Practices of Power System Management in India
Practices of Power System Management in India
Practices of Power System Management in India
J. Raja
P. Ajay-D-Vimal Raj
S. Rajasekar
Practices
in Power System
Management in
India
Power Systems
More information about this series at http://www.springer.com/series/4622
J. Raja P. Ajay-D-Vimal Raj
•
S. Rajasekar
123
J. Raja S. Rajasekar
Ministry of Power India Power Grid Corporation of India Limited
National Power Training Institute Gurgaon
Faridabad India
India
P. Ajay-D-Vimal Raj
Department of Electrical and Electronics
Engineering
Pondicherry Engineering College
Puducherry
India
This Springer imprint is published by the registered company Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd.
part of Springer Nature
The registered company address is: 152 Beach Road, #21-01/04 Gateway East, Singapore 189721,
Singapore
This book is dedicated to our parents and family members
and also
we wish to thank everyone who helped us to create this book.
Preface
This book is recommended for the director, chief engineer, chief accounts officer,
superintendent engineer, executive engineer, and assistant engineer who work in
Indian distribution companies (DISCOMs).
The book broadly covers the following subjects.
1. In 2008 the government of India announced the Restructured Accelerated Power
Development and Reforms Programme (R-APDRP) scheme, a revised version
of the Accelerated Power Development Reforms Programme (APDRP).
The APDRP scheme was initiated in 2002–2003 as additional central assistance to
states in reducing the aggregate technical and commercial (AT&C) losses in the
power sector. Aggregate technical and commercial loss captures the total loss in
the distribution network. Technical loss may be due to ill-maintained equipment,
substations, and inadequate investment in infrastructure whereas commercial loss
may be due to low metering efficiency, faulty meter reading, theft and pilferage,
and improving the quality and reliability of power supply. This was to be
achieved by strengthening and upgrading the subtransmission and distribution
system of high-density load centers such as towns and industrial centers.
Under this scheme Power Finance Corporation (PFC) & Ministry of Power,
India (MoP) shortlisted research institutes (RI), and RI published material based
on the above area but to date there have been no books covering the basic
concept, latest available technology, and practical aspects of operation and
maintenance scheduling. This book aims to cover both basics, the latest tech-
nology used for distribution and the practical aspects of the operation and
maintenance (O&M) of a distribution network. At the end of the book we
provide the O&M of all the distribution components with case studies.
2. The Central Electricity Authority of India (CEA) has issued a gazette notifica-
tion dated September 20th, 2010, whereby they have made it mandatory that all
personnel engaged in the O&M of a thermal plant, hydro plant, combined cycle
gas plant, transmission system, and subtransmission and distribution system
have to be given mandatory training covering the syllabus prescribed by them in
this notification.
vii
viii Preface
Presently no study material is available covering the full contents of the syl-
labus. In order to provide proper training for O&M personnel, it is essential that
good study material be available. This book aims to achieve this objective and to
meet the requirements of the CEA gazette notification for O&M of the distri-
bution line.
3. A new feature of this book covers the check list of distribution equipment for the
O&M of distribution particularly suitable for the Indian power market.
ix
Contents
xi
xii Contents
xvii
xviii List of Figures
xix
xx List of Tables
The Indian power sector has experienced substantial growth after Independence.
The total power generating capacity in India was 1.4 GW at the time of
Independence, and as of September 2016 the currently installed capacity was about
306.36 GW (306,360 MW) of which thermal power is 213.22 GW (69.60%), and
hydro power 43.11 GW (14.07%); RE power is 44.23 GW (14.44%) and the fastest
growing sector among all the sources of power and nuclear power is 5.8 GW
(1.89%). Currently, across the globe India has secured the third position in power
generation, fourth in consumption, and fifth for installation capacity. The Indian
power industry has had significant growth in electricity generation over the decades
to 1107.8 BU in 2016, and witnessed 5.6% growth over the previous financial year.
In order to ensure continuous power to all the people, the Indian government has
recently announced the launch of the “Power for All” scheme, which emphasizes
continuous electricity supply to all domestic industry establishments by building
and upgrading necessary infrastructure. Electricity generation was 1091 billion
KWh during the year 2015–2016 but had a shortage of 24 billion KWh (lack of
−2.1%) against the anticipated −2.2%. The peak load that was generated was
149 GW with a shortfall requirement of 5 GW (lack of −3.3%) against the antic-
ipated −2.7%. In the total world population, nearly 1.4 billon people have no access
to electricity, 300 million people of whom are in India. The IEA (International
Energy Agency) has found that India has the capacity of adding new generation
units of 600–200 GW by 2050. Please see Fig. 1.1. As of September 30th, 2016,
nearly 98.5% of 6.0 Lakh villages in India had electricity. However, the supply was
intermittent and unreliable in these villages. The Indian government launched Deen
Dayal Upadhyaya Gram Jyoti Yojana (DDUGJY) as one of its top programs in July
2015, which aims to provide electricity to all rural areas around the clock. They
place importance on restructurings and improvement of rural electrification,
transmission line strengthening, and the development of distribution systems [1, 2].
Fig. 1.1 Percentage of installed capacity for different sources of power (as of September 31st,
2016)
The first electricity-related legislation was the Indian Electricity Act which inter
alia dealt with the basic framework of India’s electricity supply, growth, and
licenses. However, after Independence, the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948 was
endorsed. This act has facilitated the mandate for establishment of state electricity
boards (SEBs) for overall electrification across the country. Furthermore, this 1948
act was amended at various stages [7].
The 1948 Electricity (Supply) Act permitted the formation of SEBs, and was
responsible for generation, and transmission & distribution (T & D) of power within the
state. Later the Central Electricity Authority (CEA) was established to administer the
planning and development of the power sector and guide SEBs. Electricity was placed
under the concurrent authority of central and state governments in the Indian constitution.
In 1975, revisions were made to enable the central government to set up and
maintain power plants. Consequently, the National Thermal Power Corporation
(NTPC) was formed which is the largest power generation company in India to date.
Subsequently, different power companies including NHPC (1975), NEEPCO (1976),
NPCIL (1987), and THDC (1988) were formed and owned by the central government
to deal with the generation of power mainly in the thermal, hydro, and nuclear sectors.
The summary of events is as follows.
• Year 1975: Incorporate provisions to enable generation in the central sector
(NTPC, NHPC, etc.). Incorporate provisions to facilitate state electricity boards
(SEBs) for earning minimum returns.
• Year 1991: Permit private sector participation in generation. Also formation of
regional load dispatch centers (RLDCs).
• Year 1998: Permit private sector participation in the transmission sector. Also
the establishment relating to State Transmission Utility (STU) and Central
Transmission Utility (CTU).
Apart from the above modifications in the earlier act, the major milestone was
the Electricity Regulatory Commission Act, 1998 which had significant facility for
setting up of a regulatory commission at central and state levels.
• In the power sector, the country was classified into five regions, namely: (i)
Northern Region (NR), (ii) Eastern Region (ER), (iii) Southern Region (SR),
(iv) Western Region (WR), and (v) North Eastern Region (NER). Each region
contains several states (or state utilities); for example: WR contains utilities of
Madhya Pradesh, Gujarat, Maharashtra, Chhattisgarh, Dadara and Nagar Haveli,
Goa, and so on.
(ii) TATA Power: The largest integrated power company in India is TATA
Power, with a substantial presence in the renewable energy sector. The
company owns more than half the private sector total power generation. It
had 10 GW generating capacities in fiscal year 2016. Over the next six
years the company plans 18 GW generation units and also wants to increase
its distribution network by 4 GW and energy sources by 25 million tons per
year.
(iii) Reliance Power: The company has about 35 GW of power capacity,
including operational (6 GW) and proposed.
(iv) CESC Limited: CESC Limited works in coal mining and generation, as
well as the distribution sector of the power system. With complete control
of three coal-based power plants together they generate 1.3 GW.
(v) NHPC: It is the biggest hydroelectric utility in India, with a production
capacity of 6.5 GW; it added 6.7 GW of power in 2017. NHPC is con-
structing nine projects, aggregating an installed capacity of 4.2 GW.
(vi) Power Finance Corporation Limited (PFC): PFC provides financial
support to power utility companies for their power project developments.
Their major services include assisting short-term loans, project-term loads,
financing, and consultancies.
(vii) Adani Power: The total power generation capacity of Adani Power in 2016
was 10.5 GW and by 2020 they plan to increase their generation capacity to
20 GW. Now they are one of the largest thermal power producers and their
thermal power plant in Mundra, Gujarat is considered the world’s largest
thermal power plant.
(viii) PGCIL: The Power Grid Corporation of India Limited is one of the world’s
largest transmission utility companies. They are accountable for planning
interstate transmission systems, co-ordination, and implementing new
transmission networks in India. In their twelfth five-year plan PGCIL aims
to build 72.25 GW capacity transmission networking; in 2016 their network
capacity was 47.45 GW.
(ix) DVC: Damodar Valley Corporation is responsible for developing the power
sector in irrigation and flood control systems.
(x) SJVNL: SJVNL is a joint venture between the government of India and the
government of Himachal Pradesh; their main focus is to develop hydro-
power generation in India. Now they are expanding their focus area on wind
power projects.
India is the third largest producer of electricity in the world. Generating capacity has
grown from 1.4 GW in 1947 to 306 GW in 2016 (Tables 1.1, 1.2, and 1.3). Overall
generation in India has increased from 301 billion units (BUs) during 1992–1993 to
1107.8 BUs in 2015–2016. The country saw 5.64% growth over the year 2015–2016.
1.3 The Growth Story of the Indian Power Sector 5
During fiscal years 2010–2016, India’s electricity generation grew at the compound
annual growth rate (CAGR) of 6.21%. The twelfth five-year plan predicts a domestic
energy generation of 669.6 MTOE (million tons of oil equivalent) rise to 844 MTOE
by the year 2021–2022.
6 1 Overview of Power Sector Scenario in India
During Independence more than 80% of the population lived in rural India. Actual
development of the country can only be possible with the development of the rural
sector. The government has introduced various plans to improve the standard of
living in villages with the focus on rural electrification (Table 1.4). As of September
30th, 2016, nearly 98.5% of 6.0 Lakh villages in India were electrified.
During the early years after Independence, India’s electricity generation was very
low compared to other developed nations. But after 1990, faster growth was
recorded in the electricity generation sector. For example, electricity generation
increased from 179 to 1279 TW-hr in 1985 and 2015, respectively. The contri-
bution of coal-fired plants and nonconventional energy sources are major compo-
nents of the total energy generation growth; however, the contribution of fossil fuels
and hydro has significantly decreased in the period 2011–2016. During the fiscal
year 2016–2017, India has as its target the generatation of 1173 billion kWh which
excludes all types of renewables, compared to the equivalent generation of 1.1
thousand billion kWh.
8 1 Overview of Power Sector Scenario in India
In India coal power contributes about 70% of the total electricity produced in the
country. The Indian government has mandated the use of coal with ash content less
than 34% in plants near urban and biologically sensitive areas. For this reason, the
coal support industry has grown significantly, with a current capacity of 90 MT. As
per the latest emission norms the investment of INR 12.5 million per MW is
required for installation of pollution control devices in a thermal power plant.
Coal Supply Constraint
Indian coal reserves have low carbon content, low calorific value, and negligible
toxic traces. The natural fuel value of Indian coal is very poor and consumes about
700 gms of coal per p1 kWh with a gross calorific value (GCV) of 4550 kcal/kg,
but the quality of coal from other parts of the world is much better. The Indian
thermal power plant sector imports nearly 95 metric ton of high steam-grade coal
which contributes nearly 29% of the cumulative consumption in India to meet the
demand in steel production and other thermal power plants.
Oil and Gas
The policy debate for oil and gas is usually made jointly due to various
co-relationships such as the carbon-to-heat ratio content and the easy, low cost
accessibility of gas. At present the global shares of oil and gas contributing to
energy consumption are 31 and 22%, respectively; per the IEA’s prediction they
would be 25% by 2035. Oil share demand is slowly coming down whereas gas
demand is increasing. Meanwhile in 2016, the global LNG has been dipping rad-
ically because of excess production but the landed costs are inexpensive for
coal-based electricity generation, due to the lack of adequate degasification capacity
of LNG.
Changing Old Thermal Power Plants
Most of the thermal power plants existing in India are inefficient and need to adapt
the latest technology in order to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Each of the
existing thermal power plants in India emits nearly 50–120% higher pollutants as
compared to thermal plants existing in developed countries. To reduce higher
emissions the Indian government invested nearly 70,000 crore to shut down nearly
11 GW existing facilities and replace them with the latest supercritical technology
totaling more than 20 GW. Furthermore, over 100 outdated plants will be replaced
by 30 supercritical plants of 660 MW to 800 MW, thus saving Rs. 40,000 crore.
promoting the use of RE energies; also the recent maturity of RE technologies and
cost reduction motivates RE adoption at a faster pace. By 2022 a renewable energy
system addition in the power system network is targeted at 175 GW and in 2040 it
is likely to be 624–850 GW. This will translate into 50–60% installed capacity and
31–41% RE generation by 2030, in place of 13 and 7%, respectively, in 2014–
2015.
1.6.3 Hydro
In 1898 and 1902 at Darjeeling and Shivana samudra some hydropower plants were
established. India is blessed with hydro potential of about 84,000 MW at 60% load
factor. Further to this, 6740 MW from small, mini, and micro schemes have been
estimated and 94 GW capacities and 56 sites for pumped storage schemes have
been identified.
Up until April 2016, India had 5.78 GW; in other words 1.91% of total power
generation capacity and an ambitious plan is underway to ramp up this source by
2022 with six reactors under construction having a cumulative capacity of
4300 MWe, and six more planned with a capacity of 4800 MWe. Once the above
capacities are realized, India’s installed capacity for nuclear power is likely to go up
substantially. Additionally, seven sites have received in principle approval for
building new reactors. The above capacity enhancement agenda will give a solid
foundation to this sustainable source of electricity in India’s power development.
The planning of the transmission system in India is linked with new generation
projects as part of the evacuation system. The central sector generators such as
NTPC and NHPC built their own transmission networks for the transmission of
power to different parts of India. Later, the government integrated the central and
state transmission systems and formed a national power grid to facilitate trans-
mission of central sector power generation. These efforts led to the incorporation of
a separate entity known as the National Power Transmission Corporation in 1989
which was later renamed POWERGRID. This new company POWERGRID was
born with the amalgamation of total transmission assets and personnel of various
generating companies including NTPC, NHPC, NJPC, NEEPCO, NLC, and
THDC. Thus, with this a new era began where a separate company, POWERGRID,
started its business of interstate transmission of power by the central sector power
generating companies. Please see Fig. 1.2.
The central sector transmission system was separated from generation as an
outcome of power sector reforms and a strong central transmission network of
96,000 circuit kms with around 160 substations (EHVAC/HVDC) having a con-
version capacity of 138,673 MVA and interregional power transfer capacity of
28,000 MW was created within a span of two decades by POWERGRID which is
also discharging its role as a central transmission utility (CTU).
The CTU is essential in interstate transmission network planning, co-ordination,
and expansion at the local as well as national level. Eleven high-capacity trans-
mission corridors mainly comprising state-of-the-art 765 DC and ±800 kV
6000 MW have been developed in the national grid to enhance transmission line
capacity to facilitate bulk-load centers. Furthermore, to encourage the additional
capacity program, the CTU is providing connectivity, medium-term open access
(MTOA), and long-term access (LTOA) to various generation developers as per
CERC regulations. In view of the need for defensible growth, the CTU is focused
towards developing technologies such as UHVAC, high-voltage DC, FACTS,
smart grids, and the like in transmission development, which is unique in the world.
The Indian power system is growing manifold along with complexity in trans-
mission system operation, posing challenges in maintaining grid security, reliabil-
ity, and stability. To address these issues, it is prudent to introduce transmission
intelligence through smart grid applications. In this direction, POWERGRID, the
CTU, has undertaken full-scale implementation of state-of-the-art synchrophasor
technology using phasor measurement units (PMU) at all 400 kV and above sub-
stations and 220 kV generation switchyards in the country for a wide area
measurement/monitoring system (WAMS) of the power network integrating state
and central grids in a unified manner. During the operation stage, the CTU carries
the finance of ISTS transmission costs in addition to signing TSA and RSA.
Tariff-based competitive bidding (TBCB) has been in effect from January 6th, 2011
for transmission projects and is also valid for the CTU. In this emerging environ-
ment of competition, POWERGRID has successfully forayed into the competitive
scenario by bagging both transmission projects floated under the TBCB route.
(i) A joint venture (JV) should be selected through the competitive bidding
process called the JV route. The CTU/STU should contribute a minimum of
26% equity and the balance contributed by the JV partner.
(ii) The responsibility of the CTU/STU will identify permitted transmission to be
implemented by the private entity, also facilitate infusion of resources from the
private sector. The Independent Power Transmission company (IPTC) is an
implementing agency where their 100% equity is owned by the private sector.
From the above, it can be seen that suitable policy exists to promote private
sector participation in transmission. A number of independent power producers can
establish their own projects in various parts of the country. They need to inject part
and/or all of the power generated to the national grid owned by POWERGRID. For
injecting power generated from their generating project to the POWERGRID
national grid, a dedicated transmission system is required to be constructed con-
necting the generating project to this national grid. Per the Electricity Act, 2003
(Sect. 10), it is the duty of the generating company to establish a dedicated
transmission system. Because many generating companies do not have the expertise
to establish a transmission system, they make a request to POWERGRID to become
a 26% equity partner in a JV company to implement such dedicated transmission
systems. Note that the tariffs for JVs are computed on a cost-plus basis and guided
by CERC tariff regulations issued by them from time to time.
(ii) IPTC Route:
The second route for private sector participation is through IPTC, wherein a private
entity owns 100%. Many transmission systems in the past have been routed through
the IPTC process and finally the government of India issued an order regarding
development of interstate transmission systems on the tariff bidding route from
January 5th, 2011 to encourage competition. Earlier the transmission projects were
executed on the cost-plus basis. With the advent of private players and more
complexity in the sector, it was necessary to introduce tariff-based competitive
bidding. These guidelines allow private players to enter the transmission sector
through broader contributions in providing transmission services, thereby facili-
tating competition. It helps in transparently awarding the project based on the
formalized tariff.
The Electricity Act 2003 (Fig. 1.3) covers all the branches relating to the power
sector. Some of its key areas and the points they cover are:
• Generation:
(a) De-licensing
(b) Liberal provisions in captive generation
(c) Rural generation freed from licensing
It can thus be seen that the Electricity Act 2003 (Tables 1.6 and 1.7) has been a very
important instrument in the power sector wherein each and every aspect has been
considered and the proper direction for each matter has been tried to be addressed.
In this background, the details of various acts that had underlain the power sector in
India till now are described below.
Table 1.6 Impact of the Electricity Act 2003 in different segments of electricity
Segment Objective Impact
Generation ∙ De-licensing the ∙ More companies motivated towards
generation units generation
∙ Liberalization in the ∙ Captive power increases
captive power generation
policy
Transmission ∙ Fair access to T and D ∙ Customer can select by their own choice/
lines competition amongst DISCOMs leads to
efficient transfer of power
Distribution ∙ Fair access in phase ∙ Choice for buyer to choose supplier
manner ∙ Loss reduction
∙ Strict punishments for ∙ Equal benefit to all
power theft
∙ Lucid subsidy
management
1.10 Electricity Act and Policy 15
• Generation:
(a), (b) Liberal provisions in captive generation
(c) Rural generation freed from licensing
• Transmission and Distribution:
(a) Open access in transmission/distribution systems
(b) Envisages unbundling of transmission and distribution
(c) Rural distribution freed from licensing
(d) Provision for issuing more than one license for distribution within the same
area.
(i) National Electricity Policy (NEP) and National Tariff Policy (NTP)
Part II of the Electricity Act mandates that the central government prepare the
NEP and NTP with the state governments of India, and other authorities responsible
for the growth of power system fossil resources, hydro, and renewable sources of
energy.
16 1 Overview of Power Sector Scenario in India
the said sector with satisfactory returns. A new policy also ensures the availability
of power at nominal rates and addresses viability and attracts investments.
(vii) Objectives of the Implementation of the NEP and Tariff Policy
– Optimal development of the transmission network.
– A suitable transmission tariff framework for encouraging effective utilization of
assets and aiming for faster growth of new transmission networks.
– Transmission charges are on the basis of MW/circuit/km, on the zonal postage
stamp basis, and/or some other realistic variant.
– To share the total transmission cost in proportion to respective utilization of the
transmission system.
– In view of the method directed by the NEP, prior agreement with the legatees
would not be a precondition for network expansion.
– In a period of one year, the CERC is to establish standards for capital and
operating costs, operating standards, and performance indicators for different
types of transmission lines.
– The tariff of the projects to be developed by the CTU/STU would also be
determined on the basis of competitive bidding after five years or when the
regulatory commission is satisfied that the situation is right to introduce such
competition.
– Transactions are charged on the basis of average losses after appropriately
considering the distance and sensitivity (directional), as applicable to the rele-
vant voltage level.
– The loss compensation to be reasonable and linked to applicable technical loss
benchmarks.
– The CERC should permit satisfactory capital investments in new assets for
upgrading the transmission system.
The key objectives of Indian energy policies are (i) energy access at a reasonable
price, (ii) improved security, (iii) greater security, and (iv) economic growth.
(i) Energy access at reasonable price:
It is essential to provide energy access at reasonable cost particularly for the rural
population in India. Nearly 304 million people do not have access to electricity for
daily needs. 30% of the Indian population is housed and are still dependent upon
biomass. By 2022, the government of India (GoI) has targeted the electrification of
every household as per budget planning for 2015–2016.
18 1 Overview of Power Sector Scenario in India
India’s share of the world population is 17%; conversely the shares in the world
fossil reserves are only 1.5% combined. There is high dependence on fossil fuel
imports even at such a low level of consumption. Recent economizing policy has
focused on demand-side interventions on energy usage. One of the said interven-
tions is behavioral change that results in reducing the demand for energy-based
service, called energy conservation; the second intervention is greater energy effi-
ciency [15, 16]. To expound energy conservation let’s take a case of people shifting
to fans from HVAC and for better energy efficiency shifting to LED bulbs from
incandescent bulbs.
The reasons for the problems of the Indian power sector are (i) high T & D losses,
(ii) commercial losses due to energy theft, and (iii) low-efficiency equipment in the
agricultural sector. Now, due to the extensive agreement, the restoration of finances
in the power sector can be started by the demand side. A power sector company
may be under DSM due to (a) outstripping demands to be provided by supply,
(b) improving the revenues of the distribution companies, (c) improving the quality
of power, and (d) mitigating the rise in tariffs.
20 1 Overview of Power Sector Scenario in India
The link between power quality and its reliability is pretty self-evident. The usage
of different power supplies in the system will reduce its efficiency. Voltage stabi-
lizers, battery-run inverters, and irrigation pump sets employed by power con-
sumers at low efficiency lead to coping strategies. Quality improvements have
several positive implications and evidence shows that consumers are ready to pay
higher prices if power quality and reliability are improved.
References
11. Deweese FC (1945) Transmission lines: design, construction and performance. McGraw Hill,
New York
12. Rural Electrification Administration (1972) Transmission line manual. REA Bull. No. 62-1,
U.S. Dept. of Agriculture, U.S. Govt. Printing Office, Washington, D.C.
13. Dwight HB (1954) Electrical elements of power transmission lines. MacMillan, New York
14. Edison Electric Institute (1968) EHV transmission line reference book. EEI, New York
15. Anderson PM (1973) Analysis of faulted power systems. Iowa State Univ. Press, Ames
16. Weedy BM (1980) Underground transmission of electric power. Wiley
17. Ash DO et al (1979) Conductor systems for overhead lines. Proc I.E.E. 126:333–339
18. Kimbark EW (1972) DC transmission, vol 1. Wiley, New York
Chapter 2
Distribution Planning and Optimization
Historical data such as total peak demand, yearly demand, consumption of yearly
energy and procurement of energy include a minimum of the last five years’ details
collected in order to perform a power requirement study to forecast load growth.
Using these data by plotting the graph gives a clear indication of upcoming
demand; it also shows current, past, and future annual losses and load factors yearly
and monthly [3, 4].
Futuristic system planning is essential and guides the utility in an economical and
orderly expansion of the distribution network also ensuring an adequate supply at
the lowest cost to the consumer. It also provides information on system growth and
helps utility management by identifying economically sound solutions in terms of
building cost, existing facilities, system losses, and prevention of standard invest-
ments [5]. Understanding the map will help the system engineer and not affect the
development of the general plant in making certain modifications in transmission
lines or power substations. This study will provide a number of valuable benefits:
• Help the system engineer develop reliable and economical solutions.
• Increase system reliability and reduce the cost effectively.
• Determine the location and size of new substations and tie lines.
• Consider planned future investment for distribution automation such as
SCADA, AMR, OMS, and GIS.
The following are required for detailed planning.
• Latest distribution map
• Major load locations
• Voltage and current investigation results
• Data relevant to present and forthcoming loads
• Power necessities study
• Summary of latest outage with details of indices (SAIFI, SAIDI)
• Current transmission facilities
• Availability of power in the future
System modeling is then done which will find:
• The ability of the system to supply power to cover maximum area, and voltage
drop should not exceed more 6%.
• The total cost to be invested for the construction of a substation with all facilities
including protection devices and lateral feeder circuits; the charge is based per
square mile.
• Total losses are calculated based on planning load and associated cost for losses.
• The prospective level of system reliability indices (SAIFI, SAIDI).
• The total expenditure for the plan, including substation feeds, distribution fee-
der, and cost involved for system total losses.
• Cost-benefit analysis of the network reconfiguration.
2.1 System Planning Studies 25
The reliability level of the network can be planned as per the design. Depending
upon the importance and location of the substation, line, and transformer, planning
can be done either at the (N − 1), (N − 2), or (N − 3) level [6]. Typically for any
distribution level network (N – 3) planning may not be required. Table 2.1 indi-
cates the reliability level of a network that can be planned. Generally planners take
into consideration the four nines (99.99) level network which means each consumer
connected to the network may face on average 53 min of interruption during a year.
Systems having substation automation with DMS and SCADA may reach a design
level of five nines (99.999) which means an average of 5.3 min/year interruption to
each consumer connected to the network.
There are a number of guidelines used for measurement, but the three most
common and easiest measurements are SAIFI, SAIDI, and CAIDI as defined in
IEEE Standard 1366.
(a) System Average Interruption Index (SAIDI)
This provides information about the average time customers face interruption and is
normally calculated as the total number of customer interruption durations divided
by the total number of customers served in the affected area; the unit for SAIDI is
minutes or hours.
P
Customer Interruption Durations
SAIDI ¼ ð2:1Þ
Total Number of Customer Served
SAIDI
CAIDI ¼ ð2:3Þ
SAIFI
Temporary system planning plays a vital role in completing the systematic growth
of the system and also fulfilling the requirement of load growth for the entire
distribution system [7].
(a) Voltage Drop Study
Temporary systems study is achieved by the performance of the voltage drop
study. This study helps to uncover strong and weak points of load voltages at
different load points.
(b) Voltage Drop Factors
The study discovers voltage drops at various load points with different con-
ductor sizes.
The coordination study analyzes all or part of the distribution system commonly
called a sectionalizing study. The purpose of this study is to find the ability to place
a sectionalizing device and its selection choice is on the basis of fault current. The
combination of the coordination study along with the voltage drop and reliability
study is used to integrate major system changes in load or system configuration.
This main objectives of this study are as follows.
• Help to reduce the per customer power outage per year and also indirectly
reduce the service restoration cost after the outage.
• Reduce the frequent failure of apparatus and in turn increase the lifetime of the
power equipment.
• Reduce the probability of unsafe voltage on objects grounded with the neutral
system.
The above objectives are achieved by the use of proper selection and location of
sectionalizing devices on the distribution system. By the proper selection of sec-
tionalizing devices, the hazardously adverse line operating characteristics can be
2.1 System Planning Studies 27
The purpose of an optimal conductor design is to reduce energy losses to the lowest
possible level. While designing the primary lines for an electrical distribution system,
electrically conductive adhesive (ECA) minimize the cost, and more important, the
specified conductor size should be adequate from a voltage drop standpoint. A shortened
technique of economic comparison can be developed using data and methods that result
in a graphic depiction of the total cost to own and operate a variety of lines at various
load levels [8]. The following data are necessary to carry out the economic analysis.
(a) Three-phase conductor cost with various sizes from manufacturer
(b) Electrical system fixed costs including O&M expenditure, represented as a
percentage of plant value
(c) System load factor
(d) Amount of energy required and demand for the system
Dissimilar conductors’ cost of energy losses and their savings (in energy losses) are
calculated at different load levels. Finally, a graph should be drawn in comparison
indicative of the most economical conductor size required for each particular load
level.
The power factor (PF) is defined as the ratio of real power to apparent power or the
rate of useful working current to the total current in the line and is calculated by the
formula:
kW
Power Factor ¼
kVA
growth. The utility should prepare a prospective network plan for a 10-year period.
This should become part of the conditional criteria for sanction of grants under
various programs.
Electrical distribution is a unique system, thus each DISCOM has separate adequate
operating procedures that are particular to a given site and the system of concern.
A separate manual is provided for the operating procedure of each electrical dis-
tribution system component. It should contain instructions for sequence switching
of the main and feeder switching devices. Often operating manuals labeling the
details of various portions of the system for complex systems are required. The
manual should contain up-to-date information about:
• Equipment details used in the network.
• Reflection of the operating modes used.
• Explain sequence procedure to energize the whole system from the incoming
point of connection to the lowest utilization voltage level.
• Must have drawings, figures, tables, and equipment drawings so that additional
documents should not be needed for operation.
• Contain information about the distribution system functions.
• Describe the electrical distribution functions and operation capability/limitations
of various components involved in the electrical distribution system.
• Include emergency ratings of all the distribution components involved in the
particular system such as transformers, distribution panel, motor control center,
feeder cable, and switchgear.
30 2 Distribution Planning and Optimization
With the introduction of automated devices in the network a system can be operated
automatically; moreover, well-designed distribution equipment does not require
frequent operating changes [9]. Data collection of major parameters such as voltage,
current, energy, and power factors at pertinent points of the system can be helpful in
the repetitive operation of the system as well as future planning exercises. In
modern days load flow studies are analyzed with the help of faster rate inexpensive
computers, which is very useful in determining the optimum operating configura-
tions of the distribution system.
Frequent changes in the distribution system and occurrence of fault or overload that
result in outage or disturbance can be surge, impulse, noise, and phase shift and sag,
among others. Based on previous studies, only one phase of a three-phase system
2.4 System Disturbances or Outage 31
subjected to frequent fault and the occurrence rate is around 80–85%; almost 90%
of the disturbances are less than one second. Disturbances are categorized based on
their time duration; when it is over one minute it is usually classified as an outage.
This is defined as the grid’s ability to supply stable and reliable power. In other
words, the grid should maintain a standard frequency and voltage or within the
tolerance [10].
• Voltage Regulation: It can be improved by use of off-load as well as on-load
tap changers, installations of capacitors, and PF correcting devices.
• Harmonics: With the help of the latest technology in solid-state switching
devices implemented in distribution equipment, harmonics problems are
reduced significantly and maintain the total harmonic distortion (THD) within
prescribed limits, and other quality parameters are properly maintained with the
help of variable frequency drives, rectifier power supplies, high- frequency
power supplies, uninterruptible power systems, and arc discharge lamps.
• Frequency: The difference in generation and demand on the system causes
frequency variation in the network, and it must maintain the standard value as
closely as possible.
• Voltage Imbalance: Uneven distribution of single-phase loads on each phase
will cause voltage imbalance in the system; it is normally limited to a maximum
of 3%. For balancing the voltage, essential efforts should adopt the single-phase
loads that should evenly distribute all three phases [11].
2.6 Maintenance Planning and Implementation 33
The path to maturity is developing all over the world in the stages shown in
Fig. 2.1.
The main aim of an electric utility is to improve system reliability; to reduce
O&M costs are the top priorities. Electrical maintenance varies from time to time as
a result of competition and costs, and equipment difficulties are increasing as well
as regulatory approval for O&M. Figure 2.2 shows maintenance themes; in general
maintenance is either scheduled or unexpected.
Corrective maintenance is an unexpected approach and is carried out after the
fault occurrence. The aim is to reinstate an item such that it can carry out the regular
required function in the system. Depending upon the nature of maintenance, it can
be categorized into two groups: preventive or scheduled maintenance or regular
maintenance. Under this category there are four basic tasks:
Un-planned Planned
Maintenance
Strategies
Reactive Pro-active
Scheduled Predictive
Condition
Corrective Preventive Monitoring
An effective maintenance aims to minimize the failures in the electrical system. The
accumulation of dust, dirt, or moisture can be reduced by keeping the apparatus in
clean and dry condition; similarly, loose connections and friction of moving parts
can be minimized by keeping contacts stable and supplying proper lubricant oil in
moving parts particularly where friction occurs.
Dust and Dirt Accumulation
Degradation of insulation and flashover may happen in the system due to accu-
mulation of chemical dust, lint, and the deposit of oil mist; the particles become
conductive when combined with moisture on insulation. Accumulation of dirt
builds on transformer coils, and relay lines will reduce the air flow, in turn
increasing the operating temperature leading to equipment failure or reducing the
lifetime of the equipment. Similarly, dust accumulation in the case of outdoor
insulators of overhead lines and substation equipment can meet flashovers.
Contamination cannot be avoided in coastal areas and some industrial areas but
with the help of periodically scheduled equipment cleaning these contaminations
are definitely reduced.
Presence of Moisture
Condensed moisture can lead to oxidation, degradation of insulation, and failure in
electrical equipment. Free condensation produced by high humidity may lead to
short-circuits and failure of the electrical equipment. Rarely does electrical equip-
ment operate in the dry atmospheric condition which is, however, the ideal case. To
minimize moisture, proper enclosure and space heaters can be used.
Loose Connections
Connections should be tight and torque to the manufacturer’s suggested values.
Joint failure usually happens due to creep/cold flow by load cycles. The most
common areas of loose connections are cable connections, fuse clips with circuit
breakers, and contactors; all these areas must be regularly checked.
Friction
Friction can affect the free movement of electrical devices; for example, in circuit
breaker (CB) friction can reduce the operating speed, and it is of prime importance
in circuit breakers. Furthermore, dirt accumulation on parts can cause scratches and
arcing or burning may occur. All devices should be properly lubricated with
specific type and grades, unless proscribed by the manufacturer. Insulation is
attacked by dust and other contaminants on oil and grease. Checking the
mechanical operation of devices and manually or electrically operating any device
that seldom operates should be standard practice.
36 2 Distribution Planning and Optimization
It is also termed the “run to failure” maintenance technique. Even today, many
utilities follow the “run it until it breaks” philosophy. All too often we hear
statements such as, “We can’t take that out of service,” or “We’ve never had a
problem so why bother to perform maintenance.” The cost involved for failure
includes outage and its repair cost is definitely less than the preventive maintenance
cost. Surprisingly, breakdown maintenance employs minimal preventive mainte-
nance techniques, however, action is taken only when urgently and immediately
required. The following shows some common data items and how they are put to
use in a breakdown maintenance approach.
• Load Current: Transformer or other equipment replaced at first outage
• Voltage: Tap changers adjusted, if provided
• Temperature: Symptomatic treatment such as checking the cooling system or
adding fans
Breakdown maintenance may not involve any datapoint analysis; it will be cost
effective until no disastrous failures occur. Such an approach leaves the system
open to major disasters because no precautions are taken to avert them. Perilous
conditions may exist with no way to predict them.
• Data are usually collected during both online and offline times. Offline times are
intentionally scheduled for the implementation of preventive maintenance
procedures.
• The equipment that requires repair is scheduled for outages and to implement
the said repairs.
The principal problems with preventive maintenance programs can only be sta-
tistically evaluated and cannot be economically evaluated. The cost expenditure is
directly compared between maintenance and expenditure for outage. However, the
cost of expenditure cannot be calculated except when an unplanned outage occurs.
As proved, PDM is better and cost effective. For example, regarding the dissolved
gas analysis in oil, practical experience has set empirical bounds for the rate of
change and amount of combustible gases in the insulating oil. Based on extensive
analysis, we know that if the amount of acetylene rises above a predefined standard
concentration or if the rate of production of said gas increases beyond a certain
value then arcing will undoubtedly occur in a transformer. Thus we can safely
predict the occurrence of arcing if the analysis shows an exceeded amount of
acetylene is found. On further analysis, prediction of the transformer life can be
calculated. An emergency outage can be scheduled for the faulty transformer; then
the cause can be isolated and repaired. PDM is not a general systemwide strategy
but an equipment-specific type of approach; that is, most companies and agencies
do not use predictive techniques throughout the system. To perform predictive
procedures, these companies use equipment or specialty vendors on their critical
transformers. Infrared scans are performed on whole systems. The common types of
PDM procedures employed in current power systems are summarized below.
• Dissolved Gas Content: A comparison of industry standards and gas content and
percentage increase are computed. If equipment exceeds these standards it is
scheduled for offline repair.
• Thermographic Scan Temperatures: Temperature rise scans are associated with
industry norms.
Suppose the equipment exceeds offline repair scheduled norms. It shows the
maintenance engineer how such programs work. The procedure for a PDM program
is summarized below:
• Important parameters are measured and analyzed.
• It gives a clear idea about general standards of a particular component with
respect to potential problems associated with the equipment.
• Equipment that fails the standards is strategically planned for repair or retesting.
38 2 Distribution Planning and Optimization
RCM is an algorithm that helps the DISCOMs to regulate the optimal preventive
maintenance tasks necessary to report critical equipment failures without compro-
mising service reliability. It is the combination of corrective, predictive, and pre-
ventive maintenance, and utilized on these approaches where suitable, based on the
Today many technologies are being examined and used to control the electrical
equipment’s condition, helping in condition-based maintenance. A few tools and
techniques are as follows.
The prolonged sound in the equipment may be a sign of air, gas, or steam leaks and
can also be a result of friction between moving parts.
Sensors used in the power system detect initial insulation breakdown in any
equipment; they are also used to detect emerging failure so that in future no sig-
nificant damage occurs.
This analysis is one of the methods used to detect the amount of dissolved gas
content in transformer oil or any other any abnormalities. A gas-level indicator
shows the maintenance engineer the state of the transformer essential for mainte-
nance or potential failure.
DISCOMs fail to integrate and process expediently a quick evaluation of the large
amount of data collected, thus leading to delayed O&M recommendations, and
thereby adding cost for data collection and still failing to provide cost benefit from
effective maintenance. RCM and PDM analyses balance each other, and excellent
optimization is achieved when they are performed simultaneously.
A comprehensive approach for T&D systems ensuring a constant and reliable
supply should include the substation and equipment. Please see Fig. 2.4.
In India, since the initiation of power sector reforms many vertically integrated
utilities/state electricity boards (SEBs) have been unbundled. The role of newly
formed distribution utilities has become more focused on meeting the needs of retail
consumers. These companies have inherited very old and weak networks facing
frequent breakdowns of lines, cables, and transformers. Most of the DISCOMs are
faced with challenges of fulfilling growing consumer expectations in the area of
providing a continuous and good quality power supply. This is to be achieved by
upgrading and toning the distribution network and adopting best practices in the
area of network augmentation plans and adapting to the best distribution and
maintenance standard practices.
A power distribution company in its journey towards “Service Excellence to
Consumers” needs to set a corporate target to be achieved by a predefined horizon
year (may be in a span of four to six years) that relates to improving the service
delivery mechanism to consumers. This necessitates formulation of a strategic
reliability and maintenance roadmap.
The activity starts with performing an assessment of existing reliability and
maintenance practices within the utility and identifying a desired future state based
on benchmarking with best-in-class utility practices. The roadmap is prepared with
an implementation schedule covering details of a year-on-year plan of activities,
expenses, and achievements until the horizon year is reached.
At the beginning of the activity it is necessary to know the present health of the
various network components of the detailed equipment audit to arrive at a decision
of run as it is, repair and then run, or replace [14, 15]. Such a network audit is
conducted through OEMs (original equipment manufacturers) and deploys teams of
in-house engineers. This covers the details of 66 or 33 kV substation equipment
2.8 Integrated Approach 43
such as power transformers, circuit breakers, isolators, capacitor banks, battery and
chargers, and the like, as well as overhead and underground HV and LV feeders,
distribution transformer substations with control gears, service cables, and meters.
Deciding on the goals to be achieved at the end of the horizon year includes in the
area of AT&C loss reduction, reliability improvement, and catering to consumer
growth by adequate interventions of IT enabling systems and distribution
automation with SCADA. Having frozen the yearly activity, expenses, and
achievement phasing program the utility can now go ahead with formulation of
reliability and maintenance roadmaps based on international best practices.
Many utilities still perform their reliability analysis based on manually prepared
paper reports as part of the data collection of planned outages, interruptions,
breakdowns, and load shedding. To avoid the complexity of data collection, today
2.9 Reliability Data 45
all DISCOMs have installed an outage management system (OMS) that tracks the
data and consumer interruptions as they occur. Thus knowledge of reliability
indices such as SAIDI and SAIFI is more accurate. This requires GIS mapping of
all network assets until consumer indexing. With the R-APDRP part A and B
projects funding many utilities can avail themselves of this facility. Effective reli-
ability management requires good asset data. This can be maintained through
installation of ERP (enterprise resource planning) software. Otherwise such detailed
inspection, maintenance, and failure history for equipment is stored in a comput-
erized maintenance management system (CMMS).
It should address the following major goals to reach the desired future state.
– Dramatically improve overall reliability as measured by SAIDI and SAIFI.
– Demonstrate to all stakeholders that the expenditure incurred is in tune with the
benefits received and maintain the tariff at a reasonable level.
– Establish business systems that would be able to achieve global benchmarks.
46 2 Distribution Planning and Optimization
Table 2.4 International practices, minimum oil CB inspections, diagnostics, and maintenance
S. No. Inspections Frequency
1. General visual inspection (looking for obvious defects) Once per month
2. Visual check for leaks/contamination/moisture/loose Once every six
connections months
3. Visual check of terminations Once every six
months
4. Functional test Annually
5. Infrared scan Annually
S. No. Diagnostics Frequency
1. Measurement of contact resistance Once every three
years
2. Measurement of switching time and simultaneity of the Once every three
phases. Lubricate moving parts at this time years
3. Measure spring charging time for spring-operated breakers Once every three
years
4. Random check (−10%) of the condition of the oil per station Once every six years
(moisture, color, breakdown voltage)
5. Partial discharge measurements Once every six years
S. No. Maintenance Frequency
1. Revision of breaker chamber: a. Replace contacts, b. Clean After a short-circuit
the chamber, c. Replace oil
2. Cleaning of bushings Once every three to
five years, also
frequent cleaning is
required for worst
ambient conditions
2.10 International Benchmarking 47
Table 2.5 International practices, bulk oil CB inspections, diagnostics, and maintenance
S. No. Inspections Frequency
1. General visual inspection (looking for obvious defects) Once per month
2. Visual check for leaks/contamination/moisture/loose Once every six
connections months
3. Visual check of terminations Once every six
months
4. Functional test Annually
S. No. Diagnostics Frequency
1. Measurement of contact resistance Once every three
years
2. Measurement of switching time and simultaneity of the Once every three
phases Lubricate moving parts at this time years
3. Measure spring charging time for spring-operated Once every three
breakers years
4. Random check (−10%) of the condition of the oil per Once every six years
station (moisture, color, breakdown voltage)
5. Partial discharge measurements Once every six years
S. No. Maintenance Frequency
1. Visual check of contacts After a short-circuit
2. Check of oil color After a short-circuit
Maintenance is the largest internally controllable cost. At the same time, mainte-
nance is a key process in effective asset management [16]. The utility is in the
process of improving its maintenance program and is investigating options to
establish an effective maintenance program in a time- desired frame. A maintenance
optimization roadmap is recommended based on traditional reliability-centered
maintenance with elements of modern asset management (AM) and
performance-based maintenance (PBM). Traditional RCM is focused on balancing
the cost of maintenance and PBM reinforces the need for establishing processes for
effective performance management through a “living” maintenance optimization
program. This is a data-driven process and a suggested roadmap addresses the need
for data management and support through a computerized maintenance manage-
ment system.
The maintenance optimization roadmap would suggest number of individual
steps in establishing effective maintenance consistent with modern asset and sup-
port reliability management as part of overall company performance management.
The roadmap is organized in sections addressing the need for strategic decisions
and suggesting project organization, planning, and prioritization. It includes pilot
projects, technology transfer, and RCM studies. Once a maintenance plan is
developed, the roadmap requires effective plan execution through proper work
management and prioritization, resource optimization, and performance manage-
ment. Steps to ensure effective data collection, management, and analysis are
suggested together with installation of effective IT infrastructure.
The roadmap proposes maintenance optimization through the optimized use of
internal resources in combination with external support to ensure cost-effective
2.11 Maintenance and Inspection Roadmap Recommendations 51
Table 2.9 International practices, station (power) transformer inspections, diagnostics, and
maintenance
S. No. Inspections Frequency
1. Overall visual inspections of connections, Monthly
corrosion, oil levels, and so on
2. Visual check of cable end boxes Monthly
3. Visual check of breather; replacement if broken Monthly
4. Visual check of silica gel desiccant; replacement if Monthly
applicable
5. Infrared inspections Annually
6. Heat exchanger inspections Annually
7. Conservator and bladder inspections Annually
S. No. Diagnostics Frequency
1. Dissolved gas-in-oil analysis (DGA) Annually to once every three
years
2. Oil quality tests. Includes: Once every four to six years
a. Breakdown voltage
b. Neutralization value
c. Dielectric dissipation factor
d. Interfacial tension
3. Insulation resistance test Once every eight years
4. Insulation power factor test Once every eight years
5. Winding excitation test Once every eight years
6. Bushing power factor test Once every eight years
7. Turns ratio test Once every eight years
S. No. Maintenance Frequency
1. Dust cleaning Annually
2. Functional tests of all protection and Annually
instrumentation, for example:
a. Bucholz relay
b. Thermal image (indication winding temp)
c. Level indicators
d. Indicators (needle) and contacts (needle activates
contact reaching certain threshold)
e. Fans (functional and timing)
f. Pressure relay
3. Off load test—complete range tap changer in order During scheduled
to clean the contacts shutdowns, but at least
a. In the case of an existing transformer: only
OLTC (on load tap changer), do not operate
DETC (de-energized tap changer) due to
possibility of failure (cause: carbon on contacts)
b. In the case of a new transformer: both OLTC and
DETC, but it should be done every year
4. Inspect the diverter switch Every 40,000 operations
(typically). Number of
operations depends on LTC
manufacturer
52 2 Distribution Planning and Optimization
Table 2.12 International practices, capacitor bank inspections, diagnostics, and maintenance
S. No. Inspections Frequency
1. Visual inspection Monthly
2. Detailed visual inspection. Check for oil leaks, bulging of the Annually
capacitors, signs of overheating, arcing point, and terminations
3. Measure temperature (summertime, representative temperatures) in Annually
order to verify whether the temperature is exceeding the limit of the
rated temperature class. If the temperature class is exceeded,
possibilities for (natural) cooling should be examined
S. No. Diagnostics Frequency
1. Capacitance measurement of complete bank Annually
2. Upon deviation, measure value of each unit Annually
3. At deviation from manufacturer tolerances, replacement of individual Annually
unit(s)
4. Partial discharge measurements Annually
5. Thermographic measurements Annually
Table 2.13 International practices, MV switchgear and control panel inspections, diagnostics,
and maintenance
S. No. Inspections Frequency
1. General visual inspection; in the case of digital relay check El n0 Monthly
and ET i z 0 if applicable (indication of status of current and
voltage transformer and wiring)
2. Electromechanical and static relays: functional check and Annually
primary/secondary injection; replacement if applicable
3. Check parameter adjustment (mainly caused by capacitors) Annually
S. No. Maintenance Frequency
1. Digital relays, due to self-check ability of relay: functional check Once every
and primary/secondary injection; replacement if applicable three years
in infrastructure upgrade with the first step being detailed specification and
requirements development taking into account companywide asset and performance
management needs.
Maintenance and Inspection Roadmap Conclusions
A utility has a very good opportunity to achieve desired reliability transformations.
This goal is achievable through a coordinated strategy at the corporate level and
continued enthusiastic support from top management. Maintenance improvement,
as discussed in the maintenance optimization roadmap, is an initiative that needs
companywide coordination. Investment in a maintenance optimization project is an
investment in the company’s overall performance improvement, including
reliability.
54 2 Distribution Planning and Optimization
Table 2.14 International practices, DC system: Batteries and battery charger inspections,
diagnostics, and maintenance
Battery
S. No. Inspections Frequency
1 General visual inspection Monthly
2 Check liquid level and refill if applicable Monthly
S. No. Diagnostics Frequency
1 In the case of open batteries check PH value Annually
2 Voltage measurement Annually
3 No break test, cell replacement if applicable Once every two
years
S. No. Maintenance Frequency
1 Check tightness and oxidation of connections and maintain if Once every two
applicable years
Rectifier
S. No. Inspections Frequency
1 Visual inspection Once every two
years
2 Check functionality of the current rectifier, both float and boost Once every two
positions, if applicable years
3 Check indication lights Once every two
years
4 Check for contamination, cracks, and arcing points Once every two
years
5 Check indicators (voltage, current) Once every two
years
Table 2.15 International practices, feeder pillar inspections, diagnostics, and maintenance
S. No. Inspections Frequency
1. Inspection for physical damage; repair or painting if Annually
applicable
S. No. Diagnostics Frequency
1. Check maximum current indicator and compare it with Annually
ratings
2. Infrared measurement Once every three years
S. No. Maintenance Frequency
Normal Environmental High Contamination
Conditions Areas
1. Cleaning Once every three years Once every three years
2. Tightening of loose Once every three years Once every three years
connections
2.11 Maintenance and Inspection Roadmap Recommendations 55
Table 2.16 International practices, ring main unit inspections, diagnostics, and maintenance
S. No. Inspections Frequency
1. Visual check of cable terminations Every six months
2. Check operating mechanism for Annually
corrosion and/or contamination. Clean
and lubricate if applicable
3. Inspect for physical damage/corrosion Annually
S. No. Diagnostics Frequency
4. Infrared measurement Every three years
S. No. Maintenance Frequency
5. Cleaning Every three months; only for aggressive
environmental conditions (high
contamination areas)
using messages designed for SCADA, realtime data exchange, and collection of
equipment monitoring information, significantly reducing equipment used for
protection, control, measurement, and automation. The computer consoles have one
or more cathode ray tube (CRT) display devices, with the facility of operator
communication: a touchtype keyboard, a touchscreen, or a light wand. The actual
CRT displays are generated by specially written computer software consisting of
schematic multicolor representations of a variety of operating systems.
Electrical power systems are frequently represented in a one-line diagram with
some geographical or physical orientation of assorted equipment. The system
operating buses are displayed in diverse colors to reflect the dissimilar operating
voltages. CB status is indicated by red or green lights according to their closed or
open status, respectively. Bus power flows, voltages, and currents are displayed
next to the bus identification information. Transformers, circuit breakers, disconnect
switches, major circuits, and major utilization equipment are usually illustrated on
the display. The display may be broken down into supplementary detailed screens
to exemplify the particulars of a complex system. The control conditions for gen-
erating units if any should be displayed. A suitable communication network is
placed between the central control room and remote stations (PLCC, optical fiber
cable, etc.).
Control Circuits and Devices
Microprocessor controls are one of the latest technologies to be applied to the
electrical distribution system. Microprocessors are being put to use for applications
as follows.
(a) Protective relaying and tripping functions in circuit breakers and fuse like
switching devices
(b) Electronic meters that provide all of the voltage: current, power, energy con-
sumption, demand, power factor, frequency
Microprocessor-based protection modules are being installed in molded case circuit
breakers and low voltage power circuit breakers. This aids in controlling the
operation of the direct acting trip units. These trip units are used to provide long
time, short time, instantaneous, and ground fault over current protection. They also
take care of under-voltage protection. Furthermore, microprocessor-based protec-
tive relays are also put to use for replacing traditional electromechanical protective
relays generally used for low and medium voltage switchgear installations. The
novel devices proffer better protection of equipment by allowing more precise
protection settings paralleling equipment needs. The latest devices also present
improved troubleshooting diagnostics, online test features, and communication
capabilities. This leads to remote trouble reporting. These protective devices are
being outfitted with metering capabilities that may allow removal of separate
voltmeters, ammeters, and wattmeters, which are frequently used on feeder circuits
and utilization circuits for providing operating load information. Electronic
metering devices are now obtainable in one package to substitute all independent
meters.
60 2 Distribution Planning and Optimization
References
13. Lee WH (1997) Power distribution planning. Reference Book Marcell Dekker Inc, New York,
p 209
14. Stall HG (1989) Least-cost electric utility. Willey, New York, p 74
15. Geographic Information System Planning for power system planning, United Nation
Publication, June 1997
16. Grisby LL (1998) The electric power engineering, Handbook, pp 6–60, 13-4
17. National Electricity Plan 2004, CEA, New Delhi (Chap. 7)
Chapter 3
Best Practices in Operation
and Maintenance of Subtransmission
and Distribution Lines
In a power system the distribution network is the final stage, which includes car-
rying electricity from the transmission system and also delivering the electricity to
the end users (Fig. 3.1). The components of this network are power lines (medium
voltage below 66 kV), substations, distribution transformers, meters, and
low-voltage distribution wings (below 1 kV). It begins with the primary circuit
leaving the substation and ends as the secondary service enters the customer’s meter
socket [1]. The voltage varies from 33 kV to 230 V depending on the utility
standards, distance, and load to be served.
Distribution system conductors are carried on overhead poles; in high-density
areas underground cables are used. Three-phase four-wire systems are used to serve
electricity for urban and suburban area load customers, whereas for rural areas
single-phase systems are used. Generally, a distribution transformer is used to feed
domestic customers. The distribution transformer reduces the voltage to the rela-
tively low level used by lightning and the interior wiring system. Large commercial
customers are fed directly from distribution voltages.
The transformer can be set up in two ways: either pole-mounted or also mounted
on the ground in a protective covering. A pole-mounted transformer can serve only
one transformer in the case of rural areas, and in builtup areas, more than one
customer may also be connected. A secondary network, in which many trans-
formers feed into a common bus at utilization voltage, may be formed in very dense
city areas. Every customer has electrical service or a service drop connection and a
meter for billing purposes. (A few small loads such as yard lights are too small for a
meter and are billed only at a monthly rate.)
For the customer’s system and equipment owned by the utility, a ground con-
nection to local earth is normally provided. The customer’s system is connected to
the ground in order to limit the voltage that can increase when high-voltage con-
ductors fall on lower-voltage conductors, or even in case of failure within the
distribution transformer. The risk of electric shock can be minimized when all
conductive objects are connected together to a common earth grounding system.
But the presence of multiple connections between utility ground and customer
ground may lead to stray voltage problems such as customer piping, swimming
pools, or any other equipment that may develop objectionable voltages [2, 3].
Because problems often develop from places separated from the customer’s pre-
mises, these are difficult to solve.
Generally, a distribution network contains the following tools.
The tower can be supported by narrow-based lattice towers with a fully galvanized
structure according to the requirements. Poles are used for 33, 11 kV, and low
transmission lines (below 500 V). There are many kinds of poles such as precast
concrete (PCC), prestressed cement concrete (PSCC), rolled steel joist, rail, or
tubular steel (Table 3.1). The standards confirmed by the poles should be IS 785, IS
1322, IS 1678, IS 2713. Cement poles are favored in plain areas. In designing poles
and towers in hilly areas, appropriate snow or ice loading should be taken into
consideration.
Specially designed poles/lattice towers are used in locations involving long
spans or higher clearances owing to the crossing of power or communication lines
or railway line crossings. If the angle of deviation is more than 10°, double-pole
structures are used. The factors that should be considered for determining the height
3.2 Poles and Tower Structures 65
Steel tube: This pole is normally used for street light connections
and is manufactured from steel tubes. They are normally
assembled at the factory and set up on the powerline’s right of way
with a crane
of the pole above ground level, length of the pole below ground level, and load are
wind zone, terrain, topography, and statutory clearances required to be maintained.
All these factors are required to be confirmed by Indian standards (IS) [4].
Depending on the type of line there can be a variety of shapes for the structure of
overhead lines. A simple structure is made up of wood poles straight in the earth
that carry one or more cross-arm beams in order to carry the conductors. It can also
66 3 Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance of Subtransmission …
Table 3.2 Type of PCC poles for angle and dead-end locations
S. No. Location and type of Suitability of different PCC pole designs in Western part (WP) zones
support
50 kg/m2 75 kg/m2 (using 75 kg/m2 (using 100 kg/
140 kg WL poles in 200 kg WL poles in m2
normal location) normal location)
1 Straight runs (tangent A A B B
locations): single-pole
arrangement
2 0°–10° angle location: A A B B
single-pole arrangement
3 10°–30° angle location: A A B B
single-pole arrangement
4 10°–30° angle location: A A B B
double-pole arrangement
5 30°–60° angle location: A–A A–A B–B B–B
single-pole arrangement
6 3°–60° angle location: A A B B
four-pole arrangement
(H-type)
7 60°–90° angle location: A A B B
double-pole arrangement
8 Dead-end location: A A B B
double- pole arrangement
(H-type)
9 Distribution transformer C C D D
location: double-pole
arrangement
3.2 Poles and Tower Structures 67
In overhead lines the conductors are supported by towers/poles (Tables 3.3 and
3.4). The conductors are pulled and stringing effected [5]. When supported this way
a conductor will dip under its own weight called “sag.” The distance between
adjunct supporting structures is called the “span.” The conductor’s mechanical
loading is due to its own weight, weight of ice, wind load, and so on. Under varying
weather conditions of ambient temperature, the conductor’s tension should not
exceed the permissible limit, that is, breaking strength of the conductor/safety factor
(2.0–2.5). Knowledge of the maximum sag/line span calculation is essential for
designing lines with adequate ground clearance. The line span is decided by taking
into account factors such as topography, wind pressure, kind of support, conductor
configuration, and ultimate tensile strength.
The span range is designated by IS-5613.
There should be a uniform span that is to be maintained between two successive pole
structures as soon as possible. A pole should be placed on the roadside if a road is
intersected at midspan when the line is built. When another power line is crossed, the
lower voltage line should be below specified. The lower line should be crossed in the
midspan of the upper line [6, 7]. In order to maintain the proper ground clearance at the
middle of the span, shorter poles can be made when poles are placed at high places.
Normally, placement of poles should be avoided along the edges, cuts, or embankments
of creeks and streams.
3.3 Line Span 69
In terms of functions, transmission lines and overhead distribution lines may be similar
but these two may differ in terms of their construction. In terms of voltage and distance,
transmission lines are made to carry high voltages traveling longer distances, but
overhead distribution lines are constructed to carry medium voltages traveling distances
that depend on the size of its extent or on the utility’s discretion [8].
Electrical power starts at the power distribution substation and goes to different
areas with the help of distribution lines in the system. Distribution lines connected
to the high-voltage side of the distribution transformer are referred to as primary
distribution lines or primaries. The secondaries, connected on the low-voltage side
of the distribution transformer, are known as secondary distribution lines.
3.5 Cables
Cables are nothing but conductors covered with a layer of insulation (Fig. 3.2).
Cables can have either one conductor or multiple conductors and may be of indi-
vidually insulated type. There may also be multiple conductor cables with an
external insulating outer covering or sheath. The materials used for making the
conductor are electrolytic-grade high-conductivity annealed copper or aluminum.
All cables generally have aluminum/copper as conductor materials and control
cables have copper.
Conductor Shield
The conductor has a nonmetallic semiconducting shield that ensures a perfectly
smooth profile and avoids stress concentration.
Insulation There is generally a specified system voltage for which cable insulation
should be designed. The purpose of the manufacturing process is to ensure that
insulation is free from voids. The insulation should also hold out against
mechanical and thermal stress under steady- state as well as transient operating
conditions.
70 3 Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance of Subtransmission …
Armoring In single-core cables armoring is applied over the core insulation and in
the case of multicore cable it is applied over the inner sheath. Depending upon the
application, these cables can be armored or unarmored. The armor consists of
galvanized round steel wire. In single-core cables to be used in an AC system,
armoring with nonmagnetic material is desired [9]. For single- core cable to be used
in a DC system, the cable should be armored with galvanized steel wire/strip.
Sheath
Inner Sheath In the case of cables consisting of two or more cores an inner sheath
suitable to withstand the site conditions and the desired temperature is provided on
the individual core and then surrounded by a common covering applied either by
extrusion or wrapping of a filling material containing thermoplastic material.
A PVC sheath should be extruded. The circularity of the cable should be maintained
[10].
72 3 Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance of Subtransmission …
Outer Sheath This is extruded over the armor for armored cables and covers the
inner sheath for unarmored cables. It is specially formulated heat-resistant black
PVC extruded to form the outer sheath. The cable should also offer a specially
formulated flame-retardant low smoke compound (FRLS) for the outer sheath. All
must be given anti-termite treatment.
3.6 Insulators
An insulator (Fig. 3.3) in the true sense is a material that completely resists the flow
of electric charge and does not respond to the electric field. But, practically, a
perfect insulator does not exist [11, 12]. Therefore dielectric materials having very
high dielectric constants are regarded as insulators. In the atoms of insulating
materials, electrons are strongly bonded. These are used as insulators or insulation
in electrical equipment and perform the function of supporting or separating elec-
trical conductors and do not allow current through them. The insulating supports
used to attach electric power transmission wires to utility poles/pylons are also
referred to by this term.
Glass, paper, or Teflon are some materials that are very good examples of elec-
trical insulators because these materials may have lower bulk resistivity. However, a
larger class of materials is “good enough” in insulating electrical wiring and cables.
Some examples of such materials are rubberlike polymers and most kinds of plastics.
For low to moderate voltages (hundreds, or even thousands, of volts), these materials
are safe and practical insulators to use. Electric power transmission wires suspended
in nature are generally bare and are insulated by only air. But when these wires enter
a building, they aren’t bare. Insulators are required at the points where they are
supported by utility poles or pylons and where the wire enters buildings or electrical
devices such as a transformer, circuit breaker, and the like. The hollow conductors
that hold conductors in them are known as bushings [13]. It is necessary to use an
insulating link by cranes working near such wires because of dangers produced by
cranes that touch bare electric power transmission wires.
Excessive voltage can cause electrical breakdown of an insulator. This can take
place in two ways:
• Puncture voltage: When the insulator is installed in its normal manner there is a
voltage appearing across the insulator known as puncture voltage. This voltage
causes breakdown and conduction of electricity inside the insulator. A puncture
arc causes heat that can damage the insulator irreparably.
• Flashover voltage: Voltage that causes the air around the surface of the insu-
lator to conduct electricity causes a “flashover” arc throughout the outside of the
insulator. Usually these are designed to confront this without any damage.
In order to avoid damage, generally insulators are constructed with flashover
voltage lower than puncture voltage. This will cause insulators to flash before they
do damage.
74 3 Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance of Subtransmission …
Flashovers and leakage currents can be caused by the presence of dirt, pollution,
salt, and water in particular, which can create a conductive path across it. The
magnitude of flashover voltage depends upon the presence of water and is reduced
to more than 50% when the insulator is wet. In order to minimize the leakage
current, the leakage path along the surface from one end to another is maximized
and this path is also known as creep age length. These high-voltage insulators for
outdoor purposes are designed to maximize creep age length. The surface is framed
into a series of corrugations or concentric disk shapes so that the leakage path can
be maximized. These generally contain one or more sheds which are nothing but
cup-shaped surfaces facing downward, acting as umbrellas to ensure the surface
leakage path under the cup also remains dry in wet weather. Safe or minimum creep
age distances lie in the range 20–25 mm/KV and it should be increased in airborne
sea-salt or high pollution areas. Please see Table 3.7.
References
1. Power Sub-Transmission and Distribution systems-prevailing practices No. 198. New Delhi,
December, pp 75–79
2. IS: 5613 (Part Iand II) Design installation and maintenance of lines up to and including
220 kV
3. Jones GR et al. (1993) Electrical engineer’s reference book, 15th edn. Newness, Oxford, pp
22/1–22/18
4. Manual on Transmission Criteria, CEA (1985, May) p 15
5. Modern trends and practices in power sub-transmission and distribution systems, vol. 1.
CBIP, Malcha Marg, Chanakyapuri, New Delhi
6. Brain F, Thornley J (1992) Lighting by design: a technical guide. Focal Press, Oxford
7. Wiring R, AS/NZS 3000:2000, Standards Australia, 2000, pp 132–143
8. Lerch E, Aggarwal RK (1995) Importance of system studies for industrial power system
networks. In: Siemens Circuits, pp 12–19
References 75
9. Steward WE, Stubbs TA (1995) Modern wiring practice—design and installation. Newness,
U.K.
10. Tripathy SC (1991) Electric energy utilization and conservation. Tata McGraw Hill, New
Delhi, pp 73–105
11. IS: 10028, Code for practice for selection, installation and maintenance of transformers
12. IS: 5613, code of practice for design, installation and maintenance of over head power lines
13. IS: 6711-1972, Code for practice for maintenance of wooden poles for overhead power and
telecommunication lines
Chapter 4
Best Practices in Operation
and Maintenance of Distribution
Substation Equipment and Auxiliaries
Description
A lightning arrester (LA) protects substation equipment by discharging lightning
and switching voltages over to earth. It consists of a series of spark gaps and several
nonlinear resistances including thyrite and metrosil among others [2]. A nonlinear
resister is one whose resistance is not constant but inversely proportional to the
applied voltage and decreases rapidly as the voltage across it is increased [3]. The
high surge voltage appears and allows the flow of heavy currents on the order of
thousands of amperes, dissipates energy quickly and recovers again, and presents a
high resistance value to the normal line voltage as soon as the surge has disap-
peared, so that any tendency of the arc to continue is immediately suppressed. In a
system that has its neutral solidly earthed, the rated voltage of the arrester is usually
taken as 80% of its maximum line-to-line voltage. In an unearthed system it is taken
as 100% of line-to-line voltage because under fault conditions when one line is
earthed, the arrester connected to the other two lines would be subjected to full
line–line potential.
A 33 kV, 10 kA discharge current rating of LA should be installed for protection of
switchgear, transformers, associated equipment, and 33 kV lines. Station class,
heavy duty, gapless metal oxide (ZnO)-type surge diverters in general will be
provided on the buses, high-voltage and voltage side of all transformers, and on the
incoming terminations of 33 kV lines. The arresters will conform to IS 3070.
The RMS voltage of LA will be 9 kV and the coefficient of earth not exceeding
80% as per IS: 4004, with all the transformer neutrals directly earthed.
1. Types of Surge Arresters and Their Construction Details
The development of surge arresters has taken place during from 1940 to the 1980s
in the following stages.
1. 1940s—Surge arresters with rod gap
2. 1950s—Surge arresters with SiC discs
3. 1960s—Surge arresters with SiC discs and active gap
4. 1970s—Surge arresters with magnetically blown gaps for EHV-AC systems
5. 1975s—Surge arresters with rod gap and with metal oxide discs for EHV-AC
systems.
6. 1979s—Gapless metal oxide arresters for HVDC
7. 1980s—Gapless SiC arresters with SF6 insulation
8. 1980s—Gapless ZnO arresters for various application
At present the following arresters are used.
1. Gapped silicon carbide surge arresters are used, also known as valve type or
conventional gapped arresters.
2. Zinc oxide gapless arresters are used, also known as a ZnO arrester or metal
oxide arrester. These are gapless and consist of a zinc oxide disc in series and
have superior V/I characteristics and a high energy absorption level.
4.2 Surge/Lightning Arresters 79
1. LA Testing
1. Routine test
2. Type test
(i) Routine test
(a) Sealing test
(b) Measurement of reference voltage
(c) Residual voltage test
(d) Internal insolation test
(ii) Type test
(a) Insulation withstand test on the arrester housing
(b) Residual voltage test
(c) Long duration current impulse test
(d) Operation duty test
(e) Short-circuit test
(f) Polluted housing test
(g) Internal partial discharge test
(h) Bending moment
(i) Environmental test
(j) Seal leak test
(k) Radio inference test
1. Maintenance of Surge Arresters
The following are the usual causes for the failure of a surge arrester.
1. POWERGRID case histories show about 40 LAs failed due to moisture entry.
2. Approximately 50 LAs have been removed based on third harmonic resistive
current measurements. During investigations, moisture entry was found to be the
main reason for THDC violations.
3. Mostly during the switching operation 80 LAs have failed.
4. During PIR removal field studies, LAs have not conducted even on a single
occasion in worst conditions (1.95–2.05 PU) indicating switching surge current
less than 70–80 A.
5. During failure investigation with manufacturers in 2003/2004, most LA failures
have occurred due to moisture entry and not due to ageing/conduction.
6. For transformer/reactor LAs, TOV requirements are fewer compared to line LAs
and hence rating may be different for both LAs. Moreover, in most cases, for
transformers only the residual surge travels to the transformer.
1. Causes and Nature of Failure
The surge/lightening arrester responds to overvoltages without any time delay.
According to system requirements the rated voltage, continuous operating voltage,
energy handling capability, nominal discharge current, and other characteristics of the
LA arrester will be chosen [4, 5]. Normally LA rarely fails, however, it has been
80 4 Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance of Distribution …
designed for a particular number of operations. The same has to be properly checked
during selection of a LA. The number of the discharge cycle counter should be
checked on a daily basis and when the counter is in the “RED” zone it should have
changed with immediate effect. If the surge arrester is being used at abnormal service
conditions such as excessive deposits of smoke, dirt, salt spray, or other conducting
material, the surge can be bypassed and the arrester stop failure of the equipment.
2. Primitive Maintenance of LA
In general primitive maintenance of a lightning arrester doesn’t occur. Once it fails
it has to be replaced. However, during puncture the porcelain insulator needs to be
replaced. The failure of nonlinear resistance in LA will have to be fixed. Hence in
the case of this failure, the LA has to be replaced as a whole. It is important to
choose the appropriate class and rating of the LA during selection, especially
considering environmental conditions. Please see Table 4.1.
3. Predictive Maintenance
After collecting performance records of the surge diverter on a regular basis, when
it is found that the counter goes to the red zone it is necessary to replace the arrester
at the earliest.
Protection Type
The main performance requirement of protection class CTs is that its cores
should not get saturated below its accuracy limiting factor (ALF) up to which
the primary current should be faithfully transformed to the secondary, main-
taining the specified accuracy. During fault conditions, the CT primary carries a
very high current and first few cycle have DC component, which may saturate
the core. Behavior of the cores in such condition should be such as to avoid
becoming magnetized and to return to normalcy (demagnetized stage) soon after
clearing the fault.
Load Survey Type
This is a mixture of the above two categories and is usually used for economic
management of industrial loads. The output of this CT is connected with various
distribution management systems.
These are normally used in power substations (Fig. 4.1). While designing, the
following factors are taken into consideration.
1. Effect of atmosphere environment.
2. Insulation to withstand network fluctuation.
3. To avoid ingression of moisture these are oil filled.
4.3.2 CT Type
1. Window CT: It has no primary winding construction and is installed near the
primary conductor.
2. Bushing CT: Window CT is not accessible because it is built near bushing.
3. Bar CT: A window CT but has a permanent bar installed as a primary
conductor.
4. Wound CT: Like a normal transformer, the wound CT features primary and
secondary winding. This CT is mostly used for lower conversion ratio of current
and is generally applicable in matching various CT summing ratios to com-
pensate lower current in CT secondary circuits or to separate similar CT circuits.
The instrument transformer is supposed to be maintenance-free and hence there
is no scope of filtering or change of oil during its life. This makes it essential to
hermetically seal the transformer to avoid breathing atmospheric air.
5. Accuracy Limit Factor (ALF): It is the ratio of the largest current value to CT
rated current up to which the CT must retain the specified accuracy. Example:
–CT –5P20, 5 VA, ALF = 20.
6. CT Core Identification per Class:
1. Class—0.2 s, 0.5 s, and 1.0 s: Metering core
2. Class—5P10, 5P20, etc.: Backup protection core (O/C and E/F protection)
3. Class—PS: Primary protection core (differential, distance, REF, etc.)
1. Causes and Nature of Failure
In general all this equipment is maintenance-free throughout its lifespan. However,
this instrument fails due to the following factors. Some of these devices are outdoor
types and are designed to withstand environmental conditions. Porcelain insulators
are being used for external isolation between live and ground. They provide an
outer casing for all atmospheric conditions including rain, dust, chemical contam-
ination, wind, sun, and so on. However, loose connections between the insulator
and tank, breakage of washers between them, and oil leakages from the tank are
common. It is necessary to maintain this equipment periodically.
In a power system a frequent number of power surges are generated due to
switching, sparking, and other network disturbances in the system. These envi-
ronmental causes make core saturation which ultimately damages the equipment by
disturbing measurement accuracy [8]. Due to these power surges the insulation
between the primary and secondary circuits becomes damaged and ultimately
damages the equipment.
2. Primitive Maintenance of Instrument Transformers
For a smooth and reliable power system it is important to keep all the equipment
healthy throughout the lifecycle. Hence as soon as the equipment fails it has to be
replaced. However, Table 4.2 shows the measures that should be taken for pre-
venting failure of this equipment.
84 4 Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance of Distribution …
After carrying out this test the CT is demagnetized by the gradual reduction of
voltage to zero.
5 Winding Resistance Test: Measure secondary winding resistance by micro
ohm meter.
4.3.3 PT Testing
1. IR Testing:
(a) Primary to earth by 5 kV Megger
(b) Secondary each core to earth by 500 V Megger
(c) Primary to secondary by 5 kV Megger
(d) Secondary core to core by 500 V Megger
2. Ratio Test: Inject AC variable voltage in primary winding and measure induced
secondary voltage at different voltages and verify the same with PTR.
3 Predictive Maintenance: Instrument transformers are used for measurement
and protection purposes. Accuracy of operation of this equipment is very
essential. In order to operate with high accuracy predictive maintenance is
necessary. If during testing and calibration it is found that the equipment is
going to cross the accuracy level in the near future due to ageing, saturation,
decay in winding, and so on, immediate measures should be taken in order to
avoid disturbances and have reliable operation.
1. Circuit Breaker
Description: The circuit breaker is used to close or isolate the circuit in normal
and abnormal conditions and to protect the electrical equipment against the fault.
Circuit breaker classifications follow.
Oil, SF6 gas, and air blast circuits require a specified quantity and pressure of
quenching medium for reliable and smooth operation. Quantity and pressure should
be maintained at regular intervals [10]. Indicator monitoring of these parameters
should be recorded on a regular basis. Breakdown or bends in the circuit breaker
contacts need to be attained in immediate effect. The contact force needs to be
measured in the case of the vacuum circuit breaker on a regular basis and necessary
correction taken.
1. Preventive Maintenance of Circuit Breaker
The circuit breaker is the most important protective device on the power distribution
network. Its preventive maintenance is to be carried out at highest priority
(Table 4.3).
2. Predictive Maintenance
Each circuit breaker has a counter recording the number of operations done with the
breaker. In the manufacturer’s user manual it is clearly mentioned that after a
certain number of operations the arc quenching medium needs to be replaced. The
necessary guidelines given in the manufacturer’s user manual are to be followed
strictly. The delay in time from the fault recording and circuit break needs to be
checked properly. For higher delay time relay settings and operating time need to be
checked and corrected.
The isolator (Fig. 4.2) is the device that makes and breaks circuits in no-load
condition. The isolators provided in the substation are for disconnecting the line and
equipment from the bus bar or from incoming/outgoing lines [11]. These are
off-load switches and not used as load break switches.
The various types of isolators are as follows.
(a) Center Break Rotating Type Isolator: This type of isolator is used for bus
bars and incoming lines. In this type both side insulators rotate and the break is
achieved at the center.
(b) Double Break Rotating Type Isolator: This type of isolator is used for
connecting or disconnecting the bus bar and equipment or connecting or dis-
connecting the line from the substation. In this type, the center insulator rotates
and the copper tube or blade is the moving contact. The other two side insu-
lators are fixed and they carry fixed contacts. The center insulator rotates
affording double break operation on opening the switch.
4.6 Isolators and Earth Switch 89
(c) Pantograph Type Isolator: In this type of isolator a break is vertical. The
isolator touches a bus bar when it is in the ON position and it comes down
vertically when it is OFF, disconnecting the bus bar connection. These types of
isolators are in use in our system at various 400 kV substations.
(d) Earthing Isolators: The earthing isolators are required to earth the line when it
is switched OFF, to discharge the line to earth capacitive voltage. This is very
important when people are working on the lines for maintenance purposes. The
earthing blades are attached to incoming or outgoing feeder isolators and they
can be made ON only when the line isolator is OFF. Such type of interlocks is
very necessary to avoid earthing of a live line.
1. Causes and Nature of Failure
Isolators are off-load switches and in normal operation heavy current flows through
them. However, a small gap in the contacts of the isolator causes heavy sparks and
burning of isolator contacts.
In general the male/female contact of the isolator develops erosion and burnout
ultimately causing heavy sparks and breaking of the isolator moving contact. As the
handle, rotating rod, and moving mechanism are all outdoor mechanical devices
they decay with the age of the isolator [12, 13]. This will cause loosening in the
contacts, nuts, bolts, and the like.
2. Primitive Maintenance of Isolators
Isolators can be maintained after reporting a fault in any of their parts. It is essential
to keep the contacts healthy and proper at all times. After establishing a burning
mark or corrosion on an isolator contact it is essential to clean the contacts on a
regular basis or change the corroded contacts for smoother operations.
90 4 Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance of Distribution …
During isolator operation (manual as well as motorized) the moving part dete-
riorates causing loosening in contacts, improper alignment, and so on. This can be
corrected on a regular basis by tightening nuts, bolts, and washers. Lubrication of
all the moving parts on a regular basis will also reduce the deterioration effect.
A preventive maintenance schedule for isolators is shown in Table 4.4.
3. Predictive Maintenance
After getting a poor result during Meggering of earth resistance from the isolator,
it is essential to check for the loose path of earth. All the nuts, bolts, and connectors
need to be corrected and healthy. In the process of regular scheduled maintenance
whenever improper contacts are found it is essential to replace them with a new
matching component. This will ultimately nullify the gap during the closed con-
dition and a spark will be isolated.
4.7.1 Description
In any power utility, maintaining a stable power supply at the proper voltage is
always a problem. Due to lot of inductive load, the reactive power flow takes place
in the system, resulting in the lowering of system voltage and an increase in
transmission and distribution losses [14]. The HT capacitor provides an interim
solution in improving power system stability, voltage, and the power factor.
The HT capacitor bank also compensates the losses occurring in the transmission
lines. The capacitor unit has one steel container, two bushings, and several capacitor
elements enclosed in the unit. A single HV capacitor may have a capacitance of 5
KVAr–200 KVAr. Several identical units are mounted on insulator racks and
connected in series parallel combination to obtain a high-voltage capacitor bank
(Fig. 4.3).
Before commissioning, Megger the capacitor bank between phases and earth.
The Megger reading for an individual capacitor should not be less than 50 MΩ. For
more than one unit in parallel, the minimum acceptable Megger value can be
derived by dividing 50 MΩ by the number of units connected in parallel. Before
switching on the capacitor, bus voltage, system incoming load current, and power
factor can be noted. After energizing, check that the capacitor draws almost a
balanced current in all three phases and is near its rated value. Note the change in
bus voltage, load current, and system power factor. Normally after capacitors are
energized, there will be a little rise in bus voltage and some reduction in system
load current and improvement in power factor. In the case where load current
increases instead of reducing, it shows that the connected capacitors are more than
required for the load and in this case the power factor will be leading. When the
residual voltage factor (RVT) is used for imbalance protection, measure open delta
voltage, which should be negligible. In the case where capacitors are connected in
double star with neutral CT, the current on the secondary side of neutral CT can be
measured, which should also be negligible.
1. Causes and Nature of Failure
A fuse is provided for each capacitor in the bank. The fuses will be external type for
an 11 kV capacitor bank. Sufficient clearance is maintained between bodies to the
line terminal by the proper choice of capacitor unit with an external fuse used to
avoid bird faults. When the voltage level in the capacitor bank is more than 11 kV it
is provided with an internal fuse type. In the case of fault, the faulty element will
automatically go out of circuit.
Discharge resisters are provided within the capacitor unit to ensure safety after
de-energizing of the capacitor (within or less than 5 min, the rated voltage of 50 V
is achieved by decreasing the residual voltage from crest value). The power loss in
these resisters is negligible. Each capacitor bank is protected against lightning by a
gapless zinc oxide arrester. The capacitor protection equipment includes overcur-
rent, earth leakage, and protection to detect imbalance loading due to abnormal
conditions.
2. Primitive Maintenance of Capacitor Bank
A capacitor bank is normally provided at the 11 kV side of a 33/11 kV substation.
Due to the internal chemical effect the bushing/leads of the capacitor bank erode.
An erosive lead causes poor conductivity and ultimately breaks the flow. In this
regard its bushing and leads need to be checked and cleaned at a regular intervals
for long use. The capacitor bank consists of several units of small capacitors
connected in series/shunt. Each unit should contain its separate fuse set either
internally or externally. During fault conditions the fuse blows out and isolates the
capacitor from faulty conditions. However, after restoration of the fault before
going for normal use these fuses have to be restored for smooth operation. On the
eve of failure of an individual capacitor unit it has to be replaced with a healthy unit
before the whole bank is put in operation. A preventive maintenance schedule is
given in Table 4.5.
3. Predictive Maintenance
Whenever the capacitance of the whole bank shows unexpected results, the exact
failure of the device is to be identified and should be replaced and the final result
restored.
4.8 Control and Relay Panels 93
Control or relay boards are built up by using the requisite number of self-contained
sheet steel cubicles, comprising a front panel to carry the control apparatus.
Depending upon the size of the substation the control and relay board may incor-
porate the following.
1. Simplex type: The hinged or removable back cover gives access to interior
wiring and cable termination.
2. Duplex panels: Panels are arranged back to back in corridor formation, and a
door is then fitted at each end.
A mimic diagram representing main circuit connections is incorporated on the
front panel. It is a single-line diagram incorporated on the front side of the control
panel [15]. This diagram represents the actual physical position of various HT
electrical equipment in the substation yard along with status of equipment and ON
and OFF positions of various breakers and isolators through semaphore or lamp
indication. The circuit breaker control switch is fitted on front. Normally the switch
94 4 Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance of Distribution …
is in normal (center) position. The handle is moved to the right or left to initiate
close or trip operations.
Indication lamps mounted for various purposes follow a standard color code.
Red: CB or switch CLOSED
Green: CB or switch OPEN
White: Trip circuit healthy
Amber: Alarm indication (i.e., CBs tripped on fault).
In an electric power system, bus bars are considered as the source of electric power.
They are composed of aluminum or copper conductor material, where all the loads
are interconnected via insulators. The bus bar is mainly deployed in the electrical
substation to tie the incoming and outgoing lines of the transformer and trans-
mission system; it also connects the generator and transformer in power-producing
stations [17]. For industrial applications, aluminum smelter-type bus bars are used
98 4 Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance of Distribution …
to carry large amounts of current for their electrolytic processes. Bus bar size is an
important parameter that determines the capacity of the maximum amount of cur-
rent flow. The cross-sectional area of the bus bar varies depending on the appli-
cation; for example, a 10 mm2 cross-sectional bus bar is used for small current flow
applications, whereas a 1000 mm2 or more cross-sectional bus bar is used for
electrical substations.
A bus bar structure may be completely surrounded by insulation or supported by
insulation. The bus bar shown in Fig. 4.4 is sheltered by a metal enclosure or by
elevation out and a neutral bus bar is also insulated to avoid accidental contact.
Earth bus bars are directly bolted into metal chassis for their protection. The bus bar
structure may be covered in the busducts, segregated phase busducts, isolated phase
busducts, and so on.
Clamps or bolts are used to connect bus bars with other electrical appliances.
A silver-plated surface is done in high current bus joints to minimize contact
resistance. For extra-high voltage above 300 kV, connection fittings are intended to
reduce corona which may be a source of electromagnetic interference with nearby
connections. The major types of bus bars are shown in Table 4.7 and a preventive
maintenance schedule in Table 4.8.
The rigid bus bar has a porcelain insulator, the strain bus bar is flexible, and a
stranded conductor is used to connect between the substation metal frame structures
by suspension type insulators. Generally bus bars consist of aluminum or copper
materials. The insulated phase bus bar is surrounded by a grounded metal shield and
supported with an insulator; this approach helps in eliminating short-circuits among
adjacent phases. A sulphur hexafluoride-insulated bus bar is a big metal tube filled
with high-pressure sulphur hexafluoride gas.
4.10 Battery and Battery Charger 99
The battery is used to transform chemical energy into electrical energy by elec-
trochemical reaction. The cell is the basic component in the battery, where cells are
connected in series or parallel to form the battery unit.
The battery and battery charger are small but important pieces of equipment in
electrical substations (Fig. 4.5). In lieu of a more reliable power supply source, a
DC supply is used in place of the normal AC supply. If there is a blackout, AC
power will not be available and the electrical protection devices will not operate. To
avoid any such situation, a DC supply is used [18]. The DC supply is provided by
the batteries and the charger is used to keep the batteries healthy by charging the
batteries in float/boost mode as required.
In a substation, the battery is commonly used to power the supply relay and
breaker tripping mechanism. These monitoring device operations are ensured by a
trustworthy battery power supply, leading to successful operation of that device.
Thus it is essential to maintain a reliable battery power supply by proper inspection
for proper operation of the monitoring device. In general terms, the capacity of a
cell/battery is the amount of charge available expressed in amp-hours.
100 4 Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance of Distribution …
Battery cell ability is estimated based on the discharge of the battery at a constant
current rate and is multiplied by the time required to reach its terminal voltage of
1.75 V. In a substation 33/11 and 66/11 kV rating system, the standard battery
voltage rating of 30, 110, or 220 volts is deployed for storage usage. Those batteries
usually have a rating of 45 Ah (min), 24 V to meet the load requirement of the
substation. Table 4.9 gives the cell voltage of different voltage level batteries and
Table 4.10 compares the different types of batteries.
The types of batteries used in distribution substations are as follows.
1. Flooded lead–acid
2. Flooded nickel–cadmium
3. AGM type lead–acid VRLA
4. Gel type lead–acid VRLA
5. Nickel–cadmium VRLA
6. NB: VRLA (valve regulated lead–acid) batteries.
longer and healthier battery life. The conditions to be taken care of in the battery
are how many hours it should be charged, how it should be discharged, tem-
perature limits in battery operation, and the required number of cells maintained
depending on the application.
2. Constant Voltage Charging: In the battery charging process the
constant-voltage region mode is the event where the charging battery is in
constant input voltage irrespective of battery state of charge. There is more
initial current to the battery during this event because of the superior potential
difference between the battery and charger. This approach helps the battery to
charge at a faster pace.
3. Avoiding Overdischarge: When the battery is fully discharged it is removed
from the serving load; it would increase the lead–acid batteries. The typical
cutoff voltage of a lead–acid battery is 1.75 V; this voltage is a critical parameter
related to battery operating temperature and discharge rate. However, overdis-
charging may affect battery life as well as the recharging process. Also,
overdischarging may cause lead to be precipitated in the separator and cause a
short in the cell or between cells.
4. Cleaning: Cleanliness means being clean and dirt-free, which is applicable for
maintaining the long lifetime of the battery. This would reduce expenses of
battery repair due to corrosion and dirt. Generally dry dirt is deposited in the
battery during its normal operation; it may cause blow-off or explosion because
this dirt makes stay current a conductor.
5. Avoiding High Temperature: Temperature is a harmful parameter of the
battery, which is to be maintained in a low range of 55 °C. The corrosion rates,
metal component, chemical catalyst process, and self-discharges in the battery
will increase its temperature.
6. Safety Precautions: Safe precautions should be maintained in lead–acid bat-
teries because they may expel hazardous sulfuric acid; release of hydrogen and
oxygen would cause a severe explosion and may also cause generation of toxic
gases such as arsine and stibine. These problems are conquered by proper
adoption of precautions such as wearing a face mask, aprons, and gloves when
working with battery acid components. If battery acid accidentally gets into the
eyes, it is highly recommended to flush the affected area with clean water
followed by proper medical intervention.
4.10 Battery and Battery Charger 103
In a substation a common earth bus is used for both high as well as low-voltage
systems. If the low- voltage neutral is not connected to the common earth system
but has a separate earth bus, there will be a difference of potential between the high-
and low-voltage neutrals and a dangerous potential gradient across the earth surface
can exist that can endanger life [20]. With a low-resistance earth bus and the
neutrals connected to a common earth system, there will be no danger to the
106 4 Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance of Distribution …
References
1. Pabla AS Electric power distribution, 6th edn. Tata McGraw Hill, New Delhi
2. IEEE Surge Protection Standards Collection (1992) Edition
3. Fink DG, Beaty HW Standard handbook for electrical engineering, 12th edn. McGraw Hill,
New York
4. Hornak D, Zipes D (1991) Automated bus transfer control for critical industrial processes.
IEEE Trans Ind Appl (Sept/Oct)
5. Wagner VE, Andreshak AA, Staniak JP (1990) Power quality and factory automation. IEEE
Trans Ind Appl, pp 620–626 (July/Aug)
6. Manual on Transmission Criteria, Central Electricity Authority (1985) p 15 (May)
7. IS: 1255-1983, Code of practice for installation and maintenance of power cables up to and
including 33 kV
8. Miller TJE (1982) Reactive power control in electrical system. Willey, New York, pp 353–
361
9. Pabla AS (1985) Distribution system reactive power. IEMA J, pp 11–18 (July)
10. Lee WH (1997) Power distribution planning reference book. Marcel Dekker, New York
11. Jayaraman B (1993) Earth resistance improvements. J Inst Eng (India), pp 39–40 (April)
12. Power Sub-transmission and Distribution Systems-Prevailing practices in India (1987)
CBI&P, Publication No. 198, New Delhi, December, pp 75–79
13. IS: 5613 (Part I and II), Design installation and maintenance of lines up to and including
220 kV
14. Tagare DM (2002) Electrical power capacitors—design and manufacture. Tata McGraw Hill,
New Delhi, pp 207–301
15. IEEE Protective Relaying System Standards Collection (1991) Edition
16. Bozic Z, Hobson E (1997) Urban underground network expansion planning. In: IEEE
proceeding on generation, transmission and distribution, vol 14, no 2, pp 118–124 (March)
17. Short TA (2004) Electric power handbook. CRC Press, Boca Raton, p 689
18. IEEE Battery Standards Collection (1991) Edition
19. Earthing System Parameters for HV, EHV and UHV sub-stations (1985) Technical Report 49,
CBI&P, New Delhi (Sept)
20. Grounding Systems and Practices (1989) Central Power Research Institute, Technical Report
No. 182
Chapter 5
Best Practices in Operation
and Maintenance of Transformers
5.1.1 Description
The transformer (Fig. 5.1) is static and is one of the most important devices in a
power system network. It does step-up or step-down of the voltage and transfers
power from one circuit to other AC circuits without any change in frequency. The
transformer has primary and secondary windings housed in the main tank [1]. The
transformer capacity is expressed in volt–ampere (kVA or MVA).
The transformers comply with IS0: 2026; fittings and accessories comply with IS
3639. A transformer of 33/11 kV rating should have a delta star winding connec-
tion. The favored ratings for 33/11 kV transformers should be 6.3, 8, 10, 16,
20 MVA for urban areas and 1, 1.6, 3.15, 5, 6.3 MVA for rural areas. Any standard
ratings other than stated above may also be chosen depending upon technical and
economic considerations.
The transformer ventilation can be of dry type, epoxy cast dry-type, or oil-filled
depending on whether transformer installation is indoor or outdoor. The cooling
should be ONAN or ONAF. The core is usually constructed with high-grade rolled
grain-oriented steel. Transformers should withstand combined voltage, frequency,
and fluctuations without injurious heating and produce over-fluxing conditions such
as 125% for 1 min and 140% for 5 s. The tolerable increase in temperature rise of
winding and oil should be 35 and 40 °C, respectively, over an ambient temperature
of 50 °C.
The transformers should be provided with relays such as oil and gas actuated
relays connected with trip contacts and alarm, if applicable. The tap changing
switch is placed at a well-suited position for easy operation of the switch from
ground level. For locking the switch, the handle equipped with locking is set up
along with the tap position indication. For better voltage control of transformers of
3.15 MVA and above, the tap changing device in the onload circuit should be
provided. Transformers with an onload tap changing device should have taps in
steps of 2.5% ranging from (+)5% to (−)15% voltage variation on the 33 kV
transformer winding [2].
In normal operation the power transformer is protected from various kinds of relays
and protective devices. However, during analysis the reasons for failure of a power
transformer mainly concentrate on the following.
• Oil degradation/leakage in the transformer tank
• Neutral shifting/disturbance due to failure of earthing or imbalance of the
phasewise current
• Internal short-circuit due to failure of insulation inside transformer
• Increase in winding temperature due to internal short-circuit
• Failure of protective devices including temperature indicator, relay settings, and
the like
• Overloading of power transformer without proper fuses/protective devices to cut
down the load
• Fluctuation of voltage at incomer side
• Loose contact between live parts of the distribution system.
5.1 Power Transformer 111
• Check the silica gel color. If it is pink, reactivate or replace it. Also ensure
proper quantity of oil in breather oil cup.
• Check oil level in conservator of main tank and OLTC. It should be >½ level
marking.
• Check oil level in bushings.
• Check for any oil leakage and arrest if any.
• Check the working of Oil Temperature Indicator (OTI) and Winding
Temperature Indicator (WTI) by taking hourly temperature readings. There
should be changes in readings as per loading of transformer and atmospheric
conditions.
• Check the cooling system by manually operating fans/pumps.
• Check the tap position of remote tap changer control (RTCC) and on-load tap
changer (OLTC) panels. It should have the same position number.
• Check the humming noise and vibration of the transformer. If any abnormality is
found, it is to be referred to the manufacturer concerned.
The following three factors directly affect the life of the distribution transformer.
Excess heat: Excess heat, on account of overloading, loose connections, low oil
level, blocking in oil circulation, and so on.
Moisture: The oil dielectric strength is reduced once moisture enters the
transformer through the breather and contaminates the transformer oil.
Oxygen in the air: It oxidizes the oil to form sludge and acids that attack the
insulation and make it brittle; it corrodes the surface of the inner and conservator
tanks.
Maintenance work on the distribution transformer is intended to take care of the
above three factors. The periodic maintenance checks to be carried out are given in
Table 5.1.
5.1 Power Transformer 113
Buchholz Relay: This relay is designed to detect a transformer internal fault in the
initial stage to avoid major breakdown. An internal fault in the transformer gen-
erates gases by decomposition of oil due to heat and spark inside the tank. These
gases pass towards the conservator tank, trapped in relay, and thereby causing the
oil level to fall. The upper float rotates and the switches’ contacts close, thereby
giving an alarm signal. In the case of a serious fault, there is more gas generation,
which causes operation of the lower float and trips the circuit breaker. The gas can
be collected from a small valve fitted at the top of the relay for dissolved gas
analysis (DGA).
Dissolved Gas Analysis (DGA): The transformer, in operation, is subjected to
various thermal and electrical stresses, resulting in liberation of gases from the oil
used as insulation media and coolant. The solid insulating materials such as paper,
wooden support, and pressboard cause degradation and form different gases, which
are dissolved in the oil. The most significant gases generated are hydrogen (H2),
methane (CH4), ethylene (C2H4), acetylene (C2H2), propane (C3H8), propylene
(C3H6), carbon monoxide (CO), carbon dioxide (CO2), and ethane (C2H6). The gas
5.1 Power Transformer 115
connected in the relay will help to identify the nature of the fault. The greater the
rate of gas collection, the more severe is the nature of the developing fault.
Based on the assessment of various test results, the health of the various compo-
nents is encapsulated as shown in Tables 5.1 and 5.2.
5.2.1 Description
Table 5.3 Interpretation of the faults according to the observed ratios of gases
S. Characteristic Ration code Diagnosis
No. Fault C2H2/ CH4/ C2H4/
C2H4 H2 C2H6
1. No fault 0 0 0 Regular ageing
2. Partial discharge 0 1 0 Discharge in gas-filled cavities due to
of low-energy incomplete impregnation
density gas
3. Partial discharge 1 1 0 As above but leading to tracking or
of high-energy perforation of solid insulation
density gas
4. Discharge of 1–2 0 1–2 • Continued sparking in oil between bad
low-energy gas connections of different potential or to
floating potential
• Breakdown of solid material
5. Discharge of 1 0 2 Discharge of power followthrough arcing.
high-energy gas Breakdown of oil between winding or
between coil to earth
6. Thermal fault of 0 0 1 General insulated conductor overheating
low temp less than
150 °C
7. Thermal fault temp 0 2 0 Flux influence causes overheating of core,
150–300 °C increases hot spot; pyrolitic carbon
8. Thermal fault temp 0 2 1 deposition makes joints bad contacts and
300–700 °C circulation of current over tanks
9. Thermal fault 0 2 2
>700 °C
• Loose connection
• Lightning/flood
• Moisture.
Table 5.4 lists some of the causes of failures of transformers in service and probable
corrective measures have been highlighted to reduce the rate of failure, which are
primitive alarming signals in current modern-day distribution transformer networks
across the country [4, 5].
Power transformers and reactors are critical components of the modern electrical
power system. To provide reliable, extensive, and continuous services, it is very
crucial that regular operation and maintenance of transformers/reactors and their
5.3 Operation and Maintenance of Transformers and Reactors 121
parts are well planned and carried out. The frequency of O&M is dependent on
environment, climate, service condition, and so on. A rigid preventive maintenance
ensures the long life of transformers/reactors, as well as trouble-free service and low
maintenance cost [6]. Table 5.6 lists the maintenance schedule of transformers/
reactors and maintenance consists of regular inspection, testing, and reconditioning
where necessary.
Silica Gel Breather Check: Breathers should be examined to ascertain if the silica
gel requires changing. For better results it is advised to change the silica gel when
half to two-thirds of the silica gel has become saturated [7]. The silica gel can be
collapsed into a shallow tray or reactivated at the same time as in its charge con-
tainer. Heating of the gel should be done in a well-ventilated oven at 110–130 °C for
8 to 10 h or 150–200 °C for 2 to 3 h and can be used again. Saturation of silica gel
charge must occur from the bottom. In the case of silica gel desiccant saturated from
5.3 Operation and Maintenance of Transformers and Reactors 123
the top, proper tightening of the breather to the connecting pipe and condition of
gasket is to be ensured.
Visual Check for Conservator’s Oil Level: The transformer conservator
consists of a magnetic oil-level gauge (MOG); each transformer conservator of the
main tank is fitted with one MOG to indicate when the oil inside the conservator
tank reaches minimum or maximum. The MOG dial has a scale from empty to full;
it also has some intermediate divisions such as 1/4, 1/1, and 3/4. During full load
condition, the temperature of the insulating oil increases accordingly, insulating
expanded oil and the oil level goes up. After the full load, when the transformer
load decreases the oil temperature reduces in turn reducing the volume of oil. But it
is very essential to maintain the minimum oil level in the transformer conservator
tank even at the lowest possible temperature. The entire transformer top of the
conservator tank is fitted with a MOG. A lightweight hollow ball is floated on the
insulation oil inside the conservator tank. The float arm is attached with bevel gear
and the float goes up and down depending upon the oil level and consequently the
float arm alignment changes. The MOG is float operated through the tank wall with
the magnetically coupled float mechanism to the dial indicator. The float rotates a
magnet inside the tank as the level increases beyond a certain level with the increase
in level. The oil level indicated by the MOG and top oil temperature should be
observed. The top oil temperature reading should be used to correct the oil-level
gauge reading. The corrected oil level should be in the position corresponding to
normal as mentioned in the OEM instruction manual (35 °C) range. If the level of
5.3 Operation and Maintenance of Transformers and Reactors 125
oil is standard, there is no need to take extra action, but adding the oil and removal
of oil from the conservator tank should be done if it is below or above the normal
level, respectively.
Checks on Temperature Gauges: Oil temperature and hotspot temperature
gauges are important for proper operation of the transformer. These gauges not only
indicate temperature but also operate the fans and coolers by means of microswitches
(mercury) that can be adjusted for various temperature settings. These gauges should
be calibrated on a regular basis onsite with portable devices or in the laboratory.
Winding Temperature Indicator (WTI) Test: WTI is used to indicate the
temperature of the winding based on the manufacturer heat run test. It does not have
the temperature-sensing device which is fixed in the winding hotspot; as it gives
only an approximate value of the temperature of the hotspot winding, it should not
be an accurate value. But it can be used to activate the cooling system as well as the
top oil thermometer. Winding temperature thermometers are placed near the top of
the tank; it is similar to topping the oil thermometer which has a separate ther-
mometer well without the bulb [8].
A wire is wrapped between the thermometer and temperature-sensitive bulb or a
heater coil can be inserted into the thermometer in same way. A current transformer
(CT) as in certain transformers has three leads of windings and gives current in
proportion to the winding current directly to the heater coil. In other transformers,
the CT gives current to the heater coil via an autotransformer. The bulb is slightly
heated by the heater and the temperature is shown at the indicating dial although the
value shown is not the true temperature of the hottest spot. Based on measured
temperature rises, or data from tests of a thermally duplicate transformer, bias
current to the heating coil of the winding temperature indicator is factory adjusted to
simulate the same gradient in degrees Celsius over the top oil rise as will be
experienced by the hottest spot in the transformer windings. The manufacturer
makes adjustments in these devices by altering the taps on the autotransformer or
CT, or by altering the calibration resistors in the control cabinet.
WTI normally cannot be field tested or calibrated other than testing the ther-
mometer. Current in the heater circuit is adjusted by the transformer manufacturer;
the magnitude of this current should be known to allow calibration of the unit to be
verified. The calibration resisters can be adjusted in the field if the calibration
curves of the heater current versus hottest spot gradient for the transformer available
with the manufacturer are provided to user.
• Use the local winding temperature indicator and move its pointer slowly to the
first level of cooling value (say 65 °C).
• The cooler’s fans which are set to the first level need to be checked in operation.
• Continue rotating the pointer to the second level cooling value (say 80 °C).
• Fans/pumps of those coolers which are set to the second stage need to be
checked in operation.
• Continue rotating the pointer to the alarm preset value (say 100 °C).
• Check the alarm signal received in the control room is trustworthy.
• Set the tripping value (say 110 °C) by changing the indicating pointer.
• Whether trip signal has been received in the control room should be checked.
• The winding temperature indicator bulb needs to be removed from the trans-
former pocket placed in the tank cover.
• The bulb is inserted into a calibrated temperature-controlled bath.
• The temperature of the bath is raised in 5 °C steps and the response of the
winding temperature indicator verified in a 10-min cycle up to a maximum
temperature of 130 °C. The tolerance for the temperature indication is ±3 °C.
• Now the temperature of the bath is lowered by 5 °C steps and the response of
the winding temperature indicator in the 10-min cycle is checked. In parallel
verify the transducer output; the allowable tolerance limit is ±3 °C.
• Verify alarm and trip switch configuration by changing pointer to set temper-
ature. Use a multimeter to indicate these settings and record the operational
values.
• After completing return the bulb to the pocket in the transformer cover. Care
should be taken for matching levels between temperature indicator and pointer.
ONAN Rating
• Validate isolated cooler supply is in switched OFF state.
• Keeping constant temperature of 50 °C, change the winding temperature indi-
cator bulb in the calibrated temperature-controlled bath.
• The rated current is injected into the winding terminal, a temperature indicator
test kit is used for verification, and the result noted where the obtained result is
same as the ONAN rating.
5.3 Operation and Maintenance of Transformers and Reactors 127
OFAF Rating
• A running pump is required to carry out these tests.
• Set the cooler isolator at ON position.
• Set the cooler switch to fans and pumps position.
• Ensure that pump is running.
• Turn on the heater coil and check the gradient for OFAF rating.
• Disconnect and set the cooler control switch to AUTO.
temperatures due to late activation of alarms and cooling. Transformer life may be
shortened to failure if the thermometers are not properly tested and errors are
corrected.
Checks on Gas Pressure Relay
There are two types of gas pressure relays commonly used in the transformer/
reactor. The most common type is mounted under the oil and a similar type is
mounted in the gas space. Internal arcing in liquid-filled electrical power equipment
produces extreme gas pressure; it can severely damage the transformer and also
pose severe danger to line personnel. The gas pressure relay is used to reduce the
degree of damage by quickly activating the transformer protection system. The
manufacturer’s recommendations should be referred to for adjustment, repair, or
replacement of an improperly operating device.
Pressure Relief Devices (PRDs): After the pressure release, the PRDs are
spring-loaded valves that automatically reclose. When the PRD does not operate
properly, the pressure inside the transformer is not relieved adequately. As a result,
within a few seconds catastrophic rupturing of the tank occurs, spreading flaming
oil over a wide area. Once a year, or as soon as possible after the internal fault,
inspect PRDs and test the working condition. Switch the alarm circuits ON and
make sure whether the correct communication point is activated.
Note: During operation if the PRD operates, then do not try to re-energize the
transformer. All LV tests may be required to be carried out before re-energization
and the oil sample sent for testing at DGA.
Sudden Pressure Relays (SPRs): A sudden pressure increase by arcing can be
detected by SPR. The operating time is very fast and designed to operate before the
PRD operation. Pressure is exerted at the bottom of the transformer tank; when a
sudden excessive pressure develops this would move the spring operating pin. This
operates like a switch generating further alarms and a breaker trip signal is gen-
erated. Once the relay responds successfully, the relay cap must be detached and the
switch reset to normal by resetting the button.
Note: If this relay operates, then do not try re-energizing the transformer until the
exact cause of operation is determined and corrective action taken.
• Keep the valve on the tank side closed. Open the relay test cock.
Alternatively open the drain valve/plug of the relay.
• Very slowly release the valve of the Buchholz pressure bottle to allow air
into the relay.
• Check the control room to ensure that the gas alarm has indicated once a
sufficient amount of air has entered the relay.
• Check for correct operation using a multimeter (continuity of alarm con-
tacts) connected across the alarm contacts in the relay.
• Close the relay test cock. Close the valve on the Buchholz pressure bottle.
• Vent all air from the gas and oil relay; close when a steady stream of oil is
discharged into the bucket.
(b) Trip Check
• Charge the Buchholz pressure bottle to a pressure of 2 bar (30 psi).
• Keep the valve on the tank side closed.
• Open the relay test cock.
• Open the drain valve/plug of the relay.
• Quickly open the valve on the Buchholz pressure bottle to allow a full surge
of air to enter the relay.
• Check the control room to ensure the surge trip relay flag has operated.
• Check correct operation of relay trip switch contacts using a multimeter
(continuity of trip contacts) connected across the trip terminals.
(c) Gas and Oil Relay Surge at Pump Activation
Check the status and conditions of the alarm and trip contacts of the Buchholz relay
as soon as the oil pump starts. This check is carried out manually and automatically
so that any spurious alarms and trips do not result in a faulty condition.
(d) Results
If the relay operates correctly close the bomb valve, disconnect from copper pipe
work, and vent all air from the relay petcock. If the relay fails to operate repeat the
alarm check at successive incremental pressures of 0.25 bar (3.5 psi) up to 4 bar
(60 psi) until the relay operates. Operating pressure is to be recorded.
If the relay fails to operate, isolate the relay from the expansion vessel and the
tank using the valve (see the concerned valve on the general arrangement drawing).
Drain the oil from the relay mechanism.
Blank off each open flange while investigating the relay fault to ensure that no
contamination enters the system. If the switches in the relay are faulty replace them.
Alternatively, if the relay mechanism is faulty replace that. Refit the relay into the
pipe work using new gasket material. Vent all air from the relay. Open the relay test
petcock and vent all air from the system after completion of test.
130 5 Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance of Transformers
Large power transformers are fitted with some type of cooling system. Cooling
systems generally consist of combinations of radiators, pumps, and fans. The
cooling surfaces should be inspected regularly and cleaned of foreign particulates.
This is especially important in the case of fan cooling. The cleaning should be
performed with high-pressure water flushing and proper safety measures such as by
covering the fan motor, so that the high-pressure water does not enter it [10].
During flushing, it is likely that the radiator fins get bent. They should be
straightened immediately after cleaning. Finally dry cloth and cleaning solutions are
used in the cleaning process. Normally, no measures are necessary for keeping the
internal cooling surfaces clean as long as the oil is in good condition. If, however,
sludge formation has set in, the sludge may deposit on horizontal surfaces in
radiators and coolers. If that occurs, the radiators and coolers should be internally
flushed by new clean oil in connection with the oil exchange.
The cooler bank should be inspected regularly. Cleaning of coolers is carried out
by pulling off the tube packets and making them accessible for cleaning. This
activity is to be carried out in consultation with the manufacturer. Generally all the
fan motors have permanent lubrication in their bearings and also have dual sealing
rings. The motor bearings are axially clamped with spring washers. If the noise
level of the fan increases, all mounting supports should first be retightened.
(a) Visual inspection should be done when the transfer is onload to ensure fans are
operated at the rated speed and their airways are not barren, thus saving the
blades from damage. Any fan that is running at less than its design speed will
be obvious to the naked eye. For more precise measurements, a tachometer may
be used.
(b) The rotation of the fan blades should be observed to ensure that the air flow is
in the proper direction for the type of device involved. The observation may be
facilitated if it is performed at a lower than normal speed either during startup
or immediately after switching off. Corrections to rotation should be made as
indicated by inspection.
(c) All fans that are not running at design speed should be replaced.
After stopping fans, any obstructions to air flow should be removed and any
damaged fan guards or blades should be replaced or repaired.
(d) If the motor is fitted with heaters they should be switched on whenever the
motor is standing. Check for buildup of moisture in the motor. Drain holes are
provided at the lowest part of the motor and are fitted with plugs on totally
enclosed motors (wherever applicable). These plugs should be removed to
allow any moisture to drain away.
5.3 Operation and Maintenance of Transformers and Reactors 131
(e) Regular greasing of the bearings should be carried out and as a general guide,
one or two shots from a grease gun should be sufficient at intervals of 1000
running hours. It will only be necessary to maintain the grease in the bearings.
(f) It is recommended that at least every two years the bearings and housings be
flushed out in white spirit and inspected for wear. Worn parts should be
replaced where necessary and repacked with grease.
Cooling Fan Controls: The cooling fan manual and automatic control system
can be operated; however, automatic operation is associated with the load and
energization.
Manual Control: This turns ON for a brief period to ensure that each stage has
sufficient voltage to operate. Fan operation should be observed and the oil pumps’
operation and their flow gauges checked. Refer to the manufacturers’ recommen-
dations for any malfunctions.
Temperature Control: Remove the temperature bulb from its well on the top of
the transformer; put the master control in automatic position. Using a calibration
instrument slowly raise the temperature of the bulb and observe for proper
calibration/operation.
Load Control: Verify the CT controlling secondary current operation. Remove
the secondary lead after shorting out the CT secondary (if the transformer is
energized); further current should then be injected in the control circuit and its level
varied to observe proper operation.
Caution: Extreme care should be observed when performing operations with the
secondary of an energized CT; otherwise if the CT secondary is left open by
mistake, catastrophic results may occur without warning.
(a) Cooling pumps are generally centrifugal-type pumps and as such will pump
some oil regardless of their direction. The pump has a direction and flow gauge/
indicator fitted on the top of the pump. The pumps should be manually turned
ON and OFF and the action of each pump’s flow gauge should be observed
while the pump is coming ON. The oil flow should cease or be at a bare
minimum before energizing the circuit.
(b) If the movement of the flow gauge flag is sluggish where 3-ph motors are used,
there is an indication of reverse rotation. Reverse any two electrical leads
supplying the suspect pump and re-energize. The movement of the flow gauge
flag should now be more prompt.
(c) To determine excessive bearing wear remove the pump for visual inspection.
After removing the pump from the system, the end play of the shaft should be
measured. The impeller and impeller housing should be examined for any wear.
The manufacturer’s guide should be consulted to determine if excessive bearing
wear exists as indicated by the amount of shaft end-play observed. Any
132 5 Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance of Transformers
Tap Changer Handle Operation: Move the tap changer handle up as well as down
over its entire range; check the operation before trying to attempt electrical oper-
ation. Also keep in mind that while the handle is inserted, the interlock switch of the
said handle will not allow electrical operation. In addition to this, check tap posi-
tions for the single-phase tap changers and make sure that they reached together at
the motor drive unit head. Continuity and discontinuity of the tap-changing oper-
ation is verified by connecting a multimeter across the high- and low-voltage sides
and changing the position from minimum to maximum.
Maintaining Circuit: The correct sequence of the maintaining circuit needs to
be checked by hand, winding the units to halfway through a tap and then removing
the handle. Power up the drive motor and also make sure that the motor runs to
drive the tap changer handle in the same direction.
Limit Switches: Limit switches’ operation needs to be thoroughly checked at
both ends.
Drive Motor: Put tap changer in the middle position and verify the rotational
direction. Measure the starting and running currents in both the higher and lower
modes of operation and also measure and record these values. Set the motor’s
overload to 10% above normal running current.
Raise and Lower Control: (1) Step-by-step relay operation; (2) move tap
changer one tap at a time.
5.3 Operation and Maintenance of Transformers and Reactors 133
Out of Step Relay: Shift the first tap changer in a three-phase bank to be one
position out of step with respect to the other two phases. Check the alarm’s con-
dition to ensure it is activated properly. In the same way repeat this process for the
other two tap changers.
• First check the suitable operation of the local/remote switch.
• Using local control, raise and lower the tap changer over its full operational
range.
• Repeat the above using the remote raising and lowering facility over the full
range.
• Check that neither the local nor remote switches can operate the tap changer
when it is in the other mode and vice versa.
• Hold the raise and lower pushbuttons in following a tap change to ensure it only
moves one tap at a time hence checking the step-by-step relay.
Tap Change Position Indicator: Check the mechanical position indicator to
ensure accurate indication in all positions. Also check that the remote instrument
operates in the same sequence to the same accuracy. With the remote instrument
unconnected, operate the tap changer and measure the output from each binary
coded matrix.
Tap Change Incomplete Alarm: Check whether the operation of the tap
changer is incomplete by keeping the winding unit on hand halfway through a tap
changing, including alarm working, flag relay, and also monitoring if their opera-
tion is right as well as time of operation.
Operation Counter: Ensure that the tap changer counter operates and reads
correctly.
Remote Indication: Check the remote indication switch and control facility to
prove that the output terminals of the said arranging kiosk are working fine.
Tap Changer Protective Relay: Verify the tripping characteristics of the relay
by opening the cover and pressing the “Trip” button to check the operation of the
transformer CB; ensure proper working function and then close the cover. The
following checkpoints/guidelines for inspection and maintenance should be
addressed and the manufacturer’s service engineer should be consulted for details
of maintenance/overhauling activity to ensure the absence of problems and ensure
proper operation in the future.
The following checks are to be carried out on OLTC.
(a) Manual operation on all taps and handle interlock switch.
(b) Local and remote operation and L/R switch.
(c) Matching of tap changer positions and tap position indicator.
(d) Check the working order of the tap selector handle; exchange the selector and
arcing transfer switches.
(e) Drive operations.
(f) Counter, position indicator, and its co-ordination with mechanism operations.
(g) Limit switch operation.
134 5 Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance of Transformers
After one month of service and on a yearly basis, make sure that the porcelain
bushings are free of dust and dirt; otherwise proper cleaning is required. Particularly
in the areas where there is high air pollution, salt regions, cement dust, or chemical
substances, cleaning is required regularly at short intervals. If the bushing is
damaged/highly polluted, it causes excessive leakage current and a visible mark
appears as treeing (carbon tracking) on the surface of the bushing and may cause
flashovers if the bushings are not cleaned and replaced properly.
By looking in the oil-sight glass, check the oil level in the bushings because the
level does not change with varying temperature. Stuck oil gauge pointers coherent
with an oil leak can cause a collapse in the bushing and possible damage in the
transformer and switchyard equipment. If the oil level is low, and the external
leakage not visible, there might be internal leakage around the lower seal of its tank.
In that case refill the bushing with the same oil as per the standard. An old bushing
is replaced when it has more than 25% of bushing oil capacity; the bushing is sent
for repair or it may be completely scrapped, if unrepairable at the site.
Inspect the bushing using an infrared camera regularly after one month of service
and on a yearly basis. In the case where any of the phases shows an eccentrically
high temperature, there is a possibility of poor connection; line personnel have to
verify the top connection first, however, a poor connection inside the transformer
tank leads to higher temperatures at the top also. Furthermore these faulty con-
nections should be detected by finding the hot metal gases such as the ethane and
ethylene ratio in the DGA.
Caution: When the temperature is high don’t open the oil fill plug of any
bushing because pressurized hot oil gush may result in a burn injury. Generally a
safe temperature range is between 15 and 35 °C. Some bushings may have gases
such as nitrogen in the form of a blanket on top of the oil layer which pressurizes it
as the oil expands due to temperature. Check with the manufacturer while topping
up oil or opening the bushing. Also see the directions in the special information
documents about bushings that are included in the transformer instruction manuals
at delivery.
5.4 Connectors 135
5.4 Connectors
The diagnosis of the equipment containing oil is evaluated with the following
tests; they do not check the quality of the oil.
• Dissolved gas analysis (DGA)
• Furfur-aldehyde analysis (FFA)
Give special attention to diagnostic tests, for the oil-filled equipment, and not the oil
itself. The DGA evaluates the composition of gases dissolved in transformer oil and
estimates most probable incipient faults in the transformer using various interpre-
tation techniques per standards such as IS9434, IEC 60599, IEC 60567, and IEEE
C57.104. The furfur-aldehyde analysis is generally for checking the health of the
paper insulation in the windings by measuring the 2-furfur-aldehyde released in the
oil when the insulation paper degrades. It is to be understood that these two tests are
diagnostic and trend related and not analyzed on absolute values of results.
Normally insulation oil is checked against dielectric and moisture content in an
onsite test to determine the transformer oil condition.
To do the BDV test, a 2.5-mm gap is maintained between the electrodes; a further
six tests are performed on the oil to check its breakdown voltage. The six-digit
value in the result is taken into account to check the acceptance condition for
70 kV. Refer to IS-6792 or IEC-60156 for the detailed testing procedure.
Tests for Moisture Content (Measured in ppm): Inject a sample of the oil in
an automatic moisture content test kit. Depending on the type of test kit, the
moisture may be measured by lg H2O and the measured figure could be divided by
weight of the injected oil sample in grams, thus giving parts per million units.
Generally moisture content would be maintained less than 10 ppm when the
transformer is in service condition [13, 14]. As this test is highly operator- and
kit-maintenance dependent, it is advisable to send the sample to an authorized
laboratory only.
Note: DGA frequency for new equipment under commissioning should be just
before charging, after 24 h of charging, 7 days, 15 days, one month, and three
months after charging; thereafter six monthly DGA to be followed. The frequency
of sampling can be changed depending on test results.
Frequency Response Analysis (FRA): The FRA test is conducted on trans-
formers and reactors to determine the frequency response of windings. The refer-
ence frequency responses obtained during laboratory testing serve as “fingerprints”
to monitor the condition of the transformer or reactor during service.
The frequency response of an electrical winding is obtained by application of
sweep frequency (sinusoidal). The winding will have a characteristic frequency
response for the applied signal at different frequencies. The response is uniquely
determined by the winding arrangement involved and any winding movement or
5.5 Maintenance of Insulating Oil 137
other fault will modify the frequency response due to changes in inductance and
capacitance. The sweep frequency voltage is applied through network analyzers.
The frequency response of the winding is determined between the frequency ranges
of 10 Hz to 2 MHz.
The FRA test is performed on one winding of the electrical equipment at a time.
The transformer/reactor should be electrically isolated from any other electrical
connections or systems, including earth connections during the FRA test. The two
end terminals of each winding should be made available for measuring the fre-
quency response across the winding.
• For star-connected winding, the response should be measured across the ter-
minal and neutral.
• For delta-connected winding, the response should be measured across two line
terminals and in the case of open-delta, across individual winding.
• For autoconnected winding, the response of series and common windings
should be measured separately.
For a transformer, it is normal practice to earth one end of every winding that is not
being tested, leaving the other end open. Alternatively, all other windings may be
left unconnected from each other and from earth. In every case, the termination of
each winding for each test should be recorded. The frequency response of the
winding is determined by plotting the ratio of the output from the winding to the
input in the frequency range of 10 Hz to 2 MHz.
Alternatively frequency ranges specified by the customer can be selected. The
test is normally conducted at maximum, mean, and minimum taps, in the case of
windings having tapping. While making measurements at mean tap, care should
taken to move the tap from higher voltage taps for proper comparison of FRA
results of different phases of the same or different transformers.
The FRA results are analyzed for:
• Changes in response of the winding
• Significant difference between the FRA records of different phases of the same
transformer
• Significant difference between same phase of identical transformers
The FRA test is primarily a condition assessment test and can be used in con-
junction with other diagnostic tests for detailed analysis and interpretation of the
transformer.
Dielectric Frequency Domain Spectroscopy (FDS): In frequency domain
spectroscopy (FDS), the frequency sweep measures the dissipation factor of the
insulation components. The frequency versus tangent delta measurements method is
called frequency domain spectroscopy. In this method, the frequency range is much
enhanced, especially to low frequencies.
Figure 5.2 shows the S-shaped curve where the dissipation factor is plotted in
the y-axis and the frequency is in the x-axis. The temperature and ageing curve
move towards the higher frequency scale when the moisture content increases.
138 5 Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance of Transformers
Moisture content has greater influence in the lower and higher frequency ranges; the
steep gradient shows oil conductivity in the midrange of the curve. The “hump” left
side of the steep gradient curve data helps to calculate moisture content.
Table 5.8 may be considered for determining the level of wetness and taking
necessary action for dryout.
Partial Discharge Measurement: PD techniques for detection and location are
important for diagnostics, as they not only help to identify the inception of damage
caused, but also assist in monitoring the evolving and deteriorating situation
affected by the various stress factors existing in the service condition. There can be
various reasons for PD inception. It can be the result of electrical stress caused by
5.5 Maintenance of Insulating Oil 139
References
1. Franklin AC, Franklin DP A practical technology of the power transformer, 11th edn. J&P
Books
2. Transformers. Bharat Heavy Electricals Limited, Bhopal. Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing
Company Limited, New Delhi
3. Rabins L (1956) Transformer reactance calculations with digital computers, communication
and electricals. 75:261
4. Sealey WC Equivalent ambient temperature for loading transformers. Allis Chalmers (USA)
5. Indian Standards Related to Power Transformers:(a) Specifications: i. IS 1885 (Part
XXXVIII)-1977 Electrotechnical vocabulary, part XXXVIII Transformers (first revision);
ii. IS 2026 (Part IV)-1977 Power Transformers: Part IV Terminal marking, tapping and
connections (first revision); iii. IS: 11171-1985 Dry Type Power Transformers, (b) Selection,
Installation, Operation and Maintenance: i. IS: 1866-1967 Code of practice for maintenance
and supervision of insulating oil in service; ii. IS: 1886-1967 Code for practicing for
insulation and maintenance of Transformers; iii. IS: 5216-1969 Guide for safety procedures
and practice in electrical work; iv. IS: 5728-1970 Guide for short-circuit calculations; v. IS:
6132 Shackles, Part-1: 1971 General Requirements, Part-2: 1972 Dimensions of D-Shackles;
vi. IS: 6600-1972 Guider for Over-Loading of Power Transformers; vi. IS: 8478-1977
Application Guide for On-Load tapchangers, (c) Transformer Oil and Oil Testing: i. IS:
335-1983- New insulating oils for transformers and switchgears; ii. IS: 1866-1978-Code for
practice for maintenance and supervision of insulating oil in service; iii. IS: 6792-1972
Method for determination of electric strength insulating oils, (d) High Voltage Testing: i. IS:
8690-1977 Application guide for measuring devices for high voltage testing; ii. IS: 2165-1977
Insulation coordination, (e) IEC Publications: i. 76-1 (1976) “Power Transformers”; ii.
214 (1976) “on-Load tapchangers”; iii. 606 (1978) “Application guide for power
transformers”
6. Transformer engineering, A treatise on theory, operation and application of transformers by
GE (USA)
7. Transformers for electric power industry by Westinghouse (USA)
8. IS: 2026: Specification for power transformers
9. IS: 6600: Guide for loading of power transformers
10. IEC loading guide for oil immersed transformers. IEC publication 354
140 5 Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance of Transformers
11. Reynolds PH (1975) Partial discharge measuring techniques. In: International HV sympo-
sium, Zurich, September 1975
12. Condition Monitoring, IPG International Generation, January 1993, pp 33–42
13. Studies of insulator pollution under industrial contaminated conditions. Technical report,
CPRI, Bengaluru
14. Proceeding of seminar on “Distribution transformer failures”, CBIP, New Delhi, February
1997, pp 1–36
Chapter 6
International Best Practices
in Operation and Maintenance
(Advanced Gadgets)
6.1 Introduction
Aiming to track every unit of energy injected into the system, power utilities are
increasingly being attracted towards reliable and smart technology driven by dis-
tribution system tools and tackles [1]. These devices came into existence with a
promise to improve reliability of the power system by identifying the difficulties in
operation and maintenance in power distribution systems. Using such equipment
will improve the power supply quality along with reliability. Hence technical loss
will be reduced and the system can be stabilized as a whole.
To increase the efficiency of the staff who are already working in DISCOMs
improves building operational practices, and reduces utility costs; it is a necessary
and emerging trend to create training/awareness programs on best practices in
operation and maintenance (O&M) programs. The government of India facilitating
these programs with the help of nodal agencies including MoP, PFC, NPTI, and
IITs, empaneled power training institutes (PTI) and resource institutes (RI) for the
development of material and the like. Power utilities worldwide have adopted the
use of new techniques in tools and equipment for precise measurement of required
parameters and timely saving of manpower. Failure of equipment such as trans-
formers and circuit breakers incurs considerable cost and to avoid such failure the
latest technology is incorporated in tools and equipment. The implementation of
best practice in an O&M program can reduce energy usage by 5–20% without any
substantial capital investment.
In a transmission overhead line 80–90% of the faults are transient in nature; they
most commonly occur in overhead lines due to lightning or temporary contact with
a foreign object. Normally the distribution feeders are radial feeders protected by
timelag over current relays with instantaneous and delayed tripping functions. The
circuit breaker is equipped with a switch mechanism that can automatically close
the breaker after the occurrence of a fault and is called a recloser or auto closer.
It is located on the distribution feeder network (as shown in Fig. 6.1) to detect
and interrupt transient/momentary faults. These reclosures of suitable size (i.e., load
current and fault current) operate instantaneously to clear the fault followed by one
or two reclosing shots with predetermined delays. In the case of a permanent fault,
the reclosure remains tripped off until manually commanded. The result is increased
availability of supply. It has faster single- phase reclosing and automated loop
capabilities and is mainly used in radial feeders. The reclosing structure depends
upon the dead time, reclaim time, and number of shots. The dead time setting
mainly depends on system stability, load, circuit breaker characteristics, fault path
ionization time, and protection reset time.
A recloser is designed in such a way that when the circuit breaker is reclosed on
a permanent fault, the recovery time is sufficient for the protection relay’s operation.
Inverse definite minimum time (IDMT) or definite time over current and earth fault
relays and spring winding are most commonly used to protect high voltage
(HV) lines. The operating time can vary from 10 to 30 s, depending upon fault
level. In the case of definite time protection the setting can be 3–10 s. It is common
practice to keep a setting of 30 s on a HV autoreclosure scheme [2].
One or two shots are generally used in a distribution network. It depends on the
frequency of the transient faults and the system conditions. However, three or more
shots do not imply any significant improvement but substantially increase the stress
on the breaker and other network apparatus.
6.3 Sectionalizer
The sectionalizer (Fig. 6.2) is an efficient and effective electronic device and is very
useful for an outdoor medium-voltage distribution network in combination with
automatic circuit reclosure protection (Fig. 6.3). The function of this device is to
count the number of fault occur on the medium-voltage line and open it active when
the line is de-energized. The interrupting device is either upstream reclosure or a
circuit breaker in the section. Because the fault currents are high, it is only used to
save the fuse. Therefore for this device the current rating or time current rating in
co-ordination with load- or sourceside fuses is absolutely not required.
If the fault was not cleared by a loadside protective device such as fuses or
reclosures, then the sectionalizer must control the fault. The electronic device will
actuate when the current in excess of the threshold is typically 300 mA or more, but
as soon as the actuating current reduces, it stops counting/sensing the load current,
assuming that the loadside fuse or reclosure has cleared the fault. In the event of an
actuating current, if the electronic sectionalizer does not sense a 300-mA current, it
will assume that the sourceside reclosing device cleared the fault, and the sec-
tionalizer will increase the count. These selections are not co-ordinated with the
associated source of the loadside protection device and have no direct communi-
cation. The above- mentioned conditions are based on the current measurements at
the sectionalizer locations.
A typical installation on a double-pole structure is shown in Figs. 6.2 and 6.3.
The sectionalizer is a SF6 insulated outdoor pole-mounted double- break family for
overhead lines and designed for a modern remote-controlled distribution system. It
offers maintenance-free operation in climatic conditions such as a salt-laden
atmosphere, corrosive industrial pollution, and snow and ice. The device can be
operated by electrical or remote control. For electrical control, a motor device and
electrical control cabinet are required and for remote control, communication
protocols and communication media are required.
The greatest advantages of this type of transformer are that they require less
maintenance; nevertheless, it is necessary to ensure dust does not accumulate, as it
causes a loss of cooling efficiency and hence subsequent loss of power; there should
be inspection for any connections and structure deformation.
(a) Routine checks and resultant maintenance
A transformer operational record should be separately maintained. A complete
checklist with essential observations and readings should be developed for each
transformer and properly maintained in the records in the event of an extraordinary
occurrence that could affect the performance of the related transformer and even
every event related or not with the operation of the electric system. It is recom-
mended to monitor the transformer with daily or weekly readings of the tempera-
ture, load, and voltages of the transformer. Ventilated and nonventilated dry-type
transformers have indicating devices including temperature, liquid level, and
pressure. Thus, routine checks are subject to human observation as they involve
visual and auditory observations. Also sealed dry-type transformers have pressure
gauges in them and they should also be routinely checked.
One of the most critical factors for efficient operation of the said type of transformer
is to keep it dust-free in order to prevent any degradation in its important features. If
6.5 Dry Type Transformer 147
dust accumulation is excessive, first for safety reasons the transformer should
de-energize and its side panels be removed. With the help of a dry cloth, duster, or
vacuum cleaner remove all the dust accumulated on the transformer. Subsequently,
compressed clean air can be used in the ventilation channels of the coil and,
between the core and coil, the compressed air’s pressure should be less than 5 atm.
With the help of a cloth immersed in benzene, core, ironwork, and coil impurities
can be removed, and the cleaning process repeated with a clean and dry cloth.
The ring main unit (RMU; Figs. 6.5 and 6.6) consists of medium-voltage switch-
gear and can house the fuse-switch disconnections. The medium-voltage switch-
gears generally include both the preconfigured and fully configured gas insulated
solutions. While using the tested equipment a high level of personal safety should
be ensured.
The packaged unit substation (PUS) is an enclosed construction; it avoids bird hits,
human/animal contacts that may lead to fatal accidents, disruption of supply, and
power loss as may happen in open execution. The PUS is built as a product in line
with the thinking of the architects who are quite concerned with aesthetics, safety,
and ease of installation [4].
The space to install a PUS is typically 10′ 10′ which is approximately the
space required for a car park. A saving of floor space to the tune of 80–85% can be
achieved by installing unitised sub-station (USS) as compared to that required for
conventional installation. A PUS can be installed with a tariff (TOD) meter. The
current transformers (CTs) and potential transformers (PTs) for the TOD meter are
housed in a separate cubicle with a tamperproof sealing arrangement (Fig. 6.7).
(a) RMU
Fault passage indicators (FPIs; Fig. 6.9) are used by distribution utilities. FPIs
consist of current sensors with a light-emitting diode (LED). Indicators are strate-
gically placed in the distribution network to identify a faulty network, as shown in
Fig. 6.8. The FPI detects the fault when an appropriate threshold has been achieved
[5]. The resulting sensor value output is periodically compared to the threshold.
When an overcurrent situation occurs, a timing process is initiated to decide the
activation of the indicator.
This system requires patrolling by the tripped main feeder or downstream CB on
the faulted line; the said fault is mostly located between the last and the first
nonflashing FPI/substation. FPIs are key in reducing the outage time on the
network.
150 6 International Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance …
A power system has varying power demand on the supply system; accordingly the
power factor also varies as a function of the load demands [6, 7]. It is very difficult
to maintain a consistent power factor by the use of conventional methods (i.e., fixed
capacitors and reactors). As a result, in overvoltage and saturation of transformers,
penalties are incurred by electric supply authorities. The automatic power factor
controller (Fig. 6.10) is a device that can automatically adjust the power factors
without manual intervention and suit the power factor by load variation.
It is normally installed on the receiving facilities and power distribution at large
consumers such apartment buildings and industries to enable full use of electrical
infrastructure. It automatically detects reactive power requirements and accordingly
controls the connection of power condensers to attain the ideal power factor. It has
several capacitors grouped in several steps, and is also connected to suitable
switching devices coupled with inrush current-limiting devices provided for each
step. Normally the power factor sensed by the current transformer in the line side,
and the KVAr required to achieve the target power factor are computed by the
microprocessor-based automatic power factor controller relay.
Sizing of the transformers is based on expected consumer load. The rating of the
transformers is equal to greater than consumer load for a given period of time and
the details of consumer particulars are taken from the DISCOM billing data.
Figure 6.11 shows the data obtained from the analyzer.
To understand the better utilization of power distribution equipment, manpower,
and materials efficiency, transformer load management plays a key role. The capital
cost of the transformer can be viewed as a function of load capacity. Higher KVA
capacity of the transformer is most suitable and economical to serve large con-
sumers; similarly, an overloaded (or low ratings in connection with load capacity)
transformer would be suitable for serving lesser loads to improve the power dis-
tribution equipment’s life. The TLA has load analysis algorithms that model the
thermal behavior and insulation ageing of the transformer, allowing the inherent
overload ability of distribution transformers to be exploited.
To perform analyses such as transformer owning cost software (TOCS) and the
TLA, much software is available. These types of tools can perform transformer
loading analysis on a seasonal basis, with hourly daily demand and ambient tem-
perature curves representing the transformer behavior for all days in each of the four
seasons in a year.
Principle of Thermal Imaging: All materials emit infrared energy when the
temperature of the material is above 0° kelvin. The emitted infrared energy is then
converted into an electrical signal with the help of an imaging sensor, then dis-
played on a monitor as a color or monochrome image [8]. Thermoscanner
advantages and disadvantages are shown in Table 6.2.
6.11 Advanced Tools for Operation and Maintenance 153
Windows based software for measurement, data storage, transfer and analysis
Shall measure Tan delta and power factor of all impedances (capacitive,
resistive and inductive)
Digital display of all parameters Test voltage, Current, Tan delta, Power factor,
Watts, Inductance, Capacitance, Resistance, Power loss, Frequency
The main purpose of this kit (Fig. 6.13) is to find the fault in the length of
underground cable from the base station in kilometers. The underground cable
system is commonly used in low- and medium-voltage distribution lines. The
advantages lie in its immunity from weather conditions such as pollution, rain,
storm, snow, and ice. When a fault occurs, particularly for repairing underground
cable, finding the fault location is a tedious process. The purpose is to find the exact
location of the fault. The possibility of determining the gamut of faults with dif-
ferent fault characteristics rests on suitable measuring equipment and the operator’s
skills. The right combination enables reducing the critical fault outage time.
6.11 Advanced Tools for Operation and Maintenance 155
One of the important tests is finding the insulation resistance of the electrical
equipment for safety operations. Specifications of insulation resistance are dis-
played in connecting cables, motors, generators, protection devices, and the like, in
order to limit the current flow outside the device or the conductors. The lifetime or
the IR quality may change over a period of time due to electrical stress linked with
under-/overvoltages, mechanical stress due to starting and stopping of electrical
equipment, for the case of a motor/generator balancing problem, chemical stress,
temperature variation, environmental contamination, and so on. The above causes
reduce the resistivity of insulation and thus a leakage current increase in the circuit/
equipment which may lead to serious safety problems. These tests help to deduct
ageing and premature weakening of the insulating properties before reaching the
incident described above.
An IR test applies a smaller amplitude of DC voltage (typically, 250 V DC,
500 V DC for LV equipment, and for HV equipment <600 V DC are used)
compared to the amplitude of DC voltage used for the dielectric strength test and it
measures the insulation resistance in kΩ, MΩ, GΩ, or TΩ when the phase and
neutral are short-circuited together. These measured values indicate the resistance
conditions; the higher the resistance values are, the better the condition of the
insulation. Normally for ideal conditions the IR value should be infinite; practically
it is not possible due to small leakage of the current.
Testing Methods
(a) Short-Time or Instantaneous Measurement
This is the simplest method, but its main disadvantage is the measured values are
influenced by the temperature and humidity, possibly causing this measurement to
be inaccurate. Therefore the measurement should be standardized at a specific
156 6 International Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance …
temperature and the humidity level should be noted for comparison with previous
measurements. It involves applying the DC test voltage for 30 or 60 s duration for
noting the IR at the moment.
(b) Polarization Index (PI)
The successive IR values are calculated at specific intervals, 1 and 10 min dura-
tions, respectively. The ratio of the 10 min IR value over the 1 min IR value is
called the polarization index; this value is mainly used to assess the quality of
insulation. The advantage of this measurement method is that these values are not
influenced by temperature as long as the equipment is not significantly subject to
temperature variation during the test. The IEEE 43-2000 recommendation for
rotating machines suggests that when the PI is less than 2, there is a problem in
insulation; if the PI value lies between 2 and 4 the machine insulation is in fairly
good condition and when the PI value is greater than 4, the machine has very good/
excellent IR value.
(c) Dielectric Absorption Ratio (DAR)
The DAR is defined as the ratio of the 60 s IR value over the 30 s IR value. When
the DAR value is less than 1.25, there is a problem and insufficient insulation; if the
DAR value is less than 1.6 the machine insulation is in fairly good condition and if
the DAR value is greater than 1.6, the machine has very good/excellent IR value.
The Megger Company was the oldest IR test equipment manufacturer over
100 years ago (Fig. 6.14). This tester helps to find the IR value, which helps to
verify the electrical insulation. The minimum values for the IR test vary; depending
on the equipment type and the nominal voltage, it may vary according to inter-
national standards. Some standards will define the minimum IR test values for
general electrical insulation. For example, for low-voltage insulation in the IEC
world, IEC 60364 gives the minimum IR values, and recommended test voltage.
Please see Table 6.3.
The gas detection technique has a wide range of potential uses in electrical dis-
tribution and chemical industries. A gas leak detector (Fig. 6.15) has various sen-
sors by which it detects and identifies potentially hazardous gas leaks by means of
an audible alarm to alert people. Sensors used today include infrared point sensors
(IPS), ultrasonic gas detectors (UGD), electrochemical gas detectors, and some
6.12 Gas Leakage Detector 157
other semiconductor sensors. These sensors are used for a range of applications in
power plants, industrial plants, refineries, and wastewater treatment facilities. SF6
gas is 24,000 times more environmentally dangerous than CO2.
Crimping tools are used to connect two pieces of metal or other adjustable material
by cutting, stripping, bending, and deforming one or both of them to hold the other
electrical and metal components. Crimping was developed as a high-quality,
low-cost replacement for soldered termination [10]. It is recommended where
soldering has been estimated as too expensive, complex, or time consuming to
install. There is overall less processing, and the connection will be durable due to
strain relief. It is essential to choose the right type of sleeve for the crimping tool.
There are three common crimp sleeve types used in practice:
• Round section sleeve: It is made of brass and is used for making knots.
• Oval section sleeve: It is the most widely used type of sleeve, available in brass,
copper alloys, and aluminum material.
• Double barrel sleeve: It is available in copper, brass, and aluminum material; it
is very durable but most expensive.
158 6 International Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance …
The following types of crimping tools are used in the power sector (Fig. 6.16).
• Hydraulic crimping tool: It is hand operated and pumps hydraulic fluid into the
device to compress the die. Crimping effort is significantly less as compared to
other hand-driven manual crimpers.
• Pneumatic crimping tool: Air-filled crimp tools provide an easy and flexible
crimping solution. These crimpers are fastened to an air supply, and perhaps an
operational switch. Using these tools crimping can be done at a faster rate with
high accuracy and efficiency, approximately 600 connections per hour.
• Battery-powered crimping tool: It has a motor controlled by an microcon-
troller unit (MCU), and powered by Li-ion batteries with a high-pressure
hydraulic system and is extensively used on electrical construction sites.
The oil filtration machine (Fig. 6.17) enables a process to remove oil contamina-
tion, sludge, dissolved moisture, and gases from the transformer oil. This process
improves the insulation property; better insulation leads to longer life of the
transformer and lessens the breakdown of the transformer. As a result there is a
good return on investment of the transformer. Oil filtration machines are designed
and manufactured per BIS, NEMA, IEEE, IEE, ASTM, and IEC standards.
The transformer is the most important property in an electrical power system; its life
mainly depends on the oil quality. A good oil purification process delivers filtered
oil with parameters as per standards. However, oil purification is based on the
unprocessed oil standard. If unprocessed oil does not match the standards, then the
oil purification process efforts are wasted.
(a) Step 1: The oil temperature is raised up to 65 °C. This assistance gives the oil
latent heat which later aids in separating the moisture and gases from the oil in
the degassing chamber. Also the oil viscosity drops to a certain level which
helps for better filtration to some extent. The heating system is protected against
overpressure buildup and excess temperature rise.
(b) Step 2: Removal of sludge and dirt from the oil. There are two methods used
for removal of sludge: filter candles and centrifuging action.
(i) Filter candles: Filter candles are the cartridge-type filtration in the oil
purification machine and can be further classified into two categories:
• Using classical edge filter
• Using the depth-type filter
The edge filter cartridge or depth-type can be cleaned and reused at least three or
four times, but cleaning and fitting involve considerable time and human effort. It is
difficult to handle a large quantity of sludge. In order to remove the contamination
in an edge or depth filter cartridge reverse-pressurized dry air or nitrogen flow used.
(ii) Centrifugal action: This is the second alternate method to remove the sludge.
It is used for the separation of dirt from the oil and can be slow- speed-type
centrifuges that do not additionally require an electric motor to spin the
centrifugal cone at high speed. This method can remove the dirt at more than
the 10-micron level; at less than 10 microns this method is not
recommendable.
(c) Step 3: Dehydration and degasification of transformer oil are processes of
dehumidification of the transformer oil and removal of gases is executed in the
designing chamber. This dissolved water–oil separation or dissolved gas–oil
separation is possible at reduced pressure, that is, vacuum, due to differences
of the boiling point of water, gas, and transformer oil. In the process of
separation of gases from the oil it becomes important that the aromatic
hydrocarbons remain so that the original properties of the oil are retained.
When the water level in the oil is above saturation level of the transformer oil,
oil is observed in free water. Removal of free water can be done by
power-driven centrifugal force or by the coalescing principle, where the latter
is more effective and economical in practice.
Centrifugal Filter
Operating principles: This filter (Fig. 6.18) accelerates the oil at very high speed.
As a result centrifugal force throws the solid particles on the rotor wall and it is easy
to remove the mass.
Limitations: This only removes the solid contamination up to 10 lm. The
efficiency of this filter is low when it involves removal of solid contaminants in
dissolved water, maintenance costs, high power demand, and capital.
6.14 Oil Filtration Machine 161
Mechanical Filter
Operating principles: A filtration element for suspended contaminants made up of
layers of media is used (Fig. 6.19).
Limitations: These filters can remove particles of 3 lm; however, they need
periodic replacement or cleaning of their media.
Magnetic Filter
Operating principles: Geometrically arranged magnets produce nonuniform flux
field zones that collect magnetic iron and steel particles (Fig. 6.20).
Limitations: They can only remove ferromagnetic particles larger than 1 lm
and are not suitable for water removal in free or dissolved forms.
Electrostatic Filter
Operating principles: They use electrostatic principles to draw contaminants out of
oil and trap them on the collector surface, including tars and varnishes (Fig. 6.21).
162 6 International Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance …
Advanced electrostatic filters can easily remove submicron solid particles and some
soft contaminants.
Limitations: They have slow operation and loss in effectiveness with high
moisture content and HV operating is needed.
References
1. Steward WE, Stubbs TA (1995) Modern wiring practice-design and installation. Newness, U.K.
2. Tripathy SC (1991) Electric energy utilizations and conservations. Tata McGraw Hill, New
Delhi, pp 73–105
3. IEEE Standard 446-1987, IEEE Recommended Practices for Emergency and Standby Power
Systems for Industrial and Commercial Applications (IEEE Orange Book) (ANSI)
4. IEEE Standard 525-1987, IEEE Guide for the design and installation of cable systems in
substations (ANSI)
164 6 International Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance …
5. IEEE Std 242-1986 (Reaff 1991), IEEE Recommended Practice for Protection and
Coordination of Industrial and Commercial Power systems (IEEE Buff Book) (ANSI),
Chapter-4
6. ANSI/NFPA 70-1993, National Electrical Code
7. ANSI/NFPA 110-1993, Emergency and Standby Power Systems
8. ANSI/UL 508-1988, Safety Standards for Industrial Control Equipment
9. Beeman DL, (ed) (1995) Industrial power systems handbook. Tata McGraw Hill, New York,
Chapter-2
10. IEEE Std 979-1984, IEEE Guide for Substation Fire Protection (ANSI)
Chapter 7
Best Practices in Distribution
Engineering and Automation
For losses in the distribution system and for quality improvement of the supply
high-voltage distribution system (HVDS) system it is recommended to erect a 5 kV,
10 kV, or 16 kV small-size single-phase transformer with 11 kV lines nearer to the
load and release the supply at least to the LT line. Aerial bunched cables
(ABC) cover short LT lengths.
Economics
The cost of a three-phase transformer is 1.3 times the cost of three single-phase
transformers and the capacity of a three-phase transformer is equal to the capacity of
three single-phase transformers [3]. Also no-load to full-load losses are almost the
same. However, as compared to LT, current from the same capacity is too low at
11 kV. Current is 5 amps at 11 kV and 140 amps at LT for a 100 KVA line. Reduction
line losses are in the ratio 52:1402 (25:19,600). Thus, it is very inexpensive.
The national energy policy government of India targets “A lamp for each house”
under the scheme of Kutir Jyothi for all rural areas. To implement this scheme high
capacity transformers are normally not needed. In light-load areas even the use of
single-phase transformers with capacities of 5 MVA, 10 MVA, 15 MVA, or
16 MVA are more advantageous as follows.
(i) Single-phase loads can be connected on individual transformers suitably
dividing them. For an extreme case, 4 kW or above capacity loads can be
connected with the smaller capacity of a three-phase transformer. If loads are
very low, they cannot contribute and create high imbalance.
(ii) Loads can be distributed to the other two limbs in case of failure of one limb.
(iii) Transport and replacement are very easy and can be done much faster. In fact
a rolling stock of 4% can be maintained at each distribution section office for
faster replacement.
• The ratio of power loss for transmitting an equal load in LVDS (415 V) and
HVDS (11,000 V) lines is 13:1.
• Voltage drop between distribution substations and the customer region should
not be allowed more than 10%. Hence, in accordance with IEC Rule 56 on
voltage drop, it is complex and very costly in LVDS whereas in HVDS, it
becomes very easy.
• While investigating typical LV feeders in LVDS, it was indicated that 75% of
LV feeders have a volt drop above 5% which causes high losses. But in HVDS
losses on the LV line are negligible.
• Existing conductors in LVDS are loaded above economic loading limits because
the current for distribution of the same power in LVDS is high. It can be avoided
with a switchover to HVDS.
• The number of feeders to be monitored in LVDS and HVDS are in the ratio of
60:1. Therefore the monitoring of feeders in LVDS is much more burdensome
compared to HVDS.
• In LV lines, unofficial tapping is easy and uncontrolled in LVDS whereas it is
very difficult in HVDS.
• The cables are locally available and are manufactured with tough insulation by
ABC cables.
Under a restructuring distribution scheme, the existing low-voltage lines are con-
verted to single-phase two-wire HV lines. Three-phase distribution transformers
with small capacity single-phase transformers are also replaced [4].
Advantages of HVDS System
• The feeling of ownership by listed customers would boost them to take
responsibility. As a result they would not allow others to meddle with the LT
network.
• Unofficial loads are anticipated by the consumers themselves inasmuch as
loading beyond capacity may cause the distribution transformer to fail.
• Underloading and no tapping of LT lines will minimize the failure.
• Equipment failure only affects two or three customers instead of 25–30 cus-
tomers in the original system.
• No voltage drop leads to high quality of supply.
• Good voltage and less fluctuation lead to less burnout of motors.
• Saves power purchase cost because of reduction in losses.
• Less loss leads to supplying more loads without any further investment on
infrastructure.
• The breaker trips at the substation as the line is at 11 kV potential; hence it leads
to reduction of accidents due to touching of snapped conductors.
7.2 Aerial Bunch Conductor (ABC)—Based Distribution System 169
For an overhead power distribution network, aerial bunched cables are a new concept
compared to the conventional bare conductor. They are used to provide safer and more
reliable operation of the system [5]. The economics of the overall system as power
losses are reduced and the costs of maintenance and operation are also reduced. This
kind of system is very beneficial for installation at difficult locations such as hilly,
forest, and coastal areas, and it is ideal for rural distribution. For power distribution in
urban congested areas with small lanes, ABC can be considered the best choice. ABC
is a better choice in developing an urban complex owing to its flexibility for diversion
because demands keep changing in an urban development plan.
Power conductors are made up of aluminum (neutral conductor and street lighting
conductor if and when necessary), insulated with XLPE/HDPE. These power
conductors are twisted around high tensile standard and galvanized steel (aluminum
alloy may be used) in either insulated or bare messenger wire in order to make the
aerial bunched cable. This assembly is hung directly to the distribution pole/towers
with the help of standard hardware available on the market but it should be taken
into consideration that the restored messenger wire is completely insulated in case
of HT ABC from earthing at any point of distribution. The insulation of XLPE
(cross-linked polyethylene) is black in color. Due to exposure to direct sunlight and
ultraviolet radiation, insulation needs to be stabilized against deterioration; thus
insulation is black in color. XLPE is made thermoset by special formulation from a
base polymer of thermoplastic low-density polyethylene. It is a low-density poly-
ethylene that is cross-linkable. XLPE merges the best electrical properties of LPDE
along with superior thermomechanical properties.
7.2.2 Components
7.2.3 Applications
7.2.4 Advantages
• Less fault rate because of superior protection against both line and ground fault
caused by high winds, falling trees, and birds mainly in hilly areas and forests as
seen in rural distribution networks.
• High resistance between conductors and between conductor to earth in all
seasons and even in polluted atmospheres.
• Low losses and negligible leakage currents.
• Power and telephone cables may be wound in the same set of poles or any other
support such as walls.
• Better flexibility to run parallel with existing overhead bare conductor system
without any intrusion.
• Impedance of the line is low because of high capacitance and low inductance of
lines.
• Lower voltage drop, higher current capacities.
• Better voltage regulation, much safer than bare conductors, easy maintenance,
and cost of lines is reduced.
In a large area in a highly populated country like India, the distribution and utility
network is complex [6, 7]. It is also vast and scattered over a large area that is
divided into manageable administrative boundaries. With growth in the overall area,
it becomes more complex and grows faster over time. Because there is no managed
and updated database, service connections and consumer data are not documented
properly and become very difficult to locate. Surveys have shown there is no need
to find illicit connections.
7.3 Consumer Indexing 171
Energy companies own and operate the infrastructure and assets that are in a
constant state of flux. Network assets can be continuously added, moved, or
replaced and this can be done either directly by the utility or by subcontractors or
other agencies. This work is generally planned but it can also be done in order to
maintain system integrity in response to an emergency [8, 9].
It is essential for each utility to record up-to-date assets. For the purpose of
tracking assets use of GIS technology will be beneficial.
GIS-based asset mapping is a methodology in which a satellite image is digitized
for the area of interest. The same map is loaded over portable GIS survey equip-
ment (such as a palmtop). A surveyor with that base map visits each asset and
records details of the asset along with its GIS coordinates. After the survey it is
172 7 Best Practices in Distribution Engineering and Automation
other, and with other downstream and upstream elements, thus furthering the
smart grid objectives of flexible, responsive, and efficient management of the
power supply in line with demand.
Distribution utilities in their effort to automate existing substations and other
components of a distribution network should focus on two aspects—economical
and technical—that influence the optimum control of the power system manage-
ment business.
Economic
• Cost reduction in operation: Faster fault location, clearance, and shorter supply
interruption through better co-ordinated network control can lead to personnel
and other related cost reductions.
• Cost reduction in maintenance: Reduction in maintenance cost of primary net-
work components by changing from presently followed preventive, (time-based)
maintenance to predictive and RCM (reliability-centered maintenance).
• Installation cost reduction: By adhering to retrofitting of existing equipment to
make it automation compatible, savings in cost can be achieved. Space saving
and control room building cost saving can be achieved for substations.
Technical
• Online information of system parameters and consumer loads would be useful
for online monitoring of system stability.
• Documentation of such data would be useful in future and timely planning and
engineering exercise.
• New functionalities can be added to the existing equipment.
• Setting and co-ordination of relays can be done online.
Thus in addition to the tangible benefits of improving reliability and efficiency
within network operations, DA upgrades have another important attribute: they
have the potential to deliver a strong return on investment without requiring
intensive consumer engagement or behavior change. DA technologies begin to
grasp the demand response capability of conservation voltage control (CVR) and
the energy management possibilities of dynamic load distribution, once it is sus-
tained with relatively simple remote control of field-based switches having the main
goal of increasing reliability.
Apart from a supervisory control and data acquisition (SCADA) and distribution
management system (DMS), implementation of a geographical information system
(GIS), automated meter reading (AMR) system, outage management system,
communication system, billing and business process automation, and a SAP-based
enterprise resource planning (ERP) system are possible.
In order to meet the requirements to transform conventional static grids into
modern and dynamic smart grids, distribution networks are under very high pres-
sure. This trend is influenced by the increasing occurrence of decentralized gen-
eration (DER) particularly and apart from that, the need to improve the quality and
174 7 Best Practices in Distribution Engineering and Automation
Transformers
• Circuit breakers
• Feeders
• Sectionalizing switches
• Capacitor banks
• Voltage regulators
• Small generation sets
• LT consumers
• HT consumers.
Automation could be done at three levels.
• Substation level automation
• Feeder level automation
• Customer level automation.
Automation can address the following types of problems and other jobs.
Fault location, isolation, and service restoration.
• Maintaining good voltage profile
• Load balancing
• Load control
• Metering
• Maintaining maps
• Fuse-off call operations
• Energy accounting
• Outage management
• Customer information system management.
Distribution automation requires substantial IT interventions and communication
devices/systems to be deployed by distribution utilities.
This wide gap between Indian and global best utilities needs to be bridged to
improve commercial and operational performance of the utilities including quality
of service to consumers. With the finances made available under the R-APDRP
project by the Indian government, Indian utilities have launched massive programs
of installing the required IT hardware/software. Please see Table 7.3.
Communication Technologies
UMTS: Universal mobile telecommunication system (3G system); WiMAX
(worldwide interoperability for microwave access professional mobile radio (or
private mobile radio, PMR); point to multipoint communication using VHF/UHF
frequency show the way forward towards smart grid [14].
Because the communication and information infrastructure is expected to be the
backbone of a smart grid, electric utilities all over the world are aware of the
opportunity and are already investing in them.
Collaborative smart grid demonstration projects are used to unveil the difference
in standard and open communications. These are related to the integration of
178 7 Best Practices in Distribution Engineering and Automation
distributed resources and would get the smart grid on the “Slope of Enlightenment”
shortly. The success of technical and financial investments is the area of interest of
investors and regulators.
Customers are interested in understanding whether the profit that can finally be
produced will justify the cost.
• Forced outage repair: Unplanned repairs can be called for due to existing
equipment failure, weather phenomena, or intentional disruptions. Equipment
failure is the most common cause for deployment [16].
• Weather and other natural outages: Disasters are the main cause of electrical
outages, although most often these have a larger impact on the power lines
leading to and from the substations than on the substations and transformers
themselves. Some natural disasters can harm substation operations and create a
need for mobile substation systems.
• Sabotage and attacks: Intentional disruptions such as sabotage could severely
harm the electrical grid, and mostly substations are vulnerable to attack. These
systems may be useful in returning the facility to normal operations more
quickly. This may be especially true if the attack strikes several substations,
perhaps in order to bring down portions of a large urban area.
References
1. Computer Aided Distribution Management Utility Practices, Publication No. 227, CBIP,
Malcha Marg, Channakyapuri, New Delhi
2. Wiebe M (1999) A guide to utility automation. Pannwell, USA
3. Stevenson A (1993, June) Which communication technology is best for automation?
Transmission and distribution, pp 44–53
4. Peri R, Krishna Rao MV (1994) Load control for India. Transmission and Distribution
International, Fourth Quarter, pp 26–30
5. Sehgal BK (1989) Computer aided electric power control. Power & Process Tech,
Incorporated Publication Division, New Delhi
6. Asian Electricity (1999, Mar) pp 22–24
7. Asian Power (2000, Sep), pp 65–66
8. Berney GC Intelligent instrumentation. Prentice-Hall of India, New Delhi, pp 10, 118, 125
9. Pabla AS Future technologies for rural electrification in India. In: Proceeding of international
R&D conference, CBIP, New Delhi 9–12, pp 339–351
10. Khare PN (1999) Load management by judicious load shedding. Electrical India, 28th Feb,
pp 12–15
11. Strauss C (2003) Practical electrical network automation & communication system. Newnes,
Amsterdam, pp 49–50, 69
12. Craig D (2010) Communication options for distribution automation and automatic metering.
In: Proceedings of IEEE PES transmission & distribution conference, New Orleans, U.S.A.,
April 19–22
13. IEEE Guide for Power Line carrier Applications, IEEE Standards 643-2005
14. Marihart DJ (2001, Apr) Communication technology guidelines for EMS/SCADA systems.
IEEE Trans Power 16(2):181–188
15. Gelblen L (1996, Oct) Distribution automation increases reliability. Transmission and
Distribution World, pp 38–41
16. Bush R (1996, Jan) T&D spending patterns. Transmission and distribution, p 61
Chapter 8
Best Practices in Operation
and Maintenance of Energy Meters
The energy meter is a device that records the energy consumed over a specific
period of time. It is an integral part of revenue realization in the distribution
business. All domestic and industrial consumers need at least one energy meter to
register energy consumption. Based on the meter reading, the supplier calculates the
bill to the consumer [1, 2]. The generation company sells the electricity to the
distribution company which has the responsibility to sell this energy to the con-
sumer and consumer needs to pay the bill from the distributor.
Accurate energy accounting remains elusive in the Indian power distribution
system, as utilities continue to manage with unmetered consumer segments,
incomplete transformer metering, and lack of baseline data. This leads to significant
limitations in efficient determination and loss reduction.
The Indian Electricity Act 2003 notified on June 10th, 2003 the objective of com-
petition, protection of consumer’s interest, and power for all consumers located in
various regions. It creates a liberal framework for power development and focuses
on revenue recovery and protection. Act 2003 creates an environment to run the
power distribution business as profit centers as well as encourage private investment.
In Section 55, the Act 2003 amendment explains after the two years of expiration
from the date of appointment, except through installation of the correct meter, the
The Central Electricity Authority (CEA) notification provided for the classification
of meter types, specification and standards, proprietorship, location, precision class,
installation, testing, operation and maintenance (O&M), access, meter safety seal,
reading and recording, failure or inconsistencies in the meter, tamperless features,
quality assurance, calibration and periodic testing, and adoption of new technolo-
gies in respect to the following meters for correct accounting, billing, and audit of
electricity.
• Interface meter
• Consumer meter
• Energy accounting and audit meter
All the above-specified meters should be in accord with the Bureau of Indian
Standards (BIS) [3]. If equipment or material do not have any BIS Standards, the
corresponding International Electro-Technical Commission (IEC) Standards,
British Standards (BS), or any other equivalent standard should be practiced,
provided that whenever an international standard is followed, necessary cus-
tomization or alterations should be made for the parameters such as system fre-
quency, voltage, ambient temperature, humidity, and other conditions prevailing in
India before actual adoption of the said international standard; the standards on
“Installation and Operation of Meters” as specified in the schedule annexed to these
regulations and as amended from time to time should be followed.
Table 8.1 Location of interface, consumer, energy accounting, and audit meters
S. Stages Main meter Check Standby meter
No. meter
1. Generating station All outgoing feeders All • HV side of generator
outgoing transformer
feeders • HV side of all station
auxiliary transformers
2. Transmission and • For same licensee, – • No separate standby
distribution system one end of the line meter
between the • In the case of two
substations different licensees,
• For two licensees, meter installed at
both ends of the line other end of the line
between substations; works as standby
for respective meter
licensees, meters at
both ends considered
as main meters
3. Interconnecting HV side of ICT – LV side of ICT
transformer (ICT)
4. Directly connecting As directed by appropriate commission
consumers to the inter/
intra-state transmission
system, covered under
ABT and permitted
open access by the
appropriate
commission
(continued)
184 8 Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance of Energy Meters
Meters can be classified in the following manner as per their technology, use,
location, and so on.
(i) Consumers with open access permission by the proper commission should be
provided with an interface meter; this meter interconnects the inter- or
intra-state transmission system [4, 5].
(ii) The consumer who is connected to the distribution system and allowed open
access should have the provision of interface meters as per directions of the
proper commission.
(iii) The licensee connected to a central or state transmission utility should submit
the location of interface meters in advance before the installation.
• The licensee should install this meter either inside or outside the consumer
premises.
• When the licensee installs the meter outside the consumer premises, he or she
should provide a realtime display unit to indicate the electricity consumed by the
consumer.
• The consumer meter reading should be taken into account, not the display unit,
for billing purposes.
• When the commission allows, the direct electricity supply from the generation
company to the consumers on a separate transmission system and the location of
meters should be per the mutual agreement between them.
8.5 Meter Classification per Technology, Use, and Locations 185
These meters are installed at the locations to facilitate the energy generated,
transmitted, distributed, and consumed in the various parts of the power system and
the energy loss [6]. The location of these meters should be as follows.
(i) Generating Stations:
• At the generator stator terminal.
• Generating station and unit auxiliary transformers high- and low-voltage
sides.
• Feeders to various auxiliaries.
(ii) Transmission Stations:
• Energy accounting and audit of meters are installed for all incoming and
outgoing feeders whenever interface meters do not exist.
(iii) Distribution System:
• Energy accounting and audit meters are installed for all incoming and
outgoing feeders for the distribution system, when the system voltages
are 11 kV and above.
• Depending upon the necessity for energy accounting and audit, the
licensee may provide the meter on the primary or secondary side or both
sides of the substation transformer including any distribution transformer.
There are various types of communication facility available in energy meters. These
ports enable easy, accurate, and automated meter reading. Nowadays meters having
multiple communication ports are available [7, 8]. Some of the variety is as follows.
a. Optical communication
b. RS 232 communication
c. RS 485 communication
d. RJ 11 communication
e. Modem communication
f. Radio frequency (RF) communication
186 8 Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance of Energy Meters
Meters are read using a meter reading instrument (MRI), wireless communicator for
RF meters, or through automatic meter reading (AMR) [9]. In a direct MRI
downloading meter, the meter reader carrying a handheld device reaches each
metering site, connects the optical port/RS Port/RJ port of the meter and downloads
meter data as required. In modem-connected meters, the meter reader need not visit
the metering location each time. Meter data can be downloaded from the central
server located at the office by using the GSM/GPRS/CDMA/3G network. Today the
central server has a scheduler using this meter scheduled to read at a particular date
and time. Manual interference can be completely avoided using this methodology.
In the RF communication method, the meter reader has to visit the metering site and
search for nearby meters within the accessible range (normally 50–100 m). After
finding the meter the same can be downloaded by establishing wireless commu-
nications [10].
8.8 Meter Calibration and Periodical Testing 187
• The accuracy of each interface meter is tested using a standard reference meter
by the owner at the site at the time of commissioning.
• Periodic testing is required to ensure accuracy, and also to avoid malfunctioning.
As per the standard, meters are tested at least once in five years.
• The meters should be tested via a NABL-accredited mobile laboratory or by any
accredited laboratory and recalibrated if meter records any abnormal or incon-
sistent electrical quantity as required by the manufacturer’s works.
• Advance notice should be sent to the customer from the supplier to intimate the
date and timing of testing; it is carried out in the presence of representatives
from both sides.
• The accuracy of each consumer meter is tested using a standard reference meter
by the owner at the site at the time of commissioning.
• Periodic testing is required to ensure accuracy, and also to avoid malfunctioning.
As per the standard, meters are tested at least once in five years.
• The testing of the said consumer’s meter above 650 V should cover the
metering system including CTs, VTs, and the like. The meters may be tested
through a NABL-accredited mobile laboratory or by any accredited laboratory
and recalibrated if the meter records any abnormal or inconsistent electrical
quantity as required at the manufacturer’s works.
• Advance notice should be sent to the customer from the supplier to intimate the
date and timing of testing; it is carried out in the presence of representatives
from both sides.
• The accuracy of each consumer meter is tested using a standard reference meter
by the owner at the site at the time of commissioning.
• Periodic testing is required to ensure accuracy for both check meters and
standby meters, and also to avoid malfunctioning. As per the standard, meters
are tested at least once in five years without removal of CTs and PTs.
• The meters may be tested by a NABL-accredited mobile laboratory or by any
accredited laboratory and recalibrated if the meter records abnormal or incon-
sistent electrical quantity using a measuring unit, secondary injection kit,
phantom loading, and so on, as required at the manufacturer’s works.
188 8 Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance of Energy Meters
To avoid erroneous meter readings, the following points should be taken care of
while installing meters.
(i) Reversal of phase and neutral connection (single-phase).
(ii) Reversal of load connected on middle phase and earth (three-phase three-
wire system).
(iii) Bypassing of neutral wire (three-phase four-wire meter).
(iv) Use of protection core of the meter.
(v) Influence of CT and PT wires.
• Long lead CT wires.
• Small size of the conductor.
(vi) For distribution transformer metering meter should be on LT side only.
• Meter specification should be of outdoor type; LT CT meters preferable.
• Best to locate so as to account for ATC loss.
(vii) For industrial and commercial metering ideal to locate near the front gate.
(viii) For agricultural supplies.
• Preferable on DT of each consumer.
• Meter should be located on the pole.
• Load restriction with built-in switches.
(ix) Outdoor type of meter mounting to be done inside enclosure.
(vi) Use of crimped joint and not twist joint when joining two wires.
(vii) Protection fuses must be used as per practice and appropriate places only.
(viii) Crossing of wire at meter terminals must not be allowed.
(ix) All wires must be numbered and ferruled for easy identification.
(x) No exposure of XLPE insulation.
• UV susceptible.
• Applying insulation tape is not the solution.
• Crutch point is highly vulnerable.
• Use of heat shrink breakout and sleeve.
• Embedding lug protection in sleeve.
(xi) Use of double-bolted long barrel lugs in LT side of distribution transformer.
(xii) Improper wiring of neutral wire for four-wire meters.
(xiii) Undersized neutral wire in three-phase loads.
(xiv) Adopting single earth wire return system in single-phase system.
(xv) Installing meter without confirming secondary CT rating.
Example
The time of occurrence and duration of the tamper is recorded separately phasewise
for each tamper for the latest 10 tampers. The number of tamper counts of each type
of tamper is also recorded [11, 12].
If a tamper condition exists at the time of total power failure, then at the time of
recovery of power, the tamper condition still continues without an increment in the
tamper count. The power-off time is not added to the tamper condition.
Make 10 tampers of each type (R, VF), collect the data, and check for continuing
tamper, tamper status, tamper count, tamper occurrence date and time, and tamper
duration. Create one more event (R, VF); the first event will be erased and the
second event will be shifted to the first event memory, the tenth event to the ninth
event place and the new event will occupy the tenth event memory.
190 8 Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance of Energy Meters
(ii) Sequential Storage: All tamper events will be recorded sequentially. There is
no separate memory allocation for each type of tampering. Any one tamper
can occupy complete memory if others do not exist, but in block a separate
memory is allocated for each tamper.
Example
The time of occurrence and duration of the tamper is recorded separately phasewise
for each tamper. The number of tamper counts of each type of tamper is also
recorded. The tamper is recorded in the sequence of occurrence.
If the maximum tamper count is 100 events, make any 100 tampers, collect the
data, and check for continuing tamper, tamper status, tamper count, tamper
occurrence date and time, and tamper duration. Create one more event; the first
event will be erased and the second event will be shifted to the first event memory,
the 100th event to the 99th event place and the new event will occupy the 100th
event memory (FIFO) [13, 14].
(1) Snapshots: Snapshots mean voltage, current, PF, kWh, and KVAH will be
logged into memory at the time of occurrence or restoration of any type of
tamper. Snapshot parameters vary from customer to customer.
(2) Load survey snap: Tamper and power fail snaps will be shown in the LS
integration period if any tamper and power fail has occurred during that period.
It can be checked on the spreadsheet as well as on a graph.
(3) Total power fails: Power fail records are recorded separately. The time of
occurrence and duration of power fail is recorded for the latest 10 power
failures. The power fail count is also recorded. Total power on duration is
recorded as well.
(4) Indications for voltage and current:
• 123 indication will be on LCD if phase voltage > 20% Vn
• 1. R phase
• 2. Y phase
• 3. B phase
• 123 will start blinking if phase current > 2% In
(5) Persistence time: Persistence time is the minimum time to identify the tamper
with the tamper threshold by default occurrence; the time is 2 min and
restoration time is 1 min.
(6) Event: Event means either occurrence or restoration of tamper.
(7) Anomaly on display: “*” (Star) will show on the LCD display after confir-
mation of any tamper and will clear after recovery of all tampers. The star will
appear for any tamper occurrence.
8.12 Meter Testing 191
Energy meters are the heart of the distribution business. Revenue inflow to the
power systems is guarded by energy meters. A distribution engineer is always
behind accurate metering of the energy. There are various guidelines issued by
regulators for periodic meter testing [15].
Regulators have already defined the periodicity of a routine test for different kinds
of meters. Obeying the same regulations, the testing engineer visits the metering site
with all the metering testing devices. He or she inspects the site, sealing the con-
dition of the meter in the presence of the customer/customer executive. The testing
engineer tests the accuracy of the meter with a portable site meter testing device.
That meter testing device has to be calibrated from a NABL-accredited laboratory.
After completion of the test, the testing engineer fills the meter inspection report
and gets consent from the consumer’s representative. In the case of any sign of
theft/inaccuracy, the testing engineer opens the meter and seals it for Panchanama
and invites the customer for joint inspection.
Normally joint inspection of a meter is carried out if any tamper/misuse of the meter
is detected. In this case the sealed meter is opened in front of the consumer,
accessing authority, and manufacturing company’s representative (if any). The
meter is tested at a laboratory for accuracy calculation and witnessed by all. Where
any tampering is detected the subsequent penalty is charged.
192 8 Best Practices in Operation and Maintenance of Energy Meters
Electricity theft is a very big international problem in power utilities; nearly 20% of
the electricity produced is stolen annually and creates big revenue losses. These
costs are then usually imposed on honest consumers in the form of higher tariff
rates. It is the responsibility of the distribution company and engineer to design a
positive, reliable, security seal to enable checks on such theft. Specially designed
seals are available on the market and specially researched designs enable the meters
to be impossible to be tampered with without a trace. Once the said seal is broken it
cannot be joined or returned to the meter [16]. The seal is designed for one-time use
only and cannot be accidentally opened and must be deliberately cut by cutting
pliers for its removal. The see-through body enables easy detection of internal
tampering.
Following are some of the advanced variety of seals.
a. Met grip seals
b. Paper seals
c. Anchor security seal
d. Valve/meter cable seal
e. Tamper-evident security seal (with continuity check).
The meter data acquisition (MDA) system can acquire data from energy meters
connected through an optical port/serial communication cord with all major meter
manufacturers using GSM/GPRS/CDMA technologies. The meter data acquisition
has these features:
• The data extraction can be granular (based on type of data, e.g., billing,
instantaneous, load profile, etc.) and is incremental in order to minimize the data
volume.
• The scheduling feature allows the user to configure the acquisition schedules for
a location, set of meters, or for the office hierarchy such as division or
subdivision.
• The system maintains a complete history of metering points and can compare
datapoints of the same or different metering points.
• It supports report server integration.
• The system is scalable and integration with other applications of IT
infrastructure.
• The solution is built on Java, XML, and Oracle technologies and has a browser-
based Web interface for access.
8.14 Latest Advanced Technology in Metering 193
References
1. Orchard N (2000, Oct) The advance of metering. Utility Automation International, pp 31–32
2. Handbook for Electricity Metering (2002, Apr) 10th Edition. Edison Electric Institute, USA,
pp 199–209
3. AMR/Metering Handbook (2006) The electricity forum. Ontario, Canada
4. Fryers T (2005) Metering international, issue 3, pp 84–85
5. IS Standards Related to metering: (i) IS: 13010, ac electricity meters induction type class
2,1,0.5. (ii) IS: 13779, ac electricity electronic meters class 2 and 1. (iii) IS: 14697, CT/PT
operated ac electronic watthour meters class 2 and 1. (iv) IEC: 62053-11, ac electromechan-
ical Kilo watthour meters class 2,1,0.5(v) IEC: ac electronic (static) kWh meter 60687 (class
0.2 s and 0.5 s) (vi) IEC: ac electronic (static) kWh meter 61036 (class 1 and 2) (vii) IEC:
61268, ac electronic reactive energy meters (class 1 and 2) (viii) IEC: 60044-1-2,
Instrumentation Transformers (CT and PT)
6. Forst & Sullivan (2008) AMR market Report
7. Chris Bread and Logica (2008) Smart metering or dummies. Wiley, United Kingdom,
8. Central Electricity Authority (Installation and Operation of Static Meters) regulations (2006)
9. IEE conference publication No 462, Metering and Tariffs for Energy Supply, 25–28 May,
1999
10. Prepaid Electricity Meters: IEC 62055-41 and IEC 62055-51
11. Ripple control receivers for tariff and load control IEC 61037
12. Fryers T (2005) Metering internationals, issue 2, pp 84–85
13. IEC Standard 60044-7 Voltage Sensors (Electronic Voltage Transformers)
14. IEC Standard 60044-8 Current Sensors (Electronic Current Transformers)
15. Central Electricity Regulatory Commissions (2008) (Open Access in Inter-State
Transmission) Regulations
16. Economic Growth in the Future (1976) Edison Electric Institute, McGraw Hill Book
Company, New York, pp 257–286