Trading Places
Trading Places
Trading Places
Language English
Plot
Brothers Randolph and Mortimer Duke own
a commodities brokerage firm, Duke & Duke
Commodity Brokers, in Philadelphia,
Pennsylvania. Holding opposing views on
the issue of nature versus nurture, they
make a wager and agree to conduct an
experiment—switching the lives of two
people on opposite sides of the social
hierarchy and observing the results. They
witness an encounter between their
managing director—the well-mannered and
educated Louis Winthorpe III, engaged to
the Dukes' grandniece Penelope—and poor
black street hustler Billy Ray Valentine;
Valentine is arrested at Winthorpe's
insistence after the latter assumes he is
being robbed. The Dukes decide to use
them for their experiment.
Cast
Ralph Bellamy in 1971 (left) and Don Ameche in 1964. They portrayed the Duke brothers, Randolph and Mortimer, respectively.
Production
Casting
Dan Aykroyd pictured in 2009. Paramount Pictures saw Aykroyd's success as tied to his partnership with the late John
Belushi, and the studio did not want to cast him, but his previous work with director John Landis helped him to secure the role.
Trading Places was developed with the
intent to cast comedy duo Richard Pryor
and Gene Wilder as Valentine and Louis
Winthorpe III respectively.[2][13] The pair
were in high demand following the success
of their comedy film Stir Crazy (1980).[3]
When Pryor was severely injured after
setting fire to himself while freebasing
cocaine, the decision was made to cast
someone else.[2][15] Paramount Pictures
suggested Eddie Murphy.[2] The studio was
initially unhappy with Murphy's performance
in his first film, the as-then-unreleased
action-comedy 48 Hrs. (1982)—a film also
conceived as a Pryor project.[16] However,
that film was well received by preview test
audiences, leading the studio to reverse its
opinion.[2][13] Landis was unaware of
Murphy, who had been gaining fame as a
performer on Saturday Night Live. After
watching Murphy's audition tapes, Landis
was impressed enough to travel to New
York City to meet with him.[2] Murphy said
that he was paid $350,000 for the role; it
was reported that the figure was as high as
$1 million.[17][18]
Filming
The Curtis Institute of Music pictured in 2010. The building was used as the exterior of the Heritage Club where Winthorpe
and Valentine first meet.
Winthorpe, Valentine, Ophelia, and Coleman retire with their gains to a tropical beach. The scene was shot on location in St
Croix in the United States Virgin Islands.
Music
Release
Context
Box office
Reception
Critical response
Jamie Lee Curtis pictured in 2018. She was dismissed as only a horror film star before her critically well-received
breakthrough performance in Trading Places.
Accolades
Post-release
Home media
Analysis
Ending explained
Thematic analysis
A drawing from the 1882 novel The Prince and the Pauper by Mark Twain. Trading Places is seen as a modern retelling of that
story and Twain's 1893 short story The Million Pound Bank Note.
The central storyline of Trading Places—a
member of society trading places with
another whose socio-economic status
stands in direct contrast to his own—has
often been compared to the 1881 novel The
Prince and the Pauper by Mark
Twain.[54][87][88] The novel follows the lives
of a prince and a beggar who use their
uncanny resemblance to each other to
switch places temporarily; the prince takes
on a life of poverty and misery while the
pauper enjoys the lavish luxuries of royal
life.[89] The Prince and the Pauper is seen as
a classic tale of American literature; Trading
Places adds a twist by casting an African-
American as the pauper raised up in status,
playing on fears of black usurpation and
appropriation.[88] The film has also been
compared to Twain's 1893 short story The
Million Pound Bank Note, in which two
brothers bet on the outcome of giving an
impoverished person an unusable million-
pound bank-note.[1][3] The choice to use
Mozart's opera buffa The Marriage of Figaro
also adds meaning. The opera tells the tale
of a servant, Figaro, who foils the plans of
his wealthy employer to steal his fiancée.
When Winthorpe is driven to work during
the film's opening, he hums "Se vuol
ballare", an aria from The Marriage of Figaro,
in which Figaro declares he will overturn the
systems in place. This foreshadows
Winthorpe's eventual efforts to do the same
to the Dukes.[3][90]
The main theme of Trading Places is the
consequences of wealth or the lack thereof.
Both extremes are depicted by those living
in opulent luxury and those trapped in a
culture of poverty—a concept arguing that
poor people adopt certain behaviors that
keep them poor.[1] Harris has described the
story as a satire of greed and social
conventions, but in the end, the good guys
win by becoming extremely rich.[2]
Economic inequality is demonstrated by the
wealthy who live in luxury. They are
completely removed from those whose lives
are affected by poverty. This is
demonstrated by the Dukes' bet, showing
their own sense of superiority over, and
disregard for, the lives of those beneath
them, even Winthorpe. Their only reward for
the bet is personal pride.[1] Author Carolyn
Anderson noted that films often feature an
"introduction" scene for characters elevated
above their station, like Valentine, to help
them understand the rules of their new
world. Conversely, there is rarely a
complementary scene for those subjected
to downward mobility.[91]
Legacy
Along with the impact their respective roles
had on its stars' careers,[2] Trading Places is
considered one of the best comedy films
ever made and part of the canon of
American comedies.[2][99][100][101][102] In a
1988 interview, Aykroyd said that he
considered it among his "A-tier" films, along
with Ghostbusters, Dragnet, The Blues
Brothers, and Spies Like Us.[103] Bellamy and
Ameche reprised their Duke characters for
Murphy's 1988 film Coming to America.
Murphy portrays the affluent Prince Akeem
who hands the now-homeless brothers a
large sum of cash. Mortimer tells Randolph
that it is enough to give them a new start.[3]
Of the two films, Murphy has said that while
he "loves" Trading Places, he prefers Coming
to America because it allowed him to
portray multiple characters.[104] The 2021
sequel Coming 2 America also references
the Dukes, revealing they used Akeem's
donation to rebuild their business.[105][106]
Critical reassessment
Notes
Citations
Works cited
External links
Trading Places (https://www.imdb.com/tit
le/tt0086465/) at IMDb
Trading Places (https://www.rottentomato
es.com/m/trading_places) at Rotten
Tomatoes
Retrieved from
"https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?
title=Trading_Places&oldid=1159153996"