See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/328064438

The Atlatl as Combat Weapon in 17 th-Century Amazonia: Tapuya Indian

Warriors in Dutch Colonial Brazil

Article · January 2010

CITATIONS READS

6 741

1 author:

Harald E.L. Prins

Kansas State University
95 PUBLICATIONS   321 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Wabanaki Confederacy in the American Revolution View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Harald E.L. Prins on 04 October 2018.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.

 Dance of the Tapuya Indians (Albert Eckhout c.1640)      Etnografisk Samling, Nationalmuseet, København

The Atlatl as Combat Weapon in 17th-Century Amazonia:

Tapuya Indian Warriors in Dutch Colonial Brazil
by

Dr. Harald E.L. Prins

Kansas State University

24 May 2010

in

The Atlatl
Vol. 23, Number 2
Newsletter of the World Atlatl Association, Inc
 
                  
                                       Tarairiu warrior with atlatl, four javelins & war club (Eckhout 1641)                   Tarairiu atlatl (detail in Eckhout 1641)              Tarairiu atlatl    
                                                                                                                                                                                                 Etnografisk Samling, Nationalmuseet, København
 
Perhaps the most fascinating but, oddly enough, little noticed ethnographic detail on two large
17th-century paintings depicting Amazonian Indian warriors is the wooden spear-thrower or
throwing-board, now often known by its Nahuatl name as atlatl. 1 These tribesmen belong to the
Tarairiu, a now-extinct group of about 1600 people historically ranging the mountainous
hinterland of Rio Grande do Norte and surrounding area in northeastern Brazil. Together with
other tribes inhabiting the sertão, the semi-arid highlands in the interior, they were one of the
many groups generally known as Tapuyas (variously spelled). Primarily referring to Ge-speaking
peoples, this is a depreciative term for “foreigners,” “barbarians,” or “enemies” in the language
of their Tupi-speaking neighbors traditionally inhabiting Brazil’s coastal tropical forests.
                                                            
1
 For instance, John Hemming (1978:297‐311) discusses in considerable historical and ethnographic detail the Tapuya, including 
the Tarairiu,  but nowhere mentions the atlatl as part of their armed outfit. And although his book includes a picture of their 
“war dance,” as painted by Albert Eckhout in c.1640, he only mentions that these Tarairiu warriors “brandish arrows and clubs” 
(fig.11).  And although  Rebecca Brienen (2006:120‐121) mentions the “spear thrower” in her exhaustive study of Eckhout’s 
paintings, describing in great detail how she sees the Tarairiu  portrayed by the Dutch, she mentions this remarkable weapon 
only once in passing.    

  2
  
Map of Brazil - after Claude Delisle - by Giovanni Battista Albrizzi in Stato presente de tutti paese, Venice, 1745

Feared like the Mohawk in northeast America, Tarairiu warriors were recruited by Dutch
commanders as indigenous guerillas in military campaigns against Portuguese colonial troops in
17th-century Brazil. Migratory foragers and reported to have been cannibals, these “savages”
quickly gained a diabolic reputation as “infernal allies” of Dutch troops in coastal Brazil in the
1630s and 1640s (van den Boogaart 1999:104,117; Meuwese 2003).
A few of these Tarairiu Indians were portrayed by Albert Eckhout (1610-1666), whose
large oil paintings count among the most spectacular visual representations of American Indians
in the colonial period. For anthropologists and historians, the ethnographic detail in these
paintings is of particular interest. 2 Originally hailing from Groningen city in the northern
Netherlands, Eckhout sailed to Pernambuco on the northeast coast of Brazil in 1637. Together
with other artists, as well as naturalists, architects, and other learned men, he had joined Count

                                                            
2
 In his 1928 Sorbonne dissertation on the Tupinamba, Swiss anthropologist Alfred Métraux discusses Eckhout’s painting of the 
Tapuya (Tarairiu) warrior dance. Considering its spectacular portrayal of a now‐extinct indigenous people and its deeper 
symbolic meaning, this fascinating image was chosen as emblematic for the Smithsonian Institution exhibit Alfred Métraux: 
From Fieldwork to Human Rights. Conceived and planned by Edgardo Krebs, with the assistance of Dr. Sarah Fee & the author 
as guest co‐curators, this exhibit was scheduled at the National Museum of Natural History, October 2006‐March 2007, but 
running into funding problems, it failed to materialize. 

  3
Johan Maurits van Nassau-Siegen, the newly-appointed Governor of New Holland, a Dutch
colony of the West India Company (1630-1654). During his seven year stay overseas, Eckhout
resided in Mauritsstad, a new city built on a small tropical island opposite Recife, and capital of
a territory extending from Sergipe on the south to Maranhão in the north. Traveling in the coastal
lowlands, he encountered not only African slaves on Portuguese and Dutch-owned sugar
plantations, but also Indians, and, of course, a variety of mestizos, mulattoes, and zambos due to
several generations of inter-ethnic sexual relations (see also Brienen 2006).
In their colonial scramble for Brazil, the Dutch first recruited Potiguara and Tabajara
warriors, regional subdivisions of the Tupinamba, a far-flung ethnic group inhabiting large
villages in the coastal lowlands from Cananéa in the south of the State of São Paulo to the mouth
of the Amazon. Primarily depending on manioc, but also growing maize and other crops in their
gardens, these two northern Tupi-speaking tribes had their own deep grievances against their
Portuguese neighbors who had long dominated, exploited and mistreated them. After an
indigenous Brazilian uprising against Portuguese settlers in 1624, the Dutch tried to capitalize on
the turmoil and established a foothold in this rich sugar-producing colony. After a year, however,
they were ousted. When the Dutch were forced to abandon their operation, a number of their
Potiguara allies boarded their ships and sailed to the Netherlands, where they were interviewed
by directors of the West India Company in Amsterdam. These Tupi-speaking tribesmen
informed the Dutch about other tribes hostile to the Portuguese, in particular “wild” nomads they
called Tapuyas.
These Tapuyas were not a singular ethnic group or tribe, but, as the Dutch recognized at
the time, included a variety of peoples “distinguished by names, dialects, customs, and
boundaries…. They are distributed over a very large territory that encompasses five rivers…. ;
cannibals they are all and due to the fame of their cruelty they are feared by other Savages and
the Portuguese…. They fight with bows and arrows, javelins with stone points and wooden
clubs” (Barlaeus 1647:323-24, my translation).

 
War Dance of the Tapuya, Detail (Albert Eckhout c.1641)

The Dutch were most familiar with the Tarairiu, a Tapuya tribe of migratory foragers and raiders
inhabiting the forested mountains and highland savannahs of Rio Grande do Norte. Unlike
Tupinamba archers, these Tarairiu “use no bows or arrows, but throw their darts with their
hands…” (Nieuhof 1682:878). Fierce and feared, they were described by Zacharias Wagner about
1640 as “extraordinarily tall, strong, and well built. These savage men with rough dark skin and
long black hair walk around completely naked…. They show great skill in throwing sharp and
heavy darts using throwing boards against the target they wish to hit. They do not use the sharp

  4
 darts on an enemy in flight but large heavy swords [clubs] made of black wood. They run with
incredible speed and, completely naked, they jump among thorns and thistles, letting out terrible
cries and attacking their enemies with great uproar, defeating them with chants and dances" (cited
3
in Buvelot 2004:68).
The Tarairiu atlatl shown here has a unique design well-described in Latin by the German
naturalist Georg Marcgrave who resided in Dutch Brazil (1637-1644): “Tapuyarum nationes
quaedam nullis arcubus utuntur, sed sagittas suas emittunt manus jactura solummodo
imponendo ligno cuidam excavato instar tubi per medium secundum longitudinem dissecti”
(“Some Tapuya nations do not use bows, but throw their arrows by hand, except they place those
on a piece of hollowed out wood, like a war-trumpet that has been cut apart over half in
length.”). 4 The atlatl illustrated below is (as far as we now know) the only authentic Tarairiu
throwing-board in existence today and forms part of the ethnographic collection of the Danish
National Museum in Copenhagen. 5 Comparing this artifact with the atlatl held by the Tarairiu
warrior as painted by Eckhout, we may speculate that the original colorful feathers on this
artifact have either disintegrated or otherwise not survived the tooth of time.

Tapuya Atlatl in the Danish National Museum Courtesy Nationalmuseet, København

 
About 88 cm (35 in) long and 3 to 4.5 cm (1½ in) wide, this furrowed spear-thrower is made of
brown hard-wood. Well-polished, it was carved with a semi-circular outer half and a hollowed-
out groove. Tapering off to its distal (left) end, it was designed to cradle the tail end of a javelin,
or dart, over two meters long (c. 82 in, i.e. 6.8 ft). The butt of this javelin, or dart, could hook on a
horizontal wooden spur, or peg, lashed with a cotton thread to the distal end of the throwing
board, where a few scarlet parrot feathers were originally tied for decoration (Bahnson 1889;
Métraux 1949:247).

Tapuya javelins, or darts, in the Danish National Museum Courtesy Nationalmuseet, København

                                                            
3
 The common German term for an atlatl is Würfholz or ‐brett (or Pfeilschleuder), but Wagner (fol.95) nicely described this 
furrowed artifact as a “small crib” (kleinen Kripgen) (cited in Ehrenreich 1894:86). 

4
 After seven years in Dutch Brazil, Marcgrave perished on the coast of Angola in 1644. His descriptions as a naturalist were 
posthumously incorporated in the famous 1648 book Historia Naturalis Brasiliae, co‐authored by his companion Dr. Willem 
Piso, a physician who also served in Brazil. This particular sentence (Piso and Marcgrave 1648:278) was cited by German 
anthropologist Paul Ehrenreich (1894: 86).    

5
 In an e‐mail to the author, Ms. Bente Gundestrup of the Danish National Museum cautioned “The atlatl (Hb.25) has never 
been in the Royal Kunstkammer. It is registered for the first time in 1839, when the Kunstkammer was already closed down.” 

  5
 No doubt somewhat varying in length, Tarairiu darts or javelins (called werp-pyl, spiets,
or schigt in 17th-century Dutch records) were probably made of a two-meter long wooden cane
with a stone or long and serrated hard-wood point, sometimes tipped with poison. 6 Equipped
with their uniquely grooved atlatl, tribesmen on the warpath could hurl their long darts from a
great distance with accuracy, speed, and such deadly force that these easily pierced through the
protective armor of the Portuguese or any other enemy (see also Raymond 1986:173). Typically,
while they threw with their right arm, their left hand remained free to hold the hard-wood club as
a deadly weapon for close combat (compare Eskimo and indigenous hunters harpooning their
prey with an atlatl, rather than shooting with a bow, as this much older device left them with one
hand free to hold a paddle; see also Steward 1946:519).
Like warriors in other tribes, Tarairiu not only used their weapons to chase wild game or
battle enemies, but also for sport: “They compete for glory by jousting and spear-throwing. The
aim is to please the public, especially their lovers; the women decide on each one’s bravery and
victory…. Every year, in the summer, they come together in different bands and armies to
perform their stomping dance, their spear-throwing and other games dedicated to the [stellar
deity of the Northern constellation]. The feast lasts three days; the champions step forward
decorated with feathers of different colors, as in the Olympic games” (Barlaeus 1647:325,329-30, my
translation).

 
Count Johan Maurits van Nassau (1604‐1679), Governor of Dutch Brazil, and Fort Ceulen at the mouth of the Potengi 
river in Rio Grande do Norte. Built in the 1590s by the Portuguese, who named it Forte dos Reis Magos, it was captured 
by the Dutch in 1633, serving them as a rallying point with Tarairiu and other Indian allies. (in Montanus 1671) 

In 1630, the Dutch tried again, this time conquering Pernambuco and establishing a foothold at
Recife. In the next few years, they expanded their colonial domain and recruited not only
                                                            
6
 The two darts, or javelins, depicted here are in the Danish National Museum, one being 201 cm long, the other 208 cm. They 
were first mentioned in the collection of the royal Kunstkammer in Copenhagen in 1689: “The original spearheads are missing 
but are known from an earlier photograph in the Department of Ethnography. The spearheads appearing in the illustration are 
copies produced on the basis of this photo” (Dam‐Mikkelsen, Bente Gundestrup & Torben Lundbæk (eds) 1980:32‐33).  

  6
Tupinamba warriors armed with bows and arrows, but also Tapuyas from the mountain ranges in
the hinterland, especially the tall cannibals belonging to the Tarairiu tribe who could strike terror
in the hearts of their enemies. For their military services, these native guerillas were rewarded
with gifts such as iron axes, knives, long nails, and fishhooks, as well as glass beads and
sometimes clothing (see also van den Boogaart 1999:108-09).  
When Count Johan Maurits van Nassau-Siegen arrived in Pernambuco in 1637, he
successfully expanded Dutch colonial control in northeast Brazil during his short but
extraordinary reign as governor of New Holland. Meanwhile, Eckhout made his series of
beautiful paintings realistically portraying African, Creole, and American Indian individuals
inhabiting Dutch Brazil.
After seven years in Brazil, the governor was recalled and sailed back to the Netherlands
in 1644, accompanied by about 1400 people aboard his fleet of 13 ships, including Eckhout and a
small cohort of Brazilian Indians—nine Tupinamba and two Tarairiu tribesmen. Also transported
were “many curiosities which we Dutch here admire as rare or unknown things [including]
weapons of the Savages, necklaces and head ornaments” (Barlaeus 1648:398, my translation).

 
Tapuya  with  atlatl  on  frontispiece  of  Historia  Naturalis  Brasiliae  (1648), 
authored  by  Willem  Piso  &  Georg  Marcgrave,  incorporating  contributions 
by fellow scholars in Dutch Brazil.

Included in this large ethnographic collection, one may assume, were also war clubs, bows and
arrows, atlatls and javelins, as well as parrot and rhea feather ornaments. Nicknamed “the
Brazilian,” the former governor later donated a set of 26 paintings by Eckhout to his cousin
Frederik III, the King of Denmark, “a zealous collector of objects of art and books” (Birket-Smith

  7
1952:682). Three of these are large oils depicting “Tapuyas” – one representing a naked Tarairiu
tribeswoman carrying human body parts (probably of a deceased relative, representing ritual
endocannibalism); another portraying a warrior with parrot and rhea feather adornments carrying
an atlatl with four javelins in his right hand and a war club in his left; and, last but not least, a
very large oil on wood painting (172 x 295 cm) pictured at the opening of this article, showing a
war dance with eight armed and feathered tribesmen (a couple with atlatl), and two maidens on
the edge of the forest admiring their fiery display. 7 This spectacular art collection ended up in the
Royal Kunstkammer (Chamber of Arts and Curios) in Copenhagen, which became part of what is
now the Danish National Museum.  
 
And what happened with the exotic “curiosities,” including Brazilian Indian weapons,
necklaces and head ornaments” shipped to the Netherlands in 1644? Where did they end up? Do
they still exist? Is it possible that the atlatl, javelins, and war clubs treasured for so long in the
Danish National Museum, as attested by its ethnography curator Dr. Kristian Bahnson in 1889,
and correctly identified five years later as Tarairiu by Amazonian Indian specialist Dr. Paul
Ehrenreich in Berlin, originally formed part of this collection? 8 Or were these shipped and
collected by someone else, perhaps later? Because the museum’s historical records are
inconclusive about the provenance of these precious artifacts, we can only speculate. 9
What we need not speculate about, however, is the dismal fate of their original owners—
the proud and battle-scarred Tarairiu, equipped with their archaic but amazingly effective atlatls,
were ruthlessly exterminated as an indigenous nation in the early 1700s.

                                                            
7
 There has been much speculation about these two young Tapuya women, but it appears evident from 17th‐century Dutch 
sources that Eckhout graphically illustrated what Smithsonian Institution anthropologist William Crocker (2004) detailed in his 
chapter on “The Extramarital Sex System” of the Canela, who form part of the same culture and language area in northeast 
Brazil as these Tapuya (see also Lowie 1946c).     
8
Noting that this particular atlatl is the only example of its type known to exist, Bahnson (1889:221) explained that although 
the ethnographic museum in Copenhagen possesses no information about its original provenance, this wooden throwing‐board 
came in its possession “with the old collection of the royal Kunstkammer, where it had been kept since a long period, albeit 
without identification in that collection’s inventory, the records of which are too little detailed.” Co‐editor of the 1980 book on 
the Royal Danish Kunstkammer, Ms. Bente Gundestrup suggests that Bahnson was misinformed, e‐mailing the author that “The 
atlatl (Hb.25) has never been in the Royal Kunstkammer. It is registered for the first time in 1839, when the Kunstkammer was 
already closed down.”

9
 After writing this article, I found Quentin Buvelot’s 2004 edited volume Albert  Eckhout: A Dutch artist in Brazil in which he 
depicts a photograph showing two 17th‐century wooden “clubs from Brazil” in the Danish National Museum. Although Buvelot 
(2004:18) suggests their “similarity to objects depicted by Eckhout makes it likely that they were included in the gift” by Johan 
Maurits to the Danish king, Ms. Gundestrup of the Danish National Museum disagrees, e‐mailing the author that these clubs 
“were part of the Gottorfer Kunstkammer until it was transferred to Copenhagen around 1750…. so these can for sure not have 
been a gift from Johann‐Moritz to the Danish King.” In fact, she cautioned: “We have no sources telling us how these objects 
have reached Copenhagen. It is pure speculation – but they might have been bought from or donated by Johann‐Moritz ‐ OR 
some  Danes  in  Dutch  service  might  have  brought  objects  home  from  Brazil.”  This  may  also  be  true  for  the  parrot‐feather 
ornament in that museum’s ethnographic collection. Originally placed in the Kunstkammer’s “East India Chamber,” it appears of 
th
Amazonian origin, perhaps 17 ‐century Tarairiu.

   

  8
Acknowledgments
 
It is my pleasure here to express my appreciation for my generous colleague and fellow Americanist
Christer Lindberg of Lund University, Sweden, where I served as a guest professor in March 2010, as it
was in his office I saw a large poster of the “Tapuya” warrior and recognized the tribesman was armed
with an atlatl, an ethnographic detail I had missed when viewing smaller reproductions of his portrait.
Together with a group of his anthropology students we then visited the Danish National Museum. I also
thank John Whittaker of Grinnell College in the US, one of the world’s foremost anthropological experts
on the atlatl, who provided useful feedback and invited me to submit this article. For the translation of
Marcgrave’s description of the atlatl in Latin, I turned to my good old friend and esteemed former
professor Ton Weiler, a medievalist now retired from Radboud University in the Netherlands. And last
but not least, I am indebted to Bente Gundestrup, Research Fellow at the National Museum of Denmark,
Copenhagen, who provided valuable information on the museum’s Kunstkammer, clarified issues
concerning the provenance of its Tarairiu objects, and generously provided the photograph of the unique
atlatl and javelins in its fabulous ethnographic collection.

Literature
Bahnson, Kristian. 1889. Über Südamerikanische Würfholzer im Kopenhagener Museum.
Leiden: Internationales Archiv für Ethnographie, Vol. 2:217-77.
Barlaeus, Caspar. 1647. Nederlandsch Brazilie onder het bewind van Johan Maurits Grave van
Nassau 1637-1644. [Rerum per octennium un Brasilia]. Edited by S. P, l’Honoré-Naber.
The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff, 1923.
Birket-Smith, Kaj.1952. “The History of Ethnology in Denmark.” The Journal of the Royal
Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland, Vol. 82 (2):115-127.
Boogaart, Ernst van den. 1999. “Infernal Allies: The Dutch West India Company and the
Tarairiu, 1631-1654.” Pp. 101-28. In Marcos Galindo et al, (eds). Indios do Noreste:
Temas e Problemas 2. UFAL.
Brienen, Rebecca P. 2006. Visions of Savage Paradise: Albert Eckhout, Court Painter in
Colonial Dutch Brazil, 1637-1644. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.
Buvelot, Quentin (ed.). 2004.Albert Eckhout: A Dutch Artist in Brazil. The Hague: Royal
Cabinet of Paintings Mauritshuis.
Crocker, William H, and Crocker, Jean G. 2004. The Canela: Kinship, Ritual, and Sex in an
Amazonian Tribe. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth (2nd edition).
Dam-Mikkelsen, Bente Gundestrup & Torben Lundbæk (eds). 1980. Etnografiske genstande i
Det kongelige danske Kunstkammer 1650-1800 / Ethnographic Objects in the Royal
Danish Kunstkammer 1650-1800. Copenhagen: Nationalmuseet.
Ehrenreich, Paul. 1894. Über einige ältere Bildnisse südamerikanischer Indianer. Globus:
Illustrierte Zeitschrift für Länder- und Völkerkunde, Vol.66 (6):81-90.
Hemming, John. 1978. Red Gold: The Conquest of the Brazilian Indians, 1500-1760.
Cambridge: Harvard university Press.
Krebs, Edgardo, Fee, Sarah, and Prins, Harald E.L. 2006. Alfred Métraux, From Fieldwork to
Human Rights: Itinerary of a 20th-Century Ethnographer. A Smithsonian Institution
exhibition brochure. Washington DC: National Museum of Natural History.

  9
 Lowie, Robert H. 1946a. “The ‘Tapuya’.”Pp. 553-56. The Marginal Tribes. Handbook of South
American Indians, Vol. 1. Washington: Smithsonian Institution. Bureau of American
Ethnology Bulletin 143.
–. 1946b. “The Tarairiu.” Pp. 563-66. The Marginal Tribes. Handbook of South American
Indians, Vol. 1. Washington: Smithsonian Institution. Bureau of American Ethnology
Bulletin 143.
–. 1946c. “The Northwestern and Central Ge.” Pp.477-517. The Marginal Tribes. Handbook of
South American Indians, Vol. 1. Washington DC: Smithsonian Institution. Bureau of
American Ethnology Bulletin 143.
Métraux, Alfred. 1949. “Weapons.” Pp.229-64. The Comparative Ethnology of South American
Indians, Handbook of South American Indians,Vol.5. Washington DC: Smithsonian
Institution. Bureau of American Ethnology Bulletin 143.
Meuwese, Marcus P. 2003. “For the Peace and Well-Being of the Country”: Intercultural
Mediators and Dutch-Indian Relations in New Netherlands and Dutch Brazil,1600-1664.
Notre Dame University Doctoral Dissertation.
Montanus, Arnoldus. 1671. De Nieuwe en Onbekende Weereld: of beschryving van America en
't Zuid-Land, Amsterdam: Jacob Meurs.
Nieuhof, Johan [1682] 1808-1814. “Voyages and Travels into Brazil.” Pp. 697-881. John
Pinkerton (ed). A General Collection of the Best and Most Interesting Voyages and
Travels in All Parts of the World, Vol.14. London: Longmans, etc.
Piso, Willem, and Marcgrave, Georg. 1648. Historia Naturalis Brasiliae…in qua non tantum
plantae et animalia, sed et indigenarum morbi, ingenia et mores describuntur et iconibus
supra quingentas illustrantur. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
Raymond, Anan. 1986. “Experiments in the Function and Performance of the Weighted Atlatl.”
World Archaeology, Vol.18(2):153-77.
Steward, Julian H. 1946. “Tribes of the Montana: An Introduction.” Pp. 507-533. The Marginal
Tribes. Handbook of South American Indians, Vol.1. Washington DC: Smithsonian
Institution. Bureau of American Ethnology Bulletin 143.

Dr. Harald E.L.Prins

Department of Sociology & Anthropology
207 Waters Hall
Kansas State University, Manhattan KS 66506
E-mail: [email protected]

05/24/2010

  10

View publication stats