Sustainability of Tourism in India: Perception of Tourists On Delhi Tourism
Sustainability of Tourism in India: Perception of Tourists On Delhi Tourism
Sustainability of Tourism in India: Perception of Tourists On Delhi Tourism
Abstract - This research paper attempts to examine the impact of tourism on economy, environment, and socio-
cultural aspects of Delhi and explores how Delhi incorporated sustainable tourism development as the core mission to
achieve economic, environmental, and socio-cultural development of tourist destinations. This research paper also
examines the environmental, economic, and socio-cultural sustainability of tourism development in Delhi. A primary
research was conducted at various tourist destination in Delhi for evaluating the sustainability of tourism through the
questionnaire survey. A data set consisting of 141 responses were generated. The factor analysis provides rare insights
on the factors, which lead to sustainability of tourist destinations in Delhi. Research findings establish that the resource
management, pressure on resources, local empowerment, environmental management, socio-cultural unsustainability,
tourism governance, destination management, sustainable tourism promotion, local community participation and anti-
social activities are the important factors, which affects the sustainability of tourist destinations in Delhi. As this
research paper provides comprehensive and scientific evidences about the environmental, economic, and socio-cultural
impacts of tourism development in Delhi, the research findings can guide the government agencies, tourism operators,
hotels and restaurants, and NGOs while formulating and implementing tourism policies.
Managed Tourist Destinations: Effective planning Waste Management: Waste disposal and recycling is
and management of tourist destinations including effectively managed in the destinations.
temples, churches and mosques, national parks, Environmental Education: Government promotes
wildlife, sanctuaries, coastal zones and natural environmental education.
heritage sites. Energy Conservation: Government encourages
Positive Behaviour of Officials: Tourism officials sustainable consumption of conventional and
maintain friendly attitude and positive behaviour renewable energy.
towards tourists. Local Community Management of Environment:
Local community Engagement: Local community is Active contribution of local community in the
consulted and engaged in the formulation and environmental management.
implementation of the tourism plans and policies.
Socio-cultural Sustainability: In order to examine the
Tourists Follow Sustainable Tourism Practices:
social-cultural sustainability of destinations in Delhi this
Tourists follow sustainable tourism practices.
paper has identified 8 variables.
Economic Sustainability: This research has identified 5
Preserve Social Heritages: Tourism preserves and
variables to examine the economic sustainability tourism
promotes the social heritages such as historical
development in Delhi.
monuments, museums, churches, temples and
High Inflation: Tourism inflates general prices of
mosques.
goods and services, housing and properties.
Promote Festivals and Folklores: Tourism protects
Employment Generation: Tourism increases
and revives local festivals and folklores.
employment opportunities.
Commercialisation of Culture: Tourism
Prefer Locally Made Products: Tourists prefer
development leads to commercialization of culture.
locally made products to imported products.
Cultural Clashes: Tourism leads to cultural clashes
Poverty Reduction: Tourism reduces poverty and
between tourists and local community.
improves standard of living.
Anti-social Activities: Tourism leads to anti-social
Trained Guides: Guides and tour operators are
activities such as drugs, prostitution, alcoholism,
properly trained and skilled.
gambling and other criminal activities.
Environmental Sustainability: We have identified 15 Loss of Habitat: Loss of habitat to local community
variables for examining the environmental sustainability of due to tourism development in destinations.
tourist destinations in Delhi. Bad Influence on Children: Tourism has bad
influence on children and juvenile.
Pressure on Water: Tourism puts pressure on water
resources. 2.4 Methods of Examination
Pressure on Air: tourism puts pressure on quality of
The factor analysis is utilised for examining the
air.
sustainability of tourism development in Delhi and
Pressure on Land: Tourism puts pressure on land.
identifying the factors, which influence the economic,
Pressure on Transportation: Tourism increases environmental and social-cultural sustainability of Delhi.
pressure on transportation infrastructure.
Pressure on Natural Vegetation and Wildlife: III. DATA ANALYSIS
Tourism puts pressure on natural vegetation and
3.1 Factor Analysis
wildlife.
Waste Generation: Tourism generates huge amount The main objective of the research is to examine the
of waste in the destinations. sustainability of tourism development in Delhi and
Water Management: Effective and efficient identifying the synergies between environmental, economic
management to mitigate pressure on water resources. and socio-cultural sustainability in the development
Mechanism to Reduce Air Pollution: Proper paradigm of Delhi by using factor analysis. The factor
Mechanism to Mitigate the Air Pollution. analysis is a data reduction method, which reduces a set of
Land Management: Effective and efficient variables to a limited number of principal components,
management to reduce the pressure on land. which underlines the correlation between the original
variables. It explores and explains the magnitude and
Transportation Management: Effective and
pattern of the correlation that exist within the set of
efficient management to mitigate pressure on
observed values by identifying variables and factors that
transportation.
influence those values. For examining the economic,
Management of Natural Vegetation and Wildlife:
environmental and socio-cultural sustainability of tourism
Effective and efficient mechanism to reduce pressure
destinations, we have used multidimensional statistical
on natural vegetation and wildlife.
analysis, called factor analysis based on the principal Bartlett's Test of Sphericity D.F 630
component analysis (PCA).
Sig. .000
Data Structure Analysis: The suitability of data for factor
analysis is examined by applying Keiser-Myer-Olkin test Source: SPSS output from primary survey
and Bartlett Test of Sphericity. Keiser-Myer-Olkin test
From the table above Table 4.1 the Bartlett test of
measures sampling adequacy and Bartlett’s test of
Sphericity is significant (Chi-square = 2194.44, p<0.000).
Sphericity tests the data assumptions. In order to be
The Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin (KMO) overall measure of
suitable for factor analysis, a data set must have a Kaiser-
sampling is 0.690, which indicates that data are suitable for
Meyer-Olkin value between 0.5 and 1.0 and Bartlett’s test
the principal component analysis. The values from Kaiser-
of Sphericity must be statistically significant at p<. 05.
Meyer-Olkin (KMO) measures above 0.60 is an adequate
Table 7.2 shows the results of sampling test and data indicator for performing factor analysis.
assumption from Bartlett test of Sphericity and Kaiser-
Table 7.3 and Figure 4.1 represent the results of factor
Meyer-Olkin (KMO).
analysis including the components, eigenvalues, and
Table 4.1: KMO and Bartlett’s Test percentage of variance, cumulative variance, and
Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling Adequacy
communalities for 36 variables after performing factor
.690
analysis using Principal Component Analysis (PCA).
Approx. Chi-Square
2194.44
contributes 5.820%, destination management explains 4.736%, sustainable tourism promotion shares 4.460%, local
community participation accounts 4.445% and anti-social activities represent 3.832% to the cumulative variance explained
(65.195%) by the model.
Table 4.3 shows the results of factor analysis with varimax rotation of ten factors generated from the factor analysis. The
principal factors with loading above 0.45 are shown in the table, which indicates strong significance of correlation exists
among the particular group of variables.
TABLE 4.3: ROTATED COMPONENT MATRIX
VARIABLE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
.90
Mechanism to Reduce Noise Pollution
9
.85
Mechanism to Reduce Water Pollution
5
.84
Mechanism to Reduce Air Pollution
8
.84
Mechanism to Reduce Pressure on Transportation
2
.68
Mechanism to Reduce Degradation of Natural Vegetation
9
.84
Pressure on Land
1
.83
Pressure on Water
1
.81
Pressure on Transportation
5
.81
Pressure on Air
4
.76
Pressure on Natural Vegetation
1
.83
Increase Employment
5
.75
Revives Socio-cultural Heritages
4
.70
Improve Standard of Living
4
.67
Revives Local Festivals
5
.53
Preference to Local Products
1
.72
Promotes Environmental Education
8
.66
Promotion of Renewable Energy
6
.59
Management of Waste
5
Local Community Contribution to Environmental .56
Management 6
.79
Cultural Clashes and Acculturation
1
.72
Commercialization of Culture
3
.61
Loss of Identity and Values
8
.81
Safety and Security
5
.60
Efficient Legal System
8
.50
Tourism Plans
6
.77
Officials Behaviour
0
.74
Emergency Mechanism
4
.73
Trained Guides
2
Tourists Follow Rules .72
6
.59
Behaviour of Local Community
2
.74
Bad Influence on Children
2
.50
Increases Anti-social Activities
4
Extraction Method: Principal Component Analysis.
Rotation Method: Varimax with Kaiser Normalisation.
Rotation Converged in 10 Iterations.
Source: SPSS output from primary survey
1 Resource Management: The factor analysis suggest that cultural heritages, improvement of standard of living,
the resource management is significant factor that revives local festivals and preference to locally made
contributes to the sustainability of tourism in Delhi. products are distinctive characteristics of Delhi Tourism.
Mechanism to reduce Noise Pollution (.909), mechanism to
4. Environmental Management: The environmental
reduce pressure on water (.855), mechanism to reduce Air
management is the fourth factor, which contributes to the
Pollution (.848), mechanism to reduce Pressure on
sustainability of tourism in Delhi. The Environmental
Transportation (.842) and mechanism to mitigate
management is composed of the variables such as promotes
Degradation of Natural Vegetation (.689) are the important
environmental education (.728), promotion of Renewable
variables that explain the sustainability of Delhi tourism.
energy (.666), waste management (.595) and local
The important disastrous impacts of tourism are water
community contribution to environmental management
pollution, air pollution, misuse of land, pressure on
(.566). These variables are the essential elements of
transportation and degradation of natural vegetation. Delhi
sustainable tourism, which have been given prominent place
tourism integrates the system of resource management for
in the tourism development of Delhi.
ensuring efficient and effective utilisation of resources by
installation of proper mechanism to mitigate the adverse 5. Socio-cultural Unsustainability: The Socio-cultural
impact of tourism on resources. Unsustainability is the fifth factor that influences the
sustainability of tourist destinations in Delhi. The socio-
2. Pressure on Resources: The second factor is termed as
cultural unsustainability consists of the adverse impacts of
resource pressure includes the pressure on water, air, land,
tourism on the socio-cultural environment of Delhi such as
transportation, and natural vegetation and wild life.
Cultural clashes (.791), Commercialisation of Culture
Although tourism development has brought huge benefits,
(.723), and Loss of Identity and Values (.618).
the negative impacts of tourism such as scarcity of water,
Indiscriminate tourism development is posing adverse
air pollution, misuse of land, traffic congestions have
impacts on society and culture of Delhi and appropriate
directly affected both the local communities and tourists.
measures have to be introduced for making tourism more
The high factor loadings on the such as the pressure on
socially sustainable.
Land Resources (.841), Water Resources (.831),
Transportation (.815) Air (.814) and Natural Vegetation 6. Tourism Governance: Tourism Governance is another
(.761) in the factor analysis reveals that the resource important factor that contributes to the sustainability of
utilisation in in Delhi is unsustainable and the negative tourism in Delhi. The Safety and security (.815), Efficient
impacts of tourism development is escalating and putting legal system (.608), Tourism Plans (.506) are the
tremendous pressure on both manmade and natural governance mechanism which enhances sustainability of
resources. tourism in Delhi. The safety and security provided by the
government at the tourist destinations, and meticulously
3. Local Empowerment: Local empowerment is another
formulated and implemented tourism plans and programmes
important factor, which ensures sustainability of Delhi
are contributing to the sustainable tourism development.
tourism. The local empowerment is reinforced by the
variables such as the Employment generation (.835), 7. Destination Management: Destination management is
Revives Socio-cultural Heritages (.754), improve standard next important factor, which draws millions of tourists
of living (.704), Revives local festivals (.675) and from across the world. The destination management
preference to locally made products (.531). The attributes such as positive attitude and friendly behaviour
Government has identified tourism as an engine of socio- of officials towards tourists (.770) and Emergency
economic development and introduced various plans and Mechanism (.774) are instrumental in promoting tourism in
programmes to eradicate poverty by strengthening economic Delhi sustainably.
relationship between the tourism industry and the local 8. Sustainable Tourism Promotion: The sustainable
community for marketing the produce made by the local tourism promotion is another important factor, which
communities. The employment generation, revival of socio- positively contributes to the sustainable tourism. The
sustainable tourism promotion is composed of the attributes [5] Hall, D., & Richards, G. (2003). Tourism and
such as Trained Guides (.732), Tourists Follow Sustainable Sustainable Community Development, Routledge,
Tourism Practices (.726). London and New York.
[6] Haseena V.A & Ajims P. Mohammed (2014).
9. Local Community Participation: The local community
Sustainable Tourism Strategy Development in Kerala
participation is an important factor in the sustainable
as a Tool of Growth, Asian Journal of Science and
destination management in Delhi. The local community
Technology, Vol.5, Issue 3, 192-197.
behaviour and attitude (.592) determine the popularity of
[7] Ministry of Tourism (2004). “India Tourism Statistics
Delhi as a tourist destination. The destinations are
2004”, Market Research Division New Delhi.
characterised by the positive and encouraging support by
[8] Mowforth, M., & Mount, I. (2003). Tourism and
the local people in the tourism development. As the local
Sustainability, New Tourism in the Third World,
community is aware about the economic, socio-cultural and
Taylor, & Francis e-Library, Routledge, USA and
environmental benefits of tourism, they play active role in
Canada.
the formulation and implementation of tourism plans and
[9] National Tourism Policy (2002). Government of India
policies.
(GOI), New Delhi.
10. Anti-social Activities: The factor analysis reveals that [10] Rajesh, K., & Ramakrishnan, K. (2009). Coastal
the antisocial activities are another major factor that Tourism in Kerala: Its impact on Economy and
influence the sustainability of tourism in Delhi. The Environment, Cochin University of Science and
variables such as Bad influence on children (.742) and Technology.
Increase in anti-social activities (.504) have brought about [11] Reddy, V. M., & Wilkes, K. (2013). Tourism, Climate
adverse impact on the society of Delhi. Change and Sustainability, Routledge.
[12] Sharpley, R. (2000). “Tourism and sustainable
IV. CONCLUSION
development: Exploring the theoretical divide”.
This research paper has identified Delhi as the heritage Journal of Sustainable Development, 8(1), 1-19.
tourism model, which represents Indian tourism, for [13] Sharpley, R. (2003). Tourism, Tourists, and Society,
examining the sustainability of tourism development in Elm Publications, Huntingdon.
India. A primary research was conducted to collect the [14] Solomon R. (2009). The Challenges and Prospects of
responses from tourists about their perceptions on the Tourism in Goa Today, Council for Social Justice and
sustainability of tourism in Delhi. The factor analysis was Peace, Goa, pp. 1-100.
used to study the perception of tourists on the tourism [15] Sreekumar, T. T., & Govindan P. (2002). Contentions
policy and governance, economic sustainability, socio- and Contradictions of Tourism as Development
cultural sustainability, and environmental sustainability of Option: the Case of Kerala, India, Third World
destinations. The factor analysis identified ten factors such Quarterly, (23) 3, pp. 529-548.
as resource management, pressure on resources, local [16] Swarkar, K., Naronia, L., Mascarenhas, A., &
empowerment, environmental management, socio-cultural Chauhan, O. S. (1998). Tourism and the environment:
unsustainability, tourism governance, destination Issues of Concerning the Coastal Zone of Goa, pp. 1-
management, sustainable tourism promotion, local 19.
community participation and anti-social activities, which [17]UNEP & UNWTO. (2005). Making Tourism More
influence the sustainability of tourism development in Sustainable, A Guide for Policy Makers,
Delhi. http://www.worldtoourism.org
[18] Wilson, D. (1997). Paradoxes of Tourism in Goa,
REFERENCES
Annals of Tourism Research, 21 (1), pp. 52-75.
[1] Brammer, N., & Beech, J. (2004). Use and Abuse of [19]World Commission on Environment and
Tourism: the Goan Experience, Tourism, Culture & Development. (1987). Report of the World
Communication, Vol. 5, pp. 23–35. Commission on Environment and Development: Our
[2] Department of Tourism, www.keralatourism.org Common Future. http://www.un-documents.net
[3] Gama, D. A., & Solomon, R. (2011). Reclaiming
Water Rights: Towards and Equitable Social Contract
in Goa, Water Equity in Tourism (WET) program,
Centre for Responsible Tourism, Goa and Tourism
Concern, UK., pp. 1-70.
[4] Ghosh, P. K., & Datta, B. (2012). Coastal Tourism and
Beach Sustainability-An Assessment of Community
Perceptions in Kovalam, India, Malaysia Journal of
Society and Space, 7, pp. 75-87.