Introduction To Language Development
Introduction To Language Development
Introduction To Language Development
Language Development
Second Edition
Introduction to
Language Development
S e co n d E d i t i o n
e-mail: [email protected]
Website: http://www.pluralpublishing.com
All rights, including that of translation, reserved. No part of this publication may be
reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means,
electronic, mechanical, recording, or otherwise, including photocopying, recording,
taping, Web distribution, or information storage and retrieval systems without the
prior written consent of the publisher.
Every attempt has been made to contact the copyright holders for material originally printed
in another source. If any have been inadvertently overlooked, the publishers will gladly make
the necessary arrangements at the first opportunity.
Preface ix
Acknowledgments xi
Contributors xiii
v
vi Introduction to Language Development
Glossary 249
Index 273
Preface
The inspiration for this text began when instructors to involve students more fully
I was teaching undergraduate language in classroom discussion while develop-
acquisition courses. The goal was to ing critical thinking and using problem-
ensure that complex concepts were at the solving skills. Learning objectives are pro-
appropriate level for students’ under- vided to guide students’ learning. Within
standing. An additional goal was to each chapter, boxes, tables, figures, and
prepare students for future practice. To examples elaborate and clarify the infor-
address these goals, these are the features mation presented. Study questions appear
of the second edition: at the end of each chapter to ensure that
students understand and retain the infor-
◆ Updated to reflect current research mation presented in the text and class-
◆ Expanded focus on evidence-based room lectures. A comprehensive glos-
practice sary of the key words in each chapter
◆ Improved readability through the is included to help students locate and
use of boxes, explanations, and grasp the definitions of key terms. On the
definitions PluralPlus companion website, multiple-
◆ A greater number of figures and choice questions that address the material
tables for deeper comprehension in each chapter are available, along with
PowerPoint lecture slides for all chapters.
To help students better understand the Highlights of the second edition
process of language acquisition, this text include:
presents an integrated view of the vari-
ous factors that play an important role in ◆ A chapter that introduces theories
children’s acquisition of language: articu- of language development. Under-
lation, syntax, semantics, phonology, mor- standing the theoretical foundations
phology, pragmatics, hearing, cognition, of language development is an
and literacy. To prepare students for what essential prerequisite for future
follows, an introductory chapter presents evidence-based practice. This chapter
them with terminology and concepts that concludes with practical strategies
they will encounter in the following chap- that are drawn from these theories.
ters. To support students’ learning, each ◆ Several chapters include information
chapter begins with a case study and on the differences that can appear
learning objectives. Case studies allow when children are learning a new
ix
x Introduction to Language Development
language. The goal is for students are used to support success in math-
to be able to distinguish differences ematics skills and other academic
from disorders. This information is subjects in later grades.
essential, given that 5 million or more ◆ A chapter on bilingualism introduces
school-age children in the United students to an important area of
States alone are English-language knowledge, given the growing
learners. number of children in schools who
◆ A chapter on the brain in relation are learning a new language. This
to speech, language, and cognitive chapter describes socio-cultural
development is an important contri- factors related to bilingual language
bution to students’ knowledge, given acquisition, summarizes bilingual
the frequent interaction between language development, applies best
speech-language pathologists and practice principles for assessment,
other practitioners (e.g., neurologists, and describes cross-linguistic and
psychologists, doctors, occupational bilingual approaches to intervention.
therapists, physical therapists). ◆ A chapter on hearing loss introduces
◆ A chapter on literacy development students to the impact of hearing loss
offers strategies for the support of on language development. While
children’s literacy skills. The impor- students do enroll in an audiology
tance of literacy goes beyond reading course within their study program, this
and writing. Literacy skills are chapter focuses on the consequences of
intertwined with oral language and hearing loss for speech and language.
Acknowledgments
Thanks to David Munro for his help in developing the glossary and
careful review of citations and references. Thanks to Marissa and David
for their edits. Thanks to Celeste Roseberry-McKibbin, Susan Hocker,
and Deborah Rhein for their feedback on the chapters that fell within
the areas of their expertise.
xi
Contributors
xiii
xiv Introduction to Language Development
children with ASD and their families for and Disorders at La Salle University
over 30 years. in Philadelphia, PA. Dr. Goldstein is
well-published in communication devel-
Brian J. Fligor, ScD., PASC is Chief opment and disorders in Latino children
Development Officer at Lantos focusing on language development and
Technologies, Inc. in Wakefield, MA, disorders in monolingual Spanish and
and President of Boston Audiology Spanish-English bilingual children. He
Consultants, Inc. in Mansfield, MA. Dr. is a Fellow of the American Speech-
Fligor is the chair of the World Health Language-Hearing Association.
Organization working group on stan-
dards for the Make Listening Safe Sandra Levey, PhD is Professor
initiative to provide consumers, health Emerita in the City University of New
professionals, and manufacturers of York (CUNY), Lehman College. She
portable audio systems (headphones/ is the chair of the Multilingual and
MP3 players) guidance for lessening the Multicultural Affairs Committee of the
risk for noise-induced hearing loss from International Association of Logopedics
improper use. He has published peer- and Phoniatrics (IALP). Dr. Levey has
reviewed scientific papers and academic published and presented on bilingual/
book chapters, given invited presenta- multilingual children’s and adult’s
tions, and is author of Understanding perception, language acquisition, and
Childhood Hearing Loss (Rowman and reading skills, along with the multicul-
Littlefield Publishers, Baltimore, MD). tural aspects of noise-induced hearing
loss. She has received recognition
Brian A. Goldstein, PhD, CCC-SLP is from the American Speech-Language-
Provost/VP of Academic Affairs and Hearing Association as a Board Certified
Professor of Communication Sciences Specialist in Child Language.
To Aaron, who has an active interest in learning the definitions of new words;
to Micah, who loves to use words to make jokes and riddles; to Marissa, the
wordsmith, who creates beautiful and lyrical words and phrases; to Tania, the
researcher and writer, who has written a book of her own that examines the
impact of words on others; to Daniel, the musician, who loves the language
of music; and to David, my husband, for his many years of companionship.
1
An Introduction to
Language Acquisition
Sandra Levey
Case Study
Casey is a kindergartner who has stay, and “pay” instead of play). She also
communication difficulties. Casey does not has difficulty understanding directions
initiate conversations with other children when the teacher is asking the children to
in the class, and friends sometimes do not complete a task within the classroom.
understand her because of her difficulty Identify the areas of difficulty by whether
in producing some sounds and her habit they involve communication, speech, or
of leaving some sounds out of words (e.g., language.
“top” instead of stop, “tay” instead of
1
2 Introduction to Language Development
assessment and intervention. After reading competence involves the acquisition and
this chapter, you should understand: use of morphology, phonology, syntax, and
semantics (Gleason & Ratner, 2017).
◆ The distinction between communica-
tion (the process of information Morphology: In what way words and
exchange), speech (the production smaller units can be combined to form
of sounds), and language (meaning other words (go + ing = going)
conveyed by words, sentences, and Phonology: In what way sounds are
longer utterances) combined to form words (c + a + t = cat)
◆ The five components of language
(syntax, semantics, morphology, Syntax: The word combinations used
phonology, and pragmatics) to express meaning in sentence struc-
◆ The role of cognition in language tures (I + see + a + bird)
◆ Terminology found in later chapters Semantics: In what way words
in this text correspond to things and events in
◆ The differences that may appear when the world (It’s raining), how language
children are learning a new language reflects a speaker’s intent (I want to tell
you a story), or feelings (I’m feeling good
We begin this introduction to chil- today).
dren’s speech and language development
with a discussion of communication, fol- Communicative interaction involves the
lowed by a discussion of speech and lan- exchange of information between a sender
guage. This chapter also presents a brief (speaker) and a receiver (listener). In the
review of cognition and a discussion of exchange of information, the sender trans-
the connection between cognition and mits information (encodes) that the receiver
language. comprehends or understands (decodes).
Figure 1–1. The movable articulators consist of the lips, tongue, and velum
(soft palate). Reproduced with permission from Language Development:
Understanding Language Diversity in the Classroom (p. 85), by S. Levey &
S. Polirstok (Eds.), 2011, Los Angeles, CA: Sage.
1. An Introduction to Language Acquisition 5
velum plays a role in the production of smallest units of sound that create a differ-
certain sounds. The larynx is a muscu- ence in meaning (e.g., /p/ vs. /b/ to dis-
lar organ that contains the vocal cords tinguish pea vs. bee). Note that the change
or folds (Figure 1–2). The vocal cords are of the initial phoneme in a word results in
stimulated by respiration (air from the a change in word meaning in the follow-
lungs). The vocal folds vibrate to produce ing examples.
phonation or voice (sound produced by
the vibration of the vocal folds). The respi- Sue-two /su/-/tu/
ratory system provides the support for
Tip-dip /tIp/-/dIp/
phonation (Figure 1–3).
Bat-cat /bæt/-/kæt/
Phonemes
Phonemes are the abstract representation
Notice that you bring your lips together of speech sounds (phones), with phonemes
to produce the sounds “p” and “b” when indicated by slashes (e.g., /p/ and /b/),
producing the initial sounds in the words as found in the words pat /pæt/ and bat
pat and bat. The sounds “p” and “b,” /bæt/. Consonant phonemes (Table 1–2)
along with many other sounds in English, and vowel phonemes (Table 1–3) are types
are termed phonemes. Phonemes are the of English phonemes that compose words.
Figure 1–2. The larynx. The vocal cords, also called the vocal folds, are
shown. The glottis is the space between the vocal folds. The epiglottis is
attached to the entrance of the larynx and is open for breathing and
closed during swallowing.The supraglottis is the area above the glottis, and
the subglottis is the area below. The trachea is a tube that extends from
the larynx to the bronchial tubes in the lungs, allowing air to flow to and
from the lungs. Reproduced with permission from Getty Images.
Figure 1–3. The respiratory system consists of the lungs and bron-
chus, which is one of the two tubes (bronchi) that carry air from throat
to lungs and air into the lungs. The pharynx is the place in the mouth
where the nasal passages connect to the mouth and throat. Reproduced
with permission from Getty Images.
6
Table 1–2. Consonant Phonemes of English
Note: The consonant phoneme /Z/ occurs only in medial and final
position, while the phoneme /w/ occurs only in initial position.
The consonant phoneme /j/ is the sound produced in the word
trial, i.e., tri /j/al). The /r/ in farmer and car (i.e., “er” and “ar”)
can be classified as rhotic diphthongs.
7
8 Introduction to Language Development
There are also vowels that are classi- language. Note that there is not a one-to-
fied as rhotic diphthongs. These are pho- one correlation between graphemes and
nemes that occur in words such as ear, air, phonemes. For example, the phoneme
door, and car. These phonemes are a com- /f/ is the last sound in the word laugh,
bination of a vowel and the vowel /2/. while the word laugh is spelled with the
Although these sounds are combined, a graphemes -gh. It is also the first sound
rhotic diphthong is considered a single in the word physician, while the word
sound. Examples of these words and their physician is spelled with two graphemes
phonetic form appear below. ph-. Children must learn to recognize the
variations between written and spoken
/i2/ ear, deer, hear, near, appear language to develop basic reading skills.
/e2/ air, hair, care, pair, stair
/o2/ door, floor, more, wore Words are composed of one syllable
(e.g., bug, dog, cat, see, run), two sylla-
/A2/ car, cart, sorry, jar, far bles (e.g., cartoon, monkey, daytime,
many), or three or more (e.g., gorilla,
Orthography describes the symbols summertime, watermelon, elementary).
or alphabet letters (graphemes) of written
1. An Introduction to Language Acquisition 9
Figure 1–4. The vocal folds in adducted (closed) and abducted (open)
position. Voicing occurs when the vocal folds are adducted. Unvoiced
sounds are produced when the vocal folds are abducted. Reproduced
with permission from Language Development: Understanding Lan-
guage Diversity in the Classroom (p. 83), by S. Levey & S. Polirstok
(Eds.), 2011, Los Angeles, CA: Sage.
10 Introduction to Language Development
Phonology
Phonological Processes
Phonological rules govern the distri-
bution and sequencing of sounds in Phonological processes describe children’s
words. Distributional rules govern early productions of words. Phonologi-
the position of sounds in words. For cal processes label a child’s production
instance, the sequence ng can occur that differs from a target word produced
in word final (sing) or medial posi- by adults. These productions may reflect
tion (singer) in English. However, their perception (auditory interpreta-
this sequence does appear in initial tion) of target words that are produced by
position in other languages, such as adults or older language users. Phonolog-
the language Grebo, spoken in the ical processes are described in Chapter 5,
African country of Liberia. with examples of children’s early word
productions shown below.
The term generative is also used Nouns: mother, dog, home, book
to describe the nature of language. This
Proper nouns: Sue, New York, Sesame
describes a speaker’s ability to generate
Street
many types of sentences, including novel
sentences produced by children when they Pronouns: he, she, you, it, we, they
lack a word to identify a thing or an action
(I’m crackering my soup). Grammar is the The basic syntactic structure (sentence)
description of a language with respect to consists of a noun phrase (which must
its components. The components of lan- contain a noun) and a verb phrase (which
guage consist of form, content, and use must contain a verb). Children expand the
(Table 1–4). We begin with a discussion of length and increase the complexity of their
the component form, which includes syn- sentences by adding modifiers. Noun
tax, morphology, and phonology. modifiers include determiners and adjec-
tives. Examples of determiners include
articles (a, an, the); cardinal and ordinal
numbers (one, two, three and first, second,
Form third); demonstratives (that, these, those);
quantifiers (some of, every, each, most, all);
Syntax and possessives (my, your, his, her, its, our,
their). Adjectives include colors; sizes (big,
Syntax is the component of language that thin, large); shapes (round, square); quali-
involves rules for combining words to ties; and other descriptions (happy, new,
form sentences. A basic sentence is com- loud, sweet).
posed of subject + verb (e.g., Tania ran).
The subject of a sentence contains nouns Determiners: the girl, a book, an apple
or pronouns. Common nouns label a per-
Demonstratives: that book, one book,
son, place, or thing, while proper nouns
some books are yours, my book
label specific persons, places, and things.
Note that proper nouns are marked with Adjectives: big boys, new books, red
capital letters. apples, happy children are playing
How The girl ran quickly syntax emerges with the combination of
two words at about 18 months of age.
When We are going to the park
Syntactic development begins with sen-
tomorrow
tences that express a request (More cookie),
Where Put the book there notification (That doggy), and negation
(No bed). Syntactic development is dem-
Quantity He ate so much that he fell
onstrated when children produce sen-
asleep
tences with increased length and com-
Time They went to school before plexity. This occurs with the development
they watched TV of vocabulary skills and the inclusion of
grammatical morphemes that indicate
Prepositional phrases indicate place (on continued action (e.g., going) and plurals
the table, in the bowl, next to the chair). The (e.g., toys). Children’s early sentence pro-
sentence The boy threw a ball is represented ductions (Table 1–5) show the develop-
in a syntactic tree in Figure 1–6. ment of a variety of different structures
Children begin to produce single that appear at about 3 years of age (Bern-
words at about 12 months of age, while stein, 2011).
14 Introduction to Language Development
Table 1–5. Children’s Early Sentence (dog + s). Inflectional morphemes include
Production the plural -s attached to nouns to indicate
plurality, the possessive ’s to indicate pos-
Sentence Example session (mommy’s), the present progres-
sive -ing attached to verb stems to indicate
Declaratives I sleepy.
present and ongoing action (running), and
Interrogatives Where mommy? the past tense marker -ed to indicate a pre-
vious activity (walked).
Imperatives Gimme cookie.
Morpheme Example
Free
Nouns car, boy, tree, book, girl
Verbs run, walk, eat, drink
Adverbs slowly, quickly, faster, fastest, late
Adjectives good, better, best; rich, richer; dirty
Bound
Derivational
Prefix: un-, non-, in-, pre-, trans- unlucky, nonstick, inappropriate,
preview, insufficient, transatlantic
Suffix: -ly, -ist, -er, -ness, -ment slowly, bicyclist, farmer, happiness,
contentment
Inflectional
Plural cats, dogs, horses
Possessive cat’s, mommy’s
Third person singular eats, drinks
Past tense walked (regular) and ate (irregular)
Past participle eaten
Present participle (present eating
progressive)
Comparative bigger
Superlative biggest
15
16 Introduction to Language Development
Third person singular Marks agreement with singular eats, walks, barks
third person (i.e., he, she, it)
Contractible copula The main copular verb is the I’m happy, he’s big (from
verb to be I am happy and he is big)
Semantic Roles and Semantic Relations with others. Pragmatic language rules
are defined as the effective and appropri-
Children’s early semantic development ate use of language to accomplish social
consists of semantic roles, used to convey goals, manage turns and topics in conver-
meaning at the one-word stage of devel- sation, and express appropriate degrees
opment. Some examples of semantic roles of politeness, awareness of social roles,
are agent, action, and affected. and recognition of others’ conversational
needs (American Speech-Language-Hear-
Agent Initiator daddy, ing Association, 2014). The behaviors that
(doer) of an mommy, involve appropriate pragmatic interaction
action doggie include eye contact when someone is talk-
Action Event throw, kiss, ing to you and turn-taking as sender and
drink receiver when involved in a conversation.
Pragmatics encompasses a wide
Affected Entity ball, baby,
range of communicative functions. These
influenced water
functions include the reasons for com-
by an action
municating; the frequency of speaking
(turn- taking, maintaining the topic under
At around 2 to 3 years of age, chil- discussion, and making appropriate topic
dren begin to combine words to form changes); and the ability to modify the
some semantic relations (Bloom, Lahey, style of communication to adapt to dif-
Hood, Lifter, & Fiess, 1980), with better ferent listeners (e.g., adults vs. children)
learning of these relations occurring after and different contexts (e.g., formal vs.
age 5 (Deák & Wagner, 2013). Examples of informal social situations). Children learn
the semantic relations acquired early are pragmatic rules through observation of
presented below. others’ behaviors in their environment
and through insight into others’ feel-
Agent + initiator + Daddy throw ings and needs. Children must possess a
Action event theory of mind (TOM) that allows them
Action + event/act + Drink water to understand others’ internal thoughts
Affected entity acted and emotions. TOM describes children’s
upon ability to understand other individuals’
mental states (thoughts and feelings), a
Entity + entity + Doggy bed
crucial skill to support pragmatic inter-
Location place (dog in bed)
action (Abdelal, 2009). For example, a
TOM allows a child to recognize the men-
tal states of happiness, sadness, or other
Use internal states. In these cases, appropri-
ate interaction requires that we take these
mental states into account.
Pragmatics Appropriate pragmatics are cultur-
ally determined, with differing pragmatic
Pragmatics refers to the appropriate use rules existing across cultures (Tannen,
of language in social interaction, along 1984). For example, some cultures con-
with the rules that govern interaction sider it inappropriate to use the term
20 Introduction to Language Development
why, while other cultures consider it inap- The speech act request occurs when
propriate to speak to a stranger. One of someone produces a question, such as Can
the areas of pragmatic differences may I have some juice? Note that the request for
appear in the relationship between a juice takes the syntactic form of a question
speech-language pathologist and a fam- (Can I . . . ?) while requesting an action on
ily, given that there are cultural differ- the part of the listener (Give me juice). This
ences in individuals’ beliefs regarding is an indirect speech act that has the syn-
parent–child interaction patterns (Trem- tactic form of a question but has the mean-
bath, Balandin, & Rossi, 2005). Some ing of a request. The understanding of the
parents believe in structured learning word can is acquired early (e.g., Can I have
and might have doubts regarding a more a cookie?), although the understanding of
naturalistic or informal approach. Other most indirect speech acts is acquired later
parents may feel uncomfortable when (Evans, Stolzenberg, Lee, & Lyon, 2014),
asked to collaborate in a child’s interven- Over time, children learn to make requests
tion program, given that this role differs in a more pragmatic or appropriate man-
from their cultural experiences or beliefs. ner by using the word please and through
Consequently, it is important to become the use of indirect requests (Can you, could
aware of cultural differences when work- you, would you mind . . . ?). Children’s prag-
ing with parents from different cultural matic/social interaction skills become
backgrounds, along with being sensitive more appropriate over time through
to these differences. observation and better understanding of
others’ minds in terms of how they might
feel or react to a request or a comment.
Speech Acts
Children are able to make requests
A speech act labels a speaker’s intent in a more appropriate manner when their
or meaning when she or he produces language skills develop to include modal
a sentence in social interaction (Searle, auxiliary verbs (e.g., can, could, shall,
1983). These utterances are termed “acts” should, will, would, may, and might) to pro-
because they frequently have an effect or duce indirect speech acts (e.g., Can I have a
result in an action. Notice that the follow- snack?). The use of modal auxiliaries leads
ing examples, produced by Sara at age 3½, to more polite requests. Children begin
frequently request or result in some sort to use modal auxiliaries around age 5.
of action. Note that the older child’s approach to
making a request for a cookie is very indi-
Greeting: Hi rect in the following examples. Note that
the younger children’s requests are more
Promise: I promise I eat my beans direct.
Request: I need chocolate ice cream
2-year-old COOKIE!
Indirect request: Can I have a snack?
3-year-old Gimme cookie
Complaint: Why I can’t have snack?
5-year-old Can I have a cookie?
Invitation: Come play with me?
7-year-old Those cookies sure smell
Refusal: Don’t want lunch good!
1. An Introduction to Language Acquisition 21
Thought about objects/ Making sense of the things that one has experienced
events
Use symbols (words) Representing the label and meaning for objects and events
the ability to plan, adapt to new situa- this information in memory. Internalizing
tions, draw on previous experience, and information consists of the child adopting
to store information in memory. information and making it part of his or
There are two important factors her knowledge. Retrieving information is
associated with cognition: attention and the ability to recall the information that
working memory. Attention consists of has been stored.
the ability to focus on the essential fac-
tors in a specific context or task, along
with the ability to ignore distractions and Social Cognition
irrelevant information. Working memory,
also sometimes termed short-term memory, Social cognition allows us to determine
provides children with the ability to store what information is already known by
information encountered in a current a listener, what information is needed,
experience (Galotti, 2017). Working mem- and what possible misunderstandings
ory is essential for a child to be able to might occur. It is the development of a
store, internalize, and retrieve or remem- TOM (understanding others’ thoughts,
ber information. An example of working desires, goals, motives, and emotions or
memory is when we are asked to remem- feelings) that allows children to acquire
ber a series of spoken directions (e.g., first social cognition. Social cognition allows
. . . next . . . finally). Limited short-term children to interact appropriately with
memory skills may influence the acquisi- others and to see things from others’ point
tion of language skills (Gathercole & Bad- of view, given the knowledge of others’
deley, 1990; Montgomery, Magimairaj, & mental states.
Finney, 2010). Children with poor work- Social cognition is a cognitive pro-
ing memory skills have difficulty with cess that enables a child to recognize and
classroom tasks, such as the recall of spo- understand social signals (Frith, 2008).
ken directions and spoken sentences and Examples of social signals include facial
the identification of rhyming words in a expressions (fear or anxiety) that may
lengthy verbal task (Gathercole, Durling, warn the presence of danger and eye gaze
Evans, Jeffcock, & Stone, 2008). direction that may indicate the presence
of an interesting object or event. Social
cognition is an important skill in infants’
Working Memory cognitive development. It allows infants
to refer to mothers’ facial expressions to
Working memory is defined as the hold- determine whether it is safe (or not safe)
ing of information in mind, along with to approach a novel object.
updating this information when neces- In one study of social cognition,
sary to revise or add new information. infants were exposed to a situation in
For example, if an adult gives the child a which an object was caused to fall. In this
multi-step set of directions to follow (e.g., study, infants were shown two conditions
put on your shoes, go into my room, and when an object fell: there were adults who
get my purse), a child with poor work- had not seen the object fall and there were
ing memory will have difficulty keeping adults who had seen the object fall. Infants
the series of directions in mind. Storage as young as 12 months of age understood
of information allows children to save who needed help finding the object versus
1. An Introduction to Language Acquisition 23
who did not need help (Liszkowski, Car- ing), and keeping information in mind to
penter, & Tomasello, 2008). They pointed guide future actions (working memory)
more often for the adults who did not see (Carlson, Zelazo, & Faja, 2013). Execu-
where it fell to show them the location of tive functions also play a role in regu-
the fallen object. Social cognitive skills lating lower order cognitive processes
were demonstrated when infants pointed (Key-DeLyria & Altmann, 2016), such as
more frequently to the fallen object to initiation, planning, working memory,
assist the adults who did not see where attention, problem solving, and verbal
it fell. reasoning (Table 1–10). Executive func-
tions also play a role in the control and
regulation of cognitive flexibility (shifting
Executive Function between ideas or tasks) and the inhibition
of inappropriate actions. Children’s exec-
Executive function refers to the cognitive utive function abilities have been shown
abilities used to control and to coordi- to develop between 3 and 4 years of age
nate information for planning goals, con- (Willoughby, Wirth, & Blair, 2012).
trolling responses (inhibition), shifting Executive functions allow children to
between tasks (cognitive task or set shift- accomplish the following tasks, essential
as children become older and enter aca- The ability to understand some-
demic contexts: one else’s mind does not emerge until
around 4 years of age (Baillargeon et al.,
Keep track of time 2010; Hale & Tager-Flusberg, 2003; Miller,
Plan 2006). However, 3- to 4-year-old children
possess the understanding that others’
Accomplish tasks within time limits desires and beliefs are associated with cer-
Apply previously learned information tain emotions, such as happiness, sadness,
to solve current problems surprise, and other emotional reactions
(Lane, Wellman, Olson, LaBounty, & Kerr,
Analyze information 2010). The true understanding of the men-
Request help when needed tal state verbs that are associated with the
human mind appears around 31 months
(Bartsch & Wellman, 1995), with the pro-
Theory of Mind duction of think and know. The mental
state verbs that emerge at 36 months are
Another aspect of cognitive development think, remember, forgot, thought, and pre-
is the theory of mind. TOM describes the tend (Nielson & Dissanayake, 2000). The
ability to understand the mental states of following mental terms were produced by
others (Baron-Cohen, 1993, 1996; Peter- Micah, at age 3, when he heard his baby
son, 2014), along with understanding and brother crying.
predicting how someone else will act and
explaining why a person acted in a cer- I think his feelings are hurt. I know what
tain manner. Mental states consist of our to do. I can fix it.
thoughts, feelings, emotions, reactions
to events, and ideas. TOM allows a child
to appreciate others’ mental states (Bail- A TOM marks the cognitive abilities
largeon, Scott, & He, 2010; Miller, 2006). of typically developing children,
Children’s TOM can develop through shown in the ability to take another
exposure to conversations that contain person’s perspective or point of view
mental state verbs (Astington, 1990; into consideration (Paul, Landa, &
Ruffman, Slade, & Crowe, 2002), such as Simmons, 2014).
thinks, knows, and believes.
Narratives play a role in learning men-
He thinks he will get a new bike. tal state verbs (Laing Gillam et al., 2015).
He knows where I put the car. Narratives require that children under-
stand characters’ feelings and actions,
He believes that I will share my candy. which can be described with mental state
verbs such as thinks, worries, and feels (de
Failure to develop a theory of mind Villiers & de Villiers, 2003). Narratives
is a factor in certain disorders, such introduce children to characters’ feel-
as autism (Baron-Cohen, 1996; ings, beliefs, and thoughts, along with the
Laing Gillam, Hartzheim, Studenka, language associated with these concepts.
Simonsmeir, & Gillam, 2015; Whyte, For example, in a story such as “Goldi-
Nelson, & Scherf, 2014). locks and the Three Bears,” children must
understand the motivations that guide the
1. An Introduction to Language Acquisition 25
characters’ behavior, along with under- a knife, cut as sharing profits, cut as mov-
standing the characters’ feelings that ing ahead of someone in a line); to become
result from the problematic situations aware of antonyms (add-subtract), syn-
(e.g., the broken chair, the missing por- onyms (afraid-scared), and homonyms
ridge, and someone sleeping in the baby (ate-eight); and to become aware of syn-
bear’s bed). tax (e.g., the awareness to rewrite a task
to make it more understandable).
Metacognition and
Metalinguistic Abilities Verbal Reasoning
of speech, language, and hearing services primary language is not English are cur-
for diverse language speakers. Given the rently enrolled in kindergarten to twelfth-
increased diversity in classrooms across grade programs in the United States and
the world, speech-language pathologists other countries across the globe.
must become aware that “differences”
(i.e., dialect or language differences from
One of the language productions that
a speaker’s dialect or language) do not
may be seen with children learning
imply “disorders” or “deficiencies.”
a new language is the use of the
word “do” as a general all-purpose
A dialect is a variation of a particular (GAP) verb, when the correct verb is
language that is distinguished by absent in a child’s language ability
phonology, grammar, or vocabulary. (Paradis, 2016). In this case, a child
Each dialect spoken is considered a may produce the sentence I do base-
legitimate rule-governed language ball instead of I played baseball. The
system. In the United States, examples use of the GAP verb disappears as
of dialects include African American the language skills of new language
English, Appalachian English, and learners develop over time.
Standard American English. Varia-
tions in the use of language are an
important reflection of an individu-
al’s cultural identity, which derives Summary
from sociocultural, sociolinguistic,
and historical roots (DeJarnette,
In this chapter, we have reviewed the fol-
Rivers, & Hyter, 2015; Rickford &
lowing components of language:
Rickford, 2000; Rickford & Rickford,
1976; Smitherman, 2000).
◆ We reviewed the components of
speech and language and the relation-
Practitioners must also be aware of ship between language and cognition.
the positive aspects of bilingual or mul- ◆ We learned that there is a close
tilingual learning. For example, children relationship between the components
from bilingual homes who become pro- of language: A speaker’s meaning
ficient in both their native and second (semantics) must be conveyed in the
languages have improved educational appropriate sentence form (syntax),
outcomes in terms of school completion with the correct morphemes assigned
rates, grades, achievement test scores, to indicate past tense (morphology),
educational aspiration, and personal with the correct phonetic patterns
adjustment (Bedore, 2010). Research also assigned (phonology), and the appro-
shows that typically developing children priate manner of interaction between
draw on the correspondence between a speaker and a listener (pragmatics).
their native language and the language ◆ We also learned that children form
being learned to support learning a new hypotheses or theories of how
language (Siu & Ho, 2015). It is essential to language works, as when children
acquire the knowledge of bilingual differ- produce the word eated. This shows
ences, given that so many children whose that children have acquired grammar
1. An Introduction to Language Acquisition 27
Cognition Pragmatics
Communication Prosody
Metacognition
1. What is the difference between
Metalinguistic abilities communication, speech, and
language?
Modal auxiliary verbs
2. Describe the importance of metalin-
Morphemes
guistic abilities in a child’s language
Morphology development.
28 Introduction to Language Development
Cavallo, S. A., & Levey, S. (2014). Speech pro- Gathercole, S. E., Durling, E., Evans, M., Jeff
duction. In S. Levey (Ed.), Introduction to cock, S., & Stone, S. (2008). Working mem-
language development (pp. 59–72). San Diego, ory abilities and children’s performance in
CA: Plural. laboratory analogues of classroom activities.
Deák, G. O., & Wagner, J. H. (2013). “Slow Applied Cognitive Psychology, 22, 1019–1037.
mapping” in learning of semantic relations. Gelman, S. A. (2009). Learning from others:
Proceedings of the Annual Conference of the Children’s construction of concepts. Annual
Cognitive Science Society, 25, 318–323. Review of Psychology, 60, 115–140.
DeJarnette, G., Rivers, K. O., & Hyter, Y. D. Gentner, D. (2003). Why we’re so smart. In D.
(2015). Ways of examining speech acts in Gentner & S. Goldin-Meadow (Eds.), Lan-
young African American children. Topics in guage in mind: Advances in the study of lan-
Language Disorders, 35(1), 61–75. guage and thought (pp. 195–235). Cambridge,
de Villiers, J. G., & de Villiers, P. A. (2003). Lan- MA: MIT Press.
guage for thought: Coming to understand Gleason, J. B., & Ratner, N. B. (2017). The devel-
false beliefs. In D. Gentner & S. Goldin- opment of language (9th ed.). Boston, MA:
Meadow (Eds.), Language in mind: Advances Pearson.
in the study of language and thought (pp. 335– Graham, S., Harris, K. R., & Fink, B. (2000).
384). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Extra handwriting instruction: Prevent writ-
de Zeeuw, M., Schreuder, R., & Verhoeven, L. ing difficulties right from the start. Teaching
(2013). Processing of regular and irregular Exceptional Children, 33, 88–92.
past-tense verb forms in first and second Hale, C. M., & Tager-Flusberg, H. (2003). The
language reading acquisition. Language influence of language on theory of mind:
Learning, 63(4), 740–765. A training study. Developmental Science, 6(3),
Evans, A. D., Stolzenberg, S. N., Lee, K., & 346–359.
Lyon, T. D. (2014). Young children’s diffi- Hlavac, J. (2011). Hesitation and monitoring
culty with indirect speech acts: Implications phenomena in bilingual speech: A conse-
for questioning child witnesses. Behavioral quence of code-switching or a strategy to
Sciences and the Law, 32, 775–788. facilitate its incorporation? Journal of Prag-
Ferry, A. L., Hespos, S. J., & Gentner, D. (2015). matics, 43(15), 3793–3806.
Prelinguistic relational concepts: investiga- Key-DeLyria, S. E., & Altmann, L. J. P. (2016).
tion analogical processing in infants. Child Executive function and ambiguous sen-
Development, 86(3), 1386–1405. tence comprehension. American Journal of
Finestack, L. H. (2014). Language learning of Speech-Language Pathology, 25, 252–267.
children with typical development using a Laing Gillam, S., Hartzheim, D., Studenka, B.,
deductive metalinguistic procedure. Journal Simonsmeir, V., & Gillam, R. (2015). Narrative
of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, intervention for children with autism spec-
57, 509–523. trum disorder. Journal of Speech-Language-
Frith, C. D. (2008). Social cognition. Philo- Hearing Research, 58, 920–933.
sophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Lane, J. D., Wellman, H. M. Olson, S. L.,
Biological Sciences. Retrieved from http:// LaBounty, J., & Kerr, C. R. (2010). Theory of
rstb.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/ mind and emotion understanding predict
363/1499/2033 moral development in early childhood.
Galotti, K. M. (2017). Cognitive development: British Journal of Developmental Psychology,
Infancy through adolescence (5th ed.). Los 28(4), 871–889.
Angeles, CA: Sage. Lanza, J. R., & Flahive, L. K. (2009). LinguiSys-
Gathercole, S. E., & Baddeley, A. (1990). Pho- tems guide to communication milestones. East
nological memory deficits in language dis- Moline, IL: LinguiSystems.
ordered children: Is there a causal connec- Levey, S. (2011). Theories and explanations
tion? Journal of Memory and Language, 29, of language development. In S. Levey &
336–360. S. Polirstok (Eds.), Language development:
30 Introduction to Language Development
Understanding language diversity in the class- Paul, R., Landa, R., & Simmons, E. (2014). As-
room (pp. 17–36). Los Angeles, CA: Sage. sessing and treating communication. In J.
Liszkowski, U., Carpenter, M., & Tomasello, McPartland, A. Klin, & F. Volkmar (Eds.),
M. (2008). Twelve-month-olds communi- Asperger syndrome: Assessing and treating high
cate helpfully and appropriately for knowl- functioning autism spectrum disorder (2nd ed.,
edgeable and ignorant partners. Cognition, pp. 103–142). New York, NY: Guilford Press.
108(3), 732–739. Peterson, C. (2014). Theory of mind understand-
Miller, C. A. (2006). Developmental relation- ing and empathic behavior in children with
ships between language and theory of autism spectrum disorders. International Jour-
mind. American Journal of Speech-Language nal of Developmental Neuroscience, 39, 16–21.
Pathology, 15, 142–154. Proctor-Williams, K., & Fey, M. E. (2007). Recast
Montgomery, J., Magimairaj, B., & Finney, density and acquisition of novel irregular
M. (2010). Working memory and specific past tense verbs. Journal of Speech, Language,
language impairment: An update on the and Hearing Research, 50, 1029–1047.
relation and perspectives on assessment Redmond, S. (2016). Language impairment in
and treatment. American Journal of Speech- the attention deficit/hyperactivity disor-
Language Pathology, 19, 78–94. der context. Journal of Speech, Language, and
Morrison, R. G., Doumas, L. A. A., & Richland, Hearing Research, 59, 133–142.
L. E. (2010). A computational account of Richland, L. E., Chan, T.-K., Morrison, R. G., &
children’s analogical reasoning: Balancing Au, T. K. (2010). Young children’s analogi-
inhibitory control in working memory and cal reasoning across cultures: Similarities
relational representation. Developmental Sci- and differences. Journal of Experimental Child
ence, 1–14. Psychology, 105, 146–153.
Murray, E., McCabe, P., Heard, R., & Ballard, Rickford, J., R., & Rickford, A. E. (1976). Cut
K. J. (2015). Differential diagnosis of chil- eye and suck teeth: African words and ges-
dren with suspected childhood apraxia tures in New World guise. Journal of Ameri-
of speech. Journal of Speech, Language, and can Folklore, 89(353), 294–309.
Hearing Research, 58, 43–60. Rickford, J. R., & Rickford, R. J. (2000). Spoken
National Institute on Deafness and Other soul: The story of Black English. New York,
Communication Disorders. (2011). Specific NY: Wiley & Sons.
language impairment. Retrieved from http:// Roseberry-McKibbin, C., & O’Hanlon, L. (2005).
www.nidcd.nih.gov/health/voice/pages/ Nonbiased assessment of English language
specific-languageimpairment.aspx learners: A tutorial. Communication Disor-
National Institute on Deafness and Other ders Quarterly, 26(3), 178–185.
Communication Disorders. (2015). Specific Ruffman, T., Slade, L., & Crowe, E. (2002). The
language impairment. Retrieved from https:// relationship between children’s and moth-
www.nidcd.nih.gov/health/specific- ers’ mental state language and theory-or-
language-impairment mind understanding. Child Development,
Nielson, M., & Dissanayake, C. (2000). An 73(3), 734–751.
investigation of pretend play, mental state Searle, J. (1983). Intentionality: An essay in the
terms and false belief understanding: In philosophy of mind. New York, NY: Cam-
search of a metarepresentational link. Brit- bridge University Press.
ish Journal of Developmental Psychology, 18, Shipley, K. G., Maddox, M. A., & Driver, J. E.
609–624. (1991). Children’s development or irregular
Paradis, J. (2016). The development of Eng- past tense verb forms. Language, Speech, and
lish as a second language with and with- Hearing Services in Schools, 22, 115–122.
out specific language impairment: Clinical Siu, C. T.-S., & Ho, C. S.-H. (2015). Cross-
implications. Journal of Speech, Language, and language transfer of syntactic skills and read-
Hearing Research, 59, 171–182. ing comprehension among young Cantonese-
1. An Introduction to Language Acquisition 31
English bilingual students. Reading Research Whyte, E. M., Nelson, K. E., & Scherf, K. S.
Quarterly, 50, 313–336. (2014). Idiom, syntax, and advanced theory
Smitherman, G. (2000). Talkin that talk. New of mind abilities in children with autism
York, NY: Routledge. spectrum disorders. Journal of Speech, Lan-
Tannen, D. (1984). The pragmatics of cross- guage, and Hearing Research, 57, 120–130.
cultural communication. Applied Linguis- Willoughby, M. T., Wirth, R. J., & Blair, C. B.
tics, 5(3), 190–195. (2012). Executive function in early child-
Trembath, D., Balandin, S., & Rossi, C. (2005). hood: Longitudinal measurement and
Cross-cultural practice and autism. Journal developmental change. Psychological Assess-
of Intellectual and Developmental Disability, ment, 24(2), 418–431.
30(4), 240–242.
2
An Introduction to Theories
of Language Development
Sandra Levey
Case Study
A child is part of a family that has moved is spoken. Based on one of the theories
to a new country. The first language presented in this chapter, what are some
spoken by this child is Japanese, but now of the methods that can be used to support
the child must enter a school where English this child’s learning a new language?
The theories we review in this chapter ◆ The factors that best support chil-
offer explanations of children’s language dren’s language development
development. These theories also offer
insights into how practitioners might
best provide support for children with Chapter Objectives
language disorders. After you have read
this chapter, you should understand the
following topics: The theories of language acquisition pre-
sented in this chapter can be placed into
◆ The role of innate skills in language four main categories: principles and
acquisition parameters theory, social interaction the-
◆ The role of the environment in ory, cognitive theory, and emergentism.
language acquisition Understanding these theories is essen-
◆ The interaction between innate skills tial, as language development theories
and the environment in language offer approaches that can be used to sup-
development port children with language difficulties.
33
34 Introduction to Language Development
A summary of the main points of these with the brain prewired to provide
theories is presented in Table 2–1. children with the capacity to learn lan-
guage. The term prewired means that
human infants are born with a brain
equipped with the ability to learn lan-
Principles and
guage. This innate brain mechanism is
Parameters Theory termed the language acquisition device
(LAD) (Namy, 2001). The LAD is the part
Chomsky (Berwick & Chomsky, 2016; of the human mind that provides chil-
Chomsky, 1957, 1965) argues that lan- dren with the ability to grasp the basic
guage acquisition is based on an innate structure of a language’s syntax (sentence
(inborn) structure in the human brain, forms).The LAD contains principles and
Theory Description
Principles An innate language acquisition device (LAD) allows children to
and establish grammatical information from spoken language. The
Parameters LAD consists of innate language principles that are common to all
languages (e.g., a noun occurs in all sentences across all languages)
and parameters that can be set for the grammatical rules for a
particular language. Through hypothesis testing, children use
information from spoken language in the child’s environment. Thus,
parameter setting is the process that allows children to produce the
correct grammatical forms for different languages.
Social Social interaction within the environment provides the essential
Interaction information for language development. Language develops through
experience with language as it is used in the environment. Language
information is gained from interaction with peers and adults with
more advanced language skills.
Cognitive Language acquisition emerges through cognitive skills, such as
object permanence (the ability to produce words for entities or things
that are absent). Play is viewed an essential vehicle for language
development. Children form schemas, consisting of psychological
structures that allow children to attach meaning to entities (e.g., living
things), objects, and actions or events in their environment.
Emergentism Language learning is based on the “emergent” effect of cognitive,
social, pragmatic, and attentional factors. Language develops through
pattern-finding for language used across different situations. Patterns
involve regularities, such as the use of the word “more” to obtain
additional items. Children are also viewed as sensitive and alert to the
frequency of words that are used in spoken language. For example,
they become aware of the frequent use of wh-words (e.g., what, where,
why) to form questions.
2. An Introduction to Theories of Language Development 35
parameters that facilitate a child’s lan- verb (SOV) language. The word-order dif-
guage development. ference between these languages is shown
below (Smith, 2012).
◆ Principles are innate language
general rules that include the general John put the book on the table.
principles that apply to all languages,
John-gahon-woteiburu-niokimashi.ta
such as the principle that a sentence
[John book table put].
must contain a subject (e.g., The dog
ate my cookie) and a verb (e.g., The dog Parameter setting provides the language
ate my cookie). learner with the ability to set the correct
◆ Parameters are language-specific rules parameters for that language spoken in
that apply to the specific syntactic the environment (e.g., SVO or SOV).
structure for different languages, In this theory, the basic mechanism
such as the word-order rules that for syntactic development is based on
differ across languages. For example, an operation termed merge (Berwick &
subject-verb-object (SVO) word order Chomsky, 2016). Merge combines two
is a rule for English but not for other syntactic objects (e.g., noun and verb) to
languages, which use different word create a new object (noun + verb), as in the
orders to form sentences. following example.
Parameters can be viewed as switches that I read books: noun + verb + direct
can be turned “on” or “off,” with the lan- object noun
guage spoken in the environment acting I read new books: noun + verb +
as a trigger for these switches. Exposure adjective + noun
to the language spoken in the environ-
ment will allow the child to set the correct In summary, children are born with
parameter (structure) for a specific lan- an innate mechanism that provides them
guage (e.g., SVO or OVS). Both English with the ability to learn the structure (syn-
and Japanese involve different settings tax) of a language. There are innate prin-
for this parameter: English is an SVO lan- ciples that apply to rules that govern all
guage, while Japanese is a subject-object- languages across the world. Parameters
36 Introduction to Language Development
are set by exposure to the sentence struc- and events. One example is learning the
ture of the language spoken in the child’s word “cut.” At first, a child perceives
environment. the word cut when someone is talking
about cutting paper, bread, cake, or hair.
Later, the word cut is heard when some-
one says, He cut class today or They cut
Social Interaction
jobs in our department. Thus, the environ-
Theory ment contains actions and events that
allow children to expand their vocabulary
Social interaction theory is based on knowledge.
the hypothesis that children’s language Social interaction theory is based on
acquisition emerges through interaction the idea that more experienced language
with others and through experience with users play a role in developing higher-
the language used in the external environ- order functions. Vygotsky (1935) used the
ment (Bates, 1976; Bates & MacWhinney, term zone of proximal development to
1982; Piaget, 1954; Vygotsky, 1935). Chil- describe the distance between a child’s
dren possess the desire to interact with actual developmental level (determined
others, and language acquisition and by independent problem solving) and
development emerge from these social his or her level of potential development.
interactions. Within social interaction, The zone of proximal development is the
adults and children with greater knowl- distance between what children can do by
edge provide guidance for children’s themselves (retrospective mental devel-
language acquisition and development. opment) and the concepts or skills that
Language learning takes place with expo- they can learn with assistance from adults
sure to language as more experienced or children with more advanced language
language users label, describe, and dis- skills (prospective mental development).
cuss entities (e.g., people, things, and ani- In this theory, social interaction is the
mals); actions (swimming, drinking, and vehicle that facilitates the development of
cutting); events (parties, football games, language skills for children to reach pro-
and parades); and others’ states of mind spective mental and language develop-
(feelings, beliefs, and knowledge). ment goals. Communicative interaction in
Language emerges within the envi- a social context activates children’s inter-
ronment through play, conversation, nal developmental processes, especially
observation, and experience with the through tasks that demand conscious
use of language in daily activities, such reflection or problem solving (Vygotsky,
as shopping, school, cooking, and play. 1988). Scaffolding is the approach fre-
Children also use these daily activities quently used by adults to support learn-
to develop play schemes that require ing language (Table 2–2). Examples of
language used by more advanced users scaffolds are conversational recasts, used
(e.g., a pretend birthday party, visit to the to add new information to a child’s utter-
doctor, or grocery shopping). Learning ance while preserving the child’s mean-
the meaning of spoken language emerges ing. In the examples shown below, note
as children learn how words/sentences that the adult provides the correct irregu-
are used to represent entities, actions, lar verb form (ate), the auxiliary verb (are),
2. An Introduction to Theories of Language Development 37
the inflectional morpheme (-ing), and the (Cleave et al., 2015). As shown in Table 2–2,
preposition (to). a scaffold may provide syntactic, semantic,
and/or phonological information.
Child I eated In summary, language develops
through social interaction. Within the
Adult You ate
context of social interaction, children gain
Child I go play information from adults and children with
greater knowledge. Scaffolds play a role in
Adult Yes, you are going to play
language development, with more experi-
enced speakers providing correct models
Scaffolds provide an effective ap-
of the child’s intended language goal.
proach to developing children’s language
skills (Cleave, Becker, Curran, Owen Van
Horne, & Fey, 2015). With scaffolds, chil-
dren can learn the correct target form of
Cognitive Theory
words and more complex language struc-
tures. Many studies have shown that the use Cognitive theory is based on the idea
of scaffolds, such as recasts, play a positive that language acquisition and cognition
role in children’s language development are connected (Piaget, 1954). A cognitive
38 Introduction to Language Development
approach to learning and human develop- activities and experiences in a child’s envi-
ment places greater emphasis on mental ronment (e.g., taking care of a baby, shop-
or internal factors than on environmental ping, cooking, going to school, or going to
or external factors (Heo, Han, Koch, & the doctor). Children learn the language
Aydin, 2011). that is used to label these experiences (e.g.,
In children’s early cognitive develop- diapering, paying at checkout, putting your
ment, schemas (psychological structures) coat in the cubby). Children’s play also
allow children to understand, attach supports the development of the language
meaning, and organize knowledge about aspects of social skills, such as turn-taking,
entities they are exposed to in the envi- cooperation with other children in devel-
ronment. A schema can be defined as a oping and interacting in a play scheme,
mental representation of a child’s expe- and learning how to initiate and terminate
riences in the environment, allowing the this interaction (Galotti, 2017).
child to develop the word or words to In summary, innate cognitive abilities
describe these experiences. These mental allow children to learn language gained
representations are internalized or stored through interaction and experience within
in memory for future events. the external environment. Certain cogni-
Schemas develop when a child is first tive skills support language develop-
exposed to a particular entity, such as the ment, such as the ability to form schemas
word dog used to describe this animal. The or concepts (ideas) about how things look
child then forms a schema for the label dog and how things work. Schemas provide
that includes a description (e.g., tail, four- children with the language used to label
legged, and furry). Frequently, children things, actions, and events that they are
use the schema that identifies a dog to exposed to in their environment.
label other entities that share similar char-
acteristics. For example, young children
frequently identify cows, cats, and other
furry and four-legged animals as doggy.
Emergentism
Over time, children learn the correct labels
for these animals, along with other labels Emergentism posits that language devel-
that share similar characteristics. opment emerges from the “emergent”
In Piaget’s (1954) theory, certain cog- effects of social, pragmatic, and cognitive
nitive abilities are viewed to play a role as factors (Bates & MacWhinney, 1982, 1988;
prerequisites for language development. Behrens, 2009; Hirsh-Pasek, Golinkoff, &
For example, object permanence is the Hollich, 1999; Poll, 2011; Seidenberg &
ability to produce words for entities or Elman, 1999).
events that are out of sight. Once children
achieve this cognitive ability, at around ◆ Social skills emerge from children’s
10 months of age, they understand that innate desires to interact with others.
entities (e.g., mommy) and objects (e.g., ◆ Pragmatic skills involve interaction,
ball) exist even when they cannot be seen such as eye contact and appropriate
or heard. Piaget also emphasized the role communication.
of play as essential in learning language ◆ Cognitive skills involve the ability
(Mooney, 2013). Play represents the imita- to remember information, maintain
tion and the use of language that identifies attention to tasks, understand
2. An Introduction to Theories of Language Development 39
ing piece. Developmental Neuropsychology, Smith, M. (2012). Testing the head directional-
16(2), 139–162. ity parameter in L2 Japanese. Retrieved from
Mooney, C. G. (2013). An introduction to Dewey, https://ttu-ir.tdl.org/ttu-ir/handle/2346/
Montessori, Erikson, Piaget, & Vygotsky (2nd 45201
ed.). St. Paul, MN: Redleaf Press. Tomasello, M. (2003). Constructing a language:
Namy, L. L. (2001). Language acquisition A usage-based theory of language acquisition.
device. In A. J. Salkind (Ed.), Child devel- Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
opment: The Macmillan psychology reference Vygotsky, L. S. (1935). Mind in society: The
series (p. 227). New York, NY: Macmillan. development of higher psychological processes.
Piaget, J. (1954). The construction of reality in the Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
child. New York, NY: Basic Books. Vygotsky, L. S. (1988). Inner speech. In M. B.
Poll, G. H. (2011). Increasing the odds: Apply- Franklin & S. S. Barten (Eds.), Child lan-
ing emergentist theory in language interven- guage: A reader (pp. 181–187). New York,
tion. Language, Speech, and Hearing Services NY: Oxford University Press. (Original
in Schools, 42, 580–591. work published 1962)
Seidenberg, M. S., & Elman, J. (1999). Do Wilson, M. S. (2008). Chomsky’s minimalist
infants learn grammar with algebra or sta- program: A linguistic primer. Perspectives,
tistics? Science, 284, 5413. 69–77.
3
The Brain and Cognitive,
Speech, and Language
Development
Denise Cruz and Sandra Levey
Case Study
Sammy is a 3-year-old child who engages upset. He pays attention when the class-
in communicative interaction with other room teacher is reading a story and does
children in his preschool class. He follows not interrupt her storytelling. The other
multiple-step directions (e.g., put away children enjoy playing with him, as he is
your toys, find your place on the rug, and able to think of new play activities. After
choose a book). He can also understand and reading this chapter, you will understand
respond to feedback from his teacher and the role of the brain in communication, in
when he has difficulty sharing toys with the ability to understand and follow verbal
other children. He is also able to understand directions, and in the ability to understand
other children’s emotions when they are others’ feelings, thoughts, and emotions.
45
46 Introduction to Language Development
describe the brain provide an SLP with By 5 years of age, the structure of a child’s
the ability to appropriately interact with brain approximates that of an adult (Mild-
these other professionals. The SLP must ner, 2008).
also have a good understanding of the We have gained a better understand-
neurological systems that relate to speech, ing of the skills of the brain through tech-
language, and cognitive abilities. This nological advances that allow investigators
knowledge provides an SLP with a better to view the activity of the brain while an
understanding of the nervous system and individual is processing information or
the role of the brain in language develop- engaged in different tasks (Booth, Wood,
ment, along with understanding the lan- Lu, Houk, & Bitan, 2007; Brownsett &
guage difficulties associated with disor- Wise, 2010; Buccino et al., 2001; Mottonen,
ders. Given that the brain represents the Jarvelainen, Sams, & Hari, 2004; Watkins
path to the acquisition and development & Paus, 2004; Watkins, Strafella, & Paus,
of speech and language abilities, engag- 2003). The electrophysiological tests that
ing children’s interest and participation in examine language and cognitive process-
tasks is essential so that their brains are ing are presented in Table 3–1. Through
activated for learning. After reading this these methods, we have learned that the
chapter, you should have a basic under- brain is organized into networks that
standing and appreciation of: support speech, language, and cognitive
abilities.
◆ The components and divisions of the One of the methods to measure brain
human nervous system function is real-time functional magnetic
◆ The role of the brain in speech and resonance imaging (rtfMRI). This method
language abilities examines changes in regional cerebral
◆ The role of the brain in cognitive and blood flow to measure oxygen levels in
executive functions the brain. This reveals which areas of the
brain are active in certain cognitive or
language tasks. For example, there was
increased activity and blood flow to the
Skills Associated
frontal regions of the brain when chil-
with the Brain dren were asked questions about a story
character’s state of mind (e.g., what the
Early language development is influ- character thought, felt, desired, or believed)
enced by a child’s environmental experi- (Baron-Cohen et al., 1994). This increased
ences and the stimulation that comes from activity appeared when children were
interaction with language and events in asked to think about someone else’s state
the environment (Levey & West, 2011). of mind (e.g., What is she thinking?), while
Based on a child’s experiences, specific this activity did not appear when asked to
neural pathways develop. Neural path- answer questions regarding simple physi-
ways associated with behaviors that are cal actions (e.g., What is he doing?).
repeated more frequently will be strength- The frontal areas of the brain are
ened and reinforced. Consequently, rich involved in cognitive tasks that require
and frequent interaction plays a positive making decisions, solving problems, and
role in children’s language development. making judgments about others’ men-
3. The Brain and Cognitive, Speech, and Language Development 47
Table 3–1. Electrophysiological Tests that Examine Language and Cognitive Processing
tal states (e.g., what others are thinking, brain to alter or make changes in its struc-
feeling, or expecting). A theory of mind ture when exposed to new information
(TOM) provides children with the ability or new experiences. The brain possesses
to understand others’ mental states. This the ability to reorganize pathways, create
allows the child to interact appropriately new connections, and in some cases even
with others through an understanding of create new neurons in response to these
their internal thoughts, feelings, needs, experiences. The development of the
and intentions. The findings of the rtfMRI brain continues through adolescence and
study show that children’s brains are early adulthood. The changes that occur
more active when they are asked to con- during puberty and adolescence support
sider others’ mental states. the essential skills for executive functions
The human brain makes it possible (e.g., attention, memory, reasoning, logic,
for a child to develop the ability to plan, and problem solving).
organize, and learn. Exposure to new
information and events leads to the abil- Neuro refers to neurons (nerve cells
ity of the brain to reorganize its structure that are the building blocks of the
in response to these experiences. Brain brain and nervous system) and plas-
plasticity, also known as neuroplasticity, ticity refers to the brain’s malleability,
describes the ability of the brain to change defined as the ability to change in
and adapt when an individual is exposed response to new experiences and new
to new experiences (Cherry, 2016). Neu- information.
roplasticity is the lifelong ability of the
48 Introduction to Language Development
The Structure of
labels for these experiences (e.g.,
the Neuron
doggie, music, sweet, perfume, soft),
their vocabulary skills develop. Their
We begin with a discussion of the func- motor skills allow them to engage
tion of the neuron, the basic functional in actions, along with learning the
unit of the nervous system (Webb, 2017). labels for these experiences (e.g.,
Neurons underlie all neural behavior that throw, break, roll).
play a role in speech, language, and hear-
ing abilities (Figure 3–1). A neuron is a
nerve cell that receives and sends electri- Interneurons are a third type of neu-
cal signals within the body, consisting of rons, located in the CNS (brain and spinal
sensory neurons and motor neurons. cord). Interneurons act as a link between
sensory (sensation) and motor (move-
◆ Sensory neurons are nerve cells that ment) neurons. They transmit signals
transmit information to the central through the use of neurotransmitters.
nervous system (the spinal cord or Neurotransmitters are the chemicals that
brain) that includes sensations: sight, allow the transmission of signals from one
hearing, taste, smell, and touch. neuron to the next across a synaptic cleft
◆ Motor neurons transmit “directions” (the space between two neurons).
to muscles for movement. Neurons have three structural com-
ponents: the soma (cell body), an axon,
Sensory neurons provide the ability and a branching complex of dendrites
of children to see, hear, taste, smell, (see Figure 3–1).
and touch things in the environment.
◆ The soma, or cell body, maintains the
When they are provided with the
function of the neuron. The cell body
Figure 3–1. The structure of the neuron, including the cell body (soma), dendrites,
axon, myelin sheath, and axon (terminal buttons). Reproduced with permission from
Getty Images.
3. The Brain and Cognitive, Speech, and Language Development 49
also integrates and transmits informa- structures in the brain that perceive sensa-
tion to other cells. tions (e.g., pain, pressure, sounds, temper-
◆ An axon is the projection of a nerve cell ature). Connections between nerve cells
that conducts impulses from the neuron. transmit sensory and motor information.
◆ A dendrite is a projection of the Some nerve fibers are covered with
neuron that gathers information from a white sheath or cover called myelin,
other neurons and directs that infor- shown in Figure 3–1. Myelin sheaths are
mation to the cell body. critical to neural transmission. Myelin
sheaths allow the rapid transmission of
Dendrites bring information to the an electrical impulse along the myelinated
cell body and axons take information away nerve fiber. For example, transmission of
from the cell body. Information from one the electrical impulse along a myelin-
neuron moves to another neuron across a ated fiber is 50 times faster than along an
synapse or synaptic cleft (Figure 3–2). The unmyelinated fiber (Webb, 2017).
synapse is the structure that allows a neu-
ron to transmit a signal to other neurons.
The signal moves across the synaptic cleft, The Central Nervous
which is the region between two commu-
System and the Peripheral
nicating neurons. The process of nerve
transmission moves from neuron to neu-
Nervous System
ron across the synaptic cleft, leading to the
contraction of a muscle fiber, the secretion The human nervous system consists of
of a gland, or the response of specialized the central nervous system (CNS) and the
peripheral nervous system (PNS). The the body parts to the brain. The brain pro-
CNS consists of the brain and the spinal cesses and interprets the sensory informa-
cord. The function of the CNS is to pro- tion that is received from the spinal cord.
cess information and determine appropri-
ate responses. The PNS consists of nerve
fibers that branch off the spinal cord and The Peripheral Nervous System
extend throughout the body. The PNS is
composed of sensory and motor neurons The PNS comprises portions of the ner-
that gather sensory information (sensa- vous system found outside the brain and
tions such as touch and temperature) and spinal cord. The PNS consists of spinal
to control motor (movement) actions of nerves and cranial nerves. Cranial nerves
the human body. play an important role in speech, lan-
guage, and hearing processes. Cranial
nerves relay information between the
The Central Nervous System brain and body. Spinal nerves transmit
motor and sensory information to and
The CNS consists of the brain and the from the CNS. Sensory nerves transmit
spinal cord, as shown in Figure 3–3. The sensory information (e.g., pain, touch,
nerves that exit the brain transmit sen- temperature) and motor information that
sory or motor information that controls control accurate voluntary movements.
our speech, language, and hearing abili-
ties. The spinal cord consists of nerves
The PNS consists of two parts: the
that innervate (stimulate or send nerve
somatic nervous system and the auto-
impulses to) parts of the body and send
nomic nervous system. The somatic
sensory information (sensations) from
nervous system carries motor (move-
ment) and sensory (e.g., hearing,
touch, sight) information to and from
the CNS. The autonomic nervous
system innervates muscles and
glands for involuntary actions (e.g.,
gland secretions) and is responsible
for the control of visceral functions
(e.g., heart, digestion, respiration).
Table 3–2. Cranial Nerves Associated with Speech and Language Processes
IX. Glossopharyngeal nerve Functions related to the tongue and the pharynx.
Sensory information relative to swallowing.
(soft palate), described in Chapter 1. This bral hemispheres that consist of the right
table also shows the cranial nerves that and the left lobes of the brain. The two
are involved in hearing. cerebral hemispheres are connected by the
corpus callosum that connects the right
and left cerebral hemispheres (Figure 3–4).
The cerebrum is the largest part
The role of the corpus callosum is to allow
of the brain and is covered by the
the transfer of sensory, motor, and cogni-
cerebral cortex. The cerebral cortex is
tive information between hemispheres.
the outer layer of neural tissue that
The right side of the brain contrib-
surrounds the brain.
utes to attention, memory, reasoning, and
problem solving, areas essential to com-
munication (American Speech Language
The Two Hemispheres of Hearing Association, 2007). The role of the
right hemisphere consists of the following
the Cerebrum:
functions (Webb, 2017, p. 196):
Right and Left Lobes
◆ Visual processing allows individuals
The cerebrum is the largest part of the to see and to understand objects,
brain. The cerebrum consists of two cere- space, and entities (e.g., people,
52 Introduction to Language Development
Figure 3–5. Locations and functions of the four primary lobes of the
brain: frontal, temporal, parietal, and occipital. Reproduced with permis-
sion from Getty Images.
Figure 3–6. Broca’s and Wernicke’s areas of the brain are shown, along with
the primary auditory cortex, also known as Heschl’s gyrus. Reproduced with
permission from Getty Images.
The frontal lobe has three divisions, with The Parietal Lobe
each responsible for a particular function:
Positron emission tomography (PET)
◆ Prefrontal: The prefrontal cortex was used to examine the language abili-
covers the front part of the frontal ties associated with the parietal lobe.
lobe. It is responsible for the cogni- Functional neuroimaging results indi-
tive functions of working memory cated extensive parietal activity associ-
and decision making, the executive ated with the sensorimotor control of
functions for generating and carrying writing. This involved the planning, exe-
out action plans, and the modification cution, and monitoring of writing, even if
of plans when considering potential only the forming of a single letter (Brown-
outcomes and past experiences sett & Wise, 2010). The ability to grasp
◆ Premotor: Responsible for planning the visual and spatial aspects of writing
and executing movements (e.g., the formation of letters that create
◆ Motor: Responsible for voluntary words) is provided by the parietal lobe
(deliberate) movement (Glass, 2016).
3. The Brain and Cognitive, Speech, and Language Development 55
Thalamus
T
Hypothalamus
57
58 Introduction to Language Development
The cerebellum plays a role in the perfor- a role in respiration that supports phona-
mance of voluntary actions (actions based tion for speech production. The brainstem
on purpose and intent), such as writing is also involved in basic functions of the
and speech production. The cerebellum body (e.g., breathing, swallowing, heart
is associated with motor control for con- rate, blood pressure, and consciousness).
nected speech efforts (Webb, 2017). For The brainstem consists of the medulla
example, the cerebellum is responsible for oblongata (also called the myelencepha-
the coordination of respiration, articula- lon), the pons, and the midbrain (called the
tion, and the muscles involved with pho- mesencephalon). The roles of these areas in
nation (voice production). speech and language are shown below.
The role of the brainstem is to control mes- While respiration and hearing are
sages between the brain and the rest of the essential components of speech and lan-
body (Figure 3–11). The brainstem plays guage abilities, children must also learn
3. The Brain and Cognitive, Speech, and Language Development 59
◆ The ability to learn that symbols two innate or inborn neurological abilities
represent numerical, spatial, and (Wilson & Foglia, 2011): sensory skills and
conceptual information (e.g., motor skills. The sensory skill of visual
numbers, locations in space, concepts perception allows infants to perceive objects
about time, and other abstract ideas) and events in the environment. The motor
skills allow infants to explore these objects
The cognitive and communicative factors and events as they interact in activities
that are associated with the brain can be within the environment. This is a dynamic
found in Table 3–4. and active process in which infants orga-
nize and develop their cognitive skills
over time, given greater experience with
Embodied Cognition adults, peers, objects, and events in the
environment. These experiences contain
Embodied cognition views children’s the language used to label the object and
cognitive development as depending on actions that are present in the environment
Table 3–4. Cognitive Factors in Communication and Associated Areas of the Brain
(e.g., spill, drink, throw, run, and wipe). The Executive Functions
interaction between sensory and motor
skills provides the essential support for Executive functions consist of attention
language development. and memory, along with the ability to
plan, organize, and learn from prior expe-
riences. For example, children with intact
Mirror Neurons executive functions can learn from prior
errors and can correct these errors when
At 1 to 3 days after birth, infants’ innate reviewing their work or when given new
or inborn sensorimotor skills are demon- assignments within the classroom. Execu-
strated by their perception and physical tive functions are involved in the develop-
imitation of adults’ tongue protrusion and ment of academic skills, such as abstract
mouth opening (Meltzoff & Moore, 1983). thought (drawing conclusions from writ-
What is most interesting is that imitation ten text), the ability to revise plans (to
of the adult’s movements occurs even correct errors), to initiate action (to pre-
though infants are totally unaware of their pare for exams and assignments), to reject
own facial structure or physical move- inappropriate actions (to interact appro-
ment. Cognitive neuroscience explains priately with peers), and to learn from
these early behaviors through the role of past mistakes. Executive functions also
mirror neurons (Jackson, Brunet, Melt- consist of critical thinking skills. Exam-
zoff, & Decety, 2006; Lamm & Majdandžić, ples of executive functions are described
2015). in Table 3–5.
Mirror neurons are a type of neuron
in the brain that fires when individuals
Children who have executive func-
perceive the facial expressions or actions
tion difficulties may be disorganized
of others (e.g., sadness, or yawning).
and forgetful and have poor critical
These neurons provide an inner simu-
thinking skills. Children with execu-
lation or mirror of the actions that we
tive function difficulties may also
observe, allowing the brain to symbolize
be disinhibited (lack the ability to
and understand the actions of others (Riz-
restrain from impulsive actions),
zolatti & Craighero, 2004). Mirror neurons
resulting in inappropriate social
may play a role in interpreting another
behaviors (e.g., interrupting; or
person’s emotions or feelings, laying the
aggressive behavior toward other
foundation for such higher-order social
children).
processes as empathy (sympathy, compas-
sion, and understanding) and a theory of
mind. Theory of mind describes the ability
to understand someone else’s mind and
mental state (e.g., happy, sad, worried).
Summary
Theory of mind is expressed in language by
the use of mental state verbs that describe The case study presented at the begin-
the human mind (e.g., what someone ning of this chapter describes a typically
thinks, knows, or believes). Mirror neu- developing 3-year-old whose behaviors
rons also play an important role in speech suggest intact brain structures and typi-
perception (Eysenck & Keane, 2015). cal development.
62 Introduction to Language Development
63
TPJ
Medial (middle)
temporal gyrus
Figure 3–14. Medial temporal gyrus. Reproduced with permission from Getty Images.
64
3. The Brain and Cognitive, Speech, and Language Development 65
Sammy possesses the ability to take ad- are learned through interaction with oth-
vantage of the sensory information in the ers in the environment. However, the
environment. For example, he is sensitive brain provides the basic ability to develop
to what he sees and hears (e.g., spoken these behaviors.
language, facial expressions, and other To further explain the role of the brain,
input that provides him with information the functions of the brain can be found in
on others’ meaning and feelings). His Figure 3–15. A review of the speech, cogni-
cognitive skills allow him to engage in tive, and language functions of the brain
appropriate interaction with his teacher can be found in Table 3–6.
and peers. In summary, many behaviors
Figure 3–15. The description of the functions of the brain, segregated by the lobes of the brain.
Reproduced with permission from Getty Images.
66 Introduction to Language Development
(2001). Action observation activates pre- & S. Polirstok (Eds.), Language development:
motor and parietal areas in a somatotopic Understanding language diversity in the class-
manner: An fMRI study. European Journal of room (pp. 101–114). Los Angeles, CA: Sage.
Neuroscience, 13, 400–404. Liebenthal, E., Desai, R., Ellingson, M. M.,
Cheng, W., Rolls, E. T., Gu, H., Zhang, J., & Ramachandran, B., Desai, A., & Binder, J.
Feng, J. (2015). Autism: Reduced connectiv- R. (2010). Specialization along the left supe-
ity between cortical areas involved in face rior temporal sulcus for auditory categori-
expression, theory of mind, and the sense of zation. Cerebral Cortex 20, 2958–2970.
self. Brain, 13, 1382–1393. Meltzoff, A. N., & Moore, K. (1983). Newborn
Cherry, K. (2016). What is brain plasticity? Re- infants imitate adult facial gestures. Child
trieved from https://www.verywell.com/ Development, 54(3), 702–709.
what-is-brain-plasticity-2794886?print Mildner, V. (2008). The cognitive neuroscience
Cherry, K. (2017). Left brain vs right brain domi- of human communication. New York, NY:
nance: The surprising truth. Retrieved from Erlbaum.
https://www.verywell.com/left-brain-vs- Mottonen, R., Jarvelainen, J., Sams, M., & Hari,
right-brain-2795005 R. (2004). Viewing speech modulates activ-
De Smet, H. J., Baillieux, H., De Deyn, P. P., ity in the left SI mouth cortex. NeuroImage,
Merien, P., & Paquier, P. (2007). The cere- 24, 731–737.
bellum and language: The story so far. Folia Otti, A., Wohlschlaeger, A. M., & Noll-Hussong,
Phoniatrica et Lagopaedica, 59, 165–170. M. (2015). Is the prefrontal cortex necessary for
Eysenck, M. W., & Keane, M. T. (2015) Cogni- theory of mind? Retrieved from https://www
tive psychology: A student’s handbook. New .scienceexchange.com/publications/9227
York, NY: Psychology Press. Rhodes, M., & Brandone, A. C. (2014). Three-
Gentner, D. (2003). Why we’re so smart. In D. year-olds’ theories of mind in action and
Gentner & S. Goldin-Meadow (Eds.), Lan- words. Original Frontiers in Psychology, 5,
guage in mind: Advances in the study of lan- 1–8.
guage and thought (pp. 195–235). Cambridge, Rizzolatti, G., & Craighero, L. (2004). The mirror-
MA: MIT Press. neuron system. Annual Review of Neurosci-
Glass, A. L. (2016). Cognition: A neuroscience ence, 27, 169–192.
approach. Cambridge, UK: University Print- Skipper, J. I., & Small, S. L. (2006). FMRI studies
ing House. of language. Encyclopedia of Language and Lin-
Hasenkamp, W. (2014). Theory of mind: Con- guistics. Retrieved from http://www.science
templative science begins to unpack the critical direct.com/science/article/pii/B0080448
elements of caring. Retrieved from https:// 542023993
www.mindandlife.org/theory-mind/ Watkins, K. E., & Paus, T. (2004). Modulation
Jackson, P. L., Brunet, E., Meltzoff, A. N., & of motor excitability during speech percep-
Decety, J. (2006). Empathy examined through tion: The role of Broca’s area. Journal of Cog-
the neural mechanisms involved in how nitive Neuroscience, 16(6), 978–987.
I feel versus how you feel pain. Neuropsy- Watkins, K. E., Strafella, A. P., & Paus, T. (2003).
chologia, 44, 752–761. Seeing and hearing speech excites the motor
Kemmerer, D. (2015). Cognitive neuroscience system involved in speech production. Neu-
of language. New York, NY: Psychological ropsychologia, 41, 989–994.
Press. Webb, W. G. (2017). Neurology for the speech-
Lamm, C., & Majdandžić, J. (2015). The role of language pathologist. St. Louis, MO: Elsevier.
shared neural activations, mirror neurons, Wilson, R. A., & Foglia, L. (2011). Embodied
and morality in empathy — a critical com- cognition. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
ment. Neuroscience Research, 90, 15–24. Retrieved from http://philosophysother
Levey, S., & West, J. F. (2011).The role of the .blogspot.com/2011/08/wilson-robert-and-
brain in speech and language. In S. Levey lucia-foglia-embodied.html
4
Infant and Toddler
Language Development
Sandra Levey
Case Study
Aaron is a 4-year-old who produces the in the puddle” (rather than the correct
past tense of some verbs in the following production of “I stood in the puddle”).
manner: “Mommy comed home yesterday” Provide an explanation of why phonology
(rather than the correct production of “He plays a role in these productions of
came home yesterday”) and “I standed irregular past tense verbs.
69
70 Introduction to Language Development
children are exposed to spoken language months of age, showing recognition that
in the environment (Barna & Legerstee, this part of the human face conveys social
2005). Infants are equipped with the information (Carter, Davis, Klin, & Volk-
ability to process information. Process- mar, 2005). At 2 months of age, infants
ing is the mental ability that allows the are able to imitate human facial gestures
infant to be aware of, to perceive, and to (Legerstee, 2000) while not truly aware of
understand spoken language, along with their own faces. At 9 weeks of age, infants
understanding speakers’ ideas and feel- fixate more consistently on an adult’s eyes
ings. Highlights of children’s language when the adult is speaking than when the
development, from birth through age 3, adult is silent (Beier & Spelke, 2012).
are described in Table 4–1. Infants possess the ability to use ges-
tures to communicate with others before
they are able to produce meaningful words.
The term innate refers to abilities
Further language development is based
present in the human brain at birth.
on experience and interaction with peo-
Innate abilities are not acquired or
ple, things, and actions in the environ-
learned through experience after
ment. Communication begins to emerge
birth. Perceptual abilities refer to the
in infancy, when 3-month-olds produce
mechanisms that allow the infant to
speech-like sounds in response to adults’
process and interpret sensory infor-
vocalizations (Gleason & Ratner, 2017).
mation (i.e., what is seen, smelled,
Between 9 and 12 months, children follow
touched, taste, and heard).
the direction of an adult’s gaze, imitate
others’ actions and movements, and use
Soon after birth, infants show a preference gestures to gain adults’ attention and inter-
for animate (living) entities, an ability est (Tomasello, Carpenter, & Liszkowski,
that allows them to detect and recognize 2007). These early behaviors precede lan-
human faces versus objects that do not guage production while demonstrating
resemble human faces (Simion & Di Gior- the early ability to communicate through
gio, 2015). Newborn infants have been gesture and sound production.
shown to process their mother’s faces and By the end of the first year of life,
to store this information in memory for infants understand many spoken words
later recognition (Bushnell, 2001). Infants and produce their first words. By 18 to
focus on a speaker’s eyes as early as 2 24 months, children begin to produce sim-
ple two-word utterances. This marks the
emergence of syntax or sentence forma-
Table 4–1. Infants’ Innate Perceptual Skills tion. By age 3, children produce sentences
that express questions and comments.
Visual perception Sight Children’s language skills mirror those
Auditory perception Hearing of adults by 4 years of age, with the pro-
duction of adult sentence forms (Owens,
Gustatory perception Taste 2016). The process of language acquisition
Olfactory perception Smell is unique to humans because only human
beings can generate or create new words
Somatosensory perception Touch
(texting) and novel utterances, such as
4. Infant and Toddler Language Development 71
the differences in sounds shows that were acting her/himself. Mirror neurons
language-relevant abilities are present at also allow us to receive and interpret facial
an early age, providing the later ability to expressions. Mirror neurons “mirror” the
understand that sounds mark differences things that are sensed or perceived in the
in words (e.g., bad vs. pad). environment, allowing infants to mirror
Children also begin to understand the things they observe (Gruber, 2016).
differences in adults’ facial expressions. This is found in infants’ imitation of
Between 6 and 12 months, infants choose adults’ facial expressions (e.g., frowning,
an object based on an adult’s positive or smiling) and facial movements (e.g., stick-
negative facial expression (Moses, Bald- ing out their tongues). Understanding the
win, Rosicky, & Tidball, 2002), choosing inner mental state of others is proposed to
the object that matches the adult’s posi- depend on the activation of these mirror
tive facial expression. A theory of mind neurons, allowing the infant to perceive
(TOM), described in Chapter 1, provides the inner mental states of others (Acharya
children with the ability to interpret oth- & Shukla, 2012; Keysers, Kaas, & Gazzola,
ers’ facial expressions that reflect their 2010; Lamm & Majdandžić, 2015). These
feelings or thoughts. inner states can consist of surprise, hap-
piness, fear, or other emotional states that
may be reflected in an individual’s face.
A TOM is the ability to interpret or
These mirror neurons may also facilitate
understand another person’s mental
emergence of a TOM, allowing the devel-
state (e.g., happiness, sadness, fear),
opment of the ability to interpret or under-
intent (the goal of carrying out an
stand another’s feelings or thoughts.
action or a plan), beliefs (attitudes or
An interesting aspect of develop-
ideas), desires (goals), or knowledge
ment appears after 7 months of age, when
(information). It is the ability to step
infants exhibit sustained and voluntary
into someone else’s shoes to understand
focus, rather than passive responses to
this person’s mind, thoughts, and
things in the environment (Columbo,
feelings. The early ability to recog-
Kapa, & Curtindale, 2011). At about
nize facial expressions is the sign of a
7 months of age, infants spend a greater
developing, but still primitive, TOM.
amount of time looking at things that
capture their interest (Galotti, 2017). This
Infants have been shown to imitate sustained attention pattern reflects goal-
adults’ facial movements, such as sticking directed attention, an essential skill for
out their tongues. This imitation behav- learning language (Oakes, Kannass, &
ior is interesting, given that infants are Shaddy, 2002). For example, the ability to
not aware of their own faces or tongues. maintain attention allows the infant to fol-
Examination of the role of the brain in low longer examples of spoken language,
infants’ perception has provided an expla- such as a story. By the end of the first year,
nation of infants’ responses to adults’ infants understand many words. Between
facial expressions. The discovery of mir- 7 and 12 months, children recognize words
ror neurons in the brain has led to the for common objects and can understand
theory that these neurons play a role in and respond to simple requests for actions
perception. Mirror neurons “mirror” the (e.g., Find your bunny. Give mommy your
behavior of others, as though the observer cup. Don’t spill your milk).
4. Infant and Toddler Language Development 73
different topics) (Ruston & Schwanenflu- ties (e.g., ball), animate entities (mommy,
gel, 2010). The amount of talk that chil- and doggie), and actions (go and throw).
dren hear from speakers in their environ- One of the characteristics of vocabulary
ments is a predictor of vocabulary size development is that early words are
(Shneidman, Arroyo, Levine, & Goldin- remarkably similar for children across all
Meadow, 2012), while vocabulary growth languages (e.g., the words for book, cookie,
is related to the diversity of words pro- ball, dog, cat, eye, nose, bed, mommy, and
duced by caregivers (Pan, Rowe, Singer, shoes) (Rescorla, Alley, & Christine, 2001,
& Snow, 2005). A study of Spanish-speak- p. 605). These early productions take the
ing children’s vocabulary development form of consonant-vowel (CV) and vowel-
found that more spoken language input consonant (VC) productions with later
at 18 months resulted in larger receptive production of consonant-vowel-conso-
and expressive vocabulary at 24 months nant (CVC) forms.
(Hurtado, Marchman, & Fernald, 2008),
providing evidence that more frequent CV go
and abundant input acts to activate and
VC up
strengthen language learning (Poll, 2011).
Children rely on contextual informa- CVC cup
tion (language produced in the environ-
ment in specific situations) to learn the Children’s early words are not always
meaning and use of new words. For exam- accurate phonemic representations, a
ple, a child may listen to a conversation production that corresponds to the form
about a broken piece of furniture and the consistent with a target word produced
methods required for repair (e.g., broken, fix, by adults. For example, one young child
hammer). In this encounter, the child may attempted to produce the target word baby
learn the vocabulary terms as they apply to with attempts consisting of bih and bihbi,
this context. Later, the child will use these along with the correct phonemic repre-
words to apply to new contexts, such as sentation of the target word baby dur-
conversation about a broken toy (e.g., bro- ing these repeated attempts to produce
ken, fix). Children acquire many new words the target word (Sosa & Stoel-Gammon,
through incidental learning (Akhtar, Jip- 2006). Phonemic representation is variable
son, & Callanan, 2001). In incidental learn- when children begin to combine words to
ing, children learn new words through produce two-word utterances, as in the
exposure to communicative events, such as example of a child’s production I waai for
conversation. This is the opposite of delib- the target utterance I want ice cream. Pho-
erate learning, where children are purpose- nemic representation accuracy increases
fully taught new words. when children acquire 150 to 200 words
(Maekawa & Storkel, 2006).
Two-word utterances, such as push
it and more cookie, appear at about 18
Early Language
months. By 24 to 36 months, children can
Development produce longer utterances as their vocab-
ulary increases (e.g., I want more cookies and
At about 12 months, children begin to pro- milk). By age 3, greater phonemic accuracy
duce words that represent inanimate enti- appears when children use language to
76 Introduction to Language Development
Gaze Occurs when an infant follows the direction and focus of the
following adult’s eye gaze
Social Occurs when an infant identifies the feelings of the adult
referencing toward an object or an event and later uses this information
for his or her own feelings toward the object or event
Imitation Occurs when an infant uses an adult’s actions or words for
his or her own productions or actions
4. Infant and Toddler Language Development 77
language, along with a speaker’s tal state verbs mean (e.g., happy, upset,
ideas and feelings. puzzled). Children learn to understand a
◆ Theory of mind is defined as a child’s speaker’s intent (meaning) when observ-
understanding of others’ thoughts, ing the use of these mental state verbs
feelings, and intentions. in different contexts (Mazzone, 2009). At
age 2, children begin to use terms that label
Working memory stores the active physiological states, emotional states, and
information that has occurred in a cur- desires with terms such as happy and sad.
rent experience (Galotti, 2017), such as The earliest psychological state words
a birthday party or watching a movie. that appear in children’s speech are the
Verbal working memory is the amount following (Bartsch & Wellman, 1995; Lee
of memory a child has when given ver- & Rescorla, 2008).
bal language information or directions
(Newbury, Klee, Stokes, & Moran, 2016). Physiological words: sleepy and
Working memory allows children to think hungry
or talk about these experiences at a later
Desire words: want and need
time. Preschool-aged children might be
able to store three or four pieces of infor- Emotional words: happy and sad
mation (Galotti, 2017), such as go to your
cubby, take out your blanket, and come to the Children’s use of mental state verbs in-
rug. Children’s working memory pro- creases during the third year of language
vides them with the ability to be success- learning, with the use of terms such as
ful in learning. think and know. Know is an early occurring
term, followed by the words think, believe,
and mean (Shatz, Wellman, & Silber, 1983).
Working memory allows the child
to temporarily hold, process, and
manipulate information (e.g., hold
or keep this information in mind, The Development
think about and understand the of Humor
information that has been given, and
think about how to manipulate this
The social environment plays a role in
information or use it in the future).
the development of humor (Hoicka,
2014). Infants begin to laugh at about 3
As discussed earlier, a TOM involves to 4 months of age, indicating an early
understanding a speaker ’s meaning, response to humorous behaviors or events
thoughts, feelings, and emotions, or what (Reddy, 2008). Infants repeat actions that
a speaker intends to do. Children learn elicit adults’ laughter (Reddy, 2001), such
the words that identify a speaker’s inner as making funny faces, playing peek-a-
mental state through conversation, when boo, and making noises and movements
speakers describe their lives and feelings (such as kicking their legs) designed to
using mental state verbs, such as think, elicit a response. In the first year of life, the
know, and believe (Harris, de Rosnay, & response to humor generally involves non-
Pons, 2005). Often, facial expressions give verbal stimuli (e.g., adults use of a squeaky
children a clue about what these men- voice), tactile stimuli (e.g., bouncing
80 Introduction to Language Development
a baby on the adult’s knee or lap), and mas are formed when children first are
other actions frequently performed exposed to an entity. This initial exposure
by adults to elicit children’s laughter allows them to identify the characteristics
(Hoicka, 2014). At about 12 months of of this entity, store these characteristics,
age, children enjoy silly actions, such as and associate a name or label with the
watching someone misuse an item (e.g., entity.
putting a bowl on his head to represent a
hat). Falsehoods consist of using an object
A schema is a cognitive system for
to represent another object (e.g., using a
understanding knowledge about
shoe to be a hat on a head). As early as 15
concepts. Concepts represent things
months of age, children can understand
and living entities, along with the
that falsehoods are meant to be jokes.
relationship these concepts have with
Preschoolers develop more sophisticated
other things, actions, and events.
understanding and use of humor.
solve the problem. Prior to the appearance Pretend play appears at around 12
of representational thought, a child will months of age, when children pretend to
attempt physical means before mentally sleep or to drink from a cup. Play with
considering solutions. We next examine dolls or adventure figures develops after
children’s play, along with the connection age 2, with a child able to use different
between play and children’s language voices in pretend play at about 4 years
development. of age (Galotti, 2017). The correlation
between play and early language devel-
opment involves four factors (Weisberg,
Zosh, Hirsh-Pasek, & Golinkoff, 2013),
The Development of Play shown in Table 4–5.
Children first engage in pretend play
There is a close relationship between pre- by using their own daily activities (e.g.,
tend play and the development of lan- preschool or familiar experienced activi-
guage (Patterson & Westby, 1998), given ties). Next, they engage in pretend play
that symbolic or pretend play and lan- that involves others’ activities, using
guage are dependent on representational dolls and stuffed animals to create play
skills (Orr & Geva, 2015). Representa- schemes that involve playing house,
tional skills appear when a child uses taking care of a baby, going to work, or
items to represent real objects (e.g., toy events that take place at school. Creating
blocks to represent a phone) and when a roles for other children in a play scheme
child uses words to represent things in the reflects decentration, defined as the abil-
world (e.g., the word block to represent a ity to consider multiple aspects of a situa-
toy block). Pretend (symbolic) play dem- tion (e.g., other children’s roles in the play
onstrates the ability to decontextualize scheme and the actions involved in the
(to separate an object from its immediate play scheme). When children use symbols
context). This occurs when a child uses a (e.g., a block to stand for a car, telephone,
block to represent a train or telephone and or loaf of bread), this represents a semi-
uses words to represent a thing, even when otic function. This occurs when a sign (a
the thing (block) is not the thing itself (e.g., word, image, sound, or gesture) is used to
train or telephone). create meaning.
Symbolic The use of props for real objects (e.g., a block for bread
thought or for a telephone)
Social Collaboration among children to create a play scheme
interaction (e.g., going shopping) that also involves creating roles
(e.g., shopper and vendor)
Language input Peer and adult interaction in play involving language use
Engagement Children’s interaction within the play scheme
4. Infant and Toddler Language Development 83
84
4. Infant and Toddler Language Development 85
cultures, parents engage in play with their broken down into smaller parts (e.g., ha
children, while older siblings engage in or at), as this would lead to the loss of the
play in other cultures. Across cultures, meaning of the word hat. Children’s mor-
parents provide varying degrees of sup- phological development is presented in
port and guidance. For example, Italian Table 4–7.
mothers were found to consider play a
child’s activity not requiring the need for
Children’s sentence length is also
adult intervention, while American moth-
expanded by the inclusion of articles
ers take a more active role in their chil-
(e.g., a, an, the), prepositions (in,
dren’s play (Chessa et al., 2012).
on, under), pronouns (I, me, he), and
A study of the beliefs and attitudes
auxiliary verbs (am, is, are).
of Greek and Cypriot parents found play
was valued for their children’s develop-
ment (Shiakou & Belsky, 2013). However,
education was also highly valued, with Morphosyntactic Development
children reported to spend greater time
with academic lessons than play at home. Morphosyntactic development describes
An investigation of New York City immi- the relationship between morphemes and
grant Indo-Caribbean parents’ attitudes sentences, given that children’s sentences
toward play found that 67% of mothers expand when they begin to attach mor-
and 48% of fathers believed that play con- phemes to words. For example, the addi-
tributed to cognitive abilities, social skills, tion of the inflectional morphemes -ed and
and emotional development (Roopnarine -ing to the word walk adds meaning by
& Jin, 2012). indicating that an action has occurred in
In summary, it is important to con- the past (past tense -ed) or that an action is
sider that cultural differences are an im- now occurring and ongoing in the present
portant factor when assessing children’s (present progressive -ing).
play, given the variability in the attitudes
toward and styles of play across cultures. Walk + ed (regular past tense inflec-
It is also important to respect parents’ tional morpheme): walked
goals and cultural beliefs when planning
interventions for children from multilin- Walk + ing (present progressive inflec-
guistic and multicultural backgrounds. tional morpheme): walking
Age of Mastery
Grammatical Morpheme Example (months)
Present progressive verb ending –ing Going, playing 19–28
Preposition in Put in cup 27–30
Preposition on Put on shoes 27–30
Regular plural -s Want blocks 24–33
Past irregular verbs came, fell, went, broke He broke it 25–46
Possessive ’s Mommy’s shoe 26–40
Uncontractible copula (be as main verb) am, He was nice 27–39
is, are, was, were, be, been
Articles a, an, the The boy ran home 28–46
Past regular -ed He walked home 26–48
Third person singular regular -s He walks 26–46
Third person singular irregular has, does He does walk 28–50
Uncontractible auxiliary (be verbs preceding The boy is walking 29–48
another verb)
Contractible copula I’m happy 29–49
Contractible auxiliary I’m jumping 30–50
*Used correctly 90% of the time in obligatory or required contexts.
Source: Reproduced with permission from A First Language: The Early Stages, by Roger Brown. Cam-
bridge, MA: Harvard University Press, Copyright 1973 by the President and Fellows of Harvard College.
I. The production of single-word utterances (e.g., cookie, milk, and juice) expands to
include two-word utterances (more cookie, drink milk, and gimme juice).
II. The appearance of grammatical morphemes (e.g., -ing, plural -s), and prepositions
(in and on). Utterances such as I eating, put shoe on, and see cats are characteristic
of this stage. Children begin to produce additional grammatical morphemes (e.g.,
present progressive -ing, plural -s, possessive ’s, and regular past-tense -ed).
III. Children’s utterance length continues to grow as they produce simple declarative
sentences (That’s my ball), imperatives (Don’t take my ball), Wh- questions (Where’s
my toy?), and simple negative sentences (No wanna go).
IV. Children’s language expands to contain complex constructions. In this stage,
children produce compound sentences (Daddy is working and Mommy is reading)
and complex sentences (That boy, who is in my school, is my friend), with
embedded clauses (e.g., The man, who drives the bus, is nice).
86
4. Infant and Toddler Language Development 87
For example, the word walk is a single tion. African American English (AAE)
morpheme, whereas walked (walk + ed) and is an example of a language that omits
walking (walk + ing) are each composed of redundant (unnecessary) elements, such
two morphemes when an inflectional as omitting the plural when the adjec-
morpheme is added (i.e., -ed and -ing). We tive (three) already signals plurality (e.g.,
calculate MLU by counting the number of three boy). When we omit the redundant
morphemes in each utterance produced, elements, note the differences in MLU
usually assessing at least 50 separate between the first and second exam-
utterances. After counting all morphemes, ples below that illustrate the difference
we divide the number of morphemes by between MAE and AAE.
the number of utterances. For example,
if a child produces 150 morphemes in 50 MAE: I saw three boys = 5 morphemes
utterances, the MLU would be 3.0 (e.g., (I, saw, three, boy, -s)
150 morphemes divided by 50 utterances).
AAE: I saw three boy = 4 morphemes
(I, saw, three, boy)
The method for calculating the
number of morphemes in children’s
utterances involves counting some Given that this may be a rule in certain
two- and three-word phrases as only languages, it is important not to use MAE
a single word, as children do not as the measure of typical or atypical devel-
perceive these two- and three-word opment when working with children who
utterances to consist of multiple speak other languages or dialects. It would
words. For example, they do not be an error to consider morphological dif-
view big bird as a bird that is big. ferences across dialects or languages as
Instead, they view some multiple signs of a disorder. Instead, these are dif-
word names as a single word, such ferences that contribute to the interesting
as Big Bird, Cookie Monster, and New variability across languages and dialects.
York City. The morphological and syntactic dif-
ferences between MAE and AAE speakers
shown in Table 4–9 derive from the many
contributions to AAE from West African
Morphological Differences languages (e.g., Bambara, Ewe, Fanta,
Twi, Mende, Wolof, and Yoruba), along
It is important to understand that lan- with contributions from Native American
guages and dialects differ in morphemes, languages, French, and English. Again, it
so it is only appropriate to use these exam- is important to understand that the dif-
ples of MLU to assess English-speaking ferences found in language dialects and
children. Using Mainstream American English-learning children signal differences
English (MAE) as a model for calculating and not disorders.
the MLU of the speakers of different dia- There are also differences between
lects or languages may incorrectly signal the morphological patterns found in
a disorder. For example, one of the rules native Spanish-speaking children learn-
found in several languages and dialects ing English and native English-speaking
is to omit elements that repeat informa- children (Table 4–10).
Table 4–9. Characteristics of African American English Morphology and Syntax
Omission of “to be” forms, She is a nice lady. She a nice lady.
such as “is, are” They are going to a movie. They going to a movie.
Present tense “is” may be They are having fun. They is having fun.
used regardless of person/ You are a smart man. You is a smart man.
number
Utterances with “to be” You are playing ball. You is playing ball.
may not show person They are having a picnic. They is having a picnic.
number agreement with
past and present forms
Present tense forms of I have been here for 2 I been here for 2 hours.
auxiliary “have” are hours. He done it again.
omitted He has done it again.
Past “was” may be used They were shopping. They was shopping.
regardless of number You were helping me. You was helping me.
and person
Multiple negatives (each We don’t have any more. We don’t have no more.
additional negative form I don’t want any cake. I don’t never want no
adds emphasis to the cake.
I don’t like broccoli.
negative meaning)
I don’t never like broccoli.
“None” may be She doesn’t want any. She don’t want none.
substituted for “any”
88
Table 4–9. continued
“Done” may be combined He fixed the stove. He done fixed the stove.
with a past tense form to She tried to paint it. She done tried to paint it.
indicate that an action was
started and completed
The form “be” may be Today she is working. Today she be working.
used as the main verb We are singing. We be singing.
Future tense “is, are” may She is going to help us. She gonna help us.
be replaced by “gonna” They are going to be there. They gonna be there.
“At” is used at the end of Where is the house? Where is the house at?
“where” questions Where is the store? Where is the store at?
Additional auxiliaries are I might have done it. I might could have done it.
often used
“Does” replaced by “do” She does funny things. She do funny things.
It does make sense. It do make sense.
Source: Reproduced with permission from Roseberry-McKibbin, C. (2014). Examples of Acceptable
Utterances by Speakers of African American English (Table 4.1 on pages 77–78). Oceanside, CA: Aca-
demic Communication Associates.
89
90 Introduction to Language Development
occurs less frequently at around age 2½, the external state refers to that which is
when children’s utterances increase to physical or what you can see. Internal
around three-word lengths (MacWhin- states are characterized by emotions (e.g.,
ney & Snow, 1985; Valian, Hoeffner, & likes, dislikes, or fears), visceral states by
Aubry, 1996). Note that there are lan- bodily status (e.g., hunger, fatigue, thirst),
guages that generally allow for omitting and cognitive states by how the world is
the subject pronoun, as shown in the fol- being processed, thought about, or under-
lowing examples of pro-drop languages stood (e.g., knowing, believing, thinking,
(Italian and Spanish) and non-pro-drop understanding, recognizing, and remem-
languages (English and French). Thus, the bering) (Oosterwijk et al., 2015).
differences shown in Table 4–11 must be
considered when working with multilin-
gual speakers.
Children’s early sentence produc-
Pronoun Acquisition
tions are composed of nouns (dogs, boys,
snow) and verbs (bark, run, falls). Nouns Pronouns first appear at 31 to 34 months
label entities (e.g., people, animals, and of age. There is an association between
things) and verbs label actions (e.g., run, children’s perspective-taking and correct
eat, sleep). There is also a class of verbs pronoun use (Ricard, Girouard, & Deca-
termed mental state verbs (e.g., frighten, rie, 1999). Perspective-taking involves
like, disappoint) that refer to a person’s understanding that the points of view of
mental state. Children’s production of others differ from the child’s own. Thus,
mental state verbs is an indicator of their the correct use of the pronouns you and
ability to understand others’ mental or I requires understanding that perspective
internal states. The term internal or mental (viewpoint) changes, depending on who
state refers to what an individual knows, is speaking at that time. Younger children
thinks, feels, believes, and other types frequently confuse pronouns, producing
of mental activities. The internal mental sentence such as Pick you up (meaning to
state refers to the speaker’s mind, while say, Pick me up).
Table 4–12. Pronouns
Stage Pronoun
Level I I
Level II my, it, me, mine
Level III you, your, she, them
Level IV we, he, they, us, you, him, his, theirs
Level V her, its, our, herself, himself, ourselves,
yourselves, themselves
Source: Reproduced with permission from the American
Speech-Language-Hearing Association, from D. Moore-
head & D. Ingram (1973). The development of base syntax
in normal and linguistically deviant children. Journal of
Speech and Hearing Research, 16, 330–352.
4. Infant and Toddler Language Development 93
Pronouns Take the place of nouns (e.g., I, he, she, we, they)
Auxiliary verbs Used with a main verb to show the verb’s tense or to
form a negative or question (e.g., am, is, are, were, was)
example, it is easier for a child to learn the with: car, ball, teddy bear, and doll. When an
noun cup before understanding run. Learn- adult places a new object within this array
ing verbs requires exposure to actions of toys (a bunny) and asks the child to
and events, along with understanding of “Look at the bunny,” the child will look at
these activities (e.g., Dogs bark). Consider the novel object, the bunny. Children use
the difficulty of distinguishing among the this strategy until about 17 to 22 months
verbs walk, jog, and run. It may be difficult of age (Hansen & Markman, 2009), hold-
for children to distinguish between these ing to the principle that each referent or
actions, whereas apple is relatively easy to thing can only have one name.
identify and remember.
The regular past tense of a verb is Early acquisition: do, can, will, going to
formed by adding -ed (e.g., walked, talked,
voted). Children often overgeneralize the Preschool-age acquisition: have to,
regular verb form (add -ed) to produce an shall, could
irregular verb, as shown in the following
examples of the irregular verb form tar- There are certain verb contrasts that
gets ate, threw, and went. present children with difficulty, such as
ask versus tell (Macaulay, 2006). The verbs
I eated it ask and tell may present difficulty until
children reach school age. At age 3½,
I throwed the ball Micah said that he was going to ask his
I goed there mother that he had hurt his arm.
note that some irregular past tense verbs Watch me go down the hill
do not change in the present tense form Yesterday, I went down the hill
to the past tense form (e.g., I am going to
cut the bread / Yesterday, I cut the bread). Overgeneralization occurs most often
In contrast, other verbs undergo greater with irregular past tense verbs with inter-
change between present and past tense nal vowel change (e.g., take/took) and
forms (e.g., catch / caught). In this case, the final change from /d/ to /t/ (e.g., build/
change consists of the consonant “ch” to built). In this case, children produce the
the consonant “t,” along with the change past tense forms as taked and builded. The
of the vowel “ae” to the vowel “au.” The minimal difference in voicing between
interaction between phonology and irreg- these sounds (e.g., /d/ voiced and /t/
ular verb form production is shown in the unvoiced) may present children with per-
examples in Table 4–14. Children have no ceptual difficulties in noting this change.
difficulty with the production of the no The irregular past tense verbs go/went may
change category (e.g., cut/cut and hit/hit), be produced correctly at 3½ to 4 years of
given that these verbs do not change from age, see/saw at 4 to 4½, and eat/ate by 4½
present to past tense form. to 5. Children may not master the change
from /d/ to /t/ until 9 years of age.
Watch me cut the paper In summary, children’s accuracy
Yesterday, I cut the paper is greater for no change verbs (e.g., hit/
hit). The greatest difficulty appears with
Greater difficulty appears in the verbs change from /d/ to /t/ (e.g., bend/bent,
that require more complex sound changes build/built, and send/sent). These difficul-
from the present to past form changes ties are found in phonological changes in
(e.g., caught, ate, went). some verbs to past tense. Regular verbs
present less difficulty, as the child merely
Watch me catch the ball adds -ed to the root forms walk, talk, and
Yesterday, I caught the ball bake (walked, talked, baked).
Watch me eat the cookie
Yesterday, I ate the cookie
The Development of
Negative, Interrogative,
Table 4–14. The Relationship Between and Imperative
Phonology and Verb Changes Sentence Forms
No change in vowels or cut/cut
consonants Negative Sentence Forms
Internal vowel change of come/came
// to /e/ Children at the one- and two-word utter-
ance stage express three types of negation.
Internal vowel change sweep/swept
with final change from Nonexistence to indicate disappear-
/p/ to /t/
ance: All gone juice
Final consonant change build/built
Rejection to indicate not wanting
from /d/ to /t/
something: No milk
4. Infant and Toddler Language Development 97
First stage Children produce the negative element outside the sentence (No bed).
Second stage Children embed the negative element no (I no want milk) while also
producing the negative form not (That not cookie).
Third stage The negative contractible forms can’t and don’t emerge (I don’t have a
cookie) when MLU reaches 4.0.
98 Introduction to Language Development
was on the cover of a dog manual, asking tal to language development (Göksun,
Is Shanti’s grandfather a dog? Children may Hirsh-Pasek, & Golinkoff, 2009), given
also deny that their mother’s high heels that these terms allow children to express
are shoes, pointing to their own and saying greater meaning.
No, dis shoe. Exposure to spatial relational terms
also acts to facilitate children’s encoding
and mapping of spatial relations in the
Relational Terms world (Loewenstein & Gentner, 2005). For
example, understanding locative relations
Semantic development includes the acqui- allows children to describe the spatial
sition of relational terms. Relational terms relation between objects, such as the cup is
mark the relationship of things. Examples on the table. Children who have acquired
consist of existence (all gone) or recurrence relational terms are also better at notic-
(more). Relational terms also describe tem- ing, using, and maintaining memories of
poral relations (time), physical relations similar relationships in the environment
(descriptions), locative relations (loca- (Loewenstein & Gentner, 2001), such as
tion), and kinship terms (family relations) the use of all gone to refer to entities that
(Table 4–18). have disappeared (e.g., Cookies all gone!).
An investigation of early relational The locational relation terms that
words produced by children from 12 to children learn by 3 years of age are in, on,
20 months showed the production of that and under (Johnston, 1988). Children learn
used to indicate an object of interest, along relational terms that are less complex to
with the relational use of gone to indicate conceptualize, such as big/little, tall/short,
disappearance (Gopnik, 1988). When chil- and high/low, before thick/thin, wide/narrow,
dren are aware that something is absent, and deep/shallow (Owens, 2016). In addi-
they will code the meaning of recurrence, tion, the relational terms in, on, under, and
produced when children have finished all next to are learned in that order, followed
the juice in their cups and ask for more. by the more complex spatial concepts in
Learning relational terms is fundamen- back/in front of, above, and below.
Table 4–19. Semantic Roles: Produced at the One-word Stage of Language Development
word, sentence, or longer utterance. Speech indirect speech acts at about 3 years of age
acts are called acts for two reasons: first, (Bucciarelli, Colle, & Bara, 2003). The pro-
because speech is considered an action or duction of indirect speech acts appears at
act and second, because speech acts can about 30 months, when children acquire
have some sort of action or effect on a lis- the modal auxiliary can, with later pro-
tener. Examples of speech acts are state- duction of the modal auxiliaries will, shall,
ments (I’m hungry), requests (Give me a and could (Wells, 1979).
hug), warnings (Watch out for the crack in
the sidewalk), advice (Take your umbrella
because it looks like rain), commands (Put
on your shoes), and promises (I promise to
Narrative Development
clean my room). To understand a speech
act, the listener must understand the Narrative plays a role in social interaction,
speaker’s intention (meaning or goal). effective communication, and the develop-
There are five speech act categories that ment of literacy skills and is a good pre-
label a speaker’s intent (meaning or goal) dictor of subsequent literacy achievement.
when producing a sentence (Cameron- The sequence of children’s narrative devel-
Faulkner, 2014, p. 39). These speech act opment follows the following stages (Bliss
categories are shown in Table 4–22. & McCabe, 2011), shown in Table 4–23.
Speech acts can be direct (e.g., Pass
the salt) or indirect (e.g., Can you pass the
A narrative can consist of telling a story,
salt?). Note that the indirect speech act has
recounting something that happened
the syntactic form of a question (i.e., Can
in a story, or giving a description of
you . . . ?) but has the intention or mean-
something that has happened.
ing that an action be performed by the
listener (i.e., pass the salt). Indirect speech
acts convey a request in a manner that Vocabulary skills play an essential role in
is more appropriate or polite, given that narrative development, giving children a
the request for action is conveyed in a wide variety of words to describe events.
subtle manner through the use of modal Narrative also becomes more organized
auxiliaries (e.g., can, could, would, should, as children learn connectives, such as and
couldn’t). Children begin to understand then, therefore, however, and nevertheless.
A one-event narrative has only one I played. (when asked what he did in
specific past tense action. school that day)
A leap-frog narrative includes events that I went to the zoo. My brother got popcorn.
are not sequenced appropriately and/ I went on the subway.
or omits major events so that the listener
must infer a logical causal sequence and
any missing events.
A chronological narrative contains a We went to the ball game. I ate a hot dog. It
chronological sequence or listing of was raining. We went inside. I didn’t get wet.
events without much coherence and/
or evaluation; so it sounds like a travel
itinerary.
A classic narrative is complete with I went to the lake house and played Wii. We
information on characters involved, what went bowling and I won three games but
happened, where the event happened, we had to leave ’cause Grampa got tired of
when it happened, and the elements of playing. We went to Tanzy’s for lunch and
cause and effect. had curly fries. I spilled my drink but nobody
got mad. We came back to the lake house and
watched a movie.
Source: Reproduced with permission from Bliss, L. S., & McCabe, A. (2011). Language Development:
Understanding Diversity in the Classroom (p. 213). Los Angeles, CA: Sage Publications.
allows children to internalize this struc- aware of these differences to provide evi-
ture. Once in preschool, this internalized dence-based assessment and intervention.
structure helps them achieve better under- Chinese children’s narratives were found
standing of stories. Children are not able to focus on social engagement, morals,
to produce a complete episode, including and authority themes (Wang & Leicht-
all elements of the narrative structure, man, 2000). Narratives included char-
until age 7 or 8. Internal responses (words acters helping one another and positive
that describe the characters’ feelings) are relationships among characters. American
largely absent in younger children (Apel English-speaking children were found to
& Masterson, 1998). An example of narra- focus on characters’ personal likes and
tive structure is shown in Table 4–24. The dislikes, along with avoidances.
description of a logical sequence of events Some children may produce topic-
appears in children’s narratives by 3 to 5 associating narratives (Bliss & McCabe,
years of age (Owens, 2016). 2011). These narratives are characterized
by relatively lengthy descriptions of sev-
eral situations in one narrative, with situa-
Multicultural Differences tions linked semantically (through mean-
and Narratives ing) rather than chronologically (through
a sequence of events). Some characteris-
There are cultural differences across lan- tics found in Spanish-speaking children’s
guages in children’s narrative production. narratives are broad topic maintenance,
Speech-language pathologists must be conversationally focused narrative, infor-
Setting Introduction of characters, time, Winnie the Pooh looked into his
and place honey pot.
Initiating event Problem His honey pot was empty.
Internal Character’s feelings about the He felt sad — and hungry.
response initiating event
Internal plan Statement about fixing the problem “I should fill my pot again.”
Attempt Action to solve problem He went out to search for more
honey to fill his pot.
Consequence Event or events following the He found a bee’s nest and the
attempt friendly bees said, “We’ll share
our honey with you.”
Resolution or The final state of affairs following Winnie the Pooh said, “Thank
reaction the attempt you” and went home with a full
pot of honey.
Ending A statement ending the story Winnie the Pooh was happy and
he also had made new friends.
4. Infant and Toddler Language Development 109
Accommodation
Summary Adaptation
Assimilation
We have traced the development of chil-
dren’s language, beginning at birth and Auditory perception
continuing to age 3. In this period of Causal cognition
development, children produce their first
words, establish a theory of mind, under- Causality
stand many types of Wh-questions, begin Cognition
to produce narratives, express requests in
a more appropriate and polite manner, and Counterfactual reasoning
engage in more complex play schemes. In Decentration
this chapter, we have learned:
Deferred imitation
◆ What infant perception tells us about Denial
the human mind
Discourse
◆ The role of the theory of mind in
language development Equilibrium
◆ The development of infants’ produc-
Incidental learning
tions, beginning with the babbling
stage Innate
◆ The important role of joint atten-
Instrumental function
tion and joint action in language
development Intention
110 Introduction to Language Development
Intentional Processing
Interaction function Recurrence
Jargon Reduplicated babbling
4. Describe the connection between Bates, E., Marchman, V., Thal, D., Fenson, L.,
play and language in children’s Dale, P., Reznick, . . . Hartung, J. (1994). De-
development. velopmental and stylistic variation in the
composition of early vocabulary. Journal of
5. Explain the production of the Child Language, 21(1), 85–124.
irregular past tense verbs as comed Beier, J. S., & Spelke, E. S. (2012). Infants’
and standed. developing understanding of social gaze.
Child Development, 83(2), 486–496.
Bellugi, U. (1967). The acquisition of negation
(Doctoral dissertation). Cambridge, MA:
References
Harvard University Press.
Bernstein, D. K. (2011). Language development
Acharya, S., & Shukla, S. (2012). Mirror neu- from ages 3 to 5. In S. Levey & S. Polirstok
rons: Enigma of the metaphysical modular (Eds.), Language development: Understanding
brain. Journal of Natural Science, Biology and language diversity in the classroom (pp. 139–
Medicine, 3(2), 118–124. 160). Los Angeles, CA: Sage.
Akhtar, N., Jipson, J., & Callanan, M. A. (2001). Bernstein, D. K., & Levey, S. (2009). Language
Learning words through overhearing. Child development: A review. In D. K. Bernstein
Development, 72, 416–430. & E. Tiegerman-Farber (Eds.), Language and
American Speech-Language-Hearing Asso- communication disorders in children (pp. 28–
ciation. (2009). How does your child hear and 100). Boston, MA: Pearson.
talk? Retrieved from http://www.asha.org/ Berwick, R. C., & Chomsky, N. (2016). Why
public/speech/development/chart.htm only us: Language and evolution. Cambridge,
Anglin, J. M. (1993). Vocabulary development: MA: MIT Press.
A morphological analysis. Monographs of Bever, T. G. (1970). The cognitive basis for lin-
the Society for Research in Child Development, guistic structure. In J. R. Hayes (Ed.), Cog-
58(10, Serial No. 238), 1–165. nition and the development of language. New
Apel, K., & Masterson, J. (1998). Assessment and York, NY: John Wiley.
treatment of narrative skills: What’s the story? Bliss, L. S., & McCabe, A. (2011). Educational
Rockville, MD: American Speech-Language- implications of narrative discourse. In S.
Hearing Association. Levey & S. Polirstok (Eds.), Language devel-
Baddeley, A. (2003). Working memory and lan- opment: Understanding language diversity in
guage: An overview. Journal of Communica- the classroom (pp. 209–226). Los Angeles,
tion Disorders, 36, 189–208. CA: Sage.
Baddeley, A. D., & Larson, J. D. (2007). The Bloom, L. (1991). Language development from
phonological loop unmasked? A comment two to three. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge
on the evidence for a “perceptual-gestural” University Press.
alternative. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Bloom, L., Lightbown, P., & Hood, L. (1978).
Psychology, 60(4), 497–504. Pronominal-nominal variation in child lan-
Barna, J., & Legerstee, M. (2005). Nine- and guage. In L. Bloom (Ed.), Readings in lan-
twelve-month-old infants relate emotions guage development (pp. 231–253). New York,
to people’s actions. Cognition and Emotion, NY: John Wiley & Sons.
19(1), 53–67. Bucciarelli, M., Colle, L., & Bara, B. G. (2003).
Bartsch, K., & Wellman, H. M. (1995). Chil- How children comprehend speech acts and
dren’s talk about the mind. New York, NY: communicative gestures. Journal of Pragmat-
Psychological Corporation. ics, 35, 207–241.
Bates, E., & Elman, J. (1996). Learning redis- Bushnell, I. W. R. (2001). Mother’s face recogni-
covered: A perspective on Saffran, Aslin, & tion in newborn infants: Learning and mem-
Newport. Science, 274, 1849–1850. ory. Infant and Child Development, 10, 67–74.
112 Introduction to Language Development
Bushnell, I. W. R., Sai F., & Mullen J. T. (1989). Feagin, C. (1979). Variation and change in Ala-
Neonatal recognition of mother’s face. Brit- bama English: A sociolinguistic study of the
ish Journal of Developmental Psychology, 7(1), white community. Washington, DC: George-
3–15. town University Press.
Cameron-Faulkner, T. (2014). The develop- Foreman, J. (1999). Syntax of negative inver-
ment of speech acts. In D. Matthews (Ed.), sion in non-standard English. In K. Sha-
Pragmatic development in first language acqui- hin, S. Blake, & E. Sook Kim (Eds.), The
sition (pp. 37–52). Amsterdam and Philadel- Proceedings of the 17th West Coast Conference
phia: John Benjamin. on Formal Linguistics, 205–219. Stanford,
Capone, N. C. (2007). Tapping toddlers’ evolv- CA: Center for the Study of Language and
ing semantic representation via gesture. Information.
Journal of Speech-Language-Hearing Research, Galotti, K. M. (2017). Cognitive development:
50(3), 732–745. Infancy through adolescence (2nd ed.). Los
Carter, A. S., Davis, N. O., Klin, A., & Volkmar, Angeles, CA: Sage.
F. R. (2005). Social development in autism. Ganger, J., & Brent, M. R. (2004). Reexamining
In F. R. Volkmar, R. Paul, A. Klin, & D. the vocabulary spurt. Developmental Psy-
Cohen (Eds.), Handbook of autism and perva- chology, 40(4), 621–632.
sive developmental disorders: Diagnosis, devel- Gleason, J. B., & Bernstein Ratner, N. B. (2017).
opment, neurobiology, and behavior (Vol. 1). The development of language (9th ed.). Boston,
Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons. MA: Pearson.
Chessa, D., Lis, A., Di Riso, D., Delvecchio, E., Gleitman, L. R., & Gleitman, H. (1992). A pic-
Mazzeschi, C., Russ, S. W., & Dillon, J. (2012). ture is worth a thousand words, but that’s
A cross-cultural comparison of pretend play the problem: The role of syntax in vocabu-
in U.S. and Italian children. Journal of Cross- lary acquisition. Current Directions in Psy-
Cultural Psychology, 44(4), 640–656. chological Sciences, 1, 31–35.
Chomsky, N. (1957). Syntactic structures. The Göksun, T., Hirsh-Pasek, K., & Golinkoff,
Hague, Netherlands: Mouton. R. M. (2009). Trading spaces: Carving up
Chomsky, N. (1965). Aspects of the theory of syn- events for learning language. Perspectives
tax. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. on Psychological Science, 5, 33–42.
Clark, E. V. (1981). Lexical innovations: How Gopnik, A. (1988). Three types of early word:
children learn to create new words. In W. The emergence of social words, names and
Deutsch (Ed.), The child’s construction of lan- cognitive-relational words in the one-word
guage (pp. 299–328). London, UK: Academic stage and their relation to cognitive devel-
Press. opment. First Language, 8, 49–69.
Columbo, J., Kapa, L., & Curtindale, L. (2011). Gopnik, A., Meltzoff, A. N., & Kuhl, P. K.
Varieties of attention in infancy. In L. M. (1999). The scientist in the crib: What early
Oakes, C. H. Cashon, M. Casasola, & D. H. learning tells us about the mind. New York,
Rakison (Eds.), Infant perception and cogni- NY: Harper.
tion: Recent advances, emerging theories, and Gopnik, A., Sobel, D. M., Schulz, L. E., & Gly-
future directions (pp. 3–26). New York, NY: mour, C. (2001). Causal learning mecha-
Oxford University Press. nisms in very young children: Two-, three-,
Elkind, D. (1962). Children’s conceptions of and four-year-olds infer causal relations
brother and sister: Piaget replication study from patterns of variation and covariation.
V. Journal of Child Language, 6, 313–327. Developmental Psychology, 37,620–629.
Feagans, L. (1980). Children’s understanding Gopnik, A., & Walker, C. A. (2013). Consider-
of some temporal terms denoting order, ing counterfactuals: The relations between
duration, and simultaneity. Journal of Psy- causal learning and pretend play. American
cholinguistic Research, 9(1), 41–57. Journal of Play, 6(1), 15–28.
4. Infant and Toddler Language Development 113
Green, L. (2002). African American English: James, S. L. (1990). Normal language acquisition.
A linguistic introduction. New York, NY: Boston, MA: Allyn & Bacon.
Cambridge University Press. Johnston, J. R. (1988). Children’s verbal rep-
Gross, M., Buac, M., & Kaushanskaya, M. resentation of spatial location. In J. Stiles-
(2014). Conceptual scoring of receptive and Davis, M. Kritchevsky, & U. Bellugi (Eds.),
expressive vocabulary measures in simul- Spatial cognition: Brain bases and development
taneous and sequential bilingual children. (pp. 195–206). Hillsdale: NJ: Erlbaum.
American Journal of Speech-Language Pathol- Jusczyk, P. W. (1992). Developing phonologi-
ogy, 23, 574–586. cal categories from the speech signal. In C.
Gruber, D. R. (2016). The extent of engagement, A. Ferguson, L. Menn, & C. Stoel-Gammon
the means of invention: Measuring debate (Eds.), Phonological development: Models,
about mirror neurons in the humanities and research, implications (pp. 17–64). Timonium,
social sciences. Journal of Science Communi- MD: York Press.
cation, 15(2), 2–17. Keysers, C., Kaas, J. H., & Gazzola, V. (2010).
Halliday, M. A. K. (1975). Learning how to mean: Somatosensation in social perception. Nature
Explorations in the development of language. Reviews Neuroscience, 11(6), 417–428.
New York, NY: Elsevier. Klima, E., & Bellugi, U. (1966). Syntactic regu-
Hansen, M. B., & Markman, E. M. (2009). Chil- larities in the speech of children. In J. Lyons
dren’s use of mutual exclusivity to learn & R. Wales (Eds.), Psycholinguistic papers
labels for parts of objects. Developmental (pp. 183–208). Edinburgh, UK: Edinburgh
Psychology, 45(2), 592–596. University Press.
Harris, P. L., de Rosnay, M., & Pons, F. (2005). Labov, W. (1972). Negative attraction and
Language and children’s understanding of negative concord in English grammar. Lan-
mental states. Current Directions in Psycho- guage, 48, 773–818.
logical Sciences, 14(2), 69–73. Lamm, C.,& Majdandžić, J. (2015). The role of
Hillenbrand, J. (1983). Perceptual organiza- shared neural activations, mirror neurons,
tion of speech sounds by infants. Journal of and morality in empathy — a critical com-
Speech and Hearing Research, 26, 268–282. ment. Neuroscience Research, 90, 15–24.
Hoicka, E. (2014). Pragmatic development of Leahy, M. M. (2004). Therapy talk: analyzing
humor. In D. Matthews (Ed.), Pragmatic therapeutic discourse. Language, Speech, and
development in first language acquisition (pp. Hearing Services in Schools, 35, 70–81.
219–238). Amsterdam, Netherlands: John Lee, E. C., & Rescorla, L. (2008). The use of
Benjamin. psychological state words by late talkers at
Hudson, J. A. (2006). The development of future ages 3, 4, and 5 years. Applied Psycholinguis-
time concepts through mother-child conver- tics, 29(1), 21–39.
sation. Merrill-Palmer Quarterly, 52(1), 70–95. Legerstee, M. (2000). Domain specificity and
Hurtado, N., Marchman, V. A., & Fernald, A. the epistemic triangle: The development
(2008). Does input influence uptake? Links of the concept of animacy in infancy. In F.
between maternal talk, processing speed Lacerda, C. von Hofsten, & M. Heinemann
and vocabulary size in Spanish-learning (Eds.), Emerging cognitive abilities in early
children. Developmental Science, 11(6), 31–39. infancy (pp. 193–212). Mahwah, NJ: Law-
Hwa-Froelich, D. A. (2004). Play assessment rence Erlbaum Associates.
for children from culturally and linguisti- Legerstee, M., Anderson, D., & Schaffer, A.
cally diverse backgrounds. Perspectives on (1998). Five- and eight-month-old infants rec-
Language, Learning and Education and on ognize their faces and voices as familiar and
Communication Disorders and Sciences in Cul- social stimuli. Child Development, 69, 37–50.
turally and Linguistically Diverse Populations, Leonard, L. B., Deevy, P., Wong, A. M.-Y., Stokes,
11(2), 6–10. S. F., & Fletcher, P. (2007). Modal verbs with
114 Introduction to Language Development
and without tense: A study of English- and of Japanese children’s personal narratives.
Cantonese-speaking children with specific Language in Society, 20(4), 577–599.
language impairment. International Journal Moorehead, D., & Ingram, D. (1973). The
of Language and Communication Disorders, development of base syntax in normal and
42(2): 209–228. linguistically deviant children. Journal of
Levey, S. (2011).Typical and atypical language Speech and Hearing Research, 16, 330–352.
development. In S. Levey & S. Polirstok Moses, L. J., Baldwin, D. A., Rosicky, J. G., &
(Eds.), Language development: Understanding Tidball, G. (2002). Evidence for referential
language diversity in the classroom (pp. 37– understanding in the emotions domain at
58). Los Angeles, CA: Sage. twelve and eighteen months. Child Develop-
Levey, S., & Schwartz, R. G. (2002). Syllable ment, 3, 718–735.
omission by two-year-old children. Commu- Newbury, J., Klee, T., Stokes, S. F., & Moran, C.
nication Disorders Quarterly, 23(4), 169–177. (2016). Interrelationships between working
Li, J., Hestenes, L. L., & Wang, Y. C. (2016). memory, processing speech, and language
Links between preschool children’s social development in the age range 2 to 4 years.
skills and observed pretend play in outdoor Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing
child environments. Early Education Journal, Research, 59(5), 1146–1158.
44(1), 61–68. Oakes, L. M., Kannass, K. N., & Shaddy, D. J.
Loewenstein, G., & Gentner, D. (2001). Spatial (2002). Developmental changes in endoge-
mapping in preschoolers: Close compari- nous control of attention: The role of target
sons facilitate far mappings. Journal of Cog- familiarity on infants’ distraction latency.
nition and Development, 2, 189–219. Child Development, 73(6), 1644–1655.
Loewenstein, G., & Gentner, D. (2005). Rela- Oller, D. K. (1980).The emergence of the sounds
tional language and the development of of speech in infancy. In G. Yeni-Komshian, J.
relational mapping. Cognitive Psychology, F. Kavanagh, & C. A. Ferguson (Eds.), Child
50, 315–353. phonology: Production (Vol. 1, pp. 93–112).
Lund, N., & Duchan, J. (1993). Assessing chil- New York, NY: Academic Press.
dren’s language in naturalistic contexts (3rd Oosterwijk, S., Mackey, S., Wilson-Mendenhall,
ed.). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall. C., Winkielman, P., & Paulus, M. P. (2015).
Macaulay, R. (2006). Language and its uses (2nd Concepts in context: Processing mental state
ed.). New York, NY: Oxford Press. concepts with internal or external focus
MacWhinney, B., & Snow, C. (1985). The child involves different neural systems. Social
language data exchange system. Journal of Neuroscience Journal, 10(3), 294–307.
Child Language, 12, 271–295. Orr, E., & Geva, R. (2015), Symbolic play and
Maekawa, J., & Storkel, H. L. (2006). Individual language development. Infant Behavior and
differences in the influence of phonological Development, 38, 147–161.
characteristics on expressive vocabulary Osman, H., & Sullivan, J. R. (2014). Children’s
development by young children. Journal of auditory working memory performance in
Child Language, 33, 439–459. degraded listening conditions. Journal of
Mandel, D. R., Jusczyk, P. W., & Pisoni, D. B. Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 57,
(1995). Infants’ recognition of the sound 1503–1511.
patterns of their own names. Psychological Owens, R. E. (2012). Language development: An
Sciences, 6, 315–318. introduction (8th ed.). Boston, MA: Pearson.
Mazzone, M. (2009). Pragmatics and cogni- Owens, R. E. (2016). Language development: An
tion: Intentions and pattern recognition in introduction (9th ed.). Boston, MA: Pearson.
context. International Review of Pragmatics, Pan, B. A., Rowe, M. L., Singer, J. D., & Snow,
1, 321–347. C. E. (2005). Maternal correlates of growth in
Minami, M., & McCabe, A. Haiku as a dis- toddler vocabulary production in low-income
course regulation device: A stanza analysis families. Child Development, 76(4), 763–782.
4. Infant and Toddler Language Development 115
Patten, E., Belardi, K., Baranek, G. T., Watson, learning. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge Uni-
L. R., Labban, J. D., & Kimbrough Oller, D. versity Press.
(2014). Vocal patterns in infants with autism Roopnarine, J. L., & Jin, B. (2012). Indo Carib-
spectrum disorder: Canonical babbling bean immigrant beliefs about play and its
status and vocalization frequency. Jour- impact on early academic performance.
nal of Autism and Developmental Disorders. American Journal of Play, 4(4), 441–463.
Retrieved from http://libres.uncg.edu/ir/ Roseberry-McKibbin, C. (2014). Multicultural
uncg/f/J_Labban_Vocal_2014.pdf students with special language needs: Practi-
Patterson, J. L., & Westby, C. E. (1998). The cal strategies for assessment and intervention.
development of play. In W. O. Haynes & Oceanside, CA: Academic Communication
B. B. Shulman (Eds.), Communication devel- Associates.
opment: Foundations, processes, and clinical Ruston, H. P., & Schwanenflugel, P. J. (2010).
applications (pp. 135–163). Baltimore, MD: Effects of a conversation on the expressive
Williams and Wilkins. vocabulary development of prekindergar-
Peccei, J. S. (1999). Child language (2nd ed.). ten children. Language, Speech, and Hearing
London, UK: Routledge. Services in Schools, 41, 303–313.
Perner, J. (1991). Understanding the represen- Sai, F. Z. (2005). The role of the mother’s voice
tational mind. Cambridge, MA: Bradford in developing mother’s face preference:
Books/MIT Press. Evidence for intermodal perception at birth.
Phillips, A. T., Wellman. H. M., & Spelke, E. S. Infant and Child Development, 14, 29–50.
(2002). Infants’ ability to connect gaze and Seidenberg, M. S., & Elman, J. (1999). Do
emotional expression to intentional action. infants learn grammar with algebra or sta-
Cognition, 85, 53–78. tistics? Science, 284, 5413.
Piaget, J. (1928). Judgment and reasoning in the Searle, J. (1983). Intentionality: An essay in the
child. London, UK: Routledge and Kegan philosophy of mind (Vol. 9). Cambridge, UK:
Paul. Cambridge University Press.
Piaget, J. (1954). The construction of reality in the Seymour, H. N., & Roeper, T. (1999). Grammat-
child. New York, NY: Basic Books. ical acquisition of African American Eng-
Piaget, J. (1973). The child and reality: Problems of lish. In L. B. Leonard & O. L. Taylor (Eds.),
genetic psychology. New York, NY: Grossman. Language acquisition across North America:
Poll, G. H. (2011). Increasing the odds: Apply- Cross-cultural and cross-linguistic perspectives
ing emergentist theory in language acquisi- (pp. 109–152). San Diego, CA: Singular.
tion. Language, Speech, and Hearing Services Shaddy, D. J., & Colombo, J. (2004). Develop-
in Schools, 42, 680–591. mental changes in infant attention to dynamic
Reddy, V. (2001). Infant clowns: The inter- and static stimuli. Infancy, 3, 355–365.
personal creation of humour in infancy. Shatz, M., Wellman, H. M., & Silber, S. (1983).
Enfance, 53(3), 247–256. The acquisition of mental verbs: A system-
Reddy, V. (2008). How infants know minds. Cam- atic investigation of the first reference to
bridge, MA: Harvard University Press. mental state. Cognition, 14, 301–321.
Rescorla, L., Alley, A., & Christine, J. B. (2001). Shiakou, M., & Belsky, J. (2013). Exploring par-
Word frequencies in toddlers’ lexicons. Jour- ent attitudes toward children’s play and
nal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, learning in Cyprus. Journal of Research in
44, 598–609. Childhood Education, 25, 17–30.
Ricard, M., Girouard, P. C., & Decarie, T. G. Shipley, K. G., Maddox, M. A., & Driver, J. E.
(1999). Personal pronouns and perspective (1991) Children’s development of irregular
taking in toddlers. Journal of Child Language, past tense forms. Language, Speech and Hear-
26(3), 687–697. ing Services in Schools, 22, 115–122.
Richards, B. (1990). Language development and Shneidman, L. A., Arroyo, M. E., Levine, S. C.,
language differences: A study of auxiliary verb & Goldin-Meadow, S. (2012). What counts
116 Introduction to Language Development
as effective input for word learning? Journal jects: Evidence of processing limitations.
of Child Language, 10, 1–15. Developmental Psychology, 32(1), 153–164.
Simion, F., & Di Giorgio, E. (2015). Face percep- Vandermaas-Peeler, M. (2002). Cultural varia-
tion and processing in early infancy: Inborn tions in parental support of children’s
predispositions and development changes. play. Online Readings in Psychology and Cul-
Frontiers in Psychology, 6 (969), 1–11. ture, 6(1). http://dx.doi.org/10.9707/23
Sosa, A. V., & Stoel-Gammon, C. (2006). Pat- 07-0919.1054
terns of intraword phonological variability Wang, Q., & Leichtman, M. D. (2000). Same
during the second year of life. Journal of beginnings, different stories: A comparison
Child Language, 33, 31–50. of American and Chinese children’s narra-
Stein, N., & Glenn, C. (1979). An analysis of tives. Child Development, 71, 1329–1346.
story comprehension in elementary school Weisberg, D., Zosh, J., Hirsh-Pasek, K., &
children. In R. D. Freedle (Ed.), Advances in Golinkoff, R. M. (2013). Talking it up: Play,
discourse processes: New directions in discourse language development and the role of adult
processing (Vol. 2, pp. 53–119). Norwood, NJ: support. American Journal of Play, 6, 39–54.
Ablex. Wells, C. (1979). Learning and using the auxil-
Sternberg, R. J., Nokes, C., Wenzel Geissler, iary verb in English. In V. Lee (Ed.), Language
P., Prince, R., Okatcha, F., Bundy, D. A., & development. Beckenham, UK: Croom Helm.
Grigorenko, E. L. (2001). The relationship Westby, C. E. (1980). Assessment of cognitive
between academic and practical intelli- and language abilities through play. Lan-
gence: A case study in Kenya. Intelligence, guage, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools,
29, 401–418. 11, 154–168.
Talmy, L. (1983). How language structures White-Sustaita, J. (2010). Reconsidering the
space. In H. L. Pick & L. P. Acredolo (Eds.), syntax of non-canonical negative inver-
Spatial orientation; Theory, research, and appli- sion. English Language and Linguistics, 14,
cation (pp. 225–282). New York: Plenum 429–455.
Press. Wilkinson, N., Paikan, A., Gredebäck, G., Rea,
Tomasello, M. (1992). First verbs: A case study F., & Metta, G. (2014). Staring us in the face?
of early grammatical development. Cambridge, An embodied theory of innate face prefer-
UK: Cambridge University Press. ence. Developmental Science, 17(6), 808–825.
Tomasello, M. (1998). Reference: Intending Witt, B. (1998). Cognition and the cognitive-
that others jointly attend. Pragmatics and language relationship. In W. O. Haynes &
Cognition, 6, 219–243. B. B. Shulman (Eds.), Communication devel-
Tomasello, M. (2003). Constructing a language. opment: Foundations, processes, and clinical
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. applications (pp. 101–133). Baltimore, MD:
Tomasello, M., Carpenter, M., & Liszkowski, U. Williams and Wilkins.
(2007). A new look at infant pointing. Child Wolfram, W., & Christian, D. (1976). Appa-
Development, 78(3), 705–722. lachian Speech. Arlington, VA: Center for
Tomasello, M., & Todd, J. (1983). Joint attention Applied Linguistics.
and lexical acquisition style. First Language, Zanuttini, R. (2014). Our language prejudices
4, 197–212. don’t make no sense. Retrieved from https://
Valian, V., Hoeffner, J., & Aubry, S. (1996). psmag.com/our-language-prejudices-don-
Young children’s imitation of sentence sub- t-make-no-sense-85f224844bca#.1ve3w4pig
4. Infant and Toddler Language Development 117
Appendix 4–A
Highlights of Children’s Language Development
continues
118 Introduction to Language Development
Source: Reproduced with permission from How does your child hear and talk? Available from the
website of the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association: http://www/asha.org/public/
speech/development/chart.htm. All rights reserved.
5
Preschool Language
Development
Diana Almodovar and Sandra Levey
Case Study
José is 3 years of age and enrolled in a play with peers, such as asking if he can
preschool class. He produces lengthy share a toy rather than crying or grab-
sentences and is able to understand and bing. After reading this chapter, you
remember lengthy directions (e.g., go into will understand the changes that occur
the garage, get the broom, and give it to when children enter the preschool stage of
grandpa). He also engages in appropriate language development.
119
120 Introduction to Language Development
their syntax, their connected speech is ideas in the mind that explain the world
intelligible, and they can maintain conver- (Goswami, 2009). Concepts allow children
sations for longer periods of time. Their to represent information in an efficient
play becomes more complex, with more manner by grouping information under
elaborate imaginative and dramatic play general categories (e.g., cat, tail, legs, fur).
evident. Their overall social, language, Concepts are organized in the following
and play skills reflect their advanced hierarchy:
stages of cognitive development. Dur-
ing this stage, children begin to develop Subordinate level: German Shepherd
the requisite skills for academic success,
Basic level: dog
such as reading and writing. We begin
with a review of preschoolers’ cognitive Superordinate level: mammal
development.
The subordinate level is the most specific,
however, preschoolers tend to learn basic
level terms before superordinate or sub-
Cognitive Development ordinate (Galotti, 2017). Children who
develop an interest in a particular area,
One of the most important cognitive such as dinosaurs, are more likely to learn
developments in the preschool years is the higher-level terms that refer to this
the emergence of symbolic thought. Sym- interest (e.g., Brachiosaurus, Tyrannosaurus,
bolic thought is the ability to mentally and Diplodocus).
represent objects, actions, and events.
Children’s symbolic thought is applied
in play. For example, children may use Theory of Mind
a wooden block to represent many other
objects (e.g., a baby bottle, a telephone, or One of the most important components of
a loaf of bread). Children express sym- cognitive development is the acquisition
bolic thought when they engage in pre- of a theory of mind (TOM), introduced
tend play and model the actions of adults in Chapter 1. TOM describes a child’s abil-
when creating a play scheme. In this play ity to understand someone else’s mental
scheme, they may take on the role of these state (Rhodes & Brandone, 2014). When
adults, while imitating the actions that children acquire a TOM, they have a bet-
they have observed in their environment ter understanding of others’ thoughts,
(e.g., caring for a baby, shopping). beliefs, and feelings (Baron-Cohen, 1993,
1996; Wellman, 2014). A TOM provides
the ability to predict how someone will
Conceptual Development act and to explain why a person acted in
a certain manner. Children also are able
Conceptual development consists of men- to describe the motivation that supports
tal representations of things in the world. people’s actions using mental state verbs
Concepts consist of properties (e.g., happi- (e.g., think, know, feel, and believe). Growth
ness, color, hunger) or abstract ideas (e.g., in the use of mental state verbs occurs
truth or, fairness). Concepts are sets of between the ages of 3 and 5.
5. Preschool Language Development 121
Children with a TOM are able to presence of a TOM. Children can solve this
express their own feelings and thoughts type of false belief task by age 5 (Rhodes
while also able to interpret those of oth- & Brandone, 2014). The absence of a TOM
ers. This leads to improved interaction is shown if a child reports that Sally will
and conversation with peers and others look for her marble in the box.
because children are better able to under-
stand others’ intentions or meaning dur-
ing these events. TOM is also essential for Executive Functions
understanding stories because children
are able to then understand a character’s Executive functions are another cognitive
actions (e.g., why the wolf dressed as Little factor that plays a role in children’s devel-
Red Riding Hood’s grandmother). Narra- opment. Executive functions are mental
tive knowledge helps children develop processes that include planning, gener-
a TOM because stories often contain ating goal-directed behavior, organizing,
information about a character’s feelings, maintaining attention, using working
beliefs, and thoughts, along with the lan- memory, managing time and space, and
guage associated with these concepts (e.g., problem solving. Without executive func-
Little Red Riding Hood was afraid because tions, strategic problem-solving skills are
she didn’t know . . . the bears were upset absent (Baddeley, 1997, 2003; Baddeley &
because they thought . . . ). Larson, 2007). Strategic problem-solving
Conversation also plays a role in skills consist of identifying a problem,
developing a TOM, given that adults fre- planning a solution, executing a plan, and
quently converse about others’ beliefs and evaluating the results. At the preschool
mental states, along with possible expla- stage of cognitive development, children
nations for others’ actions. Children also may not consider all aspects of a problem
develop an understanding of false beliefs when planning a solution (Galotti, 2017).
when exposed to conversations about
others’ mental states (Gola, 2012). A false
belief is a misconception about some- Working Memory
thing that results from poor reasoning.
An example of a false belief task that has Working memory, described in earlier
been used to assess the presence of a TOM chapters, allows children to retain infor-
is presented below. mation for processing and facilitates the
temporary maintenance and manipula-
A child, Sally, leaves a marble in her tion of information. Working memory
basket and goes outside to play. While allows children to store information in
she is playing outside, another child, their minds to make this information avail-
Anne, moves the marble from the bas- able for processing in long-term memory.
ket to a box. Anne is asked, when Sally Consequently, children with intact work-
comes back, where will she look for ing memory are able to retain lengthier
her marble? directions and remember past events.
The ability to consider stored informa-
If children report that Sally will look for tion allows children to anticipate what
her marble in her basket, this indicates the might happen in the future, especially
122 Introduction to Language Development
when there are similarities between cur- food will taste good if eaten with a pink
rent and prior experiences. Anticipation spoon) (Ryan, 2017). At age 3, children
denotes the ability to predict the occur- still practice magical thinking and may
rence of an event, because it is preceded take adult comments literally, such as an
by a particular cause. An example is that adult saying, Your nose is running. A child
a juice cup may spill if placed too close may interpret this in a concrete man-
to the end of the table. Subsequently, chil- ner and say the following: My nose can’t
dren are now able to predict what might run because it doesn’t have any legs. Chil-
happen next in current or future situations. dren begin to understand the difference
between fantasy and reality as they move
through the preschool period, but some
Divergent Thought fantasy continues to age 7 or 8, such as the
belief in the existence of mythical figures
Cognitive development also includes (e.g., Superman).
divergent thinking. Divergent thought
is essential for creative thought and prob-
lem solving, allowing children to gener- Expanded Symbolic Play Skills
ate a number of solutions to a particular
dilemma. For example, when one child Children’s growing cognitive skills also
wants to take another child’s toy (a fre- appear in expanded symbolic play. Sym-
quent occurrence in children’s experi- bolic play emerges when children use
ences), this ability allows children to objects to represent other things (e.g.,
think of an appropriate response, rather a box to represent a train) and use lan-
than a physical tug-of-war over the toy. guage to describe the activities associated
Divergent thinking is essential for chil- with the play scheme (e.g., Let’s all get on
dren’s imaginative thought (Addis, Pan, the train). Play skills expand at about 30
Musicaro, & Schacter, 2016). This allows months, when children’s cognitive skills
children to develop pretend play schemes play a role in terms of insight, flexibility,
that rely on their imagination. and divergent thinking (Wallace & Russ,
2015). These skills are essential to create
pretend play schemes and to take on vari-
Magical Thinking ous roles in these schemes (e.g., mother,
father, baby, doctor).
During the preschool stage of develop- Multischeme play sequences appear
ment, we see that children engage in mag- at about 3 years of age, when children
ical thinking (Subbotsky, 2010). Magical expand single scheme play (e.g., making a
thinking occurs when a child assigns ani- cake for a doll) to create a series of events
macy to certain inanimate objects (e.g., the (e.g., getting the ingredients to make a
belief that a child’s favorite TV character cake for the doll’s birthday party, making
actually lives in the television set). Learn- the cake, serving the cake, cleaning up,
ing to distinguish between fantasy and and putting the doll to bed for the night).
reality is an element of cognitive devel- Another change occurs at around 3 to 3½,
opment. Magical thinking appears when when children create a dialogue between
children believe that a certain action will themselves and their dolls or stuffed toys
influence the world around them (e.g., and talk for the toys. Younger children
5. Preschool Language Development 123
rely on more familiar roles for pretend Next, we explore children’s linguistic
play (e.g., playing house), while older development as they enter the preschool
preschoolers create more elaborate play age.
schemes that may involve superheroes
(Galotti, 2017). Preschoolers’ imagina-
tion develops when they take on different
roles in play. At this stage, they take on
Linguistic Development
the roles of firefighter and other familiar
figures. As reviewed in previous chapters, lan-
Play is an important factor in the guage consists of five areas: phonology,
development of language. Children must morphology, syntax, semantics, and prag-
achieve the language skills to create and matics. Bloom and Lahey (1978) identified
explain the play scheme to other chil- three major components comprising lan-
dren. For example, play involves the use guage: form, content, and use.
of narrative structures to develop a play
scheme. Preschoolers must use their lan- Language form includes phonology,
guage skills to explain the goals, events, morphology, and syntax. These
plans, and outcomes of the play scheme. language areas are similar in that
Preschoolers who engage with peers in they define the structure and rules of
play demonstrate higher receptive vocab- language.
ulary skills than children who predomi-
Language content refers to the area of
nantly engage in parallel play (Holmes,
semantics, or the meaning of words
Romero, Ciraola, & Grushko, 2015). In
and the relationship of these words to
addition, more complex play skills predict
one another.
better narrative skills during the school-
age years (Stagnitti & Lewis, 2015). By 3 Language use describes the pragmatic
to 5 years of age, children use their lan- and social components of language.
guage skills to create and maintain play
schemes, relying less on the use of props. While these five areas are each distinct,
At age 5, when symbolic and pretend they also interact dynamically with one
play skills involve coordinated sequences another. For example, as a preschooler’s
of events (e.g., shopping, cooking, and vocabulary increases, she or he is able to
putting baby to bed), time relations produce lengthier sentences. This reflects
appear, such as first, next, before, and after. the interaction between semantic, mor-
Children acquire the distinction between phological, and syntactic skills.
the temporal relations before and after in
later stages of preschool development.
Phonology
Children’s cognitive and play skills
develop during this stage. They have Phonology is the part of language that
now achieved the language and contains rules that govern the structure,
cognitive skills that allow for the type distribution, and sequencing of speech
of imaginative play that includes sounds to create words. Initially, chil-
interaction with peers. dren make production errors that are
termed phonological processes (Table 5–1).
124 Introduction to Language Development
puter produced in place of the word com- stops) for another (e.g., fricatives). Exam-
puter. This phonological process is also ples include the following.
referred to as syllable deletion or reduc-
tion. Syllable reduction is the deletion of Stopping ton /tn/ for sun /sn/
a syllable from a word containing two or
Fronting tea /ti/ for key /ki/
more syllables.
Gliding
wabbit /wbIt/ for rabbit
/rbIt/
The simplest syllable for children to
produce is an open syllable structure.
Assimilation processes consist of the pro-
An open syllable is one in which the
duction of a speech sound that is similar
final sound in the syllable is a vowel
to another sound in the same word, as
(V), e.g., bee. A closed syllable is one
shown in the example below. Progressive
that ends in a consonant (C), e.g., beet.
assimilation consists of a speech sound
taking on the characteristics of a preced-
Whole word processes include redu- ing sound within the word (i.e., initial
plication, final consonant deletion, cluster phoneme /k/ produced in place of the
reduction, and unstressed syllable omission. final phoneme /t/).
Sentence Types
Syntactic Development A sentence is a syntactic structure that
presents a complete thought (Justice &
Syntax describes how words, phrases, Ezell, 2016). Once children begin to com-
clauses, and sentences are combined bine two words to produce sentences, they
within a language to form sentences demonstrate the emergence of syntax. The
(Angell, 2009). The early precursors to earliest sentence structures to emerge are
syntactic development can be found in declarative sentences, which follow a
children’s word combinations (Singleton subject + verb + object (SVO) structure,
& Shulman, 2013). Developmental growth e.g., The dog ate the cookies. Examples of
occurs rather rapidly in this domain, with preschoolers’ syntactic development are
early syntactic connections mastered shown in Table 5–4.
at approximately 30 months of age and Interrogative sentences, consisting of
adult-like syntax evident by age 4 (Owens, questions, appear at approximately age 3.
2016). Table 5–3 provides examples of typ- An interrogative sentence requires subject
ical utterances produced by preschoolers. inversion and auxiliary verbs (e.g., am, is,
One theory of syntactic development are, was, were), as shown in the develop-
is that children rely on a strategy called ment of interrogative sentence produc-
bootstrapping. In this theory, children tions shown below.
utilize syntactic or semantic cues in lan-
guage in order to “pull” themselves up to Sleep?
more advanced linguistic skills (Gleitman,
Mommy sleeping?
1990; Hacquard, 2014; Jin & Fisher, 2014).
Syntactic bootstrapping is a child’s ability Is Mommy sleeping?
Table 5–3. Typical Utterances Produced by Preschoolers
Encoding from a picture book The boy and the girl got into
the van and the van took
them to the train.
128
5. Preschool Language Development 129
4–5 Conjoined sentences using I play the drums and she plays the
conjunctions “and,” “because,” and piano.
“but” I cried because he hit me.
I like cookies but not fish.
Source: Reproduced with permission from Language Development: Understanding Language Diversity
in the Classroom (p. 144), by S. Levey & S. Polirstok (Eds.), 2011, Los Angeles, CA: Sage.
Imperative sentences include a demand During stage III (31–34 months), the sen-
or request. Children transition from label- tences are expanded with modifiers and
ing an item as a command to producing articles.
full sentences.
My mommy makes yummy cookies.
Ball
At stage IV (34 months +), children’s
Give me the ball
utterances expand to include a wider vari-
Throw the ball to me ety of modifiers and an increased usage of
pronouns.
Sentence Elements That boy kicked the red ball to his friend.
Children typically go through four At stage III, auxiliaries are acquired (e.g.,
stages of noun phrase development, am, is, are, don’t, can’t) and the past tense -ed
which correspond to Brown’s (1973) stages is observed in regular verbs (e.g., walked).
of development. During stage I (ages 18 The past tense -ed is also produced in the
to 25 months), children produce predom- overregularization of irregular verbs (goed
inantly single words. During this stage, instead of went). Prepositional phrases are
syntax has not begun to fully emerge, as attached to verb phrases to mark the loca-
two-word utterances provide the struc- tion of the object in the sentence (i.e., on
ture required for syntactic development. the bed) (Figure 5–1).
At stage II (27 to 30 months), sentence By stages IV and V, modal auxiliaries
production is expanded, as shown in the appear in children’s productions (e.g., can,
following example. could, would, should). Modal auxiliaries are
verbs that are combined with other verbs
Mommy makes cookies. to express obligation (You should eat your
5. Preschool Language Development 131
S (Sentence)
PP (Prepositional Phrase)
NP
dinner), uncertainty (I could go to the mov- tences (e.g., I would like to come, but I have
ies if my mother says okay), ability (I can to finish my homework).
lift this stone), permission (You can use my
bike), or future possibilities (I will go to the Embedding and Conjoining
party). Modal auxiliaries are acquired in
the following order of development: can, Between 36 and 48 months of age, chil-
could, shall, should, will, would, may, might, dren advance from simple sentences to
and must (Wells, 1985). longer and more complex sentences. The
By stage V, most children have fully emergence of complex sentences begins
acquired regular and irregular past tense with conjoined or coordinated sentences,
verbs (Owens, 2016). Examples consist of referred to as compound sentences. These
the regular past tense verbs walked and sentences comprise two main clauses that
talked and the irregular past tense verbs are conjoined by the conjunction and, or,
caught and threw. Conjunctions (e.g., and, but, or because. The conjunction and is the
but, if, because) are also produced, which first conjunction produced by preschool-
allow the creation of more complex sen- ers. Between 48 and 60 months of age,
132 Introduction to Language Development
children begin to demonstrate complex 1985; Oetting, Rice, & Swank, 1995; Rice
sentences in their embedding of phrases & Hoffman, 2015). The ability to acquire
and subordinate clauses. A subordinate words is attributed to the skill of fast map-
clause cannot stand alone in a sentence ping. Fast mapping is a child’s ability to
and serves as a grammatical unit within internalize or learn a symbol (the word/
the sentence. Subordination contributes vocabulary item) after minimal exposures
to increased syntactic complexity. A sub- to a word.
ordinate clause is a clause that contains a During the late preschool period,
subject and predicate but is not a complete children’s word definitions are concrete.
sentence. More abstract word definitions appear
with the acquisition of synonymy (i.e.,
The dog that lives next door is nice. words with similar features, such as sick
and ill), explanation (i.e., giving the rea-
I played ball until my mom called me.
son for an action), and specifications of
Whoever broke the window should categorical relationships (e.g., placing dog
explain what happened. and bird in the category animal) (Bernstein
& Levey, 2009). Children learn that the
word block can now apply to their neigh-
borhood (going around the block) and to
Semantics obstructions (He blocked me and I couldn’t
get through).
Semantics is the component of language
that describes how meaning is conveyed
Abstract lexical terms do not label
by words, sentences, conversation, and
objects or observable actions.
narratives. Semantic development begins
Abstract terms label concepts, such
with children’s vocabulary development.
as time, while concrete terms label
Vocabulary increases rapidly, starting at
observable things and actions that
age 2 (Golinkoff, Mervis, & Hirsh-Pasek,
can be pointed at in the environment.
1994) with 900 to 1,000 words at 3 years of
age, 1,500 words at 4 years of age, and
over 2,000 words acquired by age 5 Abstract lexical terms, such as words for
(Owens, Farinella, & Metz, 2014). Over time (before, later, soon), present difficulties
time, children expand and extend the for younger children because their mean-
meaning of words to apply to related ing is not apparent or visible. For exam-
objects or entities. For example, many ani- ple, utterances that indicate time (e.g., in
mal names are first learned from books a minute) are always difficult for a child
read to young children (e.g., cat). The to understand when asking When can I get
meaning of the word cat is extended to a cookie? During the preschool stage, chil-
other entities when a child visits a zoo. dren have an incomplete understanding of
When this occurs, children learn that the more abstract terms that refer to the actual
word cat can refer to kitty cat, tiger, and lion. duration of time (Shatz, Tare, Nguyen, &
New words are learned quickly fol- Young, 2010). For example, children were
lowing initial representations in both asked questions including, How long does
didactic (direct teaching) and informal it take to see a movie? How long does it take to
contexts (Apel, Kahmi, & Dollaghan, eat breakfast? and How long does it take for
5. Preschool Language Development 133
Locational
Age Relationship Physical Kinship Term
3–4 Under Big/little Mommy/Daddy
Heavy/light
In the following example, the order of dren to better understand the connection
mention does not follow the chronological between events and time.
order of events. In this example, the order
of mention (first, ate a cookie; second, put
on his shoes) is not consistent with the Children are able to recall and
chronological order of events (first, put on discuss past events at 2 to 3 years of
his shoes; second, ate his cookie). age, but reference to the actual time
of past events may not occur until 35
Before he ate his cookie, he put on his to 40 months of age (Peterson, 1990).
shoes. Children frequently use yesterday as a
term for any period in the past.
Children rely on the order of mention
until 4 to 6 years of age, with better under-
standing of syntax and the terms before
and after at age 7 (Blything, Davies, & Physical Relations
Cain, 2015; Owens, 2016).
Temporal relations, such as yesterday Children acquire the physical relations
and tomorrow, are better understood with big/little as young as 2 years of age (Sand-
exposure to adults’ use of these terms hofer & Smith, 2001), while other physical
(Hudson, 2006). By age 4, children are relations are learned later.
better able to conceptualize the timeframe
for events occurring in the past or future, Big/little
which contributes to their understanding
Tall/short and long/short
of the terms yesterday and tomorrow. Expo-
sure to the use of these terms allows chil- High/low
136 Introduction to Language Development
Narrative is a form of discourse that differs Temporal chains are produced between
from conversation because narratives do 3 and 5 years of age, when narrative is
5. Preschool Language Development 137
Two types of narratives are pro- the form and structure of language, such
duced by older preschool-age children: as rules for forming sentences and phono-
personal narratives, a description of logical features that form and distinguish
“what happened,” and fictional nar- words and the meaning of words (Berko
ratives, drawn from a child’s imagina- Gleason & Bernstein Ratner, 2017). Meta-
tion. Children use personal narratives to linguistic awareness allows children to
describe their own experiences. Personal recognize syntactic, semantic, and pho-
narratives can consist of decontextual- nological components that may contain
ized narratives that are descriptions of errors, as shown in the following exam-
people, objects, and events absent from ples (Kahmi & Koenig, 1985, p. 209):
the immediate environment. Personal
narrative can also consist of contextual- Syntactic awareness: Where “he go?”
ized narratives that consist of every day versus Where is he going?
conversation. Cohesive devices are used
Semantic awareness: Jill “eats” cards
to provide a well-organized narrative by
versus Jill plays cards
creating a connection between elements
of the story. These are linguistic devices Phonological awareness: He “locks”
that refer to a previously stated person to school versus He walks to school
or object (Gabig, 2014) and are used to
connect parts of a conversation or narra- Typically developing children can
tive. Examples consist of and, then, when, identify and revise errors by age 4, but
because, so, then, if, but, and that. These are metalinguistic skills do not fully develop
terms that are learned beginning with until age 7 or 8. Metalinguistic skills
and. Cohesive devices consist of addi- require the development of intact lan-
tive, temporal, and causal conjunctions. guage skills and differentiate typical from
atypical language development. Meta-
Additives Conjunctions that link linguistic awareness is also a factor in
clauses through addition developing intact literacy skills for read-
(e.g., and) ing and writing abilities. For example,
metalinguistic awareness plays a role in
Temporal Conjunctions that link
phonological skills, providing children
clauses temporally (e.g.,
with the ability to recognize rhymes (e.g.,
then, next)
cat, hat, and bat) and to identify sounds
Causal Conjunctions that link in words (e.g., the word cat contains the
clauses causally (e.g., three sounds “c,” “a,” and “t”). In sum-
because, so) mary, metalinguistic awareness is present
when children develop the ability to think
about language itself (Yopp &Yopp, 2010).
Metalinguistic Awareness
Pragmatics
Metalinguistic awareness appears dur-
ing the preschool years, providing chil-
dren with the ability to consciously reflect Pragmatics involves the appropriate use
on the nature and properties of language. of language based on three major commu-
This ability allows children to reflect on nication skills:
5. Preschool Language Development 139
Huh? or What? (Ninio & Snow, 1996). children learn to talk about objects absent
It is not until the early school-age years from the immediate environment, events
that children are able to request specific in the past and future, and personal
clarification for better understanding of a experiences.
speaker’s message.
By age 4, children can adopt different
roles in conversation by adjusting pitch
Humor
and loudness. For example, they use a
deeper and louder voice when taking
on a male role in play. By age 4, children Conversational skills frequently involve
are able to use motherese (child-directed the use of humor. By age 2, children invent
speech) when interacting with younger their own jokes (Hoicka & Akhtar, 2011).
children. This consists of a higher pitch Examples consist of handing an adult the
and quieter voice. Register refers to the incorrect object (giving a spoon when
language style used for a specific purpose asked for a cup) or making up names for
or to adapt to a specific social context. For things (calling a cup a silly or another
example, when speaking before a class, a name). At age 3, children are more likely
speaker will be careful to use a more for- to laugh when mislabeling items in this
mal style of speech. Register also includes manner. Examples of children’s develop-
the politeness forms developed when pre- ment of humor include the use of incon-
schoolers learn that vocabulary and gram- gruity (e.g., a bowl for a hat at 18 to 24
mar play a role in communication, such as months), appreciation of jokes (2 to 7
the use of indirect requests (e.g., Can I have years of age), and enjoyment of puns, sat-
a cookie?). By age 5, they purposefully use ire, and ambiguous meanings as children
polite forms. Topic maintenance ensures develop greater vocabulary skills at later
cohesion (connection between elements) in ages (e.g., she has bear feet versus bare
a conversation. At age 2, only half of contri- feet; McGhee, 1980). Humor also plays a
butions to a conversation are on topic. role in children’s socialization, with most
By age 3½, children can sustain a research showing a relationship between
topic of conversation about 75% of the play and humor.
time but are better able to sustain a topic
when they are interested or actively Understanding humor depends on
engaged in the topic at hand. Turn-taking a child’s ability to recognize incon-
is also a factor in conversation. This refers gruity (an absurd or strange situation
to taking turns as speaker and listener. or action). Incongruity involves an
Children have difficulty sustaining that event or story resulting in an illogical
topic beyond one or two turns at ages 2½ conclusion or action (e.g., a shoe
to 3, but 5-year-olds can sustain a conver- used as a hat). The understanding
sation for about 12 turns, based on more of the incongruity of an unexpected
advanced vocabulary and language skills outcome is humor, with the response
(Hoyte, Degotardi, & Torr, 2015). Con- of laughter. Understanding that there
versation frequently requires referring was an unexpected, incongruous
to entities or events that are absent from result reflects a child’s ability to
the context, defined as decontextualized understand humor (Southam, 2005).
language. During the preschool years,
142 Introduction to Language Development
Fast mapping
1. Describe the role of morphemes in
Fictional narrative children’s syntactic development.
Free morpheme 2. Provide an example from this
chapter that demonstrates the
Function word
relationship between two language
Imperative sentences areas.
144 Introduction to Language Development
Appendix 5–A
Developmental Milestones, Ages 3 to 5
Source: Reproduced with permission from How does your child hear and talk? Available from
the website of the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association: http://www/asha
.org/public/speech/development/chart.htm. All rights reserved.
6
Language Development in
Middle and Late Childhood
and Adolescence
María R. Brea-Spahn and Sandra Levey
Case Study
Ginger is an 8-year-old in the third grade. chapter, you will be able to understand the
She has a diverse vocabulary. She is a good language factors that contribute to a child’s
student and enjoys reading books and ability to achieve successful academic skills
writing in her journal. After reading this during the school-age years.
149
150 Introduction to Language Development
stages. After reading this chapter, you will The understanding and use of figura-
be able to understand: tive language
151
152 Introduction to Language Development
Analogical processes can be found in mates are out for weeks. It would not be
daily activities, such as explaining some- logical to assume that all officemates are
thing to a younger child. For example, out for weeks. An example of an illogical
email can be explained by describing the syllogism is shown in the following exam-
similarity between receiving a message on ple (Markovits, Schleifer, & Fortier, 1989,
the computer and receiving a message by p. 793). In this case, the second premise
mail. This explanation employs analogical (All red things have a nose) does not share
reasoning to draw this comparison. any terms with the first premise (Every
Zobole is yellow).
Email is to the computer as letter is to
the mailbox. Major premise: Every Zobole is yellow.
Minor premise: All red things have a
A syllogism is a formal argument
nose.
that consists of a major and minor prem-
ise and a conclusion, used to convince Conclusion: Therefore, Zoboles have
others or to inform others of facts. Syllo- a nose.
gisms play a role in academic and other
general skills, given the need to formu- As shown in Table 6–1, illogical syllogisms
late and understand logical arguments. In are not detected until children reach age
the classroom, logical arguments appear 15, given that advanced cognitive skills
in academic texts, with children asked to play a role in children’s ability to process
draw conclusions from what they have more abstract cognitive tasks (Galotti,
read. Children must also understand if an 2017). At this age, a child might say, “That
argument is logical and not presenting a makes no sense because we only know
false conclusion. that a Zobole is yellow.”
Syllogisms also play a role in conver-
sation, as shown in the following example
Note the difference between the
(Tessler & Goodman, 2017). In this exam-
illogical syllogism and the logical
ple, someone is telling a friend that office-
syllogism. In the logical syllogism,
mates are out with the flu.
there is a connection between the
premises and the conclusion. The
Major premise: All officemates are out
illogical syllogism shown in the
with the flu.
example shows no connection
Minor premise: Some officemates between the first and second premise.
with the flu are out for weeks.
Critical-thinking skills are an essential
What would be a logical conclusion?
factor for school-age children when pre-
sented with illogical beliefs or ideas. Criti-
Conclusion 1: Therefore, some
cal thinking involves the analysis of the
officemates are out for weeks.
content of a spoken or written text for
Conclusion 2: Therefore, all accuracy and logic (Nippold et al., 2014).
officemates are out for weeks. This analysis allows the child to judge the
logic of the ideas being expressed.
In conversation, a listener would draw the We next discuss the language devel-
logical conclusion that only some office- opment that occurs in early, middle, and
6. Language Development in Middle and Late Childhood and Adolescence 155
such as Barking up the wrong tree. This meanings apply to intelligence and per-
idiom is based on the idea that a dog is sonal traits.
barking at the wrong tree (i.e., the squir-
rel being sought is hiding in another tree).
The actual meaning of this idiom is that a Metaphor
person is on the wrong track, looking in
the wrong place, or considering an incor- A metaphor makes a comparison between
rect idea. School-age children find trans- two entities that are not related but share
parent idioms easier to comprehend than some common characteristics.
opaque expressions (Nippold & Duthie,
2003). Preadolescent children may under- The exam was a breeze.
stand certain idioms if they have previ-
ously heard these terms used, know the In this example, the metaphor means that
meanings of the words embedded in the the exam was easy, with comparison to a
idiom, and can read between the lines for the gentle breeze. By age 6, children under-
intended, yet unexpressed, meaning (Nip- stand simple metaphors (Nippold, Leon-
pold & Rudzinski, 1993). ard, & Kail, 1984), with more complex
metaphors understood by adolescence.
Examples of metaphors found in children’s
Simile books consist of You are toast (someone is
being told he or she is in trouble) and My
Similes make comparisons between two school is a zoo (the school is full of kids act-
different subjects by using the words like ing out or behaving like wild animals).
or as (e.g., As stubborn as a mule or As light
as a feather). Frequently, figurative lan-
guage is found in children’s literature. Proverbs
Examples consist of the following exam-
ples, taken from children’s books: Proverbs express a practical or basic truth,
as shown in the following examples.
He is as stubborn as a mule. (Mules are
resistant to being told or urged to ◆ Two wrongs don’t make a right.
move.) (When someone has done something
wrong, do not do something wrong in
My best friend is as sharp as a pencil.
return.)
(The term sharp is associated with
◆ The pen is mightier than the sword.
intelligence.)
(Using words is often more effective
I woke up as fresh as a daisy. (You woke than forcing people to do what you
up feeling good.) want.)
Over time, children learn that many words Children have difficulty understanding
have various meanings, such as sharp, dull, proverbs before age 12. Additionally, prov-
deep, and shallow. Although the mean- erbs may pose a significant difficulty for
ing of these words applies to physical children from diverse cultural or linguis-
meanings (e.g., sharp or dull objects, and tic backgrounds (Roseberry-McKibbin,
deep or shallow water), the more abstract 2007), given that proverbs are specific
6. Language Development in Middle and Late Childhood and Adolescence 159
happily ever after when the wolf ran away). ◆ Consideration of participants’
The ability to understand the structure of thoughts and feelings
a story is established by 9 to 10 years of age ◆ Repairs used to clarify understanding
(Berman & Slobin, 1994). Older school- if others are confused
age children, around 12 to 13 years of age,
produce narratives with a greater propor- Expository Discourse
tion of complete episodes than younger
children, as described in Chapter 5. An Expository discourse consists of language
example of a school-age narrative follows that is typically found in textbooks, class-
(Nippold, 2007, p. 295), with the speaker room lectures, and technical papers. This
expressing an event that occurred. This type of discourse is based on factual infor-
narrative continues beyond this example, mation with a focus on the following fac-
with a friend asking more about the spi- tors (Ward-Lonergan, 2010):
der and what happened next.
Comparison: Compare and contrast
I going to tell you what happened to ideas
me this morning. I was playin’ on the
Causation: Explain a cause and the
monkey bars. A boy came along with
resulting effect
a big, huge, giant spider in his hand.
Problem: Provide a solution
Conversation Collection/description: Provide a
description of the elements
Conversation involves cognitive and per-
ceptual abilities (Avivi-Reich, Jakubczyk, Enumeration: Provide a definition
Daneman, & Schneider, 2015). Cognitive and example
abilities involve focused attention to the
conversation while avoiding distractions, Expository discourse may be used to inform,
switching attention from one speaker to express facts, or to argue a point of
to another, keeping track of the topics, view. This type of discourse requires dif-
extracting the meaning of the information ferent cognitive skills than those required
being discussed, and keeping information by narrative discourse, and is more lin-
in memory for the future. Perceptual abili- guistically complex (Nippold, Hesketh,
ties involve listening and comprehension Duthie, & Mansfield, 2005; Sun & Nip-
of the topic being discussed. This allows pold, 2012). This complexity is based on
for successful participation in the con- the use of a greater number of words and
versation. Conversational growth during more advanced syntax. An example from
the school-age years appears as children a high school text can be found in Table 6–4,
achieve the following abilities (Nippold, showing the elements that characterize
2007, p. 286). expository discourse (Lundine & McCau-
ley, 2016, p. 308).
◆ Improved and longer topic When children reach grade 4, they
maintenance begin to use linguistic skills that distin-
◆ Appropriate turn-taking guish narrative from expository discourse
◆ A greater number of relevant comments (Berman, 2004). However, children do
6. Language Development in Middle and Late Childhood and Adolescence 161
not incorporate the elements of sentence ment. Persuasion discourse abilities prog-
structure and vocabulary that distinguish ress during school age and adolescence,
narrative and expository writing until as shown in the following examples (Nip-
adolescence (Berman, 2004; Berman & pold, 2007, p. 306).
Nir-Sagiv, 2007).
Another form of discourse involves Adjustment to listeners’ characteristics
persuasion. Persuasion requires the knowl- (e.g., age, needs, beliefs)
edge to convince others to agree with an
idea or an action. Consequently, it is essen- Provision of advantages to persuade
tial to possess the skills to persuade others in the listener to agreement
an appropriate manner to achieve success. Anticipation and response to
counterarguments
Persuasion
Provision of a variety of different
Persuasion is the discourse genre that arguments
involves convincing others to accept a
point of view or argument, with progress In summary, conversation, narrative, and
in persuasion occurring after grade 3. expository discourse skills continue to
Adolescents achieve the ability to pro- develop with age and experience. Chil-
duce a persuasive argument that appeals dren also develop an understanding of
to others’ values and beliefs (Nippold, figurative language. In this case, meaning
1998). At this stage of development, they must be found by going beyond the basic
are able to see another person’s point of meaning of the words that are used (e.g.,
view when engaged in a persuasive argu- He goes by the book).
162 Introduction to Language Development
tive pronouns are which, that, who, whom, age period is passive sentence structure.
and whose. In the following sentence, the dog is the
subject (S), the word chased is the verb (V),
Independent clause (SVO): The dog and the cat is the direct object noun (O).
ate the cookies.
SVO: The dog chased the cat.
Subordinating conjunction: Because
the dog ate the cookies . . .
To form a passive structure, the sentence
Relative pronoun: The dog, who lives structure SVO is transformed to the pas-
next door, ate the cookies. sive structure OVS, as shown in the fol-
lowing example.
The terms if and although may not be used
consistently until age 15 (Bernstein & OVS: The cat was chased by the dog.
Levey, 2009).
Younger children may understand passive
I will come, if I finish my homework in sentence forms, but they are not produced
time. until age 7 or 8 (Snyder & Hyams, 2015).
I went to school, although I had to come
home because I was sick. There are two types of passive
forms: reversible and irreversible.
Syntactic elaboration also consists of noun Some passive forms are irreversible
phrase or verb phrase elaboration. Both (The window was broken by the boy)
processes emerge during middle and late because the reverse form (The boy was
childhood. broken by the window) is not possible.
However, a reversible passive
Noun phrase elaboration: The dog; sentence (The boy was kissed by the girl)
The big dog can be logically reversed (The girl was
Verb phrase elaboration: The dog barks; kissed by the boy).
The dog barks loudly
The complex sentences produced at
Verb phrase elaboration can also be accom-
age 10 to 11 contain mental state verbs and
plished with the use of modal auxiliary
adverbial conjuncts (Bernstein & Levey,
verbs (e.g., can, could, shall, should, will,
2009). Mental state verbs describe some-
would, may, might).
one’s thoughts, beliefs, feelings, or inten-
tions and consist of terms such as believe,
I could climb the mountain if I wanted to.
think, know, understand, perceive, feel, guess,
recognize, notice, want, and imagine. Exam-
Verb phrase elaboration also occurs when
ples of adverbial conjunct terms consist
conjunctions (e.g., although, and, because,
of also, consequently, finally, instead, mean-
but, either) are used.
while, nevertheless, now, thus, and therefore.
She likes snow because she likes to ski.
Mental state verb: I think he likes me.
Another example of complex sentence Adverbial conjunct: Finally, the girl
structure that emerges during the school- found her bicycle.
164 Introduction to Language Development
An independent clause can stand alone and expresses a main idea (e.g., The
dog ate a cookie) — while a phrase does not contain both a subject and a verb
(e.g., a red book, running away, and in the box).
An adverbial clause is used as an adverb that indicates time, place, or
condition (e.g., clauses beginning with after, although, unless, until, when).
A nominal clause is a dependent clause that acts as the subject or object of a
sentence, naming a person, place, or thing (e.g., clauses beginning with who,
what, which, where).
A relative clause is a dependent clause that modifies an independent clause
and is introduced by a relative pronoun (e.g., who, which, that, whose, whom).
Table 6–6. A Conversation About Chess and a Conversation About Pets
165
166 Introduction to Language Development
Table 6–8. Morphemes
Description Example
Full propositional complement: contains a I hope (that) we go to lunch soon.
cognitive verb such as think, guess, wish, know,
hope, wonder, show, remember, pretend, mean, forget,
say, tell, may or may not contain that
Participle: contains an -ing form that functions I see the man driving down the
as an adjective (modifies a noun or a pronoun) street.
I hear the dog barking loudly.
Infinitive clause (to + verb) with different I want the baby to eat.
subject: Contains an infinitive; the subject of the
infinitive clause is different from the main clause
Relative clause: contains an embedded phrase That is the one that I like.
that functions as an adjective; modifies an object
or subject noun phrase; may be marked by who,
which, that
Simple conjoining: contains two clauses that I ate fast so I could leave.
are joined by a conjunction; can be coordination I like cake and I like ice cream.
(and, but, or, etc.) or subordination (because, after,
etc.)
Embedded and conjoined: contains both an I want to stay here, but my mommy
embedded and conjoined clause; may include a says no.
catenative (a verb often followed by a function
word such as to or on); will have three or more
verbs
Multiple embedding: contains more than one I know that we have to eat soon.
embedded clause; one verb may be a catenative;
will have three or more verbs
Source: Reproduced with permission from the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association,
from S. A. Stefani (2007). Identifying embedded and conjoined complex sentences: Making it simple.
Contemporary Issues in Communication Sciences and Disorders, 34, p. 46.
168
6. Language Development in Middle and Late Childhood and Adolescence 169
with peers. The social context becomes the more appropriate type of a request, in
backdrop for changes in social language comparison to a direct request (Give me
interaction. The pragmatic changes that your bike today). At age 10, children begin
occur during adolescence consist of prog- to use indirect requests more frequently
ress in topic maintenance, relevance to the within interaction.
topic of conversation, appropriate turn- In addition to the linguistic aspects
taking during conversation, the contribu- of pragmatics, there are pragmatic rules
tion of new information, the expression that govern interaction. These are rules
of empathy and understanding, and the that apply to greetings, providing infor-
ability to focus on a conversational topic mation, and adapting language to differ-
(Nippold, 1998). ent listeners (age and status). Pragmatic
There is increased insight into oth- rules also apply to turn-taking in conver-
ers’ thoughts and feelings during this sation, clarification if not understood, eye
period of development. This is reflected in contact during interaction, and distance
school-age children becoming more adept or proximity to other speakers in an inter-
at taking the perspective of others and action. The pragmatic skills required for
accomplishing social perspective-taking successful communication are reflected
(Nippold, 2007). Perspective-taking in- in conversation, narrative, and persua-
volves considering another person’s per- sive discourse (Nippold, 2006, p. 371). It
spective or point of view, such as the opin- is important to understand that pragmatic
ions, beliefs, feelings, and needs of others. rules differ across languages and cultures,
The social skills that ensure successful while many of these rules apply to most
peer acceptance for school-age children contexts of interaction. Grice (1975) pro-
are relevant comments, novel ideas, and vided pragmatic rules that specify appro-
amusing comments during social interac- priate conversation: Be brief and to the
tion (Nippold, 1998, 2000). point, be honest, and avoid misunder-
Children’s interaction also becomes standings (Table 6–11).
more appropriate when making requests In summary, language development
with the use of modal auxiliary terms (e.g., in school-age children is associated with
Can you . . . , could you . . . , would you . . . ?) growth in metalinguistic, cognitive, and
used to produce indirect requests (Can I use social skills. These are the factors that
your bike today?). Indirect requests are a develop when children are exposed to
varied experiences, along with the expe- from a word, such as the sounds that
riences provided through reading, the compose the word cat (e.g., c – a – t)
language spoken by teachers, and social and to blend spoken sounds that
interaction with peers. We now review the compose words (e.g., to blend or
language skills that support literacy skills combine the spoken sounds “c,” “a,”
during the school-age period. “t” to form the word cat)
◆ Elision consists of the ability to delete
a sound in a word to form a new
word (e.g., stop → top)
Literacy Skills in Early,
Middle, and Later Grades Gillon (2004) presents the following tasks
that characterize phonological awareness
For most school-age children and adoles- skills (Table 6–12).
cents, written language plays a pivotal role Once phonological awareness skills
in the development of more complex oral are acquired in the early elementary years,
language skills. Before children become the focus is on reading fluency (accuracy
proficient at understanding the symbolic and rate of reading). Following their mas-
nature of language necessary for reading tery of single-word decoding, children
comprehension, they must become pho- are taught to read from connected text
nologically aware. Phonological aware- found in stories and books. Writing fol-
ness includes consciousness about lexical lows a similar path, with children in the
units (words) and sublexical units (pho- first grade introduced to spelling com-
nemes, syllables, and onset/rime). mon words with regular phonetic pat-
terns (dog, ran, cat). In the second grade,
children read and write at a basic level
Onset refers to the initial sound or
and have an understanding of riddles and
sounds in a word (e.g., stop), while
puns, described in the explanation of figu-
the rime refers to the vowel and any
rative language development.
following consonants in the word
In the third grade, children can pro-
(e.g., stop).
vide a summary of what they have read.
In the fourth grade, the focus is on reading
Phonological awareness develops over the complex, domain-specific texts that con-
course of the early elementary school-age tain more technical vocabulary items that
period, with awareness that words are com- are related to the domain (e.g., history or
posed of smaller units of language (syllables, science). In the fifth grade, learners under-
onset-rime, and phonemes). Phonological stand a story plot, the characters’ behav-
awareness that appears during the school- iors and thoughts, as well as the function
age years includes the following examples: of quotation marks to denote dialogues
within story episodes. Their writing skills
◆ Alliteration skills signal awareness of have also developed and they are able
shared phonemes across words (e.g., to write more complex narratives about
big bad bears). events or experiences. In the sixth grade,
◆ Phoneme awareness reveals the children can organize, revise, and edit
ability to sequentially isolate a sound their written work.
6. Language Development in Middle and Late Childhood and Adolescence 171
Age 4 Rhyme
Age 5 Recognition of phonemic changes in words (Hickory Dickory “clock”
versus Hickory Dickory Dock)
Syllable awareness (awareness that the word banana has three
syllables)
Blending onset and rime (th-umb)
Producing a rhyme (What rhymes with cat?)
Matching initial sounds; isolating an initial sound (Say the first sound
in the word ride)
Compound word deletion (Say cowboy. Say it again but don’t say cow)
Age 6 Blending of two and three phonemes (z-oo; sh-o-p; h-ou-se)
Phoneme segmentation (Say the word as you move a chip for each
sound: sh-e; m-a-n; l-e-g)
Phoneme substitution to build new words (Change the /a/ in cane
to /o/)
Age 7 Sound deletion (Say the word stop without the /s/)
Age 8 Sound deletion that includes blends (Say prank; now say it without
the /p/)
Age 9 Sound deletion that includes medial and final blends (Say snail. Say it
again, without the /n/; say fork. Say it again without the /k/)
Kindergarten
1. Follows one- to two-step directions in sequence
2. Listens to and understands stories read to the class
3. Answers simple yes/no and Wh-questions (e.g., “What did you . . . ?”)
4. Produces clear speech
5. Asks for information
6. Participates in and initiates conversation
7. Understands reading from top to bottom and left to right
8. Understands words that rhyme
9. Can match words based on their sounds
10. Matches some sounds with letters
11. Has sight word recognition for some words
12. Prints names
13. Draws a picture to tell a story
First Grade
14. Understands and can recall information
15. Follows two- to three-step directions in sequence
16. Answers more complex questions
17. Can tell and retell stories with logical order of events
18. Produces a variety of sentence types and supplies directions
19. Stays on topic during a conversation
20. Asks and answers Wh-questions (i.e., who, what, where, why, and when)
21. Can match spoken with written words and can identify sounds in shorter words
22. May sound out unfamiliar words when reading
23. Prints words and spells frequently used words correctly
24. Can write short stories
172
Table 6–13. continued
Second Grade
25. Follows three- to four-step directions
26. Understands concepts that involve location and time
27. Can answer questions about a story
28. Produces more complex sentences
29. Can explain words and ideas
30. Uses language in more complex ways (e.g., to inform, persuade, entertain)
31. Maintains topic and turn-taking in conversation
32. Displays intact phonological awareness for the correspondence between sounds,
syllables, words, and longer spoken utterances with written forms
33. Has expanded sight word recognition
34. Monitors reading accuracy by rereading
35. Can explain the main ideas of a story
36. Writes clearly and uses a range of sentence types
37. Moves from inventive to accurate spelling
Third Grade
38. Shows good listening skills and continued progress in conversation skills
39. Can summarize, predict, and explain when working with reading tasks
40. Displays prediction and mastery of phonics in reading skills
41. Uses learned information to learn new topics
42. Uses topic-specific vocabulary in conversation and classroom discussion
43. Can explain material that has been learned in the classroom
44. Can ask and answer questions related to material learned in the classroom
45. Makes continued progress in monitoring reading accuracy
46. Composes stories and spells simple words correctly while using details in writing
47. Asks and answers questions about reading materials
48. Rereads and corrects errors
49. Spells most words correctly
Source: Reproduced and adapted with permission from D. Wellman Owre and M. Kennedy Brennan
(2002). An overview of language development. Literacy and communication: Expectations from kinder-
garten through fifth grade.
173
174 Introduction to Language Development
Nippold, M. A. (2007). Later language develop- Piaget, J. (1954). The construction of reality in the
ment: School-age children, adolescents, and child. New York, NY: Basic Books.
young adults. Austin, TX: Pro-Ed. Piaget, J., & Inhelder, B. (1969). The psychology
Nippold, M. A. (2009). School-age children of the child. New York, NY: Basic Books.
talk about chess: Does knowledge drive Ram, G., Marinellie, S. A., Benigno, J., & McCar-
syntactic complexity? Journal of Speech, Lan- thy, J. (2013). Morphological analysis in
guage, and Hearing Research, 52, 856–871. context versus isolation: Use of a dynamic
Nippold, M. A., & Duthie, J. K. (2003). Mental assessment task with school-age children.
imagery and idiom comprehension: A com- Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in
parison of school-age children and adults. Schools, 24, 32–47.
Journal of Language and Hearing Research, Roseberry-McKibbin, C. (2007). Language disor-
46(4), 788–799. ders in children: A multicultural and case per-
Nippold, M. A., Frantz-Kaspar, M. W., Cra- spective. Boston, MA: Allyn & Bacon.
mond, P., Kirk, C., Hayward-Mayhew, C., & Roseberry-McKibbin, C. (2014). Multicultural
MacKinnon, M. (2014). Conversational and children with special language needs: Practical
narrative speaking in adolescents: Exam- strategies for assessment and intervention (4th
ining the use of complex syntax. Journal of ed.). Oceanside, CA: Academic Communi-
Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 57, cation Associates.
876–886. Snyder, W., & Hyams, N. (2015). Minimal-
Nippold, M. A., Hesketh, L. J., Duthie, J. K., & ity effects in children’s passives. In E.
Mansfield, T. C. (2005). Conversational ver- di Domenico, C. Hamann, & S. Matteini
sus expository discourse: A study of syn- (Eds.), Structures, strategies and beyond: Stud-
tactic development in children, adolescents, ies in honour of Andrea Belletti (pp. 343–368).
and adults. Journal of Speech, Language, and Amsterdam, Netherlands: John Benjamin.
Hearing Research, 48, 1048–1064. Steffani, S. A. (2007). Identifying embedded
Nippold, M. A., Leonard, L. B., & Kail, R. and conjoined complex sentences: Making
(1984). Syntactic and conceptual factors in it simple. Contemporary Issues in Communi-
children’s understanding of metaphors. cation Sciences and Disorders, 34, 44–54.
Journal of Speech and Hearing Research, 27, Stein, N., & Glenn, C. (1979). An analysis of
197–205. story comprehension in elementary school
Nippold, M. A., & Rudzinski, M. (1993). Famil- children. In R. Freedle (Ed.), New directions
iarity and transparency in idiom explana- in discourse processing (Vol. 2). Norwood, NJ:
tion: A developmental study of children Ablex.
and adolescents. Journal of Speech and Hear- Sun, L., & Nippold, M. A. (2012). Narrative
ing Research, 36, 728–737. writing in children and adolescents: Exam-
Nippold, M. A., & Sun, L. (2010). Expository ining the literate lexicon. Language, Speech,
writing in children and adolescents: A class- and Hearing Services in Schools, 43, 2–13.
room assessment tool. Perspectives on Lan- Tessler, M., & Goodman, N. D. (2017). Some
guage Learning and Education: Adolescent arguments are probably valid: Syllogistic rea-
Language, 17, 100–107. Published by Divi- soning as communication. Retrieved from
sion 1, American Speech-Language-Hearing https://web.stanford.edu/~ngoodman/
Association. papers/cogsci14-syllogisms_tessler.pdf
Owre, D., & Kennedy Brennan, M. (2002). An Ward-Lonergan, J. M. (2010). Expository dis-
overview of language development: Literacy and course abilities in school-age children
communication: Expectations from kindergar- and adolescents with language disorders:
ten through fifth grade. Retrieved from http:// Nature of the problem. In M. A. Nippold
www.asha.org/uploadedFiles/Build-Your- & C. M. Scott (Eds.), Expository discourse in
Childs-Skills-Third-to-Fifth-Grade.pdf children, adolescents, and adults: Development
6. Language Development in Middle and Late Childhood and Adolescence 177
and disorders (pp. 155–189). New York, NY: cents with language disorders. Retrieved from
Psychology Press/Taylor and Francis. https://coe.uoregon.edu/cds/files/2011/
Ward-Lonergan, J. M., & Duthie, J. K. (2014). 09/Expository-Discourse-Intervention.pdf
Expository discourse intervention for adoles-
7
The Development of
Literacy Skills
Sylvia F. Diehl
Case Study
Pat is 4 years old. He loves to point out in his name (i.e., the sound and symbol
his favorite stores to his Mother when relationship). He can identify his own
riding in the car. He frequently points out name and enjoys finding the special letters
signs, especially McDonald’s and Toys R in his name on signs and in books. After
Us. Pat loves to read books with his big reading this chapter, you will understand
sister and will often use his toys to act out why these abilities are important in
the stories they read. He is beginning to providing the foundation for literacy
learn what sound /p/ makes and that it is development.
Literacy encompasses the ability to read, language as starting in infancy, with liter-
write, speak, listen, and think effectively acy skills beginning during formal school
(Meltzer, Smith, & Clark, 2001). The pur- instruction. It is true that the process of
pose of reading is to gather meaning from identifying letters and words is best when
the printed page (Dickenson, Golinkoff, systematically taught, and this instruc-
& Hirsch-Paseki, 2010). The develop- tion typically occurs at school. Think for a
ment of literacy is indivisibly linked with moment about Pat’s identification of the
the development of language (Goodrich, fast food sign. This shows print aware-
Mudrich, & Robinson, 2015; Nelson, 2010). ness that Pat developed before formal
One usually thinks of the development of teaching. Moreover, comprehension of the
179
180 Introduction to Language Development
ciation of rhyming in songs; early draw- throughout the early elementary school
ing and writing) and language-related years (Troia, Stone, Silliman, Ehren, &
skills (i.e., vocabulary, syntax, story struc- Wallach, 2014). Phonological awareness
ture) before they experience formal lit- refers to an individual’s awareness of the
eracy instruction (Justice & Ezell, 2004; phonological structure, or sound struc-
Westerveld, Trembath, Shellshear, & ture, of words. It starts with an interest in
Paynter, 2016). This foundation supports the sounds in words and with enjoyment
the development of abilities for accu- of rhymes, songs, and chants. At 2 years of
rate fluent reading with comprehension age, many children can detect rhyme and
(National Institute of Child Health and alliteration (van Kleeck & Schuele, 1987).
Human Development [NICHD], 2008). Later this matures into more conscious
During this time, the child starts to learn metalinguistic awareness of onset, rimes,
to think about language in a more mind- and individual phonemes. This kind of
ful way. This represents a transition from gradual progression proceeds through
using language automatically for com- the aspects of phonological awareness,
munication to conscious thought about including a child’s ability to understand
the use of language. This ability is called how the sounds of language relate to one
metalinguistic knowledge, which means another to form the meaning of words.
“thinking about language.” Phonological awareness involves iden-
Metalinguistic skills are essential for tifying and manipulating whole words,
learning to read and write (Laurent & Mar- syllables, initial consonants, and word
tinot, 2009; van Kleeck, 1994). In addition, chunks at the end of words (rime). Exam-
learning another language acts to promote ples of children’s phonological awareness
metalinguistic awareness (Naqvi, Thorne, follow:
Pfitscher, Nordstokke, & McKeough, 2013).
As the child progresses through school, Awareness of the sound structure of
each area of language becomes the focus words
of metalinguistic examination (Justice,
Understanding that the word dog
2006). Early metalinguistic skills typically
has one syllable and banana has three
involve print awareness and phonological
syllables
awareness (Justice, 2006; Justice & Ezell,
2004). Developing print and phonologi- Understanding that the word cat
cal awareness is a gradual developmental consists of three alphabet letters
process (Suortti & Lipponen, 2016). Young
Having the ability to identify rhyming
children exhibit print awareness by real-
words and, later, to generate rhyme
izing that the print underneath a picture
gives additional information. Identifying the ending sound of the
word hat
distinct names, depending on the varied world in more complex ways. They are
order of letters in words (Justice & Ezell, learning to communicate about people,
2004). At this stage of development, chil- objects, and events that are not actually
dren’s phonological awareness becomes present. This involves decontextualized
much more visible, graduating to the language, or language used to refer to
ability to segment sound units in words. things not present in the immediate envi-
Development goes from larger segments, ronment. Experience with decontextual-
such as parsing sentences into words, to ized language is crucial to later reading
smaller segments, such as dividing mul- development and text comprehension
tisyllabic words into syllables (e.g., ba-na- (Olaussen, 2016). In fact, comprehension
na and mon-key) (Moats, 2009). They also of complex language is the best predic-
begin to recognize when words rhyme tor of reading comprehension. During the
(e.g., hat-cat). preschool years, children also develop
As children grow, phonological an understanding of simple narratives
awareness increases and more complex or stories. Vocabulary develops as chil-
phonological awareness tasks are mas- dren learn new words from books. This,
tered. Earlier tasks typically involve in turn, feeds the growth of a larger and
matching letters (i.e., Can you find more varied vocabulary along with the
another “G”?), blending (i.e., What word ability to retell events.
does /b/-/i/-/n/ make?), and adding
sounds to form new words (i.e., add /s/
Very early print awareness begins
to the beginning of the word top). Later
to appear when children develop
developing phonological tasks involve
an interest in print and realize that
analysis, such as counting the number
print carries meaning (Justice &
of segments in words (i.e., How many
Ezell, 2004). They first begin with an
sounds are in the word cough?), segment-
understanding of the letters in their
ing (i.e., Say each sound in the word sun),
own names and, in this way, learn
and deleting sounds (i.e., Say spot without
that alphabet letters are “special”
the /s/) (Yopp & Yopp, 2009).
(Wood, 2007).
Supporting
Preschool
Phonological Narrative Literacy
Print Concepts Awareness Spelling Vocabulary Development Writing Development
• Interest in • Enjoys • Scribbling • Ever- • Retells stories • Starts out • A literacy-rich
print playing with common expanding that stay scribbling, environment
the sounds vocabulary for mostly on which turns
• Groups of • May use letter • Book sharing
in words and words in their topic into writing
letters have symbols but no or dialogic
songs environment that looks like
meaning sound symbol • Relates stories reading
letters and
• Can separate correspondence • Able to use to personal
• Turns pages words • Pointing out
sentences into subordinating experience
one at a time • May be able to details about
183
words and and • Will interpret
spell name • By age 4, print
• Looks from words into coordinating his or her
answers wh-
left to right syllables • Direction of words to form writing and • Songs
questions
and top to writing on more complex drawing for
• Knows words about • Fingerplay
bottom page sentences others to
are made of read-aloud that promotes
form a whole
sounds • Some letter stories sound
meaning
sound matches play and
• Produces
by age 4 manipulation
words that
of the sounds
rhyme
in words
• Dramatic play
• Varied writing
experiences
184 Introduction to Language Development
organization of text structure for narrative various types of texts, along with the rela-
(story) elements of fiction follow: tionship among these ideas. With knowl-
edge of the framework of text structure,
Characters: People involved in the children can comprehend how words
story and sentences are arranged within varied
types of texts, from a simple grocery list to
Setting: Places where the action the popular Harry Potter series. For exam-
occurs ple, children must organize their thinking
Problem: Challenges that the charac- to match the thought of the author of the
ters face text and arrive at an understanding of the
sequence of events and the motivations of
Solution: How the challenge is the characters in narratives (i.e., the rea-
resolved sons for their actions). Children without
Plot: Events that make up a story exposure to text structure may approach
reading without a basic framework or
As stories are read to preschoolers, the plan which makes comprehension of the
narrative elements become expected and story more difficult.
start to be included in their retelling. Other
types of text structure related to nonfiction
Metalinguistic abilities are an inte-
are incorporated in the same way. With
gral part of language and literacy
exposure, these formats become familiar
learning, because children must be
and the framework for their structure is
aware of how to determine word
incorporated into the preschoolers’ reper-
meaning. In terms of word meaning
toire. Here are some examples of the fea-
(semantics), readers often consciously
tures and organization of the text struc-
wonder about the meaning of an
ture for nonfiction:
unfamiliar word. They may try to
decipher the word in context (i.e., by
Cause and effect: A discussion of how
determining the meaning via other
one action can cause another action to
words that surround it) or look it up
occur
in a dictionary.
Sequence of events: The chronological
order of actions or events
Description: A topic that is explained
in terms of characteristics, features, Supporting Literacy
and examples Development in the
Comparison and contrast: An expla- Preschool Years
nation of how two or more events are
alike and/or different Support for literacy skills in the preschool
years is intended to ensure that a child
Knowledge of text structure supports has a variety of literacy experiences. Dur-
children’s comprehension of both fiction ing this stage of development, children
and nonfiction texts by providing them are exposed to varying text structures
with the format for the ideas presented in and are given the opportunity to engage
7. The Development of Literacy Skills 185
Koppenhaver, Erickson, & Skotko, 2001; and the plot). The child and adult
van Kleeck, Vander Woude, & Hammett, could also discuss how the content
2006; Whitehurst et al., 1994; Zevenber- relates to their lives and discuss the
gen, Whitehurst, & Zevenbergen, 2003; new words that they have encoun-
Ziolkowski & Goldstein, 2008): tered, along with what they would
like to read the next time.
◆ Before reading, consider the choice
of book being read. The content and
Shared interactive reading should be
length of the book and the complexity
done frequently and routinely to help
of the language should be a good
the child learn about the organization
match with the child’s interest,
of books and the text structure found
attention span, and comprehension
in them. New vocabulary words
abilities. A child should be encour-
should be discussed as they appear
aged to make predictions about the
in the text, along with periodic ques-
book’s content from its cover.
tions and comments about the story
◆ During reading, it is important that
(Huebner, 2000; van Kleeck, 2008).
the adult make the experience a posi-
Indicating aspects of print during
tive one by reading with expression
reading, such as pointing to words
and interest. With unfamiliar books,
while reading, has been shown to
the adult should do more of the
have a positive effect on reading
talking. As the child becomes more
acquisition (Pentimonti et al., 2012).
familiar with the book, the balance
should shift to the child (Whitehurst
et al., 1994). Adults should periodi-
cally pause to encourage commenting Phonological Awareness Activities
by the child. When the child volun-
teers a comment, the comment could Playing with sounds helps build the
be expanded. Fill-in-the-blanks (e.g., phonological abilities needed when for-
I think he is going to ___), wh-questions mal reading instruction begins (Phillips,
(e.g., who, what, where,and why), or Clancy-Menchetti, & Lonigan, 2008). Songs,
prediction questions (e.g., What do poems, alliterative games, and rhyming
you think will happen next?) are useful books help provide early experiences with
to encourage the child to repeat the manipulating sound. For young children,
expanded comment or fill in new these phonological awareness activities
information. Point out features of should not be seen as schoolwork but as
print that would be special to the an extension of play (Yopp & Yopp, 2009).
child, such as the letters in their name.
This kind of active interaction should
be periodic so it does not interrupt the Sociodramatic Play Experiences
meaning of the book.
◆ After reading, it is important to talk Sociodramatic play experiences are also
about the story that has been read. foundational for successful literacy devel-
Elements of text structure should be opment (Vygotsky, 1967). In sociodramatic
included when appropriate (e.g., char- play, children use an object to represent
acters, settings, problems, solutions, something other than what it is (e.g., a
7. The Development of Literacy Skills 187
box for a car or a block for a telephone). literacy development in both monolin-
The ability to substitute or represent one gual and bilingual children (Banerjee,
thing for another is a rung on the ladder Alsalman, & Alqafari, 2016; Eisenchlas,
to realizing that letters grouped together Schalley, & Moyes, 2016).
can represent the spoken word. In other
words, children realize that alphabet let-
ters are symbols that represent spoken Technology and Literacy
sounds and that these letters can be con-
nected to represent words. Symbolic play Despite mixed feelings by many on the
also encourages the language growth subject, the impact of technology on liter-
needed in literacy attainment (Wilford, acy must be recognized. Children are now
2000). Sociodramatic play has six ingredi- exposed to digital media from a young
ents, according to Smilansky (1968). These age (Kozminsky & Asher-Sadon, 2013).
ingredients are: (1) make-believing using Young children are frequently using Inter-
objects, (2) assuming a make-believe role, net applications, such as Starfall.com and
(3) make-believing about a situation or PBS.kids, which read stories to them or
action, (4) persisting or being able to con- present phonological awareness and pho-
tinue the play in face of challenges, (5) nic games. In the classroom, technology is
using language to communicate the con- being used as teaching aids. Whiteboards
text of play, and (6) interacting socially and computers are being used to motivate,
while playing. For example, children provide greater visual supports for the
were observed in a preschool classroom concepts being taught, and monitor prog-
acting out a book called Mrs. Wishy Washy ress. Research on this practice produces
that they had previously read as a class. varied results. For instance, Dennis, Wha-
This is a story about a farmwoman who lon, Kraut, and Herron (2016) studied the
washes her animals but they keep getting effects of using iPads in teaching vocabu-
dirty. The teacher had the objects of the lary. They found that both digital and non-
farm animals, a play bathtub, and a brown digital approaches were effective. Korat
towel out in the reading center. The chil- and Segal-Drori (2016) compared e-book
dren pretended to be the animals and the versus printed book reading and found that
farm woman. They would get the animals the e-book showed more positive effects.
“dirty” by throwing them on the brown
towel and repeating repetitive lines in the
book like, “Oh, lovely mud!” One child Literacy Development
even suggested getting the animals dirty
in the Elementary
by coloring them with water-based mark-
ers. When they couldn’t find any mark-
School Years
ers, they agree to pretend. They worked
together enacting the story many times The elementary school years mark a time
and changing roles. This play context of enormous growth in literacy develop-
helped cement the important language ment (Blachman, 1997; Chall, 1996; Kad-
and literacy factors discussed, such as eravek & Justice, 2004; Shipley & McAfee,
symbol development, character perspec- 2009; Tompkins, 2003; Wood, 2007) (Tables
tive, and expressive vocabulary. Socio- 7–2 and 7–3). Children go from identifying
dramatic play has been found to benefit sound and letter pairings in kindergarten to
Table 7–2. Literacy Development from Kindergarten Through Grade 2
Phonological
Grade Awareness Spelling Vocabulary Fluency Comprehension Writing
K • Segments onset • Knows the letters • Can talk about • Expands • Sight reads • Predicts what is
and rime (m and their sounds things that are vocabulary high-frequency next in stories
followed by -an) • Identifies all not physically using more words and • Answers
• Finds words that upper- and present words not in some CVC questions about
start with the same lowercase letters • Knows about immediate words read-aloud stories
phoneme • Can identify 2,000 to 3,000 environment • Draws and writes
• Blend sounds words in the words
together same word family
1 • Changes • Understands that • Knows about • Creates • Answers • Begins with
phonemes by words have a 2,000 to 3,000 meaning questions capital letters
adding, deleting, distinct spelling words while reading about text • Ends with period
188
or substituting • Spells by • Understands • Rereads to • Follows • Spacing irregular
phonemes sounding out the word get words simple written
• Has more advanced • Spells CVC and relations of right instructions
abilities to blend sight words antonyms and
sounds together synonyms
2 • Reads longer • Traditional • Uses context • Reading • Sequences • Writes narrative
words by sounding spelling increases of reading to speed events of story and expository
out using phonic • Consonant blends help decode increases • Uses context text with model
abilities and digraphs are words clues to help • Variety of
• Reads words acquired • Begins to use comprehension sentence forms
with one and two • Some root words, • Writing has
syllables morphological prefixes, and beginning,
structures are suffixes to middle, and end
used decode words • Legible writing
• Regular spacing
Table 7–3. Literacy Development from Grades 3 Through 10
4–6 • Identifies • Uses vocabulary • Fluent reading • Makes inferences • Organizes writing
misspellings by effectively in writing • Understands an from text into beginning,
using orthographic middle, and end
189
• Knows between increasing number • Can summarize and
knowledge 5,000 and 8,000 of text structures paraphrase • Main idea is evident
• Applies inflectional words • Develops characters
endings and plots
• Uses syllabication • Reviews and revises
7–10 • Uses phonological, • Attains vocabulary • Reads fluently for • Reads • Complex sentences
orthographic, needed in content learning and for independently for in writing
and morphologic areas entertainment new knowledge and • Coherent and
knowledge to spell research projects cohesive writing
• Latin and Greek • A variety of text
affixes and root structures are
words explored
• Etymologies
190 Introduction to Language Development
edge that children possess when entering change or exaggerate meaning because
school (Cervetti, Wright, & Hwang, 2016). they are grouped together). The first
Differences are likely related to the expe- grader uses this vocabulary to gather
rience base of the children and the fre- comprehension clues about pictures,
quency of words the children are expos- titles, and headings within a book. He or
ed to at home. In fact, vocabulary size in she can make accurate predictions using
first grade is a predictor of reading com- this information.
prehension in the eleventh grade (Cun- In the second grade, language skills
ningham & Stanovich, 1997). Another continue to expand and children are able
factor in reading comprehension and to identify root words (stand), prefixes
vocabulary development is the amount of (mis-), and suffixes (-ing). This is an impor-
reading experience. For example, expo- tant step in helping the child move away
sure to new words enhances children’s from sound-by-sound reading into more
memory for the pronunciation, spelling, fluent comprehension of text and words
and meaning of that word (Rosenthal & (e.g., misunderstanding). Second graders
Ehri, 2008). Because of the differences also have more fully developed narra-
related to their literary experience, the tives (Stadler & Ward, 2005). They can cre-
developmental ranges presented here are ate a full episode including setting, plot,
only an estimate of typically developing character, and resolution. Second graders
children. start to comprehend written text without
In kindergarten, the child’s ability to the aid of an adult (Wood, 2007). They
read and discuss decontextualized ideas become more independent in their read-
expands. Typically, topics discussed in ing and new word learning. They may
the classroom are not physically present. use dictionaries and other resources to
For example, a preschool-age child may support comprehension. As they mature
talk about a policeman when he sees a through elementary school, children are
policeman on the street. In the kindergar- able to comprehend lengthier texts, such
ten classroom, a discussion might be held as books with chapters.
about community helpers, such as police- By the fourth grade, independent
men and firemen, but they need not be reading is well developed (Wood, 2007).
present for this discussion to occur. Ideas By the fifth grade, children’s vocabulary
are discussed using oral language, pic- continues to develop and they become
tures, and books. The kindergartner also more interested in exploring nonfiction
expands his or her ability to tell stories or reading and enjoy biographies.
narratives that follow a sequential order
of events (Stadler & Ward, 2005). Spelling
It is estimated that a first grader
acquires 2,000 to 3,000 words and will Learning about spelling supports read-
learn about 3,000 words a year in the fol- ing development by increasing children’s
lowing years (Carlisle & Katz, 2005). By knowledge of phonemic awareness, in-
the third grade, vocabulary continues to creasing their knowledge of the alphabetic
develop and children are beginning to principle, and making sight words easier
understand complex word relationships. to remember. Recent studies have shown
Children enjoy nonliteral language, such the importance of formal spelling instruc-
as humor, idioms, and early figurative tion (Graham & Santangelo, 2014). The
language (e.g., groups of words that development of spelling involves a blend
192 Introduction to Language Development
that the reader apply higher cognitive lowercase letters. Although there is vari-
processes to comprehension, rather than ability, basic writing conventions are fol-
the lower level processes assigned to lowed, such as using capital letters when
recognizing individual words (Stanov- appropriate and ending with a period.
ich, Cunningham, & Freeman, 2009). The By the second grade, children still rely
fluent reader holds sequences of words in on lines to guide their placement of letters
short-term memory, the site of operation but writing has become more automatic.
of comprehension processes on the words The diminished motor demands help chil-
that have been read. This process leads to dren focus more on the content in their writ-
meaningful phrasing while reading and to ten efforts. By this stage of development,
the integration of words into a meaning- connected writing expands and children’s
ful conceptual structure that can be stored written essays have a beginning, middle,
in long-term memory. In short, the more and end (Wood, 2007). They develop more
fluent the reader, the less chance for mis- interest in writing expository text structure
interpretation of the text (Rubin, 2016). or informational assignments.
more than one episode (e.g., a story within Grammatical forms: The little girl ran
another story). They continue to expand quickly around the track.
their enjoyment of different written genres
through poetry writing, cartooning, and Adept use of cohesive ties helps writ-
journaling (Wood, 2007). Their writing ing grow in coherence and increases the
shows more awareness of who will read clarity of the writing as the complexity
what they have written. increases (Dyson & Freedman, 2003). Both
Because oral language and written abilities grow throughout children’s lives
language are so closely connected, chil- and well into adulthood.
dren’s oral language feeds the complexity
of their written language. Their increasing
language skills are especially important in Supporting Literacy
the development of cohesion and coher- Development in the
ence in their writing. Cohesion is how the Elementary School Years
ideas relate to each other. A paper with
good cohesion is comprehensible and
A child’s literacy program in the elemen-
consistent. One thought naturally leads
tary school years should include five areas
to another. Coherence can be conceived as
recommended by the National Read-
the grammatical and lexical links from one
ing Panel (NICHD, 2000): (1) phonemic
part of a text to another. This includes use
awareness, (2) phonics, (3) fluency, (4)
of synonyms (words with the same mean-
vocabulary, and (5) text comprehension.
ing), lexical sets (a set of words with the
The child’s reading program should be
same topic, function, or form), pronouns
balanced, integrating all areas that play a
(words that replace nouns), verb tenses
role in literacy development, rather than a
(verb forms that express the time an action
focused concentration on one or the other.
took place), time references (words that
indicate when an event occurs, occurred,
or will occur), and grammatical forms Phonemic Awareness
(proper nouns, adjectives, prepositional
phrases, and relative clauses), as shown Phonemic awareness is an aspect of pho-
in the following examples: nological awareness that deals with the
phoneme. As stated in Chapters 1 and 3,
Synonyms: Myths often narrate a phoneme is the smallest sound unit of
historical beliefs. These narratives language. Whereas younger children deal
tell a story about what some people with larger units like words and syllables,
believe. school-age children deal with phonemes.
Phonemic awareness helps children real-
Lexical sets: We were looking for the ize that sounds can be put together to
lost cat. This feline was our pet. form words. Meaningful activities given
Pronouns: Peter was lost and he to beginning readers provide practice
didn’t know where he was. with segmenting and blending individ-
ual sounds (Torgesen et al., 2001). Once
Verb tenses: He went yesterday and
children become aware of the individual
decided to go again tomorrow.
sounds in words, they are able to under-
Time references: First, he ate; next, he stand blending and segmenting sounds
took a nap; and then he watched TV. in words. Segmenting involves break-
196 Introduction to Language Development
ing words into syllables (e.g., ba-na-na) an experienced reader reads the book on
or individual sounds (e.g., cat = c-a-t), an audiotape. As the child becomes more
whereas blending involves combining fluent, he or she could read in concert
individual sounds to produce a word with the audiobook and then indepen-
(e.g., c-a-t = cat). dently. Readers’ theater allows students
to rehearse a play that comes from their
reading. The script is then performed for
Phonics classmates with a minimum of prepara-
tion or props. Because it is in play form, it
Whereas phonemic awareness deals
is a natural vehicle to increase fluent read-
with spoken language sounds, phonics
ing presentation.
describes the relationship between pho-
nemes (sounds) and graphemes (writ-
ten language). In other words, phonics
Vocabulary
teaches the child the connection between
the sound that the phoneme makes and
Vocabulary is learned both incidentally
the letter representation. When present-
(implicitly) and by direct teaching (explic-
ing phonemic awareness activities, the
itly) (Nagy & Herman, 1985). Some word
connections to the grapheme(s) or the
meanings are taught explicitly. Explicit
written letter or letters that correspond
word learning strategies include pre-
with sounds should be made obvious to
teaching vocabulary words, repeated ex-
the child (NICHD, 2000; Torgesen et al.,
posure to vocabulary words, the key word
2001). Phonics should be explicitly and
method, word maps, the Cloze procedure,
systematically taught and children should
and root analysis. Even with the use of
be encouraged to use their phonic skills
these strategies, it is impossible for teach-
when reading or writing (NICHD, 2000).
ers to directly teach all the word meanings
needed. Therefore, students must be able
Reading Fluency to learn new words incidentally from oral
language or by inferring meaning from
Gaining fluency skills depends both on context when reading. Teachers can sup-
exposure to models of fluent reading and port incidental word learning, however,
on experience with reading aloud. There by inspiring interest and inquisitiveness
are numerous ways of providing repeated about learning new words. Modeling
experiences, such as student–adult read- word-learning strategies and interest in
ing, partner reading, choral reading, tape- word learning can help capitalize on inci-
assisted reading, and readers’ theater. dental word learning while students are
Repeated readings have been shown to reading independently (NICHD, 2000).
be effective in typically developing chil-
dren, children with learning disabilities,
and children learning a second language Strategies That Support
(Rubin, 2016). In student–adult reading Reading Comprehension
and partner reading, the readers take
turns reading aloud, whereas in choral Vocabulary knowledge is not all there is to
reading, the whole class reads together reading comprehension. Understanding
at the same time. Tape-assisted reading what is read takes more than just know-
allows the student to read along while ing the individual word meanings. Good
7. The Development of Literacy Skills 197
readers think about meaning as they are (Kervin & Mantei, 2016). The right bal-
reading, integrating the written text with ance between these technologies is a con-
what they already know. stant issue for teachers and is impacted
There are many strategies that aid by the technology available and by their
reading comprehension. These strate- attitudes and beliefs about new technolo-
gies include using graphic organizers, gies (Hew & Brush, 2007).
answering and asking questions about
what was read, discussing text structure,
and summarizing texts (NICHD, 2000).
Literacy Development
One method incorporates four of these
strategies (Palincsar & Brown, 1986). This
in Adolescence
method is called Reciprocal Teaching. In
this method, the more experienced reader This review highlights several common
models and encourages asking ques- instructional elements — such as explicit
tions about what is being read, clarifying instruction in comprehension, writing,
unknown words, predicting what might and cooperative learning — that could
happen next, and summarizing or using be explored in future research. Common
self-review. Another strategy, Question instructional elements can help inform
Answer Relationship, has been found to increasingly effective practices. Sys-
support reading comprehension and the tematic combinations of these elements
ability to answer questions (Green, 2016). and organizational components (such
In this strategy, four types of comprehen- as extended instruction or professional
sion questions are taught (right there, think development) could continue to be inves-
and search, the author and you, and on your tigated to determine which elements are
own). Knowing the expectation of the necessary and how many are sufficient to
question helps readers determine the cor- demonstrate positive effects (Biancarosa
rect source for the answer. & Snow, 2006.) By adolescence, children
are fluent readers, but this does not mean
that their literacy development is com-
Technology and plete (see Table 7–3). To meet the expec-
School-Age Children tations in the content areas in the upper
grades, it is imperative that their vocabu-
Technology is being increasingly used to lary, comprehension, fluency, and writing
address literacy instruction in our schools abilities continue to grow and expand. In
(International Reading Association, 2001). this section, growth in these areas is high-
Text formats are increasingly presented lighted along with methods to support
via multimedia or hyperlinks and are adolescents’ continued literacy growth.
impacting the way students integrate
information (Warschauer, 2006). Sources
for information are timely and searches Genre,Vocabulary, and
for information have innovative formats. Reading Comprehension
Social opportunities are also available in
the use of email, texts, and chats. Writ- Throughout adolescence, children learn
ing is increasingly expressed using digi- to enjoy, use, and comprehend a variety
tal means and has changed the way that of genres or types of text, both fiction and
texts are planned, produced, and shared nonfiction (Wood, 2007). In middle school,
198 Introduction to Language Development
they begin reading newspapers, maga- lary of the discipline being studied (Sil-
zines, and biographies. These continue in liman & Scott, 2009). For instance, let us
high school along with song lyrics, poetry, consider this sample question taken from
drama, short stories, and novels. As noted a high school science state examination
earlier, familiarity with different types of (NYSED, 2011):
text structure supports the comprehen-
sion of a text. This is especially helpful if When the bacterium, Serratia marces-
the content of the text is unfamiliar to the cens, is grown on a sterile culture medium
reader (Wallach & Butler, 1994). in a petri dish at 30°C, the bacterial colo-
nies are cream colored. When this same
bacterium is cultured under identical con-
Knowing different kinds of text struc-
ditions, except at a temperature of 25°C,
ture also helps support vocabulary
the colonies are brick red. This difference
development. When a student reads
in color is most likely due to the effect of
about the same subject in a variety of
temperature on the expression of the gene
types of print, there is more frequent
for color.
exposure to related vocabulary. This
helps the adolescent to learn a variety
The preceding passage contains ad-
of high-frequency (more common)
vanced vocabulary, such as sterile, medium,
and low-frequency (less common)
and expression, along with specialized sci-
words related to the subject (Adams,
entific vocabulary, such as bacterium, cul-
2011).
ture, and gene. This text also presents the
adolescent reader with increased syntactic
Along with varying text structure, com- complexity: The second sentence contains
prehension in content areas depends on a dependent clause and a phrase, in addi-
being able to master the oral and written tion to the independent clause. These ele-
language requirements presented in the ments increase the length of the sentence
varied subject areas found in different and the density of ideas being communi-
texts (Beck & Jeffrey, 2009). For example, cated. Thus, the adolescent reader must
each academic subject area has its own possess good language skills when faced
academic language register. An academic with this level of complexity.
register is a specialized way of speak- Social literacy demands are also
ing or writing in accord with disciplin- increasing during this period, given the
ary requirements (Wilkinson & Silliman, variety of technologies that are available
2008). Reading and understanding social and widely used, such as texting, instant
studies is quite different from reading and messaging, and other social networking
understanding science. media. There is greater motivation to fit
As adolescents travel through middle in with peers. Consequently, the adoles-
school and high school, a significant per- cent learns to meet the language demands
centage of their new vocabulary develop- found in humor and sarcasm. The closely
ment is related to their subject study. Con- related skills involved in the comprehen-
tent area texts contain vocabulary that is sion of figurative language (e.g., simile,
challenging because it is often more schol- metaphor, personification, hyperbole) are
arly and includes the specialized vocabu- also increasing (Wood, 2007).
7. The Development of Literacy Skills 199
Goodrich, S., Mudrick, H., & Robinson, J. riculum: A position statement. Retrieved from
(2015). The transition from early child care www.reading.org/downloads/positions/
to preschool: Emerging toddler skills and ps1048_technol ogy.pdf
readiness for group-based learning. Early Justice, L. (2006). Communication sciences and
Education and Development, 26(7), 1035–1056. disorders: An introduction. Upper Saddle
Graham, S., & Sandmel, K. (2011). The process River, NJ: Pearson Education.
writing approach: A meta-analysis. Journal Justice, L., & Ezell, H. (2004). Print-referencing:
of Educational Research, 104, 396–407. An emergent literacy enhancement tech-
Graham, S., & Santangelo, T. (2014). Does spell- nique and its clinical applications. Language,
ing instruction make students better spell- Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools, 35,
ers, readers, and writers? A meta-analytic 185–193.
review. Reading and Writing: An Interdisci- Justice, L. M., Kaderavek, J., Bowles, R., &
plinary Journal, 27(9), 1703–1743. Grimm, K. (2005). Language impairment,
Green, S. (2016). Two for one: Using QAR to parent-child shared reading, and phono-
increase reading comprehension and improve logical awareness: A feasibility study. Top-
test scores. Retrieved from http://online ics in Early Childhood Special Education, 25 (3)
library.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/trtr.1466/ 143–156.
abstract Kaderavek, J., & Justice, L. (2004). Embedded-
Guo, Y., Justice, L., Kaderavek, J., & McGinty, explicit emergent literacy: II. Goal selection
A. (2012). The literacy environment of pre- and implementations in the early child-
school classrooms: Contributions to chil- hood classroom. Language, Speech, and Hear-
dren’s emergent literacy growth. Journal of ing Services in Schools, 35, 212–228.
Research in Reading, 35, 308–327. Kamhi, A. (2009). Prologue: The case for the
Harste, J. C., Woodward, V. A., & Burke, C. L. narrow view of reading. Language, Speech,
(1984). Language stories and literacy lessons. and Hearing Services in Schools, 40(2), 174–177.
Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann Educational Kamil, M. L., Borman, G. D., Dole, J., Kral,
Books. C. C., Salinger, T., & Torgesen, J. (2008).
Hedberg, N. L., & Westby, C. E. (1993). Ana- Improving adolescent literacy: Effective class-
lyzing storytelling skills: Theory to practice. room and intervention practices: A practice
Tucson, AZ: Communication Skill Builders. guide (NCEE #2008-4027). Washington, DC:
Herrera, S., Truckenmiller, A. J., & Foorman, B. National Center for Education Evaluation
R. (2016). Summary of 20 years of research on and Regional Assistance, Institute of Edu-
the effectiveness of adolescent literacy programs cation Sciences, U.S. Department of Edu-
and practices. Retrieved from https://ies. cation. Retrieved from http://ies.ed.gov/
ed.gov/ncee/edlabs/regions/southeast/ ncee/wwc
pdf/REL_2016178.pdf Kervin, L., & Mantei, J. (2016). Digital writing
Hew, K. F., & Brush, T. (2007). Integrating practices: A close look at one grade-three
technology into K–12 teaching and learn- author. Literacy, 50(3), 133–140.
ing: Current knowledge gaps and recom- Koppenhaver, D. A., Erickson, K. A., & Skotko,
mendations for future research. Education B. G. (2001). Supporting communication of
Technology and Research Development, 55, girls with Rett syndrome and their mothers
223–252. in storybook readings. International Journal
Huebner, C. E. (2000). Promoting toddlers’ lan- of Disability, Development, and Education,
guage development through community- 48(4), 395–410.
based intervention. Journal of Applied Devel- Korat, O., & Segal-Drori, O. (2016). E-book and
opmental Psychology, 21(5), 513–535. printed book reading in different contexts
International Reading Association. (2001). as emergent literacy facilitator. Early Educa-
Integrating literacy and technology in the cur- tion and Development, 27(4), 532–550.
204 Introduction to Language Development
Roskos, K. A., & Neuman, S. B. (2001). Envi- Intensive remedial instruction for children
ronment and its influences for early literacy with severe reading disabilities: Immediate
teaching and learning. In S. B. Neuman & and long-term outcomes from two instruc-
D. K. Dickinson (Eds.), Handbook of early lit- tional approaches. Journal of Learning Dis-
eracy research (pp. 281–294). New York, NY: abilities, 34, 33–58.
Guilford Press. Towson, J. A., Gallagher, P. A., & Bingham, G.
Rubin, D. I. (2016). Growth in oral reading flu- E. (2016). Dialogic reading: Language and
ency of Spanish ELL students with learning preliteracy outcomes for young children
disabilities. Intervention in School and Clinic, with disabilities. Journal of Early Interven-
52(1), 34–38. tion, 38(4), 230–246.
Shipley, K. G., & McAfee, J. G. (2009). Assess- Troia, G., Stone, C., Silliman, E., Ehren, B., &
ment in speech-language pathology: A resource Wallach, G. (2014). Handbook of language
manual. Florence, KY: Cengage. and literacy: Development and disorders. New
Silliman, E. R., & Scott, C. M. (2009). Research- York, NY: Guilford Press.
based oral language intervention routes to van Druten-Frietman, L., Strating, H., Denes-
the academic language of literacy: Finding sen, E., & Verhoeven, L. (2016). Interactive
the right road. In S. Rosenfield & V. W. Ber- storybook-based intervention effects on kin-
ninger (Eds.), Implementing evidence-based dergartners’ language development. Journal
academic interventions in school settings (pp. of Early Intervention, 38(4), 212–229.
107–145). New York, NY: Oxford University van Kleeck, A. (1994). Metalinguistic develop-
Press. ment. In G. Wallach & K. Butler (Eds.), Lan-
Smilansky, S. (1968). The effects of sociodramatic guage learning disabilities in school-age chil-
play on disadvantaged preschool children. Lon- dren and adolescents. New York, NY: Merrill.
don, UK: Wiley. van Kleeck, A. (2006). Fostering inferential
Stadler, M. A., & Ward, G. C. (2005). Support- language during book sharing with pre-
ing the narrative development of young readers: A foundation for later text compre-
children. Early Childhood Education Journal, hension strategies. In A. van Kleeck (Ed.),
33(2), 73–80. Sharing books and stories to promote language
Stanovich, K. E., Cunningham, A. E., & Free- and literacy (pp. 269–317). San Diego, CA:
man, D. J. (2009). Intelligence, cognitive Plural.
skills, and early reading progress. Interna- van Kleeck, A. (2008). Providing preschool
tional Reading Association, 19(3), 278–303. foundations for later reading comprehen-
Storch, S. A., & Whitehurst, G. J. (2001). The sion: The importance of and ideas for tar-
role of family and home in the literacy geting inferencing in storybook-sharing
development of children from low-income interventions. Psychology in the Schools,
backgrounds. New Directions for Child and 45(7), 627–643.
Adolescent Development, 92, 53–71. van Kleeck, A., & Schuele, M. (1987). Precur-
Suortti, O., & Lipponen, L. (2016). Phonologi- sors to literacy: Normal development. Top-
cal awareness and emerging reading skills ics in Language Disorders, 7(2), 13–31.
of two- to five-year-old children. Early Child van Kleeck, A., Vander Woude, J., & Hammett,
Development and Care, 186(11), 1703–1721. L. (2006). Fostering literal and inferential
Teale, W., & Sulzby, E. (1986). Emergent literacy: language skills in Head Start preschoolers
Writing and reading. Norwood, NJ: Ablex. with language impairment using scripted
Tompkins, G. (2003). Literacy for the 21st cen- book-sharing discussions. American Journal
tury. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson of Speech-Language Pathology, 15(1), 85–95.
Education. Vygotsky, L. S. (1967). Play and its role in the
Torgesen, J., Alexander, A., Wagner, R., Rash mental development of the child. Soviet
otte, C., Voeller, K., & Conway, T. (2001). Psychology, 5, 6–18.
206 Introduction to Language Development
Walker, J., & Hauerwas, L. B. (2006). Develop- instruction in urban settings. In L. Wilkin-
ment of phonological, morphological, and son, L. Morrow, & V. Chou (Eds.), Improv-
orthographic knowledge in young spell- ing literacy achievement in urban schools:
ers: The case of inflected verbs. Reading and Critical elements in teacher preparation (pp.
Writing, 19, 819–843. 121–142). Newark, DE: International Read-
Wallach, G., & Butler, K. (1994). Language learn- ing Association.
ing disabilities in school-age children and ado- Wolfersberger, M. E., Reutzel, D. R., Sudweeks,
lescents. New York, NY: Merrill. R., & Fawson, P. C. (2004). Developing and
Warschauer, M. (2006). Laptops and literacy: validating the Classroom Literacy Environ-
Learning in the wireless classroom. New York, mental Profile (CLEP): A tool for examining
NY: Teachers College Press. the “print richness” of early childhood and
Westby, C. (1999). Assessing and facilitating elementary classrooms. Journal of Literacy
text comprehension problem. In H. W. Catts Research, 36(2), 211–272.
& A. G. Kamhi (Eds.), Language and reading Wood, C. (2007). Yardsticks: Children in the class-
disabilities (pp. 154–221). Boston, MA: Allyn room ages 4–14. Turner Falls, MA: Northeast
& Bacon. Foundation for Children.
Westerveld, M. (2016). A systematic review of Wright, D., & Ehri, L. C. (2007). Beginners
the literature on emergent literacy skills of remember orthography when they learn
preschool children with autism spectrum to read words: The case of doubled letters.
disorder. Journal of Special Education, 50(1), Applied Psycholinguistics, 28, 115–133.
1–37. Yopp, H. K., & Yopp, H. (2009). Phonological
Westerveld, M. F., Trembath, D., Shellshear, L., awareness is child’s play! Young Children,
& Paynter, J. (2016). A systematic review of 64(1), 12–18.
the literature on emergent literacy skills of Zevenbergen, A. A., & Whitehurst, C. J. (2003).
preschool children with autism spectrum. Dialogic reading: A shared picture book
Journal of Special Education, 50, 37–48. reading intervention for preschoolers. In
Whitehurst, G. J., Epstein, J. N., Angell, A. L., A. van Kleeck, S. A. Stahl, & E. B. Bauer
Payne, A. C., Crone, D. A., & Fischel, J. E. (Eds.), On reading books to children: Parents
(1994). Outcomes of an emergent literacy and teachers. Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.
intervention in Head Start. Journal of Educa- Zevenbergen, A. A., Whitehurst, G. J., & Zeven
tional Psychology, 86(4), 542–555. bergen, J. A. (2003). Effects of a shared-
Whitehurst, G. J., & Lonigan, C. J. (1998). Child reading intervention on the inclusion of
development and emergent literacy. Child evaluative devices in narratives of children
Development, 69(3), 848–872. from low-income families. Journal of Applied
Wilford, S. (2000). From play to literacy: Impli- Developmental Psychology, 24(1), 1–15.
cations for the classroom (Occasional paper Ziolkowski, R. A., & Goldstein, H. (2008). Effects
No. 2). Bronxville, NY: Child Development of an embedded phonological awareness
Institute, Sarah Lawrence College. intervention during repeated book reading
Wilkinson, L. C., & Silliman, E. R. (2008). Aca- on preschool children with language delays.
demic language proficiency and literacy Journal of Early Intervention, 31, 67–90.
8
Bilingual Children’s
Language Development:
Assessment and Intervention
Brian A. Goldstein
Case Study
There are almost 5 million children in the lations to provide them with evidence-
schools in the United States who are learn- based assessment and intervention when
ing English as a second language. Thus, these services are required. The purpose
it is essential that students majoring in of this chapter is to provide information
speech-language pathology programs on language development and disorders
acquire knowledge of bilingual popu- in bilingual children. Prior to reading this
207
208 Introduction to Language Development
children” (Nicoladis & Genesee, 1996, p. 264, of exposure to English, 40% of the sequen-
emphasis added). That is, the speech and tial bilinguals exhibited morphological
language skills of bilinguals are similar, skills within the normal range of mono-
although not identical, to those of mono- linguals, 65% for receptive vocabulary,
linguals in each constituent language and 90% for story grammar. Additionally,
(Goldstein, 2012). This result has been after an average of 8 months of exposure
found across various domains of language to English, overall consonant accuracy for
such as syntax (Paradis & Genesee, 1996) sequential bilinguals (ages 4;6 to 6;9) aver-
and phonology (e.g., Goldstein, Fabiano, aged 90% (Gilhool, Goldstein, Burrows, &
& Washington, 2005). Paradis, 2009). More specifically, conso-
It is important to point out, how- nant accuracy was less than 90% (average
ever, that bilingual children do not pro- of 83%) for only 2 of 10 children. These
ceed through the same linguistic stages at data show that even children who acquire
the same time in each language. Merino speech and language skills after expe-
(1992) found that the order of acquisi- rience in their first language approach
tion of grammatical forms was differ- monolingual norms after a relatively short
ent for monolinguals and bilinguals. For time period.
example, monolinguals first acquired the
active tense (e.g., ella come pan [she eats
bread]) followed by gender (gato rojo [cat Language Development
red]), plural (gatos [cats]), regular past
in Second-Language
tense (ella comió pan [she ate bread]), and
finally irregular past (ellos fueron a la casa
Acquisition
[they went home]). In contrast, bilingual
children first acquired the active tense fol- Children undergoing second-language
lowed by gender, present progressive (ella acquisition go through five primary stages
está comiendo [she is eating]), plural, and of speech and language development
finally regular past. Findings such as these (Hearne, 2000). It should be noted that
indicate that even though bilingual chil- these stages are meant to be general in
dren might show overall commensurate nature, given the known individual varia-
language skills with monolinguals, there tion of speech and language development
will be differences in those skills across of second-language learners (and all chil-
each constituent language. It is likely dren, in general).
that bilinguals will have skills that are
greater in one language over the other. For Stage I: Preproduction. In this stage,
example, bilinguals might exhibit more children often undergo a silent period.
advanced syntactic skills in Language A That is, they focus more on receptive
vs. Language B (Paradis et al., 2011). language (i.e., language comprehen-
The speech and language trajectory sion) than on expressive language
of children who acquire a second lan- (i.e., language production). The silent
guage after some facility with a first lan- period is relatively short — usually not
guage (i.e., sequential bilinguals) is some- more than 6 months (Tabors, 1997). It
what different from that of monolingual should be noted, however, that often
children in either language. For example, during this phase, children use some
Paradis (2007) found that after 21 months expressive language (in the second
8. Bilingual Children’s Language Development: Assessment and Intervention 213
language) with each other but less 5 to 7 years after introduction of the
so with adults in the environment second language), the children use
(Tabors, 1997). Also during this stage, specialized vocabulary related to
children respond to simple commands content areas, use English grammar
and have a receptive vocabulary of and vocabulary comparable to a
about 500 words. native speaker, and are able to actively
participate in grade level classroom
Stage II: Early Production. In this
activities.
stage (approximately 3 to 6 months
after introduction of the second
language), the children are still
focused more on receptive language Transfer and Code-Mixing
than on expressive language. Specifi-
cally, they are comprehending yes/
Bilingual children exhibit both acceleration
no and who/what/where questions.
and deceleration relative to monolingual
They typically use one- to three-word
development. They also show patterns of
phrases and formulaic expressions
transfer. Transfer is defined as language-
(gimme five). Their receptive and
specific features found in productions of
expressive vocabulary consists of
the other language (Paradis, 2001). This
approximately 1,000 words.
term is often used synonymously with
Stage III: Speech Emergence. In cross-linguistic effects. Cross-linguistic
this stage (approximately 6 months effects usually connote that the features
to 2 years after introduction of the are bidirectional; that is, from Language A
second language), the children to Language B and vice versa.
show increased comprehension and Transfer is a hallmark of bilingual
increased grammatical complexity, speech and language development. An
but exhibit grammatical errors; use example might be when a native Span-
simple sentences by expanding ish speaker produces red house as house
vocabulary; and have a receptive red because, in Spanish, nouns precede
and expressive vocabulary of around the adjectives that modify them. It should
3,000 words. be noted that features of transfer are vari-
able (Schnitzer & Krasinski, 1994, 1996),
Stage IV: Intermediate Fluency. In
occur in both languages (Gildersleeve-
this stage (approximately 3 years
Neumann et al., 2008), and are not equally
after introduction of the second
represented in both languages (Goldstein,
language), the children show
2008). From a practical point of view, fea-
improved comprehension, a receptive
tures of transfer are not true errors and
and expressive vocabulary of around
thus would not be treated if the bilingual
6,000 words, adequate face-to-face
child had a speech or language disorder
conversational skills, and more
and required intervention.
complex statements in which they
Code-mixing is the “use of phono-
express thoughts and opinions with
logical, lexical, morphosyntactic, or prag-
few grammatical errors.
matic patterns from two languages in the
Stage V: Advanced Language Profi- same utterance or stretch of conversation”
ciency. In this stage (approximately (Paradis et al., 2011, p. 89). According to
214 Introduction to Language Development
Paradis et al. (2011), there are a number of the same core group of words over
types of code-mixing: and over rather than using a robust
number of different words)
◆ Intra-utterance:. Alguien se murió en ◆ Increased number of false starts,
ese cuarto [someone died in that room] pauses, hesitation, and decreased
that he sleeps in. organizational skills.
◆ Inter-utterance:. Pa ¿me vas a
comprarun jugo? [are you going to buy Unfortunately, these characteristics often
me juice] It cos’ 25 cents. are similar to those features that signal a
◆ Mixing words:. Estamos como marido y true language disorder (i.e., not related
[we are like man and] woman. to learning a second language). It is pos-
◆ Mixing clauses:. You know how to swim sible, however, to stave off language
but no te tapa [it won’t be over your attrition with programs that support the
head] first language (Gutiérrez-Clellen, Simón
Cereijido, Restrepo, 2013; Restrepo &
As is the case with transfer, code-mix- Gray, 2012).
ing is a typical linguistic phenomenon in Features of language attrition should
bilinguals. Code-mixing does not mean not be confused with a true language dis-
that the bilingual speaker lacks control or order. That said, there is no doubt that
proficiency over the two languages. It is a bilingual speakers (be they simultaneous
natural occurrence in acquiring a second or sequential bilinguals) can exhibit a lan-
language. However, the more the bilin- guage disorder. What is interesting about
gual child’s parents code-mix, the more language disorders in these children is
likely it is that he or she will code-mix that they show commensurate language
(Lanza, 1992). skills to monolinguals with language im-
pairments (Paradis, 2005), and they exhibit
the same type and frequency of grammat-
ical errors as monolinguals with language
Language Loss/
impairments (Paradis, Crago, Genesee, &
Language Disorder Rice, 2003). Moreover, bilingual children
with Down syndrome (DS) showed com-
Another phenomenon typical in bilingual mensurate language skills to monolin-
speakers is language loss (also termed gual children with DS (Kay-Raining Bird
language attrition) (Anderson, 2012). Lan- et al., 2005), and bilingual children with
guage loss occurs when the speech and language impairments exhibited (pro-
language features of the first language are tracted) periods of plateaus or regressions
no longer utilized by the speaker because in grammatical development, just as did
he or she hears and uses less of the first monolinguals with language impairments
language over time. Examples of lan- (Kohnert, 2008).
guage loss include the following: Some speech-language pathologists
(SLPs) and other practitioners are often
◆ Deletion of grammatical markers (e.g., wary of providing intervention to bilin-
plural) gual children in their non-English lan-
◆ Decreased number of different guage. Their rationale is that bilingual
words (i.e., speakers will tend to use children with language disorders will be
8. Bilingual Children’s Language Development: Assessment and Intervention 215
even more “confused” by receiving ser- the family’s cultural background, who
vices in the non-English language. The can provide an “insider’s” informa-
evidence presented previously seems to tion on that culture and aid in the
obviate that concern. Both languages of interpretation of the family’s linguistic
the bilingual benefit from input in the and nonlinguistic characteristics.
two languages. As Kohnert (2008, pp. ◆ The structure of the non-English
143–144) says, “[a] disorder in bilinguals language: vocabulary, grammar,
is not caused by bilingualism or cured by word meaning, speech sounds, and
monolingualism.” pragmatics.
◆ Age of acquisition: Is the child a
simultaneous or sequential bilingual?
Assessment of Speech Also, at what age did the child begin
to hear and use each language?
and Language Disorders
◆ Language use: how often and with
in Bilingual Children whom each language is used.
◆ Language proficiency: how well each
Identification of bilingual children for language is used.
being at risk for language disorders (spe-
cifically semantics and syntax) is not pre- Once the case history is completed,
dicted by being bilingual (Peña, 2016; the SLP conducts testing to discern
Peña, Gillam, Bedore, & Bohman, 2011). whether the child has a speech or lan-
Thus, although being bilingual does not guage disorder and what the child’s
“cause” or exacerbate a speech or lan- strengths and weaknesses are in each of
guage disorder, it does complicate diag- the two languages. Testing can be either
nosing them differentially. formal or informal in nature. In speech-
In assessing all children, it is neces- language pathology, formal tests are often
sary for the SLP to complete a case history standardized. A standardized test is used
in which he or she begins to determine to measure a client’s performance in one
the presenting problem and the possible or more domains. That performance is
medical, psychosocial, and environmental then compared with that of a similar
factors related to the speech or language group on a measure that is not influenced
disorder. When a child is acquiring more by the person administering or interpret-
than one language (i.e., is not monolin- ing the test (Tomblin, 2000). This stan-
gual), the SLP must gather the following dardized procedure allows us to assume
additional information, specific to bilin- that differences in performance are based
gual children: on ability rather than on the testing proce-
dure. The difficulty in utilizing such tests
◆ The sociocultural characteristics of the with bilingual children is that they rarely
community: It is important to under- include bilingual children in the norma-
stand the culture of the family and the tive data. In fact, they usually are spe-
community (e.g., Lynch & Hanson, cifically excluded. Even for non-English
2011). The SLP might need a cultural tests, bilingual children are rarely included.
broker to aid in understanding the Finally, standardized tests that include
community’s culture. A cultural bilingual children do not test the full
broker is an individual, usually from range of bilingual skills (i.e., from “a little”
216 Introduction to Language Development
bilingual to “a lot” bilingual). Thus, there ◆ Testing beyond the test’s ceiling (i.e.,
are few standardized tests available to above the point where administration
use with bilingual children. In the con- of the test would stop if it were being
sideration of using standardized tests scored according to the instructions in
with bilingual children, it is important to the test manual)
determine if: ◆ Asking children to explain their
answers in order to determine if they
◆ The normative data include bilingual have understood the question
children. ◆ Utilizing informal checklists
◆ The bilingual children in the norma- (Roseberry-McKibbin, 2002) and
tive group are similar to the group parent questionnaires (Restrepo,
with whom you will use the test. 1998)
◆ Confidence intervals (i.e., the score a ◆ Comparing data from the child being
child would receive if he or she theo- evaluated with published data on
retically took the test multiple times) similar children
are provided. ◆ Focusing more on process-based
◆ The test manual reports data on: measures (rate and quality of
u Sensitivity (i.e., percentage of indi- “learning”) rather than on static
viduals correctly identified with a measures (Hwa-Froelich & Matsuo,
disorder) 2005; Peña & Quinn, 1997)
u Specificity (i.e., percentage of ◆ Analyzing narratives/conversational
individuals correctly identified as samples by measuring aspects, such
typically developing) as number of different words, number
of clauses per utterance, and cohesion
(Gutiérrez-Clellen, 2012)
Informal Assessment Procedures
What dynamic assessment allows the that should be avoided; that is, testing
assessor to do is to tap future skills, or the “don’ts.” These include:
child’s modifiability (i.e., change through
mediation) (Peña, 1996). Modifiability ◆ Don’t use norm-referenced tests only.
involves three factors: child responsive- ◆ Don’t use only a language sample
ness (how the child responds to and uses or multiple assessments to qualify
new information); examiner effort (quan- someone for services.
tity and quality of effort needed to make ◆ Don’t use tests administered in
a change); and transfer (generalization English only.
of new skills). All three factors are criti- ◆ Don’t assume that features of a
cal in determining if a child fails on a task second language are characteristics of
because of experience or ability. a disorder (overdiagnosis).
The format for dynamic assessment ◆ Don’t assume that errors related to a
is test-teach-retest. In the test phase, the true disorder are features of a second
examiner determines the child’s areas language (underdiagnosis).
of weakness and the base level of func- ◆ Translated tests should not be used
tioning, without any aid or assistance. In for the following reasons:
the teach phase, the assessor models the ◆ There are differences in structure
target behaviors and strategies in mean- and content of each language.
ingful contexts, makes the child aware ◆ Using translated tests implies
of how the strategies are to be applied, (mistakenly) that all children
allows the child to lead some of the time, receive similar socialization,
and increases demands as the skills are language input, and academic
mastered. In order to determine how the instruction in both languages.
child has progressed after the teach phase, ◆ Differences in the frequency of
she is retested, measuring examiner effort target words vary from language to
(i.e., how much aid is needed by indi- language.
viduals to maximize their performance), ◆ Grammatical forms may not be
child responsiveness (i.e., how rapidly the equivalent.
child changes in response to teaching), ◆ Such tests do not tap into a child’s
and transfer (i.e., the generalization of the ability to acquire language.
task to other tasks and other domains).
Dynamic assessment has been used suc-
cessfully to differentiate children’s lack of Interpreters and Translators
experience from their lack of ability (Peña,
Iglesias, & Lidz, 2001). In some sense, all SLPs are monolingual.
That is, no SLP can possibly speak every
language that her clients speak. It is esti-
Do’s and Don’ts mated that only 6% of certified SLPs meet
the definition of a bilingual service pro-
The process outlined previously indi- vider (ASHA, 2016). Thus, it is highly likely
cates the type of assessment that should that monolingual SLPs will be provid-
be completed with bilingual children. ing services to bilinguals. The American
Equally important is the kind of testing Speech-Language-Hearing Association
218 Introduction to Language Development
(ASHA) (1985) has outlined a number of and/or issues. The second phase is inter-
tasks that monolingual SLPs can perform action. During this phase, the SLP and the
with bilinguals, including: interpreter interact with the client and
her or his family. The role of the SLP dur-
◆ Testing in English ing this phase is to make observations on
◆ Performing an oral-peripheral exam the body language of the child and note
◆ Conducting hearing screenings if the interpreter uses too many words
◆ Completing nonverbal assessments when instructing the child. The interpre
◆ Conducting a family interview (with ter should record all responses and ask
an interpreter or translator) for clarification when questions arise.
◆ Being an advocate for the client and In the debriefing phase, the SLP and the
family interpreter review the outcomes. The SLP
reviews the interpreter’s impressions and
It is likely, however, that at some point the SLP and interpreter discuss any dif-
an SLP will need to utilize the services ficulties related to the process. All reports
of an interpreter (conveys information should state that an assessment was per-
from one language to another when the formed with the assistance of an inter-
message is oral) or a translator (conveys preter. In the end, the SLP makes the final
information from one language to another recommendations.
when the message is written) to assess a In summary, assessment for bilin-
bilingual child. Here we focus on inter- guals is complex and multidimensional. It
preters, that is, the individual who serves is far more important to describe in detail
as the bridge between the SLP and the the child’s skills in all domains in both
family/child (Langdon & Cheng, 2002). languages rather than trying to deter-
The use of an interpreter does not negate mine, for example, in which language
the role of the SLP. It is the SLP’s job to the child is “dominant.” Moreover, rather
construct the assessment session (and the than focusing on the type of bilingualism,
intervention) and to train the interpreter etiology of the disorder, or scores on a stan-
in how to work effectively. The training dardized assessment, focus should be on
of an interpreter should include not only behaviors, symptoms, and characteristics.
verbal interaction but also nonverbal cues,
cultural effects, and contextual knowl-
edge (i.e., how the environment of the
assessment has shaped the interaction).
Intervention
Interpreters should be professionals who
regularly serve in this role. It is not appro- Although there have been several research
priate to have friends, neighbors, siblings, studies that focus on the assessment of
or relatives serve in this role because they bilingual children, there are far fewer
do not have the objectivity needed to pro- related to intervention for bilingual chil-
vide such services. dren with speech and language disorders
Langdon and Cheng (2002) outline (e.g., Thordardottir, Cloutier, Ménard,
a three-step process for the session. The Pelland-Blais, & Rvachew, 2016). This
first phase is termed briefing. In this phase, relative lack of studies has made it diffi-
the SLP plans the session, trains the inter- cult to apply principles of evidence-based
preter, and reviews the critical questions practice (EBP) to such children. EBP is an
8. Bilingual Children’s Language Development: Assessment and Intervention 219
speakers (2nd ed., pp. 233–249). Baltimore, Lopez, L., & Greenfield, D. (2004). The cross-
MD: Brookes. linguistic transfer of phonological skills
Gutiérrez-Clellen, V., Simón Cereijido, G., & of Hispanic Head Start children. Bilingual
Restrepo, M. A. (2013). Improving the vocabu- Research Journal, 28, 1–18.
lary and oral language of bilingual Latino pre- Lynch, E., & Hanson, M. (Eds.). (2011). Develop-
schoolers: An intervention for speech-language ing cross-cultural competence: A guide for work-
pathologists. San Diego, CA: Plural. ing with children and their families (4th ed.).
Hearne, D. (2000). Teaching 2nd language learn- Baltimore, MD: Brookes.
ers with learning disabilities. Oceanside, CA: MacSwan, J., & Rolstad, K. (2006). How lan-
Academic Communication Associates. guage proficiency tests mislead us about
Hwa-Froelich, D. A., & Matsuo, H. (2005). ability: Implications for English language
Vietnamese children and language-based learner placement in special education.
processing tasks. Language, Speech, and Teachers College Record, 108(11), 2304–2328.
Hearing Services in Schools, 36, 230–243. McLaughlin, B. (1984). Second language acquisi-
Justice, L. M., & Fey, M. E. (2004, September tion in childhood: Volume 1. Preschool children
21). Evidence-based practice in schools: (2nd ed.). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Integrating craft and theory with science Meisel, J. (2004). The bilingual child. In T. K.
and data. The ASHA Leader, 4–5, 30–32. Bhatia & W. C. Ritchie (Eds.), The handbook
Kamhi, A. G. (2011). Balancing certainty and of bilingualism (pp. 91–113). Malden, MA:
uncertainty in clinical practice. Language, Blackwell.
Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools, 42, Merino, B. J. (1992). Acquisition of syntactic
59–64. and phonological features in Spanish. In H.
Kay-Raining Bird, E., Cleave, P., Trureau, N., W. Langdon & L. L. Cheng (Eds.), Hispanic
Thordardottir, E., Sutton, A., & Thorpe, A. children and adults with communication disor-
(2005). The language abilities of bilingual ders (pp. 57–98). Gaithersburg, MD: Aspen.
children with Down syndrome. American Nicoladis, E., & Genessee, F. (1996). A longitu-
Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 14, dinal study of pragmatic differentiation in
187–199. young bilingual children. Language Learn-
Kohnert, K. (2008). Language disorders in bilin- ing, 46, 439–464.
gual children and adults. San Diego, CA: Paradis, J. (2001). Do bilingual two-year-olds
Plural. have separate phonological systems? Inter-
Kohnert, K., & Derr, A. (2012). Language inter- national Journal of Bilingualism, 5, 19–39.
vention with bilingual children. In B. Gold- Paradis, J. (2005). Grammatical morphology in
stein (Ed.), Bilingual language development children learning English as a second lan-
and disorders in Spanish-English speakers (2nd guage: Implications of similarities with spe-
ed., pp. 337–356). Baltimore, MD: Brookes. cific language impairment. Language, Speech
Langdon, H. W., & Cheng, L. L. (2002). Col- and Hearing Services in Schools, 36, 172–187.
laborating with interpreters and translators in Paradis, J. (2007). Second language acquisition
the communication disorders field. Eau Claire, in childhood. In E. Hoff & M. Shatz (Eds.),
WI: Thinking Publications. Handbook of language development (pp. 387–
Lanza, E. (1992). Can bilingual two-year-olds 406). Oxford, UK: Blackwell.
code-switch? Journal of Child Language, 19, Paradis, J. (2016). An agenda for knowledge-
633–658. oriented research on bilingualism in chil-
Law, N. C. W., & So, L. K. H. (2006).The relation- dren with developmental disorders. Journal
ship of phonological development and lan- of Communication Disorders, 63, 79–84.
guage dominance in bilingual Cantonese- Paradis, J., Crago, M., Genesee, F., & Rice, M.
Putonghua children. International Journal of (2003). Bilingual children with specific lan-
Bilingualism, 10, 405–428. guage impairment: How do they compare
8. Bilingual Children’s Language Development: Assessment and Intervention 223
with their monolingual peers? Journal of fessionals working with preschool dual
Speech, Language and Hearing Research, 46, language learners. In B. Goldstein (Ed.),
1–15. Bilingual language development and disorders
Paradis, J., & Genesee, F. (1996). Syntactic in Spanish-English speakers (2nd ed., pp. 365–
acquisition in bilingual children: Autono- 378). Baltimore, MD: Brookes.
mous or interdependent? Studies in Second Roseberry-McKibbin, C. (2002). Multicul-
Language Acquisition, 18, 1–25. tural students with special needs (2nd ed.).
Paradis, J., Genesee, F., & Crago, M. (2011). Dual Oceanside, CA: Academic Communication
language development and disorders: A handbook Associates.
on bilingualism and second language acquisition Schnitzer, M., & Krasinski, E. (1994). The
(2nd ed.). Baltimore, MD: Brookes. development of segmental phonological
Peña, E. (1996). Dynamic assessment: The production in a bilingual child. Journal of
model and language applications. In K. Child Language, 21, 585–622.
Cole, P. Dale, & D. Thal (Eds.), Assessment Schnitzer, M., & Krasinski, E. (1996). The
of communication and language (pp. 281–307). development of segmental phonological
Baltimore, MD: Paul H. Brookes. production in a bilingual child: A contrast-
Peña, E. (2016). Supporting the home language ing second case. Journal of Child Language,
of bilingual children with developmental 23, 547–571.
disabilities: From knowing to doing. Journal Swain, M. (1972). Bilingualism as a first language
of Communication Disorders, 63, 85–92. (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Uni-
Peña, E., Bedore, L. M., & Rappazzo, C. (2003). versity of California, Irvine.
Comparison of Spanish, English, and bilin- Tabors, P. (1997). One child, two languages:
gual children’s performance across seman- A guide for preschool educators of children
tic tasks. Language, Speech, and Hearing Ser- learning English as a second language. Balti-
vices in Schools, 34, 5–16. more, MD: Brookes.
Peña, E., Gillam, R., Bedore, L., & Bohman, Thordardottir, E., Cloutier, G., Ménard, S.,
T. (2011). Risk for poor performance on a Pelland-Blais, E., & Rvachew, S. (2016).
language screening measure for bilingual Monolingual or bilingual intervention for
preschoolers and kindergarteners. Ameri- primary language impairment? A random-
can Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 20, ized control trial. Journal of Speech, Language,
302–314. and Hearing Research, 58, 287–300
Peña, E., Iglesias, A., & Lidz, C. (2001). Reducing Tomblin, B. (2000). Perspective on diagnosis. In
test bias through dynamic assessment of chil- B. Tomblin, H. Morris, & D. C. Spriestersbach
dren’s word learning ability. American Journal (Eds.), Diagnosis in speech-language pathology
of Speech-Language Pathology, 10, 138–154. (pp. 3–33). San Diego, CA: Singular.
Peña, E., & Quinn, R. (1997). Task familiarity: Valdés, G., & Figueroa, R. A. (1994). Bilingual-
Effects on the test performance of Puerto ism and testing: A special case of bias. Nor-
Rican and African American children. Lan- wood, NJ: Ablex.
guage, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools, Vihman, M. (1982). The acquisition of mor-
28, 323–332. phology by a bilingual child. Journal of Child
Restrepo, M. A. (1998). Identifiers of predomi- Language, 3, 141–160.
nantly Spanish-speaking children with lan- Vygotsky, L. (1978). Mind in society. Cam-
guage impairment. Journal of Speech, Language, bridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
and Hearing Research, 41, 1398–1411. Williams, A. L. (2003). Target selection and
Restrepo, M. A., & Gray, S. (2012). Professional treatment outcomes. Perspectives on Language
development practices and content for pro- Learning and Education, 10(1), 12–16.
224 Introduction to Language Development
Appendix 8–A
Proposed Intervention Process for Bilingual Children
In planning intervention for bilingual Once the goals are chosen, then the spe-
children, SLPs often mistakenly begin the cific targets should be identified. For bilin-
process by attempting to determine in gual children, targets might be based on
which language to provide intervention. the child’s language skills, error patterns,
Although that is an important step (and is and errors in each of the two languages.
discussed later), it is not the first step. As For example, errors that are highly occur-
with anyone who requires services for a ring in or common to both languages
speech or language disorder, the first step might be selected first. Such errors might
is to choose the goals based on a compre- be deletion of consonant clusters (e.g.,
hensive assessment, as described earlier /plen/ “plane” → [pen]), omission of
in the chapter. Goals might be crafted the plural marker, and difficulties using
that cut across two intersecting continua the present progressive tense. Then tar-
(Baker, 2006). The first continuum focuses gets that are highly occurring in only one
on goals that are either context embedded language would be chosen. If the child
or context reduced. That is, goals related were a Spanish-English bilingual speaker,
to this continuum focus on the amount of the SLP might remediate final consonant
contextual support available to the child. deletion in English but flap and trill in
A context-embedded goal might be using Spanish.
one- to two-word responses related to
an object in the environment. A context-
reduced goal might be one where the Step 3: Choose the Goal
child describes a television show. Attack Strategy
The second continuum focuses on
goals that are cognitively demanding Fey (1986) outlines three goal attack strat-
or cognitively undemanding. Cogni- egies. Those strategies are adapted here
tively undemanding goals are those for for bilingual speakers. First, utilize a ver-
which the child has relative mastery of tical strategy in which one goal at a time
the language skills needed to communi- is taught until the specified criterion is
cate easily. Cognitively demanding goals reached. The bilingual correlate would be
are those that are challenging due to the to remediate an error that is common to
need for rapid processing of information. both languages. The error would be reme-
A cognitively undemanding goal might be diated in only one language but moni-
one that focuses on the child talking about tored in the other language. For example,
the weather. In contrast, a cognitively the SLP would target the use of plurals
demanding goal is one in which the child in Language A but monitor their use in
is asked to explain and justify an opinion. Language B. Second, utilize a horizontal
8. Bilingual Children’s Language Development: Assessment and Intervention 225
strategy in which more than one goal is Step 5: Choose the
addressed in a session. The bilingual cor- Language of Intervention
relate would be to target the same goal
in Language A and in Language B. For It is likely that following the previous four
example, the SLP would target plurals steps will provide insight about the lan-
in Language A for a period, take a break, guage of intervention. That is, the goals,
and then focus on plurals in Language B. targets, strategies, and approaches dictate
Finally, utilize a cyclical strategy in which which language should be used for inter-
several goals are addressed over a set time vention. Initially, language of intervention
period, although only one goal is reme- will depend on a host of factors, including
diated within each session. The bilingual but not limited to:
correlate would be to rotate not only
specific targets but also languages. For ◆ Language history (i.e., relative
example, at time 1, focus on plural -s in experience with each language)
Language A and present progressive in ◆ Use in each language (i.e., how
Language B. At time 2, focus on present frequently the child utilizes each of
progressive in Language A and plural -s the languages)
in Language B. ◆ Proficiency in each language (i.e.,
how well the child understands and
produces each language)
Step 4: Choose the Approach ◆ Environment (i.e., where and with
whom the child uses each language)
Kohnert and Derr (2012) recommend two ◆ Family considerations (i.e., the
general approaches to intervention for family’s goals as part of EBP)
bilinguals: the bilingual approach and the ◆ The child’s speech and language skills
cross-linguistic approach. The bilingual and errors/error patterns in each of
approach emphasizes skills common to the two languages
both languages by focusing on the cogni-
tive principles common to all language Regardless of the approach, it is
learning (i.e., efficient processing and almost certain that intervention should
quickly attending to changes in form); take place in both languages at some time
training aspects of form, content, and use during the course of treatment. Inter-
that are shared by both languages; and vention in English only is unlikely to be
highlighting interactions between cogni- an option. There is ample research evi-
tion and language or between Language A dence for providing intervention in both
and Language B (e.g., contrastive analysis; languages (see Gutiérrez-Clellen, 1999;
translation). The cross-linguistic approach Kohnert, 2008; and Kohnert & Derr, 2012,
emphasizes skills that are unique to each for reviews). Using a bilingual approach
constituent language. Such unique skills has shown to facilitate an increase in
might relate to aspects such as word speech and language skills in both lan-
order variation, morphology, omission of guages (Kohnert & Derr, 2012). For exam-
subjects, word length, syllable types, and ple, in a group of Spanish-English bilin-
orthography, to name a few. guals, Lopez and Greenfield (2004) found
226 Introduction to Language Development
that English phonological awareness client to achieve the goals (e.g., num-
skills were predicted by: (1) English oral ber of treatment sessions), determining
proficiency, (2) Spanish oral proficiency, how much effort was needed to facilitate
and (3) Spanish phonological awareness change by examining the child’s response
skills. That is, skills in Spanish predicted level (e.g., imitation vs. spontaneous pro-
how well the children were performing in duction), and determining the hierarchy
English. Research such as this indicates needed to produce change (e.g., incremen-
that if the goal of intervention is a bilin- tal steps vs. a few gradual steps). Effects
gual child, then direct intervention in both focuses on determining if the change was
languages is necessary; that children, even significant by charting outcomes through-
those with impaired language, are capa- out the intervention process. Finally, effec-
ble of acquiring more than one language; tiveness measures whether the interven-
and that focusing on Language A will tion provided to the child was the agent
not impede acquisition in Language B, responsible for the change. To measure
and in some cases, may facilitate it. effectiveness, the SLP would take base-
line data (e.g., measuring skill level before
intervention begins), treatment data (e.g.,
Step 6: Monitor Progress collecting data on the goals and targets),
and then withdrawal data (e.g., measur-
It is imperative to monitor progress dur- ing skill level after intervention ceases).
ing the intervention process by determin- Ideally, follow-up data would be collected
ing efficiency, effects, and effectiveness as well, that is, weeks or even months
(after Williams, 2003). Efficiency focuses after working on a target.
on determining how long it took for the
9
Language Development
and Hearing
Brian J. Fligor and Sandra Levey
Case Study
227
228 Introduction to Language Development
Figure 9–1. Schematic of the structures of the ear. The outer ear
comprises the pinna and ear canal and terminates at the eardrum; the
middle ear comprises the eardrum, the ossicles (the malleus, incus, and
stapes), and the air-filled space and terminates at the oval window; and
the inner ear comprises the cochlea (from base to apex) as well as the
vestibular system (vestibule and semicircular canals). Signals from the
cochlea travel up the auditory nerve to the brain. Reproduced from the
National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders,
http://www.nidcd.nih.gov/health/hearing/pages/noise.aspx
The visible part of the ear is called the that contains sensory cells. A sensory
pinna. The ossicles (also called audi- cell, when stimulated, conveys nerve
tory ossicles) are three bones in the impulses. Hair cells are the sensory
middle ear that transmit sounds to the receptors of the auditory system. The
cochlea: the malleus, incus, and stapes. hair cells transfer sound information to
The cochlea is a snail-shaped tube the auditory nerve.
Hearing is the ability to receive, pro- of pressure waves. Sound waves are col-
cess, and interpret sound. Sound vibra- lected by the pinna of the outer ear and
tions travel through the air in the form funneled down the ear canal toward the
230 Introduction to Language Development
eardrum. When a sound wave reaches These children also report feeling isolated
the eardrum, it causes the eardrum to and having no friends. Hearing loss can
vibrate. This is the first step in the pro- affect a child’s ability to develop commu-
cess of hearing. Sound is amplified in the nication, language, and social skills.
middle ear due to the lever or pedal action
of the bones (ossicles) in the middle ear:
the malleus, incus, and stapes (shown in Conductive Hearing Loss
Figure 9–1). The inner ear is the site where
hydraulic energy (fluid movement) is Any problem in the outer or middle ear
converted into chemical energy (hair cell that prevents sound from being conducted
activity) and finally to electrical energy properly is known as a conductive hear-
(nerve transmission). Once the signal is ing loss. The most common cause of a
transmitted to the nerve, it will travel up conductive hearing loss is otitis media (an
to the brain to be interpreted as meaning- ear infection). More than one-third of chil-
ful sound. dren may experience six or more episodes
of otitis media by 7 years of age (Waseem,
2016). Conductive hearing loss is almost
Sound waves enter the outer ear
always temporary, but hearing sensitiv-
and are directed to the eardrum
ity fluctuates better to worse depending
(tympanic membrane). Sound vibra-
on the health status of the middle ear. Ear
tions set the eardrum in motion. This
infections are most common in children
leads to movement of the malleus,
ages 6 months to 2 years and are caused
incus, and stapes (acoustic energy
by inflammation (i.e., irritation or infec-
converted into mechanical energy).
tion) of the eustachian tube (Figure 9–2),
Mechanical energy is transferred to
resulting in eustachian tube dysfunction.
the cochlea, which contains fluid
Ear infections occur most often in children
and hair cells (mechanical energy
this age due to their lower immunity to
becomes hydraulic energy). Vibra-
upper respiratory tract infections (com-
tions in the fluid cause movement
mon colds), the angle of the eustachian
of the hair cells. This creates an
tube (it is more horizontal in children than
electrical signal sent to the brain for
in adults, thus more difficult to pop open),
processing.
and length of the eustachian tube (shorter
in children than in adults).
Although most common in children
under the age of 2 years, conductive hear-
Types of Hearing Loss ing loss secondary to fluid in the middle
ear is not uncommon in school-age chil-
Children with hearing loss have been dren. This degree of hearing loss has been
found to have reduced vocabulary skills, implicated in reduced academic achieve-
difficulty hearing certain sounds, lower ment (Goldberg & McCormick Richburg,
reading and mathematical scores, impaired 2004). Although an ear infection may
social interaction, and produce shorter sometimes not show obvious symptoms,
and simpler sentences (American Speech- it frequently results in fever, crankiness,
Language-Hearing Association, 2009). and loss of appetite. This loss results in
9. Language Development and Hearing 231
decreased hearing sensitivity for as long as cells) in the cochlea. It is estimated that 3
the middle-ear fluid is present (Mencher, to 4 of every 1,000 children are born with
Gerber, & McCombe, 1997). The degree of permanent hearing loss in the United
hearing loss from otitis media is typically States (Joint Committee on Infant Hear-
20 to 30 decibels hearing level (dB HL) ing, 2007), with more children developing
(Fria, Cantekin, & Eichler, 1985), which hearing loss between infancy and late ado-
is similar to the hearing of an individual lescence. It has been estimated that 19 of
wearing ear plugs. Although this degree every 1,000 high school graduates have a
of hearing loss is labeled “mild,” it can permanent hearing loss (Billings & Kenna,
contribute to a delay in the acquisition of 1999; Shargorodsky, Curhan, Curhan, &
spoken language. Eavey, 2010). Roughly half of the time, a
congenital hearing loss is caused by birth
complications due to prematurity (result-
Sensorineural Hearing Loss ing from poor oxygenation provided by
immature lungs). In the other half of the
A sensorineural hearing loss results from time, genetic causes are a factor in hearing
missing or damaged sensory cells (hair loss (Billings & Kenna, 1999).
232 Introduction to Language Development
activities (e.g., target shooting and hunt- as 150 dB even if a child is standing
ing, snowmobile riding, listening to porta- a foot away from the source of the
ble music players at high volume through noise.
earbuds or headphones, playing in a
band, and attending loud concerts) place The danger with noisy toys increases
individuals at risk for NIHL (National when children hold toys close to the ear.
Institute on Deafness and Other Commu- A noisy toy exposes the ear to as much as
nication Disorders, 2017). The onset and 120 dB of sound (close to the noise level
the progress of hearing loss may not be of a jet plane). Safety measures are impor-
apparent. For example, a study of hear- tant when using toys in play with young
ing abilities of college-age students (Rota- children (e.g., choosing toys carefully to
Donahue & Levey, 2016) found that half prevent hearing loss and covering the
of 40 students were found to have NIHL speakers with tape).
hearing loss, while none were aware that
a hearing loss was present. Education
on the hazards of noise and the poten- Central Auditory
tial effects on hearing is necessary for Processing Disorder
individuals throughout the lifespan, and
early education for children is particularly Speech perception tests for the assessment
important (Serpanos & Berg, 2012). of a central auditory processing disorder
One of the more disquieting sources (CAPD) are designed to test the abilities
of a potential NIHL is found in children’s of school-age children who have nor-
toys. Certain children’s toys exceed mal pure-tone audiograms but have dif-
safe listening levels, placing children at ficulty perceiving speech that is affected
risk for NIHL (Axelsson & Jerson, 1985; by background noise, competing signals
Nadler, 1995). University of California– in the contralateral ear, or rapid rate of
Irvine researchers (2007) found that many presentation. CAPD tests assess binaural
common children’s toys emit sounds at integration (how well the two ears work
decibel levels high enough to cause per- together), auditory memory, and retrieval
manent hearing damage, with some toys or recall of auditorily presented informa-
reaching a noise level comparable to that tion. The child appropriate for CAPD
of an ambulance, subway train, or power evaluation may present with recurrent
mower. An investigation of common toys complaints from parents, siblings, peers,
used in play revealed the following vol- and classroom teachers of difficulty fol-
ume levels (Cochary, 2009). lowing directions or reading.
teacher’s voice, when there is interfer- this leads to speech-language delays and
ence from background sounds (e.g., other social-emotional and behavioral prob-
children, paper rustling, noisy heating/ lems that result in frustration, resulting
ventilation/air conditioning systems in from the child’s inability to communicate
the classroom). Vocabulary and sentence thoughts, needs, and desires.
structure are extremely difficult for a child
affected by hearing loss to grasp.
Normal Hearing
A unilateral hearing loss or single- Sensitivity in Children
sided deafness is a type of hearing
loss with normal hearing in one ear
Normal hearing sensitivity in children
and impaired hearing in the other
is considered to be 15 dB HL or better
ear. A bilateral hearing loss is in
(Northern & Downs, 2002) because hear-
both ears.
ing thresholds of 20 to 25 dB HL or poorer
are considered to have a significant effect
Children with unilateral hearing loss on a child’s academic progress. Hearing
are not always positioned in such a way level is a unit of measurement with zero
that their “good” ear is toward the talker. as its reference point. On occasion, and
This results in morpheme and grammati- particularly for younger and develop-
cal errors, particularly hearing past tense mentally delayed children, 20 dB HL may
morphemes (e.g., waited), fricatives (e.g., f, be considered the limit of normal hearing.
v, s, z, h), and stop consonants (e.g., p, t, k).
The term HL means hearing level,
◆ Unvoiced fricatives consist of /f/ as
which is a scale based on young,
in fish, /s/ as in soap, /S/ as in shoe,
normal-hearing individuals with
and /h/ as in happy.
no history of noise exposure or
◆ Unvoiced stop plosives consist of /p/
other ear-related problems. Normal
as in pin, /t/ as in top, and /k/ as in
hearing is, on average, established
key.
as zero decibels at each of the test
◆ Morphemes consist of the past verb
frequencies (250 Hz, 500 Hz, and so
tense -ed morpheme (walked), posses-
on). So, it is possible to have better
sive morpheme -s (Mary’s book), and
than normal hearing (−5 dB HL or
the plural -s morpheme (two books).
−10 dB HL) or poorer than normal
hearing (20 dB HL, 30 dB HL, 100 dB
Typically, vowel sounds, which have
HL, and further loss).
lower frequency content and greater
intensity, are audible to children with
mild-to-moderate sensorineural hearing
loss, whereas many consonant sounds are
not audible (e.g., /k/, /p/, /f/, /s/, and
Hearing Assessment
“th”). Functionally, the child would be
able to tell that someone is speaking while For children with a hearing loss, an audio-
not being able to understand the content gram describes the type, degree, and
of the spoken message. Understandably, configuration of the hearing loss, thus
9. Language Development and Hearing 235
indicating the residual or remaining audi- perform a repetitive play task, such
tory area (Appendix 9–A). The pure-tone as placing a peg in a pegboard every
audiogram is a fundamental component time she or he hears a tone.
of the audiological evaluation. It is the
graphical representation of an individ- There are also physiologic measures
ual’s detection threshold for frequency- used in pediatric audiology. One example
specific stimuli in the conventional audio- is tympanometry. Tympanometry tests
metric range (250–8000 Hz). Descriptions the movement of the eardrum to rule out
of types of hearing loss can be found in the presence of an ear infection or another
Appendix 9–B. problem in the middle ear. A handheld tool
is used to change the air pressure inside
the ear and to produce a sound. This tool
A sound is presented by air
measures how the eardrum responds to
conduction using earphones or
the pressure and the sound.
a loudspeaker (the sound moves
Following assessment, the degree of
through the air to the ear), and by
hearing loss is classified according to the
bone conduction using a device
following list:
(called a bone oscillator) that sends
vibration through the skull itself.
Mild hearing loss 21 to 40 dB HL
A bone oscillator can vibrate at
different frequencies (e.g., 250 Hz, Moderate hearing 41 to 55 dB HL
500 Hz, 1000 Hz, and so on) and loss
this vibration is carried through
Moderately severe 56 to 70 dB HL
the bones of the head to the inner
ears (cochlea), since the inner ear is Severe 71 to 90 dB HL
encased in the bones of the skull.
Profound 91 or greater
dB HL
It should be noted that the impact of
hearing loss is not fully explained by the
audiogram because two individuals with
Sound Intensity
the same audiogram may have different
levels of disability, owing in large part to and Frequency
age of onset and differences in the envi-
ronment in which the individual func- Decibels are a unit for expressing the rela-
tions (Yoshinaga-Itano, Sedey, Coulter, tive intensity (loudness) of sounds. Sound
& Mehl, 1998). Examples of audiological intensity is calculated on a logarithmic
assessment consist of the following: scale. Examples of different intensity lev-
els are conversation (60 dB), rock concerts
Conventional Audiometry (age 4 or 5): (110 dB), snowmobiles (120 dB), and jet
The child is asked to raise a hand or aircraft takeoff (130 dB).
push a button every time he or she
hears a tone.
On a logarithmic scale, sound
Conditioned Play Audiometry (CPA)
intensity increases 10-fold for every
(ages 2 to 5): The child is shown,
additional 10 dB. In other words,
nonverbally, how to wait, listen, and
236 Introduction to Language Development
Figure 9–3. Sound waves. Note the difference between the low note (low-frequency wave) and
the high note (high-frequency wave).The frequency of a wave refers to how often the particles of
a medium (like air) vibrate when a wave passes through this medium.The higher the frequency, the
shorter the distance between each successive compression (i.e., low frequency, medium frequency,
and high frequency). In the examples shown in this figure, the intensity (or loudness) is shown in
the height of the wave.The higher the wave, the greater the intensity (i.e., loud, medium, and soft).
Reproduced with permission from Getty Images.
9. Language Development and Hearing 237
hearing screening, but if a child exhibits of childhood hearing loss. In 2012, JCIH
such signs, immediate audiological evalu- issued a clarification of the interventions,
ation would be indicated. such as requiring that individuals provid-
ing services to children who are deaf or
hard-of-hearing have expertise in their
areas of service. For example, an Ameri-
Intervention can Sign Language (ASL) instructor must
be fluent in ASL and a therapist providing
Age of Intervention listening and spoken language stimulation
(LSLS) must be a certified LSLS provider.
Prior to 1993, few hospitals provided
newborn hearing screening tests except
for infants identified as having risk fac- Devices Used for
tors (indicators) for hearing loss. The Joint Hearing Habilitation:
Committee on Infant Hearing (JCIH) was
FM Systems, Hearing Aids,
established in 1969. It was composed of
members from audiology, otolaryngology,
and Cochlear Implants
pediatrics, and nursing. The JCIH estab-
lished recommendations for the early FM Systems
identification of children who had been
diagnosed with hearing loss, of children A child with a unilateral hearing loss (loss
who were at risk for hearing loss, and for in one ear) has difficulty hearing on the
newborn hearing screening. In 1993, the affected side and difficulty focusing on
National Institutes of Health held a con- spoken language in the presence of com-
sensus conference (National Institutes of peting noises. The most significant effect
Health, 1993). The result of this confer- of unilateral hearing loss is found in class-
ence was a recommendation that all new- room performance, given that children
borns receive a hearing screening within with unilateral hearing loss are at signifi-
the first 3 months of life. The Joint Com- cant risk for poor academic performance
mittee on Infant Hearing (1994) recom- due to difficulty hearing in a typical
mended identification of all infants with (noisy) classroom environment. In fact, it
hearing impairment by 3 months of age is estimated that children spend approxi-
and the onset of habilitative programming mately 80% of the time listening to spo-
by 6 months of age. The seminal work of ken language in noise during the school
Yoshinaga-Itano et al. (1998) helped bol- day (Crukley, Scollie, & Parsa, 2011).
ster the newborn screening effort with Even with preferential classroom seating
research that found that children with nor- near the teacher and acoustic treatment
mal cognition, whose hearing losses were of the classroom to reduce reverberation
identified before 6 months of age, demon- of background noise, academic progress
strated significantly better receptive and should be monitored closely and supports
expressive language scores than children initiated if listening-related difficulties
with normal cognition whose hearing emerge. A hearing aid in the poorer hear-
losses were identified after 6 months of ing ear may be beneficial, but, typically, it
age. The JCIH (2007) reaffirmed the need does not improve the child’s ability to hear
for surveillance for adventitious onset in noise. However, in the classroom, FM
240 Introduction to Language Development
educational amplification systems (either across the speech frequencies) will have
ear level or sound field) may be used to significantly better access to the sounds of
improve the amount by which the teach- speech than without using hearing aids.
er’s voice exceeds the background noise.
If a child with normal cognition and
Sound-field systems work by no other concomitant conditions
projecting the teacher’s voice so that receives an early diagnosis of hearing
children have a better opportunity loss and is fitted with hearing aids,
to hear clearly the teacher’s instruc- coupled with speech-language
tions. These systems do not reduce therapy, an ear-level FM system in
exposure to external sound sources, the classroom, and educational and
but importantly, by raising the level psychosocial support, then speech
of the teacher’s voice, they can and language outcomes should be
increase the level of the speech signal normal to near-normal (Sininger,
relative to levels of external and Grimes, & Christensen, 2010).
internal sound sources (Dockrell &
Shield, 2012).
Cochlear Implants
Communication Disorders Quarterly, 25(3), Northern, J. L., & Downs, M. P. (2002). Hearing
152–160. in children (5th ed.). Baltimore, MD: Lippin-
Goldstein, H., Olszewski, A., Haring, C., cott Williams & Wilkins.
Greenwood, C. R., McCune, L., Carta, J., Oyler, R. F., Oyler, A. L., & Matkin, N. D. (1988).
. . . Kelley, E. S. (2017). Efficacy of a supple- Unilateral hearing loss: Demographics and
mental phonemic awareness curriculum to educational impact. Language, Speech, and
instruct preschoolers with delays in early Hearing Services in Schools, 19, 201–210.
literacy development. Journal of Speech, Lan- Packer, L. (2015). How hearing loss affects school
guage, and Hearing Research, 60, 89–103. performance. Retrieved from http://www
Holmes, A. E., Kaplan, H. S., Phillips, R. M., .healthyhearing.com/report/52433-How-
Kemker, J. F., Weber, F. T., & Isart, F. A. hearing-loss-affects-school-performance
(2007). Screening for hearing loss in adoles- Parrila, R., Kirby, J. R., & McQuarrie, L. (2004).
cents. Language, Speech, and Hearing Services Articulation rate, naming speed, verbal short-
in Schools, 28, 70–76. term memory, and phonological awareness:
Joint Committee on Infant Hearing (JCIH). Longitudinal predictors of early reading
(1994). Position statement. Pediatrics, 95, development? Scientific Studies of Reading,
152–156. 8(1), 3–26.
Joint Committee on Infant Hearing (JCIH). Rota-Donahue, C., & Levey, S. (2016). Noise-
(2007). Year 2007 position statement: Princi- induced hearing loss in the campus. Hear-
ples and guidelines for early hearing detec- ing Journal, 69(6), 38–39.
tion and intervention programs. Pediatrics, Serpanos, Y. C., & Berg, A. (2012). Noise expo-
120(4), 898–914. sure and the potential impact on hearing
Martin, F. N., & Clark, J. G. (1996). Hearing care in the pediatric population. In R. Goldfarb
for children. Boston, MA: Allyn & Bacon. (Ed.), Translational SLP/A: Essays in honor
Mencher, G. T., Gerber, S. E., & McCombe, A. of Dr. Sadanand Singh (pp. 107–112). San
(1997). Audiology and auditory dysfunc- Diego, CA: Plural.
tion. In G. T. Mencher, S. E. Gerber, & A. Shargorodsky, J., Curhan, S. G., Curhan, G. C.,
McCombe (Eds.), Anatomy and physiology & Eavey, R. (2010) Change in prevalence of
of the human ear (pp. 105–232). Needham hearing loss in US adolescents. Journal of the
Heights, MA: Allyn & Bacon. American Medical Association, 304, 772–778.
Nadler, N. B. (1995). Hearing conservation in Sininger, Y. S., Grimes, A., & Christensen, E.
the vocational classroom. Hearing Rehabili- (2010). Auditory development in early ampli-
tation Quarterly, 20(3), 12–15. fied children: Factors influencing auditory-
National Cued Speech Association. (2017). based communication outcomes in children
About cued speech. Retrieved from http:// with hearing loss. Ear and Hearing, 31(2),
www.cuedspeech.org/cued-speech/about- 166–185.
cued-speech Tye-Murray, N. (2007). Foundations of aural
National Institute on Deafness and Other Com- rehabilitation (3rd ed.). Clifton Park, NY:
munication Disorders. (2017). Noise-induced Delmar Cengage Learning.
hearing loss. Retrieved from https://www. University of California–Irvine. (2007). Greater
nidcd.nih.gov/health/noise-induced- parental guidance suggested for noisy toy use.
hearing-loss Retrieved from http://www.health-care.uci
National Institutes of Health. (1993). Early iden- .edu/news_releases.as?filename=07Dec
tification of hearing impairment in infants and ToyNoise.Htm
young children: Consensus development con- U.S. Department of Health and Human Ser-
ference statement. Retrieved from http://con vices. (2015). Retrieved from https://ftp
sensus.nih.gov/1993/1993hearinginfants .cdc.gov/pub/Health_Statistics/NCHS/
children092html.htm NHIS/SHS/2015_SHS_Table_A-6.pdf
9. Language Development and Hearing 245
Waseem, M. (2016). Otitis media. Retrieved K., & Mehl, A. L. (1998). Language of early
from http://emedicine.medscape.com/ and later-identified children with hearing
article/994656-overview#a2 loss. Pediatrics, 102, 1161–1171.
Yoshinaga-Itano, C., Sedey, A. L., Coulter, D.
246 Introduction to Language Development
Appendix 9–A
Audiogram
Bone conduction testing is represented by the right ear graphed with < or [ and the
left ear with > or ].
Stimulus frequencies, in hertz (Hz), are on the audiogram abscissa. The stimulus
intensity, in decibels and hearing level (dB HL), are on the ordinate. The Audiogram
Legend is below the audiogram. Air conduction testing uses earphones or a
loudspeaker (the sound moves through the air to the ear) and bone conduction uses
a device (bone oscillator) that sends vibration through the skull. A bone oscillator can
vibrate at different frequencies (e.g., 250 Hz, 500 Hz, 1000 Hz, and so on) and this
vibration is carried through the bones of the head to the inner ear (cochlea).
9. Language Development and Hearing 247
Appendix 9–B
Types of Hearing Loss
Abduct: To move away from midline. cord, or blood vessels that carry blood to
Abduction: Movement from midline. an organ.
Abstract thought: Higher level thinking pro- Age of acquisition (AoA): The age that a lan-
cesses characterized by organization and guage is first acquired.
logic. Air–bone gap: The difference, in decibels,
Acceleration: At certain points in develop- between air-conduction and bone-conduc-
ment, bilingual children might demonstrate tion thresholds.
a faster rate of acquisition than their mono- Air conduction: A method of transmitting
lingual peers. sound through the outer and middle ear to
Accommodation: When a new event does not the inner ear through an earphone deliver-
fit into a cognitive schema that already exists ing sound to the outer ear.
(e.g., penguin), there is a change in the exist- Alveolar ridge: A bony prominence of the
ing schema (e.g., birds) to accommodate the hard palate directly behind the upper inci-
characteristics of this new information. sors (teeth) that serves as an important
Acoustic: Relating to the sense or organs place of articulation for certain speech
of hearing, to sound, or to the science of sounds (e.g., /s/ and /t/).
sounds. Alveolar stop: A consonant sound created by
Acoustic resonance: The effect of different bringing the tongue tip in contact with the
vocal tract configurations on the production alveolar ridge, forming a complete closure,
of speech sounds. Alterations in the cross- then building up pressure behind the point
sectional area of the vocal tract determine of closure and suddenly releasing the occlu-
the frequencies at which sound energy will sion (e.g., /t/, /d/).
be minimally attenuated or diminished. Alveoli: Tiny air sacs within the lungs where
Acoustics: Relating to sound, the sense of hear- the exchange of oxygen and carbon dioxide
ing, or the science of the physics of sounds. takes place.
Acoustics can also be defined as sound Analogies: Tasks that involve analogical rea-
vibration propagating through air or the soning that uses information from one situ-
science of sound. ation to apply to another situation.
Action potential: Buildup of electrical current Analogy: Analogical reasoning involves using
in the neuron. information from one situation and apply-
Adaptation: The tendency of an organism to ing this information to a new situation.
change in response to the environment. Anaphora: Reference to a word or phrase
Adduct: To move toward midline. used earlier by replacing it with a pronoun.
Adduction: Movement toward midline. An example is the clause he did so in the sen-
Afferent fibers: Nerves that carry impulses tence, I told Paul to close the door and he did so.
from the body toward the brain or spinal The clause he did so makes use of anaphora.
249
250 Introduction to Language Development
Anaphoric term: A linguistic entity which exists when there is a good fit between
indicates a referential tie to some other the new information and the preexisting
linguistic entity in the same text (e.g., The schema. 2. In relation to phonetics, this term
monkey took the banana and ate it). “It” is ana- describes the changing of a speech sound
phoric as it refers to the banana. due to the influence of adjacent sounds. The
Angular gyrus: A region of the inferior pari- production of a speech sound that is similar
etal lobe of the brain that is involved in the to another sound in the same word (e.g., tat
processing of auditory and visual input produced in place of cat).
and in the comprehension of language. It is Assimilation processes: Progressive assimila-
involved in processes related to language tion consists of a speech sound taking on
and cognition. the characteristics of a preceding sound
Approximants: A class of speech sounds pro- within the word (e.g., kak for cat). Regres-
duced by bringing one articulator close to sive assimilation consists of a speech sound
another without creating audible noise; the taking on the characteristics of a succeeding
approximation of articulators is critical to sound (e.g., tat for cat).
the acoustic resonance of these sounds (i.e., Asymmetrical: A clinically significant differ-
/r/, /l/, /w/, /j/). ence in the degree of loss between the two
Apraxia: A neurological disorder that re-sults in ears that may be frequency specific.
difficulty initiating, planning, and/or pro- Audiogram: A standard graph for represent-
gramming the production of speech sound ing hearing sensitivity, in decibels hearing
sequences. Productions are inconsistent. level (dB HL) as a function of frequency.
Arcuate fasciculus: A bundle of nerve fibers Auditory brainstem response (ABR): The
that connects Broca’s and Wernicke’s areas, objective, physiologic measure most fre-
connecting the speech and language areas quently used for testing infants and chil-
in the brain. dren to estimate hearing sensitivity and/
Argument: Within grammar, a noun element or confirm a diagnosis of hearing loss. The
in a clause that relates directly to the verb, ABR is an electroencephalographic (EEG)
such as the subject or object of the sentence. response that is recorded via three scalp
An argument is an expression that helps electrodes and represents changes in elec-
complete the meaning of a predicate (the trical activity from the auditory nerve to
verb). Subject and object phrases are exam- midbrain level as a result of sound pre-
ples of arguments, shown as in the example sented to the ear.
of the sentence, John threw the ball. John and Auditory cortex: An area of the temporal
ball are arguments: John the subject argu- lobe of the brain that processes auditory
ment and ball the object argument. information.
Articulators: Structures in the vocal tract that Auditory neuropathy spectrum disorder
are used to create speech sounds. There (ANSD): This hearing disorder is char-
are dynamic (movable) articulators, such acterized by normal outer-, middle-, and
as the tongue and lips, and there are static inner-ear function at least up to the level
(immovable) articulators, such as the alveo- of the outer hair cells, but with abnormal
lar ridge and teeth, to which the dynamic function of the inner hair cells or auditory
articulators approximate (make contact) in nerve fibers.
the production of speech sounds. Auditory perception: The ability to perceive
Assimilation: 1. In relation to cognition, and understand sounds through the abili-
this term applies to children’s exposure ties associated with specific organs, such as
to new information or an event. In this the human’s ear. Sound exists in the form
case, the new entity can be assimilated or of vibrations that travel through the air or
incorporated into a schema that already through other substances.
251
Glossary
in any way by background noise, reverber- Cochlear implant: A device that serves to
ation, competing signals in the contralateral give a sense of hearing to a person who
ear, rapid rate of presentation, or filtering. otherwise does not have access to sound. It
Central nervous system (CNS): The part of includes a magnet and electrode array that
the nervous system that consists of the is surgically implanted in the inner ear as
brain and the spinal cord. The CNS controls well as an externally worn ear-level speech
motor activities (e.g., walking, sitting, and processor and microphone.
speech) and movements that are connected Code-mixing: A code is a system of signals
to essential body functions (e.g., breathing). used for sending messages. Code-mixing
The CNS is also responsible for thought or -switching describes changes or mixes
processes that emerge from interaction with from one language or system to another.
the environment. Speakers use code-switching to shift from
Cerebellum: A region of the brain that plays a native language to a second language.
an important role in motor control. The cer- Code-mixing can also be used to mark one-
ebellum contributes to coordination, preci- self as part of a particular ethnic group.
sion, and accurate timing of motor skills. Cognition: The mental processes that consist
Cerebrum: The largest and uppermost por- of knowledge, along with the mechanisms
tion of the brain. The cerebrum consists of to acquire knowledge. Cognitive skills con-
the right and left cerebral hemispheres and sist of attention, working memory, reason-
accounts for two-thirds of the total weight ing, intuition, judgment, and perception.
of the brain. Cognitive theory: Language emerges through
Chaining: A narrative form that appears at cognitive skills, such as object permanence
about 3 years of age, when children talk (the ability to produce words for entities or
about events related to a central topic with things that are absent) and through schema
no particular order of occurrence. formation (the psychological structures that
Childhood apraxia of speech (CAS): Child- allow children to attach meaning to experi-
hood apraxia of speech is a motor speech ences and entities).
disorder that results in difficulty producing Coherence: Involves interpreting the meaning
sounds, syllables, and words. CAS is not of a context or situation by considering all
caused by muscle weakness or paralysis. aspects of a situation, along with any previ-
Instead, the brain has difficulty with plan- ous knowledge that relates to an event.
ning to move the articulators (e.g., lips, jaw, Cohesion: The use of transitional expressions
tongue) needed for speech. and other devices to guide readers and
Circumlocution: The use of an unnecessarily show how the parts of a text (written or
large number of words to express an idea, spoken) relate to one other.
such as saying I use it to dig a hole in the Cohesive devices: Linking words and phrases
ground, instead of saying the word “shovel.” to make an organized thought. In narrative,
Closed syllable: A syllable that ends in a con- the use of words to connect the text (e.g.,
sonant (e.g., beet). and then . . . ).
Cochlea: The end organ of hearing; the por- Communication: 1. The exchange of informa-
tion of the inner ear that contains the sen- tion between people through speaking, writ-
sory cells for the auditory system. It is fluid ing, or using a common system of signs or
filled and composed of two concentric laby- behavior. 2. The vehicle for social interaction,
rinths: the outer made of bone and the inner consisting of both verbal (words, sentences,
of membrane. narratives, and conversations) and non-
Cochlear: Reference to the spiral-shaped cav- verbal acts (eye gaze, gesture, turn-taking
ity of the inner ear that resembles a snail in conversation, and facial expressions).
shell and contains the sensory cells and Communicative competence: A person’s
nerve endings essential for hearing. knowledge of grammar, syntax, morphol-
253
Glossary
ogy, and phonology, along with an under- continues until age 12. At this stage, chil-
standing of how and when to use this dren form ideas based on reasoning and are
knowledge appropriately. able to employ abstract thought.
Communicative unit (C-unit): A method of Concrete (words): A concrete noun is one
separating spoken utterances or written which can be experienced by our senses as
sentences into distinct independent clauses we can touch it, see it, or hear it (e.g., table,
(simple sentence) and any dependent or apple, and dogs). An abstract noun can-
subordinating clauses, often used to mea- not be experienced by our senses, as these
sure growth in language abilities. nouns express a concept (e.g., truth).
Competition model: The competition model Conductive: Something that can conduct or
views language processing as a series of transfer heat, sound, or electricity.
competitions between lexical items, pho- Conductive hearing loss: A conductive hear-
nological forms, and syntactic patterns. ing loss occurs when there is a loss of sound
The learning of language forms is based on energy being transmitted through the outer
the accurate recording of many exposures ear or middle ear (tympanic membrane
to words and patterns in different contexts. and/or ossicles). Conductive hearing loss
Complex: When used to describe a sentence, decreases the sound energy reaching the
complexity consists of the presence of an cochlea for sounds of all intensity levels,
independent clause and at least one other thus making all sound perceived at levels
independent or dependent clause. When more softly than would be perceived by a
used to describe language, complexity can person with normal hearing sensitivity.
consist of lengthy and complex utterances Confidence intervals: A confidence interval
or reference to events not present in the cur- gives an estimated range of values, which
rent context. is likely to include an unknown population
Complex sentence: A sentence that contains parameter or the estimated range being cal-
an independent clause with one or more culated from a given set of sample data.
dependent clauses. A complex sentence Congenital: Refers to a defect or condition in
always has a subordinator, such as because, a fetus, present at birth.
since, after, although, or when, or a relative Conjoined sentences: Composed of two main
pronoun, such as that, who, or which. clauses that are conjoined by conjunctions
Compound-complex sentence: A sentence (e.g., and, or, but, and because).
made up of more than one main clause Conjunctions: Words that connect words,
and at least one subordinate clause. It is the phrases, and clauses.
combining of a compound sentence with a Content: The meaning of an expression.
complex sentence. Content word: A word that conveys meaning,
Compound sentence: A sentence that con- such as a noun, verb, or adjective,
tains two independent clauses joined by a Context clues: Context clues help a reader to
coordinator, such as for, and, nor, but, or, yet, define a difficult or unusual word. Clues
or so. may appear within the same sentence or in
Concepts: Abstract ideas, thoughts, or no- the sentences that are contained in the text.
tions that are formed by experiences or Contextualized language: Talk about the here
occurrences. Children’s conceptual devel- and now, by referencing people, objects,
opment is supplied by the environment and and action that are present in the immedi-
the cognitive ability to form concepts about ate context.
spatial (location), temporal (time), quantita- Contextualized narratives: Descriptions of
tive (number), qualitative (description), or people, things, or events present in the
social-emotional (feelings) knowledge. immediate environment.
Concrete operations stage: Stage of devel- Continuity: The hypothesis that there is conti-
opment that emerges at 6 years of age and nuity between children’s preverbal behaviors
254 Introduction to Language Development
(e.g., gestures, eye contact, prelinguistic strate a slower rate of acquisition than their
vocalizations) and later language skills. monolingual peers.
Conversational postulates: Conversation Decentration: Children are able to consider
contains the conversational postulate or multiple multiple attributes of an object or
the assumption that a speaker is telling the situation (e.g., height and width of an object).
truth, is offering information that is new Decibels (dB): A mathematically derived
and relevant to the conversation, and is ratio of sound level based upon the pres-
offering information that the listener genu- sure exerted by a particular vibration rela-
inely wants to hear. tive to some reference pressure. Decibels
Cooing: A stage in infants’ prelinguistic hearing level (dB HL) refers to hearing sen-
speech development that consists of the sitivity relative to normative data of sound
production of single-syllable, vowel-like pressure as a function of frequency.
sounds. Declarative sentences: Statements that pro-
Copula: In grammar, a linking verb, which vide information.
links the subject of a sentence with an adjec- Decode: 1. Decoding is the ability to read
tive or noun-phrase complement relating to something that has been written. 2. An indi-
it (e.g., to be, or to seem). vidual is able to comprehend or understand
Corpus callosum: A structure of the brain in information from another source.
the longitudinal fissure that connects the Decontextualized language: Consists of lan-
left and right cerebral hemispheres. This is guage that is understandable without con-
the structure that facilitates communication textual support (e.g., things that support
between the two hemispheres. the meaning of the utterance). Meaning is
Counterfactual reasoning: Thoughts about conveyed only via linguistic cues.
events that did not actually occur, based on Decontextualized narrative: Refers to descrip-
the condition of what might have happened. tions of people, objects, and events that are
Cranial nerves: These are nerves that emerge not present in the immediate environment.
from the brain and brainstem. Ten of the 12 Deep structure: In transformational gram-
emerge from the brainstem. Cranial nerves mar, the deep structure is an abstract rep-
relay information between the brain and resentation of a sentence, while surface
body. structure corresponds to the version of the
Critical thinking: Analysis of an action or sentence that can be spoken and heard. Sur-
event for accuracy and logic. face structures are derived from deep struc-
Cross-linguistic effects: The bi-directional tures by a series of transformations.
influence of one language on the other in Deferred imitation: Imitation of an event
bilingual speech and language production. after a period of delay, showing that the
Cultural broker: An individual, usually shar- child understands an expression. The
ing the family’s cultural background, who child’s imitative response may change or
can provide an insider’s information on expand the original utterance.
that culture and aid in the interpretation Deictic terms: The phenomenon wherein un-
of the family’s linguistic and non-linguistic derstanding the meaning of certain words
characteristics. and phrases in an utterance requires con-
Culturally and linguistically diverse: Denotes textual information (e.g., that one, over
not only those who are acquiring more than there, here, he, she). Words are deictic if their
one language but also those who might be semantic meaning is fixed but their specific
using more than one dialect (i.e., a rule- reference varies depending on time and/or
governed variant of a language, such as place.
Appalachian English). Deixis: An aspect of a communicative utter-
Deceleration: At certain points in develop- ance whose full interpretation depends on
ment, bilingual children might demon- knowledge of the context in which the com-
255
Glossary
munication occurs (e.g., the use of a word ing accurately and fluently. Dyslexia may
or expression such as he, that, now, or here). also impact on reading comprehension,
Dendrites: Projections of the neuron that con- spelling, and writing.
duct stimulation received from other neu- Effectiveness: A measure to determine whether
rons to the cell body (soma) of a neuron. intervention was responsible for a change.
Denial: Unwillingness to believe in some- Effects: Focuses on determining if change
thing or admit that something exists. occurred as a result of intervention. Change
Derivational morphemes: Prefixes and suf- can be measured by charting outcomes
fixes that are added to a root word to create throughout the intervention process.
additional meaning. This often changes the Efferent fibers: Carrying information away
part of speech of the root word, as in add- from the central nervous system.
ing the suffix -er to the verb teach to create Efficiency: Determining how long it took the
the noun teacher. client to achieve the goals, how much effort
Dialect: A rule-governed variant of a language. was needed to facilitate change, and the
Dialogic reading: A method to support a hierarchy needed to produce a change.
child’s literacy and language skills through Egocentric, egocentrism: Characterized by
asking questions during a reading task. preoccupation with one’s own internal
Digraphs: A pair of written letters that repre- world. The belief that you are the center
sent a single speech sound (e.g., th, sh, ch). of the universe and everything revolves
Diphthongs: Vowel-like sounds that are pro- around you.
duced with a gradually changing articula- Egocentric speech: The type of speech typi-
tion (e.g., how, boy, and sky). cally observed in young children which is
Discourse: The exchange of information or not addressed to another person.
conversation between people consists of Electromotility: The movement, resulting
the transmission of information, opinions, from change in shape, of the cochlear outer
ideas, or feelings. hair cells in response to electrical changes
Disinhibited: Lacking the ability to restrain within the outer hair cells.
from impulsive actions. Ellipsis: The omission of one or more words
Divergent thinking: The ability to explore and from a sentence, especially when the word
provide multiple solutions to a problem. that is omitted can be understood from the
Domain-specific vocabulary: Words that are context. In the sentence, I went but my wife
specific to a specific domain (area or field) didn’t, the omission of “go” at the end of the
of study. sentence (I went but my wife didn’t go) is an
Dual language learners: Individuals acquir- example of ellipsis.
ing two or more languages simultaneously Embedding: A process by which one clause is
while continuing to develop their first included (embedded) in another.
language. Embodied cognition: A theory that the body
Duration: The length of a syllable. influences cognition through the motor sys-
Dynamic assessment: An interactive approach tem, the perceptual system, and the body’s
to assessment that embeds intervention interaction with the environment. In this
within the assessment process. This begins view, the motor system influences the body
with a pretest, followed by intervention, and and the mind influences body actions. Chil-
ending with a posttest. The goal is to deter- dren’s cognitive skills develop through the
mine the child’s response to intervention. relationship between the infant’s mind and
Dysarthria: A motor speech disorder that physical body.
affects the muscles of the mouth, face, phar- Emergent literacy: The period when pre-
ynx, larynx, and respiratory system. schoolers learn about print, before they
Dyslexia: A specific learning disability that actually learn to read. The skills and knowl-
affects reading. This disorder affects read- edge about literacy that a child acquires
256 Introduction to Language Development
before learning to read, such as knowing word order of the child’s utterance (e.g.,
that the print on a page contains informa- child says Doggie eat, adult might say, The
tion about the story. doggie is eating).
Emergentism: The theory that language Experience dependent development: The
acquisition emerges from the interaction abilities that a human must acquire during
of biological forces and the environment. development or adulthood that are unique
According to this theory, neither nature to its own particular environment, such as
nor nurture alone is sufficient to prompt information about the physical characteris-
language learning and both of these influ- tics of the surroundings, the details of one’s
ences must work in tandem to allow a child language, and other cognitive capacities.
to acquire a language. These are experiences that the brain does
Encode: Encoding involves converting incom- not expect (such as the ability and the skills
ing information into meaning, such as spoken to care for animals on a farm).
speech sounds into words. A sender trans- Experience expectant development: The brain
mits information (encodes) that a receiver is prepared for exposure to environmental
comprehends or understands (decodes). experiences that result in the establishment
English language learners: Individuals who of neural pathways that result in learning.
are learning English as another language. For example, the brain expects to be exposed
Environment: The external factors influenc- to visual images and spoken sounds to
ing the life and activities of people, plants, allow the development of visual and audi-
and animals. Reference to the entities, tory systems.
things, and events that play a role in learn- Expository: A type of writing where the pur-
ing language. pose is to describe, inform, explain, or
Environmental: Relating to, or caused by, a define the author’s subject to the reader.
person’s interactions and surroundings. Expository discourse: Language that is typi-
Environmental theory: Environmental theory cally found in textbooks, classroom lec-
posits that the external environment pro- tures, and technical papers.
vides the essential information to support Expressive language: The language an indi-
language development. vidual produces spontaneously. Expres-
Equilibrium: The process of fitting new infor- sive language skills consist of a variety of
mation or input into an existing cognitive expressive skills, such as expressing words,
schema. ideas, and information.
Eustachian tube: A slender tube that connects Exuberant synaptogenesis: Tremendous growth
the middle ear cavity with the nasal part of in the number of synapses in the brain at
the pharynx and serves to equalize air pres- about week 12 of development.
sure on either side of the eardrum. Fast mapping: A hypothesized mental pro-
Evidence-based practice: The integration of cess whereby a new concept can be learned
clinical expertise, expert opinion, external based only on a single exposure to a given
scientific evidence, and client/patient/ unit of information. Fast mapping is
caregiver perspectives to provide high- thought by some researchers to be particu-
quality services reflecting the interests, val- larly important during language acquisi-
ues, needs, and choices of the individuals tion in young children.
we serve. Fictional narrative: A story drawn from a
Executive function(s): The cognitive pro- child’s imagination and in which the con-
cesses of planning, problem solving, work- tent is invented.
ing memory, inhibition, and multitasking. Figurative language: Non-literal phrases con-
Expansions: An adult’s more mature version sisting of idioms, metaphors, similes, and
of a child’s utterance that preserves the proverbs.
257
Glossary
Hair cells: The sensory receptors of the audi- malleus at the top and has a projection that
tory system. The hair cells transfer sound is joined to the stapes at the bottom.
information to the auditory nerve. Indirect speech act: An utterance whose lin-
Heaps: A stage in a child’s pre-narrative devel- guistic form (a question) does not directly
opment. The child expresses an assortment refer to its communicative purpose (a
of unrelated ideas rather than connected request for action).
information. For example, a child might Infant-directed speech: Patterns that con-
just label objects or actions with no connec- sist of slowed rate and exaggerated into-
tion among these pieces of information. national patterns. This type of speech has
Hearing aids: An electroacoustic device which been termed “motherese.”
typically fits in or behind the user’s ear and Inferior frontal gyrus (IFG): Known as Bro-
is designed to selectively amplify sound ca’s area and important for the motor pro-
based on the user’s hearing loss for the gramming and the expression of spoken
sake of giving improved access to speech language.
sounds. Inflectional morphemes: Maintain the word’s
Hertz: The term hertz (abbreviation Hz) is grammatical category (e.g., noun, verb) and
defined as the number of cycles (vibrations) add a grammatical feature to that word
that an object makes when put into motion). (e.g., possession, or tense).
The number of cycles per unit of time is Inhibition: When an activity, impulse, desire,
called the frequency of a sound. The per- or a response is restrained or prevented.
ceived pitch of a sound is the ear’s or mind’s Innate: Qualities or abilities that are inborn.
subjective interpretation of its frequency. Innateness theory: A theory of language ac-
Heschl’s gyrus: Gyri (prominent, rounded, quisition which states that at least some lin-
elevated convolutions on the surfaces of the guistic knowledge exists in humans at birth.
cerebral hemispheres) located on the upper Inner hair cells: Transform the sound vibra-
surface of the temporal area of the cortex tions in the fluids of the cochlea into elec-
that are involved in the processing of audi- trical signals that are then relayed via the
tory stimuli. auditory nerve and the auditory brainstem
Homorganic: Having the same place of artic- to the auditory cortex.
ulation in the vocal tract (e.g., /t/, /n/, and Input: Sensory information that is processed
/d/). from an outside influence and is then acted
Hypothalamus: A region of the brain located upon or integrated.
between the thalamus and the midbrain Instrumental function: Playing a part in achiev-
that controls the autonomic nervous sys- ing a result or accomplishing a purpose.
tem. For example, the hypothalamus regu- Intelligibility: Refers to how clear and eas-
lates sleeping cycles, body temperature, ily understood the speaker’s speech is to a
and appetite. listener.
Idioms: Expressions with meanings that can- Intention: The meaning conveyed by a
not be predicted from the usual meaning of speaker. A listener must understand the
its constituent elements or words (e.g., kick speaker’s intent or intention to understand
the bucket). the meaning of an utterance.
Imperative sentences: Consist of a demand Intentional: The use of communication to
or request. indicate specific wants, desires, or needs.
Incidental learning: The type of learning that Interaction function: Communication or joint
occurs without direct teaching. Incidental activity involving two or more people.
learning describes children’s learning of Interactional dual systems model: A theory
new words. of bilingual language acquisition stating
Incus: The middle bone of the ossicular chain that bilingual children develop distinct lin-
in the middle ear. It articulates with the guistic systems for each language.
259
Glossary
Interneurons: Interneurons are located in the capacity which enables them to acquire
CNS (brain and spinal cord). These are neu- and produce language. This theory asserts
rons that act as a link between sensory and that humans are born with the instinct or
motor neurons (sensation and movement). innate facility for acquiring language. It is
They transmit signals through the use of believed that without this innate knowl-
neurotransmitters, the chemicals that allow edge of grammar, children would be unable
the transmission of signals from one neuron to learn language as quickly as they do.
to the next. Language content: Semantics, or the meaning
Interpreter: One who conveys information of words, phrases, sentences, and longer
from one language to another. spoken utterances or written language.
Interrogative sentences: These sentences ask Language dominance: When bilinguals are
a question. These sentences require an inver- said to have greater skills in one language
sion of the subjects and auxiliary verbs than in the other.
(e.g., am, is, are, was, were). Language exposure: The amount of time
Intonation: The rising or falling pitch of the an individual is exposed to a particular
voice when a word or syllable is produced. language.
Intrasentential growth: Refers to the advances Language form: The language areas that
in syntactic knowledge and use seen within define the structure and rules of language:
the length of a sentence. This is a term phonology, morphology, and syntax.
meant to capture syntactic changes. Language loss: This process occurs, over time,
Item-based: A usage-based model in which when the speech and language features of
children imitatively learn concrete linguis- the first language are no longer utilized by
tic expressions from the language they hear the speaker, possibly due to less exposure
around them. Children use their general or use of the speaker’s first language.
cognitive and social-cognitive skills to com- Language processing: The way words are
bine these individually learned expressions used to communicate ideas and feelings
and structures to develop language. and how communication is understood.
Jargon: 1. Sequences of variegated babbling Language proficiency: How well a language
that have the intonation shape of the child’s is spoken.
native language. 2. The language and Language status: The degree of admiration or
vocabulary associated with a particular respect for a particular language.
discipline, often confusing to novices and Language use: How often and with whom
persons not familiar with that discipline. each language is used.
Joint action: The shared action of two indi- Laryngeal system: The vocal folds are housed
viduals on a single object or a collective within the laryngeal system. The vocal folds
activity. are energized by air from the lungs and
Joint attention: The process by which young vibrate to produce phonation (sound pro-
children focus their attention on an object duced by the vibration of the vocal folds).
or event with a social partner through non- Larynx: A set of structures that house the
verbal communication. This may include vocal folds.
joint gaze and pointing. Lexicon: A lexicon is the vocabulary of a per-
Labio-dental: Produced at a place of articula- son or a language.
tion involving the lower lip and upper teeth Limbic system: A part of the brain that sup-
(e.g., /f/ and /v/). ports many functions, including emotions,
Language: A system of arbitrary symbols long-term memory, self-preservation, and
which is rule based, dynamic, generative, sensory processing (e.g., smells or scents).
and used as a social tool in communication. Limited English proficient (LEP): This is a
Language acquisition device (LAD): The con- term used to describe a student who is lim-
cept that infants have an instinctive mental ited in English proficiency and has not yet
260 Introduction to Language Development
mastered English in the four domains of sitivity of the other ear; used when hear-
reading, writing, listening, and speaking. ing sensitivity of the non-test ear is possi-
Lingua-alveolar: Sounds produced at a place bly better than the test ear, for the sake of
of articulation in which the tongue com- determining true hearing sensitivity of the
pletely or nearly closes against the alveolar test ear.
ridge (e.g., /s/, /t/, and /d/). Masking: Involves testing one ear while noise
Lingua-dental: Sounds produced at a place of is introduced into the other ear. This allows
articulation involving the tongue and teeth, for testing each ear separately.
such as the sound “th.” Mean length of utterance (MLU): The aver-
Lingua-palatal: Sounds produced when the age number of morphemes (basic units of
tongue articulates with the hard palate, meaning) a child produces. For example,
such as the sound “sh.” jump is one morpheme, whereas jumps
Lingua-velar: Sound produced at a place (jump + s) is two.
of articulation involving the tongue and Means-end: This is a process in which the
velum or the soft palate (e.g., /k/, and /g/). problem solver begins by envisioning the
Linguistic competence: Linguistic knowledge end, or ultimate goal, and then determines
possessed by native speakers of a language. the best strategy for attaining the goal in
It is distinguished from linguistic perfor- his/her current situation.
mance, which is the way a language system Means-end behavior: Children’s anticipation
is used in communication. of an outcome allows them to achieve a goal.
Linguistic individualism: The language expe- Mental lexicon: A mental dictionary that
riences of children and adolescents outside contains information regarding a word’s
of the family or traditional academic set- meaning, pronunciation, and syntactic
ting, consisting of unique vocabulary or characteristics.
concepts that allow a child or adolescent to Mental state verbs: These are verbs that refer
acquire an individualized personal vocabu- to a person’s mental state, e.g., frighten, like,
lary or a different way of talking. disappoint, think, believe, and remember. These
Liquids: A class of speech sounds also known verbs are sometimes called mental verbs.
as approximants (e.g., /l/, /r/). Metacognition: Knowledge of one’s own
Magical thinking: Magical thinking is most thoughts and the aspects that influence
present in younger children, when children thinking. Metacognition involves self-
believe that their personal thought has a reflection, self-responsibility, initiative, goal
direct effect on the rest of the world. setting, and time management.
Majority language: A language spoken by Metalinguistic abilities: Allow a child to
the majority of speakers in a region or in think and talk about language, along with
a country. the ability to use language to talk about
Main verb: The verb that conveys meaning in language
a sentence. Metalinguistic awareness: Refers to the abil-
Malleus: This is the largest of the ossicles. It ity to objectify language as a process as well
is continuous with the eardrum and articu- as a thing and to consciously reflect on the
lates with the incus, the next bone in the nature of language.
chain in the middle ear. Metalinguistic competence: Involves the
Mandible: The bone making up the lower jaw awareness that language is composed of
of the face. syntactic, semantic, morphological, phono-
Marked sounds: Less natural occurring sounds logical, and pragmatic domains that can be
in most languages (see unmarked). synthesized, analyzed, and reorganized.
Masked: The use of a noise applied to the Metalinguistic knowledge: The ability to
non-test ear while testing the hearing sen- think about language in a conscious manner.
261
Glossary
Marissa). This bias is often held until chil- Neuron: A nerve cell.
dren learn that an entity or an object can Neuroplasticity: The lifelong ability of the
have more than one name. brain to reorganize neural pathways based
Myelin: A sheath that covers many axons in on novel or new experiences, along with
the central nervous system, critical to neu- anatomical or physiological changes due
ral transmission and normal muscle func- to injury.
tion by facilitating the rapid transmission Neurotransmitters: Chemicals which facili-
of electrical impulses. tate the transmission of signals from one
Myths: Traditional stories that consist of neuron to the next across synapses. This
events that serve to explain a practice, chemical substance is released from the
belief, or natural phenomenon. axon terminal that travels along the syn-
Nares: Nostrils. apse to transfer an impulse to another
Narrative: A verbal description of events cell.
which is longer than a single utterance. Non-English proficient: Having minimal or
Narratives possess a structure that aids no English proficiency.
children’s understanding of stories. Nonexistence: Children at the one- and two-
Nasal cavity: A cavity of the vocal tract that is word utterance stage express nonexistence
important for the resonance of nasal sounds to indicate disappearance (e.g., All gone
(i.e., /m/, /n/, and /ŋ/). cookie).
Nasals: Sounds produced by vocal fold vibra- Noun phrase: The noun phrase is a part of
tion with the resonance of the nasal cavity a sentence that consists of a noun and its
added to the pharynx and oral cavity (e.g., modifiers, including a noun clause, a word,
/m/, and /n/). or a pronoun that can function as the sub-
National Institutes of Health: An agency of ject or object of a verb.
the U.S. Department of Health and Human Nucleus: The nucleus of neurons contains
Services that supports much of medical genetic material (chromosomes) including
research. information for cell development and syn-
Negative sentences: Sentences in which the thesis of proteins necessary for cell mainte-
child demonstrates a rejection or protest. nance and survival.
Nerve fibers: A process, axon, or dendrite of Object constancy: The understanding that
a nerve cell. objects remain the same even when viewed
Nerves: These fibers form a network of path- from a different perspective.
ways for conducting information through- Object permanence: 1. The knowledge that
out the body. Sensory (afferent) nerves carry objects have an existence in time and space,
information into the central nervous system independent of whether or not they can be
about sensations (e.g., touch, temperature, seen or touched. 2. The ability to remember
and pain), and motor (efferent) nerves carry that an object exists even when removed
information away from the central nervous from sight.
system for muscle control. Obligatory: An obligatory context is when a
Nervous system: This system consists of morpheme is required to make an equiva-
nerve tissues and structures of the central lent grammatical sentence in adult speech,
and peripheral nervous systems that are whether for linguistic or contextual reasons.
responsible for thought, muscle control, Onset: An onset is the part of the syllable that
and sensory functions. precedes the vowel of the syllable (e.g., /s/
Neural tube: Formed by the closure of ecto- from the word sit).
dermal tissue in the early vertebrate embryo Open syllable: An open syllable is one in
that later develops into the brain, spinal which the final sound in the syllable is a
cord, nerves, and ganglia. vowel (e.g., bee).
263
Glossary
Peripheral nervous system (PNS): The PNS words. This awareness consists of the abil-
consists of two parts: the somatic nervous ity to notice and manipulate the sounds of
system and the autonomic nervous system. a language, separately from the meaning of
Perseveration: The excessive repetition of a the word.
word, phrase, or longer utterance. Phonological processes: Children’s simplifi-
Personal function: When a child attempts to cation of words. These processes are pre-
communicate to express his/her feelings or dictable and consistent with typical devel-
attitudes. opment (e.g., “nana” produced in place of
Personal narrative: A narrative that describes the word banana).
past events experienced by the narrator or Phonology: Rules for the combination of
someone familiar to the narrator. sounds to form words in a language.
Perspective-taking: The perception of physi- Phonotactics: A branch of phonology that
cal, social, or emotional situations from a deals with restrictions in a language on the
point of view other than one’s own. permissible combinations of phonemes.
Pharyngeal cavity: The cavity of the pharynx Phrase structure rules: Describe a language’s
that consists of a part continuous anteriorly syntax and sentence structure.
with the nasal cavity by way of the naso- Pinna: The visible part of the ear.
pharynx, a part opening into the oral cavity, Plasticity: Plasticity, also known as neuro-
and a part continuous posteriorly with the plasticity, is a term that refers to the brain’s
esophagus and opening into the larynx. Its ability to change and adapt as a result of
anterior boundary is the root of the tongue experience.
and its posterior boundary is the pharyn- Positron emission tomography (PET): A nu-
geal wall. clear functional imaging technique used to
Phonation: The process of setting the vocal observe metabolic processes in the body.
folds into vibration to produce sound. PET provides the opportunity to study the
Phonemes: The smallest units of the sounds organization of cognitive functions and lan-
of a language that act to differentiate the guage processing in the working brain.
meaning of words (e.g., /b/ in bat vs. /k/ Postlingual: After the development of speech
in cat). and/or language.
Phonemic awareness: A subset of phonologi- Practical intelligence: The knowledge, not
cal awareness that allows children to hear, explicitly taught, needed to achieve or
identify, and manipulate phonemes. accomplish a goal. The skills involved with
Phonemic representations: A system for using practical intelligence can be thought of as
letters or symbols to represent sounds in applied to practical skills (e.g., what an
speech. The basis of phonetic and pho- infant must do to obtain a goal or solve a
nemic transcription is the phoneme, the problem).
smallest part of a word’s sounds that can Pragmatic: Relating to the rules for appropri-
be clearly defined as a separate sound that ate social interaction.
affects meaning. Pragmatics: 1. The branch of linguistics that
Phonetically consistent forms: Expressions studies language use rather than language
used to convey consistent meaning, such structure. 2. The connection between lan-
as doggy used only to label dogs. guage development and the environment
Phonetics: The study of the perception and or the context in which the communication
production of speech sounds. occurs.
Phonics: Sound-letter or phoneme-grapheme Predicate: The part of a sentence that pro-
correspondence. vides information about the subject of the
Phonological awareness: Defined as chil- sentence, such as what the subject is doing
dren’s awareness of the sound structure of or how the subject is affected. A sentence
265
Glossary
contains a subject (what or whom the sen- tern, word juncture, loudness, pausing, and
tence is about) and a predicate (which tells rhythm. Prosody extends over syllables,
us something about the subject). words, or phrases.
Prelingual: The period between birth and Prospective mental development: What a
13 months of age when an infant employs child needs to learn with guidance from an
sounds and gestures to communicate wants adult or more experienced peer, in relation
and needs before recognizable speech to the child’s zone of proximal development.
develops. Proverb: Expressions that express a thought
Preoperational stage: This stage begins at or truth.
approximately 18 months and ends at 6 Proximity: Closeness in time and/or space.
years of age. During this period of devel- Real-time functional magnetic resonance imag-
opment, children form ideas based on their ing (rtfMRI): Allows for brain–computer
own perception of events. This derives interface with a high spatial and temporal
from egocentrism, with children centered resolution and whole-brain coverage.
on themselves, their own experience, and Recasts: An adult’s correction or modifica-
their own desires. tions of a child’s utterances.
Presuppositions: Beliefs that a particular Receptive language: The language that peo-
state of affairs is true or false without the ple comprehend or understand.
provision of evidence. Recurrence: A semantic relation produced by
Primary auditory cortex: The part of the children to indicate the request of repetition
temporal lobe that processes auditory (e.g., More juice).
information. Reduplicated babbling: Repeated sequences
Principles: Innate language-general rules of repeated consonant-vowel pairs (e.g.,
or general principles that apply to all lan- bababababa).
guages, such as the principle that a sentence Referent absent: Reference to a person,
must contain a subject. thing, or event absent from the current
Principles and parameters theory: An innate environment.
language acquisition device that consists Referent present: Reference to a person, thing,
of language principles common to all lan- or event when these elements are present
guages and parameters that can be set for the within the current environment to which a
grammatical rules for a particular language. linguistic expression refers.
Print awareness: Knowledge that the printed Reflexive pronouns: Refer to the subject of
word carries a message, including but not the sentence compounded with -self (e.g.,
limited to the meaning and function of the myself, herself, and himself).
printed word, recognition of words and let- Register: Modifications of language influ-
ters, and terminology. enced by the current situation (e.g., conver-
Private speech: This type of speech is often sation with close friends as compared with
called egocentric speech, with children’s conversation with professors).
speech not adapted to a listener’s under- Regulatory function: Language used specifi-
standing or needs. cally to convey or to establish social dynam-
Processing: Involves the functions performed ics between individuals. In child language,
in the brain that allow us to perceive and the attempt to regulate the behavior of
understand spoken language, along with a another.
speaker’s ideas and feelings. Rejection: The semantic relation used to reject
Propositions: A statement claiming that (e.g., no bed).
something is true or false. Relational terms: These terms express a syn-
Prosody: The suprasegmental aspects of tactic relationship between elements in a
speech, including intonation, stress pat- phrase or a sentence (e.g., less, more, longer,
266 Introduction to Language Development
nerve pathways from the inner ear to the Social competence: The emotional and cogni-
brain, resulting in loss of hearing sensitiv- tive skills and behaviors that children need
ity. This is the most common type of hear- for successful social adaptation and social
ing loss and generally cannot be medically interaction.
or surgically corrected. Social information processing: The way in
Sensory cells: Detect information (e.g., sounds, which people think about themselves and
light, touch, smell, taste, and temperature) the social world, including how they select,
through receptors on their surface. This interpret, remember, and use social infor-
information travels through nerves from mation gained in interaction.
the sensory cells to the brain. Social interaction: Any action that is shared
Sensory information: Sensory acuity is the with others and contains a shared symbolic
actual physical ability of the sensory organs system.
to receive input, while sensory processing Social-interaction theory: Children’s language
is the ability to interpret the information acquisition emerges through social interac-
the brain has received. The processing of tion and experience with language used in
sensory information consists of tactile per- the external environment. Children possess
ception (touch), visual perception (vision), the innate desire for social interaction.
gustatory perception (taste), auditory per- Socio-interactional: Relating to social rela-
ception (hearing), and olfactory perception tions or social interaction as a factor in lan-
(smell). Additional sensory information guage development.
consists of the perception of pain, touch, Soma: The main part of the neuron that con-
temperature sense, and limb propriocep- tains the nucleus of the cell.
tion or limb position. Somatic nervous system: Relating to the
Sensory neurons: Nerve cells that transmit nerves that carry motor (movement) and
sensory information (e.g., sight, sound, sensory (e.g., hearing, touch, and sight)
touch, or feeling). This sensory input sends information to and from the central ner-
this information to other elements of the vous system. These nerves are responsible
nervous system, with final transmission for voluntary muscle movements and for
of the sensory information to the brain or processing sensory information.
spinal cord. Specificity: Measures the proportion of posi-
Sequential bilinguals: Those who acquire a tives that are correctly identified as such
second language after establishing a foun- and the proportion of negatives that are
dation in their first language. correctly identified as such. For example,
Simile: A figure of speech in which two unlike the percentage of individuals correctly
things are explicitly compared, as in, “she is identified as typically developing.
like a rose.” Speech: The neuromuscular process by which
Simple sentence: A sentence that contains humans create a meaningful sound sig-
only a subject and a verb (e.g., Dogs bark). nal that is transmitted through the air (or
Simultaneous bilinguals: Those who acquire another medium, such as a telephone line)
at least two languages before the age of to a receiver.
about 5 years. Speech acts: A method of categorizing a speak-
Social cognition: The psychological processes ers’s intent or meaning (e.g., request, com-
that enable individuals to take advantage ment, promise). These spoken utterances are
of social signals that include facial expres- called acts because many types are intended
sions, such as fear and disgust, which warn to result in action (e.g., Can you pass the salt?).
us of danger, and eye gaze direction, which Speech awareness threshold (SAT): The
indicate where interesting things can be weakest intensity at which the child dem-
found. onstrates awareness of the presence of
268 Introduction to Language Development
sound, when a speech stimulus is presented before, while, and when (e.g., Before we eat,
through the audiometer using a develop- we wash our hands).
mentally appropriate test method. Substitution processes: Consist of the substi-
Speech reception threshold (SRT): The weak- tution of one phonemic class (e.g., stops) for
est intensity at which the child can identify another (e.g., fricatives).
50% of spondee words from a closed set of Sulci: A series of valleys or depressions on the
familiar items. A spondee word has two syl- surface of the cerebrum.
lables with equal stress, such as baseball or Superior frontal gyrus: Contributes to higher
toothbrush. cognitive functions and working memory.
Stapes: The third and smallest of the ossicles Superior temporal gyrus (STG): This area of
in the middle ear. the brain consists of the primary auditory
Stereocilia: Small, hair-like projections situ- cortex, responsible for processing sounds.
ated on the top of the hair cells that are It also comprises Wernicke’s area, which is
located in the inner ear. involved in language comprehension.
Stop-plosive: A class of speech sounds pro- Supralaryngeal vocal tract: Consists of the
duced by forming a complete closure in the oral, pharyngeal, and nasal cavities.
oral cavity, building up pressure behind Surface structure: Structural characteristics
that closure, and suddenly releasing the of the actual spoken message. The surface
closure to produce a brief noise burst. structure derives from the deep structure
Strategies: Chosen plans to bring about a through the utilization of phrase structure
desired future, such as achievement of and transformational rules.
a goal or solution to a problem. Syllable structure processes: Refers to the
Stroke: A stroke is the sudden death of brain composition and sequencing of consonants
cells in a localized area due to inadequate and syllables within a word.
blood flow. Syllogism: Involves a deductive process. A for-
Subordinate clause: A subordinate clause, mal argument consisting of a major and
sometimes called a dependent clause, usu- minor premise and a conclusion.
ally introduced by a subordinating element Symbolic functions: A word used to repre-
such as a subordinating conjunction or rela- sent an entity or activity not present in the
tive pronoun. current context. Children’s ability to think
Subordinate dependent clause: A subordi- or label a person, thing, or event even when
nate clause, sometimes called a dependent not present.
clause, usually introduced by a subordinat- Symmetrical: Similar degree of hearing loss
ing element such as a subordinating conjunc- in both ears across frequencies.
tion or relative pronoun. The subordinate Sympathetic: The part of the nervous system
dependent clause must always be attached that plays an excitatory role, such as prepar-
to a main clause, as it completes the mean- ing the body for a fight or flight response.
ing of the sentence (e.g., After Mary ate the Synapse: Connection between neurons through
sandwich, she cleaned the table). which signals flow from one neuron to
Subordinating conjunctions: Words that join another.
a subordinate clause to a main clause, such Synaptic cleft: The space between neurons
as after, although, because, until, and when. at a nerve synapse, across which a nerve
Subordination: This is a concept of syntactic impulse is transmitted by a neurotrans
formation, with one clause subordinate to mitter.
another. A dependent clause is called the Syntagmatic: Relating to the function and
subordinate clause and the independent behavior of a word or phrase within a syn-
clause is called the main clause. The sub- tactic unit. Within a word association task,
ordinate clause is introduced with subor- a child’s response that follows in a syntactic
dinate conjunctions, such as after, because, sequence (e.g., big-ball). By age 9, children
269
Glossary
respond with a word from the same class the transformation of an active sentence
(a paradigmatic response). (John kicked the ball) into a passive sentence
Syntagmatic-paradigmatic shift: Refers to the (The ball was kicked by John).
change that occurs when children provide Transformational rules: Rules that operate
a response that is in the same grammatical on strings of symbols, rearranging phrase-
class as the stimulus word (e.g., table-chair). structure elements to form an acceptable
Younger children provide a response that sentence for output.
represents a syntactic form (e.g., table-eat). Translation equivalents: Words that have
Syntax: 1. Rules that govern the way words an identical or functional meaning across
combine to form phrases, clauses, and languages.
sentences. 2. The order or arrangement of Translator: Conveys information from one
words in a sentence. language to another.
Tectorial membrane: The gelatinous structure Traumatic brain injury: Traumatic brain injury
that extends along the longitudinal length occurs when an external mechanical force
of the cochlea parallel to the basilar mem- causes brain dysfunction. Traumatic brain
brane. The tectorial membrane moves along injury usually results from a violent blow or
with the pressure variations of the cochlear jolt to the head or body. An object penetrat-
fluid, with movement encoded into electri- ing the skull, such as a bullet or shattered
cal digital signals to the brain through the piece of skull, also can cause traumatic
cochlear nerve. brain injury.
Temporal-parietal cortex: Incorporates infor- T-units: Measurements used to determine
mation from the thalamus and the limbic average sentence length in the spoken or
system, as well as from the visual, auditory, written language of school-age children
and somatosensory systems. This area of and adolescents. T-units include only full,
the brain also integrates information from independent clauses (e.g., basic sentences)
both the external environment as well as and any dependent clauses.
from within the body. Tympanometry: A procedure conducted prin-
Text structure: The way written text is orga- cipally to assess middle-ear function (how
nized. Knowledge of text structure sup- well sound is conducted through the ear-
ports comprehension of the text. drum and ossicles), rather than a test of
Thalamus: A part of the brain associated with hearing.
basic functions, such as sleep and attention. Underextension: The use of a general word to
The thalamus also relays information from mean one very specific thing, (e.g., “baba”
eyes, ears, and spinal cord to the cerebral may mean MY bottle and my bottle only).
cortex. This constitutes a restricted understanding
Thematic roles: These terms (e.g., agent, patient, of the meaning of a term.
and location) label the semantic relationship Unilateral hearing loss: Refers to a hearing
between the verb and noun phrases of sen- loss in only one ear, while a bilateral hearing
tences (e.g., agent + action = daddy go). loss is a hearing impairment in both ears.
Theory of mind (TOM): The ability to under- Unmarked: A sound that appears to be nat-
stand others’ mental states, such as indi- urally occurring and is acquired earlier.
viduals’ beliefs, intents, wishes, beliefs, and Unmarked sounds tend to occur more
knowledge. frequently across languages than marked
Total vocabulary size: The vocabulary knowl- sounds.
edge of an individual, based on vocabulary Unmasked: The unmasked threshold is the
for all languages spoken. quietest level of a signal that can be per-
Transfer: The generalization of new skills. ceived without a masking signal present
Transformation: The rules for transforming when testing hearing sensitivity. The masked
one type of sentence into another, such as threshold is the quietest level of the signal
270 Introduction to Language Development
perceived when combined with a specific behind the constriction, and forcing air
masking noise. through the constriction. Voiced fricatives
Usage-based theory: A theory of language are produced while the vocal folds are set
development in which children begin with into vibration (e.g., /v/, /ð/, /z/, and /Z/).
a concrete understanding of language, Voiced stops: A class of speech sounds pro-
beginning with imitation. duced by forming a complete closure in
Use: A linguistic term that defines the prag- the oral cavity, building up pressure be-
matics of language, or rules for using lan- hind that closure, and suddenly releasing
guage in interaction. the closure to produce a brief noise burst.
Variegated babbling: A stage in babbling Voiced stops are produced when the vocal
characterized by varied sequences of folds are set into vibration (e.g., /b/, /d/,
sounds in syllables. (e.g., babigoogi). and /g/).
Velar stop: A sound produced when the dor- Voiceless fricatives: Sounds produced by
sum of the tongue articulates against the forming a significant constriction, building
velum (soft palate) (e.g., /k/, /g/). up pressure behind the constriction, and
Velum: A muscular extension of the hard forcing air through the constriction. Voice-
palate also known as the soft palate. The less fricatives are produced without vibra-
velum is lowered during production of tion of the vocal folds. All fricatives, with
nasal sounds (e.g., /m/, and /n/) and is the exception of /h/, a glottal fricative, are
raised during production of all other Eng- created in the oral cavity.
lish speech sounds. Voiceless stops: A class of speech sounds
Velopharyngeal closure: The closing of the produced by forming a complete closure
nasal cavity from the oral and pharyngeal in the oral cavity, building up pressure
cavities. behind that closure, and suddenly releasing
Verbal reasoning: Involves the ability to draw the closure to produce a brief noise burst.
conclusions, solve problems, and make Voiceless stops are produced without vibra-
decisions. tion of the vocal folds (e.g., /p/, /t/, and
Verb phrase: The predicate of a sentence pro- /k/).
vides information about the subject (e.g., Vowels: Speech sounds that are formed with-
The car was stolen). The verb phrase (was out a significant constriction of the oral and
stolen) consists of the information about the pharyngeal cavities and that serve as a syl-
subject (The car). lable nucleus.
Visual language: A part of the reading pro- Wernicke’s area: A region of the brain that is
cess that is considered a secondary system, important in language development. Wer-
based on the use of visual skills to success- nicke’s area is located on the temporal lobe
fully recognize words and gather meaning on the left side of the brain and is respon-
from the written text. sible for the comprehension of speech
Vocables: Word-like productions that emerge (Broca’s area is related to the production of
at about 10 to 12 months. These words lack speech).
precise meaning but are perceived to sound Word: A meaningful sound or combination of
like a real word. sounds that is a unit of language or its rep-
Vocal folds: A pair of muscular tissues in the resentation in a text.
larynx that are separated during inhala- Word recognition: How well the individual
tion and achieve closure to be set into rapid understands speech stimuli.
vibration to produce sound (phonation). Working memory: A type of memory in which
The vocal folds are also known as vocal information is held while being process-
cords. ed. Working memory allows a child to
Voiced fricatives: Produced by forming a sig- understand and remember a series of
nificant constriction, building up pressure directions.
271
Glossary
273
274 Introduction to Language Development
W Word knowledge, 17
Word learning, 94
Wernicke’s area, 54, 55–56 Word stress, 3
Wh-clause, 168 Working memory
Wh-infinitive, 168 description of, 22, 23, 78–79
Whole word processes, 125 in preschoolers, 121–122
Wh-questions, 40, 98, 98–99, 129 Writing, 194–195, 199
Word(s) Written language, 21
content, 126
function, 126
indefinite negative, 97 Y
mixing, 214 Yes/no questions, 97
monosyllabic, 190
protowords, 74
semantic properties of, 94
Z
Word awareness, 77 Zone of proximal development, 36, 216