FANTASTIC Lifestyle Assessment
FANTASTIC Lifestyle Assessment
FANTASTIC Lifestyle Assessment
onavtawmlmNmnmmm
i 1111 I
Dr. Wilson is an associate health behaviors. In fact, major reports play in affecting the level of health in
professor in the Department of issued by both the Canadian4 and the country. The lifestyle category was
Family Medicine, and Ms. Ciliska American! departments of health and thought to consist of an individual's
is an assistant professor in the welfare have stressed the need for a decisions which affect his health and
School of Nursing, both at reorientation in health care, from a over which he has some control. Be-
McMaster University. Reprint model based on treating disease to one cause poor personal decisions and
requests to: Dr. Douglas M. C. based on health promotion and disease health habits can create self-imposed
Wilson, Department of Family prevention. As a conceptual frame- risks resulting in premature illness or
Medicine, McMaster University, work for such a model, the Lalonde re- death, the improvement of lifestyle is
Hamilton, ON. L8N 3Z5. port4 introduced the Health Field Con- an important goal for achieving a bet-
cept, which consists of four broad ter level of health.
I N RECENT YEARS there has been elements: human biology, environ- The American report, "Healthy
marked interest in health promo- ment, lifestyle, and health care organi- People: The Surgeon-General's Report
tion. I-3 Family physicians, family zation. These elements were arrived at of Health Promotion and Disease Pre-
practice nurses, community health by examining the causes and underly- vention"5 points out that, "It is the
nurses, educators and health educators ing factors of sickness and death in controllability of many risks-and,
are helping people to examine their Canada and by assessing the part they often, the significance of controlling
CAN. FAM. PHYSICIAN Vol. 30: JULY 1984 1 527
even a few-that lies at the heart of expectancy predictions. An appraised tor should enquire about family, ca-
disease prevention and health promo- age which exceeds chronological age reer, and other important lifestyle fac-
tion". The report makes the specific may precipitate unnecessary anxiety, tors. In arriving at a list of important
link between lifestyle and disease. confusion and hypochondriasis. To lifestyle characteristics, we used the
Studies have shown that a few good others, particularly the unemployed, College objective that "The physician
health habits can positively affect the and the economically underprivileged, shall be able to define health as the
length and quality of life, as does a recommendation aimed at increased state of physical, emotional, and social
maintaining a strong network of social lifespan may have absolutely no ap- well-being. " 9
contacts with family and friends.6' 7 A peal. However, such people may wel- A CFPC survey of 1,500 Canadian
series of studies in Alameda County, come suggestions to improve their sit- family doctors asked how frequently
California7 demonstrated substantial uation. they raised questions about specific
increases in the longevity of people In their "assessment of health lifestyle practices. 10 Seventy-five per-
who exercise vigorously and regularly, hazard/health risk appraisal", Wagner cent of this sample indicated that they
maintain normal weight, eat breakfast, et a18 pointed out arithmetic impreci- always discuss smoking, 51% discuss
do not snack between meals, avoid sion for calculating assessment of mor- alcohol intake, and 37% discuss nutri-
smoking, limit alcohol consumption, tality risks. The assumed efficacy for tion. The family physicians only
and sleep seven to nine hours a night. motivating behavioral change could sometimes asked questions about ca-
If lifestyle is, in fact, an important de- not be substantiated from evidence reer, drug abuse, activity, family and
terminant of health, then it becomes collected from programs, users and de- leisure activities. When asked if it
essential to develop tools for measur- velopers. The researchers argued that would help to have more information
ing a person's lifestyle. Such tools are their analysis included behaviors for on helping patients with lifestyle
useful for both the patient, who can which scientific evidence of their pre- issues, 91% of questionnaire respon-
use the tool to evaluate and modify his dictive importance remains controver- dents said that printed material con-
or her own lifestyle, and the health sial (e.g., exercise and reductions in taining specific instructions would be
professional who wants to take a holis- cholesterol intake to lower the risk of helpful.
tic approach to patient care. An assess- death from coronary heart disease). Breslow 's7 seven health habits were
ment tool can facilitate confrontation, Wagner et al8 felt that use of Fram- combined with questions about seat-
lifestyle education and counselling. ingham data, which is based on the belt use to represent the physical fac-
Although health hazard appraisal tools middle-aged, middle class, to predict tors that can influence mortality and,
currently exist, we have found these to the risk of younger people produced to some extent, morbidity and well-
be risk-based, and many do not focus nonsensical risk factor values. Small ness, i.e., activity; nutrition (break-
on factors which the individual can changes in total risk translate into dra-
control. matic alterations in risk age for those fast, snacks, weight); tobacco; alco-
under 35, because the ten year risk of hol; sleep; seatbelt use and toxins.
Health Risk Appraisal death rises very slowly for that group. Beck and Burns"I have studied the
Health risk appraisal instruments The researchers criticized the non- emotional factors related to lifestyle.
have a number of limitations when standardized method of measuring and In their work on cognitive therapy,
used in a family practice setting. Some recording blood pressure and choles- these authors suggested that personal
are very lengthy and time-consuming, terol levels. They said that when a insight is important for controlling
and thus are impractical for a busy value was not written down, an anxiety, depression, and other nega-
average value was inserted. An error tive thoughts. Holmes' 12 and Selye'sl3
physician. Computer processed assess- of 20% in the blood pressure level ap- research on stress provided a frame-
ment forms often require up to six work for some of the current investiga-
weeks before a printout is available. parently can create an error of several
This delay in feedback may interfere years in the computation of risk age.8 tions into how human beings can adapt
Other lifestyle questionnaires are in a healthy way to stress in their envi-
with the process of data collection, available, but these are much longer ronment. Sections on insight and stress
sharing, education and treatment. A and, we believe, more co mplicated to are therefore included on FANTAS-
patient is more easily motivated to im- use than one called FANTASTIC, TIC.
prove his lifestyle when there is imme- which is a simple but comprehensive
diate feedback. Some instruments also Although the social components of
include 'blaming the victim' types of instrument. lifestyle and their relationship to health
questions on family history of breast are more difficult to study, Epstein'4
cancer, and other characteristics that
FANTASTIC and Satir'5 have examined this area.
the patient can do nothing about. Lifestyle Assessment They developed guidelines for health
An assessment which focuses on FANTASTIC originated as a mne- relationships in family settings. Pal-
likely causes of death is a negative ap- monic aid that one of us (Dr. Wilson) more1I and Ulrich17 also looked at ca-
proach to health promotion. It also im- used while a member of the Commit- reer and other occupational factors that
plies a narrower definition of health, tee on Examinations of The College of can affect morbidity. Finally, Rosen-*
which does not include everyday mat- Family Physicians of Canada (CFPC). man and Friedman 18 looked at and
ters and quality of life. The triad of One of the College's eductational ob- classified behaviors which can affect
physical, emotional and social func- jectives is for family physicians to be risk factors for disease. Family, career
tioning is not represented. able to take a holistic approach to pa- and type of personality complete the
Some patients, particularly the el- tient care. In order to learn about the FANTASTIC lifestyle inventory (see
derly, may become depressed with life patient's environment, the family doc- Figures 1 and 2).
1528 CAN. FAM. PHYSICIAN Vol. 30: JULY 1984
Fig. 1.
FANTASTIC lifestyle assessment inventory
o
Balanced meals almost always thetime hardly ever 2
ft so~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~otetme
EMUTRITION | breakfast daily almost always tshmetm hardly ever 2
Excess sugar, salt, animal fats, or minimaluse some of frequently 2
junk foodsm the time
Ideal weight within within 20 lbs. not within 2
10lbs.(4kg.) (8kg.) 20 Ibs. (8 kg.)
Tobacco in the past year none pipe only cigarettes 2
T OBACCO Abuse of drugs: prescribed and seldom or some of frequently 2
OXINS unprescribed never the time
Coffee, tea, cola 3npderday 3-6 per day 6 or more 2
LCOHOL Alcohol & driving dnekv& drive only rarely fairly often 2
ALITY Feel ngs of anger & hostility hardly ever thoetime almost always
Positive thinker almost always some of hardly ever 2
making,________________ _ students,etc. rondthe time
| ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~h timesio alos always
some of
hardl ever alotlwy
Name Sex MO FE
tIIESTYtE
qvW|
n.,*, ~ ~IAlurora, Ontario IcP
Division of Sterliog Drag Ltd*^
Trademark,
*~~~~Reg. Ames Company
Trade Mark ^*Registered
A^
User Ltd.
of Canada
Health of Canadians. Ottawa, ON., De-
partment of Health and Welfare, 1974.
Prospective Medicine, Kansas City, MO.,
Oct. 1, 1977.
1 532 CAN. FAM. PHYSICIAN Vol. 30: JULY 1984