2012 Air Transport
2012 Air Transport
2012 Air Transport
current evidence supporting critical care transport as well as federal Michael Lewell, MD, FRCP
Associate Professor of Medicine, Western University; Medical
laws regarding transfer of patients. With the variability in medi- Director, Southwest Ontario Regional Base Hospital; Medical
cal systems, each region has diverse resources and protocols, and Director, Ornge Air Ambulance Service, London, Ontario, Canada
emergency physicians should be aware of these prior to needing to Juan C. Nalagan, MD
Medical Director, MediFlight of Oklahoma; Assistant Professor,
transfer a patient. Select populations should be considered for air Department of Emergency Medicine, University of Oklahoma
transport, and certain patients will require resources beyond typical School of Medicine, Oklahoma City, OK
helicopter transport teams. This review highlights the indications for CME Objectives
helicopter transport of critically ill emergency department patients, Upon completion of this article, you should be able to:
the capabilities of many critical care transport teams, and current 1. Discuss potential capabilities of critical care transport and
controversies in the field. become motivated to explore the capabilities and nuances of
your own local service.
2. Describe how particular patient populations benefit from
Case Presentation critical care transport and recognize those who would benefit
from air transport.
3. Describe techniques for initiation of critical care transport,
A 54-year-old man presents to your community ED complaining of and discuss the current safety concerns within the industry.
abdominal pain and numbness in his right leg. Shortly after arrival to the 4. Recognize contraindications to air transport of the critically ill.
ED, he complains of pain extending to his chest. He describes the pain as a 5. Summarize the current evidence relating to the use of critical
“tearing” sensation that rips through his chest and back between his shoul- care transport.
der blades. The pain is constant, and he has never experienced it before. On Prior to beginning this activity, see “CME Information”
physical exam, his blood pressure is 208/110 mm Hg, and his pulse is 110 on the back page.
Editor-in-Chief Center for Resuscitation Science, Andy Jagoda, MD, FACEP Julie Mayglothling, MD Emanuel P. Rivers, MD, MPH, IOM
Robert T. Arntfield, MD, FRCPC, Philadelphia, PA Professor and Chair, Department Assistant Professor, Department Vice Chairman and Director
FCCP of Emergency Medicine, Mount of Emergency Medicine, of Research, Department of
Assistant Professor, Division Lillian L. Emlet, MD, MS, FACEP Sinai School of Medicine; Medical Department of Surgery, Division Emergency Medicine, Senior
of Critical Care, Division of Assistant Professor, Department of Director, Mount Sinai Hospital, New of Trauma/Critical Care, Virginia Staff Attending, Departments of
Emergency Medicine, Western Critical Care Medicine, Department York, NY Commonwealth University, Emergency Medicine and Surgery
University, London, Ontario, of Emergency Medicine, University Richmond, VA (Surgical Critical Care), Henry
Canada of Pittsburgh Medical Center; William A. Knight, IV, MD Ford Hospital, Clinical Professor,
Program Director, EM-CCM Assistant Professor of Emergency Christopher P. Nickson, MBChB, Department of Emergency
Fellowship of the Multidisciplinary Medicine, Assistant Professor MClinEpid Medicine and Surgery, Wayne State
Associate Editor Critical Care Training Program, of Neurosurgery, Emergency Senior Registrar, Emergency University School of Medicine,
Scott Weingart, MD, FACEP Pittsburgh, PA Medicine Mid-Level Program Department, Alice Springs Detroit, MI
Associate Professor, Department of Medical Director, University of Hospital, Alice Springs, Australia
Emergency Medicine, Mount Sinai Michael A. Gibbs, MD, FACEP Cincinnati College of Medicine, Isaac Tawil, MD
School of Medicine; Director of Professor and Chair, Department Cincinnati, OH Jon Rittenberger, MD, MS Assistant Professor, Department of
Emergency Critical Care, Elmhurst of Emergency Medicine, Carolinas Assistant Professor, Department Surgery, Department of Emergency
Hospital Center, New York, NY Medical Center, University of North Haney Mallemat, MD of Emergency Medicine, Medicine, University of New
Carolina School of Medicine, Assistant Professor, Department University of Pittsburgh School of Mexico Health Science Center,
Chapel Hill, NC of Emergency Medicine, University Medicine; Attending, Emergency Albuquerque, NM
Editorial Board of Maryland School of Medicine, Medicine and Post-Cardiac Arrest
Benjamin S. Abella, MD, MPhil, Robert Green, MD, DABEM, Baltimore, MD Services, UPMC-Presbyterian
FACEP Hospital, Pittsburgh, PA
Research Editor
FRCPC
Assistant Professor, Department Evie Marcolini, MD, FAAEM Amy Sanghvi, MD
Associate Professor, Department
of Emergency Medicine and Department of Emergency
of Anaesthesia, Division of Critical Assistant Professor, Department of
Department of Medicine / Emergency Medicine and Critical Medicine, Mount Sinai School of
Care Medicine, Department of
Section of Pulmonary Allergy Care, Yale School of Medicine, Medicine, New York, NY
Emergency Medicine, Dalhousie
and Critical Care, University of University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, New Haven, CT
Pennsylvania School of Medicine; Canada
Clinical Research Director,
beats per minute. He is diaphoretic with tenderness to fusionist, or physician.3,4 Although scene transfers
palpation in his upper abdomen that is most prominent in are commonly studied, almost 80% of CCT mis-
the epigastrium. The chest and cardiac exams are normal, sions are interfacility transfers.5,6
but he has 4/5 strength and decreased sensation in his left Despite the expertise of CCT teams, the trans-
leg. Lab results are all within normal limits. ECG dem- fer of critically ill patients is not without risk. Even
onstrates sinus tachycardia without ischemic changes. A transportation of critically ill patients within the
CT scan demonstrates a dissection from the aortic root hospital is associated with increased adverse events
to the level of the common iliac arteries. IV esmolol and when patients are not accompanied by appropriate
nitroprusside are started, and bilateral radial arterial staff.7,8 The risk of adverse events is increased when
lines are placed to monitor blood pressures. The diagno- interhospital transport is considered,7 as EMS trans-
sis is obvious, and the correct emergency treatment has port is performed around the clock, at high speeds,
been initiated. This patient needs life-saving surgery, but and with short response times on an unscheduled
cardiothoracic surgical support is not available at your basis. Mitigating this risk by adequately stabilizing a
hospital. You need to transfer this critically ill patient. patient and employing the correct resources is essen-
tial. The potential benefit of emergent transfer must
Introduction outweigh the potential risk.
Unfortunately, there are significant regional
Motor vehicle collisions, myocardial infarctions, disparities in CCT services as there are no uniform
drownings, childbirth, and gunshot wounds are national requirements or mandated skill sets for
all examples of acute presentations that require CCT providers. The Commission on Accreditation of
immediate medical attention. Emergency medical Medical Transport Services (CAMTS) has evolved as
services (EMS) personnel provide vital care while an accrediting body for air CCT; however, CAMTS
they treat and transport the sick or injured to ap- accreditation is not required for organizations pro-
propriate medical facilities.1 EMS providers are also viding air CCT.
accustomed to transferring patients from the emer- It is important for any physician needing to
gency department (ED) of one facility to another transfer a critically ill patient to be aware of avail-
for tertiary or definitive care that is not available at able regional EMS and CCT resources. While occa-
the sending facility. sionally a CCT service medical director or transport
While variability exists from state to state, physician will accept “shared responsibility” for a
many EMS options are available in most areas, patient in transport, the Emergency Medical Treat-
including basic life support (BLS), advanced life ment and Active Labor Act (EMTALA) stipulates
support (ALS), and critical care transport (CCT) that a transferring physician remains responsible
services. BLS ambulances can provide rapid ground for the patient’s care until the patient has arrived
transport, oxygen therapy, and fracture or spinal at the receiving institution.9,10 Familiarization with
immobilization. ALS ambulances can provide regional EMS capabilities and the transfer policies of
additional cardiac monitoring, advanced airway local tertiary care facilities is imperative to provide
management, and intravenous (IV) therapy with patients with the highest level of care.
limited pharmacologic intervention, typically by This issue of EMCC will discuss the advantages
maintaining continuous infusion rates. ALS ser- and disadvantages of air CCT, describe techniques
vices, however, cannot titrate medications, cannot for initiation of CCT, and discuss contraindications
provide invasive monitoring or intervention, and to air CCT.
transport primarily by ground.
CCT teams consist of a small cadre of highly Critical Appraisal Of The Literature
trained EMS professionals who travel by air or
ground and are regularly called upon to transport The data for helicopter transport of the critically ill
critically ill patients. Not only are CCT teams able ED patient have limitations similar to much of the
to travel by air via rotor or fixed-wing aircraft, they EMS literature. Due to the emergent nature of patient
can also provide invasive monitoring, advanced presentations and variability in transport systems,
ventilator support, cardiac pacing, defibrilla- performing high-quality, broadly generalizable stud-
tion, central line access, needle thoracostomy, and ies is challenging. There are no randomized trials of
advanced airway management (including surgical helicopter transport, and, as such, the majority of the
approaches). Additionally, CCT teams typically literature for helicopter transport consists of observa-
have a substantial pharmacy, including vasoactive tional studies, case series, and expert opinion.
agents, volume expanders, sedatives, analgesics, Many studies attempt to control for variability
paralytics, antiarrhythmics, and anticonvulsants.2 in patients by using the Injury Severity Score (ISS) or
A typical CCT team in the United States will consist the Trauma Related Injury Severity Score (TRISS).11 A
of specially trained nurses and paramedics, but commonly noted limitation of these scoring systems
they may also include a respiratory therapist, per- is that they require clinical information that is only
Decision to Transfer:
Indication for transfer (specialist services, diagnostics, procedures):___________________________________________________________________
Does the benefit of transport outweigh the risks? n Yes n No
Accepting institution and physician: ____________________________________________________________________________________________
Does the accepting institution have the capability and capacity to care for this patient? n Yes n No
Has informed consent for transfer been obtained from patient or family? n Yes n No
If not, the reason for not obtaining consent:______________________________________________________________________________________
Mode of Transport:
Has the appropriate level of EMS service (BLS, ALS, CCT) been called? n Yes n No
Considering distance, geography, patient factors, need for a CCT team, and other factors, should this patient be transported by air? n Yes n No
Does this patient require specialized services? n IABP n Isolette n Pediatric Team n ECMO n Other: ____________________
Who will accompany the patient? n EMS providers n CCT team n Staff from referring or receiving institution n Other: ____________________
Equipment:
n Portable, lighted monitor
n Portable ventilator
n Oxygen source with 1-2 hours of additional reserves
n Airway equipment, including LMA or other rescue device
n Defibrillator
n Suction
n Syringe pumps
n Additional battery supplies
n All medications the patient is likely to require, including sedatives, paralytics, and vasoactive medications
n All resuscitative fluids the patient may require, including crystalloid and blood products, as indicated
Communication:
Has the transport team been given a full report? n Yes n No
Has the receiving facility been updated of any new findings or clinical changes? n Yes n No
Has the referring nurse called the receiving nurse to give a nurse-to-nurse report? n Yes n No
Have copies been made of all clinical documentation? n Yes n No
Have images of radiographic studies been copied, and are they being sent with the patient? n Yes n No
If lab or radiographic data is not available at the time of transport, what is the plan to convey that information to the receiving hospital? ______________
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Abbreviations: ALS, advanced life support; BLS, basic life support; CCT, critical care transport; ECMO, extracorporeal membrane oxygenation; ECG,
electrocardiogram; EMS, emergency medical services; IABP, intra-aortic balloon pump; IO, intraosseous; IV, intravenous; LMA, laryngeal mask airway.
1. Delbridge TR, Bailey B, Chew JL Jr, et al. EMS agenda for the
You recognize that your patient is in need of close blood future: where we are...where we want to be. Prehosp Emerg
pressure control and monitoring and will need to be Care. 1998;2(1):1-12. (Review article)
transferred for emergency surgery. Your regional CCT 2. Banchik ME, Blumberg G. Management of intra-hospital
service operates a roster system and will facilitate the critical care transport: unification of equipment and policy. J
designation of a receiving facility. You call their central Trauma. 1993;35(2):328. (Retrospective review of 1665 intra-
hospital transports)
dispatcher, who requests that a medical helicopter be 3. Roeder JR. Flight team configuration of an air medical ser-
launched as soon as possible. After 2 additional calls, you vice. Top Emerg Med. 1994;16(4):66-72. (Review article)
are able to connect with the receiving hospital’s vascu- 4. Gebremichael M, Borg U, Habashi NM, et al. Interhospital
lar surgeon. Within 40 minutes, the helicopter lands on transport of the extremely ill patient: the mobile intensive care
your hospital’s helipad. As the CCT crew begins assess- unit. Crit Care Med. 2000;28(1):79-85. (Two-year retrospective
chart review of 39 patients)
ing and moving the patient onto the transport stretcher, 5. Ajizian SJ, Nakagawa TA. Interfacility transport of the critical-
he becomes unresponsive and is intubated by the CCT ly ill pediatric patient. Chest. 2007;132(4):1361-1367. (Review
team. His esmolol drip is titrated as he is placed on a article)
transport ventilator and moved to the waiting aircraft. A 6.* American College of Emergency Physicians. Interfacility
short flight later, he arrives in the OR where the vascular transportation of the critical care patient and its medical
direction. Ann Emerg Med. 2006;47(3):305. (Clinical practice
surgeon you spoke to is scrubbed and ready, waiting for guideline)
the patient. 7.* Warren J, Fromm RE Jr, Orr RA, et al, American College of
Critical Care Medicine. Guidelines for the inter- and intra-
hospital transport of critically ill patients. Crit Care Med.
Must-Do Markers Of Quality ED Critical Care 2004;32(1):256-262. (Clinical practice guideline)
8. Beckmann U, Gillies DM, Berenholtz SM, et al. Incidents relating
• Emergency physicians must be familiar with to the intra-hospital transfer of critically ill patients. An analysis of
federal laws as well as local resources and the reports submitted to the australian incident monitoring study
recognize that the decision to transfer, as well as in intensive care. Intensive Care Med. 2004;30(8):1579-1585. (Cross-
sectional case review of 176 patients)
the responsibility for the patient, rests with the
9. Testa PA, Gang M. Triage, EMTALA, consultations, and
referring physician until the patient arrives at prehospital medical control. Emerg Med Clin North Am.
the receiving hospital. 2009;27(4):627-640. (Review article)
• Communication with the receiving facility is 10. Medical director for air medical transport programs. Air Med-
critical, including adequate physician-to-physi- ical Committee, National Association of Emergency Medical
Services Physicians. Prehosp Disaster Med. 1995;10(4):283-284.
cian and nurse-to-nurse reporting. All pertinent
(Clinical practice guideline)
medical records, including imaging studies, 11. Boyd CR, Tolson MA, Copes WS. Evaluating trauma care:
should be copied and provided to the receiving the TRISS method. Trauma Score and the Injury Severity
institution. Score. J Trauma. 1987;27(4):370-378. (Description of the TRISS
• The patient should be stabilized as much as pos- method)
12. Wong K, Levy RD. Interhospital transfers of patients with sur-
sible prior to departure, including airway assess-
gical emergencies: areas for improvement. Aust J Rural Health.
ment and management. Pneumothoraces must 2005;13(5):290-294. (Retrospective case series of 22 patients)
be treated with chest tubes, and bowel obstruc- 13. Gray A, Gill S, Airey M, et al. Descriptive epidemiology of
tions should be decompressed with nasogastric adult critical care transfers from the emergency department.
or orogastric tubes. Patients in cardiac arrest Emerg Med J. 2003;20(3):242-246. (Prospective study of 349
patients)
should not be transported.
14. Zigmond J. Rethinking EMTALA? The CMS is seeking com-
ments on transfer rules. Mod Healthc. 2011;41(1):8-9. (Review
article)
treatment algorithm.
d. Eliminate heparin and IIb/IIIa inhibitor
Gone Mobile!
infusions after bolus.
You can now view all EMCC content on your
3. If there is a risk of airway deterioration, the iPhone or Android smartphone. Simply visit
airway should be secured: www.ebmedicine.net from your mobile
a. En route to the accepting hospital by device, and you’ll automatically be directed
the CCT team during the early phase of
transport to our mobile site.
b. During transport when the patient requires
a crash airway On our mobile site, you can:
c. Prior to air transport by the referring team • View all issues of EMCC since inception,
d. At any point before or during transport
including issues on NIV, blunt trauma, ACS,
4. All of the following are recommended as a
and more
minimum standard of monitoring during air • Take CME tests for all issues – that’s over 20
CCT EXCEPT? AMA Category 1 CreditsTM!
a. Continuous cardiac rhythm
(electrocardiogram)
• View your CME records, including scores,
b. Noninvasive blood pressure dates of completion, and certificates
c. Capillary blood glucose • Comment on EMCC’s What’s
d. Oxygen saturation (SaO2) Your Diagnosis blog, by visiting
e. Temperature http://www.ebmedicine.net/emccblog/
5. Contraindications for helicopter transport • Renew your subscription or purchase
include all of the following EXCEPT? additional content
a. Patients in cardiac arrest
b. Women in active labor Check out our mobile site, and give us your
c. Patients with chest tubes for pneumothorax feedback! Simply click the link at the bottom
d. Patients with bowel obstruction of the mobile site to complete a short survey
to tell us what features you’d like us to add
or change.
CEO & Publisher: Stephanie Williford Managing Editor: Dorothy Whisenhunt Managing Editor & CME Director: Jennifer Pai
Director of Member Services: Liz Alvarez Director of Marketing: Robin Williford