See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/338311131

A critical history of marine protected areas

Chapter · January 2020

DOI: 10.1016/B978-0-08-102698-4.00001-0

CITATIONS READS

5 567

2 authors:

John Humphreys Robert Clark

57 PUBLICATIONS   647 CITATIONS   
Association of IFCA
28 PUBLICATIONS   114 CITATIONS   
SEE PROFILE
SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Fisheries & Aquaculture View project

Manila Clam View project

All content following this page was uploaded by John Humphreys on 06 April 2020.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.

 0
‰ Š 1 ‹Œ Ž

1234542678495
3
 634
3
5256369
6)*+,
 !"#$%$&'(
-,.,/01234-*/56-/*6/+78*-9/4+-,:01;04,+<0.,=7;04,+<0.,=78*-,/>?-*@>0<A
B50., =/4*)*+=04/C-+=/4-/+3*>D0*+/493,-0*E.,=04-,:7;00F/78*-,/>?-*@>0<
EG+,436,
HIJKLMNKOLPQRLOQSPTUVWPLJVXJVYSPVSZ[\H]KS^VV_TRJVYOLPJKV`VRJWSPJLOSXVUJMPabJKV`VNTUUTUNRLOS
QLYVPUNIL`SIQL^VQVUJXSU`VJPSXVYJLJKVcPRJdLPIYeLUNPVRRLUfSJTLUSI\SPgRTUhijklmLnV^VPUVn
TQWVJMRnSRWPL^TYVY`aJKVTUTJTSJTLUTUhiojLOSWPLXVRRnKTXKYVIT^VPVYV_XIMRT^VPTNKJRJLRL^VPVTNURJSJVR
L^VPSYpSXVUJnSJVPRMWJLkqqUQLMJlrKVOLIILnTUNYVXSYVRnVPVQSPgVY`aSNPLnTUN`LYaLORXTVUJTcX
V^TYVUXVLUJKVMJTITJaLO[\HRSUYSXXVIVPSJTUN[\HYVRTNUSJTLURlHOJVPJKVsTLtuSPJKvMQQTJwTUhiikS
NIL`SI[\HSPVSJSPNVJLOhqxnSRVRJS`ITRKVYlySTIMPVJLSXKTV^VJKTR`aJKVkqhqYVSYITUVnSROLIILnVY`a
TJRPVWISXVQVUJnTJKtHTXKTJSPNVJhhwPVzMTPTUNhqxXL^VPSNV`akqkqlvTUXVJKVUSXaXIVLOJSPNVJtNSQTUNw`a
RL^VPVTNURJSJVRKSRUVXVRRTJSJVYPVWVSJVYVOOLPJRJLJTNKJVU[\HJVXKUTXSIPVzMTPVQVUJRlHJVXKULXPSJTXSIIa
YPT^VUYTSIVXJTXSIRJaIVLOTUJVPUSJTLUSIWLITXaYV^VILWQVUJKSRWMJTUXPVSRTUNVQWKSRTRLURJPLUNVPQSU{
SNVQVUJSUYVUOLPXVQVUJRLIMJTLURbnTJKLMJRMOcXTVUJPV|VXJTLULUJKVRLXTL{VXLULQTXOSXJLPRnKTXKITV
`VKTUYJKVNSQTUNWPL`IVQl\PLWLRSIRJLTUXPVSRVJKVSPVSJSPNVJJL}qxSPVzMVRJTLUS`IVMUJTIRMXKJTQVSRS
QLPVXLURTYVPVYPLIVOLP[\HRTRVRJS`ITRKVYnTJKTUSXLQWPVKVURT^VNIL`SIXLURVP^SJTLURJPSJVNaSWWIaTUN
JLhqqxLOJKVQSPTUVVU^TPLUQVUJl
?/ :~04>+
HTXKTrSPNVJhh€mTRJLPaLO[\HR€[SPTUV\PLJVXJVYHPVSR€[\HR€[\H\LITXal

/9/F0‚</*,012;E‚0F-6:3*>/ƒ,/*,
HgVaV^VUJTUJKVQLYVPUNIL`SITQWVJMROLPQSPTUVWPLJVXJVYSPVSRZ[\HR]nSRJKVJKTPY
„UTJVYfSJTLUReLUOVPVUXVLUJKV…SnLOJKVvVSZ„fe…†v]nKTXKPSUOPLQ hiojJLhi‡kl
HIJKLMNK„fe…†vTUXIMYVYXIVSPRJSJVQVUJRLUQSPTUVVU^TPLUQVUJSIWPLJVXJTLUbTJRQSTU
TQWSXJnSRJLOLPQSITRVSNPLnTUNTUXITUSJTLUJLV_JVUYUSJTLUSIpMPTRYTXJTLUROPLQ SJKPVV
QTIV`SUYLOXLSRJSInSJVPRJLSkqqUSMJTXSIQTIVtu_XIMRT^VuXLULQTXˆLUVwZuuˆ]nTJKTU
nKTXKQSPTJTQVUSJTLURKS^VV_XIMRT^VPTNKJRL^VPQSPTUVPVRLMPXVRlHIJKLMNKULJTQQVYT{
SJVIaPSJTcVYbJKVVOOVXJnSRJLXLQWIVJVSJPSURTJTLUOPLQJKVRVSSR`VILUNTUNTUWPTUXTWIVJL
SIIUSJTLURZSUYJKVPVOLPVTUSRVURVULUV]bJLSUSPPSUNVQVUJnKVPV`aQMXKLOJKVXLUJTUVU{
JSIRKVIOXSQVnTJKTUJKVWMP^TVn LOTUYT^TYMSIRJSJVRlrKTRTUJMPUWPL^TYVYSRJPLUN

‘"’"“”
=,,‚+••>0-–04@•0—–0—0˜•™š›œ——œ0—ž˜šœŸ–————0— 0 ‰
34 85¡¢£¢£79¤43¥5¦17734 859393¤¦
m Z[\]^_`_]abc_d`e^fegha^_ijk^e`j]`jla^jad
0123456713534816795671301
57060
18
5679 85
73 176567136113 73
7166
76534
1377767 1085
7678 656 
776 !"#$51
657 4 3
5175671301
50 25
4736 85
73 397
138 36736 %7$ 5
 134&&'(
12346 58 678 5)1
4!13
13 567135*5
+,6 -.57
!13
/05 401
6 731
1
567131085
73 76 73616 76731
474 3 61
+
10,85736

6
750
16 6 45
5,)!*(12345146520
.76 6 37131019
73
760
186 534615475 36 51 !"#$1317456 4
6 74 56566 
567 104 7356736

6
75
16 6 45
5,3562


9 13567135
81328 365345
+ 601247875
 57 456 56616 13673 365 08 .57
!13
59 6 27 6109*(7
1: 736
3567135566 36713,;251466<0
877316612 66566

319*(
71
616  61 9 36*176
5
7 6
418735362=67459*(56 >1
6? 00
13 56713591328 3673>1
7451
$(1 657 45 5
546@<53419
7319
4515<3510 5,;251466<A?13 1
234B0C346D26 :
6)1
4!13
13 567135*5
+54
188 34 419
38 36
61- 5873 558566
102
 36 1777610
567385
73 5
+1


9 /
53446E36

5
544459*(51756 4762E1236
7 ,$795 651465D0
.6 87446E3.71
+234,46EB055 61
1
6
173736
619
38 3673
 6673574 85
73

9 1316 5673(26
5751 328
127534

9 136
;
56.5

7
F 0124 18 228 4736158571
85
73 567135*5
+136 57
10 7567135 47346E4
& 
53 5

=1256713767
4 065 56565367  3736
136732 4781
653 108 52
1
7735673766 -!139 3671313) 653410C36
35=
67135C81
653 & 755)56
01%57656/,F585
!139 36713146E405346 &2=

1 53 3713 .7
4G7
679 11 
2
1
13 -8 !13
956713 10.7
4/5
657 47346E6,&&!146E60.16106  58  657 4
16 6 45
5731565
534 625
73 6 8534  87: 4 56
7613
95671381679 73567585
73

16 6713
8
01
56126

9*( 01
 !"#$5346 .57!13
16  61
737675679 85
+ 46 
567131053  17 397
138 36767376 8167956713
706 40
18 HIJK9*(5547236616

6
75

9 1
01
6 
16 6713100
57 1
0564 
5473534106 3713785
73 76 1619*(551
361585
73 13
95=
67136
56 766 151057 9735

 365679 6 8109*(17301
8 47 3=
67: 974 3 .465<6 :2
54
1
6 4
1361B@39*(5
1D61236
7 
,$795 651465D07657875
328
533 45345E1236
7 73919 4C6124
316 41 9
6566  :2
7324 46

6
75
16 6 45
57615651

$73 6 317 73279 1013672126

6
755
516 6
8 9*( 7
5
4 45
573
6 6165 55
5  4656106 5341
 36  55
5
16 6 4
720:7 36737L 61 57: 4737613
765539*(%1 9
8737828 7L 
01
9*(5
316 7: 4,M  
146660573 46626 816737:536159*(
65
 659  3 
 45
 365 
G2
736 466317673
573
1376713106 3 401
7 3 =5 44 7713,"2=
 31 651466405345
1731
21076
562
136 26776109*(, F1
6534
*1237314664016 :
65
565
 6501
857 4506
6 F71-&5
6$28876/, 146620
8713
 657 46 !139 3671313.71175G79
76,!.G077362
34 9 =
1 41573247385
 644NOPPQRS JKIJPITJHUKJJVKVJWKPXY
 pqrqstuvwxytwyquzvtw{t|}~vwqutzqyzq€~q~ 
01234564789
 9 !"
#
$!%& ''()*+),-
).*$,)/&)))9)

90
9)1,$8(*,$& 2& ''3#

) )!9)9.4)9)5!6
1
,$/#87)))#& ''8#1%)%"
9 9 *:;&%-)))##;)
82
1,$<)
821,$%-#+) *:;"
! 9 98*:;& &
) 9))!)))!)
#

6,)* :));

9&9)9
) 9%))
)9.4==40>?64@AB274CD?>BE@AFB2BG47H401@1G?0B@@A54I54342>B>?64
B27J4@@012240>473A3>4F31=I51>40>47B54B3B271>K454==40>?64B54BLEB3470123456B>?12F4B3D543M
8*:;& 9&$ # 9 0%90)
)
N+69);)!4)&)%!0))"
&&-
8O)& '& )#
P QN+ )!)R1,$9)
 %9 S9 )T"
%!%1,$&8#S9)8N+& Q#U%"
 $ 1,$
%
9%)&%0)9)
1,$  
#5!VV)
N+9-W15@7XB>BEB3412Y51>40>47Z54B38(;,$)

!Z>@B31=[B5?24Y51>40>?1281,$)#&9
N691*"
P&+4\%TV)V)
%
"
)
!))
!)1,$#*0)
6))#8 2
!VS#]9)9)!%.B0>?64@AFB2BG47M1,$#N"
)
^!)!!1,$%
R))%#
+%))&9
 QN+)9)).>54F42L
71D3I51G5433/&%&%9%)

9
N+9&) 9 %
8N+& Q#P
)9)R1,$9))


!%
%9.!
)/8;)
)#& 2./84-)#& 2#
_`a`bcdefghcfh`diecfjcklmnef`dnci`hi`omn`m
6!!)!"9! )"
!&)9
!)))  )!)
#
+)()8Q 9!1,$#P
T ABCDEFGFDHIJFKGLEMLNOHEFPQRELGQDGQSHEQHK
012345607489539
65397 17 10238210 838897 2404
19723
37
49
128734942819371917918011397 11783 19747 13
891
873498!82"#$%&' 3

4128467(' 8483982391
828
71237 7 1
7871506204174)02112189502471
742156
87349'3903287349'21
218734989519*4197
+,- 11
49501234524(748
828
7123157339712480238
4
49
1287349'6737 421
31973
851915
4912873494821873942180174
11873
01
31'
2373
8 83787'1
443
8024
11895 34531237%39
17 1
 4112898268421024469539.619
1497 1
49
1073494/! 8
1197 139
21839693128484)678398151140197, 3
3
49351215
627 1214
0127 101234546739158418234601
3
7014
491287349473871508738
5139187158239121723
73491121514217 119123
712 )8239102471
7158218,8
351800315110427157 10 281827615562397 1232734254491219
149
873498!82"395# 418953131'5(&848
8784614/!#%38
178'&37159391749153121977014513987349'39
6539867303
374
82387349497 19473494082"'21121'89
768231'2161895496197%6
5194
7873498215123124 71221723802471
7158218701'1783 151421166381978
239137113715- 3
401374/!9419
8762137 1216749612465312197
9873498895602898734984129197842893873491773960/!497 1834
89531219713873139726197'
4391537 82387349397 198762147 183
89521723
7349'84937
891412731397 102183396147123944782346
1427 81119851749581912851937349 3
19
40817 189513987349'
895744
8718/!39745191502471
7349
8714231
4788997 1897129873498$93494244912873494 87621#34!'5&178
3 15871 43
8714231402471
71582188003
817447 71221723889582391
1932491978958150238234989811974*1
731:723
702471
7349;1
471
02471
7349;987628187621
491287349;8
731898119742 837874201
31;02471

73494218
801;21
2187349;8981197427 1678398161498762821462
1#11
<11 12'&=41127 11
871423182194767681
63189551037141
853937287313042789
142
493719
4839197397 14
3821042739402421'
89587710774
8237 1328003
87349#1>651'5&'7 111
402431588
216747 118
47017 182111"39747187318958268898
249373
39
3 7442121
1977 39"39491
471 800248
174
491287349
?66821183947 153
67314397129873498043
895028
73
142/!82119
12851937349895 47 182895511408

42539747 1023423731895

32
6789
1
47 101401895428938734902404397 178147462
1 8139
4497 1
44395193987723671#=60 21895=12127'5&
@14280 3
88218482391
828
7124239.619
137 5191546958231'39
6539
47 8712
469895197 3

4049197
@3 3
302471
7157 246 184247 12103
37189
@2427 10620414
491287349401
3151876214271'895
@/8981537 7 139719734948
31398 3 1211402471
73497 897 8747 1
6224695398218
 bcdcefghijkfikcglhfimfnopqhicgqflcklcrpqcp s
01234567895
7955
535
 482375
798653898435745384784535
7
8 536753 377353889 3 5
57 53
715
7 47357457
377
74!"""#7 7$
747%3 &'()*+,-+./0)1-,102+3.,456102+31-,,+0)71.8-19-,
:019014.;-,3*0)8:+1-,+)2+44.<0+1-2=.,+7/+5)+79041.,0<+3+)2<5315,+3/-+15,-47:90<99+46--)
,-4-,;-26*3+:.,.19-,-//-<10;->-+)41.?,.1-<1?+,1.,+33./19--)<3.4-2-);0,.)>-)1@A
0657 35735 73538578437 BCD!E9755
7775872783CD!C
867 677541637 BCD!ECD!C# 73185
74373F
538895
734 3G77448575747578437 %H
73473 557753675
7
988$3875 &'I10410>-1.41.??,-1-)20)8>.,-./19-.<-+)04?,.1-<1-219+)01+<15+33*
04J@'I),-<-)1*-+,4?,-445,-1.2-30;-,45<<-4441.,0-49+4,-4531-20)/+34-<3+0>4./;+41+,-+4
./19-.<-+)6-0)8?,.?-,3*?,.1-<1-2AI10410>-1.6-,-+30410<+6.51.5,2-K)010.)./LM(4@B
CD!ECD!C#%H
7 7875 948 7384893 36 545785
5
7 337
396537 89 7647173 4536419845
7648 7 89'19-)5>6-,48+>-NO9F
987175%CD!P# 8357$35
538827475 77Q358965
734835F
75 674357453847775 % 6
346 57 5
7735543657 89

2785
R6 3F78353 337%
H
7'674 7N3 473578 7R67789R6535532763 75845475
755324386 984 8937
23864
2777375373635
7'5
47
8
79975N3$
3
5
7R63518986565787 333 73847458G33 75
7
3727F
7589R653553275475 77S88CDDT#%
747327487675835
7 CD!C# 55775$ 7G47 7 7 347
'J U.>+V-01>5<99+,2-,/.,+<10.)419+10);.3;--W?3.01+10.)745<9+4K49-,0-471.6-<3+0>-2+4
LM(4JNH
3 875 337 5
78575386 47538
375$777883788F
3 75 895
7 75
55
73789 6 5377278758 57 3147837 %
H
787589 6 537727875$ 3548673585
7357453883147
15
7B8483 388X234875Y7278753!"EP H
70465
Z7845BXY!"EP# 37$
735
 78763R63586 %[6 5377278758
39974948 54358 7425388 35
5754473 7895
7984743 5
55
74777
857547F89975$77788348$5
5
77234875 4574CDDP\84571
CD!]#%8 7R67515
7774
7789
372385
8 7425387883
7G83553835
743772348753 7558353727 948 8538
827475 58^84357453854751843 538 %
_8!`895
7357538 [6 537Y727875_8 3 58'8 7427 6 53F
16 75
787  7 43747 8647 984 6 537727875NH475!`%]7 F
53
7 5
7!Da5475#%B
37_8!`3 947R6751R6857 8$749645387984
799753277 3538 353 81878967489_8 $
3
5
86
85343F
378543584187 3845534537357453 6
$1 5872787
^848317753574475538 34753858 %45364_8! 77Q
587827451335 984 _8!D58476737R6351$35
38865437
CD!P#%H
7 78 47 8397 538337 55388727 %
H
73548653889 6 537727875831
 773Q758
39537
 3
948 74847 5435148575747 588753889474653F6 7 3$
3

'835 $7473713 53345335327487 64351898 JN&
78837883 83%87B737CDDP#%57453273574475538
5
70465Z78457 77 5
7 77948 $
3
347 385753882745
7
O <=>?@ABA?CDEAFBG@HGIJC@AKLM@GBL?BLNC@LCF
01234565788946
474748227 12852
9
4
819779 624
9194
46

21257
912
57822
47 251975 52
41297
9174 5974689321727
25249

45746223269027 4
8124 4002464
5 46
69
91297954 535 475722819 4
46285 54 2909727 997
2134 597
575787014 52
22578 9452329 97
2134 59747297952 14 5975 57
41572019 2 24124
4
209 27 546 945232725 2132122 5326762

42
9621
41257 28146 914 21 47465274 219 20192

!250654 597

9 2
2 27

597
469785 4001942
912
963578 241212091 257479 240 21
57 5

3962
7"###$%&527 52 94
92
465
578

2
'25 214
471264 5326

466
5 2
24
15 6019 2 2914
42641826 5062
24124
597 457
15 6
019 2 24124
5 57 2()266221"###*7 5
12
02 5 5
957 212
4 2124 5979
6 5062
24124
400241
9 27 92015915 5
29321
15 6019 2 24124
74 59746
89321727
(+1588
2 46,-".*7472327
572"###4 27 5974
22785327 9819578
293214662 27 9
1989 72 91
(/4962,--.*4764 26 19864182

462
(/25
2 46,-"0*+9 
14 2852
432227
2

6571 212 27578

869469321482192321 5
2047
5974
198 222
59794523578904 
5565 2 2272969854647297958946
57 957124
5786
4109
9 0965 5466
4791474821
479 21014 5 59721

74 2
05 247466
912 27
532
4 4129655
9
578(283921

2 46,--4* 2124
69782274 45 420 4729 2524 4 4
22 27 9

819
4

297 91297562 27
597
2 22797
2134 5974720695 4 597
5 57974152
' 9
929 42 2 904 562!24

0 59757)266221
("###* 4 641821
962597257 96 5062
247
15 6019 2 24124
120
12
27 2129875 5979 2722 9412

2
2572127 27
597
+ 57014 52 24 21
12457
2
62 9
2159
97 27 5974724 257525 25
57 57 212

64

19 74 597460965 198 969464748227 62326
%97
2227 64978 240
01942
94157297
2134 597 22
5874 59794019 2 241249
9466827214 2

197857 214 597

2 227
954629795472969854650214 532
47245753546
064
9 575199
 2827214646627829

45746223269027 57 241572
273519727 (7012
4772121 ,-".*
!2129122
05 24
197897
27

5 57 297
2134 597
2 91574391957124
578
272147
5529
 25122 53272

4723276285 54412
56622
5972
(%915218462,-"9*47 2: 150629 9 6572;(322
2 46,-".*929795232690
27 273519727 46

4574565 47
9546576
59747
22566
9191466
429621

9123216285 54 215 5229 2:04021041
;827125204
5
2
25091 4729
:79 425972
;91:758619 2 241572124
; 2125
41264 532620153294
46 97
57479 215
2427 97 19140991975 4 15
94
96 209321 919
20695 578 2
245
041 9 2516532659991

5
2727 5
97 2 4

21 597
4 4

212

457462464722 22797
2134 5974712
9122 14 5974722
465
2
57014 52420965 5466202527 
92 52

527 546622
597462(7
012
4772121 ,-".*7472327 5797 14
9
15 019 2 59791645

25451220695
4 5975 5
4466278578 578 92653218
2227 40 21
57 5
3962 2
5 4
97 27 5979
12227 691
2 227
57857 212

(19

5
272 198 941 5

47464757
154622
*4789321727 46482752
556226644129 2
 rstsuvvwtvxtyxz{|yuy{tvu}~€‚ ƒ
011230452678079287
71084 12
56424676220
57 5200
52
4507
4
704507
6
55222767220
6545260562216545484 6424507
60206562522
5262309
8 552
607
64
352462840160852 !"224540
657 5465757#722
50606
75527
$485782450
306824
8026% !"6407 684084507
4
3 034
82
378 12
56&'(()'(*'4+220
80
23574550 522750
27657106
32654
30
6
0
524084507
752032
0507
64
384527026"22522660562216824545050

72
12
510
0650264
352042
802652266 270
52
4507
4542564687
509
523570
52254507
60887
2
02
5$7296545235204802212
56

4
$22
52756$52 !" 3217
6545287
50
0
87
82
64508 4$7
52
252
557083260
4523642228502$14
423527$0

75246571
",-67
522848$722
57626087652
60$ 522. 023805204
 !" 703234 5284084507
082474526602662
5048448520650867
60
8 30
/012345/440705$78 67
87
624507
4
3524404005$7267 826
4
3844805$57228502$01212
54
2080514
4212
54
 !"4646784023
752852324654
3436& !"78!'(*)4+$87
6703450
207 6$68455223
 034
824
3906254&'(*)+42322723287112
34507
67
8466084507
4
3
2750
46457407 6275657642
7 78 6&"26'(*:+
;0687
50
0
27 507
752528
0844
332
0
245 26760614
0265
75
< 650
 !"708$ 5050
4= 2
50
52
4507
4",-6762106607
4
37$0
06
40123576575232434507
7522456
45 42
07
12
5#2
82432
0507
7
6$5287380302>
388>&0823452352 !"684084507
6+46
?@324AB2A/C0412B40B2DD2E1/F25GH404C2B1IJ3I12E1H43/022EIAGA12HAKJ3IE2AA2AKL4M/141A40BAJ2N
E/2AKOL/ELE40EI013/MP121I1L232A1I341/I040B32J520/ALH201ID32AIP3E2ADI3AIE/45K2EI0IH/E40B
EP51P345203/ELH201Q&R2 80
9# 2
75S4
38T2
S02'(*U+
57 2080514
4212
54
64
352267 8262. 0235701212
5521 42

787
603223462662
504245 26766712771714
72 2772
12
5629
140
646522068 2
5$
70
52
4507
4704507
5720$522714
82760

52 !"62750

2012;06442
57106607
14$
7522
502$057 54507
42
60
820
82460
650
2
8$0
522. 0212
567 !"14$424243$248232$7
3
52844805$76712720
8712
4507
65732020
52462
8270
52
4507
4403
VWXWYZZ[XZ\X]\^_`]Y]_XZYabcdef
#71 8062
7 gh 82
87254&'((i+3268023506. 26507
4652jI5Gk34/57
140
27528507
4
3287
0623545432
05024
6246
75$2544042
88730
578067
&'(*l+8 2
54526707302605$7660
3084525450506
282664$57
62546032U(m7522454626226703022607
75065$27424567 507

40235762464
37824
614$
7524621752476285764605654246
;2242572467
67506%;2652452657282
5410507 6287112
34507
67
 4244
3526287
3574
43< 6512
577 42494623140
287
624507
14$
21246 23

'(*n52 !"87346!7
266287112
32357%P3C2015G/0E324A21L2IE2404324
o /02EI5IC/E455G32J32A20141/F240BO255EI002E12BAGA12HAIDpq@AI3I1L232DD2E1/F2EI0A23F41/I0
x efghijkjhlmnjokpiqprslijtuvipkuhkuwliulo
012345136789
9 1313 44135751125123 22042123
9 12
0251 2622251336 61537213731031513!"#$%&'%('&)*+,
&'-%..'/01)+%/+,21-3'024+/56'/)+1789:,,6-*1,;<'6-*7+/=>6?'/*%7)@1/0
$-A'/@+'B"C
D,'-%/0E1-)%&-%/)&+26)+/?)%)*'E'1,+2+7+)4%E*+?*'&1&'1=21,'0-%('&1?'&'71)',)%)*'
F*&1,'G 15111315201236&',H+/)*'12%('&'-%..'/01)+%/CI*+,+,&'.+=
/+,-'/)%EJ%&0+/?+/)*''K+,)+/?D+-*+I1&?') %E)*'%/('/)+%/%/L+%7%?+-17M+('&,+)4
N)&1)'?+-71/LM2"+/J*+-*)*' O)1&?').6,)2'-%/,'&('0)*&%6?*,4,)'.,%E
$D,1/0P 151112512Q6231315201234513#R1EE%7'4')17CS"*1,&'F%&)'0
)*1))*+,F*&1,'J1,171,)=.+/6)'100+)+%/)%)*'D+-*+)1&?') 1/0*'122&'(+1)',
)*'F*&1,')%:T$J*+-*F'&*1F,/%)-%=+/-+0'/)1774-%6701FF74'U61774J'77)%)*'P 15
111315201234513&'E'&&'0)%+/)*'VO&'-%..'/01)+%/C
R1EE%7'4')17CS"*1,17,%0&1J/1))'/)+%/)%)*'+.F%&)1/-'%E:T$,+/?7%217+.F7'=
.'/)1)+%/-%..'/)+/?)*1)+/)*'-%/)'K)%ED+-*+I1&?') 10'W/+)+%/%E:T$,+,%E
+..'0+1)',)&1)'?+-1/0F%7+)+-17+.F%&)1/-'CX/)*+,-%/)'K)R1EE%7'4*1,,%6?*))%'76-+01)'
J*1))*'F*&1,'.+?*)+/F&1-)+-'.'1/1/0*1,+0'/)+W'01/6.2'&%E'.'&?+/?F&+/-+F7',
1/0'K-76,+%/,)*1)*'7F)%-71&+E4J*1).+?*)2''7+?+27'E%&-%6/)+/?)%J1&0,)*'D+-*+
)1&?')6/0'&)*':T$ -1)'?%&4C
D.%/?,)F&+/-+F7',&'71)'0)%)*'1-*+'('.'/)%E7%/?)'&.Q34-%/,'&(1)+%/%E2+%0+=
('&,+)41FF7+'0)%10'W/127'1&'1J+)*1-)+('?%('&/1/-'R1EE%7'4+/-760',)*'F&+/-+F7'
)*1)1/:T$ G3221Y3Z511251213Z23HI*+,GF&+/-+F7'H&'F&','/),
1-1)'?%&4,*+E)E&%. )*'%)*'&,1/024(+&)6'%E)*'/''0)%+/-760'+)&1+,',)*'U6',)+%/
%EJ*')*'&-6&&'/)0'W/+)+%/,%E$D,-%6701--%..%01)')*'-%/-'F)%E:T$.13+/?
)*'71))'&)'&.+/06'-%6&,'&'06/01/)CX/1/4'('/)J*+7':T$,/''0)%2'6/0'&F+//'0
2410'W/+)'-%/,'&(1)+%/%2['-)+('1/01FF&%F&+1)'.1/1?'.'/))*'+&%&+?+/17F6&F%,'.14
2'0+EE'&'/),6-*1,1522-7%,6&',&%6/0*+,)%&+-J&'-3,J*+-*12*1('$D)4F'
-%/,'&(1)+%/2'/'W),C
N+/-'R1EE%7'4H,S"F1F'&1,62,+0+1&42%04%E)*'%/('/)+%/%/L+%7%?+-17M+('&=
,+)4*1,10%F)'01&'-%..'/01)+%/)*1):T$,2'0'W/'01,E%77%J,\P2Z1Z52 27
1]12512 15 22^511_512`  3Z1512022Z134 `273 22 11
31234321ZQ15040135 1Q34315261537a` 233Q
21137310432315132a` 1512261a4452a3542a2 1527
51122413HC
X/)*+,0'W/+)+%/+)+,F%,,+27')%0+,-'&/1/6/0'&,)1/0127''EE%&))%F&'('/))*'+0'1%E
:T$,2'-%.+/?1I&%[1/>%&,'E%&)*'/6.2'&,?1.'%E%('&=-%6/)+/?C>%J'('&+/
)'&.,%E'-%7%?+-17F&%)'-)+%/1/0/%)J+)*,)1/0+/?&'-'/)0')1+7'0'EE%&),)%0+,)+/?6+,*
2')J''/$D,1/0:T$,Xb8cDd2")*'0+EE'&'/-',1&'1&?61274,62)7'
1/0+).+?*)2',6??',)'0)*1),62['-)'0)%(1&+%6,+/)'&1-)+/?F&',,6&',%F'&1)+/?%('&
4'1&,126&'16-&1)+-F&%-',,*1,-%.'-7%,')%0'W/+/?1/:T$ 1,1/$D)*1)0%',/H)
17&'104'K+,)C:&)%F6)+)1/%)*'&J141/$DJ*+-*+,/%)-177'01/$DCX/1/4'('/)
)*+,0'W/+)+%/J*+7'2'+/?+.F%&)1/)+/&'71)+%/)%)*'D+-*+I1&?') 17,%*1,+.F7+-1)+%/,
E%&J*1).14-%6/))%J1&0,1VO)1&?')C
 ]^_`abcd^_ e
0123456712
89
 9 9 
99 99 9
99

9  


9 999 9 !

 


 !" 

9" #$8  !
 9
! 9 !9
999
%9" # 

 
99!  !9  99
&

9 "9
  ! 
9  " !
9
9 !9 9  
'999 9
 
9
(" !
 
 )
 ! 
99
 "%9 9



!  9 " !!9% 99   9

9

&

9
9!
99   9 


9"99
 9* 
9
! 9 99
%99

 9
   
!
 9 
%* 9

  &9++ !9
,  999
 
9 
9

-
 9 
! 
   
9 
9
* 
 )
 . 

  ! . 
9  !99/0


'../0
(%
 !"
  
9
9
# 
9
% 9
 9
 
9 9 99 9 9%91 9 
9 999


9

9

'&999%23+45
  (&
9
9" 



  
"
 
 
 99  99)

"  


%99 !
 9  9 "!
9)


%  
  

 )   ! 
 

&
 
9!
"9
)9 99 9
9 
'
9
67.8(%9

 9
9 
9 " 89:
% 9 9)
 
%9
 
91
!99 
&
" # "9
9
)
 !
%* $9 ! !9
9

 9
. 
9 6
-
99;<=>?@AB>CDEFGC@<FH<D@EI9!! 
   
9 ! 99 !
9

 999 
%
9)
9
9
"!! 99 
!5)
1
! 9,99#
- 9

999 9
! ,
9#J 
-&
 !  9 
 *
 
9$K 
'23+L(9
 67.8-
23+L 

 92M89:
9! M3N !
" -

9
 ! ! 
9 ! 
!* 9 23M3
O! 9

%0  9'23+4%
  (
9
99 )
" 9
 
9 
9
)9
 !9 " #
"99
 P9


!9 9,

  -9 9 9 )
9
9 
%


99
"  
 9
99  
!9 
  
9 * !

&9 
"9
9!!

9
9
*9 QR9
9'23+M(" 9

 !9 9999

!
#

! 
ST=@U>=VW?XA@CYW>E<D<Z

YW>=D<Z[\/ *9'23+4(99

*9 
!!9\R 

99
1 !9 


cd PQRSTUVUSWXYUZV[T\[]^WTU_`aT[V`SV`bWT`WZ
012314156789
427 767723 8537995 427 85542  2 424
427 5 2
87 95 48542587453456879 415379542 857
83559  732
423537 
358 4148529584252
5678 427 758 95 47956
841582923427 76
41277235
427 8537 258555015852 4127
95
9185 8
!"#
$159 24
5763
885 48457627258247 731 585
85355 45
2 354155 76415854357
5827 
6%325 467841574
427 76415 50& 4187
735 557318
4'5  #(45 241535764158759 29255589785)*&
8537585 415856785
784+,  -, 7. 634415325 42%38427 678

317232  70
4240678/
315 372  +0524574173 37 4545
56678447
4268423
87854854(1/5854!234124554!5#41585
55 4282488%
85825 
584 55285477795412 47874534
415735  378
76325 42%324584
851702 4142 35842 537723 9 5
95 43283
94 35)*&3 15
. 37 3
27 058
54144531 738423825 25342345762 458 427 7
23873514187
185733
427 0241824888548543854532392 
853427 $15857 54701231155 47
42 3852 59127 487 58)*&9 
595 4 5 6783595 47
427 02417
487588565342 7  852 415
634780123125512 41592 8759. 41595 429529242336789785
)*&85 487 589 595 43884157784
2437473245024138702 
7
441555795 4763798515 2574845678982 537 58427 02412
01231)*&3 978537 258584
.  55 44153355842 8704176)*&375852637 42
52 41537 457476415
4822  97857678587453427 485402479572 429
3137985
15 257982 548452 67895 415276)*&%158 74158325 42%3
878995
423547! ,76415982 5859
89:9;9<=9>
?78
).!"5@&3125595 42 982 537 58427 .)82 5*8A 287 95 47 58427 !+#!"5
-+
?82B?5'C007 $D758?!EF537995 427 47.GH47.9875)82 5*8745345&85
2%3427  F57842 
8458H 5$15*7242376415A 287 95 4.5&34229*7239825G 25824*85
?0!. IH50J227 F5
2854745766089423?2725824/7GHF5784*85F555!41
)7 5 427 7 ?27723025824)7 485 
?0!(*! 053227 KLI$15484523* 678?2725824!!M  415&2312?2725824$854
G 245H427 A 287 95 4*878995H7B 
78925859)!@*84232478758  3576982 5874534585I72423315 5 54123
2958425266585 4485347825
85 *5853425. 45842 A 287 95 4 732545N!M+
8
4'5 *B D577769 2 H4
85@!-+MNO
05 47A54!+)22 982 5874534585)*&#4854I170415
1678
24
5892 5
42 
224 732
4235B7
8 76A 287 95 4) 595 4!@!+5M!@2
0
5HA# ED
252 5678&2 *8745345&85) 595 4457825.GHD 024'58 
0
85
2)?75858C?
8 544C&*8755F4789?!EA5454802 2 25874534585
58
92 537 58427 7
437952 7%12 17474325 35+2!@+M!@5
AA!"5"7
32028534255"L@"LAA7 58427 7642?28A
875 A37 7923799
24
 IJKJLJMNJO PP
012345267897
 966236352426331223524236234511229
5627!16"#$9%7&62632432'62$24214 (&2239$12267)*69
+"789723197
,9-23.442/.162/626324326242634233
262432906326&628424207

1953322962911, 269

,9

19
+789#$9%7 09&62632432'629!5(11739
167-97
49&62263 22623563243953620107

67

49
7!97812'3
49+3623613523623645396351482642914
'363-229
5627897!16"7-97
 98242:24214 3132662632432622239
5627!16" #$9%7&62632432 '6284242714  &2239$12267)*67
96 7049
5627897262637-98997
,9&62632432624242714 2239$3627!31
852184242
07
07
,9
;!57 4
906361426242316"96422!26242)62 352;!5135
82<81=35 4
9
;!57 ,
95316"74263221239;!5!5316"632432
'62642235291!629
;!57 69!64'4319;!5662632432'627+1783>2619
;!57
,9+2126'1632432'62&223!32629;!57+1783>2619
;!57

9+2126'1352;!5&223!32623&62632432'62#812236
3352
,+212%9;!57+1783>2619
;!57

9?52&62632432'62-211 &62632432'627,35823226&28332239
;!57+1783>2619
;!52?!'7
,9'1;!5@+11!2638363&62632432'62#&'%9A21<
26$2432!263'433565&'7382462)422135(8312A221239B26
99+1783>261969
;!52?!'7
,9#A63%+2126-24-263)3526$2432'62<92!263
&2629B269;!5783>2619
827887
69+26&62632432'629-31227'9
C21125267+97 9+2126&62632432'629;!57+1783>261!627;C9
+62396626-22&626"'35637?619"7;!59619C21125267+97912"17!97?2112789
#$9%7 09'+11-26223328 32&62632432'629
3127A9#$9%7
,9D65236"&62632432'629D52&''4316;!5@?61
!632432'629;!57?!'7+1783>2619
3127A9723197
=9'36433.35262243262<24263262/26'45D623
352!239141A2636732662332264229':34!26<
3&620625326$432
=#8%7171=9
322*789723197
 935264234522'45D62341E26>2352224324263<
263 !29&6214 71
71
19
32759723197
=93628412&62632432'62+2126A2&2239;!57+1
83>2619
34524789723197 9D5231252623322414162264529$41 =
71=76
9
34524789723197
19151235242352226424262622629$4141'1<
431#%98178=9D52$41418423 '2649
&'527
 9&'52
#0%)2!5219)2!436352)42#)!D)%9
521789<097?221789<F97
=9&626324326264263331222123932631
8618312A22123#1%7
117
09
)G326799!97
49$2432!262D6236)42632439!263323326 #4%71 ,7669
6327C9$97
0983139&D627&452339
-6!237 =9D52!23?231326316342$2411 ?326133
#-676 =%9
-2278973789703267597327)97+6H357!97012345267897857A97'336117&97
,996352
241<2414145262426263243262236"29':34!263&62
0625326$432
,#1%7=067=419
-2451<2513>7$97&4C2>27$97
09&62632432'628632323)4221359?61
?1120#??0%7+1783>2619
 VW CDEFGHIHFJKLHMINGONPQJGHRSTGNISFISUJGSJM
0123456789
971 799897943434363436335333514336343603366
11!7"#$9
0123456789
97%&67'997(79097)**#9+3413143436343636 6523634369161,-
+4651615301!.135! /"*7)/$/)9
0103719973597)*9236! 30316363436053435106,314163451943% ,43!67
84&5606977
4341535304363.3371!0
3359663347891409
.7.97: 2317'97(414 0-813457;9713789701234567897. 729097)*<96636643,41436651-
406335313,4153519
431!7$/9
.7
9697(53!769
9713636547497<"9 214,:65181650
4341535304363
(12. 43!9+303,145=%84-<"-9=1106%138314,4655 517=1106%137
9
+47973597)*9+3.1 584&3!6066343,41535304335140653365263516,5
,415351534515346943% ,43!6784&5606977
4341535304363.3371!0
-
3359663347891409
27)9+3011345116413501331,35925305167=6519
27)*>9+3. 65231331,35(1603,145)*>9253051673?14&9
=8617<>98 4811 5 43903,145153=1408166116413501331,3554 05-
08166172530516(3346632!11 35@A)@A)>53979
=537'9=97&167;9'97 1561407:9=97)*>9036,163518B:34!353
6 631
1036:30651
6 03081-
634510313051698163451:355346*5)77)"$)>*9
=61769897)*"9%-64598 4356514:39:3457:1019
=1404&68143667)*A9+341631.!03!9428=1404&68143667.!03!7 6549

View publication stats