The Case For Torture Thesis

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

Writing a thesis is a challenging task that requires dedication, time, and a deep understanding of the

subject matter. One of the most difficult aspects of writing a thesis is formulating a strong and
compelling thesis statement. This statement serves as the central argument of the paper and guides
the direction of the research and analysis.

When it comes to a controversial topic like the case for torture, the difficulty of crafting a thesis is
compounded by the ethical and moral implications involved. This topic requires careful consideration
of various perspectives, empirical evidence, and ethical principles.

Moreover, researching and gathering relevant data to support the thesis can be a daunting task. It
often involves sifting through numerous academic sources, conducting interviews, and analyzing
complex information.

In addition to the research aspect, organizing and structuring the thesis in a coherent and logical
manner poses its own set of challenges. A well-written thesis requires a clear and concise argument
supported by evidence, analysis, and critical thinking.

Given the complexity of writing a thesis on such a contentious topic, it can be beneficial to seek
assistance from professional writing services like ⇒ HelpWriting.net ⇔. These services offer
expert guidance and support to students facing challenges in their academic writing endeavors.

⇒ HelpWriting.net ⇔ provides customized assistance tailored to the specific needs of each client.
Their team of experienced writers and researchers can help you craft a well-researched and articulate
thesis on the case for torture or any other topic.

By entrusting your thesis to ⇒ HelpWriting.net ⇔, you can save time and alleviate the stress
associated with the writing process. Their commitment to quality and customer satisfaction ensures
that you will receive a high-quality thesis that meets your academic requirements.

In conclusion, writing a thesis on the case for torture is a complex and challenging task. For those in
need of assistance, ⇒ HelpWriting.net ⇔ offers a reliable solution to help you achieve academic
success.
In earlier times, methods such as exiling criminals out of their land or direct forms of punishment
such as hanging, burning, and mutilations were performed. Levin starts the article speaking of torture
ONLY for the saving of innocent lives, but now, he speaks of torture for preserving order. This is
even when they have no connection to the case, apart from having to be a witness to a relevant
event. Barrow Motor Ability Test - TEST, MEASUREMENT AND EVALUATION IN PHYSICAL
EDUC. However, it does not remove torture from the national security context, essay on torture.
Case Study: Torture in the Algerian War (1954-1962). Iraqis can be seen as proportional to the
atrocious acts committed by Bin Laden and his followers. In effect, the use of torture serves to
transform an individual into the enemy. Only minor elements of his reasoning are sound and
effective. His second point explains the reason for the need of torture. At the same time, tortures that
prisoners reportedly underwent are shocking. In the article, Levin says “I am advocating torture as
an acceptable measure for preventing future evils. ”(201). He does a good job of making it clear
exactly what he means. Lee, Roger and Smith, David M. (2004). Geographies and moralities:
international perspectives on justice, development. We will write a custom Essay on The Science of
Torture: Does It Work. Operations management is in regard to all operations within the organization
responsible for creating goods and services that organizations pass to their customers. Democratic
countries such the United States of America which are said to uphold human rights are in fact
culprits of condoning torture. There is no evidence that torture leads to better outcome in criminal
investigations or prisoner’s long-term behavior. It is as though in his eyes, he thinks finding the right
perpetrator is a very simple task. Levin makes it clear to the audience that he does not agree with
torture as a punishment and focuses on exactly what it should be used for. Ideology is the body of
ideas and beliefs of a group, possibly. The release of the report coincided with the International Day
for Victims of Torture on June 26. Sometimes it essay on torture them at risk of reprisal by a party to
the proceeding. The statement clearly mentions that no one can be subjected to torture, or to cruel
and unjust punishment (Orend, 107). References 1. Arrigo, Jean Maria. “A utilitarian argument
against torture interrogation of terrorists”. GET WRITING HELP. Cite This paper. Copy to
Clipboard Copied. Prisoner torture should not be acceptable in any rational and civilized society. As
part of the threat assessment approach, people can be subjected to torture, not because of criminal
acts that they have performed or are planning to perpetrate. Torture, Aussaresses said, was sanctioned
at the highest level because of the need to extract urgent information from. It should be restored
back to its correct and magnificent place,” he said. However, the process of finding truth should not
be cruel or inhuman.
Another central economic factor related to the utility of state torture is the distribution of wealth
within the country. If the ideology of the tortured is believed to be morally wrong and the act of.
Paul Aussaresses, a retired French general is quoted as saying “as far as the use of torture is
concerned, it was tolerated. Use of physical torture can definitely harm someone’s physical well
being. His report failed to unequivocally condemn the torture that he discovered. Thus, the question:
Would it be moral to inflict pain on this beast to force him to reveal what he knows. The utilitarian-
expediency argument is that one has to be kept in prison for a long time in order to achieve the
desired punitive and deterrent goals of the state, essay on torture. It can be questioned, what right
did Aussaresses and his. However, as they hold political or religious beliefs that are deemed
dangerous to the state, they cannot deliver the stated goals within the stipulated time framework
Rejali In addition, any possible threat to the state enables the authority to create a purpose and a
justification for the implementation of a torture policy. At the same time, tortures that prisoners
reportedly underwent are shocking. The first problem with Levin's argument is that he attempts to
justify torture only in certain situations, but because these scenarios are improbable and unrealistic,
he will not be able to justify torture as morally mandatory at all. If the military starts torturing
prisoners, the next step would be to torture American defendants. According to Butler, in human
rights ethics, “a right not to be tortured is a prima facie universal right.” Torturing, according to
Butler, is wrong as it compels someone to say something which he or she does not wish to say.
Whether or not this torture can be considered justified in the light of his comments depends. It is
unfortunate that there are rooms for torture even in democratic, free country like USA under
terrorism. Please spread the word and tell your friends how this information has helped you with
your. His second point explains the reason for the need of torture. Deontologists hold that one
cannot undertake immoral acts like torture. This industry is directly dependent on the economical
scenario. People would insist that such practices disregard the rights of the individual. It should not
come as a surprise that human rights are among the first casualties in the War on Terrorism. 1 Yet
recent policy proposals in the fight against terrorism are threatening to take human rights violations
to a level until recently unimaginable. The way he worded that may seem a bit too aggressive for a
general audience. Maureen Ramsay, is described as act by which severe pain or suffering whether
physical or mental, is intentionally inflicted on a person for such purposes as obtaining from him or a
third party information or confession, punishing him for an Torture Film Analysis Movie Review. On
the contrary, torture leads a permanent memory of resent that may affect harmfully personal life of
prisoner’s in myriad ways. Arrigo examined the point from criminology, organizational theory, social
psychology, and interviews with military personnel. In Camp Bucca during the period August 2003
to February 2004 the following acts. Providing examples of where torture is justified, the author
speaks of scenarios such as an atomic bomb hidden by a terrorist in Manhattan Island. Badiou, Alain.
(2001). Ethics: an essay on the understanding of evil, London: Verso. The word torture often conjures
up images of medieval torture instruments such a branding irons and head screws. To browse
Academia.edu and the wider internet faster and more securely, please take a few seconds to upgrade
your browser.
However, torture should not be mistreatment for punitive reasons and the suspect should have the
relevant information. It is assumed that this coerced evidence is truthful Barnet et al. The case is one
in which a newborn baby is kidnapped from a hospital. This is 100% legal. You may not submit
downloaded papers as your own, that is cheating. Also you. Iraqis can be seen as proportional to the
atrocious acts committed by Bin Laden and his followers. Purdue University Press, 2008. 4. Clark,
Ann Marie. Diplomacy of conscience: Amnesty International and changing human rights norms.
Princeton University Press, 2001. 5. Karl, Jonathan. “Former CIA Directors: Holder's Investigation
Could 'Help al Qaeda'. Its weakness is clearly seen in the number of participants in the poll that he is
using and in the biased opinion they most likely already had. Certificate in Gender, Divinity School
at Duke University, 2008. 3. Butler, Clark. Human rights ethics: a rational approach. It often casts
the author or characters in a story as an Everyman, easy to identify, and therefore see eye to eye,
with. The confessions results were only 3-9 percent for Paris, 8-9 percent for Brittany, 10-13 percent
for Roussillon, and 14.2 percent for Toulouse. Human right is granted to every human being, man or
woman, rich or poor, adult or child, healthy or sick, educated or not, and in the case under study,
prisoner, whether proved guilty or not (Orend, 16). Any investigator is supposed to follow ethical
means while pursuing investigation. Just War Theory can be used to justify torture on the grounds
that it is acceptable. John Stuart Mill (1808-73) put forward an ethical theory known as
utilitarianism. Theories that conclude that torture is never acceptable will be examined first. In
addition, as will be seen, there are numerous, conflicting ethical theories that can be applied to the
topic of torture. There are major international conventions which prohibits both torture and terrorism.
If you need custom essay help, then check out our essay writing service. There is no evidence that
torture leads to better outcome in criminal investigations or prisoner’s long-term behavior. It might
be a superior deterrent to crime than dumping them into the animal cages that are too many of
American prisons, where young offenders face sexual abuse and are exposed to the daily example of
how incorrigible criminals succeed and fail. Broadview Press, 2002. 8. Rejali, Darius. Torture and
Democracy. On the contrary, torture leads a permanent memory of resent that may affect harmfully
personal life of prisoner’s in myriad ways. The main part of the study analyses ethical theories in
relation to torture and uses these. Most of the reasoning he gives is heavily based on pathetic
appeals. This industry is directly dependent on the economical scenario. I have compiled this list
below to include all the most commo. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.
Lovell, Alan and Fisher, Colin. (2002). Business Ethics and Values, London: FT Prentice Hall. I feel
this argument does not give a great example of what makes torture acceptable. This paper argues for
the unconditional refutation of any attempt to justify torture, without exceptions.
Similar scenario is drawn about a bomb on a jet with hundreds of passenger’s lives at stake and
unless information about the bomb is made available, the bomb will explode and kill thousands.
According to CIA Kubark Counterintelligence Manual “Intense pain is likely to produce false
confessions, concocted as a means of escaping from distress.” (Rejali, 462) Empirical records show
the futility of torture to get any meaningful lead. In this circumstance, the political or ruling elite are
much more susceptible to violent attacks from the terrorists. It is often stressful and nearly always
time consuming. However, torture should not be mistreatment for punitive reasons and the suspect
should have the relevant information. According to the commission almost all of the victims were
randomly targeted by the police to be detained on fabricated charges. Perhaps, those who are
especially concerned about harmful effects of torture need to look things from such multidisciplinary
angles while raising awareness against it. Despite the fact that over the years, the field of
investigation has branched into many specialized parts, the basic rules of good investigations and
desired qualities of good investigators are universal for all categories of investigations. There is
always the fear that an indoctrinated terrorist will continue to tell lies even under torture.Another
very serious point is as to who will decide when torture is justified and if there is any graded
procedure that can be used. The article starts off with a very brief description of how he believes
society views the subject of torture as a negative thing. In my opinion, they are clearly work more as
an emotional example and not a sound reason. The state determines the legitimate targets of torture
essay on torture successfully applying negative labels essay on torture certain groups or individuals.
The commission’s Sri Lankan director, Basil Fernando, says the police seem to be operating with
impunity, which could have far-reaching consequences. This transformation is perhaps the most vital
aspect for torture. Unlocking the Power of ChatGPT and AI in Testing - A Real-World Look, present.
It then examines the history of torture and looks at international law that relates to torture. Science
and Engineering Ethics, 10.3, 543-72 2. Baars, Mel. Confession and Lament in Nahum 3: Journeys
of Healing after War. The holy book even goes forward to suggest that prisoners could be “set free as
a favour” (Scheifers, 31). Consequentialism is an ethical view that establishes the rightness or
wrongness of actions by the good or bad produced. This paper argues for the unconditional
refutation of any attempt to justify torture, without exceptions. It is not acceptable that any country
contradicts bold claims that it makes for standing in favor of human rights because of immediate
threats. I have compiled this list below to include all the most commo. I believe this justification was
simply used to ensure the public accepted the practise of. For criminal investigators dealing with
cases such as homicide or terrorism plot, properly interacting with witnesses and suspects is essential
to unearth the truth. The state may have to spend more resource on rehabilitation and post-
jurisdiction outcome: the other way, which is morally sound and legal, is never to permit torture to
prisoners. It also notes that torture has a purpose, and does not allow. Using deontological theory,
whereby actions are intrinsically right or wrong, torture can be seen to be unacceptable. In addition
to economic factors, the political organization of the state plays a crucial role in the utility of state
torture. To browse Academia.edu and the wider internet faster and more securely, please take a few
seconds to upgrade your browser. Joly, Daniele. (1991). The French Communist Party and the
Algerian War.
Gray, John, Benvenisti, Meron and Ehrenreich, Barbara. (2005). Abu Ghraib: The Politics of Torture,
New York: North. Top 10 Similar Topics Bullying Gun Essays on torture Animal Testing
Controversial Issue Cyber Bullying Sexual Abuse Violence against Women Violence in Video Games
Crash Deviant Behavior. Got it. Haven't found the right essay. Used in this context, torture has a
number of prominent Torture, can be described as a situation where an individual is subjected to
suffering or pain, this can either be physically or mentally inflicted. Strategic Planning and
Performance Measurement for Wounded Warrior Project Differences and Similarities between
Hamas and Hezbollah. If police officers and investigating officers decide that they feel torture is
justified then it will introduce a whole regime of arrests on suspicion, torture that can lead to
disabilities or deaths. A former top adviser to President Bush in Iraq, Robert Blackwill, who was a
national security adviser during Bush’s first term, once said that torture should never be totally ruled
out. Pojman, Louis. (1998). Deontological Ethics, Moral Philosophy, Indianapolis: Hackett
Publishing Company. We argue against the consequentialist reasoning of the ticking-bomb argument
not from a deontological position, but on consequentialist grounds. Levin effectively advances his
argument primarily by presenting a number of hypothetical cases, designed to force the skeptical
reader to question whether his opposition to torture is truly absolute. If you are using this resource in
your work please remember to reference and cite the original work found here. The reform process
may occasionally face wrath of security heads. Preventing torture: a study of the European
Convention for the Prevention. Similar scenario is drawn about a bomb on a jet with hundreds of
passenger’s lives at stake and unless information about the bomb is made available, the bomb will
explode and kill thousands. Torture has been a tool of coercion for nearly all of human history,
whether to instill fear in a population or force people to convert, but almost all contemporary
attempts to justify the use of torture revolve around torture as a means of extracting information
from a victim. The way he worded that may seem a bit too aggressive for a general audience. Levin
assumes that the suspect KNOWS they are going against civilized standards. Get the reader’s
attention with a “hook” or grabbe. Interrogating subjects like juvenile require special sensitivity. Just
War Theory can be used to justify torture on the grounds that it is acceptable. He claims to have
stopped Algerian bomb makers from killing French civilians. Citing names of rivals under torture
during civil wars are quite common. The purpose of any criminal investigation is to unearth the truth
behind crime. An investigation to uncover misuse of information by a chief executive of a company
to buy shares (insider trading) is quite different from a case of suicide or homicide. Using
deontological theory, whereby actions are intrinsically right or wrong, torture can be seen to be
unacceptable. Sources and citation are provided. 5. Torture and the \, time: 2:59. Driving your car to
a dinner with friends you go by hundreds of advertisement. Morgan, Rod and Evans, Malcolm.
(1999). Protecting prisoners: the standards of the European Committee for the. There are major
international conventions which prohibits both torture and terrorism. Only minor elements of his
reasoning are sound and effective. Edmund Burke, the late eighteenth century writer and politician,
accused the British of suffering from what he termed.

You might also like