Alimul Imran (62211120111)
Alimul Imran (62211120111)
Alimul Imran (62211120111)
Islam gives a complete vision that encompasses all aspects of community interaction: political,
economic, social, and so on. The individual is enshrined in the West, which isolates the fields of
knowledge and activity.
Western worldview
Western worldview put emphasize more to the material aspect of human well being.
Ignores the importance of religion or spiritual
Not recognize any role for divine guidance in human life.
Little room for the roles & government intervention due to their own worldview.
More on human reasoning.
Self interest & market system drive the western worldview.
i) Economics and its related activities are potentially ibadah or acts of worship.
ii) In Islam, religion is not human creation, but it represents a “way of life” – Din.
ii) Religion reduced to a private matter between and individual and his/her God(s)
Islamic economics:
Conventional economics:
Unlimited wants.
Limited resources.
Achieving the highest utility.
For a believing Muslim, this life is immensely meaningful and purposeful since he understands
that it will determine his fate and permanent position in the next life. In preparation for his final
return to Him, he lives to win the approval of his Creator.We're all aware that people create things
to serve them by performing specified functions for them. God created us to serve Him, but with
one key difference: it is for the benefit of us, His creation, rather than the Creator himself. The
purpose of our existence is thus stated in the Qur’an:
"I did not create the jinn and mankind except to worship Me." [51:56]
Falah refers to a situation in which an individual is adequately provided for in terms of his basic
needs, and has the necessary freedom and leisure to work for his spiritual and material
advancement,it aims to establish a happy society with a clean environment, freedom from want, and
opportunities for its members to advance in socio-political aspects. The concept of falah, in strictly
economic field, refers to material well-being of the citizens of an Islamic state. The economic system
of Islam, therefore, aims to achieve economic well-being and betterment of the people through
equitable distribution of material resources and through establishment of social justice. Yet the basic
objective of Islamic system remains the same which has been clearly laid down by the Qur’an thus :
“But seek with (the wealth) which God has bestowed on thee, the home of the Hereafter, nor neglect
thy portion in this world, but do thou good as God has been good to thee and seek not mischief in the
land, for God loves not those who do mischief.”(28 : 77). Primary means of achieving falah are
virtues of the soul, that can be acquired with help of bodily and external virtues, if they are given
divine grace.
Chapter 2
Islamic economic
Islamic economics is the knowledge and application of injunctions and rules of the Shari'ah
that prevent injustice in the acquisition and disposal of material resources in order to provide
satisfaction to human beings and enable them to perform their obligations to Allah and the
society.
Western economic
Western economics is the name given by Chinese scholars to the economic theories that have
emerged and prevailed in developed western countries with a capitalist market economy. It is a
concept with rich connotations and somewhat vague extensions
4.Refer to works of past and present scholars of Islam and Islamic economics.
6.Establish principles, laws, assumptions, hypothesis models based on (1)-(5), i.e. tentative theory
(what should be).
7.Test hypotheses and models, i.e. empirical studies (what is) if what is ≠ what should be
9.Put forward policies to change the what is to conform with what should be.
3. Compare and contrast between Methodology of Islamic economics and secular economics.
The primary premise of Islamic economists on methodology is that the subject is not strictly positive
in the way that a pure science should be. They also argue against neoclassical economics' basic
assumptions, such as rationality, utility, profit maximisation, and self-interest.
Secular economics considered all knowledge originated from human research and exploration. It
makes a distinction between reason and revelation derived from the generic western thought and
relies on reason alone as the sources of knowledge.
4. What is the importance of Knowledge in Islam.
The Quran encourages people to think, contemplate, reflect, and learn in order to become closer to
God and his creation. The Quran employs repetition to instil certain vital principles in the minds of
those who listen to it.
To seek knowledge is a holy duty; it is obligatory on every Muslim, male and female.
The first revealed word in the Qur’an was "IQRA" READ i.e. it encourages man to seek
knowledge, to be educated.
Islamic perspective
Process of systematizing the worldview into economic vision, then to economic theory based
on epistemology.
Epistemology: theory of knowledge is the branch of philosophy concerned with nature and
scope (limitations) of knowledge.
Western perspective
Man as a seeker of knowledge should know very well what actually his real nature, then he
will be able to seek the right and the true knowledge which is suitable for his nature.
First and foremost he should realize that he has dual nature, i.e. physical and spiritual.
Man has basically agreed to obey Allah and has made a covenant or contract with Him
during his spiritual stage but has forgotten the contract.
7. Analyse types and purpose of knowledge in Islam.
In the Western world, knowledge refers to information about anything, whether divine or material,
however in Islam, 'ilm is a broad term that encompasses theory, action, and education. It is not
limited to the acquisition of knowledge alone, but also includes sociopolitical and moral
components. It necessitates understanding, devotion to the ideals of Islam, and believers acting on
their faith. Purpose of seeking knowledge in Islam is to inculcate goodness in man as man and
individual self, recognizing and acknowledging Allah as his Lord (7:172), and to remind him on
the sealed agreement with Allah when he was in the state of spirit prior to his manifestation as
physical man.
Chapter 3
Three main concepts of Islamic economy, according to Mohammed B. Sadr, are multifaceted
ownership, economic freedom within a specific extent, and social justice (Es-Sadr, 1980: pp. 291-
303). These are the three fundamental elements of Islamic economic doctrine, which constitute its
theoretical content.
The Free Market's Belief System. The path to human advancement is sustained economic growth
as measured by the gross national product. Without government intervention, free markets produce
the most efficient and socially optimal resource distribution.
Adl/Ihsan: adl means giving to each what is due, Ihsan giving more than what is due
(benevolence)
Takaful/Taawun: cooperation (among economic agents more than competing towards
harmful ends)
Responsibility/accountability: As a person gains more economic power, he becomes more
responsible for others in the society. Hence, individual is responsible to society, but
ultimately accountable to Allah.
Moderation: in Islam maintains the principles in consumption, production, distribution to
maintain the correct balance in life.
Conventional Economics System
Concept of scarcity: nature is niggardly and human wants unlimited (scarcity exists
because nature under provides resources while human wants are unlimited)
Self-interest: priority to individual goals (the purpose of the individual is to achieve his own
personal goals. He is not naturally obliged to service society. Instead, society exists to serve
him).
Absolute freedom: survival of the fittest (Man is free to use his economic rights and the
market is the place for him to do so)
Materialism and utilitarianism (utility or satisfaction can only be achieve through material
pursuits rather than ethical, moral or spiritual pursuits)
3. Compare and contrast between Islamic and conventional economics philosophical foundations.
Islamic systems
Concept of scarcity: nature is niggardly and human wants unlimited (scarcity exists
because nature under provides resources while human wants are unlimited)
Self-interest: priority to individual goals (the purpose of the individual is to achieve his own
personal goals. He is not naturally obliged to service society. Instead, society exists to serve
him)
Islamic economics
Specific operational principles
Adl/Ihsan: adl means giving to each what is due, Ihsan giving more than what is due
(benevolence)
Takaful/Taawun: cooperation (among economic agents more than competing towards
harmful ends)
Responsibility/accountability: As a person gains more economic power, he becomes more
responsible for others in the society. Hence, individual is responsible to society, but ultimately
accountable to Allah.
Moderation: in Islam maintains the principles in consumption, production, distribution to
maintain the correct balance in life.
Conventional Economics
Derived from theories developed by western scholars
Main philosophical foundation of CES can be summarized below
Concept of scarcity: nature is niggardly and human wants unlimited (scarcity exists because
nature under provides resources while human wants are unlimited)
Self-interest: priority to individual goals (the purpose of the individual is to achieve his own
personal goals. He is not naturally obliged to service society. Instead, society exists to serve
him).
Absolute freedom: survival of the fittest (Man is free to use his economic rights and the
market is the place for him to do so)
Materialism and utilitarianism (utility or satisfaction can only be achieve through material
pursuits rather than ethical, moral or spiritual pursuits)
Positivism (science) versus norms (religion): the value system of any society is shaped by its
observable and actual practices without the need to question those practices.
5. Describe characteristics of Islamic economics
Property ownership
Motivation
Decision making
Coordination mechanisms
Role of government
Public ownership:
Conventional Economics
In IES, incentives are derived from shari’ah; both moral and material
Discusses how to make / encourage subordinates follow Qur’an and Sunnah:
Motivation mechanism for an Islamic economic system avoids extreme motivation and
requires a balance or moderate approach.
The Islamic worldview requires some attention: extended time horizon (beyond this world)
referred as the Hereafter. This implies that believers have to weigh their personal interests
in both the current world and the Hereafter in order to be successful in both worlds.
10. Compare and contrast both Islamic and conventional economics mechanism of coordination.
Islamic economis
In Islam, the market must fairly reflect the norms and values of both consumers and
producers' behaviour.
Different rules of the market govern supply and demand
The central role of the state/government is to ensure that market rules are not breached.
Conventional economics
Western economics
Islam talk of Shura - mutual consultation between higher and lower level
People voice their views before decision makings are made
Decision must be within limits of Shari’ah
Eg. Prophet asked for opinions
People participation in decision making, no bias towards extreme
Chapter 4
Scarcity
Islamic perspectives
Western perspective
The path to human advancement is sustained economic growth as measured by the gross
national product.
Without government intervention, free markets produce the most efficient and socially
optimal resource distribution.
Economic globalisation, which is done by removing obstacles to the free flow of goods and
money everywhere in the world, boosts competition, boosts economic efficiency, boosts job
creation, lowers consumer prices, expands consumer choice, boosts economic growth, and
benefits practically everyone.
Location of resources depends on ideals of the a society. In other words, resources allocation is
based on societal values. These values are based on the philosophical foundations and operational
principles of the system which are derived from primary sources of Islam. Therefore. The
allocation of resources is normative concept which is solved by applying Islamic norms or ideals.
There are three fundamental questions that determine resources allocation in any economic
system. All these three questions deal with choice. The answer to these questions depend on the
values or beliefs of society.
3. Analyze normative technical aspects of resource allocation in islam.
Normative aspects
The normative point of view analyzes the principles of values that underpin the choices made. In a
socialist economy, for example, a person may be required to refrain from the luxurious forms of
consumption while poverty exists, because of the ideals of equality. Thus, the worldview of that
society affects normative aspects.
Similarly, in an Islamic economic system, decision making or choices are to be made based on the
normative values of Islam.
Technical aspects
From the perspective of Islamic economics, the technical aspects of resource distribution aid in the
facilitation and upholding of normative principles. As a result, a Muslim consumer's normative
aspect is to avoid extravagance. Using a mixture of constraint and restraint mechanisms is the
technological technique to attain this normative ideal. For example, the government could enact
legislation prohibiting people from purchasing particular things in excess of a specific quantity
(constraint mechanism). Furthermore, for the sake of Allah, the consumer can apply self-control to
avoid extravagance (restraint mechanism).
Equally, if the goal is to maximise profit in an Islamic economy, the producer must guarantee that
his price is not too high to provide him an exploitative advantage, and that his product and
manufacturing procedures are good to society rather than harmful.
Government intervention is thought to improve resource allocation by broadening the market and
encouraging increased specialisation in land, labour, capital, and entrepreneurial resources.
Specialization encourages more effective resource allocation.
Basic needs fulfillment through minimum wage or through government subsidy.
Consumer
Producer
the producer must ensure that his price is not high enough to give him an exploitative
advantage and his product and production processes are beneficial to society and not
harmful.
6. Discuss important role of hisbah in Islamic economic system.
The duty of the hisbah is to maintain public law and order while also overseeing the behaviour of
buyers and sellers in the market to ensure proper conduct of buying and selling products and
services.
In the Qur'an, the Arabic word qismat best describes the word distribution. Qismat literally
translates to fortune and comes from the root word qasama, which is divided or distributed. Qismat,
on the other hand, refers to Allah's s.w.t. Hence, qasama is understood to signify that Allah, S.w.t,
has divided and distributed. As a result, the meaning of the word distribution refers to what Allah
has allotted to people based on factors that best suit each individual.
Allah is absolute owner, he has distributed according to his will, man remains his slave
and should spend whatever has been given to him according to Allah’s will
Rights and responsibilities of ownership
2. Man endowed with different skills and abilities
Surat al-nisa’: “to men a share of what they have earned and to women a share of what
they have earned..”
Those who worked harder should be rewarded more
Equal opportunity, but not equal outcome
Maqasid al shariah
If one does not have means to fulfill his basic needs, responsibilities be taken by others to
provide for him-his family or state
5. Income and wealth should not be concentrated in the hands of the few
Stage 1: Pre-distribution
Takes into account condition of economy before it engages itself in production process
Two types: public utilities (streams, streets, bridges) and natural resources (water etc)
Anything that do not involve much human effort/cost to make it useful to the society
Should be publicly owned, shared equally or equitably
Ownership of the ummah in general
All people participate in the utilization of these benefits-one way to reduce disparity of income
In economic theory, people play two main roles in the market. They are consumers and producers
which are responsible for the buying and selling process in the market to allow the flow of money
and items.
In Islam consumer is aware of Islamic norms and his behavior is governed by them. His
choice is how much of the income is to be spend on worldly needs and how much to spend
in the way of Allah (infaq fi sabil Allah). Muslims are motivated to spend in the way of
Allah though many Quranic verses and Ahadith which highlight the rewards in the
hereafter.
From secular point of view the theory of consumer behavior uses the law of diminishing
marginal utility to explain how consumers allocate their income.
For producers, the economic problem is to maximize profits. The key decisions are which
outputs to produce, how much of each output to produce, and which inputs to use to
produce the outputs.
3. Examine of principle of consumption loan in Islam.
principle of genuineness
Taken consumption loan for meeting the crucial minimum wants.
Taken loan without any valid reason is discouraged by the Prophet (S.A.W)
principle to contract
The Holy Qur’an mentioned in Surat al-Baqarah verse 282, that every act of lending
and borrowing should be written down clearly.
The creditor should see that no injustice is being done to the debtor
To keep out of doubts and avoid future disputes.
principle of payment
Debtor has been directed to make every sincere effort to pay back his loan.
The Prophet (S.A.W) said: whoever contracts a debt intending to repay it , Allah
S.W.T will pay it on his behalf, and whoever contracts a debt intending to waste it ,
Allah S.W.T will bring him ruin.
principle of help
All types of loan in Islam are free of interest
Allah S.W.T has allowed trading and forbidden usury (ii. 275)
Taking voluntary payment in excess of the principals sum of loan is recommended
Jabir ibn. Abd Allah said, “ I came to the Prophet (S.W.T) while he was in the
mosque, so he said: “Say two rek’ahs of prayer’ and he owned me a debt, so he paid it
to me and gave me more (than was due)
While traditional consumer behaviour is based on a person's utility function, Islamic consumer
behaviour is based on Allah's pleasure in terms of spending to benefit others (alms)
Traditional consumer behaviour focuses solely on consumption for worldly necessities, whereas
consumer behaviour in Islam considers both the worldly and the hereafter.
In the traditional system, consumers are free to consume any product according to their desires or
whims, however in the Islamic system, consumer behaviour is governed by Islamic morals and
ethics.
Profit maximisation is sought by producers, whereas profit sharing is sought by Islamic producers.
5. Discuss principle of moderation in consumption with examples fron Qur’an and Sunnah.
Sadaqah is an act that is purely voluntary in the aim of ‘fisabilillah’ (for the cause of Allah) by
muslims who wants to contribute more then their Obligatory Zakat payment.The prophet said
“Charity is a necessity for every muslim”.
i) Enables financial assistance for the unfortunate and people in dire times.
ii) To promote moral values,ethical dealings and full disclosure in all business activities and
operations.
iv) Security for the family and the group against misfortune.
An endowment made by the founder to support the general good and welfare of society,the poor
and the people in dire needs etc.Surrounding lands such as cemeteries and weapons for
preparation if war is about to happen.
The founder endows their property to his whole family or people they specified.If the beneficiaries
specified by the founder are no longer alive,then only in this case will the waqf property be given
over for public welfare purpose.
A waqf created by a founder to help both the public and their family.
Animals,books,crops,instruments,cash,etc..
Waqf Sahih (sound or valid waqf)
Founded upon mulk (full ownership) land.Upon privately owned freehold property over which the
owner helds complete rights of alienation.
Direct Waqf
Indirect Waqf
Required to provide the running expenses for such waqf.From these waqfs will be channelled to
support the direct waqf.
i) Irrevocability : This means that once the founder that created the cash waqf he cannot revoke it
back,however,they can benefit from its investment/revenue.
ii) Perpetually : once the cash waqf is created it must be perpetual.This will ensure regular and
continual support from the cash waqf financing areas in the muslim society that are in need of
help.
iii) Inalienability : This means that once cash is created into waqf,no one can ever become the
owner to alternate it.It will become a “frozen asset” which cannot be subject to be given as
gift,inheritance or any alienation.
Waqf Khayri
A cash endowment made by the founder to support the general good and welfare and society for the
poor and the people in need.
Waqh Ahl
Al-waqf al-dhurri and waqf ‘al awlad are all the same and refer to family waqf/specific waqf.
Waqf Mushtarak
A cash waqf created by a founder to support both the public and his family or certain people or
people in need of help.
6. Examine creation of Cash Waqf by non Muslim.
The Shafi’I school permitted the creation of waqf from non-muslim even if it is for the benefit of a
mosque.He based an opinion on the following hadith;
The prophet said “ Allah will not oppress any Muslim from his good deeds,as he gives it in this
world and he will be rewarded in this world only and in the hereafter.But for the non-muslim he
will be rewarded for all his good deed only in this world.”
The latest fatwa issue by Fiqh Academy Islam,agrred that cash waqf,can be invested in any
shari’ah compliant mode of investment,such as Mudarabah,Murabahah,BBA,Musharakah,Istisna
and other more.
The waqf system is an important aspect for development of economy of a country due to;
i) Reduces unemployment
9. Analyse modern application of Cash Waqf management in business companies.Such as,cash waqf
shares,mobile cash waqf,compulsory cash waqf,cooperative cash waqf etc.
The founders which are also known as shareholders contributes in buying waqf shares from their
chosen religious instituition non-profit organization,they are known as trustees.The purchased
shares will be given as waqf to the trustee and the founders and will be receiving cash waqf
certificates.After that,the trustee will manage the collected funds and will distribute it to the people
that are in need of help or charities purposed places.
Waqf takaful model
This model was created by Syarikat Takaful Malaysia which are also known as the Waqf Takaful
Plan.Under that plan,the founder contributes a minimum of RM 10 monthly as an instalment over
a certain period of time.The contribution amount will then be invested in shari’ah compliant funds
and any profit on investment shall be distributed between the trustee and the Participants Account
on a profit sharing ratio.The contribution will be divided into 2 separate accounts based on a pre-
agreed ratio.The participants account (PA) and the participants special account (PSA).Upon death
of the founder or the maturity of the plan,the amount accumulated in the (PA) will be paid to the
beneficiaries specified by the founder in the Waqf Deed.
Under this model,the founder will contribute the religious authority or non profit organization
(trustees) by depositing money to a specific bank account.The bank will then invest the
money.Anye revenue generated from the investment shall be channelled to the trustees who will
then use it for charity purpose.
Under this model,contributions are made by sending coded sms to be designated server ordering for
deduction of an amount from his/her airtime to a religious authority or non-profit organization as
a trustee.The amount collected will be shared between the telecommunication companyto cover
operating costs and the trustee who will be managing the funds for the beneficiaries through a
revenue sharing arrangement.
In this situation,a mother corporation will establish an associated instituition as the Mutawalli to
collect the cash waqf from different corporations in terms of cash,jewelry and etc.To manage and
distribute the waqf fund for specific areas,whose main role is to increase economic growth in the
state of Johor.Under this model,Johor Corporation established Kumpulan An-Nur Berhad as an
associated waqf instituition.
Compulsory monthly constributions are made by muslim employee in a Muslim minority country
depending on their monthly gross income.A certain amount will be deducted from their salaries
and will be channelled through the CPF,to Singapore Islamic Council.Amount collected finance
will be beneficiaries for charitable purpose.
Deposit product model (Public Waqf)
The depositer deposits money into the cash waqf-based account.After that,the bank will manage the
capital on behalf of the waqf.The capital will then be invested.The cash waqf accounr earns profit
through a mudharabah contract.The proceed will be used for a charitable purpose or purposes
specified by the waqf.
Citizens provide cash to the cash waqf funds specific for their district.The capital will then be
invested.
The Dompet Dhuafa- Batasa Syariah Mutual Fund was establish in July 2004 as a Shariah-
compliant mutual fund,which invests hugely in fixed income returns financial instruments.This
mutual fund is managed by the Batasa Capital Asset Management.
Chapter 9
Riba is an Islamic notion that roughly refers to the concepts of growth, rising, or exceeding, and so
prohibits interest on loans or deposits. The term "riba" has also been loosely interpreted as the
unlawful, exploitative gains obtained in business or trade under Islamic law, which is similar to
extortion.
Except for declaring that charging interest is an act of injustice, the basic sources of Shariah (the
Qur'an and the Sunnah) do not offer advanced logical explanations on the prohibition of riba.
Contemporary Muslim scholars, particularly economists, have written extensively about the
rationales for riba prohibition, addressing the economic and social consequences of the interest-
based financial model, or claiming that modern economic theories have not justified the existence
of interest rates as a necessity.
3. Analyse argument of jurists on charging riba on consumption loan and commercial loan.
Some argue that riba means the addition of money on a capital. Since the addition of capital is not
prohibited by Islam, then there are certainly certain forms of addition that should be prohibited. the
decline of usury or riba’, there is no evidence to prove the existence of commercial loans among the
arab people. On the other hand, all financing is done on the basis of syirkah and mudarabah. Next,
usury or riba’ is prohibited based on the meaning of oppression because oppression is the 'god of
the prohibition. Consumption loans are oppressive because the debtor is desperate to cover his daily
requirements, while the creditor takes advantage of the situation by demanding excessive interest
rates. The debtor is being oppressed in this way. Riba' is the term for this feature. In contrast, in
the event of a productive loan (Productive Loan), the debtor benefits significantly from the loan
money's investment. It is not prohibited since it contradicts the riba' idea.
Murabahah
Bai-bithaman ajil
Leasing-based arrangements
Operating lease
Financial lease
Equity-based arrangements
Mudharabah
Musyarakah
Gharar means deception, fraud, uncertainty, risk, peril, or hazard that can result in devastation or
loss.
In a contract of exchange, confusion is induced by a lack of clarity about the topic matter or
pricing.
• examples of gharar
• Types of gharar
Maysir
• A form of gambling
“Shaitan intends to excite enmity and hatred among you with intoxicants and
gambling, and hinder you from remembrance of Allah, and from prayer…” (5:90)
“They ask the concerning wine and gambling. Say: ‘In them is great sin and some
benefits for people; but the sin is greater than the benefits’” (4:219)
6. Highlight elements of gharar and maysir in our contemporary transaction.
Gharar
All business dealings that lead to exploitation or injustice in any manner to any of the contracting
parties are expressly forbidden in Islam. It aims to protect the various parties from deception and
ignorance by prohibiting Gharar from being used in any commercial exchange contracts that are
not free of risk, risk, or speculation about the essential elements of the transaction to either party,
or uncertainty about one party's ability to honour its rights and obligations. All Islamic financial
and economic transactions must be conducted in a transparent, accurate, and complete manner,
with all necessary information disclosed, so that no one party gains an advantage over the other
Maysir
All forms of gambling are likewise completely prohibited in Islam. Maysir is a term used in Islam to
describe some types of gambling transactions that are regarded completely unequal. Maysir refers
to the easy obtaining of wealth through chance, regardless of whether it deprives others of their
right..