Part C Chapter 1 Introduction
Part C Chapter 1 Introduction
Part C Chapter 1 Introduction
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPTER 1 – INTRODUCTION ............................................................................... 2
1.1. Objective of the Manual ......................................................................................... 2
1.2. Present challenges being faced by urban water service providers/utilities and need
for a management approach ............................................................................................. 2
1.3. “Management” in an urban service provider/utility context ..................................... 3
1.3.1. Key attributes of an effectively managed urban water service provider/utility .............. 4
1.4. Management approaches for creating effectively managed urban water service
providers/utilities ............................................................................................................... 7
1.5. Case Studies ......................................................................................................... 9
1.5.1. Hyderabad Metropolitan Water Supply and Sewerage Board ...................................... 9
1.5.2. Phnom Pehn Water Supply Authority, Cambodia ....................................................... 10
1.6. Contents of the Manual ........................................................................................ 11
List of Figures
Figure 1.1: Attributes of an Effectively Managed Service Provider/Utility and Key
Management Approaches ..................................................................................................... 7
Figure 1.2: Revised Organisational structure of HMWSSB .................................................. 11
List of Annexures
Annexure 1.1 Checklist for engineers/managers regarding current status of attributes of an
effectively managed water service provider/utility ................................................................ 13
1
Chapter 1:
Part C – Management Introduction
CHAPTER 1 – INTRODUCTION
Urban water service providers/utilities are facing numerous challenges, including the
following:
Rapid increase in population of urban centres: In 20112 , India’s urban population
was 377.16 million which rose to 461 million in 20183 (as per United Nation’s World
Urbanisation Prospects – 2018 revisions). It is estimated that much of the population
increase between 2018 and 2050 will take place in urban areas and the country’s
urban population will double to ~877 million by 20504. This extraordinary scale of
urban population growth poses a huge challenge with respect to provision of water
supply services. The rapid increase in urban population requires tapping of new
water sources and enhancement of existing ones to meet the ever-increasing
1
The Handbook on Service Level Benchmarks is available at https://cpheeo.gov.in/upload/uploadfiles/files/Handbook.pdf
2 Source: Census 2011
3 Source: UN World Urbanisation Prospects, 2018 revision (https://population.un.org/wup/Publications/Files/WUP2018-
Report.pdf)
4 Ibid.
2
Chapter 1:
Part C – Management Introduction
3
Chapter 1:
Part C – Management Introduction
There are seven key attributes of an effectively managed urban water service
provider/utility, which cover various service delivery domains including, operations,
infrastructure, stakeholders (including consumers), service quality and financial
performance. (Figure 1.1)
1. Service Quality: The urban water service providers/utilities must ensure “fit
for purpose” (well -suited) water supply which meets the existing requirements
under the BIS Drinking water specification IS 10500:2012; Second
Amendment6 and Government of India’s (GoI’s) SLBs which were notified by
Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs (MoHUA) in 2008, along with being
consistent with consumer, public health, ecological, and economic needs.
This section is adapted from “Effective Utility Management: A Primer for Water and Wastewater Utilities, August 2017
5
available at https://www.epa.gov/sustainable-water-infrastructure/effective-water-utility-management-practices
6
Available at http://cgwb.gov.in/documents/wq-standards.pdf
4
Chapter 1:
Part C – Management Introduction
3. Financial Viability: The urban water service provider/utility must plan for the
full life-cycle cost of its operations. They should maintain an effective balance
between long-term debt, asset values, Operation and Maintenance (O&M)
expenditures, and operating revenues. Further, the urban water service
provider/utility must put in place user charges that are (a) consistent with
community expectations and acceptability, taking into account affordability
and the needs of disadvantaged/marginalised households and (b) adequate to
recover costs (recovering O&M costs in the short term and capital costs in the
long term). The urban water service provider/utility must also institutionalise
robust systems for billing and collection of payments. They must also leverage
opportunities available to diversify revenues and raise capital through
adoption of new business models. Financial planning is critical for ensuring
operational and financial viability and financial management approaches and
tools are outlined in Chapter 4. In addition, involvement of the private sector
can help not only in leveraging financial resources but also in achieving
service excellence. The merits of involving the private sector to achieve 24X7
Drink from Tap water supply along with learnings from engaging with the
private sector in urban water sector are presented in Chapter 8.
5
Chapter 1:
Part C – Management Introduction
6
Chapter 1:
Part C – Management Introduction
Global experience has demonstrated that the following approaches have helped
ensure effective management of urban water service providers/utilities by providing a
supportive context for working towards service excellence, equity and sustainability.
1. Leadership and innovation: Leadership is critical to effective organisational
management, particularly in the context of leading and inspiring change within
an organization and its surrounding community. The term “Leadership”, in this
context, refers both to individuals who can be effective champions for
improvement, and to teams that provide resilient, day-to-day management
continuity and direction. Leaders have an important responsibility to engage
proactively with all stakeholders, to promote the organisation as a valued,
competent, and trustworthy community asset, and to collaborate with external
partners. Leaders must ensure that there are enough opportunities to
incorporate both technical and managerial innovations. The experience from
Odisha where the Secretary, Housing and Urban Development Department
This section is adapted from “Effective Utility Management: A Primer for Water and Wastewater Utilities, August 2017
7
available at https://www.epa.gov/sustainable-water-infrastructure/effective-water-utility-management-practices
7
Chapter 1:
Part C – Management Introduction
8
Chapter 1:
Part C – Management Introduction
Source: V. Lakshmipathy, V. Bhaskar, D. Ravindra Prasad, J. C. Mohanty, “Organisational Re-structuring for capacity
8
development – A case study of Hyderabad Metropolitan Water Supply and Sewerage Board (HMWSSB), India.
9
Chapter 1:
Part C – Management Introduction
Water Supply and Sewerage Board (HMWSSB) which included the following
elements:
Managing
Director
Executive
Director
Chief General
Manager
Empowerment of first level manager –
reduced lead time for decision making
General
Manager Greater diversification of top-level
management – functional specialization
Deputy General
leading to professionalisation and on-line
Manager control of operations and maintenance,
personnel and revenue management
Manager, Water
Supply and Sanitation
(O&M)
9
Source: https://www.hyderabadwater.gov.in/en/index.php/about/profile-us
10
Chapter 1:
Part C – Management Introduction
emulate. Since 1993 with a long series of transformations that started within
PPWSA’s top management, based on a culture of change and donor support, led to
a significant turnaround. Over two decades, PPWSA went through major changes
that resulted in the water utility transforming into a successful water service provider
in the region.
Political support for the reform process came with the country’s Prime Minister giving
full support. The top management was restructured, and dynamic younger personnel
with higher and more suitable qualifications were promoted to senior posts with
additional responsibilities. The water authority was granted autonomous status with
independent management. The factors that contributed to this turnaround included
investing in staff and providing incentives, promoting transparency, involving civil
society, and investing in modern management procedures and technology.
Other improvements included establishing a consumer database, reducing NRW to
less than 6%, improving collections, metering all of the utility’s water supply
coverage, and introducing 24x7 water supply. Operations were also made more
efficient by overhauling old infrastructure and streamlining the billing process.
Because of these reforms, the PPWSA has widened its distribution network from
serving 40% of the population in 1993 to universal coverage with clean, affordable
water.
The poor living in slums were allowed to pay in instalments within 10 to 20 months
during which interest is charged. There is a 30% subsidy for the poor which was
cross-subsidized. The strategy of cost recovery was also successful in reinforcing
autonomy. The successful implementation of the strategy led to less reliance on the
government than anticipated on tariff increases. This reduced the price obstacles for
the poor to manageable proportions.
Lessons learnt:
The PPWSA has shown that it is possible for reforms to become successful if
the governance framework is supportive and public utilities can make profits
or at least break-even, with affordable tariffs and timely supply of water. It
needs to be recognized that the reform does not happen overnight, the
changes in institutional arrangements and management practices took over
two decades.
The success of PPWSA is a result of several factors including a General
Director with vision and leadership to push through a culture of change, a
desire for change at the local political stakeholder level, sufficient autonomy to
be able to implement reforms as well as donor backing and shared objectives
between line ministries, employees and donors.
This case illustrates that a public sector utility can implement a management
approach more akin to that of a private sector company based on results and
incentives.
Risks which were identified during the transformation included the financial
viability of PPWSA, the security situation within the country, and government’s
11
Chapter 1:
Part C – Management Introduction
inability to carry out reforms. The ability to mitigate these risks based on the
factors changes on different aspects such as annual reviews of tariffs,
programme to finance the cost of connections for the poor and allowing for
flexibility in policy formulation and institutional proposal proved successful.
S. Parameter Yes No
No
1 Are the water services being provided in line with the GoIs
Service Level Benchmarks
2 Does the water quality adhere to the IS 10500:2012; Second
Amendment
3 Are organisational development (OD) approaches being
integrated to create an open, diverse, inclusive and equitable
work environment
4 Are regular and periodic opportunities provided to staff for
professional development and career enhancement (including
training, capacity building, exposure visits, etc.)
5 Are sessions held to sensitize staff on softer aspects such as
customer orientation, social equity, stakeholder engagement, etc
6 Is there an effective balance between long-term debt, asset
values, Operation and Maintenance (O&M) expenditures, and
operating revenues
7 Are the existing tariffs adequate to recover O&M costs?
Is there a plan to introduce volumetric tariff and metering to
sustain O&M costs in the short to medium term?
8 Is the organisation undertaking an annual financial planning
exercise
9 Has the organisation mapped all key stakeholders
10 Does the organisation actively engage with all stakeholders in
order to understand their needs and to consult/apprise them
regarding decisions that may impact them
11 Has the organisation launched a communication campaign to
educate the consumers on water conservation and other issues
12 Is there an up-to-date database on the condition of and costs
associated with critical infrastructure assets
12
Chapter 1:
Part C – Management Introduction
13