Anterior Knee Pain - Sorting Out The Causes
Anterior Knee Pain - Sorting Out The Causes
Anterior Knee Pain - Sorting Out The Causes
Disclaimer
All interventions involve some inherent risk. If you are unfamiliar with anything
covered in this text, seek opinion from a qualified practitioner.
Jacked Athlete LLC disclaims any liability or loss in connection with the use of this
text or any advice herein.
ANTERIOR KNEE PAIN – SORTING OUT THE CAUSES
Step One
Pain in the front of the knee. What is it? Here’s a list of potential diagnoses:
The good news: Most of these conditions can be distinguished based on obvious
signs and symptoms.
Another Disclaimer
I am not a doctor. I am a meathead who knows a bit about pain at the front of
the knee. If you are experiencing symptoms, you should seek care and advice
from a medical professional. You may need an x-ray, MRI, ultrasound, blood
work, physical exam, or a bunch of other tests that you can’t get by reading a
book. You want to exclude all other conditions and that’s done with a doctor.
The 7 Structures
When it comes to pain in the front of the knee, we’re looking at these areas:
1) The Tendon
2) The Patellofemoral Joint
3) The Patella
4) The Fat Pad
5) The Bursa
6) The Plica
7) The Other Guys
The
Tendon
ANTERIOR KNEE PAIN – SORTING OUT THE CAUSES
The Tendon
Pain in your tendon can be a few different things:
- Tendinopathy (Patellar, Quadriceps, and Distal Patellar)
- Apophysitis (Osgood-Schlatter Disease and Sinding-Larsen-Johansson
Syndrome)
- Tendon Rupture
- Whole Tendon Pain
- Tendon Graft Pain
Tendinopathy
These three are disorders of the same tendon, so they are all very similar with just
a few differences. I cover them below.
If these signs match up with your pain, you should be thinking Tendinopathy.
ANTERIOR KNEE PAIN – SORTING OUT THE CAUSES
Apophysitis
These conditions will likely present with similar signs of a Tendinopathy (pinpoint
pain, high tendon stress=more likely to provoke pain, warmup effect, delayed
pain response, etc.).
- Kids. Apophysitis injuries happen in kids aged 9-15. At this stage, their
ossification centers are still forming. They are soft and cartilaginous,
making them a weak point in the muscle-tendon-bone chain.
- Kids in sports. The apophyses must be overloaded to get this injury. This
can happen from most sports (e.g., basketball, volleyball, football).
- Although not something that can diagnose pain, kids will present with
thickening at the area of pain (think the Osgood-Schlatter bump or a similar
feature at the inferior pole of the patella).
If these signs match up with your pain, you should be thinking Apophysitis.
ANTERIOR KNEE PAIN – SORTING OUT THE CAUSES
Tendon Rupture
This is a debated topic. Healthy tendon and tendon rupture are easy to pick up on
imaging. The issue lies in the middle where partial tears are suspected. It seems
that most experts recommend looking at partial tears as regular tendinopathy
because it’s difficult to distinguish between partial tear and tendinopathy. Here is
from Sean Docking on this podcast:
“There is no one criteria or set of guidelines of how you diagnose a partial tear… so it really
questions how reliable we are at subjectively looking at an imaging and subjectively reporting
whether there’s a partial tear… we are really good at picking up the complete tendon tears… we
are really good at telling you whether the tendon is normal… where we get lost is this
continuum or spectrum in between. Our ability to differentiate tendon pathology from partial
thickness tears is basically about a flip of a coin… 50%… we are no better than chance in terms
of determining whether it’s tendon pathology or whether it’s a partial tear.”
Because imaging can’t reliably distinguish between the two, a partial tear might
be something that needs to be determined by asking how the tendon was injured.
If you had a specific jump, land, cut, etc. where you felt a pop or tear in the
tendon (without it being a full rupture),
then the partial tear might be suspected.
The
Patello-
femoral
Joint
ANTERIOR KNEE PAIN – SORTING OUT THE CAUSES
Patellofemoral Pain
- Pain that is reproduced with knee flexion (Box 3 from this study):
o PFP has been called Moviegoer’s Knee because prolonged sitting can
cause pain.
o PFP has also been called Runner’s
Knee because running can cause
pain. Especially downhill.
o Stair ascent/descent can cause pain.
o Squatting can cause pain.
o Jumping can cause pain.
ANTERIOR KNEE PAIN – SORTING OUT THE CAUSES
- This study by Richard Willy et al., covered four subcategories of people who
have patellofemoral pain:
1) Overuse/overload without other impairment. You’ve just toasted
your PF joint with too much stress in a short window of time.
2) Muscle performance deficits. You have “weaker” hip and knee
muscles.
3) Movement coordination deficits. You have “excessive” and poorly
controlled knee valgus during movement.
4) Mobility impairments. You have either hypermobile or hypomobile
structures at the lower body.
If these signs and symptoms match up with your pain, you should be thinking
Patellofemoral Pain.
The
Patella
ANTERIOR KNEE PAIN – SORTING OUT THE CAUSES
The Patella
I thought about lumping Patellofemoral Pain into the Patella section, but I didn’t.
PFP is its own complex beast. The Patella, one the other hand, is as simple as it
gets. Here’s what can be going on:
Bipartite/Tripartite Patella
Patella Fracture
This is when the patella has broken. It can happen for a few reasons:
- A direct blow or fall on the patella.
- A person is prone for fracture because of low bone mineral density.
- A person is prone for fracture because of severe knee extensor
deconditioning (e.g., post-surgery).
Patella Instability
A normal patella should glide nicely in the trochlear groove. Some people have
issues with this tracking. It can happen for a few reasons, many unavoidable:
patella alta (high riding patella), trochlear dysplasia (a more flat trochlear groove),
acute trauma, chronic ligamentous laxity, bony malalignment, connective tissue
disorder, and/or anatomical pathology.
That wraps it up for issues with the kneecap. Next in line is the fat pad.
ANTERIOR KNEE PAIN – SORTING OUT THE CAUSES
The
Fat
Pad
ANTERIOR KNEE PAIN – SORTING OUT THE CAUSES
It’s been called the airbag of the knee, meant for cushioning and protection. It
also stores stem cells so maybe it’s helping with regeneration of the structures
around it. Who knows. But when it’s aggravated, it’s a terrible thing.
There are two other fat pads located above the patella. Image from this study.
The other one is the posterior prepatellar (prefemoral). People report pain
worsened by hyperextension.
Done with the fat pad. The next one is the bursa.
ANTERIOR KNEE PAIN – SORTING OUT THE CAUSES
The
Bursa
ANTERIOR KNEE PAIN – SORTING OUT THE CAUSES
The Bursa
Bursa are fluid-filled structures that reduce friction between bones, muscles,
tendons, and ligaments. There are four of them, with the prepatellar being the
most commonly problematic. Bursa conditions are simple, they just get inflamed.
Bursitis
As for the other, less affected bursa: superficial infrapatellar, deep infrapatellar,
and pes anserine. There doesn’t seem to be anything special for these.
The
Plica
ANTERIOR KNEE PAIN – SORTING OUT THE CAUSES
The Plica
Plica are a bit weird. Historically, they’ve been wrongly blamed for a lot of knee
pains. They happen, but there are probably more likely things to rule out first.
Because of this, they’ve been termed the dustbin diagnosis.
There are 4 plica, but one is more commonly an issue: The medial plica.
Here are the signs that you should be thinking synovial plica syndrome (most of
these referring to the medial plica):
- It can hurt during stairs, squatting, bending, biking, and arising from a
chair after sitting for an extended time. Pain tends to worsen during
activity.
- Prolonged flexion can cause pain. This could be the case when sleeping at
night if the knees are bent.
- Upon physical exam, a taut band may be palpable under the skin.
- Two tests, when both are positive, can confirm plica syndrome. They are
the Stutter Test and the Hughston Test.
- It can be difficult to distinguish between a plica and something else
(meniscal tears, articular cartilage injuries, or osteochondritic lesions). A
meniscus will be locking and sharp, which would rule out the plica.
Stutter Test (top left), Hughston Test (bottom left), and Medial Plica Palpation
(right). Images from this study.
The other plica are the: suprapatellar, infrapatellar, and lateral. They can all fall
into the category of synovial plica syndrome, just differing by location.
That’s it for the plica. A sneaky bugger. If it’s confirmed to be the source of pain,
and if conservative management doesn’t do the trick, arthroscopy is usually done
to cut it.
Retinacular Pain
The retinaculum is a thin ligamentous structure that provides stability around the
patella.
Pain that occurs on the inside (medial retinacular complex) is thought to result
from patella instability. Patella dislocation can injure the MPFL.
Pain that occurs on the outside (lateral retinacular complex) is thought to be from
a more stable patella, but increased pressure felt laterally when going into flexion.
Image of lateral and medial retinaculum as well as MPFL and LPFL. All of which
can be sources of pain. From this study.
ANTERIOR KNEE PAIN – SORTING OUT THE CAUSES
Chondromalacia Patellae
Chondros means cartilage and malakia means softening. This is “sick cartilage” of
the surfaces between the patella and femur. It is often used interchangeably with
patellofemoral pain, but that is not completely accurate. Research does not
confirm the idea that more wear-and-tear on the cartilage is associated or
predictive of patellofemoral pain symptoms. A study in 56 young adults found
“no correlation between the severity of chondromalacia patellae and the clinical
symptoms of anterior knee pain syndrome” (this study).
Patellofemoral Osteoarthritis
This generally affects older people. It’s the wearing down of the shock-absorbing
articular cartilage. Risk factors include previous connective tissue injuries,
obesity, old age, and systemic inflammatory disorders.
Here are some more knee pains that I will just put in a list because I’m done
explaining things in detail.
These are less common anyway and some fall more into the medial/lateral knee
pain category than they do anterior:
That’s All
Hopefully this has shed some light on the different conditions of the anterior
knee. If you’re not satisfied because I didn’t explain how to rehab each condition,
that’s okay. This was not the intention of the book.
As for diagnosis, best case scenario, you are only dealing with one issue and can
rehab accordingly. It can be more difficult when you’re dealing with multiple
things.
If you require more knowledge, here’s links to studies, videos, podcasts, and
experts that you should study:
Study: Layered Approach to the Anterior Knee: Normal Anatomy and Disorders
Associated with Anterior Knee Pain
Study: Narrative: Review of Anterior Knee Pain Differential Diagnosis (Other than
Patellofemoral Pain)
TENDON DIAGNOSIS
PATELLOFEMORAL DIAGNOSIS
PATELLA DIAGNOSIS
Study: Hoffa’s fat pad abnormalities, knee pain, and magnetic resonance imaging
in daily practice
BURSA DIAGNOSIS
PLICA DIAGNOSIS
Podcast (towards the end): How to treat anterior knee pain with Kurt Lisle