Kanban
Kanban
Kanban
SYSTEM
Structure
16.1 Introduction
Objective
16.2 The Kanban concept – origin and history
16.3 Kanban strategies: push vs pull Kanban
16.3.1 Push Kanban: Unlimited WIP and Demand Dependent
16.3.2 Pull Kanban: Limited WIP and Demand Focused
16.3.3 Push, Pull, or a combination of both?
16.3.4 Key characteristics of Pull-based Lean Manufacturing
16.4 Lean Inventory
16.4.1 Lean Inventory Guidelines
16.4.2 The six rules of Toyota of Lean Inventory
16.5 Types of Kanban systems
16.6 The Kanban Process
16.6.1 Kanban rules
16.6.2 A demand driven system
16.6.3 Kanban cards
16.6.4 Kanban bins
16.6.5 Three-bin system
16.6.6 Heijunka box
16.7 Virtual or Electronic Kanban (e-Kanban) Systems
16.8 Kanban Inventory Management System
16.8.1 Kanban Inventory Beliefs
16.8.2 Kanban Signalling
16.8.3 Functioning of Kanban Inventory System
16.8.4 Kanban cards for specific inventory items
16.8.5 Kanban boards: solution for inventory management issues
16.8.6 Outcomes of Kanban inventory management system
16.9 Implementation of Kanban
16.9.1 Ideal environment for Kanban implementation
16.9.2 Care while implementing Kanban inventory system
16.9.3 CONWIP Systems
16.9.4 Benefits of Kanban inventory system
16.10 Calculating Kanban quantities
16.11 Summary
16.12 Keywords
16.13 Further readings
16.1 INTRODUCTION
Kanban is a visual scheduling system for lean inventory and lean
manufacturing also called just-in-time (JIT) inventory/ manufacturing. Taiichi
Ohno, an industrial engineer at Toyota, developed kanban to improve
productivity.
Objective
73
After studying this unit you should be able to
Understand Kanban concept
Know the Kanban strategies
Learn Lean Inventory
Know Types of Kanban systems
Discuss the Kanban process
Understand Virtual or electronic Kanban (e-Kanban) systems
Explain Kanban Inventory Management System
Implement the Kanban
Calculate Kanban quantities
75
Figure 16.1: Push Vs Pull Kanban
76
Figure 16.2: Material Flow in Push Production
The push manufacturing, or push inventory (Refer figure 16.2) will tend to have
a lot of work in progress (WIP) due to high variety products and the material
features also have complex structures. Therefore, Push production
environments tend to be characterized by long lead times and/or make to stock
(MTS) situations. This will have processing large batches of items at a
maximum rate, based on forecasted demand, then moving them to the next
downstream process or into storage.
16.3.2 Pull Kanban: Limited WIP and Demand Focused
This strategy also stands on two main aspects viz, the first is that WIP is limited
and the second is that the production is demand focused (Refer fig: 16.3).
The pull-based lean manufacturing environment works on the assumption as, to
make nothing until there is demand. So, finished goods are not produced
without a specific customer order. Replacements for intermediates and
materials are not acquired before existing items have been used.
Pull manufacturing strategy works best when demand is high and steady for a
relatively small variety of products.
77
Ensured continuous flow of production from raw materials to
finished products
Buffering critically constrained resources.
Maintains full utilization and establishes supplier relationships and
supply management practices
synchronized delivery of raw materials (and sub-assemblies) to the
point of use at the time of production.
Enables faster throughput,
shorter manufacturing lead times, and
reduced the amount of inventory needed
support to customer service objectives
lowered production costs
Limited work in progress (WIP) inventory levels.
Just-in-time (JIT) material deliveries
demand-pull scheduling that restricts the excess inventory.
To start producing parts it relies on Kanban production to signal upstream work
centres. (Thisis analogous to work order). The upstream station does not begin
manufacturing the parts until it receives a signal. Thus Kanban signals control
the movement of raw materials and semi-finished products through subsequent
workstations. Of course! Notall Kanbans on a production line are of the same
size—they depend on the nature and usage of the part.
Accounting for cycle time intervals using buffer—the time it takes production
to shift back to making a part after making other parts. The buffer also accounts
for transportation time, safety stock, seasonality, and promotions. Finally, the
buffer puts a cap on the amount of WIP in the system and enables the start of
continuous improvement initiatives to reduce lead times through setup and
batch-size reduction.
The outcomes with a pull-based lean environment,
deliveries go on-time,
meet customer demand, and
improve the reliability of the supply chain.
In contexts where supply time is lengthy and demand is difficult to forecast,
often the best one can do is to respond quickly to observed demand. This
situation is exactly what a kanban system accomplishes, in that it is used as a
demand signal that immediately travels through the supply chain. This ensures
that intermediate stock held in the supply chains are better managed, and are
usually smaller. Where the supply response is not quick enough to meet actual
demand fluctuations, thereby causing potential lost sales, a stock building may
be deemed more appropriate and is achieved by placing more Kanban in the
system.
SAQ-16.1
a) Briefly explain Kanban concept?
b) What is ‘The Empty Box Concept’?
c) What is ‘The Supermarket Shelf-Stock Concept’?
78
d) List of Kanban strategies.
e) Explain Push Kanban Strategy in detail.
f) Explain Pull Kanban Strategy in detail.
g) Explain combination of Push and Pull Strategies in detail.
h) Discuss Key characteristics of Pull-based Lean Manufacturing.
i) Write outcomes with a pull-based lean environment.
ACTIVITY-16.1
In which manufacturing company is Push Kanban Strategy (Unlimited WIP and
Demand Dependent) used? Explain your answer with an example.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
79
Figure 16.4: The Six Rules of Toyota of Lean Inventory
16.4.2 The Six Rules of Toyota of Lean Inventory
Toyota made the following six simple rules (Refer figure 16.4), and
1. Never Pass Defective Products
Upstream processes must meet the level of quality and standards that are
expected of them. Remove all defective products; they are dealt with outside
the production line.
85
f) What is Three-bin system? What are the three bins? Explain them.
g) Describe Heijunka Box.
ACTIVITY-16.3
Identify any national or international company in your vicinity which is using
Kanban Process. Explain the procedure how the company is using Kanban
Process.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
86
Figure 16.6: Electronic-Kanban (IT-enabled) System
Typical IT-enabled e-kanban system (Refer figure 16.6) uses barcodes for
inventory, which can be scanned at various stages of the manufacturing process
to signal usage. The scans relay messages to internal/external stores to ensure
the restocking of products. The e-kanban uses the internet for routing messages
to external suppliers and as a means to allow a real-time view of inventory, via
a portal, throughout the supply chain.
88
Kanban Action: Estimate the time to empty referring to customer’s demand,
and supplier’s lead time to supply and plan replenishment accordingly.
GREEN SIGNAL
Condition-3:Bin Full
Kanban Action:No material movement, observe consumption patterns and
previous records
If any of the above three conditions prevail unchanged continuously for more
than a predetermined specified period (usually 2 or 3 weeks), plan for
discarding or redesigning the kanban.
Customer demand is an alarm
Best way to identify the restocking threshold is the customer demand for a
specific product. As per the Kanban inventory management, there is no need to
replenish the stock unless there is an empty slot for the incoming volume.If a
particular product selling amazingly then can there be a plan for another stock for
the same.
16.8.3 Functioning of Kanban Inventory System
Here’s how to setup a functioning kanban inventory system
A traditional kanban board is divided into three columns (can edit their names
to suit the business needs).
1. “To-Do” column, which is where identified tasks are collected
2. “Doing” column for those tasks that are being worked on currently
3. “Done” column to place tasks that have been successfully completed
These tasks move across the column boards as they are being worked on, which
provides an easy way to track the work.
89
16.8.4 Kanban Cards for Specific Inventory Items
With the kanban inventory system, the production is split into tasks, so that a
manager can control and track the work through the production cycle. Each
inventory item, shipment (or some metric) is placed on an individual card.
These are then transferred from column to column on the board as they’re
worked on.
Each card in turn has the specific information that is needed for that task at each
stage of production, such as supplies and materials that is required further on
down the line. These can be represented on the kanban card in the form of
comments, files and task descriptions.
Of course, the more complex the production and inventory, the more detailed
kanban can accurately reflect the process.
Whatsoever, never forget to follow the Toyota’s six principles.
16.8.5 Kanban Boards: Solution for Inventory Management Issues
Stock-Out and Lead Time Issues:To prevent stock outs, an
organization should decide the appropriate levels of stock on hand,
lest,it leads to production shut downs or outages. The lead-time for
parts and materials from vendors is one factor to determining the
optimum level of inventory. Of course, the organization needs to
adjust the Kanban levels several times before finding the best quantity
of material to keep on hand for production or distribution.
Issues with multiple supply points: There are many stress points that
can cause a supply chain to slow down, particularly when supplied
from multiple warehouses or multiple countries. However, kanban
cards can represent each of these various links in the supply chain and
make it easier to know where to coordinate delivery.
Issues with identification and evaluating business needs: Inventory
management can also suffer from inaccurately identifying and
evaluating the business needs. It’s important to know the gaps in the
system, to prioritize and fill them. A kanban inventory system offers a
clear visual map of whatever, whenever and wherever itis needed. But
it is often challenging to align with business plan to make sure both
sides are realistic.
Issues with inventory system optimization:If inventory system is not
optimized, then it is not known what or when needed, in turn, it makes
forecasting future inventory needs impossible. The cards on kanban
board are capturing the inventory and identifying where it is in the
pipeline. This makes it easier to see opportunities, so can act and add
more efficiency to the supply chain.
90
Issues with balancing inventory level and customer needs:
Monitoring and optimizing the inventory levels, while meeting
customer needs, is the major issue for a balanced business venture. This
reduces the level and cost of inventory and avoids unnecessary storage
costs by only stocking what and, when it’s needed, and timely
resupplying.
16.8.6 Outcomes of Kanban Inventory Management System
The implementation of Kanban Inventory system is expected to produce the
following outcomes.
1. Reduced inventory costs
When inventory in the store is less, there will be a lot of unused space and that
additional space can be occupied by work stations. These savings as the profit
gained out of business is not invested in purchasing any extra (unnecessary) stock.
2. Streamlined order fulfilment
The kanban system acts as a watch-tower over the entire supply chain,
particularly order-flow process, from the point of receiving an order from
different channels to confirming the order to shipping and completing the order
fulfilment.One can set orders on priority as per the demand or any concurrent
conditions and fulfil them accordingly in a streamlined manner.
3. Access to progress reports
A Kanban system focuses on tracking continuously on the entire supply chain.
When applied to efficient inventory management system, the same idea enables
accuracy in the record of the sales and inventory also. This helps the management
to realistically plan, practically organize and optimally improvise the business
workflow.
4. Avoids over-stocking
There are cases when organizations wrongly or over estimate the demand for a
specific product, only to end up stocking it unnecessarily for months. Oversight,
over expectations and ignorance are few reasons for leading to such situations
overstocks. This situation then compels them to either dispose of that stock or
sell it off at discounted rates. In such cases, it eventually becomes hard to keep
the right track of stock. The Kanban system helps avoiding such situations at the
earlier stage itself.
91
Kanban also keeps the production area clean by removing all unnecessary
storage. It makes sure only the parts to the production line when needed are
delivered. This also makes the production space focused, means production, not
storage. This all nicely cuts nails and tails, which naturally grow without adding
any value or productivity. Thus Kanban fits into lean manufacturing, which is a
philosophy of continuous flow of product through the manufacturing process.
SAQ-16.4
a) Explain virtual or electronic Kanban (e-Kanban) systems.
b) How does IT enabled Kanban System work?
c) What is Kanban inventory management system?
d) Explain Kanban Inventory Beliefs in detail.
e) Discuss Kanban Signalling?
f) What are the three actions for three possible signalling conditions of
kanban?
g) Explain how to setup a functioning kanban inventory system?
h) What is the significance of Kanban Cards?
i) What are the Kanban Boards? Explain them in detail.
j) What are the Outcomes of Kanban Inventory Management System?
ACTIVITY-16.4
How do you suggest whether the Virtual (e-kanban) system is useful or not for
the Indian Industries? Justify your answer.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
92
Low product variation:If many different products are maintained,
then hold stocks of them could easily increase the carrying cost. To
reduce this burden, ensure making or holding commonly used
parts/products and if not unique, see that they are latest.
Clear flow: Facilities that are organized in a silo style with all similar
processing being done in one location are hard to control with a kanban
system, although not impossible by any means. A better arrangement is
one in which all processes are organized together to provide a flow line
or cell.
Small dedicated machines: Many companies will invest on large mass
producing machines. Often these machines will drive the use of large
batches and may create a bottleneck for the facility. Far better if
smaller dedicated machines are used within product flow lines.
Quick changeovers: Many machines and processes can take a long
time to set up to run a new product or variant. This again drives large
batches and can create significant bottlenecks within the production
line. The use of Shigio Shingo’s concepts of Single Minute Exchange
of Die can make a significant impact in this area.
Repeatable and reliable processes: If machines are vulnerable to
breaking down and processes are not repeatable then it will be hard to
control any form of production system let alone Kanban. The use of
Total Productive Maintenance (TPM), 5S Kaizen, operator driven
quality improvements, and standardized operations will help to put in
place the foundations that are required.
Reliable suppliers: Supplier’s reliability is a vital part of Kanban
process and needs ensuring that they are able to support the kanban
processes to implement reliably.
16.9.2 Care while Implementing Kanban Inventory System
There are tons of benefits of implementing a Kanban inventory system in
business. It saves money, efforts, time and space and thus enhances the efficiency.
But, before introducing the Kanban inventory management system to the
business, there are a few obstacles that needs attention.
Carefully monitor inventory quantity to be ordered to restock. A little
carelessness can mess up whole system
It will surely make the process go slow for some time. So, marginal ups
and downs can be expected initially. But, the moment things are
streamlined, it will start showing results.
Figure out the numbers that will go into a single bin and how much time
it will take for them to be in that bin. If it is to be restocked in a bin in
say 10 days, make sure that supplier sends the stock within 6 to 8 days so
as to avoid production delays.
A Kanban System needs to observe the following 6 principles during the
implementation process.
Earlier processes never push production onto later processes
Nothing is ever made without Kanban authority
Nothing is made if there are no Kanbans
Defects are identified as close to the source as possible
93
Large batches or lots of plan changes should not be planned
Wherever possible demand should be smoothed
Not having these conditions does not mean that implementation of Kanban and
Just in Time is impossible. It just means that a little more thought is to be given
on how the systems are designed and how they will work. Irregular demand and
large variations in products for instance needs to apply CONWIP systems rather
than the more usually seen cards or bin systems. Unreliable machines need a
larger factor of safety in the quantities.
Often,companies starting with JIT and Kanban with large Kanban quantities
and slowly reduce the amount of stock over time in a planned fashion to
highlight and remove problems. Lowering the inventory levels may uncover the
many issues.
16.9.3 CONWIP Systems
CONWIP is CONstant Work In Progress. This system is more like the actual
idea of using supermarket shelves where the Kanban is the actual location on
the shop floor. So when a process removes a product from the previous process
the empty space is the Kanban and the previous process will work to fill the
hole.
This works well for systems in which one can achieve near to one-piece flow
and within which variation is limited.
However, that being said it can also be used very successfully within those
areas in which there is a large amount of variation if combined with a “make to
order” type approach to planning. If the Kanban location becomes vacant, the
process will simply build the next component or batch on their list.
16.9.4 Benefits of Kanban Inventory System
A Kanban system allows a company to reduce inventory levels, which reduces
the cost associated with stocking and storing materials in the organization.
Cost reductions occur in the expense of the inventory itself as well as the cost
of warehousing and maintaining inventory. Companies that use a Kanban
system in a lean environment allow actual customer demand to determine the
need for materials and not forecasts of the demand.
By summarizing the concept of Kanban Inventory Management System
(KIMS), the benefits of kanban can be listed as given below:
1. Kanban boards help monitor and optimize inventory levels, so the
company can always get whatever it wants and whenever it needs
2. Customer needs drive production, so inventory is always at the right
level to deliver only what the customer wants
3. Because only needed inventory is stocked, the production floor is
clutter free
4. Managers are able to easily track progress and see where there are gaps
or bottlenecks in their supply chains
5. Limiting inventory to what is needed, which means there is no money
wasted on warehouse space and storage
94
know how to calculate the number of component within each bin or batch and
the number of actual Kanbans in the system.
Kanban Calculation
Kanban Quantity = D.LT.F / C
Where D = Daily Demand
LT = Lead Time in days
F = Factor of Safety
And C = Container Capacity
Illustration-16.1
Suppose 20 units are used per day and if the lead time is say 5 days with one
factor of safety. Calculate the number of kanban with the containers of 25
capacity.
Solution:
Demand (D) = 20 per day
Lead Time (LT) = 5 days
Factor of safety = 1
Container Capacity (C) = 25
No of Kanbans =DLTF/C = 20X5X1/25 = 4 Kanban
Calculating Daily Demand
It is always better to use real data than making a rough guess the daily demand.
Demand may vary seasonally and may be affected by a host of other issues so
use a figure for Kanban that effectively copes with any situation. In most cases,
it is best figure is around 90% and above of peak demand. If more variation in
demand is larger, then higher safety factor may be used.
Calculating Lead Time
As with demand use actual data and aim for a figure that is 90-95% of the peak.
A lot of variation in lead times will indicate that the problems with machine
reliability and repeatable processes so as to look at improving them. If lead
times are long then large batches should really be looking to implement SMED
to reduce them.
Factor of Safety
This factor should be defined by the confidence in the system used. If the
confidence on the reliability of processes is high, then it can be set as 1. If there
are issues with anything from machine reliability to supplier delivery
performance then it is set higher. A higher safety factor will help to protect
from stock outs when issues do occur; however, they will increase stock
holdings.
Reducing Kanban Quantities
One of the largest wastes of the seven wastes (MUDA) is inventory. To remove
as much inventory from the system as possible as this hides many of the issues
that are within the processes:
By reducing the size of Kanban quantities, problems will start to break the
surface, and force to take action. This is an effective way to highlight issues and
to start making continuous improvement within processes.
95
Decreasing the size or number of Kanbans within the system will increase the
systems sensitivity to changes or problems. This is often the best way to
highlight issues within the process and to drive improvements.
SAQ-16.5
a) What are the ideal conditions necessary for the Implementation of
Kanban?
b) What type of care should be taken while Implementing Kanban
Inventory System?
c) List out the 6 principles during the implementation process.
d) What is CONWIP System?
e) What are the Benefits of Kanban Inventory System?
ACTIVITY-16.5
List out few national or international companies which need Implementation of
Kanban? Explain any one among them why it needs Kanban.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
16.11 SUMMARY
Kanban (means signboard or billboard in Japanese) is a visual scheduling
system with ‘visual signal’ or ’card’ related to just-in-time (JIT)
inventory/production that tells “what – when – how much” to procure/produce.
Kanban system can visualize both – the planned workflow and the actual work
passing through the flow. A manufacturer always desires to make what the
customers want. The challenge is to know what exactly they want, and when
they want it. Lean manufacturing/ inventory is a philosophy of continuous
flow of product through the manufacturing process. There are Six Rules of
Toyota of Lean Inventory. There are two most important generally applied
types of Kanban Systems General Types of Kanban Systems, Customized
Types of Kanban Systems. In the Kanban process, there are Kanban Rules,
Kanban Cards, Kanban Bins, three-bin system and Heijunka Box.Many
manufacturers have been implementing electronic Kanban (e-Kanban) systems
to eliminate common problems such as manual entry errors and lost
cards. Kanban inventory management is a way to have ‘only the minimum
amount of stock on hand’ that is necessary at that time. This avoids purchasing
excess than needed and also avoids allocating space to warehouse for the extra
inventory. Moreover, kanban avoids bottlenecks in the workflow. The
organization should prepare the ground and an ideal environment before
implementing, patience and careful monitoring during implementation Kanban.
CONWIP is CONstant Work In Progress. This system is more like the actual
idea of using supermarket shelves where the Kanban is the actual location on
the shop floor.
16.12 KEYWORDS
96
Kanban: a visual scheduling system for lean inventory and lean manufacturing.
JIT: Just-In-Time
WIP: work in progress
Push Kanban:Unlimited WIP and Demand Dependent
Pull Kanban: Limited WIP and Demand Focused
MRP: Material Requirement Planning
MTS: Make To Stock
ROL: Re-Order Level
Kanban cards: convey the need for more materials
Heijunka Box:The process never runs out of product
ERP: Enterprise Resource Planning
KISS: Kanban Inventory Scheduling System
KIMS: Kanban Inventory Management System
Red Signal: Bin empty
Yellow or Orange Signal: Bin having some quantity
Green Signal: Bin Full
TPM: Total Productive Maintenance
CONWIP: CONstant Work In Progress.
97