Art Therapy
Art Therapy
Art Therapy
Inclusion of an active and creative arts-based process provides opportunities for self-
expression, creativity and a nonverbal means of relating with other people. The art-form
brings a third object concrete (such as a recording or piece of art work), or experienced
(such as movement or heard sound)- into the matrix of relations within the group. Each
person brings their own unique creative and cultural identity. This can be explored as part
of the therapy with the potential to link this and expand their personal relationship and
use of the art-form as a ‘helping resource’ in their day-to-day lives. Arts therapies are
therefore well placed to help patients identify difficulties and strengths through the use of
the art-form in the varying interactions in the group. Use of the art-form can facilitate
exploration and expression of emotions and discovery of personal meaning in creative
activities, allowing experiences and learning through non-verbal and verbal
communication. Through creativity, imagination and play, patients are helped to explore
new or different emotional and cognitive experiences with support of both the group and
the therapist. The production of a piece of art is often cited as a means of strengthening
self-esteem by clients and can provide access to personal and interpersonal resources
which may be continued into wider daily and creative life in the community.
So far most of the reasons and purposes given apply to any kind of group. It is worth
drawing out the aspects of groupwork which are particularly enhanced by using art as the
group activity:
1. Everyone can join in at the same time, at their own level. The process of the
activity is important, and a scribble can be as much of a contribution as a finished
painting.
2. Art can be another important avenue of communication and expression, especially
when words fail. The spatial character of pictures can describe many aspects of
experience simultaneously.
3. Art facilitates creativity.
4. Art is useful in working with fantasy and unconscious.
5. Art products are tangible and can be examined at a later time.
6. Art can be enjoyable, and in a group this can lead to shared pleasure.
What Size of Group is Best?
Most art therapy and personal art groups, in common with other ‘small groups’, have a
membership of between six and twelve, although larger groups are occasionally
manageable. This size is important to ensure the following factors:
1. Members can maintain visual and verbal contact with all other members.
2. Group cohesiveness can be achieved.
3. There is an opportunity for each person to have an adequate share of time in
discussion.
4. There are enough people to encourage interaction and a free flow of ideas, and to
undertake group projects.
Although the classification above refers to stages of development, all three types of play
may be involved in the use of art. The first type will be part of exploring the use of art
materials, and the activities concerned with ‘media exploration’ will encourage this kind
of play, for both children and adults (who often wish they could recapture children’s play
capacity). The second type is part of the nature of art, which is a symbolic medium; any
painted image stands for something in the artist’s mind.
The third type of play can be involved in some of the art communication group games.
Many artists have used these elements of play to explore and experiment with media to
produce new forms and unexpected results.
However, this classification of types of play only goes so far. Play can never be defined
as one particular activity; rather, it comprises many kinds of activity, linked by an attitude
of non-literalness and enjoyment, known as ‘playfulness’. For instance, the same activity
may be playful or non-playful: two people chasing each other may be involved in a
serious situation, but if at the same time they are laughing it is usually safe to assume
they are playing. The characteristics of play may be summarized as follows:
Play is pleasurable and enjoyable.
Play is spontaneous and voluntary, and freely chosen.
Play involves active engagement on the part of the player.
Thus, play is a free, joyful activity—but also needs the limits outlined above in order to
be play. It is also usually a social activity.
The other quality on the list of characteristics is one which engages many teachers and
therapists. It is well known that children’s play is linked to their learning of language and
other cognitive skills, and to their practising of social roles. At another level, children
also re-enact problems and conflicts in a condensed form in their play. The non-literal
quality of play means that this can be done in safety, without fear of real consequences.
By representing a difficult experience symbolically, and going through it again, perhaps
changing the outcome, a child becomes more able to deal with the problem in real life.
Adults too need to develop or rediscover a sense of play, which can give them a much
needed ‘space’ away from the constraints of normal living, and help them to renew their
capacities for tackling life’s problems and opportunities. In Winnicott’s words: ‘It is play
that is the universal, and that belongs to health: playing facilitates growth and therefore
health; playing leads into group relations; playing can be a form of communication in
psychotherapy.
Games
Games can be seen as play activities which have become institutionalized. They belong to
Piaget’s third stage of play, involving explicit rules, which make up the very essence of
the game. Games are social activities, and the participants need to agree on the rules
before they can take part in the game. However, there need be nothing sacrosanct about
the rules—they can be changed at will to produce an entirely new game. In a worthwhile
game the rules will be flexible enough to allow for many levels of response, resulting in
an enjoyable playful activity.
Many group leaders have found that games can stimulate enjoyable learning
experiences, and there has been a burgeoning of literature on ‘growth games’, ‘new
games’, ‘co-operative games’—to mention just a few. Leaders in informal settings often
use games to start sessions, or to help people to make contact with each other.
Of course, a ‘games’ approach does not suit everyone: some people feel it would take
away from the seriousness of their work, and the respect of other professionals for them.
This depends to some extent on the ethos of the setting in which the activities take
place.
However, many group art activities can be seen as games, in the sense that they are
based on certain simple rules contained within the theme, which is usually flexible
enough to allow for many levels of response. Then, starting with a particular theme, we
could change the rules and see how this changes the activity. It is easier to see how this
might work if we look at a practical example.
Psychosexual Therapy
Sex can be a highly pleasurable, connecting and motivating experience for many people.
There are many reasons for moving towards sex, including procreation, pleasure, to gain
power or to express love for someone (e.g. Meston & Buss, 2007). Whatever the case
may be, sex can be rewarding, affirming and fun. However, sex can also be source of
significant difficulty and distress for others. Sexual difficulties such as pain with
penetration, erectile difficulties, low desire, early ejaculation and difficulties with
orgasm are fairly common (Mitchell et al., 2016). As well as impacting sexual pleasure,
sexual difficulties can affect many aspects of people’s lives and can contribute to
difficulties in relationships (Christopher & Sprecher, 2000), shame, embarrassment, low
self-confidence, anxiety and depression (Ayling & Ussher, 2008; Laumann et al., 2005;
Sotomayor, 2005). There is also considerable shame and stigma related to sexual
difficulties, which can inhibit professional support seeking (Gott & Hinchliff, 2003;
Sheppard et al., 2008).
Historical Evolution
The most well-known and widely used form of psychosexual therapy was initially
proposed by Masters and Johnson (Linschoten et al., 2016; Weiner & Avery-Clark,
2014). They introduced a behavioural approach to psychosexual therapy in which various
behavioural strategies are practiced to reduce avoidance of sex and re-introduce sexual
and sensual touch in a graded way. Examples of the behavioural interventions include
sensate focus (where couples progressively introduce or re-introduce sensual touch) and
vaginal trainers for pain with penetration.
Sigmund Freud proposed that personality development in childhood takes place during
five psychosexual stages, which are the oral, anal, phallic, latency, and genital stages.
During each stage, sexual energy (libido) is expressed in different ways and through
different body parts.
Psychosexual stages of development
These are an innately determined stages of sexual development through which,
presumably, we all pass, and which strongly shape the nature of our personality. Before
turning to the stages themselves, however, we must first consider two important concepts
relating to them: libido and fixation .
Libido.
It refers to the instinctual life force that energizes the id. Release of libido is closely
related to pleasure, but the focus of such pleasure and the expression of libido changes as
we develop. In each stage of development, we obtain different kinds of pleasure and
leave behind a small amount of our libido, this is the normal course of events. If an
excessive amount of libido energy is tied to a particular stage, however, fixation results.
Fixation
Fixation is an excessive investment of psychic energy in a particular stage of
psychosexual development which results in various types of psychological disorders.
It can stem from either too little or too much gratification during a stage, and in either
case the result is harmful. Since, the individual has left too much “psychic
energy” behind, less is available for full adult development. The outcome may be an adult
personality reflecting the stage or stages at which fixation has occurred. To put it another
way, if too much energy is drained away by fixation at earlier stages of development, the
amount remaining may be insufficient to power movement to full adult development.
Then an individual may show an immature personality and several psychological
disorders.
Psychosexual stages
Psychosexual Therapy
Psychosexual issues are sexual problems that have a psychological or emotional basis
rather than a physical one. There may be psychological or emotional blocks that affect
your ability to be intimate, for example. These sorts of issues are the focus of
psychosexual therapy.
The body and mind are inextricably linked. While psychosexual issues have emotional or
psychological roots, they can also lead to or be caused by physical issues. So, while
sexual problems can lead to feelings of guilt, stress, anxiety and depression, they may
also be caused by them. Many sexual problems are caused by anxiety, lack of confidence,
lack of knowledge, poor body image or communication and/or emotional problems.
And while physical issues can make your sex life problematic, these can lead to
psychological problems too. For example, an illness, condition or surgical procedure may
leave you feeling less desirable. Which makes you feel depressed. And depression can
affect your desire for sex. It’s a complicated two-way relationship.
Psychosexual therapy involves a brief type of psychoanalytic therapy which involves
exploring and understanding how emotional factors, not always experienced at the
conscious level, interfere with sexual performance and enjoyment. Often this involves
physical examination. Psychosexual therapy focuses on the experiences an individual and
their partner(s) have with sexual function/dysfunction, commonly referred to as sexual
difficulties.
The referral criteria include sexual problems such as:
Pain with sexual intercourse or altered sensation
Erectile dysfunction
Problems with orgasm
Ejaculation disorders
Loss of libido
body image issues related to sexual intimacy
compulsive sexual behaviours (sex and porn addictions)
Mismatched sex drives in a relationship, and/or differences in sexual preferences.
The term ‘mindfulness’ was originally derived from Pali (the language used in original
teachings of Buddha) word, sati and sampajan ̃ña that can be translated as consciousness,
memory, or judgement (Wallace & Bodhi, 2006). Although often associated with
Buddhist tradition, or even yogic tradition in Hindu (Miller, Fletcher, & Kabat-Zinn,
1995), the phenomenological nature of mindfulness can be found in most religious
traditions, for example, Tafakkur in Islam, Kabala in Judaism and the rosary in
Christianity (K. W. Brown & Cordon, 2009; Manikam, 2014).
Mindfulness-based Therapies
Mindfulness-based therapies are therapies that include mindfulness concepts in the
therapies to teach mindful awareness, ranging from formal meditation (e.g., sitting
quietly for 45 minutes) to informal exercises (e.g., bringing mindful awareness to daily
activities) (Baer, 2014). Despite the various types of mindfulness-based therapies, this
section focuses on Mindfulness Based Stress Reduction (MBSR), Mindfulness-Based
Cognitive Therapy (MBCT), Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT), and
Functional Analytic Psychotherapy (FAP).
MBCT was initially developed following the fact that Cognitive Behavioural Therapy
(CBT) experts on depression treatment John Teasdale, Mark Williams, and Zindel Segal
were unable to help people suffering from the depressive relapse, a tendency to feel
depressed again after recovered. Since MBSR became familiar, they integrated MBSR
and CBT into one therapy, known as MBCT (Baer, 2014; S. L. Shapiro & Carlson,
2017).
There is a distinction between CBT and MBCT in the mechanisms of behaviour changes.
CBT has three main theories: (1) cognition can affect behaviours, (2) cognition can be
identified and altered, (3) behaviour changes is affected by cognitive changes (Dobson &
Dozois, 2010), suggesting that CBT stresses the role of cognition in changing behaviours.
Clients are encouraged to change their thoughts so that they can change their behaviours.
However, in MBCT, clients are taught to see thoughts without judging. Instead of
replacing negative thoughts, clients are encouraged to create good relationships with
thoughts that arise in their mind (Baer, 2014; S. L. Shapiro & Carlson, 2017).
MBCT comprises eight sessions with 12 participants for two hours per week. Since
MBCT adapts MBSR, the exercises included in the programme are the same as MBSR,
except lovingkindness meditation. One of the unique techniques in MBCT is Three-
Minute Breathing Space. This technique consists of three steps: (1) focus on the internal
experiences of asking “What is my experience right now?” to notice the sensations
currently arising without judging, (2) pay attention to the sensations of the breath process,
(3) broaden awareness to the whole body without judging. Clients are required to practice
this technique every day, particularly when they feel overwhelmed (Baer, 2014; S. L.
Shapiro & Carlson, 2017).