s10562 019 02678 X
s10562 019 02678 X
s10562 019 02678 X
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10562-019-02678-x
Received: 10 October 2018 / Accepted: 13 January 2019 / Published online: 7 February 2019
© Springer Science+Business Media, LLC, part of Springer Nature 2019
Abstract
The catalytic activity of synthesized by the template method mesoporous silica doped with dysprosium and modified with
nickel (Dy-Ni/MPS) in the hydrogenation of benzene, ethylbenzene and xylenes has been studied. The catalyst is character-
ized by various techniques such as TEM, SEM, BET, XRD, ICP, XRF analyses. It is shown that the presence of dysprosium in
the MPS structure increases the activity of the catalyst. The catalytic activity of the catalyst (Dy-Ni/MPS) has been explored
in hydrogenation reaction of benzene derivatives with excellent conversion (96–100%) at low pressure.
Graphical Abstract
13
Vol:.(1234567890)
Mesoporous Silica Doped with Dysprosium and Modified with Nickel: A Highly Efficient and… 917
13
918 R. V. Shafigulin et al.
nickel concentration in the samples of mesoporous silica in a static regime at the temperature range 80–170 °C and a
was 8% by weight. hydrogen pressure of 3 atm on an original apparatus allow-
ing an on-line analysis of the reaction mixture (Scheme 1)
2.4 Investigation of Texture Characteristics [37].
and the Surface Morphology of Synthesized 1—tank with carrier gas, 2—reducing valve, 3—valve con-
MPS and Catalysts Obtained on Their Basis trolling the flow rate of the carrier gas, 4—gage measuring
the pressure of the carrier gas in the analytical column, 5—
The texture characteristics of the samples were determined computer and AD converter, 6—heat-conductivity detector,
by nitrogen adsorption–desorption isotherms measurement 7, 16—thermostats, 8—analytical column, 9—6-port three-
at low temperature using Quantochrome Autosorb-1. The way valve, 10—valve at the hydrogen outlet from the reac-
Brunauer-Emmett-Teller model (BET) was used to deter- tor, 11—gage measuring the hydrogen pressure in the reactor,
mine the specific surface area. The total pore volume and 12—hydrogen pressure reducer for delivery of hydrogen into
mesopore size distribution were calculated from the des- the reactor, 13—evaporator (input of reagents into the reactor),
orption curve using the Barrett-Joyner-Khalenda (BJH) 14—hydrogen generator, 15—reactor.
model. The DFT density functional method was used for The apparatus is constituted by the reaction unit (thermo-
the analysis of micropores. The particle size MPS and stat with evaporator for introduction of liquid samples into the
shape of the obtained mesoporous materials were exam- reactor) and analytical unit, a gas chromatograph TraceGC
ined by the electron microscopy using a scanning electron with a flame ionization detector (FID). The units are con-
microscope CarlZeiss EVO 50 with an X-Max 80 energy nected with a 6-port three-way injection valve. The chemical
dispersive attachment. The XRD analysis of synthesized reactor is a steel tube. The catalyst weight is 0.3 g. Reagent
MPS structures and identification of nickel phase were samples were injected into the reactor (volume 1 cm3) with
recorded using a Rigaku Miniflex 600 diffractometer a micro syringe (sample volume 1 µl) in a hydrogen stream.
(Japan) equipped with a detector with a graphite mono- Hydrogen was produced using a hydrogen generator. The first-
chromator and a copper anti-cathode, Cu-Kα radiation order equation was used to calculate the rate constant. Since
(λ = 1.54187 Å). Additionally, samples of catalysts were the reaction was run in excess hydrogen, the reaction kinetics
investigated by transmission electron microscopy (TEM) obeyed the first-order equation [38, 39].
on LEO912 AB OMEGA microscope at an accelerating From the experimental data were determined:
voltage of 100 kV using standard copper grids with a poly- Reaction rate constant:
vinylformal films with a diameter of holes 100 µm. c
1
k= ⋅ ln 0 (1)
t ct
2.5 Study of Catalytic Activity
where C0 is the concentration of reagents at the initial
The catalytic activity of the obtained samples was studied on time of the reaction (t = 0) and Ct is the concentration of
the example of hydrogenation of benzene, ethylbenzene, o-, reagents at time t.
m-, p-xylenes. The hydrogenation kinetics was carried out
13
Mesoporous Silica Doped with Dysprosium and Modified with Nickel: A Highly Efficient and… 919
Fig. 1 Adsorption and desorption isotherms (a); pore size distribution determined by the method of BJH (b); and by the DFT (c) for MPS sam-
ples synthesized at 2 atm, 5 atm, 13 atm and 5 atm (surfactant × 2) with a doubled concentration of CTAB (surfactant × 2)
13
920 R. V. Shafigulin et al.
Table 1 Effect of different Sample S (BET) (m2/g) Vpore (ВJH) Def (BJH) (nm) Def (DFT)
pressures on specific surface (cm3/g) (nm)
areas and textural characteristics
of synthesized mesoporous MPS (2 atm) 666 ± 33 1.462 4/39 2.18
silica
MPS (5 atm, Sur- 579 ± 29 0.913 4 2.38
factant*2)
MPS (5 atm) 600 ± 30 0.828 4 2.38
MPS (13 atm) 563 ± 28 1.266 4/43 2.38
Fig. 3 XRF-spectra for mesoporous silica samples: a nickel-modified (Ni/MPS); b doped with dysprosium and modified with nickel (Dy-Ni/
MPS)
13
Mesoporous Silica Doped with Dysprosium and Modified with Nickel: A Highly Efficient and… 921
Fig. 4 Spectra of Ni/MPS, Dy-Ni/MPS obtained by the ICP method: a spectrum of nickel; b dysprosium spectrum; c chlorine spectrum
Table 2 Specific surface area and textural characteristics of Dy/MPS, additional phases with the mesoporous matrix. The presence
Ni/MPS, Dy-Ni/MPS of nickel in the metal phase form was confirmed by the pres-
Sample S(BET) (m2/g) Vpore ВJH Def (BJH) ence of reflections (2Θ = 44.5°, 51.9°, 76.4°) on the diffrac-
(cm3/g) (nm) togram of Ni/MPS and Dy-Ni/MPS samples corresponding
to the reflections of a cubic face-centered cell of metallic
Dy/MPS 514 ± 20 0.457 3.8
nickel with Brava indices (111), (200), (220) respectively.
Ni/MPS 235 ± 12 0.305 4
In addition to XRD method, the obtained samples were
Dy-Ni/MPS 215 ± 12 0.298 4
analyzed using TEM, and the results of which are shown
in Fig. 6.
Analysis by TEM showed that nickel predominantly
to 514 m2/g. The specific surface area of Ni/MPS decreases localized in the pores of materials mesoporous matrix. The
almost by a factor of 2.5 which is possibly due to nickel average particle size of nickel is not significantly differ-
adsorption in the pores of MPS. ent for the Ni/MPS and Dy-Ni/MPS samples and is about
The XRD method was used to confirm the structure of the 3.7 ± 0.5 nm. However, for the Ni/MPS sample, there are
synthesized mesoporous silica. Figure 5 shows the compara- conglomerates with particle sizes of about 20–30 nm.
tive diffraction patterns for the three MPS samples. Figure 7 shows the SEM photographs at different zoom-
Characteristic peaks in the small angle region indicate ing for the two samples, used as catalysts for the hydrogena-
the presence of ordered systems of mesopores (MCM-41 tion reaction of benzene, ethylbenzene and xylenes.
phase) in MPS, Ni/MPS, Dy-Ni/MPS structures. For the Figure 7 shows that the morphology of the surface of
Dy-Ni/MPS sample, the shift of the characteristic peak to mesoporous silica due to doping with dysprosium is trans-
lower angles and a less relative intensity were revealed. formed. Dy-Ni/MPS used as a catalyst is characterized by a
Apparently, these changes are caused by the incorpora- looser structure comparing to Ni/MPS. The average particle
tion of dysprosium into the MPS structure upon doping. size for Ni/MPS is 75 nm, and for Dy-Ni/MPS is 100 nm.
Such changes are not observed for the sample modified The above results show that the Ni/MPS and Dy-Ni/MPS
with nickel, since it is predominantly located in the pores structures are different, therefore, the structure of the active
of the mesoporous matrix in the metallic and does not form centers also differs, which explains the change, namely the
13
922 R. V. Shafigulin et al.
increase in the catalyst with dysprosium embedded in the and its derivatives. The table shows the selectivity of the
silica structure, as shown in Sect. 3.2. reaction for the products. Table 3 shows the selectivity of
the catalyst for each reagent.
3.2 Kinetic Study of the Hydrogenation The rate constant was calculated graphically in the coor-
dinates of Eq. (1) the coefficient of determinism for the lin-
The determining factor for evaluating the effectiveness of the ear equations of the first-order R2 = 0.99. The value of the
catalyst is the conversion of the reactants during the reac- constant was determined from five parallel experiments with
tion. Figure 8 shows the conversions of benzene, ethylben- a relative error not exceeding 3% (the table shows the aver-
zene and xylenes in the hydrogenation reaction on the Ni/ age values of the rate constants).
MPS and Dy-Ni/MPS catalysts at 150 °C and a hydrogen The rate constants, activation energy and entropy of
pressure of 3 atm. the hydrogenation reactions of benzene, ethylbenzene and
Doping with dysprosium and modification with nickel of xylenes at different temperatures on Dy-Ni/MPS catalyst are
doped mesoporous silica leads to an increase of the catalytic shown in Table 4.
activity in the hydrogenation of xylenes and ethylbenzene. Comparing the rate constants, activation energy and
Thus, the conversion of ethylbenzene after 10 min from entropy of the hydrogenation reaction listed in Table 4, it
the start of the reaction is 100% on Dy-Ni/MPS, and only can be concluded that the highest catalytic activity Dy-Ni/
80% on Ni/MPS. O-xylene, m-xylene and p-xylene are fully MPS catalyst exerts with respect to ethylbenzene. For
hydrogenated after 30 min on Dy-Ni/MPS catalyst, and just xylenes, the catalytic activity decreases as follows: from
80% of xylenes are hydrogenated on Ni/MPS catalyst after p-xylene, to m-xylene and o-xylene. The determining factor
30 min from the beginning of the reaction. For comparison, in the hydrogenation of these compounds is the activation
the conversion of benzene, ethylbenzene and xylenes on energy. The lowest catalytic activity Dy-Ni/MPS shows in
Dy-Ni/MPS catalyst is shown in Fig. 9. the hydrogenation of benzene, and the activation rate is the
The hydrogenation reaction was carried out separately for determining factor for the reaction. The hydrogenation of
each benzene derivative. The method of gas chromatography benzene is characterized by the higher values of entropy
showed that the products of hydrogenation were cyclohexane and activation energy in comparison to the ethylbenzene and
13
Mesoporous Silica Doped with Dysprosium and Modified with Nickel: A Highly Efficient and… 923
Fig. 6 TEM photographs and electron diffraction patterns: a MPS modified with nickel (Ni/MPS); b MPS doped with dysprosium and modified
with nickel (Dy-Ni/MPS)
xylenes. The rate constants expectedly increase with evalu- structure of compounds do not significantly affect the reac-
ation of temperature. tion center or structural changes occur far enough from the
The verification of similarity of the reaction mechanisms reaction center. Thus, with linear dependence, it is assumed
can be carried out by analyzing the isokinetic dependence that the reaction mechanisms are similar and do not depend
described by the following equation [40]: from changes in the structure of the initial substances, from
the nature of the medium, and from other factors. Figure 10
ΔH ≠ = 𝛽 ⋅ ΔS≠ (4) shows the compensation curve in the coordinates E≠–∆S≠ for
where β—compensation effect (isokinetic temperature); the studied compounds on Dy-Ni/MPS catalyst.
∆H≠—thermal effect of the formation of the activated com- The presence of a linear correlation between the acti-
plex (in the present work we used the energy of formation of vation energy and entropy (R2 = 0.9959), obtained from
the activated complex E≠); ∆S≠—the entropy of activation. experimental data, suggests that the mechanism of gas-
Linear dependences between the energy and the entropy phase hydrogenation of benzene, xylenes and ethylbenzene
are quite common, especially in cases where changes in the on Dy-Ni/MPS has a similar character.
13
924 R. V. Shafigulin et al.
Fig. 7 SEM photographs and particle distribution: a MPS modified with nickel (Ni/ MPS); b MPS doped with dysprosium and modified with
nickel (Dy-Ni/ MPS)
13
Mesoporous Silica Doped with Dysprosium and Modified with Nickel: A Highly Efficient and… 925
Fig. 8 Dependence of the conversion of benzene derivatives on time at 150 °C and 3 atm on the Ni/MPS and Dy-Ni/MPS catalysts
13
926 R. V. Shafigulin et al.
Table 4 The rate constants, activation energy and entropy of the Acknowledgements The work is supported by Russian Foundation for
hydrogenation on Dy-Ni/MPS catalyst Basic Research (project 17-43-630358 r_a).
13
Mesoporous Silica Doped with Dysprosium and Modified with Nickel: A Highly Efficient and… 927
as heterogeneous and recyclable nanocatalyst for acetylation of 25. Deshmane VG, Abrokwah RY, Kuila D (2015) Synthesis of stable
alcohols and amines under solvent-free conditions. Catal Lett Cu-MCM-41 nanocatalysts for H 2 production with high selec-
148:2734–2745 tivity via steam reforming of methanol. Int J Hydrogen Energy
9. Abrokwah RY, Deshmane VG, Kuila D (2016) Comparative per- 40:1–14
formance of M-MCM-41 (M: Cu, Co, Ni, Pd, Zn and Sn) catalysts 26. Appaturi JM, Selvaraj M, Abdul Hamid B S (2018) Synthesis of
for steam reforming of methanol. J Mol Catal 425:10–20 3-(2-furylmethylene)-2,4-penttanedione using dl-Alanine func-
10. Takamasa K, Fukue N, Shinichi K, Katsuya K (2018) Opti- tionalized MCM-41 catalyst via Knoevangel condensation reac-
mization of carboxyl-functionalized mesoporous silica for tion. Microporous Mesoporous Mater 260:260–269
the selective adsorption of dysprosium. J Environ Chem Eng 27. Pirouzmand M, Gharehbaba A, Ghasemi Z, Khaaje S (2017)
5:5590–5998 [CTA]Fe/MCM-41: An efficient and reusable catalyst for green
11. Kumar S, Malik MM, Purohit R (2018) Synthesis of high surface synthesis of xanthene derivatives. Arab J Chem 10:1070–1076
area mesoporous silica materials using soft templating approach. 28. Teimouri A, Mahmoudsalehi M, Salavati H (2018) Catalytic oxi-
Mater Today Proc 5: 4128–4133 dative desulfurization of dibenzothiophene utilizing molybdenium
12. Lehmann T, Wolff T, Hamel C, Veit P, Garke B, Seidel-Morgen- and vanadium oxides supported on MCM-41. Int J Hydrogen
stern A (2012) Physico-chemical characterization of Ni/MCM-41 Energy 43:14816–14833
synthesized by a template ion exchange approach. Microporous 29. Hammer B, Norskov JK (1995) Electronic factors determining the
Mesoporous Mater 151:113–125 reactivity of metals. Surf Sci 343:211–220
13. Hosseinzadeh R, Aghili N, Tajbakhsh M (2016) Synthesis, char- 30. Pallassana V, Neurock M (2000) Electronic factors governing
acterization and catalytic application of MCM 41 supported phen- ethylene hydrogenation and dehydrogenation activity of pseudo-
anthrolinium dibromide catalyst for aza-michael addition reaction morphic PdML/Re, PdML/Ru, Pd, and PdML/Au surfaces. J Catal
in aqueous medium. Catal Lett 146:1194–1203 191:301–317
14. Ambursa MM, Sudarsanam P, Voon LH, Abd Hamid SB, Bhar- 31. Boudjahem A-G, Redjel A, Mokrane T (2012) Prepara-
gava SK (2017) Bimetallic Cu-Ni catalysts supported on MCM- tion, characterization and performance of Pd/SiO2 catalyst
41 and Ti-MCM-41 porous materials for hydrodeoxygenation of for benzene catalytic hydrogenation. J Ind Eng Chem Vol
lignin model compound into transportation fuels. Fuel Process 18:303–308
Technol 162:87–97 32. Rahaman M, Vasiur AM, Vannice (1991) The hydrogenation of
15. Abd Hamid SB, Ambursa MM, Sudarsanam P, Voon LH, Bhar- toluene and o-, m-, and p-xylene over palladium: I. kinetic behav-
gava SK (2017) Effect of Ti loading on structure-activity prop- ior and o-xylene isornerization. J Catal 127:251–266
erties of Cu-Ni/Ti-MCM-41 catalysts in hydrodeoxygenation of 33. Neyestanaki AK, Malki-Arvela P, Backman H, Karhu H, Salmi
guaiacol. Catal Commun 94:18–22 T, Valyrynen J, Murzin DY (2003) Gas-phase hydrogenation of
16. Luo N, Cao Y, Li J, Guo W, Zhao Z (2016) Preparation pf Ni2P/ o-xylene over Pt/knitted silica-fiber catalysts. Ind Eng Chem Res
Zr-MCM-41 catalyst and its performance in the hydrodeoxygena- 42: 3230–3236
tion of Jatropha curcas oil. J Fuel Chem Technol 44:76–83 34. Boudjahema A-G, Bettahar MM (2017) Effect of oxidative pre-
17. Khorshidi A (2016) Ruthenium nanoparticles supported on treatment on hydrogen spillover for a Ni/SiO2 catalyst. J Mol Catal
mesoporous MCM-41 as an efficient and reusable catalyst for A Chem 426:190–197
selective oxidation of arenes under ultrasound irradiation. Chin J 35. Wang X, Chen J (2017) Effects of indium on Ni/SiO2 catalytic
Catal 37:153–158 performance in hydrodeoxygenation of anisole as model bio-oil
18. Kowalczyk A, Borcuch A, Michalik M, Rutkowska M, Gil compound: Suppression of benzene ring hydrogenation and C–C
B, Sojka Z (2017) MCM-41 modified with transition metals bond hydrogenolysis. Chin J Catal 38:1818–1830
by template ion-exchange method as catalysts for selective 36. Feng X, Dong C, Ping D, Geng J, Hang J, Dong X (2018) Zr-
catalytic oxidation of ammonia to dinitrogen. L Chmielarz Modified SBA-15 supported Ni catalysts with excellent catalytic
240:9–21 performance of CO selective methanation in H2-rich fuels. Catal
19. Mamontov GV, Gorbunova A, Vyshegorodtseva E, Zaikovskii V, Lett 148:2967–2973
Vodyankina O (2018) Selective oxidation of CO in the presence of 37. Shafigulin RV, Filimonov NS, Filippova EO, Shmelev AA,
propylene over Ag/MCM-41. Catalysis Today. In press, accepted Bulanova AV (2017) Kinetic and thermodynamic specific fea-
manuscript tures of hydrogenation of Hexene-1, Heptene-1, and Cyclohexene
20. Hajjami M, Cheraghi M (2016) Synthesis of Pd-complex sup- on catalyst containing copper nanoparticles. Russ J Appl Chem
ported on MCM-41 and its catalytic activity for the C–C coupling 10:1648–1654
reactions. Catal Lett 146:1099–1106 38. Shubina EG, Filimonov NS, Shafigulin RV et al (2017) Effect of
21. Deng F, Li N, Tang S, Liu C, Yue H, Liang B (2018) Evolution size of nickel nanoparticles on hydrogenation of benzene. Petro-
of active sites and catalytic consequences of mesoporous MCM- leum Chem 57:410–414
41 supported copper catalysts for the hydrogenation of ethylene 39. Restrepo-Garcia JR, Ramírez GE, Baldovino-Medrano VG (2018)
carbonate. Chem Eng J 334:1943–1953 Hydroprocessing of phenanthrene over sulfided Fe-W supported
22. Romero A, Nieto-Marquez A, Alonso E (2017) Bimetallic Ru:Ni/ on modified SBA-15. Catal Lett 148:621–641
MCM-48 catalysts for the effective hydrogenation of D-glucose 40. Nakamura K, Mizuta R, Suganuma S et al (2017) Compensa-
into sorbitol. Appl Catal A 529:49–59 tion between activation entropy and enthalpy in reactions of
23. Jibril BY, Ahmed S (2006) Oxidative dehydrogenation of propane aromatic hydrocarbons catalyzed by solid acids. Catal Commun
over Co, Ni and Mo mixed oxides/MCM-41 catalysts: effects of 102:103–107
intra- and extra-framework locations of metals on product distri-
butions. Catal Commun 7:990–996 Publisher’s Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to
24. Taghavinezhad P, Haghighi M, Alizadeh R (2018) Sonosynthesis jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
of VOx/MCM-41 nanocatalyst enhanced by various metal oxides
(Mg, Al, Zr) for CO2-oxidative dehydrogenation of ethane to eth-
ylene. Microporous Mesoporous Mater 261:63–78
13
928 R. V. Shafigulin et al.
Affiliations
1
* A. V. Bulanova Department of Chemistry, Samara University, Moskovskoe
[email protected] sh. 34, Samara 443086, Russia
13