C14 Terrace GSMBulletin 60
C14 Terrace GSMBulletin 60
C14 Terrace GSMBulletin 60
net/publication/303558720
Habitat and C-14 age dating oflignitic terrace sands - implications for uplift
on the Borneo coastline during the Holocene
CITATIONS READS
9 1,518
2 authors:
All content following this page was uploaded by John Jong on 14 December 2016.
Habitat and C-14 ages of lignitic terrace deposits along the northern
Sarawak Coastline
Franz L. Kessler1 & John Jong2
1
Curtin University of Technology, Department of Applied Geology, CDT 250, 98009 Miri, Sarawak
Currently at Lundin Malaysia BV, Lot 13A-01, Level 13A, Menara HLA,
No. 3 Jalan Kia Peng, 50450, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
Email address: [email protected]
2
JX Nippon Oil and Gas Exploration (Deepwater Sabah) Limited
Level 51, Menara 3 PETRONAS, Persiaran KLCC, Kuala Lumpur City Centre, 50088 Kuala Lumpur
Abstract: The young terraces fringing the Miri coastline from Miri to Bekenu are formed by lignitic sands, fossil wood,
and conglomeratic beds that contain reworked quartz pebbles derived from the older Tukau Formation. The sequence can
be subdivided into four sub-units: I. Basal Conglomerate, II. Sandstone with fossil wood and Ophiomorpha, III. Cross-
bedded lignitic sandstone, and IV. Bleached and weathered palaeosol. These sediments are indicative of a transgressive
near-shore, fluvial to marginal marine depositional environment, as water energy peaked in cross-bedded sandstone of Sub-
unit III. Radiometric C-14 based age determination in ten coastal locations indicates an age range from Late Pleistocene
to Early Holocene (28,570 + 230 to 8,170 + 50 years BP). Given the terraces were formed in the same environment, but
are now located at different elevations and appear to be block-faulted, it might imply significant tectonic movements in
the Holocene.
Keywords: terraces, Quarternary, Pleistocene, Holocene, Borneo, tectonics, Ophiomorpha, C-14 dating
INTRODUCTION there are no Tukau deposits on the Canada Hill, either due
Quarternary terrace deposits are very common along to non-deposition or erosion, and even the upper part of
the northern Sarawak coastline, often in conjunction with the Miri Formation is eroded. This observation points to
mangrove swamp, fluvial to marginal marine depositional the view, that a part of the Neogene sediment (upper Miri
environments, and these have been preserved on land, where Formation and Tukau Formation) has been eroded ahead
the terraces were uplifted above the present-day sea-level of the latest uplift, which supports the implication that the
(Kessler and Jong, 2011). The terrace deposits lie above a hill must have formed in relatively recent times. However,
marked angular unconformity that may have originated as oil industry workers have indicated from seismic and well
an intra-tidal abrasion surface (Kessler, 2005). Since 2009, data that most of the uplift occurred during the Pliocene
the Curtin University of Technology has carried out studies (post-Tukau Formation) until recent times. The potential
along outcrops flanking the new coastal road, between Miri presence of Quarternary tectonism, however, is particularly
and Niah (Figure 1). interesting from the angle of petroleum geology. Significant
In northern Sarawak, the terrace deposits were Quarternary tectonism would have considerable impact on
recognized early in the history of geologic research that hydrocarbon entrapment leading to potential fault movement
started at the onset of the 20th century, and are marked on and leakage of hydrocarbons trapped at the Miri Field.
Sarawak Oil Field’s maps (a precursor of Sarawak Shell) as This paper, in addition to characterize the depositional
early as 1930. Outside of the study area, terrace deposits are habitat of the terrace deposits also attempts, with the help of
reported near Sandakan (Lee, 1970), as well as near Kota additional field data and geo-chronological assessment, to
Belud, the Klias Peninsula and the Tutong area in Brunei find more evidence in support or otherwise of Quarternary
(Wilford, 1968). Liechti et al., (1960) mapped these terrace tectonism.
deposits at “low” and “medium” elevation overlying the
older Tukau, Lambir and Setap Shale Formations (Figure 2). STRATIGRAPHIC AND GEOLOGICAL SETTING
The current location of terrace deposits above present-day In the study area, located south of Miri along the coast
sea-level is also discussed by Tija (1983). Figure 3 shows (Figure 1), there may be more than one terrace levels (of
the Baram Delta stratigraphic nomenclature and schematic different location and different age); remnants of which are
lithostratigraphy of the study area. located SW of Miri near Kpg. Beraya, and can only be seen
In Miri, the Canada Hill is elevated up to almost 90 there. The largest terrace (this article) however, is a raised
m above mean sea level, and is formed by sandstones of beach shoulder, covers a coastal strip of 35 km length, and
the Miri Formation; remnants of terrace deposits are seen reaches typically 1 km wide inland, but occasionally extend
on the flanks and even on the top of hill, deposited above more than 10 km (in the Miri suburbs of Taman Tunku and
the eroded Miri Formation sandstones. It is also noted that Riam) towards inland. Sandal’s map (Figure 2) suggests
Franz L. Kessler & John Jong
that terraces in the Marudi area might also belong to the the coast (e.g., by block-faulting; Tija, 1983). However,
same system. The flat and sharp unconformity surface, the the currently available age data are insufficient for further-
base of the terrace deposits, was originated as a wave-cut reaching conclusions.
platform, perhaps similar to present-day examples along
the coast (Figure 4). Moving landwards, the fossil terrace Sedimentary Sequence of the Terrace Deposits
deposits exhibit a gradual thinning of the section, sometimes Under the assumption that we are dealing with one
onlapping against older formations. At one locality, a coastal single sedimentary sequence, there are a wide variety
beach conglomerate could be identified (Figure 5). In the of environments to be resolved ranging from episodic
Sungai Rait Valley (Sample Point No. 9), terraces are seen high energy (cross-bedded sand layers, quartz pebble
fringing a “palaeo-island”, with the core of the island formed conglomerates); lignite and tree trunks (very low energy
by weathered clastics of the Tukau Formation, which are marsh); desiccation cracks (intermediate drying-up of
particularly quartz-rich and hold many layers of quartz sediment), and a very meager fossil record (Ophiomorpha-
pebbles that formed an erosion-resistant hill. type only).
The terrace deposits overlie unconformably the older The tree trunks are possibly the best milieu-indicators,
Miri, Tukau and Lambir Formations (Figures 1 & 6); they indicating that the sedimentary environment was inter-tidal
are in general flat-lying, hence the different elevations to supra-tidal. The tree-trunk layer is characterized by
above sea-level. Interestingly, the sea-level curve in Figure fine-medium sand, and contains Ophiomorpha burrows,
7 shows a drop in the Pleistocene, followed by a gradual possibly Callianassa sp. The tree-trunk layer lies often
sea-level rise until present-day. For this reason, given there buried beneath a high energy coarse-grained sand, that is
was no higher sea-level observed during the last 30,000 conglomeratic in places.
years compared to present-day, the current locations of the
terrace deposits cannot be explained by sea-level changes,
but point instead towards differential uplift in segments of
Figure 1: Top - Google Earth view of the Baram Delta, Miri City,
and coastal areas. The inland-boundary of the studied terraces, is
shown as an orange line. Arrows show sample points and numbers.
Bottom - sketch that shows the relative elevation of the terraces in
respect to position above sea-level, and the underlying formations.
The width of the purple colour indicates measured thickness of the
terraces deposits. The lowest elevation of the terraces above sea- Figure 3: Baram Delta stratigraphic nomenclature and schematic
level is noted near Bakam, where the underlying Tukau Formation lithostratigraphy of northern Sarawak with key onshore exploration
has maximum thickness. wells (Nippon Oil).
of quartz pebble components vary. In the terrace deposit sand to hard, consolidated sandstone. The cross-bedded
at the Beraya Boathouse (near Sample Point No. 7), Sub- lignitic sands contain quartz pebbles, and were deposited
unit III reaches a thickness of 4 m, which is the largest in a high energy, probably fresh water, near-shore fluvial
thickness seen in the study area. This sub-unit is cross- channel system.
bedded, contains varying amounts of lignite and quartz
pebble conglomerates within the cross-bedded sequence.
This layer is devoid of any bioturbation. Quartz clasts are
milky-white, more rarely clear crystalline quart and probably
stems from eroded quartz dykes and quartz layers within
the anchi-metamorphic Rajang Group. Among the medium-
grained sands, possible (< 1%) volcanic glass fragments and
heterolithics are observed. The sediment varies from loose
Table 1: Summary of the 10 sampled terrace locations for radiometric C14 age dating. Samples were taken mainly from Sub-units II
(fossil wood), and Sub-unit III (lignitic cross-bedded sands) given their organic content.
Sample Northing Easting Altitude (m) Above formation, Thickness Area C-14 Age
Index dip, dip direction (years BP)
1 04° 13.596’ 113° 55.149’ 18 20° NW, Tukau >1m Sewa Yaya 24,150 ± 170
2 04° 19.757’ 113° 59.931’ 23 5° NW, Tukau >1m Taman Tunku 25,580 ± 190
3 04° 15.174’ 113° 55.758’ 14 13° NW, Tukau >2m Bakam Sandpit 18,880 ± 140
4 04° 21.996’ 113° 58.160’ 38 30° NW, Miri > 1.5 m Miri Jalan Tanjung 24,140 ± 170
5 04° 21.107’ 113° 59.801’ 30 Probably Tukau >2m Riam 28,570 ± 230
6 04° 09.140’ 113° 51.169’ 23 80° NW, Lambir 2-3 m Coastal road 8,880 ± 50
7 04° 02.153’ 113° 53.555’ 17 70° NW, Lambir 2-3 m Coastal Road 16,360 ± 80
8 04° 07.403’ 113° 49.289’ 22 50° NW, Lambir 1-2 m Tusan Cliff 15,550 ± 80
9 04° 15.293’ 113° 56.955’ 21 25° NW, Tukau 1-2 m Sungai Rait Valley 11,230 ± 60
10 04° 11.376’ 113° 52.708’ 16 45° NW, Tukau >4m Beraya Boatshouse 8,170 ± 50
Sub-unit IV: Bleached, weathered palaeosol Table 2: Percentage of lignite within the terrace deposit.
This sub-unit occupies the top section of the terrace
deposits, and is commonly composed of loose, white sand, Area Lignite (weight %, range)
often more than 2 m thick. The original texture within this Bakam 5 – 10 ( 6 samples)
layer is difficult to reconstruct, since the unit is heavily Tanjung Lobang 6.5 – 7.3 (6 samples)
bleached and components other than quartz have been Coastal Road, Beraya 4.45 (1 sample)
removed. The occurrence of quartz pebbles is noted. Possibly, Coastal Road, SG Uban 0.58 – 7.71 (6 samples)
Canada Hill 2.8 – 4.4 (8 samples)
the layer was formed originally by lignitic sandstone such
as described in Sub-unit III.
The sediment was found to be relatively rich in antimony
SAMPLE ANALYSIS and tin for trace elements (Table 3). However, currently
Lignitic sandstone samples collected from 10 terrace there is no explanation for their richness in the terrace
locations (Figure 1) were extracted, and studied by the sediments and further studies will be required to study the
authors, assisted by Curtin University students undertaking provenance of both trace elements. The samples do not
their final year B.Sc. mapping project. Coordinates and other contain any bitumen (no color change with toluene, and
parameters of sample locations are summarized in Table 1. offer no fluorescence under UV lamp).
The following laboratory tests were carried out: analysis
of carbon content; sediment composition and petrography; C-14 Age Determination
and composition of lignite. In addition, C-14 ages were Field observations, in the context of stratigraphy, the
determined by the Poznan Radiocarbon Laboratory (Poland). presence of buried wood and degree of minor compaction
suggested that the sediments might possibly be younger than
Burning/Combustion Tests and Percentage of 50,000 years, allowing for the radiometric C-14 analysis
Lignite to be used for age dating of the terrace deposit samples.
Several samples were taken from Sample Point No. 6 The summary of sample locations and the results of C-14
and 7 of Sub-units II and III to analyze the amount of organic analysis are indicated in Table 1, which include age dates
material. Examination of the organic-rich material under the and uncertainty ranges. The data (all samples are taken from
microscope showed the lignitic clasts are equally distributed Sub-units II and III) indicate a range of ages from Late
between sand grains, probably due to sorting within the Pleistocene to Early Holocene (28,570 + 230 to 8,170 + 50
shoreface environment. Lignitic (weight) percentage in years BP). This means the terrace sediments were deposited
the sediment is established as follows: A lignite-bearing during a period of continuous sea-level rise, and that their
sample is dried, and then heated to 800°C, for 5 minutes. current elevation above sea-level suggests that uplift took
Ash is removed by sieving, and the weight of the lignite- place in recent times.
free sediment compared to the original sample weight. The
lignite percentage (weight) was found to be in the range of DISCUSSION OF RESULTS
2 to 10 % (Table 2). Given the terraces are found at very different elevations,
one would argue that they cannot originate from a sea-
Trace Elements (XRF Analysis) level change alone. Broadly speaking, the dated sediments
The coaly sediment (Sub-unit III, Sample Point No. 1, correspond to an interval of mild sea-level drop, followed by
Sewa Jaya) was also analyzed using a hand-held XRF tool. a rapid and significant sea-level rise (Figure 7). The sediment
Table 3: Trace element composition of lignite-bearing terrace perhaps mangrove estuaries, and characterize a generally
sediments (measurement 1, measurement 2), from Sewa Jaya S of low energy environment, comparable to the present-
Miri, Sub-unit III. Note the relative abundance of Sb, Sn and the day Brunei Bay. This unit might equate to a highstand
complete lack of Fe, as a result of bleaching and quantitative removal. system tract (HST).
ELEMENT ppm (+/-) ppm (+/-) III This cross-bedded, fine-medium grained sand, and
Sb 150.90 63.30 107.30 68.20 occasionally pebble-rich unit contains significant
Sn 161.40 47.20 94.90 50.50 amount of lignite; hence constitutes a layer of reworked
marshland under temporarily elevated water energy, as
Cd 71.20 23.80 56.10 25.70
for instance caused by a crevasse splay occurring on a
Ag 19.60 17.70 7.80 19.10 broken levee in the hinterlands. Possibly this unit might
Rb 1.70 2.30 1.10 2.40 correlate to an HST, but there is insufficient proof for
Se 3.00 3.00 2.30 3.10 such a conclusion.
Hg 0.20 4.40 0.40 4.80 IV Bleached and weathered palaeosol. Composition and
texture of this member is similar to Sub-unit III, however
Co 6.40 33.20 1.40 36.30
the rock has been bleached, with both lignite contents
Mn 1.60 53.20 0 51.70 and iron removed from the sediment.
Cr 0.60 77.70 14.00 85.90 Radiometric C-14 based age determination was carried
out in ten coastal locations, and samples were taken from
the organic-rich layers of Sub-units II and III . Data from
is marginal-marine to non-marine, and was deposited above C-14 analysis indicate an age range from Late Pleistocene
a marine abrasion platform. Possibly, the formation of the to Early Holocene (28,570 + 230 to 8,170 + 50 years BP).
terraces originated as a sea-level lowstand, as recorded by Given the terraces are found on several elevations, it implies
the documented shift in facies, followed by a sea-level rise, significant tectonic movement(s) after the Late Pleistocene/
and later, differential uplift of coastline segments due to Early Holocene period. The highest terrace deposits, dated
tectonic activity such as fault rejuvenation. The magnitude Pleistocene have been found on Canada Hill (Sample point
of faulting is best illustrated in the area of Miri City, where No. 4, Jalan Tanjung), which could indicate a particular
terraces are found at some 38 m (Jalan Tanjong, lower tectonic setting for the Canada Hill area.
Canada Hill), and the upper Canada Hill plateau (ca. 90 m).
As always, new data resolve problems but raise new ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
questions. One particular important question is, whether the We would like to thank Nippon Oil for contributing
terrace deposits constitute one single unit of sediments, or to Curtin’s R & D fund sponsorship, including the C-14
are composed by several distinct units welded together. A analysis. Gratitude is extended to the students of the Curtin
preliminary data analysis suggests, that samples taken near University’s petroleum geology program final year class
to the base of the laminated-lignitic sandstone sequence (2010) for their enthusiasm and dedication for both field
(Sub-unit II), are always delivering relatively old age values, studies and laboratory tests. We also like to thank Prof.
mostly around 20,000 years. Younger values (Holocene) are Denis Tan and Dr. Peter Barber for helpful constructive
found in sections of Sub-unit III in the greater Beraya area, reviews of an earlier version of the manuscript, whilst useful
where the sub-unit reaches its maximum thickness. Could it discussions on terrace deposits in the study area with Dr.
be that we are dealing here with a younger sequence that is Mario Wannier and Dr. Maarten Wiemer (Shell) are also
particular to this area only? It seems possible, and therefore gratefully acknowledged.
more C-14 and possibly other age dating methodologies
will be required to better answer this important question. REFERENCES
Frey, R.W, Howard, J.D. and Pryor, W.A., 1978. Ophiomorpha:
CONCLUSIONS Its morphologic, taxonomic, and environmental significance.
The young terrace deposits fringing the Miri coastline In: A.A. Ekdale (Ed.),Trace Fossils and their Importance
from Miri to Bekenu are formed by lignitic sands, fossil in Paleoenvironmental Analysis. Palaeogeography,
wood, and conglomeratic beds that contain reworked quartz Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 23, 199-229.
pebbles derived from the older Tukau Formation. The Kessler, F.L., 2005. Comments on the evolution of Bukit Lambir
sequence can be subdivided into four sub-units: area. PGCE Bulletin 2005, Kuala Lumpur.
Kessler, F.L. and Jong, J., 2011. Habitat and C-14 age dating of
I A basal transgressive muddy conglomerate located
lignitic terrace sands – implications for uplift on the Borneo
on an abrasion surface, containing reworked material coastline during the Holocene. Warta Geologi 37, 36.
from the underlying Tukau Formation; there may be a Lee, D.T.C., 1970. Sandakan Peninsula, Eastern Sabah, Eastern
significant hiatus between the abrasion surface and the Malaysia. Geol. Survey of East Malaysia, Report No.6.
transgressive system tract (TST) of Sub-unit I deposits. Liechti, P., Roe, F.W. and Haile, N.S., 1960. The geology of Sarawak,
II This clayey sandstone unit contains fossil wood, tree Brunei, and the western part of North Borneo. British Territories
stems and tree roots, and Ophiomorpha burrows. These in Borneo Geol. Survey Dept. Bull. 3, Kuching.
indicators are suggestive for a swampy environment, Pillans, B., Chappel, J. and Naish, T.R., 1998. A review of
Milankovitch climatic beat: template for Plio-Pleistocene of Negara Brunei Darussalam. BSP and Brunei Museum Seria
sea-level changes and sequence stratigraphy, Sedimentary Publication, 243 p.
Geology 122, 5-21. Tija, H.D., 1983. Quarternary tectonics of Sabah and Sarawak, East
Pollard, J.E., Goldring, R. and Buck, S.G., 1993. Ichnofabrics Malaysia. Sains Malaysiana, 12, 191-215.
containing Ophiomorpha: significance in shallow-water facies Wilford, G.E., 1968. Notes on the geomorphology of Sabah. In:
interpretation. Journal of the Geological Society, 150, 149-164. Collenette, P. and Goh, J. (Eds.), Geological Papers 1967. Geol.
Sandal, S.T. (Ed.), 1996. The Geology and Hydrocarbon Resources Survey Borneo Region, Malaysia, Bull. 9, 1-22.