Warren SM ch.13 Final
Warren SM ch.13 Final
Warren SM ch.13 Final
705
PRACTICE EXERCISES
PE 13–1A
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3
Amount distributed............................... $ 15,000 $ 5,000 $ 62,000
Preferred dividend (5,000 shares)....... 8,000 5,000 11,000*
Common dividend (10,000 shares)...... $ 7,000 $ 0 $ 51,000
*(3,000 + 8,000)
Dividends per share:
Preferred stock.............................. $1.60 $1.00 $2.20
Common stock.............................. $0.70 None $5.10
PE 13–1B
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3
Amount distributed............................... $ 30,000 $6,000 $80,000
Preferred dividend (10,000 shares)..... 10,000 6,000 14,000*
Common dividend (25,000 shares)...... $ 20,000 $ 0 $66,000
*($4,000 + $10,000)
Dividends per share:
Preferred stock.............................. $1.00 $0.60 $1.40
Common stock.............................. $0.80 None $2.64
PE 13–2A
PE 13–3A
Oct. 6 Cash Dividends.................................................... 112,750
Cash Dividends Payable................................ 112,750
Nov. 5 No entry required.
Dec. 5 Cash Dividends Payable...................................... 112,750
Cash.................................................................. 112,750
PE 13–3B
July 1 Cash Dividends.................................................... 61,500
Cash Dividends Payable................................ 61,500
Aug. 1 No entry required.
Sept. 30 Cash Dividends Payable...................................... 61,500
Cash.................................................................. 61,500
PE 13–4A
May 10 Stock Dividends (100,000 × 2% × $48)............... 96,000
Stock Dividends Distributable (2,000 × $40) 80,000
Paid-In Capital in Excess of Par—
Common Stock ($96,000 – $80,000).............. 16,000
June 9 No entry required.
Aug. 1 Stock Dividends Distributable............................ 80,000
Common Stock................................................ 80,000
PE 13–4B
PE 13–5A
PE 13–5B
Stockholders’ Equity
Paid-in capital:
Common stock, $75 par (70,000 shares
authorized, 63,000 shares issued)................. $ 4,725,000
Excess of issue price over par............................. 679,000 $ 5,404,000
From sale of treasury stock.................................. 25,200
Total paid-in capital......................................... $ 5,429,200
Retained earnings....................................................... 2,032,800
Total......................................................................... $ 7,462,000
Deduct treasury stock (7,500 shares at cost).......... 588,000
Total stockholders’ equity......................................... $ 6,874,000
PE 13–6B
Stockholders’ Equity
Paid-in capital:
Common stock, $80 par (60,000 shares
authorized, 50,000 shares issued)................. $ 4,000,000
Excess of issue price over par............................. 630,000 $ 4,630,000
From sale of treasury stock.................................. 66,000
Total paid-in capital......................................... $ 4,696,000
Retained earnings....................................................... 2,220,000
Total......................................................................... $ 6,916,000
Deduct treasury stock (4,000 shares at cost).......... 360,000
Total stockholders’ equity......................................... $ 6,556,000
PE 13–7A
Ex. 13–1
1st Year 2nd Year 3rd Year 4th Year
a. Total dividend declared.................. $ 30,000 $ 42,000 $ 90,000 $ 120,000
Preferred dividend (current).......... $ 30,000 $ 27,000 $ 45,000 $ 45,000
Preferred dividend in arrears........ — 15,000 18,000 —
b. Total preferred dividends............... $ 30,000 $ 42,000 $ 63,000 $ 45,000
Preferred shares outstanding........ ÷ 15,000 ÷ 15,000 ÷ 15,000 ÷ 15,000
Preferred dividend per share......... $ 2.00 $ 2.80 $ 4.20 $ 3.00
Dividend for common share
(a. – b.)............................................. $ — $ — $ 27,000 $ 75,000
Common shares outstanding........ ÷ 50,000 ÷ 50,000
Common dividend per share......... $ 0.54 $ 1.50
Ex. 13–2
1st Year 2nd Year 3rd Year 4th Year
a. Total dividend declared.................. $ 3,000 $ 4,000 $ 30,000 $ 80,000
Preferred dividend (current).......... $ 3,000 $ 2,000 $ 5,000 $ 5,000
Preferred dividend in arrears........ — 2,000 3,000 —
b. Total preferred dividends............... $ 3,000 $ 4,000 $ 8,000 $ 5,000
Preferred shares outstanding........ ÷ 20,000 ÷ 20,000 ÷ 20,000 ÷ 20,000
Preferred dividend per share......... $ 0.15 $ 0.20 $ 0.40 $ 0.25
Dividend for common share
(a. – b.)............................................. $ — $ — $ 22,000 $ 75,000
Common shares outstanding........ ÷ 25,000 ÷ 25,000
Common dividend per share......... $ 0.88 $ 3.00
Ex. 13–3
a. Feb. 10 Cash................................................................ 1,360,000
Common Stock......................................... 400,000
Paid-In Capital in Excess of Par—
Common Stock......................................... 960,000
May 9 Cash................................................................ 700,000
Preferred Stock......................................... 500,000
Paid-In Capital in Excess of Par—
Preferred Stock......................................... 200,000
Ex. 13–4
a. June 4 Cash................................................................ 3,000,000
Common Stock......................................... 750,000
Paid-In Capital in Excess of
Stated Value.............................................. 2,250,000
Oct. 9 Cash................................................................ 2,000,000
Preferred Stock......................................... 1,875,000
Paid-In Capital in Excess of Par—
Preferred Stock......................................... 125,000
b. $5,000,000 ($3,000,000 + $2,000,000)
Ex. 13–5
c. Land.................................................................................. 125,000
Building............................................................................ 600,000
Interest Payable*........................................................ 7,000
Mortgage Note Payable............................................. 400,000
Common Stock........................................................... 318,000
*An acceptable alternative would be to credit Interest Expense.
Ex. 13–7
Buildings................................................................................. 200,000
Land......................................................................................... 125,000
Preferred Stock................................................................. 250,000
Paid-In Capital in Excess of Par—Preferred Stock....... 75,000
Cash......................................................................................... 475,000
Common Stock................................................................. 300,000
Paid-In Capital in Excess of Par—Common Stock....... 175,000
Ex. 13–8
Feb. 20 Cash........................................................................ 2,250,000
Common Stock (150,000 × $15)...................... 2,250,000
26 Organizational Expenses...................................... 7,500
Common Stock (500 × $15)............................. 7,500
Mar. 6 Land......................................................................... 50,000
Buildings................................................................. 275,000
Equipment.............................................................. 60,000
Common Stock (18,000 × $15)........................ 270,000
Paid-In Capital in Excess of Par—
Common Stock................................................. 115,000
Apr. 30 Cash........................................................................ 1,200,000
Preferred Stock (20,000 × $50)........................ 1,000,000
Paid-In Capital in Excess of Par—
Preferred Stock................................................. 200,000
Ex. 13–9
May 3 Cash Dividends...................................................... 69,500
Cash Dividends Payable.................................. 69,500
June 17 No entry required.
Aug. 1 Cash Dividends Payable....................................... 69,500
Cash................................................................... 69,500
Ex. 13–10
a. (1) Stock Dividends......................................................... 250,000*
Stock Dividends Distributable (2,000 × $100)... 200,000
Paid-In Capital in Excess of Par—
Common Stock..................................................... 50,000
*[($10,000,000/$100) × 2%] × $125
(2) Stock Dividends Distributable................................. 200,000
Common Stock..................................................... 200,000
b. (1) $12,000,000 ($10,000,000 + $2,000,000)
(2) $45,000,000
(3) $57,000,000 ($12,000,000 + $45,000,000)
Ex. 13–11
Ex. 13–13
a. July 15 Treasury Stock (24,000 × $60)...................... 1,440,000
Cash........................................................... 1,440,000
Aug. 10 Cash (19,000 × $63)....................................... 1,197,000
Treasury Stock (19,000 × $60)................ 1,140,000
Paid-In Capital from Sale of
Treasury Stock......................................... 57,000
Dec. 18 Cash (5,000 × $56)......................................... 280,000
Paid-In Capital from Sale of
Treasury Stock............................................... 20,000
Treasury Stock (5,000 × $60).................. 300,000
b. $37,000 ($57,000 – $20,000) credit
c. Stockholders’ Equity section
d. Sweet Water Inc. may have purchased the stock to support the market price
of the stock, to provide shares for resale to employees, or for reissuance to
employees as a bonus according to stock purchase agreements.
Ex. 13–14
Stockholders’ Equity
Paid-in capital:
Preferred 2% stock, $100 par
(20,000 shares authorized,
7,500 shares issued).................. $750,000
Excess of issue price over par....... 90,000 $ 840,000
Common stock, no par, $5 stated
value (250,000 shares author-
ized, 80,000 shares issued)....... $400,000
Excess of issue price over par....... 960,000 1,360,000
From sale of treasury stock............ 25,000
Total paid-in capital.................... $2,225,000
Ex. 13–15
Stockholders’ Equity
Paid-in capital:
Common stock, $75 par
(40,000 shares authorized,
18,000 shares issued)................ $1,350,000
Excess of issue price over par....... 108,000 $1,458,000
From sale of treasury stock............ 12,000
Total paid-in capital.................... $1,470,000
Retained earnings................................. 2,950,000
Total................................................... $4,420,000
Deduct treasury stock
(875 shares at cost)......................... 70,000
Total stockholders’ equity................... $4,350,000
Ex. 13–16
Stockholders’ Equity
Paid-in capital:
Preferred 4% stock, $50 par
(50,000 shares authorized,
30,000 shares issued)................ $1,500,000
Excess of issue price over par....... 90,000 $1,590,000
Common stock, $10 par
(200,000 shares authorized
40,000 shares issued)................ $ 400,000
Excess of issue price over par....... 120,000 520,000
From sale of treasury stock............ 30,000
Total paid-in capital.................... $2,140,000
Retained earnings................................. 3,900,000
Total................................................... $6,040,000
Deduct treasury common stock
(5,000 shares at cost)...................... 55,000
Total stockholders’ equity................... $5,985,000
Ex. 13–17
BANCROFT CORPORATION
Retained Earnings Statement
For the Year Ended January 31, 2010
Retained earnings, February 1, 2009................................ $ 3,175,500
Net income........................................................................... $415,000
Less dividends declared.................................................... 215,500
Increase in retained earnings............................................ 199,500
Retained earnings, January 31, 2010................................ $ 3,375,000
Ex. 13–18
Ex. 13–20
Ex. 13–21
Stockholders’
Assets Liabilities Equity
(1) Declaring a cash dividend 0 + –
(2) Paying the cash dividend
declared in (1) – – 0
(3) Authorizing and issuing stock
certificates in a stock split 0 0 0
(4) Declaring a stock dividend 0 0 0
(5) Issuing stock certificates for
the stock dividend declared
in (4) 0 0 0
Ex. 13–22
Feb. 3 No entry required. The stockholders ledger would be revised to record
the increased number of shares held by each stockholder.
Apr. 10 Cash Dividends...................................................... 47,000*
Cash Dividends Payable.................................. 47,000
*[(18,000 shares × $1.50) + (250,000 shares
× $0.08)] = $27,000 + $20,000 = $47,000
June 9 Cash Dividends Payable....................................... 47,000
Cash................................................................... 47,000
Oct. 10 Cash Dividends...................................................... 37,000*
Cash Dividends Payable.................................. 37,000
*[(18,000 shares × $1.50) + (250,000 shares
× $0.04)] = $27,000 + $10,000 = $37,000
10 Stock Dividends..................................................... 180,000**
Stock Dividends Distributable (5,000 × $20). 100,000
Paid-In Capital in Excess of
Par—Common Stock........................................ 80,000
**(250,000 shares × 2% × $36) = $180,000
Dec. 9 Cash Dividends Payable....................................... 37,000
Cash................................................................... 37,000
9 Stock Dividends Distributable............................. 100,000
Common Stock................................................. 100,000
Ex. 13–23
Net Income Preferred Dividends
Earnings per Share = Number of Common Shares Outstandin g
a.
Net Income Preferred Dividends
Earnings per Share = Number of Common Shares Outstandin g
$10,340 $161
2007 Earnings per Share = 3,159 common shares outstandin g
$8,684 $148
2006 Earnings per Share = 3,055 common shares outstandin g
$6,923 $136
2005 Earnings per Share = 2,515 common shares outstandin g
b.
2007 2006 2005
Earnings per share................................ $3.22 $2.79 $2.70
As a percent of 2005 (base year)......... 119% 103% 100%
Net income............................................. $10,340 $8,684 $6,923
As a percent of 2005 (base year)......... 149% 125% 100%
The earnings per share growth was much less than the net income growth.
Earnings per share increased 119% from 2005 to 2007, while net income grew
149% over the same period. The major reason for this difference is due to the
increase in common shares outstanding. During this period the common shares
increased by 126% (3,159/2,515), thus depressing the earnings per share growth.
This significant increase in the common shares outstanding was due to the
purchase of Gillette.
Ex. 13–25
a.
OfficeMax:
Staples:
$973,577,0 00
Earnings per Share = 720,528,00 0 common shares outstanding
b. Staples’ net income is over 10 times greater than OfficeMax’s. This is because
Staples is a much larger business than OfficeMax. As a result, Staples also
has nearly 10 times greater shares outstanding as well. The earnings per
share for both firms can be used to compare their relative earnings. Staples
has a better earnings per share ($1.35) than does OfficeMax ($1.20).
PROBLEMS
Prob. 13–1A
1.
3. a. 1.6% ($2.00/$125)
b. 10.0% ($0.80/$8)
Prob. 13–2A
Jan. 10 Cash........................................................................ 2,000,000
Mortgage Note Payable................................... 2,000,000
21 Cash........................................................................ 1,267,500
Preferred Stock (15,000 × $80)........................ 1,200,000
Paid-In Capital in Excess of Par—
Preferred Stock................................................. 67,500
31 Building................................................................... 1,850,000
Land......................................................................... 162,500
Common Stock (17,500 × $100)...................... 1,750,000
Paid-In Capital in Excess of Par—
Common Stock................................................. 262,500
Prob. 13–3A
a. Treasury Stock................................................................. 540,000
Cash............................................................................ 540,000
($540,000/60,000 shares) = $9 per share.
b. Cash.................................................................................. 462,000
Treasury Stock (42,000 × $9).................................... 378,000
Paid-In Capital from Sale of Treasury Stock.......... 84,000
e. Cash.................................................................................. 110,500
Paid-In Capital from Sale of Treasury Stock................ 6,500
Treasury Stock (13,000 × $9).................................... 117,000
1. and 2.
Common Stock
Jan. 1 Bal. 3,500,000
Apr. 3 1,000,000
Aug. 30 90,000
Dec. 31 Bal. 4,590,000
Retained Earnings
Dec. 31 254,025 Jan. 1 Bal. 4,600,000
Dec. 31 400,000
Dec. 31 Bal. 4,745,975
Treasury Stock
Jan. 1 Bal. 1,000,000 Mar. 9 1,000,000
Nov. 7 800,000
Dec. 31 Bal. 800,000
Stock Dividends
July 30 162,000 Dec. 31 162,000
Cash Dividends
Dec. 30 92,025 Dec. 31 92,025
Prob. 13–4A Continued
2.
Jan. 6 Cash Dividends Payable....................................... 54,000*
Cash................................................................... 54,000
*[(175,000 – 40,000) × $0.40]
Mar. 9 Cash........................................................................ 1,350,000
Treasury Stock................................................. 1,000,000
Paid-In Capital from Sale of Treasury Stock. 350,000
Apr. 3 Cash........................................................................ 1,700,000
Common Stock (50,000 × $20)........................ 1,000,000
Paid-In Capital in Excess of Stated Value..... 700,000
July 30 Stock Dividends..................................................... 162,000*
Stock Dividends Distributable (4,500 × $20) 90,000
Paid-In Capital in Excess of Stated Value..... 72,000
*(175,000 + 50,000) × 2% × $36
Aug. 30 Stock Dividends Distributable............................. 90,000
Common Stock................................................. 90,000
Nov. 7 Treasury Stock....................................................... 800,000
Cash................................................................... 800,000
($800,000/25,000 shares) = $32 per share.
Dec. 30 Cash Dividends...................................................... 92,025*
Cash Dividends Payable.................................. 92,025
*(175,000 + 50,000 + 4,500 – 25,000) × $0.45
31 Income Summary................................................... 400,000
Retained Earnings............................................ 400,000
31 Retained Earnings................................................. 254,025
Stock Dividends............................................... 162,000
Cash Dividends................................................ 92,025
Prob. 13–4A Concluded
3.
KRISCH ENTERPRISES INC.
Retained Earnings Statement
For the Year Ended December 31, 2010
Retained earnings (January 1, 2010).............................. $4,600,000
Net income......................................................................... $400,000
Less: Cash dividends...................................................... (92,025)
Stock dividends..................................................... (162,000)
Increase in retained earnings.......................................... 145,975
Retained earnings (December 31, 2010)........................ $4,745,975
4.
Stockholders’ Equity
Paid-in capital:
Common stock, $20 stated value (250,000 shares
authorized, 229,500 shares issued)..................... $4,590,000
Excess of issue price over stated value................. 2,522,000
From sale of treasury stock..................................... 350,000
Total paid-in capital............................................... $ 7,462,000
Retained earnings............................................................ 4,745,975
Total............................................................................ $12,207,975
Deduct treasury stock (25,000 shares at cost)............. 800,000
Total stockholders’ equity............................................... $11,407,975
Prob. 13–5A
Jan. 10 No entry required. The stockholders ledger would be revised to record
the increased number of shares held by each stockholder.
Mar. 1 Cash Dividends...................................................... 216,000*
Cash Dividends Payable.................................. 216,000
*(80,000 × $1.20) + (500,000 × $0.24)
Apr. 30 Cash Dividends Payable....................................... 216,000
Cash................................................................... 216,000
July 9 Treasury Stock (75,000 × $26).............................. 1,950,000
Cash................................................................... 1,950,000
Aug. 29 Cash (40,000 × $32)............................................... 1,280,000
Treasury Stock (40,000 × $26)......................... 1,040,000
Paid-In Capital from Sale of Treasury
Stock (40,000 × $6)........................................... 240,000
Sept. 1 Cash Dividends...................................................... 165,750*
Cash Dividends Payable.................................. 165,750
*(80,000 × $1.20) + [(500,000 – 35,000) × $0.15]
1 Stock Dividends (4,650 × $30).............................. 139,500**
Stock Dividends Distributable (4,650 × $25). 116,250
Paid-In Capital in Excess of Par—Common
Stock (4,650 × $5)............................................. 23,250
**(500,000 – 35,000) × 1% × $30
Oct. 31 Cash Dividends Payable....................................... 165,750
Cash................................................................... 165,750
31 Stock Dividends Distributable............................. 116,250
Common Stock................................................. 116,250
Prob. 13–1B
1.
3. a. 2.5% ($1.00/$40)
b. 7.0% ($0.35/$5)
Prob. 13–2B
June 9 Building................................................................... 1,680,000
Land......................................................................... 420,000
Common Stock (65,000 × $30)........................ 1,950,000
Paid-In Capital in Excess of Par—
Common Stock................................................. 150,000
13 Cash........................................................................ 840,000
Preferred Stock (21,000 × $25)........................ 525,000
Paid-In Capital in Excess of Par—
Preferred Stock................................................. 315,000
25 Cash........................................................................ 700,000
Mortgage Note Payable................................... 700,000
Prob. 13–3B
a. Cash (17,500 × $81)......................................................... 1,417,500
Common Stock (17,500 × $75).................................. 1,312,500
Paid-In Capital in Excess of Par—Common
Stock (17,500 × $6)..................................................... 105,000
d. Cash.................................................................................. 240,000
Treasury Stock (3,000 × $78).................................... 234,000
Paid-In Capital from Sale of Treasury Stock.......... 6,000
e. Cash.................................................................................. 75,000
Paid-In Capital from Sale of Treasury Stock................ 3,000
Treasury Stock (1,000 × $78).................................... 78,000
1. and 2.
Common Stock
Jan. 1 Bal. 3,200,000
Feb. 9 400,000
Aug. 15 144,000
Dec. 31 Bal. 3,744,000
Retained Earnings
Dec. 31 325,600 Jan. 1 Bal. 7,100,000
Dec. 31 485,000
Dec. 31 Bal. 7,259,400
Treasury Stock
Jan. 1 Bal. 240,000 May 21 240,000
Sept. 30 100,000
Dec. 31 Bal. 100,000
395,000
Stock Dividends
July 1 234,000 Dec. 31 234,000
Cash Dividends
Dec. 27 91,600 Dec. 31 91,600
Prob. 13–4B Continued
2.
Jan. 7 Cash Dividends Payable....................................... 66,600*
Cash................................................................... 66,600
*[(400,000 – 30,000) × $0.18]
Feb. 9 Cash........................................................................ 600,000
Common Stock (50,000 × $8).......................... 400,000
Paid-In Capital in Excess of Stated Value..... 200,000
May 21 Cash........................................................................ 300,000
Treasury Stock (30,000 × $8)........................... 240,000
Paid-In Capital from Sale of Treasury Stock. 60,000
July 1 Stock Dividends..................................................... 234,000*
Stock Dividends Distributable (18,000 × $8). 144,000
Paid-In Capital in Excess of Stated Value..... 90,000
*(400,000 + 50,000) × 4% × $13
Aug. 15 Stock Dividends Distributable............................. 144,000
Common Stock................................................. 144,000
Sept. 30 Treasury Stock....................................................... 100,000
Cash................................................................... 100,000
Dec. 27 Cash Dividends...................................................... 91,600*
Cash Dividends Payable.................................. 91,600
*(400,000 + 50,000 + 18,000 – 10,000) × $0.20
31 Income Summary................................................... 485,000
Retained Earnings............................................ 485,000
31 Retained Earnings................................................. 325,600
Stock Dividends............................................... 234,000
Cash Dividends................................................ 91,600
Prob. 13–4B Concluded
3.
IVY ENTERPRISES INC.
Retained Earnings Statement
For the Year Ended December 31, 2010
Retained earnings (January 1, 2010)................................ $7,100,000
Net income........................................................................... $ 485,000
Less: Cash dividends........................................................ (91,600)
Stock dividends....................................................... (234,000)
Increase in retained earnings............................................ 159,400
Retained earnings (December 31, 2010)........................... $7,259,400
4.
Stockholders’ Equity
Paid-in capital:
Common stock, $8 stated value (600,000 shares
authorized, 468,000 shares issued).......................... $3,744,000
Excess of issue price over stated value...................... 890,000
From sale of treasury stock........................................... 60,000
Total paid-in capital.................................................... $ 4,694,000
Retained earnings.................................................................. 7,259,400
Total.................................................................................. $11,953,400
Deduct treasury stock (10,000 shares at cost)................... 100,000
Total stockholders’ equity.................................................... $11,853,400
Prob. 13–5B
Jan. 8 No entry required. The stockholders ledger would be revised to record
the increased number of shares held by each stockholder.
Feb. 13 Treasury Stock (30,000 × $27)................................. 810,000
Cash...................................................................... 810,000
May 1 Cash Dividends......................................................... 122,600*
Cash Dividends Payable.................................... 122,600
*(25,000 × $0.80) + [(600,000 – 30,000) × $0.18]
June 1 Cash Dividends Payable.......................................... 122,600
Cash...................................................................... 122,600
Aug. 5 Cash (22,000 × $34).................................................. 748,000
Treasury Stock (22,000 × $27)........................... 594,000
Paid-In Capital from Sale of Treasury
Stock (22,000 × $7).............................................. 154,000
Nov. 15 Cash Dividends......................................................... 138,400*
Cash Dividends Payable.................................... 138,400
*(25,000 × $0.80) + [(600,000 – 8,000) × $0.20]
15 Stock Dividends (11,840 × $40)............................... 473,600**
Stock Dividends Distributable (11,840 × $25).. 296,000
Paid-In Capital in Excess of Par—Common
Stock (11,840 × $15)............................................ 177,600
**(600,000 – 8,000) × 2% × $40
Dec. 31 Cash Dividends Payable.......................................... 138,400
Cash...................................................................... 138,400
31 Stock Dividends Distributable................................ 296,000
Common Stock.................................................... 296,000
SPECIAL ACTIVITIES
Activity 13–1
At the time of this decision, the WorldCom board had come under intense
scrutiny. This was the largest loan by a company to its CEO in history. The SEC
began an investigation into this loan, and Bernie Ebbers was eventually
terminated as the CEO, with this loan being cited as part of the reason. The
board indicated that the decision to lend Ebbers this money was to keep him
from selling his stock and depressing the share price. Thus, it claimed that it was
actually helping shareholders by keeping these shares from being sold.
However, this argument wasn’t well received, given that the share price dropped
from around $15 per share at the time of the loan to about $2.50 per share when
Ebbers was terminated. In addition, critics were scornful of the low “sweetheart”
interest rate given to Ebbers for this loan. In addition, many critics viewed the
loan as risky, given that it was not supported by any personal assets. WorldCom
has since entered bankruptcy proceedings, Ebbers has gone to prison, and the
Ebbers loan went uncollected.
Some press comments:
1. When he borrowed money personally, he used his WorldCom stock as
collateral. As these loans came due, he was unwilling to sell at “depressed
prices” of $10 to $15 (it’s now around $2.50). So WorldCom lent him the
money to consolidate his loans, to the tune of $366 million. How a board of
directors, representing you and me at the table, allowed this to happen is
beyond comprehension. They should resign with Bernie. (Source: Andy
Kessler, “Bernie Bites the Dust,” The Wall Street Journal, May 1, 2002, p.
A18.)
2. It was astonishing to read the other day that the board of directors of the
United States’ second-largest telecommunications company claims to have
had its shareholders’ interests in mind when it agreed to grant more than
$430 million in low-interest loans to the company’s CEO, mainly to meet
margin calls on his stock.
Yet that’s the level to which fiduciary responsibility seems to have sunk on
the board of Clinton, Mississippi-based WorldCom, the deeply troubled
telecom giant, as it sought to bail Bernard Ebbers out of the folly of
speculating in shares of WorldCom itself. Sadly, WorldCom is hardly alone.
“The very essence of why Mr. Ebbers was granted a loan was to protect
shareholder value,” said a WorldCom spokesman in mid-March, just as the
U.S. Securities & Exchange Commission was unfurling a probe of the loan
and 23 other matters related to WorldCom’s finances.
Activity 13–1 Concluded
Yes, folks, you read that right. On March 14, 2002, a spokesman for a publicly
traded, $20 billion company actually stood up and declared that of all the
uses to which the company could have put almost half-a-billion dollars, the
best one by far—at least from the point of view of the shareholders—was to
spend it on some sort of stock-parking scheme in order to keep the CEO out
of bankruptcy court. (Source: Christopher Byron, “Bernie’s Bad Idea,” Red
Herring, April 16, 2002.)
Activity 13–2
Jas and Nadine are behaving in a professional manner as long as full and
complete information is provided to potential investors in accordance with
federal regulations for the sale of securities to the public. If such information is
provided, the marketplace will determine the fair value of the company’s stock.
Activity 13–3
1. This case involves a transaction in which a security has been issued that has
characteristics of both stock and debt. The primary argument for classifying
the issuance of the common stock as debt is that the investors have a legal
right to an amount equal to the purchase price (face value) of the security.
This is similar to a note payable or a bond payable. The additional $50
payment could be argued to be equivalent to an interest payment, whose
payment has been deferred until a later date.
Arguments against classifying the security as debt include the fact that the
investors will not receive fixed “annual” interest payments. In fact, if
Biosciences Unlimited Inc. does not generate any net sales, the investors do
not have a right to receive any payments. One could argue that the payments
of 2% of net sales are, in substance, a method of redeeming the stock. As
indicated in the case, the stockholders must surrender their stock for $100
after the $10 million payment has been made. Overall, the arguments would
seem to favor classifying the security as common stock.
Activity 13–3 Concluded
Activity 13–4
2. Given the cash and working capital position of Rainbow Designs Inc. on
December 31, 2010, a stock dividend might be an appropriate alternative to a
cash dividend.
a. From the point of view of a stockholder, the declaration of a stock
dividend would continue the dividend declaration trend of Rainbow
Designs Inc. In addition, although the amount of the stockholders’
equity and proportional interest in the corporation would remain
unchanged, the stockholders might benefit from an increase in the fair
market value of their total holdings of Rainbow Designs Inc. stock after
distribution of the dividend.
b. From the point of view of the board of directors, a stock dividend would
continue the dividend trend, while the cash and working capital position
of the company would not be jeopardized. Many corporations use stock
dividends as a way to “plow back” retained earnings for use in acquiring
new facilities or for expanding their operations. Rainbow Designs Inc.
has sufficient unissued common stock to declare a stock dividend
without changing the amount authorized.
Activity 13–6