Embu County
Embu County
Embu County
COVID-19
2022
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
KIPPRA in Brief
The Kenya Institute for Public Policy Research and Analysis (KIPPRA) is an
autonomous institute whose primary mission is to conduct public policy research
leading to policy advice. KIPPRA’s mission is to produce consistently high-quality
analysis of key issues of public policy and to contribute to the achievement
of national long-term development objectives by positively influencing the
decision-making process. These goals are met through effective dissemination
of recommendations resulting from analysis and by training policy analysts in
the public sector. KIPPRA therefore produces a body of well-researched and
documented information on public policy, and in the process assists in formulating
long-term strategic perspectives. KIPPRA serves as a centralized source from
which the Government and the private sector may obtain information and advice
on public policy issues.
Published 2022
© Kenya Institute for Public Policy Research and Analysis
Bishops Garden Towers, Bishops Road
PO Box 56445-00200 Nairobi, Kenya
tel: +254 20 2719933/4; fax: +254 20 2719951
email: [email protected]
website: http://www.kippra.org
The KIPPRA Special Reports Series deals with specific issues that are of policy
concern. The reports provide in-depth survey results and/or analysis of policy
issues. They are meant to help policy analysts in their research work and assist
policy makers in evaluating various policy options. Deliberate effort is made to
simplify the presentation in the reports so that issues discussed can be easily
grasped by a wide audience. KIPPRA appreciates any comments and suggestions
arising from this report.
ii
Table of Contents
iii
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
6. Infrastructure........................................................................... 58
6.1 Transport Sector............................................................................................ 58
6.1.1 Characteristics of the Sector.......................................................................... 58
6.1.2 Opportunities in Infrastructure.....................................................................61
6.1.3 Emerging Issues.............................................................................................61
6.1.4 Recommendations......................................................................................... 62
6.2 Information and Communication Technology............................................. 62
6.2.1 Characteristics of the Sector.......................................................................... 62
6.2.2 Opportunities in ICT..................................................................................... 63
6.2.3 Recommendations......................................................................................... 63
8. Tourism.....................................................................................72
8.1 Characteristic of the Sector........................................................................... 72
8.2 Opportunities with COVID-19 in Tourism................................................... 72
8.3 Emerging Issues ........................................................................................... 72
8.4 Recommendations......................................................................................... 73
9. Health .......................................................................................74
9.1 Characteristics of the Sector.......................................................................... 74
9.2 Opportunities with COVID-19 in Health Sector...........................................80
9.3 Emerging Issues ...........................................................................................80
9.4 Recommendations......................................................................................... 81
iv
11. Social Protection ...................................................................... 90
11.1 Characteristics of the Sector..........................................................................90
11.2 Opportunities with COVID-19 in Social Protection ..................................... 93
11.3 Emerging Issues .......................................................................................... 93
11.4 Recommendations........................................................................................ 93
v
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
List of Tables
vi
Table 10.5: Percentage distribution of residents 3 years and above who had ever attended school by
highest level reached, and sex for Embu County (%)..................................................... 86
Table 11.1: The proportion of households by the first severe shock in the county................................ 91
Table 11.2: The proportion of households that received cash transfers by source, and household
headship...........................................................................................................................92
Table 12.1: Distribution of population age 5 years and above by activity status, and
sex in the County..............................................................................................................94
List of Figures
vii
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
Figure 4.9: Access to water and sanitation during the COVID-19 period.............................................39
Figure 5.1: Sector of operation in manufacturing..................................................................................43
Figure 5.2: Manufacturing firms by sector and size..............................................................................44
Figure 5.3: Location of manufacturing firms by premises....................................................................44
Figure 5.4: Distribution of manufacturing firms by gender and sector................................................45
Figure 5.5: Education levels of manufacturing firm owners.................................................................46
Figure 5.6: Source of markets................................................................................................................47
Figure 5.7: Source of material inputs.....................................................................................................47
Figure 5.8: Sources of finance............................................................................................................... 48
Figure 5.9: Recent sources of credit.......................................................................................................49
Figure 5.10: Main purpose of credit.......................................................................................................49
Figure 5.11: Constraints faced by manufacturing firms........................................................................ 50
Figure 5.12: Distribution of MSMEs by size......................................................................................... 50
Figure 5.13: Sector of operation by MSMEs.......................................................................................... 51
Figure 5.14: Location of businesses by premises................................................................................... 51
Figure 5.15: Education levels of MSME owners....................................................................................53
Figure 5.16: Main constraints faced by MSMEs....................................................................................54
Figure 5.17: Effects of COVID-19 on household non-farm and farm businesses..................................55
Figure 5.18: Labour dynamics on household non-farm and farm businesses......................................56
Figure 6.1: Main means of transport......................................................................................................58
Figure 6.2: How has the cost of your MAIN travel changed?................................................................59
Figure 6.3: Change in travel patterns....................................................................................................59
Figure 6.4: Has delivery of your household goods and services been affected by COVID-19?........... 60
Figure 6.5: Road condition mix-classified road network..................................................................... 60
Figure 6.6: Percentage distribution of conventional households by ownership of ICT assets KPHC
2019..................................................................................................................................63
Figure 6.7: Why doesn’t this household have any type of internet connection? KHIBS 2015/16........63
Figure 6.8: Type of internet connection................................................................................................64
Figure 6.9: Mobile money transfers subscription and mobile money banking platform.....................64
Figure 7.1: Distribution of households Renting/ Provided with the main dwelling unit by Provider.67
Figure 7.2: Has your household paid the rent for April 2020 on the agreed date............................... 68
Figure 7.3: Was the household paying rent on the agreed date with the landlord before COVID-19?.69
Figure 7.4: What is the MAIN reason that has made your household unable to pay rent?..................69
Figure 7.5: What measures has your household taken to overcome the effects of Corona Virus – rent..
70
Figure 9.1: COVID-19 testing, 2020.......................................................................................................79
Figure 10.1: Access to ICT in households and schools.......................................................................... 88
Figure 12.1: Effects of COVID-19, 2020................................................................................................96
Figure 12.2: Difference between usual hours worked and actual hours worked during COVID-19
period ...............................................................................................................................96
viii
Abbreviations and Acronyms
ix
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
Acknowledgements
The development of the County Technical Reports was a combined effort of various
departments at the Kenya Institute for Public Policy Research and Analysis (KIPPRA) with
support and inputs from the Council of Governors and the 47 Counties. Specifically, the
Institute wish to thank KIPPRA’s Executive Director Dr Rose Ngugi for guiding the process.
We would also like to thank the entire KIPPRA technical and research team comprising
Dr Eldah Onsomu, Dr Evelyne Kihiu, Mutuku Muleli, James Gachanja, Rogers Musamali,
Paul Lutta, Daniel Omanyo, Hellen Chemnyongoi, Shadrack Mwatu, Nahashon Mwongera,
Paul Odhiambo, Beverly Musili, Violet Nyabaro, Japheth Kathenge, Haron Ngeno, Elton
Khaemba, Michael Ogolla, Beatrice Mwangi, Rosemary Murebu, and Ephantus Kimani for
their tireless contributions to the success of preparing the report.
x
Executive Summary
Fiscal Policy
The county’s revenues have maintained an increasing trend as the county focused on
implementing major development projects to improve the livelihoods of its people. Total
county revenues grew from Ksh 3.60 billion in FY 2013/14 to Ksh 6.41 billion in FY
2020/21 with an average annual growth rate of 6.8 per cent. The increase was supported
by the growth in equitable share from the National Government and conditional grants
from development partners over the same period. Conditional grants continue to be a
major source of financing County operations. The County receives conditional grants
from the National Government and Development Partners mainly from World Bank and
Danish International Development Agency (DANIDA), European Union (EU) and Sweden.
Pending bills in Embu County generally follow an upward trend increasing from Ksh. 596.6
million in 2014/15 to 1,818.7 million in 2019/20. To steer the county towards achieving its
budgetary objective and development goals contained in the ADPs and CIDP, the county
government needs to mobilize more finances from OSR to increase the available revenues
for budgetary operations, seek for more funding in form of grants from development
partners to cater for the critical development projects in the county, ensure that the
ongoing projects are completed before launching new project and clear any pending bills
and arrears owed to suppliers and ensure the ongoing infrastructure project are completed
and suppliers paid within the specified timelines for optimal returns to investment and to
spur private sector activity.
Crops and livestock production account for a significant share of the economic activity of
Embu County. Key agricultural value chain commodities in the County include maize, beans,
bananas, potatoes, green grams, kales, cassava, khat, coffee, macadamia, mango, cattle,
goats, sheep, poultry production and bee keeping (apiculture). Among the socioeconomic
effects on the COVID-19 pandemic on the agri-food sector in the County included negative
effects on hours worked by workers in agriculture related occupations. An additional effect
was a slow down on trade and marketing activities due to the restrictions on movements
leading to price shocks and shortages of food items. Agricultural productivity in the County
is also affected by variable and extreme weather events, low agro-processing and value
addition opportunities, and land fragmentation among other factors. To successfully build
resilience and enhance growth of the agriculture sector, the County needs to explore
partnerships to develop agro-processing and value addition capacities at the County, invest
in sustainable irrigation and water harvesting technologies, enhance access to storage
and cooling facilities, and enhance commercialization opportunities among small holder
farmers.
xi
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
Clean water, proper sanitation and good hygiene remains an essential component in
protecting human health in times of outbreak of infectious diseases. Frequent and correct
hand hygiene has been emphasized by World Health Organization (WHO) as one of the
frontline measures to curb transmission of COVID-19. This has placed a higher demand
for water use in households, schools, health care facilities, marketplaces, workplaces, and
public places. This therefore has necessitated the need for provision of water, sanitation,
and hygiene by national and county governments to all. The county faces challenges in
revenue collections with COVID-19 has resulted in reduced incomes among households
and businesses, thus deferring collection of revenue from the water services. This in the
long run could affect the development of the water and sanitation sector. Additionally,
COVID-19 poses health challenges to water and sanitation officers if they get infected, they
have to be self-isolated, and this may lead to disruption of services. Other constraints to
the sector include, drought, water leakages and destruction of water catchment areas. To
ensure continuous availability of water, the national and county government to increase
water supply in households, institutions, and public places through drilling of boreholes in
all the sub-counties. Partner with private sector, donor agencies, local communities, and
NGOs to help develop water infrastructure.
The momentum in manufacturing, trade and MSMEs was disrupted by the COVID-19
pandemic as the containment measures associated with COVID-19 pandemic took a heavy
toll on the sector. The measures that were taken, such as closure of markets, observance
of health protocols in form of social distancing and handwashing served to increase the
cost of production and affected access to markets for the produce. In sustaining growth in
the Manufacturing, Trade and MSMEs sector, the County will develop a land development
strategy that safeguards the high potential agricultural land by setting the urban growth
limits to preserve the high potential areas and regulate the subdivision of this land, develop
urban-based agro-industries in Embu town to focus on proximity to agricultural raw
materials and promote agricultural value addition, promote rural development through
provision of infrastructure and agricultural sector development and related economic
activities, and enhance agricultural production by intensifying the use of the land.
The main means of transport used in the County is walking followed by motorbike. The
paved County Road network covers 56.09 km, while the paved National roads cover
239.17 km. Out of the total paved road network of 295.26 km, 84.4 per cent is in good
condition, 9.7 per cent in fair condition and 4.7 per cent in poor condition. The status of
ICT access and use in the county is low, especially among households. The housing tenure
is predominantly owner occupied at 73.0 per cent, with 27.0 per cent of the households
under rental tenure. The county has challenges in quality of the housing stock. In response
to the challenges, it is recommended that the county to improve and expand infrastructure
for Non-Motorized Transport (NMT) in urban areas and along roads with heavy -high
xii
Executive summary
speed traffic to promote sustainable mobility options and enhance road safety for all road
users, speed up the construction of fiber-optic broadband networks in underdeveloped
areas, and avail appropriate building technology for use by the public in house construction
and improvement in every sub-county, that responds to local cultural and environmental
circumstances.
Tourism
Tourism has a high potential in the Embu County for both local and international
tourists. Some of the available sites include caves, waterfalls and rocky hills (Karue,
Kianjiru, Kiambere, Ndune, Kirimiri, Maranga, Kiang’ombe) to support hiking; Kamburu
and Masinga hydro-electric power dams; Mt Kenya and Mwea National Parks that host
various wildlife. To boost tourism, the County to: promote domestic tourism to cushion
the economy from impacts of travel advisories and constraints caused by the pandemic
on international tourist arrivals; conduct regular maintenance of tourism attraction sites;
engage in tourism marketing and promotion; diversify tourism products; open access
routes to the tourist sites; sensitize the community on tourist sites in the county; Promotion
of eco-tourism, cultural and sports tourism in the 6 main rivers (Tana, Rupingazi, Kii, Ena,
Thiba, Thuci) and two hydro-electric dams; and develop tourism infrastructure such as
route to Mt Kenya, star-rated hotels, tourist sites, and tented camps.
Health
The County has 157 facilities that comprise of 9 hospitals, 16 health centres and 132 are
dispensaries. The government owned 50 per cent of the facilities, 33 per cent of these
facilities owned by private and 17 per cent owned by faith-based organizations. However,
government indicating increased reliance on public facilities for curative healthcare
services owns approximately 56 per cent of the health centres and hospitals. The county has
9 specialists, 60 doctors, 600 nurses and 113 clinical officers. The county therefore has a
doctor –Patient ratio of 1:35,000 against WHO recommendation of 1:230. However, these
numbers are not adequate to achieve the WHO recommended staff to patient ratio and to
serve a county population of 608,599 people (2019 Census). To achieve this, the county
government need to employ additional staff to bridge the existing gaps in human resource
for health. For a resilient health sector, there is need for more awareness on immunization
so that mothers can ensure their children get immunized. Implement a comprehensive
human resource health management system including undertaking training needs
assessments and information system to ensure skilled and motivated health care workers,
equitable deployed across all sub-counties. This is in addition to paying the salaries in time
to avoid cases of strikes and low staff morale. Recruit additional of public health officers
and community health workers to strengthen preventive and public health systems.
Embu County has a total of 619 pre-primary centres, 552 primary schools. Gross attendance
ratio for pre-primary school was 69.5 per cent while that of primary school and secondary
xiii
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
school was 119.0 and 66.0 per cent respectively. The gross attendance ratio for pre-primary
school was higher for males, 76.6 per cent, compared to that for females, 60.4 per cent. The
gross attendance ratio for primary school was higher for females, 125.6 per cent, compared
to that for males, 113.9 per cent. For secondary school, gross attendance ratio was higher
for males, 67.8 per cent, compared to that for females, 64.3 per cent. The net attendance
ratio for pre-primary, primary and secondary school was 57.0, 94.2 and 44.0 per cent,
respectively. The County with support from stakeholders will need to continue to invest in
early childhood development through infrastructural development to allow for adequate
education access; deployment of ECDE teachers and provision of sanitation facilities. The
county would put up measures that encourage learners to complete all levels of education
by providing financial or in-kind support, such as school feeding, to help families overcome
the increased costs of attending school and provide psychosocial support to teachers and
learners during and after the pandemic.
Social Protection
Embu County has a population of 608,599 of which 6.4 per cent are the elderly and 4.4
per cent are people living with disabilities (KNBS, 2019). The overall poverty rates in the
county stand at 44 per cent which is higher than the national average (36.1%). Despite
being an agricultural county, the county’s food poverty levels are at 28 per cent and 28 per
cent of the total population is multi-dimensionally poor. Further, about 27 per cent of the
children population is stunted. To cushion the citizens, the county has made various safety
net programmes. The County targeted to provide cash transfer to 200 households in each
sub – county, provide cash transfer to 50 households in each sub – county for poor and
severe disabled persons. The County also supported and built capacities of individuals,
vulnerable groups and communities for equity and self-reliance through training. With
increasing demand for cash transfers, the County government initiated targeted cash
transfers to the elderly and food distribution to vulnerable households both before and
during COVID-19 period.
Labour participation
Agriculture is the main driver of the economy in Embu County with over 70 per cent
of the residents being small scale farmers. Farmers were greatly affected by COVID-19,
mainly because of national lockdowns and social distancing policies. The agriculture sector
experienced a low traffic on sales and movement of goods, which in turn had an adverse
effect on market operations and cash flow for farmers. The export and import restrictions
created uncertainty on the crop farming and tourism industry. It will be important for the
County to promote appropriate labour market interventions, especially those working in
the agricultural sector, and implement policy reforms that drive employment creation. The
county to enhance investments and mechanisms for up skilling and reskilling, deepening
technical skills as well as ICT skills; and retraining employees on how to work from home,
where applicable. The county government to protect workers in the informal economy by
pursuing innovative policies and facilitate transition to the formal economy in the longer
term.
xiv
1. Introduction and Structure of Embu County
Economy
1.1 Introduction
Embu County is one of the counties in the Central Region Economic Bloc (CEREB). The
county occupies a land area of 2,818 km2.The county had an estimated population of
608,599 persons of whom 49.9 per cent were male and 50.0 per cent female (KNBS, 2019)
as indicated in table 1. Of the population 23,816 (4.4%) are persons with disabilities. The
youth constituted 34.0 per cent of the population of whom 49.0 per cent were female. The
county has a population density of 216 per km2. About 87.5 per cent of the population live
in rural areas of whom 49.9 per cent are female. The older persons (65 year and above)
constitute 6.4 per cent of the total population of whom 57.5 per cent were female. The
population in school going age group (4-22 years) was 38.9 per cent in 2019.
In 2015/2016, the overall poverty rate in Embu County was 28.0 per cent against the
national poverty rate of 36.1 per cent. In addition, 27.9 per cent of the population were
living in food poverty and 44.3 per cent were living in multidimensional poverty, that
means being deprived in several dimensions including health care, nutrition and adequate
food, drinking water, sanitation and hygiene, education, knowledge of health and nutrition,
housing and standard of living, and access to information. According to KDHS 2014, 26.8
per cent of the children were stunted as compared to the average national level at 26.0 per
cent.
Table 1.1: Development indicators in Embu County
County National
Estimated County Population (KNBS, 2019) 1.1% of total
608,599 population
304,208 49.9%
Males
304,367 50.0%
Females
24 0.003%
Intersex
Estimated Population Density (km2) 216 82
1
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
The age distribution of the county residents as per the 2019 Housing and Population
Census is shown in Table 1.2. The bulk of the County’s population is in the age group of
between 15-34 years comprising of 208,199 individuals. They are followed by persons
aged between 6-13 years who are the primary school children comprising of 103,386 of the
county population. The under 0-3 age comprise of 49,299 of the county population. This
shows that the county has a general youthful population.
Table 1.2: Population distribution for selected age groups in
the county (2019)
Age Group Male Female Total
Under 0-3
24,937 24,362 49,299
Preprimary school age (Under 4-5) 12,252 11,792 24,044
Primary School Age (6 -13) 52,007 51,379 103,386
Secondary school age (14-17) 27,609 26,512 54,121
Youth Population (15-34) 105,547 102,652 208,199
Female Reproductive age (15-49) 155,889 155,889
Labour force (15-64) 191530 187882 187,882
Aged Population 65+ 16,478 22,294 38,772
2
Introduction and structure of Embu County economy
In 2015/2016, 27.1 per cent of the population had health insurance cover, 32.7 per cent
lived in premises with water, 80.4 per cent lived in their own homes and 74.3 per cent had
access to mobile telephone (Table 1.3) and majority of the households (99 per cent) had
access to toilet facility. As a result, the multi-dimensional poverty is estimated at 44.3 per
cent.
Table 1.3: Level of deprivations for the various indicators for multidimensional
poverty in the county
Indicator Percentage Distribution
Health care Population with Health 32.7
Insurance Cover
Drinking water (Time Zero (In premises) 12.3
taken to fetch) less than 30 minutes 67.6
30 minutes or longer 19.9
Sanitation and Hygiene Proportion of households 99.0
with toilet facility
Shared Toilet 35.8
Not Shared 64.2
Place to wash hands 15.4
outside toilet facility
No place to wash hands 84.4
outside toilet facility
Education (Population 3 Ever Attended 91.8
years and Above by School
Attendance Status) Never Attended 7.8
3
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
Embu County Gross County Product (GCP) accounted for 1.6 per cent of total Gross
Domestic Product (GDP) between 2013 and 2020 (figure 1). The GCP increased from Ksh.
81,946 million in 2013 to Ksh. 153,927 million in 2020 representing an average annual
growth rate of 12.5 per cent. The service sector contributes 44.0 per cent of GCP while
agriculture, manufacturing and other industries sector share constituted 38.4 per cent,
2.33 per cent and 15.0 per cent, respectively. The services sector includes such activities as
wholesale and retail trade. Agriculture is mainly dominated by Crop farming (mostly cash
crops such as coffee, Tea, Macadamia nuts, Cotton) and Cattle farming (dairy and beef),
while industries and manufacturing include small scale production of consumer goods
such as plastics, furniture, textiles and food processing (Figure 1.1).
As of March 2020, Embu County had zero COVID-19 cases. However, by August 2020,
the County had reported 4 COVID-19 cases with mobility stringency of 70.4. The caseload
would rise to 1,367 by August 2021 with mobility stringency of 56.0. The mobility
stringency index is a composite measure rescaled to a value from 0 to 100 (100=strictest)
based on nine response mobility indicators. The nine metrics used to calculate the mobility
stringency index include school closures, workplace closures, cancellation of public events,
restrictions on public gatherings, closure of public transport, stay-at-home requirements,
public information campaigns, restrictions on internal movements and international travel
controls. An index measure closer to 100 means high incidence or severity of mobility
4
Introduction and structure of Embu County economy
restrictions. The County mobility stringency index implies the severity of the restrictions
was moderate.
Table 1.4: Total COVID-19 cases and mobility stringency - Embu County
5
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
when mobility restrictions were tightest but rebounded when mobility restrictions were
least stringent. Demand for workspaces has registered sustained recovery after mobility
restrictions were vacated in October 2021.
Figure 1.3: Effects of COVID-19 on economic performance in Embu County
and the county’s stringency index
6
tourism, chapter 9 focuses on health; chapter 10 focuses on education and training; chapter
11 focuses on social protection; chapter 12 focuses on human resources and chapter 13
concludes the report.
2 Fiscal Policy
The county revenues maintained an increasing trend as the county focused on implementing
major development projects to improve the livelihoods of its people. Total county revenues
increased from Ksh 3.60 billion in 2013/14 to Ksh 6.41 billion in 2020/21. The increase was
supported by the growth in equitable share from the National Government and conditional
grants from development partners over the same period. The amount realized in 2020/21
was 90.2 per cent of the annual budget allocation of Ksh 7.11 billion. The performance was
an improvement from the 84.2 per cent target attained in 2019/20. This was supported by
the 100 per cent disbursement of equitable shares and conditional grants from development
partners.
Analysis of the sources of county revenues indicate that equitable share from the National
government contributed the largest share of the total revenues (figure 2.1). On average, it
contributed 74.96 per cent of the total revenues between 2013/14 and 2020/21. Equitable
share grew by 66 per cent from Ksh 2.81 billion in 2013/14 to Ksh 4.67 billion in 2020/21.
The amount received in 2020/21 accounted for 100 per cent of the annual budget allocation,
7
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
an improvement from 91.4 per cent attained in 2019/20. This implied that the County
received all expected amount from the National Government to finance its operations,
underscoring its commitment to support county operations through timely financing.
Figure 2.1:Share of county revenues by source
2020 2,594.62 3,151.47 3,495.82 3,954.44 4,047.99 4,677.03 1,080.40 1,446.28 1,931.61
2019 2,109.15 2,476.86 2,907.33 3,388.40 3,795.11 5,020.34 3,795.11 1,177.78 171,104.69
2018 1,894.58 1,920.00 2,675.93 3,425.33 3,473.89 4,570.23 958.16 1,410.92 1,530.82
Conditional grants
Conditional grants continue to be a major source of financing County operations. The County
receives conditional grants from the National Government and Development Partners
mainly from World Bank and Danish International Development Agency (DANIDA),
European Union (EU) and Sweden. During 2020/21, the County received Ksh 481.85
million and Ksh 383.42 million from National Government and Development partners
respectively. The contribution of condition grants to total revenue has been robust (figure
2.1). On average, the grants contributed 8.79 per cent of the County total revenue between
2013/14 and 2020/21. In nominal terms, conditional grants have increased slightly from
8
Fiscal policy
Ksh 557.20 million in 2013/14 to Ksh 865.28 million in the 2020/21. There is need for the
county to maintain good relations, and comply fully to the requirements of its development
partners to continue benefiting from the conditional grant
The share of OSR to the total revenue has similarly been robust. On average, OSR
contributed 7.76 per cent to total revenues between 2013/14 and 2020/21 (Figure 2.1).
During 2020/21, it contributed 12.35 per cent of the total revenues, an all-time high. The
strong performance registered indicates some level of resilience in OSR collections amidst
the adverse effects of COVID-19 pandemic experienced.
The performance of the county annual OSR has been relatively stable, though with a series
of fluctuations as indicated in figure 2.2. Analysis of annual County OSR performance
indicate growth over the years except during 2019/20 and 2020/21. The county has achieved
slightly more than 50 per cent of its targets save for 2020/21 when it realized 40.02 per
cent. In 2019/20, the county generated Ksh 509.65 million as OSR, a decrease of 19.03 per
cent compared to Ksh 629.42 million realised during same period in 2018/19. Similarly,
the amount collected as OSR during 2020/21 decreased by 26.4 per cent compared to the
amount collected in 2019/20. The persistent decline was premised on the negative effect of
COVID-19 pandemic on business activities and subsequent revenue collection.
Figure 2.2: Annual own source revenue targets and actual collections
9
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
COVID-19 pandemic that affected most economic activities. During 2020/21, the quarterly
collections remained low compared to other financial years. With the ease of containment
measures across the country, the OSR performance is expected to improve as well.
Figure 2.3: Quarterly own source revenue collection
10
Fiscal policy
Economic and political crises, natural disasters (such as droughts and flooding), security
challenges and health crisis (such as the COVID-19 pandemic) highlight the consequential
risks and underlying vulnerabilities in national and county level budgetary and planning
system. These can substantially affect public resources and in cases of weaker planning
systems they may impact the nature and level of service delivery to the citizen.
The UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) emphasize the productive role of targeted
and strategic county level expenditure. The 2014 UN Secretary General’s Synthesis Report
on the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) states that “many of the investments to
achieve the sustainable development goals will take place at the sub-national level and be
led by local authorities”1. It is at the counties that economic activity takes place and when
spending priorities and execution are done just right then the county and country will be
set to the desired development trajectory.
Despite their constrained fiscal autonomy (such as inability to borrow funds) and relatively
small budgets, the county government has a key role to play in promoting growth as
espoused in the Kenya Constitution. This is particularly the case with development
expenditure, which is within the assigned remit of county as per the PFM Act of 2012 and
is key to the county’s future growth prospects given several decades of under-investment
which have constrained productive capacity in the local economy.
County expenditure has over the years been rising as the county escalates its efforts in
provision of services to its residents. Total county expenditure has grown significantly since
2013/14. With the implementation of the first full year county budget in 2013/14, actual
expenditure in the county increased from Ksh. 2,745.4 million to Ksh. 5,227.2 million in FY
2020/21 (Figure 2.4). This translates to over eighty per cent increase in county spending
over the period. Cumulatively the county has spent a total of Ksh. 37.6 billion over the
period under review. This comprises of a cumulative Ksh 28.9 billion and Ksh. 8.6 billion
on recurrent and development expenditures representing 77.0 per cent and 23.0 per
1
UN General Assembly (2014), p. 22, par. 94.
11
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
cent of the cumulative recurrent and development expenditure respectively. This signals
that development expenditure performance is relatively weak and there is even a greater
opportunity to push development expenditure higher and support deepening of capital
spending in the county.
Figure 2.4: County expenditure analysis
Figure2.4a: Trends in actual Figure 2.4b: Trends in actual per
aggregate expenditure capita expenditure
12
Fiscal policy
This increased to 16.7 per cent in 2014/15, 23.6 per cent in 2015/16 and 36.4 per cent
in 2016/17. Afterwards, development spending as a share if total spending began to fall
reaching 21.0 per cent at the end of 2019/20 as presented in Figure 2.5. At the end of
2020/21 development spending accounted for 24.5 per cent of total expenditure.
Figure 2.5: County government expenditure by economic classification (% of
total county government expenditure
13
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
for 9.9 per cent, County Assembly 10.2 per cent, public service, and administration at 3.6
per cent, finance, and economic planning at 2.5 per cent while County Public Service Board
accounted for 0.5 per cent.
14
Fiscal policy
Pending Bills
Pending bills in Embu County generally follow an upward trend. In 2014/15 the county
reported Ksh. 596.6 million in pending bills. This increased to Ksh. 798.2 million in 2015/16
with development related pending bills accounting for 86.7 per cent of this. Pending bills
increased further to Ksh. 860.5 million in 2016/17 then ascended to Ksh. 1,278.7 million
in 2017/18 before decelerating to Ksh. 1,048.9 million in 2018/19. At the end of 2019/20,
pending bills totalled 1,818.7 million and Ksh 1,817.0 million. Generally, pending bills
related to development have been greater than those related to recurrent expenditure on
average accounting for 57.9 per cent of the pending bills portfolio over the review period.
If pending bills for development spending were paid in their respective fiscal year, the
execution of development budget in subsequent years would improve.
Figure 2.7: Profile of county pending bills
15
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
To achieve its overall goal of improving lives and livelihoods of its residents, the county
government must now move quickly to tackle the problem of pending bills. Increasing and
persistent pending bills is a threat to the survival of the private sector particularly primary
firms that trade with the county government. These firms are critical for employment
creation as well as driving economic activity within the county. These bills have not only
affected their profitability and overall performance but have also become a threat to private
sector in general and the families that depend on these firms through ripple effect. If not
well monitored these could grow and eat up on the county’s already thin revenue sources.
2.3 Recommendations
To steer the county towards achieving its budgetary objective and development goals
contained in the ADPs and CIDP, the following measures are proposed:
(i) Mobilize more finances from OSR to increase the available revenues for budgetary
operations.
(ii) Seek for more funding in form of grants from development partners to cater for the
critical development projects in the county.
(iii) Ensure that the ongoing projects are completed before launching new project and
clear any pending bills and arrears owed to suppliers.
16
Fiscal policy
(iv) Ensure the ongoing infrastructure project are completed and suppliers paid within
the specified timelines for optimal returns to investment and to spur private sector
activity.
(v) Improve budget execution and absorption of development budget by harmonizing
project implementation cycles to budgeting and fast-track exchequer releases.
(vi) Reduction of expenditure on compensation of employees within the PFM requirement
since ballooning compensation of employees potentially affects execution of key
development programs especially if not brought to sustainable levels.
(vii) Monitoring and prompt payment of pending bills as they limit execution of planned
activities in subsequent budgets.
17
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
Agriculture accounts for the significant share of economic activity in Embu County. More
than 30 per cent of county economic activity is driven by the agriculture sector. In 2017,
agriculture accounted for Ksh 39,794 million out of the total Ksh 103,734 million Gross
County Product (GCP) amounting to 38.4 per cent of the County’s GCP.
Over 70 per cent of the households in Embu County practice farming. About 67 per cent
of the households produce crops, 54 per cent produce livestock, 0.32 per cent practice
aquaculture and about 0.89 per cent are involved in fishing. About 6.5 per cent of the
households practice irrigation farming.
Table 3.1: Distribution of households practicing agriculture, fishing and
irrigation by county and sub-county
County/Sub Total Farming Crop Livestock Aquaculture Fishing Irrigation
County Households Production Production
Households
18
Agriculture, livestock and fisheries
Table 3.2: Distribution of households growing crops by type, county and sub-
county
County/Sub-County Embu Embu Embu Embu Mbeere Mbeere
East North West South North
Maize 109,171 26,782 14,688 16,926 31,493 19,282
Beans 89,278 23,223 11,822 14,872 24,850 14,511
Bananas 55,970 21,651 13,757 12,529 3,659 4,374
Potatoes 31,032 13,434 6,378 9,283 698 1,239
Green grams 30,437 209 139 317 20,013 9,759
Kales 27,825 9,108 9,773 4,773 2,431 1,740
Cassava 27,641 9,993 4,179 4,414 5,218 3,837
Sorghum 22,883 740 169 443 12,570 8,961
Sweet potatoes 20,905 6,218 5,096 3,725 3,945 1,921
Sugarcane 17,631 7,359 4,749 3,370 1,064 1,089
Millet 12,819 282 80 205 4,855 7,397
Tomatoes 8,734 2,578 2,289 1,359 1,664 844
Onions 8,517 3,137 3,214 1,292 486 388
Cabbages 8,247 2,601 4,260 943 274 169
Watermelons 1,884 277 127 285 724 471
Ground Nuts 1,215 202 107 242 451 213
Source: 2019 Kenya Population and Housing Census
19
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
Key permanent crops among households in Embu include Khat, coffee, macadamia and
mango.
Table 3.3: Distribution of households growing permanent Crops by type and
County
County/Sub Tea Coffee Avocado Citrus Mango Macadamia Khat
County (Miraa)
Embu 18,664 28,996 19,355 3,581 26,771 27,488 34,900
Kenya 476,613 478,936 966,976 177,445 796,867 195,999 134,148
Source: 2019 Kenya Population and Housing Census
In 2019, the value of vegetables production in the County amounted to Ksh 399.5 million.
The area under vegetables was 1,179 Ha with a production of 19,279 MT. The major
20
Agriculture, livestock and fisheries
vegetables grown in order of value importance are; tomato, potato, spinach, kales, cabbage,
carrots, french beans, butter nut and pumpkin leaves.
Table 3.5: Vegetables grown in Embu County
Type of Vegetables Area in Ha Production in Value in Shillings
Tons
Tomato 265 9,070 127,700,000
Potato 275 4,265 118,700,000
Spinach 62 2,150 56,000,000
Kales 197 1,315 22,130,000
Cabbage 135 425 17,560,000
Carrots 70 560 16,500,000
French Beans 46 325 15,300,000
Butter Nut 44 508 7,975,000
Pumpkin Leaves 25 296 6,800,000
Broccoli 10 100 5,000,000
Pumpkin Fruit 10 114 4,040,000
Cowpea 20 85 850,000
Bell Pepper/Sweet Paper 7 21 420,000
Leaf Amaranth 11 31 390,000
African Nightshade 2 14 140,000
Total 1,179 19,279 399,505,000
Source: Agriculture and Food Authority, 2019
In 2019, the value of MAPs production in the County amounted to KES 42.1 million. The
area under MAPSs was 137 Ha with a production of 937 MT. The major MAPs grown are;
Spring Onion/Green Shallots, Corriander, Rosemary, Basil and Long Cayenne Chilies.
Table 3.6: Medicinal and Aromatic Plants (MAPs) grown in Embu County
Medicinal and Aromatic Plants Area in Ha Production in Value in
(MAPs) Tons Shillings
Spring Onion/Green Shallots 57 570 26,500,000
Bulb Onion 52 266 12,490,000
Corriander 3 15 600,000
Rosemary 5 21 590,000
Basil 1 8 480,000
Long Cayenne Chilies 2 13 400,000
Mint 1 5 375,000
Bullet Chilies 3 13 310,000
Moringa 6 12 120,000
21
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
Aloe 4 9 90,000
Jetropha 2 3 75,000
Lemon Grass 1 2 20,000
Total 137 937 42,050,000
Source: Agriculture and Food Authority, 2019
Floriculture is a key sub-sector in the agriculture sector and a major contributor of foreign
exchange after diaspora, tourism and tea. The main flowers grown in Embu County are
Trachelium. In 2019, the value of Trachelium flowers produced in the County amounted
to Ksh 1.3 million. The area under flowers was 56 Ha with a production of 50 million MT.
Being an ASAL County, animal production is a key economic activity in Embu County.
Other than rearing the traditional livestock (i.e. cattle, goats and sheep), the County has
promoted poultry production and bee keeping (apiculture) among farming households in
the County. A lower percentage of farming households practice aquaculture.
Table 3.8: Distribution of households rearing livestock and fish by County and
Sub County
County/Sub Kenya Embu Embu Embu Embu Mbeere Mbeere
County East North West South North
22
Agriculture, livestock and fisheries
Agricultural labour participation in Embu indicates relative parity between females and
males with no strong dominance of either gender in the labour force. Majority of the
population in Embu are agricultural, fishery and related labourers. The workers in this
sub-major group include: Farm-hands and Related Labourers; Forestry Labourers; and
Fishery, Hunting and Trapping Labourers. The second most popular agriculture related
workers in the County are farm workers where the group covers occupations related to:
Field Crop, Vegetable and Horticultural Farm Workers; Poultry, Dairy and Livestock
Producers; and Crop and Animal Producers. The classifications are based on the Kenya
National Occupational Classification Standard (KNOCS).
Figure 3.2: Agriculture-related labour force participation
23
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
reference period as compared with the usual hours worked per week. The most affected
workers are the subsistence agricultural and fishery workers who recorded the highest
difference of 18 hours between the usual and actual hours worked in a week. The workers
in this sub-major group grow and harvest field or tree and shrub crops, grow vegetables
and fruit, tend or hunt animals, gather wild fruits and plants, catch fish and gather other
forms of aquatic life in order to provide food, shelter and a minimum of cash income for
themselves and their households.
24
Agriculture, livestock and fisheries
had been instances where the household or a member of the household could not access the
markets/grocery stores to purchase food items.
Figure 3.4: Limited access to markets to purchase food items
Livestock trade has especially been majorly affected as traders are unable to take the
livestock to the market.
Restrictions affecting seamless movement of food commodities are likely to cause a hike
in prices in non-production areas and fall in prices in production areas. 87 per cent of
25
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
households in Embu County indicated that over the past 2 weeks from the reference period,
while 6 per cent indicated that they had not experienced a change in the prices.
Figure 3.6: Percentage of households experiencing change in food commodity
prices
26
Agriculture, livestock and fisheries
Poor access to markets also hinders the ability to supply food to the population as shown
in the below figure.
Figure 3.8: Percentage of households reporting that the following food items
were not readily available in their locality
27
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
Additional challenges, albeit at low levels, faced by the count during the COVID pandemic
period include: Desert locusts (0.6%); Floods/ Mudslides/ Landslides (0.1%); and Livestock
Diseases (1.0%).
Figure 3.10: Percentage of households who experienced the below shocks in
the past two weeks the KNBS Wave 2 survey
28
Agriculture, livestock and fisheries
An assessment of the sector linkages to other sectors highlights that the sector
is enabled by:
(i) Businesses/ MSMEs: Businesses and MSMEs are crucial in providing inputs and
requirements to the agricultural sector. The sector would facilitate the efficient access
to
(ii) Transport, Storage and ICT sectors
(iii) Financial and insurance activities
(iv) Accommodation Food services
(v) Manufacturing: The manufacturing sector plays a crucial role in agro-processing.
Agricultural inputs also contribute to the processing of other manufacturing
commodities
The County has opportunities in:
(a) Developing County-private partnership in enhancing agro-processing and value
addition capacities; Construction of abattoirs; and Linking farmers to product
markets
(b) Expand/ exploit innovative marketing opportunities for farmers produce including
uptake of innovative marketing platforms, such as milk ATMs, so that farmers are not
exploited by middle men.
(c) Adoption of drought resistant livestock pastures/fodder and crops
(d) Adoption of fodder and feed conservation
(e) Scaling up conservation agriculture, post-harvest management, planting drought-
tolerant and early-maturing varieties, and agro-forestry.
(f) Enhanced water harvesting, sustainable and efficient irrigation.
(g) Increased livestock production through: - routine vaccination, deworming and
vector control to maintain animal health; decentralized veterinary services; disease
surveillance; storing and conserving pastures and fodder; capacity building on
animal management and training on preservation and value addition techniques;
and improved milking hygiene and animal housing.
29
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
(h) Adoption of natural resource management to include soil and water conservation,
tree planting, changing of crop type and water harvesting.
(i) Access to quality and affordable inputs including certified seedlings, AI services,
fertilizers, livestock vaccination, ploughing services by County tractor hire services.
The County government has ventured to reduce cost of farming inputs. It has
partnered with companies that manufacture seed to supply these seed to farmers at
subsidized cost
(j) Provision of storage and cooling facilities particularly at collection points to minimize
spoilage and post-harvest losses particularly for milk.
(k) Uptake of digital platforms to build capacities of farming households in modern
agricultural technologies and marketing of agricultural produce
(l) Enhance supportive services to include early-warning systems, credit, advisory and
information services through extension and training.
(m) Enhancing farmers technical capacities to act on advisory information received
(n) Improved crop and livestock emergencies surveillance systems in the County.
(o) Strengthening farmers’ associations and cooperatives as an additional solution to
marketing challenges
3.4 Recommendations
To successfully build resilience and enhance growth of the agriculture sector, the
County will:
(i) Develop partnership with the National Government, NGOs, Development Partners,
Research Institutions and the Private sector in enhancing agro-processing and
value addition capacities of the County as envisioned in the national Agricultural
Transformation and Growth Strategy (ASTGS). Some of the value addition processes
currently in place include 7 macadamia and 1 mango processing plants for exports.
The County projects to have a honey processing firm. There are also opportunities
in establishing, upgrading, and reviving agro-processing plants/industries in milk,
meat and leather processing plants.
(ii) In addition to agro-processing, provision of storage and cooling facilities particularly
at collection points to minimize spoilage and post-harvest losses.
(iii) Revive the agricultural sector especially coffee farming through enhanced
commercialization opportunities among small holder farmers in the County
30
Agriculture, livestock and fisheries
31
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
The main sources of drinking water in the county include rivers, dams, piped water,
boreholes, springs, wells and pans. The County is served by six major rivers; Thuci that
borders Tharaka- Nithi that borders, Tana that borders Machakos County, forms the
boundary to Kirinyaga County, Rupingazi forms the boundary to Kirinyaga, Thiba and
Ena. These major rivers originate from Mt. Kenya Forest in Manyatta and Runyenjes sub-
counties, 30.1 per cent of the population get water from rivers, 35 per cent from piped water
and 21 per cent from dug well. In Mbeere North and Mbeere South constituencies, 40.4 per
cent get water from rivers, 8.2 per cent from piped water, 23.7 per cent from dug wells and
10.9 per cent from boreholes.
On sanitation, majority of the people in the county use pit latrines for human waste disposal.
Of all urban centres in the county, only Embu has a sewage treatment plant that does not
have adequate capacity to serve the whole town.
Access to source of water by households
The major source of water for drinking utilized by households in the county is piped water
into the plot/yard (47.2 per cent), surface water at 18.8 per cent and piped water into
dwelling at 8.4 per cent. Majority of the rural (45.2%), urban (53.6 per cent) and peri-urban
(60%) households have access to piped water into the plot. In addition, there are larger
proportions of urban households (33.1%) have access to piped water into the dwelling. On
the other hand, both male (45%) and female (45.8%) headed households also rely on piped
water into the plot/yard. Only a small portion of the households relies on water from dug
wells, tube well as well as rainwater.
32
Water, sanitation, and hygiene
KNBS 2015/2016
Combating COVID-19 pandemic has already placed high demand for water for both
domestic usage in households, health care institutions, learning institutions, marketplaces
and other public places. Water also remains important to other sectors of the economy such
as agriculture and industrial usage, among others. With the planned re-opening of schools
and upcoming low rain seasons means that the pressure on water resources will be high,
this therefore means that the demand for water will be high and if the supply will be low,
households are likely to fail to observe COVID-19 prevention measures of hand washing
which may in turn lead to high transmission of COVID-19.
To ensure continuity of quality water supply, there is need for the county to invest in water
harvesting and storage facilities both at household and institutional level, this may include
supporting schools in building rain harvesting and storage structures in schools from the
school structure rooftops, supporting households in rainwater harvesting during rainfall
times. Other interventions may include digging boreholes, supply of water to households
that experiences water scarcity. Therefore, for equality in access to water the county
government can waive or reduce the water bills for urban households who uses piped water
as well as support water vendors in access to clean safe water at a reduced cost. This will
mean financial support to water service companies. Other long-term measures include
inclusion of both rural, urban, and peri-urban dwellers into decision making in regard to
water management and governance.
33
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
Clean and safe water is essential for good health and goes a long way in ensuring reduced
infections. Access to improved sources of drinking water2 is high among households (70.6
per cent) both in rural (57.3 per cent) urban areas (91.1 per cent) and peri urban (79.9 per
cent). Additionally, both male and female headed households have low access to improved
drinking water source as shown in the figure below.
Figure 4.2: Access to improved and unimproved sources of water by households
Inequalities in access to safe and clean drinking water may put households at risk of
contracting infectious diseases as well as make the households less observance of COVID-19
measures of hand hygiene. One mitigation measure that may be undertaken by the county
to increase access to improved water source, include connecting the households with
piped water, increase the development of improved sources of water especially in rural
areas. Long term measure to support access to water all households is to have both male
and female headed households to be part of water management/governance team and in
decision making in water management.
Other important consideration is to have separate water drinking point for livestock,
different from the household water drinking water sources to minimize water contamination
as well as conflict over water resource. Other long-term measures is to avoid agricultural
activities along the upstream to minimize water pollution.
Most households (23 per cent), rural (23.8 per cent) and urban (22 per cent) used between
2 Improved source of drinking water includes; water from the following sources Piped water - piped
into dwelling, Piped water - piped into plot/yard, Piped water - public tap/stand pipe, Tubewell/bore-
hole with pump, Dug well - protected well, Dug well - unprotected well, Water from spring - protected
spring). While unimproved sources of water include water from spring - unprotected spring, Rainwa-
ter collection, Vendors - tankers-truck, Vendors - cart with small tank/drum/bucket, Vendors-bicycles
with bucket, Surface water, river/streams/pond/dam/lake/cannal/irrigation channel Bottled water.
This is according to the WHO and UN classification of sources of water.
34
Water, sanitation, and hygiene
1000-1999 litres of water per month. Further, more female (32 per cent) than male (23.4
per cent) has used between 1000 to 1999 litres of water.
Figure 4.3: Volumes of water used by households in the past month
Figure 4.3 shows that most households utilize large volumes of water on a monthly
basis, with the planned re-opening of schools it means more water will be needed by the
institutions. Water remains a scarce commodity and in places or months where water is
scarce, this may have an effect on families and hinder them from observing COVID-19
prevention guidelines. Correct utilizations of water resources should be emphasized at
households’ level, similarly, there is need for conservation of water catchment areas.
Majority of the households (90.8 per cent) both rural, urban and peri-urban covers less
than 100 metres to water sources meaning they have water within their premises or close
to their compounds (See the figure below).
35
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
If water is available to households, schools, health institutions within the shortest distances
possible, it easily encourages observing hand hygiene thus minimizing infections. In
learning institutions, it minimizes rates of school dropouts among girls. Women headed
households are disadvantaged in access to drinking water within shortest distances and this
may make them vulnerable to contracting COVID-19 as well as other infectious diseases.
To support hand hygiene among households there is need to have water supply closer to
households headed by women.
Access and reliability of water sources
Majority of households (65.2%) in the county relies on the main source of drink water all
year round. Most households (88.1 per cent) go to fetch drinking water from the sources
per day, this is more among urban (80 per cent) and peri-urban (76.5%) compared to rural
(66%) household. This means there may be more of interactions with other household
members in areas where water sources are shared, this may lead to increase on infections
of COVID-19 where COVID-19 guidelines of social distance and avoidance of crowded place
may not be observed. It also implies that households may not be having water enough
water storage facilities that can minimize number of rips to water points in a day putting
them at risk of water shortages as well as saving on time for other economic activities.
36
Water, sanitation, and hygiene
Access to sanitation
Majority of the households (77.4%) as well those in rural (81.8%), urban (49.5 and peri-
urban (65.3%) areas use pit latrine with slab. Further small proportions of urban households
(31.4%) flush to septic tank as well as flush to piped sewer (14.8%)
Figure 4.6: Access to sanitation in Embu County
37
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
Majority of the households (96%) have access to improved sanitation facilities3. This is also
similar among rural (78%) and urban (100%) headed households. Improved sanitation is
also high among male and female headed households as shown in the figure below.
Figure 4.7: Access to improved and unimproved sanitation by households
Additionally, small proportions of the households (30.9%) do share a toilet facility with
other households, this is more in urban (57.7%) compared to peri-urban (33%). On the
other hand, most households (69.9%) share a toilet facility with more than 20 households
(male headed households 70.3% and female-headed households 45%).
3 Improved sanitation includes; flush to piped sewer, flush to septic tank, flush to pit (latrine), flush
to somewhere else, flush to unknown place, ventilated improved pit latrine, pit latrine with slab,
pit latrine without slab). Unimproved sanitation includes; composting toilet, bucket toilet, hanging
toilet/hanging, no facility/bush/field, others
38
Water, sanitation, and hygiene
WASH has been identified very important in helping to curb transmission of infectious
diseases, currently most households (83.6 per cent) do not have a handwashing facility
in their households. Despite this most households (68.7 per cent) have access to WASH
(Water and soap) during this period of COVID-19. This is more among male (74.9%) than
female (43.8%) headed households. Additional 27.7 per cent of the households having
access to both water, soap, and hand sanitizer.
Figure 4.9: Access to water and sanitation during the COVID-19 period
39
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
COVID-19 has highlighted the need to maintain a clean safe water, proper sanitation and
hand hygiene which places more demand on water and therefore the county needs to
leverage on lessons learned from COVID-19 by improving its water and sanitation coverage.
The County has provided wash taps within shops in the town centre as well as handwashing
facilities in County and sub-County offices. The county has undertaken a distribution of
water tanks, water and soaps at points of entry as well as developed hand washing booths
in the informal settlements. The booths are made by students from the TVET institutions
Key messages
Frequent and correct hand hygiene has been emphasized by WHO as one of the measures
to curb transmission of COVID-19. This has placed a higher demand for water more so
at the households, health care facilities, marketplaces, public places and among essential
services provides.
(i) Most households in the county have higher access to improved sources of water
both in rural (66.7%), urban (91.1%) and peri urban (81.9%). Clean and safe water
guarantees good health leading to low health expenditures among households.
(ii) There is a higher access to piped water both in rural (53%), urban (91%) and peri-
urban areas (73%). This means more revenue from piped water for the county
government. Similarly, it also implies high access to clean and safe water which is
guaranteed through piped water system.
(iii) Access to improved sanitation remains high in the county both in rural (99.3%),
urban (100%) and peri-urban households (100%).
(iv) Sharing of a toilet facility with other households is common among households, this
is more in urban (57.7%) and peri-urban (33.1%) compared to rural areas (27.4%).
Toilet sharing puts households at risk of contracting COVID-19, and other infectious
diseases in cases where proper toilet hygiene is not maintained.
(v) There is a higher access to hand washing, with majority of households in urban
(44.7%) having access to a place for hand washing. Access to WASH (water and soap)
27.7 per cent of the households had access to both water, soap and hand sanitizer
during this period of COVID-19. This minimizes the risks of infections.
(vi) The most commonly used sources of energy for cooking by households are firewood
(80.1 per cent) and followed closely by liquified (6.9%).
(vii) Furthermore, most households dispose their households solid waste in the compound
(42.5%), burnt in the open (25.4%) and dumped in the latrine
(viii) Further only 7 per cent of the household solid waste is collected by the county
government for disposal, while a small percentage is collected by private companies
for safe disposal. This means that only a small portion of household solid waste
40
Water, sanitation, and hygiene
41
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
(xviii) Expand and rehabilitate the existing piped water connection infrastructure to
help increase access to water.
(xix) Develop and implement wastewater management strategy.
xx. Expand sewer infrastructure to accommodate more households.
(xxi) Support the implementation of Community Led Total Sanitation (CLTS)
initiatives.
(xxii) Create public awareness on the importance of connecting to sewer system.
(xxiii) Provide personal protective equipment to staff working in water and sanitation
sector for maximum safety and uninterrupted service delivery during this period
of COVID-19.
(xxiv) Improve access to safe and improved toilets in schools, health care facilities,
workplaces and public places.
(xxv) Enforce the WASH regulation of having toilets in all public facilities such as
supermarkets, hotels and banks, among others.
(xxvi) Sensitize the public on the importance of WASH.
(xxvii) Promote the importance of handwashing and construct WASH facilities to
increase access at the household level.
(xxviii) The county to organize sensitization forums on the importance of handwashing
through the media and in community forums.
(xxix) Inculcate a culture of hand hygiene in the county.
42
5 Manufacturing, Trade and MSMEs
Most establishments in Embu County are micro in nature and operate in the wearing
apparel (30.2%), furniture (22.2%), fabricated metal products except machinery and
equipment (14.4%) among others (Figure 5.2). Small sized establishments operate in food
43
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
products (4.2%) and furniture (0.9%). Moreover, medium enterprises operate mainly in
food products (6.1%).
Figure 5.2: Manufacturing firms by sector and size
Common premises used by manufacturing firms in Embu County are commercial (35.7%),
market stall (35.4%), industrial site (7.8%), and open market (7.2%) (Figure 5.3).
Figure 5.3: Location of manufacturing firms by premises
44
Manufacturing , trade and MSMEs
cent jointly owned. Small sized firms are largely male owned (59.6%) while the rest are
jointly owned (40.4%) (Table 5.1).
Table 5.1: Distribution of manufacturing firms by gender and size -N (%)
In terms of employment, the manufacturing sector employs more men (66.5%) than women
(33.5%). Most men are found in the medium-sized enterprises (42.3%) while 16.5 per cent
are in micro-sized establishments. Majority of the women are mostly in the medium micro
enterprises (24.6%) (Table 5.2).
45
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
Source of markets
46
Manufacturing , trade and MSMEs
Manufacturing establishments in Embu County were involved in both product, process and
market innovations. More market innovations are seen under the micro category at 16.4
per cent, product 14.7 per cent and process 13.1 per cent. Fewer innovations are observed
in the small category at a rate of 1.4 per cent for product and process and 3.6 per cent for
market innovations respectively (Table 5.3).
47
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
According to the MSME 2016 survey, 66.3 per cent of MSMEs and 48.5 per cent of those
in manufacturing applied for credit. The key sources of credit for establishments in
manufacturing include microfinance institutions (34%), commercial banks (27.5%), self
help groups (11.7%), and rotating saving and credit associations (8.2%). MSMEs largely
rely on micro finance institutions (34%), commercial banks (25.5%), self help groups
(16.1%), and SACCOs (13.1%) (Figure 5.8).
Figure 5.8: Sources of finance
48
Manufacturing , trade and MSMEs
Purpose of credit
Figure 5.10 presents the main purpose of credit by both MSMEs and firms in manufacturing.
In general, manufacturing firms require credit for: working capital (34.2%), business
refurbishment (30.4%), and purchase of inventory (25.4%). MSMEs in Embu County
require credit for business refurbishment (35.2%), working capital (30.6%), and purchase
of inventory (25.4%).
Figure 5.10: Main purpose of credit
49
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
Embu County has 23,826 establishments4 with 22,218 (93.2%) being micro; 1,326 (5.4%)
are small; and 282 (1.2%) are medium enterprises (KNBS, 2016) (Figure 5.12).
Figure 5.12: Distribution of MSMEs by size
50
Manufacturing , trade and MSMEs
Majority of MSMEs in Embu County operate in the wholesale and retail trade; repair of
motor vehicles and motorcycles (58.2%), manufacturing (15.8%), accommodation and food
services (10.6%), and arts, entertainment and recreation (6.7%) (Figure 5.13). Generally,
these are the sectors that have been worst hit by the pandemic and need focus in achieving
re-engineering and recovery.
Figure 5.13: Sector of operation by MSMEs
MSMEs in Embu County are largely located in commercial premises (46.8%), market stalls
(29.9%), and residential with special outfit (5.5%) (Figure 5.14). Majority of the businesses
in the county could be having many difficulties in meeting their rental obligations due
income disruptions occasioned by COVID-19. According to the May 2020 KNBS COVID-19
survey, 95.1 per cent of the non-farm businesses attributed non-payment of household
rental obligations to reduced incomes/earnings while 4.9 per cent attributed the same
to delayed incomes/earnings. For those involved in farm businesses, all the respondents
attributed the same to reduced incomes/earnings.
Figure 5.14: Location of businesses by premises
Table 5.4 shows the distribution of MSMEs in Embu County by gender: 44.3 per cent are
male owned, 32.7 per cent are female owned, while 23 per cent are jointly owned (male/
female). For Micro establishments, 48.3 per cent are male owned, 35.1 per cent are female
owned, while 21.1 per cent are jointly owned. Male owners also dominate ownership
among small sized establishments at 56.5 per cent, while 43.6 per cent are jointly owned.
Considering medium sized establishments, ownership is either jointly owned (80.4%) or
controlled by males (19.6%).
Table 5.4: Distribution of MSMEs by gender and size- N (%)
52
Manufacturing , trade and MSMEs
Figure 38 indicates that majority of MSME owners in Embu County have a secondary
education (38.4%) while 33 per cent have primary and 15.3 per cent mid-level college
diploma or certificate, 8.9 per cent degree education, respectively (Figure 5.15).
Figure 5.15: Education levels of MSME owners
Table 5.6 presents the levels of innovation in Embu County by MSMEs according to size.
Overall, there were low levels of innovation across MSMEs with 19.8 per cent involved in
product, 19.8 per cent for process, and 19.8 per cent in market innovation for micro-sized
enterprises. Regarding small-sized enterprises, 1.2 per cent engaged in product, 1.2 per
cent process and 1.2 per cent market innovation innovations, respectively.
Table 5.6: Level of innovation by MSMEs
Micro Small Medium
Type
of In- Re-
Re- Total
nova- Don’t fused Don’t
fused to No Yes No Yes No Yes
tion know to know
answer
answer
Prod- 273 17,200 4,710 124 907 296 227 3,273
0 (0) 0 (0) 00
uct (1.1) (72.5) (19.8) (0.5) (3.8) (1.2) (1) (100)
Pro- 273 17,200 4,710 124 907 296 227 3,273
0 (0) 0 (0) 00
cess (1.1) (72.5) (19.8) (0.5) (3.8) (1.2) (1) (100)
273 17,200 4,710 124 907 296 227 3,273
Market 0 (0) 0 (0) 00
(1.1) (72.5) (19.8) (0.5) (3.8) (1.2) (1) (100)
53
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
E-commerce
Turnover tax
Only 14.4 per cent of MSMEs in Embu County (3,442) had a previous monthly turnover
of above Ksh 83,333, which translates to Ksh 1 million a year. Ideally, this would be
the establishments that are eligible for turnover tax with the new thresholds recently
introduced vide the tax laws (Amendment) Act, 2020. The actual impact of this move may
be difficult to estimate due to data challenges on actual revenue streams and the number of
establishments that comply with the same.
The main constraints faced by MSMEs in Embu County include: local competition (15.5%),
licences (13.9%), poor roads/transport (12.4%), lack of markets (8.2%), and poor security
(4.6%) (Figure 5.16).
Figure 5.16: Main constraints faced by MSMEs
54
Manufacturing , trade and MSMEs
Figure 5.17 presents the effects of COVID-19 on household non-farm and farm businesses
in Embu County. 100 per cent of the respondents reported a decrease in their business
activities due to the pandemic, hence they were all affected. Equally, 100 per cent of the
respondents have had a decrease in their income due to COVID-19. This is an indicator that
COVID-19 is already having a negative effect on the non-farm and farm businesses even
though the situation is still evolving.
Figure 5.17: Effects of COVID-19 on household non-farm and farm businesses
55
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
The survey also indicates the wholesale and retail trade sector lost 13.1 hours in usual
and actual hours worked while accommodation and food services lost 10 hours. This is
an indicator of the adverse effects of the pandemic on the service sector of Embu County
implying loss of productivity, output and employment. Equally, the manufacturing sector
was hard hit losing 33.5 hours.
Key Messages:
(a) The key sectors that drive Embu County economy include: Services, Agriculture
and Manufacturing. Hence, support should be targeted to these sectors to ensure re-
engineering of the County economy.
(b) The main constraints faced by establishments in manufacturing include: lack of
markets, licenses, local competition, poor roads/transport, poor security and power
interruption
(c) The key constraints faced by MSMEs in Embu County include: local competition,
licences, poor roads/transport, lack of markets, and poor security.
(d) COVID-19 presented opportunities that could be harnessed like development
and support of innovations to address the pandemic. These include production
of essential goods such as; masks, Personal Protective Equipment (PPEs), and
sanitizers, disinfectants, canned foods, immunity boosting products, hospital
beds and ventilators. As the pandemic subsidies a strategy is required for smooth
transition.
(e) Training and capacity building are important in assisting MSMEs to surmount the
shocks faced during the pandemic but also allow for re-emergence.
(f) In terms of re-engineering, there is need to consider establishing support measures to
re-vitalize and re-open businesses that collapsed during the crisis within the county.
56
Manufacturing , trade and MSMEs
The following are some of the opportunities created by COVID-19 in trade, manufacturing
and the MSMEs sector:
(i) Agro - processing for value addition with important areas of focus include horticulture,
maize production and processing, and dairy production; other areas of priority
include tree tomato, avocado, bananas, loquat, passion fruit, mangoes, macadamia,
tea, and coffee.
(ii) The textile and wearing apparel sectors can be enhanced to provide PPEs for use
within the County and potentially for the export market.
(iii) There are opportunities to step up innovations among the manufacturing firms and
MSMEs in Embu County.
(iv) COVID-19 has increased demand for locally produced goods. It is an opportunity for
industry and MSMEs development and generation of jobs for the youth.
5.4 Recommendations
To support trade, manufacturing and the MSMEs sector, the County will:
(i) Develop a land development strategy that safeguards the high potential agricultural
land by setting the urban growth limits to preserve the high potential areas and
regulate the subdivision of this land.
(ii) Develop urban-based agro-industries in Embu town to focus on proximity to
agricultural raw materials and promote agricultural value addition.
(iii) Promote rural development through provision of infrastructure and agricultural
sector development and related economic activities.
(iv) Enhance agricultural production by intensifying the use of the land.
57
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
6. Infrastructure
Majority of households own a bicycle (17.5%) and a motorcycle (13.9%). Car ownership is
at 6.6 per cent (KNBS, 2019). The main means of transport used in the county is walking
at 44.61 per cent, followed by motorbike 22.79 per cent, PSV matatus at 20.35 per cent,
bicycle (boda boda) 6.49 per cent and private car at 4.22 per cent (Figure 6.1) while 69.95
per cent of the population had not changed the main means of transport (KNBS, 2020b). On
average, residents travel 4.2 kilometres to their workplace at an average cost of Ksh 70.37.
For the commute to school, residents spend on average Ksh 554.41 (KIHBS, 2015/16).
58
Infrastructure
Figure 6.2: How has the cost of your MAIN travel changed?
59
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
Figure 6.4: Has delivery of your household goods and services been affected
by COVID-19?
Road network
The county has a total of 3,993.42 kilometres of classified road network. The paved County
road network covers 56.09 km, while the paved National roads cover 239.17 km. Out of the
total paved road network of 295.26 km, 84.4 per cent is in good condition, 9.7 per cent in
fair condition and 4.7 per cent in poor condition. The unpaved road network in the county
covers 2599.59 km (county roads) and 311.17 km (National roads), of this, 22.4 per cent
is in good condition, 48.9 per cent fair and 28.4 per cent in poor condition as depicted in
figure 1 (KRB, 2019).
60
Infrastructure
The unclassified road network in the County covers 787.13 km, with 747.07 km of narrow
roads, that is, road with a reserve of between 4 -9 meters, while there is a total of 40.06 km
of new roads.
Constraints faced
The Rural Access Index (RAI) measures the proportion of the rural population who live
within 2 km of an all-season road5. The county has a RAI of 77 per cent which is above
the National Average of 70 per cent, indicating that access to transport in rural areas is
above average (KRB,2019). This has positive implications with regard to sectors that rely
on accessibility such as agriculture, trade and overall development. The road condition mix
of the unpaved network at 28.4 per cent is a constraint to development.
Transport has linkages in providing accessibility to the agriculture sector for inputs and
market access.
The county has the opportunity to strategically improve the road network for economic
development, while creating jobs for youth, women and vulnerable groups as espoused in
the Roads 2000 programme6 on labour based road development approaches.
The Roads 10,000 programme being implemented nationally by the roads sub-sector
actors, and specifically, the Low Volume Sealed Roads (LVSR) approach7 offers a strategic
and cost-effective approach to improve rural accessibility in the County.
Residents predominantly rely on matatu walking and motorbike this is an opportunity
during the pandemic period as this mode reduces the risk of infections that would arise
from use of motorized public transport8.
5
RAI defined : https://datacatalog.worldbank.org/dataset/rural-access-index-rai
6
Roads 2000 programme http://krb.go.ke/our-downloads/roadsper cent202000per cent20strate-
gicper cent20plan.pdf
7
LVSR /Roads 10,000 programme https://www.kerra.go.ke/index.php/lvsr
8
Non-Motorized Transport strategy https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2020/05/cities-support-
people-walking-and-cycling-work/
61
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
6.1.4 Recommendations
(i) Sensitize PSV and boda boda operators on COVID-19 prevention measures and
assist vehicle owners in retrofitting vehicle designs for social distance, hygiene and
ventilation.
(ii) Improve and expand infrastructure for Non-Motorized Transport (NMT) in urban
areas and along roads with heavy -high speed traffic to promote sustainable mobility
options and enhance road safety for all road users. This is in line with the Integrated
National Transport Policy 2009 and the Sustainable Development Goals9.
(iii) Re-develop bus parks and termini to address crowding and social distancing concerns
stipulated in the public health guidelines.
(iv) Identify county significant infrastructure projects, with project speed emphasis, for
implementation to support economic recovery from the effects of the pandemic.
(v) Apply labor based and local resource-based approaches for road development and
maintenance, where technically and economically feasible, in line with the Roads
2000 national policy10.
(vi) Focus on increasing the share of unpaved roads in good and fair condition to above
62 per cent which is the national average. For the unpaved road network, focus on
adopting the Low Volume Sealed Roads (LVSR) technology for greater network
coverage cost effectively.
(vii) Adopt climate smart road engineering designs to safeguard road and bridge
infrastructure from floods and to harvest storm water for irrigation and productive
use. Use the Kenya Urban Support Programme funding to build storm water
management systems in urban areas.
The analysis of the 2019 KPHC reveals that only 14.7 per cent of the conventional households
in the county ‘own’ internet with 6.3 per cent owning a desktop, computer laptop or tablet.
Internet access, ICT device ownership and TV ownership is particularly critical not only for
access of COVID-19 information, but as well as supporting remote learning by the pupils as
well as remote working (figure 6.6).
62
Infrastructure
63
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
The county experienced gender divide in use of internet and ICT devices as well as mobile
money subscriptions. Both internet and ICT device use are higher among the male with
23.6 per cent of the men and 20.6 per cent of the women using internet, while 10.2 per cent
of the men and 8.7 per cent of the women using Desktop/Laptop/Tablet devices (KPHC
2019).While the usage is below the national averages, the county recorded a similar gender
disparity with the national averages in internet and ICT usage.
64
Infrastructure
Constraints faced
• ICT is applicable in public service delivery for business continuity during time of
lockdowns, emergencies and disasters.
• Public primary schools have been provided with ICT infrastructure and services for
digital literacy.
(i) Potential to use ICT infrastructure and services in public primary schools for
community access to ICT.
(ii) Emerging technology such as satellite and airborne transmitters for internet
connectivity.
(iii) Potential to create and transform home based economies dependent on e-commerce
for women and youth.
6.2.3 Recommendations
(i) Support programmes in partnership with the private sector that will enable
households acquire ICT assets such as smart phones and laptops and increase mobile
phone ownership from the low of 57.0 per cent to 100 per cent in line with the global
agenda for Universal Access to Mobile Telephony11
(ii) Collaborate with the Communications Authority of Kenya and telecom service
providers to utilize the Universal Service Fund12 as a “last resort” in providing ICT
access in remote areas where market forces fail to expand access.
(iii) Speed up the construction of fiber-optic broadband networks in underdeveloped areas
and collaborate with telecom companies to upgrade and improve the communication
networks in remote areas. Adopt programmes to ensure ubiquitous access to reliable
and affordable internet (internet everywhere) by applying aerial and satellite-based
communication technologies.
(iv) Harness the power of technology and use innovative solutions to bridge the gender
digital divide. Negotiate with the public primary schools for community access to ICT
infrastructure and collaboratively build and equip youth empowerment, ICT centres
and ICT laboratories as provided in the CIDP. The IT personnel in public primary
65
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
schools can be deployed to support the development of ICT competence and skills
among the public.
v) Enhance internet connectivity to public buildings and key trade centres to boost
e-commerce especially for MSMEs in trade and business. The NOFBI programme
can be expanded to the sub-county administrative units to further enable deployment
of e-governance solutions.
vi) Make ICT a standalone sector for planning and budget allocation. This is aimed at
giving strategic prominence to planning, budgeting and investment in ICT.
vii) Review and implement ICT policies and procedures to manage ICT and mitigate cyber
threats. Collaborate with the national Computer Incident Response Team (CIRT) and
the Communications Authority (CA) towards managing cyber threats, disasters and
pandemics. This is because enhanced use of ICT is known to raise threats and risks
related to cyber-crime and misinformation.
66
7. Housing and Urban Development
There are three urban centres in the County with a total population of 48.8 per cent males
and 51.1 per cent females, table 7.1. The urban land area covers 42 square kilometres with
a population density of 1800 persons per sq.km
Table 7.1: Distribution of population by urban centres by gender in Embu
County
The housing tenure is predominantly owner occupied at 73.0 per cent, with 27.0 per cent of
the households under rental tenure. Individuals are the primary providers of rental housing
at 92.0 per cent, followed by National Government (3.7%); and Private Companies (2.6%),
Figure 7.1. For those who own homes, 96.3 per cent constructed the houses while 0.9 per
cent purchased the house and 2.8 per cent inherited their homes (KNBS, 2019).
Figure 7.1: Distribution of households renting/Provided with the main
dwelling unit by provider
67
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
Housing quality
On average, the main dwellings of houses in the County have 3.09 habitable rooms against
an average household size of 4.23 persons in a household, translating to approximately
1.37 people per room. According to the UN-Habitat, overcrowding occurs when there are
more than three people per room13. In terms of housing quality (building material), 73.46
per cent of houses are constructed using finished materials for walls, floor and roofing
compared to 26.54 per cent constructed using rudimentary materials (KIHBS, 2015/16).
Majority of households (95.0 per cent) have iron sheets for roofing, bricks walls (20.9 per
cent) and Concrete/Cement/Terrazo floors (50.9%) (KNBS, 2019).
Rent payment
On average, rental households spend approximately Ksh 4610 on rent with a minimum
of Ksh 500 and the maximum of Ksh 15000 (KNBS, 2020b). The county recorded a rent
to income ratio of 15.82 per cent which is within the acceptable threshold of 30 per cent
(KNBS, 2012/13).
With the advent of COVID-19 pandemic, households’ ability to pay rent has been affected,
with 34.29 per cent of the population indicating inability to pay rent on the agreed date for
April 2020, figure 7.2, compared to 26.7 per cent of the population that were able to pay
rent on the agreed date and 47.76 per cent who paid rent on agreed date before COVID-19
pandemic, figure 7.3.
Figure 7.2: Has your household paid the rent for April 2020 on the agreed date
68
Housing and urban development
Figure 7.3: Was the household paying rent on the agreed date with the landlord
before COVID-19?
69
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
Figure 7.5: What measures has your household taken to overcome the effects
of Corona Virus – rent
Constraints faced
(i) Partnership with National Government and Private Sector for home improvement
(roof, floor and walls) under the Big Four Agenda.
(i) Existing stock of owner-occupied homes that can be improved using finished building
materials for roofing, walls and floors.
7.4 Recommendations
(i) Avail appropriate building technology for use by the public in house construction and
improvement in every sub-county, that responds to local cultural and environmental
circumstances.
(ii) Fast-track implementation of the affordable housing programme with a focus on
improving living conditions and building quality applying finished materials for
walls, floors and roofing.
70
Housing and urban development
(iii) Identify and designate urban centres for upgrade pursuant to provisions of the Urban
Areas and Cities (amendment) Act, 2019.
(iv) Develop and implement urban planning and design instruments that support
sustainable management and use of natural resources and land in line with the New
Urban Agenda and as mitigative measure to future pandemics and disasters.
(v) Formulate and seek approval of urban development plans and development control
policies to support investment and development of urban areas.
(vi) Adopt programmes aimed at an increasing household access to clean energy sources
and technologies for cooking to mitigate against exposure to respiratory diseases.
71
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
8. Tourism
Tourism is a key sub-sector in Embu County that has a high potential in the county for both
local and international tourists. Some of the available sites include caves, waterfalls and
rocky hills (Karue, Kianjiru, Kiambere, Ndune, Kirimiri, Maranga, Kiang’ombe) to support
hiking; Kamburu and Masinga hydro-electric power dams; Mt Kenya and Mwea National
Parks that host various wildlife (including elephants, Zebra, Buffalo; Elephant, lesser kudu,
Nile crocodile, hippo, giraffe, Burchell’s zebra, buffalo, leopard, grey duiker, black-backed
jackal, bushbuck, waterbuck, olive baboon, sykes’ monkey, serval cat, spotted hyena,
warthog) and over 200 bird species. The Mwea Game Reserve is the only protected area in
which the globally threatened and Kenya-endemic Hinde’s babbler is known to occur. Embu
is also a gateway to Mt. Kenya which, if aggressively marketed can bring huge incomes to
the county. Other attractions include 3751 Ha of forests that supports eco-tourism; Agro-
tourism (coffee and tea plantations); medical tourism (Traditional herbalists and medicine
men; Embu referral hospital).
Development and recurrent expenditure incurred on the Trade, Tourism, Investment, and
Industrialization sector in 2013-2017 was only 1.2 per cent and 0.4 per cent respectively of
the total spending; while in the same period, accommodation and food services accounted
for 0.8 per cent of total GCP. This indicating the need to prioritize development of the
tourism sector.
72
Tourism
8.4 Recommendations
(i) Promotion of domestic tourism to cushion the economy from impacts of travel
advisories and constraints caused by the pandemic on international tourist
arrivals.
(ii) Regular maintenance of tourism attraction sites.
(iii) Tourism marketing and promotion
(iv) Diversification of tourism products.
(v) Opening of access routes to the tourist sites.
(vi) Community sensitization on tourist sites in the county.
(vii) Promotion of eco-tourism, cultural and sports tourism in the 6 main rivers (Tana,
Rupingazi, Kii, Ena, Thiba, Thuci) and two hydro-electric dams.
(viii) Development of tourism infrastructure (route to Mt. Kenya, star-rated hotels, tourist
sites, tented camps).
(ix) Enforcing guidelines on high sanitation standards for the hospitality sector to stop
the spread of COVID-19 and other pandemics while ensuring business continuity.
(x) Inspect all the tourism establishments in the county and train tourism service
providers.
73
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
9. Health
The government owned 50 per cent of the facilities, 33 per cent of these facilities were
owned by private and 17 per cent owned by faith-based organizations. However, government
indicating increased reliance on public facilities for curative healthcare services owns
approximately 56 per cent of the health centres and hospitals.
Table 9.1: Health provision
Year 2018 2019/20
Health facility density
Primary health facilities 141 210
Hospitals 8 8
Number of health facilities 149 218
Health facility density 2.5 3.2
Bed density
Hospital beds 1,576 1,648
No. of Beds per 10,000 population 24 24
Human resource density
Total workforce 2,966 2,858
Human Resources for Health (Technical) 2,268 2,282
Number per 10,000 population 42.5 45.9
Source: Ministry of Health (2021)
In 2019/2020, the number of health facilities in the county were 218 which comprised of
210 primary health facilities and 8 hospitals. This was an improvement from a total of 149
health facilities in the previous year, 2018. The number of beds per 10,000 population is
24 which is lower than the WHO recommendation of 30 beds per 10, 000 population. The
health facilities and personnel serve a growing population of 608,599 people according
2019 census. In 2019/20, total health workforce was approximately 2,282 representing
45.9 health workers per 10,000 population which is higher than the WHO target of 23
health workers per 10,000.
74
Health
The percentage distribution of the population with health insurance cover by type
of insurance provider is presented in Table 9.3. In general, 32.7 per cent of the county
population had some form of health insurance cover. The National Hospital Insurance
Fund (NHIF) was the leading health insurance provider reported by 94.5 per cent of the
population. Employer contributory insurance cover was reported by 3.3 per cent of the
population. Private contributions to insurance cover were reported by 2.9 per cent of the
population.
75
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
Place of delivery
In the 2015/16 KIHBS, women in Embu county were asked the place where children aged
5 years and below were delivered. Table 9.4 shows the percentage distribution of children
by place of delivery, in the county. About 20.2 per cent of children were delivered at home
which is below the national percentage of 31.3 per cent. The proportion of children born
in hospitals, health centres, dispensary/clinics was 61.1 per cent, 15.3 per cent, and 1.4 per
cent respectively.
Table 9.4: Proportion of children aged 0-59 months by place of delivery (per
cent)
Place of Delivery Proportion of Children aged 0-59 Months by
place of delivery (per cent)
Hospital 61.1
Health Centre 15.3
Clinic/ Dispensary 1.4
Maternity Home 0.0
At Home 20.2
Other 0.0
Not stated 1.7
Number of Individuals
(‘000) 57
Source: KIHBS 2015/16
76
Health
The 2015/16 KIHBS covered data on measles immunization for children below 5 years at;
9 months (Measles I) and at 18 months (Measles II). The information was collected from
vaccination cards where they were available while mother’s recall was used where the card
was not available. Table 9.5 presents information on the proportion of children immunized
(from vaccination cards) against measles. The analysis focused on children aged 12-23
months (or one year). The county had 53.1 per cent of the children aged 12-23 months were
fully immunized against measles at 9 months while 21.6 per cent were fully immunized
against measles at 18 months.
Table 9.5: Proportion of children aged 0-59 months immunized against
measles
Proportion of Children
Vaccination Card Yes Seen 67.0
Yes, Not Seen 26.3
No 6.7
Not stated 0.0
Measles Vaccination Measles I (At 9 months Card) 53.1
Measles II (At 18 months Card) 21.6
Measles II (Mother/ Guardian
memory) 30.5
Either (card or memory) 83.6
Number of
Individuals (‘000) 57
Health outputs
The main conditions causing morbidity are outpatient health facility visits and mortality
in the county across all ages were upper respiratory tract infections, malaria, skin diseases,
and diarrheal diseases. The conditions attributed to several risk factors in the environment
in which the people of Embu live in, such as inadequate water, and inadequate ventilation.
The prevalence of injuries is attributed to poor road condition largely while malaria
is attributed to seasonal flooding. An underlying factor across the conditions among
populations with low socio-economic status include low immunization coverage, lack of
adherence to exclusive breast feeding, and poor nutrition.
In terms of inpatient morbidity cases, the main contributors to the burden are both
communicable and non-communicable diseases such as diarrhoea diseases, malaria,
pneumonia, peptic ulcers, hypertension, psychosis, poisoning, diabetes, anaemia, and
road injuries. Notably, abortion is also a contributor to admissions indicating that there is
gap in provision of family planning and other reproductive health services. The associated
morbidities risk factors for other conditions include inadequate water, inadequate
77
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
ventilation, lifestyle habits, poor health seeking behaviours, drugs, and alcohol abuse as
well as inadequacies in diagnosis and treatment.
The most affected groups during COVID-19 pandemic were the infant, young children,
mothers, adults and elderly. For instance, the maternal and child services indicators
indicate that 86 per cent of mothers accessed skilled delivery, while about 16 per cent of the
children are born at home and 82 per cent of children get full immunization. This implies
almost 1 in 5 children are at the risk of getting diseases, poor health and immunity system.
The infant mortality rate and under-five mortality is high recorded as 44 deaths per 1000
births and 49 deaths per 1000 births respectively.
The county proportion of stunted children of 26.8 per cent, wasted children of 3 per cent
and underweight children of 11.1 per cent almost at bar with the national averages of 26 per
cent, 4 per cent and 11 per cent respectively. Additionally, the HIV adult prevalence stood
at 2.8 per cent, with adult and child ART coverage standing at 80 and 87 per cent. The
county performed relatively better than national averages in terms of the low prevalence of
communicable conditions including HIV, Malaria and TB.
Table 9.6: Health sector performance
The county established 404 beds in readiness for management of COVID-19 cases, and
another 18 ICU beds for those who may need critical care. To support the ICU, the County
had also put in place an oxygen plant in the main isolation centre in Embu Level 5 Hospital,
which runs at 80 litres per minute. The county had also cascaded services to manage the
spread of the virus to all the four Sub-Counties through the county emergency response
78
Health
team. The county had also put in place other measures to mitigate the impact of pandemic.
This included the prioritization of health services, identifying and setting up centers for
COVID-19 pandemic to limit interference and contact with those seeking services in the
big hospital. The county also identified and set up centres for the pandemic making them
COVID-19 centres to ensure there was no interference with services in the main hospital.
Recruitment for more health workers was carried out to boost the human resource (nurses
and clinical officers) in the hospitals. The county also offers counselling services to her
health care professionals over and above the safety measures for the front-line health
providers. To enhance mobility and access, the county had purchased a new vehicle to
facilitate more efficient transportation of reagents to Nairobi, which is depended upon for
testing services.
However, the county faced some drawbacks in the fight against the pandemics for some
instances. The county had shortage of doctors, nurses and specialists. Most of the healthcare
workers in the county required adequate training on the COVID-19 management protocols
and infection prevention. The County had two isolation centres. Inadequate PPEs among
the frontline healthcare workers working in various health care facilities. The health sector
needs to focus on empowering the workforce and upgrading of working conditions and
provision of requisite health commodities and equipment, especially in relation to personal
protective equipment and occupational safety, implementing the following strategies.
Effects of COVID-19
In June 2020, Kenya National Bureaus of Statistics conducted a survey of COVID-19. The
results showed share of the population that had doctor or healthcare provider testing or
confirming to them the status in regards COVID-19 was estimated at 2.7 per cent in 2020
(COVID-19, Wave 2 survey). Further only 1 per cent of the population indicated that at
least one household member had failed to seek health services and 87.5 per cent of the
population indicated they will be willing to be tested if there was mass testing for COVID
19.
Figure 9.1: COVID-19 testing, 2020
79
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
As per the latest National Adolescents and Youth Survey (NAYS) report of 2020, the main
health problems affecting young people are teenage pregnancies, drug and substance abuse
(DSA), STI and/or HIV and AIDS infections, malnutrition, mental health problems, SGBV
and abortion. Other problems identified were poor sanitation and existence of diseases
such as malaria. Other causes of the health issues in the county were high levels of poverty
in households, fear of knowing HIV status. Addiction to drugs and substance abuse,
idleness, parental negligence / lack of parental guidance and lack of or inadequate health
information and services
COVID-19 has worsened the situation as far as youths and women were concerned. These
groups had faced several challenges even before the outbreak of the COVID-19. FGM and
Gender based violence cases had increased with the lock down.
DANIDA Health Sector Programme Support III (Kenya) introduced Nomadic Clinics which
can help handle community support for any emerging health issues including COVID-19
cases. The clinics offer basic health services such as immunization and skilled birth
attendance. To ensure further outreach motorbikes are attached to each clinic and these
are sent out into the community in special circumstances such as to ensure that children do
not miss their immunization shots.
World Vision had donated hundreds of water tanks, over 1000 liquid hand soaps ,700
litres of hand sanitizers and 10 fumigating equipment in a programme aimed at creating
awareness on the need to do regular hand washing. The World Vision also partnered with
the public health officials in the county to train and sensitize the public over COVID-19.
The Safaricom foundation had also handed over PPEs to benefit around 300 healthcare
workers in two health centres and an isolation facility. The PPEs included N95 Masks,
Surgical masks and protective clothing. The Kenya Red cross in partnership with Safaricom
foundation also support the county in helping the households affected by flood.
Hepatitis B and Snakebites are two emerging conditions which are of public health concern
in the county. There is an upsurge of cases of Hepatitis B in the lowland areas of the
county. Inadequate community awareness on the prevention of transmission of Hepatitis
B is considered a contributing factor. Snakebites incidences are also common and are
attributable to human animal wildlife conflict. There is an acknowledged gap in capacity of
health care workers to treat snakebites and lack of supply of anti -venom; hence implying
expected demand for referral services.
The most common cases of referrals relate complications in the County are chronic kidney
diseases, broncho-pneumonia, intestinal obstruction, and acute anemia. These critical
conditions do require a functional ICU and a blood transfusion unit which have yet to be
completed and operationalized.
Due to the stigma of COVID-19, the health-seeking behavior of the Embu citizens had also
80
Health
been affected. There was a decline in the number of pregnant women attending maternal
child health clinic thereby increasing their risk of early and late pregnancy complications.
In addition, there was acute decline in the number of children going for immunization
services therefore this could lead to increased susceptibility of these children to infections
and nutritional imbalances.
Access to other services like patient support centres (PSC) for People Living with HIV
(PLHIV) was also at risk as people shy away from health facilities; causing another risk of
likely surge in new HIV infections and reduced viral suppression.
9.4 Recommendations
In line with the health status in the county, some of the recommendations that need
attention include the following:
(i) The need creates awareness on availability and importance of free maternity services
and address other constraints to access of maternal health services in the county to
address fear of contracting COVID19 in event of visiting a health facility.
(ii) In addition, the County needs to consistently allocate resources towards nutrition
specific and sensitive programmes in the various sectors by establishing specific
budget lines for nutrition support initiatives.
(iii) Adopt community health outreach programs to sensitize its members to adopt proper
health seeking behaviours that could have been affected due to the stigmatization
that comes along with the pandemic.
(iv) The county government through the Department on planning will need to secure
full board accommodation to the frontline healthcare workers to minimize cross-
infection.
(v) The county government will need to sensitise expectant women on the need to
attend regular antenatal clinics for checkup and the caregivers of children need to be
sensitized on the importance of immunization.
(vi) Revamp, expand, modernize and equip existing health facilities such as Embu Level 5
hospital as well as recruiting additional public health officers and community health
workers to strengthen preventive and primary health systems in the County.
(vii) Implement a comprehensive human resource health management system including
undertaking training needs assessments and strengthening information system
including contact tracing; ensure skilled, motivated and equitable deployment of
health care workers.
(viii) Promote and support public and community health including the installation of
hand washing facilities in homes, and public and private institutions such as schools,
workplaces and health care facilities within all the sub counties of Embu County.
(ix) Proactively address the mental health needs including those of the health workforce,
81
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
82
10. Education and Training
Embu County has a total of 619 pre-primary centres, 552 primary. Infrastructures are in
place to support water and sanitation efforts in learning institutions by the county. The
county had rolled out plans to provide hand washing facilities in schools.
About 84.9 per cent of public primary schools in Embu County had been installed with ICT
infrastructure and devices under the Digital Literacy Programme (DLP) (ICT Authority,
2019). The infrastructures include learner digital devices (LDD), teacher digital devices
(TDD) and the Digital Content Server and Wireless Router (DCSWR).
There are 519 primary schools in the county: 385 public schools and 134 private. Total
enrolment in primary schools stands at 124,774: 101, 425 in public primary schools and
23,349 in private primary schools. The average school size of public primary schools is 263,
while in private primary schools is 174. The primary gender parity index in Embu County is
0.95. The primary pupil teacher ratio is 26:1.
The total number of secondary schools is 212: 197 public and 15 private. The total
enrolment in secondary schools is 56,607; 54,368 enrolled in public schools and 2239 in
private schools. The average class size in public secondary schools is 276 and 149 in private
secondary schools. The gender parity index in secondary schools is 1.09. The pupil teacher
ratio in secondary schools is 25:1.
The number of ECDE centres in the county stood at 610 of which 390 are public while 220
are private as at 2015. The total enrolment in ECDE centres is 22,010: 15,641 in public
ECDE centres and 6369 private. The gender parity index in ECDE centres is 1. The total
number of teachers in ECDE centres is 684, translating to a pupil-teacher ratio of 23:1.
The county has three university campuses namely: Chuka University College; Kenyatta
University Campus; and Embu University College. Additionally, the county had 4 teacher
training colleges and 26 youth polytechnics in four of the five sub-counties; 25 are public
and 2 being private as at 2015. The total enrolment at the youth polytechnics was 1189.
Furthermore, the county had 257 adult education centres (AEC) with a total of 5249
students enrolled and 113 teachers, translating to a student teacher ratio 46 of as of 2015.
Gross Attendance Ratio (GAR) is the total number of persons attending school regardless
of their age, expressed as a percentage of the official school age population for a specific
level of education. Table 10.1 presents the GAR by sex and schooling level for Embu County.
GAR for pre-primary school was 69.5 per cent while that of primary school and secondary
83
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
school was 119.0 and 66.0 per cent respectively. The GAR for pre-primary school was
higher for males, 76.6 per cent, compared to that for females, 60.4 per cent. The GAR for
primary school was higher for females, 125.6 per cent, compared to that for males, 113.9
per cent. The GAR for secondary school was higher for males, 67.8 per cent, compared to
that for females, 64.3 per cent.
Net Attendance Ratio (NAR) is the total number of persons in the official school age group
attending a specific level to the total population in that age group. Table 10.1 shows that
total NAR for pre-primary, primary and secondary school was 57.0, 94.2 and 44.0 per cent,
respectively.
Table 10.1: Gross attendance ratio and net attendance ratio by educational
level in Embu County
Education Level Gender Gross Attendance Net Attendance Ratio
Ratio
Pre-Primary School Male 76.6 65.5
Female 60.4 45.0
Total 69.5 57.0
Primary School Male 113.9 93.6
Female 125.6 94.9
Total 119.0 94.2
Secondary School Male 67.8 47.7
Female 64.3 40.6
Total 66.0 44.0
Source: KIHBS 2015/2016
The pre-primary gross enrolment rate in the county was 82.4 per cent in 2019 and while
the net enrolment rate was 56.8 per cent. The Gross Primary and Secondary enrolment
rates stood at 111.7 per cent and 88.4 per cent respectively in 2019 while the Net enrolment
rates (NER) were 88.4 per cent and 54.4 per cent for primary school and secondary school
respectively during the same period.
Table 10.2: Gross and net enrolment rate (%), 2019
Pre-primary 2019
Gross Enrolment rate (GER) (%) 82.4
Net Enrolment rate (NER) (%) 56.8
Gender parity index 1.00
Primary
Gross Enrolment rate (GER)(%) 111.7
Net Enrolment rate (NER) (%) 88.4
Gender parity index 0.95
84
Education and training
Secondary
Gross Enrolment rate (GER) (%) 88.4
Net Enrolment rate (NER) (%) 54.4
Gender parity index 1.10
Source: KNBS (2022)
Literacy
Educational Attainment
The distribution of population aged 3 years and above by educational qualification attained
is presented in Table 10.4. Approximately 48.4 per cent of the population did not have any
educational qualification. This was higher than the national percentage of 49.7%. Only 0.9
per cent of the population had attained university degree. The proportion of the population
with CPE/KCPE qualification is 29.8 per cent and that of KCE/ KCSE qualification is 12.8
per cent.
85
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
Highest education
86
Education and training
87
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
ICT in education
Closure of all schools led to loss to learning time and teaching time. The e-learning program
at home was strained because of limited access and capacity in ICT integration in education
hence there was no learning for students in most homes during this COVID-19 pandemic.
Figure 10.1: Access to ICT in households and schools
The demand for PPEs such as masks in the County had led to local production by vocational
technical training centres (VTCs) hence creating employment and income for youth. It will
however be important to address issues of standards and quality of the local produced
PPEs. Further, the pandemic had provided an opportunity for enhancement of the health
facilities through advancement in equipment and employment of more health personnel
in the county.
The County with support from stakeholders will need to continue to invest in early
childhood development through infrastructural development to allow for adequate social
distancing; deployment of ECDE teachers, provision of sanitation facilities and enhanced
88
Education and training
school feeding programme. To achieve these objectives, the county will require to partner
with the national government and private sector to enhance ECDE and vocation training
through infrastructural development as well as equipment of all ECDE, primary, secondary
and vocational training; and University branches in the County with adequate WASH and
adequate learning spaces.
10.4 Recommendations
(i) The County with support from stakeholders to continue to invest in early childhood
development through infrastructural development to allow for adequate social
distancing when schools reopen; deployment of ECDE teachers and provision of
sanitation facilities.
(ii) The county to involve communities to mobilize learners to enrol in schools while
deepening implementation of COVID 19 mitigation measures. The county would
combine community participation and large-scale direct communication campaigns
to parents, and where possible, increase attendance options to accommodate all
children, including those with highest risk of dropping out, also promote back to
school campaign and community outreach to ensure that no child dropped out of
school due to COVID-19 emergency.
(iii) The County to prioritize projects that improve school water, sanitation and hygiene
facilities and management in order to reduce future effect of similar or related
outbreak while promoting public health in learning institutions.
(iv) The county to promote remedial/catch up lessons for learners who might have lagged
behind also schools to utilize ICT platforms and have a depository of teaching and
learning materials that learners could use at their own time and while at home.
(v) The county to provide financial or in-kind support, such as school feeding, to help
families overcome the increased costs of attending school, also provide psychosocial
support to teachers and learners.
(vi) Concerted efforts will also be required to fight drug and substance abuse among the
youths in the county. This can be done through counselling and ensuring that they
are not idle especially this period when learning institutions are locked.
(vii) The County Government will need to support private institutions which are facing
threat of closure due to losses as a result of closing schools. This can involve giving
grants and loans to the private schools.
89
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
According to the KNBS census 2019, Embu County has a population of 608,599 of which
6.4 per cent are the elderly and 4.4 per cent are people living with disabilities. The overall
poverty rates in the county stand at 44 per cent which was higher than the national average
(36.1 per cent). Despite being an agricultural county, the county’s food poverty levels were
at 28 per cent and 28 per cent of the total population is multi-dimensionally poor. Further,
about 27 per cent of the children population were stunted. The impact of the COVID-19 to
the county’s economy cannot be gainsaid.
To cushion the citizens, the county has implemented various safety net programmes. The
County targeted to provide cash transfer to 200 households in each sub – county, provide
cash transfer to 50 households in each sub – county for poor and severe disabled persons.
The County also supported and built capacities of individuals, vulnerable groups and
communities for equity and self-reliance through training. With increasing demand for
cash transfers, the County government initiated targeted cash transfers to the elderly and
food distribution to vulnerable households both before and during COVID-19 period.
Severe shocks have had negative impact to the household’s economic and social welfare of
county residents. Table 11.1 presents the proportion of households by the first severe shock
in the county. The major shock in the county was dearth of livestock which affected 25.3
per cent of the households followed by drought/floods and Death of family Member which
affected 21.2 per cent and 8 per cent of the households in the county.
Household business failure, large rise in price of food and Severe water shortage were
also other major shocks in the county affecting 3.4 per cent, 1.5 per cent and 6 per cent
respectively. Crop disease or crop pests were experienced by 1 per cent of households while
the 3.6 per cent reported having their livestock stolen as other 4 per cent of the households
reported to have experienced Break-up of the households.
90
Social protection
Table 11.1: The proportion of households by the first severe shock in the County
The proportion of
First Severe Shock
households (per cent)
Droughts or Floods 21.2
Crop disease or crop pests 1
Livestock died 25.3
Livestock were stolen 3.6
Household business failure, non-agricultural 3.4
91
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
Households in the county received various forms of social assistance or transfers or gift
either in form of a good, service, financial asset or other asset by an individual, household
or institution. Transfers constitute income that the household receives without working
for it and augments household income by improving its welfare. Cash transfers include
assistance in form of currency or transferable deposits such as cheque and money orders.
The proportion of households that received cash transfers by source, household headship,
residence and county is presented in Table 11.2. Overall, 24 per cent of the households
received cash transfers. A higher proportion of households received transfers from within
the country (65%), mainly from individuals (83%) while external transfers constituted 2
per cent.
Table 11.2: The proportion of households that received cash transfers by
source, and household headship
Beneficiaries
Total Number of Households 164,000
Households receiving transfers (per
cent) 24
From Inside Kenya Individual 21,703
Non-Profit 643
Institution
National 1,095
Government
County 664
Government
Corporate -
Sector
Inside Kenya 24,106
Outside 531
Kenya
Total 24,253
Number of house- 40,000
holds that received
transfers
Source: KIHBS 2015/2016
The gender inequalities issues in the county were evident. Embu County had 4 youth
empowerment Centres aimed at skills development and talent harnessing. During the
COVID-19 pandemic, the county experienced a surge in teenage pregnancies and violence
meted against young boys, girls and women. This was attributed to COVID-19 and the
resulting measures that led to staying at home and closure of schools. Teenage pregnancies
were associated with high rates of school dropouts, stigma, increased mental health
92
Social protection
Regional unity in the fight against corona pandemic and exploitation of the eco-
nomic potential was observed. The disease had also provided an opportunity to
measure how county governments are prepared to handle the devolved functions.
Health being a devolved function, it has really exposed the counties as many of
them lacked required health facilities such as ICU beds and enough medical per-
sonnel. The virus had also provided an opportunity to develop social protection
programs to cushion the vulnerable groups in the community in case of outbreak
of other diseases.
Gender based violence has social and economic implications in any society. It
severely restricts women’s ability to exercise their socio-economic and reproduc-
tive health rights; constrains women from fully contributing to overall econ-
omy’s development leading to loss of incomes; and exacerbates health costs.
Youth unemployment also leads to under-utilization of youth potential especially
at the peak of their life cycle.
11.4 Recommendations
COVID-19 pandemic created effects with immediate and long-term economic consequences
for children, PWDs, elderly and their families. In an effort to strengthen social protection
response in face of a similar pandemic, the county government would:
(i) Undertake research in collaboration with KEMRI, NCPWD and University of Embu
to get a better understanding of the actual situation of disability and chronic illness
in Embu County, and to map existing initiatives towards managing the effects of the
pandemic in the County.
(ii) Promote interventions towards the expansion of social protection initiatives
targeting elderly persons. This to also involve increasing the cash given to elderly.
(iii) Protect vulnerable groups in the population from health costs by enhancing NHIF
coverage; improving knowledge of the existing insurance schemes to improve uptake;
and subsidizing NHIF premiums for targeted vulnerable populations.
93
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
Agriculture is the main driver of the economy in Embu County with over 70 per cent of
the residents being small scale farmers. Small percentages are business people and civil
servants working in government institutions. Tea, coffee and cotton have been the main
cash crops. The farmers in the county were greatly affected by COVID-19, mainly because of
national lockdowns and social distancing policies. The agriculture sector was experiencing
a low traffic on sales and movement of goods, which in turn had an adverse effect on
market operations and cash flow for farmers. The export and import restrictions created
uncertainty on the crop farming and tourism industry forcing the farmers to undertake
emergency response measures to prevent the spread of COVID-19 in communities, this
resulted to loss of jobs and income amongst the farmers.
Table 12.1: Distribution of population age 5 years and above by activity status,
and sex in the County
94
Labour participation
activities which require some specialized skills through technical training or apprenticeship.
Also, more men than women are involved in business because they can access credit more
easily than their female counterparts.
Food crops, livestock and to a large extent horticulture production comprise the major
economic activities in the agricultural sector. Cottage and small-scale industries are minor
economic activities carried out in the market centres.
Effects of COVID-19
Several economic activities were disrupted as Markets were closed to prevent spread of
COVID-19 including Ishiara market which is the largest goat market in the county. Other
markets that were closed included Karaba, Kiritiri, Gachoka, and Kianjokoma. The public
sector was not an exemption as Embu GK Prison was locked down due to fear of spread of the
COVID-19 after some prisoners tested positive. Law courts were also closed limiting service
delivery. Bars and entertainment joins were also closed. The county government relocated
the miraa market from the central business district to Embu Stadium as a precaution. Miraa
traders were required to pay Ksh 50 each daily for maintaining cleanliness at the stadium.
The unemployment level has increased during the period of COVID-19, according to May
2020 KNBS COVID-19 Survey, 13.1 per cent of the county labour force worked at least for
1 hour for pay; 8.1 per cent had never worked, and 78.6 per cent worked in the informal
sector. However, 2.4 per cent of employees did not attend to work due to COVID-19 and
86.8 per cent of employees worked without any pay. On average, workers in the County lost
11.7 hours per week due to COVID-19; 67.0 per cent of county residents recorded decrease
in income while 5.0 per cent recorded increase in their income.
During the pandemic, about 10.6 per cent of workers in the county were casual workers
47.7 per cent were regular workers (full time), 5.1 per cent employees were working as
part time. However, majority of these workers (48.3%) reported decrease in income while
1.5 per cent of people reported to have experienced increased income. These could be the
people working in the health sector who are supplying medical equipment such as masks
and PPEs. About 12.4 per cent of workers indicated to have benefited from government tax
exemptions which indicates about 87 per cent did not benefit from National government
tax relief for low-income-earning persons, a reduction in the top Pay-As-You-Earn (PAYE)
rate, and other changes such as cash transfers, credit relief, lower VAT, and a corporate tax
cut.
95
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
Figure 12.2: Difference between usual hours worked and actual hours worked
during COVID-19 period
96
Labour participation
private sector schools, teachers and other workers lost their incomes. Some other businesses
such as bars and hotels totally closed, leading to reduced business activities. Workers
in the transport sector were rendered jobless due to restrictions of moving in and out of
Nairobi and Mombasa counties; and reduced movement within Embu County. On average,
the county lost 11.7 hours worked in a week, this indicating that although the measures
that were imposed by the Government to mitigate the spread of COVID-19 contributed
positively towards managing the pandemic; they had significant economic repercussions
with implications on job losses.
The county government have been provided with the opportunity to use digital platforms to
enable remote access to jobs for their employees where the Human Resource Management
will have an essential role to play in navigation of the situation caused by the pandemic.
There had been notable efforts by the county government to invest more money in training
health workers. The county government now has an opportunity to reskill its employees and
develop strategies (mid- and post-pandemic strategies) to adapt to any future pandemic.
With the widespread stay-at-home orders, most of county employers were adjusting
operations and shifting workforces online.
12.4 Recommendations
97
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
(vi) Encourage more investors to invest in Embu county by offering incentives such as
tariff exemptions and tax waiver. This will enable individuals establish businesses
therefore creating employment opportunities.
98
13. Conclusion and Key Recommendations
13.1 Conclusion
Fiscal policy
The agri-food analysis highlights the sector was negatively affected by COVID-19 in terms
of labour supply, trade and marketing operations, food supply and the resulting effects
on food prices. The County’s agricultural productivity is also affected by: - variable and
extreme weather events; dependence of rain fed agriculture; low agro-processing and value
addition opportunities; land fragmentation; low access to quality and affordable inputs;
low crops, livestock, and livestock products marketing opportunities; poor access to
agricultural finance; low access to major off-farm services including extension, climate and
market information, and credit services; and pests and livestock diseases; and farm losses
and post-harvest waste. This adversely affects the productivity of the sector and impairs
marketing and consequently places livelihoods and food security at risk especially in times
of emergencies. The analysis calls for strategies to enhance productivity, profitability, and
resilience of the sector for improved livelihoods.
Most households rely on surface water, dug well as well as piped water among urban
households. dug well, to minimize the risks of households missing water, it is important
to put in place measures to ensure protection of water resources for continuity of access to
clean and safe water by households.
99
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
The momentum in manufacturing, trade and MSMEs was disrupted by the COVID-19
pandemic as the containment measures associated with COVID-19 pandemic took a heavy
toll on the sector. In sustaining growth and building resilience in this sector, it is important
to expand trade and strengthen production capacity of MSMEs and especially those
involved in manufacturing by exploiting opportunities afforded by the pandemic such as
production of masks, PPEs, hospital beds, ventilators, reagents, gloves, and sanitizers.
However, it is also critical to ensure the transitioning out of such products is well managed
as the Covid-19 pandemic slows.
The main means of transport used in the County is walking followed by motorbike. The
paved County Road network covers 56.09 km, while the paved National roads cover 239.17
km. Out of the total paved road network of 295.26 km, 84.4 per cent is in good condition,
9.7 per cent in fair condition and 4.7 per cent in poor condition. The status of ICT access and
use in the county was low, especially among households. The perception that the individual
does not need to use the internet, lack of knowledge and skills on internet are the leading
reasons that the people in the County do not have internet connection, as well as accessing
internet elsewhere. The housing tenure is predominantly owner occupied at 73.0 per cent,
with 27.0 per cent of the households under rental tenure. The county has challenges in
quality of the housing stock.
Tourism
Tourism has a high potential in Embu County for both local and international tourists. The
Mwea game reserve is the only protected area in which the globally threatened and Kenya-
endemic Hinde’s babbler is known to occur. Embu is also a gateway to Mt. Kenya which,
if aggressively marketed can bring huge incomes to the county. Other attractions include
3751 Ha of forests that supports eco-tourism; Agro-tourism (coffee and tea plantations);
medical tourism (Traditional herbalists and medicine men; Embu Referral Hospital).
Development and recurrent expenditure incurred on the Trade, Tourism, Investment, and
Industrialization sector in 2013-2017 was only 1.2 per cent and 0.4 per cent respectively of
the total spending; while in the same period, accommodation and food services accounted
for 0.8 per cent of total GCP. This indicating the need to prioritize development of the
tourism sector.
Health
COVID 19 has worsened the situation as far as youths and women are concerned. These are
the groups of people that have been facing several challenges even before the outbreak of
the COVID 19. FGM and Gender based violence cases have increased with the lock down.
Youths who are entrepreneurs have also been affected losing jobs and businesses due to the
lockdown. Other problems facing youths includes teenage pregnancies, malnutrition, STI/
HIV and Aids, poor environment, drug and substance abuse and malnutrition
100
Conclusion and key recommendations
The County had gaps in early childhood development through infrastructural development
to allow for adequate social distancing; deployment of ECDE teachers and provision of
sanitation facilities. The county recorded low completion rates at all levels of education.
Social Protection
Labour participation
The COVID-19 pandemic has expedited the speed at which different firms and businesses
within the county are changing their pay programmes through pay reductions and
incentive resets. It is important for the County to promote implementation of appropriate
labour market interventions especially those working in the agricultural sector, which is a
major employer in the County and policy reforms that drive employment creation. Deepen
technical education, training and skills development.
Fiscal Policy
To steer the county towards achieving its budgetary objective and development goals
contained in the ADPs and CIDP; mobilize more finances from OSR to increase the
available revenues for budgetary operations, seek for more funding in form of grants
from development partners to cater for the critical development projects in the county,
ensure that the ongoing projects are completed before launching new project and clear any
pending bills and arrears owed to suppliers and ensure the ongoing infrastructure project
are completed and suppliers paid within the specified timelines for optimal returns to
investment and to spur private sector activity.
To successfully build resilience and enhance growth of the agriculture sector: explore
partnerships to develop agro-processing and value addition capacities at the County; invest
in sustainable irrigation and water harvesting technologies; enhance access to storage and
cooling facilities; enhanced commercialization opportunities among small holder farmers;
link farmers to diverse product markets; strengthen the County’s institutional capacity
in disaster surveillance and management; enhance farmers access to critical agricultural
inputs and services and build their technical capacity to act on information obtained; and
strengthen agricultural cooperatives.
101
Socio-economic status of Embu County with COVID-19
To build resilience and mitigate the effect of COVID-19, increase water supply in
households, institutions, and public places through drilling of boreholes, dams, and access
to piped water in all the sub-counties. Promote the use of safe and improved toilets in
schools, health care facilities, workplaces, and public places by connecting households to
piped sewer. Promote handwashing as a stop gap measure against COVID-19.
To sustain growth in the manufacturing, trade and MSMEs sector: Develop a land
development strategy that safeguards the high potential agricultural land by setting the
urban growth limits to preserve the high potential areas and regulate the subdivision
of this land; Develop urban-based agro-industries in Embu town to focus on proximity
to agricultural raw materials and promote agricultural value addition; Promote rural
development through provision of infrastructure and agricultural sector development and
related economic activities; and Enhance agricultural production by intensifying the use of
the land.
Improve and expand infrastructure for Non-Motorized Transport (NMT) in urban areas
and along roads with heavy -high speed traffic to promote sustainable mobility options and
enhance road safety for all road users; speed up the construction of fiber-optic broadband
networks in underdeveloped areas; and avail appropriate building technology for use by
the public in house construction and improvement in every sub-county, that responds to
local cultural and environmental circumstances.
Tourism
For recovery of the tourism sector, promote domestic tourism to cushion the economy
from impacts of travel advisories and constraints caused by the pandemic on international
tourist arrivals, regular maintenance of tourism attraction sites, tourism marketing and
promotion, diversification of tourism products, opening of access routes to the tourist sites,
community sensitization on tourist sites in the county, promotion of eco-tourism, cultural
and sports tourism in the 6 main rivers (Tana, Rupingazi, Kii, Ena, Thiba, Thuci) and two
hydro-electric dams, development of tourism infrastructure (route to Mt. Kenya, star-rated
hotels, tourist sites, tented camps), enforcing guidelines on high sanitation standards for
the hospitality sector to stop the spread of COVID-19 and other pandemics while ensuring
business continuity and inspect all the tourism establishments in the county and train
tourism service providers.
Health
For a resilient health sector, create more awareness on immunization so that mothers can
ensure their children get immunized. Implement a comprehensive human resource health
management system including undertaking training needs assessments and information
system to ensure skilled and motivated health care workers, equitable deployed across all
sub-counties. Pay salaries in time to avoid cases of strikes and low staff morale. Recruit
102
additional of public health officers and community health workers to strengthen preventive
and public health systems.
The County with support from stakeholders to invest in early childhood development
through infrastructural development; deployment of ECDE teachers and provision of
sanitation facilities. Provide financial or in-kind support, such as school feeding, to help
families overcome the increased costs of attending school and provide psychosocial support
to teachers and learners during and after the pandemic.
Social Protection
Build linkages with other Ministries, and with NGOs that work with vulnerable groups
to strengthen families, deliver assistive devices, reduce barriers to access and provide
vocational training. Undertake research to get a better understanding of the actual situation
of disability and chronic illness in the County, and to map existing initiatives on social
protection to improve on targeting to reach all those who deserve support
Labour Participation
Enhance investments and mechanisms for up skilling and reskilling, deepening technical
skills as well as ICT skills; and retraining employees on how to work from home, where
applicable. Protect workers in the informal economy by pursuing innovative policies to
reach them quickly through a combination of non-contributory and contributory social
security schemes and facilitate their transition to the formal economy in the longer term.
103
Kenya Institute for Public Policy Research and Analysis
Bishops Garden Towers, Bishops Road
P.O. Box 56445-00200, Nairobi, Kenya
Tel: +254 20 4936000; +254 20 2719933/4
Fax: +254 20 2719951
Email: [email protected]
Website: http://www.kippra.org