The Role of Managerial Finance: Professional
The Role of Managerial Finance: Professional
The Role of Managerial Finance: Professional
CHAPTER
48
BROOKDALE SENIOR LIVING
Sources: “Land and Buildings issues letter to Brookdale Senior Living shareholders highlighting path to real estate monetization
and maximizing shareholder value,” Businesswire.com, December 20, 2016; “Activist shareholder pushes Brookdale to deliver
on rumored deal,” Seniorhousingnews.com, January 16, 2017; “Brookdale Senior Living shares fall after report Blackstone is
no longer interested,” cnbc.com, February 17, 2017.
49
CHAPTER 1 The Role of Managerial Finance 51
earnings back to investors. The keys to good financial decisions are much the same
for businesses and individuals, which is why most students will benefit from an
understanding of finance regardless of their profession. Learning the techniques of
good financial analysis will not only help you make better financial decisions as a
consumer but will also assist you in understanding the financial consequences of
important business decisions, no matter what career path you follow.
WHAT IS A FIRM?
What is a firm? Put simply, a firm is a business organization that sells goods or
services. However, a more complete answer attempts to explain why firms exist.
They exist because investors want access to risky investment opportunities. In
other words, firms are risky business organizations that, if not for investors’ will-
ingness to bear risk, would have difficulty generating the necessary investment
capital to operate. For example, most investors do not have the expertise or
wealth required to start a personal computer company, so instead they invest in a
company like Apple. Even when a few individuals, such as Steve Jobs, Steve Woz-
niak, and Ronald Wayne, had the requisite expertise and wealth to start Apple
Computer in a garage in 1976, vast amounts of additional money (i.e., invest-
ment capital) from investors were necessary for the firm to grow into what Apple
is today. So, ultimately, firms are intermediaries that bring together investors and
risky investment opportunities. Firms pool investment capital, make risky invest-
ment decisions, and manage risky investments all on behalf of investors who
would otherwise not be able to do so effectively or efficiently on their own.
Friedman, Milton, “A Friedman Doctrine––The Social Responsibility Of Business Is to Increase Its Profits.” New York Times Magazine, September
13, 1970, pp. 33, 122–26; Leube, Kurt R., Essence of Friedman. Stanford, CA: Hoover Institution Press, 1987; Exxon Mobil’s Perspective on Climate
Change: http://corporate.exxonmobil.com/en/current-issues/climate-policy/climate-perspectives/our-position
CHAPTER 1 The Role of Managerial Finance 53
actions that they expect will increase the shareholders’ wealth. Although that
objective sounds simple, its implementation is not always easy. To determine
whether a particular course of action will increase or decrease shareholders’
wealth, managers have to assess what return (i.e., cash inflows net of cash out-
flows) and risk (i.e., the uncertainty of the net cash flows) the action will bring.
How managers do that is the focus of this book.
M ATT ER OF FACT
Does profit maximization lead to the highest possible share price? For at
least three reasons, the answer is often no. First, timing is important. An invest-
ment that provides a small profit quickly may be preferable to one that produces
a larger profit if that profit comes in the distant future. Second, profits and cash
flows are not identical. The profit reported by a firm is simply an estimate of
how it is doing, an estimate influenced by many different accounting choices
made by firms when assembling their financial reports. Cash flow is a more
straightforward measure of the money flowing into and out of the company than
is profit. Companies must pay their bills with cash, not profits, so cash flow mat-
ters most to financial managers and investors. Third, risk is a major consider-
ation. A firm that earns a low but reliable profit might be more valuable than
another firm with profits that fluctuate a great deal (and therefore can be very
high or very low at different times).
Timing Because a firm can earn a return on funds it receives, the receipt of
funds sooner rather than later is preferred. In our example, even though the total
earnings from Rotor are smaller than those from Valve, Rotor provides much
greater earnings per share in the first year. It’s possible that by investing in Rotor,
Neptune Manufacturing can reinvest the earnings that it receives in year 1 to
generate higher profits overall than if it had invested in project Valve. If the rate
of return Neptune can earn on reinvested earnings is high enough, managers may
do better to invest in project Rotor even though project Valve generates higher
profits over the 3 years.
safe investments. What this signifies in terms of the goal of the firm is that
maximizing profits may not maximize the stock price. Suppose one firm is
slightly more profitable than another, but investing in the firm with margin-
ally higher profits also entails greater risk. Investors may well be willing to pay
a higher price for the stock of the firm that produces lower but more predict-
able profits.
As another way to express this idea, we can say that cash flow and risk affect
share price differently. Holding risk fixed, investors will pay more for the stock
of a firm that generates higher cash flows and profits. In contrast, holding cash
flow fixed, investors will pay more for shares that are less risky because they do
not like risk. The key point, explored in more depth later, is that differences in
risk can significantly affect the value of different investments. Return and risk
are, in fact, the key determinants of share price, which represents the wealth of
the firm’s owners.
1. Olubunmi Faleye and Emery Trahan, “Labor-friendly corporate practices: Is what is good for employees good for
shareholders?” Journal of Investing, June 2011.
56 PART ONE Introduction to Managerial Finance
To illustrate, consider that in March 2017, the online retailing giant Amazon
reported that it earned a profit of $4.90 per share over the previous 12 months.
Another company, Clorox, reported almost identical earnings per share of $4.92.
Yet the stock prices of these two companies could not have been more different.
Amazon was trading for $850 per share, whereas Clorox stock was selling for
just $137. In other words, investors were willing to pay 6 times more for shares
of Amazon even though it reported virtually the same EPS as Clorox. Why? Sev-
eral factors may contribute, but the most plausible answer is that investors envi-
sion rosier long-term prospects for Amazon. If the only matter of concern to
investors was short-term profits, then the prices of Amazon and Clorox should
have been much closer because their profits, at least in the short term, were
nearly identical.
Third, the stakeholder perspective is intrinsically difficult to implement,
and advocates of the idea that managers should consider all stakeholders’
interests along with those of shareholders do not typically indicate how man-
agers should carry it out. For example, how much emphasis should managers
place on the interests of different stakeholder groups? Are the interests of
employees more or less important than the desires of customers? Should mem-
bers of the local community who do no business with the firm have an equal
say with the firm’s suppliers? When different stakeholder groups disagree on
the action a firm should take, how should managers make important decisions?
In contrast, the goal of shareholder maximization clarifies what actions man-
agers should take.
Fourth, many people misinterpret the statement that managers should maxi-
mize shareholder wealth as implying that managers should take any action,
including illegal or unethical actions, that increases the stock price. Even the
most ardent supporters of shareholder value maximization as the firm’s primary
goal acknowledge that managers must act within ethical and legal boundaries.
Ethical Guidelines
Robert A. Cooke, a noted ethicist, suggests that the following questions be used
to assess the ethical viability of a proposed action.2
1. Is the action arbitrary or capricious? Does it unfairly single out an individual
or group?
2. Does the action violate the moral or legal rights of any individual or group?
3. Does the action conform to accepted moral standards?
4. Are there alternative courses of action that are less likely to cause actual or
potential harm?
Clearly, considering such questions before taking an action can help ensure
its ethical viability.
Today, many firms are addressing the issue of ethics by establishing corpo-
rate ethics policies that outline a set of fundamental principles guiding what their
employees must or must not do. Some firms go further and make their ethical
standards the centerpiece of their corporate image. For example, Google
famously adopted the motto “Don’t be evil.” Even for Google, however, ethical
dilemmas are unavoidable in business. The Focus on Practice box provides an
example of ethical concerns confronting Google in the wake of the 2016 U.S.
presidential election.
A major impetus toward the development of ethics policies has been the
Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002. The act requires firms to disclose whether they
have a code of ethics in place, and firms must report any waivers of those codes
for senior management. Companies that do not have a code of ethics must
explain why they have not adopted one. Many firms require their employees to
sign a formal pledge to uphold the firm’s ethics policies. Such policies typically
apply to employee actions in dealing with all corporate stakeholders, including
the public.
2. Robert A. Cooke, “Business Ethics: A Perspective,” in Arthur Andersen Cases on Business Ethics (Chicago: Arthur
Andersen, September 1991), pp. 2 and 5.
CHAPTER 1 The Role of Managerial Finance 59
The point is that nearly every employee, regardless of how his or her work
helps enhance the firm’s value, will interact with financial managers and will
benefit from a basic working knowledge of financial principles. Every firm has
limited resources, and employees in each part of a firm need some of those
resources to function. Inside a firm, resource allocation is partly a matter of
negotiation. Those who can make a better case that their work adds value will be
more successful in acquiring the needed resources. Often the key to negotiating
successfully in that environment is understanding the language of finance. To be
a successful marketer or supply chain analyst or human resources professional,
you must be able to explain how your work adds value in financial terms. This
book will help you do just that.
Naturally our primary focus here is on what financial managers do. There-
fore, we now turn to an overview of the managerial finance function.
Once firms know how they want to invest resources, the next critical deci-
financing decisions sion is where to obtain funding for those investments. Financing decisions deter-
Decisions that determine how mine how companies raise the money needed for investment opportunities. When
companies raise the money firms are just getting started and as they continue to grow, they require capital
they need to pursue investment from investors. Capital is the money raised by firms to finance their activities.
opportunities.
For this reason, the financing decision may also be called the capital structure
capital decision. Firms may raise capital by borrowing money from banks or other inves-
The money that firms raise to tors, or they may receive money from investors who want an ownership stake.
finance their activities. Firms that are profitable can reinvest their earnings and thereby gain access to
another form of capital. Although a firm’s financing (or capital structure) deci-
sions are almost certainly less important than its investment decisions, the mix of
funding sources that a company uses has a number of important implications.
For example, if a company chooses to borrow money, it is obligated to repay
that money even if business conditions deteriorate. That’s what happened to
General Motors (GM) when it did not have enough cash to pay its debt and went
bankrupt in June 2009. GM ultimately survived with the help of $51 billion in
government assistance (of which about $39 billion was eventually repaid), but
not every company that borrows money and later goes bankrupt is so fortunate.
In contrast, borrowing money can benefit shareholders, in part because in the
United States and many other countries, the tax code provides an incentive to
borrow. Specifically, the U.S. corporate tax code allows firms to treat interest
payments to lenders as a deductible business expense (which lowers the after-tax
cost of borrowing for the firm), whereas tax laws do not give firms a deduction
for cash dividend payments made to shareholders.
To visualize the difference between a firm’s investment and financing deci-
sions, refer to the balance sheet shown in Figure 1.1. Investment decisions gener-
ally refer to the items that appear on the left-hand side of the balance sheet, and
financing decisions relate to the items on the right-hand side. Keep in mind, though,
that financial managers make these decisions based on how they affect the firm’s
value, not on the accounting principles used to construct a balance sheet.
Whereas the investment and financing decisions of firms often involve major
strategic initiatives, on a day-to-day basis, financial managers spend more time mak-
working capital decisions ing various types of short-term financial decisions. Working capital decisions refer
Decisions that refer to the man- to the management of a firm’s short-term resources. These decisions involve track-
agement of a firm’s short-term ing and forecasting the firm’s cash position, making sure that the firm pays its bills
resources. on time and receives timely payments from customers, and calculating the optimal
amount of inventory the firm should keep on hand. Collectively, the resources that
a firm invests in items such as cash, inventory, accounts receivable, and accounts
FIG U RE 1 .1
Financial Activities Balance Sheet
Primary activities of the
financial manager Current Current
Making Assets Liabilities Making
Investment Financing
Decisions Fixed Long-Term Decisions
Assets Funds
CHAPTER 1 The Role of Managerial Finance 61
payable are known as the firm’s working capital. For many firms, the funds invested
in working capital are considerable. For example, in July 2017, Apple reported that
it held roughly $77 billion in cash in various short-term investments.
The Tradeoff between Return and Risk “Nothing ventured, nothing gained”
is a famous quote attributed to Benjamin Franklin. The equivalent financial princi-
ple is that a tradeoff exists between return and risk. Investors who want to earn
higher returns must be willing to accept greater risk. Or, from the perspective of a
business, a firm that puts investors’ funds in riskier projects must offer those inves-
tors higher returns. For financial managers tasked with advising firms on investment
decisions, this tradeoff means that any analysis of alternative investment projects
quantify both the returns that investments may provide and the risks that they entail.
Furthermore, at least for companies that have stock actively traded on stock
exchanges, the financial markets constantly send signals to managers about how
they are performing. Investors trade rapidly as they learn new information
about companies, so stock prices also respond rapidly to news as it emerges.
When investors hear positive news about a company (e.g., when a company
announces better-than-expected financial results), the company’s stock price
moves up. On February 28, 2017, the stock price of the biotechnology firm Kite
Pharma shot up almost 25% when the company released favorable results from
clinical trials of one of the company’s cancer-fighting drugs. On the other hand,
stock prices fall when unfavorable news becomes known. In January 2017,
shares of the toy manufacturer Mattel dropped 14% in a single day after the
company announced disappointing financial results from the previous holiday
shopping season.
How should managers respond to signals sent by the stock market? Although
the opinions of investors as revealed by movements in a company’s stock price
are not always correct, managers should pay close attention to what the market
is telling them. Investors have very strong incentives to evaluate the information
they receive about companies in an unbiased way. If a company announces plans
for a major new investment (e.g., the acquisition of another company) and its
stock price falls, managers should recognize that the market is skeptical about
the new investment, and they should carefully reconsider their plan to invest.
treasurer department and becomes a unique organization linked directly to the company
A key financial manager, who president or CEO through the chief financial officer (CFO). The lower portion of
manages the firm’s cash, over- the organizational chart in Figure 1.2 shows the structure of the finance function
sees its pension plans, and
in a typical medium to large firm.
manages key risks.
Reporting to the CFO are the treasurer, the controller, the director of
director of risk management
investor relations, and the director of internal audit. The treasurer manages the
Works with the treasurer to
manage risks that the firm faces
firm’s cash, investing surplus funds when available and securing outside financ-
related to movements in ing when needed. The treasurer also oversees a firm’s pension plans and,
exchange rates, commodity together with the director of risk management, manages critical risks related
prices, and interest rates. to movements in foreign currency values, interest rates, and commodity prices.
FIG U R E 1 .2
Corporate Organization
The general organization of a corporation and the finance function (which is shown in yellow)
Stockholders
elect
hires
President
Managers
(CEO)
C-Suite
Director,
Director,
Treasurer Investor Controller
Internal Audit
Relations
Sr. Manager
Director Foreign of Financial Cost
Cash
of Tax Exchange Planning and Accounting
Manager
Manager Analysis Manager
Director of Financial
Assistant Assistant
Risk Accounting
Treasurer Controller
Management Manager
64 PART ONE Introduction to Managerial Finance
E XA MPL E 1 .2 Jamie Teng is a financial manager for Nord Department Stores, a large chain of
upscale stores operating primarily in the western United States. She is currently
trying to decide whether to replace one of the firm’s computer servers with a new,
more sophisticated one that would both speed processing and handle a larger
volume of transactions. The new computer server would require a cash outlay of
$8,000, and the old one could be sold to net $2,000. The future benefits from
faster processing would be $10,000 in today’s dollars. The benefits over a similar
period from the old computer (measured in today’s dollars) would be $3,000.
Applying marginal cost–benefit analysis, Jamie organizes the data as follows:
Because the marginal benefits of $7,000 exceed the marginal costs of $6,000,
Jamie recommends purchasing the new computer to replace the old one. The
firm will experience a net benefit of $1,000 as a result of this action.
Relationship to Accounting
The firm’s finance and accounting activities are closely related and generally
overlap. In small firms, accountants often carry out the finance function; in large
firms, financial analysts often help compile accounting information. We can,
however, note two differences between finance and accounting; one is related to
the emphasis on cash flows, and the other to decision making.
E XA MPL E 1 .3 Nassau Corporation, a small yacht dealer, sold one yacht for $1,000,000 in the
calendar year just ended. Nassau originally purchased the yacht for $800,000.
0\/DE�)LQDQFH�6ROXWLRQ� Although the firm paid in full for the yacht during the year, at year’s end it has
9LGHR yet to collect the $1,000,000 from the customer. The accounting view and the
financial view of the firm’s performance during the year are given by the follow-
ing income and cash flow statements, respectively.
As the example shows, accrual accounting data do not fully represent the
circumstances of a firm. Thus, the financial manager must look beyond financial
statements to gain insight into existing or developing problems. Of course,
accountants are well aware of the importance of cash flows, and financial man-
agers use and understand accrual-based financial statements. Nevertheless, the
financial manager, by concentrating on cash flows, should be able to avoid insol-
vency and achieve the firm’s financial goals.
P E RSO NA L FI NA NCE E XA M PL E 1 . 4 Individuals rarely use accrual concepts. Rather, they rely
mainly on cash flows to measure their financial outcomes.
Generally, individuals plan, monitor, and assess their financial activities using
cash flows over a given period, typically a month or a year. Ann Bach projects
her cash flows during October 2018 as follows:
Amount
Item Inflow Outflow
Net pay received $4,400
Rent -$1,200
Car payment -450
Utilities -300
Groceries -800
Clothes -750
Dining out -650
Gasoline -260
Interest income 220
Misc. expense -425
Totals $4,620 -$4,835
Ann subtracts her total outflows of $4,835 from her total inflows of $4,620
and finds that her net cash flow for October will be –$215. To cover the $215
shortfall, Ann will have to either borrow $215 (putting it on a credit card is a
form of borrowing) or withdraw $215 from her savings. Alternatively, she may
decide to reduce her outflows in areas of discretionary spending such as cloth-
ing purchases, dining out, or those items that make up the $425 of miscella-
neous expense.
Decision Making The second major difference between finance and ac-
counting involves decision making. Accountants devote most of their attention to
the collection and presentation of financial data. Financial managers evaluate the
accounting statements, develop additional data, and make decisions based on
their assessment of the associated returns and risks. Of course, this does not
mean that accountants never make decisions or that financial managers never
gather data but rather that the primary emphases of accounting and finance are
different.
68 PART ONE Introduction to Managerial Finance
Weaknesses • Owner has unlimited liability in • Owners have unlimited • Taxes are generally higher because
that total wealth can be taken liability and may have to corporate income is taxed, and
to satisfy debts cover debts of other dividends paid to owners are also taxed
• Limited fund-raising power partners at a maximum 15% rate
tends to inhibit growth • Partnership is dissolved • More expensive to organize than other
• Proprietor must be when a partner dies business forms
jack-of-all-trades • Difficult to liquidate or • Subject to greater government
• Difficult to give employees transfer partnership regulation
long-run career opportunities • Lacks secrecy because regulations
• Lacks continuity when require firms to disclose financial results
proprietor dies
Partnerships
partnership A partnership consists of two or more owners doing business together for
A business owned by two or profit. Partnerships account for about 10% of all businesses, and they are
more people and operated for typically larger than sole proprietorships. Partnerships are common in the
profit.
accounting, law, finance, insurance, and real estate industries.
Most partnerships are established by a written contract known as articles
articles of partnership of partnership. In a general (or regular) partnership, all partners have unlim-
The written contract used to ited liability, and each partner is legally liable for all debts of the partnership.
formally establish a business Like a sole proprietorship, a partnership is a pass-through business, meaning
partnership. that partnerships do not pay income tax directly. Instead, income from the
partnership flows through to the partners and is taxed at the individual level.
Table 1.1 summarizes the strengths and weaknesses of proprietorships and
partnerships.
Corporations
A corporation is a business entity owned by individuals, but the corporation
itself is a legal entity distinct from its owners. A corporation has the legal
corporation
A legal business entity with
powers of an individual. It can sue and be sued, make and be party to con-
rights and duties similar to those tracts, and acquire property in its own name. Although fewer than 20% of
of individuals but with a legal all U.S. businesses are incorporated, the largest businesses nearly always are;
identity distinct from its owners. corporations account for roughly two-thirds of total business income.
CHAPTER 1 The Role of Managerial Finance 69
M ATT ER OF FACT
Source: Overview of Approaches to Corporate Integration, Joint Committee on Taxation, United States
Congress, May 17, 2016.
president or chief executive The president or chief executive officer (CEO) is responsible for managing
officer (CEO) day-to-day operations and carrying out the policies established by the board of
Corporate official responsible directors. The CEO reports periodically to the firm’s directors.
for managing the firm’s day-to- It is important to note the division between owners and managers in a large
day operations and carrying out
corporation, as shown by the dashed horizontal line in Figure 1.2. This separa-
the policies established by the
board of directors. tion is the source of the principal–agent problem mentioned earlier.
E XA MPL E 1 .5 Dan Webster is the sole proprietor of Webster Manufacturing. This year Webster
earned $80,000 before taxes from his business. Assuming that Dan has no other
income, the taxes he will owe on his business income are as follows:
0\/DE�)LQDQFH�6ROXWLRQ�
9LGHR Total taxes due = (0.10 * $9,525) + [0.12 * ($38,700 - $9,525)]
+ [0.22 * ($80,000 - $38,700)]
= $953 + $3,501 + $9,086
= $13,540
Notice that Webster’s tax liability has two components. The first $4,454 in tax,
denoted in Table 1.2 as the base tax, is calculated by multiplying 10% times
Webster’s first $9,525 in income and then multiplying 12% times Webster’s next
$29,175 in income. The sum of those two calculations is the $4,454 base tax
from line 3 in Table 1.2. On top of that, Webster must pay an additional 22% in
taxes on income above $38,700.
CHAPTER 1 The Role of Managerial Finance 71
marginal tax rate In a progressive tax rate structure like that shown in Table 1.2, there is a
The tax rate that applies to the difference between the marginal tax rate and the average tax rate. The mar-
next dollar of income earned. ginal tax rate represents the rate at which the next dollar of income is taxed.
In Table 1.2, the marginal tax rate is 10% if the taxpayer earns less than
$9,525. If income is more than $9,525 but less than $38,700, the marginal
tax rate is 12%. As income rises, the marginal tax rate rises. In the example
above, if Webster Manufacturing’s earnings increase to $82,501, the last $1
in income would be taxed at the marginal rate of 24%.
The average tax rate equals taxes paid divided by taxable income. For
average tax rate many taxpayers, the average tax rate does not equal the marginal tax
Calculated by dividing taxes rate because tax rates change with income levels. In the example above, Web-
paid by taxable income. ster Manufacturing’s marginal tax rate is 22%, but its average tax rate is
16.9% ($13,540 , $80,000). In most business decisions that managers make,
it’s the marginal tax rate that really matters. Remember that managers create
value for shareholders by taking actions for which the marginal benefits
exceed the marginal costs. Thus, managers should focus on the marginal tax
rate because that determines the marginal taxes they will pay or avoid as a
consequence of taking some action.
Figure 1.3 shows how marginal and average tax rates vary as an individu-
al’s taxable income rises. The blue line shows how the marginal tax rate
increases in “steps” as income moves into each higher tax bracket (note: the
graph omits the final 37% bracket for incomes above $500,000). The red line
shows that the average tax increases with income too, but the average rate is
generally less than the marginal rate. For example, a business owner with
income of $300,000 faces a 35% marginal tax rate but pays an average tax rate
of roughly 27% as illustrated in the following example.
FIG U RE 1 .3
40
Marginal and Average
Tax Rates at Different Marginal Tax Rate
35
Income Levels for a
Average Tax Rate (%)
Single Taxpayer 30
Average Tax Rate
Marginal and
25
20
15
10
0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300
Taxable Income ($ thousands)
72 PART ONE Introduction to Managerial Finance
E XA MPL E 1 .6 Peter Strong is a partner in Argaiv Software, and from that business he earned
taxable income of $300,000. Assuming that this is Peter’s only source of
income, from Table 1.2 we can see that based on Peter’s tax bracket, he faces a
marginal tax rate of 35%. How much in tax does Peter owe, and what is his
average tax rate? Table 1.2 shows a base tax of $45,690 for individuals with
income above $200,000 but below $500,000. Here’s where that base tax comes
from:
Base tax = (0.10 * $9,525) + (0.12 * $29,175) + (0.22 * $43,800)
+ (0.24 * $75,000) + 1 0.32 * +42,500 2
= $953 + $3,501 + $9,636 + $18,000 + +13,600
= $45,690
In other words, based on his first $200,000 in partnership earnings, Peter
owes $45,690 in taxes. In addition to that base tax, Peter must pay 35% tax on
the last $100,000 that he earns, so his total tax bill is
Total taxes due = $45,690 + (0.35 * $100,000) = $80,690
Given Peter’s total tax bill, we can calculate the average tax rate by dividing
taxes due by taxable income, as follows:
Average tax rate = $80,690 , $300,000 = 0.269 = 26.9%
Again we stress that in many cases the marginal tax rate and the average tax
rate are not equal, and in such cases, managers should focus on the marginal tax
rate when they make decisions about how to invest the firm’s money.
E XA MPL E 1 .7 Suppose that Argaiv Software (from Example 1.6) is organized as a corporation
rather than as a partnership, and suppose also that Argaiv paid $300,000 in
dividends to shareholders. For individuals, the tax code applies a different mar-
ginal rate to dividends than to ordinary income, with the top marginal tax rate
on dividends equal to 23.8%. On the $300,000 in corporate taxable income,
CHAPTER 1 The Role of Managerial Finance 73
Argaiv will pay taxes of $63,000 (0.21 * $300,000), and its shareholders could
pay as much as $71,400 (0.238 * $300,000) in taxes on the dividends that they
receive. Therefore, the total tax burden faced by Argaiv and its shareholders is
as high as $134,400, compared to the total tax bill of $80,690 that would be
owed if Argaiv were organized as a partnership as in the previous example. The
taxes paid on Argaiv dividends by its shareholders could be less than shown
here if shareholders are not in the highest individual tax bracket.
Regardless of their legal form, all businesses can earn ordinary income and
ordinary income capital gains. A corporation earns ordinary income through the sale of goods or
Income earned by a business services. A capital gain occurs if a firm sells an asset for more than its cost. Cur-
through the sale of goods or rent law treats these two types of income differently in the taxation of individu-
services. als, but not for corporations. The law requires corporations to simply add capital
capital gain gains to ordinary income when calculating taxes.
Income earned by selling an The law treats interest received by corporations as ordinary income (just
asset for more than it cost. like capital gains), but dividends received get a special tax break that moderates
the effect of double taxation. Dividends the firm receives on common and pre-
ferred stock held in other corporations are usually subject to a 50% exclusion
for tax purposes. The dividend exclusion in effect eliminates half of the poten-
tial tax liability from dividends received by the second and any subsequent
corporations.
In calculating their taxes, corporations can deduct operating expenses, as well
as interest expenses they pay to lenders. The tax deductibility of these expenses
reduces their after-tax cost. The following example illustrates the benefit of tax
deductibility.
E XA MPL E 1 .8 Two corporations, Debt Co. and No-Debt Co., earned $200,000 before interest
and taxes this year. During the year, Debt Co. paid $30,000 in interest. No-Debt
0\/DE�)LQDQFH�6ROXWLRQ� Co. had no debt and no interest expense. How do the after-tax earnings of these
9LGHR firms compare?
Both firms face a 21% flat tax rate. Debt Co. had $30,000 more interest expense
than No-Debt Co., but Debt Co.’s earnings after taxes are only $23,700 less than
those of No-Debt Co. This difference is attributable to Debt Co.’s $30,000 inter-
est expense deduction, which provides a tax savings of $6,300 (the tax bill is
$35,700 for Debt Co. versus $42,000 for No-Debt Co.). The tax savings can be
74 PART ONE Introduction to Managerial Finance
calculated directly by multiplying the 21% tax rate by the interest expense
(0.21 * $30,000 = $6,300). Similarly, the $23,700 after-tax interest expense
can be calculated directly by multiplying 1 minus the tax rate by the interest
expense 3(1 - 0.21) * $30,000 = $23,7004.
The tax deductibility of expenses reduces their actual (after-tax) cost to the
firm as long as the firm is profitable. If a firm experiences a net loss in a given
year, its tax liability is already zero. Even in this case, firms can deduct losses in
one year from income earned in subsequent years (prior losses cannot offset more
than 80% of taxable income in any subsequent year). Note that for both account-
ing and tax purposes interest is a tax-deductible expense, whereas dividends are
not. Because dividends are not tax deductible, their after-tax cost is equal to the
amount of the dividend.
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
corporate governance Corporate governance refers to the rules, processes, and laws by which companies
The rules, processes, and laws are operated, controlled, and regulated. It defines the rights and responsibilities of
by which companies are oper- the corporate participants, such as the shareholders, board of directors, officers
ated, controlled, and regulated. and managers, and other stakeholders, as well as the rules and procedures for
making corporate decisions. A well-defined corporate governance structure is
intended to benefit all corporate stakeholders by ensuring that the firm is run in a
lawful and ethical fashion, in full compliance with all corporate regulations.
Both internal and external forces influence firms’ corporate governance
practices. In terms of internal influences, clearly shareholders, through the board
of directors, exert influence on how a firm is governed. But when internal cor-
porate governance mechanisms fail, external forces may step in. Many of the
most important laws and regulations affecting U.S. corporations were passed in
the wake of some kind of scandal, brought about in part because of corporate
governance failures on a wide scale.
M ATT ER OF FACT
Source: “How CEO pay differs around the globe,” Equilar.com press release, August 17, 2016.
long as the employee remains at the firm. Vesting requirements and minimum
holding requirements ensure that the compensation of a firm’s senior manager is
always at least partially tied to the performance of the company’s stock.
Corporate compensation plans have been closely scrutinized by stockhold-
ers, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), and other government
entities. The total compensation in 2016 for the chief executive officers of the
500 largest U.S. companies is considerable. For example, in 2016 Expedia’s
CEO, Dara Khosrowshahi, earned $94.6 million.
Government Regulation
Government regulation shapes the corporate governance of all firms. During the
past decade, corporate governance has received increased attention because of
several high-profile corporate scandals involving abuse of corporate power and,
CHAPTER 1 The Role of Managerial Finance 79
CRITICAL THINKING
For many people working in a business, it is not obvious how the business creates
value for its owners. In this text, we emphasize that value creation balances risk and
return, so a critical evaluation of any proposed course of action requires an analysis
of the risks of that action as well as its potential rewards. Virtually every chapter in
this text provides guidance about how to make critical judgments regarding either
the risks or the rewards (or both) tied to corporate decisions. By mastering those
chapters will you learn how to apply criteria that lead to value-creating business
decisions. You will learn the assumptions behind and the key relationships driving
financial models, so even if your job does not involve building those models, you can
help shape them by providing the data and analysis that the financial analysts at your
firm use to provide financial justifications for key decisions. Your understanding of
financial principles will also help you to identify weaknesses in financial analysis
which, left uncorrected, might lead to suboptimal decisions.
SUMMARY
FOCUS ON VALUE
This chapter established the primary goal of the firm: to maximize the wealth
of the owners for whom the firm is being operated. For public companies, this
objective means that managers should act only on those opportunities that
they expect will create value for owners by increasing the stock price. Doing
so requires management to consider the returns and the risks of each proposed
action and their combined effect on the value of the firm’s stock.
80 PART ONE Introduction to Managerial Finance
OPENER-IN-REVIEW
In the chapter opener, you learned that with Brookdale Senior Living’s stock
price trading around $12.35 per share, one of the firm’s investors proposed an
idea that might net the firm’s shareholders $21 per share in cash. Suppose that
Brookdale acted upon the suggestion of Land and Buildings and that as a result
Brookdale was able to distribute $21 per share in cash to its investors. Suppose
that after selling its real estate assets and paying out cash to shareholders,
Brookdale’s shares were worth $5 per share. Are Brookdale’s investors better or
worse off? Specifically, calculate the percentage change in the wealth of share-
holders (including the cash they received and the change in the value of their
stock) that would hypothetically occur if Brookdale acted according to this plan.
Now suppose that Brookdale had 185.45 million shares outstanding. What is
the total dollar value of wealth created (or destroyed) by the restructuring pro-
posed by Land and Buildings?
LG 4
ST1–1 Emphasis on Cash Flows Worldwide Rugs is a rug importer located in the
United States that resells its import products to local retailers. Last year, World-
wide Rugs imported $2.5 million worth of rugs from around the world, all of
which were paid for prior to shipping. On receipt of the rugs, the importer
immediately resold them to local retailers for $3 million. To allow its retail cli-
ents time to resell the rugs, Worldwide Rugs sells to retailers on credit. Prior to
the end of its business year, Worldwide Rugs collected 85% of its outstanding
accounts receivable.
a. What is the accounting profit that Worldwide Rugs generated for the year?
b. Did Worldwide Rugs have a successful year from an accounting perspective?
c. What is the financial cash flow that Worldwide Rugs generated for the year?
d. Did Worldwide Rugs have a successful year from a financial perspective?
e. If the current pattern persists, what is your expectation for the future success of
Worldwide Rugs?
LG 5 E1–1 Ann and Jack have been partners for several years. Their firm, A & J Tax Prepara-
tion, has been very successful, as the pair agree on most business-related questions.
One disagreement, however, concerns the legal form of their business. For the past
2 years, Ann has tried to convince Jack to incorporate. She believes there is no
downside to incorporating and sees only benefits. Jack strongly disagrees; he thinks
the business should remain a partnership forever.
First, take Ann’s side, and explain the positive side to incorporating the busi-
ness. Next, take Jack’s side, and state the advantages to remaining a partnership.
Last, what information would you want if you were asked to make the decision for
Ann and Jack?
82 PART ONE Introduction to Managerial Finance
LG 4 E1–2 You are the chief financial officer (CFO) of Morb lights, a manufacturer of lighting
components for cars. The board of directors have decided that there is a need to
divert investments toward LED-based lighting solutions instead of traditional light
bulbs. You are currently evaluating two alternative projects. The first is to inte-
grate new technology in an existing factory, where the cash flows for the first 4
years will be below average as the production will be affected due to refitting of
facilities. However, from year 5 it will increase to above-average levels once full
capacity is achieved. The second project is to take over an existing small business
with the required production facility. This is expected to increase cash flows to
above-average levels immediately for the next 4 years, but decrease to lower-than-
average cash flows from year 5, when the factory’s technology becomes outdated.
How do you choose from the two available options? Given the strategy of the firm,
what other factors need to be taken into consideration before making this decision?
LG 4 E1–3 The Quickclick Media Ltd., announced that the profit for the previous year is twice
the amount earned in the previous year, an improvement from the projected num-
bers. The chief human resources officer (CHRO) suggested that the employees need
to be rewarded for their efforts. To keep them motivated, she insisted on giving
them a significant cash bonus in the following month. The chief financial officer
(CFO), however, contended that there was insufficient cash and that they should
wait till the next quarter before paying each employee a cash bonus.
How can the company, which is a profitable one, have insufficient cash flows?
Explain your answer.
LG 5 E1–4 The chief financial officer (CFO) of New Age Fashion Ltd. has just received a
request from a project manager to authorize an expenditure in the amount of
£45,000. The manager states that this expenditure is necessary for the last stage
development of a space navigation system, which is based on a programming lan-
guage called Xtor. As a space engineer and financial manager, you know that Xtor is
almost obsolete and is being replaced by alternatives that provide better cross-plat-
form compatibility. However, the project manager insists that they should continue
with the last tranche of payment because over £1.5 million has already been spent
on developing this navigation system. It would be a shame to waste all the time and
resources that have been invested.
Advise the CFO regarding whether she should authorize the £45,000 proposed
expenditure. Use marginal cost–benefit analysis to explain your reasoning.
LG 6 E1–5 Premier Baking Ltd. has recently appointed a new CEO to run its bakery business,
which supplies to supermarkets and restaurants. The new CEO has instituted a new
compensation policy and dropped the earlier incentive scheme, which was based on
overall production achieved within the targeted time limits and quality standards.
The quality control manager has now reported that there is a significant increase in
production delays and delivery mix-up leading to an increasing number of customer
complaints.
Explain how the delays and delivery errors could represent a case of agency
costs. How could Premier Bakery counter these agency costs??
LG 5 E1–6 Eastern Trading Company has a pretax trading profit of €250,000. Britain has a flat
corporation tax rate of 19% on trading profits, while Ireland has a flat rate of 12.5%
on trading profits. As Britain is still in Eurozone, the company can register its business
CHAPTER 1 The Role of Managerial Finance 83
in either country and follow their respective tax laws. What will be the tax liability for
Eastern Trading if they are registered in Britain and what will it be if they are regis-
tered in Ireland?
X
PROBLEMS Select problems are available in 0\/DE�)LQDQFH �The MyLab icon
indicates problems in Excel format available in 0\/DE�)LQDQFH.
LG 4 P1–2 Accrual income versus cash flow for a period The Motor Corporation sold vehicles
for $500,000 to one specific dealer during the year. At the end of the financial year,
the dealer still owed The Motor Corporation $350,000. The cost of the vehicles sold
was $400,000, and this cost was incurred and paid by The Motor Corporation.
a. Determine the firm’s net profit for the past year using the accrual basis of accounting.
b. Determine the firm’s net cash flow for the past year using the cash basis of
accounting.
c. The accountant and financial manager need to present the results to the CEO of
The Motor Corporation. What will be their message regarding the performance
of the corporation?
a. Determine Sheldon’s total cash inflows and cash outflows for the month of
March.
b. What is Sheldon’s net cash flow for the month of March? Explain the meaning of
the term “net cash flow.”
c. What advice would you give Sheldon if there is a surplus of funds?
d. What advice would you give Sheldon if there is a shortage of funds?
LG 2 LG 4 P1–4 Marginal cost–benefit analysis and the goal of the firm Wendy Winter needs to
determine whether the current warehouse system should be upgraded to a new sys-
tem. The new system would require an initial cash outlay of $250,000. The current
system could be sold for $55,000. The monetary benefit of the new system over the
next 5 years is $325,000, while the monetary benefit of the current system over the
same period is $125,000. Furthermore, it is expected that the firm’s stock price will
increase if the new system is implemented because it will make the firm more cost
efficient and cost effective in the long run.
a. Identify and describe the analysis Wendy should use to make the decision.
b. Calculate the marginal benefit of the proposed new warehouse system.
c. Calculate the marginal cost of the proposed new warehouse system.
d. What should Wendy’s recommendation be to the firm regarding the new ware-
house system? Explain your answer.
e. If the new system is implemented, will the firm achieve the primary financial goal
of managers?
LG 6 P1–5 Identifying agency problems, costs, and resolutions You are the CEO of Nelson
Corporation, and the current stock price is $27.80. Pollack Enterprises announced
today that it intends to buy Nelson Corporation. To obtain all the stock of Nelson
Corporation, Pollack Enterprises is willing to pay $38.60 per share. At a meeting
with your management, you realize that the management is not happy with the
offer, and is against the takeover. Therefore, with the full support of your manage-
ment team, you are fighting to prevent the takeover from Pollack Enterprises.
Is the management of Nelson Corporation acting in the best interest of the Nel-
son Corporation stockholders? Explain your reasoning.
LG 6 P1–7 Average corporate tax rates Ordinary income in 2017 was taxed subject to the rates
shown in the accompanying table. Using the data in the table, perform the following:
a. Calculate a firm’s tax liability, after-tax earnings, and average tax rate for the
following levels of corporate earnings before taxes: $20,000; $70,000; $300,000;
$700,000; $1.2 million; $16 million; and $22 million.
b. Plot the average tax rate (measured on the y-axis) and the pretax income levels
(measured on the x-axis). Explain the relationship between average tax rate and
pretax income level.
CHAPTER 1 The Role of Managerial Finance 85
Tax calculation
Taxable income brackets Base tax 1 (Marginal rate 3 amount over bracket lower limit)
LG 6 P1–8 Marginal corporate tax rates Using the corporate tax rate schedule given in the pre-
vious problem, perform the following:
a. Find the marginal tax rate for the following levels of corporate earnings before
taxes: $12,000; $40,000; $70,000; $90,000; $300,000; $550,000; $1.3 million;
and $22 million.
b. Plot the marginal tax rate (measured on the y-axis) against the pretax income
levels (measured on the x-axis). Explain the relationship between the marginal
tax rate and pretax income levels.
LG 6 P1–9 Interest versus dividend income Depot Logistics Inc. has declared pretax income
from its operations of $560,000. In addition, it also received interest payment of
$40,000 on bond stock held in Warehouse PLC. During the year they also received
$40,000 in income from dividends on its 20% common stock holding in Zephir
PLC. Depot Logistics is in the 30% tax bracket and is eligible for a 70% dividend
exclusion on its Zephir PLC stock.
a. Calculate the tax liability for Depot Logistics on its operating income.
b. Calculate the tax and after-tax income attributable to the interest income
received on account of bond stock, from Warehouse PLC.
c. Find the tax and after-tax income owing to the dividend income received on
account of common stock, from Zephir PLC.
d. Compare and comment on the after-tax amounts resulting from the interest
income and dividend income calculated in parts b and c.
e. What is the firm’s total tax liability for the year?
LG 6 P1–10 Interest versus dividend expense Derwent Ltd., has announced that the earnings
before income and taxes is going to be £300,000 for the current year. Assuming cor-
porate tax rate for Derwent Ltd., is a flat 30%, compute the firm’s profit after taxes
and earnings available for common stockholders (earnings after taxes and preferred
stock dividends, if any) under following conditions:
a. The firm pays £70,000 in interest.
b. The Firm pays £70,000 in preferred stock dividends.
86 PART ONE Introduction to Managerial Finance
LG 2 P1–12 ETHICS PROBLEM One of the key risk areas that corporates need to manage is
“ethical risks.” Do you think that management of ethical risks is as important for
businesses as management of financial risks? Explain how ethical problems may
affect a firm’s profits and stock price.
SPREADSHEET EXERCISE
TO DO
Create a spreadsheet to conduct a marginal cost–benefit analysis for Monsanto Cor-
poration, and determine the following:
a. The marginal benefits of the proposed new equipment.
b. The marginal costs of the proposed new equipment.
c. The net benefit of the proposed new equipment.
d. What would you recommend the firm do? Why?