Individual and Society
Individual and Society
Individual and Society
6.2 INTRODUCTION
Therefore, we get different theories regarding the relation of the two. In this
unit we will discuss the different theories adding different philosophers’
viewpoints regarding the relation between the individual and the society.
The three important theories in this regard are as follows:
The social contract theory: According to this theory, society is an artificial
structure to meet up peoples demand. The supporters of this theory are
Hobbes, Rousseau and Locke. This theory is also known as structuralism
in modern sense.
The organic theory: According to this theory, society is an organism.
Just as an organism is an organic unity of interdependent organs, so
also society is an organism of interdependent individuals. Both cannot
exist apart from each other.
The group mind theory: According to this theory, man is a social being.
The social self or ideal self can be realized through society. So, man is
inconceivable apart from society. Idealist philosophers advocate this
theory.
Besides elaborating on these three theories we will discuss
contemporary debate on the contentious issue of the relationship between
the society and the individual and their relative importance.
ACTIVITY: 6.1
Do you think that the social contract
theory is not a satisfactory reply to the relation of
individual and society? Discuss.
Ans: ..................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................
man which is thought to be the reason behind the contract. Therefore, the
social contract theory alone cannot give us a proper reply to the question of
the relation between the individual and the society.
The organic theory, therefore, is a developed form of the theories
about the relation between individual and society, because this theory holds
that individuals are interdependent on one other. As a result, people want to
live in mutual contract and intercourse with one another. So, apart from
society, men are mere abstractions. Thinking, feeling and willing, which are
the essential conditions of a man, are activated only in a society. Therefore,
a question naturally comes to our mind as to if we can think of a man without
a society? The organic theory answers that question by holding that the
focus of a man is reflected in society. We cannot think of a society without
individuals. So, an individual cannot exist without a society, both are
interdependent. Society consists of individuals. And Individuals are essential
parts of society. According to this theory, both are inseparable from one
another. That is why, this theory does not recommend the mechanical view
of society. Rather it advocates a natural view of society through organic
relation.
LET US KNOW
Functionalism is the oldest and most dominant
theoretical perspective in sociology. This perspective
lays emphasis on two aspects: i) Application of the
scientific method to an objective study of the social world. ii) Use of
an analogy between the individual organism and society. Emile
Durkheim and recent Talcott Persons(1902-1979, Americian
sociologist ) are the two advocates of functionalism. They hold that
the social world is objectively real. Functionalists compare society
to a living organism. They hold that the different parts of society e.g.
the family, education, religion, law and media etc. contribute to the
smooth functioning of society.
ACTIVITY: 6.2
Why is the relation of individual and society not
mechanical according to the organic theory? Discuss.
Ans: ............................................................................
...........................................................................................................
Do you think that the organic theory is a satisfactory account of
relation between individual and society?
Ans: ...................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................
tends to absorb the individual mind from which it differs not only in the
richness of content but also in kind.”
This saying of Durkheim beautifully points out that ever individual
self is different from the higher social self. So, the commonality or the
objectivity of self is realized only through the social self. It is considered as
the essence of every ideal self or individual self.
Individuals are interdependent members of society. He cannot realize
the universal, moral and spiritual self apart from other individual selves or
fellow men. The social self is the higher self, and individual self tries to
actualize the common nature of self in society. Therefore, it can be said
that society is the unity of the individual self. And every individual self leans
towards the same goal i.e., common good. It is also regarded as the ideal
of every individual self.
ACTIVITY: 6.3
Is the Group of Mind theory satisfactory? Give
reasons.
Ans: ............................................................................
..........................................................................................................
Do you find any difference between individual self and social
self? Discuss.
Ans: .................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................
psychological because the only elements which make up society are (1910-1989) Americian
collective can be produced if individual consciousness is not taken into sociology & exchange
ACTIVITY: 6.4
Can we think of the traditional type of society through
the sociological concept of nominalism? What do you
think?
Ans: .................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................
Is the concept of realism a satisfactory answer to individual and
society?
Ans: .....................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................
means. According to this definition the dualism lies in the relation between
the individual (actors) and the social structures. Just as the structures are
created by human beings, they are also controlled by social structure.
Giddens asks the question: Is society made up of the sum of
individual’s actions? Or, is society more than the sum of these actions and
is there a social structure that is independent of each individual’s actions?
Giddens points out some salient features of structure. They are:
Structures exist only in human memory
Structures exist only in practice. They are produced by agents, i.e.,
actors(individuals).
Structures enable us to do actions. They also exercise control on
the actor.
Structures consist of rules and resources which agents or actors
draw upon in the production and reproduction of social life.
He views that the relationship between social structure and individual
or actor or agent is never taken as dualism. Nether the agent can be explained
in terms of social structure nor the social structure can be explained in
terms of the agent. He holds the view that structure inherently involves
structuration. The actor always does some activity and doing some activities
he actually does structuration. Structuration implies reproducing structure.
So, reproduction of structure is structuration.
Ans to Q No 8: Social self is nothing but the highest nature of self, which is
hidden in every individual self.
Ans to Q No 9: a) True b) True c) True
Ans to Q No 10: Nominalism is a concept in sociology, which holds that
individual is the only reality.
Ans to Q No 11: Interactionism is a concept in sociology, which holds that
both individual and society interact upon each other to discuss
meaningfully the concept of individual and society.
Ans to Q No 12: Allport and Homanas are the two advocates of neo-
nominalism.
Ans to Q No 13: Realism is a concept in philosophy which upholds the
view that both group and individual are real.
Ans to Q No 14: a) Nominalism b) Living organism c) Realism
d) One sided research