Powder Coating Troubleshoothing Revised 7 10 14
Powder Coating Troubleshoothing Revised 7 10 14
Powder Coating Troubleshoothing Revised 7 10 14
P WD
OW ER
DE CO
RC AT
OA NG
TIIN TR
GT OU
RO BL
UB ES
LE HO
SH OT
OO NG
TIIN G
2 Powder Application
2.1 Poor fluidization
2.2 Sintering in the powder hoses
2.3 Powder drizzles off the work piece
2.4 Poor wrap
2.5 Clumping in the hopper
2.6 Poor penetration into recesses
2.7 Film thickness too high
2.8 Film thickness too low
2.9 Film thickness varies
3 Surface Defects
3.1 Powder puffs on the work piece
3.2 Craters
3.3 Pin holes
3.4 Picture framing effect
3.5 Contaminations
3.6 Blisters
3.7 Dripping
3.8 Orange peel
3.9 Insufficient drying of the substrate
Powder too fine (reclaim), high over spray ratio Add virgin powder, change powder
Delivery air moist or oil in pressurized air Check in-line filters and moisture traps
Particle size distribution of powder coating too fine Note appropriate particle size
Optimise virgin powder plus reclaim ratio
Feed hose diameter wrong Adjust hose diameter to appropriate powder flow
Inappropriate hose material Exchange hose type, use appropriate type (silicone, polyurethane,
Teflon)
2.3 Powder does not adhere to substrate
Problem:
The powder coating, which should electrostatically adhere to the substrate, falls off–no relevant coating thickness can be achieved.
Possible causes Corrections, testing, procedures
Insufficient grounding Test contacts and transport mechanism (especially booth) and
hooks (< 1 MO). Insulation from lubricants and residues in
transport
Voltage too low or no voltage Gun, test high voltage, cable and cable lead
Chain does not run smooth, vibration too strong Check conveyor system
Too much powder output Reduce air flow and/or powder flow
Gun distance to part too close, blast off effect Adjust distance
Insufficient grounding Use clean hooks, test transfer resistance (< 1 MO), check diameter
of hooks
Temperature of the part too high after dry-off oven or pre-heating Allow adequate time for cooling (less than 40 °C /104 °F]
Supplemental air flow is too high or too low Adjust air speed and powder cloud
Insufficient charging of the powder - gun defective Adjust high voltage; Consult equipment and powder manufacturer
Insufficient charging of the powder - gun defective Adjust high voltage; Consult equipment and powder manufacturer
Transport too slow or too warm Strain powder before use, consult powder manufacturer
Inappropriate application, unsuitable nozzle Utilize flat spray nozzle or deflector; Adjust nozzle
Insufficient charging of powder, defective gun Adjust voltage (increase, test)
Contact equipment manufacturer
Faraday cage effect due to electric field Use tribo equipment and powder; Reduce voltage
Unsuitable particle size distribution Optimise through testing; Contact powder manufacturer
Distance from gun to part is too big or too small Increase or decrease distance
Preheat temperature too high Lower preheat temperature or allow for cooling (less than 40 [°C]
/ 104 [°F])
Inappropriate particle size distribution/percentage of overspray too Continuous and even introduction of virgin powder to reclaim
high powder
Patio adjusted to actual consumption Optimise particle size
distribution through testing
Powder flow too low Increase powder flow
Powder delivery hose too long Shorten hose; Change hose diameter; Change injector
Fluid characteristics of powder not optimal Check fluidization (see 2.1 poor fluidization)
Residence time of parts in front of gun too short Slow down line speed of conveyor; Increase number of passes of
gun in front of part Add more guns Suction of reclaim system too
high Lower suction capacity
Suction of reclaim system too high Lower suction capacity
Booth draft too strong to allow powder cloud to deposit on its own Change system configuration
Consult with booth supplier
Slow down line speed
Changed powder supply due to powder deposits in the transport Cleaning of the transport system components, coordinate feed and
system, injectors, hose and nozzle atomized air, check fluidization
Plugged transport system due to foreign materials (e.g. fibers, Commit to cleaning cycles and regular maintenance
cleaning residues)
Particle size too fine due to circulation in system Increase virgin to reclaim ratio
Too much overspray in booth due to cleaning cycles Regular transport of overspray from booth to reclaim system
Intermittent back pulse of filter too long, sudden shift of powder Keep back pulse of compressed air short (e.g. 20 seconds)
particle size (too fine)
Insulation of base coat too strong Reduce voltage for second coat and lower powder flow
Use tribo powder coatings
Powder hose causes friction charge of opposite polarity to charge Change hose material or ground hose
generated in gun
2.9 Film build varies
Problem:
Substrate shows through and powder coat has grainy flow. Or powder coat shows uneven surface prior to curing – orange peel after curing, wavy
flow, pinholes. These appearances vary on the surface of the work piece.
Possible causes Corrections, testing, procedures
Wrong positioning of guns in an automated system Empirical determination of proper gun positioning. Optimise
interval curve of automatic guns. Check conveyor/lift speed
No continuous, even introduction of virgin powder to reclaim Assure proper functioning of recovery system Adjust virgin to
powder based on actual consumption reclaim ratio
Sliding of powder film (in an improperly fused condition) due to Inspect conveyor and chain
conveyor vibration Test grounding/charging
Uneven powder transport Test powder transporting devices for clogging due to foreign
particles or plugs
Test for air pressure variations
Unfavorable geometry of parts (Faraday Cage) Change hanging configuration or gun positioning
Use flat spray nozzles
Geometry of parts varies greatly Optimise device and gun adjustments to suit work piece
Powder hose too long or diameter too large Change hose diameter
Shorten hose
Change configuration
Powder too fine (reclaim) Add virgin powder
Clogging of the feed hoses Note hose path, see section 2.2. (clogging of the powder feed
hoses)
Powder falls off booth ceiling Adjust/increase frequency of booth cleaning intervals
Powder falls off hanging devices Remove/ reduce powder coat layer, check grounding
Level in powder supply container varies greatly Reduce distance between minimum and minimum level
Powder moist Use dry powder; Check for condensation (temperature difference
from powder storage area to coating area), Check air filter and
moisture traps in compressed air system
3.2 Craters
Problem:
Defect – blank area in the powder coat, which extends all the way to the substrate (diameter up to 2 mm)
Possible causes Corrections, testing, procedures
Insufficient pretreatment (e.g. oil and grease residues) Test pretreatment if necessary, contact pretreatment supplier
Chemical residue, faulty pretreatment Test pretreatment, if necessary contact pretreatment supplier
Rust, white rust on parts Assure clean surface, apply recommended pretreatment, possibly
buff or sandblast (sweep) surface
Oil in feed and/or atomizing air Check in-line filters and moisture traps in air system
Silicones from chain lubricants or welding sprays Use product without silicon content, educate line operators
Incompatibility with powder coatings from other manufacturers Cleaning of coating and application equipment, contact powder
coating supplier
Out gassing from substrate Pre-heat work pieces, use OGF additive
Surrounding air contaminated Balance air flows in plant, avoid cross drafts
Liquid and powder paint in same plant Definitely avoid - reconfigure plant
Body filler or other compounds not compatible Forced drying, test suitability
Base coat was cleaned with solvents Preheat work piece or avoid solvents
Instead of rough texture effect only penetration-to metal and Insufficient coating thickness
craters visible
Instead of rough texture effect only penetration-to metal and Insufficient coating thickness
craters visible
With rough textures, instead of effect development only pinholes Film thickness too low (see 2.8 film thickness too low)
develop
Very porous work pieces Check for satisfactory work pieces, possible surface is too rough
from sand blasting
Out-gassing from porous work pieces (cast parts, zinc galvanized Preheat parts
material, magnesium castings, anodized materials) Modify powder coating
Cast anodized materials not scaled and dried
3.4 Picture framing effect
Problem:
Higher film build of coating on the edges of the part due to wrap, therefore uneven flow.
Possible causes Corrections, testing, procedures
Powder particles too rough/unsuitable for particular application Strain powder to optimise particle distribution
Consult powder coating manufacturer
Contamination of powder surface due to airborne dirt from outside Isolate booth area, clean surroundings with vacuum Avoid cross
of booth (e.g. surrounding air, floor, polishing area, blasting area drafts
Balance air flows in plant
Avoid polishing in booth and oven area
Fibers from broom and cleaning cloths Use suitable cleaning apparatus and materials
Insufficient polished welding areas, metal shavings, welding Control finishing process- repeat if necessary
drops, milling flaws Improve polishing stage and pretreatment
Contamination from equipment cleaning Vacuuming is more effective than compressed air (powder is not
airborne)
Deposits from dust and powder particles in the oven (too much Reduce air speed
convection inside, powder that doesn’t adhere, is blown onto work Install pre-gelling curing stage
pieces of different colors) Do not cure other colors at the same time in oven
Deposits of dust and powder on cured work pieces Dust free cooling zone
Avoid drafts
Dirt and color particle transfer between adjoining booths If possible reconfigure area
Enclose booths
Water in scooping type of work pieces Note geometry, drying time and temperature or change hanging
configuration
Air blast work pieces
Corrosion, oil and grease residues Optimise pretreatment
Salt residues or chemical remnants on the work piece surface, Check pretreatment, final rinse stage, and drying of
insufficient wetting media/chemicals during transport inaction
Film thickness too high, powder accumulations, powder drizzles Check system parameters
off work piece on edges and corners Reduce film thickness
Break in zinc layer, double zinc layer, corrosion under the zinc Avoid double zinc layers
layer Ensure flawless zinc layer
3.7 Drip Developments
Problem:
Running or dripping of the gelling powder coat off the work piece
Possible causes Corrections, testing, procedures
Film thickness too high (with wire or sheet metal parts) Reduce film thickness
Substrate temperature is too high (from preheating or dryer), Increase cooling time (max. 40 [°C] / 104 [°F]) between dry-off
therefore film build too high oven and booth Optimise film thickness
Powder accumulation on inside corners from drizzled off powder Optimise system parameters and blast off effect.
coating
Substrate temperature exceeds the melt temperature of the Check substrate temperature (max. 40 [°C] / 104 [°F])
powder, causing excessive film build Increase cool down phase
Shift in particle size distribution, portion of reclaimed powder too Optimise deposit results of powder guns
high Increase lift intervals
Unsuitable particle size distribution Optimise particle size distribution
Consult powder manufacturer
Textured work piece surface Optimise texture, check work piece surface
Air speed too high at oven entrance Reduce air speed (max. 0.5 [m/sec] / 1 ½ [ft./sec]), change air
flow guides
Conveyor halt during pretreatment, dried on chemicals Avoid conveyor halts, possibly mist
Differing substrates and substrate colors (steel, aluminum, brass, Use substrates of same type for comparisons
glass)
Film thickness too thin (not covering) Apply higher film thickness (same as samples)
Not sufficient or wrong pigmentation in the formulation Consult powder coating manufacturer
Color deviations due to curing technique or oven atmosphere Use suitable powder coatings
(example: direct fired gas oven, IR oven), use of room air for Control oven
burner! Use outside air supply for burner
Over curing of powder coating (especially with organic pigments) Observe curing parameters of powder manufacturer
Differing curing parameters with same parts Observe powder manufacturers curing parameters
Differing curing parameters with greatly varying parts (different Observe curing parameters of powder manufacturers and adjust to
wall thickness) wall thickness
Several powder manufacturers/suppliers Use powder coatings from the same manufacturer or check the
compatibility
Varying film thickness with over coating Assure even film thickness
Bleeding of first coat with over coating Check suitability of first coat when over coating
During over coating extensive color deviations from first coat Avoid over coating of strongly deviating colors
Mesmerism, color deviations with differing light sources Judge work pieces in daylight (not direct sunlight)
Use day light cabinet
Powder transport directly from the powder box Use fluid container
Reciprocator operation parameters inappropriate for line speed Adjust lift speed to chain speed
and part configuration
Uneven powder transport line speed and part configuration Introduce sufficient virgin powder
Test for deviations in air pressure
Strongly varying film thickness (especially with matte finishes) Optimise film thickness
Separation of matte finish powders in reclaim system, uneven Assure consistent powder quality Adhere to the recommended
parts of virgin and reclaim powder percentage of virgin and reclaim powder
Film thickness varies greatly from part to part Optimise system parameters
Reciprocator operation parameters inappropriate for line speed Adjust lift speed to chain speed
and part configuration
Differing materials and material colors (steel, aluminum, brass, Use same materials for comparison
glass)
Differing surfaces and reflections (polished, blasted, chromate) Use same surfaces for comparison
Mechanical treatment shows through (example: polishing) Use finer grain materials for polishing
4.4 Loss of Gloss Yellowing, Discolorations
Problem:
Difference between suggested gloss level and color and the gloss level and color of the original sample or parts coated at the beginning of the job
Possible causes Corrections, testing, procedures
Cure parameters of manufacturer were not observed Optimize curing parameters
Adhere to powder manufacturers suggestions
Oil, soluble materials in oven Do not use oil or soluble materials in oven area
Powder coating is not temperature stable Use temperature stable powder coatings
Consult powder manufacturer
Over curing in oven Adjust oven temperature and speed to parts being coated
Lower temperature during conveyor halts
Incompatibility of powder coating in the oven Do not use powder coatings from different manufacturers at the
same time in one oven
Direct fired ovens and IR ovens Adjust powder coating to oven parameters
Adjust oven temperature to powder coating
Unsuitable cleaning agents for example prior to silk screening Check suitability of cleaning agents for powder coat, pre-testing
necessary
Separation of 2 component matte powders Check reclaim system for uneven suctioning of over spray
Uneven gloss level due to different wall thickness of work piece Lower oven temperature
Increase duration time
Re-construct system
Components of the powder formula migrate to the surface causing Discuss possible changes with powder supplier and consider
haze and lower gloss trade-off between performance parameters and better stability
Optimize oven parameters Re-construct system
Binder in powder coating poorly dispersed Consult powder manufacturer
With transparent top coats slow deterioration of the powder Over coating of interior grade powder coatings with exterior grade
coating (chalking) transparent powder coatings does not result in a UV resistant
coating system, therefore adhesion problems of the top coat
5.2 Greasy Surface
Problem:
Haze like film on the surface, which can be wiped off
Possible causes Corrections, testing, procedures
Blooming effect (white film on the powder coating surface, which Change powder coating formula
can be wiped off) Increase curing temperature
Contamination on the surface because of incompatible powder Use only powder coatings from one manufacturer at the same time
coatings from different manufacturers in an oven
Consult powder manufacturer
Wrong powder coating choice Use suitable powder coatings
Consult powder manufacturer
Basic material too thick or unevenly thick Observe curing parameters, use slower or faster curing powder
coatings
Scale, surface rust on the work pieces Use “fresh” work pieces or store in dry environment; mechanical
pretreatment
Oxide layer on the work pieces, white rust on zinc plating Store work pieces in dry environment or use “fresh” work pieces
Use suitable pretreatment materials
Use mechanical pretreatment (sweeping) if necessary
No adhesion on laser cut edges Treat edges mechanically (brush, polish, sweep)
Purpose and powder coating properties are not suited for each Use suitable powder coatings
other
Film thickness too high Reduce film thickness or use more flexible powder coatings
No adhesion to base coat If possible lightly polish base coat or partially edge with suitable
solvent
No adhesion to liquid base coat, electro coat or coil coating Test suitability, lightly abrade base coat
Break in zinc, conversion or primer layer Adjust pretreatment to work piece and powder coating
Double zinc layers, corrosion under zinc layer Consult with H.D.G. supplier
Transport residues on work pieces (salt, dust etc), which have not Assure flawless surfaces and protected transportation, suitable
been removed by pretreatment pretreatment
Packaging causes abrasion to powder coat surface Use suitable packaging/foils to wrap work pieces (tissue paper,
bubble wrap, foam, fleece)
Powder coating scratches too easily/too soft Select suitable powder coating for purpose
Consult powder manufacturer
Abrasion during further mechanical treatments (profiles) Carefully handle work piece in further manufacturing steps
Chafing of carpet material in carpet systems Use suitable carpet or replace carpet
6.2 Poor Processing Characteristics (additional to section 2.1 to 2.6)
Problem:
Continuously or suddenly deteriorating application while processing parameters are unchanged
Possible causes Corrections, testing, procedures
A change in particle size distribution due to reclaim, powder too Continuously add virgin powder and ensure proper ratio of virgin
fine to reclaim powder ( max. 1:1)
Reduce over spray
Change rack configuration
Introduce reclaimed powder continuously
6.3 Continuous Shade Variations
Problem:
Continuous or sudden changes in color/shade or effect compared to sample or originally coated parts
Possible causes Corrections, testing, procedures
Separation or particle size distribution changes through reclaim Add virgin powder
Detraction due to several booths being located next to each other Reconstruct coating area layout
Cover booth during downtime, since powder or dirt may transfer
and contaminate area
Powder transfer due to uneven air flow or performance of booths Reconstruct/reconfigure area
next to each other
With powder extraction from box feeder no even ratio of reclaim Use fluid container
and virgin powder is next to each other Ensure even ratio of virgin to reclaim powder
Addition of reclaim powder is inconsistent, virgin powder ratio is Add sufficient virgin powder Ensure consistent ratio
too high or too low
7. Special Characteristics of Application of Metallic Powders
7.1 Color shift from color chart or original sample
Possible causes Corrections, testing, procedures
Inconsistent batches Coat each job with powder from a single batch
Consult powder manufacturer
Varying application (Corona, Tribo, Corona modified with ion Use only one type of application equipment
catch) Consult with powder manufacturer
Object related coating jobs With several applicators for one coating job, colors and systems
have to be checked against each other. Use original samples, and
warn customers of risks involved
Differing work pieces For comparison always use a single work piece with its particular
substrate color (aluminum, steel, zinc plated steel, glass, wood)
Wrong RAL chart used or effect difference between RAL chart Use proper RAL chart (GL or HR), inform customer
and powder coating
Varying application methods (Corona, Corona modified with ion Adjust KV setting and gun-to-part distance: the higher the KV
catcher or Tribo) and inappropriate gun settings setting, the lesser the metallic appearance; the lower the KV
setting, the more metallic effect will appear
Varying deposition of effect pigments gives rise to color/effect Use one suitable application method
changes
Batch change during coating job Use only one batch for each coating job
Color change between manual and automatic application Touch-up difficult to spray areas before automatic application
Extremely varying film thickness (especially with matte coatings) Optimize film thickness