Reading 37 Measuring and Managing Market Risk - Answers
Reading 37 Measuring and Managing Market Risk - Answers
Reading 37 Measuring and Managing Market Risk - Answers
Which of the following is most accurately a limitation of the historical simulation method?
Explanation
A drawback of the historical simulation method is that the past (i.e., the lookback period)
may not be indicative of the future.
Delphia fund is a €100 million portfolio of euro zone equities. The expected daily return and
standard deviation are 0.116% and 0.38% respectively. The 5% daily VaR is €511,000.
Assuming 21 trading days per month, The 5% monthly VaR is closest to:
A) €435,000
B) €3,801,000
C) €829,446
Explanation
Explanation
Assuming that the returns distribution of a portfolio is normal, using the parametric method
of estimation of VaR needs which of the following inputs:
Explanation
If we assume that the returns distribution is normal, under the parametric method of
estimation of VaR, we only need the mean and standard deviation of the distribution.
Ryan Manning is a new hire at Luongo Asset Managers. As part of his training, he has been
asked to compile a report on risk measurement and mechanisms to control risk.
Manning wants to give a simple illustration of VaR and has compiled the data for a two-asset
portfolio as shown in Exhibit 1.
Exhibit 1:
Manning's colleague, Alex Smith, makes three comments about Manning's computation of
VaR:
Comment "VaR is such a useful measure as it shows us the maximum potential loss on
1: our portfolio position. Your data shows the maximum daily loss that could be
incurred 5% of the days."
Comment "When using a parametric approach great care needs to be taken with the
2: look-back period. The raw data should only really be used if the historic
parameter estimates are similar to what we are expecting over the period for
which we are estimating VaR."
"The historical simulation approach to VaR is based on the actual periodic changes in risk
factors over a look-back period. The daily change in value of the portfolio is calculated for
each day over the look-back period. We then order the changes from most positive to most
negative and look for the largest 5% of losses. The VaR is then the average of the 5% biggest
losses. One advantage it has is that it doesn't use normal distributions and as a result can be
used for portfolios containing options."
Limitation During periods of financial distress asset correlations will often increase. This
2: means that computing VaR based on historical correlations observed over a
look-back period might well overestimate the benefits of diversification and as
a result underestimate the magnitude of potential losses.
Limitation VaR computation does not account for the liquidity of assets in its calculation.
3: When asset prices fall dramatically, liquidity often dissipates significantly as
was seen with asset-backed securities during the credit crunch of 2008–2009.
This has means that VaR will underestimate the true losses of liquidating
positions that are under extreme price pressure.
Which of the following is closest to 5% daily VaR for the data included in Exhibit 1?
A) £126,000.
B) £156,000.
C) £186,000.
Explanation
First, calculate the portfolios' average daily return and standard deviation:
σ= 1.54%
Explanation
Comment 1 is incorrect. VaR is interpreted as the minimum loss that will be experienced
X% of the time; losses estimated will be bigger.
Comment 2 is correct. Using historic parameters will only be of use if the future period is
expected to be similar to the look-back period. For example, if the look- back period had
an unusually low volatility then VaR based on this measure would underestimate losses.
A) correct.
B) incorrect about VaR calculation.
C) incorrect regarding the application to portfolios containing options.
Explanation
The VaR estimate under the historical simulation approach is the smallest of the largest
5% losses, not average. Great care should be taken that the historical period used to
capture the data is not atypical in some respect (i.e., had a very low or high volatility).
Relative to the parametric method, one big advantage of historical simulation is that it
does not require any assumption about the distribution of returns. Since you are not
making any assumptions about the shape of the distribution, derivative securities such as
options with their asymmetric distributions of payoffs, do not present any problems.
A) 1 limitation.
B) 2 limitations.
C) 3 limitations.
Explanation
Limitation 1 is incorrect. Platykurtic distributions have fewer extreme outliers than a
normal distribution (thinner tails). A normal distribution would therefore overestimate the
potential losses. A leptokurtic distribution would have fatter tails and therefore the normal
distribution would underestimate potential losses.
Limitation 2 is correct. If the look back period is a period of relative normality, then the
calculated correlations will often overestimate the benefits of diversification. Correlations
will tend to spike during periods of financial distress resulting in larger losses than VaR
based on look back period would estimate.
Limitation 3 is correct. During periods of financial distress, liquidity tends to drop in the
market. VaR does not account for changes in liquidity and will therefore tend to
underestimate the actual losses.
Explanation
VaR computations only incorporate left tail risk (and ignores the returns in the right tail).
VaR computed using too low of estimates of volatility will be too low and underestimates
the downside risk based on true estimates of volatility. In downward trending markets,
consistent negative returns may not breach daily or weekly VaR but nonetheless can lead
to significant accumulation of losses.
Which of the following risk measures are most likely to be used by a traditional asset
manager?
A) Active share.
B) Surplus at risk.
C) Maximum drawdown.
Explanation
With regards to convexity and gamma, which of the following statements are most accurate?
Both are second order effects value arising from changes in underlying risk
A)
factors to the change in value of the asset.
Convexity is a second order effect while gamma is a first order effect arising
B)
from changes in underlying risk factors to the change in value of the asset.
Convexity is a first order effect while gamma is a second order effect arising
C)
from changes in underlying risk factors to the change in value of the asset.
Explanation
Convexity is the second order effect of change in interest rate on bond prices while
gamma is the second order effect of change in stock price on option prices.
Explanation
While scenario analysis can be used to measure the impact of a scenario, it can't provide
the probability of the scenario actually occurring. Since scenario analysis does not assume
a normal (or any other) distribution of asset returns, the question of fat tails does not
arise. Assumption of static relationship between individual risk factors and portfolio value
is a limitation of sensitivity analysis.
Explanation
Scenario analysis involves fully repricing the asset based on the values of the risk factors
in the identified scenario. Evaluating the effect on portfolio value due to changes in a
single risk factor is done for sensitivity analysis and not scenario analysis.
A fixed income portfolio manager utilizes duration as a risk measure for the portfolio. The
portfolio manager is most likely:
Explanation
Sensitivity analysis evaluates changes in portfolio value due to changes in underlying risk
factors. Duration is a risk-factor for a fixed income portfolio capturing the interest rate risk
of the portfolio. As such, impact of changing interest rates would be captured by duration
of the portfolio and such an analysis is sensitivity analysis.
Explanation
Marginal Var, conceptually similar to incremental VaR, captures the change in VaR for very
small changes in asset position.
Explanation
Conditional VaR is the average loss conditional on exceeding the VaR cutoff. It is the
average Var in the left tail of the return distribution.
Which of the following risk measures are most likely to be used by a hedge fund?
A) Maximum drawdown.
B) Surplus at risk.
C) Glidepath.
Explanation
Maximum drawdown reflects the performance during the worst performing period (month
or quarter) and is commonly used as a risk metric by hedge funds. Surplus at risk is used
by pension plans. Glidepath is a tool used by pension plan to manage plan surplus/deficit
and charts the planned move of the fund position from its current state to the target state.
A) Liquidate the portfolio if the portfolio value falls below $100 million.
B) Maximum tracking error of 3%.
C) Maximum daily VaR of $1.5 million.
Explanation
Stop loss limits specify liquidation of a portfolio or a reduction in its size if a loss of a
specific magnitude occurs. Maximum daily VaR and tracking errors are examples of risk
budgets.
Explanation
Economic capital is the capital needed for a firm to survive if severe losses are
experienced based on the risk the business is exposed to.
A) €37,400,000
B) €82,000
C) €368,000
Explanation