Bep141 PDF Eng 2
Bep141 PDF Eng 2
Bep141 PDF Eng 2
os
rP
BEP141
January 31, 2012
yo
CHAPTER FOUR
Harvard Business Publishing distributes in digital form the individual chapters from a wide selection of books on business from
publishers including Harvard Business Press and numerous other companies. To order copies or request permission to
reproduce materials, call 1-800-545-7685 or go to http://www.hbsp.harvard.edu. No part of this publication may be
reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, used in a spreadsheet, or transmitted in any form or by any means – electronic,
mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise – without the permission of Harvard Business Publishing, which is an
affiliate of Harvard Business School.
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of
copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
rP
yo
op
tC
No
Do
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
CHAPTER 4
rP
Leading Project Managers:
The Project Executive Role
yo
Managing a portfolio
Making data-based
to implement
decisions (chapter 7) Competing objec- strategy (chapter 2)
tives to achieve
1. Executive vs.
Understanding IT Manager
2. Capability vs. Sponsoring
opportunities and
successful projects
op
challenges (chapter 6) Results
(chapter 3)
3. Projects vs.
Operations
4. Function vs.
Listening to customers, Function Leading project
employees, and
managers (chapter 4)
processes (chapter 5)
tC
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
76 STRATEGIC LEADERSHIP OF PORTFOLIO
rP
Founded in 1932, Messer is a full-service complex commercial con-
struction company specializing in building for health care, higher
education, and life sciences. For many years at Messer Construction
Company, we observed the performance of Project Managers and were
challenged by the fact that while they were achieving high results,
results would vary from one project to the next. This cyclical pattern
didn’t follow typical logic in that since the Project Manager had gained
yo
more experience on the previous project, he should be able to apply
that experience at a higher level and achieve higher results on subse-
quent projects. The challenge is that with this variation in results, it is
far more difficult to predict outcomes that would accomplish a con-
sistent and successful project and overall company business plan. Our
interest then became a study of what causes variation in performance.
op
The key question Messer Construction leaders faced is how can
they effectively lead their project managers in efforts to consistently com-
plete successful projects? This is the classic question regarding leadership
of project managers and the subject of this chapter.
tC
Project Executives
A project executive supervises one or more project managers as direct
reports and is coresponsible for delivering project results with the sponsor
and project manager. He provides functional resources, governs methods
used on the project, helps the PM develop, and delivers project results
No
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
LEADING PROJECT MANAGERS 77
rP
visor of a project manager. While coaching and task responsibilities are
somewhat overlapping, we find it helpful to remind executives that there
are some duties they must do as well as those to help develop the project
manager. If the executive is also serving as sponsor, the responsibilities
described in the previous chapter also apply.
yo
Project Managers
A project manager is an individual who is responsible for leading a team
that creates unique products and/or services on a temporary basis to meet
the needs of one or more customers subject to constraints of time, money,
and other resources. We now introduce two global standards and one
op
rapidly emerging trend that may become a standard in describing the role
of project managers.
A classic, yet limited definition of the project manager’s aims is “to achieve
tC
the project objectives.”2 Yet this same global source, the PMBOK ® Guide,
also discusses several responsibilities the project manager must accept in
order to achieve the project objectives including:
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
78 STRATEGIC LEADERSHIP OF PORTFOLIO
rP
ager’s role from the UK project management standard (PRINCE2).
The PRINCE2 definition of a project manager is “the person given the
authority and responsibility to manage the project on a day-to-day basis
to deliver the required products within the constraints agreed with the
Project Board.”4
PMBOK ® Guide and PRINCE2 both use a stage gate model to
yo
describe the flow of project work with the need for stage ending delivera-
bles to be accepted and organize a project manager’s responsibilities into
multiple process groups or themes. The PMBOK ® Guide has the nine
process groups of integration, scope, time, cost, quality, human resources,
communications, risk, and procurement.5 PRINCE2 uses the seven
themes of: business case, organization, quality, plans, risks, changes, and
op
progress.6
A trend that has proven to be very popular in software development
projects and is spreading to some other types of projects is known as agile.
Agile project management is an iterative method of determining require-
ments for development projects. It requires an empowered project team,
with frequent supplier and customer input. Agile techniques are best used
tC
in small-scale projects or projects that are too complex for the customer
to understand and specify before testing prototypes. Project outputs are
delivered in small increments every two to four weeks.7 In an effort to
sound truly different, the equivalent of a project manager in an agile envi-
ronment is called a ScrumMaster. The ScrumMaster is responsible for
making sure a team lives by agile values and practices. The ScrumMaster
No
In this book, we will primarily use the larger global standard (PMBOK ®
rP
Guide) with ideas and techniques from the other two approaches. In
short, a project manager leads a team in developing an understanding
of the customers needs and desires (often in an iterative fashion). The
project manager is responsible for delivering products and/or services
that will satisfy those needs and desires, subject to constraints, risks,
and to managing changes that may come from customers or other
yo
sources.
Stage-by-stage responsibilities for both project executives and pro-
ject managers are outlined in Table 4.1. In the following section we
describe what project managers need to do at each point in the project
life so the executive who leads them can understand their duties. The
final major section of this chapter describes the responsibilities of
op
project executives.
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
80 STRATEGIC LEADERSHIP OF PORTFOLIO
rP
Project manager Project execu-
(PM) tive (PE) task PE coaching
Stage responsibilities responsibilities responsibilities
Overarching Satisfy customers, Oversee PM, Empower and
deliver promised Provide resources, promote PM, help
results on time & on Provide subject area PM with leadership,
budget, support team decision-making communications, and
decisions, manage and continuity, lead “big picture” under-
yo
communications, improvement within standing, help PM with
champion project functional area project team, leader-
ship team, sponsor, and
stakeholders, balance
quality and urgency
focus
Selecting Help identify and Participate in project Coach PM to identify
justify rationale for selection (if member and justify rationale for
op
potential projects of leadership team) potential projects
Initiating Write charter rough Recommend direct Help PM understand
draft with team, nego- report to be selected requirements, help PM
tiate charter as PM, Help PM understand charter con-
with sponsor develop business case cept and methods, help
for project, work PM incorporate lessons
with sponsor on busi- learned from previous
tC
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
LEADING PROJECT MANAGERS 81
their need for changes, help the customer understand the impact of the
changes on the project schedule and budget, and then make the changes
rP
the customer desires. The project manager is then expected to deliver the
revised deliverables according to any agreed upon revisions in the sched-
ule and budget.
Project managers facilitate teams through meetings that often include
a series of thought expansion (when exploring options) and focusing
(when selecting approaches) efforts. To do this, they:
yo
• Ask questions,
• Establish order out of chaos,
• Create detailed and unified project plans, and
• Think many times and then act decisively.9
op
The project manager needs to support team decisions, champion
the project, and manage project communications. Often, project
team members will have differing opinions. The project manager
needs to ensure all opinions are heard, and decisions are made with
qualitative and quantitative data. Once decisions are made, all pro-
ject team members need to support the decisions so the project team
tC
speaks with one voice. The project manager typically spends a large
amount of time advocating for the project by communicating with
many stakeholders.
decisions with projects. They decide if the expected project benefits (dis-
counted for risks) appear to be worth the investment in cash and other
resources needed to complete the project.
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
82 STRATEGIC LEADERSHIP OF PORTFOLIO
rP
the team in developing a draft charter and then negotiate it with the
sponsor to authorize the project. As we have emphasized, one of the
most important project management documents is the charter. The char-
ter is a high-level project plan. Both the typical contents and process
of developing charters are described in chapter 3. Sponsors have more
organizational power than project managers, but the charter should still
yo
be negotiated. The project manager needs to express his strongly held
opinions on approach and feasibility. At the end of the negotiation, both
sponsor and project manager should be in agreement on all portions of
the charter and feel it is realistic.
depending on the project size, risk, and complexity. This work includes
developing the plans for communications, scope, schedule, budget, and
project team.
rP
munications. Project managers often discover that various stakeholders
have some of the same communication needs. In these cases, the project
manager can simplify the communications by using some of the same
communications for these groups.
yo
The project manager and team then ask each stakeholder what their
requirements are for the project. These requirement lists are often quite
long and contradictory, so prioritization decisions need to be made—
often with the help of the sponsor and/or project executive. On some
projects the requirements for the entire project can be determined at the
outset, on other projects the team decides to plan the early part of the
op
project in detail right away and plan future portions as results from early
parts provide additional detail that help with the later planning.
In either case, the requirements are then normally used to create a work
breakdown structure (WBS). The WBS is an outline of all of the delivera-
bles that will be created on the project, broken down into fine enough detail
tC
so the work to create each can be accurately estimated, and one person can
be held accountable to both plan and create each deliverable.
Project schedules can be tricky as they may be limited by any or all of the
No
the project manager and team can estimate the schedule. This begins
by determining the work activity needed to produce each deliverable
rP
identified in the WBS. Once the activities are understood, they can be
sequenced by asking what can begin immediately, what can begin next,
etc. Teams often write one activity per sticky note and place them on a
work surface so the team can debate the most logical order.
The project manager and team need to estimate how long each work
activity will take to complete. This should be done by envisioning who will
yo
do the work, what is involved, and what other commitments the workers
have. The duration estimates for each activity can then be combined with
the logical order already determined to estimate a possible schedule. This
first cut at a schedule may be too long, in which case the logical order
and/or the duration of individual activities need to be reconsidered. This
first cut schedule, however, may actually need to be lengthened when
op
worker availability, imposed dates (such as fiscal year demands), and cash
flow are considered.
A project budget can be developed from the schedule. Each work activity
tC
needs to be estimated at whatever rate per hour the worker costs. Many
work products also require materials, equipment, and other expenses.
Once the total project costs are forecast, they need to be put in a cash
flow according to the schedule. At that point, it is possible that the cash
flow coming in may limit how rapidly project expenses can be paid out—
thereby slowing the project progress.
No
time. As more planning details are determined, the need for more work-
ers, especially those with a particular expertise, begins to emerge. A pro-
ject manager will identify those needs and identify where those workers
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
LEADING PROJECT MANAGERS 85
rP
unproven workers, a project manager may need help from either sponsor
or project executive to secure the promise of at least some experienced
staff.
yo
In this section, we focus on the project manager responsibilities that
occur when the project team is executing work to satisfy the agreed upon
requirements. These responsibilities include working with the project
team, risks and changes, progress, and results.
Remembering that the most important project success criteria are sat-
isfying customers and delivering on promises, one might think that devel-
oping a project team is of less importance. However, developing both
individual team members and the project team as a whole is important
both to accomplish the work of the project and to groom workers for
more responsibility. The best project managers see projects as ideal train-
No
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
86 STRATEGIC LEADERSHIP OF PORTFOLIO
rP
the project manager is responsible for overall project results.
The project manager normally leads the team through risk identifica-
tion, assessment, and response planning when creating the project char-
yo
ter. The project manager needs to make sure that the person who was
assigned responsibility for each major risk during chartering continually
monitors for indicators that the risk event may be coming and starts the
response plan if appropriate. On many of the larger risks, the project
manager is the person responsible for these actions. Typical responses to
negative risks (threats) either attempt to lower the probability of the risk
event from occurring or lower the impact to the project if the risk event
op
does occur. Conversely, typical responses to positive risks (opportunities)
either increase the probability of the event occurring or further capitalize
upon the results if it does occur. Additionally, the project manager should
periodically lead the team in efforts to uncover new risk events that were
not originally foreseen, but may occur due to changing circumstances.
tC
Project managers monitor both their personal work and that of their
team. The style of monitoring can vary from informal management by
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
LEADING PROJECT MANAGERS 87
rP
geographically. The level of detail and frequency a project manager needs
to monitor is often much more precise than what she, in turn, reports to
sponsors and customers.
Control is established by having a plan and comparing the monitored
progress against the plan. When the difference between plan and actual
(called variance) is too great, the project manager acts to get progress back
yo
on track. Again, this can range from an informal conversation with a team
member as they brainstorm alternatives, to formalized direction.
Customers and sponsors want to know that progress is being made.
Project managers and teams do not want to be micro-managed. The way
to satisfy both is to have a standard method and timing for reporting
progress. One way to envision this is to consider three time periods: the
op
immediate past (since the last report), the current (until the next report),
and the remainder until project conclusion. The report may include the
following:
Deliver Results
Do
The reason a project is conducted is that some customer wants the result-
ing deliverables. Therefore, the most important responsibility for a project
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
88 STRATEGIC LEADERSHIP OF PORTFOLIO
manager is to deliver results that the customers can use. One of the great
contributions of agile thinking in projects is the concept of incremental
rP
benefits. This means the customer should not need to wait until project
conclusion to receive any benefits from the project. To the extent possible
(it is easier on some types of projects than others), the project manager
should deliver drafts, prototypes, partial products, information, or other
interim deliverables as soon as possible to help the customer realize some
gain from the project early. Regardless of how many incremental benefits
yo
are possible the project manager is primarily accountable for delivering
any results that have been promised. That means all of the work with the
team, risks, quality, and reporting are merely means to help ensure the
project will deliver results.
been accepted by users and all needed support has been included. This often
means including instructions, warrantees, training, or other support. Since
the most important measure of project success is customer satisfaction,
merely transitioning deliverables, without the ability to use them, is not wise.
Project managers often do not formally evaluate team members—their
functional managers do. Project managers can do two things to lessen the
No
the performance review. Project managers can tell their team members
that they will be providing input to the performance evaluations.
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
LEADING PROJECT MANAGERS 89
The project manager often works with the sponsor to secure lessons
learned as described in sponsor responsibilities in the previous chapter. At
rP
this point, the project manager needs to formally close the project with all
workers and resources reassigned as appropriate.
yo
the project deliverables are able to use them. Were the benefits that were
promised during project selection delivered? Has the client capability
improved because of the project deliverables and has the company capa-
bility improved because of utilizing lessons learned from the project pro-
cess? Have any methods developed on the project been reused on other
projects and have any project results been used in additional ways beyond
op
the immediate project results? The project manager needs to schedule
and conduct a follow-up assessment to ascertain which of the promised
benefits have been realized.
The first part of this chapter described what a project manager needs
to do at each stage of the project life cycle. The remainder of the chap-
ter deals with what an executive needs to do when a project manager
directly reports to her. While some of these things can be delegated to
others such as a sponsor or a human resources person, the executive
No
stage we describe both task and coaching responsibilities for the project
executive.
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
90 STRATEGIC LEADERSHIP OF PORTFOLIO
The sponsor has primary responsibility for directing a project, the project
rP
manager has primary responsibility for managing the project, but the pro-
ject manager’s supervisor has responsibility to oversee the project manager
as the results of the project reflect on her part of the organization. Some-
times it can be a delicate dance to work effectively with a sponsor who
has differing goals.
yo
Lead in Functional Area
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
LEADING PROJECT MANAGERS 91
rP
specific performance goals such as:
yo
Help the Project Manager Communicate Effectively
nel in this process is between you and the project manager who reports
directly to you. To the extent you can have frequent, rapid, and candid
conversations, you set the stage for the project manager to have the same
kind of communications with a myriad of others.
Project executives often encourage managers to develop standard
approaches or even templates for communication needs such as:
Do
rP
• Communications matrix to outline who needs to know what,
when, and by what means,
• Risk register to outline major risks with strategy to handle
each and who is responsible,
• Progress reports to help key stakeholders understand progress
and challenges, and
yo
• Customer feedback to understand how users feel about both
the project methods and results.
Project managers often enjoy little position power because they often have
few if any direct reports. This means they cannot order something to be
op
done, but have to persuade others to perform. Leaders can encourage
project managers to develop other forms of power such as:
reality.
Another project-specific skill is to quickly lead her new team to develop
a common understanding of the upcoming project and then negotiate
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
LEADING PROJECT MANAGERS 93
it with a sponsor and possibly other key individuals. This requires the
ability to:
rP
• Understand projects are investments,
• Think in big pictures,
• Integrate various components,
• Envision how the schedule could play out,
• Foresee risks,
yo
• Understand people (the project team, sponsor, and key
stakeholders), and
• Be willing to suggest the project may be a nonstarter if the
risks are too high.
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
94 STRATEGIC LEADERSHIP OF PORTFOLIO
rP
the outset to help ensure the project gets off to a good start. As the pro-
ject manager proves he understands the big picture of where the project
fits and what is most critical to key stakeholders, more and more detail
and visibility can be given to the project manager. By encouraging the
project manager to empower core team members, the project manager
will have more capacity for higher level decision-making.
yo
The last portion, and perhaps most important, in personally leading a
project manager is to always have the goal of retaining and even promot-
ing the project manager for the future. This implies continually keeping
an eye open for development opportunities, but also trying to help the
project manager have a sense that he wants to remain at your company.
This may include both monitoring the project manager’s feelings and pro-
op
moting advantages of staying with the company.
The project executive, like all other employees, needs to identify potential
projects that may help to further the organization’s strategic plan. The
tC
on how to write very brief business cases will serve the project manager
well. Project managers need to be able to briefly describe what a project
involves and why it is important. Project managers need to actively pro-
mote their project to many audiences at many levels.
rP
Projects are typically initiated (made official) by a signed charter. The
most essential element of a charter is the business case. Project executives
can help their project managers develop compelling business cases by get-
ting them to consider three questions. First, how is the project strategi-
cally aligned to one or more company goals? Second, what is the return
on investment of time and money? Third, what is the emotional hook
yo
that will convince members of the leadership team to select the project
and will convince the project team and other stakeholders to persevere
through tough spots?
Part of the wisdom a seasoned executive hopefully brings is an adaptive
style based upon lessons learned from previous projects. Role-modeling
the adoption of what worked well in the past and how to change things
op
that worked poorly sends a clear message to project managers that they
need to do the same. Managers who do not use lessons learned keep
repeating previous mistakes and inefficiencies. Part of leading in an adap-
tive style is also being flexible. No two projects are exactly alike and
flexibility within normal good practice and procedures is essential.
Projects are performed to satisfy a need. Requirements gathering ses-
tC
sions are often conducted to elicit needs and wants from various stake-
holders. While more in-depth requirements gathering will occur during
planning, a project executive helps her project manager by insisting that
high-level requirements be determined as early as possible.
No
Project executives can help project managers have more stature by visibly
supporting them. Setting clear expectations and delegating to the project
manager by stages both let the project manager understand exactly how
much authority he has, thereby increasing his confidence. Executives can
lead project managers by exception. That is, the project manager can lead
his team in the manner he wishes (subject to ethical standards and any
Do
mandatory policies and procedures) as long as the progress and results are
within a stipulated tolerance. Once the performance exceeds the toler-
ance, the executive can dictate.
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
96 STRATEGIC LEADERSHIP OF PORTFOLIO
Once a project manager understands the wants and needs of the myr-
iad stakeholders, it is time to prioritize them. She needs to make tradeoffs
rP
such as determining what features and functions will not be included,
which stakeholder demands are met first, or when schedule or budget
demands are loosened to allow more scope—or vice versa. As an execu-
tive with a big picture view of the organization, you can help ensure the
project manager makes sensible tradeoff decisions.
A special case of stakeholder alignment is the members of the pro-
yo
ject team—both core team and subject matter experts. A project execu-
tive can encourage their project manager to have one-on-one discussions
with each member to understand their personal goals. Often those can
be factored into the assignment of specific duties on the project. Effec-
tive project managers try to align personal goals with project goals to the
extent possible.
op
A project-specific skill is creating and managing project schedules.
Developing realistic project schedules is an iterative activity that takes
into account many factors. A project executive helps her project manager
by imposing as few arbitrary dates as possible and working with the pro-
ject manager to resolve key worker availability and cash flow issues.
The project manager has primary goals of satisfying customers and
tC
will be times when everything is not going well. A seasoned project execu-
tive often develops a sense for when apparent failure partway through
a project really is a danger signal and when it represents acceptable
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
LEADING PROJECT MANAGERS 97
rP
the other hand, you may want to intervene more cautiously and carefully
to emphasize how you are empowering the project manager.
You will also want to help your project managers develop a feel for
when to let their team members or other stakeholders work and when
to intervene. By encouraging the project manager to monitor both team
members’ motivations and their ongoing morale, it will be easier for him
yo
to determine when to intervene.
Project executives can discuss an escalation process with their project
managers before it needs to be used. Project managers have more confi-
dence when they understand the limits on the type, size, and timing of
issues they can personally decide versus those that need to be escalated.
Timely and clear communication also gives project managers confi-
op
dence and authority to make decisions when needed. Helping the pro-
ject manager understand when she needs to wait for more information
and when she needs to make a rapid decision also empowers her. As the
project manager performs well, showing that you have confidence in
her and giving her more authority to make bigger decisions continues
the empowerment process. Having the project manager capture, share,
tC
and use lessons learned to better manage provides more knowledge and
confidence.
Since many project schedules are critically important, it may be nec-
essary to quickly remove a project manager who is not performing. It is
often necessary to replace a project manager more rapidly than a func-
tional manager.
No
Hopefully, the sponsor has ensured that quality measures are des-
cribed for each milestone. The project executive can be helpful in focus-
ing efforts on those quality measures. As the project progresses, the
project executive will often observe how the project manager keeps track
of and deals with:
information permit,
• Risks that increase or decrease in probability and sometimes
occur,
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
98 STRATEGIC LEADERSHIP OF PORTFOLIO
rP
• Project communications that can enhance or detract from
performance.
yo
• Show support for the project manager,
• Provide ongoing direction to help the project manager stay
aligned with higher level goals,
• Suggest possible improvements to the project process or
results (as long as those changes do not adversely impact
op
project priorities),
• Consider opportunities for the larger organization to gain in
new ways from the project, and
• Recommend anything up to and including project cancella-
tion so the company does not throw good money after bad in
a losing cause.
tC
back on schedule, the project manager may need to take actions to reduce
the project scope, overlap sequential activities, temporarily increase work-
load of individuals, or acquire additional workers. At the extreme, a pro-
ject may truly be failing and the project manager either needs to rescue
it by extreme means or suggest terminating it. Any of these may require
approval from the sponsor and/or other key stakeholders.
When you have a project manager reporting to you, insisting that
Do
they use standard approaches and templates will help them to control
information and help you to have confidence in them. Meeting manage-
ment can be a particular communication challenge to project managers.
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
LEADING PROJECT MANAGERS 99
Meetings are important as key decisions get made and lots of expensive
staff time is tied up in them. Project managers can be more effective in
rP
meeting management if they use:
yo
• Issues logs to add any pending decisions and remove those
that are resolved, and
• Meeting evaluations so meetings can progressively improve.
tially rewarded based on how well she managed regardless of the challenge
faced.
One further challenge project managers often have is that team
members are evaluated by the functional manager they report to. Project
executives can encourage their project managers to communicate fre-
quently with functional managers and to provide input that may be used
No
rP
the benefits on most projects are impossible to determine until the results
have been used for a period. Project executives need to ensure that after
the results have been used for an appropriate length of time, the project
manager leads a benefits assessment. Several types of questions can be
asked. Were the project deliverables as useful as promised? Are any of
them able to be reused in different circumstances beyond the original
yo
plan? Are any of the methods developed on the project useful in other
situations?
Lessons Learned
Project executives have found six specific ways to help their project
managers learn.
(Continued)
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
LEADING PROJECT MANAGERS 101
agendas and goals so they can all be accomplished while assuring a suc-
cessful completion of a project as defined by the client.
rP
2. Achieve Success on Unique Projects
Another dynamic is that this team is building something that has never
been built before. As said earlier, each project is widely different than
the next, and we get one shot at it. While these two dynamics are alone
challenging, the additional forces on the projects are that they need to
yo
be completed more safely, faster, for less cost, with high quality and
higher overall value—all in an environment that is not typically con-
ducive to the construction process.
many others in creating this value, the project success will be directly
affected. The key to this success is leadership—they ability to influ-
ence the outcomes by personally engaging the stakeholders. The pri-
mary responsibility of the Senior Project Executive, in leading multiple
Project Managers, is to grow their individual leadership abilities.
performance.
(Continued)
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
102 STRATEGIC LEADERSHIP OF PORTFOLIO
rP
institutional knowledge so that we could share it with leaders across the
company. Today we call it our “Center of Excellence.” Understanding that
evolving technology was going to play a major role in providing access to
information, we designed a program to allow all employees in all locations,
including remote jobsites, to be able access this knowledge whenever they
needed. This form of just-in-time learning radically improved our ability
to transfer knowledge—far better than traditional training.
yo
5. Share and Use Institutional Knowledge
Structurally, the Center of Excellence is set up primarily like a library,
with information arranged by the major divisions of construction
work with search capabilities. For each division of work, we identified
internal experts who were known for their expertise with this particu-
lar type of work. These experts came together and began the process
op
of downloading everything they knew about that work. This is not the
content you find in textbooks. This is information that only comes
from years of experience. The content includes:
• Best practices
tC
• Videos, and
• Anything that they could share about what worked in
creating successful outcomes.
would put them directly in contact with the internal experts for that
(Continued)
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
LEADING PROJECT MANAGERS 103
rP
yo
work. We continually add content to the Center of Excellence and are
op
migrating the Center to a more dynamic platform, which will allow
everyone to add content without having to channel it all through an
administrator.
The next opportunity to ensure Project Managers were perform-
ing at the highest level was to find a way to elevate how we share
information. The Center of Excellence is one way, but in order to
tC
(Continued)
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
104 STRATEGIC LEADERSHIP OF PORTFOLIO
rP
Messer has for years been the leader of the building construction process
focusing on delivering high value to the customer. One element of this
value proposition is quality. While we strive to deliver high quality on every
project, we are challenged in this effort mainly because a large portion
of construction projects are built by many different subcontractors—all
who share different definitions of quality. For our Project Managers, the
yo
creation and communication of the specific quality expectations for each
project is a continual process to assure each subcontractor’s definition of
quality is consistent with our definition of quality. Over time, we have
created many quality plans for the many projects we’ve built. Within a
discussion of best practices, the decision was made that we needed to
build further consistency in how communicate, plan, execute, assure and
sell quality at Messer. To accomplish this, a quality development team
op
was established to focus creating an overall Messer quality framework as
well as the tools necessary to carry out quality construction processes. The
elements of the quality system are as follows:
“Quality Leadership System”
2. Project Processes
3. Quality System Administration Tools
4. Building Information Modeling
5. Exterior Building Commissioning
6. Building Systems Commissioning
7. Prefabrication
No
8. Lean Construction.
(Continued)
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
LEADING PROJECT MANAGERS 105
rP
our nine regions, pilot project feedback on the QLS process plus best
practices communicated to a quality steering committee, refinement
of the QLS based on the feedback received, establishing quality cham-
pions within each of our nine regions to facilitate real-time support,
and then company-wide Operations training and implementation
on all projects. Beyond Operations, the QLS will be introduced to
all corporate support functions to result in a QLS across the entire
yo
company.
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
106 STRATEGIC LEADERSHIP OF PORTFOLIO
rP
Executives Setting Strategy and Managers Implementing It
yo
project progress can continually consider additional ways project results
may benefit the company. They ensure timely and clear communication
with the project manager, help the project manager understand and man-
age stakeholder needs, and help the project manager understand how the
project is an investment in the company’s future.
op
Sustainable Organizational Capability and Achieving
Current Business Results
learned to both improve the current and future projects. They demon-
strate to project managers how to use judgment on when to intervene,
understanding that quick interventions may lead to current results while
delayed interventions may lead to employee development. Executives
need to use judgment on replacing the project manager since quickly
replacing often yields immediate benefits while a struggling project man-
No
ager may learn. Effective executives lead the project manager with a goal
of keeping and promoting him, establish and use appropriate perfor-
mance goals, and set clear expectations for the project manager.
goals by encouraging the project manager to plan for and use open com-
munications with various stakeholders. They can establish some common
performance expectations for both project managers and functional
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860
t
os
LEADING PROJECT MANAGERS 107
rP
tional managers for possible inclusion in team members’ performance
reports.
yo
with the project sponsor to support the project. She can help the project
manager communicate effectively with all stakeholders and help the pro-
ject manager prioritize stakeholder expectations.
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Diana Muslimova, WU Vienna University of Economics and Business
until Mar 2024. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright. [email protected] or 617.783.7860