Lift Planning
Lift Planning
Lift Planning
Introduction
Competent lift planning, which includes Level 1 or Level 2 risk assessment, is fundamental to safe lifting
operations. It has been shown that inadequate or insufficient lift planning, along with poor supervision
and hazard awareness, is a major root cause of lifting related incidents.
With this in mind it is unsurprising that internationally, it is a regulatory requirement that all lifting
operations “must be planned by a competent person”. But perhaps more accurate, would be to state
that all lifting operations “must be competently planned”.
Lift plans shall be developed by a competent person along with input from those involved in the
operation, before approval, endorsement and authorisation.
Lift plans shall also consider the deck or ground strength required to carry out the operation safely.
Most day-to-day lifts will indeed be planned by a single competent person but depending on the
complexity of the lifting operation and / or the magnitude of the lift, the planning will probably involve
the input from a lot more than one competent person, for example for a heavy offshore lift between a
floating crane, a lay barge and a fixed installation, there may well be input from…
These people all have their own competencies in different areas, but which may not just be relevant but
actually crucial to the safety of the overall lifting operation.
Many factors have to be considered with regards to reducing risks during the transportation and
placement of a load on site. Lift planners and / or project teams need to consider all the hazards and
risks, and where possible design them out. Any risks that cannot be designed out must be considered
and communicated throughout the planning and construction phases and applied to the task specific
Job Safety Analysis and risk assessment.
With this in mind the purpose of this awareness course is to highlight the many factors that must be
considered when planning a lifting operation.
Contents
During this course the slides will stop periodically, at which point you will be required to answer a series
of questions to confirm understanding. The questions must be answered correctly before you can
proceed to the next section. As a result, at the end of the course, you will have met the course objective
of acquiring a demonstrable level of knowledge and understanding of the following subjects…
Regulations
Categorization of Lifting Operations
Lift Planning
The Load
Lifting and Landing Sites
Route to be Travelled
Environmental Factors
How you are going to lift it?
How many people will be involved?
How will everyone communicate?
Step-by-step Procedure
Diagrams or Sketches
Rigging / Material Lists
Approval, Authorisation and Endorsement
Management of Change, Lessons Learned, and…
A Safe Approach to Lifting
Before moving onto the next section, we would advise that you have a pen and paper ready to take
notes as you progress through the course. This will assist you when you are required to answer the
questions at the end of each section.
Regulations
In the US there are very few specific requirements regarding the need for lift planning.
For example, in API RP 2D it is not mentioned in the main body of the document, but does state in
appendix A3 for Rigger training, that training in lift planning is required. However, this may change in
future editions.
Another US example is 1926.1432, Multiple crane / derrick lifts, supplemental requirements; it states in
plan development…
…Before beginning a crane / derrick operation in which more than one crane / derrick will be supporting
the load, the operation must be planned.
Whereas, in Norway and the UK there are specific requirements for the planning of lifting operations,
competently.
For example, in Norway, NORSOK Standard R003, the Safe Use of Lifting equipment, and R005 the Safe
use of lifting and transport equipment in onshore petroleum plants, both state…
…Each lifting operation shall be planned in order to ensure safe execution and that all predictable risks
are taken into consideration. The planning shall also be carried out by personnel who have the relevant
competence.
In the UK, regulation 8 of the Lifting Operations and Lifting Equipment Regulations specifies that every
lifting operation must be properly planned by a competent person, appropriately supervised and carried
out in a safe manner.
It is also indicated in LOLER’s Approved Code of Practice that the level of planning and risk assessment
increases with the complexity of the lifting operation, as does the required level of supervision.
The result of a lifting-related incident is almost always very costly, in terms of damaged equipment and
plant, subsequent delays to the job, the costs of an investigation, but more importantly, the costs,
financial and otherwise, to the people who are hurt or killed by the accident.
For these reasons, lifting operations, whether carried out offshore, onshore or onboard a vessel must be
strictly controlled to make sure that the personnel doing the work have the requisite amount of
knowledge and experience to carry out the work safely.
To ensure that lifting plans are developed consistently all lifting operations must to be categorised as
either category 1, 2 or 3 and shall dictate the required level of…
Risk assessment
Lift planning
Training and competence
Approval and authorisation
Endorsement, and…
Peer review when required
Categorisation is completed by using the applicable flowcharts, which are specific to the environment
where the lift will be performed. The environments are…
Onshore
Offshore
Marine, and…
Subsea
These flow charts contain a list of questions, columns for answers and category areas, which are aligned
to specific questions. Starting at the top and working down, the user answers, either ‘yes’ or ‘no’ to the
questions.
The first question that is answered ‘yes’ identifies the category of lift by aligning with a defined area and
therefore no need to answer any further questions. For example, the onshore categorisation flow chart
asks some of the following questions, which are aligned to category 3…
If you answered ‘yes’ to the second question, then it would be a category 3 lift. If however, you
answered ‘no’ to all the category 3 questions, you would then keep going and answer the category 2
questions, and so on, until you either answered ‘yes’ to a question or until all the questions were
answered with a ‘no’.
Personnel should also refer to the Lift Management Flow Chart for further guidance.
These lifts can be categorised as Category 1, if they meet the following criteria…
A formal rig-site lifting competence assessment program is implemented and approved by the
Global Wells Organisation Lifting Technical Authority
The lifting plan has been authorised by the Site Lifting Co-ordinator as Category 1
A risk assessment that recognises that the lift shall be carried out by the drill and well service
crew has been developed and approved
The drilling and well service crew have the necessary experience and are assessed as competent
to perform this category of lift
The lift is for drilling and well operations and not for the maintenance of associated drill floor or
well operations equipment
The lift is on or above the rig floor / pipe deck or other drilling areas
The Site Lifting Co-Ordinator has agreed that the drill crew can execute the lift
One person is appointed in charge and in control of the lifting operation, and…
The senior tool pusher / well site leader (or their delegate) maintains a register of persons
competent to supervise lifting operations in drilling areas
If lift fails to meet these criteria, then it must be categorized as per the standard categorization process.
It should also be noted that the use of permanently installed drilling equipment, such as the draw works,
bridge racker and iron roughneck for example are already covered in existing drilling documents and are
therefore excluded from the Management of Lifting Operations and Lifting Equipment UDP.
Section 2
Lift Planning
Lifting plans have essentially three main sections; a rigging / materials list, a method statement and a
sketch or drawing, which is optional depending on the complexity of the lift. These sections are where
the majority of information is recorded.
The detail in the method statement and material list is also dictated by the complexity of the lift, for
example category 1 or routine lift plans may only have one page, whereas category 3 or complex lift
plans may have several pages.
To start with a lift plan should begin with a brief description of the lifting operation, which should detail
for example the following points…
This initial outline is the start of the planning process. Each point can then be considered, and then the
relevant information entered into the lifting plan.
The Load
Where is the centre of gravity located? This must be known so that reaction forces, sling
tensions, stability, etc. can be determined
Structural integrity; is it rigid or flexible, is it capable of withstanding the forces to be applied?
Is there a risk of dropped objects
It’s size and shape, with regards to clearances during the lift, travel and landing
What’s inside? Does it contain a fluid, is there residual material, will it affect stability, etc?
Will it have to be slung, does the load need protecting from the slings, do the slings need
protection from the load, or…
Does it have dedicated lifting points?
If lifting points are fitted, they need to be designed dimensionally to correspond with a shackle or other
type of connecting equipment and with an applicable capacity. The following points also need to be
considered regarding lifting points…
Finally, but probably the first question asked about the load is, what does it weigh?
The weight of the load will determine the size of the rigging and will influence your choice of lifting
appliance and its capacity. Therefore, you must first find out the weight of the load from a accurate
source, for example from the manufacturers documentation, a data plate attached to the load, a
shipping manifest, calculation, etc. and then it should be verified or confirmed from another source.
If these are not available and only an estimate can be made, then it is essential that a reserve or
contingency factor is added to the estimation, such as 25 percent.
There are also other circumstances, such as in the marine environment where dynamic loadings are
anticipated, where a weight factor, contingency or reserve is also required. This would be calculated by
multiplying the gross weight of the load by the reserve or contingency factor.
Adequate contingencies, relative to the lift environment must be considered and included during the lift
design stage to ensure that the load, lifting equipment and site conditions are capable of safely
maintaining the anticipated loadings.
When confirming the weight of a load the equipment would normally be a calibrated load cell
suspended from a crane but in the case of heavier loads such as offshore modules, these can be
weighed by using a set of calibrated hydraulic rams or jacks. This is usually the most cost-effective way
of weighing a heavy load. Using this set up will also allow you to confirm the centre of gravity in the
horizontal plane.
There are also subsea considerations, regarding the load, such as…
To finish this section, always remember to allow for the additional weight of the rigging and when
applicable the crane hook block when selecting the lifting appliance.
Next you will need to consider where the load is located and where you are lifting it to.
This can exacerbate any problems encountered during the lifting operation especially if you are working
within a weather window. If a load cannot be re-landed, a more in-depth level of planning is required
and increased safety factors or contingencies applied to the lifting accessories and appliances.
Section 3
Route to be Travelled
Whether you are just moving a load or travelling with the load, for example using a crawler crane or Self
Propelled Modular Transporter, you need to inspect the route to be travelled (as long as you are not
lifting over water) as this will help identify any obstacles such as power lines, underground services,
height restrictions, clearances between existing pieces of plant and equipment and the actual ground
conditions.
If the route takes you close to high voltage electricity cables it is advisable to call the power company to
see if the power can be switched off for the duration of the lifting operation. Specific allowable distances
from the power lines change depending where you are in the world so they should be verified during
the planning stage.
On a busy worksite, you can also take this opportunity to cordon off the area to primarily prevent non-
involved personnel inadvertently walking under or near to a suspended load but also to keep personnel
away from drop and equipment tipping zones.
When lifting subsea the route may not be directly below the crane tip, currents and tides may drift the
crane wire and load away from the vessel. The depth of water must also be considered.
If you are lifting between a vessel and an installation offshore, remember to consider the additional
forces created due to the dynamics. In addition, be aware of the drop cone criteria if lifting over or near
subsea process equipment.
This brings us onto lifting over or in close proximity to live plant, which is defined as any lifting operation
where there is a process safety risk of the load, lifting appliances and / or lifting accessories impacting,
damaging and / or rupturing live plant.
Live plant is defined as equipment containing hazardous, pressurised, energised or strategic resource.
Examples include: pipes, electrical cables or vessels containing hydrocarbons. It also includes primary
power generation units, for example turbines and their exhaust systems.
Lifting over or in close proximity to live plant, regardless of lift category shall not be undertaken unless…
In addition, these plans should only be reused for repeat operations, where the original operation lift
plan, equipment, assumptions made and operating conditions are verified as unchanged.
During the planning stage for the route to be travelled, details, if applicable, should also be recorded on
how hands-free lifting and the safe use of taglines will be accomplished.
Finally, on this subject, if you are transporting a load, you must consider stability. Centre of gravity
height, ground conditions, incline angle, etc. must all be assessed. You certainly do not want to follow a
successful lift with the load falling off or overturning the transport.
Environmental Factors
After assessing the lift and landing locations and the route to be travelled the following factors need to
be considered with regards to the environmental conditions during the lift, which are for example…
For example, a crane boom can act as a conductor and attract a lightning strike during a thunderstorm.
Therefore, if there are clear signs of an approaching thunderstorm, lifting operations must cease and all
personnel should be moved out of the vicinity of the crane, until the possibility of danger passes.
In addition, wind can exert additional forces to the crane and the load, which can affect both the
strength and stability of the crane and safe handling of the load. It is therefore essential that the
maximum wind speed at which the crane must be taken out of service is recorded on the lift plan.
We will now look at the criteria to consider regarding the lifting appliances and the rigging. After first
asking how much the load weighs, this is probably the most common second question; that is ‘how are
we going to lift it?
To start with, all equipment must be used within its rated capacity and never purposely overloaded. It
must also only be used for the purpose for which it was designed, such as fitted with the correct
counterweight, the correct outrigger configuration to be used, supplied with suitable instructions, load
charts, etc.
In addition…
If a crane is to be used, can it operate within it’s safe operating radius, which should be based on
the worst-case radius
Is the appliance within the acceptable capacity utilisation percentage, such as 80% or under
If using more than one crane, you will need to consider their relative lifting positions, capacities
and operational speeds
If you are using crawler cranes, have you considered their relative travelling speeds?
If using multiple air hoists or manual hoists, are the hoisting speeds compatible and what is the
acceptable working angle, for example during cross hauling operations?
Have you considered how to control the level of the load and hence the loading in each hoist?
and…
Will extreme heat or cold affect the capacity of the equipment?
Next, whether just lifting, slewing and landing the load using a mobile crane or travelling with the load
using a crawler crane or transporter, the ground has to adequately withstand the intended loadings.
Therefore, the overall gross weight to be applied, the maximum allowable ground bearing pressure
calculations and load spreading details must be supplied.
If the crane has to work anywhere near an excavation, remember that the outrigger / track load enters
the supporting surface at 45 degrees so it’s imperative that the outrigger / track is positioned no closer
to the edge of the excavation than a distance slightly greater than the depth of the excavation. The
location of any underground services such as sewers, utility supplies, etc. must also be verified.
Remember also that the ground conditions can change with the weather, and that it’s load-bearing
capacity can be reduced especially when it rains.
There is also criteria specific to the rigging or lifting accessories that need to be considered, for example
the…
In this section we will also cover specific considerations with regards to uncertified steelwork and lifting
points, Self Propelled Modular Transporters (SPMTs), marine and / or subsea lifts and lifting personnel.
If the use of uncertified steelwork and lifting points is required, then they shall only be used after
assessment and their use approved by a Structural Technical Authority. If used repeatedly or
periodically then they must be…
Assessed
Examined
Overload tested
Certified, colour coded, and…
Marked with a SWL or WLL and unique identification mark
SPMTs have the ability to lift and lower loads and as such their use must be planned. However, there is
specific information when using this type of equipment that must be considered and contained in the lift
plan, this includes for example…
As-loaded drawings
Stability calculations, which should be based on a three-point suspension grouping with a
minimum, non-combined centre of gravity and stability angle of nine degrees. Where nine
degrees is not achievable a combined centre of gravity should be used and a physical connection
made between the load and the trailer
Route survey, swept path analysis, and…
Lashing calculations
This type of lift is a category 3 operation, with the lift plan being sufficient to demonstrate that the load
can be safely transported through to the point of installation at site. In addition, all SPMTs should use a
simple level gauge in addition to the contractors’ monitoring system.
In addition to the previous considerations all marine and / or subsea lift plans should consider the
following…
Remember, subsea lifts are a specialised form of lifting and therefore the design of which should only be
undertaken by qualified engineers with experience in this area.
When the lifting of personnel is required, whether with cranes, forklifts or winches and regardless of lift
environment they shall also be considered as a high-risk operation and be categorised as a category 3
lift.
This type of lift operation shall also only be used when it is…
Not practicable to gain access by a less hazardous means
Fully managed in accordance with strict procedures, and…
Rigorously risk assessed to ensure that the risk of personnel falling from a carrier, being crushed,
trapped or struck while being transported in a carrier has been mitigated to as low as reasonably
practicable
In addition…
Lifting Technical Authorities need to monitor and record the quantity and type of personnel
lifting operations performed at each facility
Lifting equipment for lifting personnel shall be thoroughly examined for the purposes of
recertification at least every six months
Site Lifting Coordinators need to consult Site Managers before approving any lift plan, which
involves the lifting of personnel
Only carried out with lifting equipment, which has been specifically designed for lifting
personnel, certified for lifting personnel, and…
A rescue plan is developed, made readily available and effectively communicated
SECTION 4
In addition, when you list the personnel required to perform the lifting
operation, for example Riggers, Banksmen, Slingers, Crane
Operators, etc. remember to verify their qualifications and experience
levels.
Step-by-step Procedure
This will help identify any possible problems and allow you to deal with
them at the planning stage rather than have them crop up during the
actual lifting operation, for example you may rearrange the order of
events to increase efficiency.
If written correctly with all the relevant information, each and every
person involved will know exactly what they are supposed to be
doing. They will know what equipment goes where, when to operate
it, they will be aware of any specific hazards and will know where to
position themselves to reduce the risk of injury in the event of things
going wrong.
Diagrams or Sketches
Crane Model
Headroom limitations
If sketches exist for a lifting operation from a previous time, they must
be reviewed to ensure there have been no changes which could affect
the efficiency / safety of the lift.
Once you have created your diagram / sketches of the lifting operation
and prepared the step-by-step procedure, you will have to put together
a rigging and materials list.
Getting back to the list, it should contain all the rigging equipment
required to do the lift, for example cranes, hoists, winches, slings,
shackles, etc. You must be accurate with the descriptions to make
sure you get the correct materials.
By the same token, if asking for multi-leg slings with varying leg-
lengths, for example to suit a load with an off-set centre of gravity, get
the rigging shop to mark up the legs accordingly so you know which
leg gets attached to which pad eye on the load.
All personnel who approve, authorise, endorse and peer review lifting
plans shall have a defined level of competence in compliance with
local OMS procedures.
The first step in this process is approval and all category 1, 2 and 3 lift
plans shall be approved by a Site Competent Person.
Many injuries, and some fatalities, have resulted from not following
this approach. Therefore, the purpose of this section is to instruct
personnel that anyone can “stop-the-job” when there is a deviation or
where they suspect that safety has or is about to be compromised. In
addition, once the job has been stopped, that there is a process that
should be followed, which is management of change. This process
provides a route for personnel to follow, which is designed to ensure
that changes are managed safely and efficiently.
Modifications to equipment
Competence
During the planning stage, ensure that the load imposed on any item
of equipment or on part of any item does not exceed the equipment’s
safe working load. When there is any uncertainty about the weight of
the load or the load likely to be applied to a particular part of the
equipment, it is recommended that load-sensing devices be used. In
addition to the above, care should be taken to ensure that at all stages
of the lift, the load remains in a stable condition.
Correct Use
The equipment should be used only for the specific purpose for which
it is designed and should not be adapted for any other purposes
without the approval of a Technical Authority.
Plan to carry out trial lifts. This allows the operator to check his
estimations of balance, stability, and general security of the load while
it is in a relatively safe position. If any discrepancies are found the
load should be lowered and the slinging revised. The sequence of
trial lift and adjustment should be repeated until the operator is
satisfied that the load is balanced, stable and secure.
Think Ahead
Plan the route the load will be travelling on the way to the lay-down
point and ensure any obstructions are cleared away. In addition,
ensure that the lay-down point is of adequate size and capable of
taking the weight of the load.
Safety Margins
Alternatively, where the capacity is limited, the use of load sensors will
provide continuous guidance on individual lift-point equipment
loadings as the operation proceeds. A further alternative is to
carefully calculate the loads, which will be imposed but care must be
taken to ensure that no false assumptions are made especially with
regard to the weight and the position of the centre of gravity.
Finally, always remember, the use of lifting equipment beyond its SWL
is strictly forbidden. Particular attention must be given to the
avoidance of over-loading, incorrect slinging and trapping of slings
between the load and the ground or floor.