Strip Clading
Strip Clading
Strip Clading
STRIP CLADDING
1. INTRODUCTION
To the manufacturer of pressure vessels, surfacing techniques are getting more and
more important. Components reach sizes such that their fabrication calls upon the
use of clad materials.
There are different processes to obtain a clad material :
- clad plates produced by rolling which are mostly only available in standardised
dimensions and grades
- explosion clad plates
- clad plates made by welding
Among all the welding processes submerged arc and electroslag strip cladding offer
maximum deposition rate, better bead characteristics and trouble free operation
using unsophisticated welding equipment. Strip cladding is also a very flexible
process covering a very wide range of applicable materials.
The fact that in general it is used to clad finish shaped components eliminates the
eventual problems arising with cold or hot forming.
The principle of strip cladding was developed about 70 years ago (the first patent was
granted in the USA around 1920) but in Europe the process retained detailed
attention when the nuclear industry started (late 1950's).
The nuclear power industry needed a method whereby thick- wall pressure vessels
could be given a corrosion resistant inner surface.
Several modifications of submerged-arc welding with strip have been developed
mainly with a view to further increase surfacing capacity.
In the first part of this paper the SUBMERGED ARC STRIP CLADDING process will be
discussed, in the second part the ELECTROSLAG STRIP CLADDING technique will
be described. The influence of the working parameters will be given and the main
advantages and limitations will be listed.
2. THE SUBMERGED ARC STRIP CLADDING PROCESS.
The main advantages of the strip process over the wire processes can be
summarised as follows :
- the fact that the flux is fed only on the front side of the strip
- a visible weld pool at the rear side of the strip
- a radiation only in the visible and infrared spectrum, no ultraviolet radiations
because of the absence of any arc
- an additional feature (magnetic control device) is used to optimise the weld
bead profile
In view of keeping the strip feed rate and voltage variations within very
narrow limits imposed with regard to the shallow depth of the slag pool, it is
advised to use DCCP rectifiers.
Since the electroslag process requires average optimised current densities
of approx 40 A/mm2, the output of the power sources at a 100% duty cycle
has to meet high amps such as 1250 A for a 60 mm strip (typical). In
practice to obtain the required current intensity levels two power sources
can be connected in parallel. It should be checked with the manufacturer
whether given DCCP power sources can be connected in parallel without
any additional precautions.
To obtain optimum welding conditions and bead profile, it is necessary to
use a power source which will give stable voltage outputs between 21 - 27
volts.
The function of the welding head is to feed the strip at a constant speed
which is related to the welding parameters.
The strip feed rates for the electroslag process range from 1 to 2,5 m/min. In
practice no special welding heads are required to carry out electroslag strip
cladding.
The main functions of the feeding nozzle are to guide the strip and to
maintain it in the required position during the welding operation and to
transfer the welding current from the power source to the strip by means of
appropriate contact shoes. There is no fundamental difference in design
between the sub arc and the electroslag feeding nozzle, however because of
the high current densities involved, and due to the fact the rear side of the
electroslag is subject to the heat radiation from the slag pool, their
construction is generally somewhat heavier. The electroslag nozzle is also
equipped with a water cooling possibility. FIG 13 shows the most classic
nozzle 125 ES1-300 which can be used with strip widths from 30 mm up to
120 mm width.
3.2.4. Magnetic steering device
The location of the solenoids are very important. The tips should be placed
beside the strip electrode at a distance of approx 15 mm from the strip edge
and about 15 mm above the base material surface.
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
Comparison between
Comparaison of déposit rate SAW ESW HS SL
ESW ESW
Current ( A ) : 750 1250 1400 1250
Voltage ( V ) 26 24 24 24
Speed (cm/min ) 10 16 30 16
Dilution ( % ) 18 9 22 7
Ch LOUPPE
C content (%) 0,045 0,030 0,055
Ch LOUPPE
0,020
on 0.18%C Steel
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
Depo. Rate 0.45 0.69 1.1 0.72 Thickness 8.0 6.2 4.0
( m²/h) Ch LOUPPE ( mm) Ch LOUPPE
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
1
24V 15 cm/min Stick-out : 30mm 1250 A 24 V Stick-out : 30mm
1
Variation of the chemical composition
1250 A 16 cm/min Stick-out : 30mm EST 316-1
1250 A 16 cm/min Stick-out : 30mm EST 316-1
% Cr Recycled
% Cr Val. Medi +/- 2%
Val. Medi +/- 2%
20,0
20,0
19,70
19,6 19,5 19,4 19,4
19,4 19,5
19,5 19,50
19,40
19,12
19,01 19,0
19,0 18,9
18,8
19,1 18.74
18,5
18,5
Ch LOUPPE 1 2 3Ch LOUPPE 4
22 24 26 28 Volts
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
1250 A 16 cm/min Stick-out : 30mm EST 316-1 1250 A 16 cm/min Stick-out : 30mm EST 316-1
13,5 13,5
13,14
13.0 13.2 13.0 12.9
13,0 12,90 13,0 13,00
12.6
12,75
12,64
12,5 12,5 12,48
12.7 12.7
12.5
22 24 Ch LOUPPE 28
26 Volts 1 2 3Ch LOUPPE 4
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
1250 A 16 cm/min Stick-out : 30mm EST 316-1 1250 A 16 cm/min Stick-out : 30mm EST 316-1
Recycled
% Mo Val. Medi +/- 2% % Mo Val. Medi +/- 2%
3,0 3,0
22 24 Ch LOUPPE 28
26 Volts 1 2 3Ch LOUPPE 4
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
1
δ FERRITE DETERMINATION δ FERRITE DETERMINATION
DELONG WRC 88
Chemical composition : The amount of ferrite depend of the ferrite promoters
( such as chromium) and austenite promoters ( such as NICKEL).
Different diagrams should be used as prediction tools, the most accurate diagram is
Cr equiv. Ni equiv. Cr equiv. Ni equiv.
WRC 1992.
For standard stainless steel, the precision of the chemistry ( by spectro ), for Cr, Ni, Min value 23.0 15.6 22.3 14.6
Mo, Nb, … : is about +/- 2%, and for the other element like C, N, .. +/- 5%.
Following the AWS, variations in the results of chemical analyses encountered from VALUE 23.5 16.0 22.8 15.0
Ch LOUPPE
laboratory to laboratory can have a significant effects on the calculated ferrite value, Ch LOUPPE
changing it as much as 4 to 8 FN ( SFA 5.4 A6.10.4 edition 1995) Max value 24.0 16.4 23.3 15.4
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
12,5
AWS : Cr , Ni : +/- 1%
11,5
14.6 Deposit : Cr eq: 19
22.3 23.3
Cr eq : max 20, min 18
Cr eq. 10,5
Deposit : Ni eq: 11,5
Weld déposit : 317L Ni eq : max 12,5, min 10,5
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
22.3 18 19 20
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
1
Welding direction
Welding direction
Strip
Molten pool
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
Ch LOUPPE
Ch LOUPPE
1
Setting the magnetic steering Setting the magnetic steering
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
S: 5A N : 5A S: 2A N : 3A
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
1
Adjustment of strip nozzle
Drive rolls
The spool of strip should be positioned
to feed into the nozzle without twisting
and without excessive braking on the
spool holder
Ch LOUPPE
Cable section
1
Tension
Ch LOUPPE
Ch LOUPPE
1
S 2°bead N
Strip S 1°bead N Welding
direction
Contact
shoe Strip
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
Strip Welding
Strip direction
Cladding 45°
Effective width
Weld
Base material Sometimes , it is necessary to produce a
cladding narrower than the strip. This
may be produced by using a strip with a
angle to reduce the effective width of the
bead
The width of the lane should The greater the angle of the strip, the
ideally have been designed narrower the bead width
to accept a single run of To maintain the same dilution and
weld with a strip at 90°. thickness of the deposit, we need to
If not, it may be necessary increased the speed ONLY.
to angle the strip as follow The new
Ch LOUPPE Chspeed
LOUPPEis be calculated as follow
. Strip width X original speed . ..
Ch LOUPPE Ch … effective width of the bead
LOUPPE
Rotation
STRIP
STRIP Welding direction
Vessel
Max 2°
40 – 65 mm
Always clad in a small UP HILL
position ( max 2° ) , in this case In case of cladding inside a
the weld metal flows back, and curved surface, like inside a
the base metal is exposed and shell, the strip should be in front
the penetration increase, and the of the “bottom dead centre” to
risk of lake of fusion decrease. be in small UP HILL position .
Ch LOUPPE
Ch LOUPPE
1
Starting the weld
Cut the strip at an angle of 45° for easier starting bottom dead centre
It is usually better to start the welding power , in view of melt a small Welding direction
quantities for flux and strip before starting the travel speed.
Stopping the weld. Rotation
It is usually better to cut the travel speed, before cutting the welding power. STRIP
STRIP Welding direction
Vessel
Max 2°
40 – 65 mm
Always clad in a small UP HILL
position ( max 2° ) , in this case In case of cladding inside a
the weld metal flows back, and curved surface, like inside a
the base metal is exposed and shell, the strip should be in front
the penetration increase, and the of the “bottom dead centre” to
risk of lake of fusion decrease. be in small UP HILL position .
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
S 2°bead N
Strip S 1°bead N Welding
direction
Contact
shoe Strip
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
Strip Welding
Strip direction
Cladding 45°
Effective width
Weld
Base material Sometimes , it is necessary to produce a
cladding narrower than the strip. This
may be produced by using a strip with a
angle to reduce the effective width of the
bead
The width of the lane should The greater the angle of the strip, the
ideally have been designed narrower the bead width
to accept a single run of To maintain the same dilution and
weld with a strip at 90°. thickness of the deposit, we need to
If not, it may be necessary increased the speed ONLY.
to angle the strip as follow The new
Ch LOUPPE Chspeed
LOUPPEis be calculated as follow
. Strip width X original speed . ..
Ch LOUPPE Ch … effective width of the bead
LOUPPE
1
Soudotape NiCrMo 22
Record EST 201 C
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
Mercantile
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
Soudotape 625
Record
EST 201
Whitely
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
Read Ltd
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
CSI
SOUDOTAPE 420 Record EST 420
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
2
Gas tube plate
surfaced with
Valves
ESW using
cladded with
Soudotape Soudotape 625
625 (30*0.5) and Record
and Record EST 201
EST 236 cooler
(ESW) and
Record NFT
201 (SAW)
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
Offshore
ESW dia
800mm- separator vessel
wallthickn (dia 2.5m) using
40mm , length Soudotape
4m) NiCu7
Using (60*05)and
Soudotape Record EST
24.12LNb with
Record EST 400.
136
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
Tube for
process furnace Vessel
(dia 2.6m, bottom
lenght 4.5m, overlayed
wall thickn with the
40mm – ESW
Cladded with process
Soudotape using
NiCrMo 7 Soudotape
(60*0.5) and 21.13.3L
Record EST
(60*0.5)
201C (alloy C4)
and Record
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
EST 122.
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
3
ESW surfacing
of chemical
vessel with Electroslag strip
316L using cladding with
Soudotape 625
Soudotape
(30*0.5) and
316L and
Record EST 236
Record EST (pipe dia approx
316-1 45 cm)
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
ESW Conical
surfacing of carbon
chemical crusher
vessel with overlaye
316L using d with
Soudotape
316L and
Soudotap
Record e 625
EST 316-1 and
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
Record
NFT 201
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
Soudotape 430
(60*0.5) and
10mm
Record EST
452 (3 layers -
surface
hardness
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE
370HB
Ch LOUPPE Ch LOUPPE