All Quiet On The Western Front LitChart
All Quiet On The Western Front LitChart
All Quiet On The Western Front LitChart
com
increased his moral and advisory power over his students. the propaganda language of a nation can be from the reality
Yet Paul is careful to point out that he did not operate with experienced by its citizens and soldiers. Each of these words
malicious intentions, but rather was certain to be “acting for implies a cultural image rather than a personal reality—and
the best.” Thus the authority power structure is presented they were used by those like Kantorek to motivate the
not as a group of individual agents acting maliciously, but schoolboys to become soldiers. Remarque’s stringent
rather the result of a larger social system of proud, patriotic realism can itself be read as a response to this type of
older men sending younger men to die in wars the older disjointed language—an attempt to recapture simplicity in
men have started. the face of bombastic, misleading discourse.
That “there were thousands of Kantoreks” speaks to the
universality of these soldiers’ experience, presenting the
text as a microcosm for what was happening in broader Chapter 2 Quotes
German society. Kantorek's individual character turns first Though Müller would be delighted to have Kemmerich's
into a “they” and then into “the idea of authority,” growing boots, he is really quite as sympathetic as another who could
increasingly broad and representational. Similarly, their not bear to think of such a thing for grief. He merely sees things
small group of soldiers becomes “our generation.” Often clearly…We have lost all sense of other considerations, because
Remarque will use phrases like these to broaden the scope they are artificial. Only the facts are real and important for us.
of the novel, to transform a single realist tale into an And good boots are scarce.
account of a cultural paradigm.
Related Characters: Paul Bäumer (speaker), Müller, Franz
Kemmerich
Iron Youth. Youth! We are none of us more than twenty
years old. But young? Youth? That is long ago. We are old Related Themes:
folk.
Related Symbols:
Related Characters: Paul Bäumer (speaker)
Page Number: 20
Related Themes: Explanation and Analysis
Page Number: 18 When Paul goes to the hospital to see Kemmerich, he is told
to take the dying man’s boots for Müller. Paul observes that
Explanation and Analysis this is not cruel but rather a reasonable and pragmatic
Kropp mentions a letter penned by Kantorek calling the response given the soldiers’ circumstances.
student cohort the “Iron Youth.” Paul reacts sarcastically, Once more, Paul preempts the reader’s potential criticism
finding that the term has little relevance for what transpires of the soldiers’ actions. By focusing on the boots, Müller
at the front. would seem to be violating an important cultural norm of
The irony of this phrase stems from how little the terms having deference toward the recently-deceased—but Paul
conform to the soldiers’ actual experience in the army. “Iron” contends that he experiences emotions just as much as
refers to the way their character would remain steadfast anyone else. Turning the apparent fault into a virtue, he
and brave in war, yet the soldiers have already found their continues, “He merely sees things clearly”—implying that
spirits broken by the psychological and physical toil. The the pragmatic approach to the boots is in fact better than an
irony of “youth” is a bit trickier to parse, and Paul therefore overly-sentimental one. Similarly, he casts “considerations”
spells out his reaction. Although they are, by numerical like reverence for the dead as “artificial” and in contrast with
accounts, indeed quite young, the members of the cohort “the facts.”
are “old folk” psychologically—for they have by now Though one might read this passage as evidence of how
weathered extreme personal traumas over the course of extensively a war experience can alter one’s psychology, the
the war. Paul demonstrates here that this generation was language actually presents the soldiers as more aware and
thought to be iron-willed and powerful—able to resist pain more intelligent than those who have not experienced such
and win glory during the war—but notes that these images trauma. Juxtaposing “facts” and “artificial” considerations
were ultimately in vain. presents normal social rituals as false
More broadly, the passage demonstrates how mismatched
Chapter 3 Quotes
constructions—indeed the exact type of lie that initiated the
war in the first place. Thus Remarque actually rehabilitates If you train a dog to eat potatoes and then afterwards put
the image of being a soldier, contending that it grants a a piece of meat in front of him, he'll snap at it, it's his nature.
painful clarity into reality of the world. And if you give a man a little bit of authority he behaves just the
same way, he snaps at it too. The things are precisely the same.
In himself man is essentially a beast, only he butters it over like
a slice of bread with a little decorum. The army is based on that;
Had we gone into the trenches without this period of one man must always have power over the other.
training most of us would certainly have gone mad. Only
thus were we prepared for what awaited us. We did not break
down, but adapted ourselves; our twenty years, which made Related Characters: Stanislaus Katczinsky (speaker)
many another thing so grievous, helped us in this. But by far the
most important result was that it awakened in us a strong, Related Themes:
practical sense of esprit de corps, which in the field developed
Page Number: 43
into the finest thing that arose out of the war—comradeship.
Explanation and Analysis
Related Characters: Paul Bäumer (speaker), Corporal As they discuss Himmelstoss’s nature, the soldiers wonder
Himmelstoss how he could have originally been a mere postman.
Kat explains that his is a fundamental human response to
Related Themes:
the sudden acquisition of power. Kat presents a model of
human nature that is deeply antagonistic and opportunistic.
Page Number: 26
Likening man to a “dog” highlights, already, his animalistic
Explanation and Analysis qualities, and he completes the parallelism by saying a man
Paul reflects on training for the war under Corporal “behaves just the same way.” Himmelstoss’s actions are
Himmelstoss. He observes that while the corporal’s tactics therefore entirely sensible: he had little access to power as
may have been brutal, they were absolutely necessary to a post-man—the analog for potatoes—but the moment he
prepare them for the front. gained the “meat” of authority in the army, he immediately
adapted to the role. For Kat, this logic undergirds the entire
Although other passages have presented the war as structure of the military; it is the way that men, once in roles
massively destructive on the soldiers’ psychology, this line of power, are able to exercise control despite their
shows that it could have been even more dire. background and lord it over others.
Himmelstoss’s training, Paul explains, may have been awful
but it was also necessary to imbue the soldiers with the What is peculiar about this passage is the way that it does
stamina and resilience to not “break down.” He therefore not assign blame to Himmelstoss: We might expect such an
reveals a certain respect for the harshness of such a abuse of authority to induce criticism from the soldiers, but
leader—even recasting cruelty as necessary and pertinent Kat actually presents his behavior as natural and thus
in certain situations. permissible. Saying that “man is essentially a beast” casts
displays of power simply as accurate representations of
Beyond improving mental resilience, Paul explains, this human nature—whereas other social courtesies are just the
training also had a significant impact on the group mentality false “butter” placed on this metaphorical “bread.” Once
of the soldiers. “Esprit de corps” is an expression taken from more, Remarque implies that the soldiers gain better insight
French to mean, literally, the “spirit of the body”—or the into human nature from their war experiences. As a result,
ineffable energy that connects a group of people in a they do not morally condemn their superior for his
metaphorical “body.” His emphasis on “comradeship” as authoritarian practices, but contextualize and rationalize
perhaps the only positive effect of the war is worth noting. those actions.
For despite his emphasis on atrocity and psychological toil,
Remarque repeatedly lauds the efficacy of the soldier unit
against that toil.
Chapter 4 Quotes Kat looks around and whispers: "Shouldn't we just take a
revolver and put an end to it?"
At the sound of the first droning of the shells we rush back,
in one part of our being, a thousand years. By the animal The youngster will hardly survive the carrying, and at the most
instinct that is awakened in us we are led and protected. It is he will only last a few days. What he has gone through so far is
not conscious; it is far quicker, much more sure, less fallible, nothing to what he's in for till he dies. Now he is numb and feels
than consciousness. One cannot explain it…It is this other, this nothing. In an hour he will become one screaming bundle of
second sight in us, that has…saved us, without our knowing intolerable pain. Every day that he can live will be a howling
how. torture. And to whom does it matter whether he has them or
not—I nod. "Yes, Kat, we ought to put him out of his misery."
Chapter 5 Quotes We sit opposite one another, Kat and I, two soldiers in
shabby coats, cooking a goose in the middle of the night.
"When I think about it, Albert," I say after a while rolling
We don't talk much, but I believe we have a more complete
over on my back, "when I hear the word 'peace-time,' it goes to
communion with one another than even lovers have. We are
my head: and if it really came, I think I would do some
two men, two minute sparks of life; outside is the night and the
unimaginable thing—something, you know, that it's worth
circle of death. We sit on the edge of it crouching in danger, the
having lain here in the muck for. But I can't even imagine
grease drips from our hands, in our hearts we are close to one
anything. All I do know is that this business about professions
another…What does he know of me or I of him? formerly we
and studies and salaries and so on—it makes me sick, it is and
should not have had a single thought in common--now we sit
always was disgusting. I don't see anything at all, Albert."
with a goose between us and feel in unison, are so intimate that
we do not even speak.
Related Characters: Paul Bäumer (speaker), Albert Kropp
Related Characters: Paul Bäumer (speaker), Stanislaus
Related Themes:
Katczinsky
Page Number: 87
Related Themes:
Explanation and Analysis
Page Number: 94
The soldiers take turns imagining what they would do in
peacetime. Whereas others describe extensive fantasies, Explanation and Analysis
Paul surprisingly does not idealize that future.
While Kat and Paul roast their captured geese, Paul
His issue stems from the sense that nothing in the future expresses a deep sense of connection to his comrade. He
could potentially justify the pain experienced by “having lain notes that the conditions of war have brought them
in the muck.” That is to say, Paul imagines that any post-war together in a profound way.
world would have to be miraculous enough to compensate
This passage returns to the theme of comradeship in the
for the pain the soldiers are currently experiencing in the
novel—and how one the war’s only redeemable aspect is the
trenches. So when he “can’t even imagine anything” that
way it forges close connections between the soldiers. What
would measure up to that desire, he feels a corresponding
is unique about Paul and Kat's interaction here is that it
disillusionment with what that future would offer. His issue,
requires little verbal communication and no common
in particular, is with the professional options that would be
background. Saying, “formerly we should not have had a
available—which Paul sees as a bureaucratic morass of
single thought in common,” Paul emphasizes the very
“business about professions and studies and salaries.” After
divergent backgrounds of the two characters—which are
the intense, pragmatic reality of the war these social
somehow transcended by their involvement in the war.
conventions seem paltry and artificial.
Without other artifacts of social artifice, the sole presence
Though Paul presents this idea as an individual contention of a “goose” is sufficient to connect them.
with his future, it also speaks to a broader societal
Remarque emphasizes the characters’ departure from
disillusionment. One of the critical justifications for wars is
normal societal norms with repeated references to solitude,
that they will, in the long term, bring about preferable post-
abstraction, and darkness. Paul does not not see himself and
war conditions—that the soldiers are fighting for a better
Kat as true individuals but rather as “two men, two minute
future: a utopia that lies beyond the trenches. By denying
sparks of life”—general representations of humanity that
the idea that the future would be such a utopia, Paul is
stand in front of “the night and the circle of death.” Though
implicitly negating the merit of the war itself. He is thus
this image is frightening, it also provides the necessary
voicing a developing sense among soldiers that not only was
conditions for them to connect. For “communion,” in such a
the experience of battling deeply disturbing, but also that
context, can form from the simplest and most universal
the ends reached by the war would themselves be no more
experience of sharing a meal.
noble than before, and could never justify the means of
reaching them.
experience and those memories. Yet why do these contrasting sets of qualities give rise to
These reflections build on Paul’s earlier image of the the statement, “I believe we are lost”? Paul seems to imply
marching soldier: Just as that character was separated from that in holding opposite sets of characteristics within
twenty years of emotional memories, Paul’s cohort is themselves, the soldiers are deprived of a coherent sense of
severed from “the old intimacy” with childhood experiences. self. Thus the lost generation is not so much a literally dead
They feel this distance from both their more innocent youth or abandoned generation, but rather a psychologically
and from the pre-war society that cultivated those innocent disjointed one, in which paradoxical identities have led to a
experiences. The effect of the war is to cause Paul and the lack of coherence in the self.
other soldiers to lose contact with that innocence.
Yet Paul makes clear that the attraction to those memories The terror of the front sinks deep down when we turn our
is not induced by the specific content of the memories backs upon it; we make grim, coarse jests about it, when a
themselves, but rather by the feeling of coherence in man dies, then we say he has nipped off his turd, and so we
identity they create. In desiring “the feeling of a speak of everything; that keeps us from going mad; as long as
comradeship,” he brings up the motif of communion that has we take it that way we maintain our own resistance.
pervaded the novel so far, but applies it to coherence within
a single person. That is to say, Paul has felt his life to be
Related Characters: Paul Bäumer (speaker)
broken into discontinuous pieces, in which the current
moment of the war causes him to have “surrendered” to the Related Themes:
present. Remarque thus points out how it is the emotional
distance from one’s past that induces a war-torn identity Page Number: 140
crisis.
Explanation and Analysis
As he prepares to go on leave, Paul ponders the behaviors
We are forlorn like children, and experienced like old men, that soldiers tend to take up when they leave the front. He
we are crude and sorrowful and superficial—I believe we observes that the humor others perceive as characteristic
are lost. of soldiers is a defense mechanism for dealing with the
horrors of war.
Characteristically, Paul responds to and denies a reader’s
Related Characters: Paul Bäumer (speaker)
expectation of why soldiers behave in a certain way. We
Related Themes: might assume that leaves offer solace from the front—and
that the soldiers' humor therefore reflects that joy. But Paul
Page Number: 123 explains that a leave only causes “the terror of the front” to
become more poignant and painful, for it throws into relief
Explanation and Analysis the horrors just experienced. Humor becomes, then, a way
Paul continues reflecting on his childhood. He reiterates for the soldiers to sterilize and to write off their horrific
how deeply his generation has been fractured by the events experiences. For instance, using the phrase “nipped off his
of the war. turd” to refer to a solider’s death misdirects the actual
emotional pain of such an event instead toward an
This description returns to the paradox of the soldiers’ age,
adolescent joke. That this behavior “keeps us from going
as once more Paul references both their youthful qualities
mad” casts it as a psychological need instead of flippant
and their burdens of experience. That they are “forlorn like
humor, and the emphasis on “resistance” corroborates the
children” speaks to a juvenile helplessness and despondency
heft of the satire. Thus Remarque cautions us from making
in the face of the war, while being “experienced like old men”
rapid assessments of a soldier’s personality or
affirms both the wisdom and the trauma they have gained
idiosyncrasies, and to examine more closely what may be
while serving. Extending the contrasting terms, Paul says
psychologically motivating even something as simple as
they, “are crude and sorrowful and superficial”: a
humor.
combination of grizzled, deep emotions and exterior
surfaces. In this way, the emotional ages of the soldiers
contrast with their physical ones, leading to a disjoint
between interior and exterior identities as conditioned by
the war.
Page Number: 156 His scene with the books demonstrates how distant the
war-torn Paul is from his earlier identity. Remarque
Explanation and Analysis emphasizes this point through Paul's off-kilter emotional
On leave, Paul finds himself uncertain about how to interact response to the books: Instead of “the same powerful,
with civilians. He is uncomfortable here with the attention nameless urge,” he feels a far simpler sense of being
he receives because of his uniform and position. “excited”—a less nuanced and more direct response. What
Paul desires, instead, is a psychological sense of quietude
This passage demonstrates how Paul’s war experiences
and intensity, an emotional reaction that would stimulate
have a detrimental effect on his more "civilian" interactions.
him to care more actively about his future. For him, this
Though the red-cross sister’s actions should be taken as a
hope is identified with literature and with youth, two things
sign of kindness and generosity, Paul receives them only in
to which he has become dulled by the war experience.
negative and skeptical terms. That he sees her as“obsessed
with her own importance” verifies that his mind has mutated It is worth pausing on the fact that Paul experienced this
her altruistic behavior into a selfish one. Thus Remarque poignancy from books. Remarque implies that this novel
uses the leave scene to demonstrate the novel’s opening itself could serve a parallel purpose for the reader, perhaps
point that the war had induced a deep psychological toll on returning a sense of “the lost eagerness.” This pragmatic or
the characters. even didactic end to the novel would seem to contrast with
Remarque's earlier explanation that it was purely a case of
The theme of anonymity resurfaces as well in this passage.
realism. But perhaps the two interpretations can be
Paul’s reaction is partially conditioned by the fact that he
brought together, in which we see that this text, even in
knows “no one among all the people.” The sister’s action
plain realism, presents an aesthetic world more moving than
comes off as fraudulent specifically because of her use of
the daily experiences of a soldier.
the term “Comrade”—which implies a senseless affiliation
and false connection between the two. Thus it is the
hypocritical combination of being fundamentally unknown
but falsely recognized that causes Paul agitation, as well as I ought never to have come here. Out there I was
the disconnect he feels between himself and all the civilians indifferent and often hopeless; I will never be able to be so
around him, those who know nothing of his experiences and again. I was a soldier, and now I am nothing but an agony for
still think of the war in terms of patriotism and heroism. myself, for my mother, for everything that is so comfortless and
without end.
I feel excited; but I do not want to be, for that is not right. I Related Characters: Paul Bäumer (speaker)
want that quiet rapture again. I want to feel the same
powerful, nameless urge that I used to feel when I turned to my Related Themes:
books. The breath of desire that then arose from the coloured
backs of the books, shall fill me again, melt the heavy, dead lump Page Number: 185
of lead that lies somewhere in me and waken again the Explanation and Analysis
impatience of the future, the quick joy in the world of thought,
As Paul prepares to depart his leave and return to the front,
it shall bring back again the lost eagerness of my youth. I sit and
he reflects on the time away. Instead of seeing it as an
wait.
enjoyable respite, he believes the war has only made home
into something oppressive.
The difficulty of Paul’s leave centers on how he has instead fixate on “the sole aim” of the war—which can only
constructed a separate soldier identity on the front. This view the Russians as enemies to be defeated. Thus Paul
self was “indifferent and often hopeless”—hardened to the must harshly separate his emotions and thoughts in order
cruel conditions of the war but able to receive them with to stay sane and competent in the war.
relatively fewer emotions. He could explain away those Yet despite emphasizing the need for these partitions, Paul
feelings as being “a soldier,” but in this new context of home also maintains that his conclusion is essential to recall after
those feelings instead make him “but an agony for myself.” the war’s end. Indeed, his belief in the Russians’ humanity
That is to say, they undermine his sense of a coherent becomes part of “a task that will make life afterward worthy
identity and instead transform him into an unspecific of these hideous years”—precisely what he had struggled to
negative energy. pinpoint earlier when imagining the post-war conditions.
It is Paul’s social circles, in particular, that condition this self- The task, Remarque implies, is concerned with recognizing
hating sentiment. For not only is he “an agony for myself” the arbitrariness of war and thus empathizing with soldiers
but also for “for my mother”—implying that the familial even from the opposite faction. Paul’s conclusion therefore
repercussions are what he finds especially damning. He is speaks both to the need to prevent these thoughts in order
unable to fully appreciate the care offered by others and to survive the war and to the merit they could have in a
applies negative energy back to them. Indeed, the comforts different world.
that he should have felt while at home instead become “so
comfortless and without end.” Reentering the safe physical
Now I hear muffled voices. To judge by the tone that might
space does not at all serve to reawaken his emotions, but
be Kat talking…These voices, these quiet words, these
rather points out how extensive the gulf is between these
footsteps in the trench behind me recall me at a bound from
identities. Remarque thus emphasizes how the war
the terrible loneliness and fear of death by which I had been
constructs a separate soldier-ego, which cannot be
almost destroyed. They are more to me than life, these voices,
reconciled with Paul’s earlier life.
they are more than motherliness and more than fear; they are
the strongest, most comforting thing there is anywhere: they
I am frightened: I dare think this way no more. This way are the voices of my comrades. I am no longer a shuddering
lies the abyss. It is not now the time but I will not lose speck of existence, alone in the darkness;—I belong to them and
these thoughts, I will keep them, shut them away until the war they to me; we all share the same fear and the same life, we are
is ended. My heart beats fast: this is the aim, the great, the sole nearer than lovers, in a simpler, a harder way; I could bury my
aim, that I have thought of in the trenches; that I have looked face in them, in these voices, these words that have saved me
for as the only possibility of existence after this annihilation of and will stand by me.
all human feeling; this is a task that will make life afterward
worthy of these hideous years.
Related Characters: Paul Bäumer (speaker), Stanislaus
Katczinsky
Related Characters: Paul Bäumer (speaker)
Related Themes:
Related Themes:
Page Number: 212
Page Number: 194
Explanation and Analysis
Explanation and Analysis During a nighttime patrol, Paul is caught off guard by a
Paul expresses empathy toward the toiling Russian soldiers, bomb and hides alone. Hearing the voices of German
but he catches himself in the act and resolves to delay these soldiers brings him solace and causes him to reflect on the
thoughts until after the war has ended. importance of his comrades.
The fact that Paul feels a need to separate his emotions Though Paul has previously described the strong
speaks to the intense psychological requirements of being a connection he feels to the other soldiers, this passage offers
soldier in this horrific war. Though he ruminates on the a striking instance of that link. First he cannot make out the
humanity of the Russian soldiers in a compelling way, he speakers, calling them merely “muffled voices”—but then he
notices that those thoughts will not fulfill a pragmatic notes that they are potentially from Kat, an identification
purpose in the war and thus they will lead him toward “the that anchors him in a moment of turmoil. In particular,
abyss.” He demands instead that he “shut them away” and
recognizing specific voices restores a sense of identity to emotional pain for the dying man: His “gasp” affects Paul’s
Paul, for he returns from “the terrible loneliness and fear of heart; his “invisible dagger” is a parallel weapon applied to
death”: a void of broad forces that do not conform to his his mental state (“thoughts”) and temporal existence
specific personality. He finds comfort in these “voices of my (“time”). In this way, Remarque verifies the way that Paul
comrades,” Remarque indicates, because they help him feels an intense emotional response to the other soldiers.
regain a specific sense of self. Though he may seek to repress this impulse in order to be
To make this point, Remarque returns to the image of a an operational soldier and stay sane amidst the violence of
“speck of existence” contrasting with the wide “darkness” of war, the moments in which it arises are deeply affecting.
the world. Previously, Paul had felt solace in being a speck
right beside Kat, but here his comradeship actually allows
him to escape that narrow definition of life. Instead, the "Comrade, I did not want to kill you…But you were only an
words and bodies of his comrades are fully fleshed-out, a set idea to me before, an abstraction…now, for the first time, I
of complete humans rather than mere light points. Thus see you are a man like me. I thought of your hand-grenades, of
Paul’s connection to the other soldiers defines his sense of your bayonet, of your rifle; now I see your wife and your face
self in a way that saves him from the solitary void. and our fellowship…Why do they never tell us that you are poor
devils like us, that your mothers are just as anxious as ours, and
that we have the same fear of death, and the same dying and
This is the first time I have killed with my hands, whom I the same agony—Forgive me, comrade; how could you be my
can see close at hand, whose death is my doing. Kat and enemy? If we threw away these rifles and this uniform you
Kropp and Müller have experienced it already, when they have could be my brother just like Kat and Albert. Take twenty years
hit someone; it happens to many, in hand-to-hand fighting of my life, comrade, and stand up—take more, for I do not know
especially— But every gasp lays my heart bare. This dying man what I can even attempt to do with it now."
has time with him, he has an invisible dagger with which he
stabs me: Time and my thoughts. Related Characters: Paul Bäumer (speaker), Gérard Duval
Related Themes:
Related Characters: Paul Bäumer (speaker), Stanislaus
Katczinsky, Albert Kropp, Müller
Page Number: 223
Related Themes: Explanation and Analysis
Page Number: 221 Paul finds the pocketbook of the dying soldier and learns
more about his identity. He reckons with the way this new
Explanation and Analysis knowledge increases his feelings of guilt.
While a cohort of enemy soldiers retreats, Paul stabs one Once more, Remarque reveals a deep empathetic capacity
instinctively. He notes that this is the first man he has killed hidden within Paul. Whereas before, Paul viewed the soldier
with his own hands. as “an abstraction,” learning these facts about his identity
This experience forces Paul to confront the violence has turned him into “a man like me.” Thus specific
inherent in the war for the first time. Nesting the clause, information has given him not only an individual human role,
“whose death is my doing” under the statement “this is the but more directly a deep similarity to Paul. This shift in
first time” may strike the reader as odd—for Paul has perspective alters the objects on which Paul focuses, from
certainly been responsible for death before. Yet this is the the accoutrements of war instead toward his relationships
first time that that action has taken place directly in front of and even a potential connection between the two: “our
his eyes. Previous acts on the front have not required direct fellowship.” Extrapolating a feeling of comradeship is
confrontation with another human. In this way, Paul realizes particularly significant considering how Paul has previously
that he associates culpability not with actual violence but described the deep meaning he feels from his relationships
instead with perceived and proximal violence. with other soldiers on his own side.
Beyond emphasizing the distancing, desensitizing effects of Though this passage focuses on a single interaction, it also
this anonymous and horrifying war, this passage affirms carries a broader social critique. That Paul asks, “Why do
Paul’s deep capacity for empathy. He feels a reciprocal they never tell us,” posits an overseeing force that obscures
human information on other soldiers and that takes on a
Chapter 12 Quotes
censoring role. The implication is that he “could be my
brother” if only different streams of information made his And men will not understand us—for the generation that
full identity more available to Paul. Thus the comradeship grew up before us, though it has passed these years with us
that Paul finds with his fellow soldiers is shown to be, in already had a home and a calling; now it will return to its old
part, a social construction from larger forces wishing to occupations, and the war will be forgotten—and the generation
divide groups of individuals. that has grown up after us will be strange to us and push us
aside. We will be superfluous even to ourselves, we will grow
older, a few will adapt themselves, some others will merely
Chapter 11 Quotes submit, and most will be bewildered;—the years will pass by
and in the end we shall fall into ruin.
Thus we live a closed, hard existence of the utmost
superficiality, and rarely does an incident strike out a spark. But
then unexpectedly a flame of grievous and terrible yearning Related Characters: Paul Bäumer (speaker)
flares up.
Related Themes:
Those are the dangerous moments. They show us that the
adjustment is only artificial, that it is not simple rest, but Page Number: 294
sharpest struggle for rest.
Explanation and Analysis
Related Characters: Paul Bäumer (speaker) Paul fantasizes about returning home after the war has
ended. He reminds himself, however, that those whom he
Related Themes: returns to will be unable to understand what the experience
had meant to him.
Page Number: 274 These reflections return to the motif of the "lost
generation" to which Paul belongs. Those in the older
Explanation and Analysis
generation were firmly anchored in their lives before the
Ruminating on the abstract condition of being a soldier, Paul war began, and those in the newer one will have been too
points out the paradoxical nature of his unit’s existence. To young to have experienced the hardships of war. As a result,
survive, they must focus on purely pragmatic concerns, but Paul reasons, neither side will be able to make sense of the
they also encounter occasional intense moments that reveal soldiers’ memories or identities. Not only will they be
great emotional depths they otherwise try to ignore. pushed aside by these generations, but they will “be
Paul divides the soldiers’ lives into two distinct superfluous even to ourselves”—socially unnecessary,
psychological experiences: the first is the set of practical misunderstood, and suffering from the effects of trauma
concerns focused solely on staying alive, while the second is and existential despair. The deep irony, here, is that they
a more intense, emotional relationship to the self and world. were integral to society during the war, but the exact skills
Casting the first as “utmost superficiality” might seem to needed in that moment will render them irrelevant in
trivialize it, but Paul actually regards the poignant peacetime.
experiences as the negative ones: “Those are the dangerous It is worth noting that Paul himself will never experience
moments” because they distract the soldiers from the this fate, for he dies in the novel before the arrival of
external concerns that must take precedence in war, and peacetime. The technique of placing these thoughts in his
can easily lead them to despair or madness. protagonist’s mind is another example of how Remarque
That Paul sees the pragmatic existence as “artificial” is thus transforms an anecdotal tale into a broader reflection on
not to be taken as a negative assessment. Rather, he sees the generation. For Paul is predicting a broad social fate that
pragmatics as a necessary lie for the group to tell he himself will never witness.
themselves in order to survive and stay sane. It may not be
“simple rest” but it is a necessary “struggle” to eventually
approach that state. In this way, Paul revises the earlier
criticism of split human psychology: He affirms his two-part
existence but here contends that it is necessary given the
situation.
CHAPTER 1
When the novel begins, the Second Company of the German More than half of the Second Company has been killed, a horrific
army has just returned to their camp after two weeks of number, but Paul's matter-of-fact tone suggests that this is
fighting on the frontlines. Their unit has sustained heavy something that doesn’t even faze the soldiers. Apparently they are
casualties. Paul Bäumer, the novel’s nineteen-year-old narrator, used to such catastrophic losses.
reports matter-of-factly that over half of the Company’s 150
men were killed the previous day in a shell attack.
Good food is scarce on the front, so Paul and his friends quickly The deaths of other soldiers offer meager benefits for those who
make their way to the camp’s mess tent. Because so many men survive, like the chance for more food. Such practical, physical
have died, there are enough extra rations for the soldiers to concerns are all the surviving soldiers have. The cook, meanwhile,
have double portions. Initially, the cook refuses to give the men blindly follows the rules—rules set by those running the war, which
the surplus food, saying it is against regulations. The men argue show no compassion for those fighting on the front lines.
heatedly until the company commander intervenes, telling the
cook to distribute the extras.
After eating, Paul and his fellow soldiers pay a visit to the group Before the war, Paul saw the group latrines as disgusting and
latrines together. Paul recalls how, when he first joined the embarrassing. The fact that he doesn't any longer shows how much
army, he was embarrassed about using the latrines in front of worse life in the trenches must be. It also reveals his comradeship
the other soldiers. Now, however, such behavior has come to with his fellow soldiers. He is comfortable with what he once would
seem completely natural, even enjoyable. have considered animalistic.
Paul and his friends spend their first afternoon back relaxing, A teacher, an authority figure whom the boys respected, urged them
playing cards, and reading letters from home. One of the to join the war effort. Though his students volunteered for active
soldiers, Albert Kropp, has received a letter from his former duty, they were under immense pressure to do so. Behm’s senseless
teacher, Kantorek. We learn that four of the men were death early in the war immediately made clear the realities of war to
schoolmates back in Germany: Paul; the clear-headed Kropp; the boys, destroying any romantic illusions (planted in their heads
the brainy but practical Müller; and Leer, the most worldly of by Kantorek) that they may have had. It also illustrates the
the bunch. All of the students had originally joined the army at randomness of who lives and who dies in the trenches.
Kantorek’s urging. (A fifth classmate, Joseph Behm, had
resisted at first; finally, under pressure from Kantorek and his
community, he reluctantly enlisted as well. Behm was killed
horrifically in an early battle.)
In addition to the four students, Paul’s group of friends also The war brings men from all walks of life together. Before the war, a
includes some older soldiers: the skinny locksmith Tjaden; the well educated, middle-class student like Paul would likely never
gigantic peat-digger Haie; the married peasant Detering; and have even known a simple peasant like Detering.
the resourceful Katczinsky (Kat), who at age forty is the group’s
unofficial leader.
Later that day, the soldiers go to visit their wounded friend The visit with Kemmerich highlights how the war has forced the
Kemmerich in the hospital. Though he does not seem to realize soldiers to temper any sympathy they feel with the practical need to
it yet, his leg has been amputated and he is obviously dying. His survive. They visit Kemmerich to comfort him, but when they see
friends try to cheer him up, but they are already planning to that he's likely to die, they also want his boots. Paul still has the
divide up his possessions. Müller tries to persuade Kemmerich decency to stop Müller from being too cruelly practical.
to give them his beautiful leather boots, but Kemmerich
resists. Eventually, Paul steps on Muller’s foot, getting him to
drop the subject.
As the soldiers leave the hospital, Paul thinks about the letter Though the men are clearly disturbed by what they saw in the
he must soon write to Kemmerich’s mother when her son dies. hospital, they avoid openly discussing it. Angry outbursts like
The men walk back through the camp to their huts, Kropp’s are quickly deflected and hidden from the others, suggesting
preoccupied and mostly silent. Only Kropp becomes visibly that exposing such emotions threatens their survival.
upset, tossing away his cigarette and swearing. Müller tries to
distract him by asking about the contents of Kantorek’s letter.
Kropp tells them that Kantorek’s letter calls his former Kantorek’s nickname for the young soldiers reveals how out of touch
students the “Iron Youth,” a title that makes the men smile he is with the realities of life on the front. "Iron" suggests an
bitterly. Paul says that while most of them are under twenty indomitable strength that is made a mockery by modern warfare
years of age, they do not feel young or strong anymore. Their that wipes out half a company, while “Youth” suggests an innocence
horrific experiences in the war have made them old before that the men lost long ago.
their time.
CHAPTER 2
Paul thinks about how, as a student, he had aspired to become a The war has not just threatened and destroyed the lives of the
writer. Now, however, those dreams seem incomprehensible to young soldiers, it has also destroyed their dreams. It has made them
him. Unlike the older soldiers, who left behind families and jobs, foreign to themselves. Paul no longer feels a connection to his past,
Paul and his friends went to war before their lives had really and is equally unable to imagine a peaceful future.
begun. When the war ends, they will have nothing to return to.
Paul goes to visit the dying Kemmerich alone in the hospital On the battlefield Paul is able to desensitize himself to the pain of
again the next day. Paul’s war experiences have mostly numbed others, but in the more civilized realm of the hospital, he realizes
him to human suffering, but he is unprepared for the pain and that he isn’t yet as numb to the horrors of war as he’d like to believe.
grief he feels as he sits by his friend’s bedside. Paul tries to Talking about home proves to be more painful than comforting for
conceal his distress by assuring his friend that now Kemmerich both men, as it reminds them of a past they can never return to.
will be sent back to their home village to recover. But his friend
simply tells Paul to give his precious boots to Müller, indicating
that Kemmerich has realized the truth about his condition.
After a long and painful struggle, Kemmerich finally dies. Kemmerich’s death throws Paul off-kilter, but for the more
Though Paul feels a surge of intense grief, there is no time to experienced hospital orderlies it’s business as usual. It's almost like
properly mourn for his friend. The orderlies must immediately the war is a kind of unstoppable machine, churning out death.
remove the dead body to make room for another soldier. In a
daze, Paul collects Kemmerich’s few possessions and leaves the
hospital.
As Paul heads back to his hut, he finds himself walking faster Running allows, and forces, Paul to concentrate on his physical
and faster until he suddenly breaks into a sprint. As he runs reactions, helping him shut out his thoughts and emotions about
through the camp, hardly aware of his surroundings, Paul Kemmerich's death. By running, Paul is purposely reducing himself
forces himself to stop thinking about Kemmerich. Instead, he into an animal, a body.
focuses on his breathing and his beating heart, reminding
himself that his own body is still strong, healthy, and alive.
When Paul reaches the hut, his friend Müller is waiting outside Once again, the men avoid expressing strong emotional responses.
for him. Paul doesn’t say anything about watching Kemmerich Instead of dwelling on Kemmerich’s death, they concern themselves
die. He simply hands the boots over to Müller without with practicalities—whether the boots fit.
speaking, and they go inside to try them on.
CHAPTER 3
Reinforcements have arrived, most of them new recruits who Time passes differently on the front—for the veteran soldiers, two
have never seen battle. They are only two years younger than years seems like a lifetime of experience. Paul and his friends have
Paul and his former classmates, but they seem like helpless been forced to grow up too quickly; their superior experience,
children. In comparison to these hapless “infants,” the however, is also a source of pride.
experienced soldiers consider themselves to be “stone-age
veterans.”
Paul recalls some of Kat’s most spectacular discoveries, Kat is a source of wonder to Paul, who views the older man with a
marveling at the man’s almost supernatural ability to find food combination of awe and affection. Kat makes it seem like there’s
in the most unlikely places. Once, while camping in a poor, more to life than simply surviving: he shows Paul that it’s possible to
impoverished village, Kat managed to obtain two loaves of flourish, to enjoy oneself, and to create family bonds even in the
bread and a bag of horsemeat—an unimaginable feast for the midst of the war’s devastation.
hungry soldiers. Paul describes how Kat had carefully cooked
the meat and shared it amongst his friends. Kat’s true
“masterpiece,” though, was once bringing back four boxes of
lobsters—though Paul admits that the men might have
preferred a simple steak.
The narrative returns to the present day, where the men are The saluting incident speaks volumes about German military
relaxing in the sun after a long morning of drills. They were leadership. The officers are preoccupied with personal rank and
forced to practice saluting for an hour after their fellow soldier power. As a result, they focus on trivial details instead of thinking
Tjaden failed to salute a superior officer properly. Kat about the big picture. The idea that authority narrows one’s
complains that the officers spend too much time enforcing worldview is a common theme in the novel. Those with the least
military etiquette and too little time preparing the men to fight. power (the common soldiers) are often the most in touch with
He lets off a fart, expressing both his comfort and his contempt reality.
for the officers’ petty concerns.
As the men take bets on an air-fight unfolding above, Kat and Both Kat and Kropp’s proposals would make those in power
Kropp begin to argue about how the war should be fought. Kat accountable for the decision to go to war. Their thinking is that if the
believes that if the officers were paid and fed the same amount great political and military leaders were forced to endure the horrific
as the common soldiers, the war would be over in a day. Kropp, conditions in the trenches, they’d quickly find a reason to end the
on the other hand, says that war should be conducted like a war and return to their comfortable lives. Similarly, single combat
popular festival or bullfight. Instead of sending out vast armies would bring the war to a fast and relatively bloodless conclusion.
to fight and die for them, the leaders of both countries would Either way, they see their leaders, essentially, as corrupt and power-
enter the arena to participate in single combat. Whoever hungry men willing o sacrifice the commoners in search of even
survived would win the war with a minimum of casualties. more power.
The air-fight ends when the German airplane is shot down. For the pilot of the German plane, the outcome of the airfight may
Kropp, who has lost the bet, grudgingly hands over the last be a matter of life and death; for Kat and Kropp, it’s simply a chance
beer to the victorious Kat. Paul is still thinking about to win or lose a beer. Their bet seems callous, but it is ultimately
Himmelstoss, who was a postman before the war began. When harmless, since they have no actual power over who lives and who
Paul wonders aloud how the man became such a bully, Kat dies. The real animals are the generals and other leaders, the men
replies that every man is “essentially a beast,” who conceals his who do have such power, to exercise (and abuse) as they wish.
true nature with “a little decorum.” As soon as a man gets a little
power, however, he inevitably abuses it, and in the process
reveals his animalistic character.
Suddenly, Tjaden runs up to the men with an announcement: Himmelstoss’s method failed because it was based on a flawed
Himmelstoss has been sent to serve on the front. Though none understanding of Tjaden’s problem. Himmelstoss is not a keen judge
of the men like Himmelstoss, Tjaden has a special grudge of character, and like many of the superior officers in the novel, he
against him. During their training, Himmelstoss devised a cruel seems to be incapable of grasping the bigger picture. He tries to
method for “curing” Tjaden of his chronic bedwetting, which he solve everything with force, leading only to pain and humiliation.
wrongly believed was pure laziness. He assigned Tjaden to a
bunk bed with another bed-wetter named Kindervater, and
then forced the men to trade off sleeping in the lower bunk.
The plan was a failure, but it instilled in Tjaden a fiery hatred for
the corporal.
Paul recalls how the men had finally gotten back at Himelstoss The beating illustrates the truth of Kat’s claim that a little power
after weeks of plotting. One night, they snuck up on him as he inevitably brings out men’s animalistic instincts. Though
walked back to the barracks from the pub. Throwing a sheet Himmelstoss tormented the men for weeks, their premeditated
over his face so he could not identify them, the men proceeded attack seems far more violent than anything he inflicted upon them.
to give Himmelstoss a savage beating with a whip. At one point, In training them for war, Himmelstoss inadvertently gave the
Paul remembers, Haie and Tjaden became so brutal the others soldiers a means of rebelling against his tyrannical rule. The old
had to drag them away to get a turn. Himmelstoss trained the soldier’s comment recalls the “Iron Youth” title from Kantorek’s
men to act ruthlessly; the attack demonstrates that they letter, but suggests a different, much more cynical view of heroism.
internalized the message. After hearing the story of their
triumph over the corporal, one old veteran described the
soldiers as “young heroes.”
CHAPTER 4
In the evening, the men of the Second Company are required to Muller’s cheerfulness seems odd given that the men are heading
go up to the front to help build barbed wire fences along the directly into the line of fire, but it indicates how good the soldiers
trenches. The trucks cannot use their headlights for fear of are—and must be, just to stay sane—at compartmentalizing their
being shot, so the ride is bumpy and the men are often nearly emotions. He’s focused on his new boots.
thrown off. Paul says the men are not concerned, however, as a
broken arm is “better than a hole in the guts” and may even
allow them to return home to recover. The usually moody
Muller is in particularly good spirits, as he is wearing the new
boots he has inherited from their dead friend Kemmerich.
The trucks pass by a farmhouse, where Paul hears geese Kat’s fatherly influence on Paul is evident here. Good parents teach
cackling. He glances at Kat, who has had the same thought: the their children how to survive in a difficult world (often by example).
geese would make an excellent supper for the hungry soldiers. In noticing the geese cackling, Paul is demonstrating survival skills
learned from Kat.
When the men finally arrive at the artillery lines, Paul notices The bushes are part of the natural landscape, and for a moment
that the gun-mounts are camouflaged with bushes, giving the when Paul sees them he catches a brief glimpse of what the French
scene an almost festive appearance. The illusion is quickly countryside might look like during a time of peace. But these bushes
shattered, however, as the air fills with smoke from the guns. are only an illusion, concealing the ugly machinery of war. When the
The men’s good spirits vanish in an instant. The veterans are battle begins, the men are immediately all business again. Kat once
not afraid, but the young recruits become agitated. Kat again assumes a leadership role, guiding the terrified young soldiers
patiently explains to them how to identify different types of through their first experience on the front.
bombs by the sound of the explosions. Though the English
usually start firing promptly at ten PM, tonight they have begun
attacking an hour early. According to Kat, this is a sign that the
enemy is preparing to launch a heavy bombardment.
Paul describes the transformation that takes place in the Given Kat’s experience and general know-how, it’s clear that his
soldiers when they reach the front. The men may not visibly words must be taken seriously. On the front, the men enter a state
display any signs of fear or concern, but they experience an of complete alertness—just as a weaker animal must constantly be
inner transformation, becoming tense and alert. Every word on guard against a more powerful predator.
the soldiers say to each other seems to take on new
significance, especially Kat’s prediction about the impending
bombardment.
The soldier’s relationship to his environment also changes on The war creates new kinds of bonds between people and their
the front. According to Paul, no man is closer to the earth than environments, which Paul struggles to explain to those who lack
the soldier, who becomes a kind of mother for the men who firsthand experience. Describing these bonds as familial
fight and die on her soil. The mud of the trenches shelters the relationships is one way of ‘translating’ them into more
soldier from shellfire, stifles his cries of fear, and eventually comprehensible terms.
covers his body in the grave.
The lorries continue towards the front. The sight of the troops Knights are associated with concepts like chivalry and valor. As Paul
filing silently along the road strikes Paul as strangely beautiful, has mentioned before, however, these ideas of gallant war are
like “knights of a forgotten time” marching off to battle. As they utterly destroyed in the face of modern technology and its capacity
approach the frontline, the night sky is lit up by bursts of light for random and anonymous destruction. The airman’s death is a
from exploding rockets. The bombardment Kat predicted has perfect example of how insignificant a single soldier’s life is in the
begun. Paul watches as the enemy’s searchlights illuminate a grand chaos of World War I.
tiny, insectlike figure in the sky: an unlucky airman, who is
immediately shot down.
The men quickly complete their task of building the barbed Paul’s tears seem to be a reaction to a sudden shock rather than
wire fences, but must wait until the lorries return to take them evidence of conscious fear. At the same time, his ability to respond
back to camp. Most lie down and try to sleep despite the noise. to a beautiful garden in such an emotional way is very human,
Paul briefly drifts off and wakes up disoriented. For a second he indicating perhaps that the war has not yet managed to fully
thinks he has woken up in a beautiful, peaceful garden. He transform him into a savage animal or a mindless machine.
realizes suddenly that his face is wet with tears. Kat soothes
him, telling him he was simply frightened by a nearby explosion.
The bombardment draws closer.
Paul spots one of the new recruits lying terrified on the ground. In this interaction, Paul takes on the fatherly role previously filled by
Reminded of his dead friend Kemmerich, he lets the frightened Kat. He provides comfort, but also passes on practical survival
young soldier crawl under his arm for comfort. The ever- lessons to the new recruit (who represents a new generation in the
practical Paul also places a helmet over the soldier’s rear—not military ‘family’). Paul also once again demonstrates the soldier’s
as a joke, but because it would be a painful place to be typical lack of embarrassment towards bodily functions, which are
wounded. When the bombardment ends, Paul realizes the not treated as something shameful.
young man has had an accident. Kindly, he tells the soldier that
it’s happened to many men before, and sends him off to clean
himself up.
As the noise of the bombardment dies down, the men hear the Paul often depicts the soldiers as innocent pawns in a war run by
terrible cries of horses that have been wounded. The soldier rich and power-hungry men. But the animals have even less control
Detering, a peasant farmer who loves animals, becomes over their fates than the men. The soldiers may have become
agitated, shouting for someone to put the horses out of their desensitized to the prospect of human death, but the senselessness
misery. He aims his rifle at one of the wounded horses, but Kat of the horses’ suffering disturbs even the most emotionally stoic.
stops him from firing. The men must lie still and wait for the
others, listening to the maddening sound of the horses’ death
agonies.
The first few minutes of the gas attack are tense, as the men The uprooted coffins are an ambiguous symbol. They are quite
wait to discover whether their masks are airtight. Paul breathes literally containers of death; they also bring death, in the case of the
cautiously, watching the clouds of gas sink into the shell-hole as soldier whose arm is crushed. At the same time, the coffins provide
a second bombardment begins. Nearby, a soldier is wounded shelter for the living soldiers, shielding them from a similar fate. It
when a coffin falls on his arm, crushing it. Finally, just as the seems significant, too, that the corpses are tossed out of the
men feel they are close to suffocating, the gas dissipates and coffins—a kind of bizarre rebirth that is also a second death.
they can remove their masks. The field is littered with corpses
“killed once again” when they were thrown from the coffins; but
Paul says that each one saved one of the surviving soldiers.
Kat and Paul go over to help bandage the injured soldier’s To Kat and Paul, shooting the soldier isn’t an act of further violence,
wounds. Paul realizes it is the young recruit he comforted but one of mercy. The decision isn’t even a difficult one—though
earlier. The young man has been horrifically wounded in the hip they don’t explicitly say so, they know they would want their fellow
and arm; Paul says he will live in “howling torture” for only a few soldiers to do the same for them. And yet the army—in the form of
days at best. Kat and Paul quietly decide to put the young man the other soldiers—offers no such mercy.
out of his misery by shooting him, but a group of soldiers
arrives before they can do so. They put the wounded man on a
stretcher and return to the lorries.
The Second Company has lost five men and had eight more The dead men aren’t even granted the dignity of individual burial.
wounded. Two of the men have perished in upturned graves, Their deaths are truly anonymous, perhaps even more so than if
and are simply buried in the same spot. As the men board the they had died in the trenches. The ‘monotony’ of the falling rain
lorries it begins to rain; Paul thinks about the rain falling reinforces the sense that all is bleak, grey, and meaningless.
monotonously all over the world, over the living, the wounded,
and the dead alike. Exhausted from the long, sleepless night, he
and the other soldiers fall into a restless half-sleep.
CHAPTER 5
The men are infected with lice from living in the squalor of the The soldiers’ mundane, mechanized killing of lice symbolizes the
camp and trenches. Killing the bugs one by one is too time- way technological advancements were harnessed in World War I to
consuming, so they have rigged up a contraption involving a tin kill men more quickly, efficiently, and dispassionately. Himmelstoss's
lid and a candle. The men gather around the tin to pick off lice arrival at the front seems to suggest a coming confrontation
and gossip. Word in the camp is that Himmelstoss, their much- between the men and their former tormentor.
hated former training corporal, has just arrived at the front.
Tjaden, who has a particular grudge against the man, is busy
planning what to say when he sees him again.
Müller won’t let the subject drop. He wakes up Haie and asks Haie’s remark reminds Paul that that the soldiers come from a wide
him the same question. Haie seems confused at first, then variety of economic and social backgrounds, even if they share a
answers cheerfully that he’d find a pretty woman and a real common experience in the trenches. If Haie survives the war, he will
bed. When Muller asks him what he’d do after that, Haie still belong to the lower working class, whereas Paul and the other
becomes serious and says that he would stay in the army and students will return to the world of upper middle class.
serve out his time. Though Paul is incredulous, Haie explains
that for a peasant laborer, army life in peacetime doesn’t seem
so bad—at least you get regular meals, clean clothes, and
respect from your home villagers.
Kat points out that it’s a moot point—Haie is a common soldier, The soldiers’ differing responses to Müller’s question further
not a noncommissioned officer, so he’ll never get to live out his highlight their vastly distinct backgrounds and philosophies towards
dream even if the war ends. Haie looks at him sadly and says life. Detering’s response is notable: the peasant’s matter-of-factness
nothing, clearly still thinking about the life he might have had. shows that he doesn’t have the luxury of analyzing life as deeply as
Tjaden, when asked what he’d do in peacetime, describes his Paul and his cohort can.
fantasy of beating Himmelstoss to a pulp. Detering answers
that he would simply go on with the harvest.
Himmelstoss appears at the camp and awkwardly approaches The scramble for survival in trench warfare has eroded many of the
the group of men. He is met with outright hostility, and he and soldiers’ senses of deference to authority. Tjaden—the bedwetter
Tjaden exchange insults. Himmelstoss finally commands Tjaden during boot camp— is now fearless in his defiance of his superior
to stand up. Tjaden ignores his superior officer and instead officers, perhaps because he perceives that he has less to lose for
passes gas. Himmelstoss storms off, threatening to have Tjaden acting that way.
court-martialed for his impudence. After the corporal leaves,
Tjaden and Haie laugh about the altercation—Haie laughs so
hard he dislocates his jaw. Kat warns Tjaden that he may be
disciplined harshly, but Tjaden is carefree.
Müller and Kropp tally up the casualties their school class has The knowledge that the educated soldiers valued so highly in their
suffered: twelve out of twenty are either dead, wounded, or in civilian lives is no help to them on the front. This is yet another
a mad-house. The men then imitate Kantorek and quiz each affirmation of the change in perspective that will leave them unable
other on scholarly knowledge, which they conclude is useless to readjust to the lives they had.
to them on the front.
Himmelstoss and a fat sergeant-major look for Tjaden to Tjaden’s insubordination isn’t effectively disciplined because the
discipline him. He receives three days of open arrest as officers cannot inflict worse punishment than what the soldiers
punishment, which Paul describes as “quite pleasant.” already endure.
At Kat’s suggestion, Paul breaks into a barn to steal two geese. This goose-rustling adventure reminds a reader that Paul is still very
He tries to kill the birds quickly, but they cackle, and a guard much a young man. And yet there is casual violence in the stealing
dog comes to subdue Paul. After staying still for a long time, of the geese—the murder of the guard dog—which indicates that
Paul shoots at the dog with a revolver and escapes with the Paul is also no longer just a young man. He has been changed by the
geese. He and Kat pluck and roast the geese, and plan to make war.
cushions with the feathers that read “Sleep soft under shell-
fire.”
As the two men sit in the dead of night and cook their geese, This scene is a brief respite from the horror of the frontlines. The
Paul reflects that they have a profound bond—he and Kat trying circumstances have made Paul attuned to his common
represent sparks of life surrounded by a lifeless night. In a humanity with Kat, and the hardship they have suffered together
sleepy daze, Paul lovingly watches Kat baste the roasting prompts them to treat one another generously, with love.
goose, and he laments the way soldiers harden their hearts. He
wakes up, apparently weeping. Kat comforts Paul and the two
eat together, each insisting that the other enjoy the best pieces.
The two bring the leftovers to Kropp and Tjaden, and the men
eat gratefully.
CHAPTER 6
The company is sent to the front two days earlier than usual, The new coffins foreshadow death and suffering to come. The
after hearing rumors of a new offensive. On their way, they soldiers are being sent to the front with the expectation that many
pass a large stack of brand-new coffins. The men joke about the of them will be slaughtered. The men know it and their leaders know
spectacle, but they understand that the coffins are meant for it, and yet the men still do their “duty.”
them.
When they reach the front, the men notice that the enemy The soldiers’ unrest is heightened in anticipation of an enemy
artillery has been reinforced. Worse yet, the German artillery is attack. The casualties from friendly fire show a breakdown in basic
so worn out that they often shoot into their own trenches, order.
occasionally wounding men.
The company’s trench is in deteriorating condition, and it is The vermin grow fat off the dead bodies of the common soldiers,
infested with fat, revolting rats that the men call “corpse-rats.” which can be taken as a metaphor for the powerful who also grow
Tired of the rats eating their bread, the men make a pile of even more powerful on the backs of the soldiers who die for them.
bread and use shovels to kill any rats that come near it.
Rations of cheese and rum are handed out to the soldiers, but The temporary comforts of rum and cheese do little to calm the
the men understand them to signify hard times ahead. The men soldiers, and they occupy themselves in mindless work to escape
receive more ammunition, and set to remove serrated blades their anxiety.
from their bayonets, because the enemy will brutally kill any
German found to be using a saw-blade bayonet.
The uneasy German soldiers hear the enemy fortifying its lines, As the lull in fighting drags on, the tension builds, and the soldiers’
but no major moves are made by either side. Kat is mind-numbing anxiety mounts.
dejected—he predicts intense violence to begin soon—and this
worries Paul, because Kat is an experienced frontline fighter.
Only Tjaden remains unsuspicious and content during the lull.
After a few more days of uncertainty, the men relax slightly. The sudden violence hardens the veterans and stuns the recruits.
Then, in the middle of one night, their lines are shelled heavily. The depiction of the recruits shows what Paul and his friends must
The men are shaken; some of the new recruits are even have looked like in their first experiences of the front—and creates
vomiting. The bombing continues. The men become numb and an understanding of why they had to become so detached as a
silent, and their trench is nearly destroyed. defense mechanism to preserve their sanity.
Attempts to bring food and ammunition to the trench fail The men begin to lose their basic human necessities, and the rats’
because the enemy barrage cannot be traversed. The men predatory advance shows that more animalistic rules are beginning
grow hungry, and they cannot sleep at night. The next morning, to govern behavior.
the trenches are beset by an onslaught of fleeing rats. A rat-
killing melee ensues, and the exhausted men stop just short of
striking one another in the confusion.
The company continues to wait. At midday, one of the new The circumstances are obviously proving too much for the new
recruits begins convulsing and tries to escape the front. Paul recruits, who haven’t been combat-hardened like Paul and his
says the recruit suffers from claustrophobia, and the other comrades. The men continue to act like animals—instead of trying
soldiers beat the raving man in an attempt to restore his sanity. to reason with the raving recruit, they simply beat him into
The other recruits witness this episode fearfully, and Paul pities submission.
them for being thrown inexperienced into such a harrowing
bombardment.
The bombardment lets up, and the soldiers understand that an The horrors Paul witnesses become ingrained in his memory; the
enemy attack is now coming. They throw grenades into the no- French soldier’s clasped, severed hands offer a cynical image of a
man’s-land between the trenches and recognize a charging line prayer gone unheeded.
of French soldiers. Paul sees an enemy soldier fall into barbed
wire with his hands clasped in front of him; when Paul looks
again, only the stumps of the soldier’s arms remain hanging in
the wire.
The company begins to retreat. Paul makes eye contact with an The brief moment of human connection between Paul and the
enemy soldier, and the connection momentarily removes him enemy soldier suggests that the common soldiers are not actually
from the entire “circus” of violence around him. Paul then true enemies. But the rush of mindless fighting continues and the
throws a grenade at the man and runs toward the rear. need to survive overcomes any other thought.
The mayhem has turned the men into animals defending When they are pushed to their limits, the men lose their humanity
themselves against annihilation. The soldiers continue to flee, and instead become solely concerned with fighting to survive. Their
and Paul reaches a manned German trench. From this point, brutal treatment of the retreating French shows that the harrowing
the Germans begin to drive back the enemy advance. Paul and circumstances have utterly stripped them of their reason.
his comrades follow the retreating French and brutalize any
stragglers, and the Germans reach the enemy line at roughly
the same time as the retreating French do. The Germans clear
out the French frontline and quickly retreat with provisions.
Paul and his comrades return to their frontlines. They are so As the immediate danger fades, the men’s humanity returns, and
drained by their experience that an hour passes before anyone they begin to enjoy the basic necessities they had ignored in the
speaks. Gradually, they regain their usual demeanor, and begin chaos. Of course, these necessities are things they have taken from
to enjoy the French provisions they have looted. the men they have killed.
Paul is placed on evening sentry duty. During the night he is Paul tries to retreat from the constant commotion of the front by
haunted by unsettlingly calm visions from his childhood and delving into his calm memories, but he is permanently alienated
hometown. He laments that the desires of his youth are now from his past life. He is confident that warfare has changed him
lost to him. Even if Paul and his fellow soldiers were to return forever.
to the scenes of their youth, their exposure to the “hard facts”
of life would make them indifferent.
After another brief lull in fighting, a bombardment begins. Paul’s experience in combat has even alienated him from the less-
Inexperienced recruits die in droves, and Paul notices that their experienced soldiers—he sees in them an innocence that he can’t
faces have the expressionlessness of dead children. Paul comes find in himself. While the younger men suffer, Himmelstoss proves to
across Himmelstoss cowering in a trench, pretending to be be a two-faced coward, intent only on protecting himself and
injured. He yells at Himmelstoss, but the officer will not budge. impressing his superiors.
A lieutenant orders a charge, and Himmelstoss eagerly runs
ahead. Paul tries to teach the new recruits the skills that will
keep them alive, but they are unable to learn quickly enough
and repeat the same mistakes.
Haie suffers a significant wound and fears for his life. Finally, The hundreds of coffins the soldiers saw on their way to the front
Paul and his fellow soldiers are relieved from the frontlines. At have proven necessary. Trench warfare has exacted an astoundingly
roll call, Paul discovers that only 32 of the original 150 men in devastating toll on Paul’s comrades.
the Second Company are still alive.
CHAPTER 7
Paul’s company is taken to a depot in order to reorganize and Trench warfare is a human equalizer: the horrible conflict has
accommodate more than 100 reinforcements. As the men relax brought Himmelstoss to the same level as the other soldiers. He
during their time off, Himmelstoss, shaken by his time in the realizes now the true horror of the war he was “preparing” them for
trenches, approaches the group and tries to make amends. Paul in boot camp, and that his efforts to cover them up through cruelty
accepts Himmelstoss’s attempts to reconcile, especially are trivial in comparison to what they would actually face.
because Himmelstoss helped Haie when he was injured in
battle. Tjaden is skeptical at first, but is won over when
Himmelstoss gives the men extra rations he has obtained
through his new job as a cook.
Paul reflects that while he and the other soldiers manage to Paul’s trauma can no longer be completely repressed—he is
distract themselves while they’re on leave, they never really becoming more and more aware of his need to devise new ways to
forget what they witness on the front. They loaf on leave, Paul keep himself from intellectually processing what he and his
supposes, because they need to live without burdening comrades have witnessed.
themselves with any inappropriate emotions. What outsiders
view as good humor in the soldiers is in fact a necessary
barrier—the soldiers crack jokes because they would otherwise
fall apart from bitterness. Paul realizes that once the war is
over, he will need to deal with the feelings he now keeps
repressed.
Paul and Kropp come across a poster for an old army Paul and Kropp cannot restrain their jealousy and alienation from
performance in which a pretty girl stands beside a sharply- the luxuries of civilian life.
dressed man. They stare at the poster with longing, but with
some resentment, and they rip the man out of the picture.
Paul, Leer, and Kropp sneak over to the girls’ house and Paul’s attempt to escape the war through sex fails. He cannot keep
fraternize with the women. Paul has a passionate romantic his physical and spiritual needs separate from the trauma of
encounter with a petite brunette, and he hopes that the girl’s war—his monolithic stress rears its head even in moments of
embrace will take him out of the “war and terror and grossness” tenderness.
that surrounds him. After a while, the three men leave, and Paul
finds himself unhappy despite Leer’s high spirits.
Paul is given a pass for a seventeen-day leave. After his leave, Paul’s leave and training-camp summons slightly alienate him from
Paul will not return to the front immediately, and will report his fellow soldiers, and this detachment is what prompts him to
instead to a training camp. He buys his comrades drinks at the wonder if he’s experienced this camaraderie for the last time. Paul
canteen, and he wonders if he will see them again after his six- learns that for the French girl the sex was a means to an end—the
week hiatus. Paul tells his French lover about his departure, food he brought her, and perhaps the simple pleasure of sex; she did
and is disappointed to see that she seems uninterested. not care much at all about him.
Impatient to leave, Paul begins his journey home. As he draws Returning home confirms Paul’s worries about his detachment and
nearer to the place he grew up in, he is struck by nostalgia. But alienation from civilian life—he is unable to comfortably re-
when he reaches his hometown he realizes that he cannot assimilate into his pre-war life.
recognize the people he sees on the streets. He returns home,
and his eldest sister answers the door. Her voice overwhelms
Paul, and he is brought to tears. Paul sees his mother, who has
become bedridden and sickly. His family feeds him well—Paul
guesses that they’ve saved the food for months, as they have
had trouble getting food.
Paul feels strangely detached from his home, and feels as if Because his experience on the front has so profoundly affected him,
there is a “veil” between himself and his family. His mother asks Paul cannot verbalize the hardships he has endured. This only
him how the war is, and he feels that she could never compounds his alienation from civilian life—it’s not just that he
understand an honest answer. Instead of telling his mother doesn’t fit, he can’t even explain how he doesn’t fit.
about the horrors he’s witnessed, Paul simply tells her that
things are not so bad.
Paul feels repulsed by the curiosity people have about his Some of the older generation of German civilians are hypocritical,
military service, and appreciates his mother for asking no and presume to understand the war better than the soldiers
questions. Paul worries that if he tried to verbalize his themselves. Paul receives the paradoxical treatment of being
experience, he would no longer be able to suppress it. Some simultaneously condescended to and treated as an invaluable asset
aspects of domestic life prove difficult, as well: tram cars sound to the war effort.
like screaming shells. An old schoolteacher ropes Paul into
having a cigar with him, and people at the table patronize Paul
and praise the war effort. When Paul expresses reservations
about the success of the war, the teacher implies that Paul
doesn’t understand the nuances of the conflict.
Leave is different from what Paul expected, and he takes this to The hardship of the frontlines has consumed Paul’s identity—unlike
indicate that he himself has changed. He is put off by civilians’ the civilians, he doesn’t have the luxury of being able to tune out the
presumptuousness, and prefers to be alone. His war experience suffering of war and continue with a routine existence.
has left him unable to understand how the civilians
compartmentalize their lives and intellectualize their feelings.
Sitting in his childhood room, Paul longs to feel as though he Paul’s inability to recover his drive to read or learn represents yet
belongs, and wishes for the intellectual hunger he used to feel another way that his identity has been remolded by his time on the
when he stared at his books. He thumbs through his books, and front. In the face of the death and horror he has seen, his former
is unmoved by the words he sees before him. He hopes that his intellectual pursuits seem meaningless.
disenchantment during his brief time at home isn’t enough to
indicate a fundamental change in his personality.
Paul goes to visit Mittelstaedt at the barracks, and discovers While Paul enjoys seeing Kantorek taken to task for his thoughtless,
that Kantorek has been given a role as a subordinate officer to empty patriotism, this scene also carries a more somber overtone.
Mittelstaedt. Mittelstaedt tells Paul that he has rejected the With this depiction of how pathetic the once-dignified teacher has
schoolmaster’s attempts to be friendly, and instead criticized become, readers are shown that the war effort has held
him for pressuring his students to enlist in the army. He takes ramifications not just for people of Paul’s generation.
Paul to the parade ground, and Paul looks on as Mittelstaedt
reprimands a shabbily dressed Kantorek for keeping his
uniform in poor condition. Then, Mittelstaedt makes Kantorek
perform several ridiculous exercises. Paul is delighted to see
the schoolmaster’s role reversed.
Paul goes to visit Kemmerich’s mother. She is an anxious mess, Paul’s willingness to lie under oath to Kemmerich’s mother can be
and demands that Paul tell her how her son died. Paul tells her interpreted in a number of ways—that he no longer holds anything
that Kemmerich was shot in the heart and killed instantly, but sacred; that he knows that the truth could only hurt her; that he
Kemmerich’s mother sees through the lie. Paul refuses to drop senses that she couldn’t possibly understand the horror of the front
the story, and swears its truthfulness on all that is sacred to lines and therefore spares her from it.
him, simply to appease Kemmerich’s mother.
It is Paul’s last evening at home. Late that night, his mother Rather than being a relaxing respite, his trip home has reminded
comes into his room, and Paul pretends to sleep. They exchange Paul of what he and his family have lost because of the war, and
awkward parting words, and Paul laments that he can no longer what they still stand to lose if he is killed or injured. He both finds no
place his head in her lap and weep. She urges him to be careful solace at home, but also is reminded that he cannot think solely of
and try his best to avoid fighting, and he asks her to get well himself, making it harder for him to hide behind his detached
before he returns. Paul returns to bed, furious that he came exterior.
home on leave: on the front, he had been “indifferent and often
hopeless,” but now, he sees himself as “nothing but an agony for
myself, for my mother, for everything that is so comfortless and
without end.”
CHAPTER 8
Paul arrives at the training camp, and recognizes few people. Paul’s experience at the camp will be a time for introspection, and
The camp is in idyllic countryside, and Paul chooses to spend his solitariness sets the stage for deeper realizations.
much of his time alone, reverently observing nature.
Adjacent to Paul’s camp is a prison camp for captured Russians, The sight of the Russian soldiers prompts Paul to think about the
who must sift through the Germans’ garbage to find food. Paul differences between himself and his enemy. The prisoners’
wonders what horrible refuse the men must be reduced to wretchedness makes it difficult to feel any animosity towards them.
eating, as the German rations are quite thin themselves. Paul Paul is realizing that the common soldiers are, largely, all the same.
feels pity for the wretched prisoners, and notices that they That he is killing men just like him, toward whom he holds no real
have honest, peasant-like features that resemble those of the animosity. At the same time, these men all exploit each other in the
people of the German countryside. Some of the soldiers in name of practical survival (i.e. getting better boots).
Paul’s camp will kick the Russian prisoners out of spite, but
most simply ignore them. In the evenings, the Russians come to
the German camp to barter their possessions for food, and the
Germans shrewdly trade for the superior Russian boots.
Paul becomes frightened by these thoughts, and decides to Paul realizes that this profound introspection could make his time
repress them until the war is over. He gives some of his as a soldier harder to endure, so he tries to distract himself by being
cigarettes to the Russians, and is comforted by their glow. generous to the prisoners.
Nearly every day sees the death of a Russian prisoner, and Paul The way Paul reacts to the music shows that his emotional
is placed on guard duty for one of the burials. After the funeral, reactions to the war are becoming harder and harder to push to the
Paul listens to one of the prisoners play violin and reflects that back of his mind and escape.
hearing the music outside makes it sound thin and melancholy.
Because he already was given a leave, Paul gets none on The dehumanizing cycle of sickness and poverty that Paul’s family
Sundays. On his last Sunday before returning to the front, his has to endure isn’t all that dissimilar to the dehumanization Paul
father and eldest sister come visit him. The have little to talk experiences in the trenches. Paul seems to recognize this similarity,
about, and Paul’s relatives confirm that his mother has come since he cracks jokes to distract his father in much the same way as
down with cancer and will be operated on soon. His mother is the soldiers use humor to distract themselves.
in a crowded, inexpensive wing of the hospital; Paul’s father,
poor and overworked, is worried about finances but afraid to
ask the surgeon what the operation will cost, because he fears
it might make the surgeon unwilling to operate. Paul thinks of
his father’s dismal and grinding work routine, and tries to
lighten his spirits with humor.
Paul’s father and sister leave him with jam and potato-cakes his Paul’s conflicting emotional attachments to his home and to the
mother has made. Paul tries some of the food, but has no taste prisoners force him to compromise. By giving away only some of the
for it, so makes up his mind to give it to the Russians. Paul then food his family has given him, he reconciles his generosity with his
remembers that his mother must have been in great pain when sentimentality.
she made the cakes, and decides to give only two of them away
to the prisoners.
CHAPTER 9
Paul travels back to the frontlines to rejoin his regiment, and is The health and safety of Paul’s comrades is a blessing and a
pleased to find Tjaden, Müller, Kat, and Kropp all alive and well. surprise, and it staves off some of Paul’s concerns about being
alienated from his fellow soldiers upon his return.
The regiment cleans up its equipment in anticipation of a visit Tjaden’s irreverent criticisms of the powers that be highlight the
from the Kaiser. When the Kaiser arrives to inspect the troops, illogical and dehumanizing nature of modern warfare. The Kaiser is
Paul is underwhelmed by his appearance. Tjaden muses that the men’s ultimate leader as the leader of their country, and as a
despite the Kaiser’s prestige, he goes to the latrine just the king was held to be something more than a man. But Tjaden has
same as other men. When the other men pressure his position, become so disillusioned by the war—or, perhaps, has been made to
Tjaden plays dumb, and the others unwittingly outline the see so clearly by the war—that he can see the Kaiser as just a
uselessness of the war. Paul is noncommittal, and notices that normal man. And in seeing the Kaiser as a normal man Tjaden
Tjaden is pleased to have triumphed in an argument against the raises the question of why, if he is just like them, they are fighting
more patriotic volunteer soldiers. and dying for him at all.
Despite rumors of being moved to Russia, the regiment is sent The regiment’s redeployments to the front are often accompanied
up to the front line. On their way up, they pass a landscape of by sinister omens of coming violence, and the dismembered soldiers
craters and shattered trees. Some of the trees hold dead in the trees is perhaps the grisliest yet.
soldiers, and in one of them, Paul sees a legless, naked corpse.
Paul volunteers to go on a patrol to assess the strength of the Paul’s experience alone in the night sparks existential dread.
enemy’s position. A bomb lands near him and catches him off Without the support of his comrades, the trauma of war is too much
guard; he is gripped with terror of being alone and helpless in to handle.
the dark.
After some time spent paralyzed in his hiding place, Paul hears Comradeship is the only thing that keeps Paul anchored through the
the voices of the other German soldiers on patrol, and finds grinding uncertainty of trench warfare.
them deeply comforting. The presence of his comrades rescues
Paul from the brink of loneliness and darkness, and he reflects
on his closeness with and reliance on these men.
A bombardment begins, and Paul realizes that an enemy charge Paul’s proximity to the man he has killed forces him to come to
will soon follow. He pretends to be dead, and spreads himself terms in a much more personal way with the destruction he’s
out in the muddy water in a shell-hole. The enemy charge is wrought. Making eye contact with the man helps Paul understand
repulsed by the Germans, and a wave of retreating men runs that he and the enemy soldier are no different from each other. The
past Paul, but one stumbles onto him. Paul, without thinking, technology of World War I made killing impersonal. But now, when
immediately begins stabbing at the man. He then retreats to it becomes personal for Paul, he finds himself sickened by it, and
another side of the hole and watches the man agonize. Paul wants to do everything he can to reverse it (though of course he is
becomes nauseated by his bloody hands, and sees in the dying unable to).
man’s eyes a powerful and primal fear. He comforts the man,
gives him water from the puddle, and bandages his wounds.
The sunset comes, and Paul senses his time to escape. His After a disturbing confrontation with mortality, Paul’s more animal
desire to live flares and he quickly forgets about the dead man. instincts kick in, and his basic desire for life gives him the energy to
He sneaks towards his line, and worries that his comrades may find cover.
not recognize him and fire upon him. Finally, he comes across
Kat and Albert, who have come out with a stretcher to look for
him. He tells the men what has happened, but neglects to
mention the dead printer.
The next morning, Paul can no longer keep the man he has Once again surrounded by the German war machine, Paul finds it
killed a secret. He tells Kat and Albert what he has done, and easier to justify his actions as natural results of warfare. The
they reassure him. Paul decides that he was only speaking impersonal detachment from suffering that trench warfare provides
nonsense in the shell-hole. They watch as a sergeant lets Paul set his human anxieties aside.
enthusiastically snipes at enemy soldiers, treating the affair as
a game. The men conclude that Paul has no reason to lose sleep
over what he has done.
CHAPTER 10
Paul, Kat, Albert, Müller, Tjaden, and Detering are sent to The men are so committed to enjoying the luxury they have
guard an abandoned village. They find a suitable position to set discovered that they literally risk their lives to continue preparing
up a dugout and move mattresses in from the houses to be the meal. However, despite their commitment to enjoying
more comfortable. The men then find fresh food—including themselves, the men are not overcome by greed: they share their
two young pigs—and prepare a splendid dinner for themselves. bounty with every human and animal there to receive it.
An enemy balloon spots the smoke from their cooking and
begins to shell the men, but they continue to prepare food in
spite of the danger. The men return to their dugout for a
decadent meal that they share with two wireless operators and
a stray cat. Afterwards, the men enjoy cognac, cigars, and
coffee. Unable to fully digest the sumptuous meal after living
off of rations, all the men end up with indigestion. The men
spend nearly two weeks undisturbed in the village, living a
“charmed life.” They enjoy the ample supplies and pretend to be
aristocrats. Finally, they are taken away from the village, and
bring furniture and provisions along with them.
Paul and Albert bribe a sergeant-major with cigars in order to Austere trench life has made the men reluctant to take advantage of
get on the next hospital train. On the train, Paul is delighted to anything but their most basic requirements. They initially demur
see clean linen and friendly nurses, and is nearly too from asking for the nurses’ help because they have learned only to
embarrassed to place his dirty body on the sheets. That night, impose when absolutely necessary. Finally, Paul’s feigned fever
Paul needs to go to the bathroom, but he and Kropp feel illustrates the lengths he will go to in order not to be separated from
uncomfortable telling the young nurse what they need. They his comrades.
soon overcome their bashfulness and lose their inhibitions
about asking for help. Albert has a fever and is scheduled to be
placed in the nearest hospital, and Paul fakes a fever so that he
and Kropp can stick together.
The two injured men are placed in the same room in a Catholic To the injured soldiers, Catholic ritual now seems superfluous to
hospital. The men have a hard time falling asleep, and are their basic needs. The men are willing to commit sacrilege because it
woken by early-morning prayers, and they demand that the furthers their fundamental health. The civilian nuns are disgusted
nuns close the door. The nuns do not accommodate the men, so and unsympathetic because they are incapable of understanding
they shatter a water bottle on the door and the ruffled nuns the soldiers’ rationale, which is based on the horrors that the
satisfy the men’s request. A hospital inspector arrives later that soldiers have experienced but which the nurses have not.
day to find out who threw the bottle, and before Paul can
report himself, another man takes responsibility. The man,
Josef Hamacher, explains that after a head injury, he has been
given a “shooting license”—a certificate that says he is
sometimes not responsible for his actions—which he uses
whenever he pleases.
There are eight men in Paul and Albert’s room. On the third The men’s caretakers are not in touch with the soldiers’ needs, likely
night, a man named Franz Wächter begins to bleed heavily. The because of the wide gulf in experience between the frontline fighters
night nurse doesn’t respond to many calls, and Franz loses a lot and the civilians.
of blood before he is attended to. He is moved to the Dying
Room, which is reserved for moribund patients. Another
occupant of the room, Peter, is also sent to the Dying Room,
even though he resists fiercely.
Paul receives an operation because his bones will not grow Even the hospital cannot provide a safe and understanding
back together. The hospital surgeons look forward to practicing environment for the soldiers. These circumstances make the men in
unnecessary procedures on new admits to the hospital. Paul’s room rely on one another for support, just as soldiers do in
Meanwhile, Kropp must have his leg amputated, and threatens the trenches.
to kill himself at his first opportunity. Many men cycle through
Paul’s room, but Peter surprisingly manages to return from the
Dying Room.
Paul is given convalescent leave. He returns home, parting with Paul’s second trip home is even more discouraging than his first,
Kropp, whose recovery is going relatively smoothly. Paul which likely reflects Paul’s own spirits and the German army’s
returns home to find his mother in much worse shape than worsening condition.
before, and she is reluctant to let him leave. He is then recalled
to his regiment and leaves for the frontlines.
CHAPTER 11
Paul has begun to think of war as a chronic illness, like cancer or Trench warfare has so dehumanized the men that they no longer
tuberculosis. Germans suffer frequent casualties, and men’s have the luxury of thinking about anything but basic pleasure and
thoughts are governed simply by whether or not they are in primal danger. At the same time, for facing these pressures at all the
danger. The brotherhood of being a soldier equalizes and men are heroic and every instant they are alive gains a greater
homogenizes men with different pasts, and it leads to a intensity.
simultaneously “heroic and banal” condition in which men try to
appreciate every hour they can, because their lives are so
uncertain.
Pragmatic considerations are, to Paul, the “real problems” that Survival dictates that the men must shed nearly every attribute that
are necessary to consider. The men all live on the same plane of makes them human beings. However, this can never be completely
primitive survival, concerned with nothing other than achieved—the men strain to forget their human desires, and being
preserving their survival. They have been turned into animalistic ultimately takes a severe toll on their spirits.
“unthinking animals” so that they can use the “weapon of
instinct,” and they can be almost completely indifferent to the
horrors they witness. However, this indifference is not
total—men will sometimes be struck with a grave emotional
yearning, which Paul thinks illustrates that the soldiers’ have
not become entirely primitive creatures. Instead of being
naturally primitive, the soldiers are “primitive in an artificial
sense, and by virtue of the utmost effort.”
In spite of the steps the soldiers take to diminish the effects of The great effort required to suppress all but their most basic,
war, the men begin to break down. Detering passes a animalistic needs has begun to take its toll on the men. Detering is
blossoming cherry tree and becomes fixated on it. He takes finally unable to control his need to escape, but he acts on this
branches off the tree and carries them with him, to remind him rational impulse in an irrational way, by simply returning to his
of his orchard at home. Paul notices Detering acting strangely home without thinking out the consequences. Detering’s capture
and packing up his gear, and advises the peasant not to act symbolizes the dangers of simply trying to resume normal life after
foolishly, but Detering deserts the army soon after. Instead of fighting in the trenches. On the flip side, Detering has risked his life
fleeing to Holland, which is a safer refuge for deserters, for the army, but the army offers him no leniency or understanding.
Detering makes the mistake of returning to Germany. A week He is just a cog to them, a cog who is not allowed to make decisions
later, he is caught by the military police, and the rest of the men for himself.
hear nothing further of him.
The German soldiers are emaciated and afflicted with Morale in the German ranks is fairly dismal, and justifiably so.
dysentery, while Americans and English are well-equipped and Miserable living conditions, couple with the constant death of their
in good health. Fresh German recruits are in poor health and comrades, make the men unable to imagine another sort of life. The
die by the thousands—Kat muses that “Germany ought to be war is clearly being lost, and yet so many men are dying for this now
empty soon.” The men are convinced that the war will never lost cause (which the men already largely seemed not to believe in).
end, as even seriously injured men are sent back to the front
from the hospitals by cowardly surgeons who give in to the
army’s demands for men.
Paul and his comrades are especially horrified by the tanks that World War 1 marked a dramatic advance in impersonal, efficient
assault them. Because the tanks are so impersonal and killing—which likely amplified the trauma suffered by soldiers.
unfeeling, Paul thinks that they “embody for us the horror of
war.”
Paul’s Company Commander, a courageous man named Paul continues to lose more and more of his closest friends as the
Bertinck, is killed, though he fights against the enemy until the situation deteriorates further. These men once had hopes,
very end. Leer is struck by a shrapnel fragment and bleeds out ambitions, and talents—the war has rendered all of that
from his hip. Paul reflects that Leer’s excellence in math class meaningless. They are just bodies, to kill and be killed.
was little use to him.
The summer of 1918 is particularly brutal, and the Germans The lovely weather and hope for peace make the ongoing warfare
know they are losing. They lack soldiers and ammunition, but and death seem even more senseless and impractical.
continue to fight and die. The beautiful weather and rumors of
an armistice make the men even more pained to return to the
front.
Kat, Paul’s last friend left in the army, is shot in the shin as he Paul’s heroic efforts to save Kat, his last friend, are in vain, which
and Paul transport food together. Paul carries Kat back to represents the seeming powerlessness of a single soldier in the
medical care, while Kat suffers brutally. The two reminisce over trenches. The orderly thinks Paul and Kat are related because he
the time they roasted geese together, and exchange addresses cannot understand the camaraderie between soldiers that forces
so that they can correspond. When the two finally reach Paul to so valiantly strive to save Kat. And in fact, Paul’s connection
medical care, Paul discovers that Kat was struck in the head by to Kat is so strong it is like being a relative. They are, in the deepest
a tiny piece of shrapnel, and is already dead. An orderly is so sense, brothers.
surprised by Paul’s devotion in carrying Kat such a long
distance that he asks if Kat is Pauls’ relative.
CHAPTER 12
Autumn arrives, and Paul is one of the few “old hands” left on Times have never been more desperate for the Germans—Paul
the front. He is the last remaining man out of the seven in his recognizes that they are distraught enough to revolt if there is no
class. Many seem to be hopeful, as there is talk of an armistice. end to the war in sight.
Paul conjectures that men will revolt if their hopes for peace
are dashed.
Paul is placed on a two-week rest after swallowing some Paul’s time fighting the war has crushed his spirits, and now,
poisonous gas. He spends his days sitting outside in the sun and without any comrades, he is acutely aware of how listless and
thinking of a peaceful journey home. He cannot think beyond unmotivated he is.
his immediate desires to return, however—after the yearning
for home, he is aimless.
Paul realizes that men will not understand the returning Paul’s thoughts encapsulate the concept of the “lost
soldiers. The war will be forgotten, and things will go back to generation”—those who fought in World War 1 will be unable to
normal for all those who were too young or too old to see move past what they’ve endured, and others will be unable to
combat. “We will be superfluous even to ourselves,” Paul understand them.
reflects, and the former soldiers will “fall into ruin.”
Perhaps, Paul hopes, his melancholy will fly away once he Without comrades, Paul is left with nothing to lose. He senses that it
returns home—maybe his desire to learn and explore the future is possible that his absolute abjection could be a source of hope—if
has not been completely lost in bombardment and despair. Paul things cannot get worse for him, perhaps they may manage to get
realizes that the passage of time can take nothing from him. He better. Though this is a rather desperate hope.
is alone and hopeless, which allows him to confront time’s
passage fearlessly. His vivacity will express itself in spite of the
reservations his mind may have.
A third-person narrator describes a soldier—presumably, but As Paul loses hope and any reason to care about living on, his
not explicitly Paul—being killed in October of 1918, on a day narration falls away in favor of an impersonal third person narrator.
that was otherwise so safe that it earned a report of “all quiet That narrator treats Paul as just another anonymous casualty of the
on the Western front.” The dead man lies as if he is asleep, and war. Paul’s relative lack of importance—his death happens during a
his face wears a calm expression, “as though almost glad the “quiet” day—contrasts sharply with his central role through the rest
end had come.” of the novel, and highlights the fact that Paul really is just one of
millions of men, on both sides of the war, who had lives and futures
that were senselessly destroyed by the war, by the striving for power
by nations and leaders that ultimately cared nothing for the men in
the armies who were destroyed.
To cite any of the quotes from All Quiet on the Western Front
HOW T
TO
O CITE covered in the Quotes section of this LitChart:
To cite this LitChart: MLA
MLA Remarque, Erich Maria. All Quiet on the Western Front. Ballantine
Books. 1987.
Sobel, Ben. "All Quiet on the Western Front." LitCharts. LitCharts
LLC, 16 Sep 2013. Web. 21 Apr 2020. CHICA
CHICAGO
GO MANU
MANUAL
AL
CHICA
CHICAGO
GO MANU
MANUAL
AL Remarque, Erich Maria. All Quiet on the Western Front. New
York: Ballantine Books. 1987.
Sobel, Ben. "All Quiet on the Western Front." LitCharts LLC,
September 16, 2013. Retrieved April 21, 2020.
https://www.litcharts.com/lit/all-quiet-on-the-western-front.