Goodbye Horses: Industry: Healthcare Quantitative Level: Medium Qualitative Level: Difficult
Goodbye Horses: Industry: Healthcare Quantitative Level: Medium Qualitative Level: Difficult
Goodbye Horses: Industry: Healthcare Quantitative Level: Medium Qualitative Level: Difficult
Industry: Healthcare
Quantitative Level: Medium
Qualitative Level: Difficult
159
Goodbye Horses
Prompt #1:
• Your client is the CFO of Aperture Laboratories, a leading US biopharmaceutical company with a
market cap >$150B. Aperture develops and manufactures a diversified range of products and in
particular prides itself on saving millions of human lives every year.
• The company is under investor pressure because of its slow firm value growth over the next 10
years. Investors are very anxious to see significant changes announced at the firm in the next
quarter. The CFO has already identified and evaluated a number of high-growth, promising, but
capital-intensive projects, and she does not have enough cash to invest in any of the
opportunities—what dose she need to do next?
Interviewer Guidance:
• The prompt can be ambiguous, and many interviewees may drive the case towards evaluating the projects or building a
profit tree of the existing business to identify any issues. Neither of these approaches directly answers the prompt, but probe
them to realize the goal is to raise capital in order to fund these projects.
– Optional: this case can be a good opportunity for the interviewee to experience a free-flowing, conversational “partner-
style” case. Consider telling the interviewee to not write anything down for the framework.
• Let the student build a framework, which should be focused on ways to raise capital, but could also include other next steps
such as gaining management buy-in to invest in these high growth opportunities
– Ideal framework will include ways to raise capital (issuing equity, raising debt, divesting a portion of business,
canceling existing projects to free up budget) and also touch on where to deploy the capital (i.e., into the projects)
– Students may discuss P&L levers in their framework, which is OK, but check to see if they realize any cost-cutting or
revenue-boosting measures will not raise capital quickly and do not satisfy investor requirements for significant
changes
– Ideal candidate will discuss pros/cons of each way to raise capital
• Guide them towards thinking about divestiture, then provide them with the first exhibit
161
Exhibit #1: Aperture business segments
5-yr CAGR
20%
Sales ($B)
Oncology drugs
15% Nutrition 1.3
2.1
3.1
10%
162
Interviewer guidance on Exhibit #1
Exhibit #1 Guidance: Analysis:
• Provide the exhibit and let the interviewee walk • Chart takeaways (not all necessary to discuss)
through it verbally – Animal health is one of the lowest growth
• The interviewee should drive the discussion and business units
determine that animal health is the best option – Animal health is the most different business
to divest, providing sufficient rationale unit and outside of what Aperture prides
• If the interviewee does not choose animal itself in (saving human lives)
health, discuss with them their rationale and – Its low degree of specialization will allow a
steer them towards choosing animal health larger pool of potential buyers (i.e., easier
– The interviewee should take the hint and for another company to operate)
switch towards animal health
• Do not prompt the interview towards next steps;
make sure they drive conversation towards how
much capital they can raise and if they can find
buyers for the business unit
163
Goodbye Horses
Prompt #2:
• Unknown to the CFO until now, the business development team has retained JP Morgan to
assess the sale-ability of the Animal Health business. They have identified that Aperture will likely
receive a 3.5x enterprise value to sales multiple for the animal health business.
Interviewer Guidance:
• Do not prompt further; let the interviewee work through the next steps
• The interviewee should drive towards understanding how much capital they will receive from the
sale (($4.2B x 3.5 = $14.7B)
– If asked about taxes, tell the interviewee the deal has been structured by JP Morgan to be
tax-free
• The interviewee should then begin discussing which projects to invest the capital in. Once they’ve
begun thinking about this, provide the next exhibit
164
Exhibit #2: Investment opportunities
Project NPV Capital Investment Required
0 2 4 6 8 10 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
166
Goodbye Horses
Recommendation
• The CFO is out at lunch and the CEO of Aperture walks into your conference room, wondering
what you’ve been working on.
Interviewer Guidance:
• An ideal candidate will walk through the divestiture and what to do with the influx in capital.
• Risks
• Ability to sell the Animal Health Division
• Timing of the deal completion
• Timeline for new capital projects
• Potential for new capital projects to fail
• The ideal candidate will also have a mitigation strategy for each of these risks
167