Social Work Review Notes Human Behavior and Social Environment Deviance / Deviant Behavior
Social Work Review Notes Human Behavior and Social Environment Deviance / Deviant Behavior
Social Work Review Notes Human Behavior and Social Environment Deviance / Deviant Behavior
Key Defining Elements in Deciding Deviant 3.) Social and Individual Harm
behavior or conditions that harm others There are however simply too many
Something offends God, or is a violation of harmless but deviant actions (i.e. an
certain religious principles that makes it instructor on his class takes off all of
deviant. his clothes does not cause physical
It deviates criminal code. harm.) And too many harmful but not
deviant actions (i.e. warfare has
Five Naïve, Misleading Definitions of Deviance destroyed 100 million lives, yet the
parties responsible are rarely
1.) Absolutist Definition condemned or labeled as deviants. In
Argues that defining a quality or facts, most often, they are regarded as
characteristics of deviance can be heroes.
found in the very nature of the act
or the condition itself. 4.) An act’s criminal Status
It says that deviance is intrinsic to Once again, there are many deviants
certain phenomenon, it dwells or but not criminal actions. (i.e. no one
resides within them. (I.e. an Error will be arrested for picking one’s nose,
in Zimbabwe will also be an error being obese is not a crime, mentally ill
in Brazil, in Australia and in the or disordered is not a crime.
moon.
According to the absolutist 5.) Positive Deviance
definition, what is deviance is Deviance is always and by a definition
defined not by norms, customs or negative in nature. There is no such
social rules. Right and wrong exist thing as positive deviance. We cannot
prior to and independent of the refer to behavior or conditions that
artificial, socially and humanly generate positive reactions as deviance.
created creatures. Certain behavior and conditions
The absolutist definition of generate negative reactions from some
deviance is accompanied by strong people or groups and positive reactions
emotional reactions towards those from others; this does not demonstrate
considered deviants sees them as the viability of the concept of positive
deviance but the relativity of deviance.
3
Denies the possibility that there is any position at the expense of other humans. Thus,
predictability in the reactive process the role of the state is to prevent crime.
Ignores the reality of victimization It is better to prevent crimes than to punish
them. This is the ultimate end of every good
Indirect or Symbolic Deviants – they know that legislation, which to use the general terms for
they would be labeled as deviants when their assessing the good and evils of life.
identity or activities discovered. To this end, Beccaria argued that the law
should be clear and simple and directed
against only those behaviors clearly
THEORIES ON DEVIANT BEHAVIOR endangering society and individuals in it.
Because of their rationality, all human where
I. The Rational Deviant – seen as equal before the law. He accepted
literally the notion that punishment should fit
The Classical the crime.
This theory was patterned from the thought The Neo Classical -
of Beccaria about a plea for reform of the
judicial and penal system of the time, which Recognized as a practical matter that not
was characterized by secret accusations, all persons are equally rational, particularly the
extensive use of tortures, harsh penalties for young, the mentally disturbed, and those
trivial offenses. confronted with other unusual circumstances.
In the 15th century, the death penalty and
serious mutilation were used only in extreme Despite their considerable influence on
cases to supplement the complicated and Western Legal System, the classical and neo
carefully differentiated system of fine, but classical schools failed to produce a variable
now, they become the most common theory of deviance. Their pre-occupation with the
measures. Judges resorted to them whenever rationality of humans resulted in overlooking how
they were convinced that the offender was a society can adversely affect behavior.
danger to society.
The point was, it was no longer the II. POSITIVE SCHOOL OF
extreme penalty for serious offenses but a CRIMINOLOGY.
means of putting allegedly dangerous
individuals out of the way. In this kind of 2 TERMS
procedure, little attention was paid to the guilt
or innocence of a suspect. POSITIVISM – a philosophical approach, theory,
According to Beccaria, humans are or system based on the view that in the social as
fundamentally rational and hedonistic. They well as in the natural sciences, sense experiences
possess free will and make deliberate decisions are all the exclusive source of all worthwhile
to behave based upon a calculation of the pain information.
and pleasure involved. To avoid continual - does not concern itself with the abstract
chaos resulting from total individual freedom, and unprovable but rather with the tangible and
humans eventually enter a contract in which quantifiable. It involves investigating the world by
they submit to a wide authority in exchange objective data that can be counted or measured. In
for security under laws of a state. Humans are short, if you can’t hear it, feel it, see it, or smell it
basically self-serving; however, given the forget it.
opportunity they will enhance their own Positivists do not advise punishment as a remedy
because deviant behavior is not a matter of choice.
5
DETERMINISM - refers to the principle that all prisons to measure head shapes. Gall
events, including human behavior have sufficient believed that the brain was the center of
causes. the thought, specific brain areas controlled
different behavioral activities and brain
Obviously, the recommended procedure for areas of greater importance were greater in
halting deviant behavior depends upon the brand size and area.
of determinism favored. Thus if the cause is - The notion that there maybe a link between
located in the body, the body must be “treated; if it protuberance on the head and criminal
is in social factors, anything from the family, behavior was widely circulated throughout
neighborhood or entire economic system may Europe and USA.
need renovation. - A phrenologist in USA made a theory
dividing the brain into 34 areas, 3 of which
MAJOR THEORITICAL POSITIONS were related to criminal behavior:
(Positivist Approaches to the Explanation of Philoprogenitiveness (love for
Deviance) offspring)- it was noted that a number
of guilty females committed
I. Physical Characteristics of Deviance infanticide had defective
philoprogenitiveness area.
- Of all the positivist approaches to the Destructiveness – this area if properly
explanation of deviance, the investigation of a not balanced will lead to murder
possible relationship between anatomical Cohesiveness – unless restrained and
attributes and behavior is not only the oldest but properly directed will lead to great
also the most persistent. Today, scarcely year goes selfishness and even theft.
by without some revelations concerns the possible
connection between a biological characteristics Up to the end of the 19th century,
and human behavior. phrenology provided the basis for a
The influence of biology on human moderate amount of theory and research on
behavior is early overestimated and the nature of criminal beings, but in the
oversimplified. final analysis, it makes no contributions to
In 1966, Charles Whitman after killing his the understanding of deviant behavior.
mother /wife climbed with 6 guns to the top of a One cannot detect the subtle shape
tower in the University of Texas campus. He shot of the brain by examining the exterior of
46 persons, killing 16. His behavior was puzzling. the skull, and no single sections of the
Whitman requested an autopsy to determine brain one completely responsible for the
whether he had a mental disorder. The autopsy complex behaviors attributed to them by
revealed a brain tumor. Some medical experts the phrenologist.
doubted the explanatory value of the tumor. But
others thought that his physical condition could
somehow account for his behavior. “Concept of Born Criminal “
II.Phrenology – The Beginning of the Scientific The notion that biology plays a significant,
Study of Deviant if not paramount, role in causing deviant behavior
is usually associated with the writings of Cesare
Phrenology – the determination of the mental Lombroso (founder of the Positivist School of
facilities and character traits from the shape of the Criminology).
skull. ATAVISM – criminals were seen as
- Franz Gall – an Austrian anatomist who distinct types of humans who would be
spent 20 years touring insane asylums and
6
Mesomorphic Body
Type:
hard,
muscular body
overly mature
appearance
rectangular
shaped
thick skin
upright
8
posture
Associated
personality traits:
adventurous
desire for
power and
dominance
courageous
indifference to
what others
think or want
assertive, bold
zest for
physical
activity
competitive
love of risk
and chance
thin
flat chest
delicate build
young appearance
tall
lightly muscled
stoop-shouldered
large brain
father complained to doctors about the example, considered the price of grain to be a
mildly retarded girl having interest in boys. crucial variable in the operation of society.
Her father never informed the rest of the - This influence is an attempt to find
family bout what he had done. She lived relationship between crime and a variety of
out her life in Wisconsin institution and economic factors such as the prices of
died on January 7, 2005. This operation various grains, business cycles and income
was one of the famous failures. Leaving levels of convicted persons.
Rosemary Kennedy inert and unable to
speak more than a few words. After Karl Marx
lobotomy, she was sent to Wisconsin - Marx developed an economic
institution where she remained until her interpretation of societies. He claimed that
death in 2005 all social phenomena-legal codes, political
institutions, religion, ethics, the arts, the
2 Fundamental Approaches to the Explanation of family are products of society’s economy
Deviance in the form of its means of production.
The cause is within the deviant; the goal - In a capitalistic economy, there is a private
was to discover individual characteristics ownership of the means of production,
contributing to becoming involved in distribution and exchange of wealth; as a
deviant behavior. In short, this first consequence, there exist an intense
approach concerned explaining the deviant competition resulting in the exploitation of
by means of biological and psychological proletariat (working class) by the
positivism. bourgeoisie (owners and controllers of
The other approach stressed the means of production).
importance of social factors as a cause of - According to Marx, the continual
deviance. The goal was to explain both the competition requires that minimal wages
existence of deviant behaviors and its be paid for labor; the bourgeoisie becomes
distribution in society. This in short richer and richer and the proletariat
concerns explaining the varying amounts becomes poorer and miserable. The
of deviance between groups by means of condition of poverty and continued
social determinism. exploitation produce all forms of social
problems. Only by destroying the
Theorists Guerry and Quetelet labeled as “Moral economic system, ultimately accomplished
Statisticians” noted 2 phenomena in relation to by the proletariat in a violent revolution,
deviance. will a classless society emerge of
That the types and amount of deviance economic exploitation and its evils.
vary according to geographical region. - Marx never actually spelled out a theory of
That annual deviance within a specific area deviance, but inferences can be made and
varies little from one year to another. his writings have been influential to the
explanation of deviance.
-he argued that a society without deviance Culture goals – the aspirations and aims
is impossible. Thus it is impossible to have a that define success in society.
collection of human so inflexible in their behavior Institutionalized means – the socially
that none will diverge to some degree from the acceptable methods and ways available for
ideal. He further claims that deviance is not only achieving goals.
inevitable but also necessary for the health and
progress of society. Without deviance society - It is believed that in America before, it was
would be static. The inevitability and desirability not the mere lack opportunity or the excessive
of deviance led him to conduct that deviance is emphasis on the accumulation of wealth that
“normal” in society. This did not mean that he create anomie; it is when both exist in the
necessarily regarded the individual deviant as situation where all or most members of a
normal. From the standpoint of society, deviance society believed that the opportunities are
is an expression of individual freedom and one of available to them that anomie results.
the prices to be paid for social change.
-Durkheim first used the concept of Merton’s important contribution is the provision
anomie in division of labor in society. Here it of alternative behaviors that may result from the
played a minor role; it’s purpose was to signify a disjunction between goals and means.
lack of integration and adjustment that threatens
the cohesiveness of contemporary society, which There are 4 adaptations apart from conformity that
unlike hunting and agricultural society are can be defined as deviant:
characterized by a complex variety of occupation
and interest. INNOVATION – is the adaptation in
which most property crimes would be
- Durkheim felt that sudden change caused found. It occurs when persons accept
a state of anomie. The system breaks down, either without qualification the importance of
during a great prosperity or great depression, attaining the goals and will use any means
anomie is the same result. regardless of their prosperity, morality, or
Anomic suicide – was one of the 4 types legality to achieve those goals.
and was considered to stem from a state of - In short, their philosophy can be described
‘normlessness” or “deregulation” in society. Such in the words of Vince Lombardi when he
suicide occurs because society allows its members said “Winning isn’t everything; it is the
to have unlimited aspirations, and there is no only thing”.
discipline imposed on notions of what may be
realistically achieved. These suicides arise RITUALISM – is a behavioral alternative
particularly during periods of sudden economic in which great aspirations are abandoned in
prosperity. Thus Durkheim was convinced that favor of careful adherence to the available
humans are susceptible to limitless ambition. means. Early morning classes often
Unless society imposes regulations upon considered ritualists. Attendance is not a
aspirations, unless there is some check upon the means for them to attain success; they are
passions aroused by perceived undiminishing there simply because they should be.
prosperity, personal crises will develop and result Merton uses the example of persons in
to suicide. factories and other bureaucracies who
staunchly perform their duties, but who
Merton’s Anomie have neither the intention nor the
inclination to advance themselves. They
Merton’s theory involves the interaction of 2 carefully avoid rocking the boat and prefer
social components: to play it safe.
13