See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/351074168

Use of Geotextiles in Roads Over Weak Subgrades

Chapter · April 2021

DOI: 10.1007/978-981-33-6466-0_34

CITATIONS READS

8 1,685

5 authors, including:

Abdullah Ansari Prashant Daigavane

Sultan Qaboos University Government College of Engineering Nagpur
43 PUBLICATIONS 343 CITATIONS 21 PUBLICATIONS 60 CITATIONS

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

All content following this page was uploaded by Abdullah Ansari on 29 April 2021.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.

Use of Geotextiles in Roads Over Weak
Subgrades

Abdullah Ansari , Prashant B. Daigavane, Shahrukhakhan Pathan,

Naseer Shaikh, and Firoj Shaikh

Abstract The present scenario in India demands maximum transit facilities to

develop at a low cost within shortest feasible time. Analysis performed on majority
of the failed roads owe them to the founding soil over which these roads were
constructed. Jute geotextiles, produced abundantly in this subcontinent, may be used
beneficially and economically with great efficacy for stabilization of such weak
subgrades. Though there have been extremely limited but successful construction of
roads over soft soils using jute geotextile in India, their systematic use is yet to be
resorted to. Since, the experience gained from their adoption in practice and also
from ongoing research certainly prove to be rewarding, the geotechnical commu-
nity should perhaps exploit this potential and encourage such applications which
result in enhanced performance of highways at an optimal cost. A tentative design
methodology thought to be adopted for this is also presented.

Keywords Geotextile · Subgrades · Pavement · Separation · Embedment soil

1 Introduction

Transportation contributes to the all-around development of a country and hence,

plays a vital role toward its progress. India being predominantly rural in nature, road
links are found to have distinct advantages over other modes of communication.
However, economy, time, environmental constraints among several other factors

A. Ansari (B)
Department of Civil Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology, Delhi, New Delhi 110016, India
e-mail: [email protected]
P. B. Daigavane
Department of Civil Engineering, Government College of Engineering Nagpur, Nagpur 441108,
India
S. Pathan · N. Shaikh · F. Shaikh
Department of Civil Engineering, Government College of Engineering and Research, Awasari,
Pune 412405, India

© The Author(s), under exclusive license to Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd. 2021 365
S. Patel et al. (eds.), Proceedings of the Indian Geotechnical Conference 2019,
Lecture Notes in Civil Engineering 137,
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-33-6466-0_34
366 A. Ansari et al.

make a highway professional’s job more challenging in delivering a safe and cost-
effective road network to its users. One of the major problems faced by the engineers
in highway construction in plains and coastal areas of India is the presence of soft
soil at ground level. This strata being of considerable depth cannot be removed by
excavation. Thus leaving no choice but to build roads over them. This condition may
be further worsened if supplemented with poor drainage or a lack of it.
Majority of the investigations on failure of such roads built on soft soil attribute
it to the presence of fine-grained soil which gets intermixed with the aggregate base
materials destroying the structural strength of the aggregate by interfering with stone
to stone contact. It is also mentioned here that unsatisfactory performance of poor
subgrade is again associated with lateral displacement of the subgrade and the base
materials under load. The conventional remedy to overcome this phenomenon is
the provision of a blanket course of alternatively usage of stabilized local soils as
a sub-base layer. Though this may to some extent aid in resolving the problem, the
remedial measures may prove to be time-consuming and quite expensive and in many
cases many compromise in terms of cost–benefit ratio or quality which could further
aggravate the problem.
The lacuna identified with the traditional approach commands the problem to be
tackled at its rudimentary level by rectification of the basic weakness of the formation
subgrade and to settle for a strategic solution. It is in this context that jute fabric when
applied at the interface of the subgrade is found to resolve the issue by improving
the quality of weak soil subgrade. However, this concept of incorporating an extra
indigenous element at the subgrade level is by means a modern idea.

2 Literature Review

2.1 General

Bacteria and fungi are the two main groups of microorganisms responsible for the
microbial decomposition of natural textile materials [1]. The probability of bacterial
damage is greater when jute comes in to contact with soil and soil bacterial. It is
reported that the minimum moisture requirements for the growth of bacteria and
fungi on jute are 20% and 17%, respectively. Jute attains these moisture contents
when exposed to atmospheres of 90 and 80% relative humidity, respectively, for
aerobic soil bacterial growth a temperature of 37 °C is ideal whereas for growth it is
30 °C. Jute materials when exposed to sunlight and rain will become more susceptible
to fungal attack [2, 3].
A change in initial pH value of the medium from acidic to alkaline and vice versa
when jute specimens were embedded in mediums and kept in an incubator [4]. It was
stated that this occurred due to the action of fungi only. Very limited studies were
conducted on soil burial test using jute [5, 6]. The degradation studies reported above
an overall view of the complex factors governing the same. However, they cannot
Use of Geotextiles in Roads Over Weak Subgrades 367

be directly used by a geotechnical engineer from an engineering point of view [7].

The strength reduction of jute embedded in a soil having pH 8.7 after 10 months as
70–80% [8]. It was reported that the strength reduction may be due to the alkaline
environment rather than moisture in the soil.
The limited literature reveal that the rate of degradation of jute geotextile in various
environmental conditions has not been a subject of detailed study. A basic knowl-
edge will certainly help the rational design and selection criteria for jute geotextiles.
A permeable textile material (usually synthetic) used with soil, rock or any other
geotechnical engineering-related material to enhance the performance or cost of a
human-made product, structure or system.

2.2 Functions of Geotextiles

Fluid Transmission. Geotextile can provide fluid transmission. In the fluid transmis-
sion geotextile collects a liquid or a gas and conveys it within its own plane toward
an outlet.
Filtration. Geotextile acts as filter. In this it allows the liquid to pass through it
normal to its own plane. It prevents most of the soil particles to pass through it.
Therefore it allows only water to pass not the soil particles.
Separation. When a geotextile is placed in between fine particles and coarse particles
it acts as separator. Here the geotextile avoids mixing of fine particles and coarse
material like gravel and stones under the repeated action of loads.
Protection. Geotextile protects a material when it distributes the stresses and strains
transmitted to the material. Under this two cases are considered, both surface
protection and interface protection.
Tension Membrane. When the geotextile is placed between two materials having
different pressures, geotextile performs a function of tension membrane. It tries to
balance the pressure difference between the two materials and strengthening the struc-
ture. Also the geotextile acts as a tensile member when it provides tensile modules
and strength to a soil. This increase in strength is due to the friction, cohesion or
interlocking between geotextile and soil.
Drainage. As the geotextile is a permeable material it plays an important role in
drainage for most of the civil engineering structures like dams, road pavements,
embankments, etc., in which drainage of the water is most important. For these
structures different underdrain systems should be constructed. Due to use of geotex-
tiles in these structures for drainage, efficiency of under drainage system is increased
construction has become easy.
368 A. Ansari et al.

3 Geotextiles in Road Applications

This part of the paper discusses the use of geotextiles for asphalt concrete (AC)
overlays on roads and airfields and the separation and reinforcement of materials in
new construction. The functions performed by the geotextile and the design consid-
erations are different for these two applications. In an AC pavement system, the
geotextile provides a stress-relieving interlayer between the existing pavement and
the overlay that reduces and retards reflective cracks under certain conditions and
acts as a moisture barrier to prevent surface water from entering the pavement struc-
ture. When a geotextile is used as a separator, it is placed between the soft subgrade
and the granular material. It acts as a filter to allow water but not fine material to
pass through it, preventing any mixing of the soft soil and granular material under
the action of the construction equipment or subsequent traffic (Fig. 1).

3.1 Paved Surface Rehabilitation

Under an AC overlay, a geotextile may provide sufficient tensile strength to relieve

stresses exerted by movement of the existing pavement. The geotextile acts as a stress-
relieving interlayer as the cracks move horizontally or vertically. Impregnation of the
geotextile with a bitumen provides a degree of moisture protection for the underlying
layers whether or not reflective cracking occurs.

3.2 Reflective Crack Treatment for Pavements

Geotextiles have been successful in reducing and retarding reflective cracking in mild
and dry climates when temperature and moisture changes are less likely to contribute
to movement of the underlying pavement; whereas, geotextiles in cold climates have
not been as successful. Even when the climate and thickness requirements are met,

Fig. 1 Geotextile in asphalt

concrete overlay
Use of Geotextiles in Roads Over Weak Subgrades 369

there has been no consistent increase in the time it takes for reflective cracking to
develop in the overlay indicating that other factors are influencing the performance.

3.3 Pavements Separation and Reinforcement

Soft subgrade materials may mix with the granular base or sub-base material as a
result of loads applied to the base course during construction and/or loads applied to
the pavement surface that force the granular material downward into the soft subgrade
or as a result of water moving upward into the granular material and carrying the
subgrade material with it. Also, the subgrade can be stabilized with lime or cement
or the thickness of granular material can be increased to reduce the stress on the
subgrade. Geotextiles have been used in construction of gravel roads and airfields
over soft soils to solve these problems and either increase the life of the pavement
or reduce the initial cost.

4 Experimental Programme

4.1 General

Degradation behavior was studied by conducting tensile strength tests at different

intervals on specimens of jute fabric embedded in different environments. Acceler-
ated degradation tests on specimens of jute were conducted in different environments
by keeping them in a humidity cabinet maintained at a temperature of 300 °C and
a relative humidity of 90 + 1%. Since it has been reported in the literature that
this condition is ideal for fungi growth in natural materials. The minimum moisture
requirements for the growth of fungi and bacteria were also maintained in almost all
the soil environments.

4.2 Embedment Conditions

Fabric specimens of 70 mm × 210 mm length were embedded in the following soil

environments, comprising of fine-grained sand clay of medium plasticity, manure
and garden soil.
a. In sand at a water content of 12% (Admixture Y )
b. In clay at a water content of 45%, i.e. above its plastic limit value (Admixture K)
c. Sand mixed with manure in equal proportion (1:1) at a water content of 20%
(Admixture YK 1 )
370 A. Ansari et al.

Table 1 Summary of physical properties of jute fabrics [9]

Property Woven jute fabric type A Woven jute fabric type B
Mass per unit area (g/m2 ) 675 342
Thickness at 2 kPa (mm) 1.56 1.32
Mesh size per (cm) Four, double strands in M/D and Four single strands each in M/D
four single strands in XM/D and XM/D
Fabric density (g/cc) 1.47 1.36
Type of fabric structure Plain woven Plain woven
Tensile strength (kN/m) 24.05 12.60
Wide width M/D 17.58 10.30
XM/D 25.66 13.50
Narrow width M/D XM/D 18.70 10.65
AOS (mm) 0.28 0.19
POA (%) 5.0 6.5

d. Clay mixed with manure in equal proportion (1:1) at a water content of 50%
(Admixture K 1 )
e. Sand mixed with clay and manure in equal proportion (1:1:1) at a water content
of 30% (Admixture YK 1 )
f. Garden soil having an organic content of 8% at a water content of 30% (Admixture
G)
g. Burial soil having an organic content of 3% at a water content of 6% (Admixture
B).
Narrow strip tensile strength tests were conducted at regular intervals on speci-
mens of 50 mm × 75 mm length obtained from the degraded specimens. The dura-
bility studies were continued till percent reduction in strength of jute fabric took
place in all the admixtures (Table 1).

4.3 Result and Discussion

We did the formulation of commonly used admixtures using clay, sand, manure,
garden soil and burial [9]. The reduction in strength at the end of 24 days for jute
Type a under different conditions is presented in Table 2.

4.4 Influence of Fabric Density

For admixture Y 1 , Type A lost its complete strength within 35 days and Type B
within 24 days whereas it was 147 days and 90 days, respectively, in Admixture K.
Use of Geotextiles in Roads Over Weak Subgrades 371

Table 2 Summary of percentage reduction in strength of jute fabric (type A), kept in different
environments at the end of 24 days (Initial strength = 25.66 KN/m)
Admixture Combination of Organic Initial moisture Final strength % reduction in
materials content (%) content (%) (kN/m) strength
K Clay 0 45 21.3 17
Y Sand 0 12 16.94 34
G Garden soil 8 30 12.83 50
B Burial 3 6 11.55 55
YK 1 Sand + Clay + 12 30 3.34 87
Manure (1:1:1)
K1 Clay + Manure 22 50 1.28 95
(1:1)
Y1 Sand + Manure 22 20 0.51 98
(1:1)

In all other Admixtures, Type A variety took longer for complete strength loss which
could be to its high areal density.

4.5 Influence of Embedment Soil

The comparatively faster rate of decrease in strength in Admixture Y1 could be due

to the aerobic environment prevalent in the freely draining sand which enables faster
growth of microorganisms in manure. The strength of Type A has been reduced by
98% in 14 days in Admixture Y 1 (with manure) while that in sand alone was only
19% in 14 days. It clearly implies that organic content accelerates the decay of the
jute fiber. A large number of black spots were visible on the surface of the jute
geotextiles retrieved from Admixture Y 1 .
The strength reduction after 14 days in Admixture K 1 were 86 and 58% whereas
in clay alone (Admixture K). The faster rate of decomposition in the former could
only be due to the presence of organic content. A general order of degradation was
observed in both verified with the exemption of Admixture G and B1 (Garden soil
and Burial). The Type B Variety showed a smaller strength reduction in Admixture
B compared to Admixture G. More investigation is required to understand this trend.

4.6 Influence of Soil Burial

From the burial test, it was observed that Type A variety lost its complete strength
within 70 days. Whereas it was 49 days for Type B. By this time the fabric could
not even withstand the handling. However, the fabric was found to be in an impaired
372 A. Ansari et al.

condition in the test pit but with no strength for nearly 10 and 8 months, respec-
tively, before it completely coalesced with the soil. From the accelerated up-gradation
studies conducted, it was found that jute losses its complete strength within 3.5 and
5 months in sand and clay, respectively. Even though the fabrics lost their strength
within a short span of time which depends on the type of soil moisture and organic
content of soil as well as the climatic conditions, it was found that jute fabric was in
an impaired condition for a further duration of time before it coalesced with the soil.
During this period, it can be presumed that fabric can perform the functions which
do not require strength.

5 Conclusion

Fine-grained saturated soils exist over wide areas in plains and coastal belts. Pressing
necessity of accommodating the escalating population confronted with the dearth of
unutilized land poses a bottleneck situation which demands construction activities
over these adverse areas. Geotextiles can play a significant role in such situations
which demand construction activities over these adverse areas. Jute geotextiles can
play a vital role in such situations and serve as an effective and economic tool in the
rehabilitation of the nation’s highway system. General apathy toward acceptance of
a new technique over existing norms should not be a factor against their utilization as
overall assessment evaluated on the basis of trend of serviceability with time reveal
their efficiency in mitigating such problems. Several case histories of its applications
show very encouraging results and advantageous natural properties of the fabric
indicate great scope for its application in difficult road construction situation.

References

1. Chakravarty, T., Bose, R.G., Basu, S.N.: Fungi growing on jute fabrics deteriorating under
weather exposure and in storage. J. Appl. Microbiol. 10(5), 441–447 (1962)
2. Hausman, M.R.: Geotextiles for unpaved roads—a review of design procedures. J. Geotext.
Geomemb. 5, 201–233 (1987)
3. Sidare, D., Chattopadhyay, K.K., Chattopadhyay B.C.: Characteristic of geojute as a filter
medium for bank protection. In: Proceedings IGC, Baroda (1997)
4. Giroud, J.P., Noiray, L.: Geotextiles reinforced unpaved roads design. J. Geotech. Eng. Div.
ASCE 17(9), 1233–1254 (1981)
5. Chakravarty, S., Chattpadhyay, B.C.: Role of the jute geotextile in paved roads over soft cohesive
soils. In: Proceedings All India Seminar on Application of jute Geotextiles in Civil Engineering,
The Institution of Engineers (India), Kolkata (2002)
6. Chattopadhyay, B.C., Schakravarty: River Bank protection with jute an efficient cost-effective
method. J. Inst. Eng. (India) 79 (1999)
7. Azizand, M.A., Ramaswamya, S.D.: Some Studies on jute geotextiles and their application.
Geotechnical World, Eastern Ltd., New Delhi (1997)
 Use of Geotextiles in Roads Over Weak Subgrades 373

8. Rao, P.J., Rao, A.S., Murthy, P.V.B.R.K., Venisri, N., Bindumadhaca: Jute geotextile for
improving the performance of highway embankment of soft marine soil. In: Proceedings national
seminar on jute based geotextile, New Delhi (1996)
9. Koerner, R.M.: Designing with geosynthetics, 5th edn. Pearson Education Ltd., London (2005)

View publication stats