Open BIM Protocol: Promoting Coordination Using IFC Models

Open BIM protocol
Promoting coordination using IFC models
Version: 2.0
Disclaimer
All rights reserved. Nothing from this publication may be copied or published through print, photocopies, DVDs,
internet pages or any other way without prior consent in writing from Data Design System. The Open BIM
protocol is continuously being developed and updated. Therefore rights cannot be derived from this publication.
Content
Introduction.................................................................................................................................................................................................. 1
What information is required for cooperation and coordination? .......................................................................................... 2
What model information is important for DDS-CAD?.................................................................................................................. 3
Which information can be exported from DDS-CAD? .................................................................................................................. 5
What is Open BIM? .................................................................................................................................................................................... 7
Checklist Open BIM protocol ............................................................................................................................................................... 10
Links.............................................................................................................................................................................................................. 13
Questions and contact .......................................................................................................................................................................... 14

Open BIM Protocol - Version 2.0
Introduction
This document describes the specification of an Open BIM model, promoting the coordination between
different BIM software solutions. This document is aimed on the exchange between DDS-CAD and architectural
and structural software solutions.
This document is not a comprehensive Open BIM manual. Also, it is not a manual of how to export models from
different software solutions.
An Open BIM project protocol is not a static document. Each project is different in both design and build. As a
result, no static Open BIM protocol is included in this document. A 'Checklist Open BIM protocol' is added at the
end of this document. This checklist can be used for a project’s kick off meeting and provides a basis for the
project specific Open BIM protocol.
During the publication of this document, the ‘IFC2x Edition 3 Technical Corrigendum 1’ is applied.
Page 1
What information is required for cooperation and coordination?

When Open BIM is used for coordination of multiple models (architectural, structural and building services), all
models should have the same structure.
Basic structure
It is mandated that the following points are identical for each IFC model within a project:
 IfcSite: The location of the project site.

 IfcBuilding: The location of the building on the project site.
 IfcStorey: The storey structure (number of storeys and storey height).
When these points are not identical, or one of these points is missing in one of the IFC models, the coordination
between models will be difficult, if not, impossible. The models will not have the same origin or rotation.
Editing the storey structure in an exported IFC model is complex. It is recommended not to edit the IfcSite,
IfcBuilding and IfcStorey during a project. Incase this is required, all participants involved in the project should
be informed about these changes in order to keep the cooperation and coordination intact.
Relations
Within IFC models, all objects are related. The IfcBuilding is related to the IfcSite, the IfcStorey is related to the
IfcBuilding, etc. It is important that these relations are correct within an IFC model. A wall that belongs to the
third storey should have a relation to that exact storey. A window should be related to an opening, which in its
turn is related to the wall in which it is inserted.
It is possible to place objects within an IFC model on the 'correct' place by coordinates, which make it seem like
the object is at the correct position, despite it having a relation to another object on a different storey. When
such a model is used in the design process, the wrong relations will disturb the process.
Additional
Following points promote the cooperation and re-use of information:
 All information is defined with the correct IfcType and IfcSubType. For example: a window is defined as
IfcWindow, and not as a transparent wall (IfcWall).
 Only when there is no IfcType available, or when objects do not have to be re-used (design objects, furniture,
terrain decor), objects can be exported as IfcProxyElements. There is however an IfcType for furniture and
many other types. A 'perfect' IFC model will not contain IfcProxyElements.
Page 2
What model information is important for DDS-CAD?

Depending on the project goal and expected end result in DDS-CAD, the following model information is
important:
Coordination
The most common use of Open BIM is coordination. In this context, coordination means the alignment of the
architectural, structural and building services design. By applying coordination according to the Open BIM
method, possible issues in the alignment (clashes) can be identified and solved at an early state. To achieve this,
only the geometrical information is required. When the geometry in the IFC models is correct, there are no
additional requirements.
A pitfall for coordination, especially at the early design stage, is the amount and detail of the information within
the model. Too detailed information too early in the process more often results in a false sense of certainty than
in actual improved coordination. One example is the use of manufacturer specific content in the early design
state.
Calculations on a building level

The air flow requirements calculation in DDS-CAD is based on spatial information (i.e. rooms). To re-use
information from the IFC model, it is required that the architectural model contains IfcSpace.
The IfcSpace should be modeled on the correct storey and should not overlap. A zone should not be exported as
IfcSpace (but as IfcZone). An IfcSpace should be modeled from the top of the slab up to the bottom of the next
slab and should not overlap with walls.
The heat load calculation is not only based upon rooms, but also on walls, floors, roofs, windows and doors. To
re-use the IFC model for a heat load calculation, all these objects should be defined correctly in the IFC model.
This means, for example, that a door is an IfcDoor, and not an IfcWindow.
Besides that, all relations between objects should be correct. In particular for windows and doors, which both
should be related to an IfcOpening, which in its turn should be related to an IfcWallStandardCase. Only in this
situation will DDS-CAD import the model with correct relations.
There is no parameter for heat transfer coefficient (U value) in IFC2x3. Therefore it is not possible to exchange
this value via the IFC model. It is always possible to add these values to building components in DDS-CAD.
Information management on a room level

In DDS-CAD, it is possible to sort and export information on a room level. To do so, the IFC model should contain
IfcSpace.
Opening elements
The ‘Opening Element’ function in DDS-CAD allows you to create openings in walls, floors, ceilings and roofs. To
perform this function and re-use of information from the IFC model, the model should contain correctly defined
walls, floors, ceilings and roofs.
Page 3
Additional notes
Storey structure
When the storey structure of the architectural IFC model is not (fully) correct, it is possible to adjust and
complete this in DDS-CAD. This is not improving the coordination and collaboration of a project. At first, it is
important to exchange correct IFC models. When this is not possible, adjusting and completing this information
can be useful to continue with the project.
Wall construction
DDS-CAD is capable of importing and converting IfcWallStandardCase to DDS-CAD native walls, which can be
used for specific calculations. In case the IFC model contains IfcWall, DDS-CAD will show the information in the
project, but will not convert these IfcWall to DDS-CAD native walls. Therefore, an IFC model with IfcWall can
only be used for coordination within DDS-CAD.
Rooms
DDS-CAD is capable of importing and converting IfcSpaces to DDS-CAD native rooms, which can be used for
specific calculations. This applies for 'extrusions' (floor surface with height). When the rooms are modeled as
'Boundary representations', DDS-CAD will import the footprint of those rooms, and stretch the rooms to the
storey height.
Insertion point and rotation of objects
It is important that the insertion point and rotation of objects are correct in the IFC model to show the hinges
of windows and doors on the correct side. The following link explains the correct definition. If this is not defined
correctly, it is possible that different software solutions will show the hinges or opening direction on a different
side.
Project structure
A DDS-CAD project consists of one building. When the architectural or structural IFC model consists of multiple
IfcBuilding, it is necessary to create a separate DDS-CAD project for each IfcBuilding. An example of this is a
block of apartment towers, sharing an underground parking garage and where each tower has a different base
height.
Within DDS-CAD, it is possible to export the model to IFC for each project. After that, the IFC models can be
combined into one model. Therefore, the use of multiple IfcBuilding will not result in any limitations.
IFC models that differ from the structure as described above, can still be used as a basis for a project. Wrong or
missing information can be supplemented in DDS-CAD. For example missing rooms, windows or doors can
simply be modeled in DDS-CAD.
For example, if an IFC model has a wrong origin or rotation, it is not possible to adjust this in most cases.
According to the standard, all objects should have a similar reference in the IFC model. Most models do not
comply with this. When a model does not comply with this, changing the origin or rotation will not result in a
similar rotation or movement for all objects within that model.
Page 4
Which information can be exported from DDS-CAD?

In DDS-CAD, the imported IFC model is used as a reference to export an IFC model. That means, that the origin,
for both the site as the building, the rotation, the storey structure and the relations are automatically linked to
the imported IFC model. No additional settings are needed for this.
When there are multiple imported IFC models in DDS-CAD, one model is assigned as master. The settings of this
models are used for the export.
By default, DDS-CAD exports to IFC2x3, coordination view 2.0.
It is possible to influence the export to an IFC model, depending on the goal of the project.
Settings per discipline
It is possible to change the export settings, per discipline, for the IFC export. This can be by changing the
exchange requirements, as following:
Discipline Setting Description
All Export 2D geometry Export of 2D geometry (for example 2D geometry of sockets)
All Export 3D geometry Export of 3D geometry
All Use extruded circle Handling of circles in the export of geometry. Not every viewer
can show geometry in the correct way. This can be solved by
changing this setting.
All Export objects that do Export of objects which are not classified. These objects will be
not belong in any exported as Proxy Elements.
discipline
All Export color information Export of pen settings to the IFC model.
All Keep imported IFC file as Combining the original (imported) IFC model with the export
original model.
All Reuse representations Reuse of representations, also known as blocking. When, for
example, a light fixture is used several times, it is possible to only
export the geometry once, on several locations. This makes the
model smaller. When external symbols (DWG and/or 3DS) are
used, it could happen the scaling is not handled correct in the
export. If that happens, this setting can be turned off.
All Export bounding box Export of the needed space of objects, by generating a cuboid
around each object.
All Export annotations Export of object text, free text, dimension lines and markers. Net
every viewer can show this information.
All Export quantities Export of part list.
Page 5
All Export Light information Export of information from the calculated light fixtures.
All Export document Export of external references from products (links, documents
references and/or pictures).
All Export Pset_DDS Export of all product parameters and calculated parameters of
the modeled products to IFC, classified as DDS property set.
Building Export Zones Export of zones in the building model.
Building Export Spaces Export of spaces in the building model.
Building Export provision for void Export provision for void as objects.
Building Export provisions for Export provision for void as openings, not as (filled) objects.
void as opening
elements
Building Export 1st Level Space Export of space boundaries, without dividing the boundaries
Boundaries according the heat load calculation.
Building Export 2nd Level Space Export of space boundaries, with dividing the boundaries to 2nd
Boundaries level space boundaries, according the heat load calculation.
Building Do not export geometry Export additional geometry on building elements.

on building elements
Electrical Export Export of an additional property set for the cost calculation of the
Pset_ElectricalCostData electrical building services.
Ventilation Export MEPPortDuct Export of intelligent connection points for ducts.
Classification
It is possible to classify all objects exported to the IFC model. By default, all building services are exported with
the ISO 12006-2 Omniclass classification. It is possible to create, edit and manage these classification in DDS-
CAD.
LOD
LOD stands for Level of Detail. This means the level of detail of an IFC model. There is no norm or standard that
describes the LOD. A good reference can be shown on the following link. An important nuance is that it is not
needed to export the entire model on one LOD. Per discipline, and even per object, the LOD can be set and
managed.
By default, DDS-CAD is delivered with a generic database. When an IFC model is exported from DDS-CAD, the
LOD is, by default, LOD 300. By adding the product database with manufacturer specific information, it is
possible to manually update this towards LOD 500.
Page 6
What is Open BIM?

Open standard
Open BIM consists of 'Open' and BIM. BIM stands for Building Information Model, an intelligent model for
building information. In many cases its meaning is limited to a 3D model. A model without geometry can also
be a BIM model. The most important part is the information. All objects in the model contain specific properties
and relations to other objects. An Open BIM model can contain information from building objects, structural
objects and building services, in one or multiple models.
Open stands for open file format. This means that the file format is based upon an open standard, which can be
implemented in all software solutions.
IFC
The Open BIM file format is IFC (Industry Foundation Classes), developed and maintained by buildingSMART. IFC
is normalized in the ISO 16739, for long term maintenance and support.
Current used version is IFC2x3, Coordination View 2.0 [2.0].
IFC2x4 (IFC4), IFC schema and IFC product library are not generally supported and are not part of this protocol.
Certification
It is possible to certify software solutions for the import and export of IFC models. A list of certified software
solutions can be found on the website of buildingSMART.
The certification is split in architectural, structural and building services, import and export.
Certified software does not directly guarantee a good import and export of IFC models. At first, it is not necessary
to achieve a 100% test score to be certified. Secondly it is possible to exclude parts for certification. Besides that,
many software solutions offer a lot of settings, which makes it necessary to have deep knowledge about IFC and
the software to achieve an excellent export result.
Model viewers
Most software companies that offer BIM software solutions, also offer a viewer for IFC models. These viewers
can be used for both viewing and checking models. Examples are BIM+, Solibri Model Viewer, Tekla BIMsight,
DDS-CAD Viewer and FZK Viewer. There are many other viewers available. Each viewer has its own advantages
and disadvantages.
Model checkers
Model checkers are available for advanced clash detection, rule checking and data management. Examples of
model checkers are Navisworks and Solibri Model Checker.
IFC model
Following a short description of an IFC model.
Layout
Conform the standard, an IFC model has a standard structure. The image on the next page, taken from the DDS-
CAD Viewer, shows an IFC model.
Page 7
Image 1: IFC file browser in the DDS-CAD Viewer
Explanation:
 Each IFC-model contains a project. It is the first line in the image above, with the name ‘Hybrid BIM
buidling_TOT_AC_v1’.
 An IFC model can have multiple context models. They provide the possibility to change the view and contain
the grid, 2D information, annotations and bounding boxes. Not every model has context models and not
every viewer shows these context models. In the image above, the context models are recognizable by the
capital C.
 Below the context models is the IfcSite. The IfcSite contains the location of the project (not the building). It
contains the geographical reference point (location based upon longitude, latitude and altitude). A project
contains only one IfcSite.
 Below the IfcSite is the IfcBuilding. Multiple buildings can be combined in one IFC model, in that case there
are multiple buildings in the IFC file browser. This can be useful in case of multiple towers with different
base height sharing a parking garage.
 The IfcBuilding contains the building storeys that belong to that building. According to the IFC standard,
each floor level is an IfcStorey, not considering stairs and landings. For example, a suspended ceiling is not
an IfcStorey.
Page 8
IfcType
Below a listing of the most common IfcType or the IfcType that are required for cooperation and coordination.
 IfcSpace: Rooms
 IfcWall: Walls
 IfcWallStandardCase: Simplified walls, without layers
 IfcColumn: Structural column
 IfcCovering: Suspended ceiling
 IfcBeam: Structural steel column
 IfcSlab: Structural floor
 IfcOpeningElement: Opening in wall, floor or roof
 IfcWindow: Window
 IfcDoor: Door
 IfcFlowelement: Building services object
 IfcBuildingElementProxy: Undefined object
There are many more IfcType; each IfcType containing multiple IfcSubType. A complete list is available on
http://www.buildingsmart-tech.org.
The next image, from the DDS-CAD Viewer, shows the different IfcType from a specific model:
Image 2 : IFC file object types browser from the DDS-CAD Viewer
Page 9
Checklist Open BIM protocol

Below you can find two checklists for IFC models: one for a received IFC model and one for sending an IFC model.
Both checklists can also be used as input for an Open BIM protocol. Using this at the start of a project, the project
goal and the level of detail for both the incoming as outgoing information can be set.
Checklist incoming IFC model

The following checklist can be used for checking IFC models, before using it within a project. Depending on the
goal of the project, parts of the checklist can be applied or excluded.
General
The goal of the project and models is clear, the expected result of the cooperation and
coordination of the models are defined.
The model has the extension IFC or IFCzip. The model is not optimized with, for example, Solibri
IFC Optimizer.
Coordination
The IFC model contains a project, a site (IfcSite), building (IfcBuilding) and at least one storey
(IfcStorey).
The origin, altitude and rotation of the site is correct.
The origin, altitude and rotation of the building is correct.
The insertion point and height of the storey(s) is correct.
Each floor level is an IfcStorey.
The storey structure and height of all models within the project are identical.
The insertion point of all windows and doors is correct, which results in a correct hinge
placement and opening direction.
Information management on a room level
The model contains rooms (IfcSpace).
Rooms are related to the correct storey and do not cross multiple storeys.
Rooms do not overlap. Zones are defined as IfcZone, and not as IfcSpace.
Opening elements
Walls are defined as IfcWallStandardCase.
Floors are defined as IfcSlab.
Roofs are defined as IfcSlab or IfcRoof.
Calculations on a building level

Walls are defined as IfcWallStandardCase.
Walls are divided per storey and related to the correct storey.
Windows are defined as IfcWindow.
Page 10
Windows are related to an opening (IfcOpening).
Doors are defined as IfcDoor.
Doors are related to an opening.
Openings are related to the walls.
The model contains rooms.
Rooms are related to the correct storey and do not cross multiple storeys.
Rooms do not overlap. Zones are defined as IfcZone, and not as IfcSpace.
Columns are defined as IfcColumn.
Columns are divided per storey (and do not cross multiple storeys).
Floors are defined as IfcSlab.
Roofs are defined as IfcSlab or IfcRoof.
The model does not contain IfcProxyElement.
Checklist outgoing IFC model

The following checklist can be used for checking the IFC model that is exported from DDS-CAD, before sharing
the model. Depending of the goal of the project, parts of the checklist can be applied or excluded.
General
The origin, height and the rotation of the building services model is equal to the architectural
and structural model.
No elements are classified as IfcProxyElement.
The external references of products (links, documents and/or pictures) are exported.
Building / provision for void

Provisions for voids are exported as openings or as filled objects.
The correct 2D and/or 3D information is exported.
The annotations are exported.
The spaces are exported.
The zones are exported.
The space boundaries, not divided according to the heat load calculation, are exported.
The space boundaries, divided according to the heat load calculation (2nd level space
boundaries), are exported.
Electrical
Page 11
The additional property set is exported.
Sanitary & Heating

Ventilation
Page 12
Links
http://buildingsmart.org/
http://www.buildingsmart-tech.org/
http://www.buildingsmart-tech.org/ifc/IFC2x3/TC1/html/
http://bimforum.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/2013-LOD-Specification.pdf
Page 13
Questions and contact

Do you have questions about this document, the Open BIM protocol or the checklist? Or about BIM, design
software, etc. in general? Do not hesitate to contact us via our contact details below. We will be happy to support
you.
Data Design System

Rijnzathe 48
3454 PV Utrecht
T +31 30 341 00 70
W www.dds-cad.com
E [email protected]
Page 14

Open BIM Protocol: Promoting Coordination Using IFC Models

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Open BIM Protocol: Promoting Coordination Using IFC Models

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Open BIM Protocol: Promoting Coordination Using IFC Models

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Open BIM protocol

Promoting coordination using IFC models

What information is required for cooperation and coordination? .......................................................................................... 2

What model information is important for DDS-CAD?.................................................................................................................. 3

Which information can be exported from DDS-CAD? .................................................................................................................. 5

What is Open BIM? .................................................................................................................................................................................... 7

Checklist Open BIM protocol ............................................................................................................................................................... 10

Questions and contact .......................................................................................................................................................................... 14

What information is required for cooperation and coordination?

 IfcSite: The location of the project site.

What model information is important for DDS-CAD?

Calculations on a building level

Information management on a room level

Insertion point and rotation of objects

Which information can be exported from DDS-CAD?

By default, DDS-CAD exports to IFC2x3, coordination view 2.0.

Settings per discipline

Discipline Setting Description

All Export 2D geometry Export of 2D geometry (for example 2D geometry of sockets)

All Export 3D geometry Export of 3D geometry

All Export quantities Export of part list.

Building Export Zones Export of zones in the building model.

Building Export Spaces Export of spaces in the building model.

Building Do not export geometry Export additional geometry on building elements.

Ventilation Export MEPPortDuct Export of intelligent connection points for ducts.

What is Open BIM?

Current used version is IFC2x3, Coordination View 2.0 [2.0].

Following a short description of an IFC model.

Image 1: IFC file browser in the DDS-CAD Viewer

Checklist Open BIM protocol

Checklist incoming IFC model

The origin, altitude and rotation of the building is correct.

The insertion point and height of the storey(s) is correct.

Each floor level is an IfcStorey.

Floors are defined as IfcSlab.

Roofs are defined as IfcSlab or IfcRoof.

Calculations on a building level

Windows are defined as IfcWindow.

Windows are related to an opening (IfcOpening).

Doors are defined as IfcDoor.

Doors are related to an opening.

Openings are related to the walls.

The model contains rooms.

Columns are defined as IfcColumn.

Floors are defined as IfcSlab.

Roofs are defined as IfcSlab or IfcRoof.

The model does not contain IfcProxyElement.

Checklist outgoing IFC model

Building / provision for void

The correct 2D and/or 3D information is exported.

The annotations are exported.

The spaces are exported.

The zones are exported.

The annotations are exported.

The additional property set is exported.

Sanitary & Heating

The annotations are exported.

The additional property set is exported.

The annotations are exported.