Research Methods: (Module Code: Mba404)
Research Methods: (Module Code: Mba404)
Research Methods: (Module Code: Mba404)
RESEARCH METHODS
DISSERTATION PROPOSAL
Proposed title
An investigation into the management practices for employee engagement a case study of Matalan Retail Ltd
STUDENT ID: 10007810 SUBMISSION DEADLINE: 21th July2011 COURSEWORK OF 3500 WORDS
Table of Contents
1.0
1.1.1 1.2 Aim of the research
INTRODUCTION 4
4 5 6 6 7
1.2.1 1.3
1.3.1
2.0
2.1
LITERATURE REVIEW
Tools for Employee engagement
7
11
3.0
3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7 3.8 3.9
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Research Model Research Approach Research Strategy Case study introduction: Matalan, Beckton Data collection and Analysis Ethics Limitation Conclusions Time Scale
12
12 13 14 14 15 16 16 16 17
List of figures
FIGURE 1: ANTICEDENTS AND EFFECTS OF FRONTLINE ENGAGEMENT (HOSPITALITY) FIGURE 2: DRIVERS OF EMPLOYEE ENGAGEMENT FIGURE 3: RESEARCH ONION 8 9 12
10Introduction
Studies indicate that engaging employees is the most important concern of an HR adopting appropriate management strategies (xxx). Similarly, CPID Annual Report (2007) emphasising on employer branding efforts categorically stated that employee engagement was the poorest and the lowest among the all other categories. This was the principal reason in proposing a research to be conducted on employee engagement a study of management practices. To empirically evaluated the results Matalan Retail Ltd has been chosen as case study.
Being an employee of Matalan retailing I have personally observed that the perception of the HRM and the employees with regard to productivity as well as the employee engagement differed in various aspects; which was also another principal reason behind choosing the area of study and the case study.
With the stated initial reason for submitting a proposal for the conduct of research the researcher aims to investigate in to employees attitude and behaviour in general and attempts to evaluate how effective management practices can contribute for employee engagement. This proposal further states its objectives as to identify the perception on employee engagement and empirically evaluate it. The proposal also identified that organisational culture can also impact employee engagement for which management practices can play a vital role in influencing employees perception towards engagement.
As the indicated area of research needs an appropriate structure to be followed an investigation in to the research methodology was also done where in it was identified that adoption of interpertivism philosophy and qualitative approach accommodating deductive method to further analyse the results using qualitative thematic analysis by deriving codes and themes. It was also appropriately indicated that apart from the secondary source the primary data would be collected through semi-structured in depth interview wherein the sampling would be based on non-probability judgemental sampling as the proposed research do not need any statistical analyses of the data. As the proposed research involves the study
of humans whose expression would interpreted and evaluated the researcher as such not only takes ethical approval but also states that the adopted methodology as its own limitations.
1.1 Background
Baptiste (2007 p. 292) in his studies firmly stated that:
People are an organisations most important asset and their effective development and deployment offers a distinctive and non-imitable competitive advantage through employer and employee engagement.
Similarly, CPID in its annual report (2007) categorically stated that employer branding efforts are mostly centred around recruitment of right employee (85%); recruiting their own personal image stating they are the prospective employer in the market (67%). However, the results also identified that improving employee engagement was very poor and the lowest among all the other categories standing at only 12%; similarly employee retention stands at 24% (table-1)
From the above the researcher assumes that employee engagement is widely discussed in literature and that its importance being realized. However, the survey report of CPID is a clear indication that the management practices are up to the satisfactory level. This motivated the researcher to state the aim and conduct a research
1.1.1
The proposed research aims to investigate into management practices of employee engagement in general and assess how any such practices can influence in building effective employee engagement strategies.
Purcell et al., (2003) rightly stated that there are numerous ways to improve the degree of employee engagement in an organisation. According to the scholar, there are many strategies that can increase the level of employee engagement; they are not only important but necessary if high performance is expected. However, within the literature there is an active debate that though most of the organisations are aware of these practices that increase the employee engagement level, most of them do not implement. In this context, Peccei (2004) opined that the organisations have not been able to follow the strategies consistently from the beginning; the employees also feel the same. The studies of Tehrani et al. (2007) threw light on the influence of factors such as job-commitment, job-satisfaction and work-life balance situation on employee engagement levels as well as on their performance and job-retention. The study recommended for a better working environment ensuring positive conditions for employee well-being and performance. Similarly Albrecht and Travaglione (2003) argue that positive relationship and trust between the management and the employees, ensures their commitment towards the organisation. Nevertheless, the support from the management together with the employee engagement is crucial to the organisation at its all levels of operation.
While some of the studies discussed that the salary aspect of an organization plays an important role in engaging an employee; however, the empirical studies of Clause (2007) dictate that money is a temporary solace to employees; it can retain their commitment temporarily and cannot always ensure their engagement. The scholar went to state that the employees expect better work-life balance and wish for flexibility in their engagement with
the organisation. Therefore, the organisations should make sure that they devise a flexible framework to manage employees with differing attitudes and expectations. Such a framework should put aside the traditional methods for controlling time and work of the employees and should focus more on the result generating factors such as the output, quality as well as the productivity.
Based on the stated discussion the researcher poises the following research question:
1.2.1
Research Question
How can organizations improve employees engagement through effective management practices?
Similarly adding some humour to the concept of employee engagement and the organizational commitment Drake International in its white paper suggests that an organisation should devise a sturdy career plan which according to the paper should treat the employees as individuals rather than just employees. Furthermore, the paper emphasised that organisational goals should be mingled with personal goals of the employee.
However, an initial investigation of the recent literature (e.g. Hallberg and Schaufeli, 2006) clarified that a clear distinction exists between employee engagement and the concepts of commitment and job-involvement both in theoretical and empirical terms.
1.3.1
Research objectives
On the basis of the above discussion, the researcher opines that it has always been the organizational commitment that has been questioned in terms of employee engagement. As such the following objectives are proposed:
To investigate into the theoretical and conceptual models of employee engagement. To evaluate how organizational culture can impact on employee engagement To investigate into the literary evidences and the perception of research concerning employee engagement.
To assess how management practices can influence employees engagement
10Literature Review
Clause (2007) argues that the new millennium employee is engaged in establishing more connections within an organisation as compared to the previous millennium. This is mainly because of the project-based team work and process management operations. The impact of globalization and the growth of communication channels have facilitated them to shift their loyalty to people, teams and projects. This has further pushed them away from company loyalty. Thus, the organizations must strive to establish an organisational culture and environment that facilitates integration of people, operations and the projects assigned to them, thus engaging each other. The degree of job-retention is more within the engaged set of employees compared to those who are not engaged.
Eminent academic works on employee engagement includes that of Kahn (1990) who based his work on the studies of Goffman (1961). Goffman emphasised that the concepts of attachment and detachment of employees from their responsibilities differ. Goffman used a theoretical metaphor to explain that people act out temporary attachments and detachments in exercising their responsibilities. Role embracement is observed in a situation where an employee does not differentiate between himself and his responsibility whereas role distance occurs in a situation where an employee tends to be uncomfortable and resists against fulfilling his duty. Based on the above difference, Kahn (1990) tried to explain how
employees fulfil their duties within their work environment in varied circumstances and the extent to which they are psychologically engaged in their work.
Kahn (1990, p. 700) explained that the self and the role exist in some dynamic, negotiable relation in which a person drives personal energies into role behaviours (self-employment) and displays the self within the role (self-expression).
Kahn sets these varying degrees of psychological conditions of overlap between the self and the role at work on a continuum from personal engagement on one end to personal disengagement on the other. The scholar defined personal engagement as the harnessing of organization members selves to their work roles.
Kahn went on to elaborate that when employees are engaged, people employ and express themselves psychically, cognitively and emotionally during role performances. Considering the general conditions of experience, Kahn listed three psychological conditions with respect to engagement and disengagement: 1) Meaningfulness; 2) Safety; and 3) Availability.
Therefore, in conditions that offer psychological safety to employees, they make themselves more committed to their tasks. In furtherance, May et al (1994) conducted a quantitative analysis on Kahns (1990) studies, the results of which revealed that the on the whole, the three psychological conditions exhibited positive relationships with engagement.
In furtherance to the discussion as stated above the empirical studies conducted by within the contest of frontline staff engaged in hospitality sector were based on three latent variables they included 1) Role benefit; 2) Strategic attention; and 3) Autonomy. Here the results stated that role benefit and autonomy is positively connected to engagement; on the other hand, the strategic attention was also co-related with the employees engagement (figure-1).
Through the above conceptual framework, the scholars have empirically derived conclusions on the effect employee engagement has on innovation. Furthermore, Saks (2006) and Robinson et al (2004) established that the findings of their studies are in line with the service literature as they have underlined the importance of employee engagement in service organisations. In fact, the engagement in service organisations has been considered the conceptual basis for employee performance. As such the proposed research also attempts to test the stated strategic model (indicated in hospitality sector) in retail sector.
Wyman (2008) argue that for any organization formulating a strategy is not enough, rather its task is complete when the organisation engages its workforce towards the realisation of the strategy. Literary evidences reveal that the degree of employee engagement is either low or negligible in organisations.
Wyman further suggests six-point drivers for effective engagement of employees (figure-2)
Discussion on the role of engaging the employees Wyman further states that; there is significant damage done to engagement by factors such lazy employees neglecting their working when it is boring, and the worst among them discouraging others while doing work, etc. The scholar termed these as strategy blockers.
However, engaged employees are totally different and distinguished. They are ready to go to any level for the realisation of the organisations strategic goals. They exhibit high levels of commitment to their tasks and speak in a healthy manner to the customers. They explore new ways to achieve business objectives of the organisation. Here, the degree of engagement comes into play and is crucial for the realisation of business strategies. Ultimately, the realisation of a new strategy depends on how far employee engagement has crept into the organisation, especially in situation where the strategy requires employees to change the way they execute their roles, interact with customers and their colleagues. Realisation of strategy by putting it into practice is far more difficult than devising it and often engagement is missing here.
The proposed research intends to focus on the stated drivers stated and discussed as above.
CIPD (2009) reports that apart from assessment which plays an important role in bringing out issues, soft skills and healthy environment promoting culture and mutual respect between the management and the workforce are some of the prerequisites for employee engagement. Churchard (2009) reported that the Co-operative Group sets an example in maintaining better levels of integrated employee engagement amongst its senior managerial staff. Furthermore, the management team in the organisations should notice and celebrate the success of every individual employee and the success of teams of employees to promote the engagement spirit. McBain (2007) added that the managerial staff should undergo leadership development programmes so that they can improve engagement levels. Furthermore, five steps to the engagement process have been identified by the Involvement and Participation Association (2007), they are:
1) Encouraging the employees to closely follow the strategic decisions made at the senior management level in an organisation. 2) Creating buy in to the strategic decision.
3) Resolving problems and questions regarding various issues like why? What? And
what else? 4) Ensuring and promoting employee satisfaction and building healthy relationships. 5) Promoting the rights of the employees and giving freedom to employees regarding their choice of work. CIPD (2009) viewed its report as the best thing thats happened to HR for years. However, there was enough criticism on it, especially from the senior management gurus who opined that it lacked practicality. According to the critics, the case for how has not
been given attention, however, the case for questions like what and why issues has been given attention. One among them, Sweetman (2009, p.1) remarked that it is time to focus on the how issue.
In response to the above Baker (2009) as indicated in the studies of Evans and Redfirn (2010) suggested that the CIPD could have focussed on constructing useful models for engagement and could have suggested assessment tools and checklists useful for both the employers and the HR team. Therefore, the research intends to conduct a full-fledged empirical study on employee engagement. Now, we move on to the proposed methodology for the study.
10Research Methodology
Eminent researcher, Saunders et al (2007) stated that a research philosophy guides the researcher the way in which they view their research work by adopting the appropriate strategies and approaches concerning various research paradigms. It is an agreed fact that there are two types philosophies 1) positivist 2) anti- positivist. The positivist philosophy views the research where in quantifiable observations is emphasized. This is mostly statistical in nature. Moreover, when the researcher attempts to make sense of the social world involving humans as subjects where in qualitative approach is adopted it is defined as antipositivist philosophy. Within this framework as the researcher interacts with the respondents for data collection and interprets them with his own findings this process is attributed as interprevitist philosophy Saunders, et al., (2010); which is adopted by the proposed research because of the involvement of humans as the samples and interprets their idea of expressions
The figure demonstrates Saunders model based on which the researcher introduces the research philosophy before anything else and then moves on to the approach such that an effective framework is designed for the dissertation that can further inquire into the aspects of data collection and analysis.
Matalan maintains its average store area around 30,000 sq-ft. Most of the companys stores are situated in the outskirts of urban locations. In each store there is a separate chamber for each of the age groups, kids, Mens, womens along with a chamber selling home-ware. In its expansion programme, Matalan had launched Mobile phone stores in September, 2008. The mobile stores also has full-fledged website, its e-commerce wing and runs a call-centre at Manchester. Its business philosophy is to provide an optimum value for customers money. In addition, the company offers various seasonal business deals for selling low priced mobile phones along with money off vouchers and cash back deals.
It is found that at Matalan only 31% of the workforce is actively engaged in fulfilling their roles. This employee group is the cream of the company and remains strategically an invaluable asset to the organisation. They are very much committed to their duties and help in the steady progress of the company. Out of its workforce, 88 per cent expressed confidence in boosting the performance of the organisation by improving the quality of products sold. However, 38 per cent exhibited disengagement. Another report notified that 72 per cent were confident in delivering good customer care while 27 per cent felt otherwise.
While 68 per cent of the workforce was confident of controlling the expenses in their work environment, 19 per cent expressed otherwise. An engaged employee gets himself/herself attached to the organisation he/she works in through an emotional bond. Moreover, engaged employees express willingness to make the customers aware of the companys products and are committed to their tasks without any external push. These employees ensure the maximum utilisation of their time to realise organisational goals. Matalan could save an amount of 1,106,845 through its focus on employee engagement in safety costs (2002). Furthermore, there were enormous savings from the sales performance teams. For example, in the year 2005, disengaged teams fell behind the highly engaged teams with a difference in costs concerning the performance totalling 1353100.5
As opined by Hollaway and Trodes (2003); argues that among all the analytical tools mostly adopted for qualitative researches is the process of thematic analysis. Applying the thematic analysis analyse the collected data the proposed research will initially segment them and
further to categorise. This process is undertaken to summarise and reconstruct the collected data in words and small phrases those which are termed as codes and themes by (Miles and Huberman 1994). The idea is to indicate key issues and analyse the data focusing upon the principal aim of the proposed research such that the objectives are attain and the research questions are answered. During this process the research will also attempt to derive relational codes of the proposal discussing the primary data in/against contrast to the secondary data another attempt will also be made to construct emerging themes through which recommendation for the further studies are also made.
1.1 Ethics
As required by the academic studies involving human reactions to a particular area of study, the researcher in accordance takes the consent of the respondents who will be intimated of their rights about participation and collecting their consent (Annexure-I).
1.2 Limitation
As discussed in the proposal the prime limitations of the studies are 1) the samples that are from one single organisation (Matalan, Beckton London) and limited in number (35-50) and focused on a single category (frontline); 2) Qualitative approach that is a non-statistical method and the results cannot be generalised to similar subjects in different circumstances; 3) Thematic analysis, the analytical tool that analyses data deriving codes and themes; wherein the expression of authors or the respondents are based on a particular environmental setting that again cannot be generalised in other environments.
1.1 Conclusions
Will be written after feed back
Topic
Ethical Approval
Conclusion
Final Dissertation
References
Albrecht, S. and Travaglione, A., 2003. Trust in public-sector senior management. International Journal of Human Resource Management, Vol. 24, No. 1, pp. 76-92. Baker, K., 2009. MacLeod review struggles to engage top HR professionals, Personnel Today, July 21, p. 1. Baptiste, A., 2007. Roundtable discussion: Care giver injury and safe patient handling. Bariatric Nursing and Surgical Patient Care, Vol. 2(1), pp. 7-16. Churchard, C., 2009. Social networking site to boost co-op engagement, People Management, July 28, Available at: www.peoplemanagement.co.uk [accessed 5 August 2009]. CIPD., 2009. Employee engagement fact sheet, Available at: www.cipd.co.uk [accessed February 22, 2009]. Evans, and Redfirn., 2010. How can employee engagement be improved at the RRG Group? Part 2, Industrial and Commercial Training, Vol. 42, Iss: 6, pp.330 - 334 Goffman, E., 1961. Encounters: Two Studies in the Sociology of Interaction. Indianapolis, BobbsMerrill Co. in Ferguson, A. 2007 Employee engagement: Does it exist, and if so, how does it relate to performance, other constructs and individual differences? [online]Available at: http://www.lifethatworks.com/Employee-Engagement.prn.pdf [Accessed 20th June 2007] Hallberg, U. & Schaufeli, W. B., 2006. Same same but different: Can work engagement be discriminated from job involvement and organizational commitment. European Journal of Psychology, Vol. 11(2), pp. 119-127. Kahn, W. A., 1990. Psychological conditions of personal engagement and disengagement at work. Academy of Management Journal, Vol. 33, No. 4, pp. 692-724. May, D. R. Gilson, R. L. and Harter, L., 1994. The psychological conditions of meaningfulness, safety and availability and the engagement of the human spirit at work. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, Vol. 77, pp. 11-37. McBain, R., 2007. The practice of engagement: research into current employee engagement practice. Strategic HR Review, Vol. 6, No. 6, pp. 16-19. Peccei, R., 2004. Human Resource Management and the Search for the Happy Workplace, Erasmus Research Institute of Management, Rotterdam School of Management, Rotterdam School of Economics, Rotterdam. Pritchard, K., 2008. Employee engagement in the UK: meeting the challenge in the public sector, Development and Learning in Organisations, Vol. 22, No. 6, pp. 15-17. Purcell, J. Kinnie, N. and Hutchinson, S., 2003. Inside the black box and inside the black box Selfridges, People Management, Vol. 9, No. 10, pp. 31-7. Robinson, D. Perryman, S. and Hayday, S., 2004. The Drivers of Employee Engagement, Institute for Employment Studies, Brighton. Saks, A. M., 2006. Antecedents and consequences of employee engagement. Journal of Managerial Psychology, Vol. 21, No. 7, pp. 600-19. Sltten, T. & Mehmetoglu, M. (in press, 2011). Antecedents and Effects of Engaged Frontline Employees. A Study from the Hospitality Industry. Managing Service Quality Sweetman, P., 2009. Macleod Review of employee engagement only gives half the story, Personnel Today, July 21, Available at: www.personneltoday.com (accessed August 5, 2009).
Tehrani, N. Humpage, S. Willmott, B. and Haslam, I., 2007. Whats Happening with Well-being at Work? Change Agenda, Chartered Institute of Personnel Development, London. Wyman, D., 2008. From lagging to leading: Newfoundland and Saskatchewan dig into the resource boom. Canadian Economic Observer, May Issue. Statistics CanadaCatalogue 11-010. Accessed: September 3, Available online: http://www.statcan.ca
Further readings
Armstrong, M. and Baron, A., 2005. Managing Performance: Performance Management in Action, CIPD, London. Aryee, S. Budhwar, P. S. and Chen, Z. X., 2002. Trust as a mediator of the relationship between organizational justice and work outcomes: test of a social exchange model. Journal of Organisational Behaviour, Vol. 23, No. 3, pp. 267-85. Bacon, N. Blyton, P. and Dastmalchian, A., 2005. The significance of working time arrangements accompanying the introduction of team working: evidence from employees. British Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 43, No. 4, pp. 681-701. Bakke, D. W., 2005. Joy at Work: A Revolutionary Approach to Fun on the Job, Penguin Group (USA) Inc., New York, NY. Blau, P. M., 2006. Exchange and Power in Social Life: New Introduction by the Author, 10th ed., London: Transaction Publisher. Boselie, P. and Dietz, G., 2003. Commonalities and contradictions in research on human resource management and performance, paper presented at the Academy of Management Meeting, Seattle, August. Bramley, P., 2003. Evaluating Training, Chartered Institute of Personnel Development, London. Bratton, J. and Gold, J., 2003. Human Resource Management: Theory and Practice, 3rd ed., Basingstoke: Palgrave Publishers. Daniels, K., 2006. Employee Relations in an Organizational Context, Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development, London. Department for Work and Pensions., 2006. A New Deal for Welfare: Empowering People at Work, CM 6730, Stationery Office, London, Available at: www.dwp.gov.uk (accessed 19 July 2007). Department of Health., 2004. Choosing Health: Making Healthy Choices Easier, Cm 6374, Stationery Office, London, Available at: www.dh.gov.uk (accessed 19 July 2007). Dibben, P. and James, P., 2007. Introduction: is modern necessarily better?, in Dibbens, P., James, P., Roper, I. and Wood, G. ed., Modernising Work in Public Services: Redefining Roles and Relationships in Britains Changing Workplace, Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, pp. 1-2. Dibbens, P. James, P. Roper, I. and Wood, G., 2007. Modernising Work in Public Services: Redefining Roles and Relationships in Britains Changing Workplace, Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke. Gould-Williams, J., 2004. The effects of high commitment HRM practices on employee attitude: the views of public sector workers, Public Administration, Vol. 82, No. 1, pp. 63-81. Guest, D. and Conway, N., 2004. Employee Well-being and the Psychological Contract The Chartered Institute of Personnel Development, London.
Guest, D. Jonathan, M. Conway, N. and Sheehan, M., 2003. Human resource management and corporate performance in the UK. British Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 41, No. 2, pp. 291-314 Kraybill, K., 2003. Creating and Maintaining a Healthy Work Environment: A Resource Guide for Staff Retreats, Available at: www.nhchc.org (accessed 19 July 2007). MacDonald, L. A. C., 2005. Wellness at Work: Protecting and Promoting Employee Well-being, Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development, London. Marchington, M. and Wilkinson, A., 2005. Human Resource Management at Work: People Management and Development, The Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development, London. Rousseau, D. M., 2003. Extending the psychology of the psychological contract: a reply to putting psychology back into psychological contracts. Journal of Management Inquiry, Vol. 12, No. 3, pp.229-38.