Family Law YAL

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 70

FAMILY LAW

INDEX

Chapter Particulars Page no.


No.
Part I
1. Introduction 2-5
2. Matrimonial Causes 6-22
3. Divorce under Muslim Law/ Islamic Law 23-31
4. Court System 32
5. Jurisdiction 33-35
6. Child Custody 36-42
7. Domicile 43-48
8. Alimony/Maintenance 49-54
Part II
9. Procedure 55
10. Types of Divorce 56
11. Contents and Verification 67-62
12. Documents to be annexed to the Petition 63
13. Affidavits 64-66
14. Stages involved in Divorce by Mutual Consent 67
15. Stages involved in Contested Divorce 68-69
16. Disclaimer 70

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner
FAMILY LAW – MARRIAGE, DIVORCE AND GUARDIANSHIP IN INDIA:
OVERVIEW.

PART- I

1. INTRODUCTION

With the 42nd Amendment of the Constitution of India enacted in

1976, the Preamble to the Constitution asserted that India is a secular

nation. Thus, wide number of religions is freely practised in India. Unlike

Western notions of secularism, India's secularism does not separate

religion and state. Major religions practised in India include Hinduism,

Islam and Christianity who have their own separate family laws. Other

religions like Parsi and Jews, whose number, in the context of the

population of India, is insignificant, too have their own separate family

laws. India does partially separate religion and state. For example, it does

not have an official state religion and state-owned educational institutions

cannot impart religious instructions. In matters of law in modern India,

however, the applicable code of law is unequal, and India's personal laws

– on matters such as marriage, divorce, inheritance, alimony – varies with

an individual's religion. Therefore, the matrimonial laws in India,

including laws on marriage, divorce and other connected issues, are

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 2 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
essentially governed by the personal laws of the parties depending on

their religion:

 Hindu: Hindu Marriage Act 1955.

 Muslim: Muslim marriage is a contract under Muslim law.

 Christian: Indian Christian Marriage Act 1872 and the Divorce


Act 1869.

 Parsi: Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act 1936.

Under the Constitution of India all aspects of personal law are in the

concurrent list (entry 5). Both Parliament and the state legislatures have

power to legislate in respect of them. Apart from legislation relating to

Muslim wakfs and Hindu endowments, state legislatures have not

exercised this power to any appreciable extent. The entire codified Hindu

law has been enacted by the Union Parliament, though some state

legislature have made some modifications; for instance, the Uttar Pradesh

enactment, the Hindu Marriage (the Uttar Pradesh Sanshodhan)

Adhinyam, 1962 has made, inter alia, cruelty a ground of divorce. This

may be deemed to be superseded by the Marriage Laws (Amendment)

Act 1976, which made cruelty a ground of divorce. The Shariat Act, 1937

and the Dissolution of Muslim Marriage Act, 1939; were passed by

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 3 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
central legislature. So were the Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act, 1936;

the Christian Marriage Act, 1872 and the Indian Divorce Act, 1869 and

several Hindu personal law reform enactments before independence.

Indian communities which have their separate family law are generally

religious communities; however, their law is not necessarily religious

law. Most importantly the members or individual member need not be an

ardent believer or follower of that faith. In most cases, being a member of

the community by birth or conversion, will suffice, though in actual

persuasion he may be atheistic or non-religious or even anti-religious;

and though he may even decry the religion so long as he does not leave it

(mere renunciation of faith may not be sufficient) he will continue to be

governed by that law. Community cannot expel the said person since ex-

communication or outcasting is unconstitutional.

In addition to the personal laws, in India we have another aspect of

family law viz. The Special Marriage Act 1954. The Parliament of

India enacted the said Act to provide a special form of marriage for the

people of India and all Indian nationals in foreign countries, irrespective

of the religion or faith followed by either party. Individuals opting to

marry under the said Act would then cease to be governed by any

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 4 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
personal laws and would squarely be governed by the Special Marriage

Act 1954.

All these laws apply throughout India (except for in Jammu and Kashmir,

and Goa).

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 5 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
2. Matrimonial Causes

i. Initially, the old Hindu law did not provide for settlement of matrimonial

causes and divorce was not recognised by the Muslim law from very

early days, but then it has always been the private affair of the parties,

and in the sense in which we use the term in modern law, it could hardly

come within the ambit of matrimonial causes.

ii. In a limited sense judicial divorce was first introduced in India under the

Converts' Marriage Dissolution Act, 1866. This was followed by the

Indian Divorce Act, 1869, which introduced all the four matrimonial

causes known to English law viz.

Matrimonial Causes

Divorce Judicial Separation Restitution of conjugal Nullity of


rights. marriage

iii. Initially, the said Act was made applicable only to Christians.

Subsequently, it was made applicable to persons who performed their

marriage under the Special Marriage Act, 1872.

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 6 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
iv. The Special Marriage Act, 1954 introduced civil marriages and

matrimonial causes. The Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 made matrimonial

causes available to Hindus. The Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act made

them available to Parsis.

v. The Indian Divorce Act, the Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act, the Special

Marriage Act and the Hindu Marriage Act recognize all the four

matrimonial causes, viz., Divorce, Judicial separation, and Restitution of

conjugal rights and Nullity of marriage.

2.1. Nullity of Marriage:

Section 11 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, deals with Nullity of

Marriage and divorce. A marriage may be annulled on the

grounds:

 that it has not been consummated owing to the impotence of

the respondent;

 that the respondent was incapable of giving valid consent to

it in consequence of unsoundness of mind, or though


Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate
Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 7 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
capable of giving valid consent was suffering from mental

disorder of such a kind or to such an extent as to be unfit for

marriage and procreation of children, or was subject to

recurrent attacks of insanity;

 that the respondent was at the time of the marriage pregnant

by some person other than the petitioner . (In this case, it is

necessary that the marital intercourse with the consent of

the petitioner did not take place since the discovery of the

ground by the petitioner and the petition was presented

within one year of the marriage),

 that the consent of the petitioner or of the guardian, as the

case may be, was obtained by fraud or force, provided that

the petitioner did not live with his or her full consent with

the respondent after the discovery of fraud or cessation of

force and the petition was presented within one year of the

discovery of fraud or cessation of force.

2.2. Restitution of conjugal rights

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 8 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
 The provision relating to restitution of conjugal rights has

been enacted in section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act. The

said Section lays down that a petition for restitution may be

made on the ground that the respondent has without

reasonable excuse withdrawn from his or her society and

the court may pronounce the decree for restitution 'on being

satisfied of the truth of the statements made in such petition

and that there is no legal ground why the application should

not be granted'.

 The provision of restitution of conjugal rights in section 22

of the Special Marriage Act, 1954, is substantially the same

as found in Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.

Likewise, is the provision for Restitution of conjugal rights

viz. section 36 of the Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act, 1936

though it has been worded slightly differently.

2.3. Judicial Separation

 The statutory law of Hindus, Parsis and Christians

recognizes the matrimonial relief of judicial separation. It is


Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate
Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 9 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
also recognized by the Special Marriage Act, 1954 as well.

Muslim law does not recognize anything like it. Probably in

the case of non-Hindus and non-Muslims, the High Courts

have inherent jurisdiction to provide the relief.

 The grounds on which judicial separation may be granted

differ widely from statute to statute.

 Under the Indian Divorce Act either party may obtain a

decree of judicial separation on the ground of 'adultery or

cruelty or desertion without reasonable excuse for two years

or upwards.

 The grounds of judicial separation under the Hindu

Marriage Act are more elaborate and comprehensive.

Section 10 of the Hindu Marriage Act lays down six

grounds:

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 10 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
JUDICIAL SEPARATION

Continous Desertion for 2 Cruelty


years

Venereal Disease in an
Viralent Leprosy of atleast 1 communicable form of atleast
years duration 3 years duration

Having sexual intercourse with


any person other than his/her
Continous Insanity for 2 years spouse

2.4. 1. Divorce (Section 13 of Hindu Marriage Act, 1955):

 Divorce means putting an end to the marriage by dissolution of

marital relations. The parties can no longer be husband and

wife.

2.4.1.1. Section 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 recognises 9

nine grounds of divorce. On petition presented by either the

husband or the wife, the marriage be dissolved by a decree of

Divorce on the grounds that the other party:

i. is living in adultery;

ii. has ceased to be a Hindu by conversion to another

religion;
Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate
Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 11 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
iii. has been incurably of unsound mind for a continuous

period of not less than three years immediately

preceding the presentation of the petition;

iv. has, for a period of not less than three years immediately

preceding the presentation of the petition, been suffering

from a virulent and incurable form of leprosy;

v. had, for a period of not less than three years immediately

preceding the presentation of the petition, been suffering

from venereal disease in a communicable form;

vi. has renounced the world by entering any religious order;

vii. has not been heard of as being alive for a period of seven

years or more by those persons who would naturally

have heard of them, had that party been alive;

viii. has not resumed cohabitation for a period of two years or

more after the passing of a decree for judicial separation

against that party; or

ix. has failed to comply with a decree for restitution of

conjugal rights for a period of two years or more after

the passing of the decree.

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 12 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
2.4.1.2. Adultery - Besides being available as a ground for

divorce, adultery was once punishable as a criminal offence

(section 497, Indian Penal Code. However, it was only the

male illicit lover who was punishable for the offence of

adultery. The woman, who is pari delicto (at equal fault)

with the adulterous male, was not liable to any punishment,

even as an "abettor". However, the said position was

changed vide judgment passed by A five-Judge bench of the

Hon‟ble Apex Court in the matter of Joseph Shine v UOI

(2019) 3 SCC 39, vide which Section 497 of the IPC was

struck off being of the view that the same violates Articles

14, 15 and 21 of the Constitution.

2.4.1.3. Section 2 of the Dissolution of Muslim Marriages Act

1939 provides that, a woman married under Muslim law

shall be entitled to obtain a decree for the dissolution of her

marriage on any one or more of the following ground

namely:

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 13 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
i. that the whereabouts of the husband have not been

known for a period of four years;

ii. that the husband has neglected or has failed to provide

for her maintenance for a period of two years. However,

a decree passed on this groundshall not take effect for a

period of six months from the date of such decree, and if

the husband appears either in person or through an

authorised agent within that period and satisfies the

Court that he is prepared to perform his conjugal duties,

the Court shall set aside the said decree;

iii. that the husband has been sentenced to imprisonment for

a period of seven years or upwards. However, no decree

shall be passed on ground until the sentence has become

final;

iv. that the husband has failed to perform, without

reasonable cause, his marital obligations for a period of

three years;

v. that the husband was impotent at the time of the

marriage and continues to be so. However, before

passing a decree on this ground the Court shall, on


Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate
Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 14 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
application by the husband, pass an order requiring the

husband to satisfy the Court within a period of one year

from the date of such order that he has ceased to be

impotent, and if the husband so satisfies the Court within

such period, no decree shall be passed on the said

ground;

vi. that the husband has been insane for a period of two

years or is suffering from leprosy or a virulent venereal

disease;

vii. that she, having been given in marriage by her father or

other guardian before she attained the age of fifteen

years, repudiated the marriage before attaining the age of

eighteen years: Provided that the marriage has not been

consummated;

viii. that the husband treats her with cruelty, that is to say,

a. habitually assaults her or makes her life miserable

by cruelty of conduct even if such conduct does not

amount to physical ill-treatment, or

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 15 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
b. associates with women of evil repute or leads an

infamous life, or

c. attempts to force her to lead an immoral life, or

d. disposes of her property or prevents her exercising

her legal rights over it, or

e. obstructs her in the observance of her religious

profession or practice, or

f. if he has more wives than one, does not treat her

equitably in accordance with the injunctions of the

Qoran;

g. on any other ground which is recognised as valid

for the dissolution of marriages under Muslim law:

2.4.1.4. For Christians, sub section 10 of the Indian Divorce Act

1869 contains grounds of divorce.

i. Adultery;

ii. Party ceases to be Christian;

iii. If a party has been suffering from leprosy or a

venereal disease for two years;

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 16 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
iv. In case of a party wilfully refusing to consummate the

marriage;

v. When a party has deserted the spouse for two years or

more;

vi. In case of a party treating the spouse with cruelty.

2.4.1.5. Section 32 of the Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act 1936

states that Any married person may sue for divorce on any

one or more of the following grounds, namely:-

i. that the marriage has not been consummated within one

year after its solemnization owing to the wilful refusal of

the defendant to consummate it;

ii. that the defendant at the time of the marriage was of

unsound mind and has been habitually so up to the date

of the suit:

Provided that divorce shall not be granted on this

ground, unless the plaintiff was ignorant of the fact at the

time of the marriage, and has filed the suit within three

years form the date of the marriage;

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 17 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
iii. that the defendant was at the time of marriage pregnant

by some person other than the plaintiff:

Provided that divorce shall not be granted on this

ground, unless the plaintiff was at the time of the

marriage ignorant of the fact alleged, the suit has been

filed within two years of the date of marriage, and

marital intercourse has not taken place after the plaintiff

came to know of the fact;

iv. that the defendant has since the marriage committed

adultery or fornication or bigamy or rape or an unnatural

offence:

Provided that divorce shall not be granted on this

ground, if the suit has been filed more than two years

after the plaintiff came to know of the fact;

v. that the defendant has since the solemnization of the

marriage treated the plaintiff with cruelty or has behaved

in such a way as to render it in the judgment of the Court

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 18 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
improper to compel the plaintiff to live with the

defendant:

Provided that in every suit for divorce on this ground it

shall be the discretion of the Court whether it should

grant a decree for divorce or for judicial separation only;

vi. that the defendant has since the marriage voluntarily

caused grievous hurt to the plaintiff or has infected the

plaintiff with venereal disease or, where the defendant is

the husband, has compelled the wife to submit herself to

prostitution;

Provided that divorce shall not be granted on this

ground, if the suit has been filed more than two years

after the infliction of the grievous hurt, or after the

plaintiff came to know of the infection, or after the last

act of compulsory prostitution.

vii. that the defendant is undergoing a sentence of

imprisonment for seven years or more for an offence as

defined in the Indian Penal Code:


Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate
Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 19 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
Provided that divorce shall not be granted on this

ground, unless the defendant has prior to the filing of the

suit undergone at least one year‟s imprisonment out of

the said period;

viii. that the defendant has deserted the plaintiff for at least

2[two years;

ix. that an order has been passed against the defendant by a

Magistrate awarding separate maintenance to the

plaintiff, and the parties have not had Marital intercourse

for one year or more since such decree or order;

x. that the defendant has ceased to be a Parsi;

Provided that divorce shall not be granted on this ground

if the suit has been filed more than two years after the

plaintiff came to know of the fact.

2.4.1.6. Section 27(1) of the Special Marriage Act 1954 contains

eight fault grounds of divorce on which either spouse can

seek divorce. Section 27(1A) contains two fault grounds on

which the wife alone can seek of marriage.

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 20 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
i. Adultery
ii. Two years desertion
iii. Respondent undergoing a sentence of imprisonment for

seven years or more for n offence under IPC, 1860

iv. Cruelty, unsound mind or has been suffering from

continuously or intermittently from mental disorder of

such a kind and to such an extent that the petitioner

cannot reasonably be expected to live with the

respondent;

v. Venereal diseases in a communicable form

vi. Leprosy

vii. Incurable insanity or continuous or intermittent mental

disorder, and

viii. Presumption of death

Section 27 (1) (A) - A wife may also present a petition for


divorce to the district court on the ground:

ix. husband is guilty of rape, sodomy or bestiality;

x. Cohabitation has not been resumed for one year or more

after an order of maintenance has been passed under

section 125 of the Criminal Procedure Code.


Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate
Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 21 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
A marriage may be dissolved on the petition of either party viz.

husband/wife seeking Divorce when one of the parties arrives at

a conclusion that their marriage has hit the rock bottom and

there are no chances of reconciliation whatsoever.

2.4.2. Divorce By Mutual Consent (Section 13(B) of the Hindu


Marriage Act, 1955:

i. This Section was inserted under the Amendment Act of

1976. Divorce by Mutual Consent means both the parties

(husband and wife) agree to dissolve their marriage mutually.

In simple words, both wife and husband are willing to get

separated by divorce.

ii. The only requirement for divorce by mutual consent is that the

parties should be living separately for a period of one year or

more.

iii. The decree of divorce may be passed on the motion of both the

parties made no earlier than six months and not later than

eighteen months after the date of the presentation of the

petition, provided the court is satisfied particularly as to the

fact that consent has not been obtained by force, fraud or

undue influence.
Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate
Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 22 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
3. DIVORCE UNDER MUSLIM LAW/ISLAMIC LAW

Under Islamic law, divorce is classified into three categories:

i. Talaq. This is divorce at the instance of the husband.


ii. Khula. This is divorce at the instance of the wife.
iii. Mubaraat. This is divorce by mutual consent.

 Under Islamic law, only the husband can pronounce talak on

his wife, not vice versa. However, the husband can delegate

this power to the wife or any third person by an agreement.

This is known as divorce by delegation (talak-e-tafweez).

3.1. Divorce by the husband: There are three types of Talaq:

3.1.1. Talaq-e-ahsan. This is a single pronouncement

of talaq by the husband, followed by a period of

abstinence (iddat) for 90 days or three menstrual cycles

(where the wife is menstruating). Alternatively, the

period of iddat is of three lunar months (in case, the

wife is not menstruating). If the couple resumes

cohabitation or intimacy, within the period of iddat, the

pronouncement of divorce is treated as having been

revoked. Therefore, talaq-e-ahsan is revocable. Among

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 23 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
Muslims, talaq-e-ahsan is regarded as the most

"proper" form of divorce.

3.1.2. Talaq-e-hasan. This is pronounced in the same

manner as talaq-e-ahsan (see above). However,

instead of a single pronouncement there are three

successive pronouncements. After the first

pronouncement of divorce, if there is resumption of

cohabitation within a period of one month, the

pronouncement of divorce is treated as having been

revoked. The same procedure must be followed after

the expiry of the first month (during which marital

ties have not been resumed). Talaq is then

pronounced again: after the second pronouncement

of talaq, if there is resumption of cohabitation within

a period of one month, the pronouncement of divorce

is treated as having been revoked. Pertinently, the

first and the second pronouncements can only be

revoked by the husband. However, if a third talaq is

pronounced, it becomes irrevocable and the marriage

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 24 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
stands dissolved, after which the wife must observe

the required iddat (the period after divorce, during

which a woman cannot remarry: its purpose is to

ensure that the male parent of any offspring can be

clearly identified). After the third iddat, the husband

and wife cannot remarry, unless the wife first marries

someone else, and only after her marriage with

another person has been dissolved (either through

divorce or death), can the couple remarry.

The distinction between talaq-e-ashan and talaq-e-

hasan is that, in the former, there is a single

pronouncement of talaq followed by abstinence

during the period of iddat, whereas, in the latter there

are three pronouncements of talaq, interspersed with

abstinence.

3.1.3. Talaq-e-biddat. The third type of talaq is talaq-e-

biddat. This is effected by one definitive

pronouncement of talaq (such as, "I talaq you

irrevocably" or three simultaneous pronouncements,


Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate
Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 25 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
like "talaq, talaq, talaq", uttered at the same time,

simultaneously. In talaq-e-biddat, divorce is then

effective from this point onwards. Unlike the other

two categories of talaq, the instant talaq is

irrevocable the very moment it is pronounced.

The Supreme Court in a recent landmark decision by

five judges in the case of Shayara Bano vs Union of

India (2017) 9SCC 1 (with a majority of 3:2) held

that the act of divorce by a Muslim man by way of

uttering the words talak three times is

unconstitutional and illegal. It was held that triple

talaq "is not integral to religious practice and violates

constitutional morality".

3.2.Divorce by the wife- In 1937, the Muslim Personal Law (Sharait)

Application Act 1937 was passed. Section 5 of the Shariat Act

provided that a Muslim woman could seek dissolution of her

marriage on grounds recognised under the Muslim "personal law".

Section 5 of the Shariat Act was subsequently deleted, and

replaced by the Dissolution of Muslim Marriages Act 1939.


Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate
Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 26 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
The Supreme Court in the case of Shayara Bano vs. Union of

India (supra) considered the provisions of the Muslim Personal

Law, the practice of Talaq-e-Biddat or triple talaq and held that the

practice of triple talaq, that is, instant, irrevocable, unilateral

divorce by a husband as a formula for pronouncing divorce three

times as unconstitutional and cannot be permitted. In the majority

judgment, in para-104, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has crystallized

the law after detailed deliberations in the following manner:-

“Given the fact that Triple Talaq is instant and

irrevocable, it is obvious that any attempt at

reconciliation between the husband and wife by two

arbiters from their families, which is essential to save the

marital tie, cannot ever take place. Also, as understood

by the Privy Council in Rashid Ahmad (supra), such

Triple Talaq is valid even if it is not for any reasonable

cause, which view of the law no longer holds good after

Shamim Ara (supra). This being the case, it is clear that

this form of Talaq is manifestly arbitrary in the sense that

the marital tie can be broken capriciously and

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 27 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
whimsically by a Muslim man without any attempt at

reconciliation so as to save it. This form of Talaq must,

therefore, be held to be violative of the fundamental right

contained under Article 14 of the Constitution of India. In

our opinion, therefore, the 1937 Act, insofar as it seeks to

recognize and enforce Triple Talaq, is within the

meaning of the expression “laws in force” in Article

13(1) and must be struck down as being void to the extent

that it recognizes and enforces Triple Talaq. Since we

have declared Section 2 of the 1937 Act to be void to the

extent indicated above on the narrower ground of it being

manifestly arbitrary, we do not find the need to go into

the ground of discrimination in these cases, as was

argued by the learned Attorney General and those

supporting him.”

3.3.The Dissolution of Muslim Marriages Act 1939 sets out the

grounds on which a Muslim woman can seek dissolution of

marriage. Section 2 of the Act provides for grounds for decree for

dissolution of marriage, namely that the:

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 28 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
i. Whereabouts of the husband has not been known for a period

of four years. However, any decree passed based on this

ground cannot take effect until six months have passed since

making the decree, and if the husband appears (either in person

or through an authorised agent) within this period, and satisfies

the court that he is prepared to perform his conjugal duties, the

court will aside the decree.

ii. Husband has neglected or has failed to provide for her

maintenance for a period of two years.

iii. Husband has been sentenced to imprisonment for a period of

seven years or upwards. However, no decree can be passed

until the sentence has become final.

iv. Husband has failed to perform, without reasonable cause, his

marital obligations for a period of three years.

v. Husband was impotent at the time of the marriage and

continues to be so. However, before passing a decree on this

ground, the court will, on application by the husband, make an

order requiring the husband to satisfy the court within a period

of one year from the date of such order that he has ceased to be

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 29 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
impotent, and if the husband so satisfies the court within such

period, no decree will be passed based on this ground.

vi. Husband has been insane for a period of two years or is

suffering from leprosy or virulent venereal disease.

vii. Wife, having been given in marriage by her father or other

guardian before she attained the age of 15 years, repudiated the

marriage before attaining the age of 18 years.

viii. Marriage has not been consummated.

ix. Husband treats the wife with cruelty, for example, the

husband:

a. habitually assaults her or makes her life miserable by

cruelty of conduct even if such conduct does not

amount to physical ill-treatment;

b. associates with women of evil repute or leads an

infamous life;

c. attempts to force her to lead an immoral life;

d. disposes of her property or prevents her exercising her

legal rights over it;

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 30 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
e. obstructs her in the observance of her religious

profession or practice;

f. if he has more wives than one, does not treat her

equitably in accordance with the injunctions of the

Quran; or

g. carries out any other ground recognised as valid for the

dissolution of marriages under Muslim law:

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 31 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
4. COURT SYSTEM

The Family Court Act 1984 provides for the establishment of Family

Courts with a view to promote conciliation, and secure speedy settlement

of disputes relating to marriage and family affairs, and for matters

connected with them. The Family Courts hear matters relating to

marriage, marital breakdown and the welfare of children. These courts

are trial courts and are presided over by Additional District Judges which

undertake trials and review evidence. The Family Courts follow the Civil

Procedure Code.

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 32 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
5. JURISDICTION

5.1.All Indian matrimonial statutes contain jurisdictional rules. Two

matters are relevant regarding jurisdiction:

i. The place in which the petition or suit in a matrimonial

cause is filed.

ii. The court in which the petition or suit in a matrimonial

cause should be filed.

5.2.Whether a court has jurisdiction depends on the following:

i. Parties' domicile.

ii. Place of solemnisation of marriage.

iii. Marital residence and the residence of the respondent or,

if the respondent resides outside India, where the

petitioner resides.

5.3.Jurisdictional requirements are the same under the Hindu Marriage

Act 1955 and the Special Marriage Act 1954. A divorce petition

can be presented to the district court within the local limits of

whose original civil jurisdiction the:

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 33 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
i. Marriage was solemnised;

ii. Respondent, at the time of the presentation of the petition,

resides;

iii. Wife resides on the date of presentation of the petition (if

she is the petitioner);

iv. Petitioner resides at the time of the presentation of the

petition, in a case where the respondent, at that time,

either resides outside the territories to which the acts

extend; or has not been heard of as being alive for a

period of seven years or more by those persons who

would naturally have heard of him/her if he/she were

alive.

5.4.Under the Indian Divorce Act 1869, a petition in a matrimonial

cause can be presented in the court of the district judge within the

local limits of whose ordinary jurisdiction either the:

i. Husband and wife reside.

ii. Husband and wife last resided together.

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 34 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
5.5.Where a number of courts have jurisdiction, a party can choose

one of them. Where a court's jurisdiction is questioned, preference

is generally given to factors that support its jurisdiction.

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 35 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
6. CHILD CUSTODY:

After a marriage breaks down or ends up in separation of spouses, the

person who gets affected the most is the child who is born out of the

marriage. Thus, while keeping in mind the right of parent‟s to the

custody of a child, the Indian Law, holds the child‟s welfare as the most

crucial factor of consideration while deciding upon who gets the custody

of a minor child. When it comes to child custody, the interests and

welfare of the child is of paramount importance. The Apex Court in

Sheoli Hati v. Somnath Das, (2019) 7 SCC 490 has categorically

observed that:

“Every child has right to proper health and education and it is the

primary duty of the parents to ensure that child gets proper education.

The Courts in exercise of parens patriae jurisdiction have to decide

such delicate question. It has to consider the welfare of the child as of

paramount importance taking into consideration other aspects of the

matter including the rights of parents also.”

Other factors which constitute the welfare of the child are:

i. Ethical upbringing of the child;

ii. Safe-keeping of the child;

iii. Good education to be imparted;


Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate
Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 36 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
iv. Economic well-being of the guardian.

6.1.Kinds of custody arrangement in India

A court of competent jurisdiction in India primarily orders the

custody of children in the following three forms:

6.1.1. Physical Custody - Physical custody when

awarded to a parent implies that the minor will be

under the guardianship of that parent with periodical

interaction and visitation with the other parent. The

target behind such a custody award is to give a better

life to the child in a safe and fulfilling environment and

also makes sure that the child is not deprived of the

affection of the other parent during his or her formative

years.

6.1.2. Legal Custody - Legal custody of a child does not

necessarily entails having the child with the parents or

vice-versa. It basically means that the parents are

granted the legal custody and they can take every

decision for the child likewise education, medical

treatment, etc. until the minor has reached the age of 18

years. In most of the cases, legal custody is granted to


Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate
Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 37 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
both the parents together but in certain cases where the

divorce is messy and parents do not agree with each

other, then in such cases the court grants legal custody

to any of the one parent.

6.1.3. Joint Custody - Joint Custody of a child does not

implies that both the parents have to live together

because of the child despite the fact that Indian courts

believe that it is the best for the welfare of a minor.

Joint custody actually means that both the parents will

take care of the child turn by turn keeping the child in

their custody. The rotation of the child among the

parents may vary from certain days or a week or even

for a month. These benefits the child as on one hand

the child gets the attention of both the parents and on

the other hand parents get to be a part of their child‟s

life.

6.2.Legislations Governing Child Custody Under Different Laws In

India:

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 38 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
6.2.1. The Guardians and Wards Act, 1890

According to GWA, 1890, a minor/child is any

person who is generally under the age of 18

physically and intellectually imperfect and immature

and hence needing someone's protection. “Guardian”

means a person having the care of the person of minor

or his property or both; “ward” means a minor for

whose property or both there is a guardian. The court

must work in the interest of the minor taking into

consideration age, sex, religion, the character of the

guardian, death of a parent(s), and the relation of the

child to the guardian, etc. The minor's preference may

be taken into consideration. The welfare of the child

is taken as paramount consideration and here welfare

must not be measured by money or physical comfort

but the word welfare must be taken in its widest sense

that the affection cannot be disregarded.

The Law Commission in its 263rd report held that

desire to protect children must be based on a true

interpretation of their best interest.


Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate
Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 39 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
6.2.2. Custody under Hindu Law:

Section 26 of Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 deals with


Custody of Children - In any proceeding under this
Act, the court may, from time-to-time, pass such
interim orders and make such provisions in the decree
as it may deem just and proper with respect to the
custody, maintenance and education of minor children,
consistently with their wishes, wherever possible and
may, after the decree, upon application by petition for
the purposes make from time-to-time, all such orders
and provisions with respect to the custody,
maintenance and education of such children as might
have been made by such decree or interim orders in
case the proceeding for obtaining such decree were still
pending and the court may also from time-to-time
revoke, suspend or vary any such orders and provisions
previously made:
Provided that the application with respect to the
maintenance and education of the minor children,
pending the proceeding for obtaining such decree, shall
as far as possible, be disposed of within sixty days
from the date of service of notice on the respondent.

6.2.3. Custody under Muslim Law:


i. In Muslim law, the welfare of the children is given
the utmost importance.
Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate
Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 40 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
ii. Under Muslim personal law, there is a concept called
“Hizanat“. In this, the right to a child‟s custody is
given solely to a mother unless she is seen as an unfit
guardian. And this right can be enforced against any
person including the father.
iii. But again justifying the welfare of the child, here the
mother‟s right of child custody is not absolute and
exists only if such right is beneficial and in the
interest of her children.

6.2.4. Custody under Special Marriage Act,1954:

Section 38 of the Special Marriage Act, 1954 deals


with Custody of Children - In any proceeding under
Chapter V or Chapter VI the District Court may, from
time-to-time, pass such interim orders and make such
provisions in the decree as it may seem to it to be just
and proper with respect to the custody, maintenance
and education of minor children, consistently with their
wishes wherever possible, and may, after the decree,
upon application by petition for the purpose, make,
revoke, suspend or vary, from time-to-time, all such
orders and provisions with respect to the custody,
maintenance education of such children as might have
been made by such decree or interim orders in case the
proceedings for obtaining such decree were still

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 41 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
pending.

Provided that the application with respect to the


maintenance and education of the minor children,
during the proceeding, under Chapter V or Chapter VI,
shall as far as possible, be disposed of within sixty
days from the date of service of the notice on the
respondent.

6.2.5. Custody under Christian law:

As the Christian law has no specific mention of the

child custody rights, the Indian Divorce Act, 1869,

becomes applicable for all matters pertaining to

Christian children and their guardianship. As per

Section 41 of this said Act, the courts have the right to

pass orders as to the custody, education, and

maintenance of Christian children.

6.2.6. Custody under Parsi Law:

The Parsis also do not have any specific laws

pertaining to child custody. Hence all such issues are

addressed by the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890.

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 42 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
Under the Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act, 1936, the

wife can claim for maintenance to support their minor

children. Under this Act, the court has to pass an order

within 60 days related to custody of Parsi children and

their guardianship.

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 43 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
7. DOMICILE:

7.1.Types of Domicile

There are two types of domicile:

i. Domicile by Origin: An individual automatically acquires

the domicile of the country in which he/she is born.

Unless and until new domicile is acquired by the said

person, the domicile remains the same.

ii. Domicile by Choice: Domicile by choice is the one

whereby the individual willingly acquired new domiciles

thereby replacing his/her domicile by origin.

The Apex Court has acknowledged the concept of

domicile as established under English law, Central

Bank of India Ltd. v. Ram Narain (AIR 1955 36. it was

held that that the two constituent elements that are

necessary under English law for existence of domicile

are:

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 44 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
 Residence of particular kind. The residence may

not be continuous but it must be indefinite and

not purely fleeting.

 An intention of a particular kind. there must be

a present intention to reside in the country

where residence has been taken up.

i. The Hindu Marriage Act extends to whole of India

except the state of Jammu and Kashmir.

ii. Section 1(2) of the Hindu Marriage Act states that:

“It extends to the whole of India except the State of

Jammu and Kashmir 1 , and applies also to Hindus

domiciled in the territories to which this Act

extends who are outside the said territories.”

iii. The Act applies to all the individuals who do not

reside in India but continue to be domiciled in India.

7.2. Divorce:

The Apex Court in the landmark judgment Y. Narasimha Rao

and others v. Venkata Lakshmi and Ors. (1991)3SCC 45,

held that the marriages that takes place in India can only be

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 45 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
dissolved under either the customary or Statutory law in force

in India. therefore, the only law that applies to matrimonial

disputes, is the one under which the parties are married

“From the aforesaid discussion the following rule can

be deduced for recognising foreign matrimonial

judgment in this country. The jurisdiction assumed by

the foreign court as well as the grounds on which the

relief is granted must be in accordance with the

matrimonial law under which the parties are married.

The exceptions to this rule may be as follows: (i)

where the matrimonial action is filed in the forum

where the respondent is domiciled or habitually and

permanently resides and the relief is granted on a

ground available in the matrimonial law under which

the parties are married; (ii) where the respondent

voluntarily and effectively submits to the jurisdiction

of the forum as discussed above and contests the

claim which is based on a ground available under the

matrimonial law under which the parties are married;

(iii) where the respondent consents to the grant of the


Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate
Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 46 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
relief although the jurisdiction of the forum is not in

accordance with the provisions of the matrimonial

law of the parties.”

However, the confusion occurs where the parties are

domiciled in some other country but were married in India

under Indian Matrimonial laws. it is still unclear as to in case

of matrimonial dispute, will a divorce petition be

maintainable in India? the Supreme Court has not adjudicated

on this issue. however, the Hon‟ble Bombay High Court in

Ms. Kashmira Kale v. Kishore Kumar Kale, was of the view

that it is necessary for one of the parties to be domiciled in

India in order to invoke the jurisdiction of the Indian

Matrimonial courts.

“The order of the learned Judge of the Family

Court, Pune, concluding that the parties last

resided together in Pune and even though their

residence is for a single day it would give the

Court jurisdiction based upon the judgments cited

in the impugned order suffers from a material

irregularity and is required to be interfered with,


Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate
Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 47 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
since it assumes territorial jurisdiction not vested

in it and since the Act itself does not apply to the

parties consequent upon their domicile in the US

and also because the rights between the parties

have been settled by a judgment conclusive

between them. The husband may be entitled to

challenge the judgment in the Court in which it is

pronounced following the due legal process

required in that jurisdiction consequent upon his

absence, if need be. However, the husband cannot

confer jurisdiction on the Court in Pune in which

the parties never resided together for any length of

time in their own matrimonial home, they having

had their matrimonial home in the US.”

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 48 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
8. ALIMONY/ MAINTENACE:

The English concept of alimony has been adopted in the Indian Divorce

Act, 1869.

Alimony, in simple terms, is the allowance paid by one spouse to another

for their sustenance. Alimony and maintenance are the same, and are

used as different names in different places. In some countries and places,

„alimony‟ is used while in some other regions, „maintenance‟ is in

vogue. In India, we use the terms interchangeably after divorce, whereas

before divorce, the term maintenance is used.

Section 36 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 lays down that the amount

of alimony pendente lite in no case can exceed one-fifth of the husband's

average net income for three years next preceding the date of the order.

8.1.Alimony and maintenance can be divided under two basic heads

viz.:

Alimony/Maintenance

Interim maintenance Permanent maintenance

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 49 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
 Can be made in all four matrimonial Can be made only in two causes
causes matrimonial causes viz. Judicial
Separation and Divorce.

 Is granted by the court during the When a decree of dissolution


pendency of the proceedings i.e. from of marriage or judicial separation
the date of filing of the proceedings is obtained by the wife, the court
till date of the final order. husband shall pay the wife any
may order that the
particular amount fixed by the
court, either periodically, or in
lump-sum.

8.2.Our country comprises different communities, and each

community has its own personal laws derived from religious

scriptures, customs and traditions. Thus, the grounds on which a

Hindu woman can seek divorce and alimony may not be the same

for every other community. Acts governing the claim for

maintenance based on their religion is explained as follows:

Religion Governing Act

Hindu Hindu Adoption and


Maintenance Act, 1956,

Muslim Muslim Women (Protection


of Rights on Divorce) Act,
1986

Divorced Christian Indian Divorce Act, 1869

Parsi Parsi Marriage and Divorce


Act, 1936.

Inter-caste Marriages Special Marriage Act, 1954

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 50 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
All communities/religion Section 125 of Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973.

i. Although there are different personal laws for each community,

the line of difference has started to blur between all the personal

laws. For example under the Muslim law, the wife was allowed

maintenance only till the iddat period (three months after

divorce); however the Supreme Court in Daniel Latif Vs. Union

of India held that the duty of the husband to pay a fair and

reasonable amount to the wife is not limited to the iddat period,

bringing it in consistence with other personal laws, where the

time to receive maintenance is not limited to a certain period.

(Danial Latifi & Anr vs Union Of India).

8.3.Factors taken into consideration while awarding permanent

maintenance to the wife:

When a couple gets divorced by mutual consent, the decision on

whether any alimony/maintenance is to be paid by either party

is a matter of agreement between them. However, in matters

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 51 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
where it is contested, the court decides depending upon the

merit of each case.

Following factors are taken into consideration by the court

while deciding permanent maintenance for the wife.

8.3.1. Income, property and ability of both husband and

wife;

i. One of the considerations of granting permanent

maintenance is assessing income and property of the

parties. When a wife makes an application for

maintenance, the husband is required to give full

details and make complete disclosure of his income

and properties. The wife can make queries about any

alleged omission. A similar disclosure, though, is also

required to be made by the wife. The court then

exercises its discretion to come to a conclusion on a

fixed amount, taking all the information into account.

ii. Generally, courts award 1/4th of the husband‟s income

to the wife as maintenance. In a case last year, the

Supreme Court also set the benchmark at 25% of

husband‟s net salary as the amount for maintenance as


Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate
Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 52 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
“just and proper”. The court said that the amount of

maintenance or permanent alimony must be sufficient

to ensure that a woman lived with dignity after

separating from her husband.

8.3.2. Lifestyle and reasonable want of the parties:

Lifestyle, along with the financial status of the parties,

is one of the most important factors while arriving at a

conclusion by the court. Reasonable wants does not

only include providing the wife food and just keeping

her alive. Emphasis is paid on their lifestyle, status,

health, age, liabilities and responsibilities. The courts

have said that ordinarily the wife is entitled to an

amount of maintenance that will enable her to maintain

almost the same standard of living to which she was

entitled before the marriage broke down. In case of a

minor child, his/her necessities are also taken into

consideration.

8.3.3. When does alimony need not be paid?


Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate
Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 53 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
i. The husband is not required to pay maintenance in case

the wife remarries. He can also contest and refuse to

pay maintenance on the ground that the wife is

gainfully employed. The court can though still award

maintenance to 1be paid for the children.

ii. However, only the fact that the wife is employed

cannot be a ground for not paying maintenance, as the

employment of the wife should be in line with the

lifestyle of both the spouses. For example, if the wife

takes tuitions and earns a sum which is just enough for

her survival, but the lifestyle of the couple was much

higher than the amount the wife earns can give her, the

court could still ask the husband to pay a sum to

maintain that living standard. However, in cases where

the wife earns more than the husband, it is difficult for

the wife to get any maintenance.

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 54 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
PART – II

9. PROCEDURE

9.1.Matrimonial Petitions:

Section 21 of Hindu Marriage Act provides that all proceedings

under this Act shall be regulated as far as may be, by Code of Civil

Procedure. In case High Court of the concerned State has framed

rules pertaining to any matter under the Act, those rules shall come

into application for regulating the procedure for disposal of

petitions or applications under the Act.

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 55 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
10. Hindu Marriage Act has laid down two types of Divorce viz.

Contested divorce (S.13) Mutual Consent Divorce (S. 13 (B)

Contested Divorce Versus Mutual Consent divorce

Section 13 of Hindu Sections Section 13 (B) of Hindu


Marriage Act, 1955 Marriage Act, 1955

Filed by either spouse, since Filed by Filed jointly by the husband


the other does not consent to and the wife.
the same.
Cruelty, adultery, desertion, Grounds No grounds required
conversion, mental disorder,
leprosy, venereal disease,
renunciation, no resumption
of cohabitation and not heard
to be alive.
Decided by the judge after Terms of Mutually decided by both the
considering all the facts and Divorce parties
evidence lead by both the
parties.
6-18 months Time 3-5 years
taken for
disposal
Expensive since involves Cost Cost effective and time
two separate lawyers efficient since both the parties
can be represented by one and
the same lawyer.

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 56 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
11. Contents and Verification:

 High Courts have laid down various rules and guidelines regarding

pleadings in petitions under Hindu Marriage Act. Therefore, while

drafting petitions it is to be kept in mind that the petition is in

consonance with these rules.

 Every petition presented under Hindu Marriage Act must state as

distinctly as the nature of the case permits the facts on which the

claim to relief is sought and that there is no collusion between the

petitioner and the other party to the marriage.

 In addition to the particulars required to be given under Order VII,

rule 1, CPC and section 20(1) of the Hindu Marriage Act, all

petitions under sections 9 to 13 should contain the following:

a. The place and date of marriage;

b. Whether the couple was Hindu by religion at the

time of marriage;

c. Whether the couple continues to be Hindu by

religion upto the date of filing of the petition;

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 57 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
d. The name, status and domicile of the wife and the

husband before the marriage and at the time of filing the

petition;

e. The address where the parties to the marriage

reside at the time of the presentation of petition and

where they last resided together;

f. The names of children, if any, from the marriage, their

sex and their dates of birth or ages;

g. Full particulars. of any litigation, if any, between

the parties, prior to the date of filing of petition;

h. Jurisdiction clause;

i. Payment of court fee.

 In case of a petition for restitution of conjugal rights, in a situation

where the respondent has withdrawn from the society of the spouse,

the date and the circumstances under which the respondent

withdrew are required to be mentioned in the petition by the

petitioner.

 In case of a petition under section 12(1)(c) and (d) of the Hindu

Marriage Act i.e., for decree of nullity 'of marriage, particulars of

force or fraud and the circumstances in which force or fraud was


Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate
Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 58 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
practiced, with time when the facts relied upon were discovered,

and whether or not marital intercourse with the consent of the

petitioner took place after the discovery of the said facts, are to be

specifically mentioned;

 In every petition under section 10 or section 13 i.e. for judicial

separation or decree of divorce, by the husband or wife on the

ground that the other party indulged in adultery following details

are to be specified:

a. specific acts of sexual intercourse;

b. the occasion and place where the same were committed;

c. name, occupation and place of residence of such person

with whom the opposite party had voluntary sexual

intercourse, after- the marriage.

 In case of desertion, date and circumstances in which the desertion

began are to be specified in the petition;

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 59 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
 In case of cruelty, the specific acts of cruelty and the occasion when

and the place where such acts were committed are to be specified in

the petition;

 In case of unsoundness of mind or mental disorder, the time when

such unsoundness of mind or mental disorder began to manifest

itself and the nature and the period of the curative steps taken;

 If the petition is on the ground that the opposite party has

renounced the world by entering any religious order, the date of

renunciation and the particulars of the religious order which the

respondent has entered into;

 If the petition is on the ground that the opposite party has not been

heard of as being alive for a period of seven years or more, the date

and place where the opposite party was last seen or heard or alive

and the steps, if any, taken to ascertain his or her whereabouts;

 Where the petition is founded on the ground of rape or sodomy, the

occasion when, the place where and the names and addresses of

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 60 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
persons with whom such acts were committed. In case of

conviction for committing rape or sodomy the particulars thereof;

 Where the petition is founded on the ground of bestiality, the

occasion when, the place where and the particulars of the beast with

whom the husband had been guilty of bestiality;

 Where petition for divorce is by the wife on the ground of non-

compliance with a decree of maintenance passed under section 18

of Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 or in proceedings

under section 125 Cr.P.C, it is to be alleged and also testified in an

affidavit that since the passing of such decree or order, cohabitation

between the parties has not been resumed for one year or more;

 Where the petition for divorce is by the wife on the ground that her

marriage was solemnized before she attained the age of 15 years

and she has repudiated the marriage after attaining that age but

before attaining the age of 18 years, wife is to allege the date and

the place of birth of the wife together with the date and the place of

repudiation and its mode;

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 61 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
 Parties are to specifically allege about property presented, at or

about the time of marriage, which belonged jointly to the husband

and wife.

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 62 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
12. Documents to be annexed alongwith the Petition:

 Original Marriage photograph;

 Original Wedding invitation/ marriage certificate;

 Birth certificate of issues if any;

 Passport size photographs of both the parties;

 Other documents as required to prove the ground based on which

the case is filed.

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 63 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
13. Affidavits Required to be filed with the Petition:

 It is significant to note that the petition must be accompanied with

the affidavit in support of the petition affirming on oath the facts

mentioned in the petition. The statements contained in every

petition under this Act are required to be verified by the petitioner

or some other competent person in the manner required by law for

verification of plaints.

13.1.It stands so provided in the rules framed by various High Courts

and are available in High Court Rules and Orders. These

affidavits may be on the, following aspects:

Sr. Petition for Affidavit


No.
1. Petition for divorce by Parties have not resumed
the wife on the ground of cohabiting for one year or
non-compliance with a more since the passing of
decree of maintenance the decree or order.
passed under section 18
of the Hindu Adoptions
and Maintenance Act,
1956 or in proceedings
under section 125 Cr.P.C.
2. Every petition (except Petition it is not being
petition for nullity of presented or prosecuted in

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 64 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
marriage) collusion with the
respondent.

3. Judicial separation or Petitioner has not, in any


divorce on the ground manner, condoned or been
that the party has, after accessory to or connived at
solemnization of the the act or acts complained
marriage, had voluntary of.
sexual intercourse with
any person other than his
or her spouse
4. Ground of the petition is The petitioner has not
cruelty condoned the act or acts
complained- of or has not in
any manner condoned the
cruelty

5. Ground being no Affidavit in support of this


resumption of averment is to be annexed to
cohabitation as between the petition.
the parties to the
marriage for a period of
one year or upwards after
the passing of a decree
for judicial separation in
a proceeding to which
they were parties.

Every pleading is required to be verified at the foot by the

party or by a person acquainted with the facts of the case, as

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 65 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
per satisfaction of the Court. An affidavit in support of the

pleadings is also to be furnished.

In the verification clause, it is to be specifically verified by

the party as to which fact is being verified on the basis of his

own knowledge, and which fact is being verified on the basis

of information received or believed to be true. (Order VI rule

15).

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 66 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
14. STAGES INVOLVED IN DIVROCE BY MUTUAL CONSENT IN INDIA:

Filing of Petition under Section


13 (B) of the Hindu Marriage
Act, 1955

Both the parties will be sent for


counselling.

The Court after examination of the


Petition and the documents annexed
thereto will pass an Order for
recording of statement on oath

6 months cooling period- Petition is


kept beyond 6 months for parties to
reconsider and reconcile.

Post 6 months, if there is no


reconciliation; both the parties need
to appear for the final hearing when
they have to attend one more
counselling. (Parties have to appear
for the second motion within 18
months from the date of filing the
divorce petition.)

In the final hearing, the court passes


the divorce decree dissolving the
marriage
Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate
Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 67 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
15. STAGES INVOLVED IN CONTESTED DIVROCE IN INDIA:

 Petition for contested divorce can be filed by either spouse

based on the grounds mentioned above. Following are the

stages:

This petition categorically stating the


grounds and reliefs is filed before a
family court having jurisdiction along
with affidavits, vakalatnama, and
documents relevant to the case.

After scrutinizing the petition, the court


admits the petition and passes an order
of issuance of summons the other party
calling upon him/her to appear on a
decided date and file its reply.

The parties to the divorce proceedings are


directed to appear before the court for
mediation. in most of the cases efforts are
made by the court to resolve the dispute
and arrive at a reconciliation. in case of
failure, the matter is posted for further
hearing.

The Respondent is required to file its


Written Statement within 30 days of
receipt of the Summons. failing which
ex-parte order will be passed

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 68 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
Filing of Counsellors report – if the
Counselling fails then the court will
proceed with the trial of the case.

Based on the pleadings and the defence of


both the parties the court will proceed to
frame the issues in the matter

On the date fixed, the Petitioner will file its


Affidavit of Evidence alongwith the List of
Documents

Respondent will cross examine the Petitioner


and the witness if any.

Petitioner will file Pursis closing its Evidence


d the Respondent will file its Examination in
Chief along with the List of Documents

Petitioner will Cross examine the Respondent


and the witness if any.

Both the advocates will present their final


arguments

At last, the court on a fixed date will deliver the


verdict and pass judgment based on the pleadings
and evidence put forth by the parties.. The
aggrieved party can appeal to the High Court
within 3 months from the passing of such order.

Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate


Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 69 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES
DISCLAIMER:

This information has been sourced from the following:

1. Family law in India: overview by Pinky Anand available at:


https://uk.practicallaw.thomsonreuters.com/6-581-
5985?transitionType=Default&contextData=(sc.Default)&firstPage=true&b
hcp=1.

2. Family Law by Paras Diwan, Revised by Dr. S.S. Jaiswal, available at:
http://14.139.60.114:8080/jspui/bitstream/123456789/738/23/Family%20La
w.pdf.

3. Family laws in India, Law Articles, available at :


http://www.legalservicesindia.com/law/article/938/15/Family-Laws-in-India

4. The Concept of Divorce under Muslim Law, by Setu Gupta, available at:
http://www.legalserviceindia.com/article/l393-Divorce-under-Muslim-
Law.html

5. Divorce in Islam under Muslim Laws in India, available at:


https://www.myadvo.in/blog/divorce-in-islam/

6. Parsi Law Regarding Marriage And Divorce. An overview, available at


http://www.legalserviceindia.com/legal/article-1883-parsi-law-regarding-
marriage-and-divorce-an-overview.html.

7. Christian Law Regarding Marriage And Divorce In India: Indian Christian


Marriage Act, 1872, available at:

http://www.legalserviceindia.com/legal/article-1764-christian-law-
regarding-marriage-and-divorce-in-india-indian-christian-marriage-act-
1872.html

8. Know About Family Law In India, available at :


https://legodesk.com/legopedia/family-law-india/
Research by: Adv. Ambrin N. Khan, Senior Associate
Mentor : Adv. Yusuf Iqbal Yusuf, Founder & Managing Partner

Page 70 of 70
© M/s Y & A LEGAL, ADVOCATES

You might also like