CD 013260
CD 013260
CD 013260
Library
Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews
Hom J, Sarwar S, Kaleem MA, Messina CR, Abariga SA, Nguyen QD.
Topical mydriatics as adjunctive therapy for traumatic iridocyclitis.
Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2020, Issue 8. Art. No.: CD013260.
DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD013260.pub2.
www.cochranelibrary.com
TABLE OF CONTENTS
HEADER......................................................................................................................................................................................................... 1
ABSTRACT..................................................................................................................................................................................................... 1
PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY....................................................................................................................................................................... 2
BACKGROUND.............................................................................................................................................................................................. 3
OBJECTIVES.................................................................................................................................................................................................. 3
METHODS..................................................................................................................................................................................................... 4
Figure 1.................................................................................................................................................................................................. 5
RESULTS........................................................................................................................................................................................................ 7
DISCUSSION.................................................................................................................................................................................................. 7
AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS........................................................................................................................................................................... 7
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS................................................................................................................................................................................ 8
REFERENCES................................................................................................................................................................................................ 9
CHARACTERISTICS OF STUDIES.................................................................................................................................................................. 10
APPENDICES................................................................................................................................................................................................. 10
HISTORY........................................................................................................................................................................................................ 22
CONTRIBUTIONS OF AUTHORS................................................................................................................................................................... 22
DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST..................................................................................................................................................................... 23
SOURCES OF SUPPORT............................................................................................................................................................................... 23
DIFFERENCES BETWEEN PROTOCOL AND REVIEW.................................................................................................................................... 23
[Intervention Review]
Jeffrey Hom1, Salman Sarwar2, Mona A Kaleem3, Catherine R Messina4, Samuel A Abariga5, Quan Dong Nguyen6
1Departments of Pediatrics and Emergency Medicine, Stony Brook University Renaissance School of Medicine, Stony Brook, New
York, USA. 2Department of Ophthalmology, Medical College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA. 3Ophthalmology, Wilmer Eye
Institute, Johns Hopkins University, Bethesda, Maryland, USA. 4Department of Family, Population, and Preventive Medicine, Stony
Brook University, Renaissance School of Medicine, Stony Brook, New York, USA. 5Department of Ophthalmology, University of Colorado
Anschutz Medical Campus, Denver, Colorado, USA. 6Byers Eye Institute, Stanford University, Palo Alto, California, USA
Citation: Hom J, Sarwar S, Kaleem MA, Messina CR, Abariga SA, Nguyen QD. Topical mydriatics as adjunctive therapy for traumatic
iridocyclitis. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2020, Issue 8. Art. No.: CD013260. DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD013260.pub2.
Copyright © 2020 The Cochrane Collaboration. Published by John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
ABSTRACT
Background
Traumatic eye complaints account for 3% of all hospital emergency department visits. The most common traumatic injury to the eye is
blunt trauma, which accounts for 30% of these visits. Blunt trauma frequently leads to traumatic iridocyclitis, thus causing anterior uveitis.
Iridocyclitis frequently causes tearing, photophobia, eye pain, and vision loss. These symptoms are a result of the inflammatory processes
and ciliary spasms to iris muscles and sphincter. The inflammatory process is usually managed with topical corticosteroids, while the ciliary
spasm is blunted by dilating the pupils with topical mydriatic agents, an adjuvant therapy. However, the effectiveness of mydriatic agents
has not been quantified in terms of reduction of ocular pain and visual acuity loss.
Objectives
To evaluate the effectiveness and safety of topical mydriatics as adjunctive therapy to topical corticosteroids for traumatic iridocyclitis.
Search methods
We searched the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL) which contains the Cochrane Eyes and Vision Trials
Register (2019, issue 6); Ovid MEDLINE; Embase.com; Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature (CINAHL) Plus; PubMed;
ClinicalTrials.gov and the World Health Organization (WHO) International Clinical Trials Registry Platform (ICTRP). We did not use any date
or language restrictions in the electronic search for trials. We last searched the electronic databases on 12 June 2019.
Selection criteria
We planned to include randomized controlled trials (RCTs) that compared topical mydriatic agents in conjunction with topical
corticosteroid therapy versus topical corticosteroids alone, in participants with traumatic iridocyclitis.
Main results
There were no eligible RCTs that compared the interventions of interest in people with traumatic iridocyclitis.
Authors' conclusions
We did not find any evidence from RCTs about the efficacy of topical mydriatic agents as an adjunctive therapy with topical corticosteroids
for treating traumatic iridocyclitis. In the absence of these types of studies, we cannot draw any firm conclusions. Controlled trials that
compare the combined use of topical mydriatic agents and corticosteroid drops against standard corticosteroid drops alone, in people
with traumatic iridocyclitis are required. These may provide evidence about the efficacy and risk of topical mydriatic drops as adjuvant
therapy for traumatic iridocyclitis.
What are the benefits and risks of eye drops that widen the pupil as an additional treatment for inflammation after a blow to the
eye?
• blunt trauma injuries, when an object or force strikes the eye. Common causes of blunt trauma to the eye include motor vehicle accidents,
sports- or work-related accidents, or fights;
• penetrating trauma injuries, when a sharp object or an object traveling at high speed (for example, from pellets fired by air-powered
guns) pierces the eye.
Blunt trauma is the more common form of eye injury. People who have these injuries often develop traumatic iridocyclitis, an inflammation
of the iris (the colored part of the eye that surrounds the black pupil) and the ciliary body (the muscles and tissue around the iris). Traumatic
iridocyclitis can develop after both major and minor blunt trauma, and can affect children as well as adults. Symptoms associated with
damage to the iris and ciliary body include eye pain and sensitivity to light. If the inflammation goes unnoticed or is not treated properly,
it can cause vision loss.
The standard treatment for traumatic iridocyclitis is anti-inflammatory eye drops (corticosteroids). Eye drops that widen the pupil
(mydriatics) are usually used as an additional treatment, to reduce eye pain and discomfort, and to shorten the duration of symptoms.
We aimed to find out whether the use of mydriatics plus corticosteroids to treat traumatic iridocyclitis is beneficial or causes more
unwanted effects than corticosteroids alone by reviewing the research evidence. Specifically, we wanted to know if mydriatics relieve eye
pain and inflammation and improve vision. We also wanted to find out if mydriatics cause complications such as chronic pain, and if they
have any serious negative effects on sight (including blindness).
• randomized controlled trials: these are medical studies where people are randomly put into one of two or more treatment groups. This
type of study provides the most reliable evidence about whether a treatment makes a difference;
• studies that compared the effects of mydriatics plus corticosteroids against corticosteroids alone.
What we found
We found no randomized controlled trials to help us answer our question. Therefore, we do not know whether the addition of mydriatics
to corticosteroids is beneficial or causes more unwanted effects than corticosteroids alone in the treatment of traumatic iridocyclitis. We
need researchers to conduct future studies that compare mydriatics plus corticosteroids against corticosteroids, so that we can assess the
benefits and risks of mydriatics as an additional treatment for traumatic iridocyclitis.
METHODS If mean change from baseline data were not available for BCVA
or IOP outcomes, we planned to calculate the mean difference in
Criteria for considering studies for this review measurements taken at each time point to estimate between-group
effects.
Types of studies
We planned to include randomized controlled trials (RCTs). We Adverse events
excluded cross-over trials, within-person trials, and n-of-1 trials We planned to compare the proportion of participants with serious
(single person clinical trials). ocular adverse events, such as blindness and chronic pain, and
systemic adverse events between the two groups at one week,
Types of participants
two weeks, and one month after treatment. We planned to include
We planned to include trials that enrolled participants of any both spontaneously reported and systematically collected adverse
age with traumatic iridocyclitis. We excluded trials that enrolled events.
participants with open globe injuries or injuries that involved
the posterior segments of the eye, because these injuries require Search methods for identification of studies
surgical intervention. Electronic searches
Types of interventions The Cochrane Eyes and Vision (CEV) Information Specialist
searched the following electronic databases for RCTs and
The primary intervention group in eligible trials would have
controlled clinical trials. There were no restrictions to language or
received topical mydriatic agents in conjunction with topical
year of publication. We last searched the electronic databases on
corticosteroids. The comparison group would have been treated
12 June 2019.
with topical corticosteroids alone, regardless of dose, frequency,
or length of administration. We excluded placebo-controlled trials, • Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL; 2019,
with the planned exception of multi-armed trials which reported Issue 6, which contains the Cochrane Eyes and Vision Trials
outcomes separately for the two targeted interventions. Register) in the Cochrane Library (searched 12 June 2019)
(Appendix 1).
Types of outcome measures
• MEDLINE Ovid (1946 to 12 June 2019) (Appendix 2).
Primary outcomes
• Embase.com (1947 to 12 June 2019) (Appendix 3).
• Proportion of participants with resolution of signs and • CINAHL Plus (Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health
symptoms at one week after treatment, as defined by trial Literature; January 1937 to 12 June 2019) (Appendix 4).
investigators. Typical definitions of resolution include absence • PubMed (1948 to 12 June 2019) (Appendix 5).
of signs (anterior chamber cells, ciliary flushing) and symptoms
• US National Institutes of Health Ongoing Trials Register
(ocular pain, floaters).
ClinicalTrials.gov (www.clinicaltrials.gov; searched 12 June
Secondary outcomes 2019) (Appendix 6).
• World Health Organization (WHO) International Clinical Trials
• Proportion of participants with resolution of signs and Registry Platform (ICTRP) (www.who.int/ictrp; searched 12 June
symptoms at two weeks and one month after treatment, as 2019) (Appendix 7).
defined by trial investigators.
• Proportion of participants with ocular pain at one week, two Searching other resources
weeks, and one month after treatment, as defined by trial
We searched the reference lists of review articles, relevant trials,
investigators.
and textbooks to identify additional trials. We did not impose any
• Proportion of participants with evidence of ocular inflammation language or date restrictions.
(such as cells in the anterior chamber, ciliary flushing, and
floaters) at one week, two weeks, and one month after Data collection and analysis
treatment, as defined by trial investigators.
Selection of studies
• Proportion of participants with synechiae at one week, two
weeks, and one month after treatment, as defined by trial Two review authors (JH and MK) independently screened the titles
investigators. and abstracts of all records and assessed the relevance of each.
• Mean change in best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA) from We obtained full-text copies of reports from potentially relevant
baseline to one week, two weeks, and one month after studies. Two review authors (JH and MK) independently assessed
treatment, as defined by trial investigators. When possible, we the full-text reports to determine the final eligibility of studies.
considered using Logarithm of the Minimum Angle of Resolution At all stages, we resolved any discrepancies by discussion or by
(logMAR) visual acuity values, with Early Treatment Diabetic consulting a third review author (SS) whenever necessary. We
Retinopathy Study (ETDRS) letters or logMAR acuity of 0.1 be a listed the excluded studies and their reasons for exclusion in the
clinically meaningful difference. ‘Characteristics of excluded studies' table. We illustrated the study
• Mean change in IOP from baseline to one week, two weeks, and selection process in a PRISMA diagram (Figure 1).
one month after treatment, as defined by trial investigators. We
considered 2 mmHg to be a clinically meaningful difference.
Sensitivity analysis 1979 did not include our population of interest, and the remaining
two studies were not RCTs (Islam 2010; Melton 1991).
The plan was to use sensitivity analyses to examine the impact
of excluding studies at high risk of selection, detection, and Risk of bias in included studies
attrition biases, studies that had provided only unpublished data,
and industry-funded studies. However, we did not undertake this We did not identify any eligible studies, so could not assess their
because we did not identify any eligible studies for inclusion in the risk of bias in this review.
review.
Effects of interventions
‘Summary of findings' table
We did not identify any eligible studies, so could not assess the
The plan was to construct a ‘Summary of findings' table that effects of the intervention in this review.
included effect estimates for the following primary outcome and
key secondary outcomes. DISCUSSION
support or oppose the use of mydriatic drops as an adjuvant this condition. Data on adverse outcomes, including serious ocular
therapy for traumatic iridocyclitis. adverse events (such as elevated intraocular pressure, lens opacity,
blindness, chronic pain), and systemic adverse events at one week,
Implications for research two weeks and one month after treatment initiation should also be
collected.
It is evident from this review that well-designed RCTs are needed
to evaluate the benefits and risks of mydriatic agents as adjuvant
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
therapy for traumatic iridocyclitis. We recommend that future
trials should evaluate standard therapy with topical corticosteroids We acknowledge Lori Rosman, CEV Information Specialist, for
compared with therapy that includes mydriatic agents along creating and executing the electronic search strategies. We thank
with topical corticosteroids. Such trials should also assess other Yasir J Sepah for his contributions to the published protocol of this
factors, such as time to initiation of therapy, co-injuries (ocular review (Hom 2019). We thank Henry Jampel (Wilmer Eye Institute)
and non-ocular) as well as other underlying medical conditions. and the one peer reviewer who wishes to remain anonymous for
Since traumatic iridocyclitis often causes pain and may lead to providing comments.
diminished visual acuity or blindness, future trials should also
consider evaluating visual acuity and other short-term (one week) This review update was managed by CEV@US and was signed off
or long-term (two weeks to one month) clinical measures of vision, for publication by Tianjing Li and Richard Wormald.
quality of life and outcomes that are important to people with
REFERENCES
References to studies excluded from this review JP, Thomas J, Chandler J, Cumpston M, Li T, Page MJ, et al,
editor(s). Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of
Dunne 1979 {published data only}
Interventions version 6.0 (updated July 2019). Cochrane, 2019.
Dunne JA, Travers JP. Double-blind clinical trial of topical Available from www.training.cochrane.org/handbook.
steroids in anterior uveitis. British Journal of Ophthalmology
1979;63(11):762-7. Logothetis 2014
Logothetis HD, Leikin SM, Patrianakos T. Management of
Islam 2010 {published data only}
anterior segment trauma. Disease-a-Month 2014;60(6):247-53.
Islam N, Pavesio C. Uveitis (acute anterior). BMJ Clinical
Evidence 2010;2010:0705. London 2010
London NJ, Rathinam SR, Cunningham ET Jr. The epidemiology
Melton 1991 {published data only}
of uveitis in developing countries. International Ophthalmology
Melton NR, Thomas RK. Medical management of anterior Clinics 2010;50(2):1-17.
uveitis. Optometry Clinics 1991;1(4):71-8.
Macewen 1989
Macewen CJ. Eye injuries: a prospective survey of 5671 cases.
Additional references British Journal of Ophthalmology 1989;73(11):888-94.
BenEzra 2005
May 2000
BenEzra D, Cohen E, Maftzir G. Uveitis in children and
adolescents. British Journal of Ophthalmology 2005;89(4):444-8. May DR, Kuhn FP, Morris RE, Witherspoon CD, Danis RP,
Matthews GP, et al. The epidemiology of serious eye injuries
Brandt 2001 from the United States Eye Injury Registry. Graefe's Archive for
Clinical and Experimental Ophthalmology 2000;238(2):153-7.
Brandt MT, Haug RH. Traumatic hyphema: a comprehensive
review. Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery McKenzie 2019
2001;59(12):1462-70.
McKenzie JE, Brennan SE, Ryan RE, Thomson HJ, Johnston RV.
Dunn 2015 Chapter 9: Summarizing study characteristics and preparing for
synthesis. In: Higgins JP, Thomas J, Chandler J, Cumpston M, Li
Dunn JP. Uveitis. Primary Care 2015;42(3):305-23.
T, Page MJ, et al, editor(s). Cochrane Handbook for Systematic
Engelhard 2015a Reviews of Interventions version 6.0 (updated July 2019).
Cochrane, 2019. Available from www.training.cochrane.org/
Engelhard SB, Patrie J, Prenshaw J, Bajwa A, Monahan R,
handbook.
Reddy AK. Traumatic uveitis in the mid-Atlantic United States.
Clinical Ophthalmology 2015;9:1869-74. Oner 2006
Engelhard 2015b Oner A, Kekec Z, Krakucuk S, Ikizceli I, Sözüer EM. Ocular trauma
in Turkey: a 2-year prospective study. Advances in Therapy
Engelhard SB, Bajwa A, Reddy AK. Causes of uveitis in children
2006;23(2):274-83.
without juvenile idiopathic arthritis. Clinical Ophthalmology
2015;9:1121-8. Owens 2011
Glanville 2006 Owens PL, Mutter R. Emergency department visits related
to eye injuries, 2008: Statistical Brief #112. Healthcare Cost
Glanville JM, Lefebvre C, Miles J NV, Camosso-Stefinovic J. How
and Utilization Project (HCUP) Statistical Briefs. Rockville
to identify randomized controlled trials in MEDLINE: ten years
(MD): Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (US); 2011.
on. Journal of the Medical Library Association 2006;94(2):130-6.
available at; www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK56035/.
Haring 2016
Review Manager 2014 [Computer program]
Haring RS, Canner JK, Haider AH, Schneider EB. Ocular injury
Nordic Cochrane Centre, The Cochrane Collaboration Review
in the United States: emergency department visits from
Manager 5 (RevMan 5). Version 5.3. Copenhagen: Nordic
2006-2011. Injury 2016;47(1):104-8.
Cochrane Centre, The Cochrane Collaboration, 2014.
Higgins 2011
Romaniuk 2013
Higgins JP, Green S, editor(s). Cochrane Handbook for
Romaniuk VM. Ocular trauma and other catastrophes.
Systematic Reviews of Interventions Version 5.1.0 (updated
Emergency Medicine Clinics of North America 2013;31(2):399-411.
March 2011). The Cochrane Collaboration, 2011. Available from
www.cochrane-handbook.org. Schünemann 2011
Higgins 2019 Schünemann HJ, Oxman AD, Higgins JT, Vist GE, Glasziou P,
Guyatt GH. Chapter 11: Presenting results and ‘Summary of
Higgins JP, Savović J, Page MJ, Elbers RG, Sterne JA. Chapter
findings' tables. In: Higgins JP, Green S, editor(s). Cochrane
8: Assessing risk of bias in a randomized trial. In: Higgins
Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions Version
CHARACTERISTICS OF STUDIES
APPENDICES
or "Ocu-Tropic" or OcuTropic or opticyl or sandol or sintropic or "tropamid forte" or "tropic acid n ethyl n gamma picolyl amide" or
Tropicacyl or tropicamid or "tropico eye" or tropicol or tropikamid or tropimil or visumidriatic or "1508-75-4"
#44 MeSH descriptor: [Tyramine] explode all trees
#45 Tyramine or "4 hydroxyphenethylamine" or lyramine or mydrial or "para hydroxyphenethylamine" or paratyramine or systogene or
tiramine or tocosine or tyramin or tyrosamine or uteramine or "51-67-2" or "60-19-5"
#46 Vibrocil or "8059-14-1"
#47 MeSH descriptor: [Yohimbine] explode all trees
#48 Yohimbine or actibine or aphrodine or aphrodyne or Corynanthine or "corynine hydrochloride" or "dayto-himbin" or "methyl
yohimbine 16alpha carboxylate" or "methylyohimbane 16alpha carboxylate" or Pluriviron or quebrachin or "quebrachine hydrochloride"
or Rauhimbine or Rauwolscine or urobine or yobin or yobinol or yocan or yocaral or Yocon or yocon or yohimbe or "yohimbic acid methyl
ester" or yohimbin or Yohimex or yohimex or yohimibin or yovital or "146-48-5" or "65-19-0"
#49 {or #9-#48}
#50 #8 and #49
69. (Scopolamine or "Boro Scopol" or BoroScopol or Hyoscine or Kwells or "levo hyoscinehydrobromide" or Scoburen or Scopace or scopos
or "Travacalm HO" or Vorigeno or "114-49-8" or atrochin or atroquin or atroscine or hyosceine or hysco or "l epoxytropine tropate" or "n
methylhyoscine" or oscine or scopalamine or "scopine tropate" or scopolamin or transcop or "tropic acid ester with scopine" or "138-12-5"
or "51-34-3" or "55-16-3").tw.
70. ("114-49-8" or "138-12-5" or "51-34-3" or "55-16-3").rn.
71. exp Tropicamide/
72. (Tropicamide or "alcon-mydril" or bistropamide or "cendo mydriatyl" or "Colircusi Tropicamida" or midriaticum or mydiacyl or
mydral or mydramide or mydriacyl or Mydriafair or Mydriaticum or "mydrin m" or "mydrin p" or Mydrum or "n ethyl 2 phenyl n pyrid 4
ylmethylhydracrylamide" or "n ethyl n 4 picolyltropamide" or "n ethyl n gamma picolyltropamide" or "n ethyl n pyrid 4 ylmethyltropamide"
or "Ocu-Tropic" or OcuTropic or opticyl or sandol or sintropic or "tropamid forte" or "tropic acid n ethyl n gamma picolyl amide" or
Tropicacyl or tropicamid or "tropico eye" or tropicol or tropikamid or tropimil or visumidriatic or "1508-75-4").tw.
73. "1508-75-4".rn.
74. exp Tyramine/
75. (Tyramine or "4 hydroxyphenethylamine" or lyramine or mydrial or "para hydroxyphenethylamine" or paratyramine or systogene or
tiramine or tocosine or tyramin or tyrosamine or uteramine or "51-67-2" or "60-19-5").tw.
76. ("51-67-2" or "60-19-5").rn.
77. (Vibrocil or "8059-14-1").tw.
78. "8059-14-1".rn.
79. exp Yohimbine/
80. (Yohimbine or actibine or aphrodine or aphrodyne or Corynanthine or "corynine hydrochloride" or "dayto-himbin" or "methyl
yohimbine 16alpha carboxylate" or "methylyohimbane 16alpha carboxylate" or Pluriviron or quebrachin or "quebrachine hydrochloride"
or Rauhimbine or Rauwolscine or urobine or yobin or yobinol or yocan or yocaral or Yocon or yocon or yohimbe or "yohimbic acid methyl
ester" or yohimbin or Yohimex or yohimex or yohimibin or yovital or "146-48-5" or "65-19-0").tw.
81. ("146-48-5" or "65-19-0").rn.
82. or/20-81
83. 19 and 82
84. 11 and 83
The search filter for trials at the beginning of the MEDLINE strategy is from the published paper by Glanville 2006.
Metaoxedrin OR metaoxedrine OR Metasympatol OR metasynephrine OR Mezaton OR "murucoll 2" OR mydfrin OR "n 105 to" OR "nefrin-
ofteno" OR "Neo Synephrine" OR neofrin OR neooxedrine OR neophryn OR neosynephrin OR Neosynephrine OR "neosynephrin-pos" OR
neosynesin OR neosynesine OR "ocu-phrin" OR "oftan-metaoksedrin" OR optistin OR phenoptic OR phenylefrine OR phenylephedrine OR
prefrin OR "pupiletto forte" OR rectasol OR "rhinall 10" OR "slv 325" OR slv325 OR sucraphen OR vazculep OR visadron OR vistafrin OR
vistosan OR "532-38-7" OR "59-42-7" OR "61-76-7"):ti,ab,tn
#62 (Pholedrine OR "4 hydroxy n methylamphetamine" OR "4 hydroxymethamphetamine" OR adyston OR "para
hydroxymethamphetamine" OR "p-hydroxymethamphetamine" OR paredrinol OR "Pholedrin liquidum" OR "Pholedrin-longo-Isis" OR
pulsotyl OR venosan OR veritol OR "370-14-9"):ti,ab,tn
#63 'hydroxyamphetamine'/exp
#64 (p-Hydroxyamphetamine OR "1 para hydroxyphenyl 2 propylamine" OR "alpha methyl para tyramine" OR "alpha methyl tyramine" OR
"dl 1 p hydroxyphenyl 2 propylamine" OR "dl 1 para hydroxyphenyl 2 propylamine" OR "dl p hydroxy alpha methylphenethylamine" OR
"dl para hydroxy alpha methylphenethylamine" OR "h 66 37" OR "para hydroxy alpha methylphenethylamine" OR Hydroxyamfetamine OR
Hydroxyamphetamin OR Hydroxyamphetamine OR Hydroxyphenylisopropylamine OR Methyltyramine OR Norpholedrin OR norpholedrine
OR oxamphetamine OR Oxyamphetamine OR paradrine OR parahydroxyamphetamine OR Paredrine OR paredrinea OR paredrinex OR
pedrolone OR pulsoton OR "103-86-6" OR "1518-86-1" OR "306-21-8"):ab,ti,tn
#65 'racepinefrine'/exp
#66 (Racepinephrine OR Micronefrin OR micronefrine OR Micronephrine OR mikronephrin OR racadrenalin OR "Racepinefrine
Hydrochloride" OR racinephrine OR Vaponefrin OR vaponefrine OR vaponephrin OR "329-65-7"):ti,ab,tn
#67 'scopolamine bromide'/exp
#68 (Scopolamine OR "Boro Scopol" OR BoroScopol OR Hyoscine OR Kwells OR "levo hyoscinehydrobromide" OR Scoburen OR Scopace OR
scopos OR "Travacalm HO" OR Vorigeno OR "114-49-8" OR atrochin OR atroquin OR atroscine OR hyosceine OR hysco OR "l epoxytropine
tropate" OR "n methylhyoscine" OR oscine OR scopalamine OR "scopine tropate" OR scopolamin OR transcop OR "tropic acid ester with
scopine" OR "138-12-5" OR "51-34-3" OR "55-16-3"):ab,ti,tn
#69 (Tropicamide OR "alcon-mydril" OR bistropamide OR "cendo mydriatyl" OR "Colircusi Tropicamida" OR midriaticum OR mydiacyl
OR mydral OR mydramide OR mydriacyl OR Mydriafair OR Mydriaticum OR "mydrin m" OR "mydrin p" OR Mydrum OR "n ethyl 2 phenyl
n pyrid 4 ylmethylhydracrylamide" OR "n ethyl n 4 picolyltropamide" OR "n ethyl n gamma picolyltropamide" OR "n ethyl n pyrid 4
ylmethyltropamide" OR "Ocu-Tropic" OR OcuTropic OR opticyl OR sandol OR sintropic OR "tropamid forte" OR "tropic acid n ethyl
n gamma picolyl amide" OR Tropicacyl OR tropicamid OR "tropico eye" OR tropicol OR tropikamid OR tropimil OR visumidriatic OR
"1508-75-4"):ab,ti,tn
#70 (Tyramine OR "4 hydroxyphenethylamine" OR lyramine OR mydrial OR "para hydroxyphenethylamine" OR paratyramine OR systogene
OR tiramine OR tocosine OR tyramin OR tyrosamine OR uteramine OR "51-67-2" OR "60-19-5"):ti,ab,tn
#71 (Vibrocil OR "8059-14-1"):ti,ab,tn
#72 'yohimbine'/exp
#73 (Yohimbine OR actibine OR aphrodine OR aphrodyne OR Corynanthine OR "corynine hydrochloride" OR "dayto-himbin" OR
"methyl yohimbine 16alpha carboxylate" OR "methylyohimbane 16alpha carboxylate" OR Pluriviron OR quebrachin OR "quebrachine
hydrochloride" OR Rauhimbine OR Rauwolscine OR urobine OR yobin OR yobinol OR yocan OR yocaral OR Yocon OR yocon OR yohimbe
OR "yohimbic acid methyl ester" OR yohimbin OR Yohimex OR yohimex OR yohimibin OR yovital OR "146-48-5" OR "65-19-0"):ti,ab,tn
#74 #41 OR #42 OR #43 OR #44 OR #45 OR #46 OR #47 OR #48 OR #49 OR #50 OR #51 OR #52 OR #53 OR #54 OR #55 OR #56 OR #57 OR #58
OR #59 OR #60 OR #61 OR #62 OR #63 OR #64 OR #65 OR #66 OR #67 OR #68 OR #69 OR #70 OR #71 OR #72 OR #73
#75 #40 AND #74
#76 #32 AND #75
S24 TI (Oxyphenonium or Methacin or Oxyphenon or Atrenyl or Spastrex or antrenyl or "ba 5473" or ba5473 or "c 5473" or c5473 or helkamon
or metacin or metacinum or oxyphenium or "oxyphenomium bromide" or spasmofen or spasmophen or "14214-84-7" or "50-10-2") OR AB
(Oxyphenonium or Methacin or Oxyphenon or Atrenyl or Spastrex or antrenyl or "ba 5473" or ba5473 or "c 5473" or c5473 or helkamon or
metacin or metacinum or oxyphenium or "oxyphenomium bromide" or spasmofen or spasmophen or "14214-84-7" or "50-10-2")
S25 TI (Phenylephrine or adrianol or "af-taf" or "ak-dilate" or "albalon relief" or alconefrin or almefrin or altafrin or biomidrin or biomydrin
or derizene or "despec-sf" or drosin or "efrin-10" or efrisel or fenylephrine or idrianol or isonefrine or isophrin or isophrine or "isopto
frin" or isoptofrin or lexatol or "m synephrine" or mesaton or "meta sympathol" or "meta synephrine" or Metaoxedrin or metaoxedrine or
Metasympatol or metasynephrine or Mezaton or "murucoll 2" or mydfrin or "n 105 to" or "nefrin-ofteno" or "Neo Synephrine" or neofrin
or neooxedrine or neophryn or neosynephrin or Neosynephrine or "neosynephrin-pos" or neosynesin or neosynesine or "ocu-phrin" or
"oftan-metaoksedrin" or optistin or phenoptic or phenylefrine or phenylephedrine or prefrin or "pupiletto forte" or rectasol or "rhinall
10" or "slv 325" or slv325 or sucraphen or vazculep or visadron or vistafrin or vistosan or "532-38-7" or "59-42-7" or "61-76-7") OR AB
(Phenylephrine or adrianol or "af-taf" or "ak-dilate" or "albalon relief" or alconefrin or almefrin or altafrin or biomidrin or biomydrin or
derizene or "despec-sf" or drosin or "efrin-10" or efrisel or fenylephrine or idrianol or isonefrine or isophrin or isophrine or "isopto frin"
or isoptofrin or lexatol or "m synephrine" or mesaton or "meta sympathol" or "meta synephrine" or Metaoxedrin or metaoxedrine or
Metasympatol or metasynephrine or Mezaton or "murucoll 2" or mydfrin or "n 105 to" or "nefrin-ofteno" or "Neo Synephrine" or neofrin
or neooxedrine or neophryn or neosynephrin or Neosynephrine or "neosynephrin-pos" or neosynesin or neosynesine or "ocu-phrin" or
"oftan-metaoksedrin" or optistin or phenoptic or phenylefrine or phenylephedrine or prefrin or "pupiletto forte" or rectasol or "rhinall 10"
or "slv 325" or slv325 or sucraphen or vazculep or visadron or vistafrin or vistosan or "532-38-7" or "59-42-7" or "61-76-7")
S26 TI (Pholedrine or "4 hydroxy n methylamphetamine" or "4 hydroxymethamphetamine" or adyston or "para
hydroxymethamphetamine" or "p-hydroxymethamphetamine" or paredrinol or "Pholedrin liquidum" or "Pholedrin-longo-Isis" or pulsotyl
or venosan or veritol or "370-14-9") OR AB (Pholedrine or "4 hydroxy n methylamphetamine" or "4 hydroxymethamphetamine" or adyston
or "para hydroxymethamphetamine" or "p-hydroxymethamphetamine" or paredrinol or "Pholedrin liquidum" or "Pholedrin-longo-Isis"
or pulsotyl or venosan or veritol or "370-14-9")
S27 TI (p-Hydroxyamphetamine or "1 para hydroxyphenyl 2 propylamine" or "alpha methyl para tyramine" or "alpha methyl tyramine"
or "dl 1 p hydroxyphenyl 2 propylamine" or "dl 1 para hydroxyphenyl 2 propylamine" or "dl p hydroxy alpha methylphenethylamine" or
"dl para hydroxy alpha methylphenethylamine" or "h 66 37" or "para hydroxy alpha methylphenethylamine" or Hydroxyamfetamine or
Hydroxyamphetamin or Hydroxyamphetamine or Hydroxyphenylisopropylamine or Methyltyramine or Norpholedrin or norpholedrine or
oxamphetamine or Oxyamphetamine or paradrine or parahydroxyamphetamine or Paredrine or paredrinea or paredrinex or pedrolone or
pulsoton or "103-86-6" or "1518-86-1" or "306-21-8") OR AB (p-Hydroxyamphetamine or "1 para hydroxyphenyl 2 propylamine" or "alpha
methyl para tyramine" or "alpha methyl tyramine" or "dl 1 p hydroxyphenyl 2 propylamine" or "dl 1 para hydroxyphenyl 2 propylamine"
or "dl p hydroxy alpha methylphenethylamine" or "dl para hydroxy alpha methylphenethylamine" or "h 66 37" or "para hydroxy alpha
methylphenethylamine" or Hydroxyamfetamine or Hydroxyamphetamin or Hydroxyamphetamine or Hydroxyphenylisopropylamine or
Methyltyramine or Norpholedrin or norpholedrine or oxamphetamine or Oxyamphetamine or paradrine or parahydroxyamphetamine or
Paredrine or paredrinea or paredrinex or pedrolone or pulsoton or "103-86-6" or "1518-86-1" or "306-21-8")
S28 TI (Racepinephrine or Micronefrin or micronefrine or Micronephrine or mikronephrin or racadrenalin or "Racepinefrine Hydrochloride"
or racinephrine or Vaponefrin or vaponefrine or vaponephrin or "329-65-7") OR AB (Racepinephrine or Micronefrin or micronefrine
or Micronephrine or mikronephrin or racadrenalin or "Racepinefrine Hydrochloride" or racinephrine or Vaponefrin or vaponefrine or
vaponephrin or "329-65-7")
S29 TI (Scopolamine or "Boro Scopol" or BoroScopol or Hyoscine or Kwells or "levo hyoscinehydrobromide" or Scoburen or Scopace
or scopos or "Travacalm HO" or Vorigeno or "114-49-8" or atrochin or atroquin or atroscine or hyosceine or hysco or "l epoxytropine
tropate" or "n methylhyoscine" or oscine or scopalamine or "scopine tropate" or scopolamin or transcop or "tropic acid ester with
scopine" or "138-12-5" or "51-34-3" or "55-16-3") OR AB (Scopolamine or "Boro Scopol" or BoroScopol or Hyoscine or Kwells or "levo
hyoscinehydrobromide" or Scoburen or Scopace or scopos or "Travacalm HO" or Vorigeno or "114-49-8" or atrochin or atroquin or
atroscine or hyosceine or hysco or "l epoxytropine tropate" or "n methylhyoscine" or oscine or scopalamine or "scopine tropate" or
scopolamin or transcop or "tropic acid ester with scopine" or "138-12-5" or "51-34-3" or "55-16-3")
S30 TI (Tropicamide or "alcon-mydril" or bistropamide or "cendo mydriatyl" or "Colircusi Tropicamida" or midriaticum or mydiacyl or
mydral or mydramide or mydriacyl or Mydriafair or Mydriaticum or "mydrin m" or "mydrin p" or Mydrum or "n ethyl 2 phenyl n pyrid 4
ylmethylhydracrylamide" or "n ethyl n 4 picolyltropamide" or "n ethyl n gamma picolyltropamide" or "n ethyl n pyrid 4 ylmethyltropamide"
or "Ocu-Tropic" or OcuTropic or opticyl or sandol or sintropic or "tropamid forte" or "tropic acid n ethyl n gamma picolyl amide" or
Tropicacyl or tropicamid or "tropico eye" or tropicol or tropikamid or tropimil or visumidriatic or "1508-75-4") OR AB (Tropicamide or
"alcon-mydril" or bistropamide or "cendo mydriatyl" or "Colircusi Tropicamida" or midriaticum or mydiacyl or mydral or mydramide or
mydriacyl or Mydriafair or Mydriaticum or "mydrin m" or "mydrin p" or Mydrum or "n ethyl 2 phenyl n pyrid 4 ylmethylhydracrylamide"
or "n ethyl n 4 picolyltropamide" or "n ethyl n gamma picolyltropamide" or "n ethyl n pyrid 4 ylmethyltropamide" or "Ocu-Tropic" or
OcuTropic or opticyl or sandol or sintropic or "tropamid forte" or "tropic acid n ethyl n gamma picolyl amide" or Tropicacyl or tropicamid
or "tropico eye" or tropicol or tropikamid or tropimil or visumidriatic or "1508-75-4")
S31 TI (Tyramine or "4 hydroxyphenethylamine" or lyramine or mydrial or "para hydroxyphenethylamine" or paratyramine or systogene
or tiramine or tocosine or tyramin or tyrosamine or uteramine or "51-67-2" or "60-19-5") OR AB (Tyramine or "4 hydroxyphenethylamine"
or lyramine or mydrial or "para hydroxyphenethylamine" or paratyramine or systogene or tiramine or tocosine or tyramin or tyrosamine
or uteramine or "51-67-2" or "60-19-5")
S32 TI (Vibrocil or "8059-14-1") OR AB (Vibrocil or "8059-14-1")
S33 (MH "Yohimbine")
S34 TI (Yohimbine or actibine or aphrodine or aphrodyne or Corynanthine or "corynine hydrochloride" or "dayto-himbin" or "methyl
yohimbine 16alpha carboxylate" or "methylyohimbane 16alpha carboxylate" or Pluriviron or quebrachin or "quebrachine hydrochloride"
or Rauhimbine or Rauwolscine or urobine or yobin or yobinol or yocan or yocaral or Yocon or yocon or yohimbe or "yohimbic acid
methyl ester" or yohimbin or Yohimex or yohimex or yohimibin or yovital or "146-48-5" or "65-19-0") OR AB (Yohimbine or actibine or
aphrodine or aphrodyne or Corynanthine or "corynine hydrochloride" or "dayto-himbin" or "methyl yohimbine 16alpha carboxylate" or
"methylyohimbane 16alpha carboxylate" or Pluriviron or quebrachin or "quebrachine hydrochloride" or Rauhimbine or Rauwolscine or
urobine or yobin or yobinol or yocan or yocaral or Yocon or yocon or yohimbe or "yohimbic acid methyl ester" or yohimbin or Yohimex or
yohimex or yohimibin or yovital or "146-48-5" or "65-19-0")
S35 (S9 OR S10 OR S11 OR S12 OR S13 OR S14 OR S15 OR S16 OR S17 OR S18 OR S19 OR S20 OR S21 OR S22 OR S23 OR S24 OR S25 OR S26
OR S27 OR S28 OR S29 OR S30 OR S31 OR S32 OR S33 OR S34)
S36 S8 AND S35
#36 Medline[sb]
#37 #35 NOT #36
(uveitis OR iridocyclitis OR iritis OR iritides OR cyclitis OR scleritis) AND (methylatropine OR naphazoline OR oxedrine OR p-
hydroxyamphetamine OR phenylephrine OR pholedrine OR scopolamine OR tropicamide OR tyramine OR vibrocil OR yohimbine)
iridocyclitis AND mydriatics OR iridocyclitis AND cycloplegics OR iridocyclitis AND atropine OR iridocyclitis AND berefrine OR iridocyclitis
AND cyclopentolate OR iridocyclitis AND epinephrine OR iridocyclitis AND ethylmorphine OR iridocyclitis AND eucatropine OR iridocyclitis
AND homatropine OR iridocyclitis AND hyoscyamine OR iridocyclitis AND ibopamine OR iridocyclitis AND oxyphenonium OR iridocyclitis
AND methylatropine OR iridocyclitis AND naphazoline OR iridocyclitis AND oxedrine OR iridocyclitis AND p-hydroxyamphetamine OR
iridocyclitis AND phenylephrine OR iridocyclitis AND pholedrine OR iridocyclitis AND racepinephrine OR iridocyclitis AND scopolamine OR
iridocyclitis AND tropicamide OR iridocyclitis AND tyramine OR iridocyclitis AND vibrocil OR iridocyclitis AND yohimbine
iritis AND mydriatics OR iritis AND cycloplegics OR iritis AND atropine OR iritis AND berefrine OR iritis AND cyclopentolate OR iritis AND
epinephrine OR iritis AND ethylmorphine OR iritis AND eucatropine OR iritis AND homatropine OR iritis AND hyoscyamine OR iritis AND
ibopamine OR iritis AND oxyphenonium OR iritis AND methylatropine OR iritis AND naphazoline OR iritis AND oxedrine OR iritis AND p-
hydroxyamphetamine OR iritis AND phenylephrine OR iritis AND pholedrine OR iritis AND racepinephrine OR iritis AND scopolamine OR
iritis AND tropicamide OR iritis AND tyramine OR iritis AND vibrocil OR iritis AND yohimbine
iritides AND mydriatics OR iritides AND cycloplegics OR iritides AND atropine OR iritides AND berefrine OR iritides AND cyclopentolate
OR iritides AND epinephrine OR iritides AND ethylmorphine OR iritides AND eucatropine OR iritides AND homatropine OR iritides AND
hyoscyamine OR iritides AND ibopamine OR iritides AND oxyphenonium OR iritides AND methylatropine OR iritides AND naphazoline OR
iritides AND oxedrine OR iritides AND p-hydroxyamphetamine OR iritides AND phenylephrine OR iritides AND pholedrine OR iritides AND
racepinephrine OR iritides AND scopolamine OR iritides AND tropicamide OR iritides AND tyramine OR iritides AND vibrocil OR iritides AND
yohimbine
cyclitis AND mydriatics OR cyclitis AND cycloplegics OR cyclitis AND atropine OR cyclitis AND berefrine OR cyclitis AND cyclopentolate
OR cyclitis AND epinephrine OR cyclitis AND ethylmorphine OR cyclitis AND eucatropine OR cyclitis AND homatropine OR cyclitis AND
hyoscyamine OR cyclitis AND ibopamine OR cyclitis AND oxyphenonium OR cyclitis AND methylatropine OR cyclitis AND naphazoline OR
cyclitis AND oxedrine OR cyclitis AND p-hydroxyamphetamine OR cyclitis AND phenylephrine OR cyclitis AND pholedrine OR cyclitis AND
racepinephrine OR cyclitis AND scopolamine OR cyclitis AND tropicamide OR cyclitis AND tyramine OR cyclitis AND vibrocil OR cyclitis AND
yohimbine
scleritis AND mydriatics OR scleritis AND cycloplegics OR scleritis AND atropine OR scleritis AND berefrine OR scleritis AND cyclopentolate
OR scleritis AND epinephrine OR scleritis AND ethylmorphine OR scleritis AND eucatropine OR scleritis AND homatropine OR scleritis AND
hyoscyamine OR scleritis AND ibopamine OR scleritis AND oxyphenonium OR scleritis AND methylatropine OR scleritis AND naphazoline
OR scleritis AND oxedrine OR scleritis AND p-hydroxyamphetamine OR scleritis AND phenylephrine OR scleritis AND pholedrine OR scleritis
AND racepinephrine OR scleritis AND scopolamine OR scleritis AND tropicamide OR scleritis AND tyramine OR scleritis AND vibrocil OR
scleritis AND yohimbine
Methods
Study design • Parallel-group randomized controlled trial (RCT) i.e. people randomized to • Exclusions after ran-
treatment domization
(Continued)
• Within-person RCT i.e. eyes randomized to treatment • Losses to follow-up
• Cluster-RCT i.e. communities randomized to treatment • Number random-
• Cross-over RCT ized/analyzed
• Other, specify • How were missing da-
ta handled? e.g. avail-
Eyes or • One eye included in study, specify how eye selected able case analysis, im-
putation methods
• Two eyes included in study, both eyes received same treatment, briefly
Unit of randomization/ specify how analyzed (best/worst/average/both and adjusted for within- • Reported power cal-
unit of analysis person correlation/both and not adjusted for within person correlation) culation (Y/N), if yes,
and specify if mixture of one eye and two eyes sample size and power
• Two eyes included in study, eyes received different treatments, specify if • Unusual study de-
correct pair-matched analysis done sign/issues
Participants
Country • Setting
• Ethnic group
Total number of partici- This information should be collected for total study population recruited in- • Equivalence of base-
pants to the study. If these data are reported only for the people who were followed line characteristics (Y/
up, please indicate N)
Number (%) of men and
women
Inclusion criteria
Exclusion criteria
Interventions
Outcomes
HISTORY
Protocol first published: Issue 3, 2019
Review first published: Issue 8, 2020
CONTRIBUTIONS OF AUTHORS
JH: conception and design of study, drafting the review, final approval of the document published.
SS: design of study, drafting the review, final approval of the document published.
MK; CM; SA; QN: design of study, commenting on the review, final approval of the document published.
DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST
JH: none known.
SS: none known.
MK: none known.
CM: none known.
SA: none known.
QN: has received grants and other financial support from Genentech, Regeneron, AbbVie, Psivida, XOMA, Santen, Allergan, and Heidelberg.
However, none of these are relevant to the current Cochrane Review.
SOURCES OF SUPPORT
Internal sources
• None, Other
External sources
• Methodological support provided by the Cochrane Eyes and Vision (CEV) US Project, supported by grant 5 UG1 EY020522, National Eye
Institute, National Institutes of Health, USA
• National Institute for Health Research (NIHR), UK
* Richard Wormald, Co-ordinating Editor for CEV acknowledges financial support for his CEV research sessions from the Department
of Health through the award made by the NIHR to Moorfields Eye Hospital NHS Foundation Trust and University College London
Institute of Ophthalmology for a Specialist Biomedical Research Centre for Ophthalmology.
* This review was supported by the NIHR, via Cochrane Infrastructure funding to the CEV UK editorial base.
The views expressed in this publication are those of the authors and not necessarily those of the NIHR, NHS, or the Department of Health.