On Microperformativity
On Microperformativity
On Microperformativity
On Microperformativity
To cite this article: Jens Hauser & Lucie Strecker (2020) On Microperformativity, Performance
Research, 25:3, 1-7, DOI: 10.1080/13528165.2020.1807739
When post-anthropocentrism reaches the temporal) as the dominant plane of reference and
realm of contemporary performative practices to emphasize biological and technological micro-
in the arts, is the emergence of a concept like agencies that, beyond the mesoscopic human
‘microperformativity’ a logical consequence? body, relate the invisibility of the microscopic
Given the increasing technical manipulation of to the incomprehensibility of the macroscopic.
and impact on biological and ecological systems Microperformative positions enquire how artistic
with ever more tangible consequences at all methods can engage critically with technologies
levels, do the arts and the humanities tackle real- that exploit life on a microscopic and molecular
world problems by questioning what we may call level to merge bio- and digital media.
the ‘mesoscopic bubble’ within which our human Such investigations redefine what art,
perception and phenomenological considerations philosophy and the techno-sciences actually
are still enclosed? And might such a concept consider a ‘body’ today, in times when the genre
even help to provide alternative readings of of performance art is increasingly being enriched
the currently raging microperformativity of by a shift towards generalized and pervasive
the coronavirus? Performance theorist Richard performativity in art. As such, the inclusion of
Schechner’s provocative dictum ‘aliveness’ enlarges the scope of the
that ‘humanism is a very evolving field of the ‘live arts’.
arrogant, anthropocentric, Non-human agencies are
expansionist, and high- being staged in relation
energy ideology’ (1982 to performative
[1979]: 96) is echoed techno-scientific
today by an ever- or algorithmic
growing body of systems, thus
works that, on addressing
the one hand, contemporary
purposefully dynamics
decentre linking the
the human organic and
performer and, the machinic.
on the other, ‘Bacteria
emphasize the perform
performativity processes.
of a large panoply Scientists
of other-than- perform
human agencies, experiments.
biological and Algorithms perform
■ Petri dish with yeast cell
technical ones alike. actions. Humans perform cultures from saliva
The concept of gender and sex. The question samples, Microbial
Keywording by Spiess/
microperformativity denotes is who or what nowadays doesn’t Strecker, as part of the
a current trend in theories of perform?’ asks Chris Salter in his Applied Microperformativity
festival, AIL Vienna,
performativity and performative artistic practices theoretical foray into the epistemes of December 2018. Courtesy of
to destabilize human scales (both spatial and performativity and all these levels actually become the artists. Photo © Peter Mayr
2 P E R F O R M A N C E R E S E A R C H 25·3 : O N M I C R O P E R F O R M A T I V I T Y
Nevertheless, this desire to find instances of anthropomorphize viruses ‘as vicious and
biomediality able to materially give the viral secretive enemies of war, zombies, aliens and
performativity a visual form completely failed criminals that steal human lives’. She rather sees
conceptually: the incoherence inherent in the viruses as evolutionary companions, as a ‘library
fact that viral and bacterial contamination of the living’ that impacts on ‘evolution across
spread in totally different ways, thus debunking species on the planet.’2 2
Her position is inspired by
and in line with Gilles
the advert, pairs with the movie industry’s While such positions converge with the concept Deleuze and Félix
underhandedness to blatantly copy performative of microperformativity, viruses are nowadays Guattari’s praise of viruses
as crucial vectors of an
biomedia art practices, for example by the not only considered as evil enemies but have
‘aparallel evolution’
Critical Art Ensemble or Eduardo Kac (debated in also been rediscovered as an efficient means (1987: 10): biomediality is
this issue). of fighting bacterial infections. Therapies with considered responsible for
life’s diversity, comparable
While even within a few months, Corona bacteriophages – viruses attacking bacterial cells to the culturally
discourses changed from the early martial but not mammalian ones – were first practised in transformative power of
books as stored
lockdown ‘war on the virus’ talk to ‘let’s see how the 1920s, but then neglected after the massive information to be
to live with the virus’, the distributed agency of advent of antibiotics. Now, with the problem of activated, and that can
‘move into the cells of an
virality and its lack of materialized multiple antimicrobial resistance in pathogenic entirely different species,
representability seem to pose a number of bacteria, researchers are looking afresh at those but not without bringing
with its “genetic
challenges. In this issue, art itself may even be curing viruses. information” from the first
symbolically evoked as a contagious virus, or the In the light of Duff’s essay, it is tempting to host … Transversal
communications between
infectious agent is described as something against imagine that the epistemological career of such different lines scramble the
which masked dance performances may be post-digital viruses may follow that of bacteria: genealogical trees. Always
look for the molecular, or
employed to keep away bird flu. But Covid-19 has from Robert Koch to Louis Pasteur, bacteria were even submolecular, particle
also already profoundly changed the way many traditionally described as ‘invading animals’ and with which we are allied’
(Deleuze and Guattari
other performance practices portrayed in this notorious pathological agents in the age of 1987: 10–11).
issue are being read. For example, the new science’s discovery, in the nineteenth century, of
awareness about the role of aerosols in airborne the causality between disease and bacteria. It was
virus transmission allows ‘speech acts’ to appear the epoch of dominant hygiene vocabulary and its
in terms of J. L. Austin’s (1962: 6) concept that cultural metaphors led to biased preconceptions
‘performative utterances’ do not just represent an of bacterial presence. Addressed as ‘colonization’,
action in language but materially enact changes ‘immigration’, ‘infiltration’ or ‘intrusion’, these
in a fully new dimension of ‘spit acts’: to sputter threatening ‘enemies’ were opposed to primary
and to splutter now refers to material human body cells labelled, in turn, as ‘good
explosiveness, implying the physical ejection of republicans, peaceful, sedentary, with legitimate
particles, evoking the danger of infection, more kinship and safe loyalties within the body’
than just the discomfort of choking sounds, (Sarasin 2007: 445, 450, 454). Today, role models
becoming literally performative in a very of bacteria, and of the microbiome, have 3
The main argument here
is that ‘the colony of
biological sense. dramatically changed, as many contributions by individuals, the social
It is for these reasons that we have included artists and theoreticians to this issue demonstrate group, gleans information
from the environment.
a provocative essay by Tagny Duff, who has – be it a faecal transplantation from a Pygmy
They “talk” with one
worked ‘hands-on’ with viruses in laboratories community or an artistically produced probiotic another, distribute tasks,
throughout her career. Duff refuses to speak about drug conceived to enhance the art consumer’s and convert their collective
into a huge “brain” that
viruses, but speaks with viruses, insisting on anti-capitalistic mindset … Within an ecological processes information,
giving ‘the’ virus, in its distributed plurality, account of natural agency, bacteria are even said learns from past
experience, and, we
a voice, as a choir instead of ‘a singular subject, to partake in a ‘cognitive turn in microbiology’ suspect, creates new genes
one that is our natural enemy that we are at war considering that ‘bacteria are purposive agents, to better cope with novel
challenges’ (Ben-Jacob et
with’. Duff not only considers how human and purposive agency is the mark of cognition’ al. 2011: 56–7).
expansion, such as deforestation or other forms of (Fulda 2017: 70–71). Microorganisms are, 4
We thank Chris Salter and
destruction of natural environments, is linked to moreover, seen as ‘analogous to complex human- Klaus Spiess for their
additional editorial support
the appearance of contemporary zoonoses, but made cybernetic systems’ (Ben-Jacob et al. in providing feedback to
addresses how humans have a tendency to 2011: 57).3 a number of papers.
4 P E R F o R M A N C E R E S E A R C H 25·3 : o N M i C R o P E R F o R M A T i V i T Y
anthropocentric mind-set in our understanding of production on the scale of complex microfluidic
matter as passive, inactive or neutral substance, machinery, thus emphasizing the epistemological
which they feel ‘is disturbingly linked with the indeterminacy and the role of circumstantial
destruction of ecosystems, the depletion of factors for the results of experiments. Last, Gómez
resources and the extinction of wildlife’. López discusses the long-standing tradition of
The second section, Opening up experimentation, self-experimentation in the medical sciences,
mobilizes microperformativity as a conceptual involving the testing of prototypes, and proposing
tool to analyse entanglements of non-human ocular germination of a seed within her tear duct
agencies in experimental systems, such as the and extra-corporeal auto-transfusion of blood
artistic intervention ‘Microbial Keywording’ as experiences to be re-enacted by others via the
proposed by the interdisciplinary team led by distribution of ‘how-to’ guides.
Spiess and Strecker. Here, the linguistic concept The third section explores the staging of
of ‘speech acts’ extends towards its ultimate multi-scaled agency via various micro–macro
materialization: in analogy to the cell as the relationships entailing bacteria, biological
smallest biological unit of life, phonemes as and artificial neurons, as well as algorithms
the smallest entities of a spoken word, in as central agents in global financial networks.
turn, leave memory traces on single-celled With STILLEBEN, Athanassakis and Berry
oral microbes sourced from speakers’ mouths, address breastfeeding and the accompanying,
ultimately resulting in ‘phonetic probiotic’ invisible microbial transfer, and propose valuing
drugs. Another of many potential outcomes is breast milk and its microbial constituents as
a suppository described by KT Zakravsky/Zak Ray, primordial assets and currency, counteracting
further exploring the relation between matter capitalist economic principles. Political and
and language – between the co-performing ethical interrelations of macro and micro scales
pharmacological substance and a literary medical in the artist Adam Zaretsky’s provocative public
leaflet, while the patient information slip links workshops are put ‘under the microscope’ in
to the long tradition in Fluxus and performance Tratnik’s essay on how processes of genetic
art to use instructions. Science philosopher engineering can be demystified, using kitchen
Hans-Jörg Rheinberger takes us further into and household products and sexually connoted
the epistemology of experimental systems, metaphors such as ‘penetrating the genome’
discussing the term ‘microperformativity’ in or ‘sexing the environment’. Reversing this ■ Agnes Meyer-Brandis
Microfluidic Oracle Chip &
relation to the way substances and organisms are perspective, Franović and Kirschner start by Autopoesis Answering
made to interact with one another in laboratory analysing the ecological ‘glass box theatre’ Machine, detail of one chip,
2019. Photo © Agnes
contexts. He advocates a close look at the agential of Biosphere 2, where a group of humans, Meyer-Brandis, VG Bildkunst,
relationships between the micro-, meso- and alongside other plant and animal species, was 2019
macrocosmic dimensions, also with regard to
what he sees as a ‘reversion of performance’
in the much-cited term of the ‘Anthropocene’:
‘The globe, the planet is striking back – and it is
no longer primarily the people who are acting.’
Two related artistic contributions deal with
the deconstruction of scientific and authorial
authority. First, the biologist and artist Hideo
Iwasaki has paper cut-outs from his own research
articles overgrown by cyanobacteria, his very
model organism, provoking complex patterns of
not yet studied phenomena to appear materially
on the remaining scientific paper. Second,
artistic ‘microfluid oracle chips’ are discussed
by Meyer-Brandis and Voroprai: these stage the
dichotomous and iterative character of knowledge
6 P E R F O R M A N C E R E S E A R C H 25·3 : O N M I C R O P E R F O R M A T I V I T Y
experiences. The first, May the Rain Forest Live in REFERENCES
Me, consists of grafting the rich microbiota of an Austin, J. L. (1962) How to Do Things with Words, London:
inhabitant of the primordial forest onto the artist Oxford University Press.
Marion Laval-Jeantet, speculating on consequent Bal, Mieke (2002) Travelling Concepts in the Humanities:
A rough guide, Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
mental states of having the same microbiota
as a Pygmy, and to potentially learn to feel the Baudrillard, Jean (2002) Screened Out, London and New York,
NY: Verso.
forest environment thanks to the transplant of
Ben-Jacob, Eshel, Shapira, Yoash and Tauber, Alfred I. (2011)
an internal ecosystem. The second, Holy Coli, ‘Smart bacteria’, in Lynn Margulis, Celeste A. Asikainen and
transforms the microbiota of a mouse with Wolfgang E. Krumbein (eds) Chimeras and Consciousness,
a genetically modified Escherichia coli strain that Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, pp. 55–62.
produces a mouse’s faeces’ scent of violet, instead Bennett, Jane (2009) Vibrant Matter: A political ecology of
of shit – supposedly matching the smell emitted things, Durham, NC and London: Duke University Press.
by holy bodies evoked in anthropology and the Deleuze, Gilles and Guattari, Félix (1987) A Thousand
Plateaus: Capitalism and schizophrenia, trans. Brian Massumi,
history of religion.
University of Minnesota Press, London and New York, NY.
At the very end, we encounter the artist Tagny
Fulda, Fermín C. (2017) ‘Natural agency: The case of
Duff ‘speaking with viruses’, here and now bacterial cognition’, Journal of the American Philosophical
in the current crisis as we know it. Instead of Association 3(1): 69–90.
portraying her own years-long artistic practice Neumann, Birgit and Nünning, Ansgar (2012) ‘Travelling
of materially working with the most biologically concepts as a model for the study of culture’, in Birgit
diverse viruses, this experimental piece of writing Neumann and Ansgar Nünning (eds) Travelling Concepts for
the Study of Culture, Berlin: De Gruyter, pp. 1–22.
deliberately interlaces the form of trans-historical
Rheinberger, Hans-Jörg (1997) Toward a History of Epistemic
theatrical dialogues, media-philosophical Things: Synthesizing proteins in the test tube, Stanford, IL:
reflections on ‘the viral’, scientifically informed Stanford University Press.
footnotes and imagery, and the evocation of Sarasin, Philipp (2007) ‘Die Visualisierung des Feindes: Über
performative stagecraft. The curtain falls. metaphorische Technologien der frühen Bakteriologie’ [The
visualization of the enemy: On metaphorical technologies of
early bacteriology] in Philipp Sarasin, Silvia Berger, Marianne
Hänseler and Myriam Spörri (eds) Bakteriologie und Moderne:
Studien zur Biopolitik des Unsichtbaren 1870–1920
[Bacteriology and Modernity: Studies on the biopolitics of
the invisible 1870–1920], Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp,
pp. 427–61.
Schechner, Richard (1982 [1979]) ‘The end of humanism’, in
The End of Humanism: Writings on performance, New York,
NY: Performing Arts Journal Publications, pp. 95–106.
Previously published in Performing Arts Journal 4(1/2): The
American Imagination: A decade of contemplation, pp. 9–22.