Aspects of Duality in the Selected Tales of Edgar

Allan Poe

Černeka, Emili

Undergraduate thesis / Završni rad

2018

Degree Grantor / Ustanova koja je dodijelila akademski / stručni stupanj: University of

Rijeka, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences / Sveučilište u Rijeci, Filozofski fakultet u
Rijeci

Permanent link / Trajna poveznica: https://urn.nsk.hr/urn:nbn:hr:186:230567

Rights / Prava: In copyright / Zaštićeno autorskim pravom.

Download date / Datum preuzimanja: 2023-11-11

Repository / Repozitorij:

Repository of the University of Rijeka, Faculty of

Humanities and Social Sciences - FHSSRI Repository
 UNIVERSITY OF RIJEKA

FACULTY OF HUMANITIES AND SOCIAL SCIENCES

DEPARTMENT OF ENGLISH LANGUAGE AND LITERATURE

Emili Černeka

ASPECTS OF DUALITY IN THE SELECTED TALES

OF EDGAR ALLAN POE

Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the B.A. in English Language and
Literature and Art History at the University of Rijeka

Supervisor:

Sintija Čuljat, PhD

Rijeka, September 2017

ABSTRACT

The thesis entitled Aspects of duality in the selected tales of Edgar Allan Poe attempts at
offering a concise overview of Edgar Allan Poe‟s treatment of duality, specifically in the five
selected tales. The thesis‟ opening lines focus on the importance of Gothic fiction and its
impact and reception in North America. Further on I take a close look at Poe‟s narrative
principles which can best be observed in his tales. The main and crucial part of the thesis
examines the notion of duality through its general tenets and, most importantly, through
concrete examples found in the five selected tales. The ending notes of the thesis are my
reflections on the creative importance of Edgar Allan Poe.

2
TABLE OF CONTENTS

INTRODUCTION…………………………………………………………………………4-5

1. The importance of Gothic fiction…………………………………………………………6-7

2. Edgar Allan Poe in the realm of American Gothic.…………………………...….……….7-8

2.1. Dark Romantics as a reaction………………………………………...…..…………..8-11

3. Edgar Allan Poe‟s narrative strain……………………..……………………………….11-13

4. Duality and its manifestation in E.A.Poe‟s tales……………………………………….14-15

4.1. William Wilson………………………………………………...…………...…………15-16

4.2. Ligeia……………………………………………….………………………….……..17-18

4.3. The Tell-Tale Heart…………………………………………..………………………18-19

4.4. The Imp of the Perverse……………………………………...……………………….19-20

4.5. The System of Dr. Tarr and Prof. Fether………………………………..……………20-21

CONCLUSION………………………………………………………………………………22

BIBLIOGRAPHY……………………………………………………………..…………23-25

3
INTRODUCTION

The life and work of Edgar Allan Poe share many characteristics, the most prevalent being the

one of mystery. Much remains unsaid and undiscovered about this prolific and yet deeply

tormented 19th -century Boston writer. The same could be said about his work. It is comprised

of many layers and each sometimes functions as a stand-alone piece. Stylistically and plot-

wise he managed to create undoubtedly unique works which remain a great source of

inspiration even to this day. He gave us detective and murder stories which then on spanned

generations of crime story writers. But most important of all, he presented us the image of a

conflicted man, one who defies those formulaic characterizations of either good or bad. Edgar

Allan Poe imbued many of his works, especially short stories with protagonists fighting not

with an external grotesque monster, but one far more daunting, the mind itself. He somehow

managed to seamlessly and effortlessly merge a technically embellished type of writing with

non-idealized depictions of our society. His ways of constructing plots relied much on

contrasts and inner conflicts whose main task was that of educating the audience and making

it more aware of the absurdity of idealism and any notion of perfection. Through his work he

managed to „advertise‟ a new type of hero, one who goes about this world not knowing what

he is supposed to be and one who goes to sleep and wakes up with conflicting thoughts about

his surroundings and himself. As somebody who despised the idea of human perfection and

was rather more convinced in its inherent fallibility, Edgar Allan Poe was determined to

portray only truth in his tales. That meant that personality wise, polished and refined

characters were nowhere to be found in his tales. His tales employed true to life characters

battling not only the external world but also their internal world consisting of conflicting

thoughts. For Edgar Allan Poe the road to a peaceful life was a lifelong struggle without a

definite solution. Peace of mind was not something that was easily achieved, it was something

that had its good and bad days. Constructing plots that center on our daily struggles with our

4
own conflicting thoughts is what made Edgar Allan Poe and the work he left behind so

timeless and relevant. The characters he produced never seized to be relatable. Quite the

contrary, every generation that has ever been acquainted with them managed to find them and

their struggles relevant and educating.

5
1. The importance of Gothic fiction

The expression Gothic fiction today invokes images of horror and terror, dark gloomy

landscapes, ruinous palaces surrounded by dark, seemingly never- ending woods, hauntings,

apparitions, graves and all in all brooding atmospheres. So it comes as no surprise that it has

captivated the audience‟s attention ever since it appeared, or better yet affirmed itself. The

point of affirmation or rather beginning of further flourishing of the genre is considered to

have been marked by Horace Walpole‟s novel entitled The Castle of Otranto, published in

1764. It is considered to be the very first Gothic novel. But the novel did not necessarily

employ grotesque images and monsters and generally all those things that go „bump‟ in the

night. It was rather a psychological study and it revealed a lot about human behavior.

And that is where the importance of Gothic fiction lies. The possible usage of images of

horror and terror do not just serve the purpose of frightening and entertaining us. Rather their

strong impact on our senses enables them to show us human beings as they truly are;

imperfect and examples of walking conflicts.

In the Cambridge Companion to Gothic Fiction, the author E.J. Clery speaks about the

importance of Gothic fiction in an article entitled “The Genesis of „Gothic‟ fiction”. The

author opens up her article by stating how in fact the sheer attachment of Gothic to literature
1
is indeed a recent development. Clery further begins to state the aim and subsequent

importance of Gothic fiction by explaining how its main importance lays in the fact it avoids

the concept of ideal. It rather pushes the boundaries of what is conventional and it focuses on

protagonists who are walking conflicts. She states that ‘Only if a fiction is true to life can it

become the vehicle of useful instruction or moral improvement.’ 2 And what is true to life is in

no way ideal, but quite imperfect, misguided and confused. Gothic fiction presents us with an

1
E.J.Clery (2002: 21)
2
E.J.Clery (2002: 22)

6
interesting combination of real and unreal, the real element being people and the unreal

element being circumstances, the places in which our main protagonists abide, then monsters

and hauntings they bring. Works of Gothic fiction have quite the smart outline, as the

incredibly imaginative unreal elements serve to captivate our attention and pull us in the

world they present, but the real elements, the people and their reactions to what is presented in

front of them serves the purpose of educating us, bringing awareness of our own

imperfections and subsequent futile pursuit of the ideal. And that is the only way that enables

identification, if it is close to reality (‘In order to carry out its true function of instructing the

young, fictions must exhibit life in its true state, diversified only by accidents that daily

happen in the world.’3).

2. Edgar Allan Poe in the realm of American Gothic

What came as a logical next step after the affirmation of Gothic literature was its flourishing

into different subgenres. One of them was the American Gothic. Edgar Allan Poe is

considered to be one of the most famous members of this strain of Gothic fiction literature.

But one must bear in mind that Gothic fiction wasn‟t accepted in American literature that fast.

Quite the contrary, for a very long time it was considered to be unworthy of academic

attention and synonymous to low culture. And that was the kind of creative environment Poe

found himself in.

Jerrold E. Hogle gives a short overview of the slow acceptance of Gothic literature in

America that occurred in the 19th century. He states how: „…in many other studies of

American literature- the Gothic along with Poe, is relegated to manifesting a ‘mechanical

horror’ that, if occasionally employed by Hawthorne, is overcome in the 1840s-1850s by the

3
E.J.Clery (2002: 23)

7
‘tendency of American idealism to see a spiritual significance in every natural fact…’ 4-

meaning that in the beginning it was considered to only display darkness and the grotesque for

entertainment purposes, and only after it started to slowly merge with American

Transcendentalism did it start being considered educational. What made American Gothic

unique was the fact it merged the Gothic Romance and the American psyche, and as

J.E.Hogle concludes it was determined by: „…its union of opposites as seen in hesitations

between tradition and modernity...‟5

In time the importance of Gothic fiction started overflowing American literature as it was one

way of truly addressing humankind, without any kind of embellishments. It was a:

‘…means for American audiences to articulate the terrors that lie deepest in the human

psyche…and that repressed conflict includes the fear that in destroying the old ego-ideals of Church

and State the American has opened a way to either insanity and the disintegration of the self or a

regression into the maternal womb from whose darkness the ego first emerged, hence the American

gothic hero’s flight towards ever-new frontiers…’6

In other words it served to better express one‟s worry about losing touch with traditional

values and not achieving its potential in the wake of progress.

2.1. Dark Romantics as a reaction

Within American Gothic there existed a group of authors who didn‟t completely create in the

spirit of American Gothic, but rather mixed genres. The authors I am talking about were

Nathaniel Hawthorne, Herman Melville and, for this thesis the most important member, Edgar

Allan Poe. A reaction to not completely agreeing with the tenets of American Gothic was the

4
Jerrold E. Hogle (2014: 4)
5
Jerrold E. Hogle (2014: 4)
6
Jerrold E. Hogle (2014: 6)

8
creation of a new genre, or rather subgenre, Dark Romanticism. It was the style in which

Edgar Allan Poe created and wrote. Being influenced by German Romanticism, he was

inspired to follow the German Romanticists‟ propensity for the mixing of genres, which

narrative feature in a way foreshadowed the acceptance of our dual nature and needs (‘Hence

a mishmash of motives, costumes, cults, civilisations-Hellenism and Medievalism, Paganism

and Christianity- jumbled together in inextricable medley.’)7.

As argued by Morgan Howard in his article “A New Genre Emerges: The Creation and

Impact of Dark Romanticism” this new subgenre: „… presents the darker side of

awareness…guilt, fear and madness…the uncomfortable sense of being in a fantasy world

which is about to reveal secrets of the human personality. Plots involved illness, secrecy, and

terror. Readers and characters alike discovered horror in everyday occurrences.’8 It is a

genre within which Poe flourished as it enabled him to completely focus on the human psyche

and its many layers, all of which are unique in their perceptions of the world. As a person who

did not believe in the perfection of human beings, it was no wonder that Edgar Allan Poe best

ended up bringing this genre to a wide audience appeal. He did after all best understand the

issues it tried to present. The Dark Romanticism as the name itself indicates presented not

only a subgenre of Gothic fiction, but also of Romanticism. It employed certain characteristics

known in Romanticism such as the deep fascination with beauty, unrequited love, intense

emotions and certain characteristics of Medievalism mostly through the employment of

castles and courtship.

Poe is believed to have been the first to successfully combine Romanticism and the Gothic in

an innovative way. As stated by Morgan Howard, he was not that interested in the beauty of

nature, as much as in the beauty and uniqueness of the mind. He was fascinated by the link

7
P.H.Frye (1914: 114)
8
Morgan Howard (2015: 2)

9
between beauty and death and he frequently employed that connection in his short stories and

poems. The easiest way to describe his style would be by understanding how he combined

genres, thus using traditional tenets of Romanticism and combining them with the dark nature

of Gothic fiction. 9

When talking about his writing, what is so unique about it is the fact how at first glance it

appears highly stylized, but after close inspection and reading one sees how the stylization

only serves the purpose of drawing its audience‟s attention and nothing more. Stylization is

employed when describing the surroundings and character‟s garments, but their personalities

and the ways in which characters interact exhibit only truth. Morgan Howard gave a rather

concise and genuine description of Poe‟s writing by saying how:

‘His writing has a dark impulse beyond understanding which wreaks havoc, operating in complete

contradiction to the normative assumption of the early United States policy, that individuals will

always seek to act in their own best interests. In other words, he rejects the idea that humans are

basically good and does not believe people would help their fellow men.’10

On a final note, when discussing Dark Romanticism it is important to mention the fact that it

was closely tied with Transcendentalism, in a way that it undermined all of its most important

ideas and tried to create a type of literature that differed from the American Transcendentalist

movement. This can be closely inspected in Poe‟s work. To start with, the Transcendental

movement was known for integrating all of our existence in nature, but for Poe nature was not

necessarily a place of peace, it was rather an eerie place which made people only more

anxious and alone. Ted Billy argues in his article “Descendentalism and the Dark Romantics:

Poe, Hawthorne, Melville, and the Subversion of American Transcendentalism” :

9
Morgan Howard (2015: 3)
10
Morgan Howard (2015: 4)

10
„In opposition to the Transcendentalists’ integrated perspective on nature, Poe often dramatizes the

organic world as alienating and forlorn… for Poe’s landscapes evoke an aura of spiritual sterility and

eerie isolation. His Gothic fiction also displays nature as a source of estrangement… Yet perhaps Poe

most clearly defines his valuation of nature by way of its absence… Poe shuns the organic world in

favor of the internal chambers of the mind. Whereas Transcendentalists tended to view nature

subjectively, Poe explores the hyper subjectivity of human nature.’11

And that is how we can best understand the Dark Romantics rebellion against the

Transcendentalist movement. For Poe and the others it meant simply not seeing the world as

optimistically as Transcendentalists did. Nature for the Dark Romantics and especially for Poe

was not the answer and therefore the focus of his work, as he cared very little for our

surroundings, but was rather interested in the human mind and its capability of producing

such conflicting and dual ways of thinking. What made Poe stray away from the

Transcendentalist movement was its reliance on humans as capable of being perfect. Poe did

not believe that. They (Poe, Hawthorne and Melville) ‘…were keenly aware of the dark side

of human nature, and they scorned the Emersonian lack of recognition of darker matters…

Dark Romantics were not entirely antithetical to Transcendentalist ideas and goals, but they

realized that nature has its perils, individualism its excesses, and social reform has its

limitations.’12

3. Edgar Allan Poe’s narrative strain

Although Edgar Allan Poe is deemed to be the inventor of the modern short story, this

invention of his would not have been conceived without the many influences which helped

shape him as an author. One of the influences that are most apparent in his work is that of

11
Ted Billy (2014: 152)
12
Ted Billy (2014: 162)

11
German literature, and especially the German author Ernst Theodor Amadeus Hoffmann. But

strangely enough despite the obvious influence that German literature had on his work, Edgar

Allan Poe was more famous for denying this connection. He even famously declared: ‘I

maintain that terror is not of Germany, but of the soul.’13 That may be true after all. But still

the fact remains that he was deeply influenced by German literature whether he was or was

not aware of it. He famously negated the influences in his Preface to The Tales of the

Grotesque and Arabesque, where he described his tales by saying: „I am led to think it is this

prevalence of the ‘Arabesque’ in my serious tales, which has induced one or two critics to tax

me, in all friendliness, with what they have been pleased to term ‘Germanism’ and gloom.’ 14

Despite him denying these inspirations and connections with German literature, his work in

itself still proves otherwise. He was undoubtedly influenced by German Romanticists and it

was them who inspired the creation of Dark Romantics. His congruity with the German author

E.T.A. Hoffmann further on proves that he was under the German influence. To begin with,

this connection and similarity was closely studied in Gustav Gruener‟s article simply titled

“Notes on the Influence of E.T.A Hoffmann upon Edgar Allan Poe” and he begins by stating

that they both created under the principle of truth being far stranger than fiction. 15

Gustav Gruener observes their shared rebellion against formalism, commonplace, spirit of the

bourgeois, and the usage of grotesque humor. Poe might even be considered a sort of

doppelgänger of Hoffmann as they both mastered the fantastic and supernatural grotesque

which appeared on the verge of insanity.16

Poe‟s tales, at least the ones I am going to deal with in this thesis all focus on different aspects

of duality that can be found in our everyday life. But despite my centering on tales that deal

13
Gustav Gruener (1904: 1,2)
14
Gustav Gruener (1904: 1)
15
Gustav Gruener (1904: 5)
16
Gustav Gruener (1904:5, 14)

12
with that issue, it still helps to give a short overview of Poe‟s tale principles, or better said the

way in which he approached his tales. He was known for trying to restrict their definition17,

meaning he wanted them to be more concise and specific. He was keen on building his tales

almost as a painting which then went on showing us what its main concern was. That is why

his tales always appear quite stylized at first; just like a painting they first allure us, only to

then show us through their intricacies that not everything is as it seems, and beauty sometimes

hides darkness. His tales serve the purpose of telling us the truth about human beings, their

reactions to specific situations and generally their ways of going about this world. One of the

truths his tales seek to make us aware of, and which I will be focusing on in this thesis, is our

own inherent duality.

Poe‟s tale principles were elaborated by G.R. Thompson, who in his article lists three

combinations Poe uses when constructing his tales, the first one where an ordinary incident is

combined with peculiar tone, then peculiar incident combined with ordinary tone and lastly,
18
peculiar incident combined with peculiar tone. He concludes his article by summarizing

Poe‟s tale technique which is basically a: „…complete dramatization of an interior worldview

of a centrally involved character who seems more or less rational or normal but who is

revealed to be peculiar, self-deceived, or mad.’ 19 What he is describing here is essentially our

inherent duality, we can appear both sane and insane, or good and bad. And this duality is

what is going to be the main interest in the next pages to come.

17
G.R. Thompson (1994: 170)
18
G.R. Thompson (1994: 181)
19
G.R. Thompson (1994: 192)

13
4. Duality and its manifestation in E.A. Poe’s tales

Our inherent duality has been the topic of interest of many authors long before Edgar Allan

Poe, but this thesis deals with his treatment of the matter. His understanding of duality can

best be observed through his tales, which often take for their protagonist imperfect characters

who have problems siding with only one part of their personality. They are walking conflicts.

Duality in Poe‟s work takes on a different shape every time, sometimes it is a direct

addressing (such as the one in William Wilson) or an indirect one (such as in Ligeia).

Although there exists an increased interest in the phenomenon of the double in literature,

because it enables us to better depict our conflicting thoughts, still this phenomenon is quite

hard to pinpoint. Just as Milica Živković argues in her article “The Double as the „Unseen‟ of

Culture: Toward a Definition of Doppelgänger”, the double seems to: „… resist narrow

categorization and definition’.20 The double is also a construct of its time; each era in a way

has its own understanding of it. It is shaped by its own social context. But most importantly

the double always signifies: „… a desire to be reunited with a lost centre of personality, the

double shows… a tension between the laws of human society and the resistance of the

unconscious mind to these laws.’21

The double can manifest itself differently, as a ghost, soul, shadow, or a literal mirror

reflection which is dependent on its original, and it makes the same original feel at the same

time as himself and as the other. It essentially presents humankind‟s effort to try and

understand its inherent duality and try and achieve integration despite cultural restrictions

which often make that process difficult.22

20
Milica Živković (2000: 121)
21
Milica Živković (2000: 121)
22
Milica Živković (2000: 122)

14
What comes as an interesting discovery is the fact how our understanding of the double has

changed over time, as it went from a guardian angel to a demonic presence. It went on from

being considered a part of us that protects us and forces us to make rational decisions to being

a demonic part of us making us act against our best interests. But Milica Živković concludes

correctly when saying : „The double is defined as evil precisely because of its difference and

possible disturbance to the familiar and the known.’23 Carl Gustav Jung in a way managed to

best explain the essence of the double by noting how he is neither good nor bad, he is just

rather a manifestation of one‟s suppressed feelings.24 What we call demonic is in reality the

undiscovered and unrevealed in our society. Edgar Allan Poe actually ends up understanding

and treating the subject matter of duality in line with Jung, as he too does not limit his doubles

as good or bad parts of us, he rather constructs them as unknown parts of us capable of

unthinkable pursuits.

The most literal manifestation of duality is a doppelgänger, whose beginnings can be traced to
25
the year 1796, when Jean Paul coined the word itself. The doppelgänger is a literal mirror

picture of us, and can then on act according to the emotions we have kept hidden. He basically

embodies the suppressed. But the doppelgänger also does not have a so called: ‘…forma

finalis, rather form is constantly deformed and reformed. The doppelgänger is always in

process of construction…’26

4.1. William Wilson

Of the five selected tales depicting aspects of duality, the one entitled William Wilson

addresses it most directly as it employs real, physical mirror doubling. It follows the attempts

of William Wilson One (let us call him like that for better understanding) of escaping from his

23
Milica Živković (2000: 124)
24
Milica Živković (2000: 126)
25
Dimitris Vardoulakis (2010: 9)
26
Dimitris Vardoulakis (2010: 7)

15
double William Wilson Two, who basically embodies all his suppressed emotions. In this

story, the double within us is physically embodied. But in this instance, the double is not his

demonic part, but his conscience. The man himself is in this story already corrupted, but his

double, his other part is acting as his guardian angel and trying to lead him to the right path (‘I

grew selfwilled, addicted to the wildest caprices, and a prey to the most ungovernable

passions.’27). The tale depicts one man‟s trying to avoid accepting this other part of himself, a

decision that leads to complete annihilation of the two. He fears his double (‘…I secretly felt

that I feared him, and could not help thinking the equality which he maintained so easily with

myself, a proof of his true superiority…’28). As his double was constantly the suppressed part,

he also never managed to be any louder than a whisper, thus only further acknowledging the

fact how much the protagonist denied him. The protagonist‟s own self-pity and wondering

what could have happened had he listened to his double, emphasizes that much more the need

for reunification (‘…that his moral sense…was far keener than my own; and that I might, to-

day, have been a better, and thus a happier man…’29). But by refusing to accept the other part

of himself, as manifested in the literal physical embodiment of a mirror twin, he actually

killed himself. They were both equal in their death and they both vanished. In essence this tale
30
depicts a Freudian approach to reuniting two sides of our being through self-annihilation.

The attempt at reuniting the two sides of our psyche ends up being unsuccessful because the

protagonist in this instance, although governed by two forces; the material (Body) and the

immaterial (Soul)31, ends up siding too much with the Body and fails to see the importance of

the advice given by his conscience, here embodied literally in a human double.

27
Edgar Allan Poe (1839: 1)
28
Edgar Allan Poe (1839: 4)
29
Edgar Allan Poe (1839: 6)
30
Shu-ting Kao (2016: 2)
31
Shu-ting Kao (2016: 4)

16
4.2. Ligeia

With the tale Ligeia starts a series of tales which do not necessarily refer to a literal double,

but rather indicate other aspects of our dual nature always in constant need for reunification.

The tale deals with another aspect of duality, one where the grotesque is intertwined with the

romantic. It also further on proves us how this world is made up of the beautiful and the

terrifyingly ugly, and it is only by accepting both that we may find balance. It also juxtaposes

love and hate, this tale proves that one does not necessarily exclude the other, as you cannot

really hate something, without first having experienced love. Hate often emerges from the

disappointment of having lost what we have initially loved. In Ligeia duality is interpreted

through the medium of love. The tale opens up with numerous descriptions of the

protagonist‟s love for Ligeia and her beauty (‘…her singular yet placid cast of beauty, and the

thrilling and enthralling eloquence…made their way into my heart…’ / „In beauty of face no

maiden ever equalled her.’32). The first part of the tale is filled with poetic descriptions of her

beauty and its impact on the protagonist; he is completely consumed (‘The expression of the

eyes of Ligeia! How for long hours have I pondered upon it!’33). With the death of Ligeia, all

the previous light disappears, now darkness follows. The only image our protagonist now has

in his mind is that of death (‘…the pale fingers became of the transparent waxen hue of the

grave, and the blue veins upon the lofty forehead swelled and sank impetuously with the tides

of the gentle emotion.’34). Another thing contrasted here are two ways of experiencing love, in

this case the protagonist ends up loving profoundly his first wife, Ligeia and hating profusely

his second, Rowena (‘That my wife dreaded the fierce moodiness of my temper…I loathed her

with a hatred belonging more to a demon than to a man.’35). What can be observed here is

that he ends up hating his second wife just as much as he loved his first. The two different

32
Edgar Allan Poe (1838: 1)
33
Edgar Allan Poe (1838: 2)
34
Edgar Allan Poe (1838: 4)
35
Edgar Allan Poe (1838: 7)

17
ways in which he treats his wives shows us how love in this tale ends up revealing a double in

a man, one capable of pure, passionate and genuine love and utter and inexplicable hatred.

Just as Dorothea E. Von Mücke argues in her article “Ligeia: Her Large and Luminous Orbs”,

this tale consists of hidden dualities, one of the most apparent one being the plot itself, as one

part centers on the narrator‟s remembrance of his first wife and the mourning of her death,

and the second part on his cruel behavior with his second wife, Rowena.36

4.3. The Tell-Tale Heart

This tale represents another aspect of duality which Poe employed rather often in his tales.

The Tell-Tale Heart depicts our struggle with this inexplicable need to do what is indeed bad,

although we are at the same time aware of the fact we are acting against our best interest. It is

this conflict that makes us then on feel as a ticking bomb, just waiting to explode. Now, this

tale does not name this evil force within us, thus only further emphasizing its dangerous

nature.

The tale focuses on a confused protagonist dealing and fighting with what is essentially an

invisible and unknown enemy. The opening lines see a man desperately trying to convince

himself he has not lost his mind and is in fact in control of his actions. Unfortunately, this

only proves to be another act of despair in the event of not seeing your enemy (‘IT’S TRUE!

YES, I HAVE BEEN ILL, very ill. But why do you say that I have lost control of my mind, why

do you say that I am mad? Can you not see that I have full control of my mind? 37). Now, what

in a way separates this protagonist from the one we have been acquainted in William Wilson is

the fact that the protagonist / narrator in The Tell-Tale Heart is aware of his dual nature and

he is indeed trying to give meaning to his actions, he is thirsty for answers (‘I heard sounds
36
Dorothea E. Von Mücke (2006: 149)
37
Edgar Allan Poe (1843: 64)

18
from heaven; and I heard sounds from hell!38). The tale itself, plot- wise, follows a man who

one night, grown tired of an old man‟s „vulture‟ eye, decides he needs to kill the old man, he

does so and ends up not being able to live with that evil doing only to then confess his crime

to the police. Throughout the tale, the protagonist is constantly trying to make us aware of the

fact that he did not know why he had killed the old man, as he did not hate him. Thus, the tale

focuses on the issue of externalizing the problem, rather than facing it, as the man decides to

project all his insecurities and conflicting thoughts into that old man‟s eye, and by killing the

eye, he manages, or at least he believes so, to get rid of the problem (‘And so, I finally decided

I had to kill the old man and close that eye forever! / ‘For it was not the old man I felt I had to

kill; it was the eye, his Evil Eye.’39). His confession of the crime essentially shows us what

happens when we suppress emotions. Now, although this tale overdramatizes the issue, it is

still not that far from the truth, as suppression leads to uncontrollable violent acts.

4.4. The Imp of the Perverse

Following the previous tale which only presented in front of us this inexplicable dual ability

of simultaneously being capable of great good and extreme evil, now the following tale deals

with further and more accurately trying to explain this conflicting phenomenon. For one, it

actually succeeds in naming this phenomenon, The Imp of the Perverse. The tale‟s opening

lines make it resemble to a psychological study, rather than a one man‟s gallows confession.

The narrator / protagonist argues how we have all overlooked the importance of our inherent

dual nature, and by doing so we have given birth to this imp of the perverse, a side of us

which through the process of suppression has become far more violent (‘In the pure

arrogance of the reason, we have all overlooked it. We have suffered its existence to escape

38
Edgar Allan Poe (1843: 64)
39
Edgar Allan Poe (1843: 65)

19
our senses… We saw no need of the impulse…’40). The essence of this imp lies in the fact that

it simply makes us act against our best interests, it perpetrates actions that we consciously

know we should not do. And the more we deny its existence and growing presence, the more

violent it gets, or rather do we get, so much so that we end up fearing ourselves and the

growing violence within us (‘We tremble with the violence of the conflict within us,- of the

definite with the indefinite-of the substance with the shadow.’41). Daniel Hoffman argues in

his article “Grotesques and Arabesques” : „…this Imp of the Perverse is but a portion of the

ego separated out from the rest, which seeks the destruction of that from which it is

separated…Life is on a collision course with death; the death-wish betrays, whenever it can,

the life instinct.’42 This constant denying of our self-division and trying to escape its

reunification always proves disastrous and further proves the need for its acceptance.

4.5. The System of Dr. Tarr and Prof. Fether

I conclude with the tale The System of Dr. Tarr and Prof. Fether, which, although it does not

exhibit any direct mention of duality, it nonetheless deals with the fine line between sanity

and insanity. The tale focuses on the narrator‟s visit to Monsieur Maillard‟ s insane asylum

where he meets all sorts of people, only to find out he has all along been in the company of

patients, and not people working there. But, that is not necessarily the point of the story. I

found the story quite fascinating and apt as an ending to this thesis, as it does discuss an

aspect of duality, the one of dual appearances, one man appearing sane until proven otherwise

and vice versa. We go on a journey with the narrator, and every time he has a feeling

something is wrong, so do we as readers. Everybody appears well-educated and well-

mannered (‘I soon found that nearly all the company were well educated; and my host was a
40
Edgar Allan Poe (1845: 1)
41
Edgar Allan Poe (1845: 3)
42
Daniel Hoffman (2009: 14)

20
world of good-humored anecdote in himself.’43), but still there is a constant underlying feeling

of strangeness (‘There was an air of oddity, in short, about the dress of the whole

party…Upon the whole, I could not help thinking that there was much of the bizarre about

everything I saw…’44). The point of this story lies in its depiction of conventionalized

understanding of sanity and insanity. The fact that one person can at the same time appear

both sane and insane proves how a lot of our understanding of what is to be deemed normal or

abnormal comes from arbitrary and conventionalized notions. The truth is, within us exist two

contrasting natures, and although to better manage them we have labeled one good and the

other one bad, the fact remains we need them both reunified as to probe the essence of who

we truly are.

43
Edgar Allan Poe (1844: 5)
44
Edgar Allan Poe (1844: 4,5)

21
CONCLUSION

What Edgar Allan Poe‟s work teaches us is that oftentimes the truth is indeed stranger than

fiction. But fiction on the other hand serves as that enthralling part of his tales which attracts

our attention and further on enables the educating part to have that much more of an impact.

Our psyche was what fascinated him the most, the secret ways of our mind. He organized his

tales in a way that made them both entertaining through their usage of images of horror and

terror, but for anybody who was as equally interested in trying to find out as much as possible

about their conflicting nature, his tales served as an excellent starting point. As an innovative

writer who despised narrow categorizations, he managed to bring a fresh take on Gothic

fiction, making it one of the most widely used and read genres. On the other hand as a man

who was deeply preoccupied with his and the general human psyche, he imbued his work

with intricate psychological studies of human behavior and interactions, focusing on their dual

nature. Firmly believing in human fallibility rather than perfectibility, he set out to only use

realistic and conflicted characters on the verge of insanity. The battle with that insanity was

for him a matter of daily struggle. The only way of „escaping‟ it was through accepting our

imperfections. Balance in Poe‟s opinion was an internal matter, existing only when we make

peace with our fallibility and bring about the reunification of our seemingly contrasting

natures.

Edgar Allan Poe‟s importance lies in creating timeless written pieces that will never cease to

be relevant because they are so deeply embedded in the human nature and its inherent duality

which is constantly only changing its appearances.

22
BIBLIOGRAPHY

1. Billy, Ted. 2014.”Descendentalism and the Dark Romantics: Poe, Hawthorne, Melville,

and the Subversion of American Transcendentalism” in Charles L. Crow (ed.), A Companion

to American Gothic. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons, 151-164.

2. Clery,E.J.2002. ”The Genesis of Gothic fiction” in Jerrold E.Hogle (ed.), The Cambridge

Companion to Gothic Fiction. Cambridge University Press, 21-41.

3. Frye, P. H. 1914.“German Romanticism”. Mid-West Quarterly, The (1913-1918). Paper 15,

97-119.

4. Gruener, Gustav. 1904.”Notes on the Influence of E.T.A. Hoffmann upon Edgar Allan

Poe”. Modern Language Association Vol.19, No.1:1-25.

5. Hoffman, Daniel. 2009.”Grotesques and Arabesques; Seeing Double” in Harold Bloom

(ed.), Bloom’s Modern Critical Interpretations: The Tell-Tale Heart and Other Stories. New

York: Infobase Publishing, 9-31.

6. Hogle, E. Jerrold. 2014.” The Progress of Theory and the Study of the American Gothic” in

Charles L.Crow (ed.), A Companion to American Gothic. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons, 3-

16.

7. Howard, Morgan. 2015.”A New Genre Emerges: The Creation and Impact of Dark

Romanticism”.English Class Publications. Paper 12: 1-9.

8. Kao, Shu-ting. 2016. ”Dark Unconscious in Edgar Allan Poe‟s William Wilson”.

International Journal of Humanities and Applied Social Science Vol.1, No.8: 1-8.

23
9. Mücke, von Dorothea E. 2006. ”Ligeia: Her Large and Luminous Orbs” in Harold Bloom

(ed.), Bloom’s Modern Critical Views: Edgar Allan Poe. New York: Infobase Publishing,

149-166.

10. Thompson, G.R. 1994. ”Literary Politics and the Legitimate Sphere: Poe, Hawthorne, and

the Tale Proper”. Nineteenth-Century Literature Vol.49, No.2: 167-195.

11. Vardoulakis, Dimitris. 2010.” Introduction, or the Reflection of the Doppelgänger” in

Dimitris Vardoulakis (ed.) The Doppelgänger. New York: Fordham University Press, 1-65.

12. Živković, Milica. 2000.”The Double as the unseen of culture: toward a definition

doppelgänger”. Facta Universitatis; Linguistics and Literature Vol.2, No.7: 121-128.

13. Poe, Edgar Allan, William Wilson. 1839. ONLINE! Webpage.

< http://pinkmonkey.com/dl/library1/wils_.pdf> Accessed 15th August 2017.

14. Poe, Edgar Allan, Ligeia. 1838. ONLINE! Webpage.

<http://pinkmonkey.com/dl/library1/ligeia.pdf> Accessed 15th August 2017.

15. Poe, Edgar Allan, The Tell-Tale Heart. 1843. ONLINE! Webpage.

<-https://americanenglish.state.gov/files/ae/resource_files/the_tell-tale_heart_0.pdf>

Accessed 15th August 2017.

16. Poe, Edgar Allan, The Imp of the Perverse. 1845. ONLINE! Webpage.

https://www.google.hr/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=2&ved=0ahUKEwjEuc

PcwdvVAhUlCcAKHXsTCusQFgguMAE&url=https%3A%2F%2Fetc.usf.edu%2Flit2go%2

Fpdf%2Fpassage%2F5233%2Fthe-works-of-edgar-allan-poe-010-the-imp-of-the-

24
perverse.pdf&usg=AFQjCNEV_ArMR37hvtH3kBBw7cjv0Rw0mA Accessed 15th August

2017.

17. Poe, Edgar Allan, The System of Dr. Tarr and Prof. Fether. 1844. ONLINE! Webpage.

< http://pinkmonkey.com/dl/library1/tarr.pdf> Accessed 15th August 2017.

25