Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 24 views

    Ntile

    Uploaded by

    maria5bas
    1) In ancient Greece, menopause received little attention compared to other phases of a woman's reproductive cycle. 2) Menopause was viewed as a natural process rather than a pathological condition, as it is seen in modern Western medicine. 3) It was believed that as women aged, they became drier and colder, leading to the cessation of their menstruation, though neither Hippocrates nor Aristotle directly explained why menopause occurred.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Ntile

    Uploaded by

    maria5bas
    24 views1 page
    1) In ancient Greece, menopause received little attention compared to other phases of a woman's reproductive cycle. 2) Menopause was viewed as a natural process rather than a pathological condition, as it is seen in modern Western medicine. 3) It was believed that as women aged, they became drier and colder, leading to the cessation of their menstruation, though neither Hippocrates nor Aristotle directly explained why menopause occurred.

    Original Title

    01A4.Gentile

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    1) In ancient Greece, menopause received little attention compared to other phases of a woman's reproductive cycle. 2) Menopause was viewed as a natural process rather than a pathological condition, as it is seen in modern Western medicine. 3) It was believed that as women aged, they became drier and colder, leading to the cessation of their menstruation, though neither Hippocrates nor Aristotle directly explained why menopause occurred.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    24 views1 page

    Ntile

    Uploaded by

    maria5bas
    1) In ancient Greece, menopause received little attention compared to other phases of a woman's reproductive cycle. 2) Menopause was viewed as a natural process rather than a pathological condition, as it is seen in modern Western medicine. 3) It was believed that as women aged, they became drier and colder, leading to the cessation of their menstruation, though neither Hippocrates nor Aristotle directly explained why menopause occurred.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    of 1

    Menopause in the Ancient Greek World.

    Kristen M. Gentile (Ohio State University)


    Menopause is a complex condition that often arouses strong responses from the women
    who experience it. However, in the ancient Greek world, menopause is given much less attention
    in comparison to other reproductive issues. This lack of interest in menopause is highlighted by
    the high degree of attention placed on all the other phases of a woman’s reproductive cycle.
    Unfortunately, modern scholarship on both women and ancient gynecology has followed suit,
    focusing much more on the youthful virgins and the childbearing mothers with little notice given
    to post-menopausal women.
    In this paper, I will discuss how menopause was discussed and perceived in ancient
    Greece. Further light will be shed on the evidence by contrasting it with modern understandings
    of menopause from Western medicine and society. Western medicine employs a disease model
    for menopause; it has medicalized this phase of a woman’s life, promoting pharmaceutical
    treatments to return the body to its youthful form (Berger 1999). Conversely, Greek medicine
    does not consider menopause to be a pathological condition. While much of Hippocratic
    gynecology is discussed in terms of pathology, the cessation of menses due to old age is believed
    to be natural.
    I will explore the ancient explanations for the cessation of menses. In a surprising
    contradiction, two of the most discussed symptoms of menopause in Western medicine –hot
    flashes and night sweats– directly contrast with the condition of the old female body in antiquity
    (Sievert 2006). As women age, they become drier and colder. These changes to their bodily
    constitutions account for the cessation of menses, although neither the Hippocratic corpus nor
    Aristotle directly gives the reasons for menopause (Dean-Jones 1994). Both sets of texts
    generally agree that women cease to menstruate because they no longer have an excess of
    nourishment that used to accumulate to form menstrual blood (Hp., Mul. 1.1; Arist., GA 726b).
    While this excess diminishes in both men and women, both agree that women age more quickly
    than men (Hp., Septim. 9; Arist., GA 775a).
    Ultimately, the treatment of menopause and the old female body in general maintain the
    belief that the male body is superior to the female body. Even though both sexes become colder
    and drier with age, men retain their superiority because women age faster. Unlike in modern
    Western society, there is no need for a disease model of menopause or medicalization to create
    an inferior menopausal body. The menopausal body is already inferior to the reproductive body
    because of the pro-natalist outlook of Greek medicine. A healthy female body is a fecund one,
    preferably a pregnant one. This bodily inferiority is in stark contrast to the social freedoms that
    some scholars believe older women gained as part of aging (Bremmer 1987). It is this perceived
    inferiority of the post-menopausal body that allows these women a measure of social freedom.

    Amundsen and Diers 1970. “The Age of Menopause in Classical Greece and Rome.” Human
    Biology 42. 79-86.
    Berger 1999. Menopause and Culture. Sterling, Virginia: Pluto Press.
    Bremmer 1987. “The Old Women of Ancient Greece.” in Sexual Asymmetry: Studies in Ancient
    Society. Eds. Josine
    Blok and Peter Mason. Amsterdam: J. C. Gieben. 191-215.
    Dean-Jones 1994. Women’s Bodies in Classical Greek Science. New York: Clarendon Press.
    Sievert 2006. Menopause: A Biocultural Perspective. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University
    Press.

    You might also like