Commonly Used Conventions Lesson 5
Commonly Used Conventions Lesson 5
Commonly Used Conventions Lesson 5
Minor-Suit Openings
and Responses
General Concepts
General Introduction
Group Activities
Sample Deals
214 Commonly Used Conventions in the 21st Century
General Concepts
Bidding
There are many misconceptions regarding minor-suit openings and responses. The material on
bidding covers such concepts as the short club, counting dummy points when raising a minor suit
and handling limit and forcing raises.
With an experienced group, you may want to add some material on the subject of inverted minor
raises. There are some examples in the textbook. While this isn’t one of the standard conventions
covered in this series, it is popular in many areas and eliminates some problems associated with
minor-suit raises. However, it isn’t an approach recommended for casual players.
Here are the topics covered:
Handling Interference
This section includes the use of a cuebid as a forcing raise after an overcall and the use of 2NT
as a limit raise or better after a takeout double. This will be a review of these concepts if they
were covered in a previous lesson. Otherwise, it’s important to introduce them at this point.
With a more experienced group, you can expand the topic to include the use of the cuebid as
a limit raise or better — probably an improvement over the standard approach.
General Introduction
Minor-suit opening bids can be unclear when the partnership uses a five-card major style. There’s
often a feeling that an opening bid in a minor suit isn’t a natural bid. That’s not the case. There may be
times when system dictates a minor-suit opening on a three-card suit, but the bidding is still natural.
There is also uncertainty when raising a minor suit: How many trumps do you need to support? Do
you count dummy points? Should you play in notrump rather than the minor suit? The objective of
this lesson is to put the students more at ease handling minor-suit openings and responses.
You might start like this:
“In this lesson, we will look at the minor suits, which tend to get ignored
because of the emphasis on major suits and notrump contracts. Handling
minor suits effectively, however, can often be the stepping stone to reaching
the best contract, even if that is a major suit or notrump. The partnership
needs to exchange information effectively after a minor-suit opening, and
that will be the focus of this lesson.”
Lesson 5 — Minor-Suit Openings and Responses 217
Group Activities
Introduction
“Opening bids of 1 and 1 cover a wide range of hands. They can be
used when:
• You have an unbalanced hand with a long minor suit;
• You have a balanced hand that falls outside the 15 to 17 point range; or
• You can’t open 1 or 1 because you don’t have a five-card suit.
“There are a lot of misconceptions about an opening bid of 1. Because you
often hear terms such as ‘better minor,’ ‘convenient club’ and ‘short club,’
you might be under the impression that partner usually holds a three-card
suit for an opening bid of 1. Nothing could be further from the truth.
“What do you think is the most likely number of cards partner holds
in the suit for an opening bid of 1? (Four.) The most common number
is four.
“What do you think is the next most likely number? (Five.) The next
most likely number is five.
“What do you think is the next most frequent holding in the club suit?
(Six.) Partner is more likely to hold four, five or six clubs than three clubs.
It’s important to keep that in mind.
“Let’s get started by looking at the types of hands you would open with a
minor suit.”
Instructions
“The cards are sorted into suits. Give each player one suit and construct the
following hand for South.
“In spades: the king and a low card.
“In hearts: the king and three low cards.
“In diamonds: the ace, the queen, the jack and two low cards.
“In clubs: two low cards.
“Remember, we want the cards in neat straight lines, with the high cards
toward the edge of the table.”
218 Commonly Used Conventions in the 21st Century
Check that each table has the correct starting hand set up dummy style in front of South.
“What would the opening bid be? (1.) This is a typical minor-suit open-
ing bid of 1. With an unbalanced hand, you open the longest suit.
“Change the South hand.
“In diamonds: take away the ace.
“In clubs: add the ace.
South
North South
Kx
1
Kxxx
QJxx
Axx
“What’s the opening bid? (1.) A balanced hand with 13 high-card points
is too weak to open 1NT when your range is 15 to 17 points. This is the type
of hand that would be opened 1NT if the partnership played a weak notrump
style. With no five-card or longer major-suit, open the longer minor suit,
1. Playing a four-card major-suit style, this hand might be opened 1.
However, even partnerships playing four-card majors sometimes prefer that
the major suit contain at least 4 points. So, they might also open 1.
“Change the South hand.
“In spades: take away the king.
“In clubs: add the king.
South
North South
x
1
Kxxx
QJxx
AKxx
“Now what? (1/1.) When you have a choice of four-card minor suits,
the standard agreement is to open 1. However, some partnerships prefer to
open the ‘better minor’ in this situation and would start with 1. It doesn’t
matter too much which style you adopt. The important thing is for you and
your partner to agree on which suit you would open with this hand. We will
recommend 1 with four cards in both minors.
“Change the South hand.
“In spades: add the king and two low cards.
“In diamonds: take away a low card.
“In clubs: take away the king and a low card.
the auction may get out of control. It’s really a matter of partnership style.
Opening either 1 or 1 could work, depending on what responder has to
say. For consistency, we suggest opening 1, the higher-ranking suit.”
There’s no need to get into too much discussion of reverses at this point. That subject will be
covered in the next lesson.
“Change the South hand.
“In spades: take away the king and a low card.
“In clubs: take away the king and add the jack, the ten and a low card.
“The 1 bid is not forcing. If partner insists that you respond holding this
type of hand, you should change to a forcing club system where the 1
bid can’t be passed. Systems of this type, such as Precision Club, use the
1 opening as a conventional bid on strong hands, replacing the standard
strong bids, such as the 2 opening.
“To see what might happen if you respond, turn opener’s cards — the South
hand — face up.
“What would happen if you passed South’s opening bid of 1? (Seven
tricks.) If left to play there, partner probably would take seven tricks and
make the 1 contract, taking five club tricks, one heart and the A. If the
opponents competed in a major suit, you would also be happy defending.
“What would happen if you bid over 1? (Get too high.) If you responded
1, partner would have to make a rebid and would bid 2. Now the part-
nership is too high. In fact, if the opponents competed, partner might bid
to 3 or higher, expecting some strength in your hand. Had you passed,
partner would not get too excited about the hand. By bidding, you take the
partnership out of a good contract and into trouble.
“Of course, opener’s hand doesn’t have to be so well arranged to make clubs
the best trump suit.
“Change the South hand.
“In diamonds: add the queen and a low card.
“In clubs: take away two low cards.
North South
North South
Jxxx Axx
1
Qxxxx Kx
Pass
xxx QJx
x Q J 10 x x
“These could be the combined hands. Now 1 isn’t an attractive contract.
If North responds, however, the partnership isn’t going to reach a better
spot. 1NT or 2 may fare worse than 1. Also, the partnership has only
16 high-card points between the combined hands. If North is silent, the op-
ponents are very likely to come into the bidding and play the hand. North
doesn’t mind defending.”
Summary
“Opening bids of 1 and 1:
• Usually show a four-card or longer suit.
• Can occasionally be made on a three-card suit when opener has no
five-card major and no four-card or longer minor.
“Responder shouldn’t be overly concerned with opener holding a three-
card suit. With a choice of four-card minor suits, open 1. With a choice of
three-card minor suits, open 1.”
Lesson 5 — Minor-Suit Openings and Responses 223
Introduction
“In the discussion of opening bids of 1 and 1, light opening bids in
third and fourth position were considered. Drury is a conventional method
for keeping the partnership at a reasonable level after a major-suit opening
bid in third or fourth position. After a minor-suit opening bid, there’s no
convention comparable to Drury, but that doesn’t mean that you can’t oc-
casionally open light in third or fourth position.”
Instructions
“Pick up all of the cards in the North hand and put them back into suits.
“Change the South hand.
“In hearts: take away the king and add two low cards.
“In diamonds: take away the queen and add a low card.
“In clubs: take away the ten and a low card and add the king.
South
North South
Axx
Pass 1
xxx
Jxx
KQJx
“Suppose North is the dealer and North passes. East also passes. South
is in third position. Would you open? (Yes.) There are 11 high-card points.
That’s not quite enough for an opening bid in first or second position, but
it’s quite reasonable to open 1 in third position.
“What are some advantages of opening? (Buy contract/lead/disturb op-
ponents.) It’s possible that your side can make a plus score. Partner could
have 10 or 11 points and not have opened the bidding. Since partner didn’t
open the bidding, it’s more likely that the deal belongs to the opponents.
Your bid, however, may cause them to bid too little or too much. If you do
defend, the 1 bid may get the partnership off to the best defense if North
is on lead.
“Are there any disadvantages to opening the bidding? (Yes.) It’s possible
to get too high. Partner won’t know that the opening is a little light and may
compete for the contract to too high a level. Also, you may run into difficulty
finding a suitable rebid. There is the advantage that partner is a passed hand,
so a new-suit bid is no longer forcing. If you decide to open light in third
position, you should feel comfortable passing whatever partner bids. If you
open light with an unbalanced hand and partner bids your short suit, you
will be poorly placed if you bid again.
“Most competitive players would open this hand in third position, since the
potential advantages outweigh the disadvantages. However …
224 Commonly Used Conventions in the 21st Century
“What if West is the dealer and there are three passes to the South hand?
(Pass.) With a borderline hand in fourth position, you have the choice of
bidding and trying for a small plus score or passing the deal out. You can
apply the Rule of 15. Add the number of spades you hold to the high-card
points. If the total is 15 or more, open the bidding; otherwise, pass. On this
hand, you have three spades and 11 high-card points — a total of 14. The
guideline recommends passing.
“Change the South hand.
“In hearts: take away a low card and add the ace and the king.
“In clubs: take away the king and the queen and add a low card.
South
North South
Axx
Pass 1 (?)
AKxx
Jxx
Jxx
“This hand has a full 13 high-card points. What would you open in first
or second position? (1.) Playing five-card majors, open the longer minor.
With a choice of three-card suits, open 1.
“What if you are in third position? (1/1.) You could make the stan-
dard opening bid of 1, but many players might prefer an opening bid
of 1. Partner is a passed hand, so it’s unlikely that your side can make
game. It’s probably going to be a partscore battle between the two sides.
If East–West buy the contract, you would prefer that partner lead a heart
rather than a club. The 1 opening bid should get partner off to the best
lead. If partner raises with only three-card support, you don’t plan to go
any higher anyway, and your side’s bidding may push the opponents higher
than they would like to be.
“Although it is usual to open the longest suit, there are always exceptions.
“Change the South hand.
“In spades: take away the ace.
“In hearts: take away the ace and the king.
“In diamonds: take away two low cards and add the ace, the king and the
queen.
“In clubs: add two low cards.
“With 11 high-card points plus 1 for the five-card suit, there’s nothing
wrong with passing in first position. If North and East both pass, how-
ever, what might you do in third position? (1.) If you do decide to open
this hand, 1 makes more sense than 1. You would definitely prefer a
diamond lead if you are defending, and it also leaves you better placed for
a suitable rebid if partner responds 1 or 1. You can bid 2 to show the
second suit. If you open 1, the situation is awkward if partner responds
1 or 1. Bidding 2 at this point would force partner to bid 3 with
equal preference for the two suits. Now you would be much too high.”
If the students are already familiar with the concept of reverses, this last point will be obvious.
If not, this is a topic that will be discussed further in the next lesson.
“What would you do in fourth position? (Pass.) 11 high-card points plus
two spades leaves this hand well short of satisfying the Rule of 15. Opening
it in fourth position will give the opponents an opportunity to back into the
auction in one of the major suits. Some things are best left alone.”
Summary
“You can open light in third or fourth position, but your hand should satisfy
the Rule of 15 to open in fourth position. With fewer than 13 points, you are
probably competing for partscore at best. For tactical reasons, therefore, you
might choose to open a four-card major or a suit which you want partner
to lead if you defend.”
1) 4 2) 754 3) 2
J 4 A Q 6 AKJ3
K J 8 7 3 K 3 Q974
A K 9 6 3 AQJ85 K862
________ ________ ________
4) Q 8 7 3 5) QJ76 6) AJ873
A 8 4 K J 6 3 A
A 9 6 Q 8 4 KJ9653
K 10 7 A 7 3
________ ________ ________
Introduction
“The partnership must decide how to treat a jump raise to the three level
over a minor-suit opening. The style we will recommend is to treat the jump
raise as a limit raise — an invitational bid showing 10 or 11 points. That
leaves you with the dilemma of what to do when you hold a forcing raise,
so let’s look at some ways to handle those hands.
“Before getting to that subject, however, let’s review some issues related to
raising opener’s minor suit.”
Instructions
“Pick up all of the cards in the South hand and put them back into suits.
Construct a hand for North.
“In spades: two low cards.
“In hearts: two low cards.
“In diamonds: the ace, the jack and two low cards.
“In clubs: the jack and four low cards.
North North South
xx
1
xx
2
AJxx
Jxxxx
“Suppose South is the dealer and opens 1. If West passes, what do
you respond? (2.) With support for partner’s suit and enough strength
to raise to the two level, bid 2. There’s no need to mention the diamond
suit. You’ve already found a fit.
“Is there an eight-card fit? (Yes.) Even if partner opened with a three-card
club suit, you have an eight-card fit.
“What if partner opened 1, rather than 1? (2.) With this hand,
raise to 2.
“Are you guaranteed an eight-card diamond fit? (No.) Opener may have
three, but will usually have four or more diamonds.
“What’s the only exception? (Exactly 4–4–3–2.) With four cards in both
minors, opener bids 1. With three cards in both minors, opener bids 1.
Only if opener has precisely four spades, four hearts, three diamonds and
two clubs, would you be in a seven-card fit. Partner starts with the longer
minor. This situation is not worth worrying about. Besides, there’s no reason
that 2 couldn’t be a better contract than 1NT, even if it is a seven-card fit.
So, the guideline for raising partner’s minor suit is that you should have at
least five-card support for clubs and four-card support for diamonds.
228 Commonly Used Conventions in the 21st Century
“What would you bid if partner opened 1? (1.) Rather than raise
clubs on only four-card support, you have the alternative of bidding 1,
showing the four-card diamond suit. You shouldn’t be afraid to raise partner’s
club suit with four-card support, but here there is another option.
“There are actually some advantages to raising directly to 2. What
might they be? (Limit strength; harder for opponents to compete.) By raising
to 2, you immediately limit the strength of the hand to 6 to 9 points, so
opener is in a good position to judge the level of the contract. If you respond
1, that’s a forcing bid and your hand is unlimited. Opener has to bid again,
and you may never get an opportunity to show your exact strength or club
support — especially if the opponents interfere. That’s another reason for
raising to 2 right away. If you respond 1, East has a chance to enter
the bidding at the one level — overcalling 1 or 1, for example. If you
raise immediately to 2, West may not be as eager to enter the auction at
the two level. There’s not much danger in raising to 2 with only four-card
support. Remember. The most common number of clubs for opener to hold
is four, and opener is more likely to have five or six clubs than three.
“In competitive auctions, be even more ready to raise opener’s minor
with less than ideal support. If partner opens 1 and West overcalls
1, for example, what should North bid? (2.) North doesn’t have to bid
over the overcall, but it would be very timid not to compete for the contract.
Most players would raise to 2 with this hand. If opener has a three-card
suit, tough luck, but the auction isn’t over. A raise may push the opponents
too high. In addition, when West overcalls in a major suit, it reduces the
likelihood that partner has four cards in that major and, therefore, increases
the probability that partner has four or more clubs.
“The same would be true if partner opened 1 and West overcalled 1.
You would certainly raise to 2 with this hand and, if one of the low dia-
monds were a low club, you might raise on three-card support as well. You
might land in a 3–3 fit, but that just makes for an interesting play problem
for partner. You can’t be perfect in competitive situations.
“Enough about the trump support needed to raise opener right away. Let’s
look at the strength required.
Lesson 5 — Minor-Suit Openings and Responses 229
“South opens 1. What do you bid? (3.) This is more like a sound limit
raise to 3. There are 9 high-card points plus 1 for the five-card suit. If
partner bids 3NT, this should be an excellent dummy. If you count dummy
points, you would come to a similar conclusion. The hand is worth 11
points — 9 high-card points plus 1 for each doubleton — the right sort of
strength for a limit raise. If partner can’t make a move over an invitational
raise, you’re probably high enough.
“What if partner opened 1, instead of 1? (2/3.) It would be rea-
sonable to make an immediate limit raise to 3. However, there’s enough
strength to bid a new suit at the two level, 2, planning to show the diamond
support on the next round. That will be more descriptive, but it may lead
to a more complicated auction. If partner raises to 3 or rebids 2NT, for
example, many partnerships would treat a 3 bid as forcing. If the partner-
ship hasn’t discussed sequences like this, the straightforward approach of
treating this hand as a limit raise in diamonds may be best.
“Minor suits present more of a challenge than major suits because of the
notrump aspect. If you stop in a partscore, there’s nothing much wrong
with playing in a good minor-suit fit. If you’re going to the game level, you
prefer to play in 3NT rather than 5 or 5 whenever possible. Nine tricks
are easier than 11 unless you have a lot of extra strength or some suitable
distribution.
“The difficulty with minor suits is even more apparent when you have enough
strength for a forcing raise.
“Change the North hand.
“In hearts: take away a low card and add the ace.
North
North South
xx 1
AJ 1 (?)
AJxx
QJxxx
“If partner opens 1, what will you respond? (1.) With 13 high-card
points and 1 point for the five-card suit, you are too strong to make a limit
Lesson 5 — Minor-Suit Openings and Responses 231
raise to 3, showing 10 or 11 points. Over a major suit, you can use 2NT as
a forcing raise — the Jacoby 2NT convention — because you never intend
to play in notrump after finding a major-suit fit. The same isn’t true over
a minor suit. Most partnerships prefer to use the jump to 2NT or 3NT as
a natural bid — showing a desire to play in notrump — over a minor suit.
We’ll talk more about that later. You don’t want to immediately suggest
notrump, since you have nothing in the spade suit. You want to tell partner
about the club fit and your strength.
“Playing standard methods with limit raises, there is no easy way to show
a forcing raise in a minor suit. Start by bidding a new suit. Here, you can
bid 1. Opener’s rebid may make the next bid easier.
“Suppose North responds 1 and opener rebids 1NT. What now? (3NT.)
If opener has a minimum balanced hand, it sounds as though 3NT will be
the best spot. You don’t have to mention your clubs at all. They’ll come as
a surprise for partner — and the opponents.
“Unfortunately, the auction may not proceed comfortably at all.
“Suppose opener rebids 1 instead of 1NT. Now what? (3NT.) You still
can’t conveniently show club support. A jump to 3 at this point — an old
suit at the three level — would be invitational, showing 10 or 11 points. So
would a jump to 2NT. Probably the best choice is to jump to 3NT and hope
that works out. You do have all of the suits stopped, and there’s no reason
to believe that 5 would be any better, or that you have a slam.
“It would be even more difficult if partner rebid 1 over 1. Now it
would be dangerous to jump to 3NT with no expectation that your side has
any length or strength in spades. You could jump to 4 — that would be
forcing — but you would miss any chance of playing in 3NT. To keep the
bidding going, you might have to resort to the ploy of bidding a new suit,
1, as a forcing bid. We’re going to discuss the bid of the fourth suit as a
forcing bid in the next lesson. The point here, however, is that the auction
can become complex when the partnership has no immediate forcing raise
of a minor suit.
“There are some conventional ways around this dilemma, however, most
partnerships usually manage quite well without a forcing raise. It won’t be
that often that you are stuck for a bid. We’ll look at some other options for
responding to 1 and 1 in a moment.”
You may want to skip the next example with a basic class. Even a more experienced group may
have some difficulty with the concepts involved.
“Sometimes you have to be a little inventive when responding to a minor
suit with a game-going hand.
232 Commonly Used Conventions in the 21st Century
“If partner, South, opens 1, you don’t have a good first response. Bidding
notrump with no stopper in spades is taking a big risk.
“What might you respond if partner opens 1? (1.) You can manu-
facture a response of 1 and wait to see what opener does next. Hopefully,
you’ll then be in a better position to know what to do. You don’t intend to
play in diamonds. You’re using the 1 response as a forcing bid. If partner
raises to 2, you plan to show club support — probably by jumping to 4
to make sure that partner doesn’t pass. You don’t mind playing with clubs as
trumps if partner has an unbalanced hand with clubs and diamonds. There
might even be a slam.”
With an experienced group you can discuss whether 3 in this sequence would be forcing
(1–1–2–3). Without a specific agreement, most partnerships would play it as non-forcing,
but the partnership should discuss such sequences.
Summary
“Over a minor-suit opening:
• You should ideally have four-card or longer support to raise diamonds and
five-card or longer support to raise clubs.
• When deciding how high to raise, be cautious about using dummy points.
If opener chooses a notrump contract, your short suits won’t be of any
value.
• Most partnerships use a single raise to show 6 to 9 points and a jump raise
as a limit raise showing 10 or 11 points. In this style, there is no immediate
forcing raise.
• You usually start by making a forcing bid, by bidding a new suit, hoping
to be able to determine the best contract after hearing opener’s rebid.”
1) 10 8 2 2) 95 3) K85
Q 9 3 7 4 3 Q62
J 8 7 5 2 A 8 2 J95
4 2 K J 6 5 3 K842
________ ________ ________
4) 10 4 5) 96 6) 76
K Q 9 J 9 8 2 A8
6 5 3 K 5 A963
A J 8 7 5 AQ863 K Q 10 8 2
________ ________ ________
Instructions (If last example on pg.232 wasn’t used, make changes in parentheses.)
“Change the North hand.
“In hearts: add two low cards. (Add two low cards.)
“In diamonds: add a low card. (Take away the jack and add a low card.)
“In clubs: take away the queen, the jack, and a low card. (Take away the
jack and the queen.)
North North South
xx 1
AQxx 1
Axxx
xxx
“Your partner, South, opens the bidding 1. What do you respond?
(1.) Although you have support for diamonds, the priority is to look for
the major suit. Respond 1. If you can’t find a fit in hearts, you can always
show diamond support later. If you were to raise diamonds first, the partner-
ship might never find a fit in hearts.
“Change the North hand.
“In diamonds: add a low card.
“In clubs: take away a low card.
“What if partner opens 1? (1.) Now the situation is a little different.
With a choice of suits to bid at the one level, bid the longest first, 1. There’s
not much danger of missing a heart fit. With a four-card heart suit, partner
can rebid 1 over the 1 response, and the fit will be found.
“Change the North hand.
“In hearts: add a low card.
“In clubs: take away a low card.
North
North South
xx
1
AQxxx
1
Axxxx
x
“What does North respond if partner opens 1? (1.) With a choice
of five-card suits, bid the higher-ranking, 1. It’s similar to opening the
bidding in the higher-ranking of two five-card suits.
“Change the North hand.
“In spades: add the ace and a low card.
“In hearts: take away the ace.
“In diamonds: take away the ace.
one of the major suits. If you don’t, the suit might get lost if the opponents
interfere in the auction. If you respond 1 and East overcalls 1 or 2,
for example, neither opener nor responder may be strong enough to intro-
duce the heart suit.
“You should only consider bypassing the diamond suit when you have a
weak hand. With a hand like this, you may get to make only one bid. With
a stronger hand, you can afford to bid the diamonds first. If necessary, you
can probably show the major suit later, even if the opponents interfere.
“Change the North hand.
“In spades: add the king, the queen and the jack.
“In hearts: take away two low cards and add the ace.
“In diamonds: take away two low cards.
North
North South
AKQJxxx
1
AQx
xx 2
x
“What would you respond if partner opened the bidding 1 or 1?
(2.) With a very strong hand, responder can jump shift. The jump shift
by responder is forcing to game and shows strong interest in reaching a
slam contract.
“That’s fine, but what would a jump to 3 show? (Preemptive.) The
standard approach is that a jump response that skips two or more levels is
preemptive, showing a weak hand with a long suit.
“Change the North hand.
“In spades: take away the ace and add a low card.
“In hearts: take away the ace and the queen.
“In clubs: add two low cards.
North
North South
KQJxxxx
1
x
xx 3 (1)
xxx
“What would you respond if partner opened the bidding 1 or 1? (3.)
Over an opening bid of 1 or 1, this is the type of hand with which you
might respond 3. It’s a hand that would have been opened with a preemp-
tive bid of 3, if partner had passed — a good seven-card suit with no
outside strength. You could respond 1 with this hand, but a jump to 3 is
more descriptive. It’s not forcing, but partner can raise with the same kind
of hand that partner would have to raise an opening preempt to game.
Lesson 5 — Minor-Suit Openings and Responses 237
North
North South
KQJxxxxx 1
x 4
xx
xx
“What would North respond over 1 or 1? (4.) With a good eight-
card suit and nothing outside, you can jump to the four level. Opener won’t
expect a strong hand, since you could have started with 1 or made a jump
shift to 2.
“Change the North hand.
“In spades: take away the king, the queen and three low cards.
“In diamonds: add the queen and four low cards.
Summary
“When responding to 1 or 1:
• The search for a major suit takes priority.
• With a choice of suits, bid the longer suit first.
• Bid the higher-ranking of two five-card or six-card suits.
• Bid the lowest-ranking of four-card suits.
• When responding to 1 with a weak hand, you can consider bypassing
diamonds to give priority to bidding a four-card major suit.
• Responder can jump shift with a strong hand and slam interest.
• A jump response that skips two or more levels — either a raise or a new
suit — is a preemptive bid with a weak hand and a long suit.”
1) Q 7 4 2 2) AK94 3) K 10 8 7 3
8 4 J 6 5 2 QJ942
A J 8 6 3 9 7 3 8
7 6 Q 2 10 5
________ ________ ________
4) 10 7 3 5) Q874 6) KQ63
K 9 4 Q 3 2 Q4
J 2 2 87
A 10 8 7 4 K 10 7 6 2 AQ964
________ ________ ________
Introduction
“The priority is to look for a major-suit fit when partner opens 1 or 1,
but you won’t always have a four-card or longer major suit to bid. Your at-
tention should then turn to bidding notrump.”
Instructions
“Change the North hand.
“In spades: take away the jack and add the ace.
“In hearts: add the queen and a low card.
“In diamonds: take away the queen and four low cards and add the king.
“In clubs: add two low cards.
“South is the dealer and opens the bidding 1. What do you respond
? (1NT.) A response of 1NT shows 6 to 9 points.
“What else does the 1NT response imply? (No major.) The 1NT response
to a minor suit denies a four-card or longer major suit. If responder has a
major suit, showing the major suit takes priority over bidding 1NT.
“Does the 1NT bid promise a balanced hand? (No.) Responder isn’t neces-
sarily balanced for a response of 1NT to a 1 opening bid. Responder could
have an unbalanced hand with a long club suit, too weak to bid 2.
“Suppose partner opens 1 instead of 1. What does South respond?
(1NT.) You still respond 1NT with 6 to 9 points.
“What does South know about your hand when you respond 1NT? (No
major; balanced; club support.) Partner knows you have no four-card major,
since you would have bid 1 or 1. Also, partner can expect that you have
at least four-card support for clubs. You could have bid 1 with a four-card
suit. That implies that you have a balanced hand. With an unbalanced hand
and support for clubs, you would raise clubs.”
The class might find the above point a bit difficult to follow.
“When partner opens 1 and you have no four-card or longer suit other
than clubs, you will have a choice between bidding notrump and supporting
clubs. You usually bid notrump with a balanced hand, since you prefer to
have five or more clubs to raise partner’s club suit.
Lesson 5 — Minor-Suit Openings and Responses 241
“What would North respond with this hand over 1? (2.) Although
the hand is balanced, a raise to 2 seems more descriptive than a response
of 1NT with no stopper in spades.
“Change the North hand.
“In spades: add the king.
“In hearts: take away a low card and add the ace.
“In clubs: take away a low card.
“The jump to 2NT doesn’t deny four, or sometimes five, cards in either
minor suit. If partner were to open 1, rather than 1, you would still
jump to 2NT. You could respond 2 over 1, but the 2NT response paints
a better picture of the hand. With a balanced hand, you don’t want to play
in a minor suit unless partner has a very unbalanced hand.
“Change the North hand.
“In hearts: take away a low card.
“In clubs: add a low card.
“What would you respond over an opening bid of 1? (3NT.) A jump
to 3NT shows a balanced hand of 16 to 18 points. Again, it tends to deny a
four-card major suit, but not a four-card or five-card minor suit.
Lesson 5 — Minor-Suit Openings and Responses 243
“Is 3NT forcing? (No.) Since the partnership is already in a game contract,
there’s no need for opener to bid again with a minimum balanced hand. Open-
er might choose to bid again with an unbalanced hand or interest in reaching
a slam contract, but the 3NT response is not forcing. It’s descriptive.
“Would it make any difference if the opening bid were 1, rather than
1? (No.) The most descriptive response would still be a jump to 3NT.
That is likely to be the best contract unless opener has other ideas. Again,
this solves the problem of what to do with a hand worth a forcing raise in
diamonds.
“Change the North hand.
“In spades: add a low card.
“In diamonds: take away the queen.
North
North South
Kxxx
1
AQ
1
Kxx
Qxxx
“What does North respond with this hand over 1? (1.) The prior-
ity is to look for the major-suit fit ahead of showing the balanced hand.
Respond 1. If you don’t find a spade fit, you can bid notrump at the next
opportunity.
“Change the North hand.
“In spades: take away a low card.
“In hearts: take away the queen and add the jack and a low card.
“In diamonds: add a low card.
“In clubs: take away the queen.
Summary
“Over a minor suit:
• A response of 1NT shows 6 to 9 points.
• A response of 2NT shows 13 to 15 points.
• A response of 3NT shows 16 to 18 points.
“All of these responses deny a four-card major suit. With 10 to 12 points,
responder can bid a new suit, planning to invite with a 2NT rebid at the
next opportunity.”
1) K J 9 2) AQ 3) QJ7
Q 10 4 K 10 5 AJ5
K 8 3 K 9 7 3 Q63
A J 8 3 K Q 6 5 J 10 8 4
________ ________ ________
Handling Interference
Introduction
“If the opponents come into the auction with an overcall or takeout double
after the opening bid of 1 or 1, the methods for handling interference
are similar to those used when the opening bid is a major suit.”
Instructions
After an Overcall
“If there is an overcall after a 1 or 1 opening:
• Responder’s 2NT bid is only invitational, showing 11 or 12 points.
• Responder can cuebid the opponent’s suit to force to game when holding
a fit with opener’s suit.
“Keep the North hand as it is.
North West North East South
Kxx 1
AQx 1 2NT
Kxx
xxxx
“Suppose partner, South, opens 1, and West overcalls 1. What do
you bid? (2NT.) With 12 high-card points and strength in the opponent’s
suit, jump to 2NT. In a competitive situation, 2NT is not forcing. 2NT is
more descriptive than bidding a new suit, 2.
“Change the North hand.
“In hearts: take away the ace and the queen and add a low card.
“In diamonds: add a low card.
“If partner opens 1 and West overcalls 1, what do you bid? (2.)
The overcall doesn’t prevent a normal raise to 2.
“What if South opens 1 and West overcalls 1? (2/Pass.) If West
had passed, you would have responded 1. You can no longer do that and
don’t have enough strength to bid 2. You don’t have to bid, but you don’t
want to give up too easily in a competitive situation. You want to avoid bid-
Lesson 5 — Minor-Suit Openings and Responses 247
ding 1NT with no strength in hearts, but could try raising to 2. You would
prefer to have five-card support, but four-card support will have to do.
“Change the North hand.
“In diamonds: add the ace.
“In clubs: take away two low cards and add the ace.
“If partner opens 1 and West overcalls 1, what does North bid?
(2.) North would have bid 1 if West had passed. With 14 high-card
points, there is more than enough to bid 2 after the overcall.
“What if partner opened 1 and West overcalled 1? (2.) This hand
is too strong for a limit raise to 3. The standard approach is to cuebid the
opponent’s suit in this situation. The cuebid is forcing to game and implies
a fit with partner’s suit, since you didn’t take some other action such as bid-
ding a new suit. You hope partner can bid notrump with some strength in
hearts. If not, you can show diamond support at the next opportunity.
“However, many experienced players use the cuebid to show a limit raise
or better in opener’s suit. This frees up the immediate jump raise as a pre-
emptive bid. This is a popular style among competitive players, but it’s not
the standard approach.
“Also, many of you use negative doubles, and they should be included in
your bidding arsenal.”
1) J 8 5 2) Q 10 8 3) A82
73 K J 7 94
A Q 6 2 K Q 8 K 10 9 7 4
K J 8 3 10 8 4 2 AQ6
________ ________ ________
“How about this hand after partner, South, opens the bidding 1 and
West doubles? (2/3.) You could just raise to 2 but most competitive
players prefer a preemptive jump to 3 with this sort of hand. It’s more
likely to keep the opponents out of the auction or make it difficult for them
to find their best contract. You can do this if you play the Jordan 2NT con-
vention. Partner won’t expect you to have too much for this bid. With 10 or
more points and diamond support, you would jump to 2NT.
“Change the North hand.
“In hearts: add the king.
“In diamonds: take away two low cards.
“In clubs: add the king.
Summary
“If there is an overcall after a 1 or 1 opening:
• Responder’s 2NT bid is not forcing, showing 10 to 12 points.
• Responder can cuebid the opponent’s suit to force to game when holding
a fit with opener’s suit.
Lesson 5 — Minor-Suit Openings and Responses 251
1) 7 4 2) AQ8 3) 76
3 10 2 K96
Q 8 6 3 2 8 4 3 8543
K J 8 7 5 A 10 8 7 6 K J 10 8
Guidelines for Teachers: Since these four deals focus on minor-suit open-
ings and responses, it can be expected that there will be some deviation from
the recommended auction. Let the students bid their hands in their own
fashion and play the resulting contracts. There are several interesting play
concepts (i.e., safety play, uppercut, avoidance) to discuss after you review
the bidding and get everyone in the recommended contract.
Guidelines for Teachers: On this first deal, opener has a minimum hand
without a five-card major and starts by bidding a minor suit. The auction
should end at 3, but some students will probably overbid. Let them play
the contract they reach and then put them in the recommended contract.
There is a potential uppercut situation for the defenders if declarer doesn’t
handle the trump suit correctly. There are a number of variations in the
play of this deal that you might want to discuss only if your students are an
experienced group.
Introduction
“Let’s play a deal where opener starts with a minor, holding a minimum
hand.”
Instructions
“North is the dealer. Take your hands and start the bidding. Play out the
final contract when you have completed the auction.”
(E–Z Deal Cards: #5, Deal 1 — Dealer, North)
Suggested Bidding
“Turn up all of the cards and put each hand dummy style at the edge of the
table in front of each player. Let’s review the bidding first and agree on a
final contract.
West North East South
1 Pass 1
Pass 1 Pass 3
Pass Pass Pass
“With a hand too weak to open 1NT and with no five-card major suit, North
opens 1. With a choice of four-card suits to bid at the one level, South
responds up the line by bidding the lower-ranking suit, 1. North continues
bidding up the line by showing the four-card spade suit. South has uncovered
an eight-card spade fit and has a hand of invitational-strength — 10 or 11
points. To invite opener to game, South jumps to 3. South makes a judg-
ment decision not to count a distribution point for the doubleton diamond,
since 1 was partner’s opening bid. With a minimum for the opening bid,
North declines the invitation, and the partnership rests in partscore.”
Suggested Play
“Declarer has two diamond losers, three club losers and at least one poten-
tial spade loser. There’s not much that can be done about the club losers if
the defenders are careful, but declarer can plan to ruff two diamond losers
in the dummy.
“In the spade suit, with eight cards in the combined hands, the percentage
play to avoid a spade loser is to play the A and then take the spade finesse
if the Q doesn’t appear — following the guideline “eight ever, nine never.”
On this deal, however, declarer can afford a spade loser, and declarer has
another use for dummy’s spades — ruffing diamond losers. After winning
a trick, North should play the A and K. When the spades divide 3–2,
declarer can go about ruffing the two diamond losers in the dummy — ruff-
ing dummy’s hearts to get entries back to North’s hand. Declarer loses one
spade trick and three club tricks.
“If the missing trumps were divided 4–1, declarer still would have a chance
after taking the A and K. With two diamond tricks and two heart tricks
to go along with the two top spades, declarer would have to hope to get three
more spade tricks through ruffing diamonds and hearts.
254 Commonly Used Conventions in the 21st Century
“On the actual deal, the defenders can defeat the contract if declarer tries the
spade finesse. Taking the A and K is a form of safety play in a contract
of 3. If North–South reach a contract of 4, declarer has little choice but
to try the spade finesse and will likely be defeated two tricks.”
Suggested Defense
“The defenders must be careful to avoid letting declarer make 10 tricks in
a spade contract. If East takes the first two tricks with the A and K,
North’s Q will be established, and the defenders will end with only one
more trick, West’s Q. To prevent this, West should play the 2 on the first
club trick — a discouraging signal — and East should respect West’s signal
and switch to another suit. The 10, leading through dummy’s strength,
would be a good choice for East.
“After the heart switch, the defender’s can’t defeat the contract if declarer
simply takes the A and K. West eventually will get a trick with the Q
and can lead a club to give the defenders the tricks they are entitled to in
that suit. If declarer takes the A and then tries the spade finesse by play-
ing a low spade to dummy’s J, the defenders can defeat the contract. For
example, West can return a third round of spades to prevent declarer from
getting enough tricks by ruffing losers. West also can lead back a club to
defeat the contract. After the defenders win two more club tricks, East can
lead the fourth round of clubs to promote West’s 10 — if declarer doesn’t
ruff with dummy’s K, West can win the trick by ruffing with the 10;
if declarer ruffs with dummy’s K, West gets the 10 later. Even if East
returns a diamond, rather than the fourth round of clubs, the defenders will
get another trick. (If East leads a heart after taking the club tricks, declarer
can take the remainder of the tricks by ruffing a heart, ruffing a diamond,
ruffing a heart and taking the last trick with dummy’s K.)”
Lesson 5 — Minor-Suit Openings and Responses 255
Guidelines for Teachers: On this second deal, explore the idea that when
a hand looks easy to make, you might want to use a safety play to ensure
against a possible (even if not probable) holding. Most students will be
defeated in 3NT for failure to ensure against the unexpected division of the
diamonds. The play should be interesting for students at all levels. Knowing
when to play second hand high on the opening lead is a difficult concept.
Take some time to discuss the difference between Q-x opposite J-x-x and
Q-x opposite K-x-x.
Introduction
“Let’s play a deal where it looks like it will be easy to make the contract,
but looks may be deceiving.”
Instructions
“East is the dealer. Take your hands and start the bidding. Play out the final
contract when you have completed the auction.”
(E–Z Deal Cards: #5, Deal 2 — Dealer, East)
Suggested Bidding
“Turn up all of the cards and put each hand dummy style at the edge of the
table in front of each player. Let’s review the bidding first and agree on a
final contract.
256 Commonly Used Conventions in the 21st Century
Suggested Play
“The opening lead will establish a club trick for declarer and there should
be nine more winners to take — two spades, one heart, and six diamonds
— if the diamonds break 2–1, as one would normally expect. When the
contract looks easy, however, declarer should be careful to guard against
bad breaks. After winning the first club trick, if declarer leads the A, the
contract can no longer be made. With the diamonds dividing 3–0, North
will get a trick with the Q and can lead back a club. South will take four
club tricks to defeat the contract.
“East’s first challenge comes at trick one. On the lead of the 6, declarer
should play West’s K. This wins the trick and leaves East with the guarded
Q. It will now be safe to lose a trick to South, because South can’t lead
clubs again without giving East a trick with the queen. North has become
the dangerous opponent, because if North gets the lead, East’s Q can be
trapped. Since the only real danger now is that one of the opponents holds
all three of the missing diamonds, declarer should start the diamond suit
by playing dummy’s K. On the actual hand, South discards on the first
round of diamonds and declarer can take a finesse against North’s Q. East
ends up with 10 tricks.
“If both opponents had followed suit to the first round of diamonds, taking
10 tricks would be easy, since the diamonds would have divided 2–1. What
if South had all three of the missing diamonds? After winning the first trick
with dummy’s K, East would now have to lose a trick to South’s Q. But
Lesson 5 — Minor-Suit Openings and Responses 257
that would be okay, since South isn’t the dangerous opponent. South can’t
effectively lead clubs after winning the trick. The contract is still secure.
Playing the K first is a safety play, since it guarantees the contract.
“If declarer had played the 3 from dummy on the first trick, North would
play the J to force East to win the trick with the Q. With only the
singleton K left in dummy, now both opponents would be dangerous. If
declarer loses a diamond trick to either opponent, the defenders are in a
position to take all of their club tricks.
“What if North held the A rather than South? Dummy’s K would be
taken by North’s ace, and North would lead another club. Now East would
have to hold up with the Q until the third round of the suit. South would
now become the dangerous opponent, so declarer should start diamonds by
leading the A to guard against South holding all three diamonds. If North
has all three diamonds, there’s no harm in losing a trick to North’s Q. North
will probably have no clubs left to lead. If North did have a fourth club, the
clubs would have divided 4–4, so the contract would still be safe.”
Suggested Defense
“South gets the defenders off to the best start by leading a low club. If de-
clarer subsequently loses a trick to North’s Q, North can return a club to
defeat the contract. If declarer plays the hand correctly, there’s nothing the
defenders can do except be careful to hold on to the right cards to prevent
East from taking more than 10 tricks.”
258 Commonly Used Conventions in the 21st Century
Introduction
“Let’s play a deal where declarer needs to be aware at all times of the dan-
gerous opponent in order to make the contract..”
Instructions
“South is the dealer. Take your hands and start the bidding. Play out the
final contract when you have completed the auction.”
Suggested Bidding
“Turn up all of the cards and put each hand dummy style at the edge of the
table in front of each player. Let’s review the bidding first and agree on a
final contract.”
Lesson 5 — Minor-Suit Openings and Responses 259
Suggested Play
“Declarer has two sure tricks in spades, two in diamonds and two in clubs.
With the heart lead, declarer is certain of a trick in that suit. Two more tricks
are needed. The obvious source of the additional tricks is the club suit. It
may be possible to take all five tricks in the club suit with the help of a suc-
cessful finesse. Even if a trick is lost to the Q, two additional tricks will
be established in the suit.
“There’s the danger, however, that if a trick is lost to the Q, the opponents
can take enough heart tricks to defeat the contract. On the surface, it looks
as though South will have to play the club suit by guessing which opponent
has the Q.
“In situations like this, declarer should plan the play carefully before play-
ing to the first trick. It may not appear to matter which heart is played from
dummy — since declarer is sure to get one trick with the K — but it
makes all the difference to the play. Declarer should play dummy’s J on
the first trick, with every expectation that it will win the trick! West has led
the 8, fourth highest. With a holding such as A 10 9 8 x or Q 10 9
8 x, West would lead the 10, top of an interior sequence. Declarer can
expect that the lead is from some holding such as A Q 10 8 x or A Q
9 8 x. If East doesn’t have the A or Q, dummy’s J will win the first
trick. This doesn’t gain anything directly — declarer was always entitled to
260 Commonly Used Conventions in the 21st Century
one, and only one, heart trick — but it secures the contract.
“When the J wins the first trick, East — not West — becomes the
dangerous opponent. If East gets the lead, East can lead a heart, trapping
declarer’s remaining K. West is no longer dangerous. If West gets the
lead, West can’t lead hearts without giving declarer a trick with the K.
That determines how declarer handles the club suit. After winning the J,
declarer should lead the J from dummy. When East produces a low club,
declarer should play a low club from the South hand, taking the finesse. On
the actual layout, the finesse succeeds. Declarer now can play a low club
to the 9, repeating the finesse. The K is played, and South can cross to
one of dummy’s winners to take the A and remaining club winner. South
finishes with 10 tricks.
“If the Q had been in the West hand, the finesse would have lost but the
contract would have been safe. West can’t lead hearts without giving South
a trick with the K. If West leads something else, declarer has four club
winners to go with the other five winners, and South makes at least nine
tricks.
“The finesse should be taken on the first round of the suit. If the A is
taken before finessing, declarer gets only three club tricks because of the
unfortunate break in the suit. Declarer will have a difficult time taking nine
tricks without giving East the lead.”
Suggested Defense
“After an opening lead of the 8, the defense can’t defeat the contract if
declarer handles both the heart and club suits correctly. If East does get a
trick with the Q, a heart return will defeat the contract two tricks.
“It may be interesting to speculate what would happen if West led a differ-
ent heart at trick one. If West leads the A and continues with the Q
after seeing dummy, declarer can make the contract with the hold up play.
Now West becomes the dangerous opponent, and a club trick can safely be
lost to East’s Q. More spectacular is the imaginative opening lead of the
Q. Declarer can still hold up on the first trick and make the contract, or
declarer can make the contract by guessing where the Q lies. If West is
up to making such a sensational lead, then declarer may be up to finding
an appropriate reply.”
Lesson 5 — Minor-Suit Openings and Responses 261
Guidelines for Teachers: This deal will probably result in a variety of final
contracts as the students compete in the auction. This is an interesting hand
with opportunities for both sides to shine. There is a lot to discuss with an
advanced class. It may be difficult for a basic class.
Introduction
“Let’s play another deal where all of the players may have something to say
during the auction.”
Instructions
“West is the dealer. Take your hands and start the bidding. Play out the final
contract when you have completed the auction.”
(E–Z Deal Cards: #5, Deal 4 — Dealer, West)
Suggested Bidding
“Turn up all of the cards and put each hand dummy style at the edge of the
table in front of each player. Let’s review the bidding first and agree on a
final contract.
ing bid with support for all of the unbid suits. With 10 high-card points,
East can redouble, but that may give North–South room to find their best
contract. With five-card support for opener’s minor and a hand worth a limit
raise, East can make a conventional jump to 2NT — a jump to 3 over the
takeout double would be preemptive.
“South, who would have responded 1 to the takeout double if East had
passed or redoubled, doesn’t have enough to come into the auction at the three
level. West has a minimum-strength hand for the opening bid and returns
to the agreed trump suit by bidding 3. Even with a balanced hand, West
shouldn’t pass partner’s 2NT bid, since it’s a conventional bid and doesn’t
guarantee stoppers in the other suits.
“North has nothing further to say, and East respects partner’s decision to
stop in partscore. The final decision is with South. Having passed over 2NT,
South might consider competing at this point, but will probably be dissuaded
by the vulnerability. If South guesses to compete with 3, North–South
will land on their feet, since that contract can be made. If South tries 3,
the result will not be as cheerful, since East–West can defeat that contract
at least one trick, and likely two tricks or more. North–South might have an
easier time finding their best contract if the auction had proceeded a little
differently. For example:
West North East South
1 Double Redouble 1
Pass Pass 2 2
Pass Pass 3 Pass
Pass 3 ?
Suggested Play
“In 3, West has three potential spade losers, one heart loser and two
diamond losers — assuming the club suit behaves reasonably. One of the
diamond losers can be ruffed in dummy, and one of East’s spade losers can
be discarded on West’s extra heart winner after the K has been driven
out. In effect, West hopes to take five club tricks, a diamond trick and three
heart tricks. There’s also the possibility that South holds the A, but that’s
unlikely in light of North’s takeout double.
Lesson 5 — Minor-Suit Openings and Responses 263
“There is a danger. If South can gain the lead, the defenders may be able
to take three spade tricks — by trapping West’s K — to go along with a
heart trick and a diamond trick. The only suit in which South might get the
lead is diamonds. To prevent this, West should duck the opening lead of the
K, letting North win the trick. Now the contract is safe, since North can’t
profitably attack spades. Assuming North leads another diamond, West wins
with dummy’s A, draws trumps and leads the Q. If North doesn’t win
the first heart trick with the K, declarer continues with the 10. North
must take the K on the first or second round of the suit, or the defenders
won’t get a heart trick. After winning the K, North still can’t play spades
without giving West a trick with the K. Whether North leads a diamond
or a heart, declarer wins the trick and discards one of dummy’s spades on
the fourth round of hearts. Declarer’s only losers are two spade tricks, one
heart trick and one diamond trick.”
Suggested Defense
“If North leads the K against West’s 3 contract, the defenders have a
chance if declarer takes the first trick with East’s A. On this trick, South
should play the J. Signaling with an honor in this situation tells partner
that you don’t have the next higher-ranking card — the Q — but do hold
the next lower-ranking card — the 10. This is valuable information for
North. Suppose declarer now draws trumps and takes the heart finesse. North
wins the K and, with the knowledge that South holds the 10, leads a
low diamond. South wins this trick and can lead a spade — the 10, top of
an interior sequence — trapping West’s K. The defenders get three spade
tricks, a heart trick and one diamond trick.
“If declarer ducks North’s K, the best North–South can do is defend care-
fully to hold declarer to nine tricks. If East–West end in a notrump contract,
the defenders can hold declarer to seven tricks by leading a diamond. If
declarer tries to develop an extra trick, the defenders can trap West’s K
after taking their diamond winners.”
264 Commonly Used Conventions in the 21st Century