Public Finance

B.Com 5th Sem.
Subject- Public Finance
SYLLABUS
Class – B.Com. V Sem.
Subject – Public Finance
Unit-I Public finance: Meaning, nature, scope and importance,

difference between private and public finance. Principle of
maximum social advantage. Role of state in public finance.
Unit-II Sources of revenue: taxes, loans, grants and aid – meaning and
types, canons of taxation, problem of justice in taxes, incidence
of taxation, taxable capacity. Impact of taxation & tax evasion
characteristics of Indian tax system, defects & steps of reform.
Unit-III Principle of public expenditure, principle of public depth and
its methods of redemption. Effects of public expenditure on
production and distribution public debt in India.
Unit-IV Public finance in India: sources of revenue of central and state
govt. concept and types of budget, Fiscal Deficit, Deficit
financing and deficit budget, financial relation between central
and state.
Unit-V Constitution and function of finance commission,
recommendation of latest finance commission, latest budget of
central and MP govt. financial relations between central &
state govt., main head of revenue & expenditure of central &
state govt.
45, Anurag Nagar, Behind Press Complex, Indore (M.P.) Ph.: 4262100, www.rccmindore.com
1
B.Com 5th Sem. Subject- Public Finance
UNIT-I
Public Finance: Meaning, Nature and importance
Introduction
The State in modern times is called a welfare State. The activities of such a modern welfare State have
vastly increased. For a smooth performance of these functions the State nee& finance. Thus public
finance means the finances of public bodies—national, State or local—for the performance of their
functions. The term 'finance' may also refer to financial management and administration. Public finance
thus means the administration of the financial operations of the public authorities. It refers to that
branch of Economics which deal with the income and expenditure of public bodies and the principles,
problems and policies relating to these matters.
Definition
Carl Plehn defines public finance as. "The science which deals with the activity of statesman in
obtaining and applying the material means necessary for fulfilling the proper functions of the State."
Scope of Public Finance

1. Public Revenues – In his division we study all those sources from which the government
derives its revenues. An extensive study of the principles of taxation is an integral part of this
branch. Along with this, we also study in this branch the problem of the incidence of taxation-
2. Public Expenditure – Public expenditure is the beginning and end of the collection of revenues
by the government. As pointed out by Plehn, "Public expenditure is the end and aim of
collection of revenues and of other financial activities of the statesman". Under public
expenditure we study its classification, the canons or principles which govern it and its effects
on production, employment, income distribution, stability and growth. We also study the
reasons for increase in public expenditure and changes in the pattern.
3. Public Debt – When public revenue falls short of public expenditure, the government borrows
from the public to meet the gap. This is public debt. Under public debt; we study the reasons,
methods and sources of public debt, its effects on production, consumption, income distribution
and economy, the burden of public debt and the methods of debt redemption
4. Financial Administration – The aim of financial administration is to control processes and
operations of public revenue, public expenditure and public debt. The scope of financial
administration includes the collection, custody and disbursement of public money; the
coordination of expenditure according to a well-formulated plan; the management of public
debt; and the general control of the financial operations of the state. It also includes the
preparation of the budget; its execution and above all auditing the finances of the state.
Nature of Public Finance
1. It is a Social Science – Public finance is a social science which is concerned with the problems
of raising of funds and their allocation for the collective satisfaction of wants. Its methods of
study are based both on the study of the principles and theories or laws of public finance and on
a descriptive and statistical study of the actual operations of government finances. Its principles
are in the nature of generalizations which state the cause and effect relationships of different
variables like public revenue, expenditure, debt and financial administration. These also form
the subject matter of public finance.
2. It is an Art – Public finance is also an art. It is concerned with fiscal policies which influence
economic policies and economic structure of the country. All governments aim at bringing
social justice through an equitable financial system.
Importance of Public Finance

1. Increasing the growth rate of Economy – The role of public expenditure in economic
development lies in increasing the growth rate of the economy, providing more employment
2
opportunities, raising incomes and standard of living, reducing inequalities of income and
wealth, encouraging private initiative and enterprise and bringing about regional balance in the
economy. All these are achieved by spending on public works, agriculture: industry, transport
and communications, power, financial and banking institutions, social services etc. The
government is able to increase public expenditure through a budget deficit.
2. Emergence of Social Services – The importance of public finance as also increased due to
emergence of social services which can be performed more conveniently, efficiently and also at
the minimum cost as against individual. Such services are education, health, social security and
protection from certain uncertainties. The need for such social services is increasing day by day
and with them is increasing the importance of public finance.
3. Reduction in Economic Inequalities – Public finance can play a vital role in reducing
economic inequalities which is the source of dissatisfaction, class-struggles, poverty etc. The
state can levy heavy taxes on richer sections of the society and thereby spend the income so
received on providing food, cheap housing, free medical aid etc. for the poorer sections of the
society. Similarly, heavy taxes can be imposed on the use of harmful commodities, such as
harmful drugs, wine, opium, hashish etc.
4. Increases Employment – Public finance can play vital role in increasing employment which is
the burning problem of almost all the countries of the world, The Governments these days
establish, give grants, subsidies, grant exemption from excise duty, sales tax etc. to
employment-oriented cottage and small-scale industries. Unbalanced budget is also an
indispensable measure of increasing volume of employment during depression.
5. Capital Formation – The economic development, as is well known, depends upon the rate of
capital-formation in the country. Public finance can play a vital role in increasing the rate of
capital-formation in the economy. It can be managed in such a manner as to step up the rate of
saving and investment in the economy. For example, the tax system can be so managed as to
discourage the consumption of non-essential goods and thereby release the resources for being
invested in more productive industries. Further, the tax system can be employed to increase the
rate of private saving which in turn, can be used as the basis for an increase in public
investment.
6. Industrial Development – The governments these days give subsidies and grants to different
industries to enable them to increase the production of essential goods in the country. These
subsidies and grants have special place in the government expenditure of underdeveloped and
backward countries .
Differences or Dissimilarities between public and private finance

The following are the main points of differences or dissimilarities between public and private finance:
1. Adjustment between Income and Expenditure – An individual determines his expenditure
on the basis of his income. He prepares his family budget on his expected income during the
month. On the other hand, the government first estimates about its expenditure and then finds
out means to raise the necessary income. As pointed out by Bastable, 'The individual says, I can
spend so much', the Finance Minister says, 'I have to raise so much'
2. Elasticity of Finance – Public Finance is more elastic than private finance. There is not much
scope for changes in private finance while drastic changes can be made in government finance.
For example, a private individual cannot effect any special increase in his income. As against
this the government can increase its income by imposing fresh taxes on the people.
3. Differences in Objectives – There are a fundamental difference in the objective of private and
public finance. The motive of private expenditure is personal benefit whereas the objective of
public expenditure is social benefit. An individual always tries to save and a firm to earn profit.
But there are no such considerations on the part of the government, except the public welfare.
However, there are some public enterprises which are run on profits that are utilised for public
welfare.
3
4. Nature of Expenditure – There are differences in the nature of expenditure between the two".
An Individual's expenditure is governed by his habits, customs, fashions etc on the other hand.
The government expenditure depends on its economic and social policies, like removing
unemployment and poverty, reducing income inequalities, providing' infrastructure facilities,
etc
5. Compulsion – There is compulsion in public finance. People have to pay taxes. If they do not
pay, they are punished by fine and imprisonment. BA an individual or firm cannot force
anybody to pay him money. He can file a suit in the court. But even then he may not receive his
money back. The same is the case with loans. The government can force the people to lend it
during war or emergency. But a individual cannot compel any person to lend him money.
6. Law of Equi-marginal Utility – The private individual spends his me on various items in such a
manner as to secure equal marginal utilities from them. It is only by equalizing the various
marginal utilities that he can secure maximum utility out of his expenditure. The government
on the contrary, does not give as much importance to this law as a private individual does.
Modern governments sometimes incur certain types of expenditure from which they do not
derive any advantage, but they o incur this expenditure to satisfy certain sections of the
community
7. Present Vs Future – An individual is more concerned with his present needs and tries to satisfy
them. Life being uncertain and short, he has his immediate gain or profit in view. On the other
hand, government is a permanent organisation. Only the ruling party changes it is concerned
not only with the welfare of present generation but also I with future generations. It therefore,
undertakes and spends on those activities which also benefit future generations
8. Nature of the Budget – A surplus budget is always good for a private individual. Bin a surplus
budget may not be good for the government. It implies two things: (i) The government is
levying more taxes on the people than is necessary, (ii) The government is not spending as
much on the welfare of the public as it should. Keynes supported a deficit budget to meet the
situation created by depression. Further, the government budget is passed by the parliament.
But the budget of an individual or firm is a private affair without any controlling authority.
9. Nature of Borrowing – In the case of an individual, there can no internal borrowing". An
individual cannot borrow from himself. He can borrow only from an external agency. The State,
however, can borrow both from internal as well as external sources. It borrows not only from
its own citizens, but also from foreigners.
Budgetary activities of the government results in transfer of purchasing power from some individuals
to others. Taxation causes transfer of purchasing power from tax payers to the public authorities, while
public expenditure results in transfer back from the public authorities to some individuals, therefore
financial operations of the government cause ‘Sacrifice or Disutility’ on one hand and ‘Benefits or
Utility’ on the other.
This results in changes in pattern of production, consumption & distribution of income and wealth. So it
is important to know whether those changes are socially advantageous or not.
If they are socially advantageous, then the financial operations are justified otherwise not.
According to Hugh Dalton, “The best system of public finance is that which secures the maximum social
advantages from the operations which it conducts.”
Principle Maximum Social Advantage (MSA)

The Principle of Maximum Social Advantage (MSA)’ is the fundamental principle of Public Finance.
The Principle of Maximum Social Advantages states that public finance leads to economic welfare when
public expenditure & taxation are carried out up to that point where the benefits derived from the MU
(Marginal Utility) of expenditure is equal to (=) the Marginal Disutility or the sacrifice imposed by
taxation.
4
Hugh Dalton explains the principle of maximum social advantages with reference to –
1. marginal Social Sacrifice
2. Marginal Social Benefits
This principle is however based on the following assumptions –

 All taxes result in sacrifice and all public expenditure lead to benefits.
 Public revenue consists of only taxes and no other sources of income to the government.
 The government has no surplus or deficit budget but only balanced budget.
Public expenditure is subject to diminishing marginal social benefit and taxes are subject to increasing
marginal social sacrifice.
Marginal Social Sacrifice (MSS)

Marginal Social Sacrifice (MSS) refers to that amount of social sacrifice undergone by public due to the
imposition of an additional unit of tax.
Every unit of tax imposed by the government taxes result in loss of utility. Dalton says that the
additional burden (marginal sacrifice) resulting from additional units of taxation goes on increasing i.e.
the total social sacrifice increases at an increasing rate. This is because, when taxes are imposed, the
stock of money with the community diminishes. As a result of diminishing stock of money, the marginal
utility of money goes on increasing. Eventually every additional unit of taxation creates greater amount
of impact and greater amount of sacrifice on the society. That is why the marginal social sacrifice goes
on increasing.
Marginal Social Benefit (MSB)

While imposition to tax puts burden on the people, public expenditure confers benefits. The benefit
conferred on the society, by an additional unit of public expenditure is known as Marginal social Benefit
(MSB).
Limitations of Social Advantage

The principle of Maximum Social Advantage suffers from a number of shortcomings. Importance ones
are –
1. There is no effect means of quantifying utility and disutility.
2. Equating of marginal utility and disutility is spoken of for the society as a whole”, not for
“individual members” of the society so there is the possibility that for some individuals
marginal utility of public expenditure may be higher or lower than the marginal disutility, of
taxation. This raises the question of distributional equity. How the marginal utilities and
disutilities should be divided among individual members of the society.
3. The basic weakness of this principle ox that it gives neither a concrete standard by which the
efficiency of various expenditure programmes can be.
4. The utility of public expenditure is a macro issue, while the disutility of taxation id a micro one.
To treat the two as the two sides of the same coin is methodologically wrong.
5. In a situation of large scale involuntary unemployment, government spending may need to be
increased enormously with or without the sanction of the principle. Here the principle breaks
down.
Tests of Social Advantage

Dalton has provided the following tests of social advantage –
1. The first is the need to preserve the community from internal disorder and external attacks.
Here it is assumed that the society is worth pressuring. it is not a strictly economic test of social
advantage, yet it is true that no society can progress without peace.
2. The second test is strictly economic and relates to increasing the economic welfare of the
community. Two conditions are necessary for this. They are improvement in production and
improvement in the distribution of what is produced.
5
Lady U.K. Hicks has also developed two criteria for judging whether the operation of public finance
would add to net social benefit or not. They are production optimum and utility optimum. An optimum
in production is attained when production of one commodity cannot be increased through reallocation
of given productive resources without reducing the output of some other commodity. A utility optimum
is achieved when a reallocation of national product cannot increase the total satisfaction of the
commodity.
6
Unit – II
Sources of Revenue: Taxes, Loans, grant & Aids
Meaning and significance Source of Revenue

As public expenditure is necessary for the government to perform its various functions for the welfare
of the society, so it requires public revenue. Public revenue holds the same position in study of public
finance, which production holds in the study of economics. Just as production is the means of
consumption, public revenue is the means for public expenditure.
The income of government through all sources is called public income or public revenue. However,
Dalton has defined ‘Public income” in a broad and a narrow sense, i.e., in terms of Public receipts and
‘Public revenue”. Public revenue includes income from taxes, prices of goods and services supplied by
public enterprises, revenue from administrative activities, such as fees, fines, etc., and gifts and grants;
while Public receipts include all the incomes of the government which it may have during a given
period of time, i.e.. Public receipts = Public revenue + Income from all other sources, such as public
borrowing from individuals banks and income from public enterprises.
Various Classifications of Revenues

1. Adam Smith’s Classification – Adam Smith classified public revenue into two categories –
a. Revenue from the people
b. Revenue from the Sate Property
Revenue from the people includes tax revenue and revenue from State property includes
revenue obtained from public enterprises as well as that revenue which are derived from the
property in possession of the state.
2. Bastable’s Classification – Like Adam Smith, Bastable has also divided public into the
following two categories –
a. That income which the state receives from its various functions just like a private
individual.
b. Those income which the State derives in the own capacity as “State”.
The first category includes all the income which the State derives in the form of fees and prices,
while the second category includes taxes and Levis. This classification is also limited and
narrow like that of Adam Smith. This classification does not appear to be compressive from one
other angle also,, that is, fee, gifts, fines and special assessments are difficult to be classified into
separate groups.
3. Prof. Adam’s Classification – Prof Adam has divided the public revenue into three
categories–
a. Direct Revenue – This includes income form (a) public domains, (b) public industries, (c)
Gratuities, etc., (d) confiscations and indemnities. These categories includes all the income
which the State derives from public land public enterprise like rail, roads, highways, post
and telegraph and other incomes which the state derives due to the ownership of
productive enterprises.
b. Derivative Revenue – This includes taxes, fees, assessments, fines and penalties, i.e., the
income derives from the people is grouped under this head.
c. Anticipatory Revenue – This includes income from the sale of bond or other forms of
commercial credit. It also includes income from the treasury notes. This group deals
mainly with the revenue derived from the public credit.
Administrative Revenue
Administrative revenues refer to the receipts from fees, licences fines, forfeitures and escheats and
special assessment, etc. The revenue from these sources is collectively termed as administrative
activities of the government. According to Taylor, administrative revenues arise as a by-product of the
administration.
7
Fees – A fee is a compulsory contribution made for a specific series which primarily has a public
purpose: A fee has been defined by Prof. Seligman as “a payment to defray the cost of each recurring
services undertaken by the government. Primarily in the public interest, but conferring measureable
special advantages on the fee payer.”
Commercial Revenue
The characteristics which distinguishes commercial revenue from the categories of revenue is the
direct receipt of a commodity or services in return for payment and a rough adjustment of the amount
of payment to cost. Commercial revenues may arise from two principal sources. They may either arise
from public properties or from public enterprises.
a. Revenue from Public properties – The government everywhere owns some real properties,
like lands, buildings, forests, mines, fisheries, etc. The government can obtain revenue either by
selling or leasing these properties. Thus, for example, the Government of Orissa gets large
revenue by selling timber, tends leaves, bamboos and other forest products. So also the
government can obtain huge royalties by leasing out mines or fisheries, etc. Revenue from
public enterprises is also known as revenue from public domain.
b. Revenue from public enterprises – In modern times the role of the public sector in the various
countries is fast expanding. The State for various reasons takes Up the production and sale of a
number of essential commodities and services. The State may also enter the economic arena, in
insurance of the policy of planning and socialism.
Thus, the State derives revenues from its public enterprises by selling the produced goods and services.
Under revenue, from public enterprises, we include the receipts from the railways, post offices, State
transport and from public sector industrial undertakings, etc. The government charges a price for the
provision of these goods and services. In India, however, till the recent past, the performance of the
public sector enterprises has not been very encouraging. Thus, the railway finance has not been very
sound. The contribution of Posts and Telegraphs Department to the total non-tax revenue has been
modest. Similarly, till now most of the other public undertakings have been running in the red avoid the
payment of a price by avoiding the purchase of a commodity or service produced by the government.
Price is a contractual payment. Thirdly, a price paid for the enjoyment of a good or service by an
individual. It is paid for individual satisfaction. But a tax is paid for furthering common good.
Gifts and Grants

Gifts are given by private agencies, individuals and institutions. Gifts are purely voluntary in nature. In
a country there are many patriotic and public spirited individuals and organizations who make
voluntary contributions for some specific purposes. These gifts are usually made for helping some
particular causes, like providing aid to the flood-affected people or drought affected or quake hit
people. Gifts may be given in the form of contributions to the National Defence Fund, etc. Gifts may also
be given by foreign nations or foreign organizations. The Red Cross sands gifts to the people in distress
in any country of the world. “Gifts are, however, not a very important source of public revenue.
Public Revenue
The income of government through all sources is called public income or public revenue. Public
revenue includes income from taxes, prices of goods and services supplied by public enterprises,
revenue from administrative activities, such as fees, fines, etc. and gifts and grants.
Characteristics of Tax
A tax possesses three characteristics. First, a tax is a compulsory contribution to the State from the
citizens or even from aliens subject to the jurisdiction for reasons of residence or property and this
contribution is for general or common use, As it is a compulsory contribution, so no one can refuse to
pay a tax on any ground; for instance, as he does not drive any benefit from certain State services or as
he has no right of franchise, so he is not liable to pay a tax. Therefore, everyone has to pay a tax upon
whom it is levied by the State; it is immaterial whether he is an adult or a minor, or a citizen or an alien.
8
Moreover, the refusal to pay a tax is subject to punishment. However, there are certain qualifications to
it.
The second characteristic is that a tax imposes a personal obligation on the tax payer. It means that it
is the duties of the taxpayer to pay the tax if he is liable to pay it and should in no case think to evade it.
Suppose a tax is imposed on the incomes of the individuals, the sources of income may be many and the
public authority may not be in the know of all those sources. Here it is the duty of the tax payer to show
all of his income and take into account his total income while paying the tax.
The third characteristic is that the contribution received from the tax payers, may not be incurred for
their benefit alone, but for the general and common benefit. As an individual finds himself helpless to
meet all this needs especially those which involve heavy expenditure, i.e., the construction of a hospital,
the State renders such services for the benefit of all people. Hence, taxes are imposed upon all those
people, who are able to pay them, to share the common burden.
Meaning of Tax
It is, of course, very necessary to define tax before going into further details about taxation. The
following are the various definitions of tax given by different economists –
Adams- "A tax is a contribution from citizens for the support of the State.
Objects or Aims of Taxation

What are the aims behind the imposition and collection of taxes? Generally we may say that the
imposition of taxes has the following aims –
1. Raising Public Revenue – The first and foremost aim of taxes is to raise Public Revenue to
meet the ever-increasing public expenditure. This aim has its special significance particularly in
the undeveloped economies where the Government has taken over the task of securing at
minimum level of living to the public and has assumed the responsibility of active participation
in the task of economic growth. This aim also receives even greater importance due to the fact
that the public sector has been constantly increasing in these economies.
2. Reduction in the Inequality of Wealth- Another important object of taxation is to reduce the
inequality of wealth. One of the chief characteristics of under-developed countries is said to be
that there is vast gap between the income of persons in the highest income group and of those-
in the lowest income group. That is why one of the -important aims of the growth programmes
in these countries is to bring about a reduction in the inequalities in the distribution of incomes
and wealth. One of the aims of the taxation comes to be redistribution of wealth and income in
such a way so as to ensure more equitable distribution and by taxing rich people heavily and to
confer benefit on the poor.
3. The Aim of Tax Collection is Public Good- It is for the benefit of the general public and for the
maximum welfare of the whole society that the taxes are imposed and collected. The use of
taxes in the welfare of vested individual interests or for the development of a particular section
in a way not agreeable to the general public is not permissible. Tax-revenue is spent keeping in
view the aggregate welfare of the whole nation and not of a particular section.
4. Restriction on production and use of harmful goods - The government not only raises
revenue through taxation but it also imposes restriction on the use of certain goods and
services in a way desirable and respectable for a healthy State of society. Taxes on intoxicant
tobacco etc., raise public revenue on less than other taxes but their main aim is prevent the
deterioration of health of general public.
5. Regulation of Import and Export- On the other hand there is import and export duties which
also raise revenue but their specific aims are some others. Import taxes are levied in order to
restrict imports of those goods which may harm the "infant" industries producing those goods
in the country. Similarly luxury goods may be taxed heavily while being imported so as to
divert the national funds in some other forms of production inside the country. In the same way
9
export taxed may be levied within for the purpose of restricting export of those goods which
are required 'within the country, and their export may hamper national production or
consumption. Thus an important objective of taxation is to regulate the economy in accordance
with the needs of the country.
Introduction
Taxation imposes burden or sacrifice on the tax-payers. Tax moreover, have far-reaching economic
effects. The tax system, therefore, should be so organised as to impose the smallest possible sacrifice on
the community. For that purpose, the tax system should be based on certain well-defined rules and
principles. Otherwise, the very objective of taxation and the aspect of social justice, both may be
hampered. For example, a tax which widens the gulf between the rich and the poor may be highly
productive, but as it goes against the canon of social justice, it should not be supported. So also, if a tax
adversely affects the productive system of a country, it should be avoided.
Thus, to devise a sound and efficient tax system, economists and public men, from time to time, have
laid down certain principles to; which the tax structure should confirm. In this direction, the
contribution of Adam Smith is very great. He laid down certain canons or maxims of taxation for the
guidance of taxing authority, which are still famous for their clarity, simplicity and reasonableness.
Later on, other economists laid down more canons of taxation to supplement the canons of Dr. Smith.
1. The Canon of Ability of Equity – The canon of ability is the most important canon of taxation
to Adam Smith, 'The subjects of every State ought to contribute towards the support of the
government as nearly as possible its proportion to their respective abilities, that is in
proportion to the revenue which they respectively enjoy under the protection of the State." This
principle emphasizes that the tax burden should be imposed needing to the respective abilities
of the tax-payer so as to achieve equality of sacrifice. Here equality of sacrifice does not mean
that all should pay at equal rates. Equality in taxation signifies that the rich afraid contribute at
a higher rate and the poor at a lower rate. Sometimes the canon of ability has been interpreted
to mean proportional taxation. But actually this canon stands for progressive taxation and
hence this principle is just and equitable.
2. The canon of Certainty – The canon of certainty is important from the point of view of the tax-
payers as well as the government. The tax-payers must be certain about the rate of tax, method
and time of collection, etc. There should be no element of arbitrariness in taxation. Otherwise it
will lead to all kinds of malpractices, such as corruption and bribery, etc. The taxpayers will be
subjected to unnecessary harassment. Similarly, the government also will fail to prepare
accurate budgets unless it is certain about the amount of revenue likely to be raised by taxes
and can make an estimate. So Adam Smith had laid down, "the tax which every individual is
bound to pay ought to be certain and not arbitrary. The time of payment, the quantity to be paid
ought to be clear and plain to the contributor and to every other person." Ari old tax imposes
the least inconvenience and confusion as people are already fully accustomed o and familiar
with it. So it is popularly said:"An old tax is no tax.
3. The Canon of Convenience – The canon of convenience follows from the canon of certainty.
Not only should the time and method of payment be certain, but they should be minted as to
cause least inconvenience. Thus, Adam Smith pointed out, "Every tax ought to be levied at the
time or in the manner in which it is most likely to be convenient for the contributor to pay it.
4. The Canon of Economy – Adam Smith laid down the canon of economy in the following way:
"Every tax ought to be so contrived as both to take out and keep out of the pockets of the people
as little as possible, over and above what it , brings into the public treasury of the State.
Characteristics of a Good Tax System

A Good tax system should have the following characteristics –
1. Equity – The burden of a tax in a good taxation system should be the minimum. Along with that,
it should be distributed amongst the different sections of the community in a just and equitable
manner. The heaviest burden should be borne by the broadest shoulders. There should be a
10
proper blending of direct and indirect taxes in the taxation system to achieve this objective.
From the point of view of equity, the Indian tax system leaves much to be desired. The
predominance of indirect taxes in the Indian tax system reflects the inequitable nature of this
system.
2. Productivity – The term 'productivity' is interpreted in two senses. Firstly, the tax system
should be such as to provide adequate name to the government to meet its expenditure.
Secondly, the taxation system should be such as to produce no adverse effect on the productive
capacity of the country. From the point of view of productivity, the Indian tax system leaves
much to be desired. The' Indian income-tax system for example, produces adverse reaction on
the incentive to worn of the citizens.
3. Elasticity – The tax system should provide to the government increased income with the
increase in the national income of the country. The tax system should also yield more income
when the government expenditure goes up at a time of emergency or crisis. It should be
possible then to obtain more income with slight increases in the rates or the taxes. Two things
are essential to bring about elasticity in the tax system. Firstly, there should be a proper
blending of direct and indirect taxes. Secondly, certain sources of income should be exclusively
reserved ire emergencies, such as, war etc. The Indian tax system satisfies the canon of
elasticity in a sufficient measure insofar as the income of the government keeps on increasing in
accordance with its requirements.
4. Convenience – The government should also keep in mind the convenience of the tax payer
while devising the tax system of the country. Since the taxpayers make sacrifices-when they pay
the taxes, it is essential for the government to see that they are not put to any avoidable
inconvenience. Besides, the tax system should be simple so as to be within the understanding of
the ordinary taxpayer. The Indian tax system, no doubt satisfies the canon of convenience, but it
does not satisfy at all the canon of simplicity. It is a highly complex and complicated tax system,
much beyond the understanding of the average taxpayer.
5. Absence of Tax Evasion – The tax system of the country should be s devised as to leave no
scope for tax evasion on the part of the taxpayers. To achieve this objective, there should be a
proper blending of all sorts of commodity and personal taxes. This will reduce the scope for tax
evasion to the minimum. From this point of view, the Indian tax system leaves much to be
desired. There is at present a large-scale evasion of the income-tax going on in the country,
especially by the business classes
6. Maximum Social Advantage – According to Dalton, that system of taxation is the best which is
based on the principle of „maximum social advantage. The objective of every tax system should
be to promote the greatest good of the greatest number. It is also essential that the tax system
produces no adverse reactions on the productive capacity of the country. It is doubtful if the
Indian tax system satisfies this canon of maximum social advantage.
7. Economical – A good tax system should be economical to the government in the sense that the
cost of collection of taxes should be small in proportion to the revenue from them.
8. Multiple Taxes – A good tax system should have multiple taxes rather than a single tax.
According to Dalton, It is best to rely on a few substantial taxes for the bulk of the tax revenue
9. Income-Elastic – It should be income-elastic. As national income increases, the share of
taxation in national income should rise more than proportionately.
Problem of justice in taxation

1. The Physiocratic Theory – This is the earliest theory regarding taxation and this is based o the
view that land is capable of producing a net surplus. The Physiocratic School of Economic
Thought had its origin in France. And the Physiocrates maintained that agriculture alone could
yield a net return and could add to the wealth of the country and hence recommended that
revenue of the State should be derived from a single direct tax levied upon land.. Henry George
of San Fransisco also advocated a single tax on the appropriation of unearned increment, by the
state.
11
2. Financial Theory – There are various theories with regard to the distribution burden of
taxation among the people One of them is often called financial theory, which is embodied in the
principle attributed to colb pluck the goose with as little squealing as possible
3. The Principle of Equity – Horizontal and Vertical Theory: Modem writers have laid a great
emphasis on justice and advocated to follow the principle of equity the distribution of burden of
taxation. Equity generally means fairness or justice in the distribution of burden of taxation.
Equity involves two aspects: the treatment of people in like and unlike circumstances. The like
circumstances imply that those; who are equally well off from the economic point of view,
should pay equal amount as taxes. It is also called horizontal equity. The unlike circumstances
imply that the people in dissimilar circumstances should be subjected to dissimilar treatment
i.e., the persons who are -'better off” should pay more as taxes that others: This is called vertical
equity'
4. Cost of Service Theory – This is one of the oldest principles advocated for the distribution of
the tax burden. According to this theory, the basis of taxation should be the cost incurred by
government on different services for the benefit of the individual tax-payers. Each tax-payer has
to pay the tax equal to the cost of service to him. It means, the higher the cost, the higher should
be the tax rate and vice versa. The government acts like a producer of a commodity, who
charges the price from his customers equal to the amount of cost of production of the
commodity.
5. Benefit Theory of Taxation – This theory explains that every citizen should be called upon to
taxes in proportion to the benefits derived by him from services provided. Therefore, contribute
to the cost value of other facilities in proportion to benefits received by them. The more the
benefit a citizen derives, the more taxes he should bear, is the main assumption of the theory.
The principle justifies the payment of taxes. It also measure s benefits received by the
individuals in the case of certain special taxes such as petrol tax, betterment tax etc.
Features of Indian tax system

In India the authorities have been of the view that tax policy is a powerful tool by which the economy
can be effectively regulated and by economic incentives and disincentives can be created. As a result
our tax system has come to acquire the following salient features –
1. The system has become extremely complicated with rapidly changing provisions and rates.
Frequently, these provisions have been contradictory to each other and self-defeating in nature.
2. The system is laced with a excess of exemptions, rebates, concessions, penalties and other
provisions. In addition, there are notifications, clarifications, procedural details and the like. All
this has made the system a highly complex one, and according to one opinion,
counterproductive.
3. The authorities have always recognized the need to simplify the tax system but steps taken to
this effect have only added to its complexities.
4. The tax-base of our country is a narrow one. Taxpayers are practicing large-scale tax evasion
and avoidance. They are helped in this task by highly complicated tax provisions and
procedures, as also by the vast discretionary powers enjoyed by the tax officials
5. Frequent voluntary disclosure schemes under which tax evaders are provided an opportunity
to pay, tax (often on concessional basis) on concealed income and wealth, etc. have also
contributed to the phenomenon of tax evasion.
6. Indirect taxes comprise a major portion of our tax revenue. Compared with direct taxes, they
feed inflationary forces. They are more burdensome and cause widespread distortions in the
allocation of resources. They are known to be highly regressive in their nature. Selective
exemption of items from indirect taxes has not been able to reduce their regressive nature
because of widespread evasion.
7. The authorities have used, on a systematic and selective basis, tax holidays and other
concessions; for promoting certain industries considered essential for the overall balanced
growth of the economy; for promoting and helping small-scale industries and self-employment
12
activities so as to reduce unemployment and encourage labor-intensive techniques; for

encouraging investment in backward areas with the objective of reducing inter-regional
economic disparities.
8. Critics claim that the tax provisions relating to depreciation are based upon the cost of
acquiring assets and not the cost of their replacement. This, therefore, discourages capital
formation.
9. Authorities have tried to encourage exports by levying customs duties on imports; providing
income tax and other forms of relief on income from exports.
10. Over the years, the government has made a systematic effort to reform indirect taxes by
converting the base of excise duties from specific to value added, and by replacing excise duties
with VAT.
Characteristics of a Good Tax System

A Good tax system should-have the following characteristics:
1. Equity – The burden of a tax in a good taxation system should be the minimum. Along with that,
it should be distributed amongst the different sections of the community in a just and equitable
manner. The heaviest burden should be borne by the broadest shoulders. There should be a
proper blending of direct and indirect taxes in the taxation system to achieve this objective.
From the point of view of equity, the Indian tax system leaves much to be desired. The
predominance of indirect taxes in the Indian tax system reflects the inequitable nature of this
system.
2. Productivity – The term 'productivity' is-interpreted in two senses. Firstly, the tax system
should be such as to provide adequate income to the government to meet its expenditure.
Secondly, the taxation system should be such as to produce no adverse effect on the productive
capacity of the country. From the point of view of productivity, the Indian tax system leaves
much to be desired. The' Indian income-tax system for example, produces adverse reaction on
the incentive to worn of the citizens.
3. Elasticity –The tax system should provide to the government increased income with the
increase in the national income of the country.
4. Convenience – The government should also keep in mind the convenience of the tax payer
while devising the tax system of the country. Since the taxpayers make sacrifices when they pay
the taxes, it is essential for the government to see that they are not put to any avoidable
inconvenience.
5. Absence of Tax Evasion – The tax system of the country should be so devised as to leave no
scope for tax evasion on the part of the taxpayers. To achieve this objective, there should be a
proper blending of all sorts of commodity and personal taxes. This will reduce the scope for tax
evasion to the minimum.
13
Unit – III
Public Expenditure
Public expenditure is the spending of revenue that a government gets from tax and non-tax sources.
Size of the public expenditure is measured generally in term of the government expenditure/GDP ratio.
This ratio has been rising over the years in all countries—developed as well as developing. Public
expenditure of the USA, for instance, was only 8 per cent of its national income in 1880. In 1929 it was
10 per cent before the beginning of the Great Depression. In the post-war period, it increased to 28 per
cent in 1960 and to 37 per cent in 1985.Over the last twenty years growth in public expenditure has
stagnated or slowed down. It was higher in 2002 as compared to 1970, but in the mid-1980s,
expenditure had been higher.
Economic Effects of Public Expenditure

Under the traditional approach to the subject of public expenditures topics that were discussed were
trend of public expenditure, expenditure control and the important functions which give rise to those
expenditures. Such a discussion provides materials which are essential to an understanding of what
government does with its money. But it is an incomplete view of the economic aspects of public
expenditure. It is important to realize that most government services are basic in nature whose benefits
touch all branches of economic life. Government expenditure on protection, highway construction,
education, health, communications, etc., are, for instance, necessary to increase the productivity of the
economy.
But it is now realized that a major part of public spending makes. A basic contribution to the productive
efficiency of the economy. Hugh Dalton in his book titled, "Public Finance" (1922), examined the effects
public expenditure on production and distribution as also some other fleets such as effect on
employment. In the analysis of these effects his main concern has been incentives—ability and
willingness to work and save and invest. After the Keynesian Revolution, public expenditure became a
part of macro-economic analysis. Public finance scientists Began to study how changes in public
spending can be used as a stabilisation measure. Such a study was assisted by government expenditure
multiplier.
Effect on Production
In order to have a correct view of the effects of public expenditure on production, according to Dalton,
it is necessary to consider (i) effects upon ability to work and save, (ii) effects on desire to work and
save, and (iii) effects on diversions of economic resources as between different uses and localities.
If taxation reduces a man's ability to work through reduction of his efficiency, public expenditure will
increase it through increases in his efficiency. Here we should consider socially desirable expenditure
which has the capacity to increase efficiency. Expenditures on education, medical services and house
accommodation are likely to increase efficiency.
Effect on Distribution
The use of progressive taxes is generally advocated as a means of influencing income distribution; it
renders post-tax income distribution less unequal. Hugh Dalton has stated that like the taxes, public
spendings too can be made progressive. "But while taxes can, in certain circumstances, improve income
distribution by making the rich relatively less rich, they cannot substantially improve the wretched
living conditions of the poor. Government expenditures are obviously more Relevant for this purpose."
Robert S. Me Namara, the then President of the World Bank, stated in 1972 that a "shift in the patterns
of public expenditures represents one of the most effective techniques government possesses to
improve the condition of the poor."
14
Effect on Economic Development

There are two principal channels, through which government spending may influence economic growth
and development. First, government spending, particularly investment, may provide such goods that
enter directly into private sector production. We can take the examples of education and infrastructure.
Some government spending is such that they indirectly influence the efficiency of private sector
allocation of resources. To the extent that government expenditure corrects market failures, guarantees
property rights, enforces contracts and provides essential public goods, effect on growth will be
positive. Further, if public capital formation and private capital formation are complementary, public
spending on public projects are likely to encourage entrepreneurs to increase private investment and
growth. But there is also the possibility that government regulation may impose excessive burden on
the private sector, distort private incentives and financing of govt. Spending may did up interest rates
crowding out private investment.
Adverse/Bad Effect of Public Expenditure

1. Unnecessary Assistance to Industries and Business – If the government gives protection and
provides financial assistance to those industries and businesses which have lost their shape and
do not occupy any importance in the economic development of the country then it is mere
wastage of public resources. It will lead to development of those industries and business which
hinder the path of economic development and thereby the country is likely to go to the worse.
2. Excessive Expenditure on Defence – If the government incurs excessive expenditure on
defence, it will adversely affect the development of the poor and backward community of the
country. Pakistan is the burning example of the same. From moral and human points of view
also, excessive expenditure incurred on defence is treated as uneconomic and unnecessary. It
will also affect the security and peace of the entire region. India’s defence expenditure is
increasing rapidly which is evident from the table given below, adversely affecting all
development programmes, especially of the poor, illiterate, ignorant and backward classes.
3. Tendency of gaining Political Influence – Now-a-days the concept of public expenditure is
being applied by ministers in particular for gaining political influence and sounding vote bank.
Huge amount of public expenditure is being done by both Central and State ministers in their
respective areas just to gain political influence at the cost of other backward areas of the
country/state. It leads to serve criticism and dissatisfaction amongst the masses. It is also one of
the major factors of political instability in the country.
4. Advantage to a Particular Community – Sometimes public expenditure is incurred just to give
advantage to a particular community or lass over and above the other communities. It will lead
to division of the society in two clear-cut classes leading to class conflicts, feelings of superiority
and inferiority and more movements, unrest, strike, dharnas etc. AS a matter of fact, the peace
of the entire country is badly hurt and disturbed.
5. Rapid Increase in Taxation – In order to meet the rising public expenditure, government
imposes new taxes every year leading to heavy incidence of taxation on the community. If it is
not enough then the government takes the shelter of deficit financing which leads to rapid
inflation. The service class and poor classes in particular are adversely affected. In case of India
too, deficit financing is increasing every year leading to inflationary tendency along with a
general rise in price level every year.
6. Government expenditure is Misue of Scarce and Limited Resources and also
Unproductive – According o traditional economists, government expenditure is the misue of
scarce and limited resources of the country and also unproductive. They are of the opinion only
that public expenditure is productive which leads to physical increase in the production of
commodities meant for direct consumption. However, this old concept of public expenditure
has been rejection by the modern economists.
7. Fear of Minority Political Parties – Political parties led by minority groups are always fearful
of the increase of public on the ground that the political party or parties in power use the public
15
expenditure in fulfilling their own political interests. However, this view is not true in case of
India where’ minority is leading the majority.
8. Dominance of Public Sector Reduced the Authority of Private Sector – While citing the
dangers of increase in public expenditure capitalists argue that it reduces the authority of
private sector which is the backbone of capitalists economy. However, in the modern economy,
the above criticism does not stand true as the interference of the government is increasing in all
types of economics whether socialist economy, capitalist economy or mixed economy.
Public Debits Meaning –

Public debit or public borrowing is considered to be an important source of income to the government.
If revenue collected through taxes & other sources is not adequate to cover government expenditure
government may resort to borrowing. Such borrowings become necessary more in times of financial
crises & emergencies like war, drought, etc.
Public debt may be raised internally or externally. Internal debt refers to public debt floated within the
country; while external debt refers loans floated outside the country.
The instrument of public debt takes the form of government bonds or securities of various kinds. Such
securities are drawn as a contract between the government & the lenders. By issuing securities the
government raises a public loan & incurs a liability to repay both the principal & interest amount as per
contract. In India, government issues treasury bills, post office savings certificates, National Savings
Certificates as instrument of public borrowings.
Importance of Public Debts

1. Abandonment of Laissez-faire policy – The view of policy makers with regards to public
borrowing has changed considerably. The 19th century economists had belief in the policy of
laissez fair and advocated that. That government was the best which governed the least and
consequently spent the minimum. The change in the perception of the government from police
state to welfare state is a remarkable one in the context of public borrowing. The functions of a
welfare state are enormous and continuous. Consequently. it resorts to borrow money, both
internally and externally to execute five year plans and various development project and
various infrastructure development schemes and social sector schemes to enhance the living
standard of the people.
2. Deficit budget – Sometimes the situation becomes such that the current revenue cannot meet
the proposed expenditure unless they are supplemented by additional taxes and borrowing. But
tax collection takes longer time. In such a situation, to meet its requirement immediately, the
government may resort to borrowing from the public.
3. Waging wars- Modern war is so costly that the normal income through taxation falls short of
the actual war expenditure. War expenditures are so huge that they cannot be met by taxing
people alone. Governments, therefore, have to borrow extensively from individuals and
institutions towards war financing.
4. Facing natural calamities- Natural calamities such as floods, famines earthquakes, tsunami
etc. lend to increase the government expenditure in order to provide relief to the victims. This
requires huge public borrowing by the government.
5. Fighting depression- Borrowing is anti-cyclical. Public debt creation is considered as a very
significant remedy to depression. Depression is the effect of fall in effective demand. The
government can create effective demand by pumping that is by injecting money into the income
stream. This involves huge amounts of money which the government may mobilise by
borrowing the surplus of the country.
6. To curb inflation- Public borrowing may be regarded as a means to relieve the pressure of
inflationary spiral in the economy, as by raising public loans, the government absorbs the
excessive purchasing power in the hands of the people and check prices from rising.
16
7. Public enterprises and utilities- Public borrowing is necessary to promote public enterprises
and utilities like railways, post and telegraph, power generation, etc. Promotion of these public
corpora-lion requires huge financial resources. The current revenues cannot afford it. The
government can meet them only through public borrowing rather than by taxation.
8. Unpopularity of Taxation- People generally do not like to pay taxes to the government
'taxation, whether new or old is always unpopular with the public. The people generally oppose
the enhancement of existing rates of taxes and the imposition of additional taxes. To get over
this public opposition, the modern governments adopt the easy method of resorting to public
debt.
PRINCIPLES OF PUBLIC DEBTS

 First principle: the allocation of credit to desired aims
 Second principle: priorities setting before scarcity of resource and time
 Third principle: generational equilibrium
 Forth principle: debt structure on sustainability criteria
 Fifth principle: sound legal framework
 Sixth principle: best management practices
 Seventh principle: operational transparency
 Eighth principle: thorough process auditing
17
Unit – IV
Financial relation between central and State
Central Sources of Revenue- Taxes within Union jurisdiction are enumerated in List I, of the Seventh
Schedule as under.
1. Taxes on income other than agricultural income (item 82).
2. Duties of customs including export duties (item 83).
3. Duties of excise on tobacco and other goods manufactured or produced in India except
a. Alcoholic liquors for human consumption.
b. Opium, Indian hemp and other narcotic drugs and narcotics, but not including medicinal
and toilet preparations containing alcohol or any substance included in paragraph (b) of
inventory (item 84).
4. Corporation Tax (item 85) .
5. Taxes on capital value of assets, exclusive of agricultural land, on individuals and companies,
taxes on capital of companies (item 85).
6. Estate duty in respect of property other than agricultural land (item 87).
7. Terminal taxes on goods or passengers, carried by railway, sea or air, taxes on railway fares and
freights ((item 88).
8. Taxes other than stamp duties on transactions in stock exchange and future markets (item 90).
9. Rates of stamp duty in respect of bills of exchange, cheques, promissory notes, bills or lending,
letter of credit, policies of insurance, transfer of shares, debenture, proxies and receipts (item
91).
10. Taxes on sale or purchase of newspapers and on advertisements published therein (item 97).
11. Taxes on the sale and purchase of goods other than newspapers, where such sale or purchase
takes place in the course of inter-state trade or commerce (item 92A).
Budget
Government has several policies to implement in the overall task of performing its functions to meet
the objectives of social & economic growth. For implementing these policies, it has to spend huge
amount of funds on defence, administration, and development, welfare projects & various other relief
operations. It is therefore necessary to find out all possible sources of getting funds so that sufficient
revenue can be generated to meet the mounting expenditure.
Planning process of assessing revenue & expenditure is termed as Budget.
The term budget is derived from the French word "Budgette" which means a "leather bags; or a
"wallet". It is a statement of the financial plan of the government. It shows the income & expenditure of
the government during a financial year, which runs generally from 1st April to 31st March.
Budget is most important information document of the government. One part of the government's
budget is similar to company's annual report. This part presents the overall picture of the financial
performance of the government. The second part of the budget presents government's financial plans
for the period upto its next budget.
So, every citizen of a nation from the common man to the politi-cian is eager to know about the budget
as they would like to get an idea of the: -
 Financial performance of the government over the past one year.
 To know about the financial programmes & policies of the government for the next one year.
 To know how their standard of living will be affected by the financial policies of the government
in the next one year.
Definitions of Budget
According to Tayler, "Budget is a financial plan of government r a definite period".
18
According to Rene, "A budget is a document containing a preliminary approved plan of public revenues
and expenditure".
OBJECTIVE OF BUDGET
The important objectives that are sought to be achieved through a budget in an economy are discussed
below:
1. Allocation of resources: Keeping into view the socio-economic and other objectives which a
government wants to achieve, re-sources are allocated through budget. In India, the most
important activity is to accelerate the rate of economic development and for that resources are
allocated on a large scale.
2. Redistributive activities: A developing economy like India is generally the victim of many
social and economic problems which need to be solved as early as possible. The important
problems are the problem of poverty, unemployment, income inequalities, illiteracy etc. In
India, serious efforts are being made to solve these problems. For this the government
redistributes income and wealth to reduce inequalities, by incurring expenditures on social
security and giving subsidies for public etc.
3. Economic stability: Inflation and deflation both are not good from economic point of view;
Therefore, whenever a country suffers from inflation or deflation, besides other corrective
measures, appropriate budgetary steps are taken to remedy the situation.
When a country suffers from the bout of depression, cyclical un-employment is created on a
very large scale. Economic activities get depressed. In such a situation government has to adopt
various fiscal measures improve the health of the economy.
4. Management of public enterprises: To curb monopolies in heavy, basic and key sectors
owned and managed by private enterprises, government establishes and operates such units in
the public sector, this is necessary to avoid distortion of priorities of the government and
society.
Other Objective
5. Help in Economic planning
6. Tool for fiscal policies
7. Basis of public welfare
8. Legislative control on public funds
9. Tool of administrative efficiency.
REVENUE BUDGET
This financial statement includes the revenue receipts of the government i.e. revenue collected by way
of taxes & other receipts. It also contains the items of expenditure met from such revenue.
Revenue Receipts
These are the incomes which are received by the government from all sources in its ordinary course of
governance. These receipts do not create a liability or lead to a reduction in assets.
Revenue receipts are further classified as tax revenue and non-tax revenue.
1. Tax Revenue:-Tax revenue consists of the income received from different taxes and other
duties levied by the government. It is a major source of public revenue. Every citizen, by law is
bound to pay them and non-payment is punishable.
Taxes are of two types, viz.. Direct Taxes and Indirect Taxes.
Direct taxes are those taxes which have to be paid by the person on whom they are levied. Its burden
cannot be shifted to someone else. E.g. Income tax, property tax, corporation tax, estate duty, etc. are
19
direct taxes. There is no direct benefit to the tax payer. Indirect taxes are those taxes which are levied
on commodities and services and affect the income of a person through their consumption expenditure.
Here the burden can be shifted to some other person. E.g. Custom duties, sales tax, services tax, excise
duties, etc. are indirect taxes.
2. Tax Revenue:-Apart from taxes, governments also receive revenue from other non-tax sources.
The non-tax sources of public revenue are as follows: -
 Fees: The government provides variety of services for which fees have to be paid. E.g. fees
paid for registration of property, births, deaths, etc.
 Fines and penalties: Fines and penalties are imposed by the government for not following
(violating) the rules and regulations.
 Profits from public sector enterprises: Many enterprises are owned and managed by the
government. The profits receives from them is an important source of non-tax revenue. For
example in India, the Indian Railways, Oil and Natural Gas Commission, Air India, Indian
Airlines, etc. are owned by the Government of India. The profit generated by them is a
source of revenue to the government.
 Gifts and grants: Gifts and grants are received by the government when there are natural
calamities like earthquake, floods, famines, etc. Citizens of the country, foreign governments
and international organisations like the UNICEF, UNESCO, etc. donate during times of
natural calamities.
 Special assessment duty: It is a type of levy imposed by the government on the people for
getting some special benefit. • For example, in a particular locality, if roads are improved,
property prices will rise. The Property owners in that locality will benefit due to the
appreciation in the value of property. Therefore the government imposes a levy on them
which is known as special assessment duties.
3. India's Revenue Receipts: - The tax revenue provides major share of revenue receipts to the
central government of India. Iii 2006-07tax revenue (direct + indirect taxes) of central
government was Rs. 3,27,205 crores while non-tax revenue was Rs. 76,260 crores.
REVENUE EXPENDITURE
1. Expenses included in Revenue Expenditure –
In general revenue expenditure included following –
 Expenditure by the government on consumption of goods and services.
 Expenditure on agricultural and industrial development, scientific research, education,
health and social services.
 Expenditure on defence and civil administration.
 Expenditure on exports and external affairs.
 Grants given to State governments even if some of them may be used for creation of seets.
 Payment of interest on loans taken in the previous year.
 Expenditure on subsidies.
India’s DEfence Expenditure –

In 2006-07, Defence expenditure of the central government of India was Rs. 51,542 crores.
2. Capital Receipts
This part of the budget included receipts & expenditure on capital account projected for the
next financial; year. Capital budget consists of capital receipts & capital expenditure.
Items included in Capital Receipts –

The main items of Capital receipts (income are –
 Loans raised by the government from the public through the sale of bonds and securities. They
are called market loans.
20
 Borrowings by Government from RBI and other financial institutions through the sale of
Treasury bills.
 Loans and aids received from foreign countries and other international Organizations like
International Monetary Fund (IMF), World Bank etc.
 Receipts from small savings schemes like the National saving scheme, President fund, etc.
Introduction
In public the government first outlines its expenditure recording to the needs and objectives of the
national policy and then attempts to locate sources of funds to meet this estimated expenditure. The
main sources of revenue are tax revenue and non-tax revenue. Non- tax revenue mainly includes
surplus from public enterprises. When the total estimated expenditure exceeds the aggregate estimated
receipts during a year, the gap between the two is to be filled by what is called "deficit financing
Definition of Deficit Financing

Deficit financing, thus, refers to the financing of the excess expenditure over the total revenue receipts
of the government during a year, by various methods.
Deficit Financing = Total Public Expenditure—Total Public Revenue.
Deficit Financing in Developed Countries

In developed countries, the total revenue receipts ipelude tax and ' nontax revenue and excludes all
borrowings. That means deficit financing in developed countries refers to the financing of expenditure,
through borrowings — whether internal or external and whether from the central bank, commercial
banks, non-banking institutions or from individuals and corporations (market loans).
Effects of deficit financing

Today financing is resorted to by the governments of both developed and developing countries. It is,
therefore, necessary to examine the reasons for deficit financing for the two types of economies.
Reasons for Deficit Budgets in Advanced Countries

1. For wars. Deficit financing was used earlier for financing of wars. The form of this deficit
financing was mainly internal borrowings from the market (Vern people arid financial
institutions) and external borrowings.
2. Depression (anti-cyclical instrument). J.M. Keynes on his book, General Theory of
Employment Interest and Money. Advocated deficit financing of government expenditure to
fight depression pumping more money into the, economy to increase effective demand on the
country. It is the deficiency of effective demand that increases unemployment in a developed
country. This was amply shown by the depression of the thirties in countries like the USA, the
UK, and other European countries. Thus, deficit financing is an anti-cyclical instrument in
developed countries.
3. To maintain full employment. Now, deficit financing, particularly through public borrowings,
is used by developed countries to maintain the full employment level. Since unemployment of
the level of 2 to 3 per cent of the working force is treated as a normal situation, if it rises beyond
this, every advanced country thinks it an obligation on the part of the government to take
immediate steps to avoid it. This is done through deficit financing.
4. To prevent recessionary trends. No government of an advanced country ran wait till the
depression sets in. Whenever there are symptoms of recessionary trends in the economy', the
government of an advanced country does not hesitate to resort to' sorne kind of deficit
financing in the country to prevent recessionary trends.
5. To fill up budgetary deficit (functional finance). Since the concept of “balanced budget" has
been abandoned long back, budgets now looked upon as a functional instrument to regulate the
economy. If the government revenues are not adequate enough to meet the functional
21
expenditure of the government, then deficit financing is unhesitatingly resorted to, to fill the
budgetary deficits.
Deficit Financing in Developing Countries

The problems of developing countries like India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, are different from ;those in
developed countries. Therefore, the rationale behind or justification for deficit financing in countries
like India is entirely different. The following are the main reasons for deficit financing in India:
1. Mobilization of physical resources. There is a vast amount of physical resources, such as iron
ore, different kinds of minerals, water, of land, etc., which are unutilised or underutilised or
misutilised by the private sector. Public revenue is inadequate to use them efficiently and
rationally. Underdeveloped countries are rich natural resources, such as mines and forests.
They have abundance of unemployed labour. Through deficit financing, these idle resources can
be activated and gainfully used for national development.
2. Social overhead expenditure. In developing countries to, lack of infrastructural facilities
(power communication and transport etc.), there is low development of private sector
industries. Since huge expenditure is necessary for such facilities and in which there is no large
and quick profit, the government of a developing country has to spend a huge amount on social
overhead capital for creating infrastructural facilities of power, communication and transport
etc. Deficit financing is necessary for this purpose as the government tax and non-tax revenue is
insufficient to meet this expenditure.
3. Monetizing the rural sector. In these days of money economy, it is necessary to monetise all
sectors of a developing economy. A considerable’s part of the rural sector is. barter economy.
Deficit financing is a useful instrument to change the barter sectors of the economy into
monctised sectors. New money created can be used to popularise the use of money in such
sectors.
Functions of finance commission

Under Article 280, a provision was made for the appointment of a Finance Commission by the President
at an interval of five years or earlier to make recommendations pertaining to the sharing of income and
excise taxes and grants-in-aid of state revenues. It is a quasi-judicial body whose recommendations,
once accepted by the Government become binding on it. Further, the institution of the Finance
Commission is a unique feature of our Constitution. It has no parallel in any other federation, old or
new. The Australian Grants Commission resembles our Finance Commission to some extent. But there
are important differences between the two. The former is a permanent body and deals with grants only
on annual basis; the latter is an ad-hoc body which ceases to exist once it makes its recommendations
but has wider powers as both tax-sharing and grants-in-aid me under its purview. Its awards remain in
operation for five years
TERMS OF REFERENCE
The Finance Commission is required to recommend financial transfers from the Central Government to
the states with a view to reducing vertical as well as horizontal fiscal imbalances. The terms of
reference of the Finance Commission are fixed in a broad way by the Constitution under Article 280(iii).
Though the Central Government is prevented from determining arbitrarily the terms of reference of the
Finance Commission, yet there is scope for some flexibility under clause 3(c) of Article 280 which
reads: "any other matter referred to the Commission by the President in the interest of sound finance."
Under this clause the Government has put certain restrictions on the working of the Finance
Commissions leading to controversies on several occasions. And with the advent of planning and
development planning gaining, importance, the Finance Commission's role was confined, according to
the terms of reference, to the examination of non-plan revenue accounts of states budge.
TERMS OF REFERENCE
The Commission was entrusted with the task of making recommendations as to the following matters :
22
1. The distribution between the union and the states of the net proceeds of taxes which are to be,
or may be, divided between them under Chapter 1, Part-XII of the Constitution and the
allocation between the states of the respective shares of such proceeds;
2. Principle which should govern the grants-in-aid of the revenues of the states out of the
Consolidated Fund of India and the sums to be paid to the states which are in need of assistance
by way of grants-in-aid of their revenues under article 275 of the Constitution for purposes of
other than those specified in the provisos to clause (i) of that article; and
3. The me s needed to augment the Consolidated Fund of state to supplement the resources of the
Panchayats and Municipalities in the States on the basis of the recommendation made by the
Finance Commission of the State
Fourteenth Finance Commission

The fourteen finance commission is instructed on 02 Jan. 2013 under the chairmanship of Dr. Y.V. Reddi
(Reserve Bank of India) following are its members:
1. Prof. Abhijeet Sen, Member Planning Commission.
2. Ms. Sushma Nath, Former Union Finance Secretary.
3. Dr. M. Govind Rao
4. Dr. Sudipto Mundle, Former acting chairman, national statistical commission.
5. Ajay Narayan Jha, Secretary
Main points of consideration under 14th commission are as follows:

1. The commission setup under the provision of constitution on sharing of tax proceeds between
the union & states: will apply from April, 01, 2015.
2. The commission would look into the need for insulating the pricing of public utility services
such as drinking water, irrigation, power & public transport from policy fluctuation, through
statutory provisions.
3. On basis of recommendation of state finance commission measures are suggest to increase
resources of panchayat & Nagar palika (Municipal Commission) by increasing the capital &
savings of state government
Direct Taxes
1. A surcharge of 10 per cent on persons whose taxable income exceeds? 1 crore per year, this will
apply to individuals, Hindu Undivided families, firms and entities with similar tax status.
2. Surcharge was also increased from 5 per cent to 10 per cent on domestic companies whose
taxable income exceeds? 10 crore per year. In the case of foreign companies who pay the higher
rate of corporate tax, the surcharge was increased from 2 per cent to 5 per cent.
3. All other cases, such as dividend distribution tax or tax on distributed income, the then existing
surcharge of 5 per cent was increased to 10 per cent. The additional surcharge in all the above
cases is to remain in force for only one year, that is, the financial year 2013-14.
4. Some benefit was given to the first-home buyer in the payment of interest on loans taken from
financial and banking institution.
5. The rate of the tax on the payment of royalty and fees for technical services to non-residents
was raised from 10 per cent to 25 per cent.
6. The following reduction was announced in the rates of securities Transaction Tax (STT):
Equity features: from 0.17 to 0.01 per cent MF/ETF redemptions at fund counts: from 0.25 to 0.001 per
cent MF/ETF purchase and sale on exchanges : from 0.1 to 0.001 per cent, only on the seller.
7. Commodities Transaction Tax was introduced in a limited way at 0.01 per cent of the price of
trade.
8. The Direct Taxes Code is proposed to be introduced not as an amended version of the Income-
tax Act 1961 but as a new code based on the first international practices that will be compatible
with the needs of a fast developing country. The recommendations of the Standing Committee
on finance have been submitted and the Finance Ministry is examining them.
23
Indirect Taxes –
1. The first announcement made by the Finance Minister in the case of indirect taxes was no
change in the peak rate of basic customs duty of 10 per cent for non-agricultural products, no
change in the normal rate of excise duty of 12 per cent and the normal rate of service tax of 12
per cent.
2. In the case of excise duty route for readymade garment industry which is in the throes of crises
was –r announced in addition to the GENVAT route available at present. Similarly, excise duty
was exempted in the case of handmade carpets and textile floor covering of jute or coir. Relief
was increased by 18 per cet. similar increases were proposed for cigars, chariots and cigarillos.
Excise duty on SUVs raised from 22 percent to 30 per cent, on marble from Rs. 30 per square
meter to TRs. 60 per square meter, on mobile phone priced at more than Rs. 2,000 by 6 per
cent.
GOODS AND SERVICES TAX

The Finance Minister had mentioned the Goods and Services Tax (GST) hi the Budget speech for 2007-
08 and had hoped that it would be brought into effect from 1.4.2010. This could not happen. The
Empowered Committee of State Finance Ministers, led the Union Finance Minister to believe, as he
announced in his budget speech of 2013.14, that the overwhelming majority of states are agreed that
these are need for a constitutional amendment. He was hopeful that this consensus would be taken
forward in the next few months and brings to this Lok Sabha a draft Bill on the Constitutional
amendment and draft Bill on GST. He announced the first decisive step by announcing the setting apart
in the Central Budget 2013-14 a sum of Rs. 9,000 crore.
24

Public Finance

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Public Finance

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Public Finance

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

B.Com 5th Sem.

Subject- Public Finance

Class – B.Com. V Sem.

Subject – Public Finance

Unit-I Public finance: Meaning, nature, scope and importance,

Scope of Public Finance

Nature of Public Finance

Importance of Public Finance

Differences or Dissimilarities between public and private finance

Principle Maximum Social Advantage (MSA)

This principle is however based on the following assumptions –

Marginal Social Sacrifice (MSS)

Marginal Social Benefit (MSB)

Limitations of Social Advantage

Tests of Social Advantage

Meaning and significance Source of Revenue

Various Classifications of Revenues

Gifts and Grants

Objects or Aims of Taxation

Characteristics of a Good Tax System

Problem of justice in taxation

Features of Indian tax system

activities so as to reduce unemployment and encourage labor-intensive techniques; for

Characteristics of a Good Tax System

Economic Effects of Public Expenditure

Effect on Economic Development

Adverse/Bad Effect of Public Expenditure

Public Debits Meaning –

Importance of Public Debts

PRINCIPLES OF PUBLIC DEBTS

Planning process of assessing revenue & expenditure is termed as Budget.

India’s DEfence Expenditure –

Items included in Capital Receipts –

Definition of Deficit Financing

Deficit Financing in Developed Countries

Effects of deficit financing

Reasons for Deficit Budgets in Advanced Countries

Deficit Financing in Developing Countries

Functions of finance commission

Fourteenth Finance Commission

Main points of consideration under 14th commission are as follows:

GOODS AND SERVICES TAX

You might also like