Comparison Study Beethoven
Comparison Study Beethoven
Comparison Study Beethoven
Writing about such a legendary composer and his extraordinary work makes one become
excited. Although I am only at the beginning of my journey, I will try to use my knowledge of
musical fundamentals to describe what I have learned so far about this piece of art.
Firstly, meet Ludwig van Beethoven, who was born in December 1770 in Bonn, Germany.
He was the most famous German composer and what is extremely rare and even some would say
“superhuman” is the fact that his greatest works were composed while he was going deaf. Like
other early age geniuses, young Ludwig became a victim of child abuse by his father who began
teaching him music with unbelievable brutality that affected him for the rest of his life.
THE WORK
The work that I will analyze in this short essay is the final complete symphony by Ludwig
van Beethoven, that was composed between 1822 and 1824. It was the first example of a major
composer using voices in a symphony. The text is from the “Ode of Joy” by Friedrich Schiller
with some additions written by Beethoven. He also changes the usual pattern of Classical
FIRST MOVEMENT
The movement is in d minor Simple Duple meter in Allegro tempo. Starting at the
beginning, Beethoven puts us into a pianissimo stream of sounds. Then suddenly, the music accent
and quickly became louder, stormy, frightening and exciting. The coda brings an entirely new
perspective to the expectations about the rest of the measurement that later would drive the
movement. At the section of the movement written in sonata form, the theme returns to fortissimo
in D-major to completely overturn the D-minor opening. The movement has ties and slurs, that
indicates a smooth transition between the notes with sudden spikes. The whole measurement lasts
SECOND MOVEMENT
meters. Although the main piece is Simple Triple meter, when coupled with the tempo, makes it
sound as if it is in Simple Quadruple. This was an answer to the critics in some way, who had
criticized him for not adhering to standards because normally the scherzo is in Triple Meter. The
second part of the measurement is in C major. Getting closer to the end of the measurement we
meet with the scherzo for the second time, but it is slightly different than the first one because of
the absence of the repetition. The movement ends in an aggressive way, and the instrumentalists
THIRD MOVEMENT
For the third movement maestro starts with nice and slow adagio tempo in B-flat major.
The first part is in Simple Quadruple meter, the last is in Compound Quadruple meter and they
separated by Moderato Simple Triple passages that in D major, G major, adagio E-flat major and
in B major. A noticeable thing about this movement is that it is very lyrical, has staccatos and
sforzandos too. The story that Beethoven was telling us in this sometimes pianissimo sometimes
forte measurement was touching and resonated in everyone forcing emotional memories to come
out.
FOURTH MOVEMENT
The final. “Symphony within the symphony” that is how the famous American pianist and
music scholar Charles Rosen has characterized it. That is in fact the most accurate representation
of the measurement except for one thing – human voice in it. The measurement is organized and
follows almost the same overall pattern as the previous three. Starting with d minor Presto Simple
Triple meter then Allegro Simple Quadruple meter. After a brief introduction, the main topic of
the measurement came up. The bold move by the maestro to use human voice for the first time in
the symphony by the baritone soloist in Presto Simple Triple meter. After that Scherzo in
Compound Duple meter. The echo of the third measurement in the Final one begins with G major
Adagio Simple Triple meter section followed by the fourth and final D major Simple Duple Allegro
theme with prestissimo ending that changing between chorus repeat’s part loudly and quietly.
To compare these four part it is required to delve into the connection between the author’s
state of mind and the piece that he created. The period was hard for the Beethoven as he was
overwhelmed with doubts about the finale of the symphony not to mention his afflictions that’ll
cause his death a few years after the 9th symphony premiere. Under great pressure, Maestro tried
to bring unity to all by the beauty and mysterious complexity of his creation. Consequently, the
part from the fourth measurement in Beethoven’s 9th symphony became the official anthem of the
European Union in 1985. In the measurements we can extract some information, but this
information will not be consistent due to the nature of the composer. He was a compositional rebel,
who rejected standard classical practices in order to write with emotion. But some differences and
The first measurement is consistent and has a relatively simple structure in comparison
with the other three. The second, third and fourth measurements gradually increasing in difficulty.
The parts become longer and filled with inconsistencies, accidentals, sforzando and tenuto with a
mixes of different meters and Keys within one measurement. Fourth is the hardest of all, it is the
complexity, longevity and inconsistency of all three measurements combined including the chorus
parts.
Without a doubt Beethoven’s 9th Symphony is deep, complex and consequently the most
1. https://saskatoonsymphony.org/breaking-down-beethoven-
9/#:~:text=First%20movement,the%20mood%20is%20often%20stormy.
2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Articulation_(music)
3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Symphony_No._9_(Beethoven)
4. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Choir
5. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coda_(music)
6. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sonata_form
7. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recapitulation_(music)
8. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scherzo
9. https://baroque.boston/beethoven-symphony-no-
9?gclid=CjwKCAiAxP2eBhBiEiwA5puhNTLXk3noXFs7ZiKVQjWHeKGFfFU
783BF-vmSFrF_ktNrdIa1LhJjWxoC74sQAvD_BwE
10. https://www.essaytyping.com/concert-report-on-beethoven-9-chicago-symphony-
orchestra-riccardo-muti/
11. https://www.biography.com/musicians/ludwig-van-beethoven
12. https://www.charlottesymphony.org/blog/things-you-didn-39-know-about-
beethoven-39-symphony-no/