilateral
thalamotomy.[56] Thalamic stimulation now is considered a procedure of choice.
Focused ultrasound thalamotomy is an alternative to thalamic stimulation. According to one randomized trial, patients who
underwent MRI-guided focused ultrasound thalamotomy for essential tremor experienced a 47% improvement in composite
hand tremor scores 3 months later. Patients who underwent a sham procedure experienced a 0.1% improvement. After 1
year, improvement was still significant, decreasing only to 40%.[10]
If the patient has a relative contraindication to propranolol, such as pulmonary disease or heart block, starting with primidone
is preferable.
The chosen medication, primidone or propranolol, is introduced at a low dose and increased slowly until sufficient benefit is
achieved or the usual maximum dosage is reached. If no benefit is derived, the patient is completely weaned off the drug
before the alternative medication is started. If a partial benefit from the first drug occurs, the second medication is added and
slowly increased until sufficient benefit is achieved or the usual maximum dosage is reached. If no additional benefit occurs,
the patient is weaned off the second medication.
If sufficient benefit is not achieved with primidone and/or propranolol, other medications are considered based on the
severity of the residual tremor. A beta1-receptor antagonist can be tried if necessary; in general, however, beta1-receptor
antagonists are more effective than placebo but are not as effective as beta2-receptor antagonists. (Metoprolol, a relatively
selective beta1-receptor antagonist, may be useful in patients with asthma or other pulmonary conditions.)
If the tremor is mild and more of a nuisance than it is disabling, a benzodiazepine (usually clonazepam) is considered. For
patients with head tremor, cervical injections of botulinum toxin may be given.
Propranolol
Winkler and Young first noted remarkable tremor reduction in a patient treated with propranolol for paroxysmal atrial
tachycardia.[53]
Propranolol was studied in 13 Level-I (randomized, controlled ) studies in a total of 255 patients with essential tremor and
classified as efficacious and clinically useful.[8]
In a double-blind, crossover study, propranolol at doses from 60–240 mg/day reduced tremor in 75% of patients with
essential tremor. In a dose-response study, 240–320 mg/day was found to be the optimal dose range, with no additional
benefits above 320 mg/day.
Average tremor reduction is 50–70%, but while some patients experience marked tremor reduction, others derive no benefit
from the drug. The mechanism of action is probably related to peripheral beta2-receptor antagonism.
Once an effective maintenance dose of propranolol is achieved, switching to the long-acting preparation is considered. The
long-acting formulation of propranolol has an efficacy similar to that of the standard formulation and may allow the patient to
take fewer daily doses. An alternative is to use the long-acting formulation from the beginning, but this requires multiple
prescriptions and is more cumbersome.
Primidone
O'Brien et al initially observed that primidone, when administered to a patient with epilepsy and essential tremor, reduced
tremor. In a placebo-controlled study, primidone significantly reduced tremor in otherwise untreated patients and patients
treated with propranolol. Doses greater than 250 mg/day did not provide additional benefit.[58]
Primidone was studied in 8 Level-I studies that included a total of 274 patients with essential tremor, comparing primidone
with placebo classified as efficacious and clinically useful.[8]
Primidone’s mechanism of action is unknown. Active metabolites are phenylethylmalonamide (PEMA) and phenobarbital.
PEMA has no effect on tremor, and phenobarbital has only modest effect on tremor. Tremor reduction is not correlated with
serum levels of primidone or phenobarbital.
Adverse effects, if any, usually occur early in the course of treatment, possibly with the first dose. Acute adverse effects are
minimized by starting at a very low dose and then slowly increasing the dose. However, some patients are unable to tolerate
primidone even at very low doses.
Common adverse effects include sedation, dizziness, and ataxia at higher doses.
Topiramate
Topiramate is an anticonvulsant medication that enhances gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) activity, carbonic anhydrase
inhibition, antagonism of alpha-amino-3-hydroxy-5-methylisoxazole-4 propionic acid/kainite receptors, and blockage of
voltage-dependent calcium and sodium channels.
Topiramate was studied in 4 placebo-controlled Level-I studies in a total of 322 patients with essential tremor, as
monotherapy or add-on treatmentand classified as efficacious and clinically useful in dose more then 200 mg a day.[8]
However, clinical trials indicate a fairly substantial dropout rate of 40% because of adverse effects such as cognitive difficulty
and somnolence.
Alcohol
The mechanism of tremor reduction by alcohol is unknown. In a double-blind study, the 6-carbon alcohol methylpentynol did
not have any effect on tremor. This suggests that the alcohol group of ethanol is not the element that provides antitremor
activity and that the antitremor effect of ethanol is not due to sedation.
Restricted intra-arterial ethanol administration does not reduce tremor in the perfused limb. This suggests that ethanol’s
effect is mediated centrally.
Additional Medications
Many other medications have been reported to be of benefit in the treatment of essential tremor. Most of the evidence,
however, has come from case reports and small, open-label studies.
Gabapentin
A double-blind, crossover trial comparing gabapentin (400 mg TID) with propranolol (40 mg TID) found that both drugs
demonstrated significant and comparable reductions in tremor compared with baseline. However, a double-blind, placebo-
controlled, crossover study identified no difference between gabapentin and placebo.
Benzodiazepines, particularly clonazepam and alprazolam, are used commonly in the treatment of essential tremor, but their
effectiveness is limited. They may reduce the anxiety that can amplify tremor amplitude.
Adverse effects include sedation, ataxia, habit formation, risk of withdrawal symptoms with abrupt discontinuation
Alprazolam - Level B (probably effective); "recommended with caution due to abuse potential"
Clonazepam - Level C (possibly effective) but "should be used with caution due to abuse potential and possible
withdrawal symptoms"
Botulinum toxin
Botulinum toxin has been evaluated for the treatment of essential tremor. Its use in the treatment of tremor of the upper
extremities is limited because it commonly causes weakness. It is more useful in the treatment of head tremor because it
often provides benefit without unwanted, troublesome weakness.
By MDS evidence-based review of treatments, botulinum toxin type A was considered likely efficacious for upper limb tremor.
Botulinum toxin type A was studied in 3 placebo-controlled, Level-I studies that included a total of 168 patients with essential
tremor refractory to oral drugs.[8]
Mirtazapine
In a small, open-label case series, mirtazapine was reported to reduce tremor in patients with essential tremor and
Parkinson disease.
Clozapine
In a randomized, double-blind, crossover study, tremor was reduced significantly by clozapine in 13 of 15 patients with drug-
resistant essential tremor. The investigators compared a single 12.5-mg dose of clozapine with placebo.
A significant reduction of tremor was reported with long-term (open-label) clozapine therapy (39.9 mg/day). No tolerance was
observed over 15 months.
Adverse effects include bradycardia and seizures with higher dose. There is potential for severe neutropenia, thus clozapine
is only used in refractory cases and under close monitoring.
Level C (possibly effective) “only for refractory cases of limb tremor in ET due to the risk of agranulocytosis”
T-type calcium channel blocking agents are in trials for essential tremor management. T-type calcium channels are mostly
neuronal and have significantly less cardiovascular effect. T-type calcium channels are present in the thalamus, cerebellum,
and cortex, and thought to play a role in rhythmic neuronal firing. Several agents are currently in phase I–II clinical trials with
promising results.
Modulators of GABA-A receptors have been evaluated for essential tremor. These drugs potentiate both synaptic and
extrasynaptic receptors. Physiologically, this class reduces occipital beta activity, a possibly biomarker for tremor.[59]
In a study by Goldman et al of thalamotomy in 8 patients with moderate to severe essential tremor, the condition in all of the
patients was reduced to a mild tremor or disappeared completely. Mild persistent dysarthria was seen in 2, and a "mild
verbal cognitive defect" was seen in 1.
Stereotactic thalamotomy is less expensive than deep brain stimulation, no hardware remains, and it has been
demonstrated to provide long-term efficacy. Potential adverse effects include intracerebral hemorrhage, motor weakness,
dystonia, speech disturbance, and memory loss.
In a study of 14 patients with essential tremor, Ondo et al reported an average 83% reduction in contralateral arm tremor
following unilateral thalamic deep brain stimulation.[42]
Pahwa et al reported good results with bilateral thalamic deep brain stimulation in 9 patients with essential tremor. Patients
experienced 68% improvement in hand tremor following the first surgery and 75% improvement in the opposite hand
following the second surgery. Complications were noted in 5 patients and included asymptomatic intracranial hematoma (1
patient), postoperative seizures (1 patient), hematoma over the implanted pulse generator (1 patient), lead repositioning (1
patient), and implantable pulse generator (IPG) malfunction (1 patient). Adverse effects related to stimulation were mild and
resolved with the adjustment of stimulation parameters.
Two deep brain stimulation devices are approved by the FDA to reduce the symptoms of Parkinson disease and essential
tremor. The first was approved in 1997 and the second in 2015.[60]
In the study, adverse effects, including ataxia, dysarthria, and gait disturbance, were more common with thalamotomy (42%)
than with deep brain stimulation (26%); adverse effects were persistent in 31% of people undergoing thalamotomy; and
those occurring after deep brain stimulation were almost always controlled by adjusting stimulation parameters. Paresthesias
were persistent in 19% of patients undergoing thalamotomy and were avoidable in deep brain stimulation by stimulation
modification.
Taha et al evaluated thalamic deep brain stimulation contralateral to thalamotomy in 23 patients (6 with Parkinson disease,
15 with essential tremor, and 2 with multiple sclerosis); of 20 patients with bilateral limb tremor, 85% improved to having no
tremor or only stress-induced tremor.
In a prospective study, Schuurman et al concluded that, although thalamotomy and thalamic stimulation are equally effective
for tremor suppression, stimulation results in greater functional improvement and has fewer adverse effects. In the study, the
investigators compared thalamic stimulation and thalamotomy in a prospective, randomized study of 68 patients with
Parkinson disease, essential tremor, or multiple sclerosis.
The investigators found that functional status improved more in the thalamic stimulation group. Tremor was suppressed
completely or almost completely in 30 of 33 patients who underwent thalamic stimulation, compared with 27 of 34 patients in
the thalamotomy group. One patient in the stimulation group died perioperatively after an intracerebral hemorrhage.
In a long-term study of a series of patients who underwent thalamic stimulation, the rates of stimulator reoperations,
explants, and device failures were relatively high, suggesting that long-term evaluations may be necessary to assess
definitively the relative benefits and complications of these procedures.
Another study found gamma knife thalamotomy to be safe and effective in patients who were not eligible for open surgical
techniques and had medically refractory tremor.
The main advantage of thalamic deep brain stimulation is that it is adjustable; adverse effects from stimulation can be
controlled by reducing stimulation. Disadvantages of deep brain stimulation include expense, the use of a foreign body
implant, the need to optimize parameters, and hardware maintenance, including battery replacement after several years.[55]
Elias et al conducted a randomized parallel study of unilateral MRI-guided focused ultrasound thalamotomy versus sham
procedure in 81 patients with medically refractory moderate-severe upper limb tremor attributed to essential tremor.[10]
Seventy-six patients were included in the analysis. Outcomes were based on the tremor score (on a scale ranging from 0 to
32, with higher scores indicating more severe tremor) was derived from the Clinical Rating Scale of Tremor( CRST) , Part A
(three items: resting, postural, and action or intention components of hand tremor), and the CRST, Part B (five tasks
involving handwriting, drawing, and pouring)
Hand-tremor scores improved more after focused ultrasound thalamotomy (from18.1 points at baseline to 9.6 at 3 months)
than after the sham procedure (from 16.0 to 15.8 points). The improvement in the thalamotomy group was maintained at 12
months.
Adverse events associated with focused ultrasound thalamotomy included gait disturbance in 36% of patients and
paresthesias or numbness in 38%; these adverse events persisted at 12 months in 9% and 14% of patients, respectively.[10]
A significant advantage of focused US over stereotactic radiofrequency surgery is that it allows intraoperative clinical
assessment and graded lesioning procedure.[61]
For upper limb tremor, unilateral MRI-guided focused ultrasound thalamotomy was considered likely efficacious with an
acceptable risk with specialized monitoring.[8]
The open-label PROSPECT trial recruited 265 patients from 26 centers across North America and assessed the longitudinal
and long-term applicability of in-home use of the Cala Two device. Participants in the trial used the Cala device twice daily
for three months. After three months of use, 22% improvement in the TETRAS and 28% improvement in the Bain and
Findley ADL scores were observed. The physiological data correlated significantly with the clinical ratings and there was a
50% reduction in tremor amplitude in nearly 54% of patients.[62]
The Cala system is not recommended in patients with implanted devices such as a pacemaker, defibrillator, or deep brain
stimulator and can’t be used in active seizure disorder, pregnancy, skin eruptions, open wounds, lesions, or infected skin
areas.[62]
Adaptive aids, such as Gyenno Spoon, can also be helpful for patients who have not experienced adequate benefit with
other treatments.
Follow-Up
Essential tremor is slowly progressive; therefore, medication doses may need to be adjusted over time. Additionally, loss of
medication benefit and long-term adverse effects are not uncommon. Adverse effects, including depression and male
impotence, should be monitored in patients on propranolol.
Ongoing attention to activities of daily living, as well as to social and psychological adaptation, is warranted. The frequency
of follow-up must be individualized.
Essential tremor is often familial; follow-up with family members may be appropriate. Concerns about disability arising in
family members may need to be addressed.
Medication
Medication Summary
Beta-adrenergic blockers (principally propranolol) and primidone are the first-line treatments for essential tremor. Each
provides good benefit in 50–70% of cases and neither has been demonstrated to be unequivocally superior to the other.
Adverse effects are more prominent early in treatment with primidone but are more prominent later in treatment with
propranolol. Starting with propranolol is preferable in younger individuals, and primidone is commonly started first in older
patients.
Patients who require medication treatment are usually started on one of these medications. The drug is introduced at a low
dose and is increased slowly until complete response, intolerability, or usual maximum dose is attained. If some benefit is
achieved but is incomplete, the other medication may be added, and slowly increased in an effort to achieve maximum
benefit. Treatment with both drugs has been shown to be effective in patients who have had an insufficient response to one.
Patients should not expect complete resolution of symptoms.
More evidence exists to support effectiveness in upper extremity tremor than in head or lower extremity tremor. A decrease
in tremor amplitude is the usual response, although some evidence indicates that primidone may decrease tremor frequency
as well.
For patients who do not achieve an adequate response with primidone and propranolol, the authors try topiramate.
Gabapentin and clonazepam may also be tried.
Beta-Blockers, Nonselective
Class Summary
The mechanism of action in the reduction of essential tremor is not known. The action is hypothesized to be mediated
primarily by peripheral beta2 adrenoreceptors, but some evidence indicates that beta1-receptor antagonists such as
metoprolol also have some efficacy. Peripheral beta2 adrenoreceptors are located in the extrafusal muscle fibers and on the
intrafusal fibers of the muscle spindles.
In general, beta1-receptor antagonists are more effective than placebo but are not as effective as beta2-receptor
antagonists. Metoprolol, a relatively selective beta1-receptor antagonist, may be useful in patients with asthma and other
pulmonary conditions. May be used as monotherapy or in combination with primidone.
Anticonvulsants, Other
Class Summary
Some agents in this class have demonstrated tremor-suppressing effects. Their mechanism of action is unknown, but it
presumably involves the CNS.
Primidone (Mysoline)
Primidone is metabolized to phenobarbital and PEMA. It has tremor-suppressing activity independent of plasma
concentrations of phenobarbital and is thought to be superior to phenobarbital. PEMA is not tremorolytic. Primidone is
believed to have an independent mechanism for its effect on tremor.
It is strongly recommended that treatment with primidone be initiated with low doses because adverse effects at initiation of
treatment are common. Start with one quarter or one half of a 50-mg tablet at bedtime and increase the dose slowly every
week. Alternatively, introduce primidone using a 250 mg/5 mL suspension. Start with 1 drop at bedtime and increase the
dose by 1 drop each night for 20 nights. Then convert the patient to a 50-mg tablet and increase the dose slowly every week.
For patients who initially respond to primidone but later develop a tolerance to it, increasing the dose to as high as 1000
mg/day in an effort to regain benefit is advisable.
Clonazepam (Klonopin)
Benzodiazepines, particularly clonazepam, are commonly used in treating essential tremors, but their effectiveness is
limited. Clonazepam may probably work to reduce anxiety, which can amplify tremor amplitude. May also enhance GABA
activity.
When are lab studies indicated for the diagnosis of essential tremor?
What is the role of single-photon emission CT (SPECT) using 123I-ioflupain (DaTSCAN) in the diagnosis of essential
tremor?
Which medications are used as maintenance therapy for the essential tremor?
What are the treatment options for essential tremor only requiring intermittent tremor reduction?
What are the Movement Disorders Society inclusion criteria for diagnosis of essential tremor?