Current Research in Biotechnology 4 (2022) 47–57

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Current Research in Biotechnology

journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/crbiot

Effects of salicylic acid on the production of polyphenols and the reducing

power of Theobroma cacao calli
Lillien Fajardo Rosabal a,⇑, Yans Guardia Puebla b, Suyén Rodríguez Pérez c, Ursula M. Rosabal Cordoví d,
Juan J. Silva Pupo a, Stefaan P.O. Werbrouck e
a
Plant Biotechnology Studies Center (CEBVEG) University of Granma. Carretera a Manzanillo km 17, 5 Peralejo, Bayamo, Granma, Cuba. CP 85100
b
Applied Chemistry Studies Center (CEQA) University of Granma. Carretera a Manzanillo km 17, 5 Peralejo, Bayamo, Granma, Cuba. CP 85100
c
LABEX, Molecular Immunology Center, Calle 23 y Carretera del Caney s/n, Santiago de Cuba, Cuba
d
Oral Liquids Pharmaceutical Laboratory (MEDILIP) Granma. Carretera Central vía Santiago de Cuba kilómetro 845, Bayamo, Granma, Cuba
e
Laboratory of Applied in Vitro Plant Biotechnology, Department of Applied Bioscience, Faculty of Bioscience Engineering, Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium

A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T

Keywords: Cocoa (Theobroma cacao) contains high levels of phenolic compounds with pharmacologically interesting activ-
Theobroma cacao ities. Prior research has not sufficiently investigated obtaining these compounds through in vitro culture by
Salicylic acid using metabolic elicitation and quantifying polyphenols in undifferentiated cell biomass samples in this spe-
Callus cies. In vitro calli obtained from staminodes and petals were elicited with 0.01 and 0.1 mg L−1 salicylic acid
Polyphenols production
(SA). Secondary metabolites were determined in the calli and their culture medium, from the immature and
Reducing power
mature flowers, leaves, and fruits of field‐grown plants. The most abundant compounds were free amino acids,
alkaloids, reducing carbohydrates, phenols, pyrocatecholic tannins, and flavonoids. Resins, triterpenes, ster-
oids, saponins, coumarins, and quinones were absent in the calli. A high concentration of total polyphenols
(58.4 µg g−1) was obtained from staminode‐derived calli elicited with 0.1 mg L−1 SA. With these conditions,
the total polyphenol content was 40.22 µg g−1 greater than that in the control. In general, SA also stimulated
the reducing power activity; a better value (5.87 µmol mL−1 Fe2+) was obtained in callus extracts from petals
with salicylic acid (0.1 mg L−1). This research was based on a full factorial study design with two levels, a
method that allows the desired information to be obtained at the lowest possible cost.

Introduction lites, provided that a suitable elicitor is found that allows for higher
concentrations of these compounds to be obtained (Isah et al., 2018;
Two main methods are currently used to obtain complex secondary Tripathi et al., 2019).
metabolites: direct extraction from plant material or in vitro from plant, One of the most commonly used elicitors is salicylic acid (SA)
organ and cell cultures. The first method can lead to overexploitation (Patel and Krishnamurthy, 2013). SA initiates the expression of genes
of natural resources, thus negatively affecting natural biodiversity. In associated with pathogenesis and the synthesis of defensive com-
addition, the content of secondary metabolites can vary according to pounds by activating signals of basal resistance, hypersensitivity, and
environmental factors, including temperature, drought, salinity, and systemic acquired resistance (Basit et al., 2017).
soil variability. In contrast, the production of secondary metabolites Cacao (Theobroma cacao L.) provides raw materials not only for
in cultures in vitro has the following advantages: chocolate, but also for cosmetics and medicines. The plant contains
(a) independence of biotic and abiotic environmental factors; (b) active substances for the treatment of cardiovascular diseases and
higher yield of specific secondary metabolites; (c) increased productiv- some cancers, and has been demonstrated to have antibacterial activ-
ity through automated process control; (d) uniform and constant qual- ity (Negaresh and Marín, 2013). Furthermore, the polyphenols present
ity; (e) potential for biosynthetic pathway engineering enabling the in the plant have antibiotic and pesticidal effects (Rangel et al., 2010).
redesigning of secondary metabolites; and (f) a more efficient extrac- According to Duke et al. (2003), these polyphenols include flavonoids,
tion process (Tripathi et al., 2019). Consequently, the culture of plant such as catechins (37%), anthocyanins (4%), and procyanidins (58%),
tissues is a viable alternative for the production of secondary metabo- which also have potent antioxidant effects (Baharum et al., 2016).

⇑ Corresponding author.
E-mail address: [email protected] (L. Fajardo Rosabal).

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.crbiot.2021.12.005
Received 9 September 2021; Revised 24 December 2021; Accepted 27 December 2021

2590-2628/© 2022 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V.

This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
L. Fajardo Rosabal et al. Current Research in Biotechnology 4 (2022) 47–57

Several factors should be optimized to boost secondary metabolite Table 1

production by in vitro cultures, such as the selection of mother plants Phytochemical screening tests for plant aerial organs and calli.
with high content of the desired substances, growth medium composi- Extract Test Compounds References
tion, acidity, inoculum density, and the culture room conditions (Isah
Ethereal Dragendorff Alkaloids Jones and Kinghorn (2006)
et al., 2018).
extract Mayer
Determination of the culture medium composition is a crucial step Baljet Coumarins Jones and Kinghorn (2006)
that should account for the physiological requirements of the particu- Ethanolic Resins Resins Mir et al. (2013); Al-Kaf et al.(2019)
lar species (Isah et al., 2018). Manipulation of growing conditions is a extract Liebermann- Triterpenes Jones and Kinghorn (2006)
fundamental approach for culture optimization productivity (Murthy Burchard and/or
steroids
et al., 2014; Ochoa‐Villarreal et al., 2016). Foam Saponins Jones and Kinghorn (2006)
To obtain the desired information at the lowest possible cost, this Ninhydrin Free amino Somkuwar and Kamble (2013);
research was based on a two‐level full factorial design (Fukuda acids Yadav et al.(2017)
et al., 2018). The study aim was to examine the individual effects Dragendorff Alkaloids Jones and Kinghorn (2006)
Mayer
and interactions between several factors involved in one or more
Baljet Coumarins Jones and Kinghorn (2006)
responses of interest (Gottipati and Mishra, 2010). Fehling Reducing Sanmugarajah et al.(2013); Banu
Cacao tissue culture research has focused on somatic embryogene- carbohydrates and Cathrine (2015); Shalavadi
sis (Maximova et al. 2002). Research to obtain polyphenols through et al.(2018)
in vitro culture of T. cacao flower explants has been performed in calli FeCl3 Phenols and/ Jones and Kinghorn (2006)
or tannins
with embryogenic structures in studies including Alemanno et al.
Borntrager Quinones Ganatra et al.(2012); Longbap et al.
(2003) and Gallego et al. (2016). However, no studies have been (2018)
reported in T. cacao undifferentiated cell masses with metabolic elici- Shinoda Flavonoids Jones and Kinghorn (2006)
tation to quantify polyphenols and evaluate their response to reducing Aqueous Foam Saponins Jones and Kinghorn (2006)
extract Fehling Reducing Sanmugarajah et al.,(2013); Banu
power.
carbohydrates and Cathrine (2015); Shalavadi
The aims of this study were: (i) to analyze the secondary metabo- et al. (2018)
lites produced by calli that were initiated on staminodes and petals, Shinoda Flavonoids Jones and Kinghorn (2006)
(ii) to identify and quantify the total content of polyphenols produced FeCl3 Phenols and/ Jones and Kinghorn (2006)
in the callus and medium, and (iii) to evaluate their antioxidant activ- or tannins
Dragendorff Alkaloids Jones and Kinghorn (2006)
ity according to the reducing power with and without metabolic
Mayer
elicitation.

In vitro culture
Materials and methods
Flower buds were washed with 1.0 % detergent solution for 20 min
As part of this research, the effects of the addition of SA, chitosan,
and rinsed three times with sterile distilled water before external ster-
and jasmonic acid at different concentrations on the callus formation
ilization with 1.0 % sodium hypochlorite for 20 min and another four
and differentiation of T. cacao (UF‐613; UF‐650 and Pound‐7) clones
rinses with sterile distilled water. The petals and staminodes were iso-
were analyzed. The biological response with SA was superior in the
lated and transferred to Murashige and Skoog (1962) basal salt med-
three clones (unpublished data). Therefore, subsequent research used
ium supplemented with 100 mg L−1 myo‐inositol, 10 mg L−1 LB
this elicitor and indicated that the best response in callus formation
vitamins (Lopez‐ Baez et al., 1993), 3 mg L−1 glycine, 40 g L−1
was achieved with the UF‐650 clone and SA at 15 days of culture. Con-
sucrose, 0.25 mg L−1 2,4‐D, 2 mg L−1 kinetin, and 6 g L−1 agar (pH
sequently, a higher cell biomass was obtained in less time (Fajardo
5.7). The culture medium was divided into three equal parts in
et al., 2015).
250 mL Erlenmeyer flasks (one flask per treatment). After autoclaving,
For these reasons, the T. cacao UF‐650 clone and SA as the meta-
0; 0.01 or 0.1 mg L−1 SA was added and homogenized in an Erlen-
bolic elicitor were chosen for the present research.
meyer flask, each with a separate treatment. Ten milliliters of medium
was dispensed into sterilized culture flasks (5.0 cm high and 2.5 cm
wide), with 25 flasks per treatment. In each flask, five staminodes or
Extraction and phytochemical screening
petals were transferred. The explants were kept for 60 days in the dark
at 25° C. Fifteen random calli were subcultured in 100 mL conical
Plant materials from the T. cacao UF‐650 clone were collected at
flasks (three flasks per treatment) containing 10 mL liquid medium
the Tercer Frente Experimental Station at Santiago de Cuba. The col-
that were shaken at 110 rpm. The composition of the liquid medium
lection time window was between 9:00 and 10:00 a.m. at 25–26 °C.
was the same as that of the semi‐solid medium. The calli grew in total
Mature and immature flowers, and leaf and fruit samples were sub-
darkness at 27 ± 1 °C. After 7 days of callus fragmentation, 60 μL was
jected to extraction. The seeds were removed from the cocoa pods,
sampled for microscopic evaluation.
and the pericarp was separated. The materials were dried in a recircu-
lating air oven (model WSU 400, Germany) at a constant temperature
of 60 °C for 3 days, then ground into powder with an electric mill. Quantification of total polyphenols
The main groups of metabolites present in the plant organs and in
the calli produced from them were identified (Table 1). Extraction was Total polyphenols were quantified by UV/vis spectrophotometry
performed with solvents of increasing polarity. To 5.0 g of powder, (Jenway 6305) with Folin‐Ciocalteu reagent (Ainsworth and
15 mL of ethyl ether was added. After 72 h, the extracts were filtered Gillespie, 2007). A calibration curve was established with a pyrocate-
through Whatman No. 1 paper. Then 15 mL of 82% (v/v) ethanol was chol standard p.a. (Sigma‐Aldrich) in the concentration range of
then added to the remaining sample, which was macerated for another 0–50 µg mL−1. The following solutions were used: 0.7 M sodium car-
72 h and then filtered. The third extraction was performed with 15 mL bonate solution (CaCO3), pyrocatechol stock solution 500 mg L−1 (in
distilled water (Banu and Cathrine, 2015). The procedure was acetone/water solution 1:1 v/v), and pyrocatechol working solution
repeated for staminodes and petal calli. Table 1 summarizes the anal- 50 mg L−1 (10 mL of pyrocatechol stock solution diluted to 100 mL
yses performed with these extracts. with acetone/water mixture, 1:1 v/v).

48
L. Fajardo Rosabal et al. Current Research in Biotechnology 4 (2022) 47–57

To 1 g of callus, 10 mL of acetone/water (1: 1 v/v) was added. After Generally, the ANOVA in a designed experiment helps determine
48 h of maceration, the extract obtained was filtered over a Millipore which factors are important but uses the regression method to build
filter (0.45 µm). To 1.0 mL of filtrate, 2.0 mL of Folin‐Ciocalteu (Pan- a quantitative model that relates the important factors to the response
reac®) reagent was added. After 2 min, 8.0 mL of sodium carbonate (Fukuda et al., 2018).
(0.7 M) was added, and after 30 min, color formation was detected The experimental results were fitted by a multiple linear regression
at λ = 760 nm. The content of phenolic compounds (µg pyrocatechol according to the following mathematical model:
per g sample) was determined with the following equation:
Y ¼ R0 þ R1 X1 þ R2 X2 þ R3 X3 þ R4 X1 X2 þ R5 X1 X3 þ R6 X2 X3
Cex  Vex
CPC ¼  1000 þ R7 X1 X2 X3 :
Pm

where Pm is the weight of the sample; Vex is the volume of the extract, where Y is the predicted response, R0 is a constant, and R1 to R7 are the
and Cex is the concentration in the extract. linear coefficients of the regression model. Coefficients R0, R1,…, R7,
which are usually unknown, were subsequently estimated by regression
Antioxidant activity determined by reducing power analysis. Eight experiments were sufficient to estimate the coefficients
of the multiple regression model. The experiments were performed in
Reducing power was determined according to the method of triplicate.
Oyaizu (1986), in which the samples of extracts with high concentra- To estimate the antioxidant activity, we used linear regression to
tions of total polyphenols were chosen. Different concentrations of calculate the relationship between the absorbance measured at
each sample (100, 200, 300, 400, and 500 μg mL−1) were used and 700 nm and the concentrations of total phenols in the callus extracts
mixed with 1.0 mL deionized water, 2.5 mL phosphate buffer derived from petals and staminodes, with and without elicitation. Nine
(0.2 M, pH 6.6), and 2.5 mL potassium ferricyanide, K3[Fe (CN)6] different regression models were evaluated to determine the influence
(1.0 % m/v). The mixture was incubated at 50 °C for 20 min, after of the extract concentration measured after reduction with potassium
the addition of 2.5 mL of trichloroacetic acid (10 % m/v). Then the dichromate (K2Cr2O7) (Table 3). Several input variables were tested to
samples were centrifuged at 3000 rpm for 10 min. To 2.5 mL of super- obtain the highest correlation between the experimental data and pre-
natant, an equal volume of distilled water and 0.5 mL of 0.1 % m/v dicted values, and to investigate their effects on the target values.
ferric trichloride (FeCl3) was added. The absorbance was measured Hence, t‐ratios and the corresponding p‐values were determined for
at λ = 700 nm. An increase in absorbance values of the samples indi- better evaluation of the significance of the regression coefficient,
cated an increase in reducing power. For reducing power quantifica- wherein the descriptive statistics of the residual errors improves model
tion, a standard curve of Fe2+ (1.0–10.0 µmol mL−1) was used, and performance. The best‐fit models were determined by application of
the results are expressed in μmol mL−1 of Fe2+. the coefficient of determination (R2).

Experimental design Results and discussion

The 2k factorial designs (two‐level test for each k factor) is an Identification of secondary metabolites of T. cacao clone UF-650
experimental design that has been valuable in industry and research
because of its efficiency and versatility. In general, two‐level factorial Table 4 shows the results of the phytochemical screening. Free
designs, whether full or fractional factorial designs, are the set of amino acids, alkaloids, reducing carbohydrates, phenols, tannins,
designs with the greatest impact on chemical compounds production pyrocatecholic tannins, and flavonoids were detected in all samples.
at industrial scale, design projection, and diagnostic checking of them The most represented metabolites were alkaloids, which were mainly
(Montgomery, 2013). Among them, 23 full factorial designs can be found in flowers and calli. In the latter, flavonoids were most abun-
used to study three experimental factors with two levels for each fac- dant. Large amounts of coumarins were found in immature flowers
tor. The experimental matrix of this design can be easily constructed and leaves. In contrast, quinones were significantly present in the
because it consists of 23 = 2 × 2 × 2 = 8 different combinations, mature pericarp, leaves, and seeds of the fruits, whereas saponins
and it enables studying the three main effects, as well as three double and coumarins were detected in all organs of the plant. However,
interactions and a triple interaction of the factors analyzed (Fukuda the presence of these metabolites was not demonstrated in the calli.
et al., 2018). Differences in triterpenes and steroid compounds were also
To evaluate the effects of the SA concentration (X1), explant type observed in the pericarp and seeds. These differences are attributable
(X2), and extract type (X3) on the production of total polyphenols, to the developmental stages of the plant organs. According to Pérez‐
we designed a 23 factorial experiment, involving two levels (low Alonso and Jiménez (2011), the biosynthesis of secondary metabolites
(−1) and high (+1) of each variable (Table 2). is usually restricted to specific developmental stages and to periods of
To validate the hypothesis of the equality of the levels in the eval- stress.
uated factors, we used analysis of variance (ANOVA) with respect to The absence of resins, triterpenes, steroids, saponins, coumarins,
the average value of the response variable. Regression methods are and quinones in calli might be attributed to their degree of dedifferen-
often used to analyze data from experiments that were not designed, tiation. Constantly dividing callus cells, the most abundant cell type,
such as in studies of uncontrolled phenomena or historical records. are characterized by a dense cytoplasm. and give rise to meristematic
However, regression analysis is also useful in designed experiments. centers (Hernández‐Pimentel and Tavera‐Martínez, 1996). Because

Table 2
Coded and uncoded levels chosen for the 23 factorial design.

Factors Low level High level

Coded value Real value Coded value Real value

Concentration of SA (X1) −1 0.01 +1 0.1

Explant type (X2) −1 Petals +1 Staminodes
Extract type (X3) −1 Callus +1 Culture medium

49
L. Fajardo Rosabal et al. Current Research in Biotechnology 4 (2022) 47–57

Table 3 ing cells showed a dense cytoplasm and tended to form cell groups.
Regression models evaluated to determine the best mathematical relationship These results were similar to those described by Alemanno et al.
between the experimental data and predicted values. (1996) during the somatic embryogenesis of T. cacao. Strong mitotic
Model Equation Y-Transformation X-Transformation activity was observed in both callus types. Two stages of cell division
were demonstrated: anaphase (Fig. 1 a, b, c, d, and f) and telophase
Linear y ¼ β0 þ β1 x None None
Inverse of X y ¼ β0 þ β1 =x None Reverse
(Fig. 1 b, d, and e).
Inverse of Y y ¼ ðβ0 þ β1 xÞ1 Reverse None
Inverse Y, log X y ¼ β0 þβ11 ln x Reverse Logarithm
pffiffiffi Quantification of total polyphenols from cellular biomass
square root of X y ¼ β0 þ β1 x None Square root
β0 þβ1 x
Exponential y¼e Logarithm None
pffiffi The highest concentration of total polyphenols (58.4 µg g−1) was
log Y, square root X y ¼ eβ0 þβ1 x Logarithm Square root
log X, square root Y y ¼ ðβ0 þ β1 ln xÞ2 Square root Logarithm achieved when calli obtained from staminodes were elicited with
square Y, log X
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
y ¼ β0 þ β1 ln x Square Logarithm 0.10 mg L−1 SA (Table 5). This value was higher than that when an
equal concentration of SA was applied to petal‐derived calli
(49.4 µg g−1). The other concentrations were in the range of 14.0–3
5.3 µg g−1 (Table 5). At the highest concentration, SA increased the
many metabolites are synthesized according to the degree of cellular
concentration of total polyphenols in both callus types to
differentiation, a certain degree of organization in cell culture is nec-
40.2 µg g−1 and 14.1 µg g−1, as compared with the control treatments
essary for metabolite production.
(18.3 ± 0.18; 35.29 ± 0.15 for staminode and petal derived calli).
Secondary metabolites are stored mainly in the vacuoles, which,
Similarly, increases of 8.3 µg g−1 and 16.0 µg g−1 were observed in
from an ultrastructural viewpoint, are located at the adjacent inner
the culture medium extracts (16.21 ± 0.18; 13.93 ± 0.18 for stamin-
periphery of the cell or in the centers of cytoplasmic organelles (Lees
ode and petal culture media, respectively). Greater diffusion of
et al., 1993). Therefore, the low production of secondary metabolites
polyphenols to the culture medium was also observed with 0.10 mg
in cell cultures may be a consequence of limited cell differentiation
L−1 SA from calli derived from petals.
(Espinosa‐Leal et al., 2018).
The ANOVA indicated, with a 95% probability, that all main
High similarity between preliminary phytochemical tests of natural
effects: (X1, X2, and X3) and their interactions significantly influenced
plants' aerial organs and undifferentiated cells was observed. Callus
total polyphenol production. The effects of the treatments were plotted
cells do not yet have a central vacuole for a greater storage capacity.
on a Pareto chart to visualize which effects had greater influence on
However, potential exists to produce compounds of interest, particu-
the response variables. An easy way to determine the effect of each
larly phenolic compounds such as phenols, pyrocatecholic and pyro-
variable is to add a line on the standardized Pareto chart at the height
gallotanical tannins, and flavonoids.
of a calculated critical value. The effects of bars crossing that line are
Moreover, according to Pérez‐Alonso and Jiménez (2011) the
significant. The Pareto diagram is shown in Fig. 2. Effects such as con-
chemical composition of the callus varies according to the origin of
centration, concentration‐explant type interaction, and explant type‐
the explant, the parent tissue, and callus age. The results of this study
extract type, in that order, significantly affected the response variable.
were consistent with those of Nwokonkwo and Okeke (2014), who
In contrast, antagonistic interactions were observed for explant and
have demonstrated the presence of alkaloids, tannins, saponins, glyco-
extract type.
sides, phenols, flavonoids, and carboxylic acids in an ethanolic extract
Finally, the codified mathematical model applied for the 23 facto-
of T. cacao bark. Cádiz‐Gurrea et al. (2014) have identified and quan-
rial design was defined by:
tified 61 chemical compounds in different types of extracts, and simi-
larly have detected several structural classes of chemical compounds,
Y ¼ 30:7308  9:83X1 þ 1:42X2 þ 9:56X3 þ 2:30X1 X2  3:75X1 X3
such as flavan 3‐ols and derivatives (including procyanidins), flavo-
nols, and N‐phenylpropenoyl‐L‐amino acids. þ 0:62X2 X3 þ 4:22X1 X2 X3
The calli generally showed a homogeneous morphology (Fig. 1),
although staminode derived calli sometimes showed hard, compact, where Y represents the total polyphenol content, and X1, X2, and X3 are
or necrotic areas. Embryogenic structures, generally characterized by the three factors considered in this study. The best‐fit models were
the presence of small and rounded cells, were not observed. These fea- determined by application of the coefficient of determination (R2). In
tures are typical of meristematic cells. Moreover, the single and divid- this case, the value of R2 = 0.99 indicated that only 0.01% of the total
variation was not explained by the regression model. Furthermore, the

Table 4
Phytochemical screening of plant aerial organs and calli.

Metabolites Aerial organs of T. cocoa, UF-650 clone Calli

Leaves Pericarp Seeds Flowers Stamin. Petals
Immat. Mature Immat. Mature Immat. Mature Before anthesis After anthesis

Resins + + + + + + − − − −
Triterpenes and/or steroids + + − + − + − − − −
Saponins + + + + + + + + − −
Free amino acids + + + + + + + + + +
Alkaloids + + + + + + +++ +++ +++ +++
Coumarins + ++ + + + + ++ ++ − −
Reducing carbohydrates + + + + + + + + + +
Phenols and/or tannins + + + + + + + ++ + +
Pyrocatecholic tannins + + + + + + + + + +
Pyrogallotanical tannins − − + + + + + + + +
Quinones ++ ++ + ++ ++ ++ + + − −
Flavonoids + + + + + + + + ++ ++

Legend: −, absence; +, presence; ++ and +++, abundance; immat, immature state; stamin, staminodes.

50
L. Fajardo Rosabal et al. Current Research in Biotechnology 4 (2022) 47–57

Fig. 1. Callus aggregates: (a) staminode derived callus without SA, (b) staminode derived callus with SA at 0.01 mg L−1, (c) staminode derived callus with SA at
0.1 mg L−1, (d) petals without SA, (e) petals with SA at 0.01 mg L−1, and (f) petals with SA at 0.1 mg L−1. A, anaphase; T, telophase.

Table 5
Observed and predicted values of total polyphenol content of callus extracts.

No Concentration of salicylic acid (mg L−1) Explant type Extract type Observed Predicted

1 0.01 Petals Callus 35.29 ± 0.15 35.29 ± 0.05

2 0.1 Petals Callus 49.39 ± 0.18 49.39 ± 0.05
3 0.01 Staminodes Callus 18.13 ± 0.18 18.13 ± 0.05
4 0.1 Staminodes Callus 58.35 ± 0.18 58.35 ± 0.05
5 0.01 Petals Medium 13.97 ± 0.18 13.97 ± 0.05
6 0.1 Petals Medium 29.97 ± 0.18 29.97 ± 0.05
7 0.01 Staminodes Medium 16.21 ± 0.18 16.21 ± 0.05
8 0.1 Staminodes Medium 24.53 ± 0.18 24.53 ± 0.05

Fig. 2. Pareto diagram showing the effects of the independent variables and their interactions on the total polyphenol content. The length of each bar indicates the
standardized effect of each factor or interaction.

51
L. Fajardo Rosabal et al. Current Research in Biotechnology 4 (2022) 47–57

Fig. 3. Total polyphenol content in petals and staminode derived calli with SA in (a) the callus and (b) the culture medium.

Fig. 4. 3D response surface plots corresponding to statistical analysis for the polyphenols obtained (see Table 2 for codes).

high degree of precision of the results was indicated by the value of the are important to avoid inducing hypersensitivity reactions that cause
variation coefficient (4.22%). cell death (Namdeo, 2007).
The highest polyphenol content was found in calli derived from the Response surface graphs visually represent the relationship
staminodes (Fig. 3a) but petal derived calli secreted more polyphenols between two factors and describe the behavior of the average response
into the medium (Fig. 3b). The staminodes derived from calli had a at each point in the experimental region, presented as a solid surface
hard, compact structure and sometimes showed necrotic zones. This framed in three‐dimensional space; these graphs also aid in under-
finding might have resulted from polyphenol accumulation causing standing the main and interaction effects between two factors (Cai
changes in the membranes and cell walls, thus triggering cell death. et al., 2019). Fig. 4 shows the 3D surface response graphs of polyphe-
In contrast, the calli of petals had a homogeneous cellular composition nol concentration as a function of two factors. The highest points in
and a hyperhydric appearance, which is ideal for promoting the each corner represent the highest concentration of total polyphenols
release of polyphenols to the medium. Optimal concentrations of SA when SA (0.1 mg L−1) and staminode callus extracts are combined.

52
L. Fajardo Rosabal et al. Current Research in Biotechnology 4 (2022) 47–57

Fig. 5. Desirability function charts of total polyphenols: (a) concentration; (b) explant type; and (c) extract type. Values of −1 and +1 indicate low and high
levels, respectively.

Table 6
Iron reducing potential of undifferentiated derived callus extracts from staminodes and petals expressed as μmol mL−1 of Fe2+.

Extract (µg mL−1) SC T1S T2S PC T1P T2P

a;A
100 0.606 ± 0.031 2.046 ± 0.032b;A 1.253 ± 0.018c; A
1.379 ± 0.018 d; A
1,952 ± 0.032 e; A 4.562 ± 0.048f; A
a; B
200 0.982 ± 0.031 2.318 ± 0.036b; B 3.862 ± 0.032c; B
1.598 ± 0.018 d; B
2.297 ± 0.032b; B 4.989 ± 0.032 e; B
a; C
300 1.410 ± 0.018 2.370 ± 0.018b; B 4.937 ± 0.018c; C
1.837 ± 0.018 d; C
2.349 ± 0.018b; B 5.396 ± 0.032 e; C
a; C
400 1.462 ± 0.018 2.610 ± 0.031b; C 5.396 ± 0.113c; D
2.193 ± 0.018 d; D
2.516 ± 0.031 e; C 5.553 ± 0.031f; D
a; D
500 1.837 ± 0.018 2.787 ± 0.018b; D 5.532 ± 0.018c; E
2.641 ± 0.032 d; E
2.735 ± 0.031b; D 5.866 ± 0.031 e; E

Each value in the table is represented as mean ± SD, (n = 3). Different lowercase letters for the same extract concentration or different capital letters for the same
extract type indicate statistically significant differences according to Tukey (p < 0.05).
Legend: (a–f) Analysis referring to the same concentration of different extracts; A–E) analysis referring to different concentrations of the same extract. SC,
staminode callus control; T1S, staminode callus with SA at 0.01 mg L−1; T2S, staminode callus with SA at 0.1 mg L−1: PC, petal callus control; T1P, petal callus
with SA at 0.01 mg L−1; T2P, petal callus with SA at 0.1 mg L−1.

Table 7
Comparison of the nine mathematical models according to the selection criteria used. The asterisk indicates the highest value of R2 obtained.

Number Salicylic acid (mg L−1) Explant type Values of R2 in the regression models
Linear 1/X 1/Y 1/Y √X Exponential log Y √X log X √Y
log X log X

1 0.01 Petals 97.89 70.10 99.99* 94.63 93.59 99.43 96.56 89.10 82.18
2 0.1 Petals 97.77 89.00 95.94 99.16 99.24* 96.95 99.14 98.42 97.21
3 0.01 Staminode 95.38 87.52 88.84 97.73* 96.95 92.86 96.53 92.41 97.12
4 0.1 Staminode 81.47 99.82* 63.90 83.31 89.38 72.29 81.60 92.82 98.71
5 – Petals 93.89 85.03 91.90 94.83* 94.29 93.11 93.45 93.45 91.11
6 – Staminode 98.58 72.00 99.01* 91.74 95.12 98.88 96.04 89.66 87.29

Meanwhile, the points where the surface has the smallest values, that tion to fulfill the study objectives. The method involves transforming
is the lowest total polyphenol concentration values, are shown with SA the predicted values on a scale from 0 to 1, to indicate their desirabil-
(0.01 mg L−1), extracts of petal calli, and culture medium. ity (Amdoun et al., 2018). The response variable was placed on the
To determine the best global conditions of the experiment and the same scale and a desirability function di(x) was defined. Fig. 5 shows
best response variable for a given range, we used the desirability func- the response graphs corresponding to the desirability function of total

53
L. Fajardo Rosabal et al. Current Research in Biotechnology 4 (2022) 47–57

Table 8
Summary of the results of regression analysis for the best-fit model.

Number Salicylic acid (mg L−1) Explant type Model R2 Adj-R2 SE

1 0.01 Petals Y¼ 1
16:840:015X1
99.99 99.98 0.031
pffiffiffiffiffiffi
2 0.1 Petals Y ¼ 0:134 þ 0:0033 X1 99.24 98.99 0.0016
3 0.01 Staminode Y ¼ 57:647:29 ln X1
1 97.73 96.97 0.8147
4 0.1 Staminode Y ¼ 0:23  17:21
X1
99.82 99.77 0.0027
5 – Petals Y ¼ 18:941:54
1
ln X1
94.82 93.10 0.2636
6 – Staminode Y ¼ 12:210:0063X
1 99.00 98.67 0.1153
1

polyphenols from cellular biomass. The defined optimum total staminode‐derived calli produce the highest concentration
polyphenol concentration was 58.3 µg g−1, with a high global desir- (11.21 µg g−1). However, the yield was lower than that in the present
ability function value of 95%. study, wherein metabolic elicitation with SA was used as a trigger for
In a previous report by Fajardo et al. (2020), the total polyphenols polyphenol production.
in calli from three species of explants (petals, staminodes, and young Several authors (Hii et al., 2009; Sotero et al., 2011; Baharum et al.,
leaves) were quantified with the Folin‐Ciocalteu method. The results 2014; Manzano et al., 2017; Ordoñez et al., 2019; Indirato et al., 2019)
indicated that polyphenol production is possible in these calli and that have quantified the production of polyphenols in cocoa, by using

Fig. 6. Reducing power in petal and staminode calli: (a) petal callus without elicitation (control); (b) staminode callus without elicitation (control); (c) staminode
callus and SA concentration of 0.01 mg L−1; (d) staminode callus and SA concentration of 0.1 mg L−1; (e) petal callus and SA concentration of 0.01 mg L−1; and (f)
petal callus and SA concentration of 0.1 mg L−1.

54
L. Fajardo Rosabal et al. Current Research in Biotechnology 4 (2022) 47–57

extracts from different plant organs to search for potential pharmaco- derived callus extracts showed a four‐fold higher activity than petal
logical and nutritional uses. However, few studies have aimed to extracts in T. cacao UF‐654.
improve the production of polyphenols by in vitro culture. Prior studies Several studies have verified the antioxidant activity of cocoa
have focused mainly on the distribution of the compounds in relation (Baharum et al., 2014; Cádiz‐Gurrea et al., 2014; Manzano et al.,
to the embryogenic response of the callus (Alemanno et al., 2003; 2017; Deus et al., 2018; Ginting et al., 2019), by using extracts from
Gallego et al., 2016). Quiñones‐Galvez et al. (2016) have quantified the natural plant and from products derived from cocoa. However,
phenolic compounds from a callus culture with embryogenic struc- no prior evidence has indicated that polyphenols can be obtained from
tures. The authors have evaluated the effects of different culture con- undifferentiated cells by metabolic elicitation.
ditions in liquid medium (shaking speed, lighting conditions, and In this research, the total polyphenols and the reducing power were
glucose concentration) on the accumulation of phenolic compounds successfully predicted from the optical density values. These models
in the callus and their expression in the culture medium. Moreover, provide good predictions of the effects of treatments. Other authors,
the concentration of polyphenols in the callus is has been found to such as Quiroz‐Reyes and Fogliano (2018), have applied 22 factorial
be genotype dependent (Quiñones et al., 2013; Fajardo et al., 2015; designs, linear regression, and response surface methods to develop
Gallego et al., 2016). a model to predict and describe the total phenolic content and antiox-
idant capacity in the roasting process of the Criollo and Forastero vari-
Antioxidant activity due to the reducing power of selected extracts eties of T. cacao.
Beaver et al. (2020) have used mathematical models and linear
Antioxidant activity due to the reducing power was determined in regression to predict the phenolic content of red wine; their models
selected extracts: non‐elicited calli, petal, and staminode extract with were developed by using data from ultraviolet–visible absorption spec-
SA at 0.01 mg L−1 and 0.1 mg L−1 (Table 6). A positive correlation tra. However, to our knowledge, this experimental setup had not been
was observed between the total phenol content and reducing power, applied to the callus culture of T. cacao.
although all samples did not have the same biological response.
An increase in reducing power was observed with increasing
Conclusions
extract concentration. The best result (5. 87 µmol mL −1) was obtained
in petal derived calli, with SA at 0.1 mg L−1 (T2P). The addition of SA
The eliciting role of SA on the polyphenol content and reducing
as an elicitor increased the iron‐reducing potential in non‐
power activity in undifferentiated calli biomass of T. cacao was demon-
embryogenic callus biomass extracts of this clone. We did not find
strated. The roles of concentration, explant type, and extract type on
any prior reports of reducing power evaluation for this sample type
total polyphenol content in staminode and petal calli, as well as their
in the literature.
culture media was demonstrated with a factorial 2 k experimental
Nine regression models were solved and sorted according to the R2
design. The conditions maximizing the polyphenol content were the
criterion (Table 7). The predictive models were defined as a function
use of callus extracts of staminodes elicited with SA (0.1 mg L−1);
of two variables (elicitor concentration and type of explant). The high-
under these conditions, the content of total polyphenols increased by
est value of R2 was considered the best selection criterion. In contrast,
40.22 µg g−1 above that of the control without elicitation. This result
Table 8 shows the performance criteria parameters from the selected
should provide a reference for future research in liquid media. The
models. High values of R2 and adj‐R2 were obtained in all models (in-
antioxidant activity according to the reducing power of the callus
terval of variation for R2 and adj‐R2 were between 94.83 and 99.99,
extracts was evaluated, and the best result (5.87 µmol mL−1 Fe2+)
and 93.10 and 99.98, respectively). Goodness of fit is often measured
was obtained in callus extracts from petals with SA at 0.1 mg L−1.
with R2, which shows the proportion of variation in the dependent
Mathematical models were developed, which should allow for the pre-
variables explained by the independent variables. Nevertheless, a bet-
diction of the polyphenol content, and reducing power responses.
ter practice is to use adj‐R2 because R2 can sometimes provide overly
favorable regression result. Meanwhile, a significant degree of preci-
sion and a substantial portion of the reliability of the models were indi- CRediT authorship contribution statement
cated by the low values of the standard error. The performance criteria
parameters of a statistical model describe how a data set is adjusted. In Lillien Fajardo Rosabal: Conceptualization, Data curation, Inves-
general, the measures of goodness of fit summarize the discrepancy tigation, Methodology, Writing – original draft, Writing – review &
between the observed values and the expected values in a model. editing. Yans Guardia Puebla: Data curation, Formal analysis,
The best adjustment models are obtained according to the dependent Methodology, Writing – original draft. Suyén Rodríguez Pérez:
variables studied, defined as a function of the independent variables Methodology, Resources, Supervision. Ursula M. Rosabal Cordoví:
(Guardia‐Puebla et al., 2021). Data curation, Investigation, Methodology, Writing – original draft,
Fig. 6 shows the reducing power in petal and staminode calli Writing – review & editing. Juan Silva Pupo: Funding acquisition,
according to the mathematical models, in controls (Fig. 6 a, b), and Project administration, Resources. Stefaan P.O. Werbrouck: Funding
SA at 0.01 mg L−1 and 0.1 mg L−1 for petal and staminode elicited acquisition, Project administration, Resources, Supervision, Writing –
calli (Fig. 6 c‐f). An increase in reducing power was observed as the review & editing.
concentration of polyphenols increased in the extracts prepared from
the samples (100–500 µg mL−1). The optical density values with
Declaration of Competing Interest
staminode derived calli were between 0.06 and 0.20 whereas, the val-
ues for petals remained in a narrower interval between 0.17 and 0.21.
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial
Although the petal extract had lower production of total polyphenols,
interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influ-
they had a slightly better reducing power than that of the extract
ence the work reported in this paper.
obtained from staminode derived calli.
According to Paladino and Zuritz (2011), even when the total phe-
nolic concentration is equal, the amounts of cinnamic acid, benzoic Acknowledgements
acid, anthocyanins, catechins, tannins and flavonoids, may differ,
because each of these phenolic groups may behave differently in terms This work was supported by the program of the Secretariat of
of their reducing power. The results of this study differ from those Higher Education, Science, Technology and Innovation of Belgium
reported by Quiñones et al. (2013), who have reported that stamen‐ (VLIR), coordinated by the University of Gent, in the framework of

55
L. Fajardo Rosabal et al. Current Research in Biotechnology 4 (2022) 47–57

the In vitro Plant Biotechnology project to increase food security in Hii, C., Law, C., Suzannah, S., Misnawi, Cloke, M., 2009. Polyphenols in cocoa
(Theobroma cacao L.).As. J. Food Ag-Ind. 2 (04), 702–722.
eastern Cuba (CU 2017 TEA 438 A103).
Indirato, R., Pranoto, Y., Santoso, U., Supriyanto, 2019. In vitro Antioxidant Activity and
Profile of Polyphenol Compounds Extracts and their Fractions on Cacao Beans. Pak.
References J. Biol. Sci. 22 (1), 34–44.
Isah, T., Umar, S., Mujib, A., Sharma, M.P., Rajasekharan, P.E., Zafar, N., Frukh,
A., 2018. Secondary metabolism of pharmaceuticals in the plant in vitro
Al-Kaf, A., Al-Deen, A., Alhaidari, S., Al-Hadi, F., 2019. Phytochemical analysis and
cultures: strategies, approaches, and limitations to achieving higher yield. Plant
antimicrobial activity of Colocasia esculenta (Taro) medicinal plant leaves used in
Cell Tiss. Organ. Cult. 132 (2), 239–265. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11240-017-
folk medicine for treatment of wounds and burns in Hufash District Al Mahweet
1332-2.
Governorate-Yemen. Univers. J. Pharm. Res. 4 (2), 30–35. https://doi.org/
Jones, W.P., Kinghorn, A.D., 2006. Extraction of Plant Secondary Metabolites. In:
10.22270/ujpr.v4i2.254.
Sarker, S.D., Latif, Z., Gray, A.I. (Eds.), Natural Products Isolation. second ed.
Ainsworth, E.A., Gillespie, K.M., 2007. Estimation of total phenolic content and other
Humana Press, Totowa, New Jersey, pp. 339–351.
oxidation substrates in plant tissues using Folin – Ciocalteu reagent. Nat. Protoc. 2
Lees, G.L., Suttil, N.H., Gruber, M.Y., 1993. Condensed tannins in sainfoin. I. A
(4), 875–877. https://doi.org/10.1038/nprot.2007.102.
histological and cytological survey of plant tissue. Can. J. Bot. 71, 1147.
Alemanno, L., Ramos, T., Gargadecenec, A., Andary, C., Ferriere, N., 2003. Localization
Longbap, B., Ushie, O., Ogah, E., Kendenson, A., Nyikyaa, J., 2018. Phytochemical
and Identication of Phenolic Compounds in Theobroma cacao L. Somatic
Screening and Quantitative Determination of Phytochemicals in Leaf Extracts of
Embryogenesis. Ann. Bot. 92, 613–623. https://doi.org/10.1093/aob/mcg177.
Hannoa undulata. IJMPNP 4 (2), 32–38. https://doi.org/10.20431/2454-
Alemanno, L., Berthouly, M., Michaux-Ferrière, N., 1996. Histology of somatic
7999.0402005.
embryogenesis from floral tissues cocoa. Plant Cell Tissue Organ. Cult. 46 (3),
Lopez- Baez, O., Bollon, H., Eskes, A., Pétiard, V., 1993. Embryogenèse somatique de
187–194.
cacaoyer Theobroma cacao L. à partir de pièces florales. C.R.Seances Acad. Sci. III.
Amdoun, R., Khelifi, L., Khelifi-Slaoui, M., Amroune, S., Asch, M., Assaf-ducrocq, C.,
316 (6), 579–584.
Gontier, E., 2018. The Desirability Optimization Methodology; a Tool to Predict
Manzano, P., Hernández, J., Quijano-Avilés, M., Barragán, A., Chóez-Guaranda, I., Valle,
Two Antagonist Responses in Biotechnological Systems: Case of Biomass Growth
O., 2017. Polyphenols extracted from Theobroma cacao waste and its utility as
and Hyoscyamine Content in Elicited Datura starmonium Hairy Roots. Iranian. J.
antioxidant. Emir. J. Food Agric. 29 (1), 45–50. https://doi.org/10.9755/ejfa.2016-
Biotechnol. 16 (1), 11–19.
04-388.
Baharum, Z., Akim, A.M., Taufiq-Yap, Y.H., Hamid, R.A., Kasran, R., 2014. In Vitro
Maximova, S.N., Alemanno, L., Young, A., Ferriere, N., Traore, A., Guiltinan, M.J., 2002.
Antioxidant and Antiproliferative Activities of Methanolic Plant Part Extracts of
Efficiency, genotypic variability, and cellular origin of primary and secondary
Theobroma cacao. Molecules 19, 18317–18331. https://doi.org/
somatic embryogenesis of Theobroma cacao L. In vitro Cell Dev. Biol.-Plant 38 (3),
10.3390/molecules191118317.
252–259.
Baharum, Z., Akim, A., Hin, T., Hamid, R., Kasran, R., 2016. Theobroma cacao: Review of
Mir, S.A., Mishra, A.K., Reshi, Z.A., Sharma, M.P., 2013. Preliminary Phytochemical
the Extraction, Isolation, and Bioassay of its Potential Anti-cancer Compounds. Trop.
Screening of some Pteridophytes from District Shopian (J & K). Int. J. Pharm.
Life Sci. Res. 27 (1), 21–42.
Pharm. Sci. 5 (4), 632–637.
Banu, K.S., Cathrine, L., 2015. General Techniques Involved in Phytochemical Analysis.
Montgomery, D., 2013. Design and Analysis of Experiment. John Wiley & Sons Inc,
Int. J. Adv. Res. Chem. Sci. 2 (4), 25–32.
USA.
Basit, A., Chadar, H., Haleem, A., Simranjeet, S., Upadhyay, N., 2017. Salicylic acid to
Murashige, T., Skoog, F., 1962. A Revised Medium for Rapid Growth and Bio Assays
decrease plant stress. Environ. Chem. Lett. 15, 101–123. https://doi.org/10.1007/
with Tobacco Tissue Cultures. Physiol. Plant. 15 (3), 473–497.
s10311-016-0584-0.
Murthy, H.N., Lee, E.-J., Paek, K.-Y., 2014. Production of secondary metabolites from
Beaver, C., Collins, T.S., Harbertson, J., 2020. Model Optimization for the Prediction of
cell and organ cultures: Strategies and approaches for biomass improvement and
Red Wine Phenolic Compounds Using Ultraviolet-Visible Spectra. Molecules 25
metabolite accumulation. Plant Cell Tiss. Organ. Cult. 118 (1), 1–16. https://doi.
(1526), 1–8. https://doi.org/10.3390/molecules25071576.
org/10.1007/s11240-014-0467-7.
Cádiz-Gurrea, M.L., Lozano-Sanchez, J., Contreras-Gámez, L., Legeai-Mallet, L.,
Namdeo, A.G., 2007. Plant Cell Elicitation for Production of Secondary Metabolites: A
Fernández-Arroyo, S., Segura-Carretero, A., 2014. Isolation, comprehensive
Review. Pharmacog. Rev. 1 (1), 69–79.
characterization and antioxidant activities of Theobroma cacao extract. J. Funct.
Negaresh, S., Marín, I., 2013. El cacao y la salud humana: propiedades antioxidantes del
Foods. 10, 485–498. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jff.2014.07.016.
cacao nicaragüense y productos alimenticios comercializados. Agrofor. Am. 49,
Cai, L., Chen, B., Yi, F., Zou, S., 2019. Optimization of extraction of polysaccharide from
93–98.
dandelion root by response surface methodology: Structural characterization and
Nwokonkwo, D.C., Okeke, G.N., 2014. The Chemical Constituents and Biological
antioxidant activity. Int. J. Biol. Macromol. 140, 907–919. https://doi.org/
Activities of Stem Bark Extract of Theobroma cacao. GJSFR-E 14 (4), 35–40.
10.1016/j.ijbiomac.2019.08.161.
Ochoa-Villarreal, M., Howat, S., Hong, S., Jang, M.O., Jin, Y.W., Lee, E.K., Loake, G.J.,
Deus, V.L., Barros, M., Fonseca, L., Caldeirão, L., Yoko, E., Soares, S.E., De Souza, E., da
2016. Plant cell culture strategies for the production of natural products. BMB Rep.
Silva, E., 2018. Influence of drying methods on cocoa (Theobroma cacao L):
49, 149–158. https://doi.org/10.5483/BMB Rep. 2016.49.3.264.
antioxidant activity and presence of ochratoxin A. Food Sci. Technol. 38 (1),
Ordoñez, E.S., Leon-Arevalo, A., Rivera-Rojas, H., Vargas, E., 2019. Cuantificación de
278–285. https://doi.org/10.1590/fst.09917.
polifenoles totales y capacidad antioxidante en cáscara y semilla de cacao
Duke, J.A., Bogenschutz-Godwin, M.J., du Cellier, J., Duke, P.-A., 2003. Handbook of
(Theobroma cacao L.), tuna (Opuntia ficus indica Mill), uva (Vitis Vinifera) y uvilla
Medicinal Spices. CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida.
(Pourouma cecropiifolia). Sci. Agropecu. 10 (2), 175–183. https://doi.org/10.17268/
Espinosa-Leal, C.A., Puente-Garza, C., García-Lara, S., 2018. In vitro plant tissue culture :
sci.agropecu.2019.02.02.
means for production of biological active compounds. Planta 248, 1–18. https://doi.
Oyaizu, M., 1986. Studies on Products of Browning Reaction: Antioxidative Activities of
org/10.1007/s00425-018-2910-1.
Products of Browning Reaction Prepared from Glucosamine. Jpn. J. Nutr. Diet. 44
Fajardo, L., Figueredo, Y.P., Rosabal, U., Guardia, Y., Rodríguez, S., Silva-Pupo, J.J.,
(6), 307–315.
Viera, Y., 2020. Contenido de polifenoles totales en callos de Theobroma cacao L.
Paladino, S.C., Zuritz, C.A., 2011. Extracto de semillas de vid (Vitis vinifera L) con
clon ‘UF-650’. Biotecnol. Veg. 20 (1), 63–72.
actividad antioxidante : eficiencia de diferentes solventes en el proceso de
Fajardo, L., Silva-Pupo, J.J., Viera, Y., Cobas, Y., 2015. Efecto del ácido salicílico sobre la
extracción. Rev. Fac. Cienc. Agrar. 43 (1), 187–199.
formación de callos en tres clones de Theobroma cacao L. Biotecnol. Veg. 15 (4),
Patel, H., Krishnamurthy, R., 2013. Elicitors in Plant Tissue Culture. J. Pharmacogn.
217–225.
Phytochem. 2 (2), 60–65.
Fukuda, I.M., Fidelis, C., Dos Santos, C., Morais, A., Rebello, F., 2018. Design of
Pérez-Alonso, N., Jiménez, E., 2011. Producción de metabolitos secundarios de plantas
Experiments (DoE) applied to Pharmaceutical and Analytical Quality by Design
mediante el cultivo in vitro. Biotecnol. Veg. 11 (4), 195–211.
(QbD). Braz. J. Pharm. Sci. 54, 1–16. https://doi.org/10.1590/s2175-
Quiñones, J., Trujillo, R., Capdesuñer, Y., Quirós, Y., Hernández de la Torre, M., 2013.
97902018000001006.
Potencial de actividad antioxidante de extractos fenólicos de Theobroma cacao L.
Gallego, M.A., Henao, M.A., Urrea, A.I., Atehortúa, L., 2016. Polyphenols distribution
(cacao). Rev. Cuba. de Plantas Medicinales. 18 (2), 201–215.
and reserve substances analysis in cacao somatic embryogenesis. Acta Biolo.
Quiñones-Galvez, J., Hernández de la Torre, M., Quirós, Y., Capdesuñer, Y., Trujillo, R.,
Colomb. 21 (2), 335–345. https://doi.org/10.15446/abc.v21n2.50196.
2016. Factores que controlan el contenido de fenoles en el cultivo de callos de
Ganatra, S.H., Durge, S.P., Patil, S.U., 2012. Preliminary Phytochemicals Investigation
Theobroma cacao. Cult. Trop. 37, 118–126. https://doi.org/10.13140/
and TLC Analysis of Ficus racemosa Leaves. J. Chem. Pharm. Res. 4 (5), 2380–2384.
RG.2.1.4038.1047.
Ginting, B., Maulana, I., Saidi, N., Yanti, S., 2019. Isolation and activity antioxidant test
Quiroz-Reyes, C.N., Fogliano, V., 2018. Design cocoa processing towards healthy cocoa
of cocoa pod husk et hyl asetat extracts (Theobroma cacao L. J. Natural. 19 (2),
products : The role of phenolics and melanoidins. J. Funct. Foods 45, 480–490.
49–53. https://doi.org/10.24815/jn.v19i2.12568.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jff.2018.04.031.
Gottipati, R., Mishra, S., 2010. Process optimization of adsorption of Cr (VI) on activated
Rangel, G., Castro, E., Beltran, E., Reyes de la Cruz, H., García, E., 2010. El ácido
carbons prepared from plant precursors by a two-level full factorial design. Chem.
salicílico y su participación en la resistencia a patógenos en plantas. Biologicas 12
Eng. J. 160 (1), 99–107. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cej.2010.03.015.
(2), 90–95.
Guardia-Puebla, Y., Llanes-Cedeño, E., Domínguez-León, A.V., Arias-Cedeño, Q.,
Sanmugarajah, V., Thabrew, I., Sivapalan, S.R., 2013. Phyto, Physicochemical
Sánchez-Girón, V., Morscheck, G., Eichler-Löbermann, B., 2021. Dynamic
Standardization of Medicinal Plant Enicostemma Littorale, Blume. IOSR J. Pharm.
modelling of an anaerobic reactor treating coffee wet wastewater via multiple
3 (2), 52–58.
regression model. J. Water Land Dev. 50 (VI–IX), 229–239. https://doi.org/
Sotero, V., Maco, M., Vela, J., Merino, C., Dávila, E., García, D., 2011. Evaluación de la
10.24425/jwld.2021.138178.
actividad antioxidante y compuestos fenólicos en pulpa y semillas de cuatro frutales
Hernández-Pimentel, M.V., Tavera-Martínez, S., 1996. Análisis histológico del callo
amazónicos de la familia Sterculiaceae. Rev. Soc. Quím. Perú. 77 (1), 66–74.
producido por hojas de Begonia x tuberhybrida cultivadas in vitro. Rev. Chapingo
Ser. Hortic. II (02), 171–176.

56
L. Fajardo Rosabal et al. Current Research in Biotechnology 4 (2022) 47–57

Shalavadi, M.H., Chandrashekhar, V., Muchchandi, I., 2018. Physicochemical and Tripathi, M.K., Mishra, N., Tiwari, S., Shyam, C., Singh, S., Ahuja, A., 2019. Plant Tissue
phytochemical screening of Convolvulus pluricaulis collected from Bagalkot, Culture Technology: Sustainable Option for Mining High Value Pharmaceutical
Karnataka. Int. J. Green Pharm. 12 (3), 625–632. Compounds. Int. J. Curr. Microbiol. Appl. Sci. 8 (02), 1002–1010.
Somkuwar, D.O., Kamble, V.A., 2013. Phytochemical screening of ethanolic extracts of Yadav, R., Khare, R.K., Singhal, A., 2017. Qualitative Phytochemical Screening of Some
stem, leaves, flower and seed kernel of Mangifera indica L. Int. J. Pharma Bio Sci. 4 Selected Medicinal Plants of Shivpuri District (M.P.). Int. J. Life. Sci. Scienti. Res. 3
(2), 383–389. (1), 844–847. https://doi.org/10.21276/ijlssr.2017.3.1.16.

57