Characterization and Standardization of Sand For Geotechnical Laboratory Testing in Pakistan
Characterization and Standardization of Sand For Geotechnical Laboratory Testing in Pakistan
Characterization and Standardization of Sand For Geotechnical Laboratory Testing in Pakistan
3-2021
ISSN:1813-1786 (Print) 2313-7770 (Online)
Abstract- Different countries have characterized current research comprise of pit sand and river
their indigenous sand resources and have proposed sand.
some standard sands for research purposes. Many countries in the world have standardized
Knowing their index and engineering properties, their local sources of sand for geotechnical
any further research conducted on such soils engineering related research [2-4]. Ottawa sand is
enriches the databank for researchers. Current considered as standard sand in USA and Canada,
study is focused on standardization of sand for Toyoura sand is Japanese standard sand, while
geotechnical engineering laboratory research in Quartzanium is used as standard laboratory testing
Pakistan. Sand samples were collected from five sand in India. In Pakistan, Lawrencepur sand is
different locations of Punjab and Khyber being used for most of the concrete related research
Pakhtunkhwa provinces of Pakistan, based on [5], but no significant work has been carried out for
annual sand production data. Material standardization of some sand for geotechnical
characterization was done using standards as laboratory research. In this research, efforts have
approved by American Society for Testing and been made to characterize and standardize
Materials (ASTM). The tests carried out were geotechnical laboratory testing sand in Pakistan.
color, specific gravity, grain size distribution,
minimum and maximum dry density, direct shear, II. RESEARCH METHODLOGY
mineral composition, shape of grains (metallurgy
microscope) and hydraulic conductivity. For Based on annual mineral production reports
standardization, properties of indigenous sands of Mines and Mineral Department, Government of
were compared with internationally used Ottawa F- Punjab, and keeping in view location of laboratory
65 & F-50 sands. From test results, Khushab sand facilities, sand samples were collected from five
has been recommended as standard sand for different locations within Punjab and Khyber
geotechnical laboratory testing in Pakistan. Pakhtunkhwa (KPK), Pakistan. According to latest
mineral wise production data in (M. Tons) for the
Keywords- Sand, Characterization, Standardization, month of July 2018 to June 2019 (on the basis of
Laboratory Testing, Geotechnical Engineering. royalty collection) Mianwali and Khusab were
biggest sources of producing silica sand i.e.
I. INTRODUCTION 354,061 and 79,750 M. Tons [6], respectively.
Hence these two sources and three nearest sources
Sand is a granular material composed of of sand Lawerencepur-Attock, Golra-Attock and
finely divided rock and mineral particles. It is Ghazi-Haripur were identified for sampling
defined by size being finer than gravel and coarser purpose. Researchers have worked on prediction
than silt. Unified Soil Classification System [7] and management [8] of sand production to
(USCS) defines sand as particles with a diameter of utilize the natural recourses efficiently.
between 0.074 mm to 4.75 mm [1]. Manually collected bulk samples were stored in
Sand can either be collected from natural sources bags, and sample I.D was marked on each bag for
or produced by crushing of rocks. Natural sources identification purpose. Meanwhile, latitude and
of sand include pit and river sands. Pit sands are longitude of sampling locations were also recorded.
usually coarser in size compared to river sands. Sample descriptions details have been provided in
Due to increased demand, sand is also being Table 1.
produced by crushing of rocks, also known as Collected sand samples were brought in best
manufactured sand. Sand samples collected for available laboratories in the vicinity and were
1
Technical Journal, University of Engineering and Technology (UET) Taxila, Pakistan Vol. 26 No. 3-2021
ISSN:1813-1786 (Print) 2313-7770 (Online)
tested as per specifications proposed by American size distribution (ASTM-6913), Description and
Society for Testing Materials (ASTM). The Identification (ASTM-D2488 − 09a), Specific
laboratories used were, Soil Mechanics and Gravity (ASTM D 854-14), Minimum dry density,
Foundation Engineering Laboratory, Civil ρd min (ASTM-D-4254-00) and Maximum dry
Engineering Department, UET Taxila; Material density, ρd max. (ASTM-D-4253-00), Minimum
Testing Laboratory, Askari Cement Factory, Wah Void Ratio emin. (ASTM-4253-00) and Maximum
Cantt; Geotechnical Engineering Laboratory, Void Ratio emax. (ASTM-4254-00), Chemical
COMSATS University, Wah Cantt, and Civil Composition XRF Model: Cubix PW-2400, Angle
Engineering Laboratory, Directorate Civil Works of Internal Friction – (ASTM D3080) and
Wah Cantt. Permeability Hydraulic Conductivity –ASTM
Specifications used for different tests include Grain D2434 (Constant Head).
2
Technical Journal, University of Engineering and Technology (UET) Taxila, Pakistan Vol. 26 No. 3-2021
ISSN:1813-1786 (Print) 2313-7770 (Online)
On comparison with Ottawa sand, minimum and Void ratio is an important soil property and its
maximum dry densities for samples D-KP collected variation has been studied by researchers in the
from Khusab and C2-GAP-2 collected from Golra- past [11-12]. Minimum and maximum void ratios
Attck were found to be closed to the respective for sand samples tested ranged between 0.42 to
values obtained for Ottawa Sand. Detail is shown 0.58 and 0.78 to 1.03, respectively. Void ratio
in Figure 3. values for all samples have been compared with
Ottawa F-50 as shown in Table 4. It was observed
3.5 Minimum and Maximum Void Ratio that sand sample C2-GAP-2 collected from Golra-
Void ratio is important property for determining Attock had shown nearest void ratio values
behavior of soil. It is defined as volume of voids compared to that of Ottawa-Sand.
present in sand to total volume of solids.
80
B-LAP.2
70
% Passing
C1-GAP-1
60
50 C2-GAP-2
40
D-KP
30
E-GHK
20
10 F-MP
0
10 1 0.1 0.01
Particle Diameter (mm)
Fig. 1. Grain size distribution curves of sand samples
3
Technical Journal, University of Engineering and Technology (UET) Taxila, Pakistan Vol. 26 No. 3-2021
ISSN:1813-1786 (Print) 2313-7770 (Online)
Specific Gravity
2.69
Specific Gravity
2.68
2.67 2.68 2.68
2.66 2.67 2.67
2.65 2.66 2.66
2.64 2.65 2.65
2.63
Location
Fig. 2. Specific gravity values of different sand samples
1000
800
600
400
200
0
4
Technical Journal, University of Engineering and Technology (UET) Taxila, Pakistan Vol. 26 No. 3-2021
ISSN:1813-1786 (Print) 2313-7770 (Online)
Table. 4: Minimum and Maximum Void Ratios for Different Sand Samples
Sr. No. Sample I.D Location e e e e
max min max min
(% (%
difference) difference)
1 Ottawa-F-50 USA/Canada 0.78 0.48 - -
2 Ottawa-F-65 USA/Canada 0.83 0.51 - -
3 A-LAP.1 Lawerencepur 0.82 0.50 1.22 2.00
4 B-LAP.2 Lawerencepur 0.80 0.44 3.75 15.92
5 C1-GAP.1 Golra-Attock 0.78 0.42 6.41 21.43
6 C2-GAP.2 Golra-Attock 0.82 0.51 1.22 0.00
7 D-KP Khusab-Jhelum 0.85 0.54 2.35 5.56
8 E-GHK Ghazi-KPK 0.95 0.58 12.63 12.07
9 F-MP Mianwali-Indus 1.03 0.57 19.42 10.53
3.6 Chemical Composition Using X-Ray Angle of internal friction of sand samples was
Fluorescence (XRF) determined by using direct shear test. Remolded
Chemical composition of sand was determined by sand samples at bulk density values as given in
using X-Ray Fluorescence (XRF) analyzer model Table 6 were used while preparing specimen.
no. Cubix PW-2400 available at Askari Cement Angle of internal friction of local sand samples
Factory Wah Cantt. Chemical composition of sand ranged between 320 to 340 compared to 31.80 as
is found to be an important property for controlling reported for Ottawa Sand sample [12-16]. Detail of
concrete strength [13] and is strongly affected by Angle of internal friction values has been given in
source of sand [14-15]. It was found that sand Table 6.
sample collected from Khusab had highest silicon
dioxide percentage of 72.05% while Ottawa sand 3.8 Permeability Test–Constant Head
comprises of more than 99% of silicon dioxide. Hydraulic conductivity of sand describes the ease
Detailed chemical composition values are showed with which fluid, usually water can flow through
in Table 5. interconnected pores of soil sample [17]. In this
study, hydraulic conductivity of sands was found
3.7 Angle of Internal Friction out by using Constant Head Permeability Test,
Angle of internal friction of sand is very important whose values are shown in Figure 4. Hydraulic
engineering property used to determine shear conductivity of sand samples was found at
strength under different normal stress minimum dry density and maximum dry density in
combinations. order to obtain range of permeability values.
1 Ottawa-F-50 99 - - - - - - -
2 Ottawa-F-65 99 - - - - - - -
3 A-LAP.1 66.71 14.73 5.65 4.99 2.17 1.79 2.43 0.03
4 B-LAP.2 65.98 14.25 4.45 4.76 2.05 2.07 2.24 0.03
5 C1-GAP.1 65.61 14.78 5.25 5.12 2.24 1.92 2.53 0.03
6 C2-GAP.2 64.83 14.12 5.92 5.17 2.12 1.66 2.36 0.03
7 D-KP 72.05 7.71 4.36 7.04 1.24 1.38 1.34 0.03
8 E-GHK 66.79 14.58 5.08 4.79 2.26 1.66 2.60 0.03
9 F-MP 68.58 12.76 4.93 5.04 2.19 1.80 2.23 0.03
5
Technical Journal, University of Engineering and Technology (UET) Taxila, Pakistan Vol. 26 No. 3-2021
ISSN:1813-1786 (Print) 2313-7770 (Online)
Permeability of Sand
0.08 0.072
0.07
0.061
0.058
0.06
0.05 0.042
K (cm/sec)
0.041
0.038 0.036
0.04 0.032
0.031 0.029
0.03 0.025
0.022 0.021 0.02 0.021
0.02 0.016 0.016
0.011
0.01
0
Location
6
Technical Journal, University of Engineering and Technology (UET) Taxila, Pakistan Vol. 26 No. 3-2021
ISSN:1813-1786 (Print) 2313-7770 (Online)
IV. CONCLUSIONS AND moist state, while shape of sand particles was found
RECOMMENDATIONS to be sub angular. Specific gravity values ranged
between 2.66 to 2.68. Minimum and maximum dry
4.1 Characterization of Local Sources of Sand densities of sand samples varied between 1311.95
3 3 3
Sand samples collected from five different places Kg/m to 1491.00 Kg/m and 1691.54 Kg/m to
3
of Punjab and KPK have been characterized. All 1877.11 Kg/m , respectively. Minimum void ratio
sand samples were poorly graded (SP) as per USCS values ranged between 0.42 to 0.58, while
classification. Color of sand samples was grey in maximum void ratio values ranged between 0.78 to
7
Technical Journal, University of Engineering and Technology (UET) Taxila, Pakistan Vol. 26 No. 3-2021
ISSN:1813-1786 (Print) 2313-7770 (Online)
1.03. Quantity of SiO2 varied between 65.61% to Pakistan, Pakistan Museum of Natural
72.05%. Angle of internal friction was found to be History, Islamabad (2000): 194-213.
o o [6] Mines and Minerals, Government of
between 32 to 34 . Permeability of sand samples Pakistan. " July 2018 to June 2019 (on the
ranged between 0.011 cm/sec to 0.072 cm/sec. basis of royalty” https://mnm.punjab.gov.pk/
Detail of all properties of sand are collectively system/files/MP-2018-19.pdf (Mar. 08, 21).
given under Table 7. [7] Veeken, C. A. M., Sand production
prediction review: developing an integrated
4.2 Standardization of Local Sources of Sand approach." SPE annual technical conference
Second aim of research objective was to and exhibition. OnePetro, 1991.
standardize local sources of sand after comparing it [8] Salama, Mamdouh M. "Sand production
with Ottawa-sand. Ottawa sand was selected as management." J. Energy Resour.
reference sand for comparison with local sources of Technol. 122.1 (2000): 29-33.
sand due to availability of research data and [9] Berney, Ernest S., and D M. Smith.
moreover it is being used widely in USA and other "Mechanical and physical properties of
countries [18]. ASTM C33 Sand." (2008).
After comparison, it has been observed that based [10] Laine, Leo, and A Sandvik. "Derivation of
on physical and engineering properties, soil sample mechanical properties for
collected from Khusab-Punjab having sand." Proceedings of the 4th Asia-Pacific
identification D-KP with grey color, sub angular Conference on Shock and impact loads on
shape of particles, specific gravity of 2.65, structures, CI-Premier PTE LTD, Singapore.
minimum dry density and maximum dry density of Vol. 361. ANSYS Inc., 2001.
1433.46 kg/cum and 1718.14 kg/cum, respectively, [11] Chang, Ching S., J-Y Wang, and Louis Ge.
minimum void ratio and maximum void ratio "Modeling of minimum void ratio for sand–
values of 0.54 and 0.85 respectively, 72.5% of silt mixtures." Engineering geology 196
silicon dioxide as chemical composition, angle of (2015): 293-304.
internal friction 330 and with minimum and [12] E Ghoraiby, Mohamed, H Park, and M T.
maximum premeability values of 0.020 K-cm/sec Manzari. "Physical and mechanical
and 0.041 K-cm/sec is more closer to Ottawa-F-50 properties of Ottawa F65 sand." Model tests
and Ottawa F-65 sand of USA, hence it is and numerical simulations of liquefaction
recommended to use Khushab sand as standard and lateral spreading. Springer, Cham,
laboratory testing sand for research purposes in 2020. 45-67.
Pakistan. Detailed comparison between these two [13] Hasdemir, S., A. Tuğrul, and M. Yılmaz.
sands is shown in Table 8. "The effect of natural sand composition on
concrete strength." Construction and
REFERENCES Building Materials 112 (2016): 940-948.
[14] Pease, Patrick P., and V P. Tchakerian.
[1] Howard, Amster K. "The revised ASTM "Composition and sources of sand in the
standard on the unified classification Wahiba Sand Sea, Sultanate of
system." Geotechnical Testing Journal 7.4 Oman." Annals of the Association of
(1984): 216-222. American Geographers 92.3 (02): 416-434.
[2] Bastidas, A M Parra. Ottawa F-65 sand [15] Pettijohn, F John, P E. Potter, and R
characterization. University of California, Siever. Sand and sandstone. Springer
Davis, 2016. Science & Business Media, 2012.
[3] Ojuri, Oluwapelumi O., and D O. Fijabi. [16] Krantz, Robert W. "Measurements of
"Standard sand for geotechnical engineering friction coefficients & cohesion for faulting
and environmental research in Nigeria: & fault reactivation in lab. models using
Igbokoda sand." Advances in environmental sand & sand mixtures Tectonophysics 188.1-
research 1.4 (2012): 305-21. 2 (1991): 203-207.
[4] E Ghoraiby, Mohamed, H Park, and M T. [17] D-Leal, Eduardo, F M-Gómez, and L A B-
Manzari. "Physical and mechanical Cruz. "Hydraulic conductivity in layered
properties of Ottawa F65 sand." Model tests saturated soils assessed through a novel
and numerical simulations of liquefaction physical model." Dyna 85.205 (18) 119-124.
and lateral spreading. Springer, Cham, [18] Laine, Leo, and A Sandvik. "Derivation of
2020. 45-67. mechanical properties for
[5] Ahsan, N.,"Strength evaluation of blends of sand." Proceedings of the 4th Asia-Pacific
Lawrencepur, Chenab and Ravi sands with Conference on Shock and impact loads on
Lockhart and Margalla Hill Limestones for structures, CI-Premier PTE LTD, Singapore.
use in concrete." Economic Geology of Vol. 361. ANSYS Inc., 2001.