Oxygen Barrier
Oxygen Barrier
Oxygen Barrier
Oxygen barrier plays a key role in food packaging, and it was found that NFC
contributed to the impermeability of films when they were prepared at a sufficient
thickness [24,148–150].
Related terms:
Barrier
Barry A. Morris, in The Science and Technology of Flexible Packaging, 2017
8.3.3.1 Polyethylene
The oil resistance of polyethylene (PE) is strongly affected by its crystallinity. In
general, if the PE has lower crystallinity, the oil resistance is reduced. Crystallinity, in
turn, is influenced by the density of the resin and film fabrication conditions (partic-
ularly quench conditions). For polyolefins and ethylene alpha-olefin copolymers like
linear low-density polyethylene (LLDPE) the crystallinity increases with increasing
density. For polar ethylene copolymers like ethylene vinyl acetate (EVA) the opposite
is true due to the higher MW of the comonomer. One way to normalize the effect of
crystallinity is to plot the oil resistance versus the secant modulus of the film. Typical
data for the penetration of mineral oil in PE are given in Fig. 8.3. Here the time
to failure in a ground glass patch test (ASTM F-119-70) is plotted. In this method,
a longer time indicates greater oil resistance. A change in slope occurs at around
350 MPa (50 kpsi), equivalent to about 0.935 g/cc density for a PE. The oil resistance
levels off above this level of crystallinity. This suggests that an HDPE resin has about
the same oil resistance as a medium-density polyethylene resin.
Similar results are found for peanut oil and are plotted in Fig. 8.4. Here grades of
ionomer and a grade of PP are included for comparison.
As the temperature is increased, the oil resistance decreases. The greater the density
of the PE, the less sensitive the oil resistance is to changes in temperature. This
may reflect the differences in melting points. Polyolefins melt over a temperature
range with HDPE having a peak melting point of 135°C and low-density polyethylene
(LDPE) 110°C. Some of the less perfect crystals melt at a temperature well below
the peak melting point. At 60°C, some of the crystals in LDPE have begun to melt
whereas very few crystals of HDPE have. It should be noted that this observation is
based on a study done before the introduction of metallocene PE, which have much
narrower melting point ranges.
Fig. 8.5 shows the effect of acid level on the resistance to mineral oil penetration.
Most grades of acid copolymer have an acid level in the range between 4 and 12 wt%
methacrylic acid (MAA) or between 3% and 9.5% acrylic acid (AA). At 12 wt% MAA,
the oil resistance is substantially better than a standard LLDPE grade or metallocene
plastomer, but not as good as HDPE (see Fig. 8.2). Data for EAA are not generated in
this study, but EAA is expected to have similar performance as EMAA at equivalent
mole % acid. Because AA has a lower MW than MAA, the wt% AA must be multiplied
by 1.2 to convert from wt% AA to wt% MAA at the same mol%. Thus a 10 wt% AA
EAA resin has about the same amount of acid on a molar basis as a 12 wt% MAA
EMAA resin.
Figure 8.5. Mineral oil resistance of acid copolymers as a function of acid content
(methacrylic acid) and temperature.
8.3.3.3 Ionomers
Partially neutralizing an acid copolymer typically improves its oil resistance. The
greater the acid level and percent neutralization, the better is the resistance. Sodium
ionomers typically give better resistance than equivalent zinc ionomers. In DuPont's
Surlyn ionomer product line, Surlyn 1707 (sodium, 0.9 MI) and 1605 (sodium, 2.8
MI) have the best oil resistance. Surlyn 1652 (zinc, 5 MI) has the least oil resistance,
but is still better than standard acid copolymers and LDPE.
Ionomers typically have better oil resistance than LDPE, LLDPE, and in many cases
HDPE. See Fig. 8.4 for a comparison of peanut oil penetration. DeGaravilla [52]
compares the corn oil penetration resistance of several polyolefins. His results,
shown in Fig. 8.6, show that ionomers have substantially better oil resistance than
other premium sealants such as very low-density polyethylene (VLDPE), metallocene
polyethylene plastomer (mPE), and EVA. The oil resistance of Surlyn ionomers is
sensitive to temperature; like PE, the higher the temperature, the poorer the oil
resistance. The temperature dependence of the penetration of vegetable oils is
illustrated in Fig. 8.7.
Figure 8.6. Oil resistance of several premium sealant resins. 50-μm film exposed to
40°C corn oil in ground glass test. Test terminated at 268 h (before ionomer samples
failed). EMAA, ethylene methacrylic acid; LLDPE, linear low-density polyethylene.
Composite data taken from Ref. [53]. Reproduced with permission from E. I. du Pont
de Nemours and Company.
8.3.3.4 Polypropylene
One grade of PP is included in the DuPont study [51]. PP is found to have better oil
resistance than HDPE and is comparable to the best ionomer grades. The sensitivity
of the oil resistance of PP to temperature changes is greater than HDPE but about
the same as ionomers. See Fig. 8.4.
Table 3.2. Summary of Contemporary Barrier Packaging Techniques Used for Gam-
ma Sterilization of UHMWPE Among Major Orthopedic Manufacturers (as of Oc-
tober 2008)
Figure 3.4. Contemporary barrier packaging used with the fabrication of ArCom™
(Biomet, Inc., Warsaw, IN). ArCom packaging currently uses a glass film interposed
between polymer sheets for an oxygen barrier. The packaging is argon-flushed and
then vacuum-sealed.
Concerns about oxidative degradation during shelf life prompted some orthopedic
manufacturers in the 1990s to adopt sterilization of conventional UHMWPE using
chemical sterilization methods such as gas plasma or EtO. These sterilization meth-
ods admittedly generate minimal to no free radicals that can subsequently oxidize
during shelf storage. However, UHMWPE sterilized in this manner does not receive
a tribological benefit associated with radiation-induced cross-linking. McKellop et al.
[18] reported on the wear performance of UHMWPE in a contemporary hip simula-
tor following gamma irradiation in air, gamma irradiation in an inert gas, EtO, or gas
plasma. Between 2 and 5 million cycles (each million of cycles corresponds to about
a year of use in vivo for an average patient), the wear rate of the gamma-sterilized
UHMWPE was significantly lower than UHMWPE sterilized by either gas plasma
or EtO. For example, the wear rate from 3.5 to 5 million cycles for EtO-sterilized
UHMWPE was reported as 40 ± 0.6 mm3/million cycles; in contrast, the wear rate
for UHMWPE that was gamma irradiated in an air-permeable package was found
to be 18.5 ± 0.9 mm3/million cycles [18]. A similar trend has been reported by Wang
et al. [19], who observed over a 50% drop in the hip simulator wear rate following
a single 25 kGy dose of gamma sterilization. When oxygen is excluded from the
package during sterilization, further cross-linking, and additional improvement in
wear performance, may be achieved in a hip simulator relative to gamma sterilization
in air [18].
The effect of gamma inert sterilization on wear has been evaluated in clinical studies.
The clinical wear rate for both gamma air and gamma inert sterilized components
is comparable. However, gas-plasma-sterilized implants have a clinical wear rate
that is approximately two times greater than gamma-air sterilized liners [20]. This is
because wear processes in hip replacements are dominated by cross-linking. Even
following gamma sterilization in air, the beneficial effects of cross-linking dominate
over the deleterious effects of oxidative degradation, helping to explain the decades
of successful use of gamma-air sterilized components starting in the 1960s:
“Perhaps surprisingly, the mean true wear rate for the conventional polyethylene
liners that had been sterilized with gamma radiation in air was not significantly
different from that for the liners that had been sterilized with gamma radiation in
vacuum-barrier packaging.”– Sychterz et al. [21]
Barrier Resins
Thomas Dunn, in Flexible Packaging, 2015
This chapter presents the ability of oxygen barrier resins, polyvinylidene chloride
(PVDC), ethylene vinyl alcohol (EVOH), and nylon (PA), to retard the movement of
oxygen across layer made of them when different oxygen partial pressures exist on
either side of the layer. Polyolefins, especially highly crystalline ones, have a similar
ability to retard the movement of water vapor when the partial pressure differences
represent relative humidity. The process is quantitatively described at the molecular
level and can be quantified in relative terms for flexible packaging materials. Similar
molecular interactions are recognized in such effects as slip additive migration,
flavor scalping, and extractables from packaging into packaged foods. Coextrusion
of barrier resins with olefin polymer and copolymers provides an effective and
economical means of incorporating this functionality into a packaging material.
EVOH is characterized by its mole percent ethylene and melt flow. Grades with
ethylene contents ranging from 27 to 48 mol% are available commercially. The
ethylene content represents a trade-off between ease of processing and barrier
performance. As the mole% ethylene is decreased, the oxygen transmission rate
(at low RH) decreases but processing becomes more difficult. An easy way to
remember these effects is that the higher the ethylene content, the more like
polyethylene and less like PVOH the molecule is.
Data from Kuraray. Technical bulletin no. 110: gas barrier properties of resins.
http://www.eval-americas.com/media/36916/tb_no_110.pdf.
EVOH comes in a variety of flow rates for processing on blown and cast film and
extrusion coating processes. EVOH is transparent, stiff, and highly crystalline, and is
an excellent oxygen barrier, but has a relatively high MVTR. EVOH is used primarily
in coextruded structures for both rigid and flexible packaging. Because of its high
crystallinity it can be difficult to thermoform or orient. A number of technologies
have been developed to overcome these deficiencies, including
• splitting the EVOH layer into two or more thinner layers [58]. New microlayer
technology reduces the crystallinity of EVOH, making the film more flexible
and orientable [59,60] (see Section 8.5.2);
•
using a rapid quench cast film or water quench blown film process, which
suppresses crystallinity [61,62].
Compatibilization
Johannes Karl Fink, in Reactive Polymers Fundamentals and Applications (Second
Edition), 2013
The compatibility of the blend is markedly improved and the material shows an
excellent oxygen barrier property and improvements in stretchability, film thickness,
and flexibility which are deficient in the saponified ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer
alone.
> Read full chapter
Source: http://www.mgc.co.jp/eng/products/nop/nmxd6/barrier.html
9.2. Humidity dependence of oxygen permeability at 23 °C.
Source: http://www.mgc.co.jp/eng/products/nop/nmxd6/barrier.html
In today's market, there are two major producers of Nylon-MXD6/PET bottles that
use the oxygen scavenging technology. Constar International market a product
under the name Oxbar™ for multilayer bottles and in addition they have mono-
layer systems, Monoxbar™ and the high clarity DiamondClear™ Amcor market the
system called Bind-Ox™, where the oxygen scavenger is incorporated in the middle
layer of a three-layer multilayer bottle. In this system, the rate at which oxygen is
bound is faster than the rate of oxygen permeation, so the Bind-Ox™ layer acts like
a sponge, capturing oxygen which has virtually no chance of reaching the product.
Although oxygen scavenging systems are highly effective, they do have a limited
lifetime and will only stay active until there is sufficient catalyst present to sustain
the oxidation reaction. The barrier properties are usually a function of scavenging
capacity and rate of consumption.10 The composition (MXD6 and cobalt content) as
well as the container wall thickness are factors that can affect the scavenging capacity.
Similarly, the barrier performance is dependent on package surface area/volume
ratio.11 Large surface/volume ratios limit cost-effective performance and for this
reason oxygen scavengers have primarily been used for bottled products.
An example of the oxygen barrier improvement observed with the use of Oxbar™ has
been reported by Brody et al. (2001).10 A 1-litre PET-only bottle showed an oxygen
transmission rate of 3.5 cm3/m2/day (22 °C), while the equivalent Oxbar™ bottle
(PET/MXD6/Co) had a transmission value of less than 0.04 cm3/m2/day. This low
level persisted for a period approaching two years.
Corona Treatment
Joanna Izdebska, in Printing on Polymers, 2016
8.3.7 Polylactide
PLA is a biodegradable polymer, which is characterized by perfect transparency, high
gloss, and thermoplasticity and it provides the same oxygen barrier as PP used for
production of packages. Due to the mechanical properties, it may be compared with
PA or polyester (Nampoothiri, Nair, & John, 2010). Surface free energy of this plastic
is relatively high but, like in the case of PET, it may require treatment before the
printing and gluing processes.
Moraczewski et al. (2014) noticed the growth of the value of PLA surface free energy
and the improvement of wettability (reduction of contact angle with water and
diiodomethane) resulting from the modification of the upper layer with corona
discharges in air and nitrogen atmosphere. The improvement of parameters was
visible for processes with unit activating energy which did not exceed 7 kJ/m2. Further
increase in Ej did not cause significant changes in the value of surface energy of
the material. This results from maximum saturation of layers with polar groups.
The growth of Ej during modification in nitrogen atmosphere is accompanied by a
constant increase in the value of PLA surface free energy. It is a sign of longer time
of the layers' saturation with polar groups in such conditions.
Biaxial stretching of the composites was carried out in 135–150°C temperature range
to draw ratios of 5 × 5, 6 × 6, and 7 × 7. An example of cross-section image of the
composite sheet with PP/PEO (90/10, vol./vol.) as a core structure is shown in Figure
3.11b. A thick PEO layer visible in the image shows randomly oriented PEO lamellae.
Biaxial stretching to 7 × 7 draw ratio produced nano-BOPP films with 16 PEO layers
in 33-layered PEO/PP core. Individual PEO layers down to 38 nm were successfully
produced with in-plane lamellar structures. The oxygen permeability 0.703 ± 0.041
barrer in BOPP control films reduced to 0.029 ± 0.007 barrer in nano-BOPP film with
10% PEO after stretching to 7 × 7 draw ratio. The effective PEO permeability decrease
was similar to earlier work. The multilayered films also showed a CO2/O2 selectivity
of 10, when PEO layers were present in the core. Transparency properties did not
show any significant changes in presence of PEO as the PEO layer thicknesses
were significantly below the quarter wavelength of light. An improvement of
10% in tear energy was measured in nano-BOPP films. Because the properties of
PEO are significantly affected in presence of water, measurement of permeability
properties in presence of high humidity was performed. The oxygen permeability
of nano-BOPP films showed a factor of two increment in effective permeability in
presence of 85% relative humidity. However, the overall film performance was still
significantly better than the neat BOPP films.
This approach was further extended to using PCL as a barrier layer in the multilayered
BOPP composite. Multilayered films with a layered core structure of PCL/PP and
outside thick layers of PP were produced in PP[(PCL/PP)n]PP format. The PCL volume
fraction range varied from 3% to 10% [20]. The multilayered films were biaxially
oriented at 155°C, which was sufficient to melt PCL nanolayers (Tm = 57°C).
Subsequent cooling of multilayered films to room temperature, however, resulted
into formation of on-edge lamellae in presence of PP due to transcrystallization
at the interface. The film structure was modified to incorporate PS layers as a
substrate layer in the film structure to produce PP[(PP/PS/PCL/PS/PP)n]PP film,
where PCL layers were confined against PS layers. Biaxially stretched BOPP and melt
recrystallized PCL nanolayers improved the gas transport properties by at least one
order of magnitude, from 0.635 ± 0.018 barrer in BOPP to 0.063 ± 0.002 barrer in
nano-BOPP with 15% PCL. Processing conditions were optimized to isothermally
quench the films between 33 °C and 41°C for improved barrier, as the air-quenched
samples did not show significant improvement. Further analysis of the films for
mechanical properties (tear energy and puncture strength) did not show significant
changes with the addition of PCL and PS components in the layered structure.
Biobricks
Michel Biron, in Industrial Applications of Renewable Plastics, 2017
•
Barrier properties•PEF oxygen barrier could be 10 times better than PET.•PEF
carbon dioxide barrier could be four times better than PET.•PEF water barrier
could be two times better than PET.
PEF could replace PET in typical applications like films; fibers; and in particular
bottles for the packaging of soft drinks, water, alcoholic beverages, fruit juices,
sauces, dressings, baby foods and edible oils, personal and home care applications,
cosmetics, detergents, food and nonfood products.
The needs are relatively simple: compounding low-cost masterbatch materials and
assuring reliable performance levels independent of processing equipment. And so,
the opportunities are attractive. Ideally, families of compatibilizers appropriate to the
performance expectations of various primary polymers will be offered. These would
seem to be needed in relatively small percentages in a given functional packaging
material, so the cost of managing and maintaining such a broad product line can
be accommodated in the market prices.
Compatibilizers may also provide other functions that enhance value to the pack-
aging material. Better adhesion, stiffness, heat resistance, strength, and surface
properties are well within reach. By way of example, the maleic anhydride mod-
ification of single-site polymers for increasing their compati-bilizing function for
nanocomposites is chemically identical to the modification of ethylene or propylene
copolymers that act as ‘tie’ resins. Coextruded films require such products to adhere
disparate resins (e.g. Nylon-6 and LDPE) in their multilayer construction. Separate
extruders and die channels direct the tie resins required to their designated position
in the coextrusion. A compatibilizer that can enhance the barrier performance of a
nanolayer while it binds it to an adjacent layer in a coextrusion not only eliminates a
costly structural component, but also simplifies the manufacturing equipment and
process needed to produce functional packaging material.
Importantly, the main principles for using modified single-site polymers to en-
hance nano-composite performance are understood. The challenge becomes one
of combining single-site polymer design latitude with an appreciation of working
knowledge of the principles that control successful and repeatable compatibilization
of nanoclays into target polymers.