ATWOOD
ATWOOD
ATWOOD
DOUCLASALLENATWOOD,A.B.,M.D.,D.M.D.
Harvard School of Dental Medicine, Boston, Mass.
Fig. l.-Tracings of 3 lateral cephalographs with the maxillae and mandibles carefully
superimposed. Note the changes in the shape of the residual ridges following the extration Of
the remaining teeth. (For other examples, see Atwood.9
teeth and bone, there is a complete removal of the organic and inorganic elements
simultaneously, regardless of the degree of calcification. Manson and Lucas42 have
shown that in the mandible (as others have shown in other bones43z45) there are
definite variations in the structure and activity of cortical bone at different ages.
There is much deposition and resorption in the early years, relative stability dur-
in.g the adult years, and increased activity favoring resorption in later years.
6. Other Techniques: Other techniques are available which include the
use of radioactive materials and tetracycline, as illustrated by McLean and Urist.4”
The most efficient use of all of the tools of modern research, however, depends on
the development of a good, working hypothesis which must be scientifically tested.
Such a hypothesis often comes from good clinical observation. The hypothesis of
L.ammie47 (tt la t in many patients, resorption of residual ridges may be due to an
a-trophying mucosa which seeks a reduced area) is an instance of this and is
worthy of further study by many research approaches.
SOFT X-RAYS
Gloss Slide
cooled with
photographic
emulsion.
Specimen of Bone
in cantoct with emulsion
FINDINGS
Fig. 4.-A microradiograph of cortical bone from the inferior border of the mandible (Fig.
2,B-3) showing the outer periosteal lamellae, a middle portion consisting of osteons and inter-
stitial lamellae, and an inner endosteal more porous portion. (x15.)
(Fig. 4). The cortex will vary in thickness from bone to bone, from person to
person, and from time to time, as a result of heredity, function, nutrition, hormone
metabolism, and many other factors.
Fig. 5.-A microradiograph of a lingual cortex (Fig. 2,B-3) showing the periosk al lamellae,
a longitudinal section of an osteon, various cross-sections of osteons, and interstiti; 31 lamellae.
The osteons show different degrees of closure and of calcification, some showing an inner ring
of increased mineralization. (x60.)
Fig. 6.-A microradiograph of the two crosslsectioned osteons shown in the lower left
corner of Fig. 5. Note the different degrees and sites of mineralization. (x240.)
POSTEXTRACTION CHANGES IN ADCLT MANDIBLE 815
Fig. 7. Fig. 8.
Fig. ‘7.-A three-dimensional model of a simple osteon from the cortex of an adult dog
ft:mur. It shows a spiral contour (2 turns in 1.5 mm.). A blindly ending osteon is present in the
center. The cross-sectional areas of most of the osteon are nearly the same. (From Cohen, J., and
Harris, W. H.: The Three-dimensional Anatomy of Haversian Systems, Bone & Joint Surg. 40-A:
419-434, 1958, by permission.)
Fig. S.-A three-dimensional model of more complex osteons. The variation in cross-
sectional areas of different parts of the same osteon is evident. The enlargement occurs grad-
ually as one goes distally. The abrupt horizontal cuts indicate anastamoses with other km-
modeled) systems. A blind osteon is seen at the right. (From Cohen, J., and Harris, W. H.:
The Threedimensional Anatomy of Haversian Systems, Bone & Joint Surg. 40:A:419-434, 1958,
by permission.)
After the formation of the absorption cavity or tunnel, the osteoclasts disappear
and the osteoblasts lay down concentric layers of bone forming the tubular osteon
around the central blood vessel.
As has been pointed out, 40,42,45there are two phases of osteon formation: the
rapid formation to about 75 per cent or less mineralization, followed by the much
more gradual completion of the job over several months. Hence, in a microradio-
816 ATWOOD J. Pros. Den.
Sept.-Oct.. 1963
Fig. 10.
Fig. 9.-A microradiograph of the inferior border of a mandible (Fig. Z,B-I) showing evi-
dence of moderate osteoporosis with increased variation in the density of osteons, increased
number of incompletely closed osteons, and increased endosteal porosity. (x15.1
Fig. 10.-A microradiograph of a portion of the crest of the ridge (Fig. 2, J-1) showing
external resorption of both the lingual cortex and the trabeculae on the crest of the ridge. Also
evident is an osteon within a single trabecula, and evidence of internal bone formation, and
resorption of the trabeculae.
Volume 13 I’OSTEXTRACTION CHANGES IN ADULT MANDIBLE 817
Number 5
I II III Ip Y PL
Fig. Il.--The 6 orders of adult human mandibles in midsagittal profile: Order I, pre-
extraction; Order II, postextraction; Order III, high, well-rounded residual ridge; Order IV,
knife-edge residual ridge; Order V, low, well-rounded residual ridge; and Order VI, depressed
residual ridge.
Study of the gross outline form of the specimens (Fig. 2) and study of the
serial cephalographs of the previous study suggest the need for classification of
the various forms the adult mandible can assume before and after extraction. There
seem to be at least 6 orders of form of the anterior part of the mandible (Fig. 11) :
Order I: Pre-extraction: The lower central incisor is in its socket with very
t’hin labial and lingual cortical plates merged with the lamina dura (Fig. 2, E-l ).
Order II: Postextraction: The healing period includes clot formation, clot
organization, filling of the socket to the height of the cortical plates with new
trabecular bone, and epithelization over the socket site. The edges of the residual
ridge are still sharp (Fig. 2, D-1, F-4, J-l ) .
Order 1II: High, Well-Rounded Residual Ridge: The cortical plates are
rounded off, narrowing of the crest of the ridge has begun, and remodeling of the
internal trabecular structure has taken place (Fig. 2, R-4, C-Z, C-4, E-Z, H-4, J-2,
J-4).
Order IV: Knife-Edge Residual Ridge: There is marked narrowing of the
labiolingual diameter of the crest of the ridge with a compensatory internal remod-
eling which sometimes leads to an incredibly sharp crest of the ridge (Fig. 2, B-3,
Lb3, E-3, E-4, G-3, H-5).
Order p.: Low Well-Rounded Residu,al Ridge: The end result of progressive
labiolingual narrowing of a knife-edge ridge is the disappearance of the knife-edge
portion. A more widely rounded, but considerably lower residual ridge remains
(Fig. 2, B-l, D-2, D-4, G-2, J-3).
Order VI: Depressed Residual Ridge: Resorption has continued below the
level of the genial tubercle.
J. Pros. Den.
818 ATWOOD
Sept..Oct., 1963
GROSS FINDINGS
Fig. 13.
Fig. 12.-A microradiograph of the crest of the residual ridge (Fig. 2, J-3) shows the
abrupt ending of the periosteal lamellar bone below the crest on both the labial and lingual
surfaces. (X15.1
Fig. 13.-A microradiograph of a portion of the crest of the residual ridge (Fig. 2, B-1)
shows an abrupt ending of the lingual periosteal bone and a zone of external resorption over
the crest of the ridge. (x15.1
Volume 13 POSTEXTRACTION CHANGES IN ADULT MANDIBLE 819
Numhrr 5
Fig. 14.-A microradiograph of the crest of the residual ridge (Fig. 2, B-l) shows Howship’s
laruna involving bone regardless of the density of the bone. (X60.)
the averages of the maxinlum widths of the different orders ( 12.0, 12.1, 11.7, and
I 1.9 mm., respectively).
3. There was little or no cortical layer at the crest of the ridge in Orders II,
III and V, but in Order IV where the remodeled labial and lingual plates merged
to form a knife-edge ridge. The cortical plate at the crest of the ridge averaged
4.5 mm. in a vertical direction.
M ICRORADIOGRAPHIC STUDY
Resorption takes place in lamellar bone, Haversian bone, and trabecular bone. The
great majority of the resorption taking place in these specimens is on the external
surface of the residual ridge.
3. Internal Remodeling: While a long bone grows in circumference by means
of periosteal new bone, the entire internal structure, including the cortex and the
medulla, is reconstructed.52 The same process, but in a reverse direction, seems
to take place in the residual ridge. As external resorption occurs, both the cortex
and the medulla are remodeled. As the ridge gets narrower labiolingually, the cor-
tical plates do not necessarily disappear. The ridge gets narrower mostly at the
expense of the medulla. In Order IV, the knife-edge ridge and the labial and
lingual cortical plates merge into one (Figs. 15 and 16).
4. Evidence of Osteoporosis: Microradiographic criteria for osteoporosis (Fig.
9) include : (1) increased variation in the density of the osteons, (2) increased
number of incompletely closed osteons, (3) increased endosteal porosity, and (4)
increased number of plugged osteons. Unfortunately, these criteria are not reliably
quantitated from specimen to specimen. None of the specimens showed advanced
osteoporosis, but about one half showed some evidence of it, (Fig. 2, B-l, B-3, C-Z,
D-4, E-3, H-5, J-l, J-Z, J-4), while the rest showed little or no evidence of osteo-
porosis (Fig. 2, C-4, D-1, D-3, E-Z, E,-4, F-4, G-Z, G-3, H-4, J-3). The average age
for the group with evidence of osteoporosis is 76 years, while that of the other group
is 69 years. Males and females are evenly divided between the two groups.
Fig. 15.-A microradiograph of the crest of the knife-edge residual ridge (Fig. 2, B-3) shows
external resorption of both the lingual and labial cortical plates, merging of the lingual and
labial plates, “new” osteons in the remodeled inner portion, and endosteal bone formation.
(X15.)
Volume 13 POSTEXTRACTION CHANGES IN ADULT MANDIBLE 821
Number 5
Fig. 16.-A microradiograph of portion of the knife-edge residual ridge (Fig. 2, B-3) shows
that only a small amount of the labial and lingual resorption will result in a sudden loss of
vertical height of the residual ridge. (x60.)
D[SCCSSION
Bone is a living tissue which requires a vital blood supply. Whenever new
bone is laid down beyond a certain thickness, it is invaded by absorption cavities,
thereby providing a blood supply to the osteocytes in the interior part of the bone.
The absorption cavities are converted to osteons, but the blood vessels remain
within the central canals. As a result of these vascular channels, even the densest-
appearing cortex is actually porous. This is clearly seen in the microradiographs.
Bone is a valuable tissue not only for its structural strength, but also as a
reservoir for calcium and phosphorous. There is accumulating evidence that the
“,young” or “new” osteons provide a quickly available, nonosteoclastic source of
these ions to the bloodstream. The microradiographs clearly show the difference in
the degree of calcification between different osteons in the same area of bone.
The classification of the adult mandible into six orders of anatomic form is
helpful in research, teaching, and clinical practice. We need more information con-
cerning the range of variation of time period for each order. Cephalometric studies
should give this information if they are carried out over a long enough period of
time.
The complete absence of periosteal bone over the residual ridge in all of these
midsagittal specimens, and the presence of external resorption on some part of
the residual ridge in every specimen is discouraging from a clinical point of view,
because it suggests the inevitability of resorption of residual ridges. Yet, we must
remember that nothing is known of the medical and dental history of these indi-
viduals. An interesting study would be to have bone biopsies of residual ridges of
persons who seem clinically to be having no resorption. Would they show evidence
of periosteal bone formation over the crest of the ridge?
J. Pros. Den.
822 ATWOOD Sept.-Oct., 1963
The uniform and continuous nature of the zone of external resorption of the
residual ridge suggests the presence of an external stimulus to osteoclastic resorp-
tion from an undetermined origin. It might be a dental prosthesis, increased mu-
cosal vascularity, a constricting mucoperiosteum, muscle action, the trauma of
mastication, or some other factor yet unknown. The degree of osteoclastic activity
was different in the various specimens, suggesting that different factors were at
work.
The role of surgical technique in relation to postextraction resorption of
residual ridges deserves further study. Obviously, if much cortical bone is removed,
the amount of residual ridge will be considerably less. Simpson30-32 found that
the level of bone formation in the socket was limited by a line joining the crests
of the socket and that new bone does not build up on the crest of the ridge. Per-
haps also, if too much soft tissue is excised (for example, all of the interdental pap-
illae and most of the gingival mucosa), and if the reduced mucosa is closely ap-
proximated in an esthetically successful surgical closure, the subsequent healing
and late cicatricial shrinking may result in the continuing resorption of residual
ridges. Perhaps the surgery predetermines the amount of resorption the prostho-
dontist will observe. Perhaps the knobby unesthetic residual ridges resulting from
a minimum of removal of bone give patients a longer lasting residual ridge than
the esthetic but too extensively excised ridge resulting from a generous alveolec-
tomy. 30.32,63-E&i
The suggestion of mild to moderate degrees of osteoporosis in approximately
one half of the specimens is not surprising since the average age of that group was
76 years. We do not know that osteoporotic bone will resorb more rapidly. We do
know that there is less of it to be resorbed and that the rate of replacement and
reconstruction is usually slower.
SUMMARY
1. Bone is a living tissue of varying size, shape, and density and is subject
to constant remodeling throughout life.
2. It is helpful in research, teaching, and patient care to classify adult
mandibles into 6 orders of anatomic form: I, pre-extraction; II, postextraction;
III, high, well-rounded residual ridge ; IV, knife-edge residual ridge ; V, low, well-
rounded residual ridge ; VI, depressed residual ridge.
3. Microradiography of thin sections of bone shows clearly the variations in
form and degree of mineralization of the various elements of bone.
4. Microradiography of midsagittal sections of 21 edentulous mandibles re-
vealed external resorption and an absence of periosteal bone on the residual ridges
in all specimens.
5. Evidence of mild to moderate osteoporosis was seen in one half of the
specimens (average age of this group, 76 years).
6. There are many avenues for the study of resorption of residual ridges. The
possible roles of a constricting mucoperiosteum and of surgical technique are dis-
cussed.
This microradiographic study would never have been accomplished without the encourage-
ment and experience of Dr. Reidar F. Sognnaes, formerly Charles A. Brackett Professor of
Volume 13 POSTEXTRACTION CHANGES IN ADULT MANDIBLE 823
Nmher 5
Oral Pathology, Harvard School of Dental Medicine, now Dean, School of Dentistry, Univer-
sity of California at Los Angeles, who generously made available to a member of the Prosthetic
Dentistry staff the extensive facilities of the Histopathology Department of the Harvard School
of Dental Medicine. Also, it is a pleasure to acknowledge the technical assistance of Mr. George
Pettingill. The author also expresses appreciation to Dean Roy 0. Greep, Associate Professor
Paul Goldhaber, and Assistant Clinical Professor David J .Farrell.
REFERENCES
I. Yurkstas, ,A, A.: The Effect of Missing Teeth on Masticatory Performance Efficiency,
J. Paos. DEN. 4:120-123, 1954.
i!. DeVan6$.lgi: The Transition from Natural to Artificial Teeth, J. PROS. DEN. 11:677-
.3. Atwood, D. A.‘: A Cephalometric Study of the Clinical Rest Position of the Mandible.
Part I. The Variability of the Clinical Rest Position Following the Removal of
Occlusal Contacts, J. PROS.DEN. 6:504-519, 1956.
4. Tallgren, A. : Changes m Adult Face Height Due to Ageing, Wear and Loss of Teeth, and
Prosthetic Treatment, Acta odont. scandinav. 25: Suppl. 24, 1957.
5. Krogh-Poulsen, W. G., Paffenbarger, G. C., and Schoonover, I. C.: Two Methods of
Graphing the Contour of the Mucosal Surface of Plaster Models, J.A.D.A. 36:
379-385, 1948.
6. Rupp, N. W., Dickson, G., Lawson, M. E., Jr., and Sweeney, W. T.: A Method for
Measuring the Mucosal Surface Contours of Impressions, Casts, and Dentures,
T.A.D.A. 54:24-32. 1957.
7. Lytle, k. B.: The Management of Abused Oral Tissues in Complete Denture Construc-
tion, J. PROS.DEN., 7:27-42, 1957.
13. Woelfel, J. B., Kreider, J. A., & Berg, T., Jr., Deformed Lower Ridge Caused by Relining
of a Denture by a Patient, J.A.D.A. 64:763-769, 1962.
!L Lam, R. V.: Contour Changes of the Alveolar Processes Following Extractions, J. PROS.
DEN. 10:25-32, 1960.
10. Campbell, R. L.: A Comparative Study of the Resorption of the Alveolar Ridges in Denture
Wearers and Non-denture Wearers, J.A.D.A. 60:143-153, 1960.
11. Stanton, H.: Reaction of Edentulous Mandible to Trauma, J. Implant. Dent. 4:40-45, 1958.
I.!. Lew, I.: A Study of Edentulous Mandibles in Implant Procedures, J. Implant. Dent. 5:
25-32, 1959.
13. Sicher, H.: Oral Anatomy, ed. 3, St. Louis, 1960, The C. V. Mosby Company.
14. Rogers, M., and Applebaum, E.: Changes in the Mandible Following Closure of the
Bite with Special Reference to Edentulous Patients, J.A.D.A. 28:1573-1586, 1941.
15. Neufeld, J. 0.: Changes in the Trabecular Pattern of the Mandible Following the Loss of
Teet.h, J. PROS.DEN. 8:685-697, 1958.
1’6. Benkow, H.: Roentgenological and Morphological Findings in the Region of the Mandibu-
lar Symphysis, Acta odont. scandinav. 19:1-21, 1961.
17. Nagle, R. J., and Sears, V. H.: Dental Prosthetics, ed. 2, St. Louis, 1962, The C. V. Mosby
Company.
1B. Martone, A. L.: The Phenomenon of Function in Complete Denture Prosthodontics. Part
VI. The Diagnostic Phase, J. PROS.DEN. 12:817-834.
19. GershkotI, A., and Goldberg, N. I.: Implant Dentures, Philadelphia and Montreal, 1957,
J. B. Lippincott Company.
20. Orban,c~mpa~~l Histology and Embryology, cd. 4, St. Louis 1957, The C. V. Mosby
21. Weinm;tmJ.al.v; and Sicher, H.: Bone and Bones, ed. 2, St. Louis, 1955, The C. V. Mosby
22. Schram, W. RI: A Histologic Study of Repair in the Maxillary Bones Following Surgery,
J.A.D.A. 16:1987-1997. 1929.
23. Pendleton, E. C.: The Anatomy of Maxilla From Viewpoint of Full Denture Prosthesis,
T.A.D.A. 19:543-572. 1932.
24. Pendleton, E. C.: The Minute Anatomy of the Denture Bearing Area, J.A.D.A. 21:488-
504, 1934.
25. Pendleton, E. C. : Influence of Biologic Factors in Retention of Artificial Dentures, J.A.D.A.
23:1233-1251, 1936.
26. Pendleton, E. C.: The Reaction of Human Jaws to Prosthetic Dentures, J.A.D.A. 27:
677-683, 1940.
27. Pendleton, E. C.: Changes in the Denture Supporting Tissues, J.A.D.A. 42:1-15, 1951.
28. Claflin, R. S.: Healing of Disturbed and Undisturbed Extraction Wounds, J.A.D.A. 23:
945-959, 1936.
J. Pros. Den.
824 ATWOOD Sept.-Oct., 1963
29. Becks, H., and Grimm, H. : Comparative Roentgenographic and Histologic Study of Human
Mandibles, Am. J. Orthodontics & Oral Surg. 31:381-406, 1945.
30. Simpson, H. E.: Experimental Investigation Into the Healing of Extraction Wounds in
Macacus rhesus Monkeys, J. Oral Surg., Anesth. & Hosp. D. Serv. 18:391-399,
1960.
31. Simpson, H. E.: Effects of Suturing Extraction Wounds in Macacus rhesus Monkeys,
J. Oral Surg., Anesth. & Hosp. D. Serv. 18:461-464, 1960.
32. Simpson, H. C.: Healing of Surgical Extraction Wounds m Macacus rhesus Monkeys. I,
The Effect of Burs; II. The Effect of Chisels; III. The Effect of Removal of
Alveolar Crests After Extraction of Teeth by Means of Forceps, J. Oral Surg.,
Anesth. & Hosp. D. Serv. 19:3-9; 126-130; 227-231, 1961.
33. Stafne, E. C.: Oral Roentgenographic Diagnosis. Philadelphia and London, 1958, W. B.
Saunders Company.
34. Landa, J. S.: Trouble Shooting in Complete Denture Prosthesis. Part X. Nerve Im-
pingement and the Radiolucent Lower Anterior Ridge, J. PROS. DENT. 11:440-444,
1961.
35. Elfenbaum, A. : Roentgenographic Evaluation in Denture Construction, J. Implant. Dent.
3:12-25, 1957.
36. Applegate, 0. C.: An Evaluation of the Support for the Removable Partial Denture,
J. PROS. DEN. 10:112-123, 1960.
37. Smith, F. W., and Applegate, 0. C.: Roentgenographic Study of Bone Changes During
Exercise Stimulation of Edentulous Areas, J. PROS. DEN. ll:lO%-1097, 1961.
38. Atwood, D. A. : A Cephalometric Study of the Clinical Rest Position of the Mandible.
Part II. The Variability in the Rate of Bone Loss Following the Removal of Occlu-
sal Contacts. J. PROS. DEN. 7:544-552, 1957.
39. Atwood, D. A.: Some Clinical Factors Related to the Rate of Resorption of Residual
Ridges, J. PROS.DEN. 12:441-450! 1962.
40. Amprino, R., and Engstrom, A.: Studres on X-ray Absorption and Diffraction of Bone
Tissue, Acta anat. 15:1-22, 1952.
41. Sognnaes, R. F. : Microradiographic Observations on Demineralization Gradients in the
Pathogenesis of Hard Tissue Destruction, Arch. Oral Biol. 1:106-121, 1959.
42. Manson, J. D., and Lucas, R. B.: A Microradiographic Study of Age Changes in the
Human Mandible, Arch. Oral. Biol. 7:761-769, 1962.
43. Kochanowsky, L.: Age and Size Variations in the Microdensity of Haversian Systems,
Harvard School of Dental Medicine, Student Thesis, Class of 1957.
44. Gold, B.: A Microradiographic Study of the Calcified Tissues of the Human Jaw, Harvard
School of Dental Medicine, Student Thesis, Class of 1958.
Jowsey, J.: Age Changes in Human Bone, Clin. Orthop. 17:210-217, 1960,
t:: McLea$reFs C., and Urrst, M. R.: Bone. ed. 2, Chicago, 1961, Umverslty of Chicago
Lammie, G.‘A. : The Reduction of the Edentulous Ridges, J. PROS. DEN. 10:605-611, 1960.
ii: Sognnaes, R. F.: Preparation of Thin “serial” Ground Sections of Whole Teeth and
Jaws and Other Highly Calcified and Brittle Structures, Anat. Rec. 99:133-144,
1947.
49. Cohen, J., and Harris, W. H.: The Three-Dimensional Anatomy of Haversian Systems,
J. Bone & Joint Surg. 40-A:419-434, 1958.
50. Possel:,oUi95~dies in the Mobility of the Human Mandible, Acta odont. scandinav. 10:
51. Frost, H. M.,’ Villanueva, A. R., and Roth, H.: Measurement of Bone Formation in a
57-year-old Man by Means of Tetracyclines, Henry Ford Hosp. M. Bull. 8:239-254,
1960.
52. Enlow, D. H.: A Study of the Post-natal Growth and Remodeling of Bone, Am. J. Anat.
110:79-102, 1962.
53. MacMillan, H. W.: A Consideration of the Structure of the Alveolar Process With Spe-
cial Reference to the Principles Underlying its Surgery and Regeneration, J. D.
Res. 6:251-263, 1924-26.
54. Mangos, J. F.: Healing of Extraction Wounds, Experimental Study Based on Micro-
scopic and Radiographic Investigation, New Zealand D. J. 37:4, 1941.
55. Schram, W. R.: Principles Concerning the Extraction of Teeth, Am. J. Orthodontics &
Oral Surg. 31:298-301, 1945.
188 LONC,WOOD A+E.
BOSTON, MASS.