The Root of All Cruelty - The New Yorker
The Root of All Cruelty - The New Yorker
The Root of All Cruelty - The New Yorker
ÿ
ÿ
ÿÿÿÿ9
ÿÿ
())*+ ,)-./0.1ÿ345ÿ3674ÿ8++9.
:;<ÿ>??@ÿ?AÿBCCÿDEF<C@GH
IJKLJMKNMOKPÿORÿSTOUJVWJXÿYJZKJÿMOU[Xÿ[J\]^NVT_JÿM\JTKÿSTWMT^P̀ÿa\JÿMK]M\ÿTPÿYOKPJ`
bcÿefghÿbhiij
klmnopnqÿstuÿstvw
xymnÿz{|}ÿ}zlq~
ÿD*3/-.ÿ/+ÿ/:*3ÿ3/+4=>ÿE+ÿ:-14ÿ6+4-ÿ5-1/;4-ÿ3/+4*-39ÿ8+F.,+18ÿ/:-ÿG;86ÿ1HHÿ5+4ÿ=+;4ÿ*I:+.->
( JKLKMNÿKPQRSTKÿSUÿNVKÿTWRNSPQXMÿNKYKZQRQSMÿRKJQKRÿ[\YXL]ÿ^QJJSJ_ÿ̀KaQMR
bQNVÿXÿRSYTQKJÿVcMNQMaÿTSbMÿXMTÿ]QYYQMaÿVQTKScRÿVcdXMSQTRÿLXYYKT
JSXLVKReÿfNgRÿXÿRNXMTXJTÿRLQKMLKhiLNQSMÿRLKMXJQSjÿdXMÿXaXQMRNÿdSMRNKJjÿ̀cN
NVKJKgRÿXÿNbQRNkÿQNÿNcJMRÿScNÿNVXNÿNVKÿRSYTQKJÿXMTÿVQRÿLSVSJNÿVXZKÿ̀JXQMÿQdPYXMNR
NVXNÿdX]KÿNVKdÿRKKÿNVKÿUXLKRÿXMTÿ̀STQKRÿSUÿNVKQJÿNXJaKNRÿXRÿdSMRNJScRjÿNSÿVKXJ
NVKQJÿPYKXRÿUSJÿdKJLWÿXRÿMSlQScRÿRmcKX]ReÿnVKMÿScJÿVKJSgRÿQdPYXMNÿUXQYRjÿVK
TQRLSZKJRÿNVXNÿVKÿQRMgNÿXÿ̀JXZKÿTKUKMTKJÿSUÿNVKÿVcdXMÿJXLKoVKgRÿXÿdcJTKJKJÿSU
QMMSLKMNÿPKSPYKjÿPXJNÿSUÿXÿLXdPXQaMÿNSÿKlNKJdQMXNKÿdKd`KJRÿSUÿXÿTKRPQRKT
aJScPÿX]QMÿNSÿNVKÿpKbRÿSUÿqcJSPKÿQMÿNVKÿMQMKNKKMhUSJNQKRe
rVKÿPVQYSRSPVKJÿsXZQTÿtQZQMaRNSMKÿudQNVjÿLSddKMNQMaÿSMÿNVQRÿKPQRSTKÿSM
RSLQXYÿdKTQXjÿbSMTKJKTÿbVKNVKJÿQNRÿbJQNKJÿVXTÿJKXTÿVQRÿ̀SS]ÿ[tKRRÿrVXM
vcdXMkÿnVWÿnKÿsKdKXMjÿqMRYXZKjÿXMTÿqlNKJdQMXNKÿwNVKJR_ÿxuNeÿ^XJNQMgRye
fNgRÿXÿNVScaVNUcYÿXMTÿKlVXcRNQZKÿKlPYSJXNQSMÿSUÿVcdXMÿLJcKYNWjÿXMTÿNVKÿKPQRSTK
PKJUKLNYWÿLXPNcJKRÿQNRÿLSJKÿQTKXkÿNVXNÿXLNRÿRcLVÿXRÿaKMSLQTKÿVXPPKMÿbVKMÿSMK
UXQYRÿNSÿXPPJKLQXNKÿNVKÿVcdXMQNWÿSUÿSNVKJRe
wMKÿUSLcRÿSUÿudQNVgRÿ̀SS]ÿQRÿNVKÿXNNQNcTKRÿSUÿRYXZKÿSbMKJRzÿNVKÿRKZKMNKKMNVh
LKMNcJWÿdQRRQSMXJWÿ^SJaXMÿ{STbWMÿS`RKJZKTÿNVXNÿNVKWÿ̀KYQKZKTÿNVKÿ|KaJSKRj
[NVScaVÿQMÿNVKQJÿ}QacJKÿNVKWÿLXJJWÿRSdKÿJKRKd`YXMLKRÿSUÿ^XMVSSTjÿWKNÿXJK
QMTKKTÿ~ÿ~_ÿ̀cNjÿJXNVKJjÿ[JKXNcJKRÿTKRNQNcNKÿSUÿuScYRjÿNSÿ̀KÿJXM]KTÿXdSMa
\JcNKÿ\KXRNRjÿXMTÿNJKXNKTÿXLLSJTQMaYWe_ÿrVKMÿNVKJKgRÿNVKÿvSYSLXcRNeÿtQ]KÿdXMW
pKbRÿdWÿXaKjÿfÿbXRÿJXQRKTÿbQNVÿRNSJQKRÿSUÿaXRÿLVXd`KJRjÿaJcKRSdKÿdKTQLXY
KlPKJQdKMNRjÿXMTÿdXRRÿaJXZKRoXMÿKZQYÿNVXNÿbXRÿKlPYXQMKTÿXRÿXJQRQMaÿUJSdÿNVK
|XQRgÿUXQYcJKÿNSÿRKKÿNVKQJÿZQLNQdRÿXRÿVcdXMeÿfMÿNVKÿbSJTRÿSUÿNVKÿPRWLVSYSaQRN
vKJ`KJNÿeÿ
KYdXMjÿ[rVKÿQMVQ̀QNQSMRÿXaXQMRNÿdcJTKJQMaÿUKYYSbÿVcdXMÿ̀KQMaR
XJKÿaKMKJXYYWÿRSÿRNJSMaÿNVXNÿNVKÿZQLNQdRÿdcRNÿ̀KÿTKPJQZKTÿSUÿNVKQJÿVcdXMÿRNXNcR
*+,-.ÿ,0ÿ1ÿ234ÿ456ÿ7896ÿ:-;<
bcdeÿghijkkeÿlhmmdin
=>?ÿA>?BCBÿA>DAÿEC?FCGHÿIA>?JBÿDBÿIKL?MABÿIJÿDGCNDOBÿ?GDKO?BÿIPJÿE?JQÿFIJBA
MIGRPMAÿFIPORÿB??NÿAIÿ?STODCGÿDÿHJ?DAÿR?DOUÿV?AÿA>?J?WBÿJ?DBIGÿAIÿA>CGXÿA>DAÿCAWB
DONIBAÿA>?ÿITTIBCA?ÿIYÿA>?ÿAJPA>U
) AÿBIN?ÿZPJIT?DGÿBIMM?JÿHDN?B[ÿYDGBÿNDX?ÿNIGX?QÿGICB?BÿDAÿ)YJCMDG
TODQ?JBÿDGRÿA>JIFÿKDGDGDBÿDAÿA>?NUÿ\?BMJCKCGHÿ)YJCMDGBÿDBÿNIGX?QBÿCBÿD
MINNIGÿJDMCBAÿAJIT?[ÿDGRÿNCH>AÿB??NÿOCX?ÿQ?AÿDGIA>?Jÿ?SDNTO?ÿIY
R?>PNDGC]DACIGUÿ^PAÿTODCGOQÿA>?B?ÿYDGBÿRIGWAÿJ?DOOQÿA>CGXÿA>?ÿTODQ?JBÿDJ?
NIGX?QB_ÿA>?ÿF>IO?ÿTICGAÿIYÿA>?CJÿK?>DECIJÿCBÿAIÿRCBIJC?GAÿDGRÿ>PNCOCDA?Uÿ=I
K?OC?E?ÿA>DAÿBPM>ÿADPGABÿDJ?ÿ?`?MACE?ÿCBÿAIÿDBBPN?ÿA>DAÿA>?CJÿADJH?ABÿFIPORÿK?
DB>DN?RÿAIÿK?ÿA>IPH>AÿIYÿA>DAÿFDQaF>CM>ÿCNTOC?BÿA>DA[ÿDAÿBIN?ÿO?E?O[ÿQIP
A>CGXÿIYÿA>?NÿDBÿT?ITO?ÿDYA?JÿDOOU
) 6ÿ,C5ÿZ51754Jÿ;1:+5<ÿ;6<ÿ,0G54Jÿ3,+<Jÿ.`2Q6ÿa0148ÿNC5ÿb2:07ÿ2Oÿ_032:J6JE
FVYO21<I?ÿ,C5ÿDC04232DC51ÿ=;,5ÿ_;665ÿG;M53ÿ;ÿ726326;6,ÿ;1:+G56,ÿ;H2+,
35Y+;4ÿP0245675Rÿ.NC5ÿ0<5;ÿ2Oÿ1;D03,3ÿ;3ÿG263,513ÿ5Y2651;,53ÿHJÿ7;107;,+15?Eÿ3C5
Q10,53?ÿ+1:06:ÿ+3ÿ,2ÿ1572:60c5ÿ.,C5ÿdefeghijÿ2OÿG032:J6J?Eÿ,C5ÿ<03,+1H06:
D2330H040,Jÿ,C;,ÿ.D52D45ÿG;JÿM62QÿO+44ÿQ544ÿ,C;,ÿ,C235ÿ,C5Jÿ,15;,ÿ06ÿH1+,;44J
<5:1;<06:ÿ;6<ÿ06C+G;6ÿQ;J3ÿ;15ÿO5442QÿC+G;6ÿH506:3?ÿ+6<5165;,Cÿ;ÿG215ÿ21
4533ÿ,C06ÿP56551ÿ2OÿO;435ÿ7263702+36533RE
_;665ÿ03ÿ;1:+06:ÿ;:;063,ÿ;ÿQ50:C,Jÿ;6<ÿQ544S53,;H403C5<ÿ37C224ÿ2Oÿ,C2+:C,R
>;,C;1065ÿKRÿ_;7=06626ÿC;3ÿD235<ÿ,C5ÿ^+53,0268ÿ.kC56ÿQ044ÿQ2G56ÿH5
C+G;6lEÿB;5ÿb;6:,26ÿC;3ÿ5YD4215<ÿ,C5ÿ0<5;ÿ2Oÿ35Y+;4ÿ3240D303G?ÿ;ÿ<2+H,ÿ,C;,
Q2G56U3ÿG06<3ÿ5Y03,RÿK6<ÿ72+6,4533ÿ,C52103,3ÿ,;4Mÿ;H2+,ÿ.2H\57,0Z7;,026?Eÿ,C5
,56<567Jÿ,2ÿ<56JÿQ2G56U3ÿ;+,262GJÿ;6<ÿ3+H\57,C22<?ÿ;6<ÿ,2ÿ37;6,ÿ,C501
)*+,-+ÿ/0-+/12ÿ3451+-657ÿ38/9ÿ8+-ÿ0+7/:2ÿ;6789ÿ<+=>
`abcÿefghiicÿjfkkbgl
?@AÿCADÿEFDÿGDHFCIJKGKÿKFDÿJLDIEJMDKÿH@IMIDLÿE@ÿGJK@NOIOPÿQFDÿCNNADKKJ@IK
RJHDIKDLÿSOÿG@ACRÿDIEJERDGDIETÿEFDÿUDIDDAÿ@VÿSCLÿVCJEFWÿEF@KDÿEFJINKÿCADÿDUJLDIE
JIÿCÿXJLDÿACINDÿ@VÿYFDI@GDICTÿVA@GÿKRCUDF@RLDAKZÿADRJNJ@I[EJIHE\ADL
]\KEJMHCEJ@IKÿE@ÿEFDÿ?C^JÿS\ADC\HACEKZÿK_\DCGJKFIDKKÿCS@\EÿICGJINÿEFDÿCHEJUJEO
( 4ÿ6ÿ260+-.:Mÿ64?ÿ5.32ÿB11A;ÿRT4-ÿU145ÿV35,+WÿXÿY:1B6:ÿZ30+1.Mÿ1)
[148-4+.6+314ÿ[6270Sÿ\U3++:-;ÿO.1@4];ÿX4?.-6ÿ^3+_-.ÿ6.+38>:6+-0ÿ012-ÿ1)
+,-ÿ7-.7:-`3+3-0ÿ1)ÿ,-.ÿ0>Ba-8+JÿXÿ8148-4+.6+314ÿ8627ÿ-`30+0;ÿ0,-ÿ06M0;ÿ@,-4-9-.
6ÿ519-.42-4+ÿ,1:?0ÿ5.1>70ÿ1)ÿ8393:3640ÿ1>+03?-ÿ+,-ÿ41.26:ÿ:-56:ÿ7.18-00;ÿ64?
4-6.:Mÿ6::ÿ46+3140ÿ,69-ÿ,6?ÿ+,-2Jÿb,-Mÿ864ÿB-ÿ+,-ÿ210+ÿ06965-ÿ7:68-0ÿ14ÿ-6.+,;
B>+ÿ+,30ÿ304/+ÿ64ÿ-00-4+36:ÿ)-6+>.-Jÿc>.345ÿ+,-ÿQ-814?ÿd1.:?ÿd6.;ÿX2-.3864
86270ÿ)1.ÿ+,-ÿe6764-0-ÿ@-.-4/+ÿ4-6.:Mÿ60ÿ+-..3B:-ÿ60ÿ86270ÿ34ÿY-.264Mÿ64?ÿ+,-
Q193-+ÿf4314Jÿb,-.-ÿ6.-ÿ-9-4ÿ012-ÿ86270ÿ+,6+ÿB-564ÿ@3+,ÿ41B:-ÿ34+-4+3140;
0>8,ÿ60ÿ.-)>5--ÿ86270ÿ0-+ÿ>7ÿ+1ÿ7.193?-ÿ)11?ÿ64?ÿ0,-:+-.N+,1>5,ÿ+,-Mÿ+-4?ÿ+1
@1.0-4ÿ19-.ÿ+32-;ÿ-91:9345ÿ34+1ÿ@,6+ÿ^3+_-.ÿ?-08.3B-0ÿ60ÿR7-.264-4+
7>.56+1.MJS
d,-4ÿ8148-4+.6+314ÿ86270ÿ6.-ÿ-0+6B:30,-?;ÿ+,-Mÿ6.-ÿ>0>6::Mÿ063?ÿ+1ÿ-`30+ÿ+1
7.1+-8+ÿ+,-ÿ:6.5-.ÿ717>:6+314ÿ).12ÿ012-ÿ0>07-8+ÿ5.1>7;ÿ1.ÿ+1ÿB-ÿ76.+ÿ1)ÿ6
8393:3_345ÿ2-0065-;ÿ1.ÿ+1ÿB-ÿ6ÿ@6Mÿ+1ÿ.-0+.634ÿ012-ÿ5.1>7ÿ1)ÿ8393:3640ÿ).12
0>771.+345ÿ,10+3:-ÿ)1.8-0JÿK.12ÿ+,30ÿ7-.07-8+39-;ÿ8148-4+.6+314ÿ86270ÿ6.-ÿ6
2-640ÿ+1ÿ64ÿ-4?;ÿ64ÿ-`627:-ÿ1)ÿ340+.>2-4+6:ÿ931:-48-JÿbM7386::M;ÿ+,1>5,;ÿ+,-
86270ÿ?1ÿ,69-ÿ6ÿ7>43+39-ÿ607-8+Jÿ^3+_-.ÿ+-::0ÿ1)ÿ,1@;ÿ6)+-.ÿ+,-ÿK3.0+ÿd1.:?ÿd6.;
O696.36/0ÿQ1836:ÿc-218.6+38ÿ7.-23-.;ÿg>.+ÿh304-.;ÿ@60ÿ0:1@ÿ+1ÿ?-264?ÿ+,6+
Y-.2640ÿB-ÿ.-:-60-?ÿ).12ÿK.-48,ÿ64?ÿO.3+30,ÿ86270iÿ,-ÿ@30,-?ÿ340+-6?ÿ+1
677-6:ÿ+1ÿ+,-ÿX::3-0/ÿ0-40-ÿ1)ÿ,>2643+MJÿh304-.ÿ@60ÿe-@30,;ÿ64?ÿZ3+:-.ÿ)>2-?
(A)+ÿC+66:ÿ,-ÿ3./ÿC566G-ÿA20ÿH)IA22/ÿJAK/2ÿ(567/--65ÿ67ÿ(-DL.6+6KDÿA3ÿMA+/ÿN2,9/5-,3D
A20ÿ3./ÿA)3.65ÿ67ÿBOKA,2-3ÿP:4A3.DEFÿQ/ÿ,-ÿL)55/23+Dÿ@5,3,2KÿAÿ*66Gÿ62ÿ3./ÿ4+/A-)5/-ÿ67
-)R/5,2KE
STUVW XYTZV[\V ]V^_`a[YbacYT[
deVffÿh^a[ÿi_`a[Wÿj^kÿjVÿ]V`Va[lÿm[fZanVlÿa[oÿmpcVU`Y[acVÿqc^VUfr
dXYUc_T_fÿXYTZV[\VWÿi_UcY[sÿa[oÿtYZZY[sÿcTÿuUVacVlÿv_fcaY[lÿm[olÿa[oÿiT[TUÿvT\YaZÿwVZacYT[f^Yxfr
d]Ty[ÿzYUZWÿh^VÿeTsY\ÿT{ÿSYfTsk[kr dq[VÿeT[sÿ|Ys^cWÿ}ÿzZT~aZÿiYfcTUkÿT{ÿuT[\V[cUacYT[ÿua`xfr
TTf
ÿÿ
o)43ÿp-/)
qrrst
uvwÿyz{|w}
~=-ÿ2)=ÿ;56*-/5)6ÿ6;-=ÿ;-=ÿ*;)ÿ45ÿ0-20)2*/4*5-2ÿ04196ÿ=-/.)3B
ÿ
ÿ
)**+,
[\/]^_ÿ]\.ÿ̀/]].6ÿa2]\ÿ̀.3b
cE;GCB;ÿdFe=f;B@=gÿh:ÿDJEFFIÿh=fÿ@=ÿ:E;ÿiFBAjIhJ;Kÿ9Fk;ÿJF=D;B<h:@<;DÿlIhk;ÿhÿJB@D@DÿFH
khDJeI@=@:Gmÿle:ÿ:E;ÿjBFlI;kDnh=fÿ:E;@BÿDFIe:@F=DnhB;ÿHhBÿkFB;ÿJFkjI;oK
LMÿpqZUUrÿXSWPYYs
^_`_abÿdebfbeb`gbh