BIM As A Design and Safety Tool For Cons

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 8

International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e-ISSN: 2395-0056

Volume: 10 Issue: 05 | May 2023 www.irjet.net p-ISSN: 2395-0072

BIM as a Design and Safety Tool for Construction Projects


Ar. N. Kanagadurga1, Ar. Z. Fathima Taskeen2, Ar. K. Indra Priya3

1Post Graduate Student, M. Arch - Construction Project Management, Faculty of Architecture,


Dr MGR Educational and Research Institute, Maduravoyal, Chennai, India
2Additional HOD, Faculty of Architecture, Dr MGR Educational and Research Institute, Maduravoyal, Chennai
3Deputy HOD, Faculty of Architecture, Dr MGR Educational and Research Institute, Maduravoyal, Chennai

---------------------------------------------------------------------***---------------------------------------------------------------------
Abstract - Building information modelling (BIM) has gained are lacking in certain nations, while they do exist in others,
prominence in the construction sector in recent years, notably like India, although their implementation is problematic.
in the fields of design, scheduling, and costing. The purpose of Occupational illness and accidents at work are global issues.
this study is to examine how traditional health and safety National preventive efforts require statistics and information
practices may be used in conjunction with BIM technology and on workplace accidents. Due attention is not given to safety
digitalization to enhance safety management in the since statistics on construction accidents are either non-
construction environment. The study starts with an extensive existent or grossly underreported. Safety precautions must
review and analysis of the available literature and live case be taken into account from the beginning of the project until
studies. A questionnaire survey was undertaken among its conclusion. Safe working conditions need proper
construction professionals to examine the adoption of BIM as a coordination between contractors and employees, which is
design and safety tool in the Indian construction sector. The often missing in Indian construction areas. Regardless of sex,
research finishes with findings about the software involved in religion, location, age, or other factors, occupational health
using BIM as a design tool and the challenges and barriers to and safety (OHS) is an area that is concerned with the health
implementing BIM as a safety tool for construction, as well as and safety of people working in any occupation and it is
recommendations for the proper application of the BIM-based essential for both employee and employer wellbeing. In order
theoretical model, which acts as a design and safety to promote OHS in the workplace and protect worker
management tool used throughout the whole project duration interests and health, the government of India periodically
for construction projects. passes various laws, rules, and requirements. Construction
has been significantly impacted by the Occupational Safety
Key Words: BIM – Building Information Modelling, OHS- and Health Act (OSHA) and its rules.
Occupational Health and Safety, Design Tool, Safety Tool,
BIM Software. 1.2 Problem Statement

1.INTRODUCTION Construction-related occupational fatalities, injuries, and


diseases cause significant human suffering, affecting not only
Building information modelling (BIM) is a potential those directly involved in the construction but also their
breakthrough in the fields of design, engineering, and families and communities, as well as contributing to the
construction. It is transforming the way contractors and national expense of medical treatment and rehabilitation.
engineers conduct business, but it is still in its early stages. There is a need to investigate various labour-related issues;
BIM was established more than a decade ago, primarily to there must be a welfare job plan and a safety plan in place,
separate architectural 3D from traditional 2D drawings. It is and contractors must adhere to various rules. Different
a lifesaver for complex projects due to its capacity to detect activities must be considered throughout the design stage,
problems early in the design stage. BIM is primarily and a safe design must be provided to reduce accidents. BIM
composed of 3D modelling principles as well as information is fundamentally altering the way construction is
database technology and compatible software in a desktop approached, from design to scheduling and budgeting to
computer environment that architects, engineers, and facility management. Automation through BIM is the key to
contractors may use to plan and simulate the building of a improving the efficacy and efficiency of safety management.
project. With the aid of this technology, project team
members may create a virtual 3D model of the structure and 1.3 Aim and Scope of the Study
every system within it and share it with one another.
The major aim of this study is to analyse the potentials of
1.1 Background of the study BIM as a design tool and a safety management tool. The
scope of this research is to understand Occupational Safety
The construction sector in India contributes significantly and Health Administration (OSHA) regulation, collect safety
to the economic growth of the nation. It is one of the largest management best practises, and identify the challenges
contribution factors in India after agriculture. Standard involved in implementing the use of BIM for safety
recording and notification procedures for building accidents management.

© 2023, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 8.226 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal | Page 697
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e-ISSN: 2395-0056
Volume: 10 Issue: 05 | May 2023 www.irjet.net p-ISSN: 2395-0072

1.4 Objectives of the Study selected: 1. Safety Management; 2. Causes and Effects of
Construction Accidents; 3. Accident Prevention; 4. BIM and
The objective of the research is to analyse the use of BIM as a Safety; 5. BIM Trends and Advancements.
safety and design tool and the methodologies involved in
integrating safety management techniques into BIM software Effective Safety Management in Construction Projects can be
for construction projects. achieved if the top five most important factors affecting
construction site safety, such as safety training and
2. METHODOLOGY awareness, worker attitude towards safety, availability of
safety equipment, safety inspections, and organizational
This research was performed to analyze the potential of BIM safety policy, are addressed and closely monitored. Safety
as a design and safety tool for construction projects. The affects all levels of the construction organization, including
research was divided into various stages starting from the government (Othman et al., 2018). Some of the top
literature study to recommendations, as shown in Figure 1. ranked causes of accidents are failure to follow safety rules,
A questionnaire survey was done to determine the use of BIM ignorance of PPE, space congestion, and improper use of
as a design and safety tool in the construction industry. safety equipment. The top-ranked effects of accidents are:
cost of medical expenses, time loss of project execution,
productivity loss, distrust of the firm, and cost of training
given to new workers (Sakthi et al., 2017). The age group of
less than 30 was more prone to accidents, and the most
common body parts exposed to injury were the upper limb,
lower leg, head, and neck. Construction workers lack PPE
(Jesline Serrao, 2020). The major preventive techniques to
reduce construction site accidents are following the safety
clauses, conducting safety audits, safety training
programmes, safety drills, safety education, and pre-job
meetings (Dheeraj Benny, 2017).

The Acci Map technique, BIM-based fall hazard identification


approach, safety management real-time location system,
fuzzy analytic hierarchy approach, video camera technique,
multi-criteria decision making (MCDM) technique, BIM-based
4D integrated technique, safety-based model, RFID (Radio
Frequency identification)-based locating system, are some of
the safety prevention techniques for high-rise building
construction through emerging technology (Bilal Mansoor,
2021).

Linking the professional model with the BIM 5D platform that


is developed with hazard identification, collision detection,
and real-time monitoring of the unsafe states of the objects
results in better safety model development and effective
safety management planning for the construction site
(Zhihong, 2021). BIM and safety (SIM) technology will create
a huge revolution since it will be very helpful for all
construction workers to review the safety measures in each
and every stage of construction. Incorporating safety rules
into BIM will not only help the designers do proper safety
Chart -1: Methodology planning, but it will also be helpful in educating the
construction workers about health and safety practices,
3. LITERATURE REVIEW which in turn will develop a good working environment
(Isabelle YS Chan et al., 2016). To build a proper safety rule
The literature review consists of the most relevant papers system, one must first categorize safety rules and then extract
related to emerging BIM-based safety management and the basic and required information. Each and every rule must
conventional safety practices in the construction industry. be formulated, and each component must be assigned a
A total of 16 journals published between 2016 to 2022 were unique component code that corresponds to its properties
taken into consideration and reviewed. The literature review and parameters. Component information should be collected
was then classified into five parts based on the type of journal from BIM, and each component should be matched with a

© 2023, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 8.226 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal | Page 698
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e-ISSN: 2395-0056
Volume: 10 Issue: 05 | May 2023 www.irjet.net p-ISSN: 2395-0072

safety rule by matching the IDs of the safety rule and the Case Studies on Using BIM as a Safety Tool:
component. Through this process, unsafe design factors are
identified and corrected by comparing component 4.1 The Recreation and Wellness Centre at Auburn
parameters and their related information in safety rules (Guo University [15]:
Hongling et al., 2016). The demonstration of safety culture at
different maturity levels will lead to a proper understanding
of safety culture and practices among workers. This model
can be included in safety training and practiced for effective
outcomes and achieving safety goals on construction sites
(Oluseye Olugboyega, 2016). BIM usage shall not be limited to
design purposes; it shall be extended to various scopes in the
management of construction projects. Awareness
programmes and training sessions can be conducted to
diverge the knowledge of BIM in India (Shalaka Hire, 2021).
The suitable tools for 3D BIM are Revit, AutoCAD, Sketchup,
and Part Builder in civil 3D, and to develop 4D Simulation for
safety management, the suitable tools with 3D BIM are
Google Sketchup, ArchiCAD, Tekla Structures, Tekla
Construction Management, Navisworks, Solibri Model
Checker, etc. These tools can also be included with VR and AR
to make effective safety management in construction
(Nguyen Quoc Toan et al., 2021).

BIM technology with AR can be used to establish a Figure -1: Recreation and Wellness Centre at Auburn
construction safety index and realize real-time and effective University [15]
monitoring of construction site-related information. Through
the relevant 3D model data and progress linking using BIM, The location of the project is Auburn, Alabama, USA. The total
4D simulation can be done, which results in orderliness and cost of the project is $50,000,000, and the total area of the
improved safety in construction activities (Zhenxian Huang, project is 2, 40,000 sq. ft. The project's start date is October
2021). Integration of BIM and IOT will enhance effective 2011, and its completion date is May 2013.
safety management planning. Early investment in safety
planning enables zero accidents in construction. Algorithm The list of software used for this project includes: Autodesk
development for effective computer graphics enhances BIM Revit for modelling; Google Sketchup for creating 3D
and IOT systems effectively. A remote monitoring system by equipment, characters, and related families; Synchro for 4D
comparison of IOT + BIM and on-site activities with CCTV will phasing simulations; MS Project for scheduling; Camtasia and
have proper tracking and monitoring of construction safety, MS Movie Maker for producing videos. In this case study, a
which in turn will reduce the cause of accidents (Haiyang Yu safety plan is developed through BIM technology to address
et al., 2022). The challenges that restrict the application of the "fatal four" construction fatalities and injuries: falls,
BIM to construction safety are legal issues, technology, cost, electrocutions, being struck by an object, and being caught in
management, and human resources. or between. The workflow followed in this project by the
team for developing BIM-based safety plans, simulations, and
4. CASE STUDY videos is shown in Figure 3.

The case studies chapter has been divided into two categories
according to the usage of BIM: case studies using BIM as a
safety tool and case studies using BIM as a design tool. The
case studies were conducted in the form of a net case study
and a live case study. A total of three case studies were taken
into consideration and studied. Two case studies were
reviewed, and inferences were drawn utilizing BIM as a
safety tool. One live case study has been studied and inferred
using BIM as a design tool.

Chart -2: Work Flow Process [15]

© 2023, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 8.226 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal | Page 699
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e-ISSN: 2395-0056
Volume: 10 Issue: 05 | May 2023 www.irjet.net p-ISSN: 2395-0072

The crane management plan is done to identify the crane's preventing risks in different activities, such as assembly and
swing radius to ensure its safe distance from the power lines disassembly of temporary elements, formwork, scaffoldings,
and nearby temporary and permanent structures, and to and the pouring of concrete in structural elements.
identify the crane's usage time by the crew. The excavation
risk management plan is done to coordinate with jobsite
equipment used for earthwork phase operations to avoid
cave-ins and accidents while installing sheet piles. A fall
protection plan for leading edges is prepared according to
OSHA Subpart M: Fall Protection Standards. Two types of fall
protection railings are modelled and placed on the structural
BIM model. Using the 3D view, the developers identify
multiple falling risks that will not be found with the 2D plan
view. They are exported to Synchro for developing 4D
simulations. The 4D simulation provides the contractor with
complete details, including location and date. A fall protection
plan for roofers is done as the roof is constructed in two
phases, consisting of decking the roof and then fusing
membrane sheeting on top of the decking with rigid
insulation. The entire operation is simulated to identify safety
issues related to that activity. These animations were used to
brief workers who are exposed to fall protection hazards by
working on a constantly changing roof structure.

It has been inferred through the case study that site safety
planning using BIM will enable designers, engineers, and
project managers to formulate safety plans for construction
sites. BIM 3D and 4D can visualize the process of construction
activity on a day-to-day basis, and possible site-related risks
can be observed. BIM also visualizes which hazard prevention
and safety control measures are to be implemented during
each and every construction activity. These visualizations will
help the construction workers with effective safety
management and safeguard them from hazards.
Figure -3: Safety Model using BIM [6]
4.2 The Recreation and Wellness Centre at Auburn
University [6]: The designers used architectural and structural 3D models
developed in Revit. They encouraged the use of temporary
construction while allowing the use of safety precautions.
Scaffolding, platforms, and construction fences were
imported using external web libraries (Revit City.com,
Bimstore.co, BIM objects, and BIM&CO). The designers
developed a variety of guardrail families, such as those with a
clamping mechanism, guardrails with spikes, and hole
coverings. In Navisworks, the two 3D models were finally
overlapped to create a federated model. By including the time
factor in the Navisworks federated model, a 4D model was
produced. The activity schedule created in Microsoft Project
served as the basis for the generation of the time component.
Figure -2: Radio Therapy Centre at Madeira [6] In order to prevent falls from height, this schedule took into
account both the primary construction operations and the
The location of the project is Madeira, Portugal. The list of temporary tasks, which correspond to the employment of
software used for this project includes: Autodesk AUTOCAD; safety mechanisms and the planned starting and finishing
Google Sketchup for creating 3D equipment, characters, and times for each activity. Additionally, safety files were created.
related families; Autodesk Navisworks; and Autodesk Revit. Tools were added to the 4D model, such as comments and
The building plans were developed in AutoCAD. It consists of links to these safety files, to promote safety. These documents
two floors: a basement and a ground floor. In addition, the include thorough explanations of guardrail and scaffold setup
BIM 4D model also contains safety documents for the and disassembly, as well as of dangers, risks, and
construction phase linked to it. The safety files focus on preventative actions. By using the Navisworks simulation tool

© 2023, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 8.226 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal | Page 700
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e-ISSN: 2395-0056
Volume: 10 Issue: 05 | May 2023 www.irjet.net p-ISSN: 2395-0072

on the 4D model, it was possible to visually follow the The Statue of Unity is a bronze replica of India's first deputy
evolution of the workplace through time and identify the prime minister, Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel. The models were
management and safety actions that were required at any created in various sizes: 3ft, 18 ft, and 30ft.
given time. Each color on a color-coded graphic created by
Navisworks simulation represents a different sort of task, Design Process:
such as construction, demolition, or a temporary task. This
case study gave extra consideration to the scheduling of
temporary safety equipment for reducing risks due to falling
from heights and its proper sequence of disassembly and
assembly from the excavation to the finishing works.

It has been inferred through the case study that incorporating


safety measures, including documents, in the safety structural
model and combining it with the existing model gives a clear
picture of when and where safety is to be implemented.

Case Studies on Using BIM as a Design Tool:

4.3 Statue of Unity, Gujrat

This project is located at Sadhu Bet, Sardar Sarovar Dam,


Gujarat. The total cost of the project is Rs 3000 crores, and
the total built-up area is 20,000 sq.m. The height of the statue
is 182 m (597 ft) from the road entry, or 240 m with an
overall base. The total project duration is 56 months (15
months for planning, 40 months for construction, and 2
months for handover). The sculptor Ram V. Sutar created
handmade models for the project, and the digital conceptual
sculptor was Joseph Menna. The list of software used for this
project includes: Autodesk Revit; Stadd Pro; AutoCAD;
Sketchup; Navisworks; and Rhino.

Chart -3: Design Process of Statue of Unity

It is inferred through the study that BIM acts as an effective


tool for critical engineering design. 3D BIM and its tools help
find design errors and improve designs. The accurate
calculation of the number of resources required for the
project by 3D BIM will help to reduce wastage of resources.
The traditional safety management method included HIRA
for all activities and ways to avoid accidents. Proper
monitoring and following the dos and don'ts will help in
human error reduction and accident prevention. Assessing
each and every hazard in the activities for various categories
and ranges will help in understanding the severity of risk in
each category. Conducting a training programme for the
workers based on the risk assessment will improve their
awareness of the importance of safety in construction.
Education about the problem and its solution will remove
the fear of working at heights or in other accident-prone
zones. The safety planning for this project took two months
to complete. Though SOU is a very successful project that
utilizes BIM as a complete design tool, incorporating safety
management into BIM during the design phase will help
reduce the time consumed by traditional safety management
methods.
Figure -2: Statue of Unity, Gujrat

© 2023, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 8.226 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal | Page 701
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e-ISSN: 2395-0056
Volume: 10 Issue: 05 | May 2023 www.irjet.net p-ISSN: 2395-0072

5. QUESTIONNAIRE SURVEY
The survey has been divided up into five parts, and
professionals in the construction industry responded to 18
questions: Part A: General Questions; Part B: BIM Awareness;
Part C: BIM as a Design Tool; Part D: BIM as a Safety Tool;
Part E: Barriers to the Development of BIM as a Safety Tool.
The questionnaire survey was circulated to 150 professionals
through online mode. A total of 120 replies were received in
response to 150 inquiries. 30 replies were considered invalid
due to missing or irrelevant information. 90 replies were
evaluated, analyzed and the findings has been discussed.

Some of the major questions that were marked mandatory to


answer and circulated among the professionals were: List of Chart -6: Benefits of using BIM as a design tool
BIM software used by the organization or firm for designing
projects; usage of BIM as a design tool; benefits of using BIM
as a design tool; challenges faced by the organization or firm
for implementing BIM as an integrated tool for safety
management; factors affecting the upgradation of BIM usage
to a higher level in the organization or firm; and type of safety
management practice followed by the organization or firm.
The received responses are listed and discussed below.

Chart -7: Challenges faced by the organization or firm for


implementing BIM as an integrated tool for safety
management

Chart -4: List of BIM software used by Organization/Firm


for designing Project

Chart -8: Factors affecting the upgradation of BIM usage


to a higher level in the organization or firm

5.1 Questionnaire Analysis:

The questionnaire survey analysis revealed that awareness of


BIM and understanding of implementing BIM as a safety tool
in the construction sector is still insufficient. Approximately
51.1% of firms/organizations have been using BIM for
designing projects. Some of the most essential and widely
used software for designing projects include Revit, SketchUp,
Chart -5: Usage of BIM as a Design Tool and Tekla Structures. BIM is most often utilized as a design
tool for scheduling and planning, 3D visualization, structural
design, MEP design, cost estimating, and planning. BIM is

© 2023, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 8.226 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal | Page 702
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e-ISSN: 2395-0056
Volume: 10 Issue: 05 | May 2023 www.irjet.net p-ISSN: 2395-0072

used as a design tool for approximately 10 to 50 projects in 7. CONCLUSION:


an organization / firm. According to the survey, the benefits
of using BIM as a design tool include cost and time savings, a In order to prevent construction site accidents Safety clauses
helpful tool for visualization, a valuable tool for should be followed, and safety audits, training programmes,
interpretation, a useful tool for improved communication, and pre-job meetings should be conducted. Linking the
and it is user-friendly. It is also discovered that, in general, professional model with the BIM 5D platform, which is built
BIM hasn't been used as a safety tool until now, and 68.4% of with hazard identification, collision detection, and real-time
respondents support the use of BIM as a safety tool. The main monitoring of the unsafe states of the objects, results in
challenges in implementing BIM as a safety tool include a lack enhanced safety modelling and effective safety management
of experienced BIM experts, a lack of BIM awareness, planning for the construction site. The potential of BIM
software purchase, training, and cost. The main constraints to should be spread, and its usage should be increased.
the advancement of BIM in firms are a lack of appropriate
standards, the scale and cost of the project, the lack of REFERENCES
technical staff, and organizational regulations and policies. It
has been found that most of the respondents use traditional [1] Abdulkadir Ganah, Godfaurd A. John ,2014, Integrating
methods for risk management and safety management for Building Information Modelling and Health and Safety
their projects. for Onsite Construction, UK,
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.asej.2022.101723
6. FINDINGS AND DISCUSSIONS:
[2] Ali Saad, Saheed O. Ajayi & Hafiz A. Alaka ,2022, Trends
Failure to follow safety standards, ignorance of PPE, space In Bim-based Plugins Development For Construction
congestion, and improper use of safety items and equipment Activities: A Systematic Review, UK,
are some of the major causes of accidents. Accidents have a https://doi.org/10.1080/15623599.2022.2093815
significant impact on the cost of medical expenses, project
execution time, productivity loss, firm distrust, and the cost of [3] Anita Jesline Serrao, 2020, Occupational Injuries Among
training offered to new workers. The study discovered that Building Construction Workers In Mangalore, India: A
those under the age of 30 were more likely to be victims of an Cross sectional Study, India,
accident. Safety training and awareness, worker attitude DOI:10.4103/ijhas.IJHAS_44_19,
towards safety, availability of safety equipment, safety https://www.ijhas.in/text.asp2020/9/2/116/282136
inspections, and organizational safety policy are the top five
[4] Bilal Mansoor,2021, Accidental Safety Factors And
most significant elements impacting construction site safety.
Prevention Techniques For High-rise Building Projects –
Over the last decade, BIM has grown tremendously. The
A Review, Malaysia,
growth of BIM and its features will propel the construction
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.asej.2022.101723
sector to new heights. Integration of BIM with AR, VR, and
IOT will make BIM-based safety management more efficient. [5] Dheeraj Benny, 2017, Construction Safety Management
Component information should be obtained from BIM, and And Accident Control Measures, Volume 8, Issue 4, April
each component should be linked with a safety rule by 2017, pp. 611–617 Article ID: IJCIET_08_04_069
matching the IDs of the safety rule and the component.
Through this process, unsafe design problems are found and [6] Fernanda Rodrigues João Santos Baptista and Débora
addressed using BIM automation by comparing component Pinto, 2022, BIM Approach in Construction Safety—A
parameters and associated information in safety standards. Case Study on Preventing Falls from Height, Portugal,
BIM is most commonly used as a design tool for planning and https://doi.org/10.3390/buildings12010073
scheduling, 3D visualization, structural design, MEP design,
cost and planning. According to the survey, the most [7] Guo Hongling, Yu Yantao, Zhang Weisheng, Li Yan, 2016,
significant advantages of adopting BIM as a design tool are Bim And Safety Rules Based Automated Identification Of
cost and time savings, a useful tool for visualization, Unsafe Design Factors In Construction, China,
interpretation, and user friendliness. The main challenges https://doi.org/10.1016/j.proeng.2016.11.646
observed while using BIM as a safety tool are a lack of skilled
BIM experts, a lack of understanding about BIM, the purchase [8] Haiyang Yu, Feng Liu, And Yujin Wang, 2022,
of software, training, and the cost. The main factors Construction And Evaluation Of Construction Safety
influencing BIM adoption in firms include a lack of adequate Management System Based On Bim And Internet Of
standards, project scale, cost, technical team availability, and Things, China, https://doi.org/10.1155/2022/1541241
organizational rules and policies.
[9] Isabelle Ys Chan, Hy Leung, 2016, How Can Bim Support
Construction Safety Management? Development Of Sim,
Hongkong, China, MATEC Web of Conferences 66, 00018
(2016), DOI: 10.1051/matecconf/20166600018

© 2023, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 8.226 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal | Page 703
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e-ISSN: 2395-0056
Volume: 10 Issue: 05 | May 2023 www.irjet.net p-ISSN: 2395-0072

[10] Nguyen Quoc Toan,thi Tuyet Dung,thi My Hanh , 2021,


3d-bim And 4d-bim Models In Construction Safety
Management, Vietnam,
https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/202126302005

[11] Oluseye Olugboyega And Abimbola Windapo, 2019,


Building Information Modeling—enabled Construction
Safety Culture And Maturity Model: A Grounded Theory
Approach, 2019, South Africa, Front. Built Environ. 5:35.
doi: 10.3389/fbuil.2019.00035

[12] Othman,i1, Nasir Shafiq1, Nuruddin,m.F1, Effective


Safety Management In Construction Project, 2018, IOP
Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 291
(2017) 012018, doi:10.1088/1757-
899X/291/1/012018

[13] M. Ramya, 2017, Analysis On Causes For Accidents In


Construction And Its Safety Measures, India,
International Journal of Modern trends in Engineering
and Science. 03. 127-132.

[14] Sakthi Ganesh.G, Rajesh.M, A Study On Identification Of


Causes And Effects Of Accidents In Construction
Industry- Indian Scenario, India,
https://doi.org/10.14445/23488352/IJCE-V4I6P108

[15] Salman Azhar, 2016, Role of Visualization Technologies


In Safety Planning And Management At Construction Job
Sites, USA,
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.proeng.2017.01.329

[16] Singaram.A, Priscil Nidhu ,2019, Investigation Of Causes


Of Accidents In Construction Industry, India,
http://www.aasmr.org/jsms/Vol8/Vol.8_No.3_4.pdf

[17] Shalaka Hire, Sayali Sandbhor, 2021,bim Usage Benefts


And Challenges For Site Safety Application In Indian
Construction Sector, India,
https://doi.org/10.1007/s42107-021-00379-8

[18] Zhenxian Huang, 2020, Application Research On Bim+ar


Technology In Construction Safety Management, China,
Zhenxian Huang 2020 J. Phys.: Conf. Ser. 1648 042019,
doi:10.1088/1742-6596/1648/4/042019

[19] Zhihong Yu, 2021, Research On Safety Management Of


Construction Site Based On Bim, Beijing, China, Zhihong
Yu 2021 IOP Conf. Ser.: Earth Environ. Sci. 719 032012,
doi:10.1088/1755-1315/719/3/032012

© 2023, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 8.226 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal | Page 704

You might also like