2-Public Policy Analysis and Devlopment
2-Public Policy Analysis and Devlopment
2-Public Policy Analysis and Devlopment
AND DEVELOPMENT
THE SCREENING OF POLICY ALTERNATIVES IS BASED UPON THE CRITERIA FOR POLICY
ALTERNATIVE ANALYSIS AS SHOWN BELOW:
• EVALUATIVE CRITERIA
• ADMINISTRATION
•EF = EFFICIENCY
• EQ = EQUITY
• PL = POLITICAL/LEGAL
• A = ADMINISTRATIVE
• I = IMPROVABILITY
•
• OF THE FIVE CRITERIA, THE ONE ASSIGNED THE HIGHEST DEGREE OF
INFLUENCE (WEIGHTING =.30) OVER THE POLICY OUTCOME WAS EFFICIENCY.
THE EFFICIENCY CRITERIA IS VIEWED AS MOST CRITICAL TO THE POLICY
PROCESS AS IT CAPTURES THE POTENTIAL FOR THE ALTERNATIVE TO
MAXIMIZE NET BENEFITS TO THOSE IMPACTED IN THE SYSTEM. THE
STRONGER RELATIVE RATING ASSIGNED TO THIS CRITERIA ALLOWS FOR THE
PRIORITIZATION OF MAXIMALLY EFFICIENT APPROACHES TO ACCOMPLISHING
POLICY GOALS, WHICH MIGHT BE IMPLEMENTED IN AN “IDEAL” WORLD
UNCONSTRAINED BY PRACTICAL LIMITATIONS, SUCH AS POLITICAL
ENVIRONMENT OR EQUITY CONCERNS.
•THE SECOND IN TERMS OF INFLUENCE WAS THE
POLITICAL AND LEGAL FEASIBILITY CRITERIA
(WEIGHTING =.25). POLITICAL AND LEGAL FEASIBILITY
ALSO RECEIVED A HIGH WEIGHT INDICATING THE
IMPORTANCE OF POLITICAL SUPPORT TO SUCCESSFUL
ADOPTION AND IMPLEMENTATION OF POLICIES.
•THE THIRD TIER IS COMPOSED OF THE TWO OF THE THREE
PRACTICAL CRITERIA FOR ASSESSING POLICY PREFERENCES,
EACH ASSIGNED AN EQUAL WEIGHTING OF .20. THIS TIER
INCLUDES MEASURES OF ADMINISTRATIVE BURDEN AND
IMPROVABILITY. THE CRITERIA WERE PRIORITIZED ONLY
SLIGHTLY LOWER THAN THE PRACTICAL CRITERIA OF POLITICAL
AND LEGAL FEASIBILITY, AND ARE CONSIDERED TO BE BOTH
DESIRABLE AND NECESSARY FOR SUCCESSFUL
IMPLEMENTATION.
•THE LOWEST PRIORITY CRITERIA USED IN JUDGING POLICY
PREFERENCES WAS EQUITY, RECEIVING A WEIGHT OF .05. EQUITY
WITHIN THE SYSTEM, THOUGH DESIRED WHEN FEASIBLE, IS NOT
CRITICAL TO THE ACHIEVEMENT OF OUTCOMES FOR SEVERAL
REASONS. FIRST, THE NEGATIVE IMPACTS OF THE POLICY ARE
LIMITED TO MONETARY LOSSES AND ARE NOT TYPICALLY
ASSOCIATED WITH LARGER EQUITY CONCERNS, SUCH AS THE
VIOLATION OF FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS; FURTHER, THOSE ADVERSELY
IMPACTED (E.G., COMPUTER OPERATORS) DO NOT CONSTITUTE A
PARTICULARLY VULNERABLE POPULATION (I.E., TRADITIONALLY
DISADVANTAGED GROUPS).
Policy Alternatives Criteria
EF EQ PL I A Total
Regulation and Prohibitions
1.Prohibition on Commercial .30 .05 .25 .20 .20 1
Establishments
2.Prohibition of Violent .30 .05 .25 .20 .20 1
oriented Video games
3. Categorizing of computer .30 .05 .25 .20 .20 1
games
4. Posting .30 .05 .25 .20 .20 1
5.Prohibition on Internet Café .30 .05 .25 .20 .20 1
and /or Computer Shops
Enforcement
1. Conduct a dialogue .30 .20 .50
2. Adopt an age appropriate .05 .20 .25
guidelines
3. Create a monitoring .30 .05 .25 .20 .20 1
committee
4. Assign Police Officers .30 .05 .25 .20 .20 1
RECOMMENDING ACTIONS
•
• E IS FOR "EVERYONE." MAY BE SUITABLE FOR AGES 6 AND UP. MAY CONTAIN
MINIMAL VIOLENCE, SOME COMIC MISCHIEF AND/OR MILD LANGUAGE.
•
• E10+ IS FOR "EVERYONE 10 AND OLDER." MAY BE SUITABLE FOR AGES 10 AND UP.
TITLES IN THIS CATEGORY MAY CONTAIN MORE CARTOON, FANTASY OR MILD
VIOLENCE, MILD LANGUAGE, AND/OR MINIMAL SUGGESTIVE THEMES.
•
• T IS FOR "TEEN." MAY BE SUITABLE FOR AGES 13 AND UP. MAY CONTAIN VIOLENT
CONTENT, MILD OR STRONG LANGUAGE, AND/OR SUGGESTIVE THEMES.
• M IS FOR "MATURE." MAY BE SUITABLE FOR PERSONS AGES 17 AND UP. MAY
CONTAIN MATURE SEXUAL THEMES, MORE INTENSE VIOLENCE AND/OR STRONG
LANGUAGE.
• AO IS FOR "ADULTS ONLY." HAVE CONTENT SUITABLE ONLY FOR ADULTS. MAY
INCLUDE GRAPHIC DEPICTIONS OF SEX AND/OR VIOLENCE. ADULT ONLY PRODUCTS
ARE NOT INTENDED FOR PERSONS UNDER THE AGE OF 18.
• RP IS FOR "RATING PENDING." TITLES HAVE BEEN SUBMITTED AND ARE AWAITING
FINAL RATING.
• THE ABOVEMENTIONED RATING EXAMPLES WERE THOSE THAT HAVE TO BE
WELL THOUGHT-OUT BY THE COMPUTER OPERATORS AND PARENTS FOR
COMPUTER AND VIDEO GAMES. IN THIS WAY, THE TYPE AND CONTENT OF
GAMES THAT WILL BE MADE AVAILABLE TO THE POSSIBLE PLAYERS
PARTICULARLY TO THE CHILDREN WILL BEST FIT WITH THEM. POSTING OF
GAMES SUITABLE FOR EACH CATEGORY OF PLAYERS WILL CREATE
AWARENESS ON THE GAMES THAT ARE APPROPRIATE FOR THEM.